betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Mono-Z Signatures of Vector Dark Matter Detection at Future Electron-Positron Colliders: FCC-ee and ILC

Abstract

We investigate the mono-ZZ signature of a vector dark matter (VDM) model at future electron-positron colliders. In this model, a stable vector boson, arising from an extended U(1)U(1) gauge symmetry, serves as a viable DM candidate that interacts with the Standard Model (SM) through a Higgs portal. We perform a detailed cut-based analysis for the mono-ZZ channel at the FCC-ee (with s=240\sqrt{s}=240 and 365365 GeV) and the ILC (with s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV), considering both leptonic and hadronic decays of the ZZ boson. Signal significances are evaluated for benchmark points using fast event simulation with MadGraph5, PYTHIA8, and Delphes3. Our results demonstrate that future e+e−e^+e^- colliders provide excellent sensitivity to Higgs-portal VDM, with the ILC's beam polarization offering an additional handle to suppress SM backgrounds. This study highlights the potential of lepton colliders in probing DM interactions.

Introduction

The nature of dark matter (DM) remains one of the most important open questions in particle physics and cosmology; see [1, 2] for recent reviews. Within the standard cosmological framework, DM accounts for approximately 27% of the total energy density of the Universe, with a cold DM abundance of ΩDMh2≃0.120\Omega_{\mathrm{DM}}h^2 \simeq0.120 [3]. Despite the success of the Standard Model (SM) in describing elementary particles and their interactions, it contains no viable candidate for this component. Identifying the particle nature of DM therefore remains a central motivation for physics beyond the SM.

The search for DM relies on complementary approaches involving direct detection, indirect detection, and collider experiments. Collider searches provide an opportunity to produce DM particles in a controlled environment and investigate their interactions with SM particles. Their production rates do not depend on the local DM density or velocity distribution, and their interpretation does not require assumptions about the Galactic halo profile. If DM particles are produced in association with a visible object, their escape from the detector leads to an imbalance in the measured momentum. Such signatures allow collider experiments to constrain the interactions connecting the visible and dark sectors, including processes mediated by additional particles that may also be produced on shell. Collider measurements thus provide information complementary to the scattering and annihilation processes probed by direct and indirect searches.

Among the many proposed scenarios, DM models based on an extended gauge sector offer a theoretically well motivated framework. In particular, vector DM (VDM)—A stable vector boson from a spontaneously broken U(1)DU(1)_{D} gauge symmetry can serve as VDM—has gained attention due to its minimality and testability. The VDM paradigm has been extensively studied in the context of hidden sectors and dark gauge symmetries [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9]. In this work, we consider a VDM model where the dark sector communicates with the SM particles exclusively through a Higgs portal interaction, with a Z2Z_{2} symmetry ensuring DM stability. The model introduces only three new free parameters: the dark gauge coupling gvg_{v}, the VDM mass MVM_{V}, and the additional scalar mass MH2M_{H_{2}}. This framework is fully developed in our previous works [10, 11, 12]. Other important studies on VDM and related Higgs portal scenarios have been carried out in Refs. [13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27].

Future electron-positron colliders, such as the FCC-ee and the ILC, provide an exceptionally clean environment for probing such weakly interacting dark sector particles [28, 29]. Unlike hadron colliders, lepton colliders feature well-defined initial states, negligible QCD backgrounds, and precise missing energy measurements. These advantages make mono-XX searches (with X=Z,γ,W,h,jX = Z, \gamma, W, h, j) powerful channels for discovering or constraining DM production. The FCC-ee, as part of the Future Circular Collider study at CERN, is designed to operate at center-of-mass energies ranging from 90 to 365 GeV with unprecedented luminosity, reaching integrated luminosities of up to 5 ab−1^{-1} at 240 GeV, and 1.5 ab−1^{-1} at 365 GeV. The ILC, proposed to be built in Japan, is planned to operate at s=250\sqrt{s} = 250 GeV, 500 GeV, and 1 TeV, with the capability of longitudinally polarized electron and positron beams, providing a powerful handle to suppress SM backgrounds and enhance signal sensitivity. Among the possible missing-energy signatures, the mono-ZZ channel is particularly well motivated [30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35]. A further motivation is the interplay with Higgs precision physics. At e+e−e^{+}e^{-} colliders the process e+e−→ZH1e^{+}e^{-} \to ZH_{1} allows the Higgs production rate to be measured model-independently from the mass recoiling against the ZZ boson, Mrec2=s−2sEZ+mZ2M_{\mathrm{rec}}^{2} = s - 2\sqrt{s}E_{Z} + m_{Z}^{2}, irrespective of the Higgs decay mode, and hence also gives direct access to invisible Higgs decays [36, 37]. The mono-ZZ search studied here is the natural generalisation of this measurement to the case where the recoil system is the pair VVVV produced by H1H_{1}, by the second scalar H2H_{2}, or through the non-resonant continuum.

In this paper, we focus on the mono-ZZ signature: e+e−→ZVVe^{+}e^{-} \to ZVV where the ZZ boson decays leptonically (Z→ℓ+ℓ−Z \to\ell^{+}\ell^{-} with ℓ=e,μ\ell= e,\mu) or hadronically (Z→jjZ \to jj), and the VDM particles VV escape detection, resulting in missing energy and momentum. We perform a detailed cut-based analysis for the FCC-ee at center-of-mass energies s=240\sqrt{s} = 240 and 365 GeV, as well as for the ILC at 1 TeV, including the impact of beam polarization. Signal and background events are generated using MadGraph5 [38], showered and hadronized with PYTHIA8 [39], and passed through a fast detector simulation with Delphes3 [40] using the IDEA [41] and ILCgen detector configuration cards. Signal significances are evaluated for benchmark points with VDM masses ranging from 30 to 250 GeV and heavy scalar masses from 90 to 600 GeV. Our results demonstrate the sensitivity of future lepton colliders to VDM in the Higgs portal framework.

The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, we briefly describe the VDM model, including its Lagrangian, scalar potential, and the relevant free parameters, as well as theoretical and experimental constraints. Section 3 is devoted to DM searches at lepton colliders, with a detailed cut-based analysis for the mono-ZZ channel at the FCC-ee. This section is divided into the leptonic mode and the hadronic mode, including event generation, selection cuts, and signal significance calculations for two center-of-mass energies. Section 4 extends the analysis to the ILC at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV, highlighting the impact of beam polarization on enhancing signal sensitivity and suppressing SM backgrounds. Finally, Section 5 presents our conclusions.

The Model

Here, we briefly introduce the main sectors of the model, which is fully developed in Refs. [11, 12]. The model extends the SM by a dark sector in which the UD(1)U_D(1) Abelian gauge symmetry is spontaneously broken via the dark Higgs mechanism. A complex scalar field SS, which carries a unit charge under UD(1)U_D(1), and the UD(1)U_D(1) gauge field VμV_\mu are introduced. Additionally, we suppose a Z2Z_2 symmetry under which the vector field VμV_\mu and the scalar field SS transform as follows:

Vμ→−Vμ,S→S∗(1)V_\mu\to-V_\mu,\qquad S \to S^* \tag*{(1)}

To ensure the stability of the DM candidate, we assume that any kinetic mixing between the vector field VμV_\mu and the SM U(1)U(1) gauge boson BμB_\mu (i.e., terms like VμνBμνV_{\mu\nu}B^{\mu\nu}) is forbidden. Thus, the vector field VμV_\mu serves as a viable DM candidate. The total Lagrangian of the model is given by:

L=LSM−14VμνVμν+(Dμ′S)∗(D′μS)−V(H,S),(2)\mathcal{L}=\mathcal{L}_{SM}-\frac{1}{4}V_{\mu\nu}V^{\mu\nu}+(D'_\mu S)^*(D'^\mu S)-V(H,S), \tag*{(2)}

where LSM\mathcal{L}_{SM} is the Standard Model Lagrangian excluding the Higgs potential term. The covariant derivative and field strength of VμV_\mu are defined as:

Dμ′S=(∂μ+igVVμ)S,Vμν=∂μVν−∂νVμ.(3)\begin{aligned} D'_\mu S&=(\partial_\mu+ig_VV_\mu)S,\\ V_{\mu\nu}&=\partial_\mu V_\nu-\partial_\nu V_\mu. \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

The scalar potential, which is renormalizable and invariant under both gauge and Z2Z_2 symmetries, takes the form:

V(H,S)=−μH2H†H−μS2S∗S+λH(H†H)2+λS(S∗S)2+λSH(S∗S)(H†H).(4)V(H,S)=-\mu_H^2H^\dagger H-\mu_S^2S^*S+\lambda_H(H^\dagger H)^2+\lambda_S(S^*S)^2+\lambda_{SH}(S^*S)(H^\dagger H). \tag*{(4)}

The quartic interaction λSH(S∗S)(H†H)\lambda_{SH}(S^*S)(H^\dagger H) represents the only interaction between the dark sector and the SM. After electroweak symmetry breaking [11, 12], the parameters of the model are given by:

ν2=MVgv,sin⁡α=ν1ν12+ν22,λH=cos⁡2αMH12+sin⁡2αMH222ν12,λS=sin⁡2αMH12+cos⁡2αMH222ν22,λSH=(MH22−MH12)sin⁡αcos⁡αν1ν2.(5)\begin{aligned} \nu_2 &= \frac{M_V}{g_v}, \\ \sin\alpha&= \frac{\nu_1}{\sqrt{\nu_1^2+\nu_2^2}}, \\ \lambda_H &= \frac{\cos^2\alpha M_{H_1}^2+\sin^2\alpha M_{H_2}^2}{2\nu_1^2}, \\ \lambda_S &= \frac{\sin^2\alpha M_{H_1}^2+\cos^2\alpha M_{H_2}^2}{2\nu_2^2}, \\ \lambda_{SH} &= \frac{(M_{H_2}^2-M_{H_1}^2)\sin\alpha\cos\alpha}{\nu_1\nu_2}. \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

Here, α\alpha is the mixing angle between weak eigenstates and mass eigenstates, and ν1\nu_1 and ν2\nu_2 are the vacuum expectation values (vevs) of the Higgs fields. The mass eigenstates of the Higgs fields can be written as:

MH2,H12=λHν12+λSν22±(λHν12−λSν22)2+λSH2ν12ν22,(6)M_{H_2,H_1}^2=\lambda_H\nu_1^2+\lambda_S\nu_2^2\pm\sqrt{(\lambda_H\nu_1^2-\lambda_S\nu_2^2)^2+\lambda_{SH}^2\nu_1^2\nu_2^2}, \tag*{(6)}

where we assume MH1=125M_{H_1}=125 GeV and ν1=246\nu_1=246 GeV. It is noteworthy that this construction is minimal, introducing only three new free parameters: the coupling gvg_v and the mass parameters MH2M_{H_2} and MVM_V.

Several remarks on the model are useful for the collider analysis below. (i) The transformation above acts as a dark charge conjugation: it forbids the kinetic mixing VμνBμνV_{\mu\nu}B^{\mu\nu} and any interaction with an odd number of VV fields, so that VV is stable and is always produced in pairs, as in e+e−→ZVVe^+e^-\to ZVV. (ii) After spontaneous symmetry breaking the vector acquires the mass MV=gvν2M_V=g_v\nu_2, which is the origin of the relation ν2=MV/gv\nu_2=M_V/g_v above; the Goldstone mode becomes its longitudinal polarisation. (iii) The physical scalars H1H_1 and H2H_2 are mixtures of the doublet and singlet components. In a generic mixing scenario, their couplings to SM particles are the SM ones rescaled by cos⁡α\cos\alpha and sin⁡α\sin\alpha, respectively (up to convention), while their couplings to the dark vector are proportional to gvMVg_vM_V times the complementary mixing factor.

Furthermore, we examine both theoretical and experimental constraints on the parameter space of the model. Theoretical constraints include conditions such as perturbativity, unitarity, and positivity of the potential, as discussed in [11]. Experimental constraints include relic density measurements and direct detection bounds.

DM Searches at Lepton Colliders

Lepton colliders provide a particularly clean experimental environment for probing DM particles, offering distinct advantages over hadron colliders. Unlike hadron machines, where large quantum chromodynamics (QCD) backgrounds, proton remnants, and pile-up effects obscure missing energy signatures, lepton colliders feature well-defined initial states, negligible QCD activity, and essentially no pile-up. These favorable conditions enable precise measurements of missing energy, an observable largely inaccessible at hadron colliders, as well as missing transverse momentum, both of which are key kinematic variables in DM searches. Moreover, the low-background environment facilitates model-independent mono-X searches (with X=γ,Z,W,hX = \gamma, Z, W, h, or jj), wherein DM particles are produced in association with a visible recoil object. These channels significantly improve sensitivity to weakly interacting dark-sector particles, establishing lepton colliders as a powerful complement to hadron colliders in the global DM search program. In this section, we focus on DM searches at future lepton colliders, specifically the FCC-ee and the ILC, via the mono-Z channel. Several studies have explored lepton collider signatures of DM [31, 32, 33, 34, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74].

Kinematic variables. The initial four-momentum is known at an e+e−e^+e^- collider, so the invariant mass of the invisible system recoiling against a visible system of energy EvisE_{\mathrm{vis}} and invariant mass mvism_{\mathrm{vis}} can be reconstructed event by event,

Mrec2=(pe++pe−−pvis)2=s−2sEvis+mvis2=2s E̸−s+mvis2(7)M_{\mathrm{rec}}^2 = (p_{e^+} + p_{e^-} - p_{\mathrm{vis}})^2 = s - 2\sqrt{s}E_{\mathrm{vis}} + m_{\mathrm{vis}}^2 = 2\sqrt{s}\,\not{E} - s + m_{\mathrm{vis}}^2 \tag*{(7)}

where E̸=s−Evis\not{E} = \sqrt{s} - E_{\mathrm{vis}} is the missing energy used in the cuts below. For the signal, MrecM_{\mathrm{rec}} is the invariant mass of the VVVV pair: it shows resonant peaks at MH1M_{H_1} and MH2M_{H_2} (when MHi>2MVM_{H_i} > 2M_V) on top of a non-resonant continuum, whereas for ZZ→ννˉℓ+ℓ−ZZ \to\nu\bar{\nu}\ell^+\ell^- it peaks at mZm_Z and for WWWW it is broad. For a given visible mass, a cut on E̸\not{E} is therefore equivalent to a cut on MrecM_{\mathrm{rec}}.

Mono-Z Channel at the FCC-ee at s=240,365 GeV\sqrt{s}=240,365\ \mathrm{GeV}

Here, we briefly explain our simulation procedure for generating signal and background events in the mono-Z channel at e+e−e^+e^- colliders. Based on the decay modes of the ZZ boson, we consider leptonic ZZ decays into a charged-lepton pair and hadronic ZZ decays into a quark-antiquark pair reconstructed as two jets, where the ZZ boson decays into two charged leptons and two jets, respectively. For the signal simulation, we generated the UFO model file by using LanHEP [75], and then generated 500000 events using MadGraph5 [38] for both signal and backgrounds. PYTHIA8 [39] is used to perform parton showering, hadronization, and decay processes. A fast detector simulation of these events is done using Delphes3 [40] with the IDEA configuration card [41]. We also perform our analysis at the FCC-ee center-of-mass energies s=240\sqrt{s}=240 and 365365 GeV, assuming integrated luminosity of Lint=5000\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{int}}=5000 and 1500 fb−11500\ \mathrm{fb}^{-1}, respectively.

Leptonic mode

For the charged leptonic decay of the ZZ boson, the process e+e−→VVZ,(Z→ℓ+ℓ−)e^+e^- \to VVZ,(Z \to\ell^+\ell^-) is considered. Its tree-level Feynman diagram is shown in Figure 1. Only ℓ=e,μ\ell=e,\mu are considered, and τ\tau-lepton is not included for simplicity. For the signal production of VVZVVZ, the final state looks like ℓℓ+E̸\ell\ell+\not{E}, where the missing energy (E̸\not{E}) is carried away by VDM particles. The main SM background for this channel is e+e−→ℓ+ℓ−ννˉe^+e^- \to\ell^+\ell^-\nu\bar{\nu}, which comes from the processes of e+e−→W+W−e^+e^- \to W^+W^- and e+e−→ZZe^+e^- \to ZZ, with the leptonic decays of the vector bosons. Subleading SM sources of ℓℓ+E̸\ell\ell+\not{E} are e+e−→τ+τ−e^+e^- \to\tau^+\tau^- with leptonic τ\tau decays, which gives softer lepton pairs that do not peak at mZm_Z (strongly reduced by Cut 2), the radiative-return process e+e−→ℓ+ℓ−γe^+e^- \to\ell^+\ell^-\gamma with the photon lost along the beam pipe (see the kinematic argument below), and two-photon processes, which carry little missing energy (reduced by Cuts 3 and 4).

Figure 1. Feynman diagrams for DM production for the mono-Z channel. Depending on the decay mode of the ZZ boson, ff can be leptons (ℓ±≡e±,μ±\ell^\pm\equiv e^\pm,\mu^\pm) or jets (j≡u,c,d,s,bj \equiv u,c,d,s,b).

MV(GeV)M_V(\mathrm{GeV})MH2(GeV)M_{H_2}(\mathrm{GeV})σ(fb)\sigma(\mathrm{fb})SS
BP13090160.336.20 (1.50)
BP2501402143.25 (4.48)
BP360170512.68 (1.22)
νℓνˉℓℓ+ℓ−\nu_\ell\bar{\nu}_\ell\ell^+\ell^-983.7

Table 1. Cross sections σ\sigma (in fb) and signal significances SS after all cuts in the charged leptonic channel at s=240\sqrt{s}=240 GeV are shown. The significances are computed by assuming an integrated luminosity of 5 ab−1ab^{-1}. The values in the parentheses denote the significances with 5% background systematic uncertainty. The value of gv=0.1g_v=0.1.

Cut Based Analysis

To enhance the signal-to-background ratio, a cut-based analysis is performed. Both signal and background events are generated using a baseline selection: PTℓ>2P_{T\ell}>2 GeV and ∣ηℓ∣<3.5|\eta_\ell|<3.5. The selection cuts for two collision energies are summarized in Table 2.

s\sqrt{s}240 GeV365 GeV
Baseline selectionOSSF lepton-pairs with PTℓ>2P_{T_\ell}>2 GeV, ∣ηℓ∣<3.5|\eta_\ell|<3.5
BP1
Cut 1OSSF lepton-pairs with PTℓ>10P_{T_\ell}>10 GeV, ∣ηℓ∣<2.8|\eta_\ell|<2.8
Cut 28080 GeV ≤mℓℓ≤100\le m_{\ell\ell}\le100 GeV
Cut 3̸ET>10\not{E}_{T}>10 GeV̸ET>15\not{E}_{T}>15 GeV
Cut 4E̸>120\not{E}>120 GeVE̸>190\not{E}>190 GeV
BP2
Cut 1OSSF lepton-pairs with PTℓ>10P_{T_\ell}>10 GeV, ∣ηℓ∣<2.8|\eta_\ell|<2.8
Cut 28080 GeV ≤mℓℓ≤100\le m_{\ell\ell}\le100 GeV
Cut 3̸ET>10\not{E}_{T}>10 GeV̸ET>15\not{E}_{T}>15 GeV
Cut 4E̸>140\not{E}>140 GeVE̸>190\not{E}>190 GeV
BP3
Cut 1OSSF lepton-pairs with PTℓ>10P_{T_\ell}>10 GeV, ∣ηℓ∣<2.8|\eta_\ell|<2.8
Cut 28080 GeV ≤mℓℓ≤100\le m_{\ell\ell}\le100 GeV
Cut 3̸ET>10\not{E}_{T}>10 GeV̸ET>15\not{E}_{T}>15 GeV
Cut 4E̸>140\not{E}>140 GeVE̸>190\not{E}>190 GeV

Table 2. Selection cuts for different BPs in the charged leptonic channel for two FCC collision energies are shown.

In the following, a detailed discussion of the selection cuts is provided.

  • Cut 1: Events are requested to contain two opposite-sign, same-flavor (OSSF) leptons, each with PTℓ>10P_{T\ell}>10 GeV and ∣ηℓ∣<2.8|\eta_\ell|<2.8. Events are vetoed if they contain any additional hard lepton, tau lepton, photon, or hadronic jet with PT>10P_T>10 GeV and

∣η∣<2.8|\eta| < 2.8. This acceptance cut selects potential events arising from the leptonic decay of the ZZ bosons.

  • Cut 2: The invariant mass of the selected OSSF leptons (MℓℓM_{\ell\ell}) must be consistent with the leptonic decay of a ZZ boson: ∣mℓℓ−mZ∣≤10 GeV|m_{\ell\ell} - m_Z| \le10\ \mathrm{GeV}.

  • Cut 3: The events are asked to have the missing transverse energy, ̸ET>10 GeV\not{E}_T > 10\ \mathrm{GeV} for s=240 GeV\sqrt{s} = 240\ \mathrm{GeV} and ̸ET>15 GeV\not{E}_T > 15\ \mathrm{GeV} for s=365 GeV\sqrt{s} = 365\ \mathrm{GeV}. The ̸ET\not{E}_T defined as:

̸ET=(∑visiblepx)2+(∑visiblepy)2.\not{E}_T = \sqrt{\left(\sum_{\mathrm{visible}} p_x\right)^2 + \left(\sum_{\mathrm{visible}} p_y\right)^2}.

where pxp_x and pyp_y are the x and y components of the momenta of all visible final-state particles.

  • Cut 4: The last variable is the missing energy (E̸\not{E}), which is reconstructed using the energy of the initial and final objects. The missing energy is defined as:

E̸=s−∑visibleE.\not{E} = \sqrt{s} - \sum_{\mathrm{visible}} E.

where EE is the energy of each visible final-state particle, and s\sqrt{s} is the center-of-mass energy of the collision.

For the leptonic mode, the thresholds on E̸\not{E} can be translated into recoil-mass thresholds with Mrec2=2s E̸−s+mℓℓ2M_{\mathrm{rec}}^2 = 2\sqrt{s}\,\not{E} - s + m_{\ell\ell}^2, which helps to interpret them physically. Setting mℓℓ=mZm_{\ell\ell} = m_Z, the thresholds of Table 2, E̸>140 GeV\not{E} > 140\ \mathrm{GeV} at s=240 GeV\sqrt{s} = 240\ \mathrm{GeV} and E̸>190 GeV\not{E} > 190\ \mathrm{GeV} at s=365 GeV\sqrt{s} = 365\ \mathrm{GeV}, correspond to Mrec≳134 GeVM_{\mathrm{rec}} \gtrsim134\ \mathrm{GeV} and Mrec≳117 GeVM_{\mathrm{rec}} \gtrsim117\ \mathrm{GeV}, respectively. At 240 GeV the selection therefore retains the H2H_2 resonance of BP2 and BP3 (140 and 170 GeV) but removes the H1H_1 peak at 125 GeV and the 90 GeV resonance of BP1; at 365 GeV it also retains the H1H_1 peak but still removes the resonance of BP1. This is consistent with the much lower signal efficiencies of BP1 than of BP2 and BP3 in Table 3 and Table 4, and suggests that a benchmark-dependent threshold or a fit of the full MrecM_{\mathrm{rec}} distribution could improve the reach for BP1. In addition, both thresholds exceed the kinematic endpoint Eγmax⁡=(s−mZ2)/(2s)≃103 GeVE_\gamma^{\max} = (s - m_Z^2)/(2\sqrt{s}) \simeq103\ \mathrm{GeV} (171 GeV) at s=240\sqrt{s} = 240 (365) GeV of radiative-return events e+e−→Zγe^+e^- \to Z\gamma in which the photon escapes along the beam pipe, so this reducible background is removed by Cut 4 in the leptonic mode.

Selection cutsννℓ+ℓ−\nu\nu\ell^{+}\ell^{-} BP1ννℓ+ℓ−\nu\nu\ell^{+}\ell^{-} BP2ννℓ+ℓ−\nu\nu\ell^{+}\ell^{-} BP3Signal BP1Signal BP2Signal BP3
Baseline Selection427424 (100%)452527 (100%)452688 (100%)452975 (100%)
After final cut25420 (5.95%)4590 (1.07%)4590 (1.07%)11709 (2.59%)48441 (10.70%)55503 (12.25%)

Table 3. Cut-flow table for different BPs for the leptonic mono-Z signal and background for s=240\sqrt{s}=240 GeV FCC-ee.

Selection cutsννℓ+ℓ−\nu\nu\ell^{+}\ell^{-} BP1ννℓ+ℓ−\nu\nu\ell^{+}\ell^{-} BP2ννℓ+ℓ−\nu\nu\ell^{+}\ell^{-} BP3Signal BP1Signal BP2Signal BP3
Baseline Selection387150 (100%)468512 (100%)468208 (100%)468379 (100%)
After final cut13914 (3.59%)13914 (3.59%)13914 (3.59%)19614 (4.19%)375811 (80.27%)405144 (86.50%)

Table 4. Cut-flow table for different BPs for the leptonic mono-Z signal and background for s=365\sqrt{s}=365 GeV FCC-ee.

The distributions of the variables which are used to select the events are shown in Figure 2 for both center of mass energies of 240 and 365 GeV.

(a) (a) ̸ET\not E_T

Distribution of missing transverse energy at $\sqrt{s}=365$ GeV

(b) (b) ̸ET\not E_T

(c) (c) MllM_{ll}

Distribution of dilepton invariant mass at $\sqrt{s}=365$ GeV

(d) (d) MllM_{ll}

(e) (e) MissE

Distribution of missing energy at $\sqrt{s}=365$ GeV

(f) (f) MissE

Figure 2. Simulated signal and background events for leptonic mono-Z production at s=240\sqrt{s}=240 GeV (left) and s=365\sqrt{s}=365 GeV (right).

To examine the discovery potential of the model, 3 benchmark points (BP’s) are defined. The specifications of BP’s are shown in Tab. 1 and Table 5 for both s=240 GeV\sqrt{s} = 240\ \mathrm{GeV}, and 365 GeV, respectively.

MVM_V (GeV)MH2M_{H_2} (GeV)σ\sigma (fb)SS
BP13090736.1155.34 (24.83)
BP25014096.8288.03 (61.90)
BP36017026.4124.41 (18.43)
νℓνˉℓℓ+ℓ−\nu_\ell\bar{\nu}_\ell\ell^+\ell^-825

Table 5. Cross sections σ\sigma (in fb) and signal significances SS after all cuts in the charged leptonic channel at s=365\sqrt{s}=365 GeV are shown. The significances are computed by assuming an integrated luminosity of 1.5 ab−1ab^{-1}. The values in the parentheses denote the significances with 5% background systematic uncertainty. The value of gV=0.1g_V=0.1.

In Table 3 and Table 4, the number of events and efficiencies after baseline selection and final selection cuts for both background and signal for different BP’s for both s=240 GeV\sqrt{s} = 240\ \mathrm{GeV} and 365 GeV are shown, respectively.

Signal Significance

After applying all cuts, we calculate the final signal significance for our benchmark scenarios using the definition:

S=SS+∑i(Bi+ϵi2Bi2)(8)S=\frac{S}{\sqrt{S+\sum_i(B_i+\epsilon_i^2 B_i^2)}} \tag*{(8)}

where SS and BiB_i are the number of signal and (iith channel) background events, respectively, for a given integrated luminosity, and ϵi\epsilon_i is the corresponding systematic uncertainty in the background estimation. Our results for the final signal significance for the three BPs are shown in Tabs. 1, Table 5. We show the significance for an ideal case with zero systematic uncertainty and, in parentheses, for a more conservative case with 5% relative systematic uncertainty applied to the dominant and subdominant backgrounds, respectively. We also tabulate the cross sections of backgrounds and signals.

Two properties of Eq. (8) help in reading the results. For ϵi=0\epsilon_i=0 it reduces to S/S+BS/\sqrt{S+B} and grows as Lint\sqrt{L_{\mathrm{int}}}. In the systematics-dominated regime, ϵB≫S+B\epsilon B\gg\sqrt{S+B}, it saturates at S→S/(ϵB)S\to S/(\epsilon B), independent of the luminosity; for instance, from the cross sections and efficiencies of the tables the hadronic BP1 at 240 GeV has S/B≃8S/B\simeq8, so S≃150S\simeq150 for ϵ=5%\epsilon=5\% is close to (S/B)/ϵ≃155(S/B)/\epsilon\simeq155, while the leptonic BP2 at 240 GeV has S/B≃0.2S/B\simeq0.2 and S≃4.5S\simeq4.5, close to (S/B)/ϵ≃4.3(S/B)/\epsilon\simeq4.3. Since S/BS/B is of order one or larger for several benchmark points, the Asimov expression SA=2[(S+B)ln⁡(1+S/B)−S]S_A=\sqrt{2[(S+B)\ln(1+S/B)-S]} is more accurate than S/S+BS/\sqrt{S+B} and can be used as a cross-check [76]. With the usual conventions of S≃1.64S\simeq1.64 for a 95% CL exclusion and S=5S=5 for a discovery, the leptonic mode with 5% systematics is below the exclusion level for BP1 and BP3 and below discovery for BP2 at 240 GeV, but all three benchmarks exceed 18σ18\sigma at 365 GeV; the hadronic mode reaches 5σ5\sigma for all benchmarks at both energies (BP3 at 240 GeV is marginal, S=4.98S=4.98). Because the two ZZ decay modes are statistically independent, they can be combined in quadrature, Scomb=Sℓℓ2+Sjj2S_{\mathrm{comb}}=\sqrt{S_{\ell\ell}^2+S_{jj}^2}; this gives Scomb≃533,155,47S_{\mathrm{comb}}\simeq533, 155, 47 (BP1–BP3) at 240 GeV and ≃2358,875,385\simeq2358, 875, 385 at 365 GeV without systematics, and ≃150,21.5,5.1\simeq150, 21.5, 5.1 and ≃966,156,42\simeq966, 156, 42 with 5% systematics, i.e. the combination is dominated by the hadronic mode.

Hadronic mode

In the hadronic channel, we look at the process e+e−→VVZe^{+}e^{-} \to VVZ, Z→jjZ \to jj, where j≡u,d,s,c,bj \equiv\mathrm{u}, \mathrm{d}, \mathrm{s}, \mathrm{c}, \mathrm{b} quarks (as shown in Figure 1). The dominant SM background processes for this channel are e+e−→νℓνˉℓjje^{+}e^{-} \to\nu_{\ell}\bar{\nu}_{\ell}jj, and e+e−→νℓℓjje^{+}e^{-} \to\nu_{\ell}\ell jj.

Cut Based Analysis

We simulate the events for both signals and backgrounds with basic cuts to the parameter space: PTj>5P_{T_j} > 5 GeV, and ∣ηj∣<3.5|\eta_j| < 3.5. After obtaining cross-sections for both signal and background, as reported in Table 9, Table 10 for s=240\sqrt{s} = 240 GeV and 365 GeV, respectively, we proceed with our cut-based analysis to optimize the signal significance, as we explain in more detail in the following.

MVM_V (GeV)MH2M_{H_2} (GeV)σ\sigma (fb)SS
BP130901620531.47 (149.73)
BP250140212149.27 (21.02)
BP3601705745.22 (4.98)
νℓνˉℓjj\nu_\ell\bar{\nu}_\ell jj421
νℓℓjj\nu_\ell\ell jj4810

Table 9. Cross sections σ\sigma (in fb) and signal significances SS after all cuts in the hadronic channel at s=240\sqrt{s}=240 GeV are shown. The significances are computed assuming an integrated luminosity of 5 ab−1ab^{-1}. The values in the parentheses denote the significances with 5% background systematic uncertainty. The value of gv=0.1g_v=0.1.

MVM_V (GeV)MH2M_{H_2} (GeV)σ\sigma (fb)SS
BP1309074452353.25 (965.73)
BP250140979826.06 (143.52)
BP360170267364.77 (37.94)
νℓνˉℓjj\nu_\ell\bar{\nu}_\ell jj374
νℓℓjj\nu_\ell\ell jj3510

Table 10. Cross sections σ\sigma (in fb) and signal significances SS after all cuts in the hadronic channel at s=365\sqrt{s}=365 GeV are shown. The significances are computed assuming an integrated luminosity of 1.5 ab−1ab^{-1}. The values in the parentheses denote the significances with 5% background systematic uncertainty. The value of gv=0.1g_v=0.1.

  • Cut1: We select the events containing two jets with PT>10P_T > 10 GeV and ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j| < 3.0. Veto the events if there is any other isolated lepton, photon, or jet with PT>10P_T > 10 GeV and ∣η∣<3.0|\eta| < 3.0. The two jets selected by this acceptance cut are used to reconstruct the hadronically decaying ZZ boson. It is realized that the jjννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu} is an irreducible background. Furthermore, a non-negligible amount of the jjℓνjj\ell\nu background survives Cut1, as the lepton ℓ\ell may be clustered into a jet, have low transverse momentum, or be close to undetectable regions such as the beam direction.

  • Cut2: As the contribution to the ννjj\nu\nu jj background comes mainly from the process e+e−→Z+γ/Ze^{+}e^{-} \to Z + \gamma/Z, where the di-jet comes from the γ/Z\gamma/Z boson, whereas the ℓνjj\ell\nu jj background comes largely from e+e−→W+W−e^{+}e^{-} \to W^{+}W^{-}, where the WW boson pair decays semileptonically. So, we select the events with dijet-invariant mass around the ZZ mass, 8585 GeV ≤Minv(jj)≤100\leq M_{\mathrm{inv}}(jj) \leq100 GeV, which reduces the backgrounds considerably. To be more specific, for a jjℓνjj\ell\nu background with a peak around the WW boson mass, it is reduced by 99%, while 60% of jjννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu} is rejected.

  • Cut3: We select the events with ̸ET>5\not{E}_T > 5 GeV for s=240\sqrt{s} = 240 GeV and ̸ET>10\not{E}_T > 10 GeV for s=365\sqrt{s} = 365 GeV.

  • Cut4: Same as the leptonic channel, for the E̸\not{E} we choose this cut to efficiently select the signal events and reject as many background events as possible. The distributions of the variables that are used to select the events are shown in Figure 3 for both center-of-mass energies of 240 and 365 GeV.

Figure 3. Simulated signal and background events for hadronic mono-Z production at s=240\sqrt{s}=240 GeV (left) and s=365\sqrt{s}=365 GeV (right).

Two kinematic remarks on the hadronic selection. (i) If the dijet system with mjj≥85m_{jj} \geq85 GeV (Cut 2) is the only visible object, energy-momentum conservation implies E̸≥(s−mjj2)/(2s)≃105\not{E} \geq(s - m_{jj}^{2})/(2\sqrt{s}) \simeq105 GeV at s=240\sqrt{s} = 240 GeV and ≃173\simeq173 GeV at s=365\sqrt{s} = 365 GeV, the minimum being reached for a massless recoil system. The thresholds of Table 6 (E̸>140\not{E} > 140 and 190 GeV) lie above this bound at both energies, i.e. they are effective, and correspond to Mrec≳134M_{\mathrm{rec}} \gtrsim134 and 117 GeV for mjj≃mZm_{jj} \simeq m_Z. (ii) The same bound shows that the radiative-return process e+e−→qqˉγe^{+}e^{-} \to q\bar{q}\gamma, whose photon energy reaches Eγmax⁡≃103E_{\gamma}^{\max} \simeq103 GeV (171 GeV) at 240 (365) GeV, is kinematically removed by Cut 4 when the photon escapes along the beam pipe. The margin is only ≃19\simeq19 GeV at 365365 GeV, comparable to the jet energy resolution, so since σ(qqˉγ)\sigma(q\bar{q}\gamma) is very large, a cross-check with a sample generated with initial-state radiation is advisable. Finally, ttˉt\bar{t} production is kinematically closed at 240240 GeV (s<2mt\sqrt{s}<2m_t), which explains why it is absent in Table 7, while at 365365 GeV it lies only slightly above threshold.

s\sqrt{s}240 GeV365 GeV
Baseline selectionPTj>5P_{Tj}>5 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.5|\eta_j|<3.5, no other particles
BP1
Cut 1Exact two jets with PTj>10P_{Tj}>10 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j|<3.0
Cut 28585 GeV ≤minv(jj)≤100\le m_{inv}(jj)\le100 GeV
Cut 3\slashed{E}_T>5 GeV\slashed{E}_T>10 GeV
Cut 4\slashed{E}>140 GeV\slashed{E}>190 GeV
BP2
Cut 1Exact two jets with PTj>10P_{Tj}>10 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j|<3.0
Cut 28585 GeV ≤minv(jj)≤100\le m_{inv}(jj)\le100 GeV
Cut 3\slashed{E}_T>5 GeV\slashed{E}_T>10 GeV
Cut 4\slashed{E}>140 GeV\slashed{E}>190 GeV
BP3
Cut 1Exact two jets with PTj>10P_{Tj}>10 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j|<3.0
Cut 28585 GeV ≤minv(jj)≤100\le m_{inv}(jj)\le100 GeV
Cut 3\slashed{E}_T>5 GeV\slashed{E}_T>10 GeV
Cut 4\slashed{E}>140 GeV\slashed{E}>190 GeV

Table 6. Selection cuts for different BPs in the hadronic channel at two FCC collision energies are shown.

Selection cutsννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj BP1ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj BP2ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj BP3νℓjj\nu\ell jj BP1νℓjj\nu\ell jj BP2νℓjj\nu\ell jj BP3Signal BP1Signal BP2Signal BP3
Event Numbers (Cut efficiencies)
Baseline Selection458814460000460000460000420000
(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)
After final cut97064196812045917967
(2.11%)(0.0009%)(4.27%)(4.44%)(4.27%)

Table 7. Cut-flow table for different BPs for the hadronic mono-Z signal and background for s=240\sqrt{s}=240 GeV FCC-ee.

Mono-Z Channel at the ILC at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV

We study e+e−→ZVVe^{+}e^{-}\to ZVV at the ILC for s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV and a total integrated luminosity of 88 ab−1^{-1}. We reconstruct the ZZ boson from either a charged-lepton pair or two jets. In addition to the three benchmarks considered at the FCC-ee, the higher collision energy allows us to study BP4 and BP5, with (MV,MH2)=(150,350)(M_V,M_{H_2})=(150,350) and (250,600)(250,600) GeV, respectively.

Selection cutsννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj BP1ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj BP2ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj BP3νℓjj\nu\ell jj BP1νℓjj\nu\ell jj BP2νℓjj\nu\ell jj BP3Signal BP1Signal BP2Signal BP3
Baseline Selection478990400000460000480000460000
(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)
After final cut9498161252652264415253740
(19.82%)(0.015%)(54.92%)(55.08%)(55.16%)

Table 8. Cut-flow table for different BPs for the hadronic mono-Z signal and background for s=365\sqrt{s}=365 GeV FCC-ee.

We use MadGraph5 for event generation, PYTHIA8 for showering and hadronization, and Delphes3 for detector simulation by using the ILCgen configuration card, as described in the FCC-ee analysis.

The ILC running scenario used for the polarized samples, denoted H20, and the three beam configurations compared in this section (unpolarized, H20, and all luminosity in (+, −-)) are defined in § 4.1.

Impact of Beam Polarization at the ILC

We write the longitudinal beam polarizations in the order (Pe−,Pe+)(P_{e^-},P_{e^+}). For each beam, P=(NR−NL)/(NR+NL)P=(N_{\mathrm{R}}-N_{\mathrm{L}})/(N_{\mathrm{R}}+N_{\mathrm{L}}), where NRN_{\mathrm{R}} and NLN_{\mathrm{L}} are the numbers of right- and left-handed particles. We take ∣Pe−∣=80%|P_{e^-}|=80\% and ∣Pe+∣=30%|P_{e^+}|=30\%, so that, for example, (+,−)(+,-) denotes a predominantly right-handed electron beam and a predominantly left-handed positron beam. If σh−h+\sigma_{h^-h^+} is the cross section for definite electron and positron helicities, the cross section for partially polarized beams is

σ(Pe−,Pe+)=14∑h−,h+=±1(1+h−Pe−)(1+h+Pe+)σh−h+.(9)\sigma(P_{e^-},P_{e^+})=\frac{1}{4}\sum_{h^-,h^+=\pm1}(1+h^-P_{e^-})(1+h^+P_{e^+})\sigma_{h^-h^+}. \tag*{(9)}

In this expression, Pe∓P_{e^\mp} is given as a fraction, and h=+1h=+1 denotes right-handed helicity.

For e+e−→W+W−e^+e^-\to W^+W^-, the tt-channel neutrino-exchange amplitude requires an eL−eR+e^-_{\mathrm{L}}e^+_{\mathrm{R}} initial state. This helicity combination accounts for 25% of unpolarized collisions, (0.10)(0.35)=3.5%(0.10)(0.35)=3.5\% for (+,−)(+,-), and 58.5% when both polarizations are reversed. The (+,−)(+,-) setting therefore suppresses a major source of events with missing momentum from neutrinos. In the signal process of Figure 1, a virtual ZZ produces a visible ZZ in association with H1(∗)H_1^{(*)} or H2(∗)H_2^{(*)}, followed by the decay to VVVV. The initial ZeeZee vertex couples to both electron chiralities, so both opposite-helicity initial states contribute to the signal. Neutral-current backgrounds such as ZZZZ also survive this polarization choice.

The original H-20 plan covers twenty years of ILC running at 250-500 GeV [77]. We use H20 for the mixed-polarization sample at the proposed 1 TeV upgrade. We assign 40% of the luminosity to each of (+,−)(+,-) and (−,+)(-,+), giving 3.2 ab−1^{-1} per setting, and 10% to each of (+,+)(+,+) and (−,−)(-,-), giving 0.8 ab−1^{-1} per setting [29, 77]. We compare H20 with two runs of the same total luminosity, one with unpolarized beams and one with all 8 ab−1^{-1} in the (+,−)(+,-) configuration.

In the H20 scenario, the total luminosity is split into four independent samples, which are analysed separately and combined at the level of the significance (see the signal-significance subsection below):

(Pe−,Pe+)(P_{e^-},P_{e^+})fraction of LintL_{\mathrm{int}}LkL_k (ab−1^{-1})
(+,−),(−,+)(+,-),(-,+)40% each3.2 each
(+,+),(−,−)(+,+),(-,-)10% each0.8 each

Table 1 (PDF p. 16).

The original H-20 scenario of Ref. [77] ends at 500 GeV, so the sharing at 1 TeV is an extrapolation to the proposed energy upgrade, with the same helicity fractions as at 500 GeV. The two same-sign settings (+,+)(+,+) and (−,−)(-,-) have a small share of the luminosity; besides contributing statistically, they are included in such programmes mainly to calibrate the beam polarizations and to control systematic effects.

It is important to note where the gain of H20 comes from. Merging the four samples with these weights would give almost no improvement: for the leptonic BP1, the luminosity-weighted cross sections of Table 13 are ≃9970\simeq9970 fb for the signal and ≃825\simeq825 fb for the ννˉℓ+ℓ−\nu\bar{\nu}\ell^+\ell^- background, i.e. S/B≃12.1S/B\simeq12.1, essentially the unpolarized value of 11.6. The benefit appears when the samples are kept separate, since their signal-to-background ratios are very different: S/B≃64S/B \simeq64 for (+,−)(+,-), 24 for (+,+)(+,+), 6.2 for (−,−)(-,-) and 5.7 for (−,+)(-,+). The (+,−)(+,-) sample, which has the largest S/BS/B and 40% of the luminosity, dominates the combined significance, and this is why the H20 values in Table 14 and Table 16 are close to, but below, those of the full-luminosity (+,−)(+,-) run when only statistical uncertainties are considered.

BenchmarksMVM_V (GeV)MH2M_{H_2} (GeV)Unpolarized cross section (fb)Polarization P(e−,e+)P(e^-,e^+)(+,+)(+,+)(+,−)(+,-)(−,+)(-,+)(−,−)(-,-)
BP130908720(80,30)75001274088705750
BP2501401140(80,30)98816701170758
BP360170317(80,30)273464324209
BP41503500.79(80,30)0.681.160.810.52
BP52506000.056(80,30)0.0480.0820.0570.037
ννˉℓ+ℓ−\nu\bar{\nu}\ell^+\ell^-752.4(80,30)3181991550934

Table 13. Comparison of the leptonic mono-Z background and signal cross sections for different choices of beam polarization at s=1\sqrt{s} = 1 TeV ILC.

Unpolarized beamsH20 scenarioOptimally polarized beams (+,−)(+,-)
BP1BP2BP3BP4BP5BP1BP2BP3BP4BP5BP1BP2BP3BP4BP5
1201.76501.41250.714.780.54130059733910.71.23243.04148.4580.210.380.047
(90.62)(23.82)(9.83)(0.15)(0.02)(630)(194)(82.3)(1.33)(0.15)(33.33)(16.98)(7.99)(0.032)(0.003)

Table 14. Signal significance in the leptonic mono-Z channel at s=1\sqrt{s} = 1 TeV with an integrated luminosity of Lint=8L_{\mathrm{int}} = 8 ab−1^{-1}. The values in parentheses denote the significance including the background systematic uncertainty.

Unpolarized beamsH20 scenarioOptimally polarized beams (+,−)(+,-)
BP1BP2BP3BP4BP5BP1BP2BP3BP4BP5BP1BP2BP3BP4BP5
3121.18762.40247.390.7430.2213377.15990.17412.892.6440.5864104.221358.49601.053.9940.885
(105.08)(13.76)(3.82)(0.011)(0.003)(923.10)(124.86)(34.89)(0.150)(0.033)(893.55)(116.85)(32.73)(0.141)(0.031)

Table 16. Signal significance in the hadronic mono-ZZ channel at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV with an integrated luminosity of Lint=8\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{int}}=8 ab−1^{-1}. The values in parentheses denote the significance including the 5% background systematic uncertainty.

The effect on the two decay modes can be seen directly in Table 13 and Table 15. Before the analysis cuts, changing from unpolarized beams to (+,−)(+,-) reduces the ννˉℓ+ℓ−\nu\bar{\nu}\ell^{+}\ell^{-} cross section from 752.4 to 199 fb. In the hadronic mode the ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj rate falls from 810 to 140 fb and the ℓνjj\ell\nu jj rate from 1340 to 240 fb. Using the BP1 signal cross sections in the same tables, the ratio of signal to total background increases by a factor of 5.5 in the leptonic mode and 8.3 in the hadronic mode.

BenchmarksMVM_V (GeV)MH2M_{H_2} (GeV)Unpolarized cross section (fb)Polarization P(e−,e+)\mathrm{P}(e^-,e^+)(+,+)(+,+)(+,−)(+,-)(−,+)(-,+)(−,−)(-,-)
BP1309091750(80,30)788801340009348060550
BP25014012100(80,30)1041017650123307900
BP3601703340(80,30)2880488034002200
BP41503508(80,30)6.911.78.25.3
BP52506000.5(80,30)0.480.820.570.37
ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj810(80,30)22014018601000
νℓℓjj\nu\ell\ell jj1340(80,30)43024029901680

Table 15. Comparison of the hadronic mono-ZZ background and signal cross sections for different choices of beam polarization at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC.

At this energy WWWW and ZZZZ fusion also give access to VVVV production through the complementary final states ννˉVV\nu\bar{\nu}VV and e+e−VVe^{+}e^{-}VV, respectively [55, 78, 79].

Leptonic mode

For Z→e+e−Z \to e^{+}e^{-} or μ+μ−\mu^{+}\mu^{-}, the two charged leptons identify the visible ZZ and the VVVV pair carries away the recoil momentum. We include the SM background e+e−→ℓ+ℓ−ννˉe^{+}e^{-} \to\ell^{+}\ell^{-}\nu\bar{\nu}. It contains ZZZZ events with one invisible ZZ decay, as well as W+W−W^{+}W^{-} events in which the two charged leptons come from different WW bosons. The former have a dilepton mass peak in the signal region, while the latter populate a broader range of mℓℓm_{\ell\ell}.

Cut Based Analysis

The baseline sample contains an opposite-sign, same-flavor (OSSF) lepton pair with pT,ℓ>2p_{T,\ell} > 2 GeV and ∣ηℓ∣<3.5|\eta_\ell| < 3.5. We apply the following four cuts to all five benchmarks, as summarized in Table 12.

s\sqrt{s}1 TeV
Baseline selectionOSSF lepton-pairs with PTℓ>2P_{T\ell} > 2 GeV, ∣ηℓ∣<3.5|\eta_\ell| < 3.5
Selection cutsBP1BP2BP3BP4BP5
Cut 1Exactly 2 OSSF leptons with PTℓ>10P_{T\ell} > 10 GeV, ∣ηℓ∣<2.8|\eta_\ell| < 2.8
Cut 28080 GeV ≤mℓℓ≤100\le m_{\ell\ell} \le100 GeV
Cut 3̸ET>20\not{E}_T > 20 GeV
Cut 4E̸>500\not{E} > 500 GeV

Table 12. Selection cuts for different BPs in the charged leptonic channel at s=1\sqrt{s} = 1 TeV ILC are shown.

  • Cut 1 selects exactly two charged leptons forming one OSSF pair. Each lepton must satisfy pT,ℓ>10p_{T,\ell} > 10 GeV and ∣ηℓ∣<2.8|\eta_\ell| < 2.8.

  • Cut 2 requires 80 GeV ≤mℓℓ≤\le m_{\ell\ell} \le 100 GeV. This window retains the ZZ peak and rejects part of the W+W−W^{+}W^{-} continuum.

  • Cut 3 requires ̸ET=∣∑visp⃗T∣>20\not{E}_T = \left|\sum_{\mathrm{vis}} \vec{p}_T\right| > 20 GeV. It suppresses events in which the missing momentum points close to the beam axis.

  • Cut 4 requires E̸=s−∑visEi>500\not{E} = \sqrt{s} - \sum_{\mathrm{vis}} E_i > 500 GeV. Here the sum runs over the reconstructed visible objects, so that this cut tests the energy carried by the recoil system.

Figure 4 shows the three distributions used after lepton selection. Of the 273 988 background events in the baseline sample, 32 165 survive all four cuts (11.74%). The corresponding signal efficiencies are 5.76%, 11.55%, and 17.12% for BP1–BP3, and rise to 92.62% and 93.73% for BP4 and BP5 (Table 11). These percentages are relative to the baseline selection.

Selection cutsSM Background ννˉℓ+ℓ−\nu\bar{\nu}\ell^{+}\ell^{-}BP1BP2BP3BP4BP5
Baseline Selection273988219302219358219598255383399699
(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)
After final cut32165126262533737585236554374624
(11.74%)(5.76%)(11.55%)(17.12%)(92.62%)(93.73%)

Table 11. Cut-flow table for different BPs for the leptonic mono-Z signal and background for s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC.

The position of Cut 4 helps explain the difference between the light and heavy benchmarks. When the lepton pair accounts for the entire visible system, Mrec2=2s E̸−s+mℓℓ2M_{\mathrm{rec}}^{2} = 2\sqrt{s}\,\not{E} - s + m_{\ell\ell}^{2}. At 1 TeV the requirement E̸>500\not{E} > 500 GeV therefore selects Mrec>mℓℓM_{\mathrm{rec}} > m_{\ell\ell}. The 90 GeV H2H_2 resonance of BP1 lies close to this boundary for an on-shell ZZ, whereas the minimum VVVV invariant masses of BP4 and BP5 are 300 and 500 GeV. Initial-state radiation, beamstrahlung, and finite energy resolution can shift the reconstructed recoil mass away from the true VVVV invariant mass.

Figure 4. Simulated signal and background events for leptonic mono-Z production (unpolarized) at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC.

Hadronic mode

For Z→qqˉZ \to q\bar{q}, with q=u,d,s,c,bq = u, d, s, c, b, we reconstruct the ZZ candidate from two jets. We include e+e−→ννˉjje^+e^- \to\nu\bar{\nu}jj, which has the same visible final state as the signal, and e+e−→ℓνjje^+e^- \to\ell\nu jj, including the charge-conjugate mode. The latter contributes when the charged lepton escapes acceptance or fails identification. Top-pair production, e+e−→ttˉ→bbˉW+W−e^+e^- \to t\bar{t} \to b\bar{b}W^+W^-, typically gives additional jets or charged leptons. We therefore treat ttˉt\bar{t} as a minor background to the exclusive mono-ZZ selection and omit it from the ILC cut flows and significances.

Cut Based Analysis

At baseline, we require jets with pT,j>5p_{T,j} > 5 GeV and ∣ηj∣<3.5|\eta_j| < 3.5, with no additional identified visible object. The selection in Table 18 uses the same missing-energy thresholds as the leptonic analysis.

s\sqrt{s}
Baseline selectionPTj>5P_{Tj} > 5 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.5|\eta_j| < 3.5, no other particles
Selection cutsBP1BP2BP3BP4BP5
Cut 1Exactly 2-jets with PTj>20P_{Tj} > 20 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j| < 3.0Exactly 2-jets with PTj>20P_{Tj} > 20 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j| < 3.0Exactly 2-jets with PTj>20P_{Tj} > 20 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j| < 3.0Exactly 2-jets with PTj>20P_{Tj} > 20 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j| < 3.0Exactly 2-jets with PTj>20P_{Tj} > 20 GeV, ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j| < 3.0
Cut 28585 GeV ≤mjj≤100\leq m_{jj} \leq100 GeV8585 GeV ≤mjj≤100\leq m_{jj} \leq100 GeV8585 GeV ≤mjj≤100\leq m_{jj} \leq100 GeV8585 GeV ≤mjj≤100\leq m_{jj} \leq100 GeV8585 GeV ≤mjj≤100\leq m_{jj} \leq100 GeV
Cut 3̸ET>20\not{E}_T > 20 GeV̸ET>20\not{E}_T > 20 GeV̸ET>20\not{E}_T > 20 GeV̸ET>20\not{E}_T > 20 GeV̸ET>20\not{E}_T > 20 GeV
Cut 4E̸>500\not{E} > 500 GeVE̸>500\not{E} > 500 GeVE̸>500\not{E} > 500 GeVE̸>500\not{E} > 500 GeVE̸>500\not{E} > 500 GeV

Table 18. Selection cuts for different BPs in the hadronic channel at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC are shown.

  • Cut 1 requires exactly two jets with pT,j>20p_{T,j} > 20 GeV and ∣ηj∣<3.0|\eta_j| < 3.0. We add their four-momenta to reconstruct the dijet candidate.

  • Cut 2 selects 8585 GeV ≤mjj≤100\le m_{jj} \le100 GeV. The lower edge lies above mWm_W, reducing the contribution from semileptonic W+W−W^+W^- decays in ℓνjj\ell\nu jj. Events with a genuine Z→jjZ \to jj in ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj populate the same mass window as the signal.

  • Cut 3 requires ̸ET>20\not{E}_T > 20 GeV. When the dijet accounts for all visible momentum, this is also a lower bound on the transverse momentum of the dijet system.

  • Cut 4 retains events with E̸>500\not{E} > 500 GeV. As in the leptonic mode, the energy is calculated from all reconstructed visible objects. For events in which only the dijet is visible, mjjm_{jj} replaces mℓℓm_{\ell\ell} in the recoil-mass relation.

The full selection retains 34.38% of the baseline ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj sample and 3.51% of the ℓνjj\ell\nu jj sample (Table 17). Although ℓνjj\ell\nu jj has the larger unpolarized cross section before selection, ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jj supplies most of the final hadronic background. The signal efficiencies relative to baseline are about 1.6% for BP1–BP3, 2.80% for BP4, and 8.91% for BP5. Figure 5 shows the dijet mass, missing transverse energy, and missing energy used in this selection.

Selection cutsννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jjℓνjj\ell\nu jjBP1BP2BP3BP4BP5
SM BackgroundsSignal
Baseline Selection499985500000500000500000500000334728500000
(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)(100%)
After final cut17190917545809180318065937244559
(34.38%)(3.51%)(1.62%)(1.61%)(1.61%)(2.80%)(8.91%)

Table 17. Cut-flow table for different BPs for the hadronic mono-ZZ signal and background for s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC.

Figure 5. Simulated signal and background events for hadronic mono-Z production (unpolarized) at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC.

Signal Significance

We use Eq. (8) for each setting separately. For H20, each yield uses the luminosity assigned to that setting. We then combine the four significances in quadrature [35],

SH20=S(+,+)2+S(+,−)2+S(−,+)2+S(−,−)2.(10)S_{\mathrm{H20}} = \sqrt{S^2_{(+,+)} + S^2_{(+,-)} + S^2_{(-,+)} + S^2_{(-,-)}}. \tag*{(10)}

Table 14 and Table 16 give the results for the leptonic and hadronic modes, respectively. The values in parentheses include a 5% normalization uncertainty for each background in Eq. (8). In the H20 combination, we treat these uncertainties as independent between beam settings. Under this assumption, BP1–BP3 retain S>5S > 5 in both decay modes for H20. For BP4, the H20 significance falls to 1.33 in the leptonic mode and 0.150 in the hadronic mode. Normalization errors shared by several beam settings would require a joint fit with common nuisance parameters.

Conclusion

We have studied the mono-ZZ signature of Higgs-portal VDM at the FCC-ee (s=240\sqrt{s}=240 and 365 GeV) and at the ILC (s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV), with a cut-based analysis of both leptonic and hadronic ZZ decays.

For gv=0.1g_{v}=0.1, MV=30M_{V}=30–60 GeV and MH2=90M_{H_{2}}=90–170 GeV (BP1–BP3), the hadronic mode at the FCC-ee is the more sensitive one, with S≃531S\simeq531, 149, 45 at 240 GeV and 2353, 826, 365 at 365 GeV (150, 21, 5.0 and 966, 144, 38 with 5% background systematics). The leptonic mode gives S≃36S\simeq36, 43, 13 at 240 GeV (1.5, 4.5, 1.2 with systematics) and 155, 288, 124 at 365 GeV (24.8, 61.9, 18.4). This is due to the roughly ten times larger Z→jjZ\to jj rate and to S/B≃8S/B\simeq8 after the selection, against S/B≲1S/B\lesssim1 in the leptonic mode. With 5% systematics, only the hadronic channel reaches 5σ5\sigma at 240 GeV, while the leptonic channel remains a cleaner, independent cross-check.

At the ILC with 8 ab−1^{-1}, beam polarization mainly improves S/BS/B, by about 5.5 (leptonic) and 8.3 (hadronic) for BP1 before cuts. With statistical uncertainties alone, this gives a gain of 1.1–1.9 for BP1–BP3. With 5% systematics, the gain is ≃7\simeq7–8 for BP1–BP3 in both modes, since the significance is then controlled by (S/B)/ϵ(S/B)/\epsilon. BP4 and BP5 stay below 1.4σ1.4\sigma in this case, so they require background normalizations controlled at the percent level. The H20 values with systematics assume uncorrelated uncertainties between beam settings and are therefore optimistic; a joint fit with common nuisance parameters is needed.

The selection can still be improved. The common E̸\not{E} thresholds correspond to Mrec≳134M_{\rm rec}\gtrsim134 (240 GeV) and 117 GeV (365 GeV) at the FCC-ee and remove the 90 GeV resonance of BP1, and E̸>500\not{E}>500 GeV at the ILC is essentially the kinematic minimum for a ZZ candidate; a benchmark-dependent MrecM_{\rm rec} window or a shape fit would help, in particular for BP1, BP4 and BP5. The hadronic results should also be cross-checked with initial-state-radiation-enabled e+e−→qqˉ(γ)e^{+}e^{-}\to q\bar{q}(\gamma) samples. Natural extensions are scans of the (MV,gv)(M_{V},g_{v}) and (MV,MH2)(M_{V},M_{H_{2}}) planes overlaid on the relic-density, direct-detection constraints, angular observables of the ZZ decay products, and the complementary mono-photon, mono-WW and vector-boson fusion channels.

Acknowledgments

R.R. is supported in part by the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) Grant No. RS-2026-25484206, and the BK-21 FOUR program through NRF. S. P. would like to thank CERN TH-Division for their support and kind hospitality during his stay at CERN. In the analysis and preparation of this manuscript, Claude and ChatGPT were used to assist with literature searches, refining the language, modifying the LaTeX code, discussing and clarifying selected physics questions, and troubleshooting issues in MadGraph. The authors take full responsibility for the content of the manuscript.

Kinematic Distributions and Cut-Flow Tables for Optimally Polarized Beams

For completeness, we present the kinematic distributions for the optimally polarized beam configuration, (Pe−,Pe+)=(+80%,−30%)(P_{e^-},P_{e^+})=(+80\%,-30\%), at the ILC with s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV. We consider the same benchmark points and selection cuts as those discussed for the unpolarized beams in the main text. In Figure 6, we show the distributions of the dilepton invariant mass, missing transverse energy, and missing energy for the leptonic mono-ZZ channel. The corresponding distributions for the hadronic mono-ZZ channel, including the dijet invariant mass, missing transverse energy, and missing energy, are shown in Figure 7. The cut-flow tables for the leptonic and hadronic channels are presented in Table 19 and Table 20, respectively. These tables summarize the number of signal and SM background events after the selection cuts, together with their corresponding cut efficiencies, for the optimally polarized beam configuration.

Selection cutsSM Background ννˉℓ+ℓ−\nu\bar{\nu}\ell^+\ell^-Signal BP1BP2BP3BP4BP5
Baseline Selection499187<br>(100%)499830<br>(100%)499828<br>(100%)499844<br>(100%)499992<br>(100%)500000<br>(100%)
After final cut17580<br>(3.52%)462<br>(0.09%)1790<br>(0.36%)3026<br>(0.61%)4880<br>(0.98%)8479<br>(1.70%)

Table 19. Cut-flow table for different BPs for the leptonic mono-ZZ signal and background at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC, considering optimally polarized beams (Pe−,Pe+)=(+80%,−30%)(P_{e^-},P_{e^+})=(+80\%,-30\%).

Selection cutsSM Backgrounds ννˉjj\nu\bar{\nu}jjℓνjj\ell\nu jjSignal BP1BP2BP3BP4BP5
Baseline Selection499977<br>(100%)500000<br>(100%)500000<br>(100%)500000<br>(100%)500000<br>(100%)500000<br>(100%)500000<br>(100%)
After final cut165572<br>(33.12%)18142<br>(3.63%)8057<br>(1.61%)7836<br>(1.57%)7922<br>(1.58%)14204<br>(2.84%)44815<br>(8.96%)

Table 20. Cut-flow table for different BPs for the hadronic mono-ZZ signal and background at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC, considering optimally polarized beams (Pe−,Pe+)=(+80%,−30%)(P_{e^-},P_{e^+})=(+80\%,-30\%).

Figure 6. Simulated signal and background events for optimal beam (Pe−,Pe+)=(+80%,−30%)(P_{e^-}, P_{e^+}) = (+80\%, -30\%) leptonic mono-Z production at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC.

(a) MℓℓM_{\ell\ell}

Missing transverse energy distribution $E_T$

(b) ̸ET\not{E}_T

(c) EE

Figure 7. Simulated signal and background events for optimal beam (Pe−,Pe+)=(+80%,−30%)(P_{e^-}, P_{e^+}) = (+80\%, -30\%) hadronic mono-Z production at s=1\sqrt{s}=1 TeV ILC.

References

References

  1. [1]M. Cirelli, A. Strumia and J. Zupan, Dark Matter, 2406.01705.arxiv.org/abs/2406.01705
  2. [2]N. Bozorgnia, J. Bramante, J. M. Cline, D. Curtin, D. McKeen, D. E. Morrissey et al., Dark matter candidates and searches, Can. J. Phys. 103 (2025) 671 [2410.23454].DOI
  3. [3]Planck Collaboration collaboration, Planck 2018 results. vi. cosmological parameters, Astron. Astrophys. 641 (2020) A6 [1807.06209].
  4. [4]T. Hambye, Hidden vector dark matter, JHEP 01 (2009) 028 [0811.0172].DOI
  5. [5]O. Lebedev, H. M. Lee and Y. Mambrini, Vector Higgs-portal dark matter and the invisible Higgs, Phys. Lett. B 707 (2012) 570 [1111.4482].DOI
  6. [6]P. Ko, W.-I. Park and Y. Tang, Higgs portal vector dark matter for GeV scale γ-ray excess from galactic center, JCAP 09 (2014) 013 [1404.5257].DOI
  7. [7]S. Baek, P. Ko, W.-I. Park and E. Senaha, Higgs Portal Vector Dark Matter : Revisited, JHEP 05 (2013) 036 [1212.2131].DOI
  8. [8]M. Duch, B. Grzadkowski and M. McGarrie, A stable Higgs portal with vector dark matter, JHEP 09 (2015) 162 [1506.08805].DOI
  9. [9]Y. Farzan and A. R. Akbarieh, VDM: A model for Vector Dark Matter, JCAP 10 (2012) 026 [1207.4272].DOI
  10. [10]S. Y. Ayazi and A. Mohamadnejad, DAMPE excess from leptophilic vector dark matter: a model-independent approach, J. Phys. G 47 (2020) 095003 [1909.10729].DOI
  11. [11]S. Y. Ayazi and M. Hosseini, W-boson mass anomaly and vacuum structure in vector dark matter model with a singlet scalar mediator, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 38 (2023) 2340002 [2206.11041].DOI
  12. [12]S. Y. Ayazi, M. Hosseini, S. Paktinat Mehdiabadi and R. Rouzbehi, Vector dark matter and lhc constraints, including a 95 gev light higgs boson, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 055004 [2405.01132].DOI
  13. [13]K.-P. Chen, H. Hu, H.-Y. Luo, Y. Wei and M. Zhong, Multi-TeV vector dark matter in the U(1)x Higgs portal model, 2611.13023.
  14. [14]W. Chao, First order electroweak phase transition triggered by the Higgs portal vector dark matter, Phys. Rev. D 92 (2015) 015025 [1412.3823].DOI
  15. [15]K. Hashino, M. Kakizaki, S. Kanemura, P. Ko and T. Matsui, Gravitational waves from first order electroweak phase transition in models with the U(1)X gauge symmetry, JHEP 06 (2018) 088 [1802.02947].DOI
  16. [16]S. Yaser Ayazi and A. Mohamnadnejad, Conformal vector dark matter and strongly first-order electroweak phase transition, JHEP 03 (2019) 181 [1901.04168].DOI
  17. [17]A. Djouadi, O. Lebedev, Y. Mambrini and J. Quevillon, Implications of LHC searches for Higgs-portal dark matter, Phys. Lett. B 709 (2012) 65 [1112.3299].DOI
  18. [18]S. Baek, P. Ko and W.-I. Park, Invisible Higgs Decay Width vs. Dark Matter Direct Detection Cross Section in Higgs Portal Dark Matter Models, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 055014 [1405.3530].DOI
  19. [19]S. Glaus, M. Mühlleitner, J. Müller, S. Patel and R. Santos, Electroweak Corrections to Dark Matter Direct Detection in a Vector Dark Matter Model, JHEP 10 (2019) 152 [1908.09249].DOI
  20. [20]A. Amiri, B. Díaz Sáez and K. Ghorbani, (sub)GeV dark matter in the U(1)X Higgs portal model, Phys. Lett. B 844 (2023) 138119 [2209.11723].arxiv.org/abs/2209.11723
  21. [21]A. Beniwal, F. Rajec, C. Savage, P. Scott, C. Weninger, M. White et al., Combined analysis of effective Higgs portal dark matter models, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 115016 [1512.06458].DOI
  22. [22]H. Shaikh and M. Di Mauro, Vector Higgs-portal dark matter: How UV completion reopens viable parameter space, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026) 115049 [2603.11233].DOI
  23. [23]A. Mohamadnejad, Gravitational waves from scale-invariant vector dark matter model: Probing below the neutrino-floor, Eur. Phys. J. C 80 (2020) 197 [1907.08899].DOI
  24. [24]M. Hosseini, S. Yaser Ayazi and A. Mohamadnejad, Gravitational wave effects and phenomenology of a two-component dark matter model, Eur. Phys. J. C 84 (2024) 485 [2308.00395].DOI
  25. [25]M. Hosseini, S. Y. Ayazi and A. Mohamadnejad, Gravitational wave in a filtered vector dark matter model, Phys. Dark Univ. 48 (2025) 101952 [2405.10662].arxiv.org/abs/2405.10662
  26. [26]M. Hosseini and R. Rouzbehi, Scale-Invariant Three-Component Dark Matter and Gravitational Wave Signals, 2611.07509.arxiv.org/abs/2611.07509
  27. [27]M. H. R. Abkenar, A. Mohamadnejad and R. Sepahvand, Spin trio: A dark matter scenario, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) 055018 [2410.22252].DOI
  28. [28]FCC collaboration, FCC-ee: The Lepton Collider: Future Circular Collider Conceptual Design Report Volume 2, Eur. Phys. J. ST 228 (2019) 261.
  29. [29]ILC collaboration, The International Linear Collider. A Global Project, 1901.09829.
  30. [30]N. Wan, M. Song, G. Li, W.-G. Ma, R.-Y. Zhang and J.-Y. Guo, Searching for dark matter via mono-Z boson production at the ILC, Eur. Phys. J. C 74 (2014) 3219 [1403.7921].DOI
  31. [31]Z.-H. Yu, X.-J. Bi, Q.-S. Yan and P.-F. Yin, Dark matter searches in the mono-Z channel at high energy e+e− colliders, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) 055010 [1404.6990].DOI
  32. [32]S. Dutta, D. Sachdeva and B. Rawat, Signals of Leptophilic Dark Matter at the ILC, Eur. Phys. J. C 77 (2017) 639 [1704.03994].DOI
  33. [33]B. Grzadkowski, M. Iglicki, K. Mekala and A. F. Zarnecki, Dark-matter-spin effects at future e+e− colliders, JHEP 08 (2020) 052 [2003.06719].DOI
  34. [34]A. Ghosh, P. K. Paul, A. Sarkar, R. Ghosh, R. Sharma and S. Bhattacharya, Mono-Z signal for dark matter searches at future lepton colliders and cosmological interpretation, 2609.33514.arxiv.org/abs/2609.33514
  35. [35]S. Kundu, A. Guha, P. K. Das and P. S. B. Dev, Eft analysis of leptophilic dark matter at future electron-positron colliders in the mono-photon and mono-z channels, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) 015003 [2110.06903].DOI
  36. [36]FCC COLLABORATION collaboration, Fcc-ee: The lepton collider, Eur. Phys. J. ST 228 (2019) 261 [1905.09525].
  37. [37]H. Baer et al., The international linear collider technical design report - volume 2: Physics, arXiv (2013) [1306.6352].arxiv.org/abs/1306.6352
  38. [38]J. Alwall, R. Frederix, S. Frixione, V. Hirschi, F. Maltoni, O. Mattelaer et al., The automated computation of tree-level and next-to-leading order differential cross sections, and their matching to parton shower simulations, JHEP 07 (2014) 079 [1405.0301].DOI
  39. [39]C. Bierlich et al., A comprehensive guide to the physics and usage of pythia 8.3, SciPost Phys. Codeb. 2022 (2022) 8 [2203.11601].arxiv.org/abs/2203.11601
  40. [40]DELPHES 3 collaboration, DELPHES 3, A modular framework for fast simulation of a generic collider experiment, JHEP 02 (2014) 057 [1307.6346].
  41. [41]IDEA STUDY GROUP collaboration, The IDEA detector concept for FCC-ee, 2502.21223.
  42. [42]B. Barman, S. Bhattacharya, S. Girromhanta and S. Jahedi, Effective Leptophilic WIMPs at the e+e− collider, JHEP 04 (2022) 146 [2109.10936].DOI
  43. [43]S.-F. Ge, K. Ma, X.-D. Ma and J. Sheng, Associated production of neutrino and dark fermion at future lepton colliders, JHEP 11 (2023) 190 [2306.00657].arxiv.org/abs/2306.00657
  44. [44]S. Kundu, A. Guha, P. K. Das and P. S. B. Dev, EFT analysis of leptophilic dark matter at future electron-positron colliders in the mono-photon and mono-Z channels, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) 015003 [2110.06903].
  45. [45]P. J. Fox, R. Harnik, J. Kopp and Y. Tsai, LEP Shines Light on Dark Matter, Phys. Rev. D 84 (2011) 014028 [1103.0240].DOI
  46. [46]Z.-H. Yu, Q.-S. Yan and P.-F. Yin, Detecting interactions between dark matter and photons at high energy e+e− colliders, Phys. Rev. D 88 (2013) 075015 [1307.5740].
  47. [47]R. Essig, J. Mardon, M. Papucci, T. Volansky and Y.-M. Zhong, Constraining Light Dark Matter with Low-Energy e+e− Colliders, JHEP 11 (2013) 167 [1309.5084].
  48. [48]A. Freitas and S. Westhoff, Leptophilic Dark Matter in Lepton Interactions at LEP and ILC, JHEP 10 (2014) 116 [1408.1959].
  49. [49]S.-I. Horigome, T. Katayose, S. Matsumoto and I. Saha, Leptophilic fermion WIMP: Role of future lepton colliders, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) 055001 [2102.08645].
  50. [50]S. Bhattacharya, P. Ghosh, J. Lahiri and B. Mukhopadhyaya, Mono-X signal and two component dark matter: New distinction criteria, Phys. Rev. D 108 (2023) L111703 [2211.10749].
  51. [51]K. Ma, Mono-γ production of a dark vector at future e+e− colliders*, Chin. Phys. C 46 (2022) 113104 [2205.05560].
  52. [52]Y. Dong, M. Ruan, K. Wang, H. Yang and J. Zhu, Particle-level transformers for 95 GeV Higgs boson searches at future e+e− Higgs factories, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026) 055025 [2510.24662].
  53. [53]B. Ait-Ouazghour, A. Arhrib, R. Benbrik, M. Boukidi, M. Chabab, K. Goure et al., Probing doubly charged Higgs bosons with three-body associated production at future e+e− colliders, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026) 095038 [2602.19866].
  54. [54]Y.-B. Liu and S. Moretti, Probing the pair production of first-generation vectorlike leptons at future e+e− colliders, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026) 055034 [2512.22490].
  55. [55]D. Buttazzo, D. Redigolo, F. Sala and A. Tesi, Fusing Vectors into Scalars at High Energy Lepton Colliders, JHEP 11 (2018) 144 [1807.04743].
  56. [56]D. Buttazzo, F. Sala and A. Tesi, Singlet-like Higgs bosons at present and future colliders, JHEP 11 (2015) 158 [1505.05488].
  57. [57]S. M. Etesami, R. Jafari, M. M. Najafabadi and S. Tizchang, Searching for lepton flavor violating interactions at future electron-positron colliders, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) 015034 [2107.00545].
  58. [58]W. Altmannshofer and P. Munbodh, Probing lepton flavor violation at linear electron-positron colliders, JHEP 08 (2025) 147 [2505.11653].arxiv.org/abs/2505.11653
  59. [59]S. Jahedi and A. Sarkar, Exploring optimal sensitivity of lepton flavor violating effective couplings at the e+e− colliders, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) 095021 [2408.00190].DOI
  60. [60]W. Altmannshofer, P. Munbodh and T. Oh, Probing lepton flavor violation at Circular Electron-Positron Colliders, JHEP 08 (2023) 026 [2305.03869].arxiv.org/abs/2305.03869
  61. [61]A. K. Barik, A. Dey and T. Samui, Search for lepton flavor violating signals at the future electron-proton colliders, Phys. Lett. B 872 (2026) 140048 [2306.10540].DOI
  62. [62]L. Calibbi, X. Marcano and J. Roy, Z lepton flavour violation as a probe for new physics at future e+e− colliders, Eur. Phys. J. C 81 (2021) 1054 [2107.10273].DOI
  63. [63]G. Haghhighat, M. Mohammadi Najafabadi, K. Sakurai and W. Yin, Probing a light dark sector at future lepton colliders via invisible decays of the SM-like and dark Higgs bosons, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) 035033 [2209.07565].DOI
  64. [64]Y. J. Chae and M. Perelstein, Dark Matter Search at a Linear Collider: Effective Operator Approach, JHEP 05 (2013) 138 [1211.4008].DOI
  65. [65]A. Birkedal, K. Matchev and M. Perelstein, Dark matter at colliders: A Model independent approach, Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004) 077701 [hep-ph/0403004].DOI
  66. [66]P. Konar, K. Kong, K. T. Matchev and M. Perelstein, Shedding Light on the Dark Sector with Direct WIMP Production, New J. Phys. 11 (2009) 105004 [0902.2000].DOI
  67. [67]C. Bartels, M. Berggren and J. List, Characterising WIMPs at a future e+e− Linear Collider, Eur. Phys. J. C 72 (2012) 2213 [1206.6639].DOI
  68. [68]H. Dreiner, M. Huck, M. Krämer, D. Schmeier and J. Tattersall, Illuminating Dark Matter at the ILC, Phys. Rev. D 87 (2013) 075015 [1211.2254].DOI
  69. [69]Z. Liu, Y.-H. Xu and Y. Zhang, Probing dark matter particles at CEPC, JHEP 06 (2019) 009 [1903.12114].DOI
  70. [70]M. Habermehl, M. Berggren and J. List, WIMP Dark Matter at the International Linear Collider, Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 075053 [2001.03011].DOI
  71. [71]J. Kalinowski, W. Kotlarski, K. Mekala, P. Sopicki and A. F. Zarnecki, Sensitivity of future linear e+e− colliders to processes of dark matter production with light mediator exchange, Eur. Phys. J. C 81 (2021) 955 [2107.11194].DOI
  72. [72]J. Kriewald, E. Pinsard and A. M. Teixeira, Enhanced di-Higgs production from TeV-scale heavy neutral leptons at future lepton colliders, 2512.16734.arxiv.org/abs/2512.16734
  73. [73]N. Vignaroli, Indirect probes of heavy neutral leptons through the dipole portal at FCC-ee, 2611.05501.arxiv.org/abs/2611.05501
  74. [74]P. Giffin, I. M. Lewis and Y.-J. Zheng, Higgs production in association with a dark-Z at future electron positron colliders, J. Phys. G 49 (2022) 015003 [2012.13404].DOI
  75. [75]A. Semenov, LanHEP — A package for automatic generation of Feynman rules from the Lagrangian. Version 3.2, Comput. Phys. Commun. 201 (2016) 167 [1412.5016].arxiv.org/abs/1412.5016
  76. [76]G. Cowan, K. Cranmer, E. Gross and O. Vitells, Asymptotic formulae for likelihood-based tests of new physics, Eur. Phys. J. C 71 (2011) 1554 [1007.1727].DOI
  77. [77]T. Barklow, J. Brau, K. Fujii, J. Gao, J. List, N. Walker et al., ILC Operating Scenarios, 1506.07830.arxiv.org/abs/1506.07830
  78. [78]A. Costantini, F. De Lillo, F. Maltoni, L. Mantani, O. Mattelaer, R. Ruiz et al., Vector boson fusion at multi-TeV muon colliders, JHEP 09 (2020) 080 [2005.10289].DOI
  79. [79]R. Ruiz, A. Costantini, F. Maltoni and O. Mattelaer, The Effective Vector Boson Approximation in high-energy muon collisions, JHEP 06 (2022) 114 [2111.02442].DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_pu22s76u
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Claude, ChatGPT

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents