WorksPhysics and Astronomy
NLO Power Corrections for -jettiness Subtractions With Fiducial Cuts
Abstract
We compute the leading logarithmic power corrections at next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order for -jettiness subtractions for color singlet production. We discuss how to disentangle these power corrections from those arising from the presence of fiducial and isolation cuts by using Projection-to-Born improved slicing. We present the results for Drell-Yan and Higgs production in gluon fusion differential in both the invariant mass and rapidity of the color singlet. Our results include all the channels contributing at leading logarithmic order for these processes, including the off-diagonal channels that receive contributions from soft quark emission. We study the numerical impact of the power corrections for Drell-Yan and Higgs production and find it to become negligible compared to the size of the NLO corrections only below . We estimate that in a fully differential calculation at NLO combining the Projection-to-Born improved slicing method and our results for the leading logarithmic power corrections may allow for keeping the slicing uncertainties under control already with , marking a significant improvement in efficiency for these methods. These results constitute a crucial ingredient for fully differential NLO calculations based on the -jettiness subtraction scheme.
Introduction
As the volume of events collected at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) and level of refinement in experimental techniques increases, the need for producing more and more precise predictions for LHC observables is becoming of primary importance. Our ability to perform calculations in QCD at higher orders is an essential step in this direction. While techniques to perform fully differential calculation for hadronic collisions at next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO) are well established [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13], and analytic results are available for inclusive cross sections at next-to-next-to-next-to-leading (NLO) for several processes [14, 15, 16, 17], in the last couple of years a number of results are pushing the state of the art for fully differential calculations of the production of a color singlet towards the NLO benchmark [18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25]. Event shape observables, such as thrust [26], or the -jettiness resolution variable, , [27, 28], can be used to perform subtractions for fixed-order calculations at the LHC [7, 8] as well as at colliders. For the particular case of color singlet production, there has been intense progress in extending exclusive calculations to NLO. With the recent calculation of the three loop beam functions [29, 30], all the required perturbative ingredients for subtractions [1] have been computed (the hard function and soft function have been calculated before, see [31, 32]). This has enabled the first predictions for fully differential color singlet production at NLO accuracy employing the subtraction method [19, 20, 21, 23, 24, 25]. In the last few years, important results have also come out for obtaining the ingredients to extend -jettiness subtraction to LO. These include the calculation of the hard, jet, beam, and soft function, which are the perturbative ingredients of the leading power factorization theorem for this observable in soft-collinear effective theory (SCET) [33, 34, 35, 36, 37]. The LO jet function has been calculated in [38] and the three-loop beam functions have been obtained in [39] (see also [40]), therefore completely determining the collinear ingredients at this perturbative order. For the case of 2 light-like directions, which is relevant for color singlet production in hadron collisions, significant advancement has happened for the determination of the three loop soft function [41, 42, 43, 44], while the LO hard function is the same as for subtraction and has been known for a long time [31]. From the scalings of the power corrections [45, 46, 47], it is clear that performing subtractions at this order will dramatically benefit from the knowledge of the power corrections. In the recent years, substantial progress has been achieved in understanding the behaviour of QCD amplitudes and cross sections in the soft and collinear limit beyond leading power for colliders, see for example [47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77]. Using the techniques of [65], in this paper we give results for the leading logarithmic (LL) power corrections for both Drell-Yan and gluon-fusion Higgs production for the 0-jet resolution variable beam thrust [28].
We begin with a brief review of -jettiness subtraction [7, 8] and fixing the notation for our calculation. -Jettiness subtraction can be used to calculate a cross section for a given -jet process. Here is the differential measurement on the final state of the process, and we will leave the dependence on it implicit for the reminder of this section. In this work we will focus on the case of color singlet production in hadron collisions, therefore we will work with 0-jettiness. The 0-jettiness variable [78, 79] is defined as
where are the momenta of the hadronic final states. Here, are label momenta in SCET, and can be obtained from the mass and rapidity of the color singlet final state as
where we have defined the light-like vectors
which are aligned with the proton beam directions, and the Born momentum fractions
The normalization factors in eq. (1) can be used to obtain different versions of the 0-jettiness resolution variable. Two natural definitions can be obtained by performing the minimization in the hadronic or in the leptonic/color singlet center of mass frame [27, 80].
This leads to the following definitions
It is by now well understood [45, 46, 47] that the hadronic definition suffers from large power corrections that grow exponentially with rapidity. This can be understood as a manifestation of the fact that the hadronic definition forces an RPI-III [81] (or boost) charge on , hence introducing a large dependence on in its power expansion coefficients. On the other hand, in the leptonic definition, the observable becomes a boost invariant quantity, thanks to the explicit factor of the color singlet rapidity exactly compensating for the RPI charge of the plus or minus component of final state hadronic momenta. For this reason, it does not come as a surprise that an expansion in this variable has a much more stable dependence on . Given this behavior, modern implementations of 0-jettiness subtraction utilize the leptonic definition, which will thus also be adopted in the remainder of this paper.
The cross section can be organized as
For , by construction of the observable, the process has at least one resolved emission on top of the Born configuration of the process. Therefore, the contribution in the region above the cut () can be calculated using a lower loop result for a process with an extra jet in the final state. All the infrared (IR) singularities related to the Born configuration are completely accounted for by the region below the cut, i.e. . In eq. (6) we have introduced the notation for the power expansion of the differential distribution in
where1
By construction of the -jettiness variable, the leading term of the expansion around , , contains all the singular terms of the distribution. The remaining powers in the expansion yield a vanishing contribution for after integration. Consequently, we have divided the contributions from the region below the cut into two parts: a subtraction term, , which must be calculated exactly, and a residual term, , that will be neglected
Calculating as the sum of the subtraction term and the integral above the cut introduces an error due to the omission of the terms in , which can be minimized by taking smaller and smaller. 2 The main challenge in the application of -jettiness subtraction is the fact that for the precision requirement of state-of-the-art calculations, very small values of are necessary. This leads to severe numerical instabilities in the calculation of the cross section with an extra emission which, in all practical applications, is obtained via Monte Carlo integration techniques. At high perturbative order, and for very small values of , the required level of precision for the above-the-cut result either requires an enormous amount of computing time or it is just beyond the reach of currently available codes.
Here determines the region where the subtraction is active. Ignoring in eq. (10) introduces a -dependent error, similar to eq. (6). However, the final result remains independent of ’s value because its contribution is both added and subtracted identically. The main benefit of eq. (10) is that the cancellation of singular terms between and happens point by point in . This in principle allows for improving numerical stability and therefore push to smaller values, see ref. [8] for more details.
In what follows, we wish to further investigate the size of . In all common implementations of slicing in the literature, the subtraction term only contains the leading power term in the distribution, i.e. . This implies that is the cumulant of the distribution beyond leading power. Order by order in perturbation theory, we have that these terms take the form
with coefficients . Consequently, at , the residual error naively scales as
Hence, at each order in , high powers of logarithms are present and they can dramatically enhance the size of these residual uncertainties as one takes to small values. As one
approaches , of course eventually the power suppression will dominate the logarithmic enhancements. However, at LO (), enhanced power corrections up to demand very low values of to minimize the impact of on the final result.
Before we continue, let us make some technical remarks. In general, the are functions of the Born kinematics, and may depend on parton distribution functions in the case of hadron collisions. The fact that only integer powers of will appear beyond leading power is not guaranteed. It is in fact known that, for example, in the presence of fiducial cuts, arbitrary fractional powers of will appear [82]. For example, cuts on the leptonic final states of a color singlet decay will induce power corrections of , in analogy to the power corrections of appearing in the -subtraction formalism when such cuts are applied. However, these fractional power corrections vanish for sufficiently inclusive observables. Moreover, they are purely kinematic in nature. Although they may be difficult to account for analytically in general, we will demonstrate in § 2 how to disentangle them from other sources of power corrections by calculating them numerically. Therefore, we can disregard these fractional power corrections and consider eq. (12) as an appropriate starting point for understanding the scaling of the slicing error. In particular, since the focus of this work is the application of -jettiness subtraction at LO, we will focus on the case . In this case,
As calculations beyond leading power at LO are very challenging, it is interesting to understand what impact may have on the slicing error the calculation of individual terms in the logarithmic expansion of the NLP series. As a matter of fact, having analytic control on them would allow for their inclusion in the subtraction term , therefore removing them from contributing to the residual error . In order to estimate such effect, one may look at the size with or without the making the assumption that for , i.e. that the numerical coefficients in front of the logarithms are of comparable size3. To get an idea of the size of the numerical improvement due to the analytic control on the LL term, we can compare it to the size of the slicing error for . In Figure 1, we show this analysis with some samples values . We see that, due to the large power of the logarithm, analytically calculating the leading logarithm at this order, may improve the numerical accuracy of the result by an order of magnitude which translates to obtaining the same accuracy with a cut that is almost 2 order of magnitudes larger than in the case with no power corrections. Although this is just a qualitative picture, as the real quantitative impact will necessarily depend on the relative size and sign of the coefficients of the logs (which will be functions of the Born kinematic and the partonic channel), the scaling of the improvement is very promising.
Figure 1. Size of next-to-leading power (NLP) logarithmic contributions to the cumulant cross section. We see that, for this region of , going from a to a dependence for the distribution has a numerical impact comparable to a reduction of in the slicing parameter. As a consequence, gaining analytic control on single logarithmic powers of the NLP correction may provide improvements on the slicing errors comparable to orders of magnitude of additional computing time.
In this work we will calculate analytically the leading logarithmic contribution to at .
Projection to Born Improved Subtractions
In realistic experimental measurements a set of kinematic selection cuts on the final state particles is required. If these selection cuts are IRC safe, they do not spoil the singular structure of the cross section. However, they may induce large power corrections to the distribution, which often times are significantly bigger than the ones due to subleading power QCD dynamics. In the case of subtraction for color singlet production, a boost prescription can be implemented to capture these fiducial power corrections at the level of the factorization theorem [82, 83, 84, 85, 86], but this method fails in the presence of photon isolation cuts. Unfortunately, in the more general cases, accounting for these cuts analytically in the subtraction term is very challenging, since they consist of non-analytic constraints on the phase space of particles. Here, following a method proposed in ref. [82], we will show how one can separate fiducial power corrections from other sources of power corrections4 and obtain them numerically. For concreteness, we focus on the case of Higgs production in gluon fusion at LO with di-photon decay. Given the desired final state measurement , which we allow for including fiducial cuts, instead of computing the cross section , we use 0-jettiness subtraction to compute the cross section for another observable , with being a Born projection of the measurement . The difference vanishes for for any infrared safe observable . This implies that can be calculated using only information about the NNLO Higgs + jet process. In formulas this takes the form
It is easy to recognize that the Projection to Born (P2B) correction factor precisely corresponds to the subtracted real emission term of a P2B subtraction in [18, 87], with all the nice numerical features that P2B subtraction carries. The main advantage of this P2B improved slicing from the point of view of the power corrections is that the slicing calculation is performed for a Born observable. This means that the residual corrections of the slicing only depend on Born kinematics and therefore they are insensitive to effects of the fiducial cuts on the full phase space (which are the ones responsible for the presence of large fiducial power corrections). The physical effect of the presence of the fiducial cuts is accounted for by the P2B correction factor that enjoys the numerical stability of the P2B subtraction, namely the fact that, point by point in the phase space of the real radiation, the counterterm is given by the full real matrix element. Notice that using projection to Born improved subtractions would not change the fact that these cuts may severely affect the perturbative convergence of the fixed order distributions in certain regions [18, 19], as this is an issue of fixed order predictions and not of the way those are obtained. Moreover, even in the case of different fiducial cuts, such as the quadratic-cuts from ref. [88], one would still benefit from employing the P2B improved subtraction compared to the traditional one. This is the case because the main effect of those cuts is to remove the linear power corrections (which in the case of 0-jettiness would be the ones scaling as ), but they would modify the power corrections beyond that. Therefore, in order to analytically improve the subtraction without employing the P2B improved subtraction, one would need to analytically calculate both the dynamical power corrections as well as the fiducial ones, now entering at .
Leading Logarithmic Power Corrections at NLO
In this section we give the results for the leading logarithmic power corrections for color singlet production at the LHC at NLO using 0-jettiness subtraction. We start by using consistency relations to understand what is the minimal set of ingredients needed to obtain the result. We will then present the results for the case of Drell-Yan and Higgs production in gluon fusion.
Consistency Relations and Differential Color Singlet Production Beyond Leading Power
The cancellation of IR singularities order by order in perturbation theory imposes constraints on the structure of the differential distribution in . We can leverage these constraints to derive consistency conditions between different contributions entering at NLP [45]. Here, we work out the consistency conditions to NLO. The modes necessary to describe the process to the order we are working are hard, (ultra)soft, and collinear. Note that we do not distinguish between and collinear modes in this counting as they will behave identically for the purposes of this section. In the same spirit we will use the word loop loosely, indicating both loop corrections as well as phase space integrals, since, mode by mode, they both contribute in dimensional regularization with the same power in the expansion to the cross section. Beyond leading power, we always need at least one collinear or soft mode, since otherwise we are confined to the Born configuration whose contributions are always proportional to , which clearly constitutes a leading power term. The next-to-leading-power term of the differential distribution in at bare level takes the form
where is the set of all possible sets of modes of length excluding purely hard contributions, is the scaling of the list of modes and represents terms that will be removed by the interference of UV counterterms (in the full theory) with lower order results, such as coupling renormalization terms. To make this definitions more concrete, at , we have contributions involving up to 3 modes, so
The scaling for a set of modes is determined by the characteristic scales associated with the soft modes , collinear modes , and the hard modes . To give some examples of scaling at three loops:
Due to the requirement of having at least one or mode contributing at NLP, we always have . Equipped with this notation, we can expand eq. (15) at each order in up to and impose the cancellation of all poles. We work out the constraints at NLO and we write the NLO distribution at NLP in terms of the minimal number of coefficients
where the dots include terms with lower powers of and constants, and for ease of notation we used , , . From eq. (18) we see that for the coefficient of the leading log, , one only needs to calculate the leading, , pole of the contribution coming from two hard loops and a single collinear emission.
For this reason, we consider the production of a color singlet in proton-proton collisions in association with a single collinear emission of momentum
We want to retain all information on the Born kinematics of the color-singlet such that the calculation of our power corrections can be applied to fully differential calculations. Following the common practice, we parametrize the Born phase space using the rapidity and the invariant mass of the color singlet
The contribution from a single collinear emission along the -direction at NLP in the 0-jettiness distribution, differential in the color singlet rapidity and invariant mass and using the leptonic definition of 0-jettiness, reads [47]
where is fixed by the measurement constraints to be
and is the subleading power expansion of the matrix element. In eq. (21) we see that we get two contributions: The first term accounts for the contribution from subleading power matrix elements integrated over the leading power collinear phase space.
Figure 2. Example SCET cut diagrams for the off-diagonal channels contributing to leading logarithm at next-to-leading-power. In blue are depicted collinear fields, while in black the color singlet particles. The red blobs represent subleading hard scattering operators whose Wilson coefficients will encode the virtual loop corrections to the process. For our NLO analysis, one needs to consider the square of the 1-loop Wilson coefficients and the interference of the 2-loop and tree-level Wilson coefficients.
The second term in the braces corresponds to the terms involving the leading power matrix element integrated over the subleading power expansion of the phase space, which in this case includes the Born measurement functions defining and as well as in terms of the momenta , and of the color charged particles. The leading power matrix elements can be obtained using two loop splitting amplitudes, while the amplitudes at NLP for a single collinear emission at two loops were derived in ref. [62, 65] from the full kinematic results of ref. [89, 90, 91].
The less obvious results are the ones for the off-diagonal subleading power matrix element related to the soft quark Sudakov derived in ref. [65] and we report them here for completeness. The one for Higgs production reads
while for Drell-Yan we have
These subleading power matrix elements have no dependence since they scale as , which is suppressed compared the behavior of the matrix element squared at LP. Notice the divergent behaviour of these subleading power matrix elements which is responsible for promoting to leading logarithm the contributions of these off-diagonal channels.
Analytic Results
We now present the explicit results for the leading logarithmic correction for 0-jettiness at NLO for Drell-Yan and Higgs production. In both cases we can factor out the leading order partonic cross section
and write the cross section at NLP as
Drell-Yan
For the case of Drell-Yan, we find for the diagonal channel
The fact that the result is proportional to -functions in is expected due to the soft-collinear consistency of the leading logarithmic term. As a matter of fact, hard and soft modes are confined to , therefore every soft pole of hard and soft nature will be accompanied by a corresponding delta function in these splitting variables. In this work we obtained the results from the collinear limit, which in general has the full phase space available in , however, since the leading divergence will necessarily need to cancel against the soft one, the leading logarithmic contribution needs to be proportional to .
At NLP the leading logarithmic correction receives contributions also from the off-diagonal channel . For this channel we obtain
These leading logarithmic off-diagonal contributions are generate by subleading power matrix elements and encode contributions due to soft quark emissions and subleading power quark-gluon splitting functions, for details see [65]. Note again the presence of delta functions in . This may seem surprising at first, since at leading power off-diagonal channels do not have contributions from soft kinematics, but that is not the case beyond leading power.
These results encode the full LL contributions at NLP at this order. The other channels start to contribute only beyond the LL at NLP.
Higgs Production in Gluon Fusion
For the case of Higgs in gluon fusion we get leading logarithmic corrections to both the diagonal channel as well as for . At NLP for the channel, there are contributions both from the expansion of the phase space as well as from the matrix element. Combining both together we get
As for the case of Drell-Yan we get PDF derivatives for the diagonal channel. This is due to the kinematic expansion of the momentum fraction beyond leading power and it is one of the contributions coming from the subleading power expansion of the phase space.
We also have a leading logarithmic contribution for the off-diagonal channel . At LP, this channel does not contribute to the LL since the matrix element is not singular in the soft and collinear limit. At NLP, there is a singularity associated with the emitted quark going soft and collinear which promotes this contribution to a leading logarithm [54, 65]. This can be clearly seen from the behaviour of eq. (23). Therefore, the leading logarithmic contribution for this channel comes from the singular behaviour of this subleading power amplitude, while the expansion of the phase space to subleading power only generates subleading logarithmic contributions. For this channel we get
The absence of PDF derivatives in this channel at this order is expected and it is one manifestation of the lack of contributions due to subleading power phase space expansion discussed above. Note that in general, beyond leading power, one may encounter PDF derivatives even integrating a subleading power matrix element against the leading power phase space. This is due to the fact that subleading power matrix elements may develop power law divergences [64, 92, 93]. In dimensional regularization these divergences generate higher-order plus distributions which involve derivatives of delta functions or plus distributions acting on the leading power phase space and therefore on the collinear PDFs in the case of hadronic collisions. For beam thrust this is not the case at NLP, however note that for distributions beyond leading power, and therefore for power corrections needed for improving subtraction, this indeed happens, see ref. [64] for details.
Numerical Results
In this section we analyze the numerical size of the power corrections calculated in the previous sections. For concreteness, we will focus on Higgs production in gluon fusion in the infinite top mass approximation and Drell-Yan in proton-proton collision. We will consider a collider center of mass energy TeV and employ PDF4LHC15_nnlo_mc PDFs, with . We do not expect any of the conclusions in this section to depend in significant way from these choices. Following the discussion in § 1 the residual slicing error, in the usual setup where the subtraction term consists of only the leading power distribution, can be written as
In this section we will present the results for the cumulant of the power corrections calculated in secs. 3.2.1 and 3.2.2, differential in rapidity, and . This shows the numerical impact of our analytic calculation and it is a proxy for since, for , the leading logarithmic term is expected to be the dominant contribution. For convenience, from now on we will fix GeV for Drell-Yan and GeV for Higgs production and drop the dependence on for the rest of the discussion in this section. As strongly depends on , we will present results for three reference values: .
Drell-Yan
In figs. 3 and 4 we show the cumulant of the power corrections calculated in § 3.2.1, normalized by the leading order rapidity spectrum for different initial state channels. To get a quantitative understanding of the size of such NLP terms, we compare them to two interesting quantities. In dark yellow is the scale uncertainty of the NLO Drell-Yan rapidity spectrum from ref. [20]. This provides a reference for the perturbative uncertainty of this class of processes at NLO and one would like the numerical error of the NLO correction, including the slicing one, to be significantly smaller compared to such uncertainty. The other quantity we decided to plot for numerical comparison is the size of the three loop hard function boundary [31], which is one of the NLO corrections to the singular distribution and it is shown in dashed gray. Note that enters the singular distribution with a . As we are comparing objects at the cumulant level, it is therefore important to point out that its functional dependence on always integrates to 1 irrespectively of the value of . Overall, gives a rough idea of the size of the boundary ingredients that enter in the subtraction term at this order. In fig. 3 we present the result for the sum of all the channels while in fig. 4 we provide a breakdown of the contributions for the two production channels that enter at LL NLP. We see that the LL NLP term gives contributions at the order of percent for and starts to become negligible compared to the size of NLO scale variation uncertainties and hard function contribution only starting from . It is interesting to notice in the channel by channel comparison of fig. 4, that the power corrections coming from the off-diagonal channel are noticeably larger than the ones for the diagonal channel. The fact that for Drell-Yan at NLO large corrections beyond leading power are coming from the channel is not completely surprising. As a matter of fact, in the applications of -subtraction to these processes it was empirically observed that the most challenging channel for taming the effect of NLP terms was indeed the channel [20]. On the one hand, this is due to the fact that at LHC energies there is an abundance of gluons from the PDFs, but it is important to recall that at NLP the off-diagonal channel is not logarithmically suppressed. Although our calculation focuses only on 0-jettiness and therefore it cannot be considered an analytic demonstration of the behavior seen in the applications of -slicing, the feature of the PDF enhancement and that this off-diagonal channel will contribute at leading log beyond leading power, we expect to generalize to the case of -slicing very naturally, since it was already shown analytically at lower order [64].
Given the experience at NNLO, where already tens of thousands of CPU hours are necessary to obtain reliable NLO above-the-cut results for , see for example refs. [94, 95], it seems unrealistic to expect that current NNLO codes for color singlet plus jet will be able to push to without requiring an outrageous amount of computing resources. Hence, these power corrections will have significant impact for realistic applications of 0-jettiness at NLO. In this regard, in Figure 5 we try the exercise of estimating the size of the slicing error if the leading logarithmic corrections at NLP are included in the subtraction term. Clearly, the real size of the residual error will ultimately depend on the actual numerical coefficients of the subleading logarithmic (and power) terms, so some assumptions are necessary for this estimate. In the following we look at the case where , i.e. we use for the next-to-leading logarithmic coefficient the same numerical value we obtained for the leading log. We neglect further subleading logs and powers as we expect that for such small values of they will not play a significant role.

Figure 5. Estimate of the slicing error after the removal of the leading logarithmic terms analytically calculated in this work (i.e. after their inclusion in the subtraction term) for various values of . The result is normalized by the leading order rapidity spectrum and plotted for comparisons are the scale variation uncertainties of the NLO spectrum from [20] and the NLO hard function contribution to the subtraction term.
Figure 4. Same as Figure 3 but for different production channels. We show the diagonal channel on the left and on the right. Both channels contribute at leading log at NLP. It is evident that the power corrections to are substantially larger than those for . Note that the plot shows the absolute value of the LL NLP cumulant, however there is a relative sign between these two channels.
Figure 3. Size of the leading logarithmic power corrections at NLO for Drell-Yan differential in rapidity. This result accounts for all the contributions entering at leading logarithmic accuracy, which at next-to-leading power include the off-diagonal channel due to contributions of soft quarks and fermion number changing collinear splitting. For comparison, the scale variation uncertainties of the NLO spectrum from [20] and the NLO hard function contribution to the subtraction term are plotted, showing that these power corrections are sizable for .
As we can observe from Figure 5, in this situation the power corrections would be noticeably smaller than the scale variation already starting from and completely negligible for . Being able to keep the slicing error under control while loosening the cuts so significantly would be a very important improvement in the feasibility and efficiency of slicing calculations at this order.
Higgs Production in Gluon Fusion
We now turn our attention to the case of Higgs production in gluon fusion. As we have seen in § 3.2.2, we have contributions from two channels. The numerical result for their sum is displayed in Figure 6, together with the NLO inclusive K-factor from [17] and the NLO hard function contribution [31] to the subtraction term for comparison.
Figure 6. Size of the leading logarithmic power corrections at NLO for Higgs production in gluon fusion differential in rapidity. This result accounts for all the contributions entering at leading logarithmic accuracy, which at next-to-leading power include the off-diagonal channel due to contributions of soft quarks and fermion number changing collinear splitting. For comparison, the NLO inclusive K-factor from [17] and the NLO hard function [31] contribution to the subtraction term are plotted, showing that these power corrections are sizable for . Note that the behaviour at very large rapidities is mainly due to the choice of normalization and will have a negligible effect in absolute terms.
For Drell-Yan we decided to show the results normalized by the leading order rapidity spectrum, since the higher order corrections are not large and therefore they do not change significantly the picture. However, in the case of Higgs production in gluon fusion it is very well known that there are sizable higher order corrections, although they are pretty flat in rapidity [10, 18, 96, 97]. For this reason, normalizing NLO results by the LO rapidity spectrum would make all the NLO ingredients appear unnaturally large. While this equally affects both the calculated power corrections and the ingredients we are comparing them to, and thus wouldn’t distort any numerical comparison between them, we preferred to avoid this. Hence, we present the results in this section normalized by the product of the LO rapidity spectrum and the NNLO inclusive K-factor, which gives a good proxy for the size of the NNLO rapidity distribution we are computing corrections to. Regarding the size of the LL power corrections, we see that, similarly to what we have seen in the previous section for Drell-Yan, they are quite sizable compared to the typical size of the NLO corrections, unless one considers values significantly below , which is quite challenging numerically. We also see that the dependence in rapidity is rather flat. Note that the behaviour at large rapidities is mainly caused by the vanishing of the normalization which is determined by the gluon PDF at large . This has an irrelevant effect in absolute terms since in that region there is very little cross section.
For completeness, in Figure 7 we show the channel decomposition of our result. We see that the contribution from the diagonal channel is by far the most dominant one being more than an order of magnitude larger than the channel. This is in contrast with what we have seen in § 4.1 in the case of Drell-Yan where the off-diagonal channel was larger. Note that the channel enters at the same logarithmic order as the diagonal channel and their relative size is most likely explained by the gluon PDF being large in the typical kinematic regions probed in Higgs production at the LHC.
Figure 7. Same as Figure 3 but for different production channels. We show the diagonal channel on the left and on the right. Both channels contribute at leading log at NLP. It is evident that the power corrections to the diagonal channel are the only one numerically relevant, since they constitute more than 95% of the total contribution. Note that the behaviour at very large rapidities is mainly due to the choice of normalization and will have a negligible effect in absolute terms.
Finally, in Figure 8 we repeat the exercise of estimating the size of the residual slicing uncertainties after including the results of § 3.2.2 in the subtraction term, assuming a similar size between the coefficients of the logarithms at NLP. We observe that the inclusion of these terms analytically alleviates the impact of slicing uncertainties and could allow for obtaining results with acceptable uncertainties with not too far from . If that turns out to be the case, it will be then interesting to see if this could roughly compete in terms of numerical efficiency with calculations purely based on P2B such as the one of ref. [18].
Figure 8. Estimate of the slicing error after the removal of the leading logarithmic terms analytically calculated in this work (i.e. after their inclusion in the subtraction term) for various values of . Plotted for comparison are the inclusive NLO K-factor and the NLO hard function contribution to the subtraction term.
Conclusions
In this work, we calculated the leading logarithmic dynamical power corrections to the 0-jettiness distribution at next-to-next-to-next-to-leading order, differential in rapidity and invariant mass, for Drell-Yan and Higgs production in gluon fusion. We have presented a method to disentangle dynamical power corrections, tied to QCD dynamics beyond leading power, from those arising from fiducial cuts using Projection to Born-improved subtractions. From the calculation of these power corrections, we can estimate that if only the leading power terms in the 0-jettiness distribution are included in the subtraction term, it would be necessary to push the slicing parameter to values below to obtain results with slicing errors at few per-mille level. On the other hand, including these leading logarithmic terms in the subtraction can substantially improve the situation. We estimate that removing this leading source of power corrections can yield a numerical improvement at NLO comparable to reducing the slicing parameter by in the cases where there are no accidental large differences between the LL NLP coefficients and the ones multiplying the subleading logarithms. This is the case at NLO and NNLO for Drell-Yan and gluon-fusion Higgs production at the LHC [45, 46, 47]. Therefore, we believe that with the inclusion of the leading logarithmic corrections and using the projection to Born improvement for the treatment of fiducial power corrections, it should be possible to perform fully differential NLO calculations with with slicing uncertainties under control. This advancement opens the door to NLO predictions based on slicing with significantly enhanced efficiency, crucial for broadening the availability and utility of these predictions in precision phenomenology studies at current and future colliders.
Acknowledgments
We thank Alexander Huss for numerous discussions throughout this work, feedback on the manuscript, and for providing the numerical results from ref. [20]. We are grateful to Iain Stewart, HuaXing Zhu, and Ian Moult for discussions which initiated this project, to Alessandro Broggio and Simone Alioli for insightful discussions, and to Pier Monni for helpful comments on this work and feedback on the manuscript. We thank the Erwin-Schrödinger International Institute for Mathematics and Physics at the University of Vienna for partial support during the Programme “Quantum Field Theory at the Frontiers of the Strong Interactions”. We thank the Galileo Galilei Institute for Theoretical Physics for the hospitality and the INFN for partial support during the completion of this work.
References
- [1]S. Catani and M. Grazzini, An NNLO subtraction formalism in hadron collisions and its application to Higgs boson production at the LHC, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 (2007) 222002, [hep-ph/0703012].DOI
- [2]F. Caola, K. Melnikov and R. Röntsch, Nested soft-collinear subtractions in NNLO QCD computations, Eur. Phys. J. C 77 (2017) 248, [arXiv:1702.01352].DOI
- [3]A. Gehrmann-De Ridder, T. Gehrmann and E. W. N. Glover, Antenna subtraction at NNLO, JHEP 09 (2005) 056, [hep-ph/0505111].
- [4]M. Czakon, A novel subtraction scheme for double-real radiation at NNLO, Phys. Lett. B 693 (2010) 259–268, [arXiv:1005.0274].DOI
- [5]R. Boughezal, K. Melnikov and F. Petriello, A subtraction scheme for NNLO computations, Phys. Rev. D 85 (2012) 034025, [arXiv:1111.7041].DOI
- [6]M. Czakon and D. Heymes, Four-dimensional formulation of the sector-improved residue subtraction scheme, Nucl. Phys. B 890 (2014) 152–227, [arXiv:1408.2500].DOI
- [7]R. Boughezal, C. Focke, W. Giele, X. Liu and F. Petriello, Higgs boson production in association with a jet at NNLO using jettiness subtraction, Phys. Lett. B 748 (2015) 5–8, [arXiv:1505.03893].arxiv.org/abs/1505.03893
- [8]J. Gaunt, M. Stahlhofen, F. J. Tackmann and J. R. Walsh, N-jettiness Subtractions for NNLO QCD Calculations, JHEP 09 (2015) 058, [arXiv:1505.04794].arxiv.org/abs/1505.04794
- [9]V. Del Duca, C. Duhr, A. Kardos, G. Somogyi, Z. Szőr, Z. Trócsányi et al., Jet production in the CoLoRFulNNLO method: event shapes in electron-positron collisions, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016) 074019, [arXiv:1606.03453].DOI
- [10]F. Dulat, S. Lionetti, B. Mistlberger, A. Pelloni and C. Spe cchia, Higgs-differential cross section at NNLO in dimensional regularisation, JHEP 07 (2017) 017, [arXiv:1704.08220].DOI
- [11]L. Magnea, E. Maina, G. Pelliccioli, C. Signorile-Signorile, P. Torrielli and S. Uccirati, Local analytic sector subtraction at NNLO, JHEP 12 (2018) 107, [arXiv:1806.09570]. [Erratum: JHEP 06, 013 (2019)].DOI
- [12]F. Devoto, K. Melnikov, R. Röntsch, C. Signorile-Signorile and D. M. Tagliabue, A fresh look at the nested soft-collinear subtraction scheme: NNLO QCD corrections to N-gluon final states in qq̄ annihilation, arXiv:2310.17598.arxiv.org/abs/2310.17598
- [13]T. Gehrmann, E. W. N. Glover and M. Marcoli, The colourful antenna subtraction method, arXiv:2310.19757.DOI
- [14]C. Anastasiou, C. Duhr, F. Dulat, E. Furlan, T. Gehrmann, F. Herzog et al., High precision determination of the gluon fusion Higgs boson cross-section at the LHC, JHEP 05 (2016) 058, [arXiv:1602.00695].arxiv.org/abs/1602.00695
- [15]B. Mistlberger, Higgs boson production at hadron colliders at N³LO in QCD, JHEP 05 (2018) 028, [arXiv:1802.00833].DOI
- [16]C. Duhr, F. Dulat and B. Mistlberger, Higgs Boson Production in Bottom-Quark Fusion to Third Order in the Strong Coupling, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125 (2020) 051804, [arXiv:1904.09990].DOI
- [17]J. Baglio, C. Duhr, B. Mistlberger and R. Szafron, Inclusive production cross sections at N³LO, JHEP 12 (2022) 066, [arXiv:2209.06138].DOI
- [18]X. Chen, T. Gehrmann, E. W. N. Glover, A. Huss, B. Mistlberger and A. Pelloni, Fully Differential Higgs Boson Production to Third Order in QCD, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 (2021) 072002, [arXiv:2102.07607].DOI
- [19]G. Billis, B. Dehnadi, M. A. Ebert, J. K. L. Michel and F. J. Tackmann, Higgs pT Spectrum and Total Cross Section with Fiducial Cuts at Third Resummed and Fixed Order in QCD, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127 (2021) 072001, [arXiv:2102.08039].DOI
- [20]X. Chen, T. Gehrmann, N. Glover, A. Huss, T.-Z. Yang and H. X. Zhu, Dilepton Rapidity Distribution in Drell-Yan Production to Third Order in QCD, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 (2022) 052001, [arXiv:2107.09085].DOI
- [21]X. Chen, T. Gehrmann, E. W. N. Glover, A. Huss, P. F. Monni, E. Re et al., Third-Order Fiducial Predictions for Drell-Yan Production at the LHC, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128 (2022) 252001, [arXiv:2203.01565].DOI
- [22]X. Chen, T. Gehrmann, N. Glover, A. Huss, T.-Z. Yang and H. X. Zhu, Differential N3LO QCD corrections to charged current production at the LHC, PoS LL2022 (2022) 004, [arXiv:2207.08584].arxiv.org/abs/2207.08584
- [23]X. Chen, T. Gehrmann, N. Glover, A. Huss, T.-Z. Yang and H. X. Zhu, Transverse mass distribution and charge asymmetry in W boson production to third order in QCD, Phys. Lett. B 840 (2023) 137876, [arXiv:2205.11426].DOI
- [24]T. Neumann and J. Campbell, Fiducial Drell-Yan production at the LHC improved by transverse-momentum resummation at N4LLp+N3LO, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) L011506, [arXiv:2207.07056].DOI
- [25]J. Campbell and T. Neumann, Third order QCD predictions for fiducial W-boson production, JHEP 11 (2023) 127, [arXiv:2308.15382].DOI
- [26]E. Farhi, A QCD Test for Jets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 39 (1977) 1587–1588.
- [27]I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann and W. J. Waalewijn, Factorization at the LHC: From PDFs to Initial State Jets, Phys. Rev. D 81 (2010) 094035, [arXiv:0910.0467].DOI
- [28]I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann and W. J. Waalewijn, N-Jettiness: An Inclusive Event Shape to Veto Jets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (2010) 092002, [arXiv:1004.2489].DOI
- [29]M.-x. Luo, T.-Z. Yang, H. X. Zhu and Y. J. Zhu, Quark Transverse Parton Distribution at the Next-to-Next-to-Next-to-Leading Order, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124 (2020) 092001, [arXiv:1912.05778].DOI
- [30]M. A. Ebert, B. Mistlberger and G. Vita, Transverse momentum dependent PDFs at N³LO, JHEP 09 (2020) 146, [arXiv:2006.05329].
- [31]T. Gehrmann, E. W. N. Glover, T. Huber, N. Ikizlerli and C. Studerus, Calculation of the quark and gluon form factors to three loops in QCD, JHEP 06 (2010) 094, [arXiv:1004.3653].DOI
- [32]Y. Li and H. X. Zhu, Bootstrapping Rapidity Anomalous Dimensions for Transverse-Momentum Resummation, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118 (2017) 022004, [arXiv:1604.01404].DOI
- [33]C. W. Bauer, S. Fleming and M. E. Luke, Summing Sudakov logarithms in B → X_sγ in effective field theory., Phys. Rev. D 63 (2000) 014006, [hep-ph/0005275].DOI
- [34]C. W. Bauer, S. Fleming, D. Pirjol and I. W. Stewart, An Effective field theory for collinear and soft gluons: Heavy to light decays, Phys. Rev. D 63 (2001) 114020, [hep-ph/0011336].DOI
- [35]C. W. Bauer and I. W. Stewart, Invariant operators in collinear effective theory, Phys. Lett. B 516 (2001) 134–142, [hep-ph/0107001].DOI
- [36]C. W. Bauer, D. Pirjol and I. W. Stewart, Soft collinear factorization in effective field theory, Phys. Rev. D 65 (2002) 054022, [hep-ph/0109045].DOI
- [37]C. W. Bauer, S. Fleming, D. Pirjol, I. Z. Rothstein and I. W. Stewart, Hard scattering factorization from effective field theory, Phys. Rev. D 66 (2002) 014017, [hep-ph/0202088].DOI
- [38]R. Brüser, Z. L. Liu and M. Stahlhofen, Three-Loop Quark Jet Function, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121 (2018) 072003, [arXiv:1804.09722].DOI
- [39]M. A. Ebert, B. Mistlberger and G. Vita, N-jettiness beam functions at N^3LO, JHEP 09 (2020) 143, [arXiv:2006.03056].DOI
- [40]D. Baranowski, A. Behring, K. Melnikov, L. Tancredi and C. Wever, Beam functions for N-jettiness at N^3LO in perturbative QCD, JHEP 02 (2023) 073, [arXiv:2211.05722].DOI
- [41]D. Baranowski, NNLO zero-jettiness beam and soft functions to higher orders in the dimensional-regularization parameter ε, Eur. Phys. J. C 80 (2020) 523, [arXiv:2004.03285].DOI
- [42]D. Baranowski, M. Delto, K. Melnikov and C.-Y. Wang, On phase-space integrals with Heaviside functions, JHEP 02 (2022) 081, [arXiv:2111.13594].DOI
- [43]D. Baranowski, M. Delto, K. Melnikov and C.-Y. Wang, Same-hemisphere three-gluon-emission contribution to the zero-jettiness soft function at N^3LO QCD, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 014004, [arXiv:2204.09459].DOI
- [44]W. Chen, F. Feng, Y. Jia and X. Liu, Double-real-virtual and double-virtual-real corrections to the three-loop thrust soft function, JHEP 22 (2020) 094, [arXiv:2206.12323].
- [45]I. Moult, L. Rothen, I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann and H. X. Zhu, Subleading Power Corrections for N-Jettiness Subtractions, Phys. Rev. D 95 (2017) 074023, [arXiv:1612.00450].DOI
- [46]I. Moult, L. Rothen, I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann and H. X. Zhu, N-jettiness subtractions for gg → H at subleading power, Phys. Rev. D 97 (2018) 014013, [arXiv:1710.03227].DOI
- [47]M. A. Ebert, I. Moult, I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann, G. Vita and H. X. Zhu, Power Corrections for N-Jettiness Subtractions at O(α_s), JHEP 12 (2018) 084, [arXiv:1807.10764].DOI
- [48]I. Moult, I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann and W. J. Waalewijn, Employing Helicity Amplitudes for Resummation, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) 094003, [arXiv:1508.02397].DOI
- [49]D. Bonocore, E. Laenen, L. Magnea, S. Melville, L. Vernazza and C. D. White, A factorization approach to next-to-leading-power threshold logarithms, JHEP 06 (2015) 008, [arXiv:1503.05156].arxiv.org/abs/1503.05156
- [50]D. Bonocore, E. Laenen, L. Magnea, L. Vernazza and C. D. White, Non-abelian factorisation for next-to-leading-power threshold logarithms, JHEP 12 (2016) 121, [arXiv:1610.06842].DOI
- [51]D. W. Kolodrubetz, I. Moult and I. W. Stewart, Building Blocks for Subleading Helicity Operators, JHEP 05 (2016) 139, [arXiv:1601.02607].DOI
- [52]M. Beneke, M. Garny, R. Szafron and J. Wang, Anomalous dimension of subleading-power N-jet operators, JHEP 03 (2018) 001, [arXiv:1712.04416].DOI
- [53]M. Beneke, M. Garny, R. Szafron and J. Wang, Subleading-power N-jet operators and the LBK amplitude in SCET, PoS RADCOR2017 (2017) 048, [arXiv:1712.07462].arxiv.org/abs/1712.07462
- [54]I. Moult, I. W. Stewart and G. Vita, A subleading operator basis and matching for gg → H, JHEP 07 (2017) 067, [arXiv:1703.03408].DOI
- [55]C.-H. Chang, I. W. Stewart and G. Vita, A Subleading Power Operator Basis for the Scalar Quark Current, JHEP 04 (2018) 041, [arXiv:1712.04343].DOI
- [56]I. Feige, D. W. Kolodrubetz, I. Moult and I. W. Stewart, A Complete Basis of Helicity Operators for Subleading Factorization, JHEP 11 (2017) 142, [arXiv:1703.03411].DOI
- [57]M. Beneke, M. Garny, R. Szafron and J. Wang, Anomalous dimension of subleading-power N-jet operators. Part II, JHEP 11 (2018) 112, [arXiv:1808.04742].DOI
- [58]M. Beneke, M. Garny, R. Szafron and J. Wang, Violation of the Kluberg-Stern-Zuber theorem in SCET, JHEP 09 (2019) 101, [arXiv:1907.05463].DOI
- [59]I. Moult, I. W. Stewart and G. Vita, Subleading Power Factorization with Radiative Functions, JHEP 11 (2019) 153, [arXiv:1905.07411].DOI
- [60]R. Boughezal, A. Isgrò and F. Petriello, Next-to-leading-logarithmic power corrections for N-jettiness subtraction in color-singlet production, Phys. Rev. D 97 (2018) 076006, [arXiv:1802.00456].DOI
- [61]R. Brüser, S. Caron-Huot and J. M. Henn, Subleading Regge limit from a soft anomalous dimension, JHEP 04 (2018) 047, [arXiv:1802.02524].DOI
- [62]I. Moult, I. W. Stewart, G. Vita and H. X. Zhu, First Subleading Power Resummation for Event Shapes, JHEP 08 (2018) 013, [arXiv:1804.04665].DOI
- [63]M. Beneke, A. Broggio, M. Garny, S. Jaskiewicz, R. Szafron, L. Vernazza et al., Leading-logarithmic threshold resummation of the Drell-Yan process at next-to-leading power, JHEP 03 (2019) 043, [arXiv:1809.10631].DOI
- [64]M. A. Ebert, I. Moult, I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann, G. Vita and H. X. Zhu, Subleading power rapidity divergences and power corrections for qT, JHEP 04 (2019) 123, [arXiv:1812.08189].DOI
- [65]I. Moult, I. W. Stewart, G. Vita and H. X. Zhu, The Soft Quark Sudakov, JHEP 05 (2020) 089, [arXiv:1910.14038].DOI
- [66]M. Beneke, M. Garny, S. Jaskiewicz, R. Szafron, L. Vernazza and J. Wang, Leading-logarithmic threshold resummation of Higgs production in gluon fusion at next-to-leading power, JHEP 01 (2020) 094, [arXiv:1910.12685].DOI
- [67]L. Buonocore, M. Grazzini and F. Tramontano, The qT subtraction method: electroweak corrections and power suppressed contributions, Eur. Phys. J. C 80 (2020) 254, [arXiv:1911.10166].DOI
- [68]M. van Beekveld, W. Beenakker, E. Laenen and C. D. White, Next-to-leading power threshold effects for inclusive and exclusive processes with final state jets, JHEP 03 (2020) 106, [arXiv:1905.08741].DOI
- [69]M. Beneke, A. Broggio, S. Jaskiewicz and L. Vernazza, Threshold factorization of the Drell-Yan process at next-to-leading power, JHEP 07 (2020) 078, [arXiv:1912.01585].DOI
- [70]C. Anastasiou and A. Penin, Light Quark Mediated Higgs Boson Threshold Production in the Next-to-Leading Logarithmic Approximation, JHEP 07 (2020) 195, [arXiv:2004.03602]. [Erratum: JHEP 01, 164 (2021)].DOI
- [71]E. Laenen, J. Sinninghe Damsté, L. Vernazza, W. Waalewijn and L. Zoppi, Towards all-order factorization of QED amplitudes at next-to-leading power, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) 034022, [arXiv:2008.01736].DOI
- [72]G. Vita, QCD Beyond Leading Power. PhD thesis, MIT, 9, 2020. arXiv:2008.10606.arxiv.org/abs/2008.10606
- [73]Z. L. Liu, B. Mecaj, M. Neubert and X. Wang, Factorization at subleading power and endpoint divergences in h → γγ decay. Part II. Renormalization and scale evolution, JHEP 01 (2021) 077, [arXiv:2009.06779].DOI
- [74]A. Broggio, S. Jaskiewicz and L. Vernazza, Next-to-leading power two-loop soft functions for the Drell-Yan process at threshold, JHEP 10 (2021) 061, [arXiv:2107.07353].DOI
- [75]T. Liu, S. Modi and A. A. Penin, Higgs boson production and quark scattering amplitudes at high energy through the next-to-next-to-leading power in quark mass, JHEP 02 (2022) 170, [arXiv:2111.01820].DOI
- [76]Z. L. Liu, M. Neubert, M. Schnubel and X. Wang, Factorization at next-to-leading power and endpoint divergences in gg → h production, JHEP 06 (2023) 183, [arXiv:2212.10447].DOI
- [77]A. Broggio, S. Jaskiewicz and L. Vernazza, Threshold factorization of the Drell-Yan quark-gluon channel and two-loop soft function at next-to-leading power, JHEP 12 (2023) 028, [arXiv:2306.06037].DOI
- [78]I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann and W. J. Waalewijn, The Beam Thrust Cross Section for Drell-Yan at NNLL Order, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106 (2011) 032001, [arXiv:1005.4060].DOI
- [79]T. T. Jouttenus, I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann and W. J. Waalewijn, The Soft Function for Exclusive N-Jet Production at Hadron Colliders, Phys. Rev. D 83 (2011) 114030, [arXiv:1102.4344].DOI
- [80]C. F. Berger, C. Marcantonini, I. W. Stewart, F. J. Tackmann and W. J. Waalewijn, Higgs Production with a Central Jet Veto at NNLL+NNLO, JHEP 04 (2011) 092, [arXiv:1012.4480].DOI
- [81]A. V. Manohar, T. Mehen, D. Pirjol and I. W. Stewart, Reparameterization invariance for collinear operators, Phys. Lett. B539 (2002) 59–66, [hep-ph/0204229].DOI
- [82]M. A. Ebert and F. J. Tackmann, Impact of isolation and fiducial cuts on qT and N-jettiness subtractions, JHEP 03 (2020) 158, [arXiv:1911.08486].DOI
- [83]S. Catani, D. de Florian, G. Ferrera and M. Grazzini, Vector boson production at hadron colliders: transverse-momentum resummation and leptonic decay, JHEP 12 (2015) 047, [arXiv:1507.06937].DOI
- [84]M. A. Ebert, J. K. L. Michel, I. W. Stewart and F. J. Tackmann, Drell-Yan q_T resummation of fiducial power corrections at N^3LL, JHEP 04 (2021) 102, [arXiv:2006.11382].DOI
- [85]S. Camarda, L. Cieri and G. Ferrera, Fiducial perturbative power corrections within the q_T subtraction formalism, Eur. Phys. J. C 82 (2022) 575, [arXiv:2111.14509].DOI
- [86]L. Buonocore, S. Kallweit, L. Rottoli and M. Wiesemann, Linear power corrections for two-body kinematics in the q_T subtraction formalism, Phys. Lett. B 829 (2022) 137118, [arXiv:2111.13661].DOI
- [87]M. Cacciari, F. A. Dreyer, A. Karlberg, G. P. Salam and G. Zanderighi, Fully Differential Vector-Boson-Fusion Higgs Production at Next-to-Next-to-Leading Order, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115 (2015) 082002, [arXiv:1506.02660]. [Erratum: Phys.Rev.Lett. 120, 139901 (2018)].
- [88]G. P. Salam and E. Slade, Cuts for two-body decays at colliders, JHEP 11 (2021) 220, [arXiv:2106.08329].DOI
- [89]T. Gehrmann, M. Jaquier, E. W. N. Glover and A. Kou kout sakis, Two-Loop QCD Corrections to the Helicity Amplitudes for H → 3 partons, JHEP 02 (2012) 056, [arXiv:1112.3554].DOI
- [90]L. W. Garland, T. Gehrmann, E. W. N. Glover, A. Koukoutsakis and E. Remiddi, The Two loop QCD matrix element for e+ e- --> 3 jets, Nucl. Phys. B 627 (2002) 107–188, [hep-ph/0112081].DOI
- [91]L. W. Garland, T. Gehrmann, E. W. N. Glover, A. Koukoutsakis and E. Remiddi, Two loop QCD helicity amplitudes for e+ e- --> three jets, Nucl. Phys. B 642 (2002) 227–262, [hep-ph/0206067].DOI
- [92]A. Bhattacharya, I. Moult, I. W. Stewart and G. Vita, Helicity Methods for High Multiplicity Subleading Soft and Collinear Limits, JHEP 05 (2019) 192, [arXiv:1812.06950].DOI
- [93]R. Boughezal, A. Isgrò and F. Petriello, Next-to-leading power corrections to V + 1 jet production in N-jettiness subtraction, Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 016005, [arXiv:1907.12213].DOI
- [94]S. Alekhin, A. Kardos, S. Moch and Z. Trócsányi, Precision studies for Drell-Yan processes at NNLO, Eur. Phys. J. C 81 (2021) 573, [arXiv:2104.02400].DOI
- [95]J. M. Campbell, R. K. Ellis and S. Seth, Non-local slicing approaches for NNLO QCD in MCFM, JHEP 06 (2022) 002, [arXiv:2202.07738].DOI
- [96]C. Anastasiou, K. Melnikov and F. Petriello, Higgs boson production at hadron colliders: Differential cross sections through next-to-next-to-leading order, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004) 262002, [hep-ph/0409088].DOI
- [97]F. Dulat, B. Mistlberger and A. Pelloni, Differential Higgs production at N^3LO beyond threshold, JHEP 01 (2018) 145, [arXiv:1710.03016].DOI






