betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

On correctly assessing the reversibility of the magnetocaloric effect from indirect measurements

Abstract

The adiabatic temperature change (ΔTadΔT_{ad}) of a magnetic refrigerant can be indirectly estimated through field (HH) and temperature (TT) dependent magnetization (MM) and specific heat (CpC_p) measurements. A direct integration approach for this estimation is frequently reported, which is an approximation to a rigorous mathematical approach. In this work, we propose an iterative method in small HH steps, to estimate ΔTadΔT_{ad} from indirect measurements. We show that this approach is able to reproduce the reversibility of the magnetocaloric effect, and provides a more accurate estimation of ΔTadΔT_{ad}, up to 10% when considering a detailed M(H,T)M(H,T) and Cp(H,T)Cp(H,T) dataset that reproduces the magnetothermal properties of gadolinium, a benchmark room-temperature magnetic refrigerant.

Introduction

The magnetocaloric effect (MCE) gives rise to a temperature change in magnetocaloric materials when exposed to a magnetic field, serving as the fundamental principle behind magnetic refrigeration. The MCE is a reversible process, and so, under adiabatic conditions, applying and removing an external magnetic field will keep the system at its starting temperature. The thermodynamics describing the MCE is well established, with over a century of research, and its discovery credited to Weiss and Piccard[1, 2], in 1917.

Magnetic refrigeration benefits from a large MCE which will depend on the magnetocaloric material (refrigerant) used, and it largely dictates the performance of such devices[3, 4, 5, 6, 7]. The study of magnetic refrigeration hinges on accurately gauging the adiabatic temperature change (ΔTad\Delta T_{ad}), either from indirect measurements (the refrigerant’s magnetization and specific heat at different temperatures and external magnetic fields) or by direct measurement of ΔTad\Delta T_{ad}. The accurate direct measurement of ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} is challenging, requiring dedicated equipment. As an alternative, ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} can be estimated using a detailed magnetization and specific heat dataset, both as a function of temperature and magnetic field.

MCE - Thermodynamics

The total differential of the total entropy of a magnetocaloric material can be written as[8],

dS=CH,pTdT+(∂M∂T)H,pdH−αTVdp,(1)dS = \frac{C_{H,p}}{T}dT + \left(\frac{\partial M}{\partial T}\right)_{H,p}dH - \alpha_T Vdp, \tag*{(1)}

CH,pC_{H,p} is the heat capacity under constant magnetic field and pressure, MM is the magnetization of the material, and αT\alpha_T is the bulk thermal expansion coefficient.

In an adiabatic-isobaric process (dp=0dp=0 and dS=0dS=0), we can write the infinitesimal temperature change due to the MCE as

CH,pTdT+(∂M∂T)H,pdH=0(2)\frac{C_{H,p}}{T}dT + \left(\frac{\partial M}{\partial T}\right)_{H,p}dH = 0 \tag*{(2)}

This mathematical description is standard, and eq. 2 is frequently seen throughout literature[6, 9, 10]. From here, obtaining ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} diverges into two different branches[7, 10].

ΔTad=−∫H1H2TCp∂M∂TdH(3)\Delta T_{ad} = -\int_{H_1}^{H_2}\frac{T}{C_p}\frac{\partial M}{\partial T}dH \tag*{(3)}
ΔTad≈−TCp,HΔSM(T)ΔH(4)\Delta T_{ad} \approx-\frac{T}{C_{p,H}}\Delta S_M(T)_{\Delta H} \tag*{(4)}

Yet, eq. 2 is a total differential equation, which cannot be rigorously solved with neither eq. 3 nor 4, as ∂M∂T\frac{\partial M}{\partial T} and CpC_p are both functions of temperature and magnetic field. Reversing the limits of integration in equation 3 evidently only changes the sign of ΔTad\Delta T_{ad}, as the integral path is the same. So, the direct use of equation 3 results in a non-reversible ΔTad\Delta T_{ad}, an incorrect description of the MCE.

Smith et al. have reported this inaccuracy, proposing the use of eq. 3, but “numerically integrating in sufficiently small increments”, updating TT on each subsequent integral. Also, Pęcharsky and Gschneidner[10] have criticized the use of eq. 4, suggesting as an alternative calculating ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} from the isentropic difference between the S(T)HiS(T)_{H_i} and S(T)HfS(T)_{H_f}: ΔTad≈[T(S)Hf−T(S)Hi]S\Delta T_{ad} \approx[T(S)_{H_f} - T(S)_{H_i}]_S.

Correctly assessing the reversible MCE

Instead of successive numerical integration, as suggested by Smith et al., ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} can be estimated by approximating the total differential equation (eq. (1)), by taking small steps in magnetic field (δH\delta H), to which a small temperature change δT\delta T is associated. This methodology is equivalent to a finite difference approach and is grounded in the accurate physical description of the MCE,

δT(Ti,Hi)=−TiCp,Hi∂M∂T(Ti,Hi)δH.(5)\delta T(T_i,H_i)=-\frac{T_i}{C_{p,H_i}}\frac{\partial M}{\partial T}(T_i,H_i)\delta H. \tag*{(5)}

Then, letting the temperature evolve by iteration;

Ti+1=Ti+δT(Ti,Hi)Hi+1=Hi+δH,\begin{aligned} T_{i+1} &= T_i+\delta T(T_i,H_i)\\ H_{i+1} &= H_i+\delta H, \end{aligned}

until Hi=HfH_i=H_f, where HfH_f is the final magnetic field intensity desired. The adiabatic temperature change from this method is simply the difference between the final and initial temperatures: ΔTad=Tf−T0\Delta T_{ad}=T_f-T_0.

To obtain ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} from M(H,T)M(H,T) and Cp(H,T)C_p(H,T), these thermophysical properties for a magnetocaloric material are necessary and, for the iterative method (eq. (5)), its calculation requires detailed information on M(H,T)M(H,T) and Cp(H,T)C_p(H,T). In this work, we have considered detailed simulated M(H,T)M(H,T) and Cp(H,T)C_p(H,T) data that adequately replicate the thermophysical properties of gadolinium, the benchmark material for room-temperature magnetic refrigeration. These were calculated via a hexagonal close packed model lattice of spin 7/2 Ising spins, by Monte Carlo sampling of its Joint Energy and Magnetization dependent Density of States (JDOS)[11]. The nearest-neighbor magnetic exchange parameter JJ was chosen to lead to the experimentally observed TcT_c value of gadolinium, and the value used was ≈5.3\approx5.3 meV. The total specific heat is then the sum of the magnetic specific heat and the lattice contribution described by the Debye model, with a Debye temperature TD=169T_D=169 K[12]. Further details on the model, Monte Carlo methodology and comparison with experimental data are available elsewhere[13]. Figure 1 shows M(H,T)M(H,T) and Cp(H,T)C_p(H,T) for 5 (out of 102) different external magnetic fields: [0, 0.5, 1, 1.5, 2] (T), for 79 temperature values between 80 and 440 K.

M(H,T) and Cp(H,T) data for different magnetic fields

Figure 1. M(H,T)M(H,T) data (top) and Cp(H,T)C_p(H,T) data (bottom) for H=0:0.5:2H=0:0.5:2 T, of an Ising spin 7/2 HCP lattice, where the lattice contribution to CpC_p is obtained from the Debye model with TD=169T_D=169 K. The dashed line indicates the critical temperature for the phase transition.

Results

Using the iterative method of eq. (5), the adiabatic temperature change ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} was calculated for a field change from 0 to 2 T, using the full dataset of Figure 1. To verify the convergence, a set of field steps were considered, δH\delta H: [0.01, 0.05, 0.025, 0.001] (T). By comparing each ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} associated to a δH\delta H, with the ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} obtained using the smallest field step considered (δH=0.001\delta H=0.001 T), a maximum relative difference <0.1%<0.1\% was observed. Also, the ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} from field application and removal describes a reversible process, within a maximum error of <0.2%<0.2\%.

As shown in Figure 2, the magnitude of ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} from field application, using the iterative method (eq. (5)) is closer to the field application estimate using eq. (3). Still, even assuming this best case scenario comparison, the difference is considerable, with a maximum relative difference larger than 10%.

Adiabatic temperature change and relative difference

Figure 2. Top - ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} from field application using M(H,T)M(H,T) and Cp(H,T)C_p(H,T) data from simulations that replicate Gd (Figure 1), estimated using eq. (5) (green and blue dots) and eq. (3) (red dots). Bottom - Relative difference of the ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} estimated from eq. (3) and 5, for field application.

Conclusion

The conventional procedure for calculating the adiabatic temperature change (ΔTad\Delta T_{ad}) from M(H,T)M(H,T) and Cp(H,T)C_p(H,T) data (eq. 3) is shown to not result in a reversible process, contrary to the thermodynamic description of the system. To correctly estimate the adiabatic temperature change, indirectly from M(H,T)M(H,T) and Cp(H,T)C_p(H,T) data, preserving the reversibility of the process, we propose approximating the total differential equation by an iterative method of using small steps in magnetic field (eq. 5).

From detailed M(H,T)M(H,T) and Cp(H,T)C_p(H,T) data, with comparable magnetothermal properties to gadolinium, we show that estimating ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} from direct integration (eq. 3) leads to a result that is 10% deviated from the more accurate value obtained through the proposed iterative method (eq. 5). This deviation is maximized near the Curie temperature, which is the temperature of interest, as it typically established the working temperature range for a given magnetic refrigeration device.

While the proposed methodology allows for the accurate indirect estimate of the ΔTad\Delta T_{ad} from magnetization and specific heat data, we also encourage the careful use of widely reported approximations.

Acknowledgments

This work was developed within the scope of the project CICECO-Aveiro Institute of Materials, UIDB/50011/2020, UIDP/50011/2020 & LA/P/0006/2020, financed by national funds through the FCT/MCTES (PIDDAC), and projects PTDC/EME-TED/3099/2020, UIDP/04968/2020-Programático, UIDB/04968/2020, NECL-NORTE-010145-FEDER-022096. J.H. Belo acknowledges FCT for contract DL57/2016 reference SFRH-BPD-87430/2012 and R. Almeida acknowledges FCT for PhD. grant reference 2022.13354.BD.

References

  1. [1]P. Weiss and A. Piccard, “Le phénomène magnétocalorique,” J. Phys. Theor. Appl. 7, 103–109 (1917).
  2. [2]A. Smith, “Who discovered the magnetocaloric effect?” The European Physical Journal H 38, 507–517 (2013).
  3. [3]J. Romero Gómez, R. Reguera García, A. De Miguel Catoira, and M. Romero Gómez, “Magnetocaloric effect: A review of the thermodynamic cycles in magnetic refrigeration,” Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 17, 74–82 (2013).DOI
  4. [4]B. Yu, M. Liu, P. W. Egolf, and A. Kitanovski, “A review of magnetic refrigerator and heat pump prototypes built before the year 2010,” International Journal of Refrigeration 33, 1029–1060 (2010).DOI
  5. [5]K. A. Gschneidner, Jr. and V. K. Pecharsky, “Thirty years of near room temperature magnetic cooling: Where we are today and future prospects,” International journal of Refrigeration-revue internationale du froid 31, 945–961 (2008).DOI
  6. [6]V. Franco, J. Blázquez, J. Ipus, J. Law, L. Moreno-Ramírez, and A. Conde, “Magnetocaloric effect: From materials research to refrigeration devices,” Progress in Materials Science 93, 112–232 (2018).
  7. [7]A. Smith, C. R. Bahl, R. Bjørk, K. Engelbrecht, K. K. Nielsen, and N. Pryds, “Materials challenges for high performance magnetocaloric refrigeration devices,” Advanced Energy Materials 2, 1288–1318 (2012).DOI
  8. [8]A. Tishin and Y. Spichkin, The Magnetocaloric Effect and its Applications (CRC Press, 2003).
  9. [9]A. Tishin, “Magnetocaloric effect: Current situation and future trends,” Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials 316, 351–357 (2007).
  10. [10]V. K. Pecharsky and J. Gschneidner, K. A., “Magnetocaloric effect from indirect measurements: Magnetization and heat capacity,” Journal of Applied Physics 86, 565–575 (1999).
  11. [11]J. C. Inácio, A. L. Ferreira, and J. S. Amaral, “Accurate estimate of the joint density of states via flat scan sampling,” (2022), arXiv:2203.02718 [cond-mat.stat-mech].arxiv.org/abs/2203.02718
  12. [12]R. W. Hill, S. J. Collocott, K. A. G. Jr, and F. A. Schmidt, “The heat capacity of high-purity gadolinium from 0.5 to 4 k and the effects of interstitial impurities,” Journal of Physics F: Metal Physics 17, 1867 (1987).DOI
  13. [13]R. Almeida, S. C. Freitas, C. R. Fernandes, R. Kiefe, J. P. Araújo, J. S. Amaral, J. O. Ventura, J. H. Belo, and D. J. Silva, “Rotating magnetocaloric effect in polycrystals—harnessing the demagnetizing effect,” Journal of Physics: Energy 6, 015020 (2024).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_qaw6njd5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents