A transversely uniaxial bianisotropic medium with equal magnetoelectric scalars was conceived by Weiglhofer in 1994. Using the scalar factorization method, he concluded that the dyadic Green functions of this medium could not be found in closed form. That conclusion is incorrect. The essentials of the derivation are reproduced here, and closed-form expressions are given for all four dyadic Green functions of the unbounded medium, linking the electric and magnetic fields to electric and magnetic source current densities.
Introduction
In 1994, Weiglhofer conceived the transversely uniaxial bianisotropic medium (TUBM) as a special case of the most general uniaxial bianisotropic medium [1]. Such a medium is the homogenized description of a composite of electrically small uniaxial inclusions whose axes lie randomly in a plane normal to a fixed direction [2]. Its constitutive relations D=ε⋅E+ξ⋅H and B=ζ⋅E+μ⋅H contain the dyadics
where ε is permittivity dyadic, μ is the permeability dyadic, ξ and ζ are the magnetoelectric dyadics, and I is the identity dyadic. The scalars ξt and ζt capture the magnetoelectric properties of the TUBM. Throughout, the permittivity and permeability dyadics are assumed to be nonsingular, i.e., εtεz=0 and μtμz=0.
Weiglhofer [1] employed the scalar factorization method he developed with Lindell [3, 4, 5] to determine the electric dyadic Green function for the TUBM in closed form. This method requires the factorization of a fourth-order scalar operator H. Weiglhofer found that factorization is possible only if
ξt=ζt.(2)
Despite that factorization, he could not determine the electric dyadic Green function Gee(r,r′) in closed form. He conclude that “the transversally uniaxial bianisotropic medium with $\xi_t = \zeta_t becomes the first known case in which a closed-form solution for the dyadic Green function is not forthcoming despite successful factorization of the fourth-order operator H.”
While exploring the capabilities of ChatGPT-6.1 Sol Light to implement the scalar factorization method, we found that Weiglhofer’s conclusion regarding the TUBM with equal magnetoelectric scalars is incorrect. In this short paper the essentials of the derivation are reproduced, and closed-form expressions are given for the dyadic Green functions linking (i) the electric field to the source electric current density, (ii) the electric field to the source magnetic current density, (iii) the magnetic field to the source magnetic current density and (iv) the magnetic field to the source electric current density.
Vectors are in bold and dyadics are double underlined. The unit vectors of the Cartesian coordinate system are ux, uy and uz. The identity dyadic is denoted by I and It=I−uzuz. The fields are time harmonic, and a factor exp(−iωt) is suppressed.
Field equations
With the source electric current density denoted by J and the source magnetic current density denoted by K, the two Maxwell curl equations are:
The square root in A± is taken on the principal branch. Its real part is nonnegative and, when that real part vanishes, its imaginary part is nonnegative. Reversing its sign merely interchanges the labels + and −. We assume A+=A− throughout.
The factorization (12) of H is crucial for the initiation of the scalar factorization method [3, 4, 5]. Given Eq. (9), W(r,r′) satisfies both of the following relations:
Here ρ is the nonnegative real square root. For the outgoing Green functions with the exp(−iωt) convention, the branches of kt=ωδt and D± are fixed by continuation from ω>0, δt>0, and A±>0, where kt>0 and D±>0 away from the source. For complex constitutive parameters, the continuation is taken with the outgoing limiting-absorption prescription, so that the choices of kt and D± must not be made independently.
The adjoint operator for the TUBM with equal magnetoelectric scalars can be written as
Weiglhofer [1] treated F3(r,r′) as the solution of a fourth-order equation of the type
HF3=Qδ(r−r′)(30)
where he had Q=0 erroneously. He could not solve Eq. (30) in closed form, which led him to the conclusion that Gee(r,r′) cannot be determined in closed form. In contrast, Eqs. (20a)–(20c) show that L3 consists of exactly the two terms that produce F1(r,r′) and F2(r,r′). In other words, Q=0 so that
F3(r,r′)=0(31)
Since every term on the right sides of Eqs. (25a) and (25b) differentiates W(r,r′) with respect to the transverse coordinates but W(r,r′) depends on ρ and z−z′ only, the first of Eqs. (15) can be integrated once with respect to ρ. With the integration constant fixed by regularity on the axis ρ=0, we get
∇tW(r,r′)=uρ4πkt(A+−A−)ρiτ(32)
where
τ=exp(iktD+)−exp(iktD−)(33)
and (uρ,uφ,uz) are the unit vectors of the cylindrical coordinate system. In addition,
(∇×uz)W(r,r′)=[∇tW(r,r′)]×uz.(34)
Hence F1(r,r′) and F2(r,r′) are available in closed form, and no part of Gee(r,r′) remains undetermined. Of course, all results here hold in the sense of distributions. Furthermore, terms in ρ−2 are understood through their limits on the axis ρ=0[1].
In the expression for Fme(r,r′), W(r,r′) appears only through ∇tW(r,r′) and (∇×uz)W(r,r′), which are available in closed form from Eqs. (32) and (34).
Magnetic field due to magnetic current
The duality transformation E→H, H→−E, J→K, K→−J[9] preserves Eqs. (3) for the TUBM with equal magnetoscalars provided that εt,z↔μt,z and ξt→−ξt. This transformation leaves δt, kt, A±, G±, τ and W unchanged. Hence, Gmm is obtained from Gee as
All four dyadic Green functions of the TUBM with equal magnetoelectric scalars are expressed through G±, τ, and ρ as well as their derivatives, provided δt=0, A±=0 and A+=A−. Written as in Eqs. (32c) and (38c), F2(r,r′) and E2(r,r′) remain valid when the coefficients of F1(r,r′) and E1(r,r′) vanish. For ξt=0 the results reduce to those for a uniaxial dielectric-magnetic medium [10].
With this success of the scalar factorization method, which had unfortunately eluded Weiglhofer [1] because of some derivational errors, we expect this method to produce more novel results soon.
Acknowledgments
Both authors were supported by EPSRC (grant number APP68512).
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Declaration of AI use
This paper emerged while experimenting with ChatGPT-6.1 Sol Light to implement the scalar factorization method. All equations were typeset by that chatbot. The authors wrote the textual material and verified the equations.
Data availability
All data analyzed in this paper are included in this paper.
References
[1]Weiglhofer, W. S., 1994, Dyadic Green function for unbounded general uniaxial bianisotropic medium. International Journal of Electronics, 77, 105–115.
[2]Weiglhofer, W. S., Lakhtakia, A., and Monzon, J. C., 1993, Maxwell Garnett model for composites of electrically small uniaxial objects. Microwave and Optical Technology Letters, 6, 681–684.
[3]Lindell, I. V., and Weiglhofer, W. S., 1994, Green dyadic for a uniaxial bianisotropic medium. IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, 42, 1013–1016.DOI
[4]Weiglhofer, W. S., and Lindell, I. V., 1994a, Fields and potentials in general uniaxial bianisotropic media. I. Axial sources. International Journal of Applied Electromagnetics in Materials, 4, 211–220.
[5]Weiglhofer, W. S., and Lindell, I. V., 1994b, Analytic solution for the dyadic Green function of a nonreciprocal uniaxial bianisotropic medium. Archiv für Elektronik und Übertragungstechnik, 48, 116–119.
[6]Tai, C.-T., 1993, Dyadic Green Functions in Electromagnetic Theory, 2nd edn. (Piscataway, NJ, U.S.A.: IEEE Press).
[7]Olyslager, F., and Lindell, I. V., 2002, Electromagnetics and exotic media: A quest for the holy grail. IEEE Antennas & Propagation Magazine, 44(2), 48–58.DOI
[8]Faryad, M., and Lakhtakia, A., 2018, Infinite-Space Dyadic Green Functions in Electromagnetism (San Ramon, CA, U.S.A.: Morgan & Claypool).DOI
[9]Lindell, I. V., 1992, Methods for Electromagnetic Field Analysis (Oxford, U.K.: Clarendon Press).
[10]Weiglhofer, W. S., 1990, Dyadic Green’s functions for general uniaxial media. IEE Proceedings H, 137, 5–10.