WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Melting Points and Formation Free Energies of Carbon Compounds with Sodalite Structure
Abstract
Using first-principles calculations, we investigate the melting temperatures and formation free energy of carbon compounds with sodalite structures, C, C, and C, where is F, Na, Cl, and so on. These compounds are expected to be phonon-mediated superconductors exhibiting high transition temperatures of up to about 100 K. We estimate as a function of pressure by using the first-principles molecular dynamics method and show the results as phase diagrams on the - plane together with the results of . It indicates that the of NaC, which has a up to about 100 K, is about K or more at GPa. Furthermore, the of FC is about 2200 K even at GPa, where its is about 80 K. Similar results are obtained for FC and ClC systems. These results suggest that some compounds can stably exist as high-temperature superconductors even at room temperature and pressure. To examine the feasibility of synthesizing these compounds, we estimate the formation enthalpies and formation free energies. These results suggest that NaC could be formed under a sufficiently high pressure of about 300 GPa and a high temperature of about 6500 K.
Introduction
Since the high-temperature superconductors of hydrogen compounds with a sodalite structure, such as YH and lanthanum decahydride (LaH),1–7) were predicted to indicate over 250 K, much effort has been made to clarify the superconductivity of these compounds and/or to find new hydrogen compounds.1–7) Based on theoretical results,1–5) experiments8–11) succeeded in finding these superconductors whose is almost close to the result of first-principles calculations. This high-temperature superconductivity (HTS) is caused by phonon-mediated attraction, and the mechanism of the superconductivity is conventional. Therefore, is determined mainly by two parameters: the electron-phonon coupling constant and the characteristic phonon frequency . When both parameters are simultaneously large, HTS can be expected. In fact, many hydrogen compounds with a sodalite structure have a large electron-phonon coupling constant , that is larger than about 2.0.1–6) Typical values of are around 1000 K.
In these hydrogen compounds, high pressure may stabilize these characteristic structures and lead to a high phonon frequency. These materials are only stable over a limited pressure and the phonon frequency decreases with pressure.1–6) Therefore, hydrogen compound HTS can only be achieved with devices using diamond anvil cells at this stage. To realize practical devices, the required pressure should be as low as possible, preferably normal pressure.
A material constructed with carbon atoms, such as diamond, has a high phonon frequency up to about 2000 K at atmospheric pressure. Boron-doped diamond has been studied as a candidate of phonon-mediated HTS, and its reaches ∼ 25 K at atmospheric pressure.12–15) Intercalated graphite and alkali-doped C compounds are known carbonate superconductors with high of up to ∼ 33 K.16–19)
On the basis of the intuitive idea that the sodalite structure plays an important role in HTS, carbon compounds with a sodalite structure have been proposed as candidates for HTS materials.20–25) Based on the density functional theory, materials composed only of carbon atoms are known to be insulators with a large charge gap.26) By combining them with another element, , to form a compound, carriers are introduced into the system,22–25) where is Li, Na, Cl, or so on. The crystal structures of the compounds are shown in Figure 1, where (a) and (b) are shown as representative examples. has a structure similar to that of shown in Figure 1(a), except for one atom.
Figure 1. (Color online) Structures of the sodalite-type compounds (a) and (b) , where large spheres represent -atoms and small spheres are carbon. Here, the crystal structure of corresponds to (a) with one atom removed.
By first-principles calculations, it has been shown that some of these compounds exhibit of about 100 K even at atmospheric pressure.20,22–25) However, the existence of , , and has not yet been experimentally demonstrated. Furthermore, their stabilities at finite temperatures neither have been clarified. Even if these are stable near , they will not be practical if the crystals become unstable below room temperature.
In this study, we investigated the stability of carbon compounds with sodalite structure by the first-principles molecular dynamics (FPMD) method. First, we estimated the temperature at which the system becomes unstable. Then, we estimated using the known relationship between and the melting point . These results are shown as phase diagrams for compounds on the - plane, together with the superconducting transition temperature .
We also calculated the formation energies of compounds from the ground state energies of the elements. To consider the effect of finite temperature, we obtained the free energies of NaC and FC as typical cases. From these results, we estimated the Gibbs free energies and discussed whether the formation of these compounds is possible.
Model and Methods
Calculations were performed using Quantum ESPRESSO (QE), which is an integrated software of open-source computer codes for electronic-structure calculations.27) In the FPMD calculations, we used the ensemble system, where the system is a supercell made up of multiple unit cells, as shown in Figure 1. To reduce finite size effects, the direction vector that determines the shape of the supercell is set to change at each time step of the simulation. This variable cell method includes system fluctuations better than the method using fixed direction vectors.
To estimate , we used a combination of the FPMD method and the -method,28) which is used to determine melting points.29–34) Our method uses FPMD simulations to determine the critical temperature at which the crystal becomes thermally unstable, and then calculates from the relationship .28) Details of the -method are discussed in Appendix § 6.
When the temperature of a system exceeds , the motion of atoms in the system changes significantly in a short period of time. Therefore, it is easy to find in the simulation. To obtain , we calculated the Lindemann parameter defined as .35–37) Here, is the displacement of each atom from its equilibrium position at , and is the distance between the nearest-neighbor atoms in the crystal at . The thermal average is taken over all atoms at each time step in the simulation.
When the value of exceeds a certain critical value, the system becomes unstable rapidly.38) Thus, we calculated as a function of temperature and found from the point where it changes significantly.
At first, we considered the diamond system to test the above method. Figure 2 shows the Lindemann parameter as a function of simulation time for a diamond system with at GPa, where is the number of atoms in the system. Here, solid circles and empty circles represent the results for and 7000 K, respectively. It indicates that the values of at K are almost constant with , and those at K increase with and seem to diverge for fs. This result suggests that is between 6000 and 7000 K.
Figure 2. Lindemann parameter as a function of simulation time , where solid circles and empty circles represent the results for and 7000 K, respectively. represents the average of the last four points of .
To analyze in more detail, we defined as the average value of at the last four points (, and 210 fs), as shown in Figure 2. As shown in the figure, it is expected that the system will reach a certain degree of equilibrium after about 150 fs. Therefore, we used as the approximate equilibrium value of .
Figure 3 shows as a function of for the systems with (solid circles) and 64 (empty circles). The value of increases with temperature and appears to diverge above .38) Hereafter, we assumed the temperature corresponding to to be , where the point of is determined by interpolation. As shown in the figure, we found that K for
Figure 3. as a function of , where solid circles and empty circles represent the results for the systems with and 64, respectively. is determined by the condition .
dependence seems not to be so large. However, the size effect of is not simple. At a certain pressure, is high when the size is large. However, the opposite also appears depending on the pressure. The use of variable supercells is speculated to be the cause of the complex size effects.
Figure 5(b) shows the of C as a function of pressure , where solid circles and solid squares represent the results for and 40, respectively. is about 3500 K at and increases slightly with pressure up to about 100 GPa, but decreases above that. This suggests that C would be able to exist stably at room temperature and pressure, although it has not yet been experimentally discovered.
N = 8 and 6800 K for . This leads to K for and 5500 K for . When the system is small, fluctuations of the system are large and tends to be low.
Figure 4 shows the of diamond as a function of pressure along with previous theoretical39,40) and experimental41,42) results. Here, the solid and empty circles represent the results for and 64, respectively. In the FPMD calculation, we used mesh numbers and 2 in wavenumber space for the systems with and 64, respectively. The obtained results are almost in agreement with those of previous works.
The figure also shows that the size effect for is greatest when and decreases as the pressure increases. This is probably due to the decrease in the fluctuations of the system with increasing pressure. The inset shows the -dependence of for the systems with and 64 at . This indicates that the -dependence is rather small compared with the size effect in both systems.
Results and Discussion
as a function of for C and C
We applied the above method to pure carbon systems C and C as reference systems for XC and XC. Figure 5(a) shows the of C as a function of pressure , where empty circles, empty squares, and solid triangles represent the results for , 48, and 96, respectively. The of C is at least 2000 K at and increases slightly with pressure. Although its is lower than that of diamond, it is stable at room temperature and pressure.
The figure indicates that for each size is almost in agreement with each other at all pressures, and the size dependence seems not to be so large. However, the size effect of is not simple. At a certain pressure, is high when the size is large. However, the opposite also appears depending on the pressure. The use of variable supercells is speculated to be the cause of the complex size effects.
Figure 5. (a) of C as a function of , where empty circles, empty squares, and solid triangles represent for the , 48, and 96 systems, respectively. (b) of C as a function of , where solid circles and solid squares represent for the and 40 systems, respectively.
and as functions of for XC and XC
We considered compounds of XC and XC, combining carbon and X-atoms. Mainly, we presented the results for compounds NaC, FC, FC, and ClC as typical cases.
Figure 6(a) shows the of NaC as a function of pressure , where solid circles and solid squares represent the results for and 56, respectively. In addition to , the superconducting transition temperature 43) as a function of pressure is also shown as empty circles, where is multiplied by 10 for ease of viewing. Here, is calculated by the tetrahedral method,27) which allows us to avoid the ambiguity in the choice of Gaussian broadening that exists in the interpolation method.
We found that the of NaC is zero and unstable at . However, is about 2,000 K at GPa and increases with pressure, reaching about 5,000 K at GPa. This result seems to be consistent with those of previous works showing that NaC is dynamically unstable for GPa.22,23) On the other hand, was calculated as 149, 123, and 113 K at , 30, and 50 GPa, respectively. As the pressure decreases, the melting point decreases and the system becomes unstable. However, appears to increase with decreasing pressure for GPa.
Figure 6(b) shows the of FC as a function of pressure , where solid circles and solid squares represent the results for and 56, respectively. In this case, is at and increases with pressure and exceeds 6000 K at GPa. Unlike NaC, FC is stable even at room temperature and pressure. is 83 K at and increases slightly with pressure. In a previous study, FC was shown to be dynamically unstable by an interpolation method.[22] However, this is not the case in the tetrahedron method and we can obtain for FC.
Figure 7(a) shows the of FC as a function of pressure , where solid circles and solid squares represent the results for and 44, respectively. Similar to Figure 6, as a function of pressure is also shown as empty circles. Although the size dependence will be somewhat large in this case, may be about 2000 K at . The figure also shows that increases with pressure and reaches a maximum at about GPa. On the other hand, is about 110 K at and decreases with increasing pressure. This material is also expected to exhibit superconductivity under normal pressure, similar to FC.
Figure 6. (a) and of NaC as functions of , where solid circles and solid squares represent for the and 56 systems, respectively. Here, empty circles represent . (b) and of FC as functions of , where solid circles and solid squares represent for the and 56 systems, respectively.
Figure 7(b) shows the of ClC as a function of pressure , where solid circles and solid squares represent the results for and 44, respectively. Empty circles represent . In this system, the behaviors of and are similar to those of FC.
For detailed data on NaC, FC, FC, and ClC, Table I gives , , , and , where the numbers in parentheses are pressure in GPa. Here, values are for the system for XC and for the system for XC.
Results for other compounds at are shown in Table II. For , we present the system for XC, the system for XC, and the system for XC. The table shows that XC has a relatively high , but is not high. On the other hand, XC and XC have high , but is low. These results suggest that decreases as the proportion of atoms in the system decreases. This can be interpreted as a reduction in the number of effective carriers that the atom brings to the system.[22] This leads to a decrease in . Conversely, an increase in the number of effective carriers reduces the stability of the system and decreases .
Figure 7. (a) and of FC as functions of , where solid circles and solid squares represent for the and 44 systems, respectively. Here, empty circles represent . (b) and of ClC as functions of , where solid circles and solid squares represent for the and 44 systems, respectively.
| NaC (30) | NaC (200) | FC (0) | FC (200) | |
| [GPa] | ||||
| [K] | 1.3 | 5.1 | 2.2 | 6.2 |
| [K] | 124 | 114 | 83 | 97 |
| 3.81 | 1.76 | 1.37 | 1.45 | |
| [K] | 407 | 744 | 731 | 830 |
| FC (0) | FC (200) | ClC (0) | ClC (200) | |
| [GPa] | ||||
| [K] | 1.5 | 4.2 | 1.9 | 3.8 |
| [K] | 106 | 60 | 116 | 31 |
| 1.78 | 1.13 | 2.07 | 0.67 | |
| [K] | 697 | 653 | 662 | 997 |
Table 1. , , , and for NaC, FC, FC, and ClC.
| HC | LiC | BC | OC | ClC | HC | |
| [K] | 0.30 | 0.11 | 0.17 | 0.51 | 0.18 | 2.2 |
| [K] | 43 | 57 | 20 | 52 | 73 | 14 |
| 0.75 | 3.47 | 2.37 | 1.23 | 1.14 | 0.53 | |
| [K] | 889 | 209 | 113 | 532 | 825 | 902 |
| OC | NaC | BC | NaC | FC | ClC | |
| [K] | 1.5 | 1.3 | 0.57 | 1.2 | 3.0 | 1.7 |
| [K] | 32 | 13 | 6 | 32 | 17 | 21 |
| 0.95 | 0.57 | 0.53 | 0.73 | 0.58 | 0.60 | |
| [K] | 463 | 670 | 336 | 765 | 955 | 951 |
Table 2. , , , and for other compounds at .
Formation enthalpies at and
From the perspective of actually synthesizing these compounds, not only but also the formation enthalpy may be important. We define the formation enthalpy such as for NaC, and similarly for other compounds. Here, , , and are the enthalpies at per atom of NaC, sodium in a bcc structure, and graphite, respectively. Note that the definition of given here is insufficient to estimate an exact value of the formation enthalpy. To obtain this, it is necessary to compare the energies of all compounds that contain the elements in the target compound in any ratio. Since this is very difficult in practice, we estimated as information that is useful for synthesizing compounds.
Figure 8 shows the of XC, XC, and XC at , where the horizontal axis is the fraction of carbon contained in compounds. Here, of is represented by empty circles, that of by empty squares, and that of by empty triangles. In addition, there is the of X-atom-doped diamond (denoted as X-diamond), in which one carbon atom in a diamond supercell made up of eight atoms is replaced by an X-atom. These are represented by solid diamonds in the figure. The solid triangle stands for the result of the graphite intercalation compound that has sodium between the layers (Na-GIC).[18] Each point of is accompanied by a value of in units of K. The values for , , and correspond to those for the systems with , 11, and 13, respectively.
For reference, the formation enthalpies per atom of graphite, pure diamond, , , and have also been added, where these are represented by solid circles. Here, stands for the experimental melting temperature, is the melting temperature at the triple point near 12 GPa, and is the decomposition temperature observed in the experiment.[44] The results for and almost agree with those of the others.[21]
Comparing the difference in the value of with those in other studies,[45] we found that it is about 0.008 eV for diamond and about 0.012 eV for . For compounds NaCl, , and ,[45] this difference is about 0.16, 0.005, and 0.11 eV, respectively, although not shown in the figure. For and , the discrepancy between our results and others’ is roughly 0.06 eV.[21] In the case of compounds, the discrepancy of does not seem to be very small.
The figure shows that the of is about 0.4 eV and close to that of . is a material well known as fullerene and can now be synthesized. Therefore, it is expected that the synthesis of is possible.
Unfortunately, has low , except for and , and may be unstable at room temperature. On the other hand, and have higher than
Figure 8. Formation enthalpies as a function of the fraction of carbon in compounds with , where the unit of is K. Here, X-diamond means that one atom is replaced by an X-atom in the 8-site diamond cell, and Na-GIC represents a graphite intercalation compound with sodium between the layers.
, even though their values are similar to each other. The value of for B-diamond is about 0.25 eV, which is small, where its is calculated as 32 K. This result seems to be related to the fact that boron-doped diamond was found to be a superconductor in experiments.[12, 14, 15] On the other hand, values of F-, Cl-, and Na-diamonds are around 1 eV or larger. This might correspond to the fact that superconducting diamonds doped with these elements have not been found.
The Na-GIC (sodium intercalated graphite)[18] considered here has the same crystal structure as the experimentally discovered Li-GIC (lithium intercalated graphite).[45] This type of Na-GIC has not been found experimentally. However, it is an interesting isomer of Na with the sodalite structure, since finite is found theoretically.[18]
Formation enthalpies as a function of at
The pressure dependence of formation enthalpies is also interesting. Figure 9 shows as a function of for , , , Na, , Na, and Na-GIC. Here, the values are calculated relative to diamond, except when . This is because the enthalpy of diamond is lower than that of graphite at pressures above about 2 GPa. Furthermore, fluorine and sodium undergo structural phase transitions when the pressure is increased,[46, 47] so the of the compounds must be calculated using the enthalpies corresponding to their structures.
Figure 9. as a function of for , , , Na, , Na, and Na-GIC.
For fluorine, the structure is used for GPa, and the structure is used otherwise.[46] For sodium, the bcc, fcc, , and structures are used for , , 200, and 300 GPa, respectively.[47]
Figure 9 indicates that increases with for , , , Na, and Na-GIC. These substances have relatively low density, so their enthalpy increases under high pressure. In fact, the densities of diamond, , and are 4.64, 3.97, and 3.79 g/cm, respectively, at GPa. Furthermore, those of NaC and Na-GIC are 4.18 and 3.54 g/cm, respectively, at GPa. Here, the melting point of Na-GIC is 0 K at GPa, and it may be thermally unstable at pressures above this.
The figure also indicates that the of NaC decreases with increasing , while the others generally increase with except FC. The of FC seems to be almost independent of . We have confirmed that the values for NaC and FC are almost the same at and 400 GPa. Therefore, it seems that these values will not decrease even if the pressure is increased further.
In contrast to NaC, the of NaC increases with pressure. This can be interpreted as the crystal structure of NaC being more sparse than that of NaC. This may also apply to the relationship between FC and FC.
Formation free energies for NaC and FC
As shown in Figure 9, the of NaC decreases with increasing pressure and becomes about 0.29 eV at GPa. In this case, the effects of finite temperature, such as lattice vibrations, may not be negligible near the melting point. To clarify the effects of phonons, we calculated the Helmholtz free energy by harmonic approximation. Comparing with experimental results,[48] we introduced a phenomenologically corrected free energy . It reproduces the experimental results better than and allows us to estimate the free energy of the liquid state. By adding to the enthalpy at , we can approximately obtain the Gibbs free energy at finite temperatures. Detailed calculation methods are given in Appendix B.
Figure 10(a) shows as a function of for diamond, NaC, and sodium at GPa. We also present the formation free energy, , which is defined as
Here, , , and are the per atom for NaC, sodium, and diamond, respectively. These values decrease with increasing temperature owing to entropy. As shown in the figure, is about eV at K, where this temperature corresponds to the of NaC, and the of diamond is about 9300 K under the same pressure. Here, to obtain , we used the system for NaC and the system for diamond.
Recalling that eV, the value of becomes about eV. Since the value is negative, the formation of NaC under this condition can be expected.[49] The result also suggests that high pressure and high temperature may favor the synthesis of NaC.
By applying a similar analysis as described above to FC, is found to be about eV at K, as shown in Figure 10(b). Here, this temperature corresponds to at GPa. We assumed that for fluorine, FC, and diamond. For the liquid state of fluorine, was assumed to be 1.2. Since the of FC is about 0.43 eV at GPa, we obtained eV. This value is small but positive. Thus, the synthesis of FC may be more difficult than that of NaC.
Figure 10. Free energy as a function of temperature for (a) Na, NaC, and diamond, and (b) F, FC, and diamond at GPa. Here, solid circles represent . The dotted lines show the formation free energy , which was determined using a similar definition as for .
In the above discussion, we have not addressed the contribution of electrons at finite temperatures. To consider it, we estimated the free energy of electrons. At GPa, NaC is metallic and the value of DOS at the Fermi level, , is 0.20 states/eV/atom. Using the free electron model, we calculated the contribution of free energy to be at low temperatures. The value is about eV at K. If liquid sodium is in the metallic state, the value of the free energy is expected to be of the same order as NaC. On the other hand, we found that diamond has an energy gap of 5.6 eV at GPa, and the electron contribution to the free energy is negligible. In this case, the of NaC may decrease by about 0.09 eV.
However, we used , which closely reproduces the experimental results. Since the experimental results should include the effect of electrons at finite temperatures, should be considered to include the effect of electrons, even if it is not complete. If so, adding the electron contribution to could result in double counting. Similarly, the effects of volume changes at finite temperatures may already be included. In any case, the contribution of these effects may be small and would not significantly change the results.
Summary
By combining the FPMD method and the Z-method, we investigated the of carbon compounds XC, , and with the sodalite structure. To verify the validity of the method, we applied it to the diamond system and compared the results with those of other theoretical and experimental works. We also discussed the assumptions adopted in the -method by comparing them with experimental results. In addition to the melting points, we obtained the superconducting transition temperature by the optimized tetrahedron method in QE.
These results suggest that , , and can exist stably at sufficiently high temperatures ( K) even under normal pressure, and the values of these compounds reach nearly 100 K. Although the of drops rapidly at pressures below 30 GPa, is over 120 K for GPa. We also showed results for several other compounds that have relatively low but are stable at ambient pressure. If these compounds can actually be synthesized, it would be possible to observe high-temperature superconductivity mediated by phonons.
To examine the feasibility of these compounds, we calculated the formation enthalpies from the ground state energies of the elements. Unfortunately, all of these values for compounds were positive and above 0.5 eV at . This suggests that the synthesis of these compounds is difficult. We also examined the pressure dependence of for , , and several representative compounds. Since and have lower densities than diamond, increases with pressure. However, the of decreases with increasing pressure, from about 0.94 eV at to 0.29 eV at GPa.
In this case, the effect of finite temperature may make the Gibbs formation free energy negative. To clarify this, we introduced a phenomenologically corrected formation free energy . Applying this to , we found the value of to be approximately eV at K and GPa. This cancels out the positive , and , which corresponds to the Gibbs formation free energy, becomes negative.
This result suggests that sufficiently high temperatures and pressures may be effective for the formation of . Applying a similar analysis to , we found that the Gibbs formation free energy is small but positive under conditions similar to those for . This result indicates that the synthesis of may be more difficult than that of .
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Number JP19K03716.
Simulation Details
All calculations of FPMD and electronic structures were carried out by using the density functional theory of Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) generalized gradient approximation and the projector augmented wave pseudopotential as implemented in QE package.27 The cutoff energies for the wave functions and charge densities were set to the suggested minimum values given in the pseudopotential files.27 For example, for a carbon atom, the two values are 40 and 323 Ry, respectively. Convergence
thresholds were set as a.u. in total energy and a.u. in force.
The of mesh in the first Brillouin zone was used for diamond systems with , systems with , and systems with . For other systems with less than 30, a mesh was used. For all systems with more than 30, a mesh was used. In the calculation of FPMD, we used the ‘vc-md’ option27 in QE, which uses the Beeman algorithm to integrate Newton’s equation. The time step is chosen to be one femtosecond (fs).
A new simulation is started with the equilibrium atomic positions at , where these atomic positions are obtained by structural optimization under the target pressure. The initial velocity distribution is a Boltzmann distribution determined by the target temperature. The instantaneous temperature is calculated at the end of every atomic move, and the temperature of the system is rescaled to the target temperature at each step. The instantaneous pressure of the system changes with each step, but is adjusted to the target pressure by modifying the cell volume. The root mean square of the displacement of the atomic positions from their initial positions at corresponds to the Lindemann parameter . Here, , , and are recorded every 10 steps during the simulation.
Figure A · 1. (a) Instantaneous pressure as a function of , (b) instantaneous temperature as a function of , and (c) Lindemann parameter as a function of , where a straight line represents the average value of . The system used is (), and the target pressure and target temperature are set to 100 GPa and 3500 K, respectively.
Figure A · 1 shows the simulation results for (a) , (b) , and (c) for () as a function of up to 2000 fs, where the target pressure and target temperature are set to 100 GPa and 3500 K, respectively. In Fig. A · 1(c), the straight line represents the average value of . Owing to the small system size, and show large fluctuations. However, these values are around the target pressure and the target temperature at all times, and no systematic deviations are observed within this calculation. The value of also appears to fluctuate around the average value.
Figure A·2. (a) Instantaneous pressure as a function of , (b) instantaneous temperature as a function of , and (c) the Lindemann parameter as a function of , where a straight line represents the average value of . Here, the system is FC with . The target pressure and target temperature are set to 0 GPa and 1000 K, respectively.
Figure A·3. (a) as a function of for NaC at the target temperature K (solid circles) and K (empty circles) with at GPa. (b) as a function of at K (solid circles) and K (empty circles) for FC with at GPa. (c) as a function of for NaC with at GPa. (d) as a function of for FC with at GPa.
As shown in Figure 6 in the main text, and were estimated to be approximately 3800 and 4600 K, respectively. The peaks of in Fig. A·1(b) appear to reach K and exceed the above temperatures. However, the system maintains its crystal structure. It is interesting that very large instantaneous fluctuations do not necessarily lead to melting.
Figure A·2 shows the simulation results for (a) , (b) , and (c) for FC () as a function of up to 500 fs, where the target pressure and target temperature are set to 0 GPa and 1000 K, respectively. In Fig. A·2(c), the straight line represents the average value up to 2000 fs. We confirmed that these values fluctuate around the average value up to 2000 fs.
Similar to the case of NaC, the fluctuations are large. As shown in the figures, it is difficult to distinguish between fluctuations in the equilibrium state and relaxation processes from the initial state at . Here, we considered the relaxation process by focusing on the behavior of in Fig. A·2(c). In our simulation, the value of starts from zero at . The value appears to approach the equilibrium value after fs. Judging from this behavior, the relaxation time may be considered to be about 100 fs.
If the crystal structure of a system becomes unstable at high temperatures, the value of is expected to become very large. Figures A·3(a) and A·3(b) show as a function of for (a) NaC (, target pressure GPa) and (b) FC (, target pressure GPa). For the case of NaC, increases sharply with for K at K, but it seems to be almost constant at K. For the case of FC, similar to NaC, is nearly constant at K, but seems to increase rapidly with at K. These results suggest that the system becomes unstable
at K for NaC, and at K for FC. To calculate more systematically, we used , which is defined as the average value of at , 190, 200, and 210 fs. Figures A·3(c) and A·3(d) show as a function of the target temperature for (c) NaC and (d) FC. The point where the temperature dependence of changes suddenly may correspond to . This behavior of is the same as that observed in the diamond system discussed in the main text. For convenience, we considered that the temperature at which approximately gives . In this simulation, the target temperature is varied in intervals between approximately and of , and the temperature at which was found by interpolation.
Although the step width of the target temperature is coarse and the system used is not so large, it may be successful in giving an approximate value of . In fact, the values of estimated from our roughly reproduced the experimental results, as shown in Figure 4 in the main text and Table B·1 in Appendix B.
Figure 4. Melting points of diamond as a function of pressure , where empty circles and empty squares represent for the and 64 systems, respectively. Solid squares, solid circles, and solid triangles represent the results of Liang et al.,42) Correa et al.,40) and Wang et al., respectively.39) The light and broken lines show the result of Bundy et al.,41) where the broken line indicates the phase boundary between graphite and diamond. The inset shows the -dependence of at GPa, where is the mesh number in wavenumber space.
Figure A·4 shows the -dependence of for the systems of NaC for at GPa (empty circles), FC for at GPa (solid squares), ClC for at GPa (empty triangles), and FC for at GPa (solid circles). This indicates that the -dependence is small in all the calculated systems, similar to the case of the diamond system presented in the main text.
Z-method
The result of the Z-method is derived under the basic assumption , where and are the internal energies of the system in the solid and liquid states, respectively. Moreover, two approximate relations, and , are used,[50] where is the specific heat at a constant volume in the solid state at , and is the entropy change between the liquid and solid states.[51] These lead to .[28]
Figure A·4. -dependence of for NaC for at GPa (empty circles), FC for at GPa (solid squares), ClC for at GPa (empty triangles), and FC for at GPa (solid circles).
The first assumption is based on the results of MD simulations and seems plausible. To confirm the validity of the second relations, we compared them with experimental results, where the difference between and was neglected. Table B·1 gives these experimental values with melting points for several elements and compounds.[52] For reference, our calculated results of were also added.
| Na | Ca | Al | NaCl | BC | BeC | |
| 3.80 | 5.20 | 3.96 | 4.05 | 3.79 | 3.69 | |
| 0.844 | 0.921 | 1.38 | 1.58 | 0.917 | 1.26 | |
| 0.222 | 0.177 | 0.242 | 0.389 | 0.242 | 0.341 | |
| [K] | 371 | 1115 | 933 | 1074 | 2743 | 2400 |
| [K] | 0.36 | 1.2 | 0.94 | 0.90 | 3.0 | 2.7 |
| size () | 16 | 32 | 4 | 8 | 45 | 12 |
Table B·1. Experimental data for , , , and together with calculated .
Although the experimental values of and [52] are larger than the theoretically expected values, the values of are relatively close to 1.23. The above results suggest that the equation is a reasonable approximation even for compounds.
To consider the validity of , we present some additional results on below. It is 431 K for Na with , 1504 K for Ca with , and 585 K for Al with . The results show that the size dependence of is not very consistent, and for larger systems does not necessarily give better values. Although it may be difficult to precisely estimate by this method, it is possible to obtain the approximate of complex systems such as compounds with a small amount of calculation.
Estimation of
To estimate the transition temperature of superconductivity, we calculated the Eliashberg electron phonon spectral function within the framework of density functional perturbation theory (DFPT)[53] in the QE package, where is the phonon frequency. Here, is defined by
where is the matrix element of the electron-phonon coupling and is the density of states at the Fermi energy per both spins. Within DFPT, the electron-phonon matrix elements are obtained from the first-order derivative of the self-consistent Kohn-Sham potential. The summation over the Fermi surface is performed using the tetrahedron method.[27, 54]
The logarithmic average of phonon frequency is written as
The electron-phonon coupling constant is given by
The transition temperature of superconductivity was calculated using the Allen and Dynes formulation,[43]
where, the factors and are decided by the , , and mean square frequency . They are given by
where . The screened Coulomb potential parameter is set to 0.1 as a typical value.
In our calculation, mesh ( mesh) is chosen to be (). In the optimization of structures, we used convergence thresholds as a.u. in total energy and a.u. in force. To verify the validity of our estimation, we calculated of YH at GPa. We found that K, while the experimental result at the same pressure is 224 K.[10, 11] For LaH, is estimated to be 212 K at GPa, but it is 245 K in the experimental results.[8, 9] These results suggest that the above formulation successfully derives for phonon high- superconductors.
As an example, the result of FC at GPa is shown. In this case, we obtained K, , and K. We confirmed that the results of are almost the same even if the meshes are different. For example, if and meshes were chosen to be $6\times6\times6$ and , respectively, we obtained a result of K. For and , we obtained $T_{\mathrm{c}}\simeq104 K.
Using , we defined as
This allows us to see the contribution of each atom to . Figure C·1 shows as a function of (solid line). Figure C·1 also shows the phonon DOS decomposed into the fluorine and carbon atoms, where the dotted line represents the contributions of fluorine atoms, and the dashed line represents the contributions of carbon atoms. It indicates that the phonon spectrum is clearly divided into two parts: components of F and C atoms. Furthermore, the contribution of phonons to is also divided into two parts, and the F atom component seems to be about of the C atom component. This result indicates that it is mainly the carbon atoms that contribute to the superconductivity of FC10. Similar results have already been obtained for XC6.22)
Figure C·1. Electron-phonon coupling constant and phonon DOS for FC10 at GPa. Here, the solid line represents , the dotted line represents the contributions of fluorine atoms to , and the dashed line represents the contributions of carbon atoms to .
Free Energy
We considered the Helmholtz free energy per atom within the harmonic approximation for phonons. In the harmonic approximation, the volume of the system does not depend on . Thus, we neglected the volume change of the system due to temperature hereafter.
Using the free energy formulation for a harmonic oscillator, we obtained
where is the phonon DOS per atom, which is calculated by QE. The internal energy was also obtained by a similar formulation as
Here, entropy can be easily obtained by .
To compare the experimental results with the above results, we considered the enthalpy of phonons, . In our approximation, the term in the enthalpy is independent of temperature. Therefore, as a function of is equivalent to , except for a constant. Since enthalpy is typically used in experiments,52) we used instead of to avoid confusion.
As shown in Fig. D·1(a), we found that the experimental result of the enthalpy for sodium52) is well fitted by for and for , where is a constant, 1.06, and is 1.19. Here, is the value to reproduce the gap in at , which will be given later. For the case of NaCl,52) we obtained and , as shown in Fig. D·1(b). The values are the same for Na and NaCl, but the values are slightly different.
As shown in Figs. D·1(c) and D·1(d), we found that similar relationships hold for entropies. That is, for and for . These relations lead to for and for , where is the phenomenologically corrected free energy that is fitted to closely reproduce the experimental results, and
The above phenomenological relations give approximate free energies of the solid and liquid states which closely reproduce the experimental results. The results shown in Fig. D·1 suggest that this approximation can be widely applied to a variety of materials. In fact, we confirmed that this method can also be applied to Al and BC.52) We found that and in the former case. In the latter case, and .
Figure D·1. Theoretical and experimental results of enthalpy as a function of for (a) Na and (b) NaCl, and those of entropy for (c) Na and (d) NaCl, where the experimental results are taken from NIST.52) Here, the experimental values of enthalpy were shifted by a constant to match the theoretical value of at .
To test the above analysis, we tried to find the phase boundary between graphite and diamond. When , the enthalpy of diamond is lower than that of graphite and diamond is stable for GPa.[41, 45] As the temperature increases, the free energy of graphite decreases more quickly than that of diamond, and graphite becomes stable. The boundary is given by , where and are the formation free energy and the formation enthalpy of graphite, respectively.
Figure D · 2 shows the of diamond and graphite and the of graphite, where is set to 1.06 for both diamond and graphite. Here, we confirmed that the of graphite almost reproduces the experimental result.[52] In the figure, the solid lines represent the of diamond and graphite at GPa. is shown as a dotted line for GPa and as a dashed line for GPa. The two lines are close to each other and look nearly identical. The result indicates that the -dependence of is very small. On the other hand, the -dependence of is not so small and dominates the conditions that determine the phase boundary.
The values are , , , , and for , , , , and GPa, respectively. Using the results above, we found that the boundary temperatures are approximately , , , and K for , , , and GPa, respectively. This boundary appears to be shifted by about GPa toward higher pressure compared with other theoretical[55] and experimental[41] results. Apart from this, the result seems to agree with those of other works.
The application to the boron-doped diamond system is also interesting. It is synthesized at high pressure ( GPa) and temperature ( K) and shows superconductivity with K.[12] Here, the boron concentration is about 3 percent. Figure D · 3 shows the of diamond, boron-doped diamond, and boron at GPa. For boron-doped diamond, we used the system, in which one atom is replaced by boron.
Figure D · 2. Phenomenological free energies of diamond and graphite (solid lines) at GPa, together with the formation free energies of graphite at (dotted line) and GPa (dashed line).
Figure D · 3. Phenomenological free energies of diamond, boron, and boron-doped diamond at GPa (solid lines). The formation free energy of boron-doped diamond is represented by a dotted line.
In a real system, the effect of entropy becomes important[56] because the boron atoms are randomly distributed in the system. We evaluated the additional entropy by treating the boron-doped system as a type of binary alloy.[57] In this case, the entropy is expressed as . For , the value is eV/K, and we add it to the of the boron-doped diamond.
In this figure, the dotted line indicates the formation free energy of the boron-doped diamond. Here, to obtain , we assumed that the crystal structure of boron is .[45, 58] It decreases with increasing temperature, and becomes negative at K. Here, is the formation enthalpy of the boron-doped diamond, and its value is about eV. This result means that the boron-doped diamond is stable at K.[59] It does not contradict the synthesis conditions of the boron-doped diamond.[12]
As mentioned above, our evaluation of the free energy is expected to be useful in finding conditions for material synthesis. To analyze the free energy of NaC, we used and as the phenomenological parameters for sodium at GPa. For simplicity, we also used for diamond and NaC. The calculated results are given in the main text.
References
- [8]8) A. P. Drozdov, P. P. Kong, V. S. Minkov, S. P. Besedin, M. A. Kuznovikov, S. Mozafari, L. Balicas, F. F. Balakirev, D. E. Graf, V. B. Prakapenka, E. Greenberg, D. A. Knyazev, M. Tkacz, and M. I. Eremets, Nature 569, 528 (2019).
- [9]9) M. Somayazulu, M. Ahart, A. K. Mishra, Z. M. Geballe, M. Baldini, Y. Meng, V. V. Struzhkin, and R. J. Hemley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 027001 (2019).
- [10]10) I. A. Troyan, D. V. Semenok, A. G. Kvashnin, A. G. Ivanova, V. B. Prakapenka, E. Greenberg, A. G. Gavriliuk, I. S. Lyubutin, V. V. Struzhkin, and A. R. Oganov, Adv. Mater. 33, 2006832 (2021).
- [11]11) P. P. Kong, V. S. Minkov, M. A. Kuznovikov, S. P. Besedin, A. P. Drozdov, S. Mozafari, L. Balicas, F. F. Balakirev, V. B. Prakapenka, E. Greenberg, D. A. Knyazev, and M. I. Eremets, Nat. Commun. 12, 5075 (2021).
- [12]12) E. A. Ekimov, V. A. Sidorov, E. D. Bauer, N. N. Mel'nik, N. J. Curro, J. D. Thompson, and S. M. Stishov, Nature 428, 542 (2004).
- [14]14) A. Kawano, H. Ishikawa, S. Iriyama, R. Okada, T. Yamaguchi, Y. Takano, and H. Kawarada, Phys. Rev. B 82, 085318 (2010).
- [15]15) H. Okazaki, T. Wakita, T. Muro, T. Nakamura, Y. Muraoka, T. Yokoya, S. Kurihara, H. Kawarada, T. Oguchi, and Y. Takano, Appl. Phys. Lett. 106, 052601 (2015).
- [18]C. M. Hao, X. Li, A.R. Oganov, J. Hou, S. Ding, Y. Ge, L. Wang, X. Dong, H. T. Wang, G. Yang, X. F. Zhou, and Y. Tian, Phys. Rev. B 108, 214507 (2023).
- [21]Q. Wei, Q. Zhang, and M. Zhang, Materials 9, 726 (2016).
- [22]K. Sano, Y. Masuda, and H. Ito, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 91, 083703 (2022).
- [27]P. Giannozzi, S. Baroni, N. Bonini, M. Calandra, R. Car, C. Cavazzoni, D. Ceresoli, G. L. Chiarotti, M. Cococcioni, I. Dabo, A. Dal Corso, S. Fabris, G. Fratesi, S. de Gironcoli, R. Gebauer, U. Gerstmann, C. Gougoussis, A. Kokalj, M. Lazzeri, L. Martin-Samos, N. Marzari, F. Mauri, R. Mazzarello, S. Paolini, A. Pasquarello, L. Paulatto, C. Sbraccia, S. Scandolo, G. Scalzuero, A. P. Seitsonen, A. Smogunov, P. Umari, and R. M. Wentzcovitch, J. Phys. Condens. Matter 21, 395502 (2009). https://www.quantum-espresso.org/
- [28]A. B. Belonoshko, N. V. Skorodumova, A. Rosengren, and B. Johansson, Phys. Rev. B 73, 012201 (2006).
- [41]F. P. Bundy, W. A. Bassett, M. S. Weathers, R. J. Hemley, H. K. Mao, and A. F. Goncharov, Carbon 34, 141 (1996).
- [43]P. B. Allen and R. C. Dynes, Phys. Rev. B 12, 905 (1975).
- [44]C. S. Sundar, A. Bharathi, Y. Hariharan, J. Janaki, V. S. Sastry, and T. S. Radhakrishnan, Solid State Commun. 84, 823 (1992).
- [45]A. Jain, S. P. Ong, G. Hautier, W. Chen, W. D. Richards, S. Dacek, S. Cholia, D. Gunter, D. Skinner, G. Ceder, and K. A. Persson, APL Mater. 1, 011002 (2013). www.materialsproject.org
- [46]C. Tandardini, F. N. Jalolov, and A. G. Kvashnin, J. Phys. Chem. C 126, 11358 (2022).
- [47]N. E. Christensen and D. L. Novikov, Solid State Commun. 119, 477 (2001).
- [48]Y. Huang, M. Widom, and M. C. Gao, Phys. Rev. Mater. 6, 013802 (2022).
- [49]To precisely discuss the synthesis conditions, it may be necessary to improve the accuracy of ΔH. Additionally, the presence of other compounds such as NaC may need to be considered.
- [50]If the simulations can be performed in sufficient detail, it is possible to determine Tₘ without using these two approximate relations.
- [51]S. M. Stishov, Usp. Fiz. Nauk 114, 3 (1974).
- [52]National Institute of Standards and Technology Federal Information Processing Standards Publications, 140, 2 (2002). https://janof.nist.gov/
- [53]S. Baroni, S. de Gironcoli, A. Dal Corso, and P. Giannozzi, Rev. Mod. Phys. 73, 515 (2001).
- [54]M. Kawamura, Y. Ghoda, and S. Tsuneyuki Phys. Rev. B 89, 094515 (2014).
- [55]L. M. Ghiringhelli, J. H. Los, E. J. Meijer, A. Fasolino, and D. Frenkel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94, 145701 (2005).
- [56]A. Manzoor, S. Pandey, D. Chakraborty, S. R. Phillpot, and D. S. Aidhy, npj Comput. Mater. 4, 47 (2018).
- [57]For a binary alloy, a lattice gas model is often used as a simple approximation. See below for its entropy formula. G. D. With, Liquid-State Physical Chemistry: Fundamentals, Modeling, and Applications (Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim, 2013) Appendix C.
- [58]G. Parakhonskiy, N. Dubrovinskaya, L. Dubrovinsky, S. Mondal, and S. v. Smaalen, J. Cryst. Growth 321, 162 (2011).
- [59]We confirmed that these results are almost unchanged even if the existence of B₄C is taken into account.
















