betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Plutonium-241 as a possible isotope for neutrino mass measurement and capture

Abstract

Tritium has been the isotope of choice for measurements of the neutrino mass and planned detection of the relic neutrino background. The low mass of 3^{3}H leads to large recoil energy of the nucleus. This has emerged as a limiting factor for both measurements. We investigate 241^{241}Pu as an alternative. The recoil is 80x smaller and it has similar decay energy and lifetime as 3^{3}H. We evaluate for the first time its soft-neutrino capture cross-section and find (σv)ν=1.52×10−45(σv)_ν = 1.52 \times 10^{-45}. This is 40% of the capture cross-section for tritium and makes 241^{241}Pu an interesting alternative for 3^{3}H.

Introduction

The measurement of the absolute neutrino mass and the detection of the cosmic neutrino background (CNB) are two of the most exciting prospects in neutrino physics for the next two decades. They are closely related. The mass measurement is looking for a deformation of the end of the beta decay spectrum caused by the finite neutrino mass, while the CNB search is looking for a small peak from neutrino capture which is separated by twice the lightest neutrino mass from the end point. Both measurements require an experimental precision and a theoretical understanding of the end of the beta decay spectrum at the level of the neutrino mass, which is of the order of tens of meV.

Candidate nuclides for the mass measurement should first of all have moderate beta-decay energy. Already for isotopes with a decay energy of 10-100 keV, an experimental precision of 1ppm would be required. A lifetime of 1-20 years is optimal since it leads to a reasonable event rate and relatively stable measurement conditions. Rhenium-187 has the lowest energy of the known beta-decaying isotopes at 2.6 keV, but due to its lifetime of 60 Gyr there would be no events close to the endpoint within a human lifetime. In addition the daughter isotope needs to be stable on the timescale of the experiment. Ruthenium-106 for example, does have a significant neutrino capture cross-section, a decay energy of 39.4 keV and a half-life of 1.48 years, but the daughter isotope Rhodium-106 decays within 30 seconds with a decay energy of several MeV and the emission of several gammas, making a clean measurement of the endpoint impossible.

For candidate nuclides for detection of the CNB there is an additional requirement to have a large neutrino capture cross-section to get an acceptable even rate. The capture cross-section has been evaluated for a large number of isotopes [1]. From this study 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H}, which has always been the isotope of choice for the mass measurement, is the isotope that best matches the requirements. The KATRIN experiment is using molecular tritium in its current world best neutrino mass limit [2]. Their current measurement is still dominated by its statistical error, but with more data it will be limited by the energy spread of the vibrational and rotational excitation spectrum of the daughter molecule (3H3He)+({}^{3}\mathrm{H}{}^{3}\mathrm{He})^{+}. The decaying tritium nucleus recoils against the electron and picks up 3.4 eV kinetic energy due to its relatively low mass. This is enough to bring the daughter molecule in one of several of the excited states and leads to an energy spread of 0.36 eV. This is the reason that future experiments, like Project8 [3] are looking at atomic tritium. The PTOLEMY experiment [4] also plans to use atomic 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H} loaded on graphene to measure the mass and in a later stage observe the CNB.

A recent study [5] found that the zero-point motion of the 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H} bound to the surface of graphene, or for that matter any surface, leads to an energy spread of ΔE∼0.5\Delta E \sim0.5 eV. They advocate the investigation of nuclei with A>100A > 100 and define a figure of merit for this effect:

γ=(Q2me/mnucl3)1/4(1)\gamma= \left(Q^{2}m_{\mathrm{e}}/m_{\mathrm{nucl}}^{3}\right)^{1/4} \tag*{(1)}

and propose 171Tm{}^{171}\mathrm{Tm} and 151Sm{}^{151}\mathrm{Sm} as candidate isotopes, which have a γ\gamma which is an order of magnitude lower than for 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H}.

Beta decay of 241Pu

Plutonium-241 is an isotope which is created by double neutron capture on Plutonium-239. About 12% of the plutonium in spent nuclear fuel is 241Pu{}^{241}\mathrm{Pu}. It mainly undergoes beta decay to 241Am{}^{241}\mathrm{Am} with a decay energy of 20.78 keV and a half life of 14.4 year, numbers very similar to those of 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H} and one would expect the experimental setup for atomic 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H} to work for 241Pu{}^{241}\mathrm{Pu} as well. What makes 241Pu{}^{241}\mathrm{Pu} interesting for the mass measurement is the large mass of the isotope and as a consequence its low recoil of 47 meV. The γ\gamma factor is 25 times smaller than for 3H{}^{3}\mathrm{H}, which according to [5] should allow for observation of the CNB for neutrino masses of mν>30m_{\nu} > 30 meV.

The daughter nuclide 241Am{}^{241}\mathrm{Am} decays trough α\alpha decay to 237Np{}^{237}\mathrm{Np} with a half life of 432 years. 237Np{}^{237}\mathrm{Np} itself has a half life of 2 million years and can be considered stable. In addition 241Pu{}^{241}\mathrm{Pu} has a small (2.4⋅10−5)(2.4 \cdot10^{-5}) probability to have an α\alpha decay to 237U{}^{237}\mathrm{U}. The energies of the α\alpha particles, and the subsequent γ\gamma's are well outside the relevant energy window around the endpoint. The biggest challenge comes from the 237U{}^{237}\mathrm{U}. It has several β\beta decays to 237Np{}^{237}\mathrm{Np} with a half life of 6.7 days and an energy up to 459 keV. The total rate from the 237U^{237}\mathrm{U} is about five orders of magnitude smaller than for 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu}, but near the endpoint the 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu} spectrum is falling rapidly and 237U^{237}\mathrm{U} is still on a plateau. At around 20 eV before the endpoint the rates become similar and a mass measurement becomes impossible without special measures to remove the 237U^{237}\mathrm{U} on a timescale much shorter than its lifetime. There are two possible ways to reduce the 237U^{237}\mathrm{U} background. First the α\alpha decay to 237U^{237}\mathrm{U} causes a considerable recoil of around 150 keV. In the design of the target this could conceivably used to remove part of the 237U^{237}\mathrm{U} from the active target area. Secondly, the β\beta decay to 237Np^{237}\mathrm{Np} is never to the ground state and always followed by a γ\gamma decay which can be used as a veto.

Neutrino capture cross-section on 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu}

In order to calculate the neutrino capture cross-section for 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu}, we follow a procedure as developed in [6], which we will summarize briefly below. We consider the two related weak processes:

ZAX⟶Z+1AY+e−+νˉe{}^{A}_{Z}X \longrightarrow{}^{A}_{Z+1}Y + e^{-} + \bar{\nu}_{e}
ν+ZAX⟶Z+1AY+e−(2)\nu+ {}^{A}_{Z}X \longrightarrow{}^{A}_{Z+1}Y + e^{-} \tag*{(2)}

Using Fermi’s Golden Rule, we can write the differential beta-decay rate dΓβd\Gamma_{\beta} and the neutrino capture cross-section as:

dΓβ=12π3×pνEνEedEe×Wβ(pe,pν)(σv)ν=lim⁡pν→01π×peEe×Wν(pe,pν).(3)\begin{aligned} d\Gamma_{\beta} &= \frac{1}{2\pi^{3}} \times p_{\nu}E_{\nu}E_{e}dE_{e} \times W_{\beta}(p_{e},p_{\nu}) \\ (\sigma v)_{\nu} &= \lim_{p_{\nu}\to0} \frac{1}{\pi} \times p_{e}E_{e} \times W_{\nu}(p_{e},p_{\nu}). \tag*{(3)} \end{aligned}

Here Wβ(pe,pν)W_{\beta}(p_{e},p_{\nu}) is the average transition rate for the decay of an atom emitting two leptons in a plane wave with momenta pep_{e} and pνp_{\nu} and Wν(pe,pν)W_{\nu}(p_{e},p_{\nu}) the average transition rate for the capture of a neutrino with momentum pνp_{\nu} with the emission of an electron with pep_{e}. They are obtained by integrating the transition amplitudes squared over the directions of the leptons, summing over the quantum numbers of the outgoing particles, and averaging over the incoming particles.

For the CNB neutrinos, with pν≪mνp_{\nu} \ll m_{\nu} we have:

Wν(pe,0)=12lim⁡pν→0Wβ(pe,pν)(4)W_{\nu}(p_{e},0) = \frac{1}{2}\lim_{p_{\nu}\to0} W_{\beta}(p_{e},p_{\nu}) \tag*{(4)}

Earlier calculations of the neutrino cross-sections [1] have been performed for two kinds of beta decays. Allowed transitions are decays where the parent and daughter isotope have the same quantum numbers and no angular momentum is carried away by the lepton pair. In this case the transition amplitudes can be approximated by a constant and their ratio can be taken as 1, after which it is straightforward to express the capture cross-section in terms of the total decay width of the isotope. This is not true for forbidden decays where the quantum numbers are different for mother and daughter and there will be a dependency on the momenta.

For a unique forbidden transition, there is only one term contributing. The matrix element and the kinematic factor factorize and the ratio of the transition rates can be calculated after which the neutrino capture cross-section is again expressed as function of the total width. For non-unique forbidden transition the matrix elements contains several terms with each its own dependency on the momenta and such a calculation can not be performed.

The novel approach of [6] is using the fact that Wβ(pe,pν)W_{\beta}(p_{\mathrm{e}},p_{\nu}) is an analytical function of the momenta, and evaluating the differential decay rate for the same kinematic region as for neutrino capture. For small enough values of pνp_{\nu} a linear approximation can be used and (σv)ν(\sigma v)_{\nu} can be found by extrapolating to pν=0p_{\nu}=0:

(σv)ν[1+α1pν/Q+O(pν2/Q2)]=ℏ3c2π2pν2dΓβdEe(5)(\sigma v)_{\nu}\left[1+\alpha_{1}p_{\nu}/Q+O\left(p_{\nu}^{2}/Q^{2}\right)\right]=\frac{\hbar^{3}c^{2}\pi^{2}}{p_{\nu}^{2}}\frac{\mathrm{d}\Gamma_{\beta}}{\mathrm{d}E_{\mathrm{e}}} \tag*{(5)}

Where we put the factors ℏ\hbar and cc back in. This procedure requires a well-measured decay spectrum.

Results

For the extraction of (σv)ν(\sigma v)_{\nu} from 5 the beta spectrum of 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu} has been measured very precisely[7]. We use a parametrization of this data as our main set. As a cross-check data set we generate a spectrum using BetaShape [8, 9] using an energy bin width of 0.06 eV. It is useful to point out that the measured spectrum has been used as one of the benchmark processes for the BetaShape program.

The results are shown in Figure 1. We see that below 5 keV, the experimental data is well described by a linear function and we find (σv)ν=1.52⋅10−45 cm2(\sigma v)_{\nu}=1.52\cdot10^{-45}\,\mathrm{cm}^{2} and α1=−0.51\alpha_{1}=-0.51. The calculated spectrum gives a value of (σv)ν=1.34⋅10−45 cm2(\sigma v)_{\nu}=1.34\cdot10^{-45}\,\mathrm{cm}^{2}, which is fairly close.

Calculated neutrino caption cross-section for $^{241}\mathrm{Pu}$ as a function of the neutrino momentum in the $\beta$ decay

Figure 1. Calculated neutrino caption cross-section for 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu} as a function of the neutrino momentum in the β\beta decay

As a cross-check we also evaluate the results for the two isotopes 151Sm^{151}\mathrm{Sm} and 171Tm^{171}\mathrm{Tm}. We generated both spectra with BetaShape using energy bins of 0.2 eV and fitted the spectrum, where we reproduced the values found in [6], which were confirmed in a similar analysis [10]. In addition we performed the same procedure for the 63Ni^{63}\mathrm{Ni} isotope and recovered the calculated cross-section from [1].

Conclusion

We have for the first time estimated the neutrino capture cross-section on 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu} and found it to be 1.52⋅10−451.52\cdot10^{-45}. The result from the actual beta spectrum and the BetaShape calculation agree within 10%, which gives confidence in this result. The relevant parameters for 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu} and other candidate isotopes are shown in Table 1. If the energy uncertainty for 3H^{3}\mathrm{H} cannot be solved, 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu} seems to be a promising replacement for at least the neutrino mass measurement, provided the 237U^{237}\mathrm{U} can be removed or its decay vetoed. It has an energy and life time which is very similar to 3H^{3}\mathrm{H}, and an experiment designed for 3H^{3}\mathrm{H} will also work for 241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu}. This is not the case for 151Sm^{151}\mathrm{Sm} or 171Tm^{171}\mathrm{Tm} which have a substantial larger energy. The energy uncertainty is more than twice smaller than for these and would according to [5] allow for a CNB observation for neutrinos with mν>30meVm_{\nu} > 30\mathrm{meV}. The expected rate is lower than for 3H^{3}\mathrm{H} but at least 10 times higher than for 171Tm^{171}\mathrm{Tm} and the calculation is based on an actual spectrum.

IsotopeQQ (keV)t1/2t_{1/2} (yr)(σv)ν(\sigma v)_{\nu} (10−46 cm210^{-46}\,\mathrm{cm}^{2})γ/γ3H\gamma/\gamma_{^{3}\mathrm{H}}
3H^{3}\mathrm{H}18.612.339.21.0
63Ni^{63}\mathrm{Ni}66.91000.0690.19
151Sm^{151}\mathrm{Sm}76.6900.0480.10
171Tm^{171}\mathrm{Tm}96.51.921.20.11
241Pu^{241}\mathrm{Pu}20.814.415.20.039

Table 1. Neutrino capture cross-sections for different isotopes. The values for 3H^{3}\mathrm{H} and 63Ni^{63}\mathrm{Ni} are taken from [1].

Acknowledgments

The author is grateful to Oleksii Mikulenko of Institute Lorentz in Leiden, Geon-Bo Kim of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and Adriaan König of Radboud University for their valuable comments.

References

  1. [2]Aker M, Beglarian A, Behrens J, Berlev A, Besserer U, Bieringer B, Block F, Bobien S, Böttcher M, Bornschein B, Bornschein L, Brunst T, Caldwell T S, Carney R M D, La Cascio L, Chilingaryan S, Choi W, Debowski K, Delfert M, Descher M, Díaz Barrero D, Doe P J, Dragoun O, Drexlin G, Eitel K, Ellinger E, Engler R, Enomoto S, Felden A, Formaggio J A, Fränkle F M, Franklin G B, Friedel F, Fulst A, Gauda K, Gil W, Glück F, Grössle R, Gumbsheimer R, Gupta V, Höhn T, Hannen V, Haußmann N, Helbing K, Hickford S, Hiller R, Hillesheimer D, Hinz D, Hudy T, Huber A, Jansen A, Karl C, Kellerer F, Kellerer J, Kleifges M, Klein M, Köhler C, Köllenberger L, Kopmann A, Korzeczek M, Kovalík A, Krasch B, Krause H, Kunka N, Lasserre T, Le T L, Lebeda O, Lehnert B, Lokhov A, Machatschek M, Malcherek E, Mark M, Marsteller A, Martin E L, Melzer C, Menshikov A, Mertens S, Mostafa J, Müller K, Neumann H, Niemes S, Oelpmann P, Parno D S, Poon A W P, Poyato J M L, Priester F, Ramachandran S, Robertson R G H, Rodejohann W, Röllig M, Röttele C, Rodenbeck C, Ryšavý M, Sack R, Saenz A, Schäfer P, Schaller née Pollithy A, Schimpf L, Schlösser K, Schlösser M, Schlüter L, Schneidewind S, Schrank M, Schulz B, Schwemmer A, Šefčík M, Sibille V, Siegmann D, Slezák M, Spanier F, Steidl M, Sturm M, Sun M, Tcherniakhovski D, Telle H H, Thorne L A, Thümmler T, Titov N, Tkachev I, Urban K, Valerius K, Vénos D, Vizcaya Hernández A P, Weinheimer C, Welte S, Wendel J, Wilkerson J F, Wolf J, Wüstling S, Wydra J, Xu W, Yen Y R, Zadoroghny S, Zeller G and Collaboration T K 2022 Nature Physics 18 160–166 URL https://doi.org/10.1038/s41567-021-01463-1
  2. [3]Esfahani A A, Asner D M, Böser S, Cervantes R, Claessens C, de Viveiros L, Doe P J, Doeleman S, Fernandes J L, Fertl M, Finn E C, Formaggio J A, Furse D, Guigue M, Heeger K M, Jones A M, Kazkaz K, Kofron J A, Lamb C, LaRocque B H, Machado E, McBride E L, Miller M L, Monreal B, Mohanmurthy P, Nikkel J A, Oblath N S, Pettus W C, Robertson R G H, Rosenberg L J, Rybka G, Rysewyk D, Saldaa L, Slocum P L, Sternberg M G, Tedeschi J R, Thümmler T, VanDevender B A, Vertatschitsch L E, Wachterdonk M, Weintraub J, Woods N L, Young A and Zayas E M 2017 Journal of Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics 44 054004 ISSN 1361-6471 URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1361-6471/aa5b4f
  3. [4]Betti M, Biasotti M, Boscá A, Calle F, Canci N, Cavoto G, Chang C, Cocco A, Colijn A, Conrad J, D’Ambrosio N, de Groot N, de Salas P, Faverzani M, Ferella A, Ferri E, Garcia-Abia P, García-Cortés I, Gomez-Tejedor G G, Gariazzo S, Gatti F, Gentile C, Giachero A, Gudmundsson J, Hochberg Y, Kahn Y, Kievsky A, Lisanti M, Mancini-Terracciano C, Mangano G, Marcucci L, Mariani C, Martínez J, Messina M, Molinero-Vela A, Monticone E, Moroña A, NuccIotti A, Pandolfi F, Parlati S, Pastor S, Pedrós J, Heros C P d l, Pisanti O, Polosa A, Puiu A, Rago I, Raitses Y, Rajteri M, Rossi N, Rucandio I, Santorelli R, Schaeffner K, Tully C, Viviani M, Zhao F and Zurek K 2019 Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics 2019 047 ISSN 1475-7516 URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1088/1475-7516/2019/07/047
  4. [5]Cheipesh Y, Cheianov V and Boyarsky A 2021 Phys. Rev. D 104(11) 116004 arXiv:2101.10069 [hep-ph] URL https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevD.104.116004DOI
  5. [6]Mikulenko O, Cheipesh Y, Cheianov V and Boyarsky A 2021 Can we use heavy nuclei to detect relic neutrinos? https://arxiv.org/abs/2111.09292 (Preprint 2111.09292)
  6. [7]Loidl M, Rodrigues M, Censier B, Kowalski S, Mugeot X, Cassette P, Branger T and Lacour D 2010 Applied Radiation and Isotopes 68 1454–1458 proceedings of the 17th International Conference on Radionuclide Metrology and its Applications (ICRM 2009)7-11 September 2009 • Bratislava, Slovak Republic URL https://hal-cea.archives-ouvertes.fr/cea-02475320
  7. [8]Mugeot X 2017 EPJ Web of Conferences 146 12015
  8. [9]Mugeot, X, Bé, M-M and Bisch, C 2014 Radioprotection 49 269–273 URL https://doi.org/10.1051/radiopro/2014017
  9. [10]Brdar V, Plestid R and Rocco N 2022 Empirical capture cross sections for cosmic neutrino detection with 151sm and 171tm https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2201.07251 (Preprint 2201.07251)

Paper details

vlnc:W_qmaxs8gb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 2

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents