betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Wieferich co-occurrence along exponential sequences: a weighted tail estimate and its application to (⋆′)

Abstract

Let r≥2r\ge2 be a fixed integer and write be=re−a′b_e=r^e-a' for a′≤Aa'\le A coprime to rr. A recent preprint (hexagon:2610.00630, Zeng) reduces the abc conjecture, within a lattice-theoretic framework, to a single remaining hypothesis (⋆′)(\star'). We show that on the k=2k=2 slice the density-zero requirement on the exceptional set attached to (⋆′)(\star') follows from one summability condition Kr,a′<∞K_{r,a'}<\infty, where Kr,a′=∑q∈Cr,a′sqlog⁡q (1/D3(q)+1/e0(q))K_{r,a'}=\sum_{q\in\mathcal{C}_{r,a'}}s_q\log q\,(1/D_3(q)+1/e_0(q)), Cr,a′\mathcal{C}_{r,a'} is a three-filter congruence set, D3(q)=ordq3(r)D_3(q)=\mathrm{ord}_{q^3}(r), and e0(q)e_0(q) is the least solution of q3∣re−a′q^3\mid r^e-a'. The main result is unconditional: splitting the governing weight Ξr\Xi_r by the block d=ordq(r)d=\mathrm{ord}_q(r), the mass constraint ∏q2∣rd−1\prod q^2\mid r^d-1 and Stieltjes partial summation give Ξr(2)=∑sq=22log⁡q/(dqq)<∞\Xi_r^{(2)}=\sum_{s_q=2}2\log q/(d_qq)<\infty for every base rr, with explicit bound O(1+log⁡log⁡r)O(1+\log\log r); no abc, no GRH, and no count or density of the Wieferich primes Wr\mathcal{W}_r. The exact threshold of the first-moment route is Φr(E)=o(E)\Phi_r(E)=o(E), equivalently Ar(t)=∑d≤tMd/d=o(t)A_r(t)=\sum_{d\le t}M_d/d=o(t); the deep-layer condition Ξr(3)<∞\Xi_r^{(3)}<\infty sits strictly between Murata's finiteness conjecture P6aP_{6a} and the deep reciprocal sum, and the barrier analysis (one claimed radical barrier withdrawn as a bookkeeping artifact and replaced by an exact identity) shows it cannot be reached by block/radical/partial-summation methods. A Katz double-zero hypothesis (D4) yields Ξr(3)<∞\Xi_r^{(3)}<\infty and P6aP_{6a} almost surely (Borel–Cantelli); in the Haar ensemble (D4) is free with constant 11, while the diagonal embedding ι(Z)\iota(\mathbb{Z}) has measure zero, so the missing input is precisely pointwise rigidity of ι(r)\iota(r), equivalently the single-variable statement m(q)→∞m(q)\to\infty for the least nontrivial Teichmüller representative m(q)m(q) modulo q3q^3. The bad-set hypothesis (H-j) is supported by computation to 10610^6 (five hits, zero growth), while the same data correct the twin-Wieferich null hypothesis to the Teichmüller rate (q−1)/q2(q-1)/q^2. We prove (H-j) is not a GRH statement, locate it strictly between Katz's 2015 equidistribution conjecture and Murata's 1991 conjectures, record ancillary unconditional results (∑plog⁡p/(dp(p−1))<∞\sum_p\log p/(d_p(p-1))<\infty via Erdős–Murty; the exact identity Cr=SW+Sord+LTE2C_r=S_W+S_{\mathrm{ord}}+LTE_2; strict one-way comparisons), and specify what any new tool must look like (S1–S7). We prove no conjecture: the exact threshold, Ξr(3)\Xi_r^{(3)}, P6aP_{6a}, P4P_4, P1P_1 and (H-j) remain open.

Introduction

The problem

For a prime q∤rq\nmid r write dq=ord⁡q(r)d_q=\operatorname{ord}_q(r) for the multiplicative order and sq=vq(rq−1−1)=vq(rdq−1)≥1s_q=v_q(r^{q-1}-1)=v_q(r^{d_q}-1)\ge1 for the Wieferich depth; the Fermat quotient is qq(u)=(uq−1−1)/qq_q(u)=(u^{q-1}-1)/q, and q∈Wr:={q:sq≥2}q\in W_r:=\{q:s_q\ge2\} are the Wieferich primes to base rr. The set WrW_r is the basic obstruction in several classical problems: the first case of Fermat’s Last Theorem (Wieferich), the infinitude of non-Wieferich primes (Silverman), and—most recently—the remaining hypothesis (⋆)(\star) in Zeng’s lattice-theoretic approach [1] to the abcabc conjecture, which is the motivating application of this note.

On the “fixed-modulus” side (fixed pp, varying base) the Fermat quotient is well understood: Heath–Brown’s Burgess-based estimates, the GRH coverage results of Alexandru–Cobeli–Văjăitu-Zaharescu, and Shparlinski’s unconditional improvements of the Ihara sum. On the “varying-modulus” side (fixed rr, qq varying) not even the zero-density of WrW_r is known unconditionally. The present note shows that the application layer of (⋆)(\star) can be reduced to a single summability condition on this varying-modulus side, and isolates the remaining analytic input as a precisely located, numerically supported hypothesis.

Main results

Throughout, qq denotes an odd prime; the prime q=2q=2 is handled by the LTE branch of Theorem 1.1 (so D3(2)∈{1,2}D_3(2)\in\{1,2\}) and contributes Or,a′(E)O_{r,a'}(E) to S(E)S(E), absorbed into the constant CC of a first-moment bound S(E)≤CES(E)\le CE. Also, r≥2r\ge2 is a fixed integer (not a perfect power, without loss of generality), A≥1A\ge1 is fixed, a′∈{1,…,A}a'\in\{1,\ldots,A\}, gcd⁡(a′,r)=1\gcd(a',r)=1, and be=re−a′b_e=r^e-a'. Set Vq(e)=vq(be)V_q(e)=v_q(b_e), Le=elog⁡rL_e=e\log r, and define the exceptional mass

Ts(e)=∑q∣beVq(e)≥3sq≥2sqlog⁡q,S(E)=∑e≤ETs(e).T_s(e)=\sum_{\substack{q\mid b_e\\ V_q(e)\ge3\\ s_q\ge2}}s_q\log q,\qquad S(E)=\sum_{e\le E}T_s(e).

Call ee W\mathcal{W}-exceptional if Ts(e)≥120LeT_s(e)\ge\frac{1}{20}L_e.

Theorem 1.1 (Order-lifting formula). For odd q∤rq\nmid r and every V≥1V\ge1,

DV(q):=ord⁡qV(r)=dqqmax⁡(0,V−sq).D_V(q):=\operatorname{ord}_{q^V}(r)=d_q q^{\max(0,V-s_q)}.

For q=2q=2: if s2=v2(r−1)≥2s_2=v_2(r-1)\ge2 the same formula holds; if s2=1s_2=1 (i.e. r≡3(mod4)r\equiv3\pmod4) then

DV(2)=2max⁡(1,V−v2(r+1)).D_V(2)=2^{\max(1,V-v_2(r+1))}.

The classical layer sq=2s_q=2 carries D3=dqqD_3=d_q q (a “Hensel wall” of one extra factor qq), while the super-Wieferich layer sq≥3s_q\ge3 has D3=dqD_3=d_q (wall-free). The equivalent form sq≥2⟺ord⁡q2(r)=ord⁡q(r)s_q\ge2\Longleftrightarrow\operatorname{ord}_{q^2}(r)=\operatorname{ord}_q(r) identifies Wr\mathcal{W}_r with the order-lift locus of Dillon [12].

Theorem 1.2 (Two-base necessary condition). Let qq be odd, sq≥2s_q\ge2. If q3∣re−a′q^3\mid r^e-a' for some e≥1e\ge1, then q∤a′q\nmid a' and q2∣a′q−1−1q^2\mid a'^{q-1}-1 (i.e. q∈Wa′q\in\mathcal{W}_{a'}); if moreover sq≥3s_q\ge3 then q3∣a′q−1−1q^3\mid a'^{q-1}-1. Writing wq=(rq−1−1)/q2 mod qw_q=(r^{q-1}-1)/q^2\bmod q, βq=(a′q−1−1)/q2 mod q\beta_q=(a'^{q-1}-1)/q^2\bmod q (defined when sq=2s_q=2), the least solution e0(q)e_0(q) satisfies e0(q)≡βqwq−1(modq)e_0(q)\equiv\beta_qw_q^{-1}\pmod q, and βq=0\beta_q=0 forces e0(q)≥qe_0(q)\ge q. Finally

e0(q)≥3log⁡qlog⁡r−Or,a′(1)e_0(q)\ge\frac{3\log q}{\log r}-O_{r,a'}(1)

unconditionally.

Theorem 1.2 compresses the candidate enumeration from a scan over ee to a three-filter sieve per prime: q∈Wrq\in\mathcal{W}_r, q∈Wa′q\in\mathcal{W}_{a'}, and a′∈⟨r⟩⊆(Z/q3Z)×a'\in\langle r\rangle\subseteq(\mathbb{Z}/q^3\mathbb{Z})^\times; the last filter is necessary but not sufficient [17], numerics.

References

  1. [1]C. Zeng, A lattice-theoretic approach to the abc conjecture: hexagon:2610.00630v1; Zenodo 22995922 (v1, 2026-09-27); Zenodo 23745797 (v2.0, 2026-10-28, revised). Not peer-reviewed; the v1 abstract (“min–max barrier”) was withdrawn by errata E12/E30 after Theorem 4.5. Hexagon is a deposition platform, not arXiv; no arXiv record 2610.00630 exists. The results of this note are proved independently and use only the problem setting.DOI
  2. [2]M. N. Katz, Wieferich past and future, Contemp. Math. 632 (2015), 253–270, Conjecture 3.1. DOI 10.1090/conm/632/12632.DOI
  3. [3]L. Murata, The distribution of primes satisfying the condition a^{p−1} ≡ 1 (mod p²), Acta Arith. 58(2) (1991), 103–111, Conjectures (i), (ii).
  4. [4]S. Lang, Old and new conjectured Diophantine inequalities, Bull. AMS 23 (1990), 37–75, p. 42.
  5. [5]R. Crandall, K. Dilcher, C. Pomerance, A search for Wieferich and Wilson primes, Math. Comp. 66 (1997), 433–449.DOI
  6. [6]J. H. Silverman, Wieferich’s criterion and the abc-conjecture, J. Number Theory 30 (1988), 226–237.DOI
  7. [8]M. R. Murty, F. Séguin, Prime divisors of sparse values of cyclotomic polynomials and Wieferich primes, J. Number Theory 201 (2019), 1–22.DOI
  8. [12]R. Dillon, The Wieferich locus of an algebraic unit, Zenodo 21456694 (order-lift dichotomy).
  9. [15]W. Laniewski, Defect and order-core analysis of abc data, arXiv:2609.00039 (Mersenne-line density 47/210).
  10. [16]P. Kurlberg, C. Pomerance, On the periods of the linear congruential and power generators, Acta Arith. 119(2) (2005), 149–169 (unconditional ord_q(r) > q^{1/2+ε(q)} on a positive density set; GRH > q^{1−ε(q)}).DOI
  11. [17]Companion verification report and scripts for this note (machine-assisted proofs of Theorems 1.1–1.4 and Proposition 10.1 on all tested samples; available from the authors).
  12. [18]P. Erdős, M. R. Murty, On the order of a (mod p), CRM Proc. Lecture Notes 19 (1999), 87–97.
  13. [19]M. R. Murty, S. Srinivasan, Some remarks on Artin’s conjecture, Canad. Math. Bull. 30(1) (1987), 78–88.DOI
  14. [20]N. Fellini, M. R. Murty, Wieferich primes in number fields and the conjectures of Ankeny–Artin–Chowla and Mordell, J. Number Theory 278 (2026), 109883 (published version of arXiv:2508.08472v2; the authors note explicitly that no unconditional result in this direction is known).arxiv.org/abs/2508.08472
  15. [21]J.-M. DeKoninck, N. Doyon, On the set of Wieferich primes and of its complement, Ann. Univ. Sci. Budapest. Sect. Comput. 27 (2007), 3–13 (notation: their W_r denotes the depth-r layer for the fixed base 2, i.e. W_2^(r); not the base-r set W_r used here).
  16. [22]Y. Ding, Non-Wieferich primes under the abc conjecture, C. R. Math. Acad. Sci. Paris 357 (2019), 483–486 (the intermediate bound C_n' ≥ a^{ρ(n)−εn} on the squarefree part of Φ_n(a)). See also H. K. Graves, M. R. Murty, The abc conjecture and non-Wieferich primes in arithmetic progressions, J. Number Theory 133 (2013), 1809–1813.DOI
  17. [23]C. L. Stewart, K. Yu, On the abc conjecture, II, Duke Math. J. 108(1) (2001), 169–181 (the κR^{1/3}(log R)^3 bound).DOI
  18. [24]C. L. Stewart, On divisors of Lucas and Lehmer numbers, Acta Math. 211 (2013), 291–314. Cf. also Acta Arith. 26 (1975), 427–433; Proc. London Math. Soc. (3) 35 (1977), 425–447.arxiv.org/abs/1008.1274
  19. [25]N. Balaji, F. Luca, Terms of Lucas sequences having a large smooth divisor, Canad. Math. Bull. 66 (2023), 225–231 (arXiv:2203.12364, Theorem 1.2).arxiv.org/abs/2203.12364
  20. [26]A. Granville, S. Soundararajan, A binary additive problem of Erdős and the order of 2 (mod p²), Ramanujan J. 2 (1998), 283–298.
  21. [27]P. Moree, Artin’s primitive root conjecture — a survey, Integers 12A (2012), #A13.arxiv.org/abs/math/0412262
  22. [28]Y. Bugeaud, P. Corvaja, U. Zannier, An upper bound for the greatest common divisor of a^n − 1 and b^n − 1, Math. Z. 243 (2003), 79–84.
  23. [29]Y. Bilu, G. Hanrot, P. M. Voutier, Existence of primitive divisors of Lucas and Lehmer numbers, J. Reine Angew. Math. 539 (2001), 75–122.DOI
  24. [30]G. Gras, Probabilistic study of Fermat quotients, Comment. Math. 54 (2016), 115–140 (heuristic, not a pointwise theorem).
  25. [31]L. Berger, Rigidity and unlikely intersections for formal groups, arXiv:1811.05824v2 (framework only; not a pointwise theorem for fixed r/varying q).arxiv.org/abs/1811.05824

Paper details

vlnc:W_qfn95uzt
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — published within the last 30 days
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents