In this paper
AbstractBibliographyThe first post-Carrollian correctionReferencesWorksPhysics and Astronomy
Gravitational observables from a post-Carrollian expansion
Abstract
Einstein gravity, with a few exceptions, only admits nonlocal observables. This feature is often attributed to diffeomorphism invariance, since a gravitational field can thereby locally be transformed away. We show this attribution to be incorrect by constructing infinitely many exact ultralocal Dirac observables in (velocity dominated aka electric) Carroll gravity. The latter describes Einstein gravity's ultrarelativistic limit, is fully diffeomorphism invariant, and of independent interest in a variety of contexts. Starting from these Carroll observables a systematic construction of Dirac observables for Einstein gravity is outlined. The resulting "post-Carrollian" expansion is organized by the number of spatial gradients or fractional inverse powers of Newton's constant, where each partial sum is local.
Introduction. The paucity of local observables in Einstein gravity hampers further progress in gravitational physics by limiting options to: compare different approaches [1, 2], isolate subsystems [2], or control the nonperturbative continuum limit of discretizations [3]. In spatially closed geometries no local observables exist in vacuum on the basis of NoGo theorems [4, 5, 6]. This feature is thought to persist for coupling to generic matter, and is witnessed by perturbative computations [2, 27, 28, 29, 13]. It is often attributed to diffeomorphism invariance: since a gravitational field can locally be transformed away, there is little to observe pointwise. The NoGo results sharpen this to the absence of local observables, i.e. ones built from the dynamical variables and their derivatives at any finite order. Conversely, the two results reported here should allow one to reframe these traditional obstructions: in fully diffeomorphism invariant Carroll gravity there exist infinitely many ultralocal observables. These enter as the zeroth order of a systematic construction of – seemingly impossible – local approximants to Einstein observables.
Carroll gravities describe Einstein gravity’s ultrarelativistic limit and together with their geometry are an active area of current research [22, 23, 24, 25]. There are several variants of which we focus here on the original, velocity dominated (aka electric) limit as introduced by Isham [17] and Henneaux [18]; see [19] for the terminology and [21, 20] for a first order formulation. For short, we shall refer to it as Velocity Dominated Carroll (VDC) gravity. For our purposes its second order Hamiltonian formulation is advantageous. The action minimally coupled to a scalar field reads
Here , , is the diffeomorphism constraint and is the Hamiltonian constraint. Both are built from the canonical pairs , , which obey standard Poisson brackets. Indices are moved with , is the associated covariant derivative, and , . The scalar field has been rendered dimensionless by the rescaling and is selfinteracting via the potential . The Lagrange multipliers play the role of lapse and shift, and are the Newton and cosmological constants. Finally, the underlying manifold is foliated in terms of spacelike hypersurfaces, which we assume to be compact and closed, for simplicity. The action (1) differs from its counterpart for Einstein gravity merely by the absence of a term in the Hamiltonian constraint, where is the Ricci scalar built from the spatial metric . The action can be obtained from by , where has spacelike distances enhanced via , , , combined with [10]. Since , this can alternatively be viewed as a limit of large Newton constant or small speed of light .2
Bibliography
Dirac observables in VDC gravity. Given the textbook-advertised uniqueness properties of the Einstein-Hilbert action (from which the Hamiltonian version derives) it is surprising that (1) is also fully diffeomorphism invariant. This is implicit in [18] and can be understood through the redundancy [10] of the so-called Ehresmann connection. Concretely, one has [26], where the Hamiltonian gauge variations , , are parameterized by descriptors that are in one-to-one correspondence to linearized diffeomorphisms along the standard lines [14]. To match we take the temporal descriptor to be a spatial density that vanishes at . The gauge variations other than are canonically generated via . Related to its full diffeomorphism invariance the action (1) also propagates the same number of physical degrees of freedom as its Einstein counterpart.
Dirac observables for (1) are essentially gauge invariant quantities, , where ‘’ means equality modulo . For the solutions we find, the vanishing holds exactly; moreover they are built from only. Our Dirac observables for VDC gravity therefore satisfy
which is a strong version of the standard characterization [15]. Without further ado we introduce now the building blocks for the construction of such ’s:
These are spatial densities of weight , , respectively. Further , so that we take in the following (in case one would want to solve , which will not be done here). The interest in the quantities (3) lies in the fact that they are invariant under temporal gauge transformations: , , where is the spatial Lie derivative, acting according to the tensor density type under consideration. This holds off-shell, i.e. without using any equations of motion. For a scalar density one has in particular , so that its spatial integral over a closed spacelike hypersurface vanishes. In addition to there are two other building blocks locally built from . These also obey , , and form a canonical pair. However, since for nontrivial potential no explicit expressions are available for them, we refrain from using them here directly.
The strategy in the following is simply to form nonlinear combinations of (3) that are spatial densities . These combinations will still be invariant under temporal gauge variations but obey . Aiming at such combinations we start with the traces of the matrix powers of . By the Cayley-Hamilton theorem holds; so one may take and as independent traces. Augmenting , one can build ratios of homogeneous polynomials in the three density variables , , . Any ratio of total density weight +1 qualifies as an with the above properties. For illustration, we note as simple examples
Result: Velocity dominated Carroll gravity admits infinitely many strong, off-shell Dirac observables of the form , where is a rational function of net spatial density weight +1 in , , .
These observables exist both in vacuum (where ) and upon minimal coupling to a scalar field . They are ultralocal in the sense that is built from the phase space variables , at a spacetime point . Additional expressions like (4) could be formed using the before-mentioned , building blocks. As a step towards a general NoGo theorem Kuchar [8] performed a systematic search for Dirac observables in vacuum VDC gravity that are linear in the momenta, and found only . This is consistent with the above result in that all other admissible ’s are nonlinear.
Additional symmetries and evasion of NoGo results. From the viewpoint of Einstein gravity the existence of these ultralocal Dirac observables is puzzling because there such a quantity cannot exist by the NoGo theorems [7, 4, 5, 6]. Somehow VDC gravity must evade the NoGo results, and we are led to inquire: how? It cannot be blamed on a breaking of diffeomorphism invariance because, as stressed before, VDC gravity is still fully diffeomorphism invariant. The key step in establishing the NoGo results is to classify all so-called generalized symmetries, i.e. operations that map a solution of the linearized field equations into another one. The result is [4, 5, 6] that all such operations are produced either by linearized diffeomorphisms or by rescalings. There are no hidden symmetries. Though initially shown in a Lagrangian formulation, the result can be transferred to phase space and then entails the absence of local Dirac observables in Einstein gravity [7]. In view of this line of reasoning one is led to suspect that VDC gravity evades the NoGo results by having hidden symmetries. Indeed, this turns out to be the case. Moreover, these additional symmetries are off-shell symmetries of the nonlinear action, not just symmetries of the linearized field equations.
To formulate the result, let be an ultralocal solution of . Explicitly, is a function of phase space variables but not their derivatives that solves
If is also a spatial +1 density we introduce local gauge variations by
and , . Then is a local symmetry of VDC gravity in the sense that
Since the action is preserved up to a boundary term the gauge variations preserve the Hamiltonian equations of motion. For the constraints , this holds exactly, while for the evolution equations it holds to linear order in . Importantly, these symmetries are unrelated to diffeomorphisms and we shall refer to them as “additional local symmetries” of VDC gravity. A further analysis shows that they also give rise to generalized symmetries in the sense of [4, 5, 6], which thereby explains how the NoGo results for Einstein gravity are evaded in VDC gravity.
Of course (7) is only relevant if ultralocal solutions of (5) exist. But just such solutions have been found in the earlier result, for example (4). Ultralocal Dirac observables for VDC gravity therefore give rise to additional local symmetries and vice versa. The reason for spelling out (5) is that it highlights the key difference to Einstein gravity. Since is ultralocal in VDC gravity, the equation (5) is for each spacetime point a linear first order partial differential equation. As such it is soluble by the method of characteristics. The characteristics are governed by a system of nonlinear ordinary differential equations, which turn out [34] to coincide, pointwise in , with the evolution equations for Bianchi I spacetimes in general relativity [16]. The pointwise counterpart of (5) thereby defines conservation laws for the Bianchi I evolution. From this viewpoint, one can recover the previously found ’s via a suitable lift (functions of to functions of ) of Bianchi I conservation laws.
From Carroll to Einstein. So far, we treated VDC gravity as a gravity theory in its own right with properties intriguingly different from Einstein gravity. One can alternatively regard Carroll gravity as the leading term in a suitable decomposition of an action principle for Einstein gravity. With different initial actions such decompositions have been presented in [35, 10, 19]. These can be used as the starting point for the construction or expansion of solutions in a tradition dating back to the analysis of Belinski-Khalatnikov-Lifshitz, see [35, 9]. In the present context, this raises the possibility of constructing observables for Einstein gravity in a new type of expansion. For the standard perturbative expansion the computation of observables for Einstein gravity has been pursued by several teams in different (also quantum) settings and encompasses weak field, small Newton constant, small clock time deviation, see e.g. [28, 29, 27, 13]. In view of the above results one is led to search for a complementary expansion of gravitational observables, where VDC gravity and its simple ultralocal observables are taken as the zeroth order. If well-posed, such an expansion could be viewed alternatively as one for large Newton constant or small speed of light (“post-Carrollian”), see after Eq. (1). It should complement resummation attempts for the weak coupling series [30, 31] and shed light on earlier notions of quasilocality [11, 12]. In a cosmological context it is an expansion away from the Big Bang. As a proof of principle a well-posed expansion of this type has been obtained for Gowdy cosmologies using integrable systems methodology [32].
In a Hamiltonian framework one will search for Dirac observables in Einstein gravity in the form , with a spatial density. Then only weak commutativity with the Hamiltonian constraint needs to be imposed, i.e. . Performing the scaling mentioned after Eq. (1) one has , where
is the gradient potential, and can also be read as if is held fixed. An expansion in powers of can therefore be viewed alternatively as one in the number of spatial gradients, in powers of , or in powers of . Taking one of the ultralocal Dirac observables of VDC gravity as the zeroth order, , we consider an ansatz of the form . It is convenient to average with the descriptor of a temporal gauge variation. The defining equation for a Dirac observable for Einstein gravity then reads , for some coefficient functions , that may depend on the phase space variables. In the present framework these will be expanded according to , , where each term may depend on the VDC phase space variables and their spatial derivatives. Inserted into the above defining equation, the lowest order reads , and the strong vanishing of the Poisson bracket for the VDC Dirac observables found earlier amounts to , . For the subleading terms one is led to a system of recursive equations
At each order, the basic structure of (9) is that of a so-called “homological equation”, , with known. For perturbations around a finite dimensional integrable system several solution techniques are available, see [33] and the references therein. These techniques do, however, not readily carry over to VDC gravity.
Solution of the recursion. Instead, we developed a custom technique (partly drawing on [34]) that invokes the following ingredients: (a) A spatial density called a “clock field”, characterized by . (b) The solution of a single set of ordinary differential equations, the previously encountered characteristics of (5). (c) An explicit recursive formula for the coefficients , , . (d) A master solution formula relating to . We now first comment consecutively on each of these ingredients and then present the solution of (9) in terms of them.
(a) There are several ways to construct a clock field. One that works both in vacuum and for a generic interaction potential is as follows. Assume that the mixed tensor from (3) is diagonalizable over the reals. Let be the unimodular metric canonically conjugate to . Then
is a spatial density and satisfies . Here is separately invariant, , and built from the components of . The logarithm is that for symmetric matrices. is a variant of a clock field in the sense of [13], but plays a different role here.
(b) The next ingredient is the characteristic flow of the Hamiltonian vector field associated with . Writing for a generic phase space point, the flow consists of solutions of the evolution equations , , pointwise in , with respect to a (unphysical) flow parameter that is a spatial density. Backpropagating a generic point with gives rise to coordinates that are invariant under temporal gauge transformations, . These we use to define an interpolating flow , , that connects the original phase space point at to its gauge invariant counterpart at . We write for the components and use to denote evaluation of a phase space function on .
(c) For the coefficients entering the solution of (9) read
where , and is the Lie derivative of a spatial density. A recursive formula, not needed here, then determines all other , , .
(d) The master formula relating the different orders of the expansion has the concise form
Technically, the key assertion is that for all there exist spatial densities and vectors (determined by (c)), such that (12) solves (9). Since contains two spatial derivatives, it entails that the are local quantities. Specifically they are of the form
where is a differential polynomial in the phase space variables (and a spatial density) containing at most spatial derivatives.
Result. Let be a clock field as in (a), let be the interpolating flow from (b), and take the as computed from (d). Then, the partial sums of the series provide systematic local approximants to Dirac observables in Einstein gravity. The leading-order term is one of the ultralocal Dirac observables for VDC gravity described earlier. The corrections are organized by the number of spatial gradients or by powers of .
This is very different from the usual weak coupling (in powers of ) or post-Newtonian (in powers of ) expansions, where all orders are highly nonlocal. The result initiates a new approach to the intrinsic physics of diffeomorphism invariant systems. It may be hoped that the obstructions mentioned in the introductory paragraph can be alleviated thereby.
The first post-Carrollian correction
Here we derive the formulas providing the first post-Carrollian correction for Dirac observables. Explicitly, we claim that given an ultralocal VDC Dirac observable , and a clock field , the expression
solves , with , from (11). We prepare the following
Lemma A.1. Let be a spatial differential polynomial in the basic phase space variables and a spatial density. Write for a spatial density . For a given clock field define . Then satisfies
In particular, $[\delta^H_{\epsilon,0}\mathcal{O}_F-F(\epsilon)]|_{\epsilon=T}=0.
Proof. The derivation is based on the interplay between the gauge variation and the derivatives of flowed quantities. From the definitions of the interpolating flow , , with , , one obtains the relations
Then
The first term evaluates to , where (the original phase space point) and (its invariant counterpart) enter. ■
One application of the Lemma is to the instance of (9). Since the assertion reads , where plays the role of in the Lemma. In order to evaluate the integral term on the right-hand side of (15) we note . It can be simplified using
This can be verified either by direct computation or by matching terms of order in the constraint algebra of Einstein gravity. So far,
Upon evaluation on the interpolating flow we use
where is the Lie derivative of a spatial density. This follows from the differentiated version, which in turn reflects the constraint algebra of VDC gravity, i.e. , . Combining (19) with (20) the integral term in the Lemma evaluates to
with , as in (11). In summary, (14) indeed solves the instance of (9), with the specific , given.
Finally, we check that is a local functional on phase space, specifically one of the form asserted in (13), for . Mostly, this follows from the fact that has regular functional derivatives given by
where we defined
By (14) we need to evaluate . Since for some ultralocal its functional derivatives reduce to pointwise ones, , etc.. Further, as does not depend on the momenta, the functional derivatives of with respect to the momenta vanish. Together
is a differential polynomial of order 2 in the phase space variables. Since is an ultralocal density on phase space, evaluation of (24) on will not change this. Finally, the interpolating flow arises from the pointwise in integrated characteristic flow . Hence
is a spatial differential polynomial in the phase space variables of degree 2.
The generalization to higher orders is considerably more complicated, but the above presentation of the case gives a good flavor of the reasoning involved.
References
- [1]J. Ambjørn, J. Gizbert-Studnicki, A. Goerlich, and D. Nemeth, Is lattice quantum gravity asymptotically safe? Making contact between causal dynamical triangulations and the functional renormalization group, Phys. Rev. D110 (2024) 126006.
- [2]W. Donnelly and S. Giddings, Observables, gravitational dressing, and obstructions to locality and subsystems, Phys. Rev. D94 (2016) 104038.DOI
- [3]B. Dittrich and P. Höhn, From covariant to canonical formulations of discrete gravity, Class. Quant. Grav. 27 (2010) 155001.DOI
- [4]I. Anderson and C. Torre, Symmetries of the Einstein equations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993) 3525.
- [5]I. Anderson and C. Torre, Classification of local generalized symmetries for the vacuum Einstein equations, Commun. Math. Phys. 176 (1996) 479.DOI
- [6]L. Marchildon, Lie symmetries of Einstein’s vacuum equations in N dimensions, J. Nonlin. Math. Phys. 5 (1998) 68.DOI
- [7]C. Torre, Gravitational observables and local symmetries, Phys. Rev. D48 (1993) R2373.DOI
- [8]K. Kuchar, General relativity: dynamics without symmetry, J. Math. Phys. 22 (1981) 2640.DOI
- [9]H. Ringström, Cosmology, the Big Bang, and the BKL conjecture, Comptes Rendus. Mécanique, 353 (2025) 53.DOI
- [10]M. Niedermaier, Nonstandard action of diffeomorphisms and gravity’s anti-Newtonian limit, Symmetry 12 (2020) 752.DOI
- [11]I. Khavkine, Local and gauge invariant observables in gravity, Class. Quant. Grav. 32 (2015) 185019.DOI
- [12]C. Goeller, P. Höhn, and J. Kirlin, Diffeomorphism-invariant observables and dynamical frames in gravity: reconciling bulk locality with general covariance, arXiv:2206.01193.arxiv.org/abs/2206.01193
- [13]B. Dittrich and J. Tambornino, A perturbative approach to Dirac observables and their spacetime algebra, Class. Quant. Grav. 24 (2007) 757.DOI
- [14]J. Pons, D. Salisbury, and K. Sundermeyer, Revisiting observables in generally covariant theories in the light of gauge fixing methods, Phys. Rev. D80 (2009) 084015.DOI
- [15]M. Henneaux and C. Teitelboim, Quantization of gauge systems, Princeton UP, 1992.
- [16]G. Ellis, R. Maartens, M. MacCallum, Relativistic Cosmology, Cambridge UP, 2012.DOI
- [17]C. Isham, Some quantum field theory aspects of the superspace quantization of general relativity, Proc. R. Soc. A351 (1976) 209.DOI
- [18]M. Henneaux, Geometry of zero signature spacetimes, Bull. Soc. Math. Belg. 31, 47 (1979).
- [19]M. Henneaux and P. Salgado-Rebolledo, Carroll contractions of Lorentz invariant theories, JHEP 11 (2021) 180.DOI
- [20]S. Pekar, A. Perez, and P. Salgado-Rebolledo, Cartan-like formulation of electric Car- rollian gravity, JHEP 09 (2024) 059.DOI
- [21]J. Hartong, Gauging the Carroll algebra and ultrarelativistic gravity, JHEP 08 (2015) 69.DOI
- [22]E. Bergshoeff, J. Figueroa-O’Farrill, and J. Gomis, A non-lorentzian primer, SciPost Phys. Lect. Notes 69 (2023).
- [23]L. Donnay, A. Fiorucci, Y. Herfray, and R. Ruzziconi, Carrollian perspective on Celestial Holography, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129 (2022) 071602.DOI
- [24]R. Ruzziconi, Carrollian Physics and Holography, Phys. Rept. 1182 (2026) 1-87.
- [25]L. Ciambelli, R. Leigh, C. Marteau, and M. Petropoulos, Carroll structures, Null geom- etry, and conformal isometries, Phys. Rev. D100 (2019) 046010.DOI
- [26]M. Niedermaier, The gauge structure of strong coupling gravity, Class. Quant. Grav. 32 (2015) 015007.DOI
- [27]M. Fröb, C. Rein, and R. Verch, Graviton corrections to the Newtonian potential using invariant observables, JHEP 01 (2022) 180.DOI
- [28]S. Giddings and J. Perkins, Perturbative quantum evolution of the gravitational state and dressing in general backgrounds, Phys. Rev. D110 (2024) 026012.DOI
- [29]C. Cheung, A. Sivaramakrishnan, J. Wilson-Gerow, and Lihang Zhou, Perturbatively dressed observables, Phys. Rev. D114 (2026) 086013.DOI
- [30]P. Damgaard and K. Lee, Schwarzschild Black Hole from Perturbation Theory to all orders, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 (2024) 251603.DOI
- [31]M. Saavedra, The classical gravitational impulse at high energies, arXiv:2605.18544.
- [32]M. Niedermaier and M. Sedighi Jafari, Dirac observables for Gowdy cosmologies regular at the Big Bang, SIGMA 22 (2026) 097.DOI
- [33]A. Nikolaev, Kato perturbative expansion in classical mechanics and an explicit expres- sion for the Deprit generator, Theor. Math. Phys. 182 (2015) 407.DOI
- [34]M. Niedermaier, Canonical Trivialization of gravitational gradients, Class. Quant. Grav. 34 (2017) 115013.DOI
- [35]D. Hansen, N. Obers, G. Oling, and B. Sogaard, Carroll expansion of general relativity, SciPost Phys. 13 (2022) 055.DOI