betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Forbidden non-unique β−β^{-} transitions and gAg_A-sensitive electron spectral-shapes

Abstract

In the present work, we have done a systematic study of beta decay properties such as electron spectral-shapes, shape factors, and logftft values for the higher forbidden non-unique β−β^{-} transitions in the mass region A=85-123. We have performed the nuclear shell model (SM) calculations to explore the sensitivity of the electron spectral-shapes for different axial-vector coupling constants gA=0.8−1.27g_{A}=0.8-1.27. The effective interactions GWBXG, G-matrix, SNET and SN100PN are used for different model spaces. In the present work, we have computed the electron spectral-shapes of 85^{85}Br, 87^{87}Rb, 93^{93}Zr, 97^{97}Zr, 101^{101}Mo, 115^{115}Cd, 117^{117}Cd, 119^{119}In, 123^{123}Sn and 135^{135}Cs by constraining the small relativistic nuclear matrix element from conserved vector-current hypothesis (CVC). We have found that the electron spectral-shapes are strongly dependent on gAg_{A} except the second forbidden non-unique β−β^{-} transition 93^{93}Zr.

Forbidden non-unique - transitions and gAg_A-sensitive β\beta spectral shapes

Abstract

Introduction

In recent years, interest in studying electron spectral-shapes has grown significantly from both experimental and theoretical perspectives. The electron spectral-shapes which are sensitive to axial coupling constants (gAg_A) play crucial role in rare-events experiments. Also, the theoretical prediction of gAg_A becomes important while designing the experiment to detect the neutrinoless double beta decay (0νββ0\nu\beta\beta) events and in predicting β\beta-decay rates. The single β\beta-decay rates are proportional to the second power of gAg_A whereas for double β\beta-decay are proportional to the fourth power of gAg_A, thus the precise value of gAg_A should be taken [2] [1]. A comprehensive study was previously conducted on allowed and forbidden β\beta-decays within the framework of the nuclear shell model (SM) and microscopic quasiparticle-phonon model (MQPM) to get the information related to the effective value of gAg_A [2, 3, 4]. From the standard model, the conserved vector current (CVC) and partially conserved axial-vector-current (PCAC) hypotheses yield free nucleon value of vector coupling constant gV=1.00g_V=1.00 and axial-vector coupling constant gA=1.27g_A=1.27, respectively [5]. However, inside nuclear matter, many-body correlations affect the value of gAg_A, and a quenched value may be required to reproduce experimental data [6]. In Ref. [7], ab initio calculations have been done for selected lighter nuclei and two-body current is included. However, it is very difficult to do ab initio calculations for heavier nuclei. So, SM calculations in a truncated model space are desirable, which requires quenching in gAg_A. The SSM has recently gained popularity for investigating the effective value of gAg_A. In current scenario, there are two methods to extract the effective value of gAg_A: (i) the half-life method [8, 9, 10], and (ii) the spectrum shape method (SSM). The effective value of gAg_A has previously been investigated using a half-life method for the different values of gAg_A, confirming the quenching of gAg_A [11, 12]. In the SSM method, the shapes of computed spectra at different gAg_A values are compared with the experimental electron spectra to extract the effective value of gAg_A [13]. Such method is used recently for the fourth forbidden non-unique β\beta-decay of 113Cd{}^{113}\mathrm{Cd} and 115In{}^{115}\mathrm{In} [13, 14, 15, 16] and measurements of 113Cd{}^{113}\mathrm{Cd} and 115In{}^{115}\mathrm{In} spectra are being also extended to other potentially sensitive candidates [17]. For 113Cd{}^{113}\mathrm{Cd}, with the SSM, the MQPM, SM, and the microscopic interacting boson-fermion model (IBFM-2) [18] yield the ratio of axial-vector coupling constant to vector coupling constant approximately 0.92 when compared with the experimental spectra. This value was the closest agreement among all three models which signifies that the SSM method does not strongly depend on the details of the Hamiltonian or many-body methods [13, 19, 20] while using half-life method the gAg_A value is not consistent with all three models. Recently, SSM method is enhanced after constraining the relativistic nuclear matrix element (s-NME) from CVC theory and obtained the better picture of electron spectral-shapes of sdsd shell nuclei 36Cl{}^{36}\mathrm{Cl}, and 24Na{}^{24}\mathrm{Na} [21]. Along with this, the spectral shapes of the second forbidden non-unique beta decay of 59,60Fe{}^{59,60}\mathrm{Fe} are also studied in the fpfp shell with different gAg_A and the strong gAg_A dependency was found which shows 59,60Fe{}^{59,60}\mathrm{Fe} are the best candidates for SSM and useful for shape measurement experiments [22].

Recently, the realistic shell model (RSM) calculations have been performed using bare and effective operators to predict the log⁡ft\log ft values and energy spectra of the second forbidden β−\beta^{-} decay of 94Nb{}^{94}\mathrm{Nb} and 99Tc{}^{99}\mathrm{Tc} and the fourth forbidden β−\beta^{-} decay of 113Cd{}^{113}\mathrm{Cd} and 115In{}^{115}\mathrm{In} [23]. Previously, the renormalization of Hamiltonian and transition operator within the RSM is also studied for two neutrino mode of double beta decay (2νββ2\nu\beta\beta) and 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta [24, 25]. Along with this, a recent nuclear SM study on gAg_A sensitive β−\beta^{-} spectral shapes in the mass region A=86-99 is done where the β−\beta^{-} transitions are potentially of great interest for future rare events experiments [26] which demand the beyond standard model (BSM) physics by measurements of rare nuclear β\beta decays and double β\beta decays. Recently, for the heavier nuclei 212,214Pb{}^{212,214}\mathrm{Pb} and 212,214Bi{}^{212,214}\mathrm{Bi}, a systematic study of electron spectra has been performed within the framework of shell model Hamiltonian which plays an important role in neutrino and dark-matter experiments due to their background contribution in these experiments. In this study there was no strong dependency of gAg_A on spectral shape was found but a moderate dependency was obtained on small relativistic nuclear matrix elements (s-NMEs) [27]. Although, s-NME is small, it can have a substantial effect on the partial half-life and the shape of beta electron spectra [15, 28]. In the present work using shell model, we have explored the sensitivity of electron spectral-shapes of 85Br{}^{85}\mathrm{Br}, 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}, 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}, 97Zr{}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}, 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}, 115Cd{}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}, 117Cd{}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}, 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In}, 123Sn{}^{123}\mathrm{Sn} and 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs} by constraining the small relativistic nuclear matrix element from conserved vector-current hypothesis (CVC). The results are reported corresponding to different gAg_A values.

The present manuscript is organized as follows: In section II, we give the theoretical background behind the SM and beta spectrum. In section III, we present the result and discussion for non-unique β−\beta^- transitions. In the end, we conclude the present work in section IV.

Theoretical Framework

Formalism

In the present study, we have computed the beta spectrum for forbidden non-unique β−\beta^- decay transitions, analyzing the energy distribution of beta electrons emitted in β−\beta^- decays. Based on the impulse approximation in nuclear β\beta-decay, the generalized theoretical formalism (Behrens-Bühring) can be found in Refs. [19, 29, 30, 31], which is used in the present work. Apart from this formalism, other β\beta-decay formalisms such as Holstein’s form factors [32] and Donnelly and Walecka formalism have been also introduced [33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38]. The Donnelly and Walecka formalism is widely used in the BSM and suitable in the modern ab initio calculations and this formalism is quite useful for current searches of BSM signatures in precision β−\beta^- decay experiments [39]. In the present work, we have followed the Behrens-Bühring formalism. The partial half-life of β\beta-decay is given as [19, 30]

t1/2=κC~.(1)t_{1/2} = \frac{\kappa}{\widetilde{C}}. \tag*{(1)}

Here, C~\widetilde{C} represents the dimensionless integrated shape function, while κ\kappa, which includes natural constants, has a value of 6289 s [40]. Furthermore, C~\widetilde{C} can be calculated as follows

C~=∫1w0C(we)pwe(w0−we)2F0(Z,we) dwe.(2)\widetilde{C} = \int_{1}^{w_0} C(w_e)p w_e(w_0-w_e)^2F_0(Z,w_e)\,dw_e. \tag*{(2)}

In Eq. 2, we use the usual dimensionless kinematics quantities which are divided by the electron rest mass as w0=W0/mec2w_0=W_0/m_ec^2, we=We/mec2w_e=W_e/m_ec^2, and p=pe/mec2=we2−1p=p_e/m_ec^2=\sqrt{w_e^2-1}. The wew_e and pep_e are the energy and momentum of emitted electrons and the w0w_0 is the endpoint energy, respectively. The F0(Z,we)F_0(Z,w_e) is the Fermi function where ZZ is the atomic number of the daughter nucleus.

The shape factor C(we)C(w_e) in Eq. 2 is given as

C(we)=∑ke,kν,κλke[MK(ke,kν)2+mK(ke,kν)2−2γkekeweMK(ke,kν)mK(ke,kν)].(3)C(w_e)=\sum_{k_e,k_\nu,\kappa}\lambda_{k_e}\left[M_K(k_e,k_\nu)^2+m_K(k_e,k_\nu)^2-\frac{2\gamma_{k_e}}{k_ew_e}M_K(k_e,k_\nu)m_K(k_e,k_\nu)\right]. \tag*{(3)}

Here, KK is the order of forbiddenness of the β\beta decay, kek_e and kνk_\nu (taking values 1, 2, 3,...) are positive integers related to the partial-wave expansion of the leptonic wave functions. The expressions for MK(ke,kν)M_K(k_e,k_\nu) and mK(ke,kν)m_K(k_e,k_\nu) involve different nuclear matrix elements (NMEs) and kinematic factors [19, 30]. Here, γke=ke2−(αZ)2\gamma_{k_e}=\sqrt{k_e^2-(\alpha Z)^2} and y=(αZwe/pec)y=(\alpha Z w_e/p_e c) are auxiliary quantities, where α=1/137\alpha=1/137 is the fine-structure constant. The term λke=Fke−1(Z,we)/F0(Z,we)\lambda_{k_e}=F_{k_e-1}(Z,w_e)/F_0(Z,w_e) represents the Coulomb function, where Fke−1(Z,we)F_{k_e-1}(Z,w_e) is the generalized Fermi function [19, 21, 29], which is given as below

Fke−1(Z,we)=4ke−1(2ke)(ke+γke)[(2ke−1)!!]2eπy×(2peRℏ)2(γke−ke)(∣Γ(γke+iy)∣Γ(1+2γke))2.(4)F_{k_e-1}(Z,w_e)=4^{k_e-1}(2k_e)(k_e+\gamma_{k_e})[(2k_e-1)!!]^2e^{\pi y} \times\left(\frac{2p_eR}{\hbar}\right)^{2(\gamma_{k_e}-k_e)} \left(\frac{\left|\Gamma(\gamma_{k_e}+iy)\right|}{\Gamma(1+2\gamma_{k_e})}\right)^2. \tag*{(4)}

The NMEs, which contain nuclear structure information for a transition between an initial (i) and final (f) state, can be written as:

V/AMKLS(N)(pm)(ke,m,n,ρ)=4πJ^i∑pnV/AmKLS(N)(pn)(ke,m,n,ρ)(Ψf∥[cp†c~n]K∥Ψi).(5){}^{V/A}\mathcal{M}^{(N)}_{KLS}(pm)(k_e,m,n,\rho) =\frac{\sqrt{4\pi}}{\hat{J}_i}\sum_{pn}{}^{V/A}m^{(N)}_{KLS}(pn)(k_e,m,n,\rho)(\Psi_f\Vert[c_p^\dagger\widetilde{c}_n]_K\Vert\Psi_i). \tag*{(5)}

The term (Ψf∥[cp†c~n]K∥Ψi)(\Psi_f\Vert[c_p^\dagger\widetilde{c}_n]_K\Vert\Psi_i) represent the one-body transition densities (OBTDs), which are model-dependent. In contrast, the functions V/AmKLS(N)(pn)(ke,m,n,ρ){}^{V/A}m^{(N)}_{KLS}(pn)(k_e,m,n,\rho) represent the single-particle matrix elements (SPMEs), which are independent of nuclear models for transitions between the initial (Ψi)(\Psi_i) and final (Ψf)(\Psi_f) nuclear states. In this work, the SPMEs are calculated using harmonic oscillator wave functions [19, 29]. In Eq. 5, the summation is taken over the single-particle states of protons (p) and neutrons (n). In the present calculations, next-to-leading-order (NLO) corrections are also included in the shape factor, leading to an increased number of NMEs (see more about the NLO corrections in Refs. [13, 19]).

The shape factor C(we)C(w_e) in Eq. (2) can be broken down into vector, axial-vector, and mixed vector-axial-vector components as a function of electron energy [2, 3, 4, 13, 19]

C(we)=gV2CV(we)+gA2CA(we)+gVgACVA(we).(6)C(w_e) = g_V^2 C_V(w_e) + g_A^2 C_A(w_e) + g_V g_A C_{VA}(w_e). \tag*{(6)}

By integrating Eq. (6) over the electron energy, we get an expression for the integrated shape function C~\widetilde{C}, which corresponds to Eq. (2)

C~=gV2C~V+gA2C~A+gVgAC~VA.(7)\widetilde{C} = g_V^2 \widetilde{C}_V + g_A^2 \widetilde{C}_A + g_V g_A \widetilde{C}_{VA}. \tag*{(7)}

In Eq. (6) the shape factors CiC_i are functions of the electron energy, while the integrated shape factors C~i\widetilde{C}_i in Eq. (7) do not depend on the electron energy or simply we can say that the C~i\widetilde{C}_i are just constant numbers.

Nuclear Shell Model Calculations

The wave functions of parent and daughter nuclei are calculated using the nuclear shell model. To calculate the OBTDs, we have used the nuclear shell model code KSHELL [41]. We have used different effective interactions like GWBXG [42, 43], G-matrix [44], SNET [45, 46], SN100PN [47, 48] for different model spaces in the SM calculations. The name of the effective interaction is shown in the last column of Table I corresponding to different transitions.

TransitionKQBRExpt.log⁡ft\log ft(SM) gA=1.00g_A=1.00log⁡ft\log ft(SM) gA=1.27g_A=1.27log⁡ft\log ft(SM+CVC) gA=1.00g_A=1.00log⁡ft\log ft(SM+CVC) gA=1.27g_A=1.27Interaction
93Zr(5/2+)→93Nb(9/2+){}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}(5/2^+) \to{}^{93}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^+)2nd90.8(15)2712.10(10)14.76513.49711.84711.752GWBXG
135Cs(7/2+)→135Ba(3/2+){}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}(7/2^+) \to{}^{135}\mathrm{Ba}(3/2^+)2nd268.70(29)100.013.48(6)11.81211.70312.93512.809SN100PN
85Br(3/2−)→85Kr(9/2+){}^{85}\mathrm{Br}(3/2^-) \to{}^{85}\mathrm{Kr}(9/2^+)3rd2905(4)——13.62513.77613.51813.378GWBXG
87Rb(3/2−)→87Sr(9/2+){}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}(3/2^-) \to{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}(9/2^+)3rd282.275(6)100.017.514(7)16.63716.81116.43016.311GWBXG
97Zr(1/2+)→97Nb(9/2+){}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}(1/2^+) \to{}^{97}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^+)4th2666(4)——18.42618.20517.34517.188GWBXG
101Mo(1/2+)→101Tc(9/2+){}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}(1/2^+) \to{}^{101}\mathrm{Tc}(9/2^+)4th2825(24)——18.58518.53819.16419.077GWBXG
115Cd(1/2+)→115In(9/2+){}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^+) \to{}^{115}\mathrm{In}(9/2^+)4th1451.9(7)——20.05620.26519.56919.452G-matrix
117Cd(1/2+)→117In(9/2+){}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^+) \to{}^{117}\mathrm{In}(9/2^+)4th2525(5)——18.83418.92117.86317.713G-matrix
119In(9/2+)→119Sn(1/2+){}^{119}\mathrm{In}(9/2^+) \to{}^{119}\mathrm{Sn}(1/2^+)4th2366(7)——20.00419.94420.85720.770SNET
123Sn(11/2−)→123Sb(1/2+){}^{123}\mathrm{Sn}(11/2^-) \to{}^{123}\mathrm{Sb}(1/2^+)5th1408.2(24)——26.93827.11926.74226.616SN100PN

Table I. The calculated log⁡ft\log ft values for the forbidden non-unique β−\beta^- transitions from the shell model, when s-NMEs are set to zero, are labeled as “log⁡ft\log ft(SM)” and after constraining the s-NMEs from CVC theory, they are labeled as “log⁡ft\log ft(SM+CVC)”, with coupling constants gA=1.00g_A=1.00, gA=1.27g_A=1.27. The ground-state to ground-state Q-values are taken from AME2020 [58].

For the decay of 93Zr^{93}\mathrm{Zr}, 85Br^{85}\mathrm{Br}, 87Rb^{87}\mathrm{Rb}, 97Zr^{97}\mathrm{Zr} and 101Mo^{101}\mathrm{Mo}, the GWBXG effective interaction is used. The model space of GWBXG effective interaction consists of 1f5/21f_{5/2}, 2p3/22p_{3/2}, 2p1/22p_{1/2}, 1g9/21g_{9/2} proton orbitals and 2p1/22p_{1/2}, 1g9/21g_{9/2}, 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, and 3s1/23s_{1/2} neutron orbitals using 68Ni^{68}\mathrm{Ni} as a core, for more details, see Refs. [49, 50, 51, 52]. For 85Br^{85}\mathrm{Br}, 87Rb^{87}\mathrm{Rb} and 93Zr^{93}\mathrm{Zr}, we do one neutron excitation from 1g9/21g_{9/2} to 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, and 3s1/23s_{1/2} orbitals. For the decay of 115Cd^{115}\mathrm{Cd} and 117Cd^{117}\mathrm{Cd}, we have used the G-matrix effective interaction. The model space has two proton orbitals 1p1/21p_{1/2} and 0g9/20g_{9/2} and five neutron orbitals 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 3s1/23s_{1/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, 1g7/21g_{7/2} with 88Sr^{88}\mathrm{Sr} as an inert core [44, 53]. Using G-matrix effective interaction we have not employed any truncation. For the decay of 119In^{119}\mathrm{In}, we have used the SNET effective interaction. The model space of SNET effective interaction has eight proton orbitals and nine neutron orbitals. In the calculations using SNET effective interaction, we have put a truncation for proton orbitals as the 1f5/21f_{5/2} 2p3/22p_{3/2}, 2p1/22p_{1/2} are completely filled and no protons are occupied in the 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2} and 3s1/23s_{1/2} orbitals while 8-10 protons in 1g9/21g_{9/2}, and 0-2 protons in 1g7/21g_{7/2} orbital. While the neutron orbitals 1f5/21f_{5/2} 2p3/22p_{3/2}, 2p1/22p_{1/2} 1g9/21g_{9/2} are completely filled and 1g7/21g_{7/2} 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2} 3s1/23s_{1/2} are completely open and restricted 0-4 neutrons in 1h11/21h_{11/2} orbital. For the decay of 135Cs^{135}\mathrm{Cs} and 123Sn^{123}\mathrm{Sn}, we have used SN100PN effective interaction. No truncation has been employed using SN100PN effective interaction which has model space 50–82 having 1g7/21g_{7/2}, 2d5/22d_{5/2}, 2d3/22d_{3/2}, 3s1/23s_{1/2}, 1h11/21h_{11/2}, orbitals [47, 48].

Results and Discussion

We present the electron spectral-shapes of higher forbidden non-unique β−\beta^- transitions in the mass range A=85−123A=85-123 for gV=1.0g_V=1.0 and gA=0.8−1.27g_A=0.8-1.27 in Figure 1–Figure 4. The computed small NME (s-NME) from CVC relation is shown in Table II. Table I presents the log⁡ft\log ft values for gV=1.0g_V=1.0 and gA=1.0g_A=1.0 and 1.271.27, and Table III shows the decomposition of shape factor for gV=gA=1.0g_V=g_A=1.0 in the calculations.

Figure 1. The theoretical electron spectra for second forbidden non-unique β−\beta^- transitions of 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr} is presented as a function of electron kinetic energy with gV=1.0g_V=1.0 and gA=0.80−1.27g_A=0.80-1.27. The dashed vertical lines mark the end-point energy for forbidden decay. Each spectrum is normalized such that the area under the curve equals unity.

Figure 4. Same as Figure 1, but for second forbidden non-unique β−\beta^{-} transitions of 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}, and fourth forbidden non-unique transition of 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}, and 119Sn{}^{119}\mathrm{Sn}.

TransitionC~V\widetilde{C}_{V}C~A\widetilde{C}_{A}C~VA\widetilde{C}_{VA}C~\widetilde{C}
93Zr(5/2+)→93Nb(9/2+){}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}(5/2^{+}) \to{}^{93}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^{+})
SM1.00103×10−111.00103 \times10^{-11}1.15633×10−111.15633 \times10^{-11}−2.15004×10−11-2.15004 \times10^{-11}7.31903×10−147.31903 \times10^{-14}
SM+CVC2.03842×10−112.03842 \times10^{-11}1.15633×10−111.15633 \times10^{-11}2.86341×10−112.86341 \times10^{-11}6.05817×10−116.05817 \times10^{-11}
135Cs(7/2+)→135Ba(3/2+){}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}(7/2^{+}) \to{}^{135}\mathrm{Ba}(3/2^{+})
SM1.05786×10−91.05786 \times10^{-9}1.01622×10−91.01622 \times10^{-9}2.07190×10−92.07190 \times10^{-9}4.14598×10−94.14598 \times10^{-9}
SM+CVC1.21435×10−91.21435 \times10^{-9}1.01622×10−91.01622 \times10^{-9}−1.91878×10−9-1.91878 \times10^{-9}3.11787×10−103.11787 \times10^{-10}
85Br(3/2−)→85Kr(9/2+){}^{85}\mathrm{Br}(3/2^{-}) \to{}^{85}\mathrm{Kr}(9/2^{+})
SM5.00605×10−75.00605 \times10^{-7}1.04551×10−71.04551 \times10^{-7}−4.28820×10−7-4.28820 \times10^{-7}1.76336×10−71.76336 \times10^{-7}
SM+CVC4.26342×10−84.26342 \times10^{-8}1.04551×10−71.04551 \times10^{-7}7.86317×10−87.86317 \times10^{-8}2.25817×10−72.25817 \times10^{-7}
87Rb(3/2−)→87Sr(9/2+){}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}(3/2^{-}) \to{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}(9/2^{+})
SM8.80885×10−148.80885 \times10^{-14}1.59705×10−141.59705 \times10^{-14}−7.34945×10−14-7.34945 \times10^{-14}3.05644×10−143.05644 \times10^{-14}
SM+CVC1.19390×10−141.19390 \times10^{-14}1.59705×10−141.59705 \times10^{-14}2.13381×10−142.13381 \times10^{-14}4.92477×10−144.92477 \times10^{-14}
97Zr(1/2+)→97Nb(9/2+){}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{97}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^{+})
SM1.80481×10−111.80481 \times10^{-11}1.68290×10−111.68290 \times10^{-11}−3.25912×10−11-3.25912 \times10^{-11}2.28597×10−122.28597 \times10^{-12}
SM+CVC4.62979×10−124.62979 \times10^{-12}1.68290×10−111.68290 \times10^{-11}6.11628×10−126.11628 \times10^{-12}2.75751×10−112.75751 \times10^{-11}
101Mo(1/2+)→101Tc(9/2+){}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{101}\mathrm{Tc}(9/2^{+})
SM1.58876×10−121.58876 \times10^{-12}2.45600×10−132.45600 \times10^{-13}3.69890×10−133.69890 \times10^{-13}2.20425×10−122.20425 \times10^{-12}
SM+CVC4.12088×10−134.12088 \times10^{-13}2.45600×10−132.45600 \times10^{-13}−7.71379×10−14-7.71379 \times10^{-14}5.80550×10−135.80550 \times10^{-13}
115Cd(1/2+)→115In(9/2+){}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{115}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+})
SM2.49942×10−142.49942 \times10^{-14}7.69019×10−157.69019 \times10^{-15}−2.63806×10−14-2.63806 \times10^{-14}6.30379×10−156.30379 \times10^{-15}
SM+CVC6.90690×10−156.90690 \times10^{-15}7.69019×10−157.69019 \times10^{-15}4.74511×10−154.74511 \times10^{-15}1.93422×10−141.93422 \times10^{-14}
117Cd(1/2+)→117In(9/2+){}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{117}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+})
SM8.37700×10−128.37700 \times10^{-12}5.32112×10−125.32112 \times10^{-12}−1.27295×10−11-1.27295 \times10^{-11}9.68629×10−139.68629 \times10^{-13}
SM+CVC1.91622×10−121.91622 \times10^{-12}5.32112×10−125.32112 \times10^{-12}1.81894×10−121.81894 \times10^{-12}9.05628×10−129.05628 \times10^{-12}
119In(9/2+)→119Sn(1/2+){}^{119}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+}) \to{}^{119}\mathrm{Sn}(1/2^{+})
SM2.82952×10−142.82952 \times10^{-14}3.64590×10−153.64590 \times10^{-15}2.01459×10−142.01459 \times10^{-14}5.20870×10−145.20870 \times10^{-14}
SM+CVC5.96564×10−155.96564 \times10^{-15}3.64590×10−153.64590 \times10^{-15}−2.30828×10−15-2.30828 \times10^{-15}7.30327×10−157.30327 \times10^{-15}
123Sn(11/2−)→123Sb(1/2+){}^{123}\mathrm{Sn}(11/2^{-}) \to{}^{123}\mathrm{Sb}(1/2^{+})
SM1.81951×10−221.81951 \times10^{-22}3.78309×10−233.78309 \times10^{-23}−1.60598×10−22-1.60598 \times10^{-22}5.91838×10−235.91838 \times10^{-23}
SM+CVC2.53090×10−232.53090 \times10^{-23}3.78309×10−233.78309 \times10^{-23}2.99880×10−232.99880 \times10^{-23}9.31278×10−239.31278 \times10^{-23}

Table III. TABLE III. The dimensionless integrated shape factors C~\widetilde{C} for the studied transitions, and their decompositions to vector C~V\widetilde{C}_{V}, axial-vector C~A\widetilde{C}_{A}, and vector-axial-vector C~VA\widetilde{C}_{VA} parts with gV=gA=1.0g_{V}=g_{A}=1.0. The results after constraining the s-NMEs are labeled as “SM+CVC”.

Nuclear Matrix Elements

In the SM calculations, the value of s-NME becomes zero because of 0ℏω0\hbar\omega calculation in the adopted model space. The s-NME plays a crucial role in the understanding of electron spectral-shapes which are discussed in recent works [15, 21, 22]. The value of s-NME can be determined in two ways: (i) using the CVC relation, and (ii) by adjusting s-NME to reproduce the experimental partial half-life. In the present manuscript, we have used the CVC relation to get the value of s-NME. The CVC theory establishes a framework for connecting s-NME with the large vector NME (l-NME) [30, 54] and the relation between s-NME (VMKK−11(0){}^{V}\mathcal{M}_{KK-11}^{(0)}) and the l-NME (VMKK0(0){}^{V}\mathcal{M}_{KK0}^{(0)}) is given as:

VMKK−11(0)=((−Mnc2+Mpc2+W0)×Rℏc+65αZ)1K(2K+1)×R×VMKK0(0).(8){}^{V}\mathcal{M}_{KK-11}^{(0)} = \left(\frac{(-M_n c^2+M_p c^2+W_0)\times R}{\hbar c}+\frac{6}{5}\alpha Z\right)\frac{1}{\sqrt{K(2K+1)\times R}}\times{}^{V}\mathcal{M}_{KK0}^{(0)}. \tag*{(8)}

In Eq. (8), MnM_n and MpM_p are the masses of the neutron and proton, respectively. The nuclear radius is given by R=1.27A1/3R=1.27A^{1/3} in fm. The s-NME which are called relativistic matrix elements, are the product of small and large components of initial and final wave functions of radial Dirac equations and l-NME which are called non-relativistic matrix elements are the product of both small components of the initial and final wave functions, as well as the product of both large components of the same wave functions, of radial Dirac equations, for more details, see Refs. [23, 54, 55, 56, 57]. These nuclear matrix elements arise from subleading terms in the relativistic expansion of the weak nuclear current, typically suppressed by powers of 1/M1/M or q/Mq/M, where MM is the nucleon mass and qq is the momentum transfer. These operators, such as p/Mp/M or r.σr.\sigma, are relativistic in nature and generally lead to small matrix elements due to this suppression. In contrast, other operators such as the radial dipole term rY1mrY_{1m} or the spin-orbit term σ×r\sigma\times r emerge from leading-order non-relativistic contributions. These typically yield larger matrix elements, especially when they involve coherent contributions from many nucleons [30, 57]. The CVC-constrained s-NME values, derived from the above relation using the calculated l-NME values, are shown in Table II. The s-NME for the second forbidden decay of 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr} and 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs} is VM211(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{211}, for the third forbidden decay of 85Br{}^{85}\mathrm{Br} and 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb} is VM321(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{321}, for the fourth forbidden decay of 97Zr{}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}, 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}, 115Cd{}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}, 117Cd{}^{117}\mathrm{Cd} and 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In} it is VM431(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{431} and for the fifth forbidden decay of 123Sn{}^{123}\mathrm{Sn} it is VM541(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{541}. The CVC relation is very important and has been utilized in various studies, resulting in a significant enhancement of the properties of beta decay. The magnitude of leading order s-NME VMKK−11(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{KK-11} is smaller than the leading order large vector l-NME VMKK0V(0)V\mathcal{M}^{V(0)}_{KK0}. However, due to the systematic, order-by-order expansion introduced by Behrens and Bühring [30], their contributions to MK(ke,kν)M_K(k_e,k_\nu) and mK(ke,kν)m_K(k_e,k_\nu) matrix elements in Eq. (3) are on similar ground. This is because of the smaller phase space factors multiplying the VMKK0(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{KK0} matrix element [30].

We further employ this s-NME to determine the electron spectral-shape as a function of gAg_A for the investigated transitions.

Sensitivity of electron spectral-shapes on gAg_{A} values

We have computed the electron spectral-shapes for 85Br{}^{85}\mathrm{Br}, 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}, 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}, 97Zr{}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}, 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}, 115Cd{}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}, 117Cd{}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}, 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In}, 123Sn{}^{123}\mathrm{Sn} and 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs} nuclei as a function of axial-vector coupling constant gAg_{A}. For the computation of spectral-shapes, we have performed two sets of calculations. In the first set of calculation, the value of s-NME is zero or directly taken from SM, and in second one, s-NME is determined through the CVC relation. In the Figure 1-Figure 4, the first set of calculations are labeled as “interaction name”, while the second CVC-constrained calculations are denoted as

“interaction name + CVC”. The CVC hypothesis assumes an ‘ideal’ calculation within an infinite single-particle model space, incorporating all two-body and higher-order correlations. The electron spectral-shapes correspond to the integrand of Eq. (2) are depicted as a function of the electron kinetic energy and the area under each curve to unity to make it easy to compare the experimental data in future experiments. The normalized spectra depend only on the ratio gV/gAg_{V}/g_{A}, so adjusting gAg_{A} alone is sufficient to get a better picture of electron spectra. The electron spectral-shapes of the studied forbidden non-unique transitions show a dependency on gAg_{A} values as well as on s-NMEs. Based on the shape of electron spectra, we have divided the studied transitions into three categories. Category I: when electron-spectral shape is weakly dependent on gAg_A values. In Figure 1, for 93Zr(5/2+)→93Nb(9/2+){}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}(5/2^{+}) \to{}^{93}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^{+}) transition, the electron spectral shape is weakly dependent on gAg_A values after constraining the s-NMEs. The dependency can be seen only in the lower electron kinetic energy region. After the electron kinetic energy around 0.02 MeV, the electron spectra become almost insensitive to gAg_A values. Category II: when the spectrum is like a bell-shaped. In Figure 2-Figure 3, electron-spectral shapes of the third forbidden non-unique transition of nuclei 85Br{}^{85}\mathrm{Br}, and 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb} and fourth forbidden non-unique transitions of 97Zr{}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}, 115Cd{}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}, 117Cd{}^{117}\mathrm{Cd} and fifth forbidden non-unique transition of 123Sn{}^{123}\mathrm{Sn} are shown.

Figure 2. Same as Figure 1, but for the third forbidden non-unique β−\beta^{-} transitions of 85^{85}Br and 87^{87}Rb, and fourth forbidden non-unique transitions of 97^{97}Zr and 115^{115}Cd.

Figure 3. Same as to Figure 1, but for the fourth forbidden non-unique β−\beta^- transition of 117Cd^{117}\mathrm{Cd}, and fifth forbidden non-unique transition of 123Sn^{123}\mathrm{Sn}.

NMEs/Transition93Zr(5/2+)→93Nb(9/2+){}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}(5/2^{+}) \to{}^{93}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^{+})
VM211(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{211}(CVC)-0.2577
VM220(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{220}-13.8324
NMEs/Transition135Cs(7/2+)→135Ba(3/2+){}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}(7/2^{+}) \to{}^{135}\mathrm{Ba}(3/2^{+})
VM211(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{211}(CVC)0.1612
VM220(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{220}7.0161
NMEs/Transition85Br(3/2−)→85Kr(9/2+){}^{85}\mathrm{Br}(3/2^{-}) \to{}^{85}\mathrm{Kr}(9/2^{+})
VM321(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{321}(CVC)-1.3103
VM330(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{330}-89.3121
NMEs/Transition87Rb(3/2−)→87Sr(9/2+){}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}(3/2^{-}) \to{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}(9/2^{+})
VM321(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{321}(CVC)1.7609
VM330(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{330}142.5303
NMEs/Transition97Zr(1/2+)→97Nb(9/2+){}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{97}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^{+})
VM431(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{431}(CVC)9.3769
VM440(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{440}791.7846
NMEs/Transition101Mo(1/2+)→101Tc(9/2+){}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{101}\mathrm{Tc}(9/2^{+})
VM431(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{431}(CVC)-2.0213
VM440(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{440}-163.8205
NMEs/Transition115Cd(1/2+)→115In(9/2+){}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{115}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+})
VM431(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{431}0
VM431(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{431}(CVC)-5.0860
VM440(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{440}-418.6533
NMEs/Transition117Cd(1/2+)→117In(9/2+){}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{117}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+})
VM431(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{431}(CVC)-6.9390
VM440(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{440}-534.3482
NMEs/Transition119In(9/2+)→119Sn(1/2+){}^{119}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+}) \to{}^{119}\mathrm{Sn}(1/2^{+})
VM431(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{431}(CVC)0.5265
VM440(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{440}40.4356
NMEs/Transition123Sn(11/2−)→123Sb(1/2+){}^{123}\mathrm{Sn}(11/2^{-}) \to{}^{123}\mathrm{Sb}(1/2^{+})
VM541(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{541}(CVC)-12.227
VM550(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{550}-1290.0080

Table 2. The calculated l-NME VMKK(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{KK} and CVC constrained s-NME, VMKK−11(0)V\mathcal{M}^{(0)}_{KK-11}(CVC) for given order of forbiddenness KK.

For 85Br(3/2−)→85Kr(9/2+){}^{85}\mathrm{Br}(3/2^{-}) \to{}^{85}\mathrm{Kr}(9/2^{+}), we see a similar type of gAg_A dependency before and after constraining s-NME calculations. For 87Rb(3/2−)→87Sr(9/2+){}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}(3/2^{-}) \to{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}(9/2^{+}), the electron spectral-shape is gAg_A sensitive and after constraining the s-NMEs the gAg_A dependency is still there and the shapes are similar in both the calculations. Previously, this spectra is studied using SM and compared with the MQPM in Ref. [4] but in the present study we also discuss the results after constraining the s-NME. For 97Zr(1/2+)→97Nb(9/2+){}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{97}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^{+}) is gAg_A dependent before and after constraining the s-NME. For the 115Cd(1/2+)→115In(9/2+){}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{115}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+}) case, we are not getting any tilt in the shape of the electron spectrum before constraining s-NMES and after that we get bell-shaped structure. For 117Cd(1/2+)→117In(9/2+){}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{117}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+}) and fifth forbidden non-unique transition of 123Sn{}^{123}\mathrm{Sn} are shown. For 85Br(3/2−)→85Kr(9/2+){}^{85}\mathrm{Br}(3/2^{-}) \to{}^{85}\mathrm{Kr}(9/2^{+}), we see a similar type of gAg_A dependency before and after constraining s-NME calculations. For 87Rb(3/2−)→87Sr(9/2+){}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}(3/2^{-}) \to{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}(9/2^{+}), the electron spectral-shape is gAg_A sensitive and after constraining the s-NMEs the gAg_A dependency is still there and the shapes are similar in both the calculations. Previously, this spectra is studied using SM and compared with the MQPM in Ref. [4] but in the present study we also discuss the results after constraining the s-NME. For 97Zr(1/2+)→97Nb(9/2+){}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{97}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^{+}) is gAg_A dependent before and after constraining the s-NME. For the 115Cd(1/2+)→115In(9/2+){}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{115}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+}) case, we are not getting any tilt in the shape of the electron spectrum before constraining s-NMES and after that we get bell-shaped structure. For the 117Cd(1/2+)→117In(9/2+){}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{117}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+}) we see again gAg_A dependency before and after CVC constrained calculations. The fifth forbidden non-unique decay 123Sn(11/2−)→123Sb(1/2+){}^{123}\mathrm{Sn}(11/2^{-}) \to{}^{123}\mathrm{Sb}(1/2^{+}) is experimentally not measurable but still important from a theoretical point of view. The SM electron spectra is gAg_A sensitive before and after constraining the s-NMEs, while in MQPM model [3], they do not see any significant gAg_A dependency for this transition. Category III: when shape of the spectrum is neither a bell-shaped nor gAg_A independent after constraining the s-NME. In Figure 4, the second forbidden non-unique transition of 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs} and fourth forbidden non-unique transitions of 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo} and 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In} nuclei are shown. For 135Cs(7/2+)→135Ba(3/2+){}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}(7/2^{+}) \to{}^{135}\mathrm{Ba}(3/2^{+}), the shape is gAg_A independent before constraining the s-NME and the similar pattern can be seen using MQPM model [3], but in our study the spectra after constraining s-NME shows different behavior. So, we see our result match with MQPM when s-NMEs are zero and diverge when CVC is applied. It is important to mention here that CVC is essential for a proper determination of s-NMEs in both approaches. The fourth forbidden non-unique decay of 101Mo(1/2+)→101Tc(9/2+){}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{101}\mathrm{Tc}(9/2^{+}) decay is weakly dependent on gAg_A values before constraining the s-NME, while, after constraining the s-NME, the spectral-shape shows completely different behavior. The shape shows two humps in the throughout energy range, first hump which is in low energy region, is scattered and the second one is in higher energy range. The electron spectral-shape of 119In(9/2+)→119Sn(1/2+){}^{119}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+}) \to{}^{119}\mathrm{Sn}(1/2^{+}) decay is insensitive to the gAg_A values throughout the energy range of electron kinetic energy before constraining s-NME and when s-NME is constrained then spectrum shows two peaks, one in lower energy side and other one in higher energy side, in general, with the increase of gAg_A values shape becomes flattened in medium energy range and get a sudden fall in higher energy region.

In our present study we have not included NLO radiative corrections as done for NMEs calculations. With the radiative corrections in the LO we have done calculations for four transitions, 85Br(3/2−)→85Kr(9/2+){}^{85}\mathrm{Br}(3/2^{-}) \to{}^{85}\mathrm{Kr}(9/2^{+}), 97Zr(1/2+)→97Nb(9/2+){}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}(1/2^{+}) \to{}^{97}\mathrm{Nb}(9/2^{+}), 135Cs(7/2+)→135Ba(3/2+){}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}(7/2^{+}) \to{}^{135}\mathrm{Ba}(3/2^{+}) and 119In(9/2+)→119Sn(1/2+){}^{119}\mathrm{In}(9/2^{+}) \to{}^{119}\mathrm{Sn}(1/2^{+}) with gV=1.0g_V = 1.0 and $g_A = 1.0 and 1.27. We found a very minimal change in the electron-spectrum figures. So, the radiative corrections do not significantly affect the final results and the shape of the spectra for the cases of studied transitions.

a branching ratio 100%, the SM results with CVC are far from the experimental value 17.514(7). For the rest of the transitions, the experimental data is not available to compare the theoretical SM results. The other model MQPM and IBFM-2 are also needed to compare our SM logft results. Our predicted logft values are quite useful for future experiments.

logft values

tbl:I presents the calculated logft values using both “SM” and “SM + CVC” approaches. The experimental data is available only in the cases of 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}, 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}, and 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}. Constraining s-NMEs improves agreement for 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr} and 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}, but not for 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}. In the case of the second forbidden non-unique decay of 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}, the branching ratio (BR) is 27%. After constraining the s-NME, the moderate quenched logft value 11.847 is closer to the experimental value 12.10(10). For the second forbidden non-unique decay of 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}, the branching ratio is 100% and the experimental logft value is 13.48(6), the SM results are improved after constraining the s-NME. In the case of the third forbidden non-unique decay of 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}, having

Decomposition of the integrated shape factor

For a comprehensive analysis of the integrated shape function, we have also calculated the values of C~\widetilde{C} along with its vector C~V\widetilde{C}_{V}, axial-vector C~A\widetilde{C}_{A}, and mixed vector-axial vector C~VA\widetilde{C}_{VA} components for the studied transitions, as shown in Table Table III. The evaluation of these components follows from Eq. (7). We present all composition components with s-NMEs derived from CVC theory. Results where s-NMEs have zero value are labeled as “SM”, while those incorporating s-NMEs from CVC theory are labeled as “SM+CVC”. These results are given for gA=gV=1.0g_A=g_V=1.0. In all calculations, we have noticed that the sign of C~V\widetilde{C}_V and C~A\widetilde{C}_A is positive in both sets of the calculations. The sign of C~VA\widetilde{C}_{VA} component in “SM” and “SM+CVC” calculations varies. For second forbidden non-unique 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}, the contribution of axial-vector and vector components C~A\widetilde{C}_A and C~V\widetilde{C}_V before constraining s-NMEs is nearly similar, while after constraining the s-NME C~V\widetilde{C}_V dominates than C~A\widetilde{C}_A and the sign of mixed component is opposite. For 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}, the axial-vector and vector components C~A\widetilde{C}_A and C~V\widetilde{C}_V contribute nearly equally in both calculations. For 85Br{}^{85}\mathrm{Br}, 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}, 97Zr{}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}, 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}, 115Cd{}^{115}\mathrm{Cd} and 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In}, the SM calculations give dominant contribution of C~V\widetilde{C}_V in comparison to C~A\widetilde{C}_A while “SM+CVC” calculations gives variation. For 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo} and 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In} the C~V\widetilde{C}_V component dominant in comparison to C~A\widetilde{C}_A, while other transitions show reciprocal behavior in “SM+CVC” calculations. For 85Br{}^{85}\mathrm{Br}, 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}, 97Zr{}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}, 115Cd{}^{115}\mathrm{Cd} and 123Sn{}^{123}\mathrm{Sn}, the “SM+CVC” shows the positive sign of mixed vector-axial vector C~VA\widetilde{C}_{VA} also they have a similar type of beta spectrum shape in the calculations after constraining the s-NME. The C~A\widetilde{C}_A term does not change its value when the s-NME is included because the s-NME is a vector nuclear matrix element so it affect only vector components and mixed component. The 3rd forbidden non-unique 87Rb(3/2−)→87Sr(9/2+){}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}(3/2^-)\rightarrow{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}(9/2^+) transition is studied earlier using SM in [4] but in this paper the study of s-NME is not included in which the sign of C~VA\widetilde{C}_{VA} component is negative but in present study “SM+CVC” gives positive sign of C~VA\widetilde{C}_{VA} component although the beta spectrum shows the similar pattern with respect to different gAg_A values.

It is important to mention here that in the Donnelly and Walecka framework, the s-NME corresponds to the longitudinal multipole (LV), while the l-NME corresponds to the Coulomb multipole (CV). Since these NMEs are of similar magnitude [39], their similar contribution is straightforward in this formalism without requiring the phase space factors.

Conclusion

In the present manuscript, a systematic SM study of electron spectral-shapes, shape factors, and log ftft values has been performed for higher forbidden non-unique β−\beta^- transitions of 85Br{}^{85}\mathrm{Br}, 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}, 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr}, 97Zr{}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}, 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}, 115Cd{}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}, 117Cd{}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}, 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In}, 123Sn{}^{123}\mathrm{Sn} and 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs} nuclei in the different mass region of nuclear chart. The nuclear matrix elements are calculated using well-known effective interactions in the SM Hamiltonian to predict the theoretical electron spectrum and other properties. The present manuscript mainly focuses on the sensitivity of electron spectral-shapes with different values of the axial-vector coupling constant. We have found that electron spectral-shapes of second forbidden non-unique transition of 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}, third forbidden non-unique transition of 85Br{}^{85}\mathrm{Br} and 87Rb{}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}, fourth forbidden non-unique transition of 97Zr{}^{97}\mathrm{Zr}, 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo}, 115Cd{}^{115}\mathrm{Cd}, 117Cd{}^{117}\mathrm{Cd}, 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In} and fifth forbidden non-unique transition of 123Sn{}^{123}\mathrm{Sn} are strongly sensitive on gAg_A values after constraining the s-NME from CVC theory. The second forbidden non-unique transition of 93Zr{}^{93}\mathrm{Zr} is weakly sensitive on gAg_A after constraining s-NME from CVC theory. The transitions of 135Cs{}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}, 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo} and 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In} have been affected significantly with the s-NME and gAg_A values. The second forbidden non-unique transition 135Cs(7/2+)→135Ba(3/2+){}^{135}\mathrm{Cs}(7/2^+)\rightarrow{}^{135}\mathrm{Ba}(3/2^+) has a branching ratio 100% and has been experimentally observed, so this is an excellent candidate for SSM. This spectrum agrees well with the previously calculated spectrum with the MQPM model [3] when s-NME is zero and diverges when constrained from CVC theory. For this transition, in CVC calculation, spectrum get similar shape when gA=1.0g_A=1.0 and gV=1.0g_V=1.0 and at neighbouring values, the spectrum changes its shape. From experimental point of view, the third forbidden non-unique transition 87Rb(3/2−)→87Sr(9/2+){}^{87}\mathrm{Rb}(3/2^-)\rightarrow{}^{87}\mathrm{Sr}(9/2^+) is also important which has a branching ratio 100% and it is also a good candidate for SSM. Previously, the electron spectrum corresponding to this transition has been calculated with SM and MQPM models, but in the present study, we have also explored the role of s-NME [3]. The fourth forbidden non-unique transition of 101Mo{}^{101}\mathrm{Mo} and 119In{}^{119}\mathrm{In} is very different from the rest of the fourth forbidden non-unique transitions, the structure changes from bell-shaped to double hump like structure and we can see a significant role of s-NME in the spectrum.

Finally, in the present manuscript, we have constrained the s-NME directly using CVC theory and found that the computed electron spectral-shapes and shape factor values are sensitive to the value of s-NME. To see a better picture of electron spectral-shapes we have decomposed the total integrated shape function into its components. The signs and relative magnitudes of CAC_A, CVC_V, and CVAC_{VA} terms have been analyzed. The electron spectral-shapes exhibit sensitivity to the gAg_A values and s-NME. Our theoretical study of electron spectral-shapes and exploration of s-NME with different gAg_A values might be useful for future measurements of electron spectral-shapes in the context of SSM.

Acknowledgement

This work is supported by a research grant from SERB (India), CRG/2022/005167. We also acknowledge the National Supercomputing Mission (NSM) for providing computing resources of ‘PARAM Ganga’ at the Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee. We would also like to thank Prof. Jouni Suhonen and Dr. Anil Kumar for the useful discussions.

References

  1. [2]J. T. Suhonen, “Value of the Axial-Vector Coupling Strength in β and ββ Decays: A Review”, Front. Phys. 5, 55 (2017).DOI
  2. [3]J. Kostensalo, M. Haaranen, and J. Suhonen, “Electron spectra in forbidden β decays and the quenching of the weak axial-vector coupling constant gA”, Phys. Rev. C 95, 044313 (2017).DOI
  3. [4]J. Kostensalo, and J. Suhonen, “gA-driven shapes of electron spectra of forbidden β decays in the nuclear shell model”, Phys. Rev. C 96, 024317 (2017).DOI
  4. [5]E. D. Commins, Weak Interactions (McGraw-Hill, New York, 2007).
  5. [6]J. Suhonen, From Nucleons to Nucleus: Concept of Microscopic Nuclear Theory, (Springer, Berlin 2007).DOI
  6. [8]G. Martínez-Pinedo, A. Poves, E. Caurier, A. P. and Zuker, “Effective gA in the pf shell”, Phys Rev C. 53, R2602 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9971316
  7. [9]A. Kumar, P.C. Srivastava, and T. Suzuki, “Shell model results for nuclear β−-decay properties of sd-shell nuclei”, Prog. of Theor. Exp. Phys. 2020, 033D01 (2020).DOI
  8. [10]V. Kumar, P.C. Srivastava, and H. Li, “Nuclear β−-decay half-lives for fp and fpg shell nuclei, J. Phys. G:Nuc1. Part. Phys. 43, 105104 (2016).DOI
  9. [11]H. Ejiri, N. Soukouti and J. Suhonen, “Spin-dipole nuclear matrix elements for double beta decays and astrophysical neutrinos”, Phys. Lett. B 729, 27 (2014).DOI
  10. [12]H. Ejiri and J. Suhonen, “GT neutrino–nuclear responses for double beta decays and astro neutrinos”, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 42, 055201 (2015).DOI
  11. [13]M. Haaranen, P. C. Srivastava, and J. Suhonen, “Forbidden non-unique β decays and effective values of weak coupling constants”, Phys. Rev. C 93, 034308 (2016).DOI
  12. [14]L. Bodenstein-Dresler et al.(COBRA Collaboration), “Quenching of gA deduced from the β-spectrum shape of 113Cd measured with the COBRA experiment”, Phys. Lett. B 800, 135092 (2020).
  13. [15]J. Kostensalo, J. Suhonen, J. Volkmer, S. Zatschler, K. Zuber, “Confirmation of gA quenching using the revised spectrum-shape method for the analysis of the 113Cd β-decay as measured with the COBRA demonstrator”, Phys. Lett. B 822, 136652(2021).DOI
  14. [16]A. F. Leder et al., “Determining gA/gV with High-Resolution Spectral Measurements Using a LiInSe2 Bolometer”, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 232502 (2022).DOI
  15. [17]L. Pagnanini et al. (ACCESS Collaboration), “Array of cryogenic calorimeters to evaluate spectral shape of forbidden β -decays: the ACCESS project”, Eur. Phys. J. A 138, 445 (2023).DOI
  16. [18]F. Iachello and A. Arima, The Interacting Boson Model (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1987).
  17. [19]M. Haaranen, J. Kotila, J. and Suhonen, “Spectrum-shape method and the next-to-leading-order terms of the β-decay shape factor”, Phys. Rev. C 95, 024327 (2017).DOI
  18. [20]P. Belli et al., “Investigation of β decay of 113Cd”, Phys. Rev. C 76, 064603 (2007).
  19. [21]A. Kumar, P. C. Srivastava, J. Kostensalo and J. Suhonen, “Second-forbidden nonunique β− decays of 24Na and 36Cl assessed by the nuclear shell-model”, Phys. Rev. C. 101, 064304 (2020).
  20. [22]A. Kumar, P. C. Srivastava, and J. Suhonen, “Second-forbidden nonunique β− decays of 59,60Fe: possible candidates for a sensitive electron spectral-shape measurements”, Eur. Phys. J. A 57, 225 (2021).
  21. [23]G. De Gregorio, R. Mancino, L. Coraggio, and N. Itaco, “Forbidden β decays within the realistic shell model”, Phys. Rev. C 110, 014323 (2024).DOI
  22. [24]L. Coraggio, L. De Angelis, T. Fukui, A. Gargano, N. Itaco, and F. Nowacki, “Renormalization of the Gamow-Teller operator within the realistic shell model”, Phys. Rev. C 100, 014316 (2019).DOI
  23. [25]L. Coraggio, N. Itaco, G. De Gregorio, A. Gargano, R. Mancino, and F. Nowacki, “Shell-model calculation of 100Mo double-β decay”, Phys. Rev. C 105, 034312 (2022).DOI
  24. [26]M. Ramalho, J. Suhonen, “gA-sensitive β spectral shapes in the mass A = 86 − 99 region assessed by the nuclear shell model”, Phys. Rev. C 109, 034321 (2024).DOI
  25. [27]M. Ramalho, J. Suhonen, “Computed total electron spectra for decays of Pb and Bi in the 220,222Rn radioactive chains”, Phys. Rev. C 109, 014326 (2024).DOI
  26. [28]J. Kostensalo, E. Lisi, A. Arrone, and J. Suhonen, “113Cd β-decay spectrum and gA quenching using spectral moments”, Phys. Rev. C 107, 055502 (2023).
  27. [29]M. T. Mustonen, M. Aunola, and J. Suhonen, “Theoretical description of the fourth-forbidden non-unique β decays of 113Cd and 115In”, Phys. Rev. C 73, 054301 (2006); Erratum Phys. Rev. C 76, 019901 (2007).DOI
  28. [30]H. Behrens and W. Bühring, Electron Radial Wave Functions and Nuclear Beta-Decay (Clarendon Press, 1982).
  29. [31]H. F. Schopper, Weak Interaction and Nuclear Beta Decay (North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1966).
  30. [32]B. R. Holstein, “Recoil effects in allowed beta decay: The elementary particle approach”, Rev. Mod. Phys. 46, 789-814 (1974).DOI
  31. [33]J. S. O’Connell, T. W. Donnelly, and J. D. Walecka, “Semileptonic Weak Interactions with C12”, Phys. Rev. C. 6, 719 (1972).DOI
  32. [34]T. W. Donnelly and J. D. Walecka, “Semi-leptonic weak and electromagnetic interactions in nuclei with application to 16O”, Phys. Lett. 41B, 275 (1972).DOI
  33. [35]T. W. Donnelly and J. D. Walecka, “Elastic magnetic electron scattering and nuclear moments”, Nucl. Phys. A 201, 81 (1973).DOI
  34. [36]T. W. Donnelly and J. D. Walecka, “Semi-leptonic weak and electromagnetic interactions with nuclei: Isoelastic processes”, Nucl. Phys. A 274, 368 (1976).DOI
  35. [37]T. W. Donnelly and R. D. Peccei, “Neutral current effects in nuclei”, Phys. Rep. 50, 1 (1979).DOI
  36. [38]J. D. Walecka, “Theoretical Nuclear and Subnuclear Physics (World Scientific, 2004).”
  37. [39]A. Glick-Magid and D. Gazit, “A formalism to assess the accuracy of nuclear-structure weak interaction effects in precision β-decay studies”, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 49 105105 (2022).
  38. [40]C. Patrignani and Particle Data Group, “Review of Particle Physics”, Chinese Phys. C 40, 100001 (2016).
  39. [41]N. Shimizu, T. Mizusaki, Y. Utsuno and Y. Tsunoda, “Thick-restart block Lanczos method for large-scale shell-model calculations”, Comput. Phys. Commun. 244, 372–384 (2019).
  40. [42]Z. Ren et al., “Reinvestigation of the level structures of the N = 49 isotones 89Zr and 91Mo”, Phys. Rev. C 106, 024323 (2022).DOI
  41. [43]P. Dey et al., “Experimental investigation of high-spin states in 90Zr”, Phys. Rev. C 105, 044307 (2022).DOI
  42. [44]N. Boelaert, N. Smirnova, K. Heyde, and J. Jolie, “Shell model description of the low-lying states of the neutron deficient Cd isotopes”, Phys Rev C 75, 014316 (2007).DOI
  43. [45]A. Hosaka, et al., “G-matrix effective interaction with the paris potential”, Nucl. Phys. A 71, 444 (1986).DOI
  44. [46]B. A. Brown, et al., “Gamow-Teller strength in the region of 100Sn”, Phys. Rev. C 50, 2270(R) (1994).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9969964
  45. [47]B. A. Brown, N. J. Stone, J. R. Stone, I. S. Towner, and M. Hjorth-Jensen, “Magnetic moments of the 2+1 states around 132Sn”, Phys. Rev. C 71, 044317 (2005).
  46. [48]R. Machleidt, F. Sammarruca, and Y. Song, “Nonlocal nature of the nuclear force and its impact on nuclear structure”, Phys. Rev. C 71, 53 R1483 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9971179
  47. [49]A. Hosaka, K.-I. Kubo and H. Toki, “G-matrix effective interaction with the paris potential”, Nucl. Phys. A 444, 76 (1985).DOI
  48. [50]X. Ji and B. H. Wildenthal, “Effective interaction for N=50 isotones”, Phys. Rev. C 37, 1256 (1988).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9954564
  49. [51]D. H. Gloeckner, “Shell-model systematics of the zirconium and niobium isotopes”, Nucl. Phys. A 253, 301 (1975).DOI
  50. [52]F. J. D. Serduke, R. D. Lawson, and D. H. Gloeckner, “Shell-model study of the N = 49 isotones”, Nucl. Phys. A 256, 45 (1976).DOI
  51. [53]R. Machleidt, “High-precision, charge-dependent Bonn nucleon-nucleon potential”, Phys. Rev. C. 63, 024001 (2001).DOI
  52. [54]H. Behrens and W. Bühring, “Nuclear beta decay”, Nucl. Phys. A 162, 111 (1971).DOI
  53. [55]R. Sadler and H. Behrens, “Second-forbidden beta-decay and the effect of (V+A)- and S-interaction admixtures:36Cl”, Z. Physik A 346, 25 (1993).DOI
  54. [56]Q. Zhi, E. Caurier, J. J. Cuenca-García, K. Langanke, G. Martínez-Pinedo, K. and Sieja, “Shell-model half-lives including first-forbidden contributions for r-process waiting-point nuclei”, Phys. Rev. C 87, 025803 (2013).DOI
  55. [57]Dag Isak August Fahlin Strömberg, “Weak interactions in degenerate oxygen-neon cores”, Ph.D. thesis (2020), https://tuprints.ulb.tu-darmstadt.de/13302.
  56. [58]M. Wang, J. H. Huang, F. G. Kondev, G. Audi and S. Naimi, “The AME 2020 atomic mass evaluation (II). Tables, graphs and references” Chin. Phys. C 45(3), 030003 (2021).

Paper details

vlnc:W_qrspf2b6
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents