betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Accurate simulations of nonlinear dynamic shear ruptures on pre-existing faults in 3D elastic solids with dual-pairing SBP methods

Abstract

In this paper we derive and analyse efficient and stable numerical methods for accurate numerical simulations of nonlinear dynamic shear ruptures on non-planar faults embedded in 3D elastic solids using dual-paring (DP) summation by parts (SBP) finite difference (FD) methods. Specifically, for nonlinear dynamic earthquake ruptures, we demonstrate that the DP SBP FD operators [K. Mattsson. J. Comput. Phys., 335:283-310, 2017] generate spurious catastrophic high frequency wave modes that do not diminish with mesh refinement. Meanwhile our new dispersion relation preserving (DRP) SBP FD operators [C. Williams and K Duru, arXiv:2110.04957, 2021] have more accurate numerical dispersion relation properties and do not support poisonous spurious high frequency wave modes. Numerical simulations are performed in 3D with geometrically complex fault surfaces verifying the efficacy of the method. Our method accurately reproduces community developed dynamic rupture benchmark problems, proposed by Southern California Earthquake Center, with less computational effort than standard methods based on traditional SBP FD operators.

Introduction

Numerical simulations of nonlinear frictional sliding along interfaces embedded in elastic solids are of utmost importance in science and engineering [23, 5, 39]. Frictional processes in both industrial materials such as steel pipes, plates and beams, and natural structures like faults in the Earth’s subsurface can lead to failure or disaster. For instance, current understanding of crustal earthquakes is that they nucleate as frictional instabilities on pre-existing fault surfaces under slow tectonic loading [3, 39, 25, 42, 8, 36, 37]. Earthquakes occur when two sides of the fault, initially held in contact by a high level of static frictional resistance, slip suddenly when the high level frictional strength catastrophically decreases. Frictional fault-slip generates strong ground shaking which can be carried by seismic (elastic) waves to far field, far away from fault zones. Thus, spontaneously propagating shear ruptures along internal interfaces in elastic solids are a useful idealisation of earthquake source processes [39, 40, 10, 2, 34, 8, 36, 37, 17, 18, 20, 24, 20, 19, 21, 11]. However, this problem is both numerically and computationally challenging, because of the unprecedented large gradients generated by nonlinear coupling of fields across the fault interface and the presence of discontinuous solutions on the fault.

Efficient and accurate numerical methods are necessary for effective and reliable numerical simulations of nonlinear dynamic shear ruptures in elastic solids. Different numerical methods have been developed [24, 20, 19, 21, 11, 8, 15]. These include standard numerical methods such as spectral method [22], finite element method [31, 32], finite volume method [4], finite difference (FD) method [11, 24, 40], and the discontinuous Galerkin finite element method [7, 15, 33]. They all have different strengths and weaknesses. However, FD methods on structured grids are attractive because they are efficient.

In this study, we derive and analyse high order accurate and provably stable FD methods for nonlinear frictional motion at interfaces in elastic solids. We consider the elastic wave equation in first-order form, subject to nonlinear friction laws at interfaces. The corresponding initial boundary value problem (IBVP) supports energy bounded solutions. For energy-stable IBVPs, a standard approach to achieve numerical stability is to derive a discrete energy estimate, by mimicking the procedure in the continuous setting. If such an estimate is possible, numerical stability is ensured. The summation-by-parts (SBP) FD [41] with the simultaneous approximation term (SAT) [29, 27, 30] technique for implementing boundary conditions enables the development of energy-stable numerical approximations.

The SBP-SAT FD method, with traditional SBP operators, have been developed for linear elastic waves and nonlinear friction laws [11, 24]. However, traditional SBP FD operators based on central finite difference stencils often suffer from spurious unresolved wave-modes in their numerical solutions. These spurious wave-modes have the potential to destroy the accuracy of numerical solutions. To improve the accuracy of SBP operators, the dual-pairing SBP (DP SBP) non-central (upwind) FD stencils were recently introduce in [28, 9]. In [14] these operators were shown to improve the accuracy of the numerical solutions of the 3D elastic wave equations in complex geometries. The main benefit for the DP SBP operators [28, 14] is that they have the potential to suppress poisonous spurious oscillations from unresolved wave-modes, which can destroy the accuracy of numerical simulations on marginally resolved meshes. However, for dynamic shear ruptures composed of discontinuous and/or (nearly) singular exact solutions, numerical errors arising from high order accurate methods may not diminish with increasing mesh resolution, because of ”Gibbs/Runge’s phenomena”. For these situations carefully designed numerical methods are necessary in order to compute accurate numerical solutions. Consequently, detailed theoretical analysis is needed in order to understand the behaviours of numerical errors and control them.

In this paper, our first objective is to derive a provably stable numerical approximation of the elastic wave equation subject to nonlinear friction laws using the DP SBP framework. As in [11, 24], first we construct a subspace of solutions satisfying the (discrete) linear elastodynamics equations and the interface condition exactly. We then project the solutions on the interface to this subspace, extracting data. A main result in this paper is the proof (see Theorem 3) of existence and uniqueness of the interface data for nonlinear friction laws in general anisotropic elastic media. We discretise the 3D elastic wave equation with the DP SBP operators, on boundary-conforming curvilinear meshes, and enforce the nonlinear interface conditions weakly using penalties. Using the energy method and the dual-pairing SBP framework [28, 14, 43, 44], we prove that the numerical method is energy-stable. The proof of energy-stability, however, bounds the growth of the numerical solutions in time but it does not guarantee the convergence of the solution, in particular in the presence of nearly singular and discontinuous exact solutions.

Our second objective is to perform error analysis. Numerical error analysis for the discrete approximation of the 3D elastic wave equation subject to the nonlinear friction laws at an internal fault/interface, is a nontrivial task. To succeed we will make some simplifying assumptions. However, our analysis are plausible and are able to explain some of the behavior of the error seen in the numerical simulations performed later in this paper. First, we linearise the friction law using a frozen coefficient argument. We derive a priori error estimates and prove the convergence of the numerical error for a linearised friction law. Second, we analyse the dependence of the parity (even/odd) of the operators on the numerical errors. For odd order accurate operators, our error analysis reveals that the DP SBP FD operators [28] have the potential to generate spurious catastrophic high frequency errors that do not diminish with mesh refinement. Numerical simulations in 3D corroborates the theoretical analysis.

Our third objective is to eliminate the high frequency catastrophic error introduced by the DP SBP FD operators [28]. Using the DP framework, it is possible to design optimised finite difference stencils such that numerical dispersion errors are significantly diminished for all wave numbers. This was the approach taken by the authors in [44] where α\alpha-DRP SBP operators were derived. These DRP SBP operators are designed to guarantee maximum relative error ≤α\le\alpha for all wave numbers. In particular the α\alpha-DRP SBP operators can resolve the highest frequency (π\pi-mode) present on any equidistant grid at a tolerance of α=5%\alpha= 5\% maximum error. For explicit schemes, these operators may provide a better resolution than any volume discretisation available today, including spectral methods, and significantly improves on the current standard for traditional operators that have a tolerance of 100% maximum error. The DRP SBP operators [44, 43] potentially eliminates the catastrophic high frequency errors. Numerical simulations performed in 3D corroborates the analysis. Our DRP SBP operators reproduces dynamic rupture benchmark problems, proposed by Southern California Earthquake Center, with less computational effort than standard methods based on traditional SBP operators.

Efficient and scalable parallel implementation is necessary for effective large scale numerical simulations. The DRP operators are implemented in the large scale code WaveQLab3D [14, 11] with near perfect scaling. The resources used is slightly larger than the 6th order upwind DP and traditional SBP schemes, but not by a large amount. We consider the DRP operators to have a marginal higher cost than the traditional and DP SBP methods.

The remaining parts of the paper will proceed as follows. In the next section, we present model equations for linear elastic solids in complex geometries and the nonlinear friction laws coupling the elastic solids at the interface. We also derive energy estimates which a stable numerical method should emulate. In § 3 we introduce the frictional gluing (hat-) variables and prove the existence and uniqueness of the hat-variables for nonlinear friction laws in general anisotropic elastic solids. In § 4, we approximate the elastic wave equation in space using the DP SBP operators, numerically enforce the friction laws using penalties and prove numerical stability. In § 5 we perform numerical error analysis. Numerical simulations are presented in § 6, corroborating the theoretical analysis. In § 7 we summarise the results.

Physical model

We consider two geometrically complex elastic solids, in the bounded domains Ω−\Omega^{-} and Ω+\Omega^{+}, separated by a smooth fault of arbitrarily shaped surface at the interface ΓF\Gamma_{\mathrm{F}}, see Figure 1. The two elastic solids, Ω−\Omega^{-} and Ω+\Omega^{+} are held together at the interface ΓF\Gamma_{\mathrm{F}} by a high level of static frictional strength. We are particularly interested in accurate modelling and efficient simulation of the dynamics of the fault-interface undergoing a nonlinear frictional sliding, when a load of finite magnitude overcomes the frictional strength at the interface, as well as the numerical computation of the emitted elastic waves propagating in the medium.

Curvilinear coordinate transform between the computational space and modelling space

Figure 1. Curvilinear coordinate transform between the computational space Ω~\tilde{\Omega} and modelling space Ω\Omega. The shaded face ΓF\Gamma_{\mathrm{F}} is a frictional interface connecting the two blocks, Ω−\Omega^{-} and Ω+\Omega^{+}, of elastic solid.

Elastic wave equation in curvilinear coordinates

As in [14, 11], for efficient numerical treatments, we map each complex elastic solids Ω±\Omega^{\pm} to a reference unit cube Ω~±\widetilde{\Omega}^{\pm} defined by the curvilinear coordinates (q,r,s)∈Ω~=[0,1]3(q,r,s) \in\widetilde{\Omega} = [0,1]^3, see Figure 1.

The Jacobian determinant for the transformation Φ−1\Phi^{-1} can be written as

J=xq(yrzs−zrys)−yq(xrzs−zrxs)+zq(xrys−yrxs).J = x_q(y_rz_s-z_ry_s)-y_q(x_rz_s-z_rx_s)+z_q(x_ry_s-y_rx_s).

Here ξη\xi_\eta is the partial derivative ∂ξ/∂η\partial\xi/\partial\eta for ξ,η∈{x,y,z,q,r,s}\xi,\eta\in\{x,y,z,q,r,s\}. Similarly,

qx=1J(yrzs−zrys),rx=1J(zqys−yqzs),sx=1J(yqzr−zqyr),qy=1J(zrxs−xrzs),ry=1J(xqzs−zqxs),sy=1J(zqxr−xqzr),qz=1J(xrys−yrxs),rz=1J(yqxs−ysxq),sz=1J(xqyr−xryq).\begin{aligned} q_x &= \frac{1}{J}(y_rz_s-z_ry_s), & r_x &= \frac{1}{J}(z_qy_s-y_qz_s), & s_x &= \frac{1}{J}(y_qz_r-z_qy_r),\\ q_y &= \frac{1}{J}(z_rx_s-x_rz_s), & r_y &= \frac{1}{J}(x_qz_s-z_qx_s), & s_y &= \frac{1}{J}(z_qx_r-x_qz_r),\\ q_z &= \frac{1}{J}(x_ry_s-y_rx_s), & r_z &= \frac{1}{J}(y_qx_s-y_sx_q), & s_z &= \frac{1}{J}(x_qy_r-x_ry_q). \end{aligned}

Let Q=(v,σ)T\mathbf{Q}=(\mathbf{v},\boldsymbol{\sigma})^T denote the unknown vector fields in the medium where σ:=(σxx,σyy,σzzσxy,σxz,σyz)T\boldsymbol{\sigma}:=(\sigma_{xx},\sigma_{yy},\sigma_{zz}\sigma_{xy},\sigma_{xz},\sigma_{yz})^T is the vector of stresses and v:=(vx,vy,vz)T\mathbf{v}:=(v_x,v_y,v_z)^T is the particle velocity vector in three space dimensions. The material parameters and the unknown vector fields in the sub-blocks Ω−\Omega^- and Ω+\Omega^+ will be denoted with the superscripts −,+-,+, respectively, that is {Q−,Q+}\{\mathbf{Q}^-,\mathbf{Q}^+\}.

Let t≥0t \ge0 be the time variable. For Q∈{Q−,Q+}\mathbf{Q} \in\{\mathbf{Q}^-,\mathbf{Q}^+\}, the equation of motion for each sub-block in the transformed curvilinear coordinates (q,r,s)(q,r,s) is given by the elastic wave equation

P~−1∂∂tQ=∇⋅F(Q)+∑ξ∈{q,r,s}Bξ(∇Q),(1)\widetilde{P}^{-1}\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\mathbf{Q}=\nabla\cdot\mathbf{F}(\mathbf{Q})+\sum_{\xi\in\{q,r,s\}}\mathbf{B}_{\xi}(\nabla\mathbf{Q}), \tag*{(1)}

where

References

  1. [1]J.D. ACHENBACH. Wave Propagation in Elastic Solids. North-Holland Series in Applied Mathematics and Mechanics. Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1975.DOI
  2. [2]DJ Andrews. Dynamic plane-strain shear rupture with a slip-weakening friction law calculated by a boundary integral method. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 75(1):1–21, 1985.DOI
  3. [3]Oded Ben-David, Gil Cohen, and Jay Fineberg. The dynamics of the onset of frictional slip. Science, 330(6001):211–214, 2010.
  4. [4]M. Benjemaa, N. Glinsky-Olivier, V. M. Cruz-Atienza, J. Virieux, and S. Piperno. Dynamic non-planar crack rupture by a finite volume method. Geophysical Journal International, 171(1):271–285, 10 2007.DOI
  5. [5]Frank Philip Bowden and David Tabor. The friction and lubrication of solids, volume 1. Oxford university press, 2001.
  6. [6]M. Carpenter and C. Kennedy. Fourth-order 2n-storage runge–kutta schemes. Technical report NASA TM-109112, NASA, Langley Research Center, Hampton, VA, 1994.
  7. [7]J. de la Puente, J.-P. Ampuero, and M. Käser. Dynamic rupture modeling on unstructured meshes using a discontinuous galerkin method. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 114(B10), 2009.DOI
  8. [8]James H Dieterich. Modeling of rock friction: 2. simulation of preseismic slip. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 84(B5):2169–2175, 1979.DOI
  9. [9]L. Dovgilovich and I. Sofronov. High-accuracy finite-difference schemes for solving elastodynamic problems in curvilinear coordinates within multi-block approach. Appl. Numer. Math., 93:176–194, 2015.
  10. [10]Eric M Dunham, Jeremy E Kozdon, David Belanger, and Lin Cong. Earthquake ruptures on rough faults. In Multiscale and Multiphysics Processes in Geomechanics, pages 145–148. Springer, 2011.DOI
  11. [11]K. Duru and E. M. Dunham. Dynamic earthquake rupture simulations on nonplanar faults embedded in 3d geometrically complex, heterogeneous elastic solids. J. Comput. Phys., 305:185–207, 2016.
  12. [12]K. Duru, J. E. Kozdon, and G. Kreiss. Boundary conditions and stability of a perfectly matched layer for the elastic wave equation in first order form. J. Comput. Phys., 303:372–395, 2015.
  13. [13]K. Duru, L. Rannabauer, A.-A. Gabriel, G. Kreiss, and M. Bader. A stable discontinuous galerkin method for the perfectly matched layer for elastodynamics in first order form. https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.06380, 2019.
  14. [14]Kenneth Duru, Frederick Fung, and Christopher Williams. Dual-pairing summation by parts finite difference methods for large scale elastic wave simulations in 3d complex geometries. Journal of Computational Physics, 454:110966, 2022.DOI
  15. [15]Kenneth Duru, Leonhard Rannabauer, Alice-Agnes Gabriel, and Heiner Igel. A new discontinuous galerkin method for elastic waves with physically motivated numerical fluxes. Journal of Scientific Computing, 88, 2021.DOI
  16. [16]Kenneth Duru, Leonhard Rannabauer, Alice-Agnes Gabriel, On Ki Angel Ling, Heiner Igel, and Michael Bader. A stable discontinuous galerkin method for linear elastodynamics in 3d geometrically complex elastic solids using physics based numerical fluxes. Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, 389:114386, 2022.DOI
  17. [17]Falk, M. L., Needleman, A., and Rice, J. R. A critical evaluation of cohesive zone models of dynamic fractur. J. Phys. IV France, 11:43–50, 2001.DOI
  18. [18]L.B. Freund. The mechanics of dynamic shear crack propagation. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 84(B5):2199–2209, 1979. Cited by: 222.DOI
  19. [19]Philippe H. Geubelle and James R. Rice. A spectral method for three-dimensional elastodynamic fracture problems. Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids, 43(11):1791–1824, 1995.DOI
  20. [20]R. A. Harris, M. Barall, R. Archuleta, E. Dunham, B. Aagaard, J. P. Ampuero, H. Bhat, V. Cruz-Atienza, L. Dalguer, P. Dawson, S. Day, B. Duan, G. Ely, Y. Kaneko, Y. Kase, N. Lapusta, Y. Liu, S. Ma, D. Oglesby, K. Olsen, A. Pitarka, S. Song, and E. Templeton. The SCEC/USGS Dynamic Earthquake Rupture Code Verification Exercise. Seismological Research Letters, 80(1):119–126, 01 2009.
  21. [21]Ruth A. Harris, Michael Barall, Brad Aagaard, Shuo Ma, Daniel Roten, Kim Olsen, Benchun Duan, Dunyu Liu, Bin Luo, Kangchen Bai, Jean-Paul Ampuero, Yoshihiro Kaneko, Alice-Agnes Gabriel, Kenneth Duru, Thomas Ulrich, Stephanie Wollher, Zheqiang Shi, Eric Dunham, Sam Bydlon, Zhenguo Zhang, Xiaofei Chen, Surendra Nadh Somala, Christian Pelties, Josué Tago, Victor Manuel Cruz-Atienza, Jeremy Kozdon, Eric Daub, Khurram Aslam, Yuko Kase, Kyle Withers, and Luis Dalguer. A Suite of Exercises for Verifying Dynamic Earthquake Rupture Codes. Seismological Research Letters, 89(3):1146–1162, 04 2018.DOI
  22. [22]Y. Kaneko, N. Lapusta, and J.-P. Ampuero. Spectral element modeling of spontaneous earthquake rupture on rate and state faults: Effect of velocity-strengthening friction at shallow depths. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 113(B9), 2008.DOI
  23. [23]Boris V Kostrov and Shamita Das. Principles of earthquake source mechanics. Cambridge University Press, 1988.
  24. [24]Jeremy E. Kozdon, Eric M. Dunham, and Jan Nordström. Simulation of Dynamic Earthquake Ruptures in Complex Geometries Using High-Order Finite Difference Methods. Journal of Scientific Computing, 55:92–124, 05 2013.DOI
  25. [25]R. Madariaga, K. Olsen, and R. Archuleta. Modeling dynamic rupture in a 3D earthquake fault model. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 88(5):1182–1197, 10 1998.DOI
  26. [26]J. E. Marsden and T. J. R. Hughes. Mathematical Foundations of Elasticity. Dover Publications Inc. New York, 1994.
  27. [27]K. Mattsson. Boundary procedures for summation-by-parts operators. J. Sci. Comput., 18:133–153, 2003.DOI
  28. [28]K. Mattsson. Diagonal-norm upwind sbp operators. J. Comput. Phys., 335:283–310, 2017.DOI
  29. [29]S. Abarbanel M.H. Carpenter, D. Gottlieb. Time-stable boundary conditions for finite-difference schemes solving hyperbolic systems: methodology and application to high-order compact schemes. J. Comput. Phys., 111:220–236, 1994.
  30. [30]J. Nordström and M.H. Carpenter. High-order finite difference methods, multidimensional linear problems. J. Comput. Phys., 173:149–174, 2001.
  31. [31]David D. Oglesby, Ralph J. Archuleta, and Stefan B. Nielsen. Earthquakes on dipping faults: The effects of broken symmetry. Science, 280(5366):1055–1059, 1998.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9582114
  32. [32]David D. Oglesby, Ralph J. Archuleta, and Stefan B. Nielsen. The Three-Dimensional Dynamics of Dipping Faults. Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, 90(3):616–628, 06 2000.DOI
  33. [33]Christian Pelties, Josep de la Puente, Jean-Paul Ampuero, Gilbert B. Brietzke, and Martin Käser. Three-dimensional dynamic rupture simulation with a high-order discontinuous galerkin method on unstructured tetrahedral meshes. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 117(B2), 2012.DOI
  34. [34]Marlon D Ramos and Yihe Huang. How the transition region along the cascadia megathrust influences coseismic behavior: Insights from 2-d dynamic rupture simulations. Geophysical Research Letters, 46(4):1973–1983, 2019.DOI
  35. [35]J. R. Rice. Constitutive relations for fault slip and earthquake instabilities. J. Appl. Mech., 50:443–475, 1983.
  36. [36]J. R. Rice and A. L. Ruina. Stability of Steady Frictional Slipping. Journal of Applied Mechanics, 50(2):343–349, 06 1983.DOI
  37. [37]Andy Ruina. Slip instability and state variable friction laws. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 88(B12):10359–10370, 1983.DOI
  38. [38]The SCEC/USGS. Spontaneous rupture code verification project. URL, 2022. https://strike.scec.org/cvws/.
  39. [39]C. H. Scholz. Earthquakes and friction laws. Nature, 391:37–42, 1998.DOI
  40. [40]Zheqiang Shi and Steven M Day. Rupture dynamics and ground motion from 3-d rough-fault simulations. Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth, 118(3):1122–1141, 2013.DOI
  41. [41]B. Strand. Summation by parts for finite difference approximations for d/dx. J. Comput. Phys., 110:47–67, 1994.
  42. [42]Ilya Svetlizky and Jay Fineberg. Classical shear cracks drive the onset of dry frictional motion. Nature, 509:205–208, 05 2014.DOI
  43. [43]C. Williams. Dispersion relation preserving fd schemes and self-affine dg elements. Master’s thesis, The Australian National University, 2021.DOI
  44. [44]C. Williams and K. Duru. Probably stable full-spectrum dispersion relation preserving schemes, 2021.arxiv.org/abs/2110.04957

Paper details

vlnc:W_ptn8bfj8
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents