betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

A new look at the temperature-dependent properties of the antiferroelectric model PbZrO3: an effective Hamiltonian study

Abstract

A novel atomistic effective Hamiltonian scheme, incorporating an original and simple bilinear energetic coupling, is developed and used to investigate the temperature dependent physical properties of the prototype antiferroelectric PbZrO3 (PZO) system. This scheme reproduces very well the known experimental hallmarks of the complex Pbam orthorhombic phase at low temperatures and the cubic paraelectric state of Pm 3m symmetry at high temperatures. Unexpectedly, it further predicts a novel intermediate state also of Pbam symmetry, but in which anti-phase oxygen octahedral tiltings have vanished with respect to the Pbam ground state. Interestingly, such new state exhibits a large dielectric response and thermal expansion that remarkably agree with previous experimental observations and the x-ray experiments we performed. We also conducted direct first-principles calculations at 0K which further support such low energy phase. Within this fresh framework, a re-examination of the properties of PZO is thus called for.

Introduction

Antiferroelectrics (AFEs) form an important class of materials that are characterized by antipolar arrangement of dipoles. Because of the various attractive functionalities provided by these materials, there is a growing interest in their use in technological applications, in particular for energy storage[1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. PbZrO3\mathrm{PbZrO_3} (PZO) is the prototypical antiferroelectric (AFE) perovskite, and AFE archetype, and its characteristics have been studied since the 1950s. Recent research activities are aimed to better understand its properties[6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12]; however, despite intensive investigations, PZO is still puzzling regarding several issues, including the origin and complex nature of its ground state and possible existence of intermediate phases before reaching its paraelectric high temperature state[13, 14]. PZO exhibits a cubic perovskite structure of Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m symmetry at high temperatures and an antipolar orthorhombic ground state below a critical temperature, TcT_{\mathrm{c}}, of about 505 K, which has the space group PbamPbam[15, 16].

This PbamPbam ground state[6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 12] consists of three structural distortions in terms of phonon mode instabilities of the cubic parent phase. The first one is a strong R4+R_4^{+} soft phonon mode associated with the zone boundary 2πa(12,12,12)\frac{2\pi}{a}\left(\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2}\right) k-point of the cubic first Brillouin zone, where aa is the lattice constant of the five-atom cubic perovskite cell. This mode characterizes an anti-phase tilting of the oxygen octahedra about the [110][110] direction in the perovskite lattice. A second mode is the Σ2\Sigma_2 mode and is indexed by the 2πa(14,14,0)\frac{2\pi}{a}\left(\frac{1}{4},\frac{1}{4},0\right) k-point. The Σ2\Sigma_2 mode consists of complex antipolar displacements of Pb ions along [110][110] accompanied by some oxygen displacements resulting in an unusual tilting pattern about the [001][001] pseudo-cubic axis. There is also a third mode contributing to the PbamPbam ground state, but that is rather weak. It has the S4S_4 symmetry and is associated with the 2πa(14,14,12)\frac{2\pi}{a}\left(\frac{1}{4},\frac{1}{4},\frac{1}{2}\right) k-point[17]. It has first been assumed that a trilinear coupling between these three modes, i.e. R4+R_4^{+}, Σ2\Sigma_2, and S4S_4 modes, plays an important role to stabilize PZO’s PbamPbam ground state (see, e.g., Refs.[7, 8]). However, first-principles studies of Ref.[6] revealed that the contribution of this trilinear term to the total energy is small compared to the energy gain of the ground state with respect to the cubic phase[6]. Recently, a theoretical framework has rather suggested that another trilinear coupling term, which is similar to flexoelectricity but that involves gradients of the octahedral tilt modes rather than strain, is responsible for the ground state of PZO with PbamPbam symmetry[18]. In contrast, a recent experimental work using resonant ultrasound spectroscopy has rather suggested biquadratic and higher order terms couplings through strains between RR and Σ\Sigma modes[19]. Remarkably, Ref.[20] discovered a novel and simpler atomistic energy which only bi-linearly couples the A-cation displacements and oxygen octahedral tilting (also known as antiferrodistortive distortion (AFD)) in ABO3\mathrm{ABO}_3 perovskites and which straightforwardly provided an unified description of many antiferroelectric and incommensurate perovskites, as well as ferrielectrics[21]. This finding therefore raises the question if such previously overlooked and simple bi-linear coupling is, in fact, the main contributor to stabilize the PbamPbam ground state of PZO.

Moreover, new low-energy phases were recently predicted by first-principles calculations in PZO, such as those of Ima2Ima2 and PnamPnam symmetries containing 30 atoms and 80 atoms per primitive cell, respectively[7, 22, 23]. The energy difference between these phases is very small and dramatically depends on the pseudopotentials and other computational details, further emphasizing that PZO is rather challenging to understand and to correctly simulate. PZO has another unsettled related question regarding a possible intermediate phase for temperatures in-between the cubic paraelectric Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m state and the antiferroelectric orthorhombic PbamPbam ground state. Experimentally, such an intermediate phase is sometimes stabilized for a narrow temperature range between the AFE and the cubic phase but still, the structure of the intermediate phase is not really fully known[24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30]. Depending on the crystal growth conditions, intrinsic or intentional chemical doping/defects may extend the temperature range in which the intermediate phase develops and/or causes the appearance of a second intermediate phase showing isothermal, i.e., time-dependent, transition process[13, 31].

A recent first-principles study by Xu. et al. suggested possible candidates for intermediate phases of PZO[32], including one consisting of a dynamical average between the rhombohedral ferroelectric R3cR3c phase and antiferroelectric PbamPbam phases. Involvement of ferroelectric rhombohedral phases and/or intermediate state was also indicated (1) in a high temperature X-ray diffraction study proposing the existence of a ferroelectric rhombohedral phase on heating the PZO crystal[26]; and (2) by Tangantsev et. al.[10], who studied the lattice dynamics of PZO from X-ray and Brillouin scattering and showed that PZO exhibits an intermediate phase on heating the crystal. One can also find in the literature other possibilities for that intermediate phase, such as one associated with lattice distortion corresponding to the M-point (k=2πa(12,12,0)\mathbf{k} = \frac{2\pi}{a}(\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2},0)) of the first Brillouin zone – as similar to the phase obtained in Ref [16]. Note also that based on several experimental techniques, some polar clusters have been proposed to co-exist in the paraelectric phase, suggesting that the purely paraelectric state is only achieved above 593 K, i.e., far above TCT_{\mathrm{C}} (see Ref. 33).

The goal of this article is two-fold. First of all, to demonstrate, via the development of a novel ab-initio effective Hamiltonian (HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}), that the bi-linear coupling of Ref. 20 can indeed lead to the stabilization of the complex antiferroelectric orthorhombic Pbam\mathrm{Pbam} ground state in PZO; Secondly, to use such novel atomistic scheme to predict that there is indeed an intermediate state in PZO being in-between the known Pm3ˉm\mathrm{Pm}\bar{3}\mathrm{m} and Pbam\mathrm{Pbam} states, but which is a state that has never been previously mentioned in the literature – to the best of our knowledge and that shows instabilities allowing to better understand the reported experimental observations. Effective Hamiltonian calculations yield that such intermediate state can be thought as originating from the known Pbam\mathrm{Pbam} ground state but when removing the R4+R_{4}^{+} phonon mode (and also the S4S_{4} mode). Such state, which is further confirmed here to be of low energy by conducting additional direct ab-initio calculations, is coined here the Σ\Sigma phase, due to the predominance of the Σ2\Sigma_{2} mode. It also has the Pbam\mathrm{Pbam} symmetry, therefore resulting in an isostructural transition in PZO with temperature when going from that phase to the ground state under cooling. Interestingly, the HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} computations also provide an intermediate state that possesses (i) a large dielectric response, as it is experimentally known in PZO for temperatures above the transition towards the ground state[34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43]; and (ii) a thermal expansion that agrees well with our measurements. These calculations also yield pseudocubic lattice parameters that are all close to each other in this intermediate state, which indicates that this novel Pbam\mathrm{Pbam} Σ\Sigma state can be thought to be a cubic phase in disguise and thus may explain why it may have been missed up to now. This Σ\Sigma state is also found to be very close in free energy to a tetragonal ferroelectric P4mm\mathrm{P4mm} phase or other ferroelectric states that we believe could be easily triggered through constrains such as chemical doping and defects, as well as the application of external electric or mechanical fields, and, therefore explain many of the experimental observations.

This article is organized as follows. Section II reports details about theoretical and experimental methods developed and/or used here. Section III provides and discusses the results, while Section IV summarizes the article.

Methods

Effective Hamiltonian

As indicated above, an effective Hamiltonian, HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}, is developed in the aim of understanding and modeling finite-temperature properties of PbZrO3_3 bulk. This HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} has the following degrees of freedoms: (1) the local soft modes ui\mathbf{u}_i in each 5-atom cells ii, which are proportional to the electric dipoles of that cell[44] and that are centered on Pb ions here; (2) the ωi\boldsymbol{\omega}_i pseudo-vectors that describes oxygen octahedral tiltings in the unit cells ii[45] and that are centered on Zr ions; ωi\boldsymbol{\omega}_i is such as its direction is the axis about which the oxygen octahedron of cell ii rotates and its magnitude is the angle (in radians) of such rotation; (3) the {ηH}\{\eta_H\} homogeneous strain tensor for which the zero value of its diagonal elements (in Voigt notation) ηH,1=ηH,2=ηH,3\eta_{H,1} = \eta_{H,2} = \eta_{H,3} is associated with the calculated first-principles-derived lattice constant of the paraelectric cubic state of PbZrO3_3 at 0 K ; and (4) vi\mathbf{v}_i vectors that quantify the inhomogeneous strain at each 5-atom cell ii[44], and that are centered on Zr ions here.

Following Refs.[46, 47, 48], the total internal energy contains two different main energies:

Etot=EFE({ui},{ηl})+Etilt({ωi},{ui},{ηl})(1)E^{\mathrm{tot}} = E^{\mathrm{FE}}(\{\mathbf{u}_i\}, \{\eta_l\}) + E^{\mathrm{tilt}}(\{\boldsymbol{\omega}_i\}, \{\mathbf{u}_i\}, \{\eta_l\}) \tag*{(1)}

where EFEE^{\mathrm{FE}} describes energetics associated with local modes, elastic variables and their interactions, while EtiltE^{\mathrm{tilt}} characterizes energetics involving oxygen octahedral tilts and their couplings with local modes and the total {ηl}\{\eta_l\} strain (that is the sum of inhomogeneous and inhomogeneous strains).

As indicated in Ref.[44], EFEE^{\mathrm{FE}} can be decomposed into five terms:

EFE=Eself({ui})+Edpl({ui})+Eshort({ui})+Eelas({ηl})+Eint({ui},{ηl}),(2)\begin{aligned} E^{\mathrm{FE}} ={}& E^{\mathrm{self}}(\{\mathbf{u}_i\}) + E^{\mathrm{dpl}}(\{\mathbf{u}_i\}) + E^{\mathrm{short}}(\{\mathbf{u}_i\}) \\ &+ E^{\mathrm{elas}}(\{\eta_l\}) + E^{\mathrm{int}}(\{\mathbf{u}_i\}, \{\eta_l\}), \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

where EselfE^{\mathrm{self}} is the local mode self energy, EdplE^{\mathrm{dpl}} pertains to the long-range dipole-dipole interaction, EshortE^{\mathrm{short}} represents the short-range interactions between local modes that go beyond dipole-dipole interactions, EelasE^{\mathrm{elas}} denotes the elastic energy, and EintE^{\mathrm{int}} describes the interaction between elastic variables and local modes. As proposed in Ref.[44], these five energies can be written as follows:

Eself=∑i{κ2ui2+αui4+γ(uix2uiy2+uiy2uiz2+uix2uiz2)}E^{\mathrm{self}} = \sum_i \left\{\kappa_2 u_i^2 + \alpha u_i^4 + \gamma\left(u_{ix}^2u_{iy}^2 + u_{iy}^2u_{iz}^2 + u_{ix}^2u_{iz}^2\right)\right\}
Edpl=Z∗2ϵ∞∑i<jui⋅uj−3(R^ij⋅ui)(R^ij⋅uj)Rij3E^{\mathrm{dpl}} = \frac{Z^{*2}}{\epsilon_\infty}\sum_{i<j}\frac{\mathbf{u}_i \cdot\mathbf{u}_j - 3\left(\hat{R}_{ij}\cdot\mathbf{u}_i\right)\left(\hat{R}_{ij}\cdot\mathbf{u}_j\right)}{R_{ij}^3}
Eshort=∑i≠j∑αβJijαβuiαujβE^{\mathrm{short}} = \sum_{i\ne j}\sum_{\alpha\beta}J_{ij\alpha\beta}u_{i\alpha}u_{j\beta}
Eelas=N2B11(η12+η22+η32)+NB12(η1η2+η2η3+η3η1)+N2B44(η42+η52+η62)\begin{aligned} E^{\mathrm{elas}} &= \frac{N}{2}B_{11}\left(\eta_1^2+\eta_2^2+\eta_3^2\right)+NB_{12}\left(\eta_1\eta_2+\eta_2\eta_3+\eta_3\eta_1\right)\\ &\quad+\frac{N}{2}B_{44}\left(\eta_4^2+\eta_5^2+\eta_6^2\right) \end{aligned}
Eint=12∑i∑lαβBlαβηl(Ri)uα(Ri)uβ(Ri),(3)E^{\mathrm{int}} = \frac{1}{2}\sum_i\sum_{l\alpha\beta}B_{l\alpha\beta}\eta_l(R_i)u_\alpha(R_i)u_\beta(R_i), \tag*{(3)}

with Rij=Ri−Rj\mathbf{R}_{ij}=\mathbf{R}_i-\mathbf{R}_j for which Ri\mathbf{R}_i and Rj\mathbf{R}_j are the lattice vectors locating sites ii and jj, respectively. α\alpha and β\beta denote Cartesian components along the [100], [10] and [1] directions, that are chosen to span the x-, y-, and z-axes, respectively. The ii index runs over all the Pb ions. For any given Pb-site ii, the jj index in EdplE^{\mathrm{dpl}} runs over all the other Pb ions. In contrast, the jj index in EshortE^{\mathrm{short}} “only” runs over the first, second and third nearest Pb neighbors of the Pb ion located at the site ii.

Furthermore, the JijαβJ_{ij\alpha\beta} coefficients in EshortE^{\mathrm{short}} can be written in the following way for the different nearest neighbor (NN) interactions:

first NN:Jijαβ=(j1+(j2−j1)∣R^ij,α∣)δαβ;second NN:Jijαβ=(j4+2(j3−j4)∣R^ij,α∣)δαβ+2j5R^ij,α⋅R^ij,β(1−δαβ);third NN:Jijαβ=j6δαβ+3j7R^ij,α⋅R^ij,β(1−δαβ),(4)\begin{aligned} \text{first NN:}\quad J_{ij\alpha\beta} &= \left(j_1+\left(j_2-j_1\right)\left|\hat{R}_{ij,\alpha}\right|\right)\delta_{\alpha\beta};\\ \text{second NN:}\quad J_{ij\alpha\beta} &= \left(j_4+\sqrt{2}\left(j_3-j_4\right)\left|\hat{R}_{ij,\alpha}\right|\right)\delta_{\alpha\beta}\\ &\quad+2j_5\hat{R}_{ij,\alpha}\cdot\hat{R}_{ij,\beta}\left(1-\delta_{\alpha\beta}\right);\\ \text{third NN:}\quad J_{ij\alpha\beta} &= j_6\delta_{\alpha\beta}+3j_7\hat{R}_{ij,\alpha}\cdot\hat{R}_{ij,\beta}\left(1-\delta_{\alpha\beta}\right), \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

where δ\delta is the Kronecker symbol and R^ij,α\hat{R}_{ij,\alpha} represents the α\alpha-component of Rij/Rij\mathbf{R}_{ij}/R_{ij}. A detailed explanation of the j3j_3 coefficient is mentioned in Ref [44]. It represents the strength (and sign) of a specific intersite interaction between second nearest neighbor for the local mode.

Regarding the second main energy of Eq. (1), we generalize that of Refs.[46, 47, 48, 49] by writing:

Etilt({ωi},{ui},{ηl})=∑i[κAωi2+αAωi4+γA(ωix2ωiy2+ωiy2ωiz2+ωix2ωiz2)]+∑ij∑αβKijαβωiαωjβ+∑i∑αK′ωi,α3(ωi+α,α+ωi−α,α)+∑i∑αβClαβηl(i)ωiαωiβ+∑i,j∑α,βDij,αβuj,αωi,αωi,β+∑i,j∑αβγδEαβγδωiαωjβujγuiδ+∑i,j∑α,βFij,αβωi,αuj,β(5)\begin{aligned} E^{\mathrm{tilt}}(\{\omega_i\},\{u_i\},\{\eta_l\})={}&\sum_i\left[\kappa_A\omega_i^2+\alpha_A\omega_i^4+\gamma_A\left(\omega_{ix}^2\omega_{iy}^2+\omega_{iy}^2\omega_{iz}^2+\omega_{ix}^2\omega_{iz}^2\right)\right]\\ &+\sum_{ij}\sum_{\alpha\beta}K_{ij\alpha\beta}\omega_{i\alpha}\omega_{j\beta}+\sum_i\sum_\alpha K'\omega_{i,\alpha}^3\left(\omega_{i+\alpha,\alpha}+\omega_{i-\alpha,\alpha}\right)\\ &+\sum_i\sum_{\alpha\beta}C_{l\alpha\beta}\eta_l(i)\omega_{i\alpha}\omega_{i\beta}\\ &+\sum_{i,j}\sum_{\alpha,\beta}D_{ij,\alpha\beta}u_{j,\alpha}\omega_{i,\alpha}\omega_{i,\beta}+\sum_{i,j}\sum_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}E_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}\omega_{i\alpha}\omega_{j\beta}u_{j\gamma}u_{i\delta}\\ &+\sum_{i,j}\sum_{\alpha,\beta}F_{ij,\alpha\beta}\omega_{i,\alpha}u_{j,\beta} \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

where the sums over ii run over all the Zr sites. The first sum of EtiltE^{\mathrm{tilt}} describes the onsite contributions associated with the oxygen octahedral tilts, as proposed in Refs.[49, 50, 51, 52]. The second and third terms represent short-range interactions between oxygen octahedral tiltings[49, 51] being first-nearest neighbors in the Zr sublattice. Note that jj runs over the six Zr sites that are first-nearest neighbors of the Zr site ii in the second term while ωi+α,α\omega_{i+\alpha,\alpha} in the third term denotes the α\alpha-component of the ω\omega pseudo vector at the site shifted from the Zr site ii to its nearest Zr neighbor along the α\alpha axis. Note also that the KijαβK_{ij\alpha\beta} parameters of this second energy are written as:

first NN:Kijαβ=(k1+(k2−k1)∣R^ij,α∣)δαβ(6)\text{first NN:}\quad K_{ij\alpha\beta}=\left(k_1+\left(k_2-k_1\right)\left|\hat{R}_{ij,\alpha}\right|\right)\delta_{\alpha\beta} \tag*{(6)}

Here, k2k_2 characterizes the strength and sign of a specific interaction between first nearest neighbors for the tilting modes (it is the equivalent of j2j_2 shown in Fig. 1 of Ref. [44] but for the tilting degrees of freedom rather than the local modes). Moreover and following Ref.[51], the fourth term of EtiltE^{\mathrm{tilt}} characterizes the interaction between strain and tiltings. As first proposed in Ref.[49], the fifth term (that depends on the Dij,αβD_{ij,\alpha\beta} coefficients) represents a trilinear coupling between oxygen octahedral tiltings and local modes. The sixth energy, which involves the EαβγδE_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta} parameters, characterizes bi-quadratic couplings between such tiltings and modes[51]. Note that the jj index runs over the eight Pb ions that are first nearest neighbors of the Zr-site ii in these fifth and sixth terms. Finally, the seventh term is the novelty here with respect to the energies provided in Refs.[49, 50, 51, 52]. It represents a recently discovered energy that couples oxygen octahedral tiltings and local modes in a bi-linear fashion[20, 53]. It is allowed by symmetry and was proposed to explain the occurrence of complex antiferroelectric, ferrielectric and even incommensurable phases in some materials[20, 21, 53]. Note that the sum over jj is about the eight Zr-sites that are nearest neighbors of the Pb-sites ii. It is given, in a less compact form than in Eq. (5), by

ΔE=Fii∑i[(ui,x+ui,y)(−ωi100,z+ωi010,z−ωi101,z+ωi011,z)+(−ui,x+ui,y)(−ωi,z+ωi110,z−ωi001,z+ωi111,z)+cyclic permutation](7)\Delta E = F_{ii} \sum_i \left[(u_{i,x}+u_{i,y})(-\omega_{i100,z}+\omega_{i010,z}-\omega_{i101,z}+\omega_{i011,z})+(-u_{i,x}+u_{i,y})(-\omega_{i,z}+\omega_{i110,z}-\omega_{i001,z}+\omega_{i111,z})+\text{cyclic permutation}\right] \tag*{(7)}

where FiiF_{ii} is a material-dependent constant that characterizes the strength of this coupling. The sum over ii runs over all the 5-atom cells of the perovskite structure, and the xx, yy, and zz subscripts denote the Cartesian components of the ui\mathbf{u}_i vectors and ωi\boldsymbol{\omega}_i pseudo-vectors. ωilmn\omega_{ilmn}, with l, m or n being 0 or 1, characterizes the ω\omega pseudo-vectors located at a(lx^+my^+nz^)a(l\hat{x}+m\hat{y}+n\hat{z}) from that of site ii, with aa being the 5-atom lattice parameter and x^\hat{x}, y^\hat{y} and z^\hat{z} being the unit vectors along the x-, y- and z-axes, respectively. Note that the Zr site ii is located at −a(12x^+12y^+12z^)-a(\frac{1}{2}\hat{x}+\frac{1}{2}\hat{y}+\frac{1}{2}\hat{z}) with respect to the Pb site ii. Figure 1 schematizes the coupling terms inherent to the first line of Eq. (7). This new coupling term is important in some systems having Pb atoms (Ref [20]), hence relaxors.

All the parameters of this effective Hamiltonian are provided in Table 1. They are determined by conducting first-principles calculations using the local density approximation (LDA)[54] within density functional theory. Cells containing up to 40 atoms are employed, along with the CUSP code[55] and the ultrasoft-pseudopotential scheme[56] with a 25 Ry plane-wave cutoff. Practically, we use the same pseudopotentials than those of Ref.[57], and thus consider the following valence electrons: Pb 5d, Pb 6s, Pb 6p, Zr 4s, Zr 4p, Zr 4d, Zr 5s, O 2s and O 2p electrons. It is important to know that these effective Hamiltonian parameters are determined by considering small perturbations with respect to the cubic state, and thus do not involve the full ionic and cell relaxation of any phase[44]. Consequently, the fact that we used LDA to obtain these parameters does not automatically imply that our energetic results for relaxed structures predicted by the effective Hamiltonian will be closer to those resulting from the direct use of LDA than to those obtained from other functionals such as the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) in the form of revised Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof[58] (PBEsol). This is especially true if employing these two functionals within first-principles calculations provides similar results in term of structure but rather small differences between the total energy of different relaxed phases – as it is, in fact, known in PbZrO3_3 bulk[59].

DipoleZ∗Z^{*}+6.383ϵ∞\epsilon_{\infty}+6.970
uu on-siteκ2\kappa_{2}+0.00628158α\alpha+0.00943γ\gamma-0.00201
uu short rangej1j_{1}-0.004023j2j_{2}+0.008550
j3j_{3}+0.000614j4j_{4}-0.0005768j5j_{5}+0.0004896
j6j_{6}+0.0000301j7j_{7}+0.0000151
ElasticB11B_{11}+4.775B12B_{12}+1.302B44B_{44}+0.0912
uu-strain coup.B1xxB_{1xx}-0.293B1yyB_{1yy}+0.0522B4yzB_{4yz}+0.00294
ω\omega on-siteκA\kappa_{A}-0.15579αA\alpha_{A}+3.523804γA\gamma_{A}-3.20618
ω\omega short-rangek1k_{1}+0.0389464k2k_{2}+0.00413634K′K^{\prime}-0.1241
ω\omega-strain coup.C1xxC_{1xx}-0.317612C1yyC_{1yy}+1.440823C4yzC_{4yz}-0.011972
ωu\omega u coup. (bilinear)FiiF_{ii}+0.02117
ωu\omega u coup. (trilinear)Dii,xyD_{ii,xy}-0.0430
ωu\omega u coup. (bi-quadratic)ExxxxE_{xxxx}+0.13945ExxyyE_{xxyy}+0.339915ExyxyE_{xyxy}-0.667303

Table 1. Parameters of the presently developed effective Hamiltonian for PbZrO3_{3}. Atomic units are used and the reference cubic lattice parameter is 7.763 Bohr.

This HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}, along with its parameters, is then used in Monte-Carlo (MC) computations on 12×12×1212 \times12 \times12 supercells (which contains 8,640 atoms) for different temperatures. Typically, 40,000 MC sweeps are conducted for each considered temperature, with the first 20,000 sweeps allowing the system to be in thermal equilibrium and the next 20,000 sweeps being employed to obtain statistical averages. However, near phase transitions, a larger number of MC sweeps is needed to have converged results, namely up to 1 million (with the first half used for reaching thermal equilibrium and the next half to extract statistical averages). It is also important to know that a temperature-dependent pressure is added in these Monte-Carlo simulations, with this pressure, P, acting on the strains to produce the following energy:

Epres=Pa3(1+ηH,1)(1+ηH,2)(1+ηH,3)(8)E_{\mathrm{pres}} = P a^3(1+\eta_{H,1})(1+\eta_{H,2})(1+\eta_{H,3}) \tag*{(8)}

where ηH,i\eta_{H,i}, with i=1i=1, 2 and 3, being the diagonal elements of the homogeneous strain tensor in Voigt notations[60] (note that the shear strains are neglected in Equation (8) because they are either null for the cubic paralectric phase or found to be rather small for the other phases encountered in the simulations). Such dependence is assumed here to be linear, as proposed in Ref.[61], and is given, in GPa, by: P=−5.489655172−0.001034483×TP=-5.489655172-0.001034483 \times T, where TT is the temperature in Kelvin with the two coefficients having been numerically found by trying to reproduce the experimental lattice constants at 10 K and 300 K.

In order to determine which structural phases are predicted from the effective Hamiltonian simulations, the following quantities are extracted from the outputs of the MC simulations at any investigated temperature:

uk,α=1N∑iui,αexp⁡(ik⋅Ri)(9)u_{\mathbf{k},\alpha}=\frac{1}{N}\sum_i u_{i,\alpha}\exp(i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{R}_i) \tag*{(9)}
ωk,α=1N∑iωi,αexp⁡(ik⋅Ri)(10)\omega_{\mathbf{k},\alpha}=\frac{1}{N}\sum_i \omega_{i,\alpha}\exp(i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{R}_i) \tag*{(10)}

where k\mathbf{k} are vectors belonging to the cubic first Brillouin zone, α\alpha denotes Cartesian components and the sums run over all the 5-atom sites. Typically, for the local modes, we look at the k\mathbf{k}-vectors at the zone-center (for the polarization) but also at the Σ\Sigma-point (for complex antipolar displacements associated with the PbamPbam state) that is defined as Σ=(14,14,0)\Sigma=\left(\frac{1}{4},\frac{1}{4},0\right) in 2π/a2\pi/a units. Such latter point is also investigated for the tilting of the oxygen octahedra, in addition to the R-point that is given by R=(12,12,12)R = \left(\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2}\right) still in 2π/a2\pi/a units. Note that a non-zero ωR,α\omega_{R,\alpha} characterizes antiphase tilting about the α\alpha-axis while a finite ωΣ,β\omega_{\Sigma,\beta} should also happen for the Pbam ground state with β\beta being different from α\alpha.

Direct First-principles calculations

We also used direct first-principles calculations to check some unexpected predictions arising from the use of the effective Hamiltonian and that will be discussed in the Results’ section. Practically, we use the generalized gradient approximation (GGA) within the revised Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof functional (PBEsol)[58], as implemented in the VASP package[62], for these first-principles computations. The projector augmented wave (PAW)[62, 63] is also applied to describe the core electrons, and we consider the Pb (5d106s26p25d^{10}6s^{2}6p^{2}), Zr (4s24p65s24d24s^{2}4p^{6}5s^{2}4d^{2}) and O (2s22p42s^{2}2p^{4}) as valence electrons with a 520 eV plane-wave cutoff.

Experiments

The lattice parameters have been determined by X-ray diffraction using a high resolution diffractometer with a Copper radiation (λ=CuKα,1=1.5405\lambda=\mathrm{CuK}_{\alpha,1}=1.5405 Å) issued from an 18 kW-rotating anode from room temperature to 750 K using a furnace with a resolution better than 0.1 K. The X-ray diagrams were analyzed fitted with a pseudo-tetragonal unit cell due to the overlap of the peaks related to the aa and bb lattice parameters of the orthorhombic unit cell. The lattice parameters at 10 K and 300 K have been obtained by Rietveld analysis (Jana software)[64] on results obtained from neutron diffraction performed at the Laboratoire Léon Brillouin (beam line 3T2, λ=1.2252\lambda= 1.2252 Å). The lattice parameters obtained at room temperature from neutron diffraction and from X-ray diffraction are in very good agreement. The orthorhombic unit cell parameters (aoa_{\mathrm{o}}, bob_{\mathrm{o}}, coc_{\mathrm{o}}) are presented in Fig. (3b) in a pseudo-tetragonal (apta_{\mathrm{pt}}, cptc_{\mathrm{pt}}) setting where ao=2apta_{\mathrm{o}} = \sqrt{2}a_{\mathrm{pt}}, bo≈22aptb_{\mathrm{o}} \approx2\sqrt{2}a_{\mathrm{pt}} and co=2cptc_{\mathrm{o}} = 2c_{\mathrm{pt}}. At room temperature the orthorhombic cell parameters are ao=5.878a_{\mathrm{o}}=5.878 Å, bo=11.783b_{\mathrm{o}}=11.783 Å, co=8.228c_{\mathrm{o}}=8.228 Å while, at 10 K, they are ao=5.878a_{\mathrm{o}}=5.878 Å, bo=11.784b_{\mathrm{o}}=11.784 Å, and co=8.197c_{\mathrm{o}}=8.197 Å.

Results

Results from the Heff simulations and X-ray diffractions

Let us now report the predictions of the effective Hamiltonian with the parameters indicated in Table 1 and the total energy described in Equation (1), with the additional feature that the second line of Equation (7) is dropped out. This dropping is made because we numerically found that incorporating all the terms of Eq. (7) provides unphysical solutions for tilting arrangements (such as tiltings associated with the XX-point of the first Brillouin zone, which is given by (0,0,12)(0, 0, \frac{1}{2}) in 2π/a2\pi/a units) while keeping the first eight terms of Eq. (7) gives rise to a selected Pbam\mathit{Pbam} ground state (Note that dropping all terms of Eq. (7) will not yield such latter ground state).

Figure 2(a) reports the temperature evolution of the non-zero tilting-related quantities, namely ωR,x=ωR,y\omega_{R,x}=\omega_{R,y} and ωΣ,z\omega_{\Sigma,z}, while Figure 2(b) shows that the only significant local mode quantity is uΣ,x=uΣ,yu_{\Sigma,x}=u_{\Sigma,y}, as obtained by heating up the system from the ground state (note that identical results are obtained by cooling down the system, and that the Heff\mathrm{H}_{\mathrm{eff}} calculations also provide a S4S_{4} mode, but for which the weight is rather small, namely less than 0.32%). The fact that all these quantities are finite at small temperature does characterize a Pbam\mathit{Pbam} ground state.

As the temperature increases up to ≃650\simeq650 K, uΣ,x=uΣ,yu_{\Sigma,x}=u_{\Sigma,y} decreases while ωΣ,z\omega_{\Sigma,z} is barely affected and ωR,x=ωR,y\omega_{R,x}=\omega_{R,y} (anti-phase oxygen octahedra tilts) gets reduced significantly until vanishing through a jump. A first-order transition to what we call here the Σ\Sigma-phase, and that is only characterized by non-zero uΣ,x=uΣ,yu_{\Sigma,x}=u_{\Sigma,y} and ωΣ,z\omega_{\Sigma,z} (complex tilts along zz direction), occurs. Such latest phase still has the Pbam\mathit{Pbam} symmetry with space group no. 55 (as indicated by the FINDSYM software[66, 67]), therefore indicating that our predicted transition around 650 K is isostructural in nature[68, 69, 70]. Note that isostructural transitions are usually of first-order, which is consistent with the jump of ωR,x=ωR,y\omega_{R,x}=\omega_{R,y} seen here at 650 K[7]. Interestingly, it is experimentally known that the Pbam\mathit{Pbam} ground state phase disappears around 511 K, which is not so far away from our predicted 650 K – especially taking into account that effective Hamiltonians have the tendency to not accurately predict transition temperatures (while qualitatively reproducing phase transition sequences, as demonstrated, e.g., by Ref.[44]). However, we are not aware of any previous work mentioning that the Pbam\mathit{Pbam} ground-state phase transforms into another PbamPbam state (that is, the Σ\Sigma phase here) under heating, therefore making our predictions provocative and novel. Within this Σ\Sigma phase, Figs 1a and 1b indicate that both ωΣ,z\omega_{\Sigma,z} and uΣ,x=uΣ,yu_{\Sigma,x}=u_{\Sigma,y} decrease with temperature and then vanish through a jump at about 1300 K. A first-order transition to cubic paraelectric Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m is thus predicted to happen, according to our effective Hamiltonian simulations.

In order to determine if these rather surprising predictions of the Heff\mathrm{H}_{\mathrm{eff}} can be realistic, Fig. 3 reports the computed χ11\chi_{11}, χ22\chi_{22} and χ33\chi_{33} diagonal elements of the dielectric tensor as well as their average χav=13(χ11+χ22+χ33)\chi_{av}=\frac{1}{3}(\chi_{11}+\chi_{22}+\chi_{33}) as a function of temperature. One can see that χ33\chi_{33} and thus χav\chi_{av} adopt very large values at the temperatures around which the known PbamPbam ground state transforms into the novel Σ\Sigma phase, which is consistent with the experimental observation of a large dielectric response around the temperatures at which the known PbamPbam ground state disappears[34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43]. Strikingly too, the coefficient CC in the fitting of χ33\chi_{33} and χav\chi_{av} by CT−T0\frac{C}{T-T_{0}} is predicted to be 1.81×1051.81\times10^{5} K and 1.49×1051.49\times10^{5} K, respectively, in the Σ\Sigma phase, which is of the same order of magnitude than the experimental values ranging between 1.36×1051.36\times10^{5} K and 2.07×1052.07\times10^{5} K (see Refs.[36, 71] and references therein) for temperatures at which the known PbamPbam ground state has vanished.

Note that we found that the increase of χav\chi_{av} and χ33\chi_{33} when the temperature gets reduced in the Σ\Sigma phase towards the known PbamPbam state can be thought to originate from the fact that there is a P4mmP4mm ferroelectric state (with a polarization along the zz-axis and no oxygen octahedral tilting) that is very close in free energy for these temperatures. In fact, reducing the FiiF_{ii} parameter in Table I to a certain critical value of 0.019 makes the intermediate phase in-between the known PbamPbam state and the Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m cubic state becoming P4mmP4mm rather than Σ\Sigma. Note also that the large dielectric response shown in Fig. 3 implies that the zone-center mode should soften when approaching the known PbamPbam phase from above, which has been indeed observed[10, 72]. It is also worth mentioning that the proximity in energy of the ferroelectric P4mmP4mm state (or other ferroelectric states) could also explain the experimental electric-field- or defect-driven single ferroelectric P-E loop observed above the known PbamPbam phase[13], or stabilized under epitaxial strain[73].

Let us now take a look at the behavior of the pseudocubic lattice parameters as a function of temperature. Figure 4a reports our predictions from the use of the presently developed effective Hamiltonian (obtained from the strain outputs) while Fig. 4b displays our own experimental results along with those of Ref.[74]. One can see that, within the known PbamPbam state, several features of the measurements are well reproduced, namely the aa and bb pseudocubic lattice constants are basically independent of the temperature while the cc pseudocubic lattice parameter significantly increases when heating PZO. The jump in the cc lattice constant seen in Fig. 4a at around 650 K confirms the first-order character of the isostructural transition between the known PbamPbam state and the Σ\Sigma phase. What is remarkable is that, within the error bars (the range of error bars for the aa and bb pseudocubic lattice parameter is from 0.0013 to 0.007 Å for the whole temperature range, while it is less than 0.0038 Å for the cc lattice parameter), the aa, bb and cc parameters are identical within our predicted Σ\Sigma phase, which may thus give the (wrong) impression that PZO is cubic if solely focusing on pseudocubic lattice parameters or strains. One can thus think that this Σ\Sigma phase is a cubic state in disguise, when focusing on pseudocubic lattice parameters. In fact, the predicted temperature evolution of 13(a+b+c)\frac{1}{3}(a+b+c) adopts a thermal expansion that is very close in the Σ\Sigma and paraelectric Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m phases, and that is characterized by an average coefficient of 7.97 ×\times 10−610^{-6} K−1^{-1}, –which is in good agreement with the present measurements giving 7.4×\times 10−6^{-6} K−1^{-1} (note that such coefficient is numerically found to be 7.77 ×\times 10−6^{-6} K−1^{-1} in our Σ\Sigma phase versus 8.36 ×\times 10−6^{-6} K−1^{-1} in the simulated Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m state). This facts suggests, once again, that the present simulations can be realistic. On the other hand, comparing Fig. 4a and 4b tells us that the jump in the cc pseudocubic lattice parameter when the known PbamPbam state disappears is more pronounced in experiments than in our present calculations. Such quantitative discrepancy can be due to the facts that this disappearance happens at higher temperature in the simulations and/or that the computations use relatively small 12×12×1212 \times12 \times12 supercells (implying that the first-order character of that transition can be reduced by the increase in critical temperature and/or finite-size effects).

Interestingly, near the temperatures at which the known PbamPbam state disappears, it has been observed in Ref [71] (see Fig. 2.9 there) that the (12,32,12)\left(\frac{1}{2}, \frac{3}{2}, \frac{1}{2}\right) diffractions peak typically associated with antiphase oxygen octahedral tiltings disappears at a temperature lower than the (14,34,0)\left(\frac{1}{4}, \frac{3}{4}, 0\right) diffraction peak that typically characterizes antiparallel displacements of Pb associated with the Σ\Sigma k-point. Such features appear to be qualitatively consistent with our predictions shown in Figs 1a and 1b. Note that our predicted Σ\Sigma-phase can be of short-range or broken into small domains in grown samples, which may explain why it has not been directly reported and reported yet. It is also interesting to realize that, in addition to a zone-center soft-mode, a central mode, with a frequency being very low, has been experimentally reported for temperatures above the known Pbam state[10, 33, 72]. Such feature may be representative of dynamical jumps between different Σ\Sigma-phases, that are with positive or negative ωΣ,z\omega_{\Sigma,z}, ωΣ,y\omega_{\Sigma,y} and ωΣ,x\omega_{\Sigma,x}. Such dynamical jumps will render cubic the overall structure of PZO, while not affecting 13(a+b+c)\frac{1}{3}(a+b+c).

Results from first-principles calculations

Let us now check if such Σ\Sigma phase is also seen as a low-energy state within direct first-principles calculations. Table 2 reports the energy of such Σ\Sigma phase, but also those of the known Pbam and R3c states, choosing the zero of energy to correspond to the cubic paraelectric Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m state. One can first see that the known Pbam is the state with the lowest energy but by only a small amount of about 1 meV/f.u. with respect to R3c. Very interestingly, Table 2 also tells us that Σ\Sigma is indeed a low-energy state in PZO, with its decrease in energy being about 235.6 meV/f.u. with respect to the cubic state, to be compared with 278.8 meV/f.u. for the known Pbam phase. In other words, having finite ωΣ,z\omega_{\Sigma,z} and uΣ,x=uΣ,yu_{\Sigma,x}=u_{\Sigma,y} (like in the Σ\Sigma and known Pbam phases) brings about 85% of the energy of the known Pbam state with respect to Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m state, with the other 15% being due to ωR,x=ωR,y\omega_{R,x}=\omega_{R,y}. Such percentages highlight the importance of the bilinear couplings of Eq. (7), which are responsible for the finite values of ωΣ,z\omega_{\Sigma,z} and uΣ,x=uΣ,yu_{\Sigma,x}=u_{\Sigma,y} in both the Σ\Sigma and known Pbam states, as well as their low energies. Table 3 provides the crystal structure and atomic positions of the known Pbam and the presently discovered Σ\Sigma phase, respectively, as predicted by direct first-principles calculations at 0 K, in the hope they can be used in the future to investigate and/or revisit structural phases of PZO. One can see from Table 3 that the pseudo lattice parameters of the Σ\Sigma phase are not close to each other at 0K, while they are at high temperatures (see Fig 4a).

PhasesEnergy(meV/fu)
Pbam278.8
R3c277.7
Σ\Sigma235.6

Table 2. Energetic gain for different low-energy states with respect to the cubic paraelectric Pm3ˉmPm\bar{3}m state, as predicted by direct first-principles calculations of PbZrO3_{3}

Pbam phase
Lattice ConstantsCell angles
abcα\alphaβ\betaγ\gamma
11.7825.8878.188909090
LabelSymbolMultiplicityWyckoff labelFractional coordinatesOccupancy
xyz
Pb1Pb4g0.875050.201210.000001
Pb2Pb4h0.871340.208900.500001
Zr1Zr8i0.623780.242460.249951
O1O4e0.000000.000000.202871
O2O4f0.000000.500000.770541
O3O8i0.761950.032950.281131
O4O4h0.094380.199200.500001
O5O4g0.157710.223530.000001
Σ\Sigma phase
Lattice ConstantsCell angles
abcα\alphaβ\betaγ\gamma
11.7175.9134.076909090
LabelSymbolMultiplicityWyckoff labelFractional coordinatesOccupancy
xyz
Pb1Pb4g0.644790.304210.000001
Zr1Zr4h0.619110.757090.500001
O1O4h0.736310.457350.500001
O2O2d0.000000.500000.500001
O3O2b0.000000.000000.500001
O4O4g0.355760.286580.000001

Table 3. Crystal structure and Atomic positions of the Pbam and Σ\Sigma phases at 0K obtained from first-principles calculations

Conclusions

We developed and used an original atomistic effective Hamiltonian, incorporating the bilinear coupling discovered in Ref.[20], in order to investigate structural and dielectric properties of bulk PZO as a function of temperature. We also conducted X-ray diffraction measurements for various temperatures. This effective Hamiltonian reproduces well (i) the existence of the known low-temperature AFE orthorhombic Pbam\mathit{Pbam} phase and the high-temperature paraelectric cubic phase; (2) the large dielectric response; and (3) the thermal expansion of the pseudocubic lattice parameters of PZO. Its most provocative prediction is the existence of an intermediate phase named here as the Σ\Sigma phase and that occurs in-between the known Pbam\mathit{Pbam} and cubic phases. This Σ\Sigma phase has the Pbam\mathit{Pbam} symmetry too, therefore yielding an isostructural transition in PZO bulks. It mostly differs from the Pbam\mathit{Pbam} ground state of PZO by the vanishing of anti-phase octahedral tiltings, and its low energy is confirmed by conducting additional direct first-principles calculations. Both the known Pbam\mathit{Pbam} state and this Σ\Sigma phase are numerically found to emerge due to the bilinear coupling terms defined in Eqn. (7). Possible reasons explaining why this Σ\Sigma phase may have been previously overlooked are provided here too. They include the possibilities that the Σ\Sigma phase only exists in a short-range fashion or is broken into small domains in real materials. Another plausible reason is that its three pseudocubic lattice parameters are basically equal to each other, therefore giving the wrong impression that it is cubic in nature when conducting, e.g., diffractions studies. Moreover, it is also possible that the ferroelectric tetragonal-like phase (that is found to be very close in energy to the Σ\Sigma phase) is experimentally observed, as it might be triggered under external stimulus (electric field, doping/defects or stress) which can thus explain some reported polar intermediate phase or polar clusters far above the known Pbam state. We hope that the present work, predicting a phase that has never been mentioned in the rich literature of the textbook antiferroelectric compound to the best of our knowledge, will generate new experimental, theoretical and computational studies and/or analysis on PZO.

The authors in Arkansas thank the Vannevar Bush Faculty Fellowship (VBFF) Grant No. N00014-20-1-2834 from the Department of Defense and the Office of Naval Research Grant No. N00014-21-1-2086. B.X. thanks the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant No. 12074277, Natural Science Foundation of Jiangsu Province (BK20201404), the startup fund from Soochow University and the support from Priority Academic Program Development (PAPD) of Jiangsu Higher Education Institutions. We are also thankful for the computational support from the Arkansas High Performance Computing Center (AHPCC). PEJ and RF thank Dr. F. Porcher from Laboratoire Léon Brillouin for performing the neutron diffraction and Rietveld analyses.

References

This figure "figure1.png" is available in "png" format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/2211.04679v1

This figure "figure2.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2211.04679v1

This figure "figure3.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2211.04679v1

This figure "figure4.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2211.04679v1

References

  1. [1]X. Hao, J. Adv. Dielectr. 3, 1330001 (2013).
  2. [2]B. Ma, D.-K. Kwon, M. Narayanan, and U. Balachandran, J. Mater. Res. 24, 2993 (2009).
  3. [3]B. Ma, M. Narayanan, and U. Balachandran, Mater. Lett. 63, 1353 (2009).
  4. [4]X. Hao, Y. Wang, L. Zhang, and S. An, Appl. Phys. Lett. 102,163903 (2013).
  5. [5]B. Peng, Q. Zhang, X. Li, T. Sun, H. Fan, S. Ke, M. Ye, Y. Wang, W. Lu, H. Niu, J. F. Scott, X. Zeng, and H. Huang, Adv. Electron. Mater. (2015).
  6. [6]J. Íñiguez, M. Stengel, S. Prosandeev, and L. Bellaiche, Phys. Rev. B 90, 220103(R) (2014).
  7. [7]S. Prosandeev, C. Xu, R. Faye, W. Duan, H. Liu, B. Dkhil, P.-E. Janolin, J. Íñiguez, and L. Bellaiche, Phys. Rev. B 89, 214111 (2014).
  8. [8]J. Hlinka, T. Ostapchuk, E. Buixaderas, C. Kadlec, P. Kuzel, I. Gregora, J. Kroupa, M. Savinov, A. Klic, J. Drahokoupil, I. Etxebarria, and J. Dec, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 197601 (2014).
  9. [9]E. Cockayne and K. M. Rabe, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 61, 305 (2000).
  10. [10]A. K. Tagantsev, K. Vaideeswaran, S. B. Vakhrushev, A. V. Filimonov, R. G. Burkovsky, A. Shaganov, D. Andronikova, A. I. Rudskoy, A. Q. R. Baron, H. Uchiyama, D. Chernyshov, A. Bosak, Z. Ujma, K. Roleder, A. Majchrowski, Ko, J.-H. Ko. & N. Setter, Nature Communications 4, 2229 (2013).
  11. [11]J.-H. Ko, M. Corny, A. Majchrowski, K. Roleder, and A. Bussmann-Holder, Phys. Rev. B 87, 184110 (2013).
  12. [12]B. K. Mani, S. Lisenkov, and I. Ponomareva, Phys. Rev. B 91, 134112 (2015).
  13. [13]H. Liu and B. Dkhil, Z. Kristallogr. 226, 163 (2011).
  14. [14]X. Tan, C. Ma, J. Frederick, S. Beckman, and K. G. Webber, J. Am. Ceramic Soc., 94, 4091 (2011).
  15. [15]H. Fujishita, Y. Shiozaki, N. Achiwa, and E. Sawaguchi, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 51, 3583 (1982).
  16. [16]H. Fujishita and S. Hoshino, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 53, 226 (1984)
  17. [17]B. Jaffe, P. Ire 49 (8), 1264 (1961).
  18. [18]K. Shapovalov and M. Stengel, arXiv:2112.12667v1 [cond-mat.mtrl-sci] (2021).
  19. [19]M. A. Carpenter, E. K. H. Salje, M. B. Costab, A. Majchrowski, and K. Roleder, J. Alloys Compd 898, 162804 (2022).
  20. [20]K. Patel, S. Prosandeev, Y. Yang, B. Xu, J. Íñiguez and L. Bellaiche, Phys. Rev. B 94, 054107 (2016).
  21. [21]T. Ma, Z. Fan, B. Xu, T.-H. Kim, P. Lu, L. Bellaiche, M. J. Kramer, X. Tan and L. Zhou, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 217602 (2019).
  22. [22]H. Aramberri, C. Cazorla, M. Stengel, and J. Íñiguez, npj Commutational Materials 7, 196 (2021).
  23. [23]J. Baker, et al. A re-examination of antiferroelectric PbZrO3 and PbHfO3: an 80-atom Pnam structure. Preprint at https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.08856 (2021).
  24. [24]E. Sawaguchi, G. Shirane, and Y. Takagi, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 6, 333 (1951).
  25. [25]V. J. Tennery, J. Electrochem. Soc. 112, 1117 (1965).
  26. [26]V. J. Tennery, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 49, 483 (1966).
  27. [27]L. Goulpeau, Sov. Phys. Solid State 8, 1970 (1967).
  28. [28]M. Tanaka, R. Saito, and K. Tsuzuki, Jon. J. Appl. Phys. 21, 291 (1982).
  29. [29]H. Fujishita, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 61, 3606 (1992).
  30. [30]H. Liu, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 101, 5281 (2018).
  31. [31]D. Kajewski, I. J-Sumara, J-H. Ko, J. W. Lee, et. al., Materials 15, 4077 (2022).
  32. [32]B. Xu, O. Hellman, and L. Bellaiche, Phys. rev. B 100, 020102(R) (2019).
  33. [33]J-H. Ko, M. Gorny, A. Majchrowski, K. Roleder and A. B-Holder, Phys. Rev. B, 87, 184110 (2013).
  34. [34]X. Dai, J.-F. Li, and D. Viehland, Phys. Rev. B, 51(5), 2654 (1995).
  35. [35]H. Fujishita, Journal of the physical society of japan, 61(10), 3606 (1992).
  36. [36]S. Roberts, Journal of American Ceramic Society, 33, 63 (1950).
  37. [37]K. Roleder and G. Kugel, Ferroelectrics 80, 161 (1988).
  38. [38]B.A. Scott and G. Burns, Journal of American Ceramic Society, 55(7), 331 (1972).
  39. [39]G. Shirane, Phys. Rev. 84, 476 (1951).
  40. [40]Z. Ujma and J. Handerek, Physica Status Solidi (a) volume 28, pages 489–496 (1975).
  41. [41]Z. Ujma and J. Handerek, Acta physica polonica, A53, 665 (1978).
  42. [42]D. Weirauchand and V.J.Tennery, Journal of the American Ceramic Society, 5, 21 (1970).
  43. [43]R. W. Whatmore and A. M. Glazer, Journal of Physics C : Solid State Phys., 12, 1505 (1979).
  44. [44]W. Zhong, D. Vanderbilt, and K. M. Rabe, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 1861 (1994); W. Zhong, D. Vanderbilt, and K. M. Rabe, Phys. Rev. B 52, 6301 (1995).
  45. [45]I. A. Kornev, L. Bellaiche, P. E. Janolin, B. Dkhil, and E. Suard, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 157601 (2006).
  46. [46]L. Chen, B. Xu, Y. Yang, L. Bellaiche, Adv. Funct. Mat. 30, 1909496, (2020).
  47. [47]Y. Yang, B. Xu, C. Xu, W. Ren, and L. Bellaiche, Phys. Rev. B 97, 174106 (2018).
  48. [48]Y. Yang, H. Xiang, and L. Bellaiche, Phys. Rev. B 104, 174102 (2021).
  49. [49]S. Prosandeev, D. Wang, W. Ren, J. Íñiguez, and L. Bellaiche, Adv. Funct. Mater. 23, 234 (2013).
  50. [50]D. Albrecht, S. Lisenkov, W. Ren, D. Rahmedov, I. A. Kornev, and L. Bellaiche, Phys. Rev. B 81, 140401(R) (2010).
  51. [51]I. A. Kornev, S. Lisenkov, R. Haumont, B. Dkhil, and L. Bellaiche, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 227602 (2007).
  52. [52]S. Lisenkov, I. A. Kornev, and L. Bellaiche, Phys. Rev. B 79, 012101 (2009).
  53. [53]H. J Zhao, P. Chen, S. Prosandeev, C. Paillard, K. Patel, Jorge Íñiguez and L. Bellaiche, Advanced Electronic Materials, 2100639 (2021).
  54. [54]P. Hohenberg and W. Kohn, Phys. Rev. 136, B864 (1964); W. Kohn and L.J. Sham, Phys. Rev. 140, A1133 (1965).
  55. [55]L. Bellaiche and D. Vanderbilt, Phys. Rev. B 61, 7877 (2000).
  56. [56]D. Vanderbilt, Phys. Rev. B 41, 7892 (1990).
  57. [57]R.G. King-Smith and D. Vanderbilt, Phys. Rev. B 49, 5828 (1994).
  58. [58]J. P. Perdew, A. Ruzsinszky, G. I. Csonka, O. A. Vydrov, G. E. Scuseria, L. A. Constantin, X. Zhou, and K. Burke, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 136406 (2008).
  59. [59]H. Aramberri, C. Cazorla, M. Stengel, and J. Íñiguez, npj Comput. Mater. 7, 196 (2021).
  60. [60]W. Voigt, Lehrbuch der kristallphysik Teubner, Leipzig (1910).
  61. [61]S. Tinte, J. Íñiguez, K.M. Rabe, and D. Vanderbilt, Phys. Rev. B 67, 064106 (2003).
  62. [62]G. Kresse and D. Joubert, Phys. Rev. B 59, 1758 (1999).
  63. [63]P. E. Blochl, Phys. Rev. B 50, 17953 (1994).
  64. [64]V. Petricek, M. Dusek, and L. Palatinus, Z. Kristallogr. 229, 345-352 (2014).
  65. [66]H. T. Stokes, D. M. Hatch, and B. J. Campbell, FINDSYM, ISOTROPY Software Suite, iso.byu.edu.
  66. [67]H. T. Stokes and D. M. Hatch, ”Program for Identifying the Space Group Symmetry of a Crystal”, J. Appl. Cryst. 38, 237-238 (2005).DOI
  67. [68]V. Ranjan, S. Bin-Omran, L. Bellaiche, and Ahmad Alsaad, Phys. Rev. B 71, 195302 (2005).
  68. [69]Hao Tian, Xiao-Yu Kuang, Ai-Jie Mao, Yurong Yang, Changsong Xu, S. Omid Sayedaghaee and L. Bellaiche, Phys. Rev. B Rapid Communications 97, 020103(R) (2018).
  69. [70]B. J. Kennedy, C. J. Howard and B. C Chakoumakos, J. Phys. Condens. Matter 11 1479 (1999).
  70. [71]Romain Faye thesis: Structures and properties of a model antiferroelectric: PbZrO3, https://tel.archives-ouvertes.fr/tel-01127295, (2014).
  71. [72]T. Ostapchuk, J. Petzelt, V. Zelezny, S. Kamba, V. Bovtun, V. Porokhonskyy, A. Pashkin, P. Kuzel, M. D. Glinchuk, I. P. Bykov, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 13, 2677 (2001).
  72. [73]L. Pintilie, I. Vrejoiu, D. Hesse, G. LeRhun, and M. Alexe, Phys. Rev. B 75, 104103 (2007).
  73. [74]H. Fujishita, Y. Ishikawa, S. Tanaka1, A. Ogawaguchi1, and S. Katano2, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 72, 1426 (2003).

Paper details

vlnc:W_ppd8azfv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents