betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The axial charge of the triton from lattice QCD

Abstract

The axial charge of the triton is investigated using lattice quantum chromodynamics (QCD). Extending previous work at heavier quark masses, calculations are performed using three ensembles of gauge field configurations generated with quark masses corresponding to a pion mass of 450 MeV. Finite-volume energy levels for the triton, as well as for the deuteron and diproton systems, are extracted from analysis of correlation functions computed on these ensembles, and the corresponding energies are extrapolated to infinite volume using finite-volume pionless effective field theory (FVEFT). It is found with high likelihood that there is a compact bound state with the quantum numbers of the triton at these quark masses. The axial current matrix elements are computed using background field techniques on one of the ensembles and FVEFT is again used to determine the axial charge of the proton and triton. A simple quark mass extrapolation of these results and earlier calculations at heavier quark masses leads to a value of the ratio of the triton to proton axial charges at the physical quark masses of gA3H/gAp=0.91+0.07−0.09g_A^{^{3}{\rm H}}/g_A^p=0.91\substack{+0.07 \\ -0.09}. This result is consistent with the ratio determined from experiment and prefers values less than unity (in which case the triton axial charge would be unmodified from that of the proton), thereby demonstrating that QCD can explain the modification of the axial charge of the triton.

Introduction

The triton (3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H}) is the simplest nucleus that undergoes weak decay, and as such is an important system with which to investigate the Standard Model (SM) origins of nuclear physics. While at the quark level the weak decay of the triton is mediated by the weak interactions, it is the strong interactions, described by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), that dictate the embedding of quarks inside nuclei and thus are key to the nuclear decay rate. A notable feature of the β\beta-decay of the triton and other nuclei is a reduction of the Gamow-Teller (isovector axial-vector) transition rate as compared to that of the neutron; this reduction scales approximately with the atomic number of the system, AA, for medium mass nuclei [1, 2, 3, 4] and can be described phenomenologically by an ad hoc reduction of the in-nucleus axial charge of the proton or by the introduction of two-nucleon interactions with the weak current [5]. For the triton, this manifests as a suppression of the isovector axial matrix element; analysis of precision tritium decay experiments finds that the ratio of the axial charge of the triton to that of the proton is gA3H/gAp=0.9511(13)g_{A}^{{}^{3}\mathrm{H}}/g_{A}^{p}=0.9511(13) [6]. This deviation from unity, and more generally, the difference of the axial charges of nuclei from that of the nucleon, is important phenomenologically and is a key aspect of nuclear physics to understand from the underlying SM. As well as probing our understanding of nuclear structure, study of tritium β\beta-decay is a very promising avenue through which to improve constraints on neutrino masses [7, 8, 9, 10]. Careful comparison of decay measurements with theoretical predictions may also reveal physics beyond that of the SM [11, 12]. Moreover, nuclear effects in Gamow-Teller transitions are important for understanding neutrinoful and neutrinoless double-β\beta decay matrix elements and thereby for sensitive searches for lepton number violation [13].

The half-life of tritium, t1/2t_{1/2}, is related to the Fermi (⟨F⟩\langle\mathrm{F}\rangle) and Gamow-Teller (⟨GT⟩\langle\mathrm{GT}\rangle) reduced matrix elements through

t1/2=K/GV2(1+δR)fV1⟨F⟩2+fAfVgA2⟨GT⟩2,(1)t_{1/2}=\frac{K/G_{V}^{2}}{(1+\delta_{R})f_{V}}\frac{1}{\langle\mathrm{F}\rangle^{2}+\frac{f_{A}}{f_{V}}g_{A}^{2}\langle\mathrm{GT}\rangle^{2}}, \tag*{(1)}

where the constants KK, GVG_{V}, and δR\delta_{R} are known precisely from theory or experiment [14], fA,Vf_{A,V} denote known Fermi functions [14], and gA≡gApg_{A}\equiv g_{A}^{p} is the axial charge of the nucleon. From the Ademollo-Gatto theorem [15], ⟨F⟩∼1\langle\mathrm{F}\rangle\sim1 and is only modified at second-order in isospin breaking and by electromagnetic corrections. The Gamow-Teller matrix element is less well determined and depends on the isovector axial current

Aka=qˉγkγ5τaq,(2)A_{k}^{a}=\bar{q}\gamma_{k}\gamma_{5}\tau^{a}q, \tag*{(2)}

where q=(u,d)Tq=(u,d)^{T} denotes a doublet of quark fields, γμ\gamma_{\mu} are Dirac matrices, and τa\tau^{a} are Pauli matrices in flavor space. In particular, the Gamow-Teller matrix element is defined from the zero-momentum projected current A~ka\widetilde{A}_{k}^{a} as

⟨3He,s∣A~k+∣3H,s′⟩=Uˉsγkγ5τ+Us′gAH⟨GT⟩,(3)\left\langle{}^{3}\mathrm{He},s\left|\widetilde{A}_{k}^{+}\right|{}^{3}\mathrm{H},s'\right\rangle=\bar{U}_{s}\gamma_{k}\gamma_{5}\tau^{+}U_{s'}g_{A}^{\mathrm{H}}\langle\mathrm{GT}\rangle, \tag*{(3)}

where gA3H≡gA⟨GT⟩g_{A}^{3\mathrm{H}}\equiv g_{A}\langle\mathrm{GT}\rangle, UsU_{s} is a relativistic spinor for the nucleus spin component s∈{+,−}s\in\{+,-\}, and τ+=τ1+iτ2\tau^{+}=\tau_{1}+i\tau_{2}. Eq. (3) is valid for zero electron mass and vanishing electron momentum. Because of the low energy scale of the β\beta-decay process, determinations of the axial charges of hadronic and nuclear systems probe QCD in the non-perturbative regime; theoretical determinations must therefore be undertaken using lattice QCD (LQCD) which is the only known systematically improvable tool for calculations in this regime. The axial charge of the proton has been calculated using LQCD for many years following the first studies in Ref. [16], see Ref. [17] for a recent summary of results. A first calculation of the axial charge of the triton was presented in Ref. [18], albeit at an SU(3)SU(3)-symmetric point with quark masses corresponding to a pion mass mπ=806m_{\pi} = 806 MeV. This work extends Ref. [18] with calculations at quark masses that are considerably closer to their physical values, corresponding to mπ=450m_{\pi} = 450 MeV and a kaon mass mK=595m_K = 595 MeV [19]. At these quark masses, the infinite volume extrapolated Gamow-Teller matrix element is determined to be ⟨GT⟩L→∞=0.938(41)\langle\mathrm{GT}\rangle_{L\to\infty} = 0.938(41). Combined with the earlier work, extrapolations of this result to the physical quark masses leads to ⟨GT⟩=gA3H/gAp=0.91−0.09+0.07\langle\mathrm{GT}\rangle= g_A^{{}^{3}\mathrm{H}}/g_A^p = 0.91^{+0.07}_{-0.09}. These are the main results of this work and show that the phenomenological modification of the axial charge of the triton can be reproduced directly from QCD.

LabelL/aL/aT/aT/aLL [fm]TT [fm]mπLm_{\pi}LmπTm_{\pi}TNcfgN_{\rm cfg}NmeasN_{\rm meas}
E2424642.807.476.39017.0421245.6×1055.6 \times10^{5}
E3232963.7311.28.51425.5428502.8×1052.8 \times10^{5}
E4848965.6011.212.7825.499804.7×1044.7 \times10^{4}

Table 1. Details of the ensembles of gauge field configurations used in this calculation, and of the measurements performed on them. In all cases, the gauge coupling is β=6.1\beta= 6.1, the tadpole-improved Sheikholeslami-Wohlert parameter is cSW=1.24931c_{\rm SW} = 1.24931 [21], and the bare light and strange quark masses in lattice units are amud(bare)=−0.2800am_{ud}^{\rm(bare)} = -0.2800 and ams(bare)=−0.2450am_{s}^{\rm(bare)} = -0.2450, respectively. Each ensemble consists of NcfgN_{\rm cfg} configurations on which a total of NmeasN_{\rm meas} measurements were made (slightly different numbers of sources were used on each configuration).

II Lattice QCD Details

The lattice QCD calculations presented in this work make use of isotropic gluon configurations generated with a Lüscher-Weisz [20] gauge action and Nf=2+1N_f = 2 + 1 flavors of fermions implemented using a tadpole-improved clover quark action [21]. All ensembles are generated using a gauge coupling of β=6.1\beta= 6.1 and with degenerate up and down quark masses corresponding to a pion mass of mπ=450m_{\pi} = 450 MeV and a strange quark mass that corresponds to a kaon mass of mK=595m_K = 595 MeV. Performing scale setting using upsilon spectroscopy extrapolated to the physical quark masses results in a lattice spacing of a=0.1167(16)a = 0.1167(16) fm. These configurations have previously been used to study two-baryon interactions [19, 22] and further details are presented in Ref. [19]. Three different lattice volumes are used, as shown in Table I.

III Spectroscopy and infinite volume extrapolation at mπ∼450m_{\pi} \sim450 MeV

In order to determine the ground-state energy of the triton and 3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He}, which are degenerate for the isospin-symmetric quark masses used in this calculation, two-point correlation functions projected to zero three-momentum are constructed using the methodology introduced in Refs. [23, 24]. The correlation functions are

Ch,s(t)=∑xΓβα(s)⟨χα(h)(x,t)χβ(h)†(0,0)⟩for s∈{+,−},(4)C_{h,s}(t)=\sum_{\mathbf{x}}\Gamma^{(s)}_{\beta\alpha}\left\langle\chi^{(h)}_{\alpha}(\mathbf{x},t)\chi^{(h)\dagger}_{\beta}(0,0)\right\rangle\quad\text{for }s\in\{+,-\}, \tag*{(4)}

where Γ(±)=14(1+γ4)(1±iγ1γ2)\Gamma^{(\pm)}=\frac{1}{4}(1+\gamma_4)(1\pm i\gamma_1\gamma_2) is a projector onto the given positive energy spin component and χ0α(h)\chi^{(h)}_{0\alpha} and χα(h)\chi^{(h)}_{\alpha} are interpolating operators with the quantum numbers of the hadron h∈{p,3H}h\in\{p,{}^{3}\mathrm{H}\}. For the triton, the interpolating operator is built from three color-singlet nucleons that are independently projected to zero three-momentum in Eq. (4). The quark propagators used to construct the correlation functions are computed using APE smeared [25] sources and point or APE smeared sinks; the resulting correlation functions are referred to as ‘SP’ and ‘SS’ respectively.1 An advantage of using local multi-hadron sources in this manner is that they can be efficiently computed for light nuclei such as the triton using baryon block algorithms whose cost scales linearly with the spatial volume [23]. A disadvantage of this approach is that since source and sink operators are distinct, it is not possible to build a variational basis of operators that would explicitly account for excited-state contamination from unbound multi-nucleon states that have small energy separations to the ground state for large volumes. Similar issues arise in the two-nucleon sector, and Ref. [22] discusses a number of consistency checks that have been applied to two-nucleon results using multiple interpolating operators on the same ensemble as used here. Given tensions between two-nucleon ground-state energy results with mπ∼800m_\pi\sim800 MeV obtained using products of zero-momentum baryon sources [26, 27] compared with results obtained using local or approximately local two-baryon sources [24, 28], it will be important to pursue variational studies of both the two-nucleon and three-nucleon sectors, including operators overlapping with bound and unbound states, in the future. However, multi-nucleon variational studies require a large set of interpolating operators whose correlation functions are significantly more costly to compute than those calculated here and are deferred to future work. While here the focus is on the triton and the nucleon, other single hadron and two-baryon systems have been studied using the same approach as applied here, on the same ensembles of gauge field configurations, as discussed in Refs. [19, 22].

The ground-state triton energy and its difference from the mass of three non-interacting nucleons are extracted in each volume from analysis of the time dependence of C3H,±(t)C_{3\mathrm{H},\pm}(t) and Cp,±(t)C_{p,\pm}(t) using the same fitting methodology as applied and detailed in Refs. [22, 29]. For completeness, the approach is summarized here. Provided that the temporal separation of the source and sink, tt, is larger than the extent of the lattice action, and small compared with the temporal extent of the lattice geometry (t≪Tt\ll T), the correlation functions are given by a sum of exponentials whose exponents are determined by the energies of the eigenstates of the given quantum numbers:

Ch,±SS′(t)=∑n=0NexZn(h)SZn(h)S′∗exp⁡(−En(h)t)for {S,S′}∈{S,P},(5)C^{SS'}_{h,\pm}(t)=\sum_{n=0}^{N_{\mathrm{ex}}}Z^{(h)S}_{n}Z^{(h)S'\ast}_{n}\exp\left(-E^{(h)}_{n}t\right)\quad\text{for }\{S,S'\}\in\{S,P\}, \tag*{(5)}

where NexN_{\mathrm{ex}} excited states contribute to the sum, Zn(h)S/PZ^{(h)S/P}_{n} denotes the overlap factor of the corresponding interpolating operators onto the nnth energy eigenstate, and thermal effects arising from the finite temporal extent of the lattice geometry have been neglected. Fits of the correlation functions to Eq. (5) determine the ground state energies Mh=E0(h)M_h = E_0^{(h)} among the fit parameters; while correlation functions for different propagator smearings have different overlap factors, the energies are common and are thus fit simultaneously. To quantify the systematic uncertainties arising from the choice of source-sink separations, tt, included in the fit, and of the truncation of the sum in Eq. (5), 200 fit windows are sampled at random from the set of all choices of contiguous time-ranges longer than tplat=6t_{\mathrm{plat}} = 6 and with final times less than tmax⁡t_{\max} (defined by the point at which the noise-to-signal ratio exceeds tolnoise=0.25tol_{\mathrm{noise}} = 0.25 for the given correlation function). For each fit range, the Akaike Information Criterion [30] (AIC) is used to perform model selection (i.e., fix the number of exponential terms in the sum above). The truncation is set as the largest NexN_{\mathrm{ex}} for which the change in AIC is ΔAIC<−0.5Ndof\Delta\mathrm{AIC} < -0.5N_{\mathrm{dof}}, where NdofN_{\mathrm{dof}} is the number of degrees of freedom of the fit. In each case, combined correlated fits are performed to average correlation functions as well as to Nboot=200N_{\mathrm{boot}} = 200 bootstrap resamplings of the correlation functions using covariance matrices computed using optimal shrinkage [31, 32, 33] and using variable projection (VarPro) [34, 35] to eliminate overlap factors. All fits with a χ2/Ndof<tolχ2=2\chi^2/N_{\mathrm{dof}} < tol_{\chi^2} = 2 are included in a set of ‘accepted’ fits (accepted fits must also pass tests that the fit results are a) invariant to the choice of the minimizer that is used to within tolsolver=10−5tol_{\mathrm{solver}} = 10^{-5}, b) agree within a prescribed tolerance of tolcorr=5σtol_{\mathrm{corr}} = 5\sigma with uncorrelated fits, and c) agree within a prescribed tolerance of tolmedian=2σtol_{\mathrm{median}} = 2\sigma to the median bootstrap result, as in Refs. [22, 29]). The final value and uncertainties for the energy are then computed from the results of all NsuccessN_{\mathrm{success}} accepted fits using a weighted average. The central value and statistical and systematic uncertainties are computed as

E‾0=∑f=1NsuccesswfE0f,δstatE‾0=δE0fmax⁡,δsysE‾02=∑f=1Nsuccesswf(E0f−E‾0)2,(6)\overline{E}_0 = \sum_{f=1}^{N_{\mathrm{success}}} w^f E_0^f,\qquad\delta_{\mathrm{stat}}\overline{E}_0 = \delta E_0^{f_{\max}},\qquad\delta_{\mathrm{sys}}\overline{E}_0^2 = \sum_{f=1}^{N_{\mathrm{success}}} w^f\left(E_0^f-\overline{E}_0\right)^2, \tag*{(6)}

where E0fE_0^f denotes the fit result from a given fit labelled by ff, and wfw_f is the associated weight. For each fit range, the statistical uncertainties δE0f\delta E_0^f are computed using 67% confidence intervals determined from the results of the NbootN_{\mathrm{boot}} resampled correlation function fits described above; the total statistical uncertainty is defined as the statistical uncertainty of the fit fmax⁡f_{\max} with maximum weight wfmax⁡w_{f_{\max}}. The statistical and systematic uncertainties are combined in quadrature to give a total uncertainty δE‾0=δstatE‾02+δsysE‾02\delta\overline{E}_0 = \sqrt{\delta_{\mathrm{stat}}\overline{E}_0^2+\delta_{\mathrm{sys}}\overline{E}_0^2}. Since each successful fit provides a statistically unbiased estimate of the ground-state energy, the relative weights wfw_f of each fit in the weighted average can be chosen arbitrarily (in the limit of large statistics) [33]. Here, as in Refs. [22, 29, 33], the weights are set as

wf=pf(δE0f)−2∑f′=1Nsuccesspf′(δE0f′)−2,(7)w^f = \frac{p_f\left(\delta E_0^f\right)^{-2}}{\sum_{f'=1}^{N_{\mathrm{success}}}p_{f'}\left(\delta E_0^{f'}\right)^{-2}}, \tag*{(7)}

where pf=Γ(Ndof/2,χf2/2)/Γ(Ndof/2)p_f = \Gamma(N_{\mathrm{dof}}/2,\chi_f^2/2)/\Gamma(N_{\mathrm{dof}}/2) is the pp-value of fit ff assuming χ2\chi^2-distributed goodness-of-fit parameters.

The resulting fitted masses are summarised for each volume in Table II and the fits are shown graphically for the proton in Figure 1 and for the triton in Figure 2. In each figure, the effective mass functions

Figure 1. Left column: effective mass functions (Eq. (8)) for the proton correlation function on the E24 (top), E32 (center), and E48 (bottom) ensembles. The orange circles and blue squares show effective masses constructed from SP and SS correlation functions respectively, and the corresponding orange and blue curves display the highest-weight fit contributing to the weighted average of Eq. (6); the light (dark) grey bands show the mass extracted from the weighted average (single highest-weight fit). Right column: masses extracted from each successful fit to the correlators. The opacity of each point is set by the contribution of the fit to the weighted average. The horizontal line and grey band in each figure correspond to the final result for the mass and its total uncertainty.

Figure 2. Effective mass functions and fit summaries for the fits of the triton correlation function on the E24 (top), E32 (center), and E48 (bottom) ensembles. All features are as in Figure 1.

aMhSS′(t)=ln⁡(∑s=±Ch,sSS′(t)∑s=±Ch,sSS′(t+a))(8)aM_h^{SS'}(t) = \ln\left(\frac{\sum_{s=\pm} C_{h,s}^{SS'}(t)}{\sum_{s=\pm} C_{h,s}^{SS'}(t+a)}\right) \tag*{(8)}

are shown for the SS and SP data along with the functional form of best fits to the correlation functions and the final result for E0(h)E_0^{(h)}. The difference between the triton mass and three times the proton mass, ΔE3H=E0(3H)−3E0(p)\Delta E_{3\mathrm{H}} = E_{0}^{(3\mathrm{H})} - 3E_{0}^{(p)}, is determined from the correlated differences of the fitted energies computed under bootstrap. The results for this quantity are also presented in Table II.

EnsembleaE0(p)aE_{0}^{(p)}aE0(3H)aE_{0}^{(3\mathrm{H})}aΔE3Ha\Delta E_{3\mathrm{H}}
E240.7258(29)2.157(40)−0.024(32)-0.024(32)
E320.7236(8)2.122(28)−0.054(24)-0.054(24)
E480.7261(16)2.168(26)−0.012(14)-0.012(14)

Table 2. Fit results for the proton and triton ground-state energies, as well as the difference ΔE3H=E0(3H)−3E0(p)\Delta E_{3\mathrm{H}} = E_{0}^{(3\mathrm{H})} - 3E_{0}^{(p)}, determined in lattice units on each ensemble.

In the limit in which mπLm_{\pi}L is sufficiently large and the pion mass is sufficiently small that the volume dependence of the proton mass is described by pp-regime chiral perturbation theory (χ\chiPT), that dependence takes the form [36, 37]

Mp(L)−Mp∞=−3gA28π2fπ2K(0,L)−gΔN23π2fπ2K(Δ,L),(9)M_p(L)-M_p^\infty=-\frac{3g_A^2}{8\pi^2 f_\pi^2}\mathcal{K}(0,L)-\frac{g_{\Delta N}^2}{3\pi^2 f_\pi^2}\mathcal{K}(\Delta,L), \tag*{(9)}

where fπf_\pi is the chiral limit pion decay constant and

K(Δ,L)≡∫0∞dλ βΔ∑n⃗≠0⃗[(L∣n⃗∣)−1K1(LβΔ∣n⃗∣)−βΔK0(LβΔ∣n⃗∣)].(10)\mathcal{K}(\Delta,L)\equiv\int_0^\infty d\lambda\,\beta_\Delta\sum_{\vec{n}\ne\vec{0}}\left[(L|\vec{n}|)^{-1}K_1(L\beta_\Delta|\vec{n}|)-\beta_\Delta K_0(L\beta_\Delta|\vec{n}|)\right]. \tag*{(10)}

Here, LL denotes the spatial extent of the lattice geometry, KnK_n are modified Bessel functions, βΔ2≡λ2+2λΔ+mπ2\beta_\Delta^2\equiv\lambda^2+2\lambda\Delta+m_\pi^2, Δ\Delta denotes the mass splitting between the nucleon and the Δ\Delta baryon, and gΔNg_{\Delta N} is the nucleon-Δ\Delta transition axial coupling. The sum in Eq. (10) is over integer triplets excluding n⃗=(0,0,0)\vec{n}=(0,0,0), and for Δ=0\Delta=0 the asymptotic behavior of Eq. (9) is ∼e−mπL/L\sim e^{-m_\pi L}/L.

While mπ=450m_\pi=450 MeV is not in the regime where chiral perturbation theory shows rapid convergence for baryon properties, it has been found to effectively describe the volume-dependence of baryon masses in this mass regime [38]. With the physical values of gA=1.26g_A=1.26, gΔN=1.4g_{\Delta N}=1.4, fπ=132f_\pi=132 MeV and Δ=300\Delta=300 MeV, Eq. (9) is used to fit to the infinite volume proton mass from the masses determined on the three volumes. This fit, displayed in Figure 3, results in an infinite volume mass of Mp∞=1.2242(12)M_p^\infty=1.2242(12) GeV.2

Figure 3. (a) Mass of the proton as a function of the spatial extent of the lattice geometry, along with the fit to this dependence via Eq. (9). (b) The binding energy of the triton as a function of the spatial extent of the lattice geometry. Grey squares correspond to the binding energies determined in the LQCD calculations, while the blue curve shows the finite-volume dependence in pionless EFT fitted to the LQCD data. The blue point at the right indicates the infinite volume extrapolation of the binding energy. For comparison, the binding energies of the pp (purple) and deuteron (green) systems obtained via an analogous FVEFT study are also shown.

Figure 3 also shows the difference between the triton energy and the three-nucleon threshold for each of the three volumes. Unlike for the proton, the form of the volume dependence of the triton energy is not known analytically, however a numerical description can be found by matching to finite-volume effective field theory (FVEFT). The procedure of matching pionless EFT to LQCD results for the binding energies of light nuclei using the stochastic variational method has been demonstrated in Ref. [39] using LQCD results with mπ=806m_\pi=806 MeV. The same procedure as detailed in that work is followed for the data presented here, and further details of the FVEFT approach used here are provided in Appendix § 0.7.3 The infinite volume extrapolation leads to an energy shift ΔE3H∞=−32(23)\Delta E_{^3\mathrm{H}}^\infty=-32(23) MeV. The FVEFT formalism is compatible with both scattering states and bound systems and the extracted energy suggests the state is not consistent with three scattering nucleons. This leaves the possibility that it is a compact three-body bound state or either a deuteron–neutron or dineutron-proton scattering state, as the binding energies of the deuteron and dineutron are 7.2(3.2) and 11.6(3.6) MeV from the FVEFT extrapolation respectively (illustrated in Figure 9 in Appendix § 0.7; note also that these results are consistent, within 1 standard deviation, with those obtained from this data via Lüscher’s method in Refs. [19, 22]). While the latter cases of 2+1 body systems can not be ruled out, there is a strong preference (80% likelihood, using the most conservative two-body binding energies) that the state is a compact three-body system. In what follows, this is assumed to be the case and the state is referred to as the ‘triton’.

Figure 9. Determination of the EFT two-body couplings, CS,TC_{S,T} from the deuteron (left) and pppp (right) energies. The horizontal bands correspond to the energy shifts from the LQCD calculations on the E24 (blue), E32 (orange), and E48 (green) ensembles. The curves in each figure show the FVEFT two-body energy shifts for L∈{24,32,48}L \in\{24, 32, 48\} (using the same color scheme) for the EFT cutoff parameter r0=0.2r_0 = 0.2 fm [49]. The LECs are determined by a simultaneous optimization matching the LQCD constraints from all three volumes to the corresponding curves; the results are shown as the red bands. To guide the eye, the intercept ranges of each band with the corresponding curve are shown as the colored bars.

In Figure 4, the resulting binding energy of the triton is compared to the results of other calculations, including that of Ref. [24] using the same action but heavier quark masses corresponding to mπ=806m_\pi=806 MeV. The extracted binding energy is compatible with those of other calculations at nearby quark masses [41, 42], although no effort is made to take into account the differences between the lattice actions or scale-setting schemes that are used. Naive extrapolations of the current result and that from Ref. [24] that are linear or quadratic in mπm_\pi are consistent with the experimental value for the binding energy of the triton, albeit with large uncertainties. The strong evidence for binding at the other masses shown in the figure, and the assumption of smooth behavior under variation in the pion mass provides additional support for the conclusion that the triton is a compact three-body system at these quark masses.

Figure 4. Binding energy of the triton as a function of the pion mass. The current result is shown in blue, along with the result obtained in a previous calculation [24] using the same action at mπ=806m_\pi= 806 MeV. The results of Refs. [41, 42] are shown in orange. The physical value of the binding is shown as a red star at the physical pion mass, as indicated by the vertical line. Linear and quadratic fits in mπm_\pi to the blue data are shown as the green and blue bands respectively.

Gamow-Teller matrix element for tritium β\beta-decay

To extract the axial charge of the triton, and hence the Gamow-Teller contribution to tritium β\beta-decay, LQCD calculations of matrix elements of the isovector axial current in the triton and proton are performed using the E32 ensemble. Only a single ensemble is used due to computational cost and for technical simplicity, the flavor-diagonal matrix element ⟨3H∣A~33∣3H⟩\langle{}^3\mathrm{H}|\widetilde{A}_3^3|{}^3\mathrm{H}\rangle is studied and is related by isospin symmetry to the tritium β\beta-decay matrix element. The resulting values are matched to FVEFT to determine the relevant low energy constants (LECs), which are then used to predict the infinite-volume matrix element.

To compute the finite-volume matrix elements, the extended propagator technique discussed in detail in Refs. [18, 43, 44, 45, 46] is used. This requires extraction of hadronic and nuclear correlation functions at a range of values of an applied constant axial field that couples to up and down quarks separately. Extended quark propagators are defined as

Sλf(f)(x,y)=S(f)(x,y)+λf∫d4z S(f)(x,z)γ3γ5S(f)(z,y),(11)S_{\lambda_f}^{(f)}(x,y)=S^{(f)}(x,y)+\lambda_f\int d^4z\,S^{(f)}(x,z)\gamma_3\gamma_5S^{(f)}(z,y), \tag*{(11)}

where S(f)(x,y)S^{(f)}(x,y) is a quark propagator of flavor f∈{u,d}f \in\{u,d\} and λf\lambda_f is the strength of the applied field for the given flavor. These quantities are calculated for five values of the external field strength λu,d∈{0,±0.05,±0.1}\lambda_{u,d} \in\{0,\pm0.05,\pm0.1\} in lattice units. Two-point correlation functions Ch,s(λu,λd)(t)C_{h,s}^{(\lambda_u,\lambda_d)}(t) are constructed from these extended propagators using the same contraction methods as for the zero-field correlation functions discussed in the previous section. For clarity, the smearing labels SS/SP are suppressed in this section. The two-point correlation functions are polynomials in λf\lambda_f of order nfn_f, the number of quark propagators of flavor ff in the correlation function. With computations at nfn_f different field strength values, the terms in the polynomial can thus be extracted uniquely [44] and are labelled as Ch,s(λf,0)(t)∣O(λfk)C_{h,s}^{(\lambda_f,0)}(t)\big|_{\mathcal{O}(\lambda_f^{k})} and Ch,s(0,λf)(t)O(λfk)\left.\frac{C_{h,s}^{(0,\lambda_f)}(t)}{O(\lambda_f^k)}\right. for k∈{0,…,nf}k \in\{0,\ldots,n_f\}. It is straightforward to show [18, 44] through insertions of complete sets of states that an effective isovector axial charge function, which asymptotes to the desired bare axial charge in the corresponding hadronic or nuclear state at large temporal separations, can be defined as

gAh(t)=Rh(t+a)−Rh(t)→t→∞gAh(0)+O(e−δt),(12)g_A^h(t) = R_h(t+a)-R_h(t) \xrightarrow{t\to\infty} g_A^{h(0)}+\mathcal{O}(e^{-\delta t}), \tag*{(12)}

where the (0) superscript denotes that the charge is not renormalized, δ\delta is the energy difference between the ground state and the first excited state with the quantum numbers of the state hh, and

Rh(t)=∑s=±ηsCh,s(λu,0)(t)∣O(λu)−Ch,s(0,λd)(t)∣O(λd)2aCh,s(0,0)(t)(13)R_h(t)=\sum_{s=\pm}\eta_s\frac{\left.C_{h,s}^{(\lambda_u,0)}(t)\right|_{O(\lambda_u)}-\left.C_{h,s}^{(0,\lambda_d)}(t)\right|_{O(\lambda_d)}}{2aC_{h,s}^{(0,0)}(t)} \tag*{(13)}

for η±=∓1\eta_{\pm}=\mp1.

The effective charges in Eq. (12) are constructed from sums of ratios of two-point functions whose time dependence is each of the generic exponential form in Eq. (5). The axial charges can therefore be isolated by fits to the time-dependence of the effective charge functions. These fits are performed using an extension of the fit range sampling and excited-state model selection procedure discussed above to background field three-point functions (see Ref. [47] for further details). The spectral representations for the O(λ)\mathcal{O}(\lambda) correlation functions appearing in Eq. (13) can be constructed as4

Ch,s(λu,0)(t)∣O(λu)−Ch,s(0,λd)(t)∣O(λd)=aηs∑τ/a=0t/a∑n,mZn(h)Zm(h)∗e−En(h)(t−τ)e−Em(h)τgAh(m,n)(0),(14)\left.C_{h,s}^{(\lambda_u,0)}(t)\right|_{O(\lambda_u)}-\left.C_{h,s}^{(0,\lambda_d)}(t)\right|_{O(\lambda_d)} =a\eta_s\sum_{\tau/a=0}^{t/a}\sum_{n,m}Z_n^{(h)}Z_m^{(h)*}e^{-E_n^{(h)}(t-\tau)}e^{-E_m^{(h)}\tau}g_A^{h(m,n)(0)}, \tag*{(14)}

where the prime on the second ZZ-factor is included to denote that, although smearings are suppressed in this section, the overlap factors differ at the source and sink, and the bare (transition) charge gAh(m,n)(0)g_A^{h(m,n)(0)} is defined from the corresponding matrix element as

⟨h,n,s∣A~33∣h,m,s′⟩=U‾n,sγ3γ5τ3Um,s′gAh(m,n)(0),(15)\langle h,n,s|\widetilde{A}_3^3|h,m,s'\rangle=\overline{U}_{n,s}\gamma_3\gamma_5\tau_3U_{m,s'}g_A^{h(m,n)(0)}, \tag*{(15)}

where ∣h,n,s⟩|h,n,s\rangle denotes states with the quantum numbers of hh and Um,sU_{m,s} denotes the spinor for state mm with spin ss. This can be used to derive a spectral representation for gAh(t)g_A^h(t):

gAh(t)=∑nZn(h)Zn(h)∗gAh(n,n)(0)((t/a+1)e−En(h)(t+a)∑kZk(h)Zk(h)∗e−Ek(h)(t+a)−(t/a)e−En(h)t∑kZk(h)Zk(h)∗e−Ek(h)t)+O(a),(16)g_A^h(t)=\sum_n Z_n^{(h)}Z_n^{(h)*}g_A^{h(n,n)(0)} \left( \frac{(t/a+1)e^{-E_n^{(h)}(t+a)}}{\sum_k Z_k^{(h)}Z_k^{(h)*}e^{-E_k^{(h)}(t+a)}} -\frac{(t/a)e^{-E_n^{(h)}t}}{\sum_k Z_k^{(h)}Z_k^{(h)*}e^{-E_k^{(h)}t}} \right)+\mathcal{O}(a), \tag*{(16)}

where the O(a)\mathcal{O}(a) contribution is detailed in Ref. [47] and depends on excited-state transition matrix elements as well as combinations of overlap factors not determined from fits of two-point functions to Eq. (5). Notably, the O(a)\mathcal{O}(a) term is absent for a single-state correlation function model. Multi-state fits have been performed both with and without these O(a)\mathcal{O}(a) terms and the AIC is used to determine whether the O(a)\mathcal{O}(a) terms should be included in the fit. For both the triton and proton, this AIC test prefers the fit without O(a)\mathcal{O}(a) terms for all fit range choices. Combined fits of 12∑s=±Ch,s(t)\frac{1}{2}\sum_{s=\pm} C_{h,s}(t) to Eq. (5) and gAh(t)g_A^h(t) to Eq. (16) without O(a)\mathcal{O}(a) terms using both SP/SS interpolating operator combinations are therefore used to determine En(h)E_n^{(h)}, the product Zn(h)Zn(h)∗Z_n^{(h)} Z_n^{(h)*}, and gAh(n,n)g_A^{h(n,n)}. For each fitting interval, ln⁡(En(h))\ln(E_n^{(h)}) and gAh(0)=gAh(n,n)(0)g_A^{h(0)} = g_A^{h(n,n)(0)} are used as nonlinear optimizer parameters with Zn(h)Z_n^{(h)} obtained from Ch,s(t)C_{h,s}(t) using VarPro as above and gAh(n,n)(0)g_A^{h(n,n)(0)} subsequently obtained from gAh(t)g_A^h(t) using VarPro. Statistical uncertainties on the ground-state matrix elements for each fit are obtained using bootstrap confidence intervals, and a weighted average performed analogously to the two-point function case described above is used to determine the final ground-state matrix element values and statistical plus fitting systematic uncertainties. Results for the ground-state matrix elements gAh(0)g_A^{h(0)} obtained using this fitting procedure for both one- and three-nucleon systems are shown in Table III.

hhgAh(0)g_A^{h(0)}gAhg_A^hgAh/gApg_A^h/g_A^p
pp1.399(9)1.230(19)–
3H{}^3\mathrm{H}1.332(40)1.171(39)0.953(30)

Table III. Fit results for the bare, gAh(0)g_A^{h(0)}, and renormalized, gAhg_A^h, axial charges of the proton and triton as well as the corresponding ratio to the axial charge of the proton. The statistical uncertainties and fitting systematic uncertainties are combined in quadrature. The fitting systematic uncertainties account for variation in the choice of fit ranges and multi-state fit models used to obtain gAh(0)g_A^{h(0)} and the resulting correlated ratio of ground-state matrix elements gAh/gApg_A^h/g_A^p as described in the main text.

The quantities gAp(t)g_A^p(t) and gA3H(t)g_A^{^3\mathrm{H}}(t) constructed on ensemble E32 for both SS and SP source– sink pairs are shown in Figure 5. Also shown are the values of the bare matrix elements determined from fits to the time-dependence of these functions as discussed above. Table III displays the extracted bare couplings gAh(0)g_A^{h(0)} as well as renormalized couplings gAh=ZAgAh(0)g_A^h=Z_Ag_A^{h(0)} obtained by multiplying by the appropriate axial current renormalization constant, ZA=0.8623(01)(71)Z_A=0.8623(01)(71) determined in Ref. [48]. The ratio gA3H(t)/gAp(t)g_A^{{}^3\mathrm{H}}(t)/g_A^p(t), which at large times asymptotes to the GT reduced matrix element ⟨GT⟩=gA3H/gAp\langle\mathrm{GT}\rangle=g_A^{{}^3\mathrm{H}}/g_A^p, and is independent of the renormalization of the axial current, is shown in Figure 6 along with the value of ⟨GT⟩\langle\mathrm{GT}\rangle that is extracted from the fits to the individual axial couplings.

Figure 5. The left panels show the proton and triton bare effective matrix element functions, gAp(t)g_A^p(t) and gA3H(t)g_A^{^3\mathrm{H}}(t), respectively, calculated on the E32 ensemble. In each figure, the orange (blue) data correspond to the SP (SS) calculations and the corresponding shaded bands illustrate the highest weight fit. The light (dark) shaded gray bands denote the extracted values of the matrix elements arising from the combined analysis (single highest-weight fit). The right panels show the values obtained for all the successful fits to different time ranges, with the opacity determined by the contribution of the fit in the final weighted average. The horizontal line and gray band in the right panels show the final central value and uncertainty.

Figure 6. The effective ratio function gA3H(t)/gAp(t)g_A^{{}^3\mathrm{H}}(t)/g_A^p(t), constructed through Eq. (12), which asymptotes to gA3H/gApg_A^{{}^3\mathrm{H}}/g_A^p and is independent of axial current renormalization. The orange (blue) data show the SP (SS) correlation functions on the E32 ensemble and the shaded band indicates the extracted value of the matrix element (not a fit to the displayed data).

The FV three-body matrix element in Table III can be used to constrain the leading two-nucleon axial current counterterm of pionless effective field theory in the finite volume. To do so, the approach developed in Ref. [49] is followed, whereby EFT wavefunctions, determined variationally and matched to the LQCD spectrum computed in the E32 volume, are used to evaluate the FVEFT matrix elements of the EFT current:

Ai,a=gA2N†τaσiN+L1,A[(NTPi)†(NTPˉa)+h.c.]+…(17)A_{i,a}=\frac{g_A}{2}N^\dagger\tau_a\sigma_iN+L_{1,A}\left[\left(N^T P_i\right)^\dagger\left(N^T\bar{P}_a\right)+\mathrm{h.c.}\right]+\ldots \tag*{(17)}

where gAg_A is the single-nucleon axial coupling, and the projectors

Pi≡18σ2σiτ2,P‾a≡18σ2τ2τa,(18)P_i \equiv\frac{1}{\sqrt{8}}\sigma_2\sigma_i\tau_2,\qquad\overline{P}_a \equiv\frac{1}{\sqrt{8}}\sigma_2\tau_2\tau_a, \tag*{(18)}

form spin-triplet and spin-singlet two-nucleon states, respectively. The two-body couterterm L1,AL_{1,A} is regulator-dependent, and in this work a Gaussian regulator scheme is used with a scale Λ\Lambda as discussed in Appendix § 0.7.

The ratio of the triton to proton matrix elements in FVEFT is given by

2gA⟨Ψ3H,s=+∣A3,3∣Ψ3H,s=+⟩⟨Ψ3H,s=+∣Ψ3H,s=+⟩=(1+L1,A3gAh3H(Λ,L)),(19)\frac{2}{g_A}\frac{\langle\Psi_{{}^{3}\mathrm{H},s=+}|A_{3,3}|\Psi_{{}^{3}\mathrm{H},s=+}\rangle}{\langle\Psi_{{}^{3}\mathrm{H},s=+}|\Psi_{{}^{3}\mathrm{H},s=+}\rangle}=\left(1+\frac{L_{1,A}}{3g_A}h_{{}^{3}\mathrm{H}}(\Lambda,L)\right), \tag*{(19)}

where ∣Ψ3H,s⟩|\Psi_{{}^{3}\mathrm{H},s}\rangle is the wavefunction for the spin-ss 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H} state and h3H(Λ,L)h_{{}^{3}\mathrm{H}}(\Lambda,L) is the spatial expectation value of a regulated form of A3,3A_{3,3} in the triton spatial wavefunction as detailed in Appendix § 0.7. The ratio of LECs L~1,A≡L1,A/gA\widetilde{L}_{1,A}\equiv L_{1,A}/g_A is determined by demanding that Eq. (19) for the E32 volume reproduces the LQCD ratio of axial charges for 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H} and for the proton computed on that volume. This value of L~1,A\widetilde{L}_{1,A} is then used to compute the axial current matrix element in variationally-optimised triton wavefunctions for different volumes, including the infinite volume wave function that allows the infinite-volume matrix element to be determined (more details on this procedure are given in Appendix § 0.7). While the counterterm L1,AL_{1,A} is scheme and scale-dependent, the triton axial charge for any volume is scale-independent. Figure 7 shows the result of this matching procedure and the volume dependence of the ratio of triton to proton axial matrix elements. As expected from the deep binding of this system, the volume effects are small. The resulting infinite-volume GT matrix element is

⟨GT⟩L=∞=gA3HgAp=0.938(41).(20)\langle\mathrm{GT}\rangle_{L=\infty}=\frac{g_A^{{}^{3}\mathrm{H}}}{g_A^p}=0.938(41). \tag*{(20)}

Discussion

In order to connect to the physical quark masses, the result for the ratio of triton and proton axial charges described in the last section can be combined with the previous determination of 3 ⁣HgA/gAp=0.979(03)(10){}^{3}\!H g_{A}/g_{A}^{p}=0.979(03)(10) in Ref. [18] at the SU(3)SU(3)-symmetric point (where mπ=mK=806m_{\pi}=m_{K}=806 MeV) using the same action and scale setting procedure. Tritium β\beta-decay has been investigated in χ\chiPT in Ref. [50] (see Refs. [51, 52] for related work in pionless effective field theory) and so the mass dependence of the ratio is in principle known. However, the quark masses in the calculation of Ref. [18], and potentially in the current work, are beyond the regime of applicability of χ\chiPT. Additionally, for the three-body system of the triton, the effective field theory results are determined numerically rather than analytically. At present, the above discussion, and the paucity of LQCD data, motivates extrapolation of the axial current matrix element ratio with the phenomenological forms of linear and quadratic dependence on the pion mass. The calculated GT matrix elements and both of these extrapolations are shown in Figure 8; the two fits result in values of 0.90(8) and 0.92(6), respectively. Given the model dependence of the forms used in this extrapolation, the envelope of the extrapolated uncertainties is taken as the extrapolated result, leading to 3 ⁣HgA/gAp=0.91−0.09+0.07{}^{3}\!H g_{A}/g_{A}^{p}=0.91^{+0.07}_{-0.09}.

Figure 8. Ratio of the axial charge of tritium to that of the single nucleon as a function of the pion mass. The result from this work and that of Ref. [18] are shown as the blue points while the physical value [6] is shown in red at the physical pion mass (indicated by the vertical line).

While extrapolated to infinite volume and the physical quark masses, these results are determined at a single lattice spacing and QED and isospin breaking effects are absent and the uncertainties from these systematic effects can as yet only be estimated. Lattice spacing effects are expected to contribute to the matrix elements at O(aΛQCD)\mathcal{O}(a\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}), however it is likely that there will be partial cancellations in these effects between the proton and triton axial charges and a full evaluation of this uncertainty will require further calculations. The leading QED effects cancel in the ratio of triton to proton axial charges and isospin breaking effects in gApg_{A}^{p} have been estimated as ≲1%\lesssim1\% [53, 54] and are assumed to be similarly small for the triton. Exponentially-suppressed FV effects due to virtual pions are neglected in the pionless FVEFT formalism that has been used. However, for the volumes and masses used in this work and Ref. [18], e−mπL∼10−4e^{-m_{\pi}L}\sim10^{-4} so these effects are expected to be negligible.

The axial charge of the triton is thus extracted from lattice QCD for the first time in this work. The extrapolated coupling ratio is in agreement with the phenomenological value 3 ⁣HgA/gAp=0.9511(13){}^{3}\!H g_{A}/g_{A}^{p}=0.9511(13) [6] and thus this calculation demonstrates the QCD origins of nuclear effects in the GT tritium β\beta-decay matrix element. In the future, the two-body pionless EFT currents that are determined using these methods will also allow for calculations of the GT matrix elements in larger nuclei and a more comprehensive investigation of the QCD origin of the phenomenological quenching of the axial charge.

Acknowledgments

We are grateful to S. R. Beane, Z. Davoudi, K. Orginos, M. J. Savage, and B. Tiburzi for extensive discussions and collaboration in the early stages of this work. This research used resources of the Oak Ridge Leadership Computing Facility at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory, which is supported by the Office of Science of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract number DE-AC05-00OR22725, as well as facilities of the USQCD Collaboration, which are funded by the Office of Science of the U.S. Department of Energy, and the resources of the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center (NERSC), a U.S. Department of Energy Office of Science User Facility operated under Contract No. DE-AC0205CH11231. The authors thankfully acknowledge the computer resources at MareNostrum and the technical support provided by Barcelona Supercomputing Center (RES-FI-2019-20032 and RES-FI-2019-3-0024). The Chroma [55], QLua [56], QUDA [57, 58, 59], QDP-JIT [60] and QPhiX [61] software libraries were used in this work. WD and PES are supported in part by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics under grant Contract Number DE-SC0011090. WD is also supported within the framework of the TMD Topical Collaboration of the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, and by the SciDAC4 award DE-SC0018121. PES is additionally supported by the National Science Foundation under EAGER grant 2035015, by the U.S. DOE Early Career Award DE-SC0021006, by a NEC research award, and by the Carl G and Shirley Sontheimer Research Fund. MI is supported by the Universitat de Barcelona through the scholarship APIF. MI and AP acknowledge support from the Spanish Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad (MINECO) under the project MDM-2014-0369 of ICCUB (Unidad de Excelencia “María de Maeztu”), from the European FEDER funds under the contract FIS2017-87534-P and by the EU STRONG-2020 project under the program H2020-INFRAIA-2018-1, grant agreement No. 824093. MI acknowledges the Massachusetts Institute of Technology for hospitality and partial support during preliminary stages of this work. This manuscript has been authored by Fermi Research Alliance, LLC under Contract No. DE-AC02-07CH11359 with the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of High Energy Physics. This work is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics under contract DE-AC05-06OR23177. The authors acknowledge support from the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Advanced Scientific Computing Research and Office of Nuclear Physics, Scientific Discovery through Advanced Computing (SciDAC) program, and of the U.S. Department of Energy Exascale Computing Project. The authors thank Robert Edwards, Bálint Joó, Kostas Orginos, and the NPLQCD collaboration for generating and allowing access to the ensembles used in this study.

A FVEFT

Following Ref. [49], the stochastic variational method is used to connect the finite volume axial matrix element to its infinite volume limit in pionless EFT. The pionless EFT Lagrangian relevant to the interaction of few-nucleon systems is

L=L1+L2+L3,(21)\mathcal{L} = \mathcal{L}_1 + \mathcal{L}_2 + \mathcal{L}_3, \tag*{(21)}

where the strong interactions between nucleons arise from

L1=N†(iD0+D22MN)N+…,(22)\mathcal{L}_1 = N^\dagger\left(iD_0 + \frac{\mathbf{D}^2}{2M_N}\right)N + \ldots, \tag*{(22)}
L2=−CS(NTPiN)†(NTPiN)−CT(NTP‾aN)†(NTP‾aN)+…,(23)\mathcal{L}_2 = -C_S (N^T P_i N)^\dagger(N^T P_i N) - C_T (N^T \overline{P}_a N)^\dagger(N^T \overline{P}_a N) + \ldots, \tag*{(23)}
L3=−D06(N†N)3+…,(24)\mathcal{L}_3 = -\frac{D_0}{6}(N^\dagger N)^3 + \ldots, \tag*{(24)}

where PiP_i and P‾a\overline{P}_a are the projectors defined in Eq. (18), MNM_N is the nucleon mass, and CSC_S, CTC_T, and D0D_0 are the relevant two and three-nucleon low-energy constants (LECs). The two-nucleon couplings can also be expressed in terms of alternative LECs C0,1C_{0,1} through the relations

CT=C0−3C1andCS=C0+C1.(25)C_T = C_0 - 3C_1 \quad\text{and} \quad C_S = C_0 + C_1. \tag*{(25)}

The nn-particle non-relativistic Hamiltonian corresponding to Eq. (21) is

H=−12MN∑i∇i2+∑i<jV2(rij)+∑i<j<kV3(rij,rjk),(26)H = -\frac{1}{2M_N}\sum_i \nabla_i^2 + \sum_{i<j} V_2(\mathbf{r}_{ij}) + \sum_{i<j<k} V_3(\mathbf{r}_{ij},\mathbf{r}_{jk}), \tag*{(26)}

where the integers {i,j,k}\{i,j,k\} label the particle, rij=ri−rj\mathbf{r}_{ij} = \mathbf{r}_i - \mathbf{r}_j denotes the displacement between particles ii and jj, and the two and three-particle potentials are given by

V2(rij)=(C0+C1σi⋅σj)gΛ(rij,L),V3(rij,rjk)=D0∑qgΛ(rij,L)gΛ(rjk,L).(27)V_2(\mathbf{r}_{ij}) = (C_0 + C_1 \boldsymbol{\sigma}_i \cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_j) g_\Lambda(\mathbf{r}_{ij},L), \quad V_3(\mathbf{r}_{ij},\mathbf{r}_{jk}) = D_0 \sum_{\mathbf{q}} g_\Lambda(\mathbf{r}_{ij},L) g_\Lambda(\mathbf{r}_{jk},L). \tag*{(27)}

Here gΛ(r,L)g_\Lambda(\mathbf{r},L) includes the Gaussian smearing which is used to regulate the interactions, and periodicity in the finite spatial volume of extent LL has been imposed in the regulator:

gΛ(r,L)=Λ38π3/2∏α=x,y,z∑q(α)=−∞∞exp⁡(−Λ2(rα−Lq(α))2/4),(28)g_\Lambda(\mathbf{r},L) = \frac{\Lambda^3}{8\pi^{3/2}} \prod_{\alpha=x,y,z} \sum_{q^{(\alpha)}=-\infty}^{\infty} \exp\left(-\Lambda^2\left(r_\alpha-Lq^{(\alpha)}\right)^2/4\right), \tag*{(28)}

where r=(rx,ry,rz)\mathbf{r} = (r_x,r_y,r_z).

As described in Refs. [39, 49], the stochastic variational approach proceeds by the optimization of a two or three-body variational wavefunction defined in terms of correlated Gaussian basis components to minimize the expectation value of the Hamiltonian in Eq. (26) and converge to a representation of the ground-state wavefunction. Since rotational symmetry is broken by the lattice geometry, shifted correlated Gaussians are used [39]. Defining a trial wavefunction as a linear combination of such shifted correlated Gaussians, the linear coefficients of the terms are optimized by solving the generalized eigenvalue problem of the variational method; the approach taken to optimization is as detailed in Ref. [49]. Given wavefunctions optimized in the same volumes as the LQCD calculations, the LECs CSC_S, CTC_T, and D0D_0 of the pionless EFT Lagrangian can be constrained by matching the finite volume energies to the LQCD results, with the allowed range of LECs determined by a fit to the constraints from the three volumes. With the LECs fixed, volume-extrapolated energies are obtained using wavefunctions optimized at infinite volume.

Figure 9 shows the determination of the two-body LECs from the LQCD results for the deuteron and dineutron energy shifts in the three lattice volumes. The couplings are regulator-scale–dependent but the resulting energy shifts are not; calculations with cutoff parameter Λ=2/r0\Lambda= \sqrt{2}/r_0 with r0∈{0.3,0.4}r_0 \in\{0.3, 0.4\} fm result in indistinguishable results from those with r0=0.2r_0 = 0.2 fm which are shown here. The extrapolation to infinite volume using these couplings is shown in Figure 10. Figure 11 shows the same analysis of the three body system, determining the three-nucleon coupling D0D_0 and leading to the infinite-volume extrapolation presented in Figure 3.

Figure 10. Extrapolation of the deuteron (green) and pppp (purple) energies to the infinite volume limit. Data points denote lattice results (from Ref. [19]), displaced slightly horizontally for clarity, while the shaded bands and infinite-volume points show the result of the FVEFT extrapolation.

Using the optimized wavefunctions, matrix elements of the isovector axial-vector current can be computed for the same finite volume as the LQCD calculations to fix the corresponding LECs, and the extrapolation to infinite-volume can then be undertaken in the same manner as that used for the binding energies themselves. The isovector axial-vector current is expressed in pionless EFT as given in Eq. (17) in the main text. In position space, the two-nucleon contribution proportional to L1,AL_{1,A} is implemented using the same gaussian regulator as for the potential, specifically

L1,A[(NT(ri)PiN(ri))†(N(rj)TPˉaN(rj)+h.c.)]gΛ(rij).(29)L_{1,A}\left[\left(N^{T}(\mathbf{r}_i)P_iN(\mathbf{r}_i)\right)^\dagger\left(N(\mathbf{r}_j)^{T}\bar{P}_aN(\mathbf{r}_j)+\mathrm{h.c.}\right)\right]g_{\Lambda}(r_{ij}) . \tag*{(29)}

The optimised triton wavefunction corresponding to volume of the E32 ensemble is used to compute the finite-volume axial matrix element in Eq. (19). Approximating the triton wavefunction as a tensor product

∣Ψ3H,s⟩=∣χs⟩⊗∣ψ(r1,r2,r3)⟩,(30)\left|\Psi_{{}^{3}\mathrm{H},s}\right\rangle= \left|\chi_s\right\rangle\otimes\left|\psi(\mathbf{r}_1,\mathbf{r}_2,\mathbf{r}_3)\right\rangle, \tag*{(30)}

Figure 11. Determination of the EFT three-body couplings D0D_0. As in Figure 9, the horizontal bands correspond to the energy shifts from the LQCD calculations on the E24 (blue), E32 (orange), and E48 (green) ensembles. The curves in each figure show the corresponding FVEFT energy shifts for the EFT cutoff parameter r0=0.2r_0 = 0.2 fm. The uncertainties on the curves are propagated from the uncertainties on the two-body LECs.

the computation of the matrix elements separates into the spin-isospin and spatial parts. The simplest spin-isospin wavefunction for the spin-up component is given by

∣χs=+⟩=16[∣n↑p↑n↓⟩−∣n↑p↓n↑⟩−∣p↑n↑n↓⟩+∣p↑n↓n↑⟩−∣n↑n↑p↓⟩+∣n↓n↑p↑⟩],(31)\left|\chi_{s=+}\right\rangle= \frac{1}{\sqrt{6}}\left[\left|n^{\uparrow}p^{\uparrow}n^{\downarrow}\right\rangle-\left|n^{\uparrow}p^{\downarrow}n^{\uparrow}\right\rangle-\left|p^{\uparrow}n^{\uparrow}n^{\downarrow}\right\rangle+\left|p^{\uparrow}n^{\downarrow}n^{\uparrow}\right\rangle-\left|n^{\uparrow}n^{\uparrow}p^{\downarrow}\right\rangle+\left|n^{\downarrow}n^{\uparrow}p^{\uparrow}\right\rangle\right], \tag*{(31)}

with an analogous expression for the spin-down wavefunction. The spatial part of the matrix element is determined from the variationally-optimized triton wavefunction and is given by

h3H(Λ,L)=∫∏kd3rk∑i<jgΛ(rij)∣ψ(r1,r2,r3)∣2∫∏kd3rk∣ψ(r1,r2,r3)∣2,(32)h_{{}^{3}\mathrm{H}}(\Lambda,L)=\frac{\int\prod_k d^3r_k\sum_{i<j}g_\Lambda(r_{ij})|\psi(\mathbf{r}_1,\mathbf{r}_2,\mathbf{r}_3)|^2}{\int\prod_k d^3r_k|\psi(\mathbf{r}_1,\mathbf{r}_2,\mathbf{r}_3)|^2}, \tag*{(32)}

where {i,j,k}∈{1,2,3}\{i,j,k\}\in\{1,2,3\} and ψ(r1,r2,r3)\psi(\mathbf{r}_1,\mathbf{r}_2,\mathbf{r}_3) is the position-space representation of the spatial wavefunction of the triton.

The LQCD ratio of the triton to proton axial couplings is reproduced by tuning the LEC ratio L~1,A=L1,A/gA\widetilde{L}_{1,A}=L_{1,A}/g_A in Eq. (19) as shown in Figure 7. Having fixed this LEC ratio, the infinite-volume matrix element is evaluated using the infinite-volume variational wavefunction, and the volume-dependence is evaluated using wavefunctions optimized at a range of intermediate volumes. Note that just as for the LECs {CS,CT,D0}\{C_S,C_T,D_0\}, the LEC ratio L~1,A\widetilde{L}_{1,A} is determined in the exponential regulator scheme, but the evaluated axial matrix element itself is independent of the choice of regulator.

Figure 7. (a) Determination of the LEC ratio L~1,A\widetilde{L}_{1,A} by matching the matrix element defined in Eq. (19), computed in the optimized FVEFT wavefunction for the E32 volume, to the LQCD result in the E32 volume, which is depicted as the horizontal band. (b) The FVEFT extrapolation of the ratio of triton to proton axial charges to infinite volume.

References

References

  1. [1]D.H. Wilkinson, “Renormalization of the axial-vector coupling constant in nuclear β-decay (II),” Nucl. Phys. A 209, 470–484 (1973).DOI
  2. [2]B.A. Brown and B.H. Wildenthal, “Experimental and Theoretical Gamow-Teller Beta-Decay Observables for the sd-Shell Nuclei,” Atom. Data Nucl. Data Tabl. 33, 347–404 (1985).DOI
  3. [3]W.-T. Chou, E.K. Warburton, and B. Alex Brown, “Gamow-Teller beta-decay rates for A ≤ 18 nuclei,” Phys. Rev. C 47, 163–177 (1993).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9968421
  4. [4]G. Martinez-Pinedo, A. Poves, E. Caurier, and A.P. Zuker, “Effective g_A in the pf shell,” Phys. Rev. C 53, 2602 (1996), arXiv:nucl-th/9603039.
  5. [5]P. Gysbers et al., “Discrepancy between experimental and theoretical β-decay rates resolved from first principles,” Nature Phys. 15, 428–431 (2019), arXiv:1903.00047 [nucl-th].DOI
  6. [6]A. Baroni, L. Girlanda, A. Kievsky, L.E. Marcucci, R. Schiavilla, and M. Viviani, “Tritium β-decay in chiral effective field theory,” Phys. Rev. C 94, 024003 (2016), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.C 95, 059902 (2017)], arXiv:1605.01620 [nucl-th].DOI
  7. [7]Ch. Kraus et al., “Final results from phase II of the Mainz neutrino mass search in tritium beta decay,” Eur. Phys. J. C 40, 447–468 (2005), arXiv:hep-ex/0412056.DOI
  8. [8]V.N. Aseev et al. (Troitsk), “An upper limit on electron antineutrino mass from Troitsk experiment,” Phys. Rev. D 84, 112003 (2011), arXiv:1108.5034 [hep-ex].DOI
  9. [9]J. Angrik et al. (KATRIN), KATRIN design report 2004, Tech. Rep. (2005).DOI
  10. [10]Ali Ashtari Esfahani et al. (Project 8), “Determining the neutrino mass with cyclotron radiation emission spectroscopy—Project 8,” J. Phys. G 44, 054004 (2017), arXiv:1703.02037 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  11. [11]Martin González-Alonso, Oscar Naviliat-Cuncic, and Nathal Severijns, “New physics searches in nuclear and neutron β decay,” Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 104, 165–223 (2019), arXiv:1803.08732 [hep-ph].
  12. [12]Andreas Crivellin and Martin Hoferichter, “Beta decays as sensitive probes of lepton flavor universality,” (2020), arXiv:2002.07184 [hep-ph].DOI
  13. [13]Jonathan Engel and Javier Menéndez, “Status and Future of Nuclear Matrix Elements for Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay: A Review,” Rept. Prog. Phys. 80, 046301 (2017), arXiv:1610.06548 [nucl-th].DOI
  14. [14]J. J. Simpson, “Half-life of tritium and the Gamow-Teller transition rate,” Phys. Rev. C35, 752–754 (1987).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9953820
  15. [15]M. Ademollo and Raoul Gatto, “Nonrenormalization Theorem for the Strangeness Violating Vector Currents,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 13, 264–265 (1964).DOI
  16. [16]F. Fucito, G. Parisi, and S. Petrarca, “First Evaluation of G(A) / G(V) in lattice QCD in the quenched approximation,” Phys. Lett. B 115, 148–150 (1982).DOI
  17. [17]S. Aoki et al. (Flavour Lattice Averaging Group), “FLAG Review 2019,” Eur. Phys. J. C 80, 113 (2020), arXiv:1902.08191 [hep-lat].DOI
  18. [18]Martin J. Savage, Phiala E. Shanahan, Brian C. Tiburzi, Michael L. Wagman, Frank Winter, Silas R. Beane, Emmanuel Chang, Zohreh Davoudi, William Detmold, and Kostas Orginos, “Proton-Proton Fusion and Tritium β Decay from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 062002 (2017), arXiv:1610.04545 [hep-lat].DOI
  19. [19]Kostas Orginos, Assumpta Parreño, Martin J. Savage, Silas R. Beane, Emmanuel Chang, and William Detmold, “Two nucleon systems at mπ ∼ 450 MeV from lattice QCD,” Phys. Rev. D 92, 114512 (2015), [Erratum:Phys. Rev. D 102, 039903 (2020)], arXiv:1508.07583 [hep-lat].DOI
  20. [20]M. Lüscher and P. Weisz, “On-Shell Improved Lattice Gauge Theories,” Commun. Math. Phys. 97, 59 (1985), [Erratum: Commun. Math. Phys.98,433(1985)].
  21. [21]B. Sheikholeslami and R. Wohlert, “Improved Continuum Limit Lattice Action for QCD with Wilson Fermions,” Nucl. Phys. B259, 572 (1985).DOI
  22. [22]Marc Illa et al., “Low-energy Scattering and Effective Interactions of Two Baryons at mπ ∼ 450 MeV from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics,” (2020), arXiv:2009.12357 [hep-lat].DOI
  23. [23]William Detmold and Kostas Orginos, “Nuclear correlation functions in lattice QCD,” Phys. Rev. D87, 114512 (2013), arXiv:1207.1452 [hep-lat].DOI
  24. [24]S. R. Beane, E. Chang, S. D. Cohen, William Detmold, H. W. Lin, T. C. Luu, K. Orginos, A. Parreño, M. J. Savage, and A. Walker-Loud (NPLQCD), “Light Nuclei and Hypernuclei from Quantum Chromodynamics in the Limit of SU(3) Flavor Symmetry,” Phys. Rev. D87, 034506 (2013), arXiv:1206.5219 [hep-lat].DOI
  25. [25]M. FalcionI, M.L. Paciello, G. Parisi, and B. Taglienti, “Again on SU(3) glueball mass,” Nucl. Phys. B 251, 624–632 (1985).DOI
  26. [26]A. Francis, J.R. Green, P.M. Junnarkar, Ch. Miao, T.D. Rae, and H. Wittig, “Lattice QCD study of the H dibaryon using hexaquark and two-baryon interpolators,” Phys. Rev. D 99, 074505 (2019), arXiv:1805.03966 [hep-lat].DOI
  27. [27]Ben Hörz et al., “Two-nucleon S-wave interactions at the SU(3) flavor-symmetric point with mᵤd ≃ mₛᵖʰʸˢ: a first lattice QCD calculation with the stochastic Laplacian Heaviside method,” (2020), arXiv:2009.11825 [hep-lat].
  28. [28]Michael L. Wagman, Frank Winter, Emmanuel Chang, Zohreh Davoudi, William Detmold, Kostas Orginos, Martin J. Savage, and Phiala E. Shanahan, “Baryon-Baryon Interactions and Spin-Flavor Symmetry from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics,” Phys. Rev. D 96, 114510 (2017), arXiv:1706.06550 [hep-lat].DOI
  29. [29]S.R. Beane et al., “Charged multi-hadron systems in lattice QCD+QED,” (2020), arXiv:2003.12130 [hep-lat].DOI
  30. [30]H. Akaike, “A new look at the statistical model identification,” IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control 19, 716–723 (1974).DOI
  31. [31]Charles Stein, “Inadmissibility of the usual estimator for the mean of a multivariate normal distribution,” in Proceedings of the Third Berkeley Symposium on Mathematical Statistics and Probability, Volume 1: Contributions to the Theory of Statistics (University of California Press, Berkeley, Calif., 1956) pp. 197–206.
  32. [32]Olivier Ledoit and Michael Wolf, “A well-conditioned estimator for large-dimensional covariance matrices,” Journal of Multivariate Analysis 88, 365 – 411 (2004).
  33. [33]Enrico Rinaldi, Sergey Syritsyn, Michael L. Wagman, Michael I. Buchoff, Chris Schroeder, and Joseph Wasem, “Lattice QCD determination of neutron-antineutron matrix elements with physical quark masses,” Phys. Rev. D99, 074510 (2019), arXiv:1901.07519 [hep-lat].DOI
  34. [34]Gene Golub and Victor Pereyra, “Separable nonlinear least squares: the variable projection method and its applications,” Inverse Problems 19, R1 (2003).DOI
  35. [35]Dianne P. O’Leary and Bert W. Rust, “Variable projection for nonlinear least squares problems,” Computational Optimization and Applications 54, 579–593 (2013).
  36. [36]A. Ali Khan et al. (QCDSF-UKQCD), “The Nucleon mass in N(f) = 2 lattice QCD: Finite size effects from chiral perturbation theory,” Nucl. Phys. B 689, 175–194 (2004), arXiv:hep-lat/0312030.DOI
  37. [37]Silas R. Beane, “Nucleon masses and magnetic moments in a finite volume,” Phys. Rev. D 70, 034507 (2004), arXiv:hep-lat/0403015.DOI
  38. [38]S.R. Beane, E. Chang, W. Detmold, H.W. Lin, T.C. Luu, K. Orginos, A. Parrēno, M.J. Savage, A. Torok, and A. Walker-Loud, “High Statistics Analysis using Anisotropic Clover Lattices: (IV) Volume Dependence of Light Hadron Masses,” Phys. Rev. D 84, 014507 (2011), arXiv:1104.4101 [hep-lat].arxiv.org/abs/1104.4101
  39. [39]Moti Eliyahu, Betzalel Bazak, and Nir Barnea, “Extrapolating Lattice QCD Results using Effective Field Theory,” Phys. Rev. C 102, 044003 (2020), arXiv:1912.07017 [nucl-th].DOI
  40. [40]Raul A. Briceño, Jozef J. Dudek, and Ross D. Young, “Scattering processes and resonances from lattice QCD,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 90, 025001 (2018), arXiv:1706.06223 [hep-lat].DOI
  41. [41]Takeshi Yamazaki, Ken-ichi Ishikawa, Yoshinobu Kuramashi, and Akira Ukawa, “Helium nuclei, deuteron and dineutron in 2+1 flavor lattice QCD,” Phys. Rev. D 86, 074514 (2012), arXiv:1207.4277 [hep-lat].DOI
  42. [42]Takeshi Yamazaki, Ken-ichi Ishikawa, Yoshinobu Kuramashi, and Akira Ukawa, “Study of quark mass dependence of binding energy for light nuclei in 2+1 flavor lattice QCD,” Phys. Rev. D 92, 014501 (2015), arXiv:1502.04182 [hep-lat].arxiv.org/abs/1502.04182
  43. [43]Phiala E. Shanahan, Brian C. Tiburzi, Michael L. Wagman, Frank Winter, Emmanuel Chang, Zohreh Davoudi, William Detmold, Kostas Orginos, and Martin J. Savage, “Isotensor Axial Polarizability and Lattice QCD Input for Nuclear Double-β Decay Phenomenology,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 062003 (2017), arXiv:1701.03456 [hep-lat].DOI
  44. [44]Brian C. Tiburzi, Michael L. Wagman, Frank Winter, Emmanuel Chang, Zohreh Davoudi, William Detmold, Kostas Orginos, Martin J. Savage, and Phiala E. Shanahan, “Double-β Decay Matrix Elements from Lattice Quantum Chromodynamics,” Phys. Rev. D96, 054505 (2017), arXiv:1702.02929 [hep-lat].DOI
  45. [45]Chris Bouchard, Chia Cheng Chang, Thorsten Kurth, Kostas Orginos, and Andre Walker-Loud, “On the Feynman-Hellmann Theorem in Quantum Field Theory and the Calculation of Matrix Elements,” Phys. Rev. D96, 014504 (2017), arXiv:1612.06963 [hep-lat].DOI
  46. [46]Zohreh Davoudi, William Detmold, Kostas Orginos, Assumpta Parrēno, Martin J. Savage, Phiala Shanahan, and Michael L. Wagman, “Nuclear matrix elements from lattice QCD for electroweak and beyond-Standard-Model processes,” (2020), arXiv:2008.11160 [hep-lat].DOI
  47. [47]William Detmold, Marc Illa, David J. Murphy, Patrick Oare, Kostas Orginos, Phiala E. Shanahan, Michael L. Wagman, and Frank Winter, “Lattice QCD constraints on the parton distribution functions of ³He,” (2020), arXiv:2009.05522 [hep-lat].DOI
  48. [48]Boram Yoon et al., “Isovector charges of the nucleon from 2+1-flavor QCD with clover fermions,” Phys. Rev. D95, 074508 (2017), arXiv:1611.07452 [hep-lat].DOI
  49. [49]W. Detmold and P. E. Shanahan, “Few-nucleon matrix elements in pionless effective field theory in a finite volume,” (2021).DOI
  50. [50]A. Baroni et al., “Local chiral interactions, the tritium Gamow–Teller matrix element, and the three-nucleon contact term,” Phys. Rev. C98, 044003 (2018), arXiv:1806.10245 [nucl-th].DOI
  51. [51]Hilla De-Leon, Lucas Platter, and Doron Gazit, “Tritium β-decay in pionless effective field theory,” (2016), arXiv:1611.00004 [nucl-th].
  52. [52]Hilla De-Leon, Lucas Platter, and Doron Gazit, “Calculation of an A = 3 bound-state matrix element in pionless effective field theory,” (2019), arXiv:1902.07677 [nucl-th].
  53. [53]Xue-min Jin, “Isospin breaking in the nucleon isovector axial charge from QCD sum rules,” (1996), arXiv:hep-ph/9602298.DOI
  54. [54]Norbert Kaiser, “Isospin breaking in neutron beta decay and SU(3) violation in semileptonic hyperon decays,” Phys. Rev. C 64, 028201 (2001), arXiv:nucl-th/0105043.DOI
  55. [55]Robert G. Edwards and Balint Joó (SciDAC, LHPC, UKQCD), “The Chroma software system for lattice QCD,” Lattice field theory. Proceedings, 22nd International Symposium, Lattice 2004, Batavia, USA, June 21-26, 2004, Nucl. Phys. Proc. Suppl. 140, 832 (2005), [832(2004)], arXiv:hep-lat/0409003 [hep-lat].DOI
  56. [56]A. Pochinsky, “Qlua, https://usqcd.lns.mit.edu/qlua.”
  57. [57]M.A. Clark, R. Babich, K. Barros, R.C. Brower, and C. Rebbi, “Solving Lattice QCD systems of equations using mixed precision solvers on GPUs,” Comput. Phys. Commun. 181, 1517–1528 (2010), arXiv:0911.3191 [hep-lat].DOI
  58. [58]R. Babich, M.A. Clark, B. Joo, G. Shi, R.C. Brower, and S. Gottlieb, “Scaling Lattice QCD beyond 100 GPUs,” in SC11 International Conference for High Performance Computing, Networking, Storage and Analysis (2011) arXiv:1109.2935 [hep-lat].DOI
  59. [59]M.A. Clark, Bálint Joó, Alexei Strelchenko, Michael Cheng, Arjun Gambhir, and Richard Brower, “Accelerating Lattice QCD Multigrid on GPUs Using Fine-Grained Parallelization,” (2016), arXiv:1612.07873 [hep-lat].arxiv.org/abs/1612.07873
  60. [60]F. T. Winter, M. A. Clark, R. G. Edwards, and B. Joó, “A framework for lattice qcd calculations on gpus,” in 2014 IEEE 28th International Parallel and Distributed Processing Symposium (2014) pp. 1073–1082.DOI
  61. [61]Bálint Joó, Dhiraj D. Kalamkar, Thorsten Kurth, Karthikeyan Vaidyanathan, and Aaron Walden, “Optimizing wilson-dirac operator and linear solvers for intel® knl,” in High Performance Computing, edited by Michela Taufer, Bernd Mohr, and Julian M. Kunkel (Springer International Publishing, Cham, 2016) pp. 415–427.

Paper details

vlnc:W_q5pcegmq
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 4

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents