betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Proton-neutron pairing correlations in N=Z nuclei with Deformed Skyrme+pnBCS model

Abstract

We investigate the effects of neutron-neutron (nn), proton-proton (pp) and proton-neutron (pn) pairing correlations on the ground-states of N=ZN = Z even-even pfpf-shell nuclei by using an axially symmetric deformed Hartree-Fock (HF)+pnBardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) model. We adopt a Skyrme energy density functional (EDF) SGII, together with contact volume- and surface-type pairing interactions, whose strengths are adjusted to reproduce empirical pairing gaps of each nucleus. It is shown that the strength of the IS pairing is correlated to the nuclear deformation: for oblate deformation with −0.3<β2<0.0-0.3<β_2<0.0, a stronger IS pairing is required to reproduce the empirical pairing gap, while for prolate deformation a weaker one is enough. Among the eight N=ZN=Z nuclei, we found that 64^{64}Ge, 68^{68}Se and 72^{72}Kr show the dominance of isovector (IV) spin-singlet superfluidity, while lighter 5 nuclei 44^{44}Ti, 48^{48}Cr, 52^{52}Fe, 56^{56}Ni and 60^{60}Zn exhibit the coexistence of IV spin-singlet and isoscalar (IS) spin-triplet superfluidities. We found also that the IS abnormal density always exhibits the oblate deformation, regardless of whether the normal density is prolate, spherical or oblate.

Introduction

The proton-neutron (pn) pairing becomes active in N∼ZN\sim Z nuclei where valence protons and neutrons occupy the same orbitals or the spin-orbit partners, having the maximum overlap between their wave functions [1, 2]. The pn pair can be further divided into isoscalar spin-triplet (IS) and isovector spin-singlet (IV) pairing components according to the total isospin of two nucleons. The pn pairing, particularly IS pairing correlations have significant impacts on the properties of N∼ZN\sim Z nuclei, such as the origin of Wigner energy [3, 4, 5], the existence of quartet cluster [6, 7, 8, 9], the abnormal bifurcation of the double binding energy differences between the odd-odd and even-even nuclei [10], low-lying spectrum of excited states [11], the strong low-energy Gamow-Teller (GT) transition [12, 13, 14], and the deuteron transfer reaction [15, 16]. In nuclei with neutron excess, the IS pairing has also significant effects on β\beta decay [17, 18] and double β\beta decay [19, 20] induced by low-energy GT strength below the β\beta decay QQ value. Experimentally, the data in 92^{92}Pd suggest a strong IS pairing correlation different from the normal IV superfluidity [21]. In the near future, high-intensity radioactive beams will provide new possibilities for studying the structural properties of unstable nuclei along the N=ZN=Z line enhancing the possibility of finding new evidences for pn pairing [1].

In order to explore the effects of pn pairing on the ground state properties, the Hartree-Fock-Bogoliubov (HFB) and Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) including the pn pairing (pnHFB or pnBCS) were introduced in Refs. [22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32]. Later, the self-consistent mean-field calculations in the full valence space were done, in which the paring interactions were taken in the forms of volume force [26, 27, 28, 32], schematic force [25], and the realistic CD Bonn potential [29, 30, 31]. In the above literatures, the obvious coexistence of IS and IV pn pairing correlation in N=ZN=Z nuclei can be obtained only when the realistic pairing interactions were adopted [24, 29, 30, 31], which enable to reproduce empirical nn, pp, and pn paring gaps, simultaneously. Moreover, IS pairing has been suggested to exist close to the N=ZN=Z line near A∼130A\sim130 in Refs. [27, 32], which shows the deformation plays an important role. And in sdsd-shell nuclei when varying the IS and IV pairing strengths with a fixed ratio of 1.5, the IS pairing dominates for large prolate or oblate deformations with ∣β2∣>0.3|\beta_2|>0.3 in 24^{24}Mg and 28^{28}Si, and only for large prolate deformation with β2>0.3\beta_2>0.3 in 32^{32}S [30]. For smaller deformations, it is still ambiguous whether a strong IS correlation exists.

In this article, we study the co-existence problem of IS and IV superfluidities in even-even N=ZN=Z pfpf-shell nuclei with the self-consistent HF+pnBCS calculations including the freedom of axial-symmetric quadrupole deformation using Skyrme EDFs. As the pairing interactions, the volume and surface pairing interactions are employed for pppp, nnnn and pnpn channels, and the IS and IV pairing strengths are varied independently to reproduce the empirical pairing gaps. The coexistence of IS and IV pairing condensations will be examined under the presence of the quadrupole deformation. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II, we present detailed formalism of the deformed pnBCS model. Numerical results and related discussions are presented in Section III. Finally, a summary is presented in Section IV.

Formalism and details

BCS model including pn pairing

The IS and IV pairing correlations on the ground state are accounted by including all pp, nn and pn pairing interactions in a BCS model so called ”pnBCS” model [33]. In this model, the Hamiltonian of the system is composed from the one-body part H0H_0 and two-body part HintH_{int},

H=H0+HintH = H_0 + H_{int}
H0=∑αq(εαq−λq)Cαq†CαqH_0 = \sum_{\alpha q}(\varepsilon_{\alpha q}-\lambda_q)C_{\alpha q}^{\dagger}C_{\alpha q}
Hint=12∑α,q1,q2β,q3,q4v(αq1)(αˉq2)(βq3)(βˉq4)Cαq1†Cαˉq2†Cβˉq4Cβq3(1)H_{int} = \frac{1}{2}\sum_{\substack{\alpha,q_1,q_2\\\beta,q_3,q_4}} v_{(\alpha q_1)(\bar{\alpha}q_2)(\beta q_3)(\bar{\beta}q_4)}C_{\alpha q_1}^{\dagger}C_{\bar{\alpha}q_2}^{\dagger}C_{\bar{\beta}q_4}C_{\beta q_3} \tag*{(1)}

where α\alpha and β\beta denote the single-particle states with quantum number Ωπ\Omega^\pi of the zz component of angular momentum and parity in the axially symmetric deformed potential, and q=(n,p)q=(n,p) denotes neutron or proton. αˉ\bar{\alpha} and βˉ\bar{\beta} denote the time-reversed state of α\alpha and β\beta, respectively. εαq\varepsilon_{\alpha q} represents the single-particle energy, and Cαq†C_{\alpha q}^{\dagger} (CαqC_{\alpha q}) is the corresponding creation (annihilation) operator, while λq\lambda_q is the chemical potential. v(αq1)(αˉq2)(βq3)(βˉq4)v_{(\alpha q_1)(\bar{\alpha}q_2)(\beta q_3)(\bar{\beta}q_4)} is the two-body matrix element for the pairing interaction. Assuming the time-reversal symmetry, the quasiparticle creation and annihilation operators are constructed by the following transformation:

(aα1†aαˉ1†aα2aαˉ2)=(uα1puα1nvα1pvα1nuα2puα2nvα2pvα2n−vα1p−vα1nuα1puα1n−vα2p−vα2nuα2puα2n)(Cαp†Cαn†CαˉpCαˉn)(2)\begin{pmatrix} a_{\alpha1}^{\dagger}\\ a_{\bar{\alpha}1}^{\dagger}\\ a_{\alpha2}\\ a_{\bar{\alpha}2} \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} u_{\alpha1p} & u_{\alpha1n} & v_{\alpha1p} & v_{\alpha1n}\\ u_{\alpha2p} & u_{\alpha2n} & v_{\alpha2p} & v_{\alpha2n}\\ -v_{\alpha1p} & -v_{\alpha1n} & u_{\alpha1p} & u_{\alpha1n}\\ -v_{\alpha2p} & -v_{\alpha2n} & u_{\alpha2p} & u_{\alpha2n} \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} C_{\alpha p}^{\dagger}\\ C_{\alpha n}^{\dagger}\\ C_{\bar{\alpha}p}\\ C_{\bar{\alpha}n} \tag*{(2)} \end{pmatrix}

where i=1i=1 or 2 labels the isospin of the quasiparticles. The superposition factors uu and vv can be obtained solving the pnBCS equation,

(εαp−λp0ΔαppˉΔαpnˉ0εαn−λnΔαnpˉΔαnnˉΔαppˉΔαpnˉλp−εαp0ΔαnpˉΔαnnˉ0λn−εαn)(uαipuαinvαipvαin)=Eαi(uαipuαinvαipvαin)(3)\begin{pmatrix} \varepsilon_{\alpha p}-\lambda_p & 0 & \Delta_{\alpha p\bar{p}} & \Delta_{\alpha p\bar{n}}\\ 0 & \varepsilon_{\alpha n}-\lambda_n & \Delta_{\alpha n\bar{p}} & \Delta_{\alpha n\bar{n}}\\ \Delta_{\alpha p\bar{p}} & \Delta_{\alpha p\bar{n}} & \lambda_p-\varepsilon_{\alpha p} & 0\\ \Delta_{\alpha n\bar{p}} & \Delta_{\alpha n\bar{n}} & 0 & \lambda_n-\varepsilon_{\alpha n} \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} u_{\alpha ip}\\ u_{\alpha in}\\ v_{\alpha ip}\\ v_{\alpha in} \end{pmatrix} = E_{\alpha i} \begin{pmatrix} u_{\alpha ip}\\ u_{\alpha in}\\ v_{\alpha ip}\\ v_{\alpha in} \tag*{(3)} \end{pmatrix}

Notice that the quasi-particle state has the good isospin, but mixes the proton and neutron states.

The pairing interactions for different channels are given by,

Vj(r1,r2)=V0j(1−xjρ(r)ρ0)δ(r1−r2)Pj(4)V_j(\boldsymbol{r}_1,\boldsymbol{r}_2)=V_0^j\left(1-x_j\frac{\rho(\boldsymbol{r})}{\rho_0}\right)\delta(\boldsymbol{r}_1-\boldsymbol{r}_2)P_j \tag*{(4)}

where jj denotes pp, nn, IS and IV pn pairing with PjP_j being the corresponding projection operators. V0jV_0^j are the strength parameters of the corresponding pairing channels, xjx_j takes 0 or 1 corresponding to volume or surface parings, and ρ0=0.16 fm−3\rho_0=0.16\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3} is the saturation density. It should be noted that we allow different parameters for different paireding channels in our calculations.

Under the axially symmetric deformation, the single-particle wave function Φα,q\Phi_{\alpha,q} and its time reversal are written as,

Φα,q=∑σϕασq(r⊥,z)ei(Ω−σ)φχσχq,\Phi_{\alpha,q}=\sum_{\sigma}\phi_{\alpha\sigma q}(r_{\perp},z)e^{i(\Omega-\sigma)\varphi}\chi_{\sigma}\chi_q,
Φˉα,q=∑σ(−1)12+σϕα−σq(r⊥,z)e−i(Ω+σ)φχσχq(5)\bar{\Phi}_{\alpha,q}=\sum_{\sigma}(-1)^{\frac{1}{2}+\sigma}\phi_{\alpha-\sigma q}(r_{\perp},z)e^{-i(\Omega+\sigma)\varphi}\chi_{\sigma}\chi_q \tag*{(5)}

where ϕασq(r⊥,z)\phi_{\alpha\sigma q}(r_{\perp},z) is the radial wave function in the cylindrical coordinate space (r⊥,z)(r_{\perp},z), and σ=±12\sigma=\pm\frac{1}{2} label the up and down components of the spin. The pairing matrix elements in Eq. (3) can then be calculated in the cylindrical coordinate space directly,

Δαppˉ=−∑β>0,σ1,σ2(uβ1pvβ1p∗+uβ2pvβ2p∗)∬∣ϕασ1p(r⊥,z)∣2Vpp(r⊥,z)∣ϕβσ2p(r⊥,z)∣22πr⊥ dr⊥ dz\Delta_{\alpha p\bar{p}}=-\sum_{\beta>0,\sigma_1,\sigma_2}(u_{\beta1p}v_{\beta1p}^{*}+u_{\beta2p}v_{\beta2p}^{*})\iint\lvert\phi_{\alpha\sigma_1p}(r_{\perp},z)\rvert^2V_{pp}(r_{\perp},z)\lvert\phi_{\beta\sigma_2p}(r_{\perp},z)\rvert^2 2\pi r_{\perp}\,dr_{\perp}\,dz
Δαnnˉ=−∑β>0,σ1,σ2(uβ1nvβ1n∗+uβ2nvβ2n∗)∬∣ϕασ1n(r⊥,z)∣2Vnn(r⊥,z)∣ϕβσ2n(r⊥,z)∣22πr⊥ dr⊥ dz\Delta_{\alpha n\bar{n}}=-\sum_{\beta>0,\sigma_1,\sigma_2}(u_{\beta1n}v_{\beta1n}^{*}+u_{\beta2n}v_{\beta2n}^{*})\iint\lvert\phi_{\alpha\sigma_1n}(r_{\perp},z)\rvert^2V_{nn}(r_{\perp},z)\lvert\phi_{\beta\sigma_2n}(r_{\perp},z)\rvert^2 2\pi r_{\perp}\,dr_{\perp}\,dz
Δαpnˉ=−∑β>0,σ1,σ2Re⁡(uβ1pvβ1n∗+uβ2pvβ2n∗)×∬ϕασ1p(r⊥,z)ϕασ1n(r⊥,z)VIV(r⊥,z)×ϕβσ2p(r⊥,z)ϕβσ2n(r⊥,z)2πr⊥ dr⊥ dz−i∑β>0,σ1,σ2Im⁡(uβ1pvβ1n∗+uβ2pvβ2n∗)×(−1)1−σ1−σ2∬ϕασ1p(r⊥,z)ϕασ1n(r⊥,z)VIS(r⊥,z)×ϕβσ2p(r⊥,z)ϕβσ2n(r⊥,z)2πr⊥ dr⊥ dz(6)\begin{aligned} \Delta_{\alpha p\bar{n}}={}&-\sum_{\beta>0,\sigma_1,\sigma_2}\operatorname{Re}(u_{\beta1p}v_{\beta1n}^{*}+u_{\beta2p}v_{\beta2n}^{*})\\ &\times\iint\phi_{\alpha\sigma_1p}(r_{\perp},z)\phi_{\alpha\sigma_1n}(r_{\perp},z)V_{IV}(r_{\perp},z)\\ &\times\phi_{\beta\sigma_2p}(r_{\perp},z)\phi_{\beta\sigma_2n}(r_{\perp},z)2\pi r_{\perp}\,dr_{\perp}\,dz\\ &-i\sum_{\beta>0,\sigma_1,\sigma_2}\operatorname{Im}(u_{\beta1p}v_{\beta1n}^{*}+u_{\beta2p}v_{\beta2n}^{*})\\ &\times(-1)^{1-\sigma_1-\sigma_2}\iint\phi_{\alpha\sigma_1p}(r_{\perp},z)\phi_{\alpha\sigma_1n}(r_{\perp},z)V_{IS}(r_{\perp},z)\\ &\times\phi_{\beta\sigma_2p}(r_{\perp},z)\phi_{\beta\sigma_2n}(r_{\perp},z)2\pi r_{\perp}\,dr_{\perp}\,dz \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

In the current pnBCS scheme, only pnˉp\bar{n} and pˉn\bar{p}n pairing correlations are included. The effects of (pn)(pn) and (pˉnˉ)(\bar{p}\bar{n}) components are effectively incorporated by multiplying a factor of 2 on the IS component as was suggested in Ref. [30].

Pairing Gaps

The empirical pp, nn and pn pairing gaps are evaluated by the formulas [34, 35],

Δpemp=18[M(Z+2,N)−4M(Z+1,N)+6M(Z,N)−4M(Z−1,N)+M(Z−2,N)]Δnemp=18[M(Z,N+2)−4M(Z,N+1)+6M(Z,N)−4M(Z,N−1)+M(Z,N−2)]Δpnemp=14{2[M(Z,N+1)+M(Z,N−1)M(Z+1,N)+M(Z−1,N)]−[M(Z+1,N+1)+M(Z−1,N+1)−M(Z+1,N−1)+M(Z−1,N−1)]−4M(Z,N)}.(7)\begin{aligned} \Delta_{p}^{emp} &= \frac{1}{8}[M(Z+2,N)-4M(Z+1,N)+6M(Z,N)\\ &\quad-4M(Z-1,N)+M(Z-2,N)]\\ \Delta_{n}^{emp} &= \frac{1}{8}[M(Z,N+2)-4M(Z,N+1)+6M(Z,N)\\ &\quad-4M(Z,N-1)+M(Z,N-2)]\\ \Delta_{pn}^{emp} &= \frac{1}{4}\{2[M(Z,N+1)+M(Z,N-1)M(Z+1,N)\\ &\quad+M(Z-1,N)]-[M(Z+1,N+1)\\ &\quad+M(Z-1,N+1)-M(Z+1,N-1)\\ &\quad+M(Z-1,N-1)]-4M(Z,N)\}. \tag*{(7)} \end{aligned}

The empirical gaps of N=ZN=Z even-even nuclei from 44Ti{}^{44}\mathrm{Ti} to 72Kr{}^{72}\mathrm{Kr} are listed in Table I.

NucleusΔpemp\Delta_{p}^{emp}Δnemp\Delta_{n}^{emp}Δpnemp\Delta_{pn}^{emp}
44Ti{}^{44}\mathrm{Ti}2.6312.6532.068
48Cr{}^{48}\mathrm{Cr}2.1282.1381.442
52Fe{}^{52}\mathrm{Fe}1.9912.0071.122
56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}2.0802.1591.115
60Zn{}^{60}\mathrm{Zn}1.6791.7821.044
64Ge{}^{64}\mathrm{Ge}1.8072.1411.435
68Se{}^{68}\mathrm{Se}1.9092.1841.522
72Kr{}^{72}\mathrm{Kr}2.0011.9851.353

Table 1. Empirical pairing gaps of N=ZN=Z nuclei from 44Ti{}^{44}\mathrm{Ti} to 72Kr{}^{72}\mathrm{Kr}

Theoretically, the mean pairing gaps are evaluated by the following formulas,

Δ‾pp=∑αΔαpp⟨Sαpp†Sαpp⟩∑β⟨Sβpp†Sβpp⟩\overline{\Delta}_{pp}=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{\Delta_{\alpha pp}\langle S_{\alpha pp}^{\dagger}S_{\alpha pp}\rangle}{\sum_{\beta}\langle S_{\beta pp}^{\dagger}S_{\beta pp}\rangle}
Δ‾nn=∑αΔαnn⟨Sαnn†Sαnn⟩∑β⟨Sβnn†Sβnn⟩\overline{\Delta}_{nn}=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{\Delta_{\alpha nn}\langle S_{\alpha nn}^{\dagger}S_{\alpha nn}\rangle}{\sum_{\beta}\langle S_{\beta nn}^{\dagger}S_{\beta nn}\rangle}
Δ‾pnIV=∑αRe(Δαpn)⟨Sαpn†Sαpn⟩∑β⟨Sβpn†Sβpn⟩\overline{\Delta}_{pn}^{IV}=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{Re(\Delta_{\alpha pn})\langle S_{\alpha pn}^{\dagger}S_{\alpha pn}\rangle}{\sum_{\beta}\langle S_{\beta pn}^{\dagger}S_{\beta pn}\rangle}
Δ‾pnIS=∑αIm(Δαpn)⟨Sαpn†Sαpn⟩∑β⟨Sβpn†Sβpn⟩\overline{\Delta}_{pn}^{IS}=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{Im(\Delta_{\alpha pn})\langle S_{\alpha pn}^{\dagger}S_{\alpha pn}\rangle}{\sum_{\beta}\langle S_{\beta pn}^{\dagger}S_{\beta pn}\rangle}
Δ‾pn=∑α∣Δαpn∣⟨Sαpn†Sαpn⟩∑β⟨Sβpn†Sβpn⟩,(8)\overline{\Delta}_{pn}=\sum_{\alpha}\frac{|\Delta_{\alpha pn}|\langle S_{\alpha pn}^{\dagger}S_{\alpha pn}\rangle}{\sum_{\beta}\langle S_{\beta pn}^{\dagger}S_{\beta pn}\rangle}, \tag*{(8)}

where Sαq1q2†=Cαq1†Cαq2†S_{\alpha q_{1}q_{2}}^{\dagger}=C_{\alpha q_{1}}^{\dagger}C_{\alpha q_{2}}^{\dagger} is the pair creation operator.

Before the pnBCS calculation, axially symmetric deformed HFB [36] calculations with only pp and nn pairing interactions are done to obtain the single-particle states for the pnBCS calculation. In the HFB calculations, the model space for all nuclei is exploited up to N=6ℏωN=6\hbar\omega in a deformed harmonic oscillator basis. The deformation parameter β2\beta_{2} of the harmonic oscillator basis and its corresponding mass quadratic moment are varied in the range −0.5<β2<0.5-0.5<\beta_{2}<0.5. The strength parameters for the pp and nn pairing interactions are determined by fitting to the empirical pairing gaps. After the HFB calculations are done, the single-particle states in the canonical basis are extracted and used as the input for the pnBCS calculations, which are performed at each deformation point taking into account the full four pairing interactions. Notice that the canonical basis is a substitute of deformed Woods-Saxon wave function as the initial wave functions to make good convergence for pnBCS calculations. The calculation is started with initial appropriate pp, nn, and pn gaps, and the iteration is finished when the self-consistent solution is obtained.

Results

In the present research, the Skyrme Energy Density Functional(EDF) SGII [37] is employed. We employed the volume-type pairing interaction for all four pairing channels in Section IIIA. Then in Section IIIB, we take the surface-type pairing interaction for the pp and nn channels, and the volume-type one for the pn channel.

Results with the volume-type interaction

Firstly, we use the volume pairing interactions for all pairing channels and assumed an equal pairing strength for the IV channel, namely, V0pp=V0nn=V0IVV_{0}^{pp}=V_{0}^{nn}=V_{0}^{IV} and xj=0x_{j}=0 in Eq. (4).

As shown in Table I, the pp and nn pairing gaps are similar values except for 64Ge{}^{64}\mathrm{Ge} and 68Se{}^{68}\mathrm{Se}, so that the pn-BCS calculations are performed at each deformation optimizing the two strengths V0IVV_{0}^{IV} and V0ISV_{0}^{IS} to minimize the root mean squared error between the empirical pairing gaps and the calculated mean pairing gaps.

Figure 1 (a) shows the ground state energies as a function of the quadrupole deformation parameter β2\beta_{2} for 44Ti{}^{44}\mathrm{Ti}, calculated by HFB and pnBCS models. The total energy at the minimum point is reduced by about 2 MeV due to the pn pairing correlations. The ratio between the IS and IV pairing strengths,

Image not extracted

Figure 1. (a): The total energy of ground state of 44Ti^{44}\mathrm{Ti} as a function of the quadrupole deformation parameter β2\beta_{2} calculated by the HFB and pnBCS models. The HFB includes only the IV pp and nn pairing interactions, while pnBCS takes into account also IS and IV pn pairing ones. Assuming V0pp=V0nn=V0IVV_{0}^{pp}=V_{0}^{nn}=V_{0}^{IV} and xj=0x_{j}=0 in Eq. (4), the IS and IV pairing strengths at each deformation are adjusted to reproduce the empirical paring gaps in Table I. (b): The paring strength ratios g=V0IV(β2)/V0IV(β2=0.0)g=V_{0}^{IV}(\beta_{2})/V_{0}^{IV}(\beta_{2}=0.0) and f=V0IS(β2)/V0IV(β2)f=V_{0}^{IS}(\beta_{2})/V_{0}^{IV}(\beta_{2}) at different β2\beta_{2} value. The vertical black line represents the deformation at the lowest energy minimum. See the text for details.

f=V0ISV0IV,(9)f=\frac{V_{0}^{IS}}{V_{0}^{IV}}, \tag*{(9)}

is shown in Figure 1 (b) as a function of deformation parameter β2\beta_{2}. Another ratio between V0IV(β)V_{0}^{IV}(\beta) at finite deformation and the one at the spherical shape,

g=V0IV(β)V0IV(β=0).(10)g=\frac{V_{0}^{IV}(\beta)}{V_{0}^{IV}(\beta=0)}. \tag*{(10)}

is also shown in the figure. It can be observed that the ratio gg is relatively flat, indicating that the IV pairing strength is changed only slightly in the presence of deformation, namely, the IV pairing is correlated weakly with the deformation. In contrast, for the ratio ff, there is a peak at the oblate deformation β2∼−0.2\beta_{2}\sim-0.2, while for prolate β2\beta_{2} deformation, the ratio ff decreases with the increasing of the deformation. That is, the IS pairing correlation is strongly affected by the deformation in both oblate and prolate regions. This characteristic feature is found in all nuclei studied in this article.

We show the pp, nn, IS and IV pn, and total pn pairing gaps of 44Ti^{44}\mathrm{Ti} in Figure 2 obtained at β2=−0.03\beta_{2}=-0.03 corresponding to the lowest energy in Figure 1(a). In Figure 2(a), we fix the strengths of the nn, pp, and IV pn pairing, and vary only the IS pairing strength by the ratio ff. As shown in the figure, when ff is smaller than 1.15, there are only pp and nn pairs. While ff is larger than 1.15, the IS pn becomes finite and keeps increasing for a larger ff value, while the pp and nn pairing gaps decrease constantly. As a result, the coexistence region of pp, nn, and pn pairing appears and the pp, nn, and pn pairing gaps can be fitted

Image not extracted

Figure 2. (a): Mean pairing gaps estimated by Eq. (8) at the energy minimum as a function of the ratio ff for 44Ti^{44}\mathrm{Ti}. The IV pairing strength V0IVV_{0}^{IV} (V0pp=V0nn=V0IVV_{0}^{pp}=V_{0}^{nn}=V_{0}^{IV}) is fixed at the minimum shown in Figure 1, whereas the IS pairing strength V0ISV_{0}^{IS} is varied. The vertical black line represents the position of ff that reproduces the empirical energy gap. (b): Mean pairing gaps as a function of the ratio V0IV/V0ppV_{0}^{IV}/V_{0}^{pp} for 44Ti^{44}\mathrm{Ti}. The pairing strength V0ppV_{0}^{pp} (V0pp=V0nnV_{0}^{pp}=V_{0}^{nn}) and V0ISV_{0}^{IS} are set to the same values at the position represented by the solid vertical black line in Figure 1(a), whereas the IV pn pairing strength V0IVV_{0}^{IV} is varied. See the text for details.

simultaneously. However, the IV pn pairing is absent in the entire region. In order to check the reason for the absence of IV pn pairing, we fix the strengths of the pp, nn, and IS pn pairing interactions, and vary only the IV pn pairing strength. The mean pairing gaps are shown in Figure 2(b) as a function of the ratio V0IV/V0ppV_{0}^{IV}/V_{0}^{pp}. As shown in the figure, when this ratio is smaller than about 1.01, there are only pp, nn, and IS pn pairing and no IV pn pairing, but when the ratio is increased slightly beyond 1.01, the pp and nn pairing suddenly disappeared, and only the IV pn pairing gap appears in the IV pairing correlations. Remarkably, despite this suddenly interchange from nn and pp to IV pn pairing gaps, the net IV energy gap exhibits a smooth dependence on the ratio parameter before and after this transition coexisting with the IV pn pairs.

This kind of sudden change of the pairing gap is also observed in [25] in pnBCS calculations with simple seniority pairing interactions. However, the pp(nn) pairs and pn pairs in [25] are incompatible. In contrast, the results presented in Figure 2(a) show that the IV and IS superfluidities of pp(nn) and pn pairs can coexist. The problem of non-coexistence is due to similarities between the proton and neutron wave functions involved in the gap equation, and also the type of pairing interaction. In order to cure this non-coexistence problem, promising models are to use interacting shell model wave functions, or projected BCS model [38], or to use realistic pairing interactions for different channels to break the symmetry in the IV channels such as G-matrices [31]. In the pnBCS model, one can obtain a mean-field solution that allows for the coexistence for the three IV pairs by using different types of pairing interaction in pp(nn) and IV pn pairing channels.

Results with different types of pairing interactions

In the previous subsection, we delved into the implications of the volume pairing interaction for both the IV and IS channels, which precludes the simultaneous existence of pp, nn, and pn IV pairing gaps. But there is empirical evidence for the exist of IV pn pairing from the energy difference observed between IS and IV states with the same spin-parity [39]. It might be necessary to modify the current pnBCS model by breaking the isospin symmetry in the isovector (IV) channel, so as to permit the coexistence of pp, nn, and IV pn pairing gaps.

In this subsection we use a surface pairing interaction in the pp and nn channels and a volume pairing interaction in the IS and IV pn pairing channels, which means xpp,nn=1x_{pp,nn}=1 and xIV,IS=0x_{IV,IS}=0 in Eq. (4). In the calculations we do not constrain any pairing strength to be the same, but vary all the parameters V0ppV_0^{pp}, V0nnV_0^{nn}, V0IVV_0^{IV} and V0ISV_0^{IS} to reproduce the three empirical pairing gaps. Because there are four free strength parameters, and three empirical pairing gaps to be reproduced, one degree of freedom among the four parameters can not be fixed by the experimental data. We then introduce a content parameter of IS pairing gap in the total pn gap defined as,

K=(Δ‾pnISΔ‾pn)2.(11)K = \left(\frac{\overline{\Delta}_{pn}^{IS}}{\overline{\Delta}_{pn}}\right)^2. \tag*{(11)}

to fix the role of a redundant parameter of the pn pairing channel. The definition of the ratio is defined to be consistent with that of the pn pairing gap,

Δpn=(ΔpnIS)2+(ΔpnIV)2(12)\Delta_{pn} = \sqrt{\left(\Delta_{pn}^{IS}\right)^2+\left(\Delta_{pn}^{IV}\right)^2} \tag*{(12)}

Figure 3 illustrates the empirical and calculated pairing gaps for N=ZN=Z nuclei from 44^{44}Ti to 72^{72}Kr at K=0.4K=0.4, where approximately 40% and 60% of the total pn pairing gaps come from the IS and IV channels, respectively. Actually, adjusting the four strength parameters V0ppV_0^{pp}, V0nnV_0^{nn}, V0IVV_0^{IV} and V0ISV_0^{IS}, all empirical pairing gaps can be reproduced at all the deformations at the fixed ratio KK as shown in Figure 3 for K=0.4K=0.4 case. That is, the coexistence of the four kinds of pairs can be obtained at any ratio of IS and IV pn pairing gaps, when different types of pp (nn), and pn pairing interactions are applied in the calculations.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Empirical and mean pairing gaps for N=ZN=Z nuclei from 44^{44}Ti to 72^{72}Kr optimized by varying V0ppV_0^{pp}, V0nnV_0^{nn}, V0IVV_0^{IV} and V0ISV_0^{IS} as a function of the deformation parameter β2\beta_2 at K=0.4K=0.4. The black dashed line represents the deformation at the lowest point of energy.

Figure 4 shows the ground state energies with the content ratio of IS pairing set at 0.0, 0.6, and 1.0, as a function of the quadrupole deformation parameter β2\beta_2 for N=ZN=Z nuclei, calculated by HFB with pp and nn pairings, and by pnBCS model with all pairing interactions. The lowest total energies are reduced by about 1-3 MeV due to the including of pn pairing correlations. The total energies for 44^{44}Ti, 48^{48}Cr, 52^{52}Fe, 56^{56}Ni, and 60^{60}Zn are insensitive to the ratio KK of IV to IS pn pairing gaps. That is, the IS and IV superfluidity coexist in the ground states of these nuclei. On the other hand, in the heavier N=ZN=Z nuclei, 64^{64}Ge, 68^{68}Se, and 72^{72}Kr, the ground states show IV pn pairing dominance, i.e., K=0.0K=0.0 case corresponds to the lower energies. The estimated deformations at the lowest energies in Figure 4 are consistent with the results including pn pairing in Ref. [31], except for 44^{44}Ti and 64^{64}Ge. Our results demonstrate also that the pn pairing does not have any significant effect on the deformation of the ground state.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. The total energies of ground states as a function of the quadrupole deformation parameter β2\beta_{2} for N=ZN = Z nuclei from 44^{44}Ti to 72^{72}Kr calculated by the HFB with nn and pp pairings and pnBCS with full pairing interactions at the ratios K=0.0,0.6K = 0.0, 0.6, and 1.01.0. See the text for details.

Table II presents the four pairing strength values V0ppV_0^{pp}, V0nnV_0^{nn}, V0IVV_0^{IV} and V0ISV_0^{IS} for the deformations correspond to the lowest energy with the ratio K=0.6K=0.6. It is evident that the pairing strengths between pp and nn pairs are always comparable with less than 10% difference. In contrast, 20∼30 % larger strength differences between IV and IS pn interactions are induced by the deformation for nuclei A≥52A \ge52.

Nucleusβ2\beta_{2}V0ppV_{0}^{pp}V0nnV_{0}^{nn}V0IVV_{0}^{IV}V0ISV_{0}^{IS}
44^{44}Ti0.00-693.58-713.16-321.79-346.44
48^{48}Cr0.00-658.46-677.65-303.87-329.39
52^{52}Fe0.25-677.57-700.13-293.66-224.51
56^{56}Ni0.280-691.97-723.00-301.67-231.24
60^{60}Zn0.27-673.91-711.54-288.17-219.82
64^{64}Ge-0.21-695.63-761.82-309.35-367.22
68^{68}Se-0.24-725.48-785.34-307.67-355.72
72^{72}Kr-0.18-739.99-767.92-311.63-371.14

Table 2. Strength parameters of different types of pairing interactions for N=ZN = Z nuclei from 44^{44}Ti to 72^{72}Kr at the ratio K=0.6K = 0.6. The volume-type pairing interaction is adopted for the pp and nn pairings, while the surface-type one is adopted for the pn pairing.

From the former subsection we found that the correlation between the IS pairing strength and the deformation. We confirm this correlation for different ratios KK in the following. Similar to Figure 1(b), the IV and IS pairing strength ratios ff and gg at K=0.2,0.4,0.6,0.8K = 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8 are shown in Figure 5. It can be seen that for all nuclei, the same correlation between the IS pairing strength and the deformation exists regardless to the content of IS pn

Image not extracted

Figure 5. The same as Figure 1(b), but for N=ZN = Z nuclei from 44^{44}Ti to 72^{72}Kr at K=0.2,0.4,0.6,0.8K = 0.2, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8. At each deformation, the pairing strengths are adjusted to reproduce all experimental pairing gaps.

pairing, i.e., the ff and gg values are almost degenerate for 4 different KK values. The curves show that the ratio gg is relatively flat, whereas the ratio ff exhibits a peak at β2=−0.1\beta_{2} = -0.1 for the light N=ZN = Z nuclei 44^{44}Ti ∼\sim 60^{60}Zr, while the peaks show variations in the range of −0.2<β2<0.0-0.2 < \beta_{2} < 0.0 for heavier N=ZN = Z nuclei 64^{64}Ge ∼\sim 72^{72}Kr. The value of ff has maximum value about 1.2 for β2∼−0.2\beta_{2} \sim-0.2, whereas ff is reduced to 0.75–0.85 for prolate β2∼0.2\beta_{2} \sim0.2. This implies that for oblate deformation, a stronger pairing strength is required to obtain the empirical pn pairing gap, while for prolate deformation a comparatively weaker pairing strength is enough.

In order to comprehend the correlation between deformation and IS spin-triplet pairing, we study the contribution of each orbit to the pn pairing matrix element in Eq. (6),

Im⁡(Δαpn‾)=∑β>0∬[Im⁡(uβ1pvβ1n∗+uβ2pvβ2n∗)vpn(T=0)×(ϕα12p(r⊥,z)ϕα12n(r⊥,z)−ϕα−12p(r⊥,z)ϕα−12n(r⊥,z))×(ϕβ12p(r⊥,z)ϕβ12n(r⊥,z)−ϕβ−12p(r⊥,z)ϕβ−12n(r⊥,z))×2πr⊥ dr⊥ dz].(13)\begin{aligned} \operatorname{Im}(\Delta_{\alpha\overline{p n}}) &= \sum_{\beta>0} \iint\left[\operatorname{Im}\left(u_{\beta1p}v_{\beta1n}^{*}+u_{\beta2p}v_{\beta2n}^{*}\right)v_{pn}(T=0)\right.\\ &\quad\times\left(\phi_{\alpha\frac{1}{2}p}(r_{\perp},z)\phi_{\alpha\frac{1}{2}n}(r_{\perp},z)-\phi_{\alpha-\frac{1}{2}p}(r_{\perp},z)\phi_{\alpha-\frac{1}{2}n}(r_{\perp},z)\right)\\ &\quad\times\left(\phi_{\beta\frac{1}{2}p}(r_{\perp},z)\phi_{\beta\frac{1}{2}n}(r_{\perp},z)-\phi_{\beta-\frac{1}{2}p}(r_{\perp},z)\phi_{\beta-\frac{1}{2}n}(r_{\perp},z)\right)\\ &\quad\left.\times2\pi r_{\perp}\,\mathrm{d}r_{\perp}\,\mathrm{d}z\right]. \tag*{(13)} \end{aligned}

It can be seen that the IS pairing contribution to the matrix element is related to the difference between the spin-up and spin-down components of the single-particle wave function. When the single-particle state is dominated by the spin up or down components, this state has a larger contribution. Therefore, we define the quantity PαP_{\alpha} to estimate the contribution of a single particle state α\alpha to the pairing matrix element:

Pα=∣2π∫(ϕα,12pϕα,12n−ϕα,−12pϕα,−12n)r dr dz∣(14)P_{\alpha}=\left|2\pi\int\left(\phi_{\alpha,\frac{1}{2}}^{p}\phi_{\alpha,\frac{1}{2}}^{n}-\phi_{\alpha,-\frac{1}{2}}^{p}\phi_{\alpha,-\frac{1}{2}}^{n}\right)r\,dr\,dz\right| \tag*{(14)}

If a single-particle state α\alpha is dominated by spin-up (or -down) component, PαP_{\alpha} approaches 1, it has a substantial contribution to IS pairing matrix element. On contrast, when the state α\alpha has similar spin up and down components, PαP_{\alpha} approaches 0, and consequently gives small contribution to IS pairing matrix element.

To elucidate the shape of individual single-particle state evolving with the deformation of nuclei, we introduce the deformation index β2α\beta_{2}^{\alpha} for each single-particle state, defined as:

β2α=π5⟨Φα,n∣2z2−r⊥2∣Φα,n⟩⟨Φα,n∣z2+r⊥2∣Φα,n⟩(15)\beta_{2}^{\alpha}=\sqrt{\frac{\pi}{5}}\frac{\langle\Phi_{\alpha,n}|2z^{2}-r_{\perp}^{2}|\Phi_{\alpha,n}\rangle}{\langle\Phi_{\alpha,n}|z^{2}+r_{\perp}^{2}|\Phi_{\alpha,n}\rangle} \tag*{(15)}

Taking 64Ge^{64}\mathrm{Ge} as an example, we focus on 21 single particle states within the 1-2 major shells below and above the Fermi surface, which make a major contribution to the gap equations. Figure 6 presents a Nilsson-type diagram of the 21 states, depicting the deformation-dependent evolution of individual energy levels. Since proton and neutron wave functions exhibit almost identical behaviors in the single-particle diagram in N=ZN=Z nucleus, we present only the single-particle energies of neutrons. PαP_{\alpha} and β2α\beta_{2}^{\alpha} of the 21 states as a function of the deformation parameters β2\beta_{2} are illustrated in Figure 7. Among

Image not extracted

Figure 6. The neutron single particle energy of 64Ge^{64}\mathrm{Ge} as a function of deformation parameter β2\beta_{2}. Single-particle states are shown in blue, black, and red colors correspond to single particle states with larger, medium, and smaller Ω\Omega values coming from the same energy levels at the spherical limit.

Image not extracted

Figure 7. PαP_{\alpha} values and the single-particle deformation index β2α\beta_{2}^{\alpha} in 64Ge^{64}\mathrm{Ge} as a function of the nuclear deformation β2\beta_{2}. The PαP_{\alpha} values are shown in panels (a), (b), and (c), while the β2α\beta_{2}^{\alpha} values are shown in panels (d), (e), and (f), respectively. The labels and colors of single particle states are the same as in Figure 6. See the text for details.

the 21 states in Figure 7 (a), (Figure 7b), and (Figure 7c), 17 states show very small PαP_{\alpha} values in the region −0.3<β2<0.0-0.3 < \beta_{2} < 0.0. As a result, a stronger IS pairing strength is required to fit the empirical pairing gap in the oblate deformation region. For prolate deformation, as the PαP_{\alpha} values of most states are going up with the increasing of the deformation, smaller IS pairing strengths will be enough to produce the pn pairing gap. For larger prolate or oblate deformation with ∣β2∣>0.5|\beta_{2}| > 0.5, the deformed states are well represented by the Nilsson quantum numbers, where the spin-zz component becomes a good quantum number. In this case, as a natural consequence, a much smaller ff is enough to reproduce the empirical pn pairing gap as illustrated in Figure 1(b) and Figure 5.

Figure 8 shows the normal density, and the abnormal density distributions of IV and IS pn pairing fields of 64Ge^{64}\mathrm{Ge}. It is evident that the shape of abnormal IV pn pairing density is similar to that of normal density since all wave functions contribute to the abnormal IV spin-singlet density in the same way as the normal density except the uu and vv factors. In contrast, the IS pn pairing field exhibits oblate shape regardless of the nuclear deformation. We have checked the IS pn pairing fields of the other seven nuclei, and found that they all exhibit similar oblate shape regardless of the deformation of normal density.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. The normal density (left) and the abnormal density distributions of IV (middle) and IS (right) pn pairings in 64Ge^{64}\mathrm{Ge} for the IS and IV mixing ratio K=0.2K = 0.2 and 0.80.8, respectively. The deformation parameter is taken to be β2=−0.2\beta_2 = -0.2, 0.00.0, and 0.20.2, for panels (a), (b), and (c), respectively.

To understand this unexpected oblate dominance in the IS abnormal density, we study the deformation dependence of the index β2α\beta_{2}^{\alpha} in Eq. (15). As illustrated in Figure 7 (d), (Figure 7e), and (Figure 7f), in the case of oblate deformations, the β2α\beta_{2}^{\alpha} of 15 states are negative among 21 states. As a natural consequence, the dominant contributions to the isoscalar pairing originate from the states with negative shape index, and the abnormal IS density becomes oblate. In the case of prolate deformation, 8 states retain still negative shape index β2α\beta_2^\alpha despite to the fact that the nucleus exhibits a prolate deformation as a whole. Furthermore, the PαP_\alpha for the states with positive shape index β2α\beta_2^\alpha remain smaller than those with negative values. As a net, the states with negative index β2α\beta_2^\alpha contribute more that those with positive index and make the IS abnormal density to be weakly oblate. The same feature is also observed in the spherical case.

Summary

We studied the competition between IS and IV pairing condensation in eight N=ZN = Z even-even nuclei from 44Ti^{44}\mathrm{Ti} to 72Kr^{72}\mathrm{Kr} by using an axially symmetric deformed HF+ pn-BCS model. We adopted a Skyrme EDF SGII with the contact pairing interactions whose strengths adjusted to reproduce the empirical pairing gaps. The coexistence ratio of IV to IS pairing condensations is changed by the pn pairing strengths to check possible co-existence and also the dominant phase of superfluidity. Among the eight N=ZN=Z nuclei, we found that the ground states of 64Ge^{64}\mathrm{Ge}, 68Se^{68}\mathrm{Se}, and 72Kr^{72}\mathrm{Kr} show the dominance of IV superfluidity. On the other hand, other five nuclei 44Ti^{44}\mathrm{Ti}, 48Cr^{48}\mathrm{Cr}, 52Fe^{52}\mathrm{Fe}, 56Ni^{56}\mathrm{Ni} and 60Zn^{60}\mathrm{Zn} exhibit the coexistence of IV spin-singlet and IS spin-triplet pairing condensations. We do not find any nucleus which shows dominant IS condensation phase in this mass region A=44∼72A = 44 \sim72.

We pointed out the correlation between the IS pn pairing strength and the nuclear deformation; for oblate deformation with −0.3<β2<0.0-0.3 < \beta_2 < 0.0, a stronger IS pn pairing strength is needed to reproduce the empirical pairing gaps. In contrast, for prolate deformation, a weaker IS pn pairing strength is enough to obtain the empirical gap. This feature can be understood looking at the spin structure of the deformed single-particle states, namely, for oblate deformation with −0.3<β2<0.0-0.3 < \beta_2 < 0.0, the spin-up and spin-down components of most of the active single-particle states are mixed up with competitive amplitudes for the IS gap equation and cancel each other largely in the IS pairing matrix element. In contrast, for prolate deformation, the active states are dominated by either spin up or spin down components and no cancelation occurs in the gap equation. We found also that the contributions to IS abnormal density are dominated by the oblate-type single-particle states regardless to the deformation of ground state density, i.e., the IS abnormal density shows always oblate deformation no matte how the deformation of normal density is prolate, spherical or prolate.

References

  1. [1]S. Frauendorf and A. O. Macchiavelli, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 78, 24 (2014).
  2. [2]H. Sagawa, C. L. Bai, G. Colo, Phys. Scr. 91, 083011 (2016).
  3. [3]W. Satula, D. J. Dean, J. Gary, S. Mizutori, and W. Nazarewicz, Phys. Lett. B 407, 103 (1997).
  4. [4]I. Bentley and S. Frauendorf, Phys. Rev. C 88, 014322 (2013).
  5. [5]I. Bentley, K. Neergard, and S. Frauendorf, Phys. Rev. C 89,034302 (2014).
  6. [6]N. Sandulescu, D. Negrea, J. Dukelsky, and C. W. Johnson, Phys. Rev. C 85, 061303(R) (2012).
  7. [7]N. Sandulescu, D. Negrea, and C. W. Johnson, Phys. Rev. C 86,041302(R) (2012).
  8. [8]D. Negrea and N. Sandulescu, Phys. Rev. C 90, 024322 (2014).
  9. [9]M. Sambataro, N. Sandulescu, and C. W. Johnson, Phys. Lett. B 740, 137 (2015).
  10. [10]Y. P. Wang, Y. K. Wang, F. F. Xu, P. W. Zhao, and J. Meng, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 232501 (2024).
  11. [11]C. Qi, J. Blomqvist, T. Back, B. Cederwall, A. Johnson, R. J. Liotta, and R. Wyss, Phys. Rev. C 84, 021301(R) (2011).
  12. [12]C. Bai, H. Sagawa, M. Sasano, T. Uesaka, K. Hagino, H. Zhang, X. Zhang, and F. Xu, Phys. Lett. B 719, 116(2013).
  13. [13]Y. Fujita, H. Fujita, T. Adachi, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 122502(2014).
  14. [14]C. L. Bai, H. Sagawa, G. Colo, Y. Fujita, H.Q. Zhang, X.Z. Zhang, and F.R. Xu, Phys. Rev. C 90, 054333(2014).
  15. [15]P. Van Isacker, D. D. Warner, and A. Frank, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94,162502 (2005).
  16. [16]K. Yoshida, Phys. Rev. C 90, 031303(R) (2014).
  17. [17]J. Engel, M. Bender, J. Dobaczewski, W. Nazarewicz, and R. Surman, Phys. Rev. C 60, 014302 (1999).
  18. [18]T. Niksic, T. Martinet, D. Vretenar, N. Paar, P. Ring, Phys. Rev. C 71, 014308(2005).
  19. [19]F. T. Avignone, S. R. Elliott, and J. Engel, Rev. Mod. Phys. 80, 481 (2008).
  20. [20]J. A. Halbleib and R. A. Sorensen, Nucl. Phys. A 98, 542 (1967).
  21. [21]B. Cederwall et al., Nature (London) 469, 68 (2011).
  22. [22]A. L. Goodman, Nucl. Phys. A 186, 475 (1972).
  23. [23]A. L. Goodman, Phys. Rev. C 58, R3051 (1998).
  24. [24]A. L. Goodman, Phys. Rev. C 60, 014311 (1999).
  25. [25]F. Simkovic, C. C. Moustakidis, L. Pacearescu, and A.Faessler, Phys. Rev. C 68, 054319 (2003).
  26. [26]G. F. Bertsch and Y. Luo, Phys. Rev. C 81, 064320 (2010).
  27. [27]A. Gezerlis, G. F. Bertsch, and Y. L. Luo, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106,252502 (2011).
  28. [28]B. Bulthuis and A. Gezerlis, Phys. Rev. C 93, 014312 (2016).
  29. [29]E. Ha, M.-K. Cheoun, F. Simkovic, Phys. Rev. C 92, 044315(2015).
  30. [30]E. Ha, M.-K. Cheoun, and H. Sagawa, Phys. Rev. C 97, 024320 (2018).
  31. [31]E. Ha, M.-K. Cheoun, H. Sagawa, and W. Y. So, Phys. Rev. C 97, 064322 (2018).
  32. [32]G.Palkanoglou, M. Stuck, and A. Gezerlis, Phys. Rev. Lett. 134, 032501 (2025).
  33. [33]A. Goswami and L. S. Kisslinger, Phys. Rev. 140, B26 (1965).
  34. [34]Z. Wu, S. A. Changizi, and Chong Qi, Phys. Rev. C 93, 034334(2016).
  35. [35]G. L. Yang, B. Qi, X. D. Wang, C. Qi, Phys. Rev. C 106, 024325(2022).
  36. [36]M. V. Stoitsov, J. Dobaczewski, W. Nazarewicz, and P. Ring, Comput. Phys. Commun. 167, 43(2005).
  37. [37]N. Van Giai and H. Sagawa, Phys. Lett. B 106, 379 (1981).
  38. [38]D. Negrea, N. Sandulescu, and D. Gambacurta, Phys. Rev. C105,034325(2022)
  39. [39]A. O. Macchiavelli et al., Phys. Rev. C 61, 041303(R) (2000).

Paper details

vlnc:W_qsm3kguv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents