WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Enhanced Q-factor and effective length silicon photonics filter utilizing nested ring resonators
Abstract
In this study, we investigate a novel design of an on-chip nested coupled ring resonator to enhance the quality factor and the effective length of the resonator. The configuration consists of an open ring and racetrack resonator, with lengths of 340 μm and 184.4 μm, respectively, with a coupling ratio of 97/3. In this regard, the proposed nested cavity has been experimentally characterized and compared with a single cavity ring resonator. Our results show a significant improvement in the quality factor by a factor of four. This improvement in performance opens up exciting new possibilities for state-of-the-art applications, such as compact optical sensors and delay lines. Our proposed design represents a significant advancement in the field of integrated optics, and we believe that it has the potential to enable a broad range of applications in the future.
Introduction
Recently, silicon photonics technology has incited a flurry of interest in both scientific and industrial communities. What has motivated the efforts in this field is the promise of high-speed optical communication capabilities enabled by wavelength division multiplexing [1]. Moreover, photonic integrated circuits (PICs) benefit (CMOS) fabrication process [2]. In addition, such a platform offers exceptional on-chip sensing capabilities [3, 4]. In turn, silicon photonics components have been exploited in for several state-of-the-art applications, for instance, on-chip photonic filters [5, 6], modulators [7], telecommunication networks [8], neural networks [9], and label-free detection [10], ring laser gyroscope to mention a few. In particular, silicon photonics ring resonators play a vital role in most of the aforementioned applications due to their strong field enhancement on the resonance and narrowband wavelength selectivity [11]. In the nonlinear regime, ring resonators can be utilized for frequency comb generation and optical thermodynamics [12, 13, 14]. Furthermore, the variation of such configuration can be utilized in RF photonics [15], delay lines [16], wavelength division multiplexing (WDM) [1], and box-like filters [17]. The prospect of topological phases in ring cavities has also been investigated [18].
Quite recently, the generation of orbital angular momentum modes from micro rings has been explored [19].
Along these lines, silicon photonics ring cavities have been widely used in sensing and spectroscopy. In most of these applications, a high-quality factor is required. Yet, to enhance the quality factor of a resonator, both the losses and the coupling coefficients must be reduced. Practically speaking, the losses in such resonators are usually limited by the surface roughness and the intrinsic loss which is prespecified by fabrication technology capabilities. Another figure of merit for the ring resonators is the free spectral range (FSR) - the spacing between cavity resonances - which depends on the cavity’s length. For many applications, a large FSR is preferred. This will translate to a very small cavity length which leads to high radiation loss and low-quality factor [20, 21, 22]. The use of a gain medium before the lasing threshold to enhance the quality factor has also been explored [23, 24, 25]. Yet, the gain medium introduces spontaneous emission noise and complexity into the whole system.
To this end, several configurations have been proposed to improve the quality factor or finesse, the ratio between the spectral range and the full width at half maximum (FWHM), and the quality factor [26, 27, 28], among which is the cascaded ring resonator arrangement in a serial or parallel manner. Although these arrangements will enhance the overall quality factor and the free spectral range due to the vernier effect, the fabrication imperfection may shift the resonance wavelength of one cavity, thus hindering its use in practical applications. An alternative design is to couple several ring cavities in a panda configuration [29]. Along these lines, hybrid integration has also been utilized to enhance the linewidth of semiconductor lasers [30]. Moreover, the omni-resonant operation has been also demonstrated [31, 32]. Although that such configuration allows for a broad spectral range, the quality factor is not significantly enhanced. As such, of interest will be to develop a novel design that can enhance the quality factor and the free spectral range and be robust against fabrication process variation. Furthermore, it would be beneficial to improve the sensitivity. In this letter, a novel silicon photonics filter configuration is presented to enhance the finesse and the free spectral range. The configuration has been both numerically and experimentally characterized and compared with a conventional ring resonator. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed design.
Analysis of the nested cavity
We begin our analysis by considering a nested ring cavity configuration. Note that the schematic of the single ring cavity and the nested ring cavity is shown in Figure 1(a) and Figure 1(b), respectively. The field transfer function for the nested ring resonator can be written as
Figure 1. Schematics of (a) the single cavity configuration. (b) the nested cavity configuration.
where and are the cross and forward coupling coefficients of the coupler , respectively. While is the length between the input and output coupler. In addition, is the transfer function of the nested cavity. Note that in the case of the single-ring cavity, . From here, the power transmission coefficient can be written as
here, with and . Moreover, and with and are the lengths of the main and coupled cavities, and stands for the propagation constant in the cavity. In equation (2), the difference in the optical propagation distance between the two cavities is . In addition, the maximum insertion loss for a nested cavity is given by [33]
Moreover, using , the full width at half maximum can be derived as [33]
where is the free space wavelength and is the group refractive index. It is worth emphasizing that the full width at half maximum for single ring resonator is and can be obtained from the previous formula by setting and . In a straightforward manner, the quality factor can be derived as:
Meanwhile, the finesse of the cavity is usually defined as . Yet, in the case of the nested cavity, it is difficult to define a fixed FSR as there are many sub-resonance lines with different suppression ratios. To solve this issue, the free spectral range for the nested cavity is calculated for two full resonance modes [33]. Another parameter of interest in sensing applications and delay lines is the effective interaction length. Interestingly, the effective length is directly proportional to the quality factor of the cavity. The effective length of the resonator can be obtained from equation (1) by using the following approximation . By doing so, one can obtain an approximate expression for the transmission:
From here, by comparing the latter formula with Beer-Lambert law for absorption (), where is a constant that accounts for intrinsic loss, we can acquire the effective interaction length for the nested cavity as
As expected, the effective length increases as the forward coupling coefficients increase. Interestingly, the total effective length of the nested cavity can be approximately obtained by multiplying the effective length of both cavities.
Parametric analysis
To illustrate these results, numerical simulations have been carried out to compare the nested and single cavities. In general, the regimes of operations for nested cavities could be divided into three regimes. First is when we have , while the second is and the last regime is . Figure 2 depicts the response of these three regimes, in all cases, the nested cavity has a higher finesse and quality factor than the single cavity. Note that throughout this paper, unless otherwise mentioned, the waveguide used is a strip waveguide with 500 nm width and 220 nm height. This, in turn, leads to a group refractive index of 4.2 and an effective refractive index of 2.42. In addition, for simplicity, we set . Figure 3 depicts the enhancement factor in the quality factor and the effective length for the nested cavity. As indicated from these figures, as the cross-coupling coefficient increases, the effective length decreases regardless of the length of the main or the nested cavity in full accord with equation (7). On the contrary, the quality factor exhibits nontrivial features versus the cross-coupling coefficient. At [see figures. Figure 3(a) and Figure 3(b)], the quality factor increases with increasing the cross-coupling coefficient, as the numerator is approximately proportional to . On the other hand, when or , the quality factor peaks then gradually declines. Meanwhile, the effective length exhibits a consistent pattern by always falling off with the increase in the cross-coupling coefficient.
Figure 2. Nested cavity simulation at different lengths. a) and b) and c) and . In all cases the length of the single cavity is . For simplicity, the cavity is assumed lossless in these simulations.
Figure 3. The enhancement factor in the quality factor and the effective interaction length at different main cavity dimensions. a) mm b) mm c) μm. d) μm . In all cases, the nested cavity length was taken to be μm.
Experimental results
The described design was sent for fabrication at the Washington Nanofabrication Facility, University of Washington. This fabrication facility performs prototypes of passive silicon photonics by Electron Beam Lithography (EBL) [34]. The fabrication process can be summarized in the following steps [35]. A piece of SOI wafer is selected. Then, the resist layer is inserted by spinning and baking a negative photo-resistive material. Afterward, the wafer is exposed to the EBL. Next, the resist is developed by immersion in a hydroxide (TMAH) for a few minutes. Then, the wafer is submitted to a rinse and dry stage. Subsequently, the unexposed areas are removed by plasma etching. After that, the oxide is deposited over the entire chip. Finally, the chip is diced. Due to fabrication issues, there are several aspects that include mismatches between the designed and the fabricated devices. Mainly these manufacturing errors generate variations mainly in the thickness and width of the waveguides. As an approximation, it is common to associate the fabrication variability of a given geometrical parameter with a Gaussian distribution, where the nominal value corresponds to the distribution mean, and the fabrication error is expressed by the standard deviation. The thickness variation associated with the SOI wafer provided by the supplier is shown in Figure 4a and Figure 4b. The results elaborate the corner analysis, which accounts for the width and thickness variability as depicted in Figure 4 inset. More details about the fabrication process are shown in Figure 4c. Due to financial constraints, we were unable to obtain scanning electron microscope pictures for our chip through a multi-project wafer run (MPW). The silicon waveguide possesses a width of approximately 500 nm, complemented by a height of around 220 nm, and is encased within a silicon dioxide cladding. To illustrate the simulation results, nested cavity and single cavity configurations have been fabricated. The designs have been measured using the automated process at the University of British Colombia (UBC). The configuration comprises an open ring and racetrack resonators of lengths of 340 μm and 184.4 μm, as shown in Figure 1(b). The coupler has a length of approximately 55 μm, with the gap width carefully maintained at 0.2 μm. Consequently, the coupling coefficient is deliberately and consistently designed to be 97/3. As expected, the nested cavity exhibits a much longer free spectral range than the single cavity, as shown in figures. Figure 5a and Figure 5b. The full width at half maximum for the proposed configuration has also enhanced from 0.8 nm to 0.2 nm. Note that the nested cavities have higher insertion loss due to longer propagation distance in the nested cavity, as clarified by equation (7). Interestingly, the insertion loss of the nested cavity is higher than the single cavity, as shown in Figure 5c. This is in good agreement with equation (7) as the nested cavity magnifies the total effective length, and hence, the intrinsic losses [see Figure 5a-Figure 5c]. Such features can be exploited.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 4. Corner analysis of the a) effective index and b) group index for the TE mode. The inset shows the normalized TE electric field intensity profile in the strip waveguide. c) The steps of fabrication process.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 5. Experimental results for the two configurations. a) Nested cavity. b) Single cavity. c) Zoomed version for the previous plots around 1565 nm.
in conjunction with cavity-enhanced techniques in biosensing applications [15, 38, 39, 40]. Moreover, in conjunction with an optical modulator, it can provide a variable delay line. Note that based on the design parameters, the FWHM and FSR can be further enhanced based on the configuration and the regime. For instance, if the design constraints demand a high FSR, the vernier effect can be used with two cavities having approximately equal lengths . Note that the nested cavity is able to provide a moderate enhancement factor in the Q-factor (which could be enhanced further by appropriate design) with only two cavities, as shown in Table 1. In this regard, the quality factor of the nested cavity, obtained using , is approximately 78250, whereas the quality factor of the single cavity is approximately 21438. The disparity between the simulation and experimental results is primarily attributed to the fact that surface roughness loss has a more pronounced effect on the quality factor of the nested cavity compared to the single cavity. The nested cavity enhances the effective path length by compelling light to undergo multiple round trips inside it. This effect is roughly equivalent to the number of round trips within the main cavity multiplied by the number of round trips in the single configuration. However, this enhancement also results in higher insertion loss in the case of the nested cavity. These characteristics position the nested cavity as a robust solution for optical communication and sensing applications.
Table 1. Comparison between different configurations
Conclusion
In conclusion, a comprehensive study of the nested cavity resonator has been presented. The proposed silicon photonics filter allows for the precise engineering of key cavity parameters. Our innovative design has demonstrated a remarkable four-fold increase in quality factor compared to the conventional ring cavities, making it a highly promising solution for on-chip spectral filters with high finesse ratios. Furthermore, this novel filter has the potential to enable a range of advanced applications, including slow light and variable delay lines. The exceptional performance and versatility of our silicon photonics filter make it a valuable addition to the toolkit of researchers and engineers working in the field of photonics. With further development, this technology could pave the way for new advances in a variety of fields, including telecommunications, sensing, and quantum computing.
Data availability statement
All data that support the findings of this study are included within the article (and any supplementary files).
Acknowledgments
This work was partially supported by Si-Ware Systems; the authors also would like to thank Lukas Chrostowski for facilitating the fabrication process and the measurements through the SiEPIC program.
Disclosures
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
ORCID iDs
M. A. Selim https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5757-4089
References
- [1]Dong P 2016 Silicon photonic integrated circuits for wavelength-division multiplexing applications IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics 22 370–8DOI
- [2]Izhakny N, Morse M T, Koehl S, Cohen O, Rubin D, Barkai A, Sarid G, Cohen R and Paniccia M J 2006 Development of CMOS-compatible integrated silicon photonics devices IEEE Journal on Selected Topics in Quantum Electronics 12 1688–97DOI
- [3]Li X, Lin Z, You M and Liu J 2020 Chip-Scale Silicon Ring Resonators for Cryogenic Temperature Sensing Journal of Lightwave Technology, Vol. 38, Issue 20, pp. 5768-5773 38 5768–73DOI
- [4]Othman A M, Kotb H E, Sabry Y M and Khalil D 2020 Micro-Electro-Mechanical System Fourier Transform Infrared (MEMS FT-IR) Spectrometer Under Modulated–Pulsed Light Source Excitation https://doi.org/10.1177/0003702819886091 74 799–807
- [5]Liu D, Xu H, Tan Y, Shi Y and Dai D 2021 Silicon photonic filters Microw Opt Technol Lett 63 2252–68DOI
- [6]Shalaby R, Selim M A, Adib G A, Sabry Y M, Gad M and Khalil D 2019 Silicon photonics dual-coupler nested coupled cavities Silicon Photonics XIV vol 10923, ed G T Reed and A P Knights (SPIE) p 58DOI
- [7]Liverman S, Li E, Gao Q and Wang A X 2018 One-volt silicon photonic crystal nanocavity modulator with indium oxide gate Optics Letters, Vol. 43, Issue 18, pp. 4429-4432 43 4429–32DOI
- [8]Selim M A, Wu F O, Ren H, Khajavikhan M and Christodoulides D 2022 Thermodynamic description of the near- and far-field intensity patterns emerging from multimode nonlinear waveguide arrays Phys Rev A (Coll Park) 105 013514DOI
- [9]Bai B, Shu H, Wang X and Zou W 2020 Towards silicon photonic neural networks for artificial intelligence Science China Information Sciences 63 1–14DOI
- [10]Luan E, Shoman H, Ratner D M, Cheung K C and Chrostowski L 2018 Silicon Photonic Biosensors Using Label-Free Detection Sensors 2018, Vol. 18, Page 3519 18 3519DOI
- [11]Zhang G, Feng X L, Liedberg B and Liu A Q 2016 Gas Sensor for Volatile Organic Compounds Detection Using Silicon Photonic Ring Resonator Procedia Eng 168 1771–4DOI
- [12]Chang L, Liu S and Bowers J E 2022 Integrated optical frequency comb technologies Nature Photonics 2022 16:2 16 95–108DOI
- [13]Selim M A, Wu F O, Pyrialakos G G, Khajavikhan M and Christodoulides D 2023 Coherence properties of light in highly multimoded nonlinear parabolic fibers under optical equilibrium conditions Opt Lett 48 1208
- [14]Selim M A, Ahmed Abas R, Sabry Y M and Khalil D A M 2020 Cavity enhanced spectroscopy using multi-longitudinal mode laser RF beating Photonic Instrumentation Engineering VII vol 11287, ed Y Soskind and L E Busse (SPIE) p 26DOI
- [15]Selim M A, Wu F O, Pyrialakos G G and Christodoulides D 2022 Coherence properties of a thermalized highly multimoded nonlinear parabolic fiber Conference on Lasers and Electro-Optics (2022), paper FTh5A.1 FTh5A.1DOI
- [16]Melloni A, Canciamilla A, Ferrari C, Morichetti F, O’Faolain L, Krauss T F, de La Rue R, Samarelli A and Sorel M 2010 Tunable delay lines in silicon photonics: Coupled resonators and photonic crystals, a comparison IEEE Photonics J 2 181–94DOI
- [17]Liu D, He J, Xiang Y, Xu Y and Dai D 2022 High-performance silicon photonic filters based on all-passive tenth-order adiabatic elliptical-microrings APL Photonics 7 051303
- [18]Leykam D and Yuan L 2020 Topological phases in ring resonators: Recent progress and future prospects Nanophotonics 9 4473–87
- [19]Wang Y, Zhao P, Feng X, Xu Y, Cui K, Liu F, Zhang W and Huang Y 2016 Integrated photonic emitter with a wide switching range of orbital angular momentum modes Scientific Reports 2016 6:1 6 1–9
- [20]Selim M A, Sabry Y M and Khalil D 2020 Sensitivity Enhancement Factor for Gain-Assisted Cavity Enhanced Spectroscopy IEEE J Quantum Electron 56
- [21]Gagliardi G and Loock H-P 2014 Cavity-Enhanced Spectroscopy and Sensing vol 179 (Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg)
- [22]Selim M A, Adib G A, Sabry Y M and Khalil D 2019 Incoherent Gain-Assisted Ring Enhanced Gas Absorption Spectroscopy IEEE J Quantum Electron 1–1DOI
- [23]Silva S, Magalhães R, Pérez-Herrera R A, Lopez-Amo M, Marques M B and Frazão O 2016 Fiber cavity ring down and gain amplification effect Photonic Sensors 6 324–7
- [24]Selim M A, Sabry Y M, Adib G A and Khalil D 2019 Active fiber-ring enhanced absorption gas spectroscopy using multi-longitudinal mode tunable laser in the NIR Photonic Instrumentation Engineering VI vol 10925, ed Y G Soskind (SPIE) p 7
- [25]Selim M A, Adib G A, Sabry Y M and Khalil D 2017 Gain-assisted broadband ring cavity enhanced spectroscopy vol 10110, ed Y G Soskind and C Olson (International Society for Optics and Photonics) p 101100X
- [26]Jin L, Li M and He J J 2011 Highly-sensitive silicon-on-insulator sensor based on two cascaded micro-ring resonators with vernier effect Opt Commun 284 156–9
- [27]Griffel G 2000 Vernier effect in asymmetrical ring resonator arrays IEEE Photonics Technology Letters 12 1642–4DOI
- [28]Suzuki A, Takahashi Y, Yoshida M and Nakazawa M 2007 An ultralow noise and narrow linewidth λ/shifted DFB Er-doped fiber laser with a ring cavity configuration IEEE Photonics Technology Letters 19 1463–5
- [29]Katti R and Prince S 2018 Design and Modelling of PANDA Ring Resonator Structure 2018 IEEE 7th International Conference on Photonics, ICP 2018
- [30]Rees A van, Fan Y, Mak J, Lammerink R E M, Franken C A A, Oldenbeuving R M, Geskus D, Epping J P, Hoekman M, Dekker R, Klein E J, Geuzebroek D H, Roeloffzen C G H, Fallnich C, Slot P J M van der and Boller K-J 2021 Narrow-linewidth hybrid-integrated semiconductor lasers by exploiting feedback from Si3N4 circuits https://doi.org/10.1117/12.2583821 11692 1169209
- [31]Shiri A, Yessenov M, Aravindrakshan R and Abouraddy A F 2020 Omni-Resonant Space-Time Wave Packets with Programmable Fabry-Pérot-Cavity Spectra Frontiers in Optics / Laser Science (2020), paper FTh5B.4 FTh5B.4DOI
- [32]Jahromi A K, Abouraddy A F, Schepler K L, Shabahang S and Shiri A 2019 Toggling between active and passive imaging with an omni-resonant micro-cavity Optics Letters, Vol. 44, Issue 7, pp. 1532-1535 44 1532–5
- [33]Adib G A, Sabry Y M and Khalil D 2017 Analysis of dual coupler nested coupled cavities Appl Opt 56 9457DOI
- [34]Bojko R J, Li J, He L, Baehr-Jones T, Hochberg M and Aida Y 2011 Electron beam lithography writing strategies for low loss, high confinement silicon optical waveguides Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B, Nanotechnology and Microelectronics: Materials, Processing, Measurement, and Phenomena 29 06F309
- [35]Chrostowski L and Hochberg M 2015 Silicon photonics design Silicon Photonics Design 1–418DOI
- [36]Vollmer F and Arnold S 2008 Whispering-gallery-mode biosensing: label-free detection down to single molecules Nat Methods 5 591–6DOI
- [37]Wojtas J 2015 Application of Cavity Enhanced Absorption Spectroscopy to the Detection of Nitric Oxide, Carbonyl Sulphide, and Ethane--Breath Biomarkers of Serious Diseases. Sensors (Basel) 15 14356–69DOI
- [38]Ventrillard-Courtillot I, Gonthiez T, Clerici C and Romanini D 2009 Multispecies breath analysis faster than a single respiratory cycle by optical feedback cavity-enhanced absorption spectroscopy J Biomed Opt 14 064026
- [39]Uddin M R, Yazid M, Law F K and Rashidi C B M 2020 Characterizations of Cascaded Micro-ring Resonators IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering vol 767 (Institute of Physics Publishing)DOI
- [40]Wu J, Moein T, Xu X, Ren G, Mitchell A and Moss D J 2017 Micro-ring resonator quality factor enhancement via an integrated Fabry-Perot cavity APL Photonics 2