betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Graded unitarity constraints on simply-laced affine Kac–Moody algebras

Abstract

We investigate constraints imposed by four-dimensional unitarity (recently formalised as graded unitarity) on possible simply-laced affine Kac–Moody vertex algebras arising from four dimensions via the SCFT/VOA correspondence. Under the assumption that the R\mathfrak{R}-filtration is weight-based with respect to the currents and the Casimir operators, with appropriately shifted RR-charge assignments for the latter, we demonstrate that all values of the level other than a discrete set are incompatible with four-dimensional unitarity. This set includes all the boundary admissible affine vertex algebras, those corresponding to rank-one Kodaira SCFTs, as well as certain non-admissible families conjecturally associated with specific Dqb(g)D^b_q(\mathfrak{g}) Argyres–Douglas theories. Specialising to slN\mathfrak{sl}_N with NN prime, we find a stronger result: under the same R\mathfrak{R}-filtration assumption, four-dimensional unitarity rules out all levels except the boundary admissible k=kN,qk = k_{N,q}, which are precisely those corresponding to the DqN(slN)D_q^N(\mathfrak{sl}_N) Argyres–Douglas theories.

Prepared for submission to JHEP

Introduction and Summary

Every four-dimensional N=2\mathcal{N}=2 superconformal field theory (SCFT) gives rise to an associated vertex operator algebra (VOA), via the SCFT/VOA correspondence [1]. These vertex algebras possess a number of nice properties that make them better behaved than generic VOAs. For example, they are conjecturally quasi-lisse so their vacuum characters satisfy finite-order modular linear differential equations [2, 3] and in many cases they admit extremely nice free field realisations [4, 5, 6, 7]. A salient feature is that when the four-dimensional theory in question is unitary, the associated VOA inherits a novel form of unitarity, christened graded unitarity in [8]. The implications of this structure for Virasoro, sl2\mathfrak{sl}_2, sl3\mathfrak{sl}_3, sl4\mathfrak{sl}_4 affine vertex algebras were also investigated loc. cit., while the more technically involved case of Zamolodchikov W3\mathcal{W}_3 algebras was examined in [9]. The variations of this structure, along with a more mathematically precise formulation were elaborated in [10]. Some preliminary consequences of four-dimensional unitarity for the associated vertex operator algebra were studied in [11, 12], which in retrospect are consequences of graded unitarity.

More recently, it was established that graded unitarity of sl2\mathfrak{sl}_2 at boundary admissible level k=−2+2qk=-2+\frac{2}{q} implies graded unitarity of the (2,q)(2,q) Virasoro minimal models [13].

A graded unitarity structure for a vertex algebra V\mathrm{V} amounts, in particular, to a conjugation operation ρ\rho (generally of order four) together with a nondegenerate half-integral good filtration R∙\mathcal{R}_\bullet on V\mathrm{V}. With respect to these ingredients, graded unitarity amounts to the requirement that a suitably defined Hermitian form is positive definite; equivalently, that the constants appearing in the two-point functions of operators with their conjugates have definite, RR-charge-dependent signs. It is an important problem to characterise to what extent the existence of a graded unitary structure constrains the underlying vertex algebra. A direct attack on the problem (for a fixed underlying vertex algebra) is complicated by the dependence of the positivity property on the choice of R\mathcal{R}-filtration. At present, there is no intrinsic characterisation of the physically relevant R\mathcal{R}-filtration without reference to four-dimensional input. One is thus led to an interesting (but seemingly difficult) problem of constraining a choice of good filtrations subject to highly specific sign requirements for two-point functions.

If, however, an R\mathcal{R}-filtration is given or assumed, then graded unitarity makes extremely precise predictions about the positivity/negativity conditions for two-point functions in the underlying vertex algebra, and these are comparatively accessible. This approach was pursued in [8, 9] for the cases where the underlying vertex algebra is Virasoro, an affine Kac–Moody VOA of type sln\mathfrak{sl}_n with n=2,3,4n=2,3,4, or the Zamolodchikov W3\mathcal{W}_3 VOA. In these works, a simple but physically motivated choice of R\mathcal{R}-filtration was assumed and consequently all but a discrete set of values for the central charge/level were ruled out by imposing the relevant positivity bounds level by level. These stringent restrictions on the central charge/level were obtained by examining the positivity constraints visible at the level of the Kac determinant at a given conformal level (and g\mathfrak{g}-weight in the Kac–Moody case). While the full set of positivity constraints from graded unitarity are much richer, it is particularly satisfying that determinant-based constraints provide such strict restrictions.

The purpose of the present paper is to generalise such a classification to all simply-laced affine Kac–Moody algebras. There are several families of four-dimensional theories which are known, or conjectured, to give rise to simply-laced affine Kac–Moody algebras. In particular, the VOAs associated with the Kodaira/Deligne–Cvitanović rank-one SCFTs [14, 15, 16, 17] are given by affine Kac–Moody VOAs Vk(g)V_k(\mathfrak{g}) at level k=−hg∨6−1k=-\frac{h^\vee_{\mathfrak{g}}}{6}-1, where h∨h^\vee is the dual Coxeter number of the corresponding simple Lie algebra g\mathfrak{g}. For simply-laced g\mathfrak{g}, these include the family,

a1⊂a2⊂d4⊂e6⊂e7⊂e8 ,(1)\mathfrak{a}_1 \subset\mathfrak{a}_2 \subset\mathfrak{d}_4 \subset\mathfrak{e}_6 \subset\mathfrak{e}_7 \subset\mathfrak{e}_8 \,, \tag*{(1)}

so the respective affine Kac–Moody VOAs are expected to be graded unitary.

Furthermore, a plethora of generalised Argyres–Douglas (AD) theories [15, 18, 19] conjecturally give rise to affine Kac–Moody VOAs. Specifically, the theories of interest are associated to irregular Hitchin systems of type ADEAD^E with a full regular puncture and an irregular puncture [20]. We denote these theories by Dqb(g)D_q^b(\mathfrak{g}), where bb and qq parametrise the irregular singularity, and g\mathfrak{g} is simply laced.1 Largely based on the requirement that the four-dimensional theory has precisely g\mathbf{g}-flavour symmetry, and the satisfaction of the Sugawara relation for the central charge, the associated VOAs for the Dqb(g)D^{b}_{q}(\mathbf{g}) generalised Argyres–Douglas SCFTs without extra mass parameters/flavour symmetries from the irregular puncture, are conjectured to be the affine Kac–Moody VOAs [21, 22, 23],

V[Dqb(g)]=Vk(g),k=−h∨+bq.(2)V[D^{b}_{q}(\mathbf{g})] = V_{k}(\mathbf{g}), \qquad k = -h^{\vee} + \frac{b}{q}. \tag*{(2)}

It is worth emphasising that (non-trivial) finite extensions by modules of affine Kac–Moody algebras do not affect the central charge c4dc_{4d} of the putative four-dimensional theory. Consequently, the agreement of the central charge alone does not distinguish the conjectured identification in (2) from possible finite extensions. However, there is a particularly important specialisation: b=h∨b = h^{\vee}, with (h∨,q)=1(h^{\vee},q) = 1, in which case the level kk is boundary admissible.2 In addition to the absence of mass parameters, the four-dimensional Dqh∨(g)D^{h^{\vee}}_{q}(\mathbf{g}) theories in this case have no exactly marginal couplings. With the stress tensor of the VOA V[Dqh∨(g)]V[D^{h^{\vee}}_{q}(\mathbf{g})] being the Segal–Sugawara stress tensor of Vk(g)V_{k}(\mathbf{g}) [12], certain technical niceness assumptions imply that the affine Kac–Moody subalgebra Vk(g)V_{k}(\mathbf{g}) does not admit non-trivial finite extensions [24]. Therefore, it is also expected that all the boundary admissible affine Kac–Moody VOAs appearing in (2) are graded unitary. Indeed, boundary admissibility has already been observed to be a recurring feature of affine Kac–Moody VOAs arising from four-dimensional unitary theories [8, 9].

Since deriving the R\mathcal{R}-filtration from first principles is beyond the scope of this work, we make the working assumption that the R\mathcal{R}-filtration on the affine Kac–Moody VOA Vk(g)V_{k}(\mathbf{g}) is weight-based, with appropriate adjustments for Casimir operators, as introduced in [8]. It is worth emphasising that affine Kac–Moody VOAs with different, non-standard R\mathcal{R}-filtrations do arise in four-dimensional unitary theories [25]. In all known examples, however, the putative four-dimensional theories are discrete gaugings of a parent unitary theory. In [8], it was further conjectured that the standard R\mathcal{R}-filtration is good; a first contribution of this paper is to prove this conjecture for any semisimple g\mathbf{g}.

We then restrict to simply-laced g\mathbf{g} and examine constraints on the level kk from graded unitarity. In line with [8], we utilise the closed-form expression for the vacuum determinant of affine Kac–Moody algebras [26], and take as our diagnostic the determinant-level consequence of graded unitarity. At each conformal level LL (and a specific fixed g\mathbf{g}-weight), we explicitly determine the relevant structure of zeros and multiplicities of the vacuum determinant. Graded unitarity predicts a definite sign for the determinant of the Shapovalov form, determined by the R\mathcal{R}-charges (after refining the R\mathcal{R}-filtration to a grading). We can compare this sign prediction with the sign implied by the closed-form expression of the vacuum determinant.

Our main result is that this comparison leads to extremely stringent restrictions on the level kk: under the standard R\mathcal{R}-filtration hypothesis, we find that all levels except the discrete set of values tabulated in Table 1 are incompatible with graded unitarity. This set includes the affine Kac–Moody algebras associated with the rank-one Kodaira SCFTs and the “class I” Dqν(g)D^\nu_q(\mathfrak{g}) generalised Argyres–Douglas theories with simply-laced flavour symmetry. Inter-

Vertex algebraLevel kkConditionsSCFT realisation
Vk(slN)V_k(\mathfrak{sl}_N)−N+Nq-N+\frac{N}{q}(N,q)=1(N,q)=1“class I” DqN(slN)D^N_q(\mathfrak{sl}_N)
−N+Nq-N+\frac{N}{q}(N,q)>1,N∤q(N,q)>1,\quad N\nmid q
Vk(so2N)V_k(\mathfrak{so}_{2N}) (N≥4)(N\ge4)−(2N−2)+2N−2q-(2N-2)+\frac{2N-2}{q}(2N−2,q)=1(2N-2,q)=1“class I” Dq2N−2(so2N)D^{2N-2}_q(\mathfrak{so}_{2N})
−(2N−2)+2N−2q-(2N-2)+\frac{2N-2}{q}q∈2N+1,(2N−2,q)>1q\in2\mathbb{N}+1,\quad(2N-2,q)>1Dq2N−2(so2N)D^{2N-2}_q(\mathfrak{so}_{2N})
−2-2N=4N=4SU(2)SU(2) with Nf=4N_f=4
−(2N−2)+Nq-(2N-2)+\frac{N}{q}1≤q≤N−22,Ngcd⁡(N,q)∈2N1\le q\le\frac{N-2}{2},\quad\frac{N}{\gcd(N,q)}\in2\mathbb{N}DqN(so2N)D^N_q(\mathfrak{so}_{2N})
−(2N−2)+Nq-(2N-2)+\frac{N}{q}1≤q≤N−22,Ngcd⁡(N,q)∈2N+11\le q\le\frac{N-2}{2},\quad\frac{N}{\gcd(N,q)}\in2\mathbb{N}+1
−(2N−2)+2N3N−2-(2N-2)+\frac{2N}{3N-2}N∈4NN\in4\mathbb{N}D3N−22N(so2N)D^N_{\frac{3N-2}{2}}(\mathfrak{so}_{2N})
−(2N−2)+2N3N−2-(2N-2)+\frac{2N}{3N-2}N∈4N+2N\in4\mathbb{N}+2
−(2N−2)+2q-(2N-2)+\frac{2}{q}q∈2N+1,N∈2N+1q\in2\mathbb{N}+1,\quad N\in2\mathbb{N}+1
−52-\frac{5}{2}N=4N=4
−223-\frac{22}{3}N=6N=6
Vk(e6)V_k(\mathfrak{e}_6)−12+12q-12+\frac{12}{q}(12,q)=1(12,q)=1“class I” Dq12(e6)D^{12}_q(\mathfrak{e}_6)
−12+3q-12+\frac{3}{q}(3,q)=1(3,q)=1D4q12(e6)D^{12}_{4q}(\mathfrak{e}_6)
−3-3rank-one E6E_6 SCFT
−6-6D22(e6)D^2_2(\mathfrak{e}_6)
Vk(e7)V_k(\mathfrak{e}_7)−18+18q-18+\frac{18}{q}(18,q)=1(18,q)=1“class I” Dq18(e7)D^{18}_q(\mathfrak{e}_7)
−18+2q-18+\frac{2}{q}(2,q)=1(2,q)=1D9q18(e7)D^{18}_{9q}(\mathfrak{e}_7)
−4-4rank-one E7E_7 SCFT
−8-8
−11-11
Vk(e8)V_k(\mathfrak{e}_8)−30+30q-30+\frac{30}{q}(30,q)=1(30,q)=1“class I” Dq30(e8)D^{30}_q(\mathfrak{e}_8)
−6-6rank-one E8E_8 SCFT
−10-10D120(e8)D^{20}_1(\mathfrak{e}_8)
−18-18D224(e8)D^{24}_2(\mathfrak{e}_8)
−22-22D324(e8)D^{24}_3(\mathfrak{e}_8)
−292-\frac{29}{2}

Table 1. Simply-laced affine Kac–Moody algebras selected by determinant-based graded unitarity constraints. Entries in pale blue are either associated VOAs of rank-one Kodaira SCFTs, or are boundary admissible affine VOAs. Entries in pale green correspond to non-admissible affine VOAs conjectured to arise in the respective Dqb(g)D^b_q(\mathfrak{g}) AD theories.

References

  1. [1]C. Beem, M. Lemos, P. Liendo, W. Peelaers, L. Rastelli, and B. C. van Rees, Infinite Chiral Symmetry in Four Dimensions, Commun. Math. Phys. 336 (2015), no. 3 1359–1433, [arXiv:1312.5344].DOI
  2. [2]C. Beem and L. Rastelli, Vertex operator algebras, Higgs branches, and modular differential equations, JHEP 08 (2018) 114, [arXiv:1707.07679].DOI
  3. [3]T. Arakawa and K. Kawasetsu, Quasi-lisse vertex algebras and modular linear differential equations, in Lie Groups, Geometry, and Representation Theory: A Tribute to the Life and Work of Bertram Kostant, pp. 41–57. Springer, 2018.
  4. [4]C. Beem, C. Meneghinelli, and L. Rastelli, Free Field Realizations from the Higgs Branch, JHEP 09 (2019) 058, [arXiv:1903.07624].DOI
  5. [5]C. Beem, C. Meneghinelli, W. Peelaers, and L. Rastelli, VOAs and rank-two instanton SCFTs, Commun. Math. Phys. 377 (2020), no. 3 2553–2578, [arXiv:1907.08629].DOI
  6. [6]C. Beem and C. Meneghinelli, Geometric free field realization for the genus-two class S theory of type a1, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021), no. 6 065015, [arXiv:2104.11668].DOI
  7. [7]C. Beem, A. Deb, M. Martone, C. Meneghinelli, and L. Rastelli, Free field realizations for rank-one SCFTs, JHEP 12 (2024) 004, [arXiv:2407.01674].arxiv.org/abs/2407.01674
  8. [8]A. Arabi Ardehali, C. Beem, M. Lemos, and L. Rastelli, Graded unitarity in the SCFT/VOA correspondence, JHEP 06 (2026) 075, [arXiv:2507.23781].arxiv.org/abs/2507.23781
  9. [9]C. Beem and H. Kulkarni, Towards a classification of graded unitary 𝒯₃ algebras, JHEP 07 (2026) 083, [arXiv:2602.15944].arxiv.org/abs/2602.15944
  10. [10]C. Beem and N. Garner, On the semi-infinite cohomology of graded-unitary vertex algebras, J. Algebra 698 (2026) 172–223, [arXiv:2509.10364].arxiv.org/abs/2509.10364
  11. [11]P. Liendo, I. Ramirez, and J. Seo, Stress-tensor OPE in 𝒩 = 2 superconformal theories, JHEP 02 (2016) 019, [arXiv:1509.00033].DOI
  12. [12]C. Beem, Flavor Symmetries and Unitarity Bounds in 𝒩 = 2 Superconformal Field Theories, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122 (2019), no. 24 241603, [arXiv:1812.06099].DOI
  13. [13]F. K. Popov and L. Rastelli, Vertex Operator Algebras in Lean: a formal library and its companion book, arXiv:2611.06616.
  14. [14]N. Seiberg and E. Witten, Monopoles, duality and chiral symmetry breaking in N=2 supersymmetric QCD, Nucl. Phys. B 431 (1994) 484–550, [hep-th/9408099].DOI
  15. [15]P. C. Argyres, M. R. Plesser, N. Seiberg, and E. Witten, New N=2 superconformal field theories in four-dimensions, Nucl. Phys. B 461 (1996) 71–84, [hep-th/9511154].DOI
  16. [16]J. A. Minahan and D. Nemeschansky, An N=2 superconformal fixed point with E(6) global symmetry, Nucl. Phys. B 482 (1996) 142–152, [hep-th/9608047].DOI
  17. [17]J. A. Minahan and D. Nemeschansky, Superconformal fixed points with E(n) global symmetry, Nucl. Phys. B 489 (1997) 24–46, [hep-th/9610076].DOI
  18. [18]P. C. Argyres and M. R. Douglas, New phenomena in SU(3) supersymmetric gauge theory, Nucl. Phys. B 448 (1995) 93–126, [hep-th/9505062].
  19. [19]D. Xie, General Argyres-Douglas Theory, JHEP 01 (2013) 100, [arXiv:1204.2270].DOI
  20. [20]Y. Wang and D. Xie, Classification of Argyres-Douglas theories from M5 branes, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016), no. 6 065012, [arXiv:1509.00847].DOI
  21. [21]D. Xie, W. Yan, and S.-T. Yau, Chiral algebra of the Argyres-Douglas theory from M5 branes, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021), no. 6 065003, [arXiv:1604.02155].
  22. [22]J. Song, D. Xie, and W. Yan, Vertex operator algebras of Argyres-Douglas theories from M5-branes, JHEP 12 (2017) 123, [arXiv:1706.01607].DOI
  23. [23]D. Xie and K. Ye, Argyres-Douglas matter and S-duality: Part II, JHEP 03 (2018) 186, [arXiv:1711.06684].DOI
  24. [24]T. Arakawa, J. Van Ekeren, and A. Moreau, Singularities of nilpotent slodowy slices and collapsing levels of W-algebras, in Forum of Mathematics, Sigma, vol. 12, p. e95, Cambridge University Press, 2024.DOI
  25. [25]C. Beem and H. Kulkarni, Twisted A₂N Argyres–Douglas theories: vertex algebras, Higgs branches, and double covers, arXiv:2609.25212.arxiv.org/abs/2609.25212
  26. [26]M. Gorelik and V. Kac, On simplicity of vacuum modules, Advances in Mathematics 211 (2007), no. 2 621–677.arxiv.org/abs/math-ph/0606002
  27. [27]P. Bouwknegt and K. Schoutens, W symmetry in conformal field theory, Phys. Rept. 223 (1993) 183–276, [hep-th/9210010].DOI
  28. [28]A. Gadde, L. Rastelli, S. S. Razamat, and W. Yan, Gauge Theories and Macdonald Polynomials, Commun. Math. Phys. 319 (2013) 147–193, [arXiv:1110.3740].DOI
  29. [29]J. Song, Macdonald Index and Chiral Algebra, JHEP 08 (2017) 044, [arXiv:1612.08956].DOI
  30. [30]M. J. Kang, C. Lawrie, and J. Song, The index from a nonpoint and rg flows, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2609.13374
  31. [31]M. J. Kang, C. Lawrie, and J. Song, One ring to rule them all: syzygy maximization for Argyres-Douglas, arXiv:2610.33151.arxiv.org/abs/2610.33151
  32. [32]H. Jiang, Macdonald index from vertex-operator algebras and graded unitarity, Phys. Rev. D 114 (2026), no. 2 025022, [arXiv:2603.29829].arxiv.org/abs/2603.29829
  33. [33]H. LI, Vertex algebras and vertex poisson algebras, Communications in Contemporary Mathematics 06 (2004), no. 01 61–110.DOI
  34. [34]A. Kapustin, Holomorphic reduction of N=2 gauge theories, Wilson-'t Hooft operators, and S-duality, hep-th/0612119.DOI
  35. [35]J. Oh and J. Yagi, Chiral algebras from Ω-deformation, JHEP 08 (2019) 143, [arXiv:1903.11123].DOI
  36. [36]S. Jeong, SCFT/VOA correspondence via Ω-deformation, JHEP 10 (2019) 171, [arXiv:1904.00927].DOI
  37. [37]Y. Zhu, Modular invariance of characters of vertex operator algebras, J. Am. Math. Soc. 9 (1996), no. 1 237–302.DOI
  38. [38]F. A. Bais, P. Bouwknegt, M. Surridge, and K. Schoutens, Extensions of the Virasoro Algebra Constructed from Mac-Moody Algebras Using Higher Order Casimir Invariants, Nucl. Phys. B 304 (1988) 348–370.
  39. [39]A. Sevrin, W. Troost, A. Van Proeyen, and P. Spindel, Extended supersymmetric σ-models on group manifolds (ii). current algebras, Nuclear Physics B 311 (1988), no. 2 465–492.DOI
  40. [40]V. Kac, Vertex algebras for beginners. 1996.
  41. [41]B. Kostant, Lie group representations on polynomial rings, American Journal of Mathematics 85 (1963), no. 3 327–404.
  42. [42]T. Vust, Covariants de groupes algébriques réductifs. Thèse no. 1671, University of Genève, 1974.DOI
  43. [43]D. I. Panyushev, On covariants of reductive algebraic groups, Indagationes Mathematicae 13 (2002), no. 1 125–129.DOI
  44. [44]D. I. Panyushev, Semi-direct products of lie algebras and their invariants, Publications of the Research Institute for Mathematical Sciences 43 (2007), no. 4 1199–1257.arxiv.org/abs/math/0506579
  45. [45]C. Jiang and J. Song, On singular vectors of simply-laced universal affine vertex operator algebras, arXiv:2510.04445.arxiv.org/abs/2510.04445
  46. [46]C. Beem, M. Martone, M. Sacchi, P. Singh, and J. Stedman, Simplifying the type A Argyres-Douglas landscape, JHEP 12 (2025) 144, [arXiv:2311.12123].arxiv.org/abs/2311.12123
  47. [47]D. Adamović and I. Vukorepa, A new quasi-lisse affine vertex algebra of type d 4, Communications in Contemporary Mathematics (2026) 2650062.
  48. [48]T. Arakawa and A. Moreau, Sheets and associated varieties of affine vertex algebras, Advances in Mathematics 320 (2017) 157–209.arxiv.org/abs/1601.05906
  49. [49]F. Lübeck, Small degree representations of finite chevalley groups in defining characteristic, LMS Journal of Computation and Mathematics 4 (2001) 135–169.DOI
  50. [50]T. Arakawa, Associated varieties of modules over Kac-Moody algebras and C(2)-cofiniteness of W-algebras, Int. Math. Res. Not. 2015 (2015), no. 22 11605–11666, [arXiv:1004.1554].

Paper details

vlnc:W_qcu68bcw
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 9

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

GPT-5.6 Sol (bare)

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents