betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Non Nucleonic Components in Short Nuclear Distances

Abstract

One of the important features of nuclear forces is their strong repulsive nature at short (≤0.5−0.6\le 0.5-0.6~Fm) distances which prevents atomic nuclei from collapsing, thus guarantying the stability for the visible matter. However the dynamical nature of this repulsion (referred to as a nuclear core) is as elusive as ever. We present the study of nuclear dynamics at extremely large internal momenta in the deuteron dominated by the nuclear core. It is demonstrated that the paradigm shift in the description of the deuteron consisting of proton and neutron to the description of the deuteron as a pseudo-vector composite system in which proton and neutron is observed in high energy electro-disintegration processes results in the emergence of a new structure. We demonstrate that this new structure can exist only if it emerges from pre-existing non-nucleonic component in the deuteron. The study of the dynamics of the predicted new structure is presented focusing on the question if it allows to understand the anomaly observed in the recent experiment at Jefferson Lab that probed deuteron structure at internal momenta above 800 MeV/c.

Introduction

Understanding the dynamics of the transition between hadronic to quark-gluon phases is one of the outstanding issues in strong interaction physics. For cold dense nuclear matter such transitions are relevant for the dynamics that can exist at the cores of neutron stars and can set the limits for the matter density before it collapses to the black hole. There are few options to investigate such transitions in terrestrial experiments These include studying nuclear medium modification of quark-gluon structure of bound nucleons in semi-inclusive processes which allow to control inter-nucleon distances[1] or probing deep inelastic scattering from nuclear target at Bjorken x>1x > 1[2, 3, 4].

Another venue in exploration of non-nucleonic components in nuclei is the probing the nuclear repulsive core. The nuclear repulsive core is a unique property of nuclear forces that keeps nuclei from collapsing and provides condition for the nuclear density to saturate. Its dynamics is still elusive, however QCD gives a new perspective on the dynamical origin of the nuclear core. In the NN\mathit{NN} system at very short distances the QCD predicts the existence of substantial component due to non-nucleonic ΔΔ\Delta\Delta as well as hidden color components[5, 6] that contribute almost 90% of the strength at distances dominated by the repulsion (Figure 1). In such a scenario the repulsion is due

Model for the NN repulsive core with substantial non-nucleonic component

Figure 1. Model for the NN repulsive core with substantial non-nucleonic component.

to the orthogonality between the wave functions of the observed NN state and the non-nucleonic component dominating in the core.

To probe the validity of such a scenario for the generation of nuclear repulsion one needs to probe deuteron wave function at internal momenta ≳800\gtrsim800 MeV/C. In the present work, new approach[7] is suggested in probing the deuteron at extremely large internal momenta.

Deuteron on the light front (LF)

Non-relativistic picture of the deuteron suggests that the observations of total isospin, I=0I = 0, total spin, J=1J = 1 and positive parity, PP, together with the relation, P=(−1)lP = (-1)^l, indicate that the deuteron consists of bound proton and neutron in S- and D- partial wave states.

However, for the deuteron structure with internal momenta comparable to the nucleon rest mass the nonrelativistic framework is not valid requiring a consistent account for the relativistic effects. There are several theoretical approaches for accounting for relativistic effects in the deuteron wave function (see e.g. Refs.[8, 9, 10, 11, 12]). In our approach the relativistic effects are accounted for similar to the one used in QCD (see e.g. [13, 14]) for calculation of quark distribution in hadrons, in which light-front (LF) description of the scattering process allows to suppress vacuum fluctuations that overshadow the composite structure of the hadron. Here one needs to identify the process in which the deuteron structure is probed. For this we consider high Q2Q^{2} electrodisintegration process:

e+d→e′+p+n,(1)e+d\to e^{\prime}+p+n, \tag*{(1)}

in which one of the nucleons are struck by the incoming probe and the spectator nucleon is probed with momenta comparable to the nucleon mass. If one can neglect (or remove) the effects related to final state interactions of two outgoing nucleons, then the above reaction at high Q2Q^{2}, measures the probability of observing proton and neutron in the deuteron with large relative momenta. In such a formulation the deuteron is not a composite system consisting of a proton and neutron, but it is a composite pseudo-vector (J=1J=1, P=+P=+) “particle" from which one extracts a proton and neutron. Thus we formulate the question not as how to describe relativistic motion of proton and neutron in the deuteron, but how such a proton and neutron are produced at such extreme conditions relating it to the dynamical structure of the LF deuteron wave function. In such formulation the latter may include internal elastic pn→pnpn\to pn as well as inelastic ΔΔ→pn\Delta\Delta\to pn, N∗N→pnN^{*}N\to pn or NcNc→pnN_{c}N_{c}\to pn transitions. Here, Δ\Delta and N∗N^{*} denote Δ\Delta-isobar and N∗N^{*} resonances, while NcN_{c} is a color octet baryonic state contributing to the hidden-color component in the deuteron.

The framework for calculation of reaction (1) in the relativistic domain is the LF approach[7] in which one introduces the LF deuteron wave function:

ψdλd(αi,p⊥,λ1λ2)=−uˉ(p2,λ2)uˉ(p1,λ1)Γdμχμλd12(md2−4(mN2+p⊥2)αi(2−αi))2(2π)3==−∑λ1′uˉ(p1,λ1)Γdμγ5ϵλ1,λ1′μ2u(p1,λ1′),(2)\psi_{d}^{\lambda_{d}}(\alpha_{i},p_{\perp},\lambda_{1}\lambda_{2})=-\frac{\bar{u}(p_{2},\lambda_{2})\bar{u}(p_{1},\lambda_{1})\Gamma_{d}^{\mu}\chi_{\mu}^{\lambda_{d}}}{\frac{1}{2}\left(m_{d}^{2}-\frac{4(m_{N}^{2}+p_{\perp}^{2})}{\alpha_{i}(2-\alpha_{i})}\right)\sqrt{2(2\pi)^{3}}}==-\sum_{\lambda_{1}^{\prime}}\bar{u}(p_{1},\lambda_{1})\Gamma_{d}^{\mu}\gamma_{5}\frac{\epsilon_{\lambda_{1},\lambda_{1}^{\prime}}^{\mu}}{\sqrt{2}}u(p_{1},\lambda_{1}^{\prime}), \tag*{(2)}

where αi=2pi+pd+\alpha_{i}=2\frac{p_{i}^{+}}{p_{d}^{+}}, (i=1,2i=1,2) are LF momentum fractions of proton and neutron, outgoing from the deuteron with α1+α2=2\alpha_{1}+\alpha_{2}=2 and in the second part we absorbed the propagator into the vertex function and used crossing symmetry. Here u(p,λ)u(p,\lambda)’s are the LF bi-spinors of the proton and neutron and ϵi,j\epsilon_{i,j} is the two dimensional Levi-Civita tensor, with i,j=±1i,j=\pm1 nucleon helicity. Since the deuteron is a pseudo-vector “particle", due to γ5\gamma_{5} in Eq. (2), the vertex Γdμ\Gamma_{d}^{\mu} is a four-vector which we can construct in a general form that explicitly satisfies time reversal, parity and charge conjugate symmetries. Noting that at the d→pnd\to pn vertex on the light-front the "-" (p−=E−pzp^{-}=E-p_{z}) components of the four-momenta of the particles are not conserved, in addition to the four-momenta of two nucleons, p1μp_{1}^{\mu} and p2μp_{2}^{\mu}, one has an additional four-momentum:

Δμ=p1μ+p2μ−pdμ≡(Δ−,Δ+,Δ⊥)=(Δ−,0,0),(3)\Delta^{\mu}=p_{1}^{\mu}+p_{2}^{\mu}-p_{d}^{\mu}\equiv(\Delta^{-},\Delta^{+},\Delta_{\perp})=(\Delta^{-},0,0), \tag*{(3)}

where

Δ−=pˉ1−+pˉ2−−pd−=4pd+[mN2−Md24+k2];k=mN2+k⊥2α1(2−α1)−mN2;α1=Ek+kzEk,(4)\Delta^{-}=\bar{p}_{1}^{-}+\bar{p}_{2}^{-}-p_{d}^{-}=\frac{4}{p_{d}^{+}}\left[m_{N}^{2}-\frac{M_{d}^{2}}{4}+k^{2}\right];\quad k=\sqrt{\frac{m_{N}^{2}+k_{\perp}^{2}}{\alpha_{1}(2-\alpha_{1})}-m_{N}^{2}};\quad\alpha_{1}=\frac{E_{k}+k_{z}}{E_{k}}, \tag*{(4)}

with Ek=m2+k2E_{k}=m^{2}+k^{2}. With p1μp_{1}^{\mu}, p2μp_{2}^{\mu} and Δμ\Delta^{\mu} 4-vectors the Γdμ\Gamma_{d}^{\mu} is constructed in the form:

Γdμ=Γ1γμ+Γ2(p1−p2)μ2mN+Γ3Δμ2mN+Γ4(p1−p2)μΔ4mN2+iΓ514mN3γ5ϵμνργ(pd)ν(p1−p2)ρ(Δ)γ+Γ6ΔμΔ4mN2,(5)\Gamma_{d}^{\mu}=\Gamma_{1}\gamma^{\mu}+\Gamma_{2}\frac{(p_{1}-p_{2})^{\mu}}{2m_{N}}+\Gamma_{3}\frac{\Delta^{\mu}}{2m_{N}}+\Gamma_{4}\frac{(p_{1}-p_{2})^{\mu}\Delta}{4m_{N}^{2}}+i\Gamma_{5}\frac{1}{4m_{N}^{3}}\gamma_{5}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\gamma}(p_{d})_{\nu}(p_{1}-p_{2})_{\rho}(\Delta)_{\gamma}+\Gamma_{6}\frac{\Delta^{\mu}\Delta}{4m_{N}^{2}}, \tag*{(5)}

where Γi\Gamma_{i}, (i=1,6)(i=1,6) are scalar functions. (see also Refs.[12]).

High energy approximation

For the large Q2Q^2 limit, the LF momenta for reaction (1) are chosen as follows:

pdμ≡(pd−,pd+,pd⊥)=(Q2xs[1+xτ−1+x2τ],Q2xs[1+xτ+1+x2τ],0⊥)p_d^\mu\equiv(p_d^-,p_d^+,p_{d\perp})=\left(\frac{Q^2}{x\sqrt{s}}\left[1+\frac{x}{\tau}-\sqrt{1+\frac{x^2}{\tau}}\right],\frac{Q^2}{x\sqrt{s}}\left[1+\frac{x}{\tau}+\sqrt{1+\frac{x^2}{\tau}}\right],0_\perp\right)
qμ≡(q−,q+,q⊥)=(Q2xs[1−x+1+x2τ],Q2xs[1−x−1+x2τ],0⊥),(6)q^\mu\equiv(q^-,q^+,q_\perp)=\left(\frac{Q^2}{x\sqrt{s}}\left[1-x+\sqrt{1+\frac{x^2}{\tau}}\right],\frac{Q^2}{x\sqrt{s}}\left[1-x-\sqrt{1+\frac{x^2}{\tau}}\right],0_\perp\right), \tag*{(6)}

where s=(q+pd)2s=(q+p_d)^2, τ=Q2Md2\tau=\frac{Q^2}{M_d^2} and x=Q2Mdq0x=\frac{Q^2}{M_dq_0}, with q0q_0 being the virtual photon energy in the deuteron rest frame. The high energy nature of this process results in, pd+∼Q2≫mNp_d^+\sim\sqrt{Q^2}\gg m_N, which makes Δ−\Delta^- term to be suppressed by the large pd+p_d^+ factor in Eq. (4), allowing to treat Δ−2mN\frac{\Delta^-}{2m_N} as a small parameter.

Keeping the leading, O0(Δ−2mN)O^0\left(\frac{\Delta^-}{2m_N}\right), terms in Eq. (5) and using the boost invariance of the wave function we calculate it in the CM of the deuteron[7] to obtain:

ψdλd(αi,k⊥)=∑λ2,λ1,λ1′uˉ(−k,λ2){Γ1γμ+Γ2k~μmN+∑i=12iΓ518mN3ϵμ+i−pd kiΔ′−}ϵλ1,λ1′2u(k,λ1′)sdλd(7)\psi_d^{\lambda_d}(\alpha_i,k_\perp)=\sum_{\lambda_2,\lambda_1,\lambda'_1}\bar{u}(-k,\lambda_2)\left\{\Gamma_1\gamma^\mu+\Gamma_2\frac{\tilde{k}^\mu}{m_N}+\sum_{i=1}^{2}i\Gamma_5\frac{1}{8m_N^3}\epsilon^{\mu+i-}p_{d\,ki}\Delta^{\prime-}\right\}\frac{\epsilon_{\lambda_1,\lambda'_1}}{\sqrt{2}}u(k,\lambda'_1)s_d^{\lambda_d} \tag*{(7)}

where k~μ=(0,kz,k⊥)\tilde{k}^\mu=(0,k_z,k_\perp) with k⊥=p1⊥k_\perp=p_{1\perp}, k2=kz2+k⊥2k^2=k_z^2+k_\perp^2 and Ek=sNN2E_k=\frac{\sqrt{s_{NN}}}{2} and sdλd=(0,sdλd)s_d^{\lambda_d}=(0,s_d^{\lambda_d}), with sd1=−12(1,i,0)s_d^1=-\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(1,i,0), sd−1=12(1,−i,0)s_d^{-1}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}(1,-i,0), sd0=(0,0,1)s_d^0=(0,0,1) and pd′+=sNNp_d^{\prime+}=\sqrt{s_{NN}}, Δ′−=1sNN[4(mN2+k⊥2)α1(2−α1)−Md2]\Delta^{\prime-}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{s_{NN}}}\left[\frac{4(m_N^2+k_\perp^2)}{\alpha_1(2-\alpha_1)}-M_d^2\right].

Since the term related to Γ5\Gamma_5 is proportional to 4(mN2+k⊥2)α1(2−α1)−Md2\frac{4(m_N^2+k_\perp^2)}{\alpha_1(2-\alpha_1)}-M_d^2, which diminishes at small momenta, only the Γ1\Gamma_1 and Γ2\Gamma_2 terms will contribute in the nonrelativistic limit defining the SS- and DD- components of the deuteron. Thus, the LF wave function in Eq. (7) provides a smooth transition to the nonrelativistic deuteron wave function. This can be seen by expressing Eq. (7) through two-component spinors:

ψdλd(α1,kt,λ1,λ2)=∑λ1′ϕλ2λ1′Ek[U(k)4πσsdλd−W(k)4π2(3(σk)(ksdλd)k2−σsdλd)+(−1)1+λd2P(k)Y1λd(θ,ϕ)δ1,∣λd∣]ϵλ1,λ1′2ϕλ1′(8)\psi_d^{\lambda_d}(\alpha_1,k_t,\lambda_1,\lambda_2)=\sum_{\lambda'_1}\phi_{\lambda_2}^{\lambda'_1}\sqrt{E_k}\left[\frac{U(k)}{\sqrt{4\pi}}\sigma s_d^{\lambda_d}-\frac{W(k)}{\sqrt{4\pi}\sqrt{2}}\left(\frac{3(\boldsymbol{\sigma}k)(ks_d^{\lambda_d})}{k^2}-\boldsymbol{\sigma}s_d^{\lambda_d}\right)+(-1)^{\frac{1+\lambda_d}{2}}P(k)Y_1^{\lambda_d}(\theta,\phi)\delta^{1,|\lambda_d|}\right]\frac{\epsilon_{\lambda_1,\lambda'_1}}{\sqrt{2}}\phi_{\lambda'_1} \tag*{(8)}

Here the first two terms have explicit SS- and DD- structures where the radial functions are defined as:

U(k)=24πEk3[Γ1(2+mNEk)+Γ2k2mNEk]U(k)=\frac{2\sqrt{4\pi}\sqrt{E_k}}{3}\left[\Gamma_1\left(2+\frac{m_N}{E_k}\right)+\Gamma_2\frac{k^2}{m_NE_k}\right]
W(k)=24πEk3[Γ1(1−mNEk)−Γ2k2mNEk].(9)W(k)=\frac{2\sqrt{4\pi}\sqrt{E_k}}{3}\left[\Gamma_1\left(1-\frac{m_N}{E_k}\right)-\Gamma_2\frac{k^2}{m_NE_k}\right]. \tag*{(9)}

This relation is known for pnpn-component deuteron wave function[12? ], which allows us to model the LF wave function through known radial SS- and DD- wave functions evaluated at LF relative momentum kk defined in Eq. (4).

The new result is that due to the Γ5\Gamma_5 term there is an additional leading contribution, which because of the relation Y1±1(θ,ϕ)=∓i34π∑i=12(k×sd±1)zkY_1^{\pm1}(\theta,\phi)=\mp i\sqrt{\frac{3}{4\pi}}\sum_{i=1}^{2}\frac{(k\times s_d^{\pm1})_z}{k}, has a PP-wave like structure, where the PP-radial function is defined as:

P(k)=4πΓ5(k)Ek3k3mN3.(10)P(k)=\sqrt{4\pi}\frac{\Gamma_5(k)\sqrt{E_k}}{\sqrt{3}}\frac{k^3}{m_N^3}. \tag*{(10)}

The unusual feature of our result is that the PP-wave is “incomplete", that is it contributes only for λd=±1\lambda_d=\pm1 polarizations of the deuteron.

Light front density matrix of the deuteron

Defining deuteron LF momentum distribution nd(k,k⊥)n_d(k,k_\perp) and density matrix:

nd(k,k⊥)=13∑λd=−11∣Ψdλd(α,k⊥)∣2andρd(α,k⊥)=nd(k,k⊥)2−α,(11)n_d(k,k_\perp)=\frac{1}{3}\sum_{\lambda_d=-1}^{1}\left|\Psi_d^{\lambda_d}(\alpha,k_\perp)\right|^2\quad\text{and}\quad\rho_d(\alpha,k_\perp)=\frac{n_d(k,k_\perp)}{2-\alpha}, \tag*{(11)}

one obtains

nd(k,k⊥)=13∑λd=−11∣Ψdλd(α,k⊥)∣2=14π(U(k)2+W(k)2+k⊥2k2P2(k))(12)n_d(k,k_\perp)=\frac{1}{3}\sum_{\lambda_d=-1}^{1}\left|\Psi_d^{\lambda_d}(\alpha,k_\perp)\right|^2=\frac{1}{4\pi}\left(U(k)^2+W(k)^2+\frac{k_\perp^2}{k^2}P^2(k)\right) \tag*{(12)}

with ∫ρd(α,k⊥)dαα=1\int\rho_d(\alpha,k_\perp)\frac{d\alpha}{\alpha}=1, ∫αρd(α,k⊥)dαα=1\int\alpha\rho_d(\alpha,k_\perp)\frac{d\alpha}{\alpha}=1 and ∫(U(k)2+W(k)2+23P2(k))k2dk=1\int\left(U(k)^2+W(k)^2+\frac{2}{3}P^2(k)\right)k^2dk=1. Due to the incompleteness of the PP-wave structure our result predicts that LF momentum distribution for deuteron depends explicitly on the transverse component of the relative momentum on the light front. This is highly unusual result, implication of which will be discussed in the next section.

For polarized deuteron the quantity that can be probed in the reaction (1) the tensor asymmetry which we define as:

AT=ndλd=1(k,k⊥)+ndλd=−1(k,k⊥)−2ndλd=0(k,k⊥)nd(k,k⊥).(13)A_T=\frac{n_d^{\lambda_d=1}(k,k_\perp)+n_d^{\lambda_d=-1}(k,k_\perp)-2n_d^{\lambda_d=0}(k,k_\perp)}{n_d(k,k_\perp)}. \tag*{(13)}

Here because of the same incompleteness of the “P−waveP-wave” structure one may expect more sensitivity that for unpolarized momentum distribution.

The new term and the non-nucleonic components in the deuteron:

One of our main predictions is that the LF momentum distribution, Eq. (12) will explicitly depend on the transverse component of the deuteron internal momentum on the light front. Such a dependence is impossible for non-relativistic quantum mechanics of the deuteron since in this case the potential of the interaction is real (no inelasticities) and the solution of Lippmann-Schwinger equation for partial S- and D-waves satisfies the “angular condition", according to which the momentum distribution in the unpolarized deuteron depends on the magnitude of the relative momentum only.

In the relativistic domain the definition of the interaction potential is not straightforward to claim that the momentum distribution in Eq. (12) should satisfy the angular condition also in the relativistic case (i.e. to be dependent only on the magnitude of kk).

To check the situation in relativistic case one considers Weinberg type equation[15] on the light-front for NN scattering amplitudes, in which only nucleonic degrees are considered, in the CM of the NN system. One obtains[16]:

TNN(αi,ki⊥,αf,kf,⊥)≡TNN(ki,z,ki⊥,kf,z,kf,⊥)=V(ki,z,ki⊥,kf,z,kf,⊥)+∫V(ki,z,ki⊥,km,z,km,⊥)d3km(2π)3m2+km2TNN(km,z,km⊥,kf,z,kf,⊥)4(km2−kf2)(14)T_{NN}(\alpha_i,k_{i\perp},\alpha_f,k_{f,\perp})\equiv T_{NN}(k_{i,z},k_{i\perp},k_{f,z},k_{f,\perp})=V(k_{i,z},k_{i\perp},k_{f,z},k_{f,\perp})+\int V(k_{i,z},k_{i\perp},k_{m,z},k_{m,\perp})\frac{d^3k_m}{(2\pi)^3\sqrt{m^2+k_m^2}}\frac{T_{NN}(k_{m,z},k_{m\perp},k_{f,z},k_{f,\perp})}{4(k_m^2-k_f^2)} \tag*{(14)}

where “i”, “m” and “f” subscripts correspond to initial, intermediate and final NNNN states, respectively, and momenta ki,m,fk_{i,m,f} are defined similar to Eq. (4).

The realization of the angular condition for the relativistic case requires:

V(ki,z,ki⊥,km,z,km,⊥)=V(k⃗i 2,(k⃗m−k⃗i)2)(15)V(k_{i,z}, k_{i\perp}, k_{m,z}, k_{m,\perp}) = V(\vec{k}_{i}^{\,2}, (\vec{k}_{m} - \vec{k}_{i})^{2}) \tag*{(15)}

resulting in:

TNNon shell(ki,z,ki⊥,km,z,km,⊥)=TNNon shell(k⃗i 2,(k⃗m−k⃗i)2)(16)T_{NN}^{\mathrm{on\ shell}}(k_{i,z}, k_{i\perp}, k_{m,z}, k_{m,\perp}) = T_{NN}^{\mathrm{on\ shell}}(\vec{k}_{i}^{\,2}, (\vec{k}_{m} - \vec{k}_{i})^{2}) \tag*{(16)}

and the existence of the Born term in Eq. (14) indicates that the potential VV satisfies the same condition in the on-shell limit.

For the off-shell potential[16] that requirements for the potential VV to satisfy angular condition in the on-shell limit and that it can be constructed through the series of elastic pnpn scatterings result to the VV and TNNT_{NN} functions satisfying the similar angular conditions (Eqs. (15),(16)). Using such a potential to calculate the LF deuteron wave function will result in a momentum distribution dependent only on the magnitude of the relative pnpn momentum.

Inclusion of the inelastic transitions will completely change the LF equation for the pnpn scattering. For example, the contribution of N∗NN^{*}N transition to the elastic NNNN scattering:

TNN(ki,z,ki⊥,kf,z,kf,⊥)=∫VNN∗(ki,z,ki⊥,km,z,km,⊥)d3km(2π)3m2+km2TN∗N(km,z,km⊥,kf,z,kf,⊥)4(km2−kf2+mN∗2−mN2)(17)T_{NN}(k_{i,z}, k_{i\perp}, k_{f,z}, k_{f,\perp}) = \int V_{NN^{*}}(k_{i,z}, k_{i\perp}, k_{m,z}, k_{m,\perp}) \frac{d^{3}k_{m}}{(2\pi)^{3}\sqrt{m^{2}+k_{m}^{2}}} \frac{T_{N^{*}N}(k_{m,z}, k_{m\perp}, k_{f,z}, k_{f,\perp})}{4(k_{m}^{2}-k_{f}^{2}+m_{N^{*}}^{2}-m_{N}^{2})} \tag*{(17)}

will not require the condition of Eq. (15) with the transition potential having also an imaginary component. Eq. (17) can not be described with any combination of elastic NNNN interaction potentials that satisfies the angular condition. The same will be true also for ΔΔ→NN\Delta\Delta\to NN and Nc,Nc→NNN_{c},N_{c} \to NN transitions. Thus one concludes that if the Γ5\Gamma_{5} term is not zero and results in a k⊥k_{\perp} dependence of LF momentum distribution then it should originate from a non-nucleonic component in the deuteron.

Predictions and estimate of the possible effects

Our calculations predict three new effects, that in probing deuteron structure at very large internal momenta (≥mN\ge m_{N}) in reaction (1): (i) the LF momentum distribution should be enhanced compared to SS- and DD- wave contributions only; (ii) there should be angular anisotropy in the LF momentum distribution; (iii) the tensor asymmetry should be significantly different as expected from SS- and DD- wave contributions only.

Observation of all the above effects will indicate a presence of non-nucleonic components in the deuteron wave function at large internal momenta.

To give quantitative estimates of the possible effects we evaluate the Γ5\Gamma_{5} vertex function assuming two color-octet baryon transition to the pnpn system (NcNc→pnN_{c}N_{c} \to pn) through the one-gluon exchange, parameterizing it in the dipole form A(1+k2/0.71)2\frac{A}{(1+k^{2}/0.71)^{2}}. The parameter AA is estimated by assuming 1% contribution to the total normalization from the PP wave. In Figure 2 (right panel) we consider the dependence of the momentum distribution of Eq. (12) as a function of cos⁡θ=(α−1)Ekk\cos\theta= \frac{(\alpha-1)E_{k}}{k} for different values of kk. Notice that if the momentum distribution is generated by the pnpn component only, the angular condition is satisfied, and no dependence should be observed.

Figure 2. (left panel) LF momentum distribution of the deuteron as a function of cos⁡θ\cos\theta, for different values of kk. (right pane). Tensor asymmetry as a function of cos⁡θ\cos\theta for different kk. Dashed lines - deuteron with pnpn component only, solid lines - with PP-wave like component included.

As Figure 2 (left panel) shows one may expect measurable angular dependence at k≳1k \gtrsim1 GeV/c, which is consistent with the expectation that non-nucleonic transition in the deuteron takes place at k≳800k \gtrsim800 MeV/c.

For tensor polarized deuteron ( Figure 2 (right panel)) we estimated the effect using Eq. (13). As the figure shows, in this case, the presence of a non-nucleonic component will be visible already at k≈800k \approx800 MeV/c, resulting in a qualitative difference in the asymmetry.

Outlook on experimental verification of the predicted effects

The predictions discussed in the previous section which are related to the existence of non-nucleonic component in the deuteron wave function can be be verified at CM momenta k≳1k \gtrsim1 GeV/c. These seem an incredibly large momenta to be measured in experiment. However, the first such measurement at high Q2Q^2 disintegration of the deuteron has already been performed at Jefferson Lab[17] reaching k∼1k \sim1 GeV/c. It is intriguing that the results of this measurement qualitatively disagree with predictions based on conventional deuteron wave functions once k≳800k \gtrsim800 MeV/c. Moreover the data seems to indicate the enhancement of momentum distribution as predicted in our calculations. New measurements will significantly improve the quality of the data allowing possible verification of the second prediction, that is the existence of angular asymmetry for LF momentum distribution. What concerns to the tensor asymmetry, it can show a strong sensitivity the non-nucleonic component in the deuteron influencing also the repulsive character of bound pnpn system at very short distances.[18] Currently there are significant efforts being made in measuring high Q2Q^2 deuteron electro-disintegration processes at Jefferson Lab employing polarized deuteron target[19].

It is worth mentioning that the analysis of exclusive deuteron disintegration experiments will require a careful account for competing nuclear effects such as final state interactions, (FSI) for which there has been significant theoretical and experimental progress during the last decade[20, 21, 22]. The advantage of high energy scattering is that the eikonal regime is established which makes FSI to be strongly isolated in transverse kinematics and be suppressed in near collinear directions.

If the experiments will not find the discussed signatures of non-nucleonic components then they will set a new limit on the dominance of the pnpn component at instantaneous high nuclear densities that corresponds to ∼1\sim1 GeV/c internal momentum in the deuteron. However if predictions are confirmed, they will motivate theoretical modeling of non-nucleonic components in the deuteron, such as ΔΔ\Delta\Delta, N∗NN^*N or hidden-color NcNcN_cN_c that can reproduce the observed results. In both cases the results of such studies will advance the understanding of the dynamics of high density nuclear matter and the relevance of the quark-hadron transitions.

Acknowledgments: This work is supported by the U.S. DOE Office of Nuclear Physics grant DE-FG02-01ER41172.

References

  1. [1]W. Melnitchouk, M. Sargsian and M. I. Strikman, Z. Phys. A 359, 99-109 (1997).
  2. [2]M. M. Sargsian, Nucl. Phys. A 782, 199-206 (2007).
  3. [3]N. Fomin (et all) Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 212502 (2010).
  4. [4]A. J. Freese, W. Cosyn and M. M. Sargsian, Phys. Rev. D 99, no.11, 114019 (2019).
  5. [5]M. Harvey, Nucl. Phys. A 352, 326-342 (1981) doi:10.1016/0375-9474(81)90413-9DOI
  6. [6]S. J. Brodsky and C. R. Ji, Phys. Rev. D 33, 1406 (1986) doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.33.1406DOI
  7. [7]M. M. Sargsian and F. Vera, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, no.11, 112502 (2023).
  8. [8]L. L. Frankfurt and M. I. Strikman, Nucl. Phys. B 148, 107-140 (1979).
  9. [9]W. Buck and F. Gross, Phys. Rev. D 20, 2361 (1979).
  10. [10]R. G. Arnold, C. E. Carlson and F. G. Gross, Phys. Rev. C 23, 363 (1981).
  11. [11]R. Dymarz and F. C. Khanna, Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 1448-1451 (1986).
  12. [12]J. Carbonell and V. A. Karmanov, Nucl. Phys. A 581, 625-653 (1995).
  13. [13]R. P. Feynman, “Photon-hadron interactions, ”CRC Press (January 1, 1972).
  14. [14]S. J. Brodsky, H. C. Pauli and S. S. Pinsky, Phys. Rept. 301, 299-486 (1998).
  15. [15]S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. 150, 1313-1318 (1966).
  16. [16]L. L. Frankfurt and M. I. Strikman, in Modern topics in electron scattering, edited by B. Frois and I. Sick, 1991.
  17. [17]C. Yero et al. [Hall C], Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, no.26, 262501 (2020).
  18. [18]M. M. Sargsian, [arXiv:2410.08384 [nucl-th]].
  19. [19]K. Slifer and E. Long, PoS PSTP2013, 008 (2013), [arXiv:1311.4835 [nucl-ex]].arxiv.org/abs/1311.4835
  20. [20]L. L. Frankfurt, M. M. Sargsian and M. I. Strikman, Phys. Rev. C 56, 1124-1137 (1997).
  21. [21]M. M. Sargsian, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 10, 405-458 (2001).
  22. [22]M. M. Sargsian, Phys. Rev. C 82, 014612 (2010).

Paper details

vlnc:W_qeu5ps24
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents