WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Remark on residual solutions in the algebra
Abstract
In this paper we study residual solutions of open bosonic string field theory in the algebra with the auxiliary identities of the ghost field. These solutions are not covered by the classification based on the defining relations alone. We show that the operator which controls the cohomology on the residual family depends only on . At positive level , cohomology can appear only on the lines . We compute it through level four and find one class at every point of each line and . These classes give exact polynomial deformations of the residual family. At level six on , the cohomology instead vanishes generically and has dimension two at and . We also compute the failure of the standard generator redefinition to preserve the auxiliary identities, and discuss the regularization of an explicit residual solution.
Introduction
In 2005 Schnabl found the first analytic solution for tachyon condensation in Witten’s open string field theory [1, 2]. In 2009 Erler and Schnabl found a simpler solution [3]; a short account is given in [4]. Since then the algebra has become a standard tool for constructing analytic solutions. Reviews can be found in [5, 6, 7], and a broader introduction to string field theory is given in [8]. Many solutions in this algebra contain the identity string field. Their interpretation requires care [9, 10], and identity-based solutions continue to appear in studies of open string renormalization group flow [11, 12].
In 2012 Erler classified solutions which admit an level expansion and satisfy the equations of motion by the defining relations of the algebra alone [13]. Under these assumptions there are six gauge orbits: the perturbative vacuum, the tachyon vacuum and four residual solutions. The residual solutions are singular from the point of view of the identity string field.
The ghost field satisfies additional relations, for , which do not follow from the defining relations. These are the auxiliary identities of [13]. With them, the four residual solutions become points of a two-parameter family. The classification does not cover solutions which need these identities. It was also observed in [13] that the cohomology of the residual family may be enhanced at special points, with a possible connection to multibrane solutions [14].
Here we study the cohomology of this family. We first give a criterion for imposing the auxiliary identities: only the part antisymmetric in the ghost derivatives survives. We then show that the operator which controls the cohomology depends only on . At positive level , a class can occur only when . Through level four the positive lines have no cohomology. On the negative lines we recover the known level-two class at the ghost brane point and find one class at every point of each line and . These classes give exact polynomial solutions without higher-order corrections.
We also examine level six on . Here the cohomology vanishes at generic points and has dimension two at and . Thus the classes found on the whole lines at levels three and four do not imply the same behavior at higher levels. Finally, we compute explicitly how the generator redefinition used in [13] fails to preserve the auxiliary identities.
Our interest in this question started from the family , discussed in the lecture [15]. This is a special case of the two-parameter solution in § 2.3 of [16]. It also appears in equation (86) of [17], with and . We return to this family and its regularization in § 7.
The cohomology calculations and the new polynomial solutions are statements in the algebra with auxiliary identities. Their interpretation as regular string backgrounds, and the definition of their energy, require further analysis.1
The rest of the paper is organized as follows. In § 2 we review the algebra and the auxiliary identities. § 3 describes the residual family, and § 4 studies its cohomology through level four. In § 5 we use the cohomology classes to construct new solutions. § 6 discusses the generator redefinition, and § 7 examines the explicit family and its regularization. We conclude in § 8. Appendix § 10 gives the closed string overlap, and appendix § 11 contains the level-six calculation.
The KBc algebra and auxiliary identities
The KBc algebra
The string fields , and have Grassmann parity even, odd and odd, respectively. Their defining relations are
We suppress the star product symbol and write . The BRST operator around is . For any function , the defining relations give
Thus and are complementary projectors. For a function , set . Then
is the left form of Okawa’s solution [18]. The case gives the Erler–Schnabl solution .2 We normalize the energy so that .
Auxiliary identities
Write and . In addition to the defining relations, the ghost field obeys
The anticommutators follow by differentiating the squared identities, including . More explicitly, induction on relates adjacent pairs of indices, while the middle pair is fixed by a squared identity or its derivative. These relations are independent of (1) [13]. They allow us to write every polynomial string field as
using the rules
A monomial in (5) has ghost number and level
At fixed ghost number and level the state space is therefore finite-dimensional. We compute cohomology in this polynomial algebra.3
A simple criterion
The auxiliary identities can also be imposed in a polynomial representation. Associate the word
with a polynomial , where is the argument of , and define . Differentiating the -th ghost multiplies by . The relations therefore remove the part symmetric under the exchange of two neighbouring gaps. Since neighbouring transpositions generate , we obtain
Thus only the part antisymmetric in the ghost derivatives survives. This criterion reproduces the cohomology around the four residual solutions given in table 2 of [13] at levels to 2.
The residual family
With the auxiliary identities, the level-zero residual solutions belong to the family [13]
The points , , and are the residual perturbative vacuum, the residual tachyon vacuum, the residual conjugate tachyon vacuum and the ghost brane solution [19]. Only these four points satisfy the equations of motion by (1) alone. The remaining points require the auxiliary identities. We write .
Following [13], introduce the odd derivation , with and . It is well defined in the auxiliary quotient, since and for , and hence it preserves the anticommutation relations. Using , and , we obtain . Consequently,
The operator therefore depends only on . If and with , then , so the cohomology lies in the kernel of . Since is a projector, has the eigenvalues on , and , respectively. Moreover , so preserves these sectors and the level. A cohomology class at level must therefore satisfy
At ghost number one the possible classes are the marginal directions at ; the state at , , which appears only for ; and states at positive level , with on the lines or with on the lines .
At level zero, the tangent vectors and are closed and independent. The only other state with ghost number one is , and using (6) we find
Both states with ghost number zero, and , are annihilated by . Hence the level-zero cohomology is two-dimensional everywhere except at , where the residual perturbative vacuum has the additional class [13]. At level the state is closed only for , and then it is not exact.
Cohomology at positive level
For , the sector on has no closed states of ghost number one. We therefore consider on , and set , . In this sector the states with ghost number one at level are with and , and the states with ghost number zero are with . Since preserves the level and the sectors, exactness in this sector is the same as exactness in the whole algebra.
This sector has no ghost number one states at level one. At level two its only state is . We find
A class therefore survives only at , the ghost brane point [13, 19].
At level three a basis is , . The differential is
Since and never vanish together, the image is one-dimensional for every . The state
is closed and is not exact for any , since .
At level four, write
On the ghost number one states,
while on the ghost number zero states,
The kernel is therefore three-dimensional and the image two-dimensional for every . The state
is closed. For it is not exact, since it has no component, and at the first image vector becomes , which is independent of . Thus is not exact anywhere on the line. We collect these results in Table 1.
| , level , | |||
| 0 | 0 | 0 | |
| , | 1 | 1 | 0 |
| , | 1 | 0 | 1 |
| , all | 2 | 1 | 1 |
| , all | 3 | 2 | 1 |
Table 1. Ghost number one cohomology in the sector at level on the line , with .
At level six on , the cohomology is instead zero at generic points and two-dimensional at and . The calculation is given in appendix § 11.
New solutions
The classes at levels two, three and four give exact solutions. At a point on , take
where is a number and is one of the states found in the previous section, with at the ghost brane point. Since is a solution, the equation of motion gives
The first term is zero because . Also : all ghosts in carry derivatives, so the final in the first factor can be moved through the second factor without a contraction, giving . Equivalently, lies in , and . Therefore (21) is a solution for every value of .
On the line the solution is
and on the line
where can be any number. At the ghost brane point, the known level-two class [13] similarly gives
Since is not exact, these are nontrivial deformations of .4 These deformations require the auxiliary identities; for a nonzero deformation the defining relations (1) alone do not give the equations of motion.
More general formal power-series deformations along these classes are also unobstructed. At order the obstruction lies at level , where has the eigenvalue . Therefore a closed obstruction is exact, and it can be removed by
Here projects onto the sector with eigenvalue . For the representatives above, and all higher-order corrections vanish.
These solutions are polynomial in and are therefore identity-based. The positive-level terms increase their singularity. Computing an action or a boundary state requires a suitable regularization.
The generator redefinition
The energy prescription in [13] uses the generator redefinition
This preserves (1) and commutes with . The energy argument also assumes that a BRST-exact identity-like term has zero overlap. The redefined generators need not obey the auxiliary identities [13]. Expanding to first order, and , and using (6) we find
where . The redefinition (27) therefore preserves the algebra but does not descend to the auxiliary quotient. For a solution which needs these identities, the redefined field solves the equations of motion only if the redefinition maps the defect back into the auxiliary ideal, and this has to be checked case by case.
This explains an obstruction behind the energy puzzle in [13]. The energy rule found there is proportional to , while the auxiliary identities connect the residual solutions by marginal directions, which suggests that their energies should be equal. Since the regularization behind the energy rule does not respect the auxiliary identities, the redefinition is guaranteed to preserve the equations of motion only at the four points which satisfy the defining relations. Even there, the energy assignment still depends on the assumed trace prescription. It cannot simply be extended along the family. An energy calculation on this family requires a regularization compatible with the auxiliary identities.
An explicit example
For the family discussed in the introduction, set and . Then
Using (2), we find , and , so solves the equations of motion for every .5 Expanding around , , so for it is in the tachyon vacuum orbit and for it is in the residual tachyon vacuum orbit: its level-zero term is [13]. The gauge transformation , with , acts as , so is a fixed point.
At there is no homotopy field in this algebra. A field of ghost number minus one has the form , and
and the right-hand side vanishes when multiplied by from the right, while . For functions with suitable Laplace representations the closed string overlap [20] is (see appendix § 10)
which gives for regular Okawa solutions. Formally, the energy and the overlap of are those of the tachyon vacuum for every [13, 15, 16], but for the traces contain identity-like terms, and one needs a prescription to define them. The interpretation of singular string fields in terms of generalized states is discussed in [21]. For related discussions of identity-based solutions and the distinction between regular and singular gauge transformations, see [17].
To regularize the gauge parameter, take , , and . Then
Thus the regularized field is an Okawa solution conjugated by a function of . For the pole of lies on the negative real axis, so the functions in the gauge parameter and its inverse admit Laplace representations supported at nonnegative wedge widths. With the usual wedge-state prescription this gives a regular gauge transformation of the tachyon vacuum. Its coefficientwise limit as is ; this does not establish continuity of singular traces.6 For , however, vanishes at and , so (32) is a singular conjugation. Its coefficientwise limit in the localized algebra can be computed explicitly:
The regularized family therefore does not return to the residual field. For traces which are defined at finite cutoff, one can see where the difficulty comes from: for we have , and the boundary term has to be controlled before an energy can be assigned to the singular conjugation.
For , a real continuous regulator with and makes vanish at some , where the numerator of does not vanish. Thus this regulated real projector ansatz cannot connect the two signs of by a regular transformation, although more general gauge parameters are not excluded. For the role of and in singular solutions see [22, 23].
Conclusions
In this paper we studied residual solutions of the algebra with the auxiliary identities of the ghost field. The operator which controls the cohomology depends only on and restricts possible classes at positive level to . Through level four we find no cohomology on the positive lines. On the negative lines there is one class at every point of and , while at level two the class survives only at the ghost brane point. The explicit representatives give exact polynomial deformations of the residual solutions.
The calculation in appendix § 11 shows a different behavior at level six. On the cohomology vanishes generically and has dimension two at and . A general description must therefore account for both classes which persist along a whole line and enhancement at isolated points.
We also showed that the standard generator redefinition breaks the auxiliary identities already at first order. The energy prescription based on this redefinition cannot be extended directly to the residual family. For the explicit family , regularizing the gauge parameter gives a regular gauge transformation for with the stated wedge-state prescription. At the coefficientwise limit differs from the original residual field.
The main open question is the cohomology at arbitrary level. It would also be useful to find a regularization compatible with the auxiliary identities and to determine whether any of these formal solutions admit a boundary-state or multibrane interpretation [14]. Other realizations of the algebra, such as those in [24], should be checked against the same identities.
Acknowledgments
I am deeply grateful to Loriano Bonora, with whom this project was started and from whom I learned this subject. I am also grateful to T. Erler for correspondence on the family (29). I acknowledge support from the Istanbul Integrability and Stringy Topics Initiative (IStringy). Algebraic checks and the preparation of the draft were assisted by Claude (Anthropic), and ChatGPT (OpenAI).
The closed string overlap
Let be an on-shell closed string vertex operator of ghost number two and weight , inserted at the midpoint. Normalize its correlator by . If has a Laplace representation with an integrable first moment, then
Cyclicity gives the first formula in (31). For the second, choose the orientation of the line so that, for widths ,
Integrating over the widths we obtain
This sign agrees with and the vanishing overlap of BRST exact fields. We define as the coefficient of . For regular Okawa solutions, writing gives . These formulas assume that the traces converge; they cannot be used to cancel singular factors inside otherwise undefined traces.
Cohomology at level six
Here we give the level-six calculation on . Set and . In the sector , bases at ghost numbers zero, one and two are
and
respectively. The matrices of in these ordered bases are
where
The relation gives , and is nonzero for every . The greatest common divisor of the nonzero minors of is proportional to . At and the rank is three, while it is four everywhere else. The cohomology is therefore
Indeed, and . Thus the cohomology is enhanced at the two points and , and vanishes at generic points of the line. At this level the other two projector sectors are contractible by (11), so (B.6) gives the full ghost number one cohomology at level six on .
References
References
- [1]E. Witten, “Non-commutative geometry and string field theory,” Nucl. Phys. B 268 no. 2, (1986) 253–294.DOI
- [2]M. Schnabl, “Analytic solution for tachyon condensation in open string field theory,” Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 10 no. 4, (2006) 433–501, arXiv:hep-th/0511286.arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/0511286
- [3]T. Erler and M. Schnabl, “A Simple Analytic Solution for Tachyon Condensation,” JHEP 10 (2009) 066, arXiv:0906.0979 [hep-th].DOI
- [4]T. Erler, “A simple analytic solution for tachyon condensation,” Theor. Math. Phys. 163 no. 3, (2010) 705–709.
- [5]L. Bonora, “A review on open SFT,” PoS ICMP2013 (2014) 001.
- [6]L. Bonora, “Prospects in string field theory,” Facta Univ. Ser. Phys. Chem. Technol. 12 no. 2, (2014) 85–99.DOI
- [7]T. Erler, “Four lectures on analytic solutions in open string field theory,” Phys. Rept. 980 (2022) 1–95, arXiv:1912.00521 [hep-th].DOI
- [8]I. Y. Aref’eva, “String field theory: From high energy to cosmology,” Theor. Math. Phys. 163 no. 3, (2010) 697–704.DOI
- [9]I. Kishimoto and T. Takahashi, “Vacuum structure around identity-based solutions,” Prog. Theor. Phys. 122 no. 2, (2009) 385–399, arXiv:0904.1095 [hep-th].DOI
- [10]S. Zeze, “Tachyon potential in KBc subalgebra,” Prog. Theor. Phys. 124 no. 4, (2010) 567–580, arXiv:1004.4351 [hep-th].DOI
- [11]J. Hristov, “Open String Renormalization Group Flow as a Field Theory,” Fortsch. Phys. 72 no. 11, (2024) 2300266.DOI
- [12]J. Hristov, “Comments on the RG-Flow in Open String Field Theory,” Fortsch. Phys. 73 no. 12, (2025) e70045.DOI
- [13]T. Erler, “The Identity String Field and the Sliver Frame Level Expansion,” JHEP 11 (2012) 150, arXiv:1208.6287 [hep-th].DOI
- [14]M. Murata and M. Schnabl, “On Multibrane Solutions in Open String Field Theory,” Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 188 (2011) 50–55, arXiv:1103.1382 [hep-th].DOI
- [15]I. Gahramanov, “On Analytical Solutions in Witten’s Cubic Open String Field Theory,” arXiv:2412.20981 [hep-th]. in Turkish.
- [16]E. A. Arroyo, “Generating Erler–Schnabl-type solution for the tachyon vacuum in cubic superstring field theory,” J. Phys. A 43 no. 44, (2010) 445403, arXiv:1004.3030 [hep-th].DOI
- [17]L. Bonora and D. D. Tolla, “Comments on lump solutions in SFT,” Eur. Phys. J. C 76 no. 4, (2016) 203, arXiv:1412.0936 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/1412.0936
- [18]Y. Okawa, “Comments on Schnabl’s analytic solution for tachyon condensation in Witten’s open string field theory,” JHEP 04 (2006) 055, arXiv:hep-th/0603159.DOI
- [19]T. Masuda, T. Noumi, and D. Takahashi, “Constraints on a class of classical solutions in open string field theory,” JHEP 10 (2012) 113, arXiv:1207.6220 [hep-th].DOI
- [20]I. Ellwood, “The closed string tadpole in open string field theory,” JHEP 08 (2008) 063, arXiv:0804.1131 [hep-th].DOI
- [21]L. Bonora and S. Giaccari, “Generalized states in SFT,” Eur. Phys. J. C 73 (2013) 2644, arXiv:1304.2159 [hep-th].DOI
- [22]H. Hata and T. Kojita, “Winding Number in String Field Theory,” JHEP 01 (2012) 088, arXiv:1111.2389 [hep-th].DOI
- [23]H. Hata and T. Kojita, “Singularities in K-space and Multi-brane Solutions in Cubic String Field Theory,” JHEP 02 (2013) 065, arXiv:1209.4406 [hep-th].DOI
- [24]H. Hata, D. Takeda, and J. Yoshinaka, “Generating string field theory solutions with matter operators from KBc algebra,” PTEP 2022 no. 9, (2022) 093B09, arXiv:2205.14599 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2205.14599