betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Methods on compositeness and related aspects

Abstract

In many physical applications, bound states and/or resonances are observed, which raises the question whether these states are elementary or composite. Here we elaborate on several methods for calculating the compositeness XX of bound states and resonances in Quantum Mechanics, and in Quantum Field Theory by introducing particle number operators. For resonances XX is typically complex and we discuss how to get meaningful results by using certain phase transformations in the SS matrix.

Introduction

We start by reviewing a few basic aspects of the problem of compositeness in hadron physics [1, 2, 3]. The Hamiltonian HH is first split in the free H0H_0 and interaction VV parts,

H=H0+V.(1)H = H_0 + V . \tag*{(1)}

Both HH and H0H_0 share the same spectrum. For H0H_0, one has the bare eigenstates,

H0∣φα⟩=Eα∣φα⟩,continuum spectrum,H_0|\varphi_\alpha\rangle= E_\alpha|\varphi_\alpha\rangle,\quad\text{continuum spectrum},
H0∣ϕn⟩=EBn∣ϕn⟩,discrete spectrum,(2)H_0|\phi_n\rangle= E_{B_n}|\phi_n\rangle,\quad\text{discrete spectrum}, \tag*{(2)}

where ∣ϕn⟩|\phi_n\rangle is a bare “elementary” state, and ∣φα⟩|\varphi_\alpha\rangle is made up by the direct product of free particles (Greek letters are used as subscripts to refer to quantum numbers, among which one has the momentum, spin, etc). The physical spectrum is comprised by the eigenstates of HH,

H∣ψα±⟩=Eα∣ψα±⟩,continuum spectrum,H|\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle= E_\alpha|\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle,\quad\text{continuum spectrum},
H∣ψBn⟩=EBn∣ψBn⟩,discrete spectrum.(3)H|\psi_{B_n}\rangle= E_{B_n}|\psi_{B_n}\rangle,\quad\text{discrete spectrum}. \tag*{(3)}

Here, the ∣ψBn⟩|\psi_{B_n}\rangle are the bound states of the theory and the ∣ψα±⟩|\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle are the scattering in/out states, respectively. Within this framework the definitions of compositeness XX and elementariness ZZ of a bound state ∣ψB⟩|\psi_B\rangle are as follows [1]. Let us consider the linear decomposition of this state in the basis of eigenstates of H0H_0,

∣ψB⟩=∑n⟨ϕn∣ψB⟩∣ϕn⟩+∫dα⟨φα∣ψB⟩∣φα⟩.(4)|\psi_B\rangle= \sum_n \langle\phi_n|\psi_B\rangle|\phi_n\rangle+ \int d\alpha\langle\varphi_\alpha|\psi_B\rangle|\varphi_\alpha\rangle. \tag*{(4)}

Then, the Parseval identity implies

⟨ψB∣ψB⟩=1=∑n∣⟨ϕn∣ψB⟩∣2⏟≡Z+∫dα∣⟨φα∣ψB⟩∣2⏟≡X,(5)\langle\psi_B|\psi_B\rangle= 1 = \sum_n \underbrace{|\langle\phi_n|\psi_B\rangle|^2}_{\equiv Z} + \int d\alpha\underbrace{|\langle\varphi_\alpha|\psi_B\rangle|^2}_{\equiv X}, \tag*{(5)}
1=Z+X.1 = Z + X .

A new interpretation based on the use of the number operators in the interaction or Dirac picture was introduced in Ref. [4], where more details can be found. The basic idea is to take two free particles of types AA and BB (H0∣ABγ⟩=Eγ∣ABγ⟩H_0|AB_\gamma\rangle= E_\gamma|AB_\gamma\rangle). The standard creation and annihilation operators of the two free particles are aα†a_\alpha^\dagger, aαa_\alpha, bβ†b_\beta^\dagger, bβb_\beta, respectively. In terms of them, the number operator NDN_D for the total number of these free particles is

ND=∫dαaα†aα+∫dβbβ†bβ=NDA+NDB,(6)N_D = \int d\alpha a_\alpha^\dagger a_\alpha+ \int d\beta b_\beta^\dagger b_\beta= N_D^A + N_D^B, \tag*{(6)}

with NDAN_D^A and NDBN_D^B the number operators for each species of particles separately. Here, the subscript DD refers to the Dirac picture used. In nonrelativistic Quantum Field Theory (QFT) one can express these operators using the fields ψA\psi_A and ψB\psi_B as [5]

ND=∫d3x[ψA†(x)ψA(x)+ψB†(x)ψB(x)],x=(t,x),(7)N_D = \int d^3x \left[\psi_A^\dagger(x)\psi_A(x) + \psi_B^\dagger(x)\psi_B(x)\right],\quad x=(t,\mathbf{x}), \tag*{(7)}

Let us notice that in the interaction picture [H0,ND]=0[H_0,N_D]=0, so that NDN_D is actually time independent, ND(t)=ND(0)N_D(t)=N_D(0). In terms of NDN_D one can give an alternative definition for the compositeness XX as [4]

X=12⟨ψB∣ND∣ψB⟩.(8)X = \frac{1}{2}\langle\psi_B|N_D|\psi_B\rangle. \tag*{(8)}

The factor 1/2 is introduced because we are considering that only two-particle states made out of AA and BB may contribute to ∣ψB⟩|\psi_B\rangle. Let us now probe the equivalence between the new definition of XX and the previous one in Eq. (5). From the linear decompositions of the bound-state ∣ψB⟩|\psi_B\rangle in states ∣ABγ⟩|AB_\gamma\rangle and ∣ϕn⟩|\phi_n\rangle (eigenstates of H0H_0) we have

∣ψB⟩=∫dγCγ∣ABγ⟩+∑nCn∣ϕn⟩,(9)|\psi_B\rangle= \int d\gamma C_\gamma|AB_\gamma\rangle+ \sum_n C_n|\phi_n\rangle, \tag*{(9)}
X=12⟨ψB∣NDA+NDB∣ψB⟩=∫dγ∣Cγ∣2.X = \frac{1}{2}\langle\psi_B|N_D^A+N_D^B|\psi_B\rangle= \int d\gamma|C_\gamma|^2 .

This definition is specially suitable for Effective Field Theories (EFTs), like e.g. ChPT and hadron physics in general. The point is that in a low-energy EFT written in terms of the (pseudo-)Goldstone bosons as the only degrees of freedom, it is valuable to define XX as in Eq. (8), since it does not require to have explicit bare “elementary” states (fields) in the theoretical set up.

This new definition is also the most adequate for the treatment in QFT since, as deduced in [4], it can be rewritten as

X=12lim⁡T→+∞1T∫d4x⟨φB∣P[e−i∫−∞+∞dt′VD(t′)∑iψAi†(x)ψAi(x)]∣φB⟩,(10)X = \frac{1}{2}\lim_{T\to+\infty}\frac{1}{T}\int d^4x\langle\varphi_B|P\left[e^{-i\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}dt'V_D(t')}\sum_i\psi_{A_i}^\dagger(x)\psi_{A_i}(x)\right]|\varphi_B\rangle, \tag*{(10)}

by expressing the number operators in terms of the nonrelativistic fields ψAi\psi_{A_i}. Compared with Eq. (9) here A≡A1A\equiv A_1 and B≡A2B\equiv A_2. Making use of the LSZ formalism one can directly express XX in terms of SS-matrix elements,

X=12lim⁡E→EB(E−EB)2gα(kB)2lim⁡T→+∞1T∫d4x⟨φα∣P[e−i∫−∞+∞dt′VD(t′)∑iψAi†(x)ψAi(x)]∣φα⟩,(11)X = \frac{1}{2}\lim_{E\to E_B}\frac{(E-E_B)^2}{g_\alpha(k_B)^2}\lim_{T\to+\infty}\frac{1}{T}\int d^4x\langle\varphi_\alpha|P\left[e^{-i\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}dt'V_D(t')}\sum_i\psi_{A_i}^\dagger(x)\psi_{A_i}(x)\right]|\varphi_\alpha\rangle, \tag*{(11)}

with gα(kB)g_\alpha(k_B) the coupling of the bound state to the continuum in/out states. Of course, the previous equation clearly shows that XX is an observable in nonrelativistic QFT since it is expressed in terms of SS-matrix elements in the presence of a local source term, made up by the number-operator density.

Explicit formulas

The Feynman diagrams appropriate for the calculation of Eq. (10) are depicted in Figure 1, where the insertion of the number-operator density in the propagator of every particle is represented by the double dots. The resulting expression for XX in terms of the off-shell coupling to AA and BB is

Feynman diagrams for the calculation of $X$ for a bound state represented by the double lines

Figure 1. Feynman diagrams for the calculation of XX for a bound state represented by the double lines. The two filled dots correspond to insertions of a number-operator density.

XℓS=∫d3k(2π)3gℓS2(k)(k2/2μ−EB)2,X=∑ℓSXℓS,(12)\begin{aligned} X_{\ell S} &= \int\frac{d^3 k}{(2\pi)^3}\frac{g_{\ell S}^2(k)}{(k^2/2\mu-E_B)^2},\\ X &= \sum_{\ell S}X_{\ell S}, \tag*{(12)} \end{aligned}

with μ\mu the reduced mass. The subscripts ℓ\ell and SS in Eq. (12) refer to particular two-particle partial wave amplitude (PWAs) coupled to the bound state (e.g. 3S1{}^{3}S_{1} and 3D1{}^{3}D_{1} for the deuteron in nucleon-nucleon (NNNN) scattering). If in the integral of Eq. (12) we assume a shallow bound state then the coupling gℓS(k)g_{\ell S}(k) can be factorized out with k=0k=0, or with its on-shell value (which is valid at this level of accuracy). Thus, XℓSX_{\ell S} becomes

XℓS=gℓS2ddE∫d3k(2π)31k2/2μ−EB=gℓS2iμ22πkB,(13)X_{\ell S}=g_{\ell S}^{2}\frac{d}{dE}\int\frac{d^{3}k}{(2\pi)^{3}}\frac{1}{k^{2}/2\mu-E_{B}}=g_{\ell S}^{2}\frac{i\mu^{2}}{2\pi k_{B}}, \tag*{(13)}

with the binding momentum kB=2μEBk_{B}=\sqrt{2\mu E_{B}}. This is one of the results of [3]. The equation for gℓS(k)g_{\ell S}(k) is obtained from the Lippmann-Schwinger equation T=V+VGTT=V+VGT in the limit E→EBE\to E_{B} and by taking the residue at the pole, so that

gℓS(k)=12π2∫0∞k′2dk′VℓS(k,k′)1k′2/2μ−EBgℓS(k′).(14)g_{\ell S}(k)=\frac{1}{2\pi^{2}}\int_{0}^{\infty}k'^{2}dk'V_{\ell S}(k,k')\frac{1}{k'^{2}/2\mu-E_{B}}g_{\ell S}(k'). \tag*{(14)}

For the case of energy-independent potentials, which corresponds to pure potential scattering, it was shown in [4] that the compositeness is exactly equal to 1 for any bound state, that is,

∑α=1nXα=1,(15)\sum_{\alpha=1}^{n}X_{\alpha}=1, \tag*{(15)}

with nn the number of coupled PWAs. We refer to [4] for the interesting detailed analysis, which is skipped here to avoid becoming too technical. This result has interesting implications like e.g. in the case of the deuteron, studied within ChPT up to N4^{4}LO in terms of energy-independent potentials with an estimated error in the reproduction of its properties of around a 4% [6, 7]. Therefore, one would conclude from Eq. (15) that for this bound state X=0.96−1.0X=0.96-1.0.

We now discuss within similar terms the case of resonances following the basic lines of scattering theory and the use of number operators [4]. A resonance stems from the analytic continuation in energy of in states with energy E+iϵE+i\epsilon, and out states with energy E−iϵE-i\epsilon (ϵ→0+\epsilon\to0^{+}). In this way, when evaluating an SS-matrix element ⟨ψβ−∣ψα+⟩\langle\psi_{\beta}^{-}|\psi_{\alpha}^{+}\rangle both ket and bra involve an energy of E+iϵE+i\epsilon. In performing the analytical continuation towards the pole position of the resonance in the complex EE-plane one has to cross the real axis along E>0E>0, borrowing in the second Riemann sheet (RS) where the resonance pole lies with ReE<0\mathop{\mathrm{Re}}E<0. For the calculation of XX for a resonance in QFT we can then proceed similarly as for the case of a bound state by isolating the double pole residue of SS-matrix elements with the external source ∑iψAi(x)ψAi(x)\sum_i\psi_{A_i}(x)\psi_{A_i}(x). The corresponding formula is

X=12lim⁡E→ER(E−ER)2gα(kR)2lim⁡T→+∞1T∫d4x⟨φα∣P[e−i∫−∞+∞dt′VD(t′)∑iψAi†(x)ψAi(x)]∣φα⟩,(16)X=\frac{1}{2}\lim_{E\to E_R}\frac{(E-E_R)^2}{g_{\alpha}(k_R)^2}\lim_{T\to+\infty}\frac{1}{T}\int d^4x\langle\varphi_{\alpha}|P\left[e^{-i\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty}dt'V_D(t')}\sum_i\psi_{A_i}^{\dagger}(x)\psi_{A_i}(x)\right]|\varphi_{\alpha}\rangle, \tag*{(16)}

with ERE_R and kRk_R the resonance pole position in energy and momentum, respectively. Of course, one can also write down a formula similar to Eq. (12) for a bound state, corresponding to analogous Feynman diagrams as those in Figure 1 with the replacement ∣ψB⟩→∣ψR⟩\lvert\psi_B\rangle\to\lvert\psi_R\rangle. The result is

XℓS=∫d3k(2π)3gℓS2(k)(k2/2μ−ER2)2+iμ2πkn[∂∂kkgℓS2(k)]∣k=kn,X=∑ℓSXℓS.(17)X_{\ell S}=\int\frac{d^3k}{(2\pi)^3}\frac{g_{\ell S}^2(k)}{(k^2/2\mu-E_R^2)^2}+\left.\frac{i\mu^2}{\pi k_n}\left[\frac{\partial}{\partial k}kg_{\ell S}^2(k)\right]\right|_{k=k_n}, \qquad X=\sum_{\ell S}X_{\ell S}. \tag*{(17)}

The extrapolation of the integral to the second RS is responsible for the additional last term as compared with Eq. (12).

In pure potential scattering it was proved in Ref. [4] that X=∑α=1nXα=1X=\sum_{\alpha=1}^{n}X_{\alpha}=1, see also [8]. For instance, this would imply that XX for the virtual or antibound state in the 1S0{}^{1}S_{0} NNNN scattering should be very close to 1, since NNNN scattering data can be described very precisely with energy-independent potentials derived from ChPT [6, 7]. If for the deuteron, with a binding momentum of around 45 MeV, the possible uncertainty was bounded to a 4%, for the virtual state in the 1S0{}^{1}S_{0} PWA one would expect it to be smaller because ∣kR∣≈10 MeV≪45 MeV\lvert k_R\rvert\approx10\ \mathrm{MeV}\ll45\ \mathrm{MeV}.

Compositeness in the Heisenberg picture

Let us denote by NH(t)N_H(t) the number operator in the Heisenberg picture. The scattering states ∣ψα±⟩\lvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle are eigenstates of HH that behave as free states when acted with operators at τ∓∞\tau\mp\infty, respectively [9]. Then,

exp⁡(−iHτ)NH(τ)∣ψα±⟩→exp⁡(−iH0τ)ND(τ)∣φα⟩,(18)\exp(-iH\tau)N_H(\tau)\lvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle\to\exp(-iH_0\tau)N_D(\tau)\lvert\varphi_\alpha\rangle, \tag*{(18)}

for τ→∓∞\tau\to\mp\infty. Taking into account in the previous equation that ∣ψα±⟩=UD(0,τ)∣φα⟩=exp⁡(iHτ)exp⁡(−iH0τ)∣φα⟩\lvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle=U_D(0,\tau)\lvert\varphi_\alpha\rangle=\exp(iH\tau)\exp(-iH_0\tau)\lvert\varphi_\alpha\rangle, with τ→∓∞\tau\to\mp\infty, we have the equality at the operational level

lim⁡τ→±∞exp⁡(−iHτ)NH(τ)exp⁡(iHτ)=ND(τ).(19)\lim_{\tau\to\pm\infty}\exp(-iH\tau)N_H(\tau)\exp(iH\tau)=N_D(\tau). \tag*{(19)}

Since H∣ψα±⟩=Eα∣ψα±⟩H\lvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle=E_\alpha\lvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle we also have that

⟨ψα±∣ND(τ)∣ψα±⟩=⟨ψα±∣NH(τ)∣ψα±⟩,τ→±∞.(20)\langle\psi_\alpha^\pm\lvert N_D(\tau)\rvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle=\langle\psi_\alpha^\pm\lvert N_H(\tau)\rvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle,\qquad\tau\to\pm\infty. \tag*{(20)}

Furthermore, as dNH(t)/dt=i[H,NH(t)]dN_H(t)/dt=i[H,N_H(t)] it follows that

ddt⟨ψα±∣NH(t)∣ψα±⟩=0,(21)\frac{d}{dt}\langle\psi_\alpha^\pm\lvert N_H(t)\rvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle=0, \tag*{(21)}

so that both expectation values in Eq. (20) are time independent, and we can simply write that

⟨ψα±∣ND(t)∣ψα±⟩=⟨ψα±∣NH(t′)∣ψα±⟩,(22)\langle\psi_\alpha^\pm\lvert N_D(t)\rvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle=\langle\psi_\alpha^\pm\lvert N_H(t')\rvert\psi_\alpha^\pm\rangle, \tag*{(22)}

for arbitrary tt and t′t'. The equality between the expectation values of NDN_D and NHN_H is also clear by taking into account the QFT expressions above for XX in Eqs. (11) and (16), since they correspond to the SS-matrix elements lim⁡T→∞1T⟨ψα−∣∫−T/2T/2dt NH(t)∣ψα+⟩\lim_{T\to\infty}\frac{1}{T}\langle\psi_\alpha^-\lvert\int_{-T/2}^{T/2}dt\,N_H(t)\rvert\psi_\alpha^+\rangle when calculated in the interaction picture. Afterwards, the residue of the double pole is isolated.

Now, the idea would be to use an appropriate operator normalized in lattice QCD to mimic the number operators. For instance, if the operator in the Heisenberg picture is O(t)O(t) and we consider a bound state made out of nucleons, like the deuteron, we could take the normalization constant to be ⟨N∣O(t)∣N⟩\langle N\lvert O(t)\rvert N\rangle, which indeed is time independent (to conclude this one can follow an analogous reasoning as used for Eq. (21)). Of course, extra discussions about the final adequate choice for the operator O(t)O(t) in lattice QCD are still required, and this should be the object of further work.

Sum rule

From a generic formula for two-particle PWAs one can deduce a sum rule for compositeness and elementariness. We follow here Ref. [10], which employs relativistic kinematics. Two-body unitarity along the right-hand cut, and above the thresholds of channels ii and jj, can be expressed as [11]

ℑT−1∣ij=δijρi,(23)\left.\Im T^{-1}\right|_{ij}=\delta_{ij}\rho_i , \tag*{(23)}

where ρi\rho_i is the phase-space factor ρi=pi/8πs\rho_i=p_i/8\pi\sqrt{s}, with pip_i the center of mass (CM) momentum for the channel ii and ss the CM total energy squared (the usual Mandelstam variable). From this equation one can resum the right-hand or unitarity cut and obtain a general expression for a PWA in coupled channels. In matrix notation it reads [11, 12]

T(s)=[K(s)−1+G(s)]−1,(24)T(s)=\left[\mathcal{K}(s)^{-1}+G(s)\right]^{-1}, \tag*{(24)}

where K\mathcal{K} is an interacting kernel and the unitary loop function Gi(s)G_i(s) is given by

Gi(s)=116π2[ai(Λ)+log⁡mi22Λ2−x+log⁡x+−1x+−x−log⁡x−−1x−],(25)G_i(s)=\frac{1}{16\pi^2}\left[a_i(\Lambda)+\log\frac{m_{i2}^2}{\Lambda^2}-x_+\log\frac{x_+-1}{x_+}-x_-\log\frac{x_--1}{x_-}\right], \tag*{(25)}
x±=s+mi22−mi122s±12s(s+mi22−mi12)2−4s(mi22−i0+),x_\pm=\frac{s+m_{i2}^2-m_{i1}^2}{2s}\pm\frac{1}{2s}\sqrt{\left(s+m_{i2}^2-m_{i1}^2\right)^2-4s\left(m_{i2}^2-i0^+\right)} ,

where mi1m_{i1} and mi2m_{i2} are the masses of the two particles in the channel ii, and ai(Λ)a_i(\Lambda) is a subtraction constant (the combination ai(Λ)−log⁡Λ2a_i(\Lambda)-\log\Lambda^2 is Λ\Lambda independent). Taking the derivative of Eq. (24) with respect to ss, in the limit s→sRs\to s_R the residue of the double pole implies that

1=−∑igi2dGi(s)ds∣sB⏟Xi+gTG(sB)dK(s)ds∣sBG(sB)g⏟Z.(26)1=-\underbrace{\left.\sum_i g_i^2\frac{dG_i(s)}{ds}\right|_{s_B}}_{X_i} +\underbrace{\left.g^T G(s_B)\frac{dK(s)}{ds}\right|_{s_B}G(s_B)g}_{Z}. \tag*{(26)}

The expression for XiX_i does not depend on aia_i or Λ\Lambda, since they disappear in the derivative of Gi(s)G_i(s). It is the same expression as in Eq. (13) for shallow bound states, and also for separable potentials [13, 14].

Resonances

For the case of resonances one should consider the unitarity loop function in the 2nd RS for those channels in which the transit to this sheet is involved to find the pole position at sRs_R. We indicate this by GII(sR)G^{\mathrm{II}}(s_R). Then, Eq. (26) implies

Xi=−gi2dGiII(s)ds∣sR.(27)X_i=-g_i^2\left.\frac{dG_i^{\mathrm{II}}(s)}{ds}\right|_{s_R}. \tag*{(27)}

However, for resonances XiX_i is typically complex. We argue next that one should actually take its absolute value ∣Xi∣\lvert X_i\rvert. This based on certain phase transformations of the S-matrix in PWAs, driving to a phase redefinition of the couplings [10]. Let us first consider a narrow resonance Γ≪MR−mth\Gamma\ll M_R-m_{\mathrm{th}}, with Γ\Gamma, MRM_R the resonance mass and width, and mthm_{\mathrm{th}} the nearest threshold. Later on we generalize these results for wider resonances. The S matrix is split in a pole term plus S0(s)S_0(s), which is assumed to be smooth in a certain domain around the resonance pole. That is,

S(s)=Rs−sR+S0(s),(28)S(s)=\frac{R}{s-s_R}+S_0(s), \tag*{(28)}

with RR the residue matrix of the resonance pole at sRs_R. Then, we impose unitarity of the S matrix in PWAs,

S(s)S(s)†=I.(29)S(s)S(s)^\dagger=I . \tag*{(29)}

The solution of this equation with S(s)S(s) given by Eq. (28), with constant S0S_0 for ss near sRs_R, is

S(s)=O(I+iλAs−sR)OT(30)S(s)=O\left(I+\frac{i\lambda\mathcal{A}}{s-s_R}\right)O^{T} \tag*{(30)}
OO†=I.OO^\dagger=I.

Here A\mathcal{A} is a rank one symmetric projection operator and SR(s)S_R(s) is the pure resonant SS matrix. The disposition of operators in Eq. (30) clearly indicates the corrections to SRS_R due to initial- and final-state interactions from S0S_0.

The dressing to SRS_R by S0S_0 typically modifies the phases of the resonance couplings in SRS_R. This is because the moduli of the couplings gig_i to the different channels have physical meaning, since they provide the partial decay widths of a narrow resonance [16], Γi=∣gi∣2/(8πMR2)\Gamma_i=|g_i|^2/(8\pi M_R^2). Then, the SS-matrix phase transformation only change the phases of the resonance couplings

SO(s)=OS(s)OT(31)S_O(s)=OS(s)O^T \tag*{(31)}
O=diag⁡(eiϕ1,…,eiϕn),O=\operatorname{diag}(e^{i\phi_1},\ldots,e^{i\phi_n}),
gi2→gi2e2iϕi.g_i^2\to g_i^2e^{2i\phi_i}.

As an example of this mechanism let us consider ππ−KK‾\pi\pi-K\overline{K} scattering in J=0J=0 and I=0I=0 (II is the total isospin). As the author checked in the calculations for Ref. [15], the coupling to ππ\pi\pi of the f0(980)f_0(980) is a positive number times a phase-factor ii, which stems from the phase-shifts of ππ\pi\pi rescattering due to the f0(500)f_0(500) resonance at the rise of the f0(980)f_0(980). This is clearly seen from Figure 2.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Isoscalar scalar ππ\pi\pi phase shifts, JPC=0++J^{PC}=0^{++}. For the experimental references see [15].

Therefore, XiX_i, Eq. (27), only changes its phase under the phase transformations of Eq. (31), and they can be chosen so that it becomes a real positive number. Hence,

Xi→∣Xi∣≥0.(32)X_i\to|X_i|\ge0. \tag*{(32)}

Let us now generalize Eq. (32) for non-narrow resonances. The point is to require the validity of the Laurent series expansion around the resonance pole up to physical values of ss above threshold, so that the resonance couplings still directly impact physical energies. This implies that sth;n<ℜsR<sth;n+1s_{\mathrm{th};n}<\Re s_R<s_{\mathrm{th};n+1}, where sth;ns_{\mathrm{th};n} is the threshold of channel nn.

Effective range expansion

We assume now that a bound or resonance pole lies close enough to a relevant threshold so that the well-known effective range expansion (ERE) can be applied. We follow here the developments in Ref. [17]. Up to and including the scattering length aa and the effective range rr the SS-wave PWA can be written as

T(k)=1−1a+12rk2+G(k),G(k)=−ik.(33)T(k)=\frac{1}{-\frac{1}{a}+\frac{1}{2}rk^2+G(k)},\qquad G(k)=-ik. \tag*{(33)}

Then, if T(k)T(k) has a resonance pole at E=ER=MR−iΓ/2E = E_R = M_R - i\Gamma/2 (energy is measured from mthm_{\rm th}), aa and rr can be given in terms of the mass and width of the resonance as

a=−2ki∣kR∣2,kR=2μER=kr−iki,(34)a=-\frac{2k_i}{\lvert k_R\rvert^2},\qquad k_R=\sqrt{2\mu E_R}=k_r-ik_i, \tag*{(34)}
r=−1ki,so that ra>2.r=-\frac{1}{k_i},\qquad\text{so that }\frac{r}{a}>2.

By applying Eq. (27) we can express the compositeness as

X=−γk2dGds=−γk2dGdk=ikrki=itan⁡ϕ2,(35)X=-\gamma_k^2\frac{dG}{ds}=-\gamma_k^2\frac{dG}{dk}=i\frac{k_r}{k_i}=i\tan\frac{\phi}{2}, \tag*{(35)}

with γk2\gamma_k^2 the residue at the pole position in the complex kk-plane. The simplicity of the ERE up to including rr perfectly illustrates the condition on the mass of the resonance, discussed at the end of Sec. 5, because

∣X∣≤1 ↔ ϕ∈[0,π/2] ↔ MR≥0,(36)\lvert X\rvert\leq1\ \leftrightarrow\ \phi\in[0,\pi/2]\ \leftrightarrow\ M_R\geq0, \tag*{(36)}

with ∣X∣=1\lvert X\rvert=1 for MR=0M_R=0 and Γ>0\Gamma>0. Furthermore, since XX is purely imaginary in Eq. (35) if its real part is taken to end with a real compositeness, as advocated in Ref. [18], then from the ERE X=0X=0. Of course, this result is not meaningful in such generality. The expression for ∣X∣\lvert X\rvert can also be rewritten as ∣X∣=(2ra−1)−1\lvert X\rvert=\left(\frac{2r}{a}-1\right)^{-1}. In the subsequent we drop the sign of modulus on XX and directly consider by this symbol the compositeness calculated within the ERE.

CDD poles. Track of elementariness

While the ERE is a smooth expansion around k=0k=0 of the combination t(E)−1+ikt(E)^{-1}+ik, which has no right-hand cut, more structure can be accounted for by allowing poles in t(E)−1t(E)^{-1}. These are the so-called CDD poles [19]. In this way, a once-subtracted dispersion relation (DR) for t(E)−1t(E)^{-1} accounting for a pole in t(E)−1t(E)^{-1} at MZM_Z gives

t(E)=1λE−MZ+β−ik,(37)t(E)=\frac{1}{\frac{\lambda}{E-M_Z}+\beta-ik}, \tag*{(37)}

with λ\lambda the residue at the CDD pole and β\beta a subtraction constant. A consequence of this pole is that the ERE or a Flatté parameterization break down for ∣k∣≳2μ∣MZ∣\lvert k\rvert\gtrsim\sqrt{2\mu\lvert M_Z\rvert}. A near-threshold CDD pole contributes to aa and rr as

δa=MZλ,δr=−λmMZ2.(38)\delta a=\frac{M_Z}{\lambda},\qquad\delta r=-\frac{\lambda}{mM_Z^2}. \tag*{(38)}

Therefore, δa→0\delta a\to0 and δr→−∞\delta r\to-\infty (unless λ=0\lambda=0) for MZ→0M_Z\to0. As a result, a large negative value of rr is a hint for a nearby CDD pole and for elementariness. Indeed, if we calculate XX from the ERE formula X=(2ra−1)−1→0X=\left(\frac{2r}{a}-1\right)^{-1}\to0 for MZ→0M_Z\to0. Nonetheless, one should keep in mind that having a near CDD pole to a resonance pole is sufficient but not necessary for the resonance to be elementary. For instance, as analyzed in Ref. [20], the CDD pole associated to the ρ(770)\rho(770) resonance is located at s=Mρ/(1−gV2)s=M_\rho/(1-g_V^2) and tends to infinity because of the KSFR relation, which requires gV=1g_V=1. This is so despite the resonance ρ(770)\rho(770) is a clear example of a qqˉq\bar q resonance. From a hadronic point of view this is clearly signaled by studying the dependence of the pole position with the number of colors of QCD NcN_c [21, 22].

Determination of X by making use of the decays of the resonance

Here we outline the method introduced in Ref. [23] to combine the knowledge of the resonance pole position and the saturation of its width and branching ratios (when they are available), and/or of the compositeness XX. This method has the advantage that it is a coupled-channel study, while the one based in the ERE takes into account only one channel. If the channel 1 is the lighter channel and 2 is the one near the mass of the resonance, the main equations are X=X1+X2X = X_1 + X_2 and Γ=Γ1+Γ2\Gamma= \Gamma_1 + \Gamma_2, with

Γ1=2X1μk(MR)∣kR∣,Γ2=X2∣kR∣MR2πμ∫Mth+∞dW k(W)W2(MR−W)2+Γ2/4.(39)\Gamma_1 = \frac{2X_1}{\mu} k(M_R)|k_R|,\qquad\Gamma_2 = \frac{X_2|k_R|M_R^2}{\pi\mu} \int_{M_{\mathrm{th}}}^{+\infty} \frac{dW\,k(W)}{W^2(M_R-W)^2+\Gamma^2/4}. \tag*{(39)}

From these equations one can then constrain the couplings or, equivalently, the partial compositeness coefficients.

As a concluding remark, we stress that the different methods used in many instances to study the nature of resonances have provided when used simultaneously a consistent picture on the nature of these resonances. Several examples are discussed in Ref. [24]. This is interesting since each method has its own realm of applicability, and the fact that one can achieve compatible conclusions from all of them reinforces the global picture that emerges.

Acknowledgements

This work has been supported in part by the MICINN AEI (Spain) Grant No. PID2019–106080GB-C22/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 . I thank Zhi-Hui Guo for the feedback on the manuscript.

References

  1. [1]S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. 130, 776 (1963)
  2. [2]S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. 131, 440 (1963)
  3. [3]S. Weinberg, Phys. Rev. 137, B672 (1965)
  4. [4]J.A. Oller, Annals Phys. 396, 429 (2018), 1710.00991
  5. [5]E.M. Henley, W. Thirring, Elementary Quantum Field Theory (McGray-Hill Book Company Inc., 1962)
  6. [6]D. Rodriguez Entem, R. Machleidt, Y. Nosyk, Front. in Phys. 8, 57 (2020)
  7. [7]E. Epelbaum, H. Krebs, U.G. Meißner, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 122301 (2015), 1412.4623
  8. [8]E. Hernandez, A. Mondragon, Phys. Rev. C 29, 722 (1984)
  9. [9]S. Weinberg, The Quantum Theory of Fields I (Cambridge University Press, 2005), ISBN 0521670535, 978-0521670531
  10. [10]Z.H. Guo, J.A. Oller, Phys. Rev. D 93, 096001 (2016), 1508.06400
  11. [11]J.A. Oller, A Brief Introduction to Dispersion Relations, SpringerBriefs in Physics (Springer, 2019), ISBN 978-3-030-13581-2, 978-3-030-13582-9DOI
  12. [12]J.A. Oller, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 110, 103728 (2020), 1909.00370
  13. [13]T. Sekihara, T. Hyodo, D. Jido, PTEP 2015, 063D04 (2015), 1411.2308
  14. [14]F. Aceti, E. Oset, Phys. Rev. D 86, 014012 (2012), 1202.4607
  15. [15]J.A. Oller, E. Oset, Nucl. Phys. A 620, 438 (1997), [Erratum: Nucl.Phys.A 652, 407–409 (1999)], hep-ph/9702314
  16. [16]R.L. Workman et al. (Particle Data Group), PTEP 2022, 083C01 (2022)
  17. [17]X.W. Kang, Z.H. Guo, J.A. Oller, Phys. Rev. D 94, 014012 (2016), 1603.05546
  18. [18]F. Aceti, L.R. Dai, L.S. Geng, E. Oset, Y. Zhang, Eur. Phys. J. A 50, 57 (2014), 1301.2554
  19. [19]L. Castillejo, R.H. Dalitz, F.J. Dyson, Phys. Rev. 101, 453 (1956)
  20. [20]J.A. Oller, E. Oset, Phys. Rev. D 60, 074023 (1999), hep-ph/9809337
  21. [21]J.R. Pelaez, G. Rios, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 242002 (2006), hep-ph/0610397
  22. [22]Z.H. Guo, J.A. Oller, J. Ruiz de Elvira, Phys. Rev. D 86, 054006 (2012), 1206.4163
  23. [23]U.G. Meißner, J.A. Oller, Phys. Lett. B 751, 59 (2015), 1507.07478
  24. [24]J.A. Oller, Z.H. Guo, Eur. Phys. J. C. These proceedings (2022)

Paper details

vlnc:W_qyj7284k
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents