betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Rational knots, quivers, and tails of colored HOMFLY-PT polynomials

Abstract

We use the knots-quivers correspondence to prove that the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial of a rational knot has a tail and give an explicit formula for calculating the tail in terms of the quiver.

Introduction

The colored Jones polynomial is a well-known invariant of knots which associates a sequence of Laurent polynomials to each knot. One of the interesting phenomena it exhibits is that for certain classes of knots, the coefficients of highest and lowest qq-powers stabilize as the color increases. This stabilization was first observed by Dasbach and Lin [7], where they proved that the first three leading coefficients of the colored Jones polynomial for an alternating knot stabilized up to a sign, and they conjectured that this stabilization would continue for all leading coefficients, forming a “tail.” Later, the tail of the colored Jones polynomial of an alternating link LL was proven to exist by Garoufalidis and Lê [8] using generalized Nahm sums. The tail was also independently proven to exist for a more general class of knots called adequate knots by Armond [3]. Finally, Beirne and Osburn [4] ask whether a tail exists in some sense for generalizations of the colored Jones polynomial.

The colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial of a knot is a sequence of Laurent polynomials in qq with coefficients in Z[a±1]\mathbb{Z}[a^{\pm1}]. After a substitution, it specializes to the colored Jones polynomial. Thus, it is natural to wonder if there is a similar stability phenomenon in the coefficients of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial.

In this paper, we use the links-quivers correspondence [15] to prove that the normalized colored HOMFLY-PT polynomials of every rational knot converge coefficient-wise to a formal power series ΨK(a,q)\Psi_K(a,q), which we call the tail of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial. In addition, we provide an explicit formula for the tail in terms of the quivers for the knots.

Limits of a sequence of polynomials

The colored Jones polynomial can be thought of as a sequence of Laurent polynomials with integer coefficients. Consider the jjth colored Jones polynomial of KK, JKj(q)J_K^j(q), normalized so that JKj(q)=1J_K^j(q)=1 for KK the unknot. Note that for j=1j=1 this is the ordinary Jones polynomial. By dividing JKj(q)J_K^j(q) by its monomial with lowest power of qq, we can write the normalized jjth colored Jones polynomial of KK to be

J^Kj(q):=∑i=0∞c^ijq2i\widehat{J}_K^j(q):=\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}\widehat{c}_i^j q^{2i}

for c^ij∈Z\widehat{c}_i^j\in\mathbb{Z}. We then say that J^Kj(q)\widehat{J}_K^j(q) converges coefficient-wise to ΦK(q)∈Z[[q]]\Phi_K(q)\in\mathbb{Z}[[q]] as a formal power series if for every i≥0i\geq0, there exists an m≥0m\geq0 such that the coefficient of q2iq^{2i} is independent of jj for all j≥mj\geq m. In this case, we say that the tail of the colored Jones polynomial ΦK(q)\Phi_K(q) exists. In fact, for all knots in which the tail exists, it is the case that the coefficient of q2iq^{2i} stabilizes when m=im=i [3].

Likewise, one can also normalize by the monomial with the greatest power of qq and obtain the “head” of the colored Jones polynomial. Note that the head of KK is determined by the tail of −K-K, the mirror knot of KK.

Now we define the tail of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial analogously to the colored Jones polynomial. Recall that for a knot KK the jjth (antisymmetric) colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial PKj(a,q)P_K^j(a,q) is a Laurent polynomial in two variables and that one can obtain the colored Jones polynomial of KK from the specialization q→q−1q \to q^{-1}, a→q2a \to q^2. Of the monomials of PKj(a,q)P^j_K(a,q) with minimum qq-power, choose the monomial with the greatest aa-power (there may be multiple monomials with minimum qq-power, so it is by convention that we choose the one with greatest aa-power). Then by dividing PKj(a,q)P^j_K(a,q) by this monomial, we can define the normalized jjth colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial of KK to be

P^Kj(a,q):=∑s∈Z,r≥0cs,rja2sq2r\widehat{P}^j_K(a,q) := \sum_{\substack{s\in\mathbb{Z},r\geq0}} c^j_{s,r}a^{2s}q^{2r}

for cs,rj∈Zc^j_{s,r}\in\mathbb{Z}. We then say that P^Kj(a,q)\widehat{P}^j_K(a,q) converges coefficient-wise to ΨK(a,q)∈Z[a±1][[q]]\Psi_K(a,q)\in\mathbb{Z}[a^{\pm1}][[q]] as a formal power series if for every i≥0i\geq0, there exists an m≥0m\geq0 such that the coefficient of q2iq^{2i} is independent of jj for all j≥mj\geq m. In this case, we say that the tail of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial ΨK(a,q)\Psi_K(a,q) exists.

Analogously to the Jones case, if we instead normalized PKj(a,q)P^j_K(a,q) by the monomial with maximum qq-power and lowest aa-power, then we would obtain the head of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial.

Knots-Quivers Correspondence

A knot KK satisfies the knots-quivers correspondence [14, 15] if there exist linear forms R,S,AR,S,A and a quadratic form QQ defined on a free Z\mathbb{Z}-module V≅ZuV\cong\mathbb{Z}^u, such that the generating function for the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomials can be written as

∑r≥0PKr(a,q)xr=∑d∈Nu(−1)R⋅dqS⋅daA⋅dqdTQd[∣d∣]q2[d1,…,du]q2x∣d∣.(1)\sum_{r\geq0}P^r_K(a,q)x^r=\sum_{d\in\mathbb{N}^u}(-1)^{R\cdot d}q^{S\cdot d}a^{A\cdot d}q^{d^TQd}\frac{[|d|]_{q^2}}{[d_1,\ldots,d_u]_{q^2}}x^{|d|}. \tag*{(1)}

In [22], Stošić and Wedrich prove that the knots-quivers correspondence holds for all arborescent knots, extending their previous proof for rational knots [21]. They detail how to calculate these forms algebraically for rational knots. Additionally, the third author gives a geometric method for calculating these quivers [11]. Note that these methods may give different quivers, but they produce the same generating function and are equivalent up to a permutation of off-diagonal entries in a manner allowable by [12]. We will thus refer to quivers obtained by the third author’s method as geometric quivers and those obtained by Stošić and Wedrich’s method as algebraic quivers. The quivers we give as examples in this paper will be geometric quivers, but some of the proofs about properties of quivers will be in terms of algebraic quivers.

Main Result

In order to prove the existence of the tail of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial, we consider a distinguished submatrix of the quiver QQ for a knot KK which controls which vertices contribute to any fixed coefficient of the limiting power series. Terms involving vertices outside of these submatrices will have arbitrarily high degree of qq as the color increases. In order to guarantee these submatrices exist and can produce a tail, the quivers must have certain properties. Thus, we give the following definition.

Definition 1.1. Let KK be a knot which satisfies the knots-quivers correspondence. Then KK is of class Q\mathcal{Q} if it admits quiver data Q,S,AQ,S,A such that:

(1) QQ has a unique minimum on its diagonal

(2) the minimum of diag⁡(Q)\operatorname{diag}(Q) is the minimum (not necessarily unique) of the whole quiver.

(3) diag⁡(Q)=S−2A\operatorname{diag}(Q)=S-2A

Now, the main theorem can be stated as follows.

Theorem 1.2. The tail of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial exists for knots KK of class Q\mathcal{Q} and is determined by the restriction of the quiver data to quadratic and linear forms Qt,St,At,RtQ^t,S^t,A^t,R^t defined on a certain submodule Vt≅ZmV^t\cong\mathbb{Z}^m of VV with a formula given by

ΨK(a,q)=∑d∈Nm(−1)Rt⋅daAt⋅dqdtQtd+St⋅d∏i=1m(q2;q2)di.(2)\Psi_K(a,q)=\sum_{d\in\mathbb{N}^m}(-1)^{R^t\cdot d}\frac{a^{A^t\cdot d}q^{d^tQ^td+S^t\cdot d}}{\prod_{i=1}^{m}(q^2;q^2)_{d_i}}. \tag*{(2)}

The precise definitions of these restricted subquivers will be given in § 3. In § 5 we will prove that rational knots are of class Q\mathcal{Q}. Consequently, Theorem 1.2 holds for all rational knots.

If we know the tail of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial, one can obtain the head of the colored Jones polynomial (i.e., the Jones tail of the mirror knot) by substituting q=q−1q=q^{-1} followed by a=q2a=q^2. More generally, by instead specializing a→qNa\to q^N, one obtains a head of the colored slN\mathfrak{sl}_N polynomials.

Furthermore, we will see that the tail of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial is a stronger invariant than the tail of the colored Jones polynomial. This will be proven in Section 6 by explicitly computing the HOMFLY-PT tails of the torus knots and twist knots. In Proposition 6.8 we will show that these two families have different HOMFLY-PT tails yet specialize to the same Jones heads.

Quiver Computation Program

This paper originated from a UIUC summer IML project supported by NSF grant DMS-2405302. As a part of the project, we wrote a Python program to compute the quivers and colored HOMFLY-PT polynomials of rational knots utilizing the third author’s geometric method of computing the quivers [11]. This approach let us compute these knot invariants efficiently, which let us investigate if the coefficients stabilized. For example, our program can produce graphs, as shown in Figure 1, for visualizing the shape of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomials. After seeing that tails were forming, we used the program to investigate the structure of the quivers, from which the data suggested that all of the rational knots are of class Q\mathcal{Q}. The program, figures, and associated data are available at [5].

Lattice Points of HOMFLY-PT Polynomial

Figure 1. The 20th-Colored HOMFLY-PT Polynomial of K5/2K_{5/2}

Structure of the Paper

Our paper proceeds as follows. In § 2, we give necessary background on rational knots, the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial, quantum algebra, and the knots-quivers correspondence. In § 3, we prove Theorem 1.2 for knots of class Q\mathcal{Q}. In § 4, we explore various other properties of the quiver and colored HOMFLY-PT polynomials. In § 5, we prove that rational knots are of class Q\mathcal{Q} by showing that the necessary properties hold after a sequence of top and right twists. In Section 6, we compute the tail of the colored HOMFLY-PT polynomial for various knots, such as the torus knots, twist knots, and all rational knots up to numerator 30. Finally, in § 7, we conclude with some questions and conjectures we have concerning the quivers and colored HOMFLY-PT polynomials.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank Jake Rasmussen for leading this project and for his support. Additionally, we wish to thank Christine Ruey Shan Lee for introducing us to the tail of the colored Jones polynomial.

AI Disclosure

The idea for the proof that rational knots are of class Q\mathcal{Q} given in § 5 was suggested by ChatGPT. It attempted a proof, which, although incorrect, was useful in giving us a starting point in proving the claim. Additionally, we used ChatGPT and Claude to find various quantum algebra identities that we used in the computations in several of the HOMFLY-PT tails. Lastly, we were assisted by ChatGPT and Claude in writing the code for our program.

Background

Rational Knots

Rational Knots. The rational knots are a family of alternating knots which can be defined inductively by finite sequences of simple twist rules. Even though rational knots are invertible, we will use the results of [11, 21], where rational knots are taken as closures of oriented rational tangles; consequently, we will define them as such here.

Definition 2.1. The (positive) rational tangles are the infinite family of oriented 4-ended tangles defined inductively by applying finite sequences of top twists (TT) and right twists (RR), as shown in Figure 2, to the trivial tangle, which we call τ0/1\tau_{0/1}.

The two twists and trivial tangle used to build positive rational tangles

Figure 2. The two twists and trivial tangle used to build positive rational tangles

Negative rational tangles can be defined similarly by taking mirrors, but we will focus our discussion on positive rational tangles, following [11, 21].

As Figure 2 suggests, it is natural to think of rational tangles as pairs of oriented embedded arcs in the 3-ball B3B^3 with boundary on ∂B3=S2\partial B^3 = S^2. Furthermore, rational tangles correspond to rational numbers by the sequence of twists used to construct them. Given u/v∈Qu/v \in\mathbb{Q}, we will write τu/v\tau_{u/v} to denote the rational tangle corresponding to this rational number. There is a topological way to understand this correspondence via Dehn twists and double branched covers (see [10] for more details), but we will only provide the combinatorial description here, which follows from the rules:

Tτu/v=τ(u+v)/vandRτu/v=τu/(u+v).T\tau_{u/v}=\tau_{(u+v)/v} \qquad\text{and}\qquad R\tau_{u/v}=\tau_{u/(u+v)}.

Observe first that Rτ0/1R\tau_{0/1}, the tangle we get by applying a right twist to the trivial tangle, is equal to τ0/1\tau_{0/1} since the two tangles are related by a Reidemeister I move. Consequently, any rational tangle can be built by first applying a top twist to τ0/1\tau_{0/1}. Then, given a sequence of twists Ta1Ra2Ta3⋯Ran−1Tanτ0/1T^{a_1}R^{a_2}T^{a_3}\cdots R^{a_{n-1}}T^{a_n}\tau_{0/1} ending in a top twist gives the rational tangle τu/v\tau_{u/v}, and a sequence Rb1Tb2⋯Rbn−1Tbnτ0/1R^{b_1}T^{b_2}\cdots R^{b_{n-1}}T^{b_n}\tau_{0/1} ending in a right twist gives τu′/v′\tau_{u'/v'}, where u/vu/v and u′/v′u'/v' are given by the continued fraction expansions

u/v=a1+1a2+1a3+⋯+1an−1+1anandu′/v′=b1+1b2+⋯+1bn−1+1bn,u/v=a_1+\frac{1}{a_2+\frac{1}{a_3+\cdots+\frac{1}{a_{n-1}+\frac{1}{a_n}}}} \qquad\text{and}\qquad u'/v'=b_1+\frac{1}{b_2+\cdots+\frac{1}{b_{n-1}+\frac{1}{b_n}}},

References

  1. [1]George E. Andrews. An analytic generalization of the Rogers-Ramanujan identities for odd moduli. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A., 71(10):4082–4085, 1974.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16592187
  2. [2]George E. Andrews. The Theory of Partitions, volume 2 of Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1998.
  3. [3]Cody Armond. The head and tail conjecture for alternating knots. Algebr. Geom. Topol., 13(5):2809–2826, July 2013.
  4. [4]Paul Beirne and Robert Osburn. q-series and tails of colored Jones polynomials. Indag. Math., 28(1):247–260, February 2017.DOI
  5. [5]Elijah Berry, Rongjiang Guo, Eduardo Perez, and Henry Zaslow. Colored HOMFLY-PT Polynomials. https://www.homfly-tails.com. Accessed: 2026-09-22.
  6. [6]D. M. Bressoud. Some identities for terminating q-series. Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society, 89(2):211–223, 1981.DOI
  7. [7]Oliver T. Dasbach and Xiao-Song Lin. On the head and the tail of the colored Jones polynomial, 2006.DOI
  8. [8]Stavros Garoufalidis and Thang T. Q. Le. Nahm sums, stability and the colored Jones polynomial, 2012.arxiv.org/abs/1112.3905
  9. [9]George Gasper and Mizan Rahman. Basic Hypergeometric Series, volume 96 of Encyclopedia of Mathematics and its Applications. Cambridge University Press, 2 edition, 2004.
  10. [10]Jonathan A. Higgins. A geometric approach to the links-quivers correspondence I: Rational tangles, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2603.01303
  11. [11]Jonathan A. Higgins. A geometric approach to the links-quivers correspondence II: Rational links, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2603.01312
  12. [12]Jakub Jankowski, Piotr Kucharski, Hélder Larraguível, Dmitry Noschenko, and Piotr Sułkowski. Permutohedra for knots and quivers. Phys. Rev. D, 104(8), 2021.DOI
  13. [13]Adam Keilthy and Robert Osburn. Rogers–Ramanujan type identities for alternating knots. J. Number Theory, 161:255–280, April 2016.DOI
  14. [14]Piotr Kucharski, Markus Reineke, Marko Stošić, and Piotr Sulkowski. BPS states, knots, and quivers. Phys. Rev. D, 96(12):121902, 2017.DOI
  15. [15]Piotr Kucharski, Markus Reineke, Marko Stošić, and Piotr Sulkowski. Knots-quivers correspondence. Adv. Theor. Math. Phys., 23(7):1849–1902, 2019.DOI
  16. [16]Christine Ruey Shan Lee and Roland van der Veen. Colored Jones polynomials without tails. Algebra. Geom. Topol., 22(6):2857–2865, December 2022.DOI
  17. [17]M. Murakami, T. Ohtsuki, and A. Yamada. Homfly polynomial via an invariant of colored plane graphs. Enseign. Math., 44:325–360, 1998.DOI
  18. [18]Kunio Murasugi. Knot Theory and Its Applications. Springer Science+Business Media, LLC, New York, 1996.
  19. [19]Robert Osburn and Matthias Storzer. Arborescent links and modular tails, 2025. 2504.18060.arxiv.org/abs/2504.18060
  20. [20]N. Yu. Reshetikhin and V. G. Turaev. Ribbon graphs and their invariants derived from quantum groups. Commun. Math. Phys., 127(1):1–26, 1990.
  21. [21]Marko Stošić and Paul Wedrich. Rational links and DT invariants of quivers. Int. Math. Res. Not., 2021(6):4169–4210, January 2019.DOI
  22. [22]Marko Stošić and Paul Wedrich. Tangle addition and the knots-quivers correspondence. J. Lond. Math. Soc., 104(1):341–361, January 2021.DOI
  23. [23]Daniel Tubbenhauer, Pedro Vaz, and Paul Wedrich. Super q-Howe duality and web categories. Algebr. Comb., 4(4):1027–1072, 2021.
  24. [24]Paul Wedrich. Categorified sℓₙ invariants of colored rational tangles. Algebr. Geom. Topol., 16(1):427–482, February 2016.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_qpqng5d2
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Claude

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents