WorksComputer Science
Multi-Material Topology Optimization for Targeted Structural Dynamic Vibration Attenuation
Abstract
Resonance-induced excessive vibrations can degrade performance, reduce reliability, and shorten the service life of engineering structures. To reduce the risk of resonance, structural natural frequencies are generally engineered to be shifted away from excitation frequencies. To achieve these frequency shifts, topology optimization provides a systematic approach to tailor structural stiffness and mass as an effective inverse design approach. Multi-material topology optimization exploits the high-dimensional design space of spatially varying material constituents by simultaneously optimizing material selection and spatial distribution over the design domain, offering great flexibility in controlling natural frequencies. This study proposes a multi-material topology optimization that attenuates excessive structural dynamic vibrations in free-vibration scenarios via a novel multivariate weight-based interpolation method. Additionally, to address non-smoothness due to mode switching amid optimization, we employ a bound formulation with an auxiliary scalar design variable to replace the max-min eigenvalue objective with constraints on individual eigenvalues. Furthermore, we study and compare three optimization formulations for multi-material design to attenuate vibrations, including maximizing fundamental eigenfrequency, maximizing the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies, and excluding frequencies from targeted frequency bands, which are smoothly approximated by a proposed rational polynomial formulation. Numerical examples are presented to demonstrate the effectiveness and applicability of our proposed method.
Introduction
Dynamic vibrations significantly affect the performance, integrity, and operational lifespan of engineered structures, where unmitigated responses can cause severe structural degradation and failure [1]. Developing effective vibration attenuation strategies has become a central objective in structural design and optimization [2]. Engineering structures, such as beams, plates, and shells, which are widely used in aircraft structures, spacecraft structures, bridges, and machinery, are inevitably subjected to dynamic excitation during operation [3]. The resulting vibration response is strongly influenced by the relationship between the external excitation frequencies and the natural frequencies, and corresponding mode shapes. When an excitation frequency coincides with a natural frequency and couples with corresponding mode shapes, resonance produces large-amplitude oscillations leading to excessive deformation [4]. Resonance-induced vibration relies on the distribution of natural frequencies: when the excitation is close to a single natural frequency, the corresponding mode generally dominates, whereas closely spaced natural frequencies or repeated eigenvalues cause multiple modes to participate simultaneously through modal superposition, resulting in complex dynamic behaviors [5], [6].
Vibration reduction can improve fatigue resistance, lower acoustic emission, enhance reliability, and prolong structure life; yet conventional mitigation strategies generally carry limitations. Passive mitigation approaches, such as structural damping enhancement and vibration isolation techniques, are widely adopted; such approaches, however, need to add additional masses and are generally effective over limited frequency ranges [7]. Active control schemes offer broadband performance, but require sensors, actuators, and energy supplies, thereby increasing complexity and cost [8]. An alternative is to design the structure such that its natural frequencies remain outside the operating frequency range to prevent resonance [9]. This approach is generally pursued by maximizing the fundamental eigenfrequency [10].
Topology optimization (TO) enables the systematic tailoring of dynamic characteristics through the distribution of material constituents and voids within a prescribed domain [11], [12], [13], [14]. Popular methods include the homogenization method [15], density-based formulation [16], [17], evolutionary approach [18], level-set [19], [20], moving morphable components (MMCs) [21], geometric projection method [22], and genetic algorithm [23], [24]. While these methods generally differ in design representation and optimization updates, their objective and constraints can be adapted to account for structural vibration characteristics [25]. The homogenization method was applied to maximize the fundamental natural frequency by optimizing the distribution of reinforcing material [26]. It was subsequently extended from individual-frequency improvement to spectral tailoring through the optimization of multiple eigenfrequencies [27]. Design sensitivity and optimality were established for repeated eigenvalues to address the difficulty of non-differentiability [28], and artificial localized modes in low-density regions in density-based methods [29].
Recent studies have extended eigenfrequency-based topology optimization to targeted vibration suppression [30] and frequency-dependent material properties [4]. Harmonic-response optimization incorporated a modal assurance criterion (MAC)-based mode-tracking strategy, where the excitation frequency is progressively increased toward the prescribed value amid optimization, penalizing structural optimization to avoid resonance [31]. While this approach targets the response at a prescribed excitation frequency, resonance avoidance over an operating frequency band requires the control of natural frequencies whose mode orders may not be known in advance. To address this issue, a frequency-band constraint was proposed to prevent natural frequencies from entering prescribed bands via Heaviside functions [32].
Compared to single-material topology optimization, multi-material topology optimization (MMTO) expands design space by optimizing structural performance through material constituents and spatial distribution. Early developments included peak-function interpolation to represent materials without increasing the number of design variables [33], rational approximation of material properties (RAMP) to accommodate an arbitrary number of isotropic and anisotropic candidate materials [34], ordered SIMP to represent multiple materials using a single elemental density variable [35], and a univariate mapping-based interpolation scheme to reduce intermediate material densities and prevent undesired layers between material phases by integrating Heaviside projections with multi-variable filtering [36]. Additionally, to enforce discrete material selection per finite element, multiphase level-set methods distinguish non-overlapping material regions [37], and phase-field formulations regularize through energy-based models [38], [39].
MMTO has been investigated for vibration attenuation, where defining proper design objectives relies on the relationship between the structural spectrum and operating frequencies. In a pioneering multi-material beam design [40], two approaches were taken: maximizing the fundamental eigenfrequency to raise the lowest resonance frequency above an operating range, and maximizing the separation between adjacent eigenfrequencies to create an interval between resonance frequencies. Dynamic MMTO has also been extended to multiple materials with frequency constraints using an alternating active phase algorithm (AAPA) interpolation scheme equipped with penalized interpolation for stiffness and linear interpolation for mass to address pseudo modes and mode switching amid optimization [41]. Simultaneous interpolation of stiffness and mass is particularly important in eigenvalue-based MMTO, because both quantities directly influence the natural frequencies and associated mode shapes. Many existing studies have considered different objectives, such as maximizing fundamental frequency, separating adjacent eigenfrequencies, and avoiding resonance in prescribed operating ranges. However, these objectives generally suffer from challenges, such as mode switching in eigenvalue maximization and effective determination of natural frequencies in a prescribed interval.
This study develops a multi-material topology optimization formulation to reduce resonance-induced excessive vibration with the following main contributions. First, we propose a novel multivariate weight-based interpolation scheme for multi-materials for stiffness and mass interpolation in eigenvalue-based MMTO. Second, we study and compare three distinct MMTO formulations based on the proposed interpolation scheme, including fundamental frequency maximization, adjacent-frequency gap maximization, and targeted frequency band generation. Third, we propose a smooth frequency band constraint based on rational polynomial approximation to address non-differentiability of frequency-band constraints.
We organize the remainder of this paper as follows. In Section 2, we introduce the mathematical formulation of structural vibration. In Section 3, we propose a multi-material interpolation scheme for stiffness and mass matrices. Section 4 presents the topology optimization formulations for eigenfrequency optimization. In Section 5, we derive design sensitivities. We describe the numerical implementation in Section 6 and demonstrate the proposed approach through numerical examples in Section 7. Finally, we summarize contributions in Section 8.
Mathematical model of structural vibration
In this section, we model structural vibration by the finite element method (FEM) under the assumptions of linear elasticity, small deformations, and undamped free vibration. Accordingly, we neglect all external forces and damping effects, so that the dynamic response is governed by the mass and stiffness distribution of the structure. This reduces the problem to a generalized eigenvalue problem, from which we extract the natural frequencies and the corresponding mode shapes. In the following sections, we present the governing equations of structural free vibration in Section 2.1, followed by the density filtering and Heaviside projection approaches in Section 2.2 to prevent checkerboard patterns, reduce mesh dependency, and promote distinct material distributions during optimization.
Governing equation for structural vibration
Undamped free vibration can be described by the second-order equation of motion given in Equation (1):
where and denote the global mass and stiffness matrices, respectively, and is the vector of nodal displacements. Since no external excitation or dissipative term appears in Equation (1), the motion is sustained entirely by the exchange between kinetic and strain energy, and the resulting oscillation is harmonic in time. Equation (1) therefore constitutes a second-order differential equation with constant coefficients, whose general solution can be expressed in the separable form , where is an eigenvector describing the spatial distribution of the motion and is the associated eigenfrequency. Substituting this solution into Equation (1), followed by elimination of the non-vanishing factor , we remove the time dependence and reduce the problem to the generalized eigenvalue problem of Equation (2):
where is the degree of freedom in the discretized model. A non-trivial solution exists only when the coefficient matrix becomes non-singular, which yields eigenpairs corresponding to the natural frequencies and mode shapes of the vibration. The eigenvectors are normalized with respect to the mass matrix according to Equation (3). This orthonormality ensures that the eigenvectors form a linearly independent basis.
Design variable filtering and projection
In this work, to prevent checkerboard patterns and mesh dependence, density filtering is applied to each design variable within a prescribed filter radius. A smoothed Heaviside projection is then applied to the filtered density design variables to reduce intermediate values and obtain a discrete material type, with the projection steepness gradually increased through a continuation scheme.
Density filter
Element-wise density formulation is prone to checkerboard patterns and mesh dependence. To suppress both, a density filter [42, 43] is applied independently to each of the two design fields, giving the filtered densities () in Equation (4):
Here, denotes the set of elements whose centroids lie within the filter radius of the element , and the linear weighting factor decays with the distance between the centroids and , so that neighboring elements at closer distances contribute more to filtered density.
Heaviside projection
Although filtering suppresses numerical instabilities, it introduces intermediate-density regions near structural boundaries. As these regions lack clear physical meaning and may complicate manufacturing, a smoothed Heaviside projection [44], given in Equation (5), is applied to each filtered field to obtain the projected physical densities .
where is the projection threshold and controls the sharpness of the projection. For small , the mapping is nearly linear, whereas for large , it approaches an ideal step function at , driving densities towards 0 and 1. Imposing a large makes the optimization highly non-linear and causes divergence; is therefore increased gradually during the optimization following the continuation rule of [45, 46, 47], explained in § 5.
Since the objective and constraints are evaluated in terms of the projected densities, the sensitivities must be transferred back to the design variables through the chain rule. The required derivative of the projection is obtained by differentiating Equation (5) and is given in Equation (6).
Multivariate weight-based multi-material interpolation
We discretize the design domain into finite elements, where and denote the numbers of elements in the horizontal and vertical directions in a 2D design domain. We propose a novel formulation, i.e., a multivariate weight-
based interpolation scheme to describe the distribution of candidate materials. For candidate materials, the scheme requires design fields, and consequently, design variables are assigned to each finite element. For example, for a three-material structure, it yields two design fields, so that the design variable of the element becomes , with .
During optimization, design variables remain continuous, so the type of the material occupying each element is identified by comparing the design field against a threshold value of as expressed in Equation (11). Values below the threshold are interpreted as the preceding candidate material and values above it as the succeeding one. The threshold is applied only to extract and report the material distribution, and does not enter the optimization; therefore, no non-differentiability is induced. For example, in an optimized three-material design, the interpolation scheme assigns the first type of candidate material (M1) per element when , the second material (M2) when and , and the third material (M3) when and , as expressed in Equation (11). Figure 1 illustrates this penalization scheme for the three-material example. Specifically, Figure 1(a) shows the interpolation between the first and second materials, while Figure 1(b) shows the interpolation between the second and third materials. The selection of either M2 or M3 requires the corresponding condition in Figure 1(a) to be satisfied first, after which the second design field distinguishes between these two materials. This hierarchical procedure is extended to a system containing user-defined materials by successively applying the interpolation scheme to the candidate materials.

Figure 1. Illustration of the penalization in the proposed multivariate weight-based interpolation: (a) the first design variable in a three-material design, which selects between the first material and the remaining two materials, and (b) the second design variable, which selects between the second and third materials.
Weights for multi-material interpolation scheme
During optimization, the design variables are firstly filtered using Equation (4) and subsequently projected using Equation (5). The projected fields are then converted into material weights, which define the contribution of each candidate material to the effective element properties. For a mesh of elements and candidate materials, the unnormalized weight of the first material follows directly from the first projected field, as shown in Equation (8).
The unnormalized weights for intermediate materials () are designed as in Equation (9):
The unnormalized weight for the last material takes the remaining fraction, which is given by Equation (10):
The weights are normalized according to Equation (11) to enforce the partition-of-unity condition. We note that this normalization guarantees that the material fractions within an element are mutually exclusive and complementary: an increase in the fraction of one material is necessarily accompanied by a corresponding decrease in the fractions of the remaining materials. Consequently, the interpolated element properties always remain bounded by those of the candidate materials.
Finite element formulation for structural vibration
We discretize the design domain using four-node bilinear quadrilateral elements, each having two translational degrees of freedom per node. Since the out-of-plane thickness of the domain is small relative to its in-plane dimensions, we assume a plane stress condition, so that the elastic modulus matrix of the th candidate material is described by Equation (12) under the plane stress assumption:
where and denote the Young's modulus and Poisson's ratio of the material , respectively. The corresponding element stiffness and mass matrices are obtained from the standard Galerkin formulation in Equation (13):
in which is the strain-displacement matrix derived from the shape function matrix , is the mass density of the material , and the integrations are carried out numerically over the element domain using Gauss quadrature.
We assume all candidate materials share the same Poisson's ratio, allowing the material properties to be decoupled from the element geometry, so that the contribution of each element to the structural response can be expressed through an effective modulus of elasticity and an effective density, as stated in Equation (14):
where is the interpolation weight of material in element , and is the number of candidate materials. These weights govern the transition between the constituent materials, thereby determining the amount of each material present in each element.
Consequently, global stiffness and mass matrices are assembled from the elemental contributions scaled by these effective properties in Equation (15):
where is the elemental stiffness matrix evaluated for unit modulus of elasticity, is the elemental mass matrix evaluated for unit material density, and is the total number of elements. Both matrices are computed once at the beginning of the analysis and reused in every iteration, which appreciably reduces the computational effort of the optimization.
With the global matrices assembled and the prescribed boundary conditions imposed, the generalized eigenvalue problem of Equation (2) is solved to obtain the eigenvalues along with associated eigenvectors. The eigenvectors are subsequently mass-normalized by Equation (3), providing a consistent basis required for sensitivity analysis in § 4.
Frequency band constraint by rational polynomial function
In many practical engineering applications, it is not sufficient merely to maximize the fundamental frequency or to widen the gap between adjacent eigenmodes. What ultimately governs the dynamic serviceability of a component is whether any of its natural frequencies coincides with the excitation frequencies generated during operation. A design possessing a high fundamental frequency may still be undesirable, if a higher mode happens to lie within the operating range. For this reason, the design requires that no natural frequency of the structure is permitted to fall inside prescribed working frequency ranges, so that resonance and the associated amplification of vibration amplitudes are avoided.
Let prohibited bands be defined by the lower and upper frequency limits and and indexed by , where is the number of bands. It is convenient to describe each band by its center and half-width by Equation (16):
where this pair of quantities maps the band onto the normalized coordinate , which equals zero at the band center and at the band edges. The exclusion requirement can be written compactly as for every eigenfrequency by the Heaviside function in Equation (17):
which returns unity whenever a frequency violates the exclusion condition and zero otherwise. However, it cannot be used directly in a gradient-based optimization: the function is discontinuous at the band edges, its derivative vanishes everywhere else, and therefore, it supplies little indication about how far a given eigenfrequency lies from the prohibited region. For example, a design whose eigenfrequency sits just inside the band and another design whose eigenfrequency lies at the band center are indistinguishable to the optimizer, and therefore, no descent direction can be constructed.
To overcome this limitation, we replace the Heaviside function with a smooth and differentiable approximation: a rational polynomial function (RPF) defined in Equation (18):
in which is a positive integer that controls transition sharpness, as illustrated in Figure 2. At the band center the normalized coordinate vanishes, and the function attains its maximum value of unity; at either band edge the normalized coordinate equals , so that the denominator becomes exactly two and the function takes the value irrespective of the choice of ; and as the frequency moves away from the band, the denominator grows without bound, and the function decays monotonically towards zero. We note that the exponent guarantees that the function is symmetric about and remains positive for all arguments. Because the level is attained precisely at the band limits for every admissible , it provides a natural and parameter-independent threshold separating admissible from inadmissible frequencies.
Figure 2. Rational polynomial function: Approximation of the Heaviside function in the frequency-band constraint.
Accordingly, the frequency band constraint (FBC) for the prohibited band is imposed in the standard non-positive form as given in Equation (19):
so that the satisfaction of the constraint requires , which indicates that the eigenfrequencies lie outside , as in Figure 2. Unlike the Heaviside measure, varies continuously with design variables through the eigenfrequencies, and its gradient conveys both the direction and the magnitude of the change required to push a frequency out of the forbidden interval. Applying the constraint to every eigenfrequency would introduce individual constraints and would make the size of the optimization dependent on the number of modes retained. To avoid this, we gathered the contributions of all eigenfrequencies into a single scalar for each band by the p-norm aggregation as in Equation (20):
where denotes the total number of eigenvalues considered in the analysis and is the aggregation parameter. The individual contributions are obtained by evaluating the rational polynomial function at each eigenfrequency with respect to the parameters of the band, leading to an aggregated measure as:
The aggregated measure in Equation (20) approximates the maximum of the individual terms from below and approaches it as increases, so that a single differentiable constraint per band replaces the full set of mode-wise conditions while still being dominated by the most critical eigenfrequency. Since each term is bounded between zero and unity, the aggregated quantity is likewise bounded, which keeps the constraint well scaled throughout the optimization. The two parameters and together determine how closely the smoothed constraint function reproduces the exact exclusion condition. Larger values of steepen the transition at the band edges, and thereby reduce the conservatism introduced by the smoothing; larger values of make aggregated values closer to true maximum at the cost of increased non-linearity of the constraint (see § 5.2 for detailed parameter setup).
Topology optimization for vibration attenuation
Using the proposed interpolation scheme, we introduce three topology optimization formulations for vibration attenuation. The first formulation maximizes the fundamental eigenfrequency, the second maximizes the gap between two adjacent eigenfrequencies, and the third creates a frequency gap within a targeted frequency range.
Maximization of fundamental frequency
The first optimization problem considered in this work aims at finding the material distribution that maximizes the fundamental eigenfrequency of the structure. Such a design is desirable in low-frequency dynamic applications, as a high fundamental frequency shifts the structural response away from low-frequency excitation. The problem is a max-min problem over the initial eigenfrequencies given by Equation (22):
where is the natural frequency, is the volume fraction of the material, and is the prescribed upper bound. The volume fraction of each material is evaluated as the element-wise average of the corresponding material weight:
in which denotes the weight of material in element , obtained from the multi-material interpolation scheme, and is the total number of finite elements in the design domain. We note that Equation (22) is not suited to gradient-based optimization, as the operator is non-differentiable. To overcome this difficulty, we adopt a bound formulation, in which an auxiliary scalar variable is introduced that acts simultaneously as the objective function and as an additional design variable, as in Equation (23):
In this form, the non-smooth operator is replaced by a set of smooth inequality constraints, each of which forces one of the lowest eigenvalues to remain above the bound . Maximizing pushes the lower part of the spectrum upwards, and at convergence, at least one of these constraints is active, so that coincides with the smallest eigenvalue where maximizing the lowest eigenvalue is equivalent to maximizing the fundamental frequency. The quantity is a scaling factor that normalizes the eigenvalue constraints to the order of unity; it is taken as evaluated at the first iteration and kept fixed thereafter.
Another advantage of this formulation is that it prevents mode switching during optimization. Because all lowest modes enter the problem through separate constraints, a change in the ordering of the modes between consecutive iterations does not introduce discontinuity in the objective function. The objective remains smooth, while the reordering is preserved by constraint sets. The optimization therefore remains stable even when repeated or closely spaced eigenvalues occur, where the original max-min statement would fail. Based on the bound variable, the design vector comprises all element-wise design fields of every material together with the scalar :
Maximizing adjacent eigenfrequency gap
The second optimization formulation introduces a different design objective to generate a wide gap between two adjacent eigenfrequencies. Such a frequency gap is of practical interest because excitation frequencies falling inside the gap cannot be matched by any structural mode, so the design becomes effectively insensitive to a range of loading frequencies rather than to one.
Here, denotes the index of the mode below which the gap is to be created, so that the modes constitute the lower eigenfrequency constraints and the modes constitute upper eigenfrequency constraints. Following the same reasoning as in the previous formulation, the non-smooth statement of maximizing is replaced by a smooth formulation in which two auxiliary scalar variables, i.e., and , are introduced and treated simultaneously as parts of the objective and as design variables. The variable acts as an upper bound on the normalized eigenvalues of the lower eigenfrequency constraints, since the first set of constraints forces every with to lie below it, whereas acts as a lower bound on the normalized eigenvalues of the upper constraint, because the second set of constraints forces every with to lie above it. Maximizing the difference simultaneously pushes the lower constraint downwards and the upper constraint upwards.
As in the maximization of fundamental frequency, the eigenvalues are normalized by , which keeps all eigenvalue constraints of the order of unity and permits the side constraints and to be imposed consistently. The remaining constraints include the volume fraction constraints, which limit the amount of each of the materials, and the box constraints on the element-wise design variables. Consequently, the vector of design variables contains all element-wise design variables per material together with the two bound variables:
Maximizing targeted frequency gap
The two aforementioned formulations do not allow the frequency gap to be positioned in a targeted frequency range. In many engineering applications, however, the excitation spectrum is known in advance. Our formulation in this section introduces frequency maximization with an explicit band constraint located at a prescribed interval as in Equation (25):
As in the maximization of fundamental frequency, the bound variable serves simultaneously as the objective function and as an additional design variable. The constraints force every normalized eigenvalue of the modes to remain above it. Maximizing therefore lifts the lower part of the spectrum, while the normalization by keeps the eigenvalue constraints of the order of unity.
In the third constraint, in which denotes the frequency-band constraint associated with the band target. This function is constructed such that it takes a value larger than one half whenever the corresponding eigenfrequency falls inside the target frequency range, and a value smaller than one half when it lies outside. Enforcing for all monitored modes expels the eigenfrequencies from the prescribed interval, and creates a gap located at the targeted spectrum. The design vector for this formulation collects the element-wise design fields of individual materials together with the bound variable.
Design sensitivity derivations
To solve our optimization with a gradient-based optimizer, the sensitivities of the objective and constraint functions need to be provided at each optimization iteration [48], [49], [50]. These sensitivities are derived analytically in the following.
Design sensitivity of material candidates
Sensitivities are obtained by the chain rule, so the gradients of the interpolation weights with respect to design variables need to be derived. We note that the index denotes a design field, , and denotes a material, , while is the penalization exponent of the SIMP interpolation. Because each un-normalized weight is a product of design variables raised to the power , its derivative with respect to a given variable is non-zero when the variable appears in the product, which leads to three distinct cases.
Sensitivity of the first material candidate
The unnormalized weight depends on the first design variable, and its gradient is given by Equation (26):
Sensitivity of intermediate material candidate
The gradient for intermediate materials , depends on two cases. The first case occurs when the design field index is lower than the material index, , the gradient follows Equation (27):
and the second case is that when the design variable index coincides with the material index, i.e., :
Sensitivity of the last material candidate
For the last material, i.e., , the gradient of the unnormalized weight in tensor form is given by Equation (29):
Since the weights used in the interpolation are normalized, the normalized gradient of weights is given by Equation (30):
Sensitivity for fundamental frequency maximization
As the bound formulation introduces an auxiliary variable () alongside the density design variables (), the sensitivities of the objective and constraints must be derived with respect to both sets of variables.
Sensitivity of objective function
Our optimization is posed as a maximization, which is solved using the method of moving asymptotes (MMA). A negative sign is introduced to recast the objective in an equivalent minimization compatible with the MMA framework:
The sensitivity of the objective with respect to the design variables is given by:
Combined sensitivity with respect to design variables and is given by:
Sensitivity of eigenfrequency constraints
Our design variables are modified following the sequence of . We apply the chain rule for sensitivity calculation. After calculating sensitivity with respect to the projected design variables, density filtering is applied using the chain rule. For eigen mode indices ; the eigenfrequency constraint is given by Equation (34):
Its sensitivity is given by:
As the sensitivity follows the chain rule, it is simplified as:
where the first term is further simplified:
where we have and .
Sensitivities of effective material properties are as:
Projection derivative term of Equation (36) is obtained from Equation (6). The term can be calculated through density filtering as:
Sensitivity with respect to the auxiliary variable is:
Final sensitivity is computed by combining Equation (39) and (40) as in Equation (41). When computing sensitivities, filtering and Heaviside projection are applied only to the density design variables, whereas neither filtering nor projection is applied to the auxiliary variables. Sensitivity for the repeated-eigenvalue case is provided in § 4.6.
Sensitivity of volume constraints
Sensitivity to volume constraints for each material is calculated from the material's volume fraction. For material , the volume constraint is given by Equation (42):
The element-wise sensitivity of the volume constraint is given by Equation (43):
which is simplified as Equation (44):
Applying chain rules for projection and density filtering to sensitivity gives Equation (45):
Sensitivity of volume constraint with respect to auxiliary variable is given in Equation (46):
Combining sensitivity with respect to both design variables yields Equation (47):
Sensitivity for adjacent frequency gap maximization
For this formulation, sensitivities of the objective and constraints must be derived with respect to the density design variable () and two auxiliary variables ( and ).
Sensitivity of the objective function
The objective indicates the separation between the two auxiliary variables and is independent of the density design variables, as given by Equation (48):
The sensitivity of the objective function with respect to the respective design variables are given by Equation (49):
where the vanishing derivative with respect to confirms that the material distribution is driven purely by the eigenfrequency bound constraints, whereas the two non-zero sensitivities push upward and downward, widening the gap. Collecting these terms in the order required by the optimizer yields the combined sensitivity:
Sensitivity of lower eigenfrequency constraints
For eigen mode indices , the lower frequency constraint is given by Equation (51):
where the normalization by the reference eigenvalue keeps all constraint values of comparable magnitude. Differentiating Equation (51) with respect to an element density gives:
in which the eigenvalue sensitivity is evaluated exactly as in Equation (36). Sensitivity with respect to auxiliary variables is given by:
Final sensitivity is given by Equation (54):
Sensitivity of upper eigenfrequency constraints
For upper eigenmodes , constraint is given by:
Sensitivity of this upper bound is given by:
where is the same as Equation (36). Sensitivity with respect to auxiliary variables is given by Equation (57):
Final sensitivity is given by:
Sensitivity of volume constraints
Sensitivity of the volume constraint for each material with respect to the density design variables, is the same as Equation (43). Sensitivity of volume constraints with respect to auxiliary variables and is given by Equation (59):
Combining sensitivity with respect to all design variables yields:
Sensitivity for targeted frequency gap
For this formulation, sensitivities of the objective function and constraints must be derived with respect to the density design variable () and one auxiliary variable ().
Sensitivity of the objective function
The objective function for this formulation is defined as:
The sensitivity of the objective function with respect to the respective design variables is given by:
Combined sensitivity with respect to both design variables and is given by Equation (63):
Sensitivity of eigenfrequency constraints
For eigen mode indices , the eigenfrequency constraint is given by Equation (64):
The sensitivity of this constraint is given by Equation (65):
where is the same as Equation (36). Sensitivity with respect to auxiliary variables is given by:
Final sensitivity is given by:
The sensitivity of the volume constraint given in Equation (47) is the same for both the fundamental frequency maximization and the prescribed frequency gap formulations, as they use the same design variables.
Sensitivity for frequency band constraint
The frequency band constraint is imposed, so that no eigenfrequency of the structure is permitted inside a prescribed band. For the band, the constraint is expressed through a rational polynomial function, and is written as:
Sensitivity of the frequency band constraint is given by:
where it is further simplified:
where the terms and are obtained from Equations (20) and (21), respectively. The term in Equation (70) is expanded as:
where is the same as Equation (36). The chain rule for projection and sensitivity is similar to the maximization of fundamental frequency. Sensitivity with respect to auxiliary variables is given by:
The final sensitivity is given by:
Sensitivity for repeated eigenvalues
Mode tracking is generally needed when the optimizer drives multiple eigenfrequencies close. In such scenarios, the standard sensitivity derived for distinct eigenvalues loses validity, as the sensitivity of an eigenvalue would have multiple distinct values (due to the different eigenvectors), as seen in Equation (37). In fact, it is only directionally differentiable, and its derivatives can be extracted from the subspace spanned by associated eigenvectors, as discussed in prior studies [28, 32].
Let a repeated eigenvalue of multiplicity be denoted by , where is the value of the coincident eigenvalues. Since exact coincidence is generally not attained numerically, two eigenvalues are treated as repeated in the present work whenever they satisfy the closeness criterion . This measure is preferred over an absolute one so that the same threshold remains meaningful across the entire spectrum, irrespective of the magnitude of the eigenvalues being compared.
Once a cluster of coincident eigenvalues has been identified, the directional derivatives are obtained by projecting elemental stiffness and mass operators onto corresponding eigenvector subspaces, where the elemental stiffness and mass perturbation matrices are assembled as:
in which and are the restrictions of the th and th eigenvectors of the repeated set to the degrees of freedom of element , and and are the corresponding elemental stiffness and mass matrices. Both and are symmetric matrices of order , and they describe how a perturbation of element redistributes energy within the degenerate subspace. Combining the two elemental perturbation matrices gives the perturbation matrix associated with the repeated eigenvalue:
We note that we can compute the eigenvectors () from the reduced matrix that spans the subspace of repeated eigenvalues, and define the directions within the degenerate subspace along which repeated eigenvalues split under an infinitesimal design perturbation. The vectors restore a well-defined, unique set of directional derivatives.
The sensitivity of each eigenvalue of the cluster with respect to the projected design variable follows the chain rule through the effective material properties:
where the stiffness and mass contributions are given by:
Finally, the sensitivity is propagated backwards through the projection and filtering operations to compute physical design variables as:
For the perturbation matrices reduce to scalars, becomes unity, and Equations (76)–(77) collapse exactly to the classical sensitivity expression for a simple eigenvalue. Treating repeated eigenvalues in this manner suppresses oscillatory behavior and mode-switching that otherwise occur when eigenfrequencies cross during optimization iterations and thereby improves convergence stability.
Numerical implementations
Our proposed multi-material topology optimization is implemented in three optimization formulations and validated by multiple numerical experiments, including maximization of the fundamental frequency, maximization of the gap between two adjacent eigenfrequencies, and the creation of frequency gaps within a targeted frequency range. The MATLAB implementation was developed with reference to the 99-line [43] and 88-line [51] topology optimization codes and univariate mapping-based code [36], with necessary modifications to accommodate the proposed multi-material interpolation scheme and eigenfrequency-based optimization formulations. All the numerical studies were implemented in MATLAB R2025b and executed on a workstation equipped with an Intel Core i7-11700K CPU @ 2.50 GHz and 16 GB of RAM.
Material properties
We define the material properties in Table 1 for the sets of three, four, five, and seven candidate materials, respectively. Young’s modulus and mass density are uniformly spaced over MPa and kgm, respectively, and Poisson’s ratio is fixed at . In all four material sets, we assume that the stiffest material has the highest density, and the most compliant material has the lowest density. We note that these two extreme materials have the same stiffness-to-density ratio, i.e., in every example. Because materials of the extreme properties are identical across experiments, differences in optimized designs can be attributed
| Number of materials | Material properties | Material1 (M1) | Material2 (M2) | Material3 (M3) | Material4 (M4) | Material5 (M5) | Material6 (M6) | Material7 (M7) |
| Three materials | Modulus of Elasticity (MPa) | 10 | 5.050 | 1 | - | - | - | - |
| Three materials | Density (Kg/m) | 1 | 0.550 | 0.100 | - | - | - | - |
| Four materials | Modulus of Elasticity (MPa) | 10 | 6.700 | 3.400 | 1 | - | - | - |
| Four materials | Density (Kg/m) | 1 | 0.700 | 0.400 | 0.100 | - | - | - |
| Five materials | Modulus of Elasticity (MPa) | 10 | 7.525 | 5.050 | 2.575 | 1 | - | - |
| Five materials | Density (Kg/m) | 1 | 0.775 | 0.55 | 0.325 | 0.100 | - | - |
| Seven materials | Modulus of Elasticity (MPa) | 10 | 8.350 | 6.700 | 5.050 | 3.400 | 1.750 | 1 |
| Seven materials | Density (Kg/m) | 1 | 0.850 | 0.700 | 0.550 | 0.400 | 0.250 | 0.100 |
Table 1. Material properties of candidate materials (Poisson's ratio for all materials)
to the number and distribution of the materials of intermediate properties which have a lower stiffness-to-density ratio than the extreme materials. We note that the properties listed in the table serve as numerical test cases and do not represent real engineering materials.
Experiment parameter setup
For implementation, the following parameters are adopted to obtain well-defined optimized topologies.
Penalization power: For all numerical examples, the penalization powers for both the stiffness and mass matrices are initially set to 1.0 and are subsequently updated every 25 iterations by a factor of 1.2 until reaching a maximum value of 5.0. If mod (loop, 25) = 0, update .
Initial design variable: For all examples, the initial value of design variables per element is set to 0.5. For example, the initial value for the three-material example is set as and for four-material as .
Scalar variable : For the pinned beam example, the scalar variable in the maximization of fundamental frequency (maximization of fundamental frequency) is initialized to 5000 with bounds defined as . In the maximization of the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies, the scalar variables and are initialized with 0.4 and 0.6, respectively, with bounds . In frequency gap generation between the targeted range, the scalar is initialized to 0.5 with bounds of . The scalar variable used for the square plate and C-clamp examples is described in § 6.4 and § 7, respectively.
Filter radius: For the pinned beam example, the filter radius in the maximization of fundamental frequency is set to 8.0 for the five-material case and 7.0 for the seven-material design case. In maximizing the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies, the filter radius is set to 7.0 for both the three-material and four-material cases. For creating a gap between the targeted frequency range, the filter radius is chosen as 7.0 for both single and double FBC. To obtain optimized topologies, different filter radii are adopted. The filter radius used for the square plate and C-clamp examples is described in § 6.4 and § 7, respectively.
Projection parameter: For the pinned beam example, the projection parameter () is initially set to 1.0 for all three formulations. In the maximization of fundamental frequency, for the five-material design case, the projection parameter is increased by a factor of 3 to 32, then by a factor of 1.5 every 25 iterations until reaching 300, i.e.,
else .
For the seven-material design case, the projection parameter is increased by a factor of 1.5 every 25 iterations, reaching a maximum of 300. For maximization of the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies, the projection parameter is increased by a factor of 1.5 to 32, then by a factor of 3 every 25 iterations until reaching a maximum value of 300. To create a gap between the targeted range, it is increased by 1.5 times every 25 iterations until reaching a maximum value of 300. The projection parameter update schemes adopted for the square plate and C-clamp examples are described in § 6.4 and § 7, respectively.
FBC steepness parameter: For all three numerical examples, to apply the frequency band constraint, the projection parameter () of the Heaviside function is increased by a factor of 1 every 25 iterations until it reaches a maximum of 32, i.e., if mod (loop, 25) = 0, update .
Projection threshold: For all numerical examples, the threshold value of the projection function is taken as 0.5.
P-norm parameter: For all numerical examples, the parameter in the p-norm approximation for the maximum functions is set to 40.
Number of eigenfrequency modes: For all examples, the number of eigenmodes considered in the analysis is 6.
Volume fractions: For maximization of both fundamental frequency and gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies, the volume fraction of the stiffest material is set to 0.3, while the remaining volume is distributed equally among the other materials. For creating gap between the targeted frequency range, the volume fractions of all materials are identical.
Stopping criteria: For all examples, the optimization is terminated once the objective function shows no further change between successive iterations and the continuation parameter has reached its maximum value.
Optimization algorithm
We adopt MMA [52] in our topology optimization. The complete procedure is summarized in Algorithm 1.
Algorithm 1: Multi-material topology optimization for dynamic vibration attenuation
Inputs: number of candidate materials ; material data , ; mesh data; number of eigenmodes to compute ; maximum number of iterations .
Output: optimized design variables .
Initialization: ; loop ;
, , ▷ filter radius, projection and P-norm parameters
initialize MMA parameters
while loop do
▷ element-wise design fields
▷ finite element analysis
solve ,
evaluate objective and sensitivity:
evaluate constraints and sensitivities:
▷ update design variables
▷ continuation scheme
If loop & then
converged true ▷ check convergence
end
loop loop
end while
return
Numerical examples
To validate the proposed method, three numerical examples are presented, including a pinned vibrating beam, a square plate, and a C-clamp. For all examples, the candidate materials and their corresponding properties, including Young's modulus, density, and Poisson's ratio, are listed in Table 1.
Vibrating beam
In this study, a two-dimensional beam with dimensions 8 m 1 m is considered (see Figure 3), where the midpoint of both ends of the beam is fixed. The design domain is discretized into 40050 finite elements.

Figure 3. Boundary condition of the pinned vibrating beam
Maximum fundamental frequency
In this example, the objective is to maximize the fundamental eigenfrequency. The evolution of the fundamental frequency over the optimization by five material candidates is shown in Figure 4(c). The maximum fundamental eigenfrequency attained is 167 rad/s. The corresponding material distribution is presented in Figure 4(d), where color bar denotes the materials ordered from the stiffest and densest (M1) to the least stiff and dense (M5).
Figure 4. Comparison of fundamental eigenfrequency maximization with five candidate materials. (a) Convergence history of the fundamental eigenfrequency of the ordered SIMP interpolation, (b) optimized multi-material design, (c) convergence history of the fundamental eigenfrequency of the proposed multivariate weight-based interpolation, and (d) optimized multi-material design.
To assess the performance of the proposed framework, results are compared with those obtained using the ordered SIMP scheme [35]. The ordered SIMP interpolation was originally developed for compliance minimization problems; however, for a fair comparison, it is extended here to the eigenfrequency maximization problem. The convergence history and the optimized topologies are shown in Figure 4. Both methods converge rapidly and yield similar layered material distributions (Figure 4(b) and Figure 4(d)), while our method achieves a slightly higher fundamental eigenfrequency of 167 rad/s, compared with 166 rad/s for the ordered SIMP method as seen in Figure 4(a) and Figure 4(c).
The beam is further optimized using seven candidate materials. As shown in Figure 5(a), the convergence is similar to that of the five-material case, with a maximum fundamental eigenfrequency of 166 rad/s. This indicates that increasing the number of candidate materials does not necessarily result in a higher fundamental eigenfrequency. The material distribution is presented in Figure 5(b).

Figure 5. Fundamental eigenfrequency maximization with seven candidate materials: (a) convergence of the fundamental eigenfrequency and (b) multi-material design.
We note that the maximization of the fundamental eigenfrequency is governed by the Rayleigh quotient, i.e., , in which the numerator represents the modal strain energy and the denominator represents the modal kinetic energy. The eigenvalue sensitivity in Equation (79) with respect to the design variable indicates that the increase in stiffness raises the eigenvalue if the resulting gain in strain energy exceeds times the accompanying gain in kinetic energy.
We find that the optimization tends to assign the stiffest and densest material to regions with high modal strain energy. Conversely, the least stiff and dense material is retained in the interior region, where reducing mass is more beneficial than increasing stiffness.
Gap maximization between adjacent eigenfrequencies
In this formulation, the objective is to maximize the frequency gap between the third and fourth eigenfrequencies. Figure 6(a) and Figure 7(a) present the evolution of the two bounding eigenfrequencies over the optimization history for the three- and four-material cases, respectively. In both cases, the gap widens, i.e., the third eigenfrequency moves downward while the fourth is driven upward. The optimized gaps obtained are 847 rad/s for the three-material design and 800 rad/s for the four-material design, as shown in Figure 6(b) and Figure 7(b).

Figure 6. Gap maximization of adjacent eigenfrequencies with three candidate materials: (a) convergence history of the eigenfrequency gap, and (b) multi-material design.

Figure 7. Gap maximization of adjacent eigenfrequencies with four candidate materials: (a) convergence history of the eigenfrequency gap, and (b) optimized multi-material design.
The topologies differ from those obtained in the preceding formulation. In particular, the stiffest and densest material is no longer concentrated in the regions adjacent to the support regions. The difference stems from the objective, which is governed not by a single eigenmode, but by the relative positions of two adjacent modes. Material layout is dictated by the difference between the modal energy distributions of the third and fourth modes.
We show the first six mode shapes of the four-material design in Figure 8, where colorbars represent mass-normalized displacement magnitudes. We note that modes , , , and are transverse bending modes, and mode is a longitudinal (axial) mode, in which the beam stays essentially straight and moves along its axis. Unlike the global bending modes , and , modes and are localized near the supports, where the end segments deflect significantly.

Figure 8. Vibrational eigenmodes: First six eigenmodes of the four-material pinned beam obtained from eigenfrequency-gap maximization in § 6.2.
Creating a gap between targeted frequency range
Unlike the preceding formulations, in which the target eigenfrequencies are identified by their modal index, this formulation imposes a frequency-band constraint that prevents any natural frequency of the structure from lying within a user-specified operating range, thereby creating a gap over that range. The proposed rational polynomial function is employed to approximate the Heaviside function to avoid non-differentiability in the FBC formulation for gradient-based optimization. Two cases are considered. The first involves a single operating range of [500, 1000] rad/s, and the second considers two different operating ranges of [300, 500] rad/s and [700, 1000] rad/s. In both cases, the structure must be designed such that none of its natural frequencies lies within the prescribed intervals.
Design for a single frequency range
We start by designing with three candidate materials, such that all natural frequencies are outside the prescribed frequency interval of [500, 1000] rad/s. The resulting eigenfrequencies are reported in Table 2, the convergence history in Figure 9(a), and the corresponding material distribution in Figure 9(b), respectively. The attained gap slightly exceeds the prescribed interval, which is attributable to the approximation error of the -norm aggregation.
| Eigenmode index () | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
| Single FBC, (rad/s) | 133 | 335 | 1000 | 1001 | 1086 | 1386 |
| Double FBC, (rad/s) | 133 | 258 | 605 | 629 | 700 | 1011 |
Table 2. First six eigenfrequencies () of the three-material beam by excluding natural frequencies from a single targeted frequency range of [500, 1000] rad/s and from two targeted frequency ranges of [300, 500] and [700, 1000] rad/s

Figure 9. Targeted frequency gap for a three-material beam: (a) convergence of the frequency gap and (b) optimized multi-material design.
Design for two frequency ranges
In this case, the structure is designed to create frequency gaps over two disjoint operating ranges, rad/s and rad/s. The frequency-band constraint is accordingly extended to act on both intervals, so that no eigenfrequency is admitted into either gap. The resulting eigenfrequencies for the three-material design are reported in Table 2, the convergence in Figure 10(a), and material distributions in Figure 10(b), respectively.

Figure 10. Two targeted frequency gaps: (a) convergence of the frequency gap, and (b) optimized multi-material design.
The convergence history shows minor variation in the eigenfrequencies during the initial iterations, followed by a sharp drop in eigenfrequencies at the 150th iteration, caused by the update of the continuation parameters; thereafter, the spectrum stabilizes rapidly and satisfies the frequency-band constraints for both intervals. It is noted that the transition occurs earlier than in a single frequency band, which is consistent with the additional constraint acting to drive the design away from the initial configuration at an earlier stage of the optimization.
Square plate design
A two-dimensional square plate with dimensions of 1 m × 1 m is shown in Figure 11, with all four corner points fixed. The design domain is discretized using 200×200 finite elements. The continuation for the projection parameter is adjusted to obtain optimized topologies with minimal intermediate-density regions. The initial value of is set to 2 for the maximization of fundamental frequency and 1 for maximizing the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies and creating a gap between the targeted eigenfrequency range. In the maximization of fundamental frequency, is increased by a factor of 3 until it reaches 32, and thereafter by a factor of 1.5 every 25 iterations up to a maximum value of 300. In maximizing gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies, is increased by a factor of 1.5 every 25 iterations until it reaches 300. In creating a gap between the targeted frequency range, is increased by a factor of 1.5 until it reaches 32, and then by a factor of 3 every 25 iterations up to 300. In addition, the filter radius is set to 8 for all three formulations. The scalar variable in the maximization of fundamental frequency is initialized to 5000, with bounds . In maximizing the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies, scalar variables and are initialized with 0.4 and 0.6, respectively, with bounds . To create a gap between the targeted range, the variable is initialized to 0.5 with bounds of .

Figure 11. Square plate: boundary condition and design domain.
Maximum fundamental frequency
In this numerical example, the fundamental eigenfrequency of a two-dimensional square plate is maximized, and the optimized material distribution for the five-material case is presented in Figure 12(b). As in the pinned beam example, the stiffest and densest material concentrates near the supports. The convergence history is shown in Figure 12(a).
Figure 12. Fundamental eigenfrequency maximization with five candidate materials: (a) convergence history of the fundamental eigenfrequency and (b) optimized multi-material design.
The convergence history shows minor variation in the eigenfrequencies during the initial iterations, followed by a sharp
Maximum gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies
In this numerical example, gap maximization between adjacent eigenfrequencies is applied to the square plate to maximize the gap between the third and fourth eigenfrequencies, and a maximized frequency gap of 8,499 rad/s is obtained for the five-material case. The convergence history in Figure 13(a) shows that the gap is opened through a reduction of the lower eigenfrequencies. The first three eigenfrequencies decrease gradually up to approximately the 150th iteration, undergo a pronounced drop thereafter, and subsequently stabilize at values close to the lower bound of the spectrum, whereas the fourth and higher eigenfrequencies vary only slightly throughout the optimization. The material distribution is presented in Figure 13(b), in which the candidate materials are placed about the center of the domain.
Figure 13. Maximizing the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies with five candidate materials: (a) convergence history of the eigenfrequency gap, and (b) optimized multi-material design.
Creating the gap between targeted frequency range
In this study, a single operating frequency range of [2000, 10000] rad/s is considered for the square plate. The resulting eigenfrequencies for the five-material design are reported in Table 3, and the convergence history is shown in Figure 14(a), from which a clear frequency gap is observed. The corresponding optimized material distribution is presented in Figure 14(b), where materials form concentric layers ordered from the stiffest material at the center to the least dense one at the boundary.
| Mode () | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
| (rad/s) | 1804 | 1804.5 | 1805 | 9992 | 9994 | 10799 |
Table 3. First six eigenfrequencies () of five-material square plate design by excluding natural frequencies from a single targeted frequency range of [2000, 10000] rad/s

Figure 14. Targeted frequency gap with five candidate materials: (a) convergence history of the frequency gap and (b) optimized multi-material design.
C-clamp design
We design a C-clamp of non-rectangular geometry in this section, as shown in Figure 15, in which the right arms are fixed. The design domain is discretized using finite elements of size . The three optimization formulations are considered. As in the previous examples, a continuation strategy is applied to the projection parameter to obtain optimized topologies with minimal intermediate-density regions. The initial value of is set to 1 for all three formulations. In maximization of both fundamental frequency and gap of adjacent eigenfrequencies, is increased by a factor of 3 until it reaches 32, and thereafter by a factor of 1.5 every 25 iterations up to a maximum value of 300. In creating a gap between the targeted frequency range, is increased by a factor of 1.5 until it reaches 32, and then by a factor of 3 every 25 iterations up to 300. In addition, the filter radius is set to 8 for all three formulations. The variable in the maximization of fundamental frequency is initialized to 5000, with bounds . In maximizing the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies, the scalar variables and are initialized with 0.4 and 0.6, respectively, with bounds . To create a gap between the targeted frequency range, the variable is initialized to 0.5 with bounds of .

Figure 15. Boundary condition and geometry of C-clamp.
Maximum fundamental frequency
The fundamental eigenfrequency is maximized for a 2D C-clamp, and the optimized material distribution for the five-material case is presented in Figure 16(b). The convergence history is shown in Figure 16(a).
Figure 16. Figure 16 Fundamental eigenfrequency maximization with five candidate materials: (a) convergence history of the fundamental eigenfrequency and (b) optimized multi-material design.
Maximum gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies
In this numerical example, gap maximization between adjacent eigenfrequencies is applied to the C-clamp in order to maximize the gap between the third and fourth eigenfrequencies, and a maximized frequency gap of 16285 rad/s is obtained for the five-material case. The convergence history in Figure 17(a) indicates that the gap is opened predominantly through a reduction of the third eigenfrequency rather than an elevation of the fourth. The optimized material distribution is presented in Figure 17(b). The layout is symmetric about the horizontal midplane. Unlike the maximization of the first eigenfrequency, the objective is to increase the fourth eigenfrequency while decreasing the third, widening the frequency gap between them.
Figure 17. Figure 17 Maximizing the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies with five candidate materials: (a) convergence history of the eigenfrequency gap and (b) optimized multi-material design.
Creating gaps between targeted frequency ranges
A single frequency gap of rad/s is considered. The resulting eigenfrequencies for the five-material configuration are reported in Table 4, and the convergence history is shown in Figure 18(a), from which a clear frequency gap spanning the interval rad/s is observed. The optimized material distribution is presented in Figure 18(b).
| Mode () | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 |
| (rad/s) | 4124 | 10332 | 24472 | 24725 | 25992 | 30637 |
Table 4. First six eigenfrequencies () of five-material C-clamp obtained by excluding natural frequencies from a single targeted frequency range of rad/s

Figure 18. Targeted frequency gap with five candidate materials: (a) convergence history of the frequency gap and (b) optimized multi-material design.
Conclusions
This study presented a novel MMTO framework with multivariate weight-based interpolation for structural vibration attenuation. Specifically, we developed three optimization formulations for multi-material designs: maximization of the fundamental eigenfrequency, maximization of the frequency gap between adjacent eigenmodes, and exclusion of natural frequencies from a prescribed interval, where we adopted an auxiliary scalar design variable within a bound formulation to replace direct minimum and maximum objective functions with individual eigenvalue constraints. We observed that the three formulations produced distinct structural dynamic responses in numerical experiments. By fundamental-eigenfrequency maximization, we increase the lowest natural frequency and thereby delay the onset of the first structural resonance. Through adjacent-frequency-gap maximization, we tailored material distribution to separate targeted neighboring eigenfrequencies and enlarge their interval. Through frequency-band constraint, natural frequencies were shifted outside a prescribed operating interval, thereby avoiding structural resonances, where we proposed a new rational polynomial function for smooth approximation of discontinuous frequency-band constraints to enable sensitivity evaluation.
Future work will extend the proposed framework toward programmable vibration attenuation, where structural dynamic characteristics can be adjusted in response to external stimuli. It may also be extended to the design of multi-material metamaterials and periodic structures for vibration and wave attenuation. Further developments toward multiphysics applications, including coupled mechanical, thermal, acoustic, or electromechanical systems, would broaden the applicability of the proposed approach to more complex engineering systems.
Acknowledgements
The authors would also like to thank the constructive suggestions from anonymous reviewers. The authors would like to thank discussions with Dr. Behzad Rankouhi from the University of Minnesota, Dr. Cheng Huang from the University of Kansas, and Dr. Nathan Hertlein from Air Force Research Laboratory. The authors would like to thank Prof. Krister Svanberg for the MATLAB codes for the MMA optimizer. Shiguang Deng would like to thank the support of the Faculty Startup Grant, the New Faculty Research Development Grant, and the General Research Grant from the University of Kansas.
Replication of results
The results presented should be reproducible through the implementation of the methodologies described in this publication.
Ethics approval and Consent to participate
Not applicable.
Data availability
All data involved are included in the paper.
Conflict of interest
No competing financial or non-financial interests.
References
- [1]S. S. Rao, Mechanical vibrations, 5th ed. Upper Saddle River, N.J: Prentice Hall, 2011.
- [2]S. Zargham, T. A. Ward, R. Ramli, and I. A. Badruddin, “Topology optimization: a review for structural designs under vibration problems,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 53, no. 6, pp. 1157–1177, Jun. 2016, doi: 10.1007/s00158-015-1370-5.DOI
- [3]A. Zhu, X. Gong, J. Zhou, X. Zhang, and D. Zhang, “Efficient Vibration Measurement and Modal Shape Visualization Based on Dynamic Deviations of Structural Edge Profiles,” Sensors, vol. 24, no. 13, p. 4413, Jul. 2024, doi: 10.3390/s24134413.DOI
- [4]Q. Li, Q. Wu, S. Dou, J. Wang, S. Liu, and W. Chen, “Nonlinear eigenvalue topology optimization for structures with frequency-dependent material properties,” R. Palej and A. Krowiak, “MODAL ANALYSIS OF MULTI-DEGREE-OF-FREEDOM SYSTEMS WITH REPEATED FREQUENCIES – ANALYTICAL APPROACH”.
- [6]B. B. Chaudhary, B. Chhntyal, and M. C. Luintel, “Transient response analysis of simply supported Pelton turbine during starting and shutdown,” Jnl Innov. Engin. Educ., vol. 7, no. 1, pp. 124–130, Dec. 2024, doi: 10.3126/jiee.v7i1.72340.DOI
- [7]C. Beards, Structural Vibration: Analysis and Damping. London : New York: Butterworth-Heinemann, 1996.
- [8]A. Molter, J. S. O. Fonseca, and L. D. S. Fernandez, “Simultaneous topology optimization of structure and piezoelectric actuators distribution,” Applied Mathematical Modelling, vol. 40, no. 9–10, pp. 5576–5588, May 2016, doi: 10.1016/j.apm.2016.01.023.DOI
- [9]Y. Maeda, S. Nishiwaki, K. Izui, M. Yoshimura, K. Matsui, and K. Terada, “Structural topology optimization of vibrating structures with specified eigenfrequencies and eigenmode shapes,” Numerical Meth Engineering, vol. 67, no. 5, pp. 597–628, Jul. 2006, doi: 10.1002/nme.1626.DOI
- [10]Z. Meng, G. Yang, Q. Wu, S. Xiao, and Q. Li, “Reliability-based topology optimization for fundamental frequency maximization with frequency band constraints,” Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, vol. 195, p. 110295, Jul. 2023, doi: 10.1016/j.ymssp.2023.110295.DOI
- [11]S. Deng and K. Suresh, “Topology optimization under thermo-elastic buckling,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 55, no. 5, pp. 1759–1772, May 2017, doi: 10.1007/s00158-016-1611-2.DOI
- [12]S. Deng and K. Suresh, “Stress constrained thermo-elastic topology optimization with varying temperature fields via augmented topological sensitivity based level-set,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 56, no. 6, pp. 1413–1427, Dec. 2017, doi: 10.1007/s00158-017-1732-2.DOI
- [13]S. Deng and K. Suresh, “Multi-constrained topology optimization via the topological sensitivity,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 51, no. 5, pp. 987–1001, May 2015, doi: 10.1007/s00158-014-1188-6.DOI
- [14]S. Deng and K. Suresh, “Multi-constrained 3D topology optimization via augmented topological level-set,” Computers & Structures, vol. 170, pp. 1–12, Jul. 2016, doi: 10.1016/j.compstruc.2016.02.009.DOI
- [15]M. P. Bendsøe and N. Kikuchi, “Generating optimal topologies in structural design using a homogenization method,” Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 71, no. 2, pp. 197–224, Nov. 1988, doi: 10.1016/0045-7825(88)90086-2.DOI
- [16]M. P. Bendsøe, “Optimal shape design as a material distribution problem,” Structural optimization, vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 193–202, Dec. 1989, doi: 10.1007/BF01650949.DOI
- [17]M. Zhou and G. I. N. Rozvany, “The COC algorithm, Part II: Topological, geometrical and generalized shape optimization,” Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 89, no. 1–3, pp. 309–336, Aug. 1991, doi: 10.1016/0045-7825(91)90046-9.DOI
- [18]Y. M. Xie and G. P. Steven, “A simple evolutionary procedure for structural optimization,” Computers & Structures, vol. 49, no. 5, pp. 885–896, Dec. 1993, doi: 10.1016/0045-7949(93)90035-C.DOI
- [19]G. Allaire, F. Jouve, and A.-M. Toader, “Structural optimization using sensitivity analysis and a level-set method,” Journal of Computational Physics, vol. 194, no. 1, pp. 363–393, Feb. 2004, doi: 10.1016/j.jcp.2003.09.032.DOI
- [20]M. Y. Wang, X. Wang, and D. Guo, “A level set method for structural topology optimization,” Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 192, no. 1–2, pp. 227–246, Jan. 2003, doi: 10.1016/S0045-7825(02)00559-5.DOI
- [21]W. Zhang, J. Yuan, J. Zhang, and X. Guo, “A new topology optimization approach based on Moving Morphable Components (MMC) and the ersatz material model,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 53, no. 6, pp. 1243–1260, Jun. 2016, doi: 10.1007/s00158-015-1372-3.DOI
- [22]H. Smith and J. Norato, “Topology optimization of structures made of fiber-reinforced plates,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 65, no. 2, p. 58, Feb. 2022, doi: 10.1007/s00158-021-03164-y.DOI
- [23]S. Y. Wang and K. Tai, “Structural topology design optimization using Genetic Algorithms with a bit-array representation,” Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 194, no. 36–38, pp. 3749–3770, Sep. 2005, doi: 10.1016/j.cma.2004.09.003.DOI
- [24]I. Pehnec, D. Sedlar, I. Marinić-Kragic, and D. Vučina, “A New Approach to Topology Optimization with Genetic Algorithm and Parameterization Level Set Function,” Computation, vol. 13, no. 7, p. 153, Jun. 2025, doi: 10.3390/computation13070153.DOI
- [25]J. Du and N. Olhoff, “Topological design of freely vibrating continuum structures for maximum values of simple and multiple eigenfrequencies and frequency gaps,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 34, no. 2, pp. 91–110, Jun. 2007, doi: 10.1007/s00158-007-0101-y.DOI
- [26]A. R. Díaz and N. Kikuchi, “Solutions to shape and topology eigenvalue optimization problems using a homogenization method,” International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, vol. 35, no. 7, pp. 1487–1502, Oct. 1992, doi: 10.1002/nme.1620350707.
- [27]Z.-D. Ma, N. Kikuchi, and H.-C. Cheng, “Topological design for vibrating structures,” Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 121, no. 1–4, pp. 259–280, Mar. 1995, doi: 10.1016/0045-7825(94)00714-X.DOI
- [28]A. P. Seyranian, E. Lund, and N. Olhoff, “Multiple eigenvalues in structural optimization problems,” Structural Optimization, vol. 8, no. 4, pp. 207–227, Dec. 1994, doi: 10.1007/BF0142705.DOI
- [29]N. L. Pedersen, “Maximization of eigenvalues using topology optimization,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 2–11, Aug. 2000, doi: 10.1007/s001580050130.DOI
- [30]L. Xue, G. Wen, H. Wang, and J. Liu, “Eigenvectors-guided topology optimization to control the mode shape and suppress the vibration of the multi-material plate,”
- [31]Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, vol. 170, p. 108835, May 2022, doi: 10.1016/j.ymssp.2022.108835. T. Liu, J.-H. Zhu, F. He, H. Zhao, Q. Liu, and C. Yang, “A MAC based excitation frequency increasing method for structural topology optimization under harmonic excitations,” Int. J. Simul. Multisc. Des. Optim., vol. 8, p. A4, 2017, doi: 10.1051/smdo/2016012.
- [32]Q. Li, Q. Wu, J. Liu, J. He, and S. Liu, “Topology optimization of vibrating structures with frequency band constraints,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 63, no. 3, pp. 1203–1218, Mar. 2021, doi: 10.1007/s00158-020-02753-7.DOI
- [33]L. Yin and G. K. Ananthasuresh, “Topology optimization of compliant mechanisms with multiple materials using a peak function material interpolation scheme,” Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimization, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 49–62, Dec. 2001, doi: 10.1007/s00158-001-0165-z.DOI
- [34]C. F. Hvejsel and E. Lund, “Material interpolation schemes for unified topology and multi-material optimization,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 811–825, Jun. 2011, doi: 10.1007/s00158-011-0625-z.
- [35]W. Zuo and K. Saitou, “Multi-material topology optimization using ordered SIMP interpolation,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 55, no. 2, pp. 477–491, Feb. 2017, doi: 10.1007/s00158-016-1513-3.DOI
- [36]W. Ding, “An easy-to-use univariate mapping-based method for multi-material topology optimization with implementation in MATLAB,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 68, no. 3, p. 48, Mar. 2025, doi: 10.1007/s00158-025-03983-3.DOI
- [37]M. Y. Wang and X. Wang, “‘Color’ level sets: a multi-phase method for structural topology optimization with multiple materials,” Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 193, no. 6–8, pp. 469–496, Feb. 2004, doi: 10.1016/j.cma.2003.10.008.DOI
- [38]R. Tavakoli, “Multimaterial topology optimization by volume constrained Allen–Cahn system and regularized projected steepest descent method,” Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 276, pp. 534–565, Jul. 2014, doi: 10.1016/j.cma.2014.04.005.DOI
- [39]S. Zhou and M. Y. Wang, “Multimaterial structural topology optimization with a generalized Cahn–Hilliard model of multiphase transition,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 33, no. 2, pp. 89–111, Dec. 2006, doi: 10.1007/s00158-006-0035-9.DOI
- [40]J. P. Blasques, “Multi-material topology optimization of laminated composite beams with eigenfrequency constraints,” Composite Structures, vol. 111, pp. 45–55, May 2014, doi: 10.1016/j.compstruct.2013.12.021.DOI
- [41]M.-N. Nguyen and D. Lee, “Improving the performance of a multi-material topology optimization model involving stress and dynamic constraints,” Composite Structures, vol. 324, p. 117532, Nov. 2023, doi: 10.1016/j.compstruct.2023.117532.DOI
- [42]M. Zhou, Y. K. Shyy, and H. L. Thomas, “Checkerboard and minimum member size control in topology optimization,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 152–158, Apr. 2001, doi: 10.1007/s001580050179.
- [43]O. Sigmund, “A 99 line topology optimization code written in Matlab,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 120–127, Apr. 2001, doi: 10.1007/s001580050176.DOI
- [44]F. Wang, B. S. Lazarov, and O. Sigmund, “On projection methods, convergence and robust formulations in topology optimization,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 43, no. 6, pp. 767–784, Jun. 2011, doi: 10.1007/s00158-010-0602-y.DOI
- [45]J. K. Guest, A. Asadpoure, and S.-H. Ha, “Eliminating beta-continuation from Heaviside projection and density filter algorithms,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 44, no. 4, pp. 443–453, Oct. 2011, doi: 10.1007/s00158-011-0676-1.DOI
- [46]T. Borrvall and J. Petersson, “Topology optimization using regularized intermediate density control,” Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, vol. 190, no. 37–38, pp. 4911–4928, Jun. 2001, doi: 10.1016/S0045-7825(00)00356-X.DOI
- [47]O. Sigmund and J. Petersson, “Numerical instabilities in topology optimization: A survey on procedures dealing with checkerboards, mesh-dependencies and local minima,” Structural Optimization, vol. 16, no. 1, pp. 68–75, Aug. 1998, doi: 10.1007/BF01211402.DOI
- [48]S. Deng, “Augmented Topological Level-Set for Large-Scale Thermo-Elastic Topology Optimization”.
- [49]S. Deng, K. Suresh, and J. Joo, “Stress-Constrained Thermo-Elastic Topology Optimization: A Topological Sensitivity Approach,” in Volume 1A: 34th Computers and Information in Engineering Conference, Buffalo, New York, USA: American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Aug. 2014, p. V01AT02A015. doi: 10.1115/DETC2014-34385.DOI
- [50]S. Deng and K. Suresh, “Topology Optimization Under Linear Thermo-Elastic Buckling,” in Volume 1A: 36th Computers and Information in Engineering Conference, Charlotte, North Carolina, USA: American Society of Mechanical Engineers, Aug. 2016, p. V01AT02A029. doi: 10.1115/DETC2016-59408.DOI
- [51]E. Andreassen, A. Clausen, M. Schevenels, B. S. Lazarov, and O. Sigmund, “Efficient topology optimization in MATLAB using 88 lines of code,” Struct Multidisc Optim, vol. 43, no. 1, pp. 1–16, Jan. 2011, doi: 10.1007/s00158-010-0594-7.DOI
- [52]K. Svanberg, “The method of moving asymptotes—a new method for structural optimization,” Numerical Meth Engineering, vol. 24, no. 2, pp. 359–373, Feb. 1987, doi: 10.1002/nme.1620240207.DOI







