betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Remark on internal relaxation in large number qubit systems

Abstract

For a time tct_{c} of calculation in an NN qubit quantum computer that is much shorter than the intrinsic Heisenberg time tHt_H, tc≪tHt_c\ll t_H, the dynamics of the system is effectively irreversible and the couplings between the qubits give rise to a relaxation time scale τrτ_r. If tH≫tc>∼τrt_H\gg t_c >\sim τ_r one looses quantum coherence exponentially fast. Since tHt_H scales exponentially with NN there is a threshold NcN_c such that for N≫NcN\gg N_c one must be aware of possible intrinsic relaxation during calculation. As an order of magnitude estimation we find Nc≈ln⁡(τr/T)N_c\approx \ln(τ_r/T) where TT is a typical system specific oscillation time of a single qubit. τrτ_r can be estimated as the typical inverse transition rate between two parts of the system, one of which is treated as an environment of the other.

*Electronic address: [email protected]

A quantum computer (see e.g. [1]) uses a number NN of coupled qubits for a calculation over a time tct_c. The actual qubit system may contain more than NN qubits, but perhaps not all of them are involved in the calculation. For simplicity we assume that the total system consists of only those NN qubits being an essential part of the calculation. An initial state is prepared at t=0t=0 and at t=tct=t_c a measurement is made. Up to tct_c the time evolution of the NN qubit has to be unitary to keep the information within the system available. In particular, the dynamics has to be reversible. There are a number of obstacles that have to be overcome in quantum computing. We mention error correction and precise implementation of desired dynamical steps for the calculation. Here we only address the influence of relaxation breaking reversibility. As discussed in [2] every system behaves essentially irreversible on a time scale which is much shorter than the time scale tHt_H of the system that is needed to resolve its discrete energy spectrum. On time scales much shorter than tHt_H the spectrum cannot be resolved as sharp values and it is best modeled by a continuous spectral density. tHt_H is often denoted as Heisenberg time of the system. If the system is treated as open (i.e. coupled to some environment) tHt_H is the Heisenberg time of the total closed system consisting of the open system plus environment. Under this condition the irreversibility becomes evident by the emergence of a relaxator in the system’s Liouville operator [2] and it results in relaxation with relaxation time τr\tau_r, which is specific for the open system. After time τr\tau_r states of the system relax to a stationary state situation1. Thus, on time scales smaller than the Heisenberg time and larger than the relaxation time the system’s state shows relaxation and cannot be described by a reversible dynamics. Typically, the Heisenberg time grows exponentially with the number of constituents of the corresponding total system. For a large isolated system one can adopt the open system view by considering two parts of it, one of which acts as the environment of the other. Intrinsic relaxation in large isolated systems is unavoidable on time scales much smaller than the Heisenberg time2.

These findings of [2] have an effect also for the NN qubit system of a quantum computer. To this end we investigate the typical exponential scaling with NN of the Heisenberg time tHt_H and parametrize it as follows

tH(N)=Teb(N−1),tH(1)=T,(1)t_H(N) = T e^{b(N-1)},\quad t_H(1) = T, \tag*{(1)}

where TT is a typical single qubit oscillation time scale, inverse to the single qubit energy separation3, and bb is some system specific real positive number of O(1)O(1). tc=tH(Nc)t_c = t_H(N_c) defines a number NcN_c by

Nc=1+b−1ln⁡(tc/T)(2)N_c = 1 + b^{-1}\ln(t_c/T) \tag*{(2)}

Since tH/tc=eb(N−Nc)t_H/t_c = e^{b(N-N_c)}, for N≫NcN \gg N_c, the condition tH≫tct_H \gg t_c is fulfilled with ease. According to [2] a relaxation time τr\tau_r emerges generically in the dynamics of system states which becomes apparent as exponential relaxation of any initial state to some stationary state with relaxation time factor e−tc/τre^{-t_c/\tau_r}. For

tH≫tc≳τr,(3)t_H \gg t_c \gtrsim\tau_r, \tag*{(3)}

the quantum computer is no longer quantum coherent, as it approaches a stationary state independent of its initial state.

We take tc=τrt_c = \tau_r as an appropriate threshold criterion such that quantum coherence is no longer guaranteed for

N≫Nc≈ln⁡(τr/T).(4)N \gg N_c \approx\ln(\tau_r/T). \tag*{(4)}

In [2] an order of magnitude estimation for τr\tau_r was given when it results from a system environment coupling,

τr=τseτseτe.(5)\tau_r = \tau_{se}\frac{\tau_{se}}{\tau_e}. \tag*{(5)}

Here τe\tau_e is a relaxation time of correlations in the environment and τse\tau_{se} is the typical inverse rate of transitions between system and environment. The threshold number NcN_c is approximately given as

Nc≈ln⁡((τse/T)(τse/τe)).(6)N_c \approx\ln\left((\tau_{se}/T)(\tau_{se}/\tau_e)\right). \tag*{(6)}

For short environmental relaxation time and very weak coupling between system and environment we have τse/τe≫1\tau_{se}/\tau_e \gg1 and the threshold number NcN_c for coupling between system and environment can be made large by reducing this coupling (increasing τse\tau_{se}).

The isolated system under the criterion tc≪tHt_c \ll t_H will act as its own environment. Formally, one may take two parts of the system, one of which acts as an environment of the other. The corresponding coupling cannot be made arbitrarily small as the qubits have to be coupled over both parts when using both parts for the calculation within tct_c. In case of internal relaxation, the order of magnitude estimate of the relaxation time yields a self-consistency equation, as there is only one typical relaxation time τr\tau_r of system and environment, τr=τcτcτr\tau_r = \tau_c^{\frac{\tau_c}{\tau_r}}. Here τc\tau_c is the typical intrinsic inverse transition rate between the two parts of the system. Consistency requires τr=τc\tau_r = \tau_c. Consequently, intrinsic coupling between two parts causes relaxation in each part. This causes breakdown of quantum coherence for active qubit-numbers N≫NcN \gg N_c with threshold number NcN_c approximately given as

Nc≈ln⁡(τc/T).(7)N_c \approx\ln(\tau_c/T). \tag*{(7)}

The intrinsic transition rate cannot be made arbitrarily small without loosing the coupling between the parts of the system. Thus, the only way to reach large numbers NcN_c is by making the energy separation of a single qubit, T−1T^{-1}, much much larger than the typical coupling strength, τc−1\tau_c^{-1}, between two parts of the system.

The arguments presented here are reformulated as follows. One can explore the full spectral content of a system of NN coupled qubits and thus its quantum dynamics within the system’s specific relaxation time τr\tau_r if one reduces NN to a number NcN_c such that the reduced system has a Heisenberg time of order τr\tau_r. Since relaxation comes about also by internal coupling in large NN qubit systems, one has to face relaxation to stationary situations when N≫Nc≈ln⁡(τr/T)N \gg N_c \approx\ln(\tau_r/T) with TT a typical oscillation time in a single qubit system and τr\tau_r an internal relaxation time which can be estimated as a typical inverse transition rate between two parts of the system, one of which acts as the environment of the other. In a calculation with N≫NcN \gg N_c and for tc≪τrt_c \ll\tau_r one will not take notice of relaxation. However, one cannot explore the full system’s dynamic, but only a part of up to the order of NcN_c qubits.

References

  1. [1]Raseena V 2025 Quantum computing: foundations, algorithms, and emerging applications Front. Quantum Sci. Technol. 4 1723319 (15pp)DOI
  2. [2]Hajdu J and Janßen M 2026 On the Modeling of Irreversibility by Relaxator Liouville Dynamics Annalen der Physik 538 e00483 (23pp)arxiv.org/abs/2510.08083

Paper details

vlnc:W_ph7h8mkt
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY-SA 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents