WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Coupling spin defects in hexagonal boron nitride to a microwave cavity
Abstract
Optically addressable spin defects in hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) have become a promising platform for quantum sensing. While sensitivity of these defects are limited by their interactions with the spin environment in hBN, inefficient microwave delivery can further reduce their sensitivity. Hare, we design and fabricate a microwave double arc resonator for efficient transferring of the microwave field at 3.8 GHz. The spin transitions in the ground state of VB- are coupled to the frequency of the microwave cavity which results in enhanced optically detected magnetic resonance (ODMR) contrast. In addition, the linewidth of the ODMR signal further reduces, achieving a magnetic field sensitivity as low as 42.4 microtesla per square root of hertz. Our robust and scalable device engineering is promising for future employment of spin defects in hBN for quantum sensing.
Introduction
Optically active spin defects constitute the main quantum hardware for applications in sensing and communication technologies[1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. Among existing solid state materials hexagonal boron nitride, a wide bang gap two dimensional material, has been shown to host variety of spin defects at room temperature[6, 7, 8]. Recently, a new class of spin defects - namely the negatively charged boron vacancy defects in hexagonal boron nitride (hBN) has emerged as a promising candidate for quantum sensing[6, 9]. The emits at ~ 810 nm, and has a ground state spin transition at ~ 3.5 GHz. Coherent control of the spin state as well as preliminary imaging experiments were demonstrated, as a proof of principle to utilize this defect as a quantum sensor[9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15]. Furthermore, the superior properties of layered materials in achieving the precise thickness of host hBN and hence controlling the distance between the quantum sensor and the sample has brought much attention and excitement to the community with the possibility of performing quantum sensing at these unexplored regimes. With these fundamental attributes, the defects have the potential to become an important tool to study physical properties of emerging 2D materials, devices and heterostructures[9, 10, 16].
To deliver the microwave fields, necessary to control and manipulate the spin state, metal waveguides such as gold stripes are commonly used[12, 13, 17]. While microwave delivery can be easily achieved by transferring a hBN flake on top of a metal stripe, it is an inefficient way to deliver the microwaves with losses. In an alternative approach, one can design and engineer a microwave cavity that resonates with the transitions of the defect spin states[18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23]. Such a cavity is posed to enhance ODMR contrast and prevent microwave power broadening, thus enhancing the spin sensitivity. In turn, the improvement of ODMR contrast and sensitivity of defects in hBN is highly sought after for magnetic, thermal and pressure sensing applications.
In this work, we effectively facilitate the process of designing and fabricating a microwave resonators that matches to the upper transition of , from to in the ground level. The microwave resonators were engineered by low cost printed circuit boards (PCBs) which can easily be tuned by changing the inner arc radius. Our results show the improvement in ODMR contrast and the magnetic field detection sensitivity of the hybrid structure, paving the way to integrating a microwave cavity to spin defects in hBN for ultra-high sensitive quantum sensing.
To create the defects, we have used a low energy nitrogen ion beam at 30 KeV to generate as shown in Figure 1a. First, hBN flakes were exfoliated on a clean silicon substrate with a thin layer of thermal oxide and further cleaned in a UV ozone chamber for 15 minutes to remove any organic residuals from the surface. During the implantation, the nitrogen ion beam was maintained at ion·cm with ion current at 21.9 pA[24, 25].

Figure 1. Spin defects in hBN. a) Creation of by nitrogen (N) ion beam implantation into the hBN lattice. b) Electronic level structure of in hBN with zero-field splitting at ground state = 3.48 GHz. By using an external magnetic field, the ground state spin triplet is split into transitions between and to match the resonance frequency of the microwave cavity (). c) Photoluminescence spectrum from representative defects in hBN. Inset, the scanning electron microscope (SEM) of a hBN flake after N ion beam radiation on areas of 50 50 m (scale bar: 50 m).
The defects are a spin 1 system with a triplet at ground state separated by 3.47 GHz between and states, as shown schematically in Figure 1b. The degeneracy of the latter states are lifted even at zero external magnetic field. This is evident with the two distinct resonances, in the ODMR spectra of the defect. The resonant frequencies, are generalized under external magnetic field () as , where and are zero-field splitting parameters, is the Landé factor, is the Bohr magneton and is Planck's constant. Without an external magnetic field, the two resonant frequencies only split about MHz which could adversely affect the characterization of the microwave resonator and the defects. Therefore, we intentionally designed the resonant frequency of the resonator, at 3.8 GHz and tune the upper resonant frequency, to match with an external magnetic field (Figure 1b).
To confirm the successful generation of the defects a confocal microscopy characterization was carried out to detect the photoluminescence (PL) emission of the defects centered at 800 nm (Figure 1c). Next, the hBN flake was transferred on to the fabricated microwave cavity which resonates with the transition between and in the ground state of .
Figure 2a shows the double arc resonator on a PCB (Rogers 4350B substrate) with a compact size (~ 28 × 15 mm). The resonator consists of two closely separated arcs by a small gap. The microwave signal is delivered through a standard 50 microstrip line which forms a capacitor with the double gap-arc by a small distance. The design was inspired by the proposal from Shamonin et al. [18]. To further characterize the design and fine tune resonant frequency, the electromagnetic numerical simulations (CST Studio Suite) were used. Figure 2b shows the simulated magnetic field strength distribution at the frequency of 3.78 GHz without any loads. The magnetic strength is uniform at the center of the double gap-arc, however it concentrates along the rims of the outer arc.

Figure 2. Microwave resonator characterizations. a) A double arc resonator on a PCB. b) Simulated magnetic field strength distribution of the resonator with the intensity color bar on the right. c) Simulated (orange) and measured (blue) return loss () of a resonator with geometrical parameters listed in the text. d) Resonance frequency of the double arc resonator as a function of the radius of the inner arc together with the 2D design of the resonator. and are the radii of the inner and outer arcs, respectively; and are the cut width of the inner and outer arcs, respectively; is the distance between the transmission line to the outer arc.
The resonant frequency of the resonator was calculated from the simulated results of return loss () of the resonator as shown in Figure 2c, and confirmed experimentally by measuring the transmission of the resonator. The resonance has a marginally lower factor of ~ 65 and resonant frequency ~ 3.8 GHz. These differences are due to the capacitive coupling modified by a metal holder used to mount the resonator to a piezo scanning stage. The design parameters of the resonator given in Table 1.
| Parameters | Comments | ||
| mm | μm | , , , , , , , , and are dielectric constant of the PCB, thickness of the copper layer on the PCB, loss tangent of the PCB material, width of copper traces, inner radius, outer radius, coupling gap, gap between the rings, and cut width of the inner and outer arcs, respectively. | |
| μm | mm | mm | |
| mm | mm |
Table 1. Design parameters for the resonator with Q factor of ~ 90 and resonant frequency of 3.78 GHz
The resonance frequency of the resonators can be tuned by modifying the radius of the inner arc . Seven resonators with different inner radius were fabricated and measured to identify the resonance frequency. The correlation between the resonance frequencies and the inner radii is shown in Figure 2d. This result shows a linear dependence between the resonance frequency and the inner radius with a slope of −0.63 GHz/mm.
To couple the defects to the resonators, the hBN flake containing the defects was transferred directly onto the PCB, in the region where the microwave field is homogeneous. To shift the upper resonant frequency, of defects to the cavity mode, a small magnetic field applied perpendicularly to the flake. Figure 3a shows ODMR spectra of in the absence of an external magnetic field (blue) and when the signal is brought to the resonance of the microwave cavity under ~ 10 mT of external magnetic field. The enhancement of ODMR contrast is increasing to ~ 7% employing the cavity resonance, compared to a pristine contrast of ~ 1.7 %, under the same microwave power (15 dBm).

Figure 3. ODMR comparison between with (orange) and without (blue) an external magnetic field. a) ODMR spectrum with and without an external magnetic field at the same microwave power. b) ODMR contrasts, c) Linewidths, and d) Magnetic field sensitivity at different microwave powers with the inset showing zoom-in the sensitivity from 0 to 15 dBm when an external magnetic field is applied.
To further corroborate the coupling strength of defects into the microwave resonator, we perform ODMR measurements under various microwave powers. Figure 3(b, Figure 3c) show the ODMR contrast and linewidth at different microwave powers. All experiments were carried out under laser excitation with power of 2 mW. The ODMR contrast increases significantly when the B field is applied to tune the ODMR resonance to the cavity mode. Notably, even under very low microwave powers (~ -20 dBM), where the signal is non detectable under zero magnetic field, the detection becomes feasible if the ODMR signal is enhanced by the microwave cavity. At maximum, 15 dBm microwave power, the ODMR contrast increases about 3.5 times, accompanied by ~ 20% linewidth reduction, when the magnetic field is applied.
With the enhancement of ODMR contract and reduction of linewidth broadening under high microwave power, the magnetic field sensitivity is expected to be reduced. The magnetic field sensitivity is defined by the ODMR contrast , average photon count rate and the linewidth as the following equation
where is a numerical parameter related to lineshape profile. In our case, for a Gaussian profile. Given the measured photon count rates, ODMR contrasts and linewidths, the magnetic sensitivities can be calculated as shown in Figure 3d. We observed an enhancement of about in magnetic sensitivity, that reaches T/ with the microwave resonator.
To summarize, we have demonstrated the coupling of spin defects () in hBN to a microwave resonator. The higher ODMR contrast ( %) and narrower linewidth ( MHz) were achieved due to the coupling between the microwave resonator and the upper resonant frequency of the under external magnetic field. Furthermore, the detectable magnetic field sensitivity can be reduced to as low as 42.2 T/, making it appropriate for detection of small magnetic fields. This result can be further improved by using different ion irradiation schemes with the possibility of reaching the sensitivity in the range of of in hBN. This improvement of sensitivity would pave the way for quantum sensing applications by using spin defects in layered hBN material.
Acknowledgments
This work is supported by the Australian Research Council (CE200100010, FT220100053) and the Office of Naval Research Global (N62909-22-1-2028).
References
- [1]Wolfowicz G, Heremans F J, Anderson C P, Kanai S, Seo H, Gali A, Galli G and Awschalom D D 2021 Quantum guidelines for solid-state spin defects Nature Reviews Materials 6 906-25DOI
- [2]Atatüre M, Englund D, Vamivakas N, Lee S-Y and Wrachtrup J 2018 Material platforms for spin-based photonic quantum technologies Nature Reviews Materials 3 38-51DOI
- [3]Awschalom D D, Hanson R, Wrachtrup J and Zhou B B 2018 Quantum technologies with optically interfaced solid-state spins Nature Photonics 12 516-27DOI
- [4]Casola F, van der Sar T and Yacoby A 2018 Probing condensed matter physics with magnetometry based on nitrogen-vacancy centres in diamond Nature Reviews Materials 3 17088DOI
- [5]Le Sage D, Arai K, Glenn D R, DeVience S J, Pham L M, Rahn-Lee L, Lukin M D, Yacoby A, Komeili A and Walsworth R L 2013 Optical magnetic imaging of living cells Nature 496 486-9DOI
- [6]Gottscholl A, Kianinia M, Soltamov V, Orlinskii S, Mamin G, Bradac C, Kasper C, Krambrock K, Sperlich A, Toth M, Aharonovich I and Dyakonov V 2020 Initialization and read-out of intrinsic spin defects in a van der Waals crystal at room temperature Nature Materials 19 540-5DOI
- [7]Mendelson N, Chugh D, Reimers J R, Cheng T S, Gottscholl A, Long H, Mellor C J, Zettl A, Dyakonov V, Beton P H, Novikov S V, Jagadish C, Tan H H, Ford M J, Toth M, Bradac C and Aharonovich I 2021 Identifying carbon as the source of visible single-photon emission from hexagonal boron nitride Nature Materials 20 321-8
- [8]Stern H L, Gu Q, Jarman J, Eizagirre Barker S, Mendelson N, Chugh D, Schott S, Tan H H, Sirringhaus H, Aharonovich I and Atatüre M 2022 Room-temperature optically detected magnetic resonance of single defects in hexagonal boron nitride Nature Communications 13 618DOI
- [9]Healey A J, Scholten S C, Yang T, Scott J A, Abrahams G J, Robertson I O, Hou X F, Guo Y F, Rahman S, Lu Y, Kianinia M, Aharonovich I and Tetienne J P 2022 Quantum microscopy with van der Waals heterostructures Nature PhysicsDOI
- [10]Huang M, Zhou J, Chen D, Lu H, McLaughlin N J, Li S, Alghamdi M, Djuga D, Shi J, Wang H and Du C R 2022 Wide field imaging of van der Waals ferromagnet Fe3GeTe2 by spin defects in hexagonal boron nitride Nature Communications 13 5369DOI
- [11]Liu W, Ivády V, Li Z-P, Yang Y-Z, Yu S, Meng Y, Wang Z-A, Guo N-J, Yan F-F, Li Q, Wang J-F, Xu J-S, Liu X, Zhou Z-Q, Dong Y, Chen X-D, Sun F-W, Wang Y-T, Tang J-S, Gali A, Li C-F and Guo G-C 2022 Coherent dynamics of multi-spin V_B center in hexagonal boron nitride Nature Communications 13 5713DOI
- [12]Gao X, Vaidya S, Li K, Ju P, Jiang B, Xu Z, Allcca A E L, Shen K, Taniguchi T, Watanabe K, Bhave S A, Chen Y P, Ping Y and Li T 2022 Nuclear spin polarization and control in hexagonal boron nitride Nature Materials 21 1024-8DOI
- [13]Gao X, Maiga B, Llacshauanga Allcca A E, Shen K, Sadi M A, Solanki A B, Ju P, Xu Z, Upadhyaya P, Chen Y P, Bhave S A and Li T 2021 High-Contrast Plasmonic-Enhanced Shallow Spin Defects in Hexagonal Boron Nitride for Quantum Sensing Nano Letters 21 7708-14DOI
- [14]Gottscholl A, Diez M, Soltamov V, Kasper C, Krauße D, Sperlich A, Kianinia M, Bradac C, Aharonovich I and Dyakonov V 2021 Spin defects in hBN as promising temperature, pressure and magnetic field quantum sensors Nature Communications 12 4480DOI
- [15]Liu W, Li Z-P, Yang Y-Z, Yu S, Meng Y, Wang Z-A, Li Z-C, Guo N-J, Yan F-F, Li Q, Wang J-F, Xu J-S, Wang Y-T, Tang J-S, Li C-F and Guo G-C 2021 Temperature-Dependent Energy-Level Shifts of Spin Defects in Hexagonal Boron Nitride ACS Photonics 8 1889-95DOI
- [16]Kumar P, Fabre F, Durand A, Clua-Provost T, Li J, Edgar J H, Rougemaille N, Coraux J, Marie X, Renucci P, Robert C, Robert-Philip I, Gil B, Cassabois G, Finco A and Jacques V 2022 Magnetic Imaging with Spin Defects in Hexagonal Boron Nitride Physical Review Applied 18 L061002DOI
- [17]Yu P, Sun H, Wang M, Zhang T, Ye X, Zhou J, Liu H, Wang C-J, Shi F, Wang Y and Du J 2022 Excited-State Spectroscopy of Spin Defects in Hexagonal Boron Nitride Nano Letters 22 3545-9DOI
- [18]Bayat K, Choy J, Farrokh Baroughi M, Meesala S and Loncar M 2014 Efficient, Uniform, and Large Area Microwave Magnetic Coupling to NV Centers in Diamond Using Double Split-Ring Resonators Nano Letters 14 1208-13
- [19]Sasaki K, Monnai Y, Saijo S, Fujita R, Watanabe H, Ishi-Hayase J, Itoh K M and Abe E 2016 Broadband, large-area microwave antenna for optically detected magnetic resonance of nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond Review of Scientific Instruments 87 053904DOI
- [20]Chen Y, Guo H, Li W, Wu D, Zhu Q, Zhao B, Wang L, Zhang Y, Zhao R, Liu W, Du F, Tang J and Liu J 2018 Large-area, three-dimensional uniform microwave antenna for quantum sensing based on nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond Applied Physics Express 11 123001
- [21]Mrózek M, Mlynarczyk J, Rudnicki D S and Gawlik W 2015 Circularly polarized microwaves for magnetic resonance study in the GHz range: Application to nitrogen-vacancy in diamonds Applied Physics Letters 107 013505arxiv.org/abs/1503.04612
- [22]Masuyama Y, Mizuno K, Ozawa H, Ishiwata H, Hatano Y, Ohshima T, Iwasaki T and Hatano M 2018 Extending coherence time of macro-scale diamond magnetometer by dynamical decoupling with coplanar waveguide resonator Review of Scientific Instruments 89 125007
- [23]Eisenach E R, Barry J F, Pham L M, Rojas R G, Englund D R and Braje D A 2018 Broadband loop gap resonator for nitrogen vacancy centers in diamond Review of Scientific Instruments 89 094705DOI
- [24]Kianinia M, White S, Fröch J E, Bradac C and Aharonovich I 2020 Generation of Spin Defects in Hexagonal Boron Nitride ACS Photonics 7 2147-52DOI
- [25]Guo N-J, Liu W, Li Z-P, Yang Y-Z, Yu S, Meng Y, Wang Z-A, Zeng X-D, Yan F-F, Li Q, Wang J-F, Xu J-S, Wang Y-T, Tang J-S, Li C-F and Guo G-C 2022 Generation of Spin Defects by Ion Implantation in Hexagonal Boron Nitride ACS Omega 7 1733-9DOI