betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Exact turning invariants for projectile motion under quadratic drag and a vertical-axis Magnus force

Abstract

A ball spinning about a vertical axis is pushed sideways by the Magnus force, so its ground track curves. We show that when the lift and drag coefficients are constant, the horizontal part of this problem is exactly solvable in elementary functions. The step that makes this work is to write the horizontal velocity as a complex number and to use path length rather than time as the independent variable. Both aerodynamic forces are quadratic in speed, so the speed cancels and what remains is a linear equation with constant coefficients in which gravity does not appear. Three exact results follow from it. The heading turns at a fixed rate per unit path length, so a half turn always costs the same distance whatever the launch conditions and whatever the drag. The horizontal speed decays exponentially in the turn angle at a rate fixed by the drag-to-lift ratio, which makes the horizontal hodograph a logarithmic spiral. The radius of curvature of the ground track equals the lift length times the cosine of the flight-path angle. The whole flight problem also collapses to one scalar differential equation controlled by two dimensionless numbers. We use this to settle a concrete question. Two identical balls thrown in opposite horizontal directions with opposite spin can meet head-on when drag is absent, on a one-parameter family we give in closed form, and they fail to meet once drag acts. Every analytic claim is checked against machine-precision numerics, and the code and data are openly available.

Introduction

The sideways deflection of a spinning ball is one of the most familiar everyday demonstrations of fluid dynamics, and one of the oldest to be studied quantitatively. Briggs measured the deflection of a baseball spinning about a vertical axis in a wind tunnel and found how it depends on spin rate and speed[1]. Mehta’s review is still the standard entry point to sports-ball aerodynamics[2], and measurements of the lift and drag coefficients of spinning balls are now routine[3, 4].

The equations of motion for a spinning ball under gravity, quadratic drag and the Magnus force are easy to write down, and they are almost always integrated numerically. Bray and Kerwin, in the standard treatment of a soccer ball struck with sidespin, put the position plainly: “These equations have no closed form solutions but can be solved numerically using a Runge–Kutta routine”[5]. Nathan’s reference study of baseball flight also uses fourth-order Runge–Kutta[3], as does the recent pedagogical treatment by Mencke et al.[6]. In the projectile-dynamics literature, Turkyilmazoglu and Altundag obtain closed forms when either the quadratic drag or the Magnus term can be dropped, and they describe the case in which both act together as highly nonlinear, with only perturbative solutions available[7]. Chudinov’s asymptotic analysis of the same problem gives the velocity hodograph as an approximate implicit formula[8]. Reviews of projectile motion with drag[9, 10] trace the analytic tradition back to Johann Bernoulli’s 1719 idea of parametrising planar motion by the tangent angle rather than by time, which decouples the equations but leaves the solution implicit.

This paper points out that one physically natural special case of the system is exactly integrable in elementary functions. When the spin axis is vertical and CLC_L and CDC_D are constant, the horizontal motion separates completely from gravity and can be solved in closed form. The invariants that come out are simple, and as far as we can tell they have not been written down before.

Section II fixes the model. Section III derives the central identity and reduces the full flight problem to a single scalar equation. Section IV collects the invariants. § 0.5 poses and answers a concrete geometric question that puts the machinery to work, namely whether two counter-spinning balls thrown in opposite directions can be made to collide head-on. Section VI describes the numerical verification, Section VII discusses scope and an open problem, and Section VIII concludes.

Model

A ball of mass mm and radius rr, with cross-sectional area A=πr2A = \pi r^2, moves through still air of density ρ\rho under gravity, quadratic drag and the Magnus force,

dvdt=−gz^−ρCDA2m∣v∣v+ρCLA2m∣v∣(ω^×v),(1)\frac{d\mathbf{v}}{dt} = -g\hat{\mathbf{z}} - \frac{\rho C_D A}{2m}|\mathbf{v}|\mathbf{v} + \frac{\rho C_L A}{2m}|\mathbf{v}|(\hat{\boldsymbol{\omega}} \times\mathbf{v}), \tag*{(1)}

where ω^\hat{\boldsymbol{\omega}} is the unit spin vector. Throughout we take the spin axis vertical, ω^=±z^\hat{\boldsymbol{\omega}} = \pm\hat{\mathbf{z}}, which is the pure-sidespin configuration studied in Refs.[1] and[5]. It is convenient to absorb the coefficients into two inverse lengths,

kL=ρCLA2m,kD=ρCDA2m,μ≡kDkL=CDCL,(2)k_L = \frac{\rho C_L A}{2m}, \qquad k_D = \frac{\rho C_D A}{2m}, \qquad\mu\equiv\frac{k_D}{k_L} = \frac{C_D}{C_L}, \tag*{(2)}

and to give a name to the lift length,

LL=1kL=2mρCLA.(3)L_L = \frac{1}{k_L} = \frac{2m}{\rho C_L A}. \tag*{(3)}

Equation (3) is the exact analogue of the radius of a constant-CLC_L turn in aircraft performance, where the centripetal requirement and the available lift both scale as v2v^2 and the speed cancels.

We write ψ\psi for the azimuth of the horizontal velocity, measured as an unwrapped angle rather than through an inverse tangent, and ss for path length, so that ds=∣v∣ dtd s = |\mathbf{v}|\,d t. The flight-path angle is γ\gamma, with tan⁡γ=vz/∣w∣\tan\gamma= v_z/|\mathbf{w}|, where w\mathbf{w} is defined in Sec. III. Sections III and IV assume CLC_L and CDC_D constant, and Sec. VI A reports what happens when that assumption is relaxed.

Exact reduction

The central identity

Combine the two horizontal components of the velocity into a single complex number,

w=vx+ivy.(4)w = v_x + i v_y. \tag*{(4)}

Three observations make the horizontal problem linear. Gravity is vertical and contributes nothing to ww. Drag is antiparallel to v\mathbf{v} and contributes −kD∣v∣w-k_D|\mathbf{v}|w. With ω^=z^\hat{\boldsymbol{\omega}} = \hat{\mathbf{z}} the Magnus term involves ω^×v=(−vy,vx,0)\hat{\omega} \times\mathbf{v} = (-v_y, v_x, 0), which is horizontal and which in complex notation is exactly iwiw, a rotation by 90∘90^\circ. Putting these together,

dwdt=(ikL−kD)∣v∣w.(5)\frac{dw}{dt} = (ik_L-k_D)\lvert\mathbf{v}\rvert w. \tag*{(5)}

The right-hand side is proportional to ∣v∣\lvert\mathbf{v}\rvert, and this is what makes the change of variable from time to path length pay off. Using ds=∣v∣ dtds=\lvert\mathbf{v}\rvert\,dt, the speed cancels identically and Eq. (5) becomes linear with constant coefficients,

dwds=(ikL−kD)w,so thatw(s)=w0e−(kD−ikL)s.(6)\frac{dw}{ds}=(ik_L-k_D)w,\qquad\text{so that}\qquad w(s)=w_0e^{-(k_D-ik_L)s}. \tag*{(6)}

Equation (6) is exact. It holds with gravity acting throughout, at any launch angle and for any ball, and it does not involve the vertical motion at all. Everything that follows comes from it.

Two features are worth emphasising. First, the quadratic velocity dependence of both aerodynamic forces is essential, because it is the common factor ∣v∣\lvert\mathbf{v}\rvert that cancels under ds=∣v∣ dtds=\lvert\mathbf{v}\rvert\,dt. A Magnus force linear in speed, of the kind that arises for vortices in superfluids where the Magnus–Lorentz correspondence is standard[11], would not have this property, and the associated turning radius would then depend on speed. Second, the reparametrisation is in the spirit of Bernoulli’s tangent-angle method[9], with the difference that here the angle variable is an exact affine function of path length. That is what upgrades the solution from implicit to explicit.

Reduction to one scalar equation

Because ∣w(s)∣\lvert w(s)\rvert is now known in closed form, the whole flight problem reduces to a single scalar equation. Take the turn angle u≡ψu\equiv\psi as the independent variable, which by Eq. (6) means u=kLsu=k_Ls, and let

Q(u)≡tan⁡γ(u)=vz∣w∣.(7)Q(u)\equiv\tan\gamma(u)=\frac{v_z}{\lvert w\rvert}. \tag*{(7)}

The Magnus force has no vertical component, so v˙z=−g−kD∣v∣vz\dot{v}_z=-g-k_D\lvert\mathbf{v}\rvert v_z. Dividing this by ψ˙=kL∣v∣\dot{\psi}=k_L\lvert\mathbf{v}\rvert gives dvz/du+μvz=−g/(kL∣v∣)dv_z/du+\mu v_z=-g/(k_L\lvert\mathbf{v}\rvert). Multiplying by the integrating factor eμue^{\mu u} and using ∣w∣=∣w0∣e−μu\lvert w\rvert=\lvert w_0\rvert e^{-\mu u} together with ∣w∣=∣v∣cos⁡γ\lvert w\rvert=\lvert\mathbf{v}\rvert\cos\gamma yields

dQdu=−λe2μu1+Q2,Q(0)=tan⁡θ,(8)\frac{dQ}{du}=-\lambda\frac{e^{2\mu u}}{\sqrt{1+Q^2}},\qquad Q(0)=\tan\theta, \tag*{(8)}

with the single dimensionless group

λ=gkLv02cos⁡2θ=gLLv02cos⁡2θ,(9)\lambda= \frac{g}{k_L v_0^2 \cos^2\theta} = \frac{gL_L}{v_0^2\cos^2\theta}, \tag*{(9)}

where θ\theta is the launch elevation and v0v_0 the launch speed. Equation (8) carries the whole problem. Given Q(u)Q(u), the heading is ψ=u\psi=u, the horizontal speed is ∣w0∣e−μu|w_0|e^{-\mu u}, the total speed is ∣w0∣e−μu/cos⁡γ|w_0|e^{-\mu u}/\cos\gamma, and the position follows by quadrature. The three-dimensional velocity equation (1) has been reduced exactly to one scalar equation in the two parameters λ\lambda and μ\mu.

Two functionals of the solution encode the geometry we shall need. Since dz/du=vz/(kL∣v∣)=sin⁡γ/kLdz/du=v_z/(k_L|v|)=\sin\gamma/k_L, the ball returns to its release height after a turn Ψ\Psi if and only if

H≡∫0Ψsin⁡γ(u) du=0.(10)H \equiv\int_{0}^{\Psi}\sin\gamma(u)\,du=0. \tag*{(10)}

Similarly d(x+iy)/du=w/(kL∣v∣)=cos⁡γ eiu/kLd(x+iy)/du=w/(k_L|v|)=\cos\gamma\,e^{iu}/k_L, so the launch-to-landing chord is

chord=1kL∫0Ψcos⁡γ(u)eiu du.(11)\mathrm{chord}=\frac{1}{k_L}\int_{0}^{\Psi}\cos\gamma(u)e^{iu}\,du. \tag*{(11)}

Equation (11) is exact and is the key formula of § 0.5.

Invariants

Constant turning per unit path length

Taking the argument of Eq. (6),

dψds=kL=const,(12)\frac{d\psi}{ds}=k_L=\mathrm{const}, \tag*{(12)}

so the heading advances by a fixed angle per unit distance travelled. Gravity, launch angle, launch speed and CDC_D are all absent from Eq. (12). Drag is antiparallel to v\boldsymbol{v} and so contributes nothing to vxay−vyaxv_xa_y-v_ya_x. It slows the ball along the path without bending it. A heading change of Δψ\Delta\psi therefore always costs

S=ΔψkL=Δψ LL,(13)S=\frac{\Delta\psi}{k_L}=\Delta\psi\,L_L, \tag*{(13)}

and in particular a 180° turn costs exactly πLL\pi L_L of path, whatever the launch conditions and whatever the drag. For a baseball with CL=0.20C_L=0.20 this is πLL=883.6\pi L_L=883.6 m.

Logarithmic-spiral hodograph

Taking the modulus of Eq. (6) and eliminating ss using Eq. (12),

∣w∣=∣w0∣exp⁡[−μΔψ],μ=CDCL(14)|w| = |w_0|\exp[-\mu\Delta\psi], \qquad\mu= \frac{C_D}{C_L} \tag*{(14)}

so the horizontal velocity traces a logarithmic spiral whose pitch is set entirely by the lift-to-drag ratio. At Δψ=π\Delta\psi= \pi this becomes the compact statement ∣wf∣/∣w0∣=e−πCD/CL|w_f|/|w_0| = e^{-\pi C_D/C_L}.

We stress that Eq. (14) governs the horizontal speed. The total speed obeys no such law, because gravity re-accelerates the ball on descent and terminal velocity places a floor under vzv_z. Using e−πCD/CLe^{-\pi C_D/C_L} for ∣vf∣/∣v0∣|v_f|/|v_0| underestimates the true ratio by more than an order of magnitude at small CL/CDC_L/C_D, as Table IV shows.

CL/CDC_L/C_De−πCD/CLe^{-\pi C_D/C_L}simulated∣vf∣/∣v0∣|v_f|/|v_0|
0.50.00190.0435
1.00.04320.2110
2.00.20790.4622
3.00.35090.5938
5.00.53350.7263
10.00.73040.8506

Table IV. Residual speed at closure, comparing the exact horizontal law (14) with the same expression applied, incorrectly, to the total speed.

Equation (14) inverts to

CDCL=ln⁡(∣w0∣/∣wf∣)Δψ(15)\frac{C_D}{C_L} = \frac{\ln(|w_0|/|w_f|)}{\Delta\psi} \tag*{(15)}

which suggests a measurement. The lift-to-drag ratio of a real ball can be read off a single tracked trajectory by comparing the decay of its horizontal speed with the swing of its heading. Gravity drops out of Eq. (15) identically, so no correction for the vertical motion is needed.

Curvature of the ground track

The radius of curvature of the horizontal projection is Rh=(dsh/dt)/(dψ/dt)=∣w∣/(kL∣v∣)R_h = (ds_h/dt)/(d\psi/dt) = |w|/(k_L|v|), and ∣w∣/∣v∣=cos⁡γ|w|/|v| = \cos\gamma, so

Rh=LLcos⁡γ.(16)R_h = L_L \cos\gamma. \tag*{(16)}

The track is tightest where the ball is climbing or diving most steeply, and it is flattest at the apex, where γ=0\gamma= 0 and Rh=LLR_h = L_L exactly. This gives a second measurement, since the radius of curvature of the ground track at the apex is LLL_L directly, without separate knowledge of CLC_L, mm or AA. In the drag-free case γ\gamma runs from +θ+\theta to −θ-\theta, so

Rmax⁡Rmin⁡=sec⁡θ,(17)\frac{R_{\max}}{R_{\min}} = \sec\theta, \tag*{(17)}

which says exactly how far the track departs from a circle.

balldragfitted radius (m)LLL_L (m)rel. errorspeed change (m/s)
baseballoff281.267705304281.2677053065.5×10−125.5 \times10^{-12}50→50.00050 \to50.000
baseballon281.267705317281.2677053063.8×10−113.8 \times10^{-11}50→3.20050 \to3.200
frisbeeoff8.0758770468.0758770465.4×10−125.4 \times10^{-12}50→50.00050 \to50.000
frisbeeon8.0758770478.0758770468.9×10−118.9 \times10^{-11}50→29.61950 \to29.619

Table 1. Zero-gravity ground track, showing the fitted circle radius against LLL_L. Drag changes the speed by more than an order of magnitude and leaves the radius unchanged.

Figure 1. Numerical verification of the turning invariants with drag off. Left: the turning rate dψ/dsd\psi/ds normalised by kLk_L, plotted along the path for three launch conditions, with a deviation from unity that never exceeds 4.4×10−164.4 \times10^{-16}. Right: the total path length required for a 180° turn, normalised by πLL\pi L_L, swept over v0∈[10,120]v_0 \in[10, 120] m/s at five launch angles, with a deviation that never exceeds 1.1×10−151.1 \times10^{-15}.

Gravity is the sole source of non-circularity

Setting g=0g = 0 in Eq. (8) gives γ≡0\gamma\equiv0 and hence Rh≡LLR_h \equiv L_L, so the ground track is a perfect circle of radius LLL_L whether or not drag is present. This is a sharper statement than it may look, because drag can reduce the speed by any factor without altering the geometry. Table I confirms it numerically. A baseball that loses 94% of its speed still traverses a circle whose fitted radius agrees with LLL_L to eleven significant figures.

The counter-spinning rendezvous

Statement of the problem

We now put the machinery to work on a concrete question. A thrower at the origin releases two identical balls at the same moment in opposite horizontal directions, one spinning about +z^+\hat{z} and the other about −z^-\hat{z}. Both curve in the same sense in the horizontal plane. Can the launch conditions be chosen so that each ball turns through exactly 180∘180^\circ and the two collide head-on at the height of release?

Label the balls AA (launched along bearing 00 with spin +z^+\hat{z}) and BB (bearing π\pi with spin −z^-\hat{z}), and give them the same launch speed and the same elevation angle. The configuration is invariant under reflection in the vertical plane at bearing 90∘90^\circ combined with the exchange A↔BA \leftrightarrow B, since a mirror reflection reverses the horizontal velocity and negates the axial spin vector. Ball BB’s endpoint is therefore ball AA’s endpoint reflected in xx, and the two coincide if and only if

Re⁡(chord)=0,(18)\operatorname{Re}(\text{chord}) = 0, \tag*{(18)}

that is, if and only if the launch-to-meeting chord is perpendicular to the launch direction. By Eq. (11) with Ψ=π\Psi= \pi, condition (18) reads

I≡∫0πcos⁡γ(u)cos⁡u du=0.(19)\mathcal{I} \equiv\int_{0}^{\pi} \cos\gamma(u)\cos u\,\mathrm{d}u = 0. \tag*{(19)}

The whole question is the sign of a single integral of the positive weight cos⁡γ\cos\gamma against cos⁡u\cos u. The rendezvous succeeds precisely when that weight is balanced about u=π/2u = \pi/2.

Without drag: an exact one-parameter family

For μ=0\mu= 0 Eq. (8) is separable, and integrating 1+Q2 dQ=−λ du\sqrt{1+Q^2}\,\mathrm{d}Q = -\lambda\,\mathrm{d}u gives

12[Q1+Q2+arcsinh⁡Q]=const−λu.(20)\frac{1}{2}\left[Q\sqrt{1+Q^2}+\operatorname{arcsinh}Q\right] = \mathrm{const}-\lambda u. \tag*{(20)}

The map Q(u)↦−Q(π−u)Q(u) \mapsto-Q(\pi-u) preserves the μ=0\mu= 0 equation, so if the solution satisfies Q(π)=−tan⁡θQ(\pi) = -\tan\theta then by uniqueness

Q(u)=−Q(π−u)(21)Q(u) = -Q(\pi-u) \tag*{(21)}

identically. Two things follow at once. First, sin⁡γ\sin\gamma is odd about u=π/2u = \pi/2, so the closure condition (10) holds automatically. Second, cos⁡γ\cos\gamma is even about u=π/2u = \pi/2 while cos⁡u\cos u is odd, so I=0\mathcal{I} = 0 exactly. Without drag the chord is always exactly perpendicular to the launch direction, at every launch angle. The rendezvous is therefore possible, and imposing Q(π)=−tan⁡θQ(\pi) = -\tan\theta fixes

λ=tan⁡θsec⁡θ+arcsinh⁡(tan⁡θ)π=f(θ)πcos⁡2θ,(22)\lambda= \frac{\tan\theta\sec\theta+ \operatorname{arcsinh}(\tan\theta)}{\pi} = \frac{f(\theta)}{\pi\cos^{2}\theta}, \tag*{(22)}

with f(θ)=sin⁡θ+cos⁡2θln⁡(tan⁡θ+sec⁡θ)f(\theta) = \sin\theta+ \cos^{2}\theta\ln(\tan\theta+ \sec\theta). Combining Eq. (22) with Eq. (9) gives the launch speed in closed form,

v0=πgLLf(θ),(23)v_{0} = \sqrt{\frac{\pi g L_{L}}{f(\theta)}}, \tag*{(23)}

for any θ\theta, which is a one-parameter family of solutions. Note that f(θ)v02/gf(\theta)v_{0}^{2}/g is the classical arc length of a drag-free parabola, so Eq. (23) is just a restatement of Eq. (13). For a baseball, Eq. (23) gives 130.87 m/s at θ=15∘\theta= 15^\circ and falls to a shallow minimum of 84.99 m/s near θ=56.5∘\theta= 56.5^\circ before rising again. At θ=45∘\theta= 45^\circ the required speed is 86.89 m/s and the meeting point lies 515.4 m away.

A detail worth recording, because it is easy to get wrong, is that at the meeting point both balls are descending. Their vertical velocities are common-mode and cancel in the relative velocity. The closing speed is therefore

∣vA−vB∣=2∣w∣=2cos⁡θ∣vf∣,(24)\lvert v_{A} - v_{B} \rvert= 2\lvert w\rvert= 2\cos\theta\lvert v_{f}\rvert, \tag*{(24)}

rather than 2∣vf∣2\lvert v_{f}\rvert. We confirm this numerically to 6.5×10−116.5 \times10^{-11} relative over θ∈[10∘,80∘]\theta\in[10^\circ, 80^\circ]. At θ=60∘\theta= 60^\circ the closing speed equals the speed of a single ball.

With drag: the chord tips below perpendicular

Once μ>0\mu> 0 the antisymmetry (21) is broken and I\mathcal{I} need not vanish. Because the closure condition (10) determines λ\lambda once μ\mu and θ\theta are given, the chord bearing at closure is a function of μ\mu and θ\theta alone. It cannot depend on CLC_{L} and CDC_{D} separately, nor on the mass, the radius or the air density. This follows from the structure of Eq. (8) rather than from inspection of the output, and it is confirmed numerically to six decimal places for coefficient pairs that share a common μ\mu.

We evaluate the leading behaviour for small drag and small launch angle. Writing β\beta for the chord bearing, a perturbative solution of Eq. (8), given in the Appendix, yields

90∘−β=(83−24π2)μθ2+O(μ2,θ4)(25)90^\circ-\beta=\left(\frac{8}{3}-\frac{24}{\pi^2}\right)\mu\theta^2+O(\mu^2,\theta^4) \tag*{(25)}

in radians. The coefficient is 8/3−24/π2=0.23495838/3-24/\pi^2=0.2349583, and Richardson extrapolation of the numerically computed deficit reproduces it to a relative accuracy of 7×10−67\times10^{-6}, as shown in the right panel of Figure 2.

Figure 2. The obstruction to the rendezvous, computed from the reduced equation (8). Left: the chord-bearing deficit 90∘−β90^\circ-\beta over μ\mu and θ\theta, strictly positive everywhere, with real sports balls marked at θ=45∘\theta=45^\circ. Middle: the folded integrand of Eq. (27), which changes sign once, showing that the positivity of I\mathcal{I} is not pointwise. Right: convergence of the numerically computed deficit to the analytic coefficient 8/3−24/π28/3-24/\pi^2 of Eq. (25) as μ→0\mu\to0.

What matters here is the sign. The coefficient in Eq. (25) is positive if and only if 8/3>24/π28/3>24/\pi^2, which is to say if and only if

π2>9.(26)\pi^2>9. \tag*{(26)}

Since π2=9.8696…\pi^2=9.8696\ldots, the deficit is positive, the chord tips below perpendicular, and the rendezvous fails. The obstruction reduces to an elementary inequality.

A tempting argument that does not work

It is natural to try to prove I>0\mathcal{I}>0 pointwise. Folding Eq. (19) about u=π/2u=\pi/2 gives

I=∫0π/2[cos⁡γ(u)−cos⁡γ(π−u)]cos⁡u du,(27)\mathcal{I}=\int_{0}^{\pi/2}\left[\cos\gamma(u)-\cos\gamma(\pi-u)\right]\cos u\,\mathrm{d}u, \tag*{(27)}

and one might argue that with drag the descent is always steeper than the ascent at matched turn angle, which would make the bracket positive everywhere. That argument is false. Because drag makes the ascending arc longer than the descending arc, the apex occurs at a turn angle greater than π/2\pi/2. We measure ua=0.543πu_{\mathrm{a}}=0.543\pi, 0.572π0.572\pi and 0.635π0.635\pi for the three cases in Figure 2. For uu slightly below π/2\pi/2 both uu and π−u\pi-u then lie on the ascent, where ∣γ∣|\gamma| is decreasing, so the ordering reverses. The bracket in Eq. (27) changes sign exactly once, as the middle panel of Figure 2 shows. The positivity of I\mathcal{I} is genuinely an integral statement, in which a large positive contribution near launch outweighs a smaller negative one near the midpoint. We record this explicitly because the pointwise argument looks convincing at first.

Numerical survey and consequences

Beyond the asymptotic regime we evaluate the deficit directly from Eq. (8) over a 60×6060\times60 grid spanning 10−2≤μ≤310^{-2}\le\mu\le3 and 2∘≤θ≤88∘2^\circ\le\theta\le88^\circ, which brackets every ball in Table III. The deficit is strictly positive throughout, with a minimum of 1.67×10−41.67\times10^{-4} degrees at the corner μ=10−2\mu=10^{-2}, θ=2∘\theta=2^\circ, where both small parameters vanish together. This is the left panel of Figure 2. We therefore state the following.

objectCL/CDC_L/C_Dclosesθ\thetav0v_0 (m/s)tt (s)vf/v0v_f/v_0
frisbee3.00yes64°19.852.8130.590
soccer1.00yes76°124.209.5830.211
table tennis0.667yes80°90.953.9660.096
golf1.00no———ψmax⁡=0.804π\psi_{\max}=0.804\pi
baseball0.571no———ψmax⁡=0.504π\psi_{\max}=0.504\pi
tennis0.455no———ψmax⁡=0.565π\psi_{\max}=0.565\pi

Table III. Closure of a single 180° turn with drag active and v0v_0 capped at 150 m/s. The minimum-v0v_0 member of the θ\theta-family is shown. Coefficients are representative constants rather than measurements.

Result. Take constant CLC_{\mathrm{L}} and CDC_{\mathrm{D}} with CD>0C_{\mathrm{D}}>0 and a vertical spin axis. Two balls released in exactly opposite horizontal directions with opposite spin, at equal launch speeds and equal elevation angles, do not collide, at any launch speed or launch angle. This is proved for small μθ2\mu\theta^2 by Eq. (25) and established numerically over the physically relevant domain. A proof valid for all μ\mu and θ\theta remains open, as does the corresponding question for unequal launch conditions, which we discuss in Sec. VII B.

The practical size of the failure is not small. The two balls miss by 2∣chord∣cos⁡β2\lvert\mathrm{chord}\rvert\cos\beta, which for the closure solutions of Table III is 1.0–1.9 m for a frisbee, 7.6–9.4 m for a table tennis ball and 30–46 m for a soccer ball.

We note in passing that this changes the count of conditions. The two residuals “return to launch height” and “ψ=π\psi=\pi” are two ways of writing the single scalar statement that two events coincide, over the three unknowns v0v_0, θ\theta and tt. The corresponding 2×22\times2 Jacobian is numerically rank one, with a singular-value ratio of 4.0×10−94.0\times10^{-9}. The physical problem still becomes genuinely two-dimensional once drag is present, through the independent condition (18), which without drag is satisfied automatically.

Numerics and validation

The full system is integrated as an eleven-component state [r,v,ω,ψ,s][\mathbf{r},\mathbf{v},\boldsymbol{\omega},\psi,s], carrying ψ\psi and ss as state variables so that the heading unwraps correctly past ±π\pm\pi without any inverse-tangent differencing. Integration uses explicit Runge–Kutta 4(5) with relative tolerance 10−1010^{-10} and event detection for the two closure events, never fixed steps[12, 13]. Parameter sweeps use a batched fixed-step integrator. Figures are produced with Matplotlib[14].

Table II summarises the verification. The reduced equation (8) reproduces γ(ψ)\gamma(\psi) from the full three-dimensional integration to better than 10−8 rad10^{-8}\,\mathrm{rad} across four balls and three launch angles, and the reduced chord bearing agrees with the full simulation to better than 10−410^{-4} degrees. The invariants (12) and (13) hold to machine precision. Equation (12) holds equally well with drag active, which confirms that drag cannot torque the azimuth.

Beyond constant coefficients

The results of Secs. III and IV require CLC_L and CDC_D constant. Two remarks bound their scope. First, under constant CLC_L the Magnus term depends on the spin direction only, so the spin magnitude is exactly inert. Trajectories for ω=50\omega= 50, 200 and 800 rad/s coincide to twelve digits. Any question about sensitivity to spin rate is therefore empty until CLC_L is allowed to depend on the spin parameter S=rω/∣v∣S = r\omega/\lvert v\rvert. With the saturating form CL=1/(2+1/S)C_L = 1/(2 + 1/S), a 10% spin mismatch between the two balls produces a 1084 m miss at the drag-free 45∘45^\circ solution, which is larger than the chord itself. Second, we have implemented a smoothed drag-crisis model in which CDC_D falls from 0.47 to 0.15 across Re∼2\mathrm{Re} \sim2–4×1054 \times10^5. With CDC_D varying, ∣w∣\lvert w\rvert no longer follows Eq. (14) exactly, although Eq. (12) survives so long as CLC_L is constant, since drag never contributes to the turning rate whatever its magnitude.

Real balls

Table III collects the closure solutions with drag active, using representative coefficients[2, 3, 4]. Only three of the six objects can complete a 180∘180^\circ turn at all below 150 m/s, because the required path πLL\pi L_L must be covered before drag exhausts the ball. A baseball manages 0.504π0.504\pi of turn at best, falling short by 0.496π0.496\pi, and a solution exists mathematically only near v0=616v_0 = 616 m/s, which is Mach 1.8 and outside the validity of an incompressible quadratic-drag model. In view of § 0.5, we emphasise that the entries in Table III are single-ball 180∘180^\circ closures and are not rendezvous solutions.

Discussion

Relation to known results

The individual ingredients used here are old. The complex substitution w=vx+ivyw = v_x + \mathrm{i}v_y is standard for rotating-frame problems. The constant-CLC_L turn radius 2m/ρCLA2m/\rho C_L A is the aircraft-performance result that a wing at fixed lift coefficient turns with a speed-independent radius. The reparametrisation of projectile motion by a geometric angle is Bernoulli’s, dating to 1719[9]. What appears not to have been noticed is that these combine, for the vertical-axis case specifically, into an exactly solvable system. The turning angle is an affine function of path length, so Bernoulli’s implicit solution becomes explicit, and the turn radius survives the addition of drag untouched.

It is worth being precise about why the vertical-axis case is special while the general one is not. For a general spin orientation the Magnus term is not a pure rotation of ww, so the horizontal equation does not close and Eq. (6) fails. This is consistent with the perturbative status of the general problem in Ref.[7]. In exterior ballistics the situation is different again. For spin-stabilised projectiles the Magnus force is usually small enough to neglect, and the relevant lateral deflection arises instead from the Magnus moment through the yaw of repose[15], a gyroscopic mechanism unrelated to the one considered here.

Figure 3. Ground track of a drag-free closure solution at θ=45∘\theta= 45^\circ. Left: the track against its best-fit circle, with an RMS residual of 1.585 m on a fitted radius of 264.06 m, which is 43 times the ball radius. Right: the radius of curvature along the path, following Rh=LLcos⁡γR_h = L_L \cos\gamma with Rmax⁡/Rmin⁡=sec⁡θR_{\max}/R_{\min} = \sec\theta.

The Magnus–Lorentz analogy familiar from vortex dynamics[11] is instructive precisely where it breaks. There the Magnus force is linear in velocity, exactly like the Lorentz force, and the resulting circular orbits have a radius proportional to speed. The aerodynamic Magnus force is quadratic, and the radius is LLL_L regardless of speed. That speed-independence is what makes Eq. (13) possible.

An open problem

If one drops the requirement that each ball turn through exactly 180∘180^\circ and asks only that two oppositely thrown balls collide head-on at release height, then the head-on condition becomes

ΔψA+ΔψB=2π,(28)\Delta\psi_A + \Delta\psi_B = 2\pi, \tag*{(28)}

so the sum of the turns is fixed while the split need not be equal. The equal split is a drag-free accident. Counting gives four unknowns v0Av_{0A}, θA\theta_A, v0Bv_{0B} and θB\theta_B against four conditions, which suggests isolated solutions with one ball turning past 180∘180^\circ. We searched for these over a 70×7070 \times70 grid with pairing restricted to ΔψA<π<ΔψB\Delta\psi_A < \pi< \Delta\psi_B, and we found candidates with genuinely unequal turns of 145∘145^\circ and 215∘215^\circ. Every refinement drained back to the degenerate corner θ→0\theta\to0, v0→∞v_0 \to\infty and stalled at a residual miss of 1.5–2.0 mm, consistent with the θ2\theta^2 law of Eq. (25). We were unable to establish either existence or non-existence of a finite-angle asymmetric solution, and we record it as open.

Figure 4. The drag-free rendezvous, showing the two counter-spinning trajectories and their common endpoint at θ=45∘\theta= 45^\circ for a baseball. The mirror symmetry is exact, with arrival times agreeing to 3.6×10−15 s3.6 \times10^{-15}\,\mathrm{s}.

Classroom use

Several of these results are accessible as exercises at intermediate undergraduate level, in a first course on classical mechanics that has already introduced quadratic drag. Deriving Eq. (6) from Eq. (1) requires only the observation that ω^×v\hat{\omega} \times v is a rotation, and it makes a clean illustration of why choosing the right independent variable matters. The statement that a 180° turn costs a fixed distance regardless of how hard the ball is thrown is counterintuitive enough to be worth setting as a prediction before the derivation. The g=0g=0 circle of Table I is a good computational exercise, as is verifying that drag does not appear in Eq. (12). Finally, § 0.5 D is a useful cautionary example of a plausible pointwise argument that fails, with the failure diagnosable by plotting one function.

Conclusion

For a ball spinning about a vertical axis with constant lift and drag coefficients, the horizontal equation of motion becomes linear with constant coefficients when path length replaces time as the independent variable, and gravity drops out of it entirely. The heading then turns at the fixed rate kLk_L per unit path length, so a given change of heading always costs a fixed distance. The horizontal speed decays exponentially in the turn angle at a rate set only by CD/CLC_D/C_L, and the ground-track radius of curvature is LLcos⁡γL_L\cos\gamma, which reduces to LLL_L at the apex. Each of these gives a quantity that can in principle be measured from a single tracked trajectory without knowing the mass, the radius or the air density separately. The remaining vertical motion reduces exactly to the one scalar equation (8) in the two parameters λ\lambda and μ\mu, which makes the whole flight problem cheap to survey.

Applying this to the symmetric two-ball rendezvous, we find that the meeting is possible without drag on a one-parameter family given in closed form, and that drag destroys it. The chord tips below perpendicular by (8/3−24/π2)μθ2(8/3-24/\pi^2)\mu\theta^2 at leading order, and the sign of that coefficient comes down to π2>9\pi^2>9. The asymmetric version of the problem and a proof of the deficit’s positivity over the whole parameter range are both left open.

Author declarations

Conflict of interest. The author has no conflicts of interest to disclose.

Funding. This work received no external funding.

Data availability. The complete source code, regression test suite and figure-generating scripts are openly available[16]. All numbers quoted in this paper are reproduced by a single driver script, and the analytic claims are encoded as regression tests with the tolerances stated in Table II.

quantityconditionmax deviation
dψ/ds=kLd\psi/ds = k_Ldrag off4.4×10−164.4 \times10^{-16}
dψ/ds=kLd\psi/ds = k_Ldrag on6.7×10−166.7 \times10^{-16}
Stot=πLLS_{\mathrm{tot}} = \pi L_Ldrag off, v0×θv_0 \times\theta sweep1.1×10−151.1 \times10^{-15}
∣w∣=∣w0∣e−μΔψ\lvert w\rvert= \lvert w_0\rvert e^{-\mu\Delta\psi}drag on, four balls<10−9< 10^{-9}
Rh=LLcos⁡γR_h = L_L \cos\gammadrag on and off<10−12< 10^{-12}
g=0g = 0 track is a circle of radius LLL_Ldrag on and off<10−9< 10^{-9}
reduced ODE vs. full 3-D γ(ψ)\gamma(\psi)drag on, four balls<10−8 rad< 10^{-8}\,\mathrm{rad}
λ\lambda from Eq. (22)drag off3.5×10−123.5 \times10^{-12}
v0v_0 from Eq. (23)drag off2×10−142 \times10^{-14}
closing speed =2cos⁡θ∣vf∣= 2\cos\theta\lvert v_f\rvertdrag off6.5×10−116.5 \times10^{-11}
Rmax⁡/Rmin⁡=sec⁡θR_{\max}/R_{\min} = \sec\thetadrag off<10−6< 10^{-6}

Table II. Verification of the analytic results against direct integration. Deviations are relative unless stated otherwise.

Leading-order deficit

We sketch the calculation leading to Eq. (25), working to first order in μ\mu and second order in θ\theta. For small QQ, Eq. (8) linearises to Q′≃−λ(1+2μu)Q' \simeq-\lambda(1+2\mu u), so

Q(u)≃θ−λ(u+μu2).(29)Q(u) \simeq\theta-\lambda\left(u+\mu u^2\right). \tag*{(29)}

Imposing closure (10), which at this order reads ∫0πQ du=0\int_{0}^{\pi} Q\,\mathrm{d}u=0, gives

λ=θπ/2+μπ2/3≃λ0(1−2πμ3),λ0=2θπ.(30)\lambda=\frac{\theta}{\pi/2+\mu\pi^2/3}\simeq\lambda_0\left(1-\frac{2\pi\mu}{3}\right),\qquad\lambda_0=\frac{2\theta}{\pi}. \tag*{(30)}

With cos⁡γ≃1−Q2/2\cos\gamma\simeq1-Q^2/2 and ∫0πcos⁡u du=0\int_{0}^{\pi}\cos u\,\mathrm{d}u=0,

I≃−12∫0πQ2cos⁡u du.(31)\mathcal{I}\simeq-\frac{1}{2}\int_{0}^{\pi}Q^2\cos u\,\mathrm{d}u. \tag*{(31)}

Using ∫0πucos⁡u du=−2\int_{0}^{\pi}u\cos u\,\mathrm{d}u=-2, ∫0πu2cos⁡u du=−2π\int_{0}^{\pi}u^2\cos u\,\mathrm{d}u=-2\pi and ∫0πu3cos⁡u du=12−3π2\int_{0}^{\pi}u^3\cos u\,\mathrm{d}u=12-3\pi^2, and expanding to first order in μ\mu, the terms independent of μ\mu cancel identically, as they must by Eq. (21). What is left is

∫0πQ2cos⁡u du≃μθ2(163−16+96π2).(32)\int_{0}^{\pi}Q^2\cos u\,\mathrm{d}u\simeq\mu\theta^2\left(\frac{16}{3}-16+\frac{96}{\pi^2}\right). \tag*{(32)}

The imaginary part of Eq. (11) is ∫0πcos⁡γsin⁡u du≃2\int_{0}^{\pi}\cos\gamma\sin u\,\mathrm{d}u\simeq2 at leading order, so

90∘−β≃I2=μθ2(83−24π2).(33)90^\circ-\beta\simeq\frac{\mathcal{I}}{2}=\mu\theta^2\left(\frac{8}{3}-\frac{24}{\pi^2}\right). \tag*{(33)}

which is Eq. (25). The coefficient is positive because π2>9\pi^2>9.

References

  1. [1]L. J. Briggs, “Effect of spin and speed on the lateral deflection (curve) of a baseball; and the Magnus effect for smooth spheres,” American Journal of Physics 27, 589–596 (1959).DOI
  2. [2]R. D. Mehta, “Aerodynamics of sports balls,” Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics 17, 151–189 (1985).
  3. [3]A. M. Nathan, “The effect of spin on the flight of a baseball,” American Journal of Physics 76, 119–124 (2008).
  4. [4]J. R. Kensrud and L. V. Smith, “Drag and lift measurements of solid sports balls in still air,” Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part P: Journal of Sports Engineering and Technology 232, 236–243 (2018).DOI
  5. [5]K. Bray and D. G. Kerwin, “Modelling the flight of a soccer ball in a direct free kick,” Journal of Sports Sciences 21, 75–85 (2003).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12630787
  6. [6]J. E. Mencke, M. Salewski, O. L. Trinhhammer, and A. T. Adler, “Flight and bounce of spinning sports balls,” American Journal of Physics 88, 934–947 (2020).DOI
  7. [7]M. Turkyilmazoglu and T. Altundag, “Exact and approximate solutions to projectile motion in air incorporating Magnus effect,” The European Physical Journal Plus 135, 566 (2020).DOI
  8. [8]P. Chudinov, “Study of the asymptotic motion of a sporting projectile taking into account the Magnus force,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2409.15110 [physics.class-ph] (2024), 10.48550/arXiv.2409.15110.arxiv.org/abs/2409.15110
  9. [9]M. V. Lubarda and V. A. Lubarda, “A review of the analysis of wind-influenced projectile motion in the presence of linear and nonlinear drag force,” Archive of Applied Mechanics 92, 1997–2017 (2022).DOI
  10. [10]P. Chudinov, “On the problem of projectile motion in a medium with quadratic resistance,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2205.01564 [physics.class-ph] (2022), 10.48550/arXiv.2205.01564.arxiv.org/abs/2205.01564
  11. [11]E. B. Sonin, “Magnus force in superfluids and superconductors,” Physical Review B 55, 485–501 (1997).DOI
  12. [12]P. Virtanen et al., “SciPy 1.0: fundamental algorithms for scientific computing in Python,” Nature Methods 17, 261–272 (2020).
  13. [13]C. R. Harris et al., “Array programming with NumPy,” Nature 585, 357–362 (2020).
  14. [14]J. D. Hunter, “Matplotlib: A 2D graphics environment,” Computing in Science & Engineering 9, 90–95 (2007).DOI
  15. [15]R. L. McCoy, “Modern Exterior Ballistics: The Launch and Flight Dynamics of Symmetric Projectiles,” 2nd ed. (Schiffer Publishing, Atglen, PA) (2012).
  16. [16]P. Gaur, “Exact Arc-Length Reduction for Projectile Motion under Quadratic Drag and a Vertical-Axis Magnus Force, with a Non-Existence Result for the Symmetric Two-Ball Rendezvous,” https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.21979028 (2026), software and data.

Paper details

vlnc:W_q5dn3dbr
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 6

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents