WorksMathematics
Rank-sensitive Hodge bounds for symphonic energy and minimizers on sheared tori
Abstract
We ask how far the minimum of symphonic energy in a homotopy class can exceed the Hodge lower bound from a pulled-back two-form. For projections from a family of sheared four-tori to the flat two-torus, we compute the minimum and the gap for every smooth shear profile. The gap depends on the variance of the profile. Attainment of the projection's pullback area energy by a coclosed test depends on its oscillation. We determine exactly which variances allow two profiles with the same positive gap and different outcomes for this test, and compute the convex relaxation beyond the oscillation threshold. In arbitrary source dimension the optimized test improves the Hodge bound precisely when the harmonic representative exceeds the rank allowed for the pullback on a set of positive measure. We also prove low-degree cohomology estimates, a sharp universal degree exponent for targets detected by low-degree cup products, and an exact defect identity that forces an immersed source to be symplectic at equality.
Cohomology and the energy gap
Let be a closed Riemannian manifold, not necessarily orientable, and a Riemannian manifold, not necessarily compact. All integrals on use its Riemannian density. For a smooth map and a smooth closed two-form on , write
Here selects the harmonic representative in real de Rham cohomology and is the metric adjoint. Critical points of are symphonic maps [7]. The pullback class is fixed in a homotopy class. How close can its harmonic representative bring us to the actual minimum of the energy?
Consider first the projection to the unit flat torus with area form . On the source take the metric for which are orthonormal. Here is real, is smooth of period one, and is its variance on one period. Theorems 5.1 and 6.1 give
For the area functional , a coclosed test realizes exactly when . Consequently the same symphonic minimum and the same positive gap occur on opposite sides of this threshold. For fixed this happens precisely for (Corollary 6.3). Beyond the threshold Proposition 6.2 computes the best test bound. The infimum of over maps in that regime remains open.
The mechanism extends to arbitrary dimensions. Hodge orthogonality gives
Speight and Svensson [9] obtain homotopy minimality for from a coclosed pullback. A surface area form, for example, has pullbacks of rank at most two, while can have higher rank. Theorem 4.1 turns such a rank violation into a uniform positive gap using coclosed test forms. The pointwise norm is a skew-symmetric instance of the dual spectral -support norm [6]. Proposition 4.3 identifies the optimal bound as a convex minimum over forms. Slobodeanu and Svensson [8] studied the second variation at surface-valued submersions with nonintegrable horizontal distributions. Hattori [3] established lower bounds for maps by calibration, including examples on flat tori. Here the sheared source metric allows direct computation of both the harmonic representative and the optimal test bound.
Han and Wei [2] study the same functional under the name -energy: their density is in a source orthonormal frame. For compact manifolds their superstrong instability hypothesis on either endpoint yields arbitrarily small energy in each homotopy class. They also prove that a compact -superstrongly unstable manifold is four-connected. Proposition 2.1 gives a complementary obstruction applicable to individual classes: a nonzero real pullback in any degree from one to four forces a positive energy infimum. Its proof uses exterior powers and Hölder’s inequality. Van Schaftingen [10] gives related estimates for induced cohomology maps using critical Sobolev energies and gap potentials. Cup products then give the degree bound in Corollary 2.2. For almost Hermitian targets, Theorem 3.1 separates the harmonic and pointwise algebraic defects and describes the geometry at equality.
Cohomology actions and mapping degree
Let , be closed Riemannian manifolds with fixed metrics. Equip real cohomology with the inner product on harmonic representatives, using the Riemannian densities on both manifolds. Orientations are needed below only for the signed mapping degree. Write .
Proposition 2.1 (Low-degree cohomology). For there is a constant depending only on the two fixed metrics and manifolds such that
For any finite energy bound the induced homomorphisms on integral cohomology in these degrees form a finite set, both modulo torsion and on the full groups.
Proof. Take orthonormal harmonic bases on and on . The matrix entries are , since each is orthogonal to the exact part of a closed form. If are the singular values of , the norm of its th exterior power satisfies
Hölder’s inequality, including the endpoint , gives
Taking the Euclidean norm of these finitely many entries proves (2.1). The images of integral cohomology modulo torsion are full lattices in the two real spaces. Homomorphisms between these lattices are integer matrices in integral bases, and every bounded subset contains finitely many of them. Two integral homomorphisms inducing the same real map differ by a homomorphism from to the torsion subgroup of . The domain is finitely generated and the latter subgroup is finite, so there are only finitely many such differences. The energy bound is simultaneous in the indicated degrees.
In particular, if a fixed homotopy class contains maps whose symphonic energies tend to zero, its real pullback vanishes in every degree covered by (2). A nonzero pullback in one such degree gives the quantitative obstruction for . This obstruction uses real cohomology, even though the preceding finiteness statement applies to integral cohomology.
Corollary 2.2 (Degree detected by cup products). Suppose are connected, closed and oriented with . Assume there are classes with , , and . There is a constant depending only on the chosen data such that
The hypothesis holds for tori of every dimension and for closed symplectic targets of every even dimension.
Proof. By naturality . The multilinear cup pairing on the finite-dimensional Hodge spaces of has finite norm . Applying (2) to each factor yields*
If the coefficient on the right vanishes, all maps have degree zero. Otherwise rearrangement gives (3). On a torus take the product of the coordinate one-classes. On a closed symplectic -manifold the th power of the symplectic class pairs nontrivially with the fundamental class.
On the unit-volume square torus , the multiplication maps have degree and energy for positive integers . Thus is the largest possible exponent in an estimate of this form valid throughout the stated class. For comparison, when , rescale a smooth degree-one map , constant on a collar, to a coordinate ball of radius in and extend it by that constant. Its degree stays one while its energy is . This shows why some restriction on the high-dimensional target matters.
The energy defect for an almost Hermitian target
Return to a closed source of arbitrary dimension. On let be an orthogonal almost complex structure with fundamental two-form . For a single map we require only . This holds for every map to an almost Kähler target, and for any map of pointwise rank at most two since . Set and on the pulled-back target tangent bundle. All endomorphism norms below are Hilbert–Schmidt norms.
Theorem 3.1 (Two squared defects). For one has
Equality in holds precisely when is harmonic and commutes with everywhere. An equality map minimizes energy among smooth maps with closed pullback in the same cohomology class. If , it minimizes in its homotopy class and is a stable symphonic map.
Proof. Since and , the squared form norm and the squared commutator norm are
The second identity follows by squaring the self-adjoint commutator and cycling the trace. Eliminating gives the pointwise density . Integrating and applying (1) to the closed pullback proves (4). Both remainders are nonnegative, and the harmonic term is fixed throughout the specified class. If , homotopy invariance preserves that class along every smooth variation. An equality map then has vanishing first variation and nonnegative second variation. □
Corollary 3.2 (Topology at equality). For a map attaining the bound in Theorem 3.1, rank is even at each point. If the map has constant rank, its horizontal bundle admits a complex vector bundle structure. If it is an immersion, then is a symplectic form on .
Proof. At equality preserves , so its real dimension is even. At constant rank this image is a smooth subbundle. Transport to by the bundle isomorphism . For an immersion . If and , then . Thus the closed pullback form is nondegenerate. □
The commutation condition is the pseudo horizontally weakly conformal condition studied by Loubeau [4] and Loubeau and Mo [5]. The complex structure on the horizontal bundle is the restriction of the associated -structure of [4]. The energy identity specifies when equality enforces this structure. In the sheared projection of Theorem 5.1, , so (4) identifies the entire excess in (9) with the squared distance of the pulled-back area form from its harmonic representative, divided by two.
Rank bounds in arbitrary dimension
Let , . A two-form has an orthonormal normal form , where . We use and put
For , is the comass. If there are no two-forms or the pullback rank vanishes, the estimates concerning nonzero classes are void. In what follows and .
Theorem 4.1. Suppose almost everywhere. For every smooth coclosed two-form on with ,
In particular, if and , then and
If has comass at most along the image of , then the same right-hand sides bound from below. If has rank at most and comass at most on , these estimates hold uniformly over all smooth maps with the same class .
Proof. At a point, write in orthonormal pairs with . If is the skew operator of , then
For the last step diagonalize : the trace on a -plane is no larger than the sum of its largest eigenvalues, with each block value counted twice. Cauchy–Schwarz gives . This coefficient is optimal pointwise: the truncation of to its first blocks realizes equality. Since is exact, it pairs to zero with on the closed source. An integral Cauchy–Schwarz inequality proves (4.1). Take and use that nonzero has positive largest block on a set of positive measure. This proves (4.2).
For the metric comparison, write , , and . In an orthonormal eigenbasis of with eigenvalues ,
The first inequality uses and skew symmetry; the second uses the operator norm bound on . Integration yields . The class and harmonic representative are unchanged across the stated family. □
Corollary 4.2. For a fixed nonzero realizable pullback class, the harmonic-test improvement in (4.2) is strictly positive if and only if rank on a set of positive measure. In that case the excess of above is at least for every map in the class subject to the rank cap.
Proof. is the integral of the sum of squares of the discarded blocks. Subtract from . For a smooth harmonic form a rank violation at one point persists on an open set. □
No almost complex structure, positivity of curvature, nonzero degree, constant rank or lower bound on the differential appears here. In fact (4.1) itself is a Hilbert-space statement for an form of bounded rank: the only cohomological input is in the -closure of exact forms. It consequently applies without asserting any density theorem for manifold-valued Sobolev maps. One can use a boundary provided the orthogonality to the selected tests is imposed. Without a boundary condition integration by parts has a boundary term. No such extension is needed for the examples.
For comparison, the squared distance of to the rank- cone is . Indeed the pointwise support estimate applied to any admissible gives , and truncation attains the minimum. Using this distance alone in (1.1) gives and loses the last term in (4.2). Neither bound is asserted to be the exact minimum over pullbacks. Equality in the harmonic test for requires, and is equivalent to, pointwise support equality with nonnegative pairing and almost everywhere. This includes possible ties among the block values.
Define the optimized lower bound
Smooth tests suffice by definition. Since dominates a positive dimensional multiple of the Euclidean norm, the supremum is finite. The formula provides a certificate whenever one test attains ; it is not a general duality assertion for the nonconvex minimization over maps.
There is, however, an exact convex problem behind this certificate. Let be the pointwise polar norm: . Its unit ball is the convex hull of the unit Euclidean ball restricted to forms of rank at most , by the support calculation in the proof above and finite-dimensional polarity. In particular on that rank cone. Write for the -closure of smooth exact two-forms.
Proposition 4.3 (Exact dual problem). For every real two-class , with , one has
If , then if and only if the harmonic representative has rank greater than on a set of positive measure.
Proof. Give the equivalent norm . Its dual norm, in the ordinary integrated pairing, is : the upper bound is polar Cauchy–Schwarz, and the reverse follows by choosing at each point a unit polar-norm maximizer and scaling it by . One can use measurable approximate maximizers instead: in measurable orthonormal local frames take a countable dense set in the polar unit ball and select the first candidate within a fixed relative error of the pointwise supremum. The resulting fields, after scaling, are in by norm equivalence. Letting the error decrease proves the norm identity. The quotient norm of is the supremum of its pairings with the unit dual ball in , by Hahn–Banach. Here consists of distributionally coclosed forms. Smooth coclosed tests are dense there: Hodge heat regularization commutes with the codifferential and converges strongly in , hence also in the dual norm. Squaring gives the claimed equality. The minimum exists by weak compactness of bounded sets in and weak lower semicontinuity of the norm on the closed affine subspace. For rank excess use (6). Without rank excess itself is an admissible competitor of cost , and the harmonic test gives the matching lower bound. □
The proposition identifies a relaxation over forms, not its realizability by differentials of maps. For its polar norm is the mass norm dual to comass; see Bangert and Katz [1] for related cohomological norms in systolic geometry.
Under the hypotheses of Theorem 3.1, combining the pointwise identity in its proof with (5) gives, whenever rank ,
Thus the improved cohomological bound retains the full commutator contribution to the energy.
An exact minimum with nonharmonic pullback
Let and write for unit-period coordinates. Given and a smooth periodic function , define an orthonormal coframe for by
Use the orientation . The volume density is independent of and has total mass one. Give the unit square metric and area form . The projection has . Put
The notation means .
Theorem 5.1. For all , , the projection is, up to translations of the target, the unique smooth minimizer of in its homotopy class. In particular it is a stable symphonic map. The exact excess over the Hodge bound is
The harmonic representative has rank four on a nonempty open set precisely when and is nonconstant. In this family that condition is also necessary and sufficient for a positive gap above the Hodge bound.
We first record a quantitative version of the convexity argument. If is a real matrix, put
.
Proposition 5.2. If is a smooth symphonic map to a flat torus and , let be a lift of the nullhomotopic difference in flat target coordinates. Then
In particular any two smooth symphonic maps in a common homotopy class differ by a translation when is connected.
Proof. In orthonormal frames , and
For , is a nonnegative quadratic polynomial on with leading coefficient . It dominates for its vertex . Since , Taylor’s integral formula gives . The constant is sharp for matrices: take . Integrate with , ; stationarity of annihilates the linear term by the variation modulo the target lattice. The last assertion follows by interchanging and in the inequality.
Proof of Theorem 5.1. In the dual frame the rows of are and , so and . The linear term in the first variation integrates to
by periodicity. The two displayed vector fields are divergence-free, including for nonconstant . Proposition 5.2 now gives the minimum and uniqueness.
To compute , average over the isometric translations in . They act trivially on cohomology; uniqueness makes invariant under all of them. An invariant exact two-form has an invariant primitive by averaging. Consequently the invariant closed representatives in this class are exactly
where all three coefficients have zero mean. Conversely zero-mean coefficients have periodic primitives. Set . In the orthonormal frame this gives
Thus its squared norm integrates to the integral of . We minimize this positive definite quadratic functional subject to . At its minimizer ; variation in gives constant, and variation in at fixed gives constant. The mean constraints yield
These smooth coefficients meet the constraints and solve the variational equations, hence give the harmonic representative. By (1), . This proves (9). In coordinates , proving the rank criterion.
When a rank-one test gives the exact area energy
Here “rank-one test” refers to the support function , not to the rank of the test form: it may have rank four. Keep the data of (8).
Theorem 6.1. There is a smooth coclosed test for which (5) certifies if and only if
In this range over all maps with , and also over the homotopy class of . Outside this range no single smooth coclosed test attains the value for . The symphonic minimum in (9) holds on both sides of the threshold.
Proof. A test attaining equality in the two inequalities used for (5) must have constant comass since . After scalar normalization and a sign choice it has comass one and everywhere. The skew operator of then maps the oriented -plane to itself: the coefficient saturates its operator norm, and no mixed coefficient in those two columns is possible. It follows, and conversely suffices for pointwise saturation, that
Coclosedness is equivalent to . Expanding using (8) leaves precisely
Thus for a periodic function . Such a has absolute value at most one for a suitable if and only if the interval of values of has length at most two. Its negative midpoint gives a constant in the admissible range. The resulting test gives and . The projection realizes the bound. The reverse implication concerned all smooth tests, not merely translation-invariant ones.
Proposition 6.2 (The value on both sides of the threshold). Use the notation and , with . There are real numbers such that
The resulting is unique, and the optimized bound is
In particular it is strictly less than one when .
Proof. Use the convex problem in Proposition 4.3. Averaging over preserves the affine class and does not increase the integral, by convexity and translation invariance. The invariant competitors are (11) with zero-mean coefficients: average smooth exact approximants for one inclusion, and approximate each zero-mean coefficient by smooth zero-mean functions for the other. For a two-form in four dimensions the polar of comass is the sum of its two block values. Indeed a test of comass one bounds each normal block separately, and the sum of the two oriented unit blocks attains this bound. Its square on is therefore , since . For fixed , the optimal is zero and the optimal is its prescribed mean by strict convexity. The remaining cost is
This coercive strictly convex functional has a unique minimizer in the closed mean-zero subspace of . Its subgradient equation is , where pointwise. Here is constant since the orthogonal complement of the mean-zero subspace consists of constants; the sum rule applies since all terms are continuous on of the unit circle. Inverting the scalar inclusion gives the displayed formula for . Multiplying by and averaging yields , hence (6.2). The zero solution is admissible in the inclusion exactly when everywhere for some constant , equivalently (6.1). Otherwise .
Corollary 6.3 (Shear profiles of equal variance). Fix and . There exist two smooth mean-zero profiles of variance with the same symphonic minimum and Hodge bound, exactly one of which admits a coclosed test realizing , if and only if . For each such pair the values of are different.
Proof. Write , and . A continuous nonconstant profile takes values strictly between its extrema on an open set. Integrating therefore gives . A profile of positive variance satisfying the test condition must have . At every profile is constant and satisfies it.
Conversely suppose . Set . Translation by a half-period changes its sign, so its mean vanishes. By dominated convergence as . The profile has variance and oscillation tending to , so it admits a saturating test for large .
To obtain the other profile, choose a smooth bump supported in , with minimum zero and maximum one. On the unit circle put on and zero elsewhere. Subtract its mean and multiply by . This produces variance . Its oscillation tends to infinity because the unscaled oscillation is one and the denominator is at most . For small the threshold is exceeded. Formula (5.2) gives the same minimum and harmonic norm in the two metrics. By Theorem 6.1 and Proposition 6.2, for the first metric and for the second.
For and , the threshold is . At both minima are , whereas the Hodge bound is . For the symphonic minimum is still and the Hodge bound is . Whether the infimum of over maps falls below in the latter example remains open.
The four coordinates here give the smallest source dimension in which the harmonic representative can have rank greater than two. They are not a hypothesis of Theorem 4.1. Taking the product of the source with any connected closed Riemannian manifold gives examples in every dimension at least four. The lifted harmonic representative remains harmonic by the product Laplacian, and the energy and squared norms acquire the volume of the added factor. The horizontal vector fields in the proof of stationarity remain divergence-free, so the lifted projection is still a global symphonic minimizer. The small-oscillation test pulls back to a coclosed test of the same pointwise comass. Taking the target product with a Riemannian manifold and pulling back its torus area form likewise preserves the rank cap; projection onto the torus cannot increase the symphonic energy since the extra pullback metric is positive semidefinite.
Scope. Proposition 4.3 gives a necessary and sufficient condition for strict improvement by the optimized test, not for a strict gap in every variational problem. The criterion uses the metric on the source and is not an invariant of the underlying topological manifold alone. On the same projection class, setting or taking constant makes the excess vanish. Determining whether pullbacks attain the convex relaxation outside the certificate regime is a separate question.
Use of computational assistance. OpenAI ChatGPT (Codex) was used to develop the rank estimate and shear example, draft and revise the proofs, search for related literature, and prepare the manuscript. The mathematical arguments above do not rely on numerical evidence.
References
- [1]V. Bangert and M. Katz, An optimal Loewner-type systolic inequality and harmonic one-forms of constant norm, Comm. Anal. Geom. 12 (2004), 703–732.DOI
- [2]Y. Han and S. W. Wei, Φ-harmonic maps and Φ-superstrongly unstable manifolds, J. Geom. Anal. 32 (2022), article 3. doi:10.1007/s12220-021-00770-6.DOI
- [3]K. Hattori, Smooth maps minimizing the energy and the calibrated geometry, J. Geom. Anal. 34 (2024), article 9. doi:10.1007/s12220-023-01452-1.DOI
- [4]E. Loubeau, Pseudo harmonic morphisms, arXiv:dg-ga/9608003 (1996).arxiv.org/abs/dg-ga/9608003
- [5]E. Loubeau and X. Mo, The geometry of pseudo harmonic morphisms, Beitr. Algebra Geom. 45 (2004), 87–102.
- [6]A. McDonald, M. Pontil and D. Stamos, Fitting spectral decay with the k-support norm, Proc. Mach. Learn. Res. 51 (2016), 1061–1069.arxiv.org/abs/1601.00449
- [7]N. Nakauchi and Y. Takenaka, A variational problem for pullback metrics, Ric. Mat. 60 (2011), 219–235.DOI
- [8]R. Slobodeanu and M. Svensson, Skyrme–Faddeev instantons on complex surfaces, Commun. Math. Phys. 335 (2015), 83–91.DOI
- [9]J. M. Speight and M. Svensson, Some global minimizers of a symplectic Dirichlet energy, Q. J. Math. 62 (2011), 737–745.arxiv.org/abs/0804.4385
- [10]J. Van Schaftingen, Estimates by gap potentials of free homotopy decompositions of critical Sobolev maps, Adv. Nonlinear Anal. 9 (2020), 1214–1250. doi:10.1515/anona-2020-0047.