betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Cavitation controls droplet sizes in elastic media

Abstract

Biological cells use droplets to separate components and spatially control their interior. Experiments demonstrate that the complex, crowded cellular environment affects the droplet arrangement and their sizes. To understand this behavior, we here construct a theoretical description of droplets growing in an elastic matrix, which is motivated by experiments in synthetic systems where monodisperse emulsions form during a temperature decrease. We show that large droplets only form when they break the surrounding matrix in a cavitation event. The energy barrier associated with cavitation stabilizes small droplets on the order of the mesh size and diminishes the stochastic effects of nucleation. Consequently, the cavitated droplets have similar sizes and highly correlated positions. In particular, we predict the density of cavitated droplets, which increases with faster cooling, as in the experiments. Our model also suggests how adjusting the cooling protocol and the density of nucleation sites affects the droplet size distribution. In summary, our theory explains how elastic matrices affect droplets in the synthetic system and it provides a framework for understanding the biological case.

Phase separation has emerged as a powerful concept to explain how biological cells structure their interior [1, 2]. It explains how membrane-less compartments with distinct chemical composition, called biomolecular condensates, form spontaneously. In contrast to classical liquid-liquid phase separation, these condensates exist in complex, crowded environments, e.g., provided by the cytoskeleton in the cytosol or the chromatin in the nucleus. This fundamentally affects the behavior of condensates: their coarsening is slowed down by sub-diffusive motion [3], they are supported against gravity by the F-actin network in the nuclei of large cells [4], and their assembly depends on the stiffness of their surrounding [5, 6]. Another example are artificially induced condensates, which typically appear in soft regions of the chromatin [7]. Taken together, these experiments and recent numerical simulations [8] demonstrate that condensates react to the elastic properties of their surrounding [9], but the detailed dynamics are still unclear.

The interaction of droplets with soft elastic matrices can be studied in detail in a synthetic system, where oil droplets are induced in a PDMS matrix by lowering the temperature [10]. Similar to the biological case, droplets are biased towards softer regions in this system [11, 12]. This elastic ripening is absent when the elastic properties of the system are homogeneous. Instead, all observable droplets attain similar sizes and their positions are correlated [10]. Interestingly, one observes smaller droplets in stiffer systems and at larger cooling rates [10]. This implies that the final state is governed by non-equilibrium processes, which is also demonstrated by the bidisperse emulsions that form after increasing the cooling rate during the experiment [11].

Theoretical descriptions of such systems have to describe how the elastic matrix affects the droplets’ dynamics. In the simplest case, the matrix exerts a pressure onto the droplets proportionally to the local stiffness, which is sufficient to explain elastic ripening [13]. Moreover, assuming a strain-stiffening surrounding can explain why droplets attain the same size, which decreases with stiffness [14, 15, 16]. However, these equilibrium models cannot describe the dependence on the cooling rate.

In this paper, we present a dynamic theory of droplet formation in elastic matrices, which is based on the assumption that droplets can break the surrounding matrix. We show that in this case some droplets cavitate and grow macroscopically, while a large fraction is restricted to mesh size. The cavitated droplets have a similar size, which decreases with larger cooling rate. We motivate our theory by first considering how the elastic matrix affects a single droplet. We then couple the dynamics of multiple droplets via the diffusion of monomers in the dilute phase. Using numerical simulations and analytical approximations, we demonstrate that this model can explain all the experimental observations of the synthetic system.

External pressure governs dynamics of droplets

To understand how droplets interact with an elastic matrix, we first consider the free energy of a single spherical droplet of radius RR. Droplet growth is driven by the differences in chemical potential and osmotic pressure between the droplet and its surrounding. We show in the SI that this can be captured by a driving strength gg, which quantifies the energy gain when the droplet volume V=(4π/3)R3V = (4\pi/3)R^3 increases. However, when the droplet grows its surface area A=4πR2A = 4\pi R^2 also increases, which comes at a cost proportional to the surface energy γ\gamma.

Moreover, the matrix surrounding the droplet must be displaced, which we capture by an elastic energy FE(V)F_E(V). Taken together, the free energy FF of the entire system reads

F=−gV+γA+FE(V)(1)F = -gV + \gamma A + F_E(V) \tag*{(1)}

where we for simplicity first consider constant driving strength gg and surface energy γ\gamma.

A droplet will grow spontaneously when the free energy decreases (∂F/∂V<0\partial F/\partial V < 0), i.e., if

g>P(R)withP(R)=Pγ(R)+PE(R)(2)g > P(R) \qquad\text{with} \qquad P(R) = P_\gamma(R) + P_E(R) \tag*{(2)}

where Pγ=2γ/RP_\gamma= 2\gamma/R is the Laplace pressure due to the surface tension γ\gamma [17, 18] and PE=∂FE/∂VP_E = \partial F_E/\partial V is the pressure exerted by the elastic matrix; see SI. A droplet thus grows when the driving strength gg exceeds the pressure PP exerted on the droplet. A stationary state with droplet radius R∗R^* is reached when g=P(R∗)g = P(R^*), which is stable if ∂2F/∂V2>0\partial^2 F/\partial V^2 > 0, or,

P′(R∗)>0(3)P'(R^*) > 0 \tag*{(3)}

A droplet is thus stable when the exerted pressure increases with its size.

Without an elastic matrix, the droplet is only affected by the Laplace pressure PγP_\gamma; see Figure 1A. The corresponding free energy shown in Figure 1D demonstrates that surface tension dominates for small droplets. In particular, droplets can only grow spontaneously (∂F/∂V<0\partial F/\partial V < 0) after overcoming a nucleation barrier, e.g., by thermal fluctuations (homogeneous nucleation) [19] or thanks to nucleation sites that lower the barrier (heterogeneous nucleation); see SI. Once the droplet is big enough, the energy decreases with increasing radius and the droplet is always unstable (Pγ′(R)<0P'_\gamma(R) < 0). Droplet growth is then only restricted by the available amount of material.

Figure 1. Breakage implies a cavitation barrier Example of pressure P=PE+PγP = P_E + P_\gamma exerted on a droplet during growth (upper panels) and corresponding free energy FF (lower panels) as a function of the droplet radius RR for three different scenarios: Without an elastic mesh (PE=0P_E = 0), the pressure curve is monotonously decreasing (Panel A). After crossing a nucleation barrier, droplets grow until all material is absorbed (Panel D). An elastic matrix increases the pressure once the droplet grows beyond mesh size (Panel B). This can lead to an energy minimum where droplets are stable (Panel E). If the mesh can break, the pressure curve exhibits a local maximum (Panel C), which leads to a cavitation barrier (Panel F).

An elastic matrix restricts droplet growth

An elastic matrix surrounding the droplet exerts an additional pressure and thus potentially opposes growth; see Eq. [(2)]. The pressure exerted by the matrix depends on its elastic response. For small deformations, the response can be characterized by the Young’s modulus EE. However, droplets can grow much larger than the mesh size ℓ\ell, implying large deformations of the matrix. The simplest model describing such hyperelastic material is the Neo-Hookean model, where the pressure on a spherical cavity of radius RR is monotonically increasing (PE′(R)>0P_E'(R)>0) and converges at large radii to PE=5E/6P_E=5E/6 [20]. If the driving strength gg is lower than the maximal pressure, the system opposes further droplet growth and leads to a stable radius R∗R_{\ast} when g=P(R∗)g=P(R_{\ast}); see Figure 1B. This steady state corresponds to a minimum in the free energy; see Figure 1E. Therefore, an elastic mesh providing resistance to droplet growth can stabilize droplets.

Breakage provides a cavitation barrier for droplets

The Neo-Hookean model is often too simple to describe realistic materials, in part because it does not account for breaking bonds in the elastic mesh. To capture breakage, we next consider a stress-strain curve that has a maximal pressure PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}} at a finite radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}}; see Figure 1C. Similar to the Neo-Hookean model, we consider an increasing pressure when droplets grow beyond the mesh size ℓ\ell. However, at the critical radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}} the mesh cannot sustain the stress anymore and breaks, resulting in a pressure decrease [21]. The stability criterion given in Eq. [(3)] indicates that droplets with R=RcavR=R_{\mathrm{cav}} are unstable and will thus expand rapidly in a cavitation event [22, 23].

The non-monotonous stress-strain relation results in a free energy that has two energy barriers; see Figure 1F. The first barrier is the familiar nucleation barrier, while the second one is the cavitation barrier. The local minimum between the two barriers corresponds to the stable state described in the case of the Neo-Hookean model. However, with breakage, droplets can overcome the second barrier and cavitate if the driving strength gg exceeds PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}}. The growth of such droplets would then only be limited by the available amount of material, similar to the case without any elastic matrix.

Multiple droplets grow when temperature is decreased

In the experiments of Style et al. [10], multiple oil droplets appeared simultaneously when the temperature was lowered. Since lowering the temperature corresponds to increasing the driving strength gg, droplets appear when gg reaches the maximal pressure exerted by the surrounding matrix. If this maximal pressure increases with the overall stiffness, we predict that lower temperatures are necessary to create droplets in stiffer systems, which was indeed observed [11]. However, this qualitative analysis does not distinguish between the Neo-Hookean and the Breakage model, since both provide a maximal pressure that explains the simultaneous growth of droplets.

To distinguish the Neo-Hookean from the Breakage model, we need to analyze the droplet dynamics in detail. Since the elasto-adhesive length scale of the experimental system is smaller than the droplet size [24], elastic interactions of droplets are negligible. In contrast, growing droplets compete for the material dissolved in the dilute phase, which couples their dynamics. We analyze this using a mean-field theory, where we describe a collection of immobile droplets by their positions x⃗i\vec{x}_i and their radii RiR_i together with the concentration field c(x⃗)c(\vec{x}) in the dilute field [13]. For simplicity, we assume that the concentration cinc_{\mathrm{in}} inside each droplet is constant and that droplets are in equilibrium with their immediate surrounding, which exerts the pressure P(R)P(R) onto the droplet. This implies that the concentration right outside the interface of a droplet is given by [13]

ceq(P,T)=csat(T)exp⁡(PcinkBT),(4)c_{\mathrm{eq}}(P,T) = c_{\mathrm{sat}}(T) \exp\left(\frac{P}{c_{\mathrm{in}} k_{\mathrm{B}} T}\right), \tag*{(4)}

where csatc_{\mathrm{sat}} is the equilibrium concentration in the absence of an elastic mesh in the thermodynamic limit, kBk_{\mathrm{B}} is Boltzmann’s constant, and TT is the system’s temperature.

Droplets grow when their surrounding is supersaturated (c>ceqc > c_{\mathrm{eq}}). The droplet growth rate reads [13]

dRidt=DRicin[c(x⃗i)−ceq(P(Ri),T)],(5)\frac{\mathrm{d}R_i}{\mathrm{d}t} = \frac{D}{R_i c_{\mathrm{in}}}\left[c(\vec{x}_i) - c_{\mathrm{eq}}(P(R_i),T)\right], \tag*{(5)}

where DD is the diffusivity of the droplet material in the dilute phase. The concentration in the dilute phase obeys

∂tc=D∇2c−cin∑idVidtδ(x⃗i−x⃗),(6)\partial_t c = D\nabla^2 c - c_{\mathrm{in}} \sum_i \frac{\mathrm{d}V_i}{\mathrm{d}t}\delta(\vec{x}_i-\vec{x}), \tag*{(6)}

where the last term accounts for material exchange with the droplets [13]. Taken together with no-flux conditions at the system’s boundary, Eqs. [(5)–(6)] conserve the total amount of droplet material.

We simulate the system by mimicking the experimental protocol of Style et al. [10]. In particular, we consider a linear relation between the saturation concentration csatc_{\mathrm{sat}} and temperature TT together with a constant cooling rate. Consequently, csatc_{\mathrm{sat}} decreases linearly from the initial value c0c_0 until it reaches the minimal value c0−Δcc_0-\Delta c at the final temperature,

csat(t)={c0−αtt<Δcαc0−Δcotherwise,(7)c_{\mathrm{sat}}(t) = \begin{cases} c_0-\alpha t & t < \frac{\Delta c}{\alpha} \\ c_0-\Delta c & \text{otherwise}, \end{cases} \tag*{(7)}

where α\alpha is the rate of the decreases. As csatc_{\mathrm{sat}} is lowered, the equilibrium concentration ceqc_{\mathrm{eq}} also decrease, see Eq. [(4)], implying a larger supersaturation c−ceqc-c_{\mathrm{eq}}, which corresponds to a higher driving strength gg. Starting with a homogeneous system at high temperature (high csatc_{\mathrm{sat}}), droplets will nucleate once gg is large enough to cross the nucleation barrier; see Figure 1D–F. In the experimental system, homogeneous nucleation is basically impossible and droplets must thus nucleate heterogeneously at nucleation sites; see SI. This suggests that surface tension effects are negligible for small droplets. In fact, surface tension is also negligible for large droplets since Ostwald ripening is slow (see SI), suggesting that the total pressure PP is always dominated by the elastic pressure PEP_E. We thus neglect surface tension for simplicity and rather assume that droplets form quickly at nucleation sites. In particular, we initialize our simulations with many small droplets with radii on the order of the mesh size, Ri(t=0)=ℓR_i(t=0)=\ell, and focus on the subsequent dynamics.

The radius at which droplets are initialized is unimportant, since they are restricted by the elastic matrix to have a small radius RR that is governed by the condition g=P(R)g=P(R). Consequently, many microscopic droplets coexist early in the simulation.

Droplets can grow macroscopically (R≫ℓR\gg\ell) when the driving strength gg exceeds the pressure exerted by the mesh. Since realistic meshes are heterogeneous [25], the exerted pressure will vary slightly from droplet to droplet.

To capture such heterogeneity for the Neo-Hookean model (NH), we consider variable mesh sizes ℓi\ell_i,

PiNH(R)=E(56−2ℓi3R−ℓi46R4),(8)P_i^{\mathrm{NH}}(R) = E\left(\frac{5}{6} - \frac{2\ell_i}{3R} - \frac{\ell_i^4}{6R^4}\right), \tag*{(8)}

where EE is the macroscopic Young’s modulus of the material. Conversely, in the Breakage model (BR), we choose random cavitation pressures Pcav(i)P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{(i)}, since this parameter dominates the cavitation barrier. We thus consider the simple form

PiBR(R)={0R<ℓPcav(i)R−ℓRcav−ℓℓ≤R≤RcavP∞R>Rcav,(9)P_i^{\mathrm{BR}}(R) = \begin{cases} 0 & R < \ell\\ P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{(i)}\dfrac{R-\ell}{R_{\mathrm{cav}}-\ell} & \ell\le R \le R_{\mathrm{cav}} \\ P_{\infty} & R > R_{\mathrm{cav}}, \end{cases} \tag*{(9)}

where we keep both ℓ\ell and RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}} fixed for all droplets, since varying these parameters does not affect the results significantly; see SI. Eq. [(9)] implies that the external pressure increases linearly when the droplet grows beyond the mesh size ℓ\ell until it reaches the cavitation radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}}. Beyond this threshold, the mesh breaks and provides a constant resistance quantified by a pressure P∞<Pcav(i)P_{\infty} < P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{(i)}.

Figure 2 shows typical simulations of Eqs. [(4)]–[(7)] for both the Neo-Hookean model (Eq. [(8)]) and the Breakage model (Eq. [(9)]). In both cases, macroscopic droplets appear and they grow with very similar rates. However, the Breakage model additionally exhibits a large number of microscopic droplets, which apparently do not grow. Since these microscopic droplets are likely not visible in the experiment, both models appear to yield mono-disperse emulsions, although this requires an extremely homogeneous mesh in the Neo-Hookean model. In contrast, the models behave differently when we nucleate new droplets during the simulation: While all newly nucleated droplets grow in the Neo-Hookean model, in the Breakage model most droplets are restricted to microscopic sizes; see SI. Consequently, we expect that the Breakage model leads to a more uniform size distribution of large droplets in realistic situations.

Figure 2. Decreasing temperatures cause monodisperse emulsions in the Neo-Hookean model (NH, Panels A,C) and Breakage model (BR, Panels B,D). (A-B) 2d projections of typical simulations at two time points. The heat map indicates the concentration cc in the dilute phase and droplets are marked with disks where color saturation indicates depth. (C-D) Droplet radii RR as a function of time tt showing that large droplets are monodisperse after reaching the final temperature at t=Δc/αt = \Delta c/\alpha (dotted black line). The red dashed line shows the theoretical prediction given by Eq. [(10)]. The model parameters are α=1.864⋅10−5 s−1ν−1\alpha= 1.864 \cdot10^{-5}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}\nu^{-1}, E=186 kPaE = 186\,\mathrm{kPa}, Δc=0.0159 ν−1\Delta c = 0.0159\,\nu^{-1}, D=50 μm2 s−1D = 50\,\mathrm{\mu m}^{2}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}, cin=ν−1c_{\mathrm{in}} = \nu^{-1}, and cinkBT=11 MPac_{\mathrm{in}}k_{\mathrm{B}}T = 11\,\mathrm{MPa}. For the NH model, we sample ℓ\ell uniformly between 0.1 μm0.1\,\mathrm{\mu m} and 0.102 μm0.102\,\mathrm{\mu m} [25] and use m=7⋅10−6 μm−3m = 7 \cdot10^{-6}\,\mathrm{\mu m}^{-3}. For the BR model, we have Rcav=1 μmR_{\mathrm{cav}} = 1\,\mathrm{\mu m}, m=1.875⋅10−4 μm−3m = 1.875 \cdot10^{-4}\,\mathrm{\mu m}^{-3}, η/m=105E μm3\eta/m = 10^{5}E\,\mathrm{\mu m}^{3}, Pcavmin⁡=EP_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min} = E, and P∞=5/6EP_{\infty} = 5/6E.

To see which of the two models provide a better explanation of the experiments, we next test their predictions quantitatively. Here, we use the experimentally measured values of DD, Δc\Delta c, α\alpha, P∞P_{\infty}, EE, and cinc_{\mathrm{in}}, while the values of the mesh size ℓ\ell and the cavitation radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}} are arbitrary and do not affect the predictions of the model; see SI. The only relevant parameter, which we adjust to match the experimental data, is η/m\eta/m quantifying the mesh heterogeneity and the density of nucleated droplets. We first focus on the intriguing non-equilibrium effect that larger cooling rates lead to more and smaller droplets. In the Neo-Hookean model, the average droplet size ⟨R⟩\langle R\rangle is independent of the cooling rate α\alpha (see Fig. 3A), while it matches the experimental data in the Breakage model (Fig. 3B), including the dispersion statistics; see SI. The two models also differ in the spatial distribution of large droplets, which we quantify by the pair correlation function, similar to the experiments [10]. Figure 3C shows that droplets are uniformly distributed in the Neo-Hookean model since their positions are solely controlled by their nucleation. In contrast, droplet cavitation seems to be correlated in the

Comparison of Neo-Hookean and Breakage models and pair correlation functions

Figure 3. The Breakage model explains the experimental data. (A,B) Comparison of the experimental data (blue dots, [10]), numerical simulations (black symbols), and analytical predictions (red lines) for the radius RR of the cavitated droplets as a function of the rate α\alpha with which the saturation concentration decreases for the Neo-Hookean model and the Breakage model. (C,D) Scaled pairwise correlation function g(r)g(r) of the cavitated droplets (see SI) for three rates α\alpha. The inset in panel D shows the correlation between the radius RR of droplets and the size RvoroR_{\mathrm{voro}} of their surrounding, which is obtained from a Voronoi tesselation. (A-D) Model parameters are as in Figure 2, except for η/m=3⋅105E μm3\eta/m = 3 \cdot10^{5} E\ \mu\mathrm{m}^{3}.

Breakage model (Figure 3D), leading to a low probability of finding two large droplets close to each other, similar to the experiments [10]. The shown data collapse suggest that the pair correlation function is scale-free. Moreover, the volume surrounding a droplet, measured from a Voronoi tessellation, is strongly correlated with its size; see inset of Figure 3D. The fact that our simulations match the experimental data quantitatively suggests that breakage is a crucial aspect.

Large droplets suppress further cavitation by depleting their vicinity

To understand how breakage affects the droplets’ dynamics, we next investigate why some droplets cavitate while others remain small; see Figure 2D. Initially, all droplets are small and grow due to the decreasing saturation concentration by absorbing the excess material from the dilute phase. Note that droplets in a softer environment, i.e., with a lower PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}}, exhibit a lower equilibrium concentration ceqc_{\mathrm{eq}}, see Eq. [(4)], and thus grow faster. This initial growth phase continues until the droplet with the lowest PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}} reaches its cavitation radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}}. At this point, the elastic matrix no longer provides enough resistance (∂P/∂R<0\partial P/\partial R < 0) and the droplet radius becomes unstable; see Eq. [(3)]. The droplet thus cavitates by recruiting material from the dilute phase as fast as possible in a diffusion limited process. Such a quickly growing droplet depletes its surrounding, effectively fixing the local driving strength to g=P∞g = P_{\infty}. Consequently, other droplets in the vicinity cannot cavitate and will remain small forever. Taken together, the growth of a cavitated droplet prevents the cavitation of other droplets in its surrounding while droplets further away might still grow, which qualitatively explains the observed pair correlation function; see Figure 3D.

The numerical data shown in Figure 2D. suggests that all droplets that become large cavitated at very similar times t=tcavt = t_{\mathrm{cav}} and grow with similar rates. To understand the growth dynamics, we first consider cavitated droplets that are homogeneously distributed with a number density nn. Assuming that the cavitated droplets absorb all excess material from the dilute phase, we predict their volume to increase as

V(t)=Vcav+αncin(t−tcav),(10)V(t) = V_{\mathrm{cav}} + \frac{\alpha}{n c_{\mathrm{in}}}(t - t_{\mathrm{cav}}), \tag*{(10)}

where Vcav=(4π/3)Rcav3V_{\mathrm{cav}} = (4\pi/3)R_{\mathrm{cav}}^{3}. The dashed line in Figure 2D shows that the equivalent prediction for the droplet radius explains the mean growth dynamics of cavitated droplets. In fact, this analysis is also valid for the Neo-Hookean model shown in Figure 2C since droplets also start growing around the same time and absorb all excess material in this case. Taken together, this analysis indicates that the large droplets are mono-disperse because they start growing at the same time and grow with the same rate. However, while these conditions are met artificially by our setup of the Neo-Hookean model, they are self-organized in the Breakage model by controlling which droplets cavitate.

The final droplet size can be estimated by evaluating Eq. [(10)] at the time tfinal=Δc/αt_{\mathrm{final}} = \Delta c/\alpha when the final temperature is reached. For simplicity, we consider the case where droplets are large compared to the cavitation threshold RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}}, which also implies tcav≪tfinalt_{\mathrm{cav}} \ll t_{\mathrm{final}} and leads to Vfinal≈Δc/(ncin)V_{\mathrm{final}} \approx\Delta c/(n c_{\mathrm{in}}). This approximation correctly predicts that the final droplet volume is independent of the quench rate α\alpha in the Neo-Hookean model where the droplet density nn is set by the initial condition; see Figure 3A. Conversely, in the Breakage model, the density of cavitated droplets might depend on the quench rate α\alpha, which could explain the observed size-dependence shown in Figure 3B.

Number and size of cavitated droplets depend on quench rate and cavitation thresholds

To understand why faster cooling leads to more and smaller droplets, we next focus on the cavitation process in the Breakage model. Since cavitated droplets suppress further cavitation in their vicinity, we hypothesize that this suppression is less efficient when the system is cooled faster, implying that more droplets can cavitate overall.

To estimate the final density nn of cavitated droplets, we analyze a simplified theoretical model. The main idea is to study a fixed density nn of cavitated droplets and test whether additional droplets could cavitate in this situation. The best estimate is then the lowest value of nn where no more droplets cavitate. For simplicity, we consider a homogeneous distribution of cavitated droplets, allowing us to focus on a single droplet of radius R=RcavR = R_{\mathrm{cav}} in a spherically symmetric domain of volume n−1n^{-1}. We then obtain the concentration field c(r)c(r) around the droplet by solving the diffusion equation with the boundary condition c(Rcav)=ceq(P∞,T)c(R_{\mathrm{cav}}) = c_{\mathrm{eq}}(P_{\infty}, T); see SI. Additional cavitation takes place in the dilute phase if there is a droplet whose critical concentration ccav=ceq(Pcav,T)c_{\mathrm{cav}} = c_{\mathrm{eq}}(P_{\mathrm{cav}}, T) is lower than the actual concentration cc at its position. Note that the cavitation pressures PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}} are randomly distributed since the elastic matrix is heterogeneous. However, since cavitation only happens for low PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}}, it is sufficient to specify the associated cumulative distribution function F(Pcav)\mathcal{F}(P_{\mathrm{cav}}) to linear order around the lower bound Pcavmin⁡P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min},

F(Pcav)=Pcav−Pcavmin⁡ηΘ(Pcav−Pcavmin⁡),(11)\mathcal{F}(P_{\mathrm{cav}}) = \frac{P_{\mathrm{cav}} - P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min}}{\eta}\Theta(P_{\mathrm{cav}} - P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min}) , \tag*{(11)}

where Pcav−Pcavmin⁡≪ηP_{\mathrm{cav}} - P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min} \ll\eta. Here, Θ(x)\Theta(x) is Heaviside’s function and η\eta describes how widely the small cavitation pressures are distributed. η\eta thus quantifies the heterogeneity of the mesh. Considering a homogeneous density mm of nucleated droplets, we can then calculate the expected value of droplets that cavitate in the volume n−1n^{-1}. This theory is self-consistent if exactly one droplet cavitates in this volume, which provides an implicit condition for the sought density nn of cavitated droplets; see SI.

The theory does not have any adjustable parameters and we thus compare it directly to our numerical simulations. Figure 4A shows that the density nn of cavitated droplets decreases when fewer droplets nucleate (smaller mm) or cavitation thresholds PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}} are wider distributed (more heterogeneous network, higher η\eta). This is because these two parameters define how many nucleated droplet possess a low enough threshold to cavitate. Conversely, Figure 4B shows that more droplets cavitate when the system is cooled faster. Since the total amount of material taken up by droplets is conserved, this implies smaller droplets for faster cooling, consistent with Figure 3B. While our theory shows the same trends as the numerical simulations, it consistently overestimates nn by roughly a factor of 2 in most cases. This is likely because we assumed a homogeneous distribution of the droplets with the lowest cavitation threshold, while in reality two droplets with low threshold might out-compete each other, effectively leading to a higher cavitation threshold than we anticipate. However, our theory indicates that the cavitated droplets deplete the dilute phase, thus suppressing further cavitation. Since this depletion is diffusion-limited, decreasing temperature slowly implies stronger suppression, leading to fewer and larger droplets.

Figure 4. Suppression of cavitation by large droplets explains numerical data. (A) Density nn of cavitated droplets from numerical simulations (black symbols) compared to the analytical prediction (red line) as a function of the mesh heterogeneity η\eta. (B) nn as a function of the rate α\alpha with which the saturation concentration decreases. (A,B) Model parameters are given in Figure 2, except η/m=3⋅105E μm3\eta/m = 3\cdot10^{5}E\,\mu\mathrm{m}^{3} in panel B.

Increasing cooling rates cause bidisperse emulsions

We showed that the number and size of the cavitated droplets depends on the depletion of the dilute phase and thus the cooling rate. This implies that additional droplets could cavitate when the cooling rate is increased, while lowering the cooling rate should merely slow down droplet growth. Indeed, experiments by Rosowski et al. showed a bimodal droplet size distribution when the cooling rate was rapidly increased in the middle of the experiment [11]. To explain this observation, we perform a numerical simulation where we rapidly increase the cooling rate well after the first generation of droplets has cavitated. This results in a second generation of cavitated droplets, which then grow together with the previously cavitated ones; see Figure 5. We show in the SI that other size distributions are possible when the rate is changed multiple times. Taken together, this demonstrates that different droplet size distributions can be engineered by adjusting the cooling protocol.

Figure 5. Increasing cooling rate yields bidisperse emulsion. Shown are the droplet radii as a function of time (A) and the droplet size distribution (B) from a numerical simulation with η/m=3⋅105E μm3\eta/m = 3 \cdot10^{5} E\ \mu\mathrm{m}^{3}, E=80 kPaE = 80\,\mathrm{kPa}, and α=7.77⋅10−6 s−1ν−1\alpha= 7.77 \cdot10^{-6}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}\nu^{-1} for t<960 st < 960\,\mathrm{s}, then α=3.11⋅10−5 s−1ν−1\alpha= 3.11 \cdot10^{-5}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}\nu^{-1}. Other parameters as in Figure 2.

Heterogeneous nucleation might explain more cavitated droplets in stiffer systems

So far, we have investigated how the density and sizes of the observed droplets depend on the cooling rate α\alpha. Another important observation of Style et al. [10] is that the droplet density nn increases linearly with the Young’s modulus EE of the elastic matrix. This implies that stiffer matrices lead to smaller droplets. Unfortunately, it is difficult to connect EE, which measures the macroscopic response of the matrix to small strains, to the microscopic details required by our model. We thus next consider several possibilities to elucidate which microscopic picture could explain the experimental data.

In the simplest case, the bulk modulus EE is connected to the pressure curve P(R)P(R). For example, the Neo-Hookean model implies PNH(R→∞)=56EP^{\mathrm{NH}}(R \to\infty) = \frac{5}{6}E; see Eq. [(8)]. The relation is more complicated for the breakage model, but recent experiments [21] indicate that both the cavitation pressure PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}} as well as the pressure P∞P_{\infty} exhibited by large droplets scale with EE. Using this scaling in our model, we obtain slightly smaller droplet densities for stiffer matrices, opposite to what we expect from the experiments; see Figure 6A. Consequently, the scaling of the pressure with EE cannot explain the observed data.

Droplet density and predicted nucleation site density as functions of Young’s modulus

Figure 6. Increasing nucleation density could explain stiffness dependence (A) Droplet density nn as a function of Young’s modulus EE. Our numerical (black symbols) and analytical (red line) theory, based on a linear scaling of pressures with EE, cannot explain the experimental data (blue dashed line, [10]). (B) Predicted nucleation site density mm as a function of EE to match the measured n(E)n(E) shown in the inset. Inset: n(E)n(E) from experiments (blue dashed line, [10]) and numerical simulations (black symbols). (A,B) Model Parameters are α=2.33⋅10−5 s−1ν−1\alpha= 2.33\cdot10^{-5}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}\nu^{-1}, and given in Figure 2

Our model would yield more (and smaller) cavitated droplets when the density mm of nucleated droplets was increased. We thus speculate that stiffer systems nucleate more droplets. Indeed, we can explain the observed linear increase of the density nn of cavitated droplets with EE by postulating that mm strongly increases with EE; see Figure 6B. So far, it is not clear how droplets actually nucleate in the elastic network, but it is likely that heterogeneous nucleation plays a role. For instance, the cross-linking molecules that are used to create the PDMS matrix could act as nucleation sites. In this case, stiffer gels would have more nucleated droplets simply because they contain more cross-linkers [10, 11, 21]. Moreover, stiffer networks might be more homogeneous [25], which would be capture by a smaller mesh heterogeneity η\eta. Taken together, these two effects might explain our prediction that the parameter m/ηm/\eta increases strongly with EE.

Conclusions

We identified a novel mechanism to create monodisperse emulsions, where some growing droplets break the surrounding elastic matrix in a cavitation event. While these droplets become macroscopic, most droplets stay constrained by the matrix and do not grow significantly beyond mesh size. The cavitation barrier imposed by the elastic matrix thus separates the stochastic nucleation phase from a deterministic growth phase. The resulting cavitated droplets have correlated positions and similar sizes, which can be controlled by the cooling rate. Our model agrees quantitatively with experiments [10, 11] and it suggests how this mechanism can be used to create microscopic patterns in technological applications.

Monodisperse emulsion also emerge in other situations of driven phase separation. For instance, supplying more droplet material externally [26], internally using solubility gradients [27], or by chemical reactions [28] all lead to narrower droplet size distributions than expected from the standard Lifshitz-Slyozov argument [29]. In all these cases, the diffusive flux between droplets that normally drives Ostwald ripening is dominated by the flux of the supplied droplet material. In our system, all droplets additionally start growing at similar times, because they cross the cavitation barrier at similar saturation concentration. Taken together, this ensures that droplets reach similar sizes, despite multiple opposing processes: Beside the heterogeneities in the elastic properties that causes the dispersion in our model, thermal fluctuations might also contribute. Moreover, both Ostwald ripening, driven by surface tension, and Elastic ripening, driven by stiffness gradients over long length scales [11, 13], will affect the droplet size distribution in realistic systems. It will be interesting to study all these interactions in the future.

We expect similar behaviors for biomolecular condensates, which often form as a response to changes in temperature, pH, salt concentration, or protein concentration in cells [30, 31, 32, 33]. Moreover, chemical modifications, like post-translational modifications, allow cells to actively regulate condensates [34, 35]. All these changes could in principle drive droplet formation, similar to the cooling in our example. Biomolecular condensates are also typically constrained by elastic matrices [3, 8, 9], which can limit their growth. Moreover, biopolymer gels often rearrange dynamically, implying that the mechanical stress exerted by droplets can relax and they can grow further akin to the cavitation event in our model. Beyond our current description, the rearrangement implies visco-elastic behavior [36, 37, 38] and biopolymer gels also often display strain-stiffening [39]. There is also the possibility of droplets wetting the mesh instead of excluding it completely [16]. Taken together with the fact that the size of typical condensates is comparable to the gel’s mesh size, we thus expect a rich phenomenology. Our theory provides a robust starting point for such future investigations.

Materials and Methods

The numerical simulations where performed using the py-pde python package [40] using an explicit Euler stepping with a second order discretization of the spatial derivative.

Acknowledgments

We thank Eric Dufresne, Pierre Ronceray, and Robert W. Style for a critical review of the manuscript and helpful discussions. For further discussions, we also thank Tal Cohen, Stefanie Heyden, and Noah Ziethen. Funding was provided by the Max Planck Society.

References

Elastic energy of a growing cavity

We consider a droplet nucleated inside a cavity of an elastic material. This cavity has original radius AA and we look for the elastic energy of the system once the droplet has grown and expanded the cavity to a radius aa. The elastic energy FEF_{\mathrm{E}} of the system is

FE=∫ω d3r ,(12)F_{\mathrm{E}} = \int\omega\,\mathrm{d}^{3}r \,, \tag*{(12)}

where ω\omega is the energy density of the system and depends on the elastic properties of the media. Assuming a spherical cavity and a perfectly homogenous system, the pressure PP exerted on the droplet is

P=−∫2σr dr ,(13)P = -\int\frac{2\sigma}{r}\,\mathrm{d}r \,, \tag*{(13)}

where σ\sigma is the biaxial stress and rr the radial coordinate of the deformed solid. We parametrize the system using the radial stretch λ=r/R\lambda= r/R, where RR is the radial coordinate in the original (non-deformed) solid. The two coordinates systems are related through volume conservation,

R3−A3=r3−a3 .(14)R^{3} - A^{3} = r^{3} - a^{3} \,. \tag*{(14)}

Using the biaxial stress definition

σ(λ)=λ2dωdλ ,(15)\sigma(\lambda) = \frac{\lambda}{2}\frac{\mathrm{d}\omega}{\mathrm{d}\lambda} \,, \tag*{(15)}

we obtain the pressure PP in terms of the energy density,

P=∫1a/A1λ3−1dωdλ dλ ,(16)P = \int_{1}^{a/A} \frac{1}{\lambda^{3}-1}\frac{\mathrm{d}\omega}{\mathrm{d}\lambda}\,\mathrm{d}\lambda\,, \tag*{(16)}

where we have used λ→1\lambda\to1 at the system’s boundary. Integrating by parts we obtain

P=ωλ3−1∣1a/A+∫1a/A3λ2ω(λ3−1)2 dλ .(17)P = \left.\frac{\omega}{\lambda^{3}-1}\right|_{1}^{a/A} + \int_{1}^{a/A} \frac{3\lambda^{2}\omega}{(\lambda^{3}-1)^{2}}\,\mathrm{d}\lambda\,. \tag*{(17)}

Defining

P0=A3ω(a/A)a3−A3,(18)P_0 = \frac{A^3\omega(a/A)}{a^3-A^3}, \tag*{(18)}

and using the definition of Elastic Energy FEF_E, we get an expression for the elastic energy in terms of the pressure exerted on the droplet

FE=4π(a3−A3)3(P−P0).(19)F_E = \frac{4\pi(a^3-A^3)}{3}(P-P_0). \tag*{(19)}

We next check whether this mechanical definition is consistent with the thermodynamic definition

∂FE∂V=P,(20)\frac{\partial F_E}{\partial V}=P, \tag*{(20)}

where FEF_E is differentiated with respect to the expanded cavity radius V=4πa3/3V=4\pi a^3/3. Differentiating [S.8],

∂FE∂V=P−P0+(a3−A3)3a2(∂P∂a−∂P0∂a),(21)\frac{\partial F_E}{\partial V}=P-P_0+\frac{(a^3-A^3)}{3a^2}\left(\frac{\partial P}{\partial a}-\frac{\partial P_0}{\partial a}\right), \tag*{(21)}

using the definition of P0P_0, see [S.7], we find

∂FE∂V=P+13a2((a3−A2)∂P∂a−A3∂ω∂a).(22)\frac{\partial F_E}{\partial V}=P+\frac{1}{3a^2}\left((a^3-A^2)\frac{\partial P}{\partial a}-A^3\frac{\partial\omega}{\partial a}\right). \tag*{(22)}

Finally, using [S.5], we obtain

∂P∂a=A3a3−A3∂ω∂a,(23)\frac{\partial P}{\partial a}=\frac{A^3}{a^3-A^3}\frac{\partial\omega}{\partial a}, \tag*{(23)}

which combined with [S.11] recovers the thermodynamic pressure given by [S.9].

Free energy of a growing droplet

We now look for a simple expression for the free energy of a growing droplet in a phase separating system. Analysing how this energy changes with volume will give us an approximation of the effect of an external pressure in this system.

Given a free energy density ff and a systems’s size VsysV_{\mathrm{sys}}, the total free energy is

F=Vf(ϕin)+(Vsys−V)f(ϕout)+γA+FE(V),(24)F = V f(\phi_{\mathrm{in}}) + (V_{\mathrm{sys}} - V) f(\phi_{\mathrm{out}}) + \gamma A + F_E(V), \tag*{(24)}

where ϕin\phi_{\mathrm{in}} is the volume fraction inside the growing droplet, ϕout\phi_{\mathrm{out}} is the volume fraction outside, FEF_E is, as before, the elastic energy, VV is the droplet’s volume, and AA is the droplet’s surface area.

We assume material conservation in the system during the droplet’s expansion,

Vsysϕˉ=(Vsys−V)ϕout+Vϕin,(25)V_{\mathrm{sys}}\bar{\phi} = (V_{\mathrm{sys}} - V)\phi_{\mathrm{out}} + V\phi_{\mathrm{in}}, \tag*{(25)}

where ϕˉ\bar{\phi} is the average concentration in the system. Assuming small changes in the dilute phase concentration, we can expand the free energy density,

f(ϕout)≈f(ϕout0)+f′(ϕout0)(Vsysϕˉ−VϕinVsys−V−ϕout0).(26)f(\phi_{\mathrm{out})} \approx f(\phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0}) + f'(\phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0})\left(\frac{V_{\mathrm{sys}}\bar{\phi} - V\phi_{\mathrm{in}}}{V_{\mathrm{sys}} - V} - \phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0}\right). \tag*{(26)}

We can then reorder the free energy as

F≈F0−Vg+γA+FE,(27)F \approx F_0 - Vg + \gamma A + F_E, \tag*{(27)}

with

g=f(ϕout0)−f(ϕin)+f′(ϕout0)(ϕin−ϕout0)(28)g = f(\phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0}) - f(\phi_{\mathrm{in}}) + f'(\phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0})(\phi_{\mathrm{in}} - \phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0}) \tag*{(28)}

and

F0=Vsys[f(ϕout0)+f′(ϕout0)(ϕˉ−ϕout0)].(29)F_0 = V_{\mathrm{sys}}\left[f(\phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0}) + f'(\phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0})(\bar{\phi} - \phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0})\right]. \tag*{(29)}

Using the definition of osmotic pressure,

Π=−f(ϕ)+f′(ϕ)ϕ,(30)\Pi= -f(\phi) + f'(\phi)\phi, \tag*{(30)}

we express gg using the difference in osmotic pressures,

g=Πin−Πout0−[f′(ϕin)−f′(ϕout0)]ϕin.(31)g = \Pi_{\mathrm{in}} - \Pi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0} - \left[f'(\phi_{\mathrm{in}}) - f'(\phi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0})\right]\phi_{\mathrm{in}.} \tag*{(31)}

Finally, using the definition of chemical potential μ=νf′(ϕ)\mu= \nu f'(\phi), with ν\nu the molecular volume, we obtain

g=Πin−Πout0−[μin−μout0]cin,(32)g = \Pi_{\mathrm{in}} - \Pi_{\mathrm{out}}^{0} - \left[\mu_{\mathrm{in}} - \mu_{\mathrm{out}}^{0}\right]c_{\mathrm{in}}, \tag*{(32)}

where cin=ϕin/νc_{\mathrm{in}} = \phi_{\mathrm{in}}/\nu is the number concentration inside the droplet. In the case of an incompressible dense phase, i.e. where ϕin\phi_{\mathrm{in}} is constant, we find that the driving strength gg is independent of droplet volume.

Stability analysis

We showed in the previous section that the driving strength gg is typically independent of the droplet volume VV. Phase separation is favorable (in the absence of surface tension and elastic effects), when g>0g > 0. To see how elastic effects affect the phase separation, we differentiate [S.16] with respect to the droplet volume,

∂F∂V=−g+2γR+PE ,(33)\frac{\partial F}{\partial V}=-g+\frac{2\gamma}{R}+P_E \, , \tag*{(33)}

where we have used [S.9] to derive the elastic pressure. Therefore, droplet growth is favourable if

g>2γR+PE .(34)g>\frac{2\gamma}{R}+P_E \, . \tag*{(34)}

A droplet will thus grow as long as the driving strength gg is bigger than the total pressure difference between the inside and outside of the droplet.

We next study the stability of a steady state, which exists when g=P(R∗)g=P(R^*). This state is stable if

∂2F∂V2∣R=R∗=∂∂V(2γR+PE(R))∣R=R∗>0 .(35)\left.\frac{\partial^2 F}{\partial V^2}\right|_{R=R^*}=\left.\frac{\partial}{\partial V}\left(\frac{2\gamma}{R}+P_E(R)\right)\right|_{R=R^*}>0 \, . \tag*{(35)}

Therefore, a droplet will be stable if the pressure increases with increasing radius.

The same stability condition can be obtained from the dynamical equations presented in the main manuscript,

dRidt=DRicin[c(x⃗i)−ceq(P(Ri),T)] .(36)\frac{\mathrm{d}R_i}{\mathrm{d}t}=\frac{D}{R_i c_{\mathrm{in}}}\left[c(\vec{x}_i)-c_{\mathrm{eq}}\left(P(R_i),T\right)\right] \, . \tag*{(36)}

A linear stability analysis shows that the droplet radius is stable if ceqc_{\mathrm{eq}} increases with droplet radius. Since ceqc_{\mathrm{eq}} is a monotonically increasing function of P(R)P(R), the stability condition reduces to

∂∂R(2γR+PE(R))∣R=R∗>0 ,(37)\left.\frac{\partial}{\partial R}\left(\frac{2\gamma}{R}+P_E(R)\right)\right|_{R=R^*}>0 \, , \tag*{(37)}

which is equivalent to Eq. [S.24].

Droplet nucleation

We here study the droplet nucleation behavior by considering the energy necessary to cross the nucleation barrier in the absence of elastic effects. We consider a supersaturated homogeneous solution with concentration c0c_0 and use the driving strength gg, Eq. S.21, to estimate the energy change due to a droplet nucleating. We assume that the differences in pressure relax much more quickly than the differences in chemical potential, implying that we can approximate the driving strength as

g≈[μout−μin]cin.(38)g \approx[\mu_{\mathrm{out}}-\mu_{\mathrm{in}}]c_{\mathrm{in}} . \tag*{(38)}

To estimate its value, we thus need to determine the chemical potentials μout\mu_{\mathrm{out}} and μin\mu_{\mathrm{in}} outside and inside the droplet, respectively.

Assuming that the nucleated droplet is small, the chemical potential outside is close to that of the homogeneous phase, which can be estimated using ideal solution theory, μout≈kBTlog⁡cout\mu_{\mathrm{out}} \approx k_{\mathrm{B}}T\log c_{\mathrm{out}}. To obtain an upper bound on the nucleation rate, we seek the strongest possible driving strength and thus use cout≈c0c_{\mathrm{out}} \approx c_0.

We estimate the chemical potential μin\mu_{\mathrm{in}} inside the droplet by considering the phase separated system, which reached an equilibrium between a dilute phase with concentration couteqc_{\mathrm{out}}^{\mathrm{eq}} and a droplet phase with concentration cineqc_{\mathrm{in}}^{\mathrm{eq}}. In equilibrium, the chemical potential of both phases are identical, and we thus have

μineq=μouteq≈kBTlog⁡(c0−Δc),(39)\mu_{\mathrm{in}}^{\mathrm{eq}}=\mu_{\mathrm{out}}^{\mathrm{eq}}\approx k_{\mathrm{B}}T\log(c_0-\Delta c), \tag*{(39)}

where c0−Δcc_0-\Delta c is a lower bound for the concentration in the dilute phase.

Finally, we assume that the chemical potential inside the droplet is constant during equilibration, μin≈μineq\mu_{\mathrm{in}}\approx\mu_{\mathrm{in}}^{\mathrm{eq}}, to obtain the estimate

g≈kBTcinlog⁡(c0c0−Δc).(40)g\approx k_{\mathrm{B}}Tc_{\mathrm{in}}\log\left(\frac{c_0}{c_0-\Delta c}\right). \tag*{(40)}

Consequently, the change in free energy ΔF\Delta\mathcal{F} due to one droplet of radius RR is

ΔF≈4πR2γ−4π3R3g,(41)\Delta\mathcal{F}\approx4\pi R^2\gamma-\frac{4\pi}{3}R^3g , \tag*{(41)}

where γ=4.4\gamma=4.4 mN/m is the surface tension measured in the experiments [10]. The location of the maximum of this curve corresponds to the nucleation radius

Rnuc=2γg≈3.09 nm,(42)R_{\mathrm{nuc}}=\frac{2\gamma}{g}\approx3.09\ \mathrm{nm} , \tag*{(42)}

where we have used the measured value cinkBT=11c_{\mathrm{in}}k_{\mathrm{B}}T = 11 MPa [11]. The associated energy barrier is

ΔFnuc=16πγ33g2≈1.76⋅10−19 J≈42.4 kBT.(43)\Delta F_{\mathrm{nuc}} = \frac{16\pi\gamma^3}{3g^2} \approx1.76 \cdot10^{-19}\ \mathrm{J} \approx42.4\,k_{\mathrm{B}}T . \tag*{(43)}

The probability PnucP_{\mathrm{nuc}} of droplet nucleation can then be estimated using classical nucleation theory,

Pnuc=ke−ΔFnuc/kBT≈k⋅10−19.(44)P_{\mathrm{nuc}} = k e^{-\Delta F_{\mathrm{nuc}}/k_{\mathrm{B}}T} \approx k \cdot10^{-19}. \tag*{(44)}

The pre-factor kk in this theory is difficult to estimate, but this expression shows that the nucleation rate is suppressed by 10−1910^{-19} and homogeneous nucleation is thus very unlikely in this system.

The fact that droplets appear in the experiments suggests that they are nucleated by alternative paths. We thus propose that heterogeneous nucleation is crucial. In heterogeneous nucleation droplets are nucleated around surfaces or imperfections, which effectively lower the nucleation barrier. The interaction of the droplet with these nucleation sites scales with the contact area, which scales with ∝R2\propto R^2 if the size of the nucleation site is about RnucR_{\mathrm{nuc}} or larger. Consequently, the primary effect of heterogeneous nucleation is to lower the effective surface tension. We thus assume that our system for small droplets has an effective surface tension that is smaller than the measured surface tension for large cavitated droplets. We thus do not discuss surface tension effects in the main text and rather assume that droplet nucleation happens quickly.

Results are independent of mesh size and cavitation radius

In the Breakage model, we use a simplified pressure curve, which is parameterized by the mesh size ℓ\ell, the cavitation radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}}, the cavitation pressure PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}}, the heterogeneity parameter η\eta, and the final pressure P∞P_{\infty} for large radii; see Fig. S.1. The mesh size ℓ\ell only determines when the pressure starts to increase, and therefore the slope of the pressure curve. Considering the cavitated droplet density nn, introducing variation in the mesh size ℓ\ell is equivalent to variations in PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}} for different droplets. Beside this, varying the mesh size ℓ\ell changes the size of the small droplets, but since they do not affect the number of cavitated droplets, we do not study this effect further. We thus for simplicity only vary PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}} and keep ℓ\ell the same for all droplets. Moreover, numerical simulations indicate that the cavitation radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}} has basically no influence on the cavitated droplet density nn; see Fig. S.2. Given these results we choose not to vary RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}} between droplets or simulations, and keep η/m\eta/m as our only free parameter to fit experimental data.

Figure S.1. Stress-strain relation of the Breakage model. Pressure PP as a function of the droplet radius RR, which is imposed in numerical simulations. The plot indicates the mesh size ℓ\ell, the radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}} at which the droplet cavitates, the maximal pressure PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}} the mesh can exert, and the pressure P∞P_{\infty} after breakage. The shaded area shows the possible values for PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}} given the distribution parameter η\eta.

Ostwald Ripening

In this section we estimate the relevant timescale for Ostwald ripening in our system to asses its relevance for the cavitated droplets. Ostwald ripening is driven by surface tension and the relevant scale is the capillary length scale ℓγ\ell_\gamma of the system [41],

Droplet density as a function of cavitation radius

Figure S.2. Droplet density is independent of cavitation radius Density nn of cavitated droplets as a function of the cavitation radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}}. Model parameters as in Figure 2 of the main manuscript, except η/m=3⋅105E μm3\eta/m = 3\cdot10^{5} E\,\mu\mathrm{m}^{3}.

ℓγ=2γcinkBT≈0.8 nm .(45)\ell_\gamma= \frac{2\gamma}{c_{\mathrm{in}} k_{\mathrm{B}} T} \approx0.8\ \mathrm{nm}\, . \tag*{(45)}

where we have used the surface tension γ=4.4 mN/m\gamma= 4.4\ \mathrm{mN}/\mathrm{m} of macroscopic droplets [10]. Linear stability analysis shows that the fastest growing mode λ\lambda is given by [28]

λ=DℓγceqR3cin .(46)\lambda= \frac{D\ell_\gamma c_{\mathrm{eq}}}{R^{3}c_{\mathrm{in}}}\, . \tag*{(46)}

Considering a typical radius R=10 μmR = 10\ \mu\mathrm{m} of a cavitated droplet, together with D=50 μm2/sD = 50\ \mu\mathrm{m}^{2}/\mathrm{s} and ceq/cin≈csat(300 K)/cin=0.054c_{\mathrm{eq}}/c_{\mathrm{in}} \approx c_{\mathrm{sat}}(300\ \mathrm{K})/c_{\mathrm{in}} = 0.054, we find λ≈2.14⋅10−6 s−1\lambda\approx2.14\cdot10^{-6}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1}. Consequently, the timescale τ=λ−1\tau= \lambda^{-1} of Ostwald ripening between the cavitated droplets is

τ≈130 hr .(47)\tau\approx130\ \mathrm{hr}\, . \tag*{(47)}

Interestingly, the same expression is obtained when considering the critical radius RcR_{\mathrm{c}} of the Lifshitz–Slyozov scaling law [41]

Rc∝(Dℓγceqtcin)1/3 .(48)R_{\mathrm{c}} \propto\left(\frac{D\ell_\gamma c_{\mathrm{eq}}t}{c_{\mathrm{in}}}\right)^{1/3}\, . \tag*{(48)}

We thus conclude that Ostwald ripening is a slow process in our system and we can neglect it.

Figure S.3. Breakage stops newly nucleated droplets from growing. (A,B) Snapshots of a typical simulation with a constant nucleation rate for Neo-Hookean (left) and Breakage pressure curves (right). Disks indicate droplets, while the heat map indicates the concentration cc in the dilute phase, gray scale indicates depth in the zz-axis. (C,D) Droplet radii over time for all nucleated droplets. pnuc=0.5 s−1p_{\mathrm{nuc}} = 0.5\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}, other parameters as in Figure 2 of the main text.

Numerical Simulations with Nucleation

To make a more realistic comparison of the Neo-Hookean model and the Breakage model, we performed numerical simulations with a simple droplet nucleation protocol. The simulations were initialized without any droplets and at each time step a droplet might nucleate with a probability pnucp_{\mathrm{nuc}}. The new droplet appears with R<ℓR < \ell. The typical simulations presented in Figure S.3 show that in the Neo-Hookean model the new droplets can grow freely, leading to a wide range of final radii. In contrast, in the Breakage model, most new droplets get stuck at mesh size and do not grow further, thus producing a monodispersed emulsion of cavitated droplets.

Figure S.4. Polydispersity increases at higher droplet densities. Polydispersity, defined as the standard deviation of the droplet radius divided by its mean, for (A) different mesh heterogeneities η/mE\eta/mE and (B) different rates α\alpha. Experimental data from [10].

Pair correlation function

To quantify the position correlations of droplets in our system we defined the pair correlation function g(r)g(r) which gives the probability of finding a droplet at distance rr from the reference droplet. It is formally defined as

g(r)=VsysN⟨∑iδ(r⃗−r⃗i)⟩,(49)g(r) = \frac{V_{\mathrm{sys}}}{N} \left\langle\sum_i \delta(\vec{r} - \vec{r}_i) \right\rangle, \tag*{(49)}

where the sum is over all cavitated droplets, the average is over different ensembles, NN is the number of cavitated droplets, and VsysV_{\mathrm{sys}} the system’s volume. In practice we calculate it as

g(r)=h(r)Vsys4πN2r2Δr,(50)g(r) = \frac{h(r)V_{\mathrm{sys}}}{4\pi N^2 r^2 \Delta r} , \tag*{(50)}

where h(r)h(r) is the histogram of the distances between droplets (a total of N(N−1)N(N-1) elements) and Δr\Delta r is the histogram’s bin size. Finally, to collapse the different curves we normalized by the mean droplet distance 2[3/(4πn)]1/32[3/(4\pi n)]^{1/3}.

Double quench experiment produces a bimodal distribution, with droplet radii over time and 2-D projections at 200 s, 800 s, and 1300 s

Figure S.5. Double quench experiment produces a bimodal distribution. Left panel: Droplet radii as a function of time displaying a bimodal distribution of the cavitated droplets and several small ones kept at mesh size. Subsequent panels: 2-D projection of a typical time evolution in this system, showing droplets starting to cavitate, grown first group of cavitated droplets, and final state of the system. Smaller droplets are shown as black dots for didactic purposes and might appear as inside cavitated droplets due to 3-D projection. Parameters are η/m=3⋅105E μm3\eta/m = 3 \cdot10^{5} E\ \mu\mathrm{m}^{3}, E=80 kPaE = 80\ \mathrm{kPa}, first cooling rate α=7.77⋅10−6 s−1ν−1\alpha= 7.77 \cdot10^{-6}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1}\nu^{-1}, second cooling rate α=3.11⋅10−5 s−1ν−1\alpha= 3.11 \cdot10^{-5}\ \mathrm{s}^{-1}\nu^{-1}. Other parameters as in Figure 2.

Theoretical estimation of cavitated droplet density nn

We here provide details on the analytical theory to predict the density nn of cavitated droplets. This is based on the simplified picture that a single large droplet depletes a surrounding volume of radius LL in a diffusion limited process. To obtain the concentration field around this droplet, we solve Eq. (6) in a spherical domain of radius L=[3/(4πn)]1/3L = [3/(4\pi n)]^{1/3} with boundary conditions ∂rc∣r=L=0\left.\partial_r c\right|_{r=L} = 0 and c(r=Rcav)=csat(t)exp⁡(P∞/(cinkBT))c(r = R_{\mathrm{cav}}) = c_{\mathrm{sat}}(t) \exp(P_{\infty}/(c_{\mathrm{in}} k_{\mathrm{B}} T)). Defining cˉ=c+αtexp⁡(P∞/(cinkBT))\bar{c} = c + \alpha t \exp(P_{\infty}/(c_{\mathrm{in}} k_{\mathrm{B}} T)) turns Eq. (6) into

∂tcˉ=D∇2cˉ+αexp⁡(P∞cinkBT)−cin∑idVidtδ(x⃗i−x⃗)(51)\partial_t \bar{c} = D\nabla^2\bar{c} + \alpha\exp\left(\frac{P_{\infty}}{c_{\mathrm{in}} k_{\mathrm{B}} T}\right) - c_{\mathrm{in}}\sum_i \frac{\mathrm{d}V_i}{\mathrm{d}t}\delta(\vec{x}_i-\vec{x}) \tag*{(51)}

with the simpler boundary conditions ∂rcˉ∣r=L=0\left.\partial_r\bar{c}\right|_{r=L} = 0 and cˉ(r=Rcav)=c0exp⁡(P∞/(cinkBT))\bar{c}(r = R_{\mathrm{cav}}) = c_0 \exp(P_{\infty}/(c_{\mathrm{in}} k_{\mathrm{B}} T)). Assuming radial symmetry and steady state, the field around a cavitated droplet of radius RcavR_{\mathrm{cav}} reads x‘x‘

cˉ(r)=[c0+α6D(Rcav2−r2)+αL33D(1Rcav−1r)]exp⁡(P∞cinkBT).(52)\bar{c}(r)=\left[c_0+\frac{\alpha}{6D}\left(R_{\mathrm{cav}}^2-r^2\right)+\frac{\alpha L^3}{3D}\left(\frac{1}{R_{\mathrm{cav}}}-\frac{1}{r}\right)\right]\exp\left(\frac{P_{\infty}}{c_{\mathrm{in}}k_{\mathrm{B}}T}\right). \tag*{(52)}

We thus simplified the cavitation scenario by assuming that once a droplet cavitates it absorbs material in a sphere of radius LL around them.

To account for heterogeneity in the cavitation pressures PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}}, we describe them through their cumulative distribution function F(Pcav)F(P_{\mathrm{cav}}), which gives the fraction of droplets whose cavitation pressure is lower than PcavP_{\mathrm{cav}}. Since only droplets with the lowest cavitation thresholds will cavitate, we only need to describe the lower end of F(Pcav)F(P_{\mathrm{cav}}). Since there must be a lowest, positive cavitation pressure Pcavmin⁡P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min}, we assume a linear expansion around this minimum,

F(Pcav)=Pcav−Pcavmin⁡ηΘ(Pcav−Pcavmin⁡),(53)\mathcal{F}(P_{\mathrm{cav}})=\frac{P_{\mathrm{cav}}-P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min}}{\eta}\Theta\left(P_{\mathrm{cav}}-P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min}\right), \tag*{(53)}

where η\eta describes how widely distributed the lower thresholds are. This expression can be rewritten using Eq. (5) to obtain the cumulative distribution in terms of the equilibrium concentrations.

F(c,t)=[cinkBTηlog⁡(cc0−αt)−Pcavmin⁡η]Θ(cinkBTlog⁡(cc0−αt)−Pcavmin⁡).(54)\mathcal{F}(c,t)=\left[\frac{c_{\mathrm{in}}k_{\mathrm{B}}T}{\eta}\log\left(\frac{c}{c_0-\alpha t}\right)-\frac{P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min}}{\eta}\right]\Theta\left(c_{\mathrm{in}}k_{\mathrm{B}}T\log\left(\frac{c}{c_0-\alpha t}\right)-P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min}\right). \tag*{(54)}

Therefore, given a density mm of nucleated droplets, the density of droplets with cavitation threshold below cc is mF(c,t)m\mathcal{F}(c,t). For this theory to be self-consistent, the aforementioned volume V=n−1V=n^{-1} must have only one droplet with a cavitation threshold below the concentration field, i.e.

1=4π∫0LmF(c(r),tˉ)r2 dr.(55)1=4\pi\int_{0}^{L}m\mathcal{F}(c(r),\bar{t})r^2\,dr. \tag*{(55)}

Here, we take the time tˉ\bar{t} such that the equilibrium concentration of the nn-th droplet matches the total amount of material in the system c0c_0,

tˉ=c0α[1−exp⁡(−Pcavmin⁡−ηn/mcinkBT)].(56)\bar{t}=\frac{c_0}{\alpha}\left[1-\exp\left(\frac{-P_{\mathrm{cav}}^{\min}-\eta n/m}{c_{\mathrm{in}}k_{\mathrm{B}}T}\right)\right]. \tag*{(56)}

Figure S.6. Increasing rate stepwise leads to increasingly more droplet cavitating. Simulation increasing the material rate α\alpha twice during the cooling process. A) Droplet radii as a function of time displaying a trimodal distribution of the cavitated droplets and several small ones kept at mesh size. B) Radii probability distribution. Parameters are η/m=3⋅105 E μm3\eta/m = 3 \cdot10^{5}\,\mathrm{E}\,\mu\mathrm{m}^{3}, first cooling rate α=α0=7.77⋅10−6 s−1ν−1\alpha= \alpha_{0} = 7.77 \cdot10^{-6}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}\nu^{-1}, second cooling rate α=4α0\alpha= 4\alpha_{0}, and third cooling rate α=16α0\alpha= 16\alpha_{0}. Other parameters as in Figure 2.

We can now combine [S.41]-[S.45] to obtain an implicit relation for the cavitated droplet density nn, which we solve numerically to obtain the lines shown in the main text.

Temperature protocol changes

Numerical simulations, where the cooling rate is increased after droplet cavitation, show that a new group of droplets can cavitate if the new rate is high enough. Examples of this type of simulations are shown in Fig. S.5 and Fig. S.6. We show in [S.41] that the concentration profile around a cavitated droplet depends strongly on the material rate α\alpha. If this rate is suddenly increased, the new concentration profile might be higher than the cavitation concentration ccavc_{\mathrm{cav}} of some of the small droplets, thus causing their cavitation. This process can then be repeated to cavitate additional droplets, as depicted in Fig. S.6. Therefore, controlling the rate α\alpha allows to control the droplet size distribution.

References

  1. [1]S. F. Banani, H. O. Lee, A. A. Hyman, and M. K. Rosen, “Biomolecular condensates: organizers of cellular biochemistry”, Nat Rev Mol Cell Biol 18, 285–298 (2017).DOI
  2. [2]J. Berry, C. Brangwynne, and M. P. Haataja, “Physical principles of intracellular organization via active and passive phase transitions”, Rep. Prog. Phys. 81, 046601 (2018).DOI
  3. [3]D. S. Lee, N. S. Wingreen, and C. P. Brangwynne, “Chromatin mechanics dictates subdiffusion and coarsening dynamics of embedded condensates”, Nature Physics 17, 10.1038/s41567-020-01125-8 (2021).
  4. [4]M. Feric and C. P. Brangwynne, “A nuclear f-actin scaffold stabilizes ribonucleoprotein droplets against gravity in large cells”, Nature cell biology 15, 1253–1259 (2013).DOI
  5. [5]C. Schway­er, S. Shamipour, K. Pranjic-Ferscha, A. Schauer, M. Balda, M. Tada, K. Matter, and C.-P. Heisenberg, “Mechanosensation of tight junctions depends on zo-1 phase separation and flow”, Cell 179, 937–952 (2019).
  6. [6]N. Kinoshita, T. S. Yamamoto, N. Yasue, T. Fujimori, and N. Ueno, Force-dependent remodeling of a tight junction protein zo-1 is regulated by phase separation, 2020, bioRxiv: 2020.10.04.323436.
  7. [7]Y. Shin, Y.-C. Chang, D. S. Lee, J. Berry, D. W. Sanders, P. Ronceray, N. S. Wingreen, M. Haat aja, and C. P. Brangwynne, “Liquid nuclear condensates mechanically sense and restructure the genome”, Cell 175, 1481–1491 (2018).
  8. [8]Y. Zhang, D. S. Lee, Y. Meir, C. P. Brangwynne, and N. S. Wingreen, Mechanical frustration of phase separation in the cell nucleus by chromatin, 2020, bioRxiv: 2020.12.24.424222.
  9. [9]T. Wiegand and A. A. Hyman, “Drops and fibers—how biomolecular condensates and cytoskeletal filaments influence each other”, Emerging Topics in Life Sciences 4, 247–261 (2020).DOI
  10. [10]R. W. Style, T. Sai, N. Fanelli, M. Ijavi, K. Smith-Mannschott, Q. Xu, L. A. Wilen, and E. R. Dufresne, “Liquid-liquid phase separation in an elastic network”, Physical Review X 8, 011028 (2018).DOI
  11. [11]K. A. Rosowski, T. Sai, E. Vidal-Henriquez, D. Zwicker, R. W. Style, and E. R. Dufresne, “Elastic ripening and inhibition of liquid-liquid phase separation”, Nature Physics 16, 422–425 (2020).
  12. [12]K. A. Rosowski, E. Vidal-Henriquez, D. Zwicker, R. W. Style, and E. R. Dufresne, “Elastic stresses reverse ostwald ripening”, Soft Matter 16, 5892–5897 (2020).DOI
  13. [13]E. Vidal-Henriquez and D. Zwicker, “Theory of droplet ripening in stiffness gradients”, Soft Matter 16, 5898–5905 (2020).
  14. [14]M. Kothari and T. Cohen, “Effect of elasticity on phase separation in heterogeneous systems”, Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids 145, 104153 (2020).
  15. [15]X. Wei, J. Zhou, Y. Wang, and F. Meng, “Modeling elastically mediated liquid-liquid phase separation”, Physical Review Letters 125, 268001 (2020).DOI
  16. [16]P. Ronceray, S. Mao, A. Košmrlj, and M. P. Haat aja, Liquid demixing in elastic networks: cavitation, permeation, or size selection?, 2021, arXiv:2102.02787 [cond-mat.soft].DOI
  17. [17]C. F. Gauss, “Principia generalia theoriae figurae fluidorum in statu aequilibrii”, in Werke: fünfter band (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg, 1877), pp. 29–77.
  18. [18]F. E. Neumann, Vorlesungen über mathematische physik: vorlesungen über die theorie der capillarität, Vol. 7 (1894).
  19. [19]D. Turnbull, “Kinetics of heterogeneous nucleation”, The Journal of Chemical Physics 18, 198–203 (1950).DOI
  20. [20]M. Mooney, “A theory of large elastic deformation”, Journal of applied physics 11, 582–592 (1940).DOI
  21. [21]S. Raayai-Ardakani, D. R. Earl, and T. Cohen, “The intimate relationship between cavitation and fracture”, Soft matter 15, 4999–5005 (2019).
  22. [22]C. W. Barney, C. E. Dougan, K. R. McLeod, A. Kazemi-Moridani, Y. Zheng, Z. Ye, S. Tiwari, I. Sacligil, R. A. Riggleman, S. Cai, et al., “Cavitation in soft matter”, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117, 9157–9165 (2020).DOI
  23. [23]A. Gent and D. Tompkins, “Nucleation and growth of gas bubbles in elastomers”, Journal of applied physics 40, 2520–2525 (1969).DOI
  24. [24]J. Y. Kim, Z. Liu, B. M. Weon, T. Cohen, C.-Y. Hui, E. R. Dufresne, and R. W. Style, “Extreme cavity expansion in soft solids: damage without fracture”, Science advances 6, eaaz0418 (2020).
  25. [25]P. Malo de Molina, S. Lad, and M. E. Helgeson, “Heterogeneity and its influence on the properties of difunctional poly (ethylene glycol) hydrogels: structure and mechanics”, Macromolecules 48, 5402–5411 (2015).DOI
  26. [26]J. Vollmer, A. Papke, and M. Rohloff, “Ripening and focusing of aggregate size distributions with overall volume growth”, Frontiers in Physics 2, 18 (2014).DOI
  27. [27]C. A. Weber, C. F. Lee, and F. Jülicher, “Droplet ripening in concentration gradients”, New Journal of Physics 19, 053021 (2017).DOI
  28. [28]D. Zwicker, A. A. Hyman, and F. Jülicher, “Suppression of Ostwald ripening in Active Emulsions”, Phys. Rev. E 92, 012317 (2015).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26274171
  29. [29]I. M. Lifshitz and V. V. Slyozov, “The kinetics of precipitation from supersaturated solid solutions”, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 19, 35–50 (1961).DOI
  30. [30]A. A. Hyman, C. A. Weber, and F. Jülicher, “Liquid-liquid phase separation in biology”, Annu. Rev. Cell Dev. Biol. 30, 39–58 (2014).DOI
  31. [31]S. Alberti, A. Gladfelter, and T. Mittag, “Considerations and challenges in studying liquid-liquid phase separation and biomolecular condensates”, Cell 176, 419–434 (2019).DOI
  32. [32]32 A. S. Lyon, W. B. Peeples, and M. K. Rosen, “A framework for understand-ing the functions of biomolecular condensates across scales”, Nat. Rev. Mol. Cell Biol. 21, 10.1038/s41580-020-00303-z (2020).DOI
  33. [33]33 A. D. Delgadillo, “Temperature drives p granule formation in caenorhabdi-tis elegans”, PhD thesis (Technischen Universität Dresden, Sept. 2015).
  34. [34]34 M. Hondele, S. Heinrich, P. De Los Rios, and K. Weis, “Membraneless organelles: phasing out of equilibrium”, Emerging Topics in Life Sciences 4, 343–354 (2020).
  35. [35]35 J. Soeding, D. Zwicker, S. Sohrabi-Jahromi, M. Boehning, and J. Kirschbaum, “Mechanisms of active regulation of biomolecular condensates”, Trends Cell Biol. 30, 4–14 (2020).DOI
  36. [36]36 F. Wottawah, S. Schinkinger, B. Lincoln, R. Ananthakrishnan, M. Romeyke, J. Gluck, and J. Käs, “Optical rheology of biological cells”, Physical review letters 94, 098103 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15784006
  37. [37]37 C. P. Broedersz, M. Depken, N. Y. Yao, M. R. Pollak, D. A. Weitz, and F. C. MacKintosh, “Cross-link-governed dynamics of biopolymer networks”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 238101 (2010).DOI
  38. [38]38 Q. Wen and P. A. Janmey, “Polymer physics of the cytoskeleton”, Current Opinion in Solid State and Materials Science 15, 177–182 (2011).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22081758
  39. [39]39 C. Storm, J. J. Pastore, F. C. MacKintosh, T. C. Lubensky, and P. A. Jan-mey, “Nonlinear elasticity in biological gels”, Nature 435, 191–194 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15889088
  40. [40]40 D. Zwicker, “Py-pde: a python package for solving partial differential equa-tions”, Journal of Open Source Software 5, 2158 (2020).
  41. [41]41 C. A. Weber, D. Zwicker, F. Jülicher, and C. F. Lee, “Physics of active emulsions”, Reports on Progress in Physics 82, 064601 (2019).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_puyhfzbb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 9

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents