WorksMathematics
Joint quadratic base changes of elliptic surfaces with torsion Z/4Z and Z/2Z x Z/6Z
Abstract
We study elliptic curves over obtained from an elliptic surface by imposing two quadratic conditions, each of which produces a new point. By the Kani-Rosen decomposition, the joint cover is rational only when the branch loci of the two conditions meet; for two quadratic conditions this means that they share a root. We apply this to two surfaces. For Elkies's rank-four K3 surface with torsion , a catalogue of quadratic conditions contains exactly two such pairs. One recovers the rank-six curve of the authors; the other gives a second, inequivalent curve with torsion and rank six. For the universal curve with torsion , conditions give exactly rational joint covers, which yield seven curves of rank two. Two more arise from a tower of conditions. Five of these nine curves are the curves of Dujella, Kazalicki and Peral; the other four are not equivalent to any of them. In both cases we determine the Mordell-Weil groups over exactly, and we prove that the curves are pairwise inequivalent under invertible changes of parameter, even over .
Introduction
By the Mordell-Weil theorem, for an elliptic curve , and by Mazur’s theorem [20] the torsion subgroup is one of fifteen groups. For each of them one asks for curves of large rank, over and over ; the current records are collected in Dujella’s tables [3, 4].
A standard way to raise the rank over is quadratic base change. Suppose a surface acquires a new point over for a quadratic polynomial . If the new point has infinite order, the rank over is at least one larger than over . If moreover the conic has a rational point, then is again a rational function field. Imposing two such conditions raises the rank by at least two over . To obtain a curve over a rational function field again, the curve with this function field must be rational.
Section 2 develops this systematically:
a genus criterion for joint covers (Lemma 2.1);
the character decomposition of the rank;
exact ranks through injective specialization, via the criteria of Gusić and Tadić [11];
two invariants of the -map that detect inequivalence of families under invertible changes of parameter.
We then apply it to two classical situations.
Torsion
Torsion . Curves of positive rank with this torsion were constructed by Kihara [15] and by Khoshnam and Moody [14]; see also [5]. Elkies [10] gave a K3 surface with torsion and rank four over , and in [8] we made a number of its quadratic sections explicit. In [9] we combined two quadratic sections of it to obtain a curve of rank six, the current record for this torsion group over to our knowledge [4], and proved by an injective specialization that its rank is exactly six.
Theorem A. Let , be the curves over of § 3.
for .
The specializations of at and of at are injective, and these curves over have rank six.
and are not equivalent (Definition 2.3), even over .
In a catalogue of 194 quadratic conditions on Elkies’s surface, exactly two pairs have rational joint covers: the pair used for (which is the curve of [9]) and the pair used for .
For , parts (1) and (2) were proved in [9]. We include the short proof because it applies verbatim to , which is new.
Torsion
Here the universal curve has rank zero. Curves of rank one over were found by Kulesz [17], Lecacheux [18], Dujella [2] and Woo [25], among others. Rank two was first reached by Dujella and Peral [7]. Dujella, Kazalicki and Peral [6] described five curves of rank exactly two and observed that the examples of MacLeod [19] are isomorphic to some of them.
Theorem B. Let be the curves over of Section 4.
for every .
No two of them are equivalent (Definition 2.3), even over .
, , , , are the five curves of [6 §8], and , , are the three curves of [7]. The curves , , , are not equivalent to any of the curves of [7] or [6], nor therefore, by [6 §1.3], to the examples of MacLeod [19].
In a catalogue of 42 quadratic conditions on the universal curve, exactly 21 pairs have rational joint covers, and they give exactly the classes .
The paper ends with two remarks on the case (§ 3.6). First, an exhaustive search shows that neither nor has a further quadratic section whose -coordinate is a constant times a divisor of the last Weierstrass coefficient (Proposition 3.3). Second, we exhibit a specialization of whose rank is seven, provided the 2-primary part of its Tate-Shafarevich group is finite.
The method
Quadratic sections
Let be an elliptic curve over , and let be squarefree and not a constant times a square. A quadratic section attached to is an with
It gives a point of over that the nontrivial automorphism sends to , or equivalently a point of the quadratic twist over . In particular, if has infinite order it is independent of .
The genus of a joint cover
For quadratic sections let be the curve with function field . For a squarefree polynomial of degree 1 or 2, let be the branch locus of :
Lemma 2.1. Let be squarefree of degree 1 or 2, with classes independent in . Then is geometrically integral of genus
In particular:
for , if and only if ; for two quadratics this means a common root;
for , .
Proof. The cover is Galois with group , and is geometrically integral by the independence assumption. By the Kani-Rosen decomposition [13], is isogenous to the product of the Jacobians of the quotients by the subgroups of index two. These are the double covers for . The branch locus of is the symmetric difference of the sets , , so . A point lying in at least one belongs to the symmetric difference for exactly of the sets , namely those meeting the set of with that point in in an odd number of elements. Summing over gives the formula. For it reads , and the union has 3 or 4 elements. □
Two irreducible quadratics with a common root are proportional. So for families of pairwise non-proportional conditions, rational joint covers come only from split quadratics with a common root, or from conditions involving linear polynomials.
The character decomposition
Let with independent in , and put . The isotypic decomposition of under gives
If is a conic with a rational point, then . Two quadratic sections of infinite order then raise the rank over by at least two. When the rank over is known exactly, (1) also determines the ranks of the three twists.
Exact rank by injective specialization
We use two criteria of Gusić and Tadić.
Theorem 2.2 ([11 Thms. 1.1 and 1.3]). Let be nonconstant and .
If with , and is not a rational square for every nonconstant squarefree divisor of , of , or of , then the specialization at is injective.
If with has exactly one nontrivial rational 2-torsion point, and is not a rational square for every nonconstant squarefree divisor of or of , then the specialization at is injective.
In all our applications we tested every squarefree product of the nonconstant irreducible factors, multiplied by every signed squarefree divisor of the integer contents. This is a superset of the divisors required. An injective specialization gives , and the torsion of injects into that of the fibre.
Invariants of the -map
Definition 2.3. Two elliptic curves over , for a field , are equivalent over if there is an invertible Möbius transformation of the -line, defined over , such that and are isomorphic over .
Let be base changes of an elliptic surface with -invariant . If and are isomorphic over for some Möbius transformation , then . Quadratic twists are included, since they do not change . We use two consequences:
(i) and have the same critical values;
(ii) for each , carries the poles of order of to those of .
For (ii), let be a binary form of degree 12 whose roots are these poles. With the transvectants [22]
put , , and, whenever ,
This quantity is unchanged by scaling and by acting on , so equivalent base changes have equal values of . In all cases below, .
Torsion : two rank-six curves
Elkies's surface
Put
and, following [9], write Elkies’s surface [10] as
Since and , the point satisfies and has order four. The discriminant is
The surface has four fibres of type (at , , , ), two of type and four of type . It is K3, and the Shioda-Tate formula [24] bounds the geometric rank by . The sections
The catalogue
Appendix A lists the split members of a catalogue of 194 rationally soluble quadratic sections of (3). There are 50 split quadratics, 143 irreducible quadratics and one linear condition, .
Proposition 3.1. All 194 polynomials are squarefree, and no two are proportional. The only pairs with a common root are (root ) and (root ). Hence these are the only pairs with a joint cover of genus zero, and no triple has a joint cover of genus at most one.
Proof. A common root can only occur among the 51 split or linear conditions, and comparing their roots gives the two pairs. The only linear condition, , has branch locus , and no other condition vanishes at . So by Lemma 2.1(1) these are the only genus-zero pairs. In any triple at most one of the three pairs has intersecting branch loci, because the two pairs above are disjoint. Hence the union of the three branch loci has at least 5 points, and Lemma 2.1(2) gives genus at least 3.
The two curves
The pair . Here
with
The substitution solves the first condition. The second becomes the conic , which has the point . With
the line gives
Since , is defined for all rational . This is the curve of [9] with .
The pair . Here
with
With and , eliminating gives the conic , and conversely
The conic has the point . The line gives
With and this gives
Sections. The new points have and , where :
Table 3.
where
Write with coprime integral polynomials:
With and , the curve is isomorphic, via , to
Exact rank and torsion
Injectivity. In (6), is not a square, so Theorem 2.2(2) applies. and each have 9 distinct nonconstant irreducible factors; has 6 and has 9. We tested 8176 and 2044 values for at (), and 1008 and 1022 values for at (). None is a square, so both specializations are injective.
Lower bound. At a good prime with , the map is a homomorphism to that kills and the torsion. At the primes used, the images of lie in one cyclic subgroup, so each prime gives a row over . For we use , and for we use :
Both are invertible modulo 3. Rational 3-torsion is excluded since and are prime to 3. So the six points are independent on the fibres, and hence over .
Upper bound. For and we have
where are the Kummer maps of the two-isogenies. The local images on and are exact annihilators under the Hilbert pairing. So explicit local points on one side cut down the possible global classes on the other. For both fibres this leaves 16 classes on each side, giving rank at most . The same bound is obtained independently by the two-isogeny descent of ellrank in PARI/GP [23].
Torsion. The reductions of at have 24 and 52 points, and those of at have 12 and 52. Hence the fibre torsion is , and so is that of . This proves parts (1) and (2) of Theorem A.
Corollary 3.2. For or , the twists and of (3) have rank one over , and has rank zero.
Proof. Apply (1) with rank and total rank 6. □
Inequivalence
Write
with , and let . Since
ramifies over , so is a critical value of . The map is branched only over , and . Modulo 101 we find , while , and . Moreover, has degree 24 and is coprime to its derivative. Hence is neither the image of a branch point of nor a critical value of , so it is not a critical value of . By § 2.5, this proves part (3) of Theorem A.
Further remarks
No further quadratic sections of the simplest type.
Proposition 3.3. Let be either (6) for or its two-isogenous curve . Let be any product of the irreducible factors of in , with exponents at most their multiplicities, and let . If and has squarefree part of degree at most four, then this squarefree part is constant; that is, the point is defined over a constant field extension of , or is a 2-torsion point. In particular neither nor has a further quadratic section of this form, nor one whose joint cover has genus one.
Sketch of proof. Write , so that . The proof has three steps.
Modular sieve. Let be a prime at which the factors of keep their degrees and stay distinct and squarefree. If the squarefree part over has degree at most 4, so does that of the reduction modulo of the primitive part. If or modulo , this reduction is , respectively , up to constants. So a divisor is excluded for all as soon as some such exists at which all residues of in fail. Over the four curves this excludes 17890 of the 32076 divisors.
Exact step. For each of the remaining 14186 divisors, let and . For outside the rational roots of the leading coefficient of , of for the irreducible factors of , and of the polynomials attached to the factors of , the polynomial is squarefree, coprime to and of full degree. The squarefree part then has degree at least 16 in every case. Among these values, every one for which the squarefree part has degree at most four gives a constant squarefree part, or a 2-torsion point.
Pencil cases. For the two divisors and (up to constants) on each isogenous side, the polynomial factors as . These were treated in the same way with replaced by ; the only special value is , for which is a 2-torsion point. □
By Proposition 3.1, the catalogue also contains no triple leading to a genus-one cover.
A conditional rank-seven specialization. At , i.e. , the fibre of is isomorphic to with , .
For this curve:
the six sections remain independent;
the two-isogeny descent gives rank at most 7;
the 2-Selmer group has dimension 8 (computed with
ell2cover);the root number is .
All of these were computed with PARI/GP [23]. As a check, the same computation at the fibre , whose rank is proved to be six, gives a 2-Selmer group of dimension 7. Since , the -Selmer corank satisfies . By the 2-parity theorem [21, 1], is odd, so . Hence the rank is seven unless \Sha(E/\mathbb{Q})[2^\infty] is infinite. We have not found a seventh point.
Torsion : nine curves of rank two
The universal curve
Let
[16]. Besides the points of order two, it has the point of order three.
(7) is Hadano’s model [12] with , , . It is isomorphic over to the model of [7, 6] with .
The discriminant is , with fibres at and at . The trivial lattice of this K3 surface has rank , so rank . The -invariant is
The group of Möbius maps , , has order six. For each , over ; for example, for ,
The catalogue and the joint covers
Appendix B lists 42 quadratic conditions , one in each orbit of . Each has a rational parametrization and a point of infinite order. We write for and for .
Proposition 4.1. Fourteen of the conditions are even, namely for
and for these . After identifying these repetitions, the signed catalogue contains 70 distinct conditions, no two of them proportional. Among unordered pairs of distinct conditions, 84 have a common root. These form 42 classes under simultaneous reflection , and exactly 21 of the classes have rationally soluble joint covers. These 21 form seven orbits of three under (Table 1).
Proof. For and , put ; the joint cover becomes the conic
We decided its solubility with qfsolve [23]. Two pairs are equivalent when some maps the subgroup onto the other subgroup. Since , equivalent covers give equivalent curves. □
| Class | Pairs |
| , , | |
| , , | |
| , , | |
| , , | |
| , , | |
| , , | |
| , , |
Table 1 (PDF p. 9). The 21 rational joint covers, grouped into classes.
The nine curves
For we take the first pair of each class; Table 2 gives the degree-four map . is the pullback , with the two sections whose -coordinates are in Appendix § 6.
| Conditions | |
Table 2. Representatives .
The condition has
With and , the pullback is isomorphic, via and , to
where
It has the section with
On we impose two further conditions:
They are parametrized by
We put and .
Two further conditions give nothing new.
is parametrized by , and
is parametrized by , and .
Here . These are identities of rational functions of degree four, and , so gives and gives . The map ramifies over , which lie over the fibres , so has two fibres of type .
Exact rank and torsion
For the curve has the integral model
to which Theorem 2.2(1) applies. For each we found the value below at which the criterion holds, testing all three products. At this the two sections are independent and ellrank [23] gives rank exactly two. The fibre torsion is .
Table 4.
This proves part (1) of Theorem B. We do not claim that the given sections generate the Mordell-Weil group; by injectivity, that question reduces to the fibres above, as in [6].
Corollary 4.2. Let be the conditions defining one of . Over , and have rank one, and has rank zero. has rank one over , and so do its twists by and .
Proof. For , apply (1) with rank and total rank 2. For , apply the same argument to the quadratic extension .
Inequivalence
For the map is unramified over . So the order-six poles of are the twelve roots of , with homogenized. The invariant (2) takes the values
| Class | |
Table 5.
These eight values are distinct. The pole divisor of for consists of two poles of order 12, eight of order 6 and twelve of order 2; for it consists of twelve poles of order 6 and twelve of order 2. By §2.5(ii), this proves part (2) of Theorem B. Together with Proposition 4.1, it also proves part (4).
Comparison with earlier constructions
The three curves of [7] are obtained as follows.
The first two come from followed by , respectively . Under these are the pairs (class ) and , the reflection of (class ).
The third, built from Hadano’s model, is the curve of [6 §8.4], and hence equivalent to by the table below. Directly, with the corresponding map to the -line, with .
For the five curves of [6 §8], with their parameter:
| [6] | Class | Change of parameter | |
| §8.1 | |||
| §8.2 | |||
| §8.3 | |||
| §8.4 | |||
| §8.5 |
Table 1 (PDF p. 11).
In each line, write for the parametrization of [6] and for our map. Then is an identity of rational functions of degree four. Since is isomorphic over to the model of [6], and over , the curves are isomorphic over , not merely twists of each other. By [6 §1.3], MacLeod’s examples [19] are isomorphic to the first three of these curves. Hence are not equivalent to any of these curves, which proves part (3) of Theorem B.
Appendix A. Split quadratic sections of Elkies’s surface
The table lists the 50 split conditions and the linear condition of the catalogue, in its original numbering.
| Label | |
Table 1 (PDF p. 12).
| Label | |
Table 6.
Appendix B. Quadratic conditions on the universal curve
For each the conic has a rational point, and is the -coordinate of a point of infinite order on over .
Table 7.
Table 8 (PDF p. 14).
Acknowledgments
A.D. acknowledges support from the Croatian Science Foundation under the project no. IP2022-10-5008 (TEBAG), the project “Implementation of cutting-edge research and its application as part of the Scientific Center of Excellence for Quantum and Complex Systems, and Representations of Lie Algebras”, Grant No. PK.1.1.10.0004, co-financed by the European Union through the European Regional Development Fund – Competitiveness and Cohesion Programme 2021–2027, and the European Union: NextGenerationEU through the National Recovery and Resilience Plan 2021–2026, Institutional grant of University of Zagreb Faculty of Science (IK IA 1.1.3. Impact4Math).
AI systems were used to optimise the programs and convert the resulting data into a readable format. The authors are responsible for the final manuscript.
References
[1] T. Dokchitser and V. Dokchitser, On the Birch–Swinnerton-Dyer quotients modulo squares, Ann. of Math. (2) 172 (2010), 567–596.
[2] A. Dujella, On Mordell–Weil groups of elliptic curves induced by Diophantine triples, Glas. Mat. Ser. III 42 (2007), 3–18.
[3] A. Dujella, High rank elliptic curves with prescribed torsion, https://web.math.pmf.unizg.hr/~duje/tors/tors.html.
[4] A. Dujella, Infinite families of elliptic curves with high rank and prescribed torsion, https://web.math.pmf.unizg.hr/~duje/tors/generic.html.
[5] A. Dujella, I. Gusić and P. Tadić, The rank and generators of Kihara’s elliptic curve with torsion over , Proc. Japan Acad. Ser. A Math. Sci. 91 (2015), 105–109.
Department of Mathematics, Faculty of Science, University of Zagreb, Bijenička cesta 30, 10000 Zagreb, Croatia
Email address, A. Dujella: [email protected]
Departamento de Matemáticas, Universidad del País Vasco, Aptdo. 644, 48080 Bilbao, Spain
Email address, J. C. Peral: [email protected]
References
- [1]T. Dokchitser and V. Dokchitser, On the Birch–Swinnerton-Dyer quotients modulo squares, Ann. of Math. (2) 172 (2010), 567–596.
- [2]A. Dujella, On Mordell–Weil groups of elliptic curves induced by Diophantine triples, Glas. Mat. Ser. III 42 (2007), 3–18.DOI
- [3]A. Dujella, High rank elliptic curves with prescribed torsion, https://web.math.pmf.unizg.hr/~duje/tors/tors.html
- [4]A. Dujella, Infinite families of elliptic curves with high rank and prescribed torsion, https://web.math.pmf.unizg.hr/~duje/tors/generic.html.
- [5]A. Dujella, I. Gusić and P. Tadić, The rank and generators of Kihara’s elliptic curve with torsion ℤ/4ℤ over ℚ(t), Proc. Japan Acad. Ser. A Math. Sci. 91 (2015), 105–109.
- [6]A. Dujella, M. Kazalicki and J. C. Peral, Elliptic curves with torsion groups ℤ/8ℤ and ℤ/2ℤ × ℤ/6ℤ, Rev. R. Acad. Cienc. Exactas Fís. Nat. Ser. A Mat. RACSAM 115 (2021), Paper No. 169.
- [7]A. Dujella and J. C. Peral, Elliptic curves with torsion group ℤ/8ℤ or ℤ/2ℤ × ℤ/6ℤ, in: Trends in Number Theory, Contemp. Math. 649, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2015, pp. 47–62.
- [8]A. Dujella and J. C. Peral, Construction of high rank elliptic curves, J. Geom. Anal. 31 (2021), 6698–6724.DOI
- [9]A. Dujella and J. C. Peral, An elliptic curve over ℚ(u) with torsion ℤ/4ℤ and rank 6, Rad Hrvat. Akad. Znan. Umjet. Mat. Znan. 28 (2024), 185–192.DOI
- [10]N. D. Elkies, Three lectures on elliptic surfaces and curves of high rank, arXiv:0709.2908 (2007).arxiv.org/abs/0709.2908
- [11]I. Gusić and P. Tadić, Injectivity of the specialization homomorphism of elliptic curves, J. Number Theory 148 (2015), 137–152.arxiv.org/abs/1409.7189
- [12]T. Hadano, Elliptic curves with a torsion point, Nagoya Math. J. 66 (1977), 99–108.DOI
- [13]E. Kani and M. Rosen, Idempotent relations and factors of Jacobians, Math. Ann. 284 (1989), 307–327.DOI
- [14]F. Khoshnam and D. Moody, High rank elliptic curves with torsion ℤ/4ℤ induced by Kihara’s elliptic curves, Integers 16 (2016), Paper A70.DOI
- [15]S. Kihara, On the rank of elliptic curves with a rational point of order 4, Proc. Japan Acad. Ser. A Math. Sci. 80 (2004), 26–27.DOI
- [16]D. S. Kubert, Universal bounds on the torsion of elliptic curves, Proc. London Math. Soc. (3) 33 (1976), 193–237.
- [17]J. Kulesz, Families of elliptic curves of high rank with nontrivial torsion group over ℚ, Acta Arith. 108 (2003), 339–356.
- [18]O. Lechacheux, Rang de courbes elliptiques, Acta Arith. 109 (2003), 131–142.DOI
- [19]A. J. MacLeod, A simple method for high-rank families of elliptic curves with specified torsion, arXiv:1410.1662 (2014).arxiv.org/abs/1410.1662
- [20]B. Mazur, Modular curves and the Eisenstein ideal, Publ. Math. IHÉS 47 (1977), 33–186.DOI
- [21]P. Monsky, Generalizing the Birch–Stephens theorem. I. Modular curves, Math. Z. 221 (1996), 415–420.
- [22]P. J. Oliver, Classical Invariant Theory, London Math. Soc. Student Texts 44, Cambridge Univ. Press, 1999.
- [23]The PARI Group, PARI/GP version 2.17.2, Univ. Bordeaux, https://pari.math.u-bordeaux.fr/.
- [24]M. Schütt and T. Shioda, Mordell–Weil Lattices, Ergeb. Math. Grenzgeb. (3) 70, Springer, Singapore, 2019.DOI
- [25]J. Woo, Arithmetic of elliptic curves and surfaces: descent and quadratic sections, PhD thesis, Harvard University, 2010.