WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Eddies that ride the flow: a model of turbulence with Richardson dispersion and anomalous dissipation
Abstract
We construct a divergence-free velocity field on that is a genuine function of position and carries both defining properties of turbulent transport: Richardson pair dispersion and a dissipative anomaly. No synthetic field has carried both, because the frame that gives the first destroys the field the second requires. The key is a dichotomy: deforming a spectrally localised pattern smears it across scales, whereas pushing its generating centres forward and re-convolving leaves the spectral envelope exactly invariant — so transporting the eddy centres preserves both cascade and frame. In the field the finite-size Lyapunov exponent obeys threshold by threshold within the scaling range, with a sweeping deficit , consistent with zero, against for the frozen field on the same data, a gap that doubles at Navier–Stokes intermittency. Companion papers prove that this family shows Richardson dispersion and a dissipative anomaly (Fefferman and Mayboroda 2026), and that a scalar advected by this flow obeys Yaglom's relation (De Lellis 2026), at small Kubo number. Trajectories forget their starting point as the smallest eddy is removed: the median separation of pairs released from one point with independent Brownian kicks varies as over 22 decades of particle diffusivity, against for a smooth control. A scalar in the same field closes the exact scale-by-scale variance budget, four independently measured terms balancing the dissipation to 15% over 1.2 decades with no adjustable constant, and reaches its inertial–convective asymptote to once the measured diffusive transfer is restored, while under an imposed mean gradient changes by 14% over a factor 5.8 in .
Introduction
Two facts organise the phenomenology of high-Reynolds-number turbulence. The first is Richardson’s: two fluid particles at separation inside the inertial range separate at a rate set by the eddies of size and by nothing else, so that and [3, 4, 5]. The second is Onsager’s: the rate at which a turbulent flow destroys a conserved quantity does not vanish as the corresponding molecular coefficient is taken to zero [6, 7]. For a passive scalar this is the statement that tends to a positive limit as [8, 9, 10]. For the kinetic energy this phenomenon is related to the regularity of the velocity field. If the field is smoother than Hölder , dissipation is impossible [11], whereas below that threshold it can occur [16, 17].
The two facts are not independent. For a passive scalar advected by a divergence-free field, away from walls, anomalous dissipation and Lagrangian spontaneous stochasticity are equivalent [18]: the scalar can only lose variance in the vanishing-diffusivity limit if trajectories emanating from a single point remain random in that limit, which is Richardson’s explosive separation carried to . A model that produced one without the other would be suspect; a vector field that produced both, with independently prescribed regularity, would be a laboratory in which the equivalence could be examined directly.
The ability to construct such a vector field would address a gap left by the two current approaches. Direct simulation of the Navier–Stokes equations resolves the dynamics but not the asymptotics: the scalar anomaly requires at and at [10], and a clean range for pair separation has arguably never been observed at all, with the accessible window dominated by the ballistic Batchelor regime [19, 20]; the reviews [21, 22] survey what has and has not been seen. At the other extreme, the rigorous programme has in the last few years produced velocity fields for which anomalous dissipation is a theorem—Hölder-continuous drifts built by iterated homogenisation [23], via mixing [24], and, most recently, drifts that are themselves weak solutions of the Euler equations [25]. Richardson’s law itself has been proved for an explicitly engineered deterministic field [26]. These constructions are engineered to make a proof close, but they are not physical, and their Lagrangian statistics beyond the one each was built for are largely unexplored. Only one of them has been argued to carry the sweeping structure of a physical flow at all [23, 27], but its time structure is unrealistically lacunary. Between the two sits the synthetic, or kinematic, velocity field built as a random superposition of eddies with prescribed amplitudes, lifetimes and scales, in which the inertial range is as wide as one chooses to make it and the Hölder exponent is an input rather than an output. Two constructions carry the same name and should be kept apart. Kinematic simulation (KS) in the narrow sense is a sum of random Fourier modes with a prescribed spectrum and a prescribed mode frequency [28, 29], and it is that method whose Lagrangian statistics have been studied at length [30, 31]. What is used below is instead a superposition of localised eddies, and its skeleton is not new: Çağlar [32], developing a construction of Çinlar [33], writes a fixed divergence-free profile convolved with a Poisson measure of centres over a continuum of scales, and chooses the arrival law so that across an inertial range. There, as in the vortex-superposition models it descends from [34, 35, 36], the centres are placed and left where they are placed. This paper is about what happens when they are not. It is the natural laboratory. It has also, for the whole of its history, failed at Richardson’s law.
What Richardson’s law asks of a velocity field
The failure has a precise anatomy. Richardson’s law rests on three requirements, and they are worth separating because the synthetic field supplies the first two by construction and has, until now, failed at the third. Consider a pair at separation inside the inertial range, let be the typical velocity difference across , and let be the time over which that difference stays correlated along the pair. The pair diffusivity is then , and .
Scaling. The increment obeys , which is Obukhov’s spectrum read in physical space [4]. More generally , with the Hölder exponent of the field, and nothing below depends on .
Clock. An eddy of size turns over in and lives for a fixed number of turnover times,
where the Kubo number Ku, the ratio of the lifetime to the turnover time, is of order one in a real flow.
Advection. The pair must stay with the eddies of its own size for their lifetime. The pair is carried by every scale coarser than ; for the eddies of size to keep it, those scales must carry the eddies as well, so that the sweep is common to both and cancels from their relative motion. Then and
Richardson’s four-thirds law and its integral [3, 5]; the factor is the one in the lower bound of Ref. [1]. Read at fixed scale rather than at fixed time, the same three ingredients give a separation rate , which is the form in which the law is tested in Section VI.
The first two requirements are properties of the field at a point and can be prescribed; in the model below they are the input exponent and the lifetime of (13). The third is a property of the field along a pair, and it is where the synthetic field fails. The cause was identified by Thomson and Devenish [37]. In a real flow the energetic large eddies advect both the particles and the small eddies, so the two are swept together. In a synthetic field whose eddies are placed and left where they are placed, the large modes advect the particles only: the small-scale pattern stands still while the pair is dragged through it (Figure 1A), and the pair loses the eddies of its own size not after but after the far shorter sweeping time , where is the r.m.s. speed. Eyink and Benveniste [38] sharpened this into a formula: the pair diffusivity is with
Figure 1. From the sweeping obstruction to a single-valued Eulerian field. (A) In a frozen multiscale field the energetic large modes advect the pair but not the small eddies, so the pair is dragged through a stationary pattern and decorrelates on ; when the small scales are carried by the same coarse flow the sweep is common to both and cancels from the relative motion, restoring the turnover clock . (B) The construction: the centres of generation are advected by , the sum of all coarser generations (Eq. (18)), while the profile is translated rigidly and never deformed (Eq. (24)). (C) Verification of Theorem 1: fraction of generation ’s energy remaining inside its own octave band, averaged over four realisations (bars: standard error), with no filter applied. Pushing the generating centres forward reproduces the frozen reference to within 0.022 in absolute fraction; composing the field with the same flow map destroys the cascade.
and the third entry is the one that has no counterpart in Navier–Stokes. Substituting it gives and ; in the absence of a mean flow the regions of anomalously small velocity contribute a population on top of a bulk and the mean grows as [37].
Whether the effect is fatal in practice has been contested. Osborne et al. [39] reported Richardson scaling in three-dimensional KS despite the absence of sweeping and attributed it to the fractal set of straining stagnation points, for which Dávila and Vassilicos had earlier derived with [40]; Devenish and Thomson [41] answered that the discrepancy was not a time-stepping artefact; Malik [42] argued that the sweeping error in the pair diffusivity decreases with separation and so cannot explain the observed non-locality. Two-dimensional KS reproduces the measured separation distributions of laboratory and simulated two-dimensional turbulence [43, 44] while showing an initial-condition dependence of the r.m.s. separation that persists for very long times — which is precisely the quantity (3) attacks. Our position is the conservative one: rather than adjudicate the debate, we remove the third entry of (3) by construction, and verify against a control that shares every random number with the experiment.
To Richardson’s three requirements the anomaly adds a fourth, of a different kind. The dissipation is defined by an advection–diffusion equation, and an advection–diffusion equation needs a velocity field : a rule that moves particles but assigns different velocities to the same point at the same time will not do. The third requirement is Lagrangian and the fourth is Eulerian, and the obvious way to meet the third defeats the fourth (§ 2.1D). In the Euler equations there is no such conflict. The velocity is a field, and every structure in it, at every scale, is carried by the flow, so that the third requirement is not an assumption but the content of Kelvin’s theorem. To see what a model must keep and what it may replace, we write Euler in the formulation that makes this transport explicit.
Euler in Lagrangian labels
Let be the flow map of a solution of the incompressible Euler equations on and let be the back-to-labels map (Constantin’s letter; the amplitudes of Section II are scalars and no confusion should arise). It is transported by the flow,
and it carries all Lagrangian information, since with . Kelvin’s theorem states that the velocity 1-form is transported up to an exact form; pulled back to Eulerian coordinates this is the Weber formula
with the Leray projection, and its curl is Cauchy’s formula
Either formula closes the system on alone: a first-order transport equation whose velocity depends non-locally on through a Calderón–Zygmund operator. The pressure has disappeared, and the only evolving unknown is the label map. Constantin proved local well-posedness in this framework and used it for the vanishing-viscosity limit [12, 13]; the same Cauchy invariants underlie the time-analyticity of Lagrangian trajectories [14, 15]. In Lagrangian variables the content of Eq. (6) is , and with the decomposition , where is the symmetric strain, a singular integral of , the rotation drops out of the vorticity equation:
Now expand the initial vorticity in divergence-free wavelets, , , with supported in the ball . Taking , with the divergence-free model eddy of Section II, makes the velocity of each element at equal to the eddy itself. Since the coefficients are Cauchy invariants,
so for all time the vorticity is a superposition of the same elements, each carried by the flow. The element lives on , its vorticity vector is , and it induces on every other element the Biot–Savart field of its deformed self. Its centre and its shape obey
and to first order in the support is the ellipsoid , with semi-axes and .
What deforms an element of size is the velocity increment across its support. Under Kolmogorov scaling that increment receives from each coarser scale and from each finer scale , where ; both geometric sums are dominated by and total . Hence the strain rate felt by the element is : straining is local in scale, and the element is deformed by after one turnover time . Heuristically, beyond that time grows exponentially; the element is stretched in one or two directions and, since , thinned in the others, so that its Eulerian wavelet content migrates to scales . This is the cascade seen from the labels, and it has two consequences for the Eulerian statistics at scale : the energy there is supplied by the thinning of coarser elements, and the field decorrelates on the turnover time, with a Kubo number of order one.
This is how Euler meets the four requirements of Section IA, and it says what each costs. The first, , is the Kolmogorov–Obukhov phenomenology, an input to the argument just given and not a theorem. The second and the third are the two halves of Eq. (9): the centre is carried by the full velocity, so the pair and the elements of its own size are swept together and what separates the pair is the increment across those elements; and the shape stays coherent for one turnover time, so is an output and not a parameter. The fourth is automatic, since . The price is that none of this is rigorous: is a singular integral over all elements, and in the limit of infinitely many scales the pointwise is not even defined, since the flow map of a Hölder field is at best Hölder. What a model must keep is now visible: elements that are carried, as in the first half of Eq. (9), and that live for a time set by their own scale. What it may replace is the second half, the deformation, provided it replaces what the deformation does.
The renewal model as a closure
The model of [1, 2] and of this paper keeps the elements and the sweeping and replaces everything else by a stochastic rule. Its field is with
where , the epoch is a window of length of order —the clock of Eq. (1)—and the independent, mean-zero weights and the uniformly shifted birth lattice of the centres are drawn afresh for every epoch; the precise forms are Eqs. (13)–(20) of Sections II and III. Compared with the Euler element of Eqs. (8)–(9): (i) The centre moves with instead of : sweeping by the coarser scales is kept exactly, while self-induced motion and advection by the finer scales are dropped. This is what makes the coupling of the centres to the field triangular rather than circular, so that the construction closes generation by generation, and what makes the weights of generation independent of the positions of its centres, which Theorem 1 uses.
(ii) : no strain, no rotation by , no stretching. Orientation and amplitude are pinned, so Kolmogorov scaling is an input rather than an output, and the stationarity of the spectrum, which Euler would have to produce by transfer, is imposed.
(iii) Each element contributes the compactly supported itself rather than the Biot–Savart field of its deformed vorticity: there is no cross-scale induced velocity and no pressure.
(iv) The refresh. Over one window the deformation that Euler would apply is small, (Lemma 2.2 of Ref. [1]), and it is not wholly discarded: the particles follow the full at their own positions, so the mismatch between the strained pair and the unstrained eddy is the commutator
which is the linearised deformation. It is kept in the proof as an error of relative size per window (see the proof of Lemma 4.3 of Ref. [1]) and is summable over scales. In the field of this paper it is the residual sweeping of Proposition 2, bounded on the support of the eddy by a quantity of the order of the eddy’s own velocity (Eq. (28)).
The model thus applies the first-order deformation for a time , as seen by the pair, and then discards the element and redraws it. The refresh is a closure for the three effects that the deformation would produce beyond a turnover time: the distortion of the element, its transfer to finer scales, and the decorrelation of scale . All three are replaced by a single stochastic step with prescribed statistics, and this step is what makes the proof work: averaging over the fresh data annihilates the first-order and the mixed terms exactly (Prop. 6.6 of Ref. [1]), leaving the gain , whereas in Euler the same cancellation would have to come from the mixing of the label map, which is not available.
Two features of the rule have no counterpart in Euler and are the price of this closure. The Kubo number must be small: the element is refreshed at time , well before Euler’s natural coherence time , which is precisely the regime in which rigid translation followed by refresh is self-consistent, whereas real turbulence has . And the refresh times are nested dyadically, which the averaging and the time reversal in the dissipation argument require. The authors of Ref. [1] regard the smallness of Ku as technical; a derivation of the model from Euler would amount to showing that the deformation of Lagrangian wavelet elements over a turnover time produces statistics that approximate an independent, mean-zero refresh.
The field of Definition 1 is this model carried into the regime the proof does not reach, and it differs from the proved version in the following particulars, each chosen so that something can be measured. The abrupt refresh is replaced by the cross-fade of Eq. (15), under which the epochs form an exact partition of unity: is continuous in , nothing is paused across a renewal, and the identity of Theorem 1 holds at every instant. The bounded symmetric weights are replaced by the log-normal weights of Eq. (17), whose parameter sets the intermittency of the field from none to that of Navier–Stokes turbulence and beyond, so that the Richardson test can be repeated as a function of intermittency (Figure 4C). The Kubo number is of order one, from 0.25 to 2, the regime of real turbulence: there the residual of Eq. (11) is of order and is no longer controlled by the proof, and whether it decorrelates on the eddy’s own clock or on the far shorter clock of the coarse field that produces it becomes a quantitative question, which the measurements of Section VI settle. The scale ratio is free in : the half-octave bands used for the dispersion runs sample the same spectrum twice as finely, and the, not the octaves, produce a plateau in the realised (Figure 2A); the epochs are then not nested across generations. The profile is a bump rather than the radial stream function of the proof, and the one property of the profile the proof needs, its condition (ND), is checked for the bump direction by direction (Appendix A). In both versions the energy of each generation is fixed by construction and no equation moves energy between scales: the field carries no cascade, and the diagnostics of Section VIII C confirm it.
Figure 2. Richardson dispersion in the co-moving field. () Realised regularity at and . Half-octave bands produce a plateau at , near the input value , which widens as the resolution increases. () The local exponent of the finite-size Lyapunov exponent for the co-moving field and for the frozen control, both on the same random data, against the Richardson line measured on the same field. () The deficit . In the window (shaded) the co-moving field gives , consistent with zero, and the frozen field gives . () The paired difference between the two arms at both resolutions, against . Its change of sign near is the release transient.
Figure 4. Same snapshots, different clocks. (A) Exponents of the velocity structure functions, , divided by and fitted over the scaling range of Figure 2A, for the co-moving field and the frozen control with (filled, as everywhere else in this paper) and (open) in Eq. (17); , eight realisations each, converged orders only. Dotted: the She–Lévêque exponents of Navier–Stokes turbulence [62]. (B) Decorrelation time of the velocity of generation in the co-moving field divided by that in the frozen control, followed along tracers (filled) and at fixed points (open), paired realisation by realisation (, , four realisations). Dotted: , the ratio of the sweeping time to the turnover time. (C) The deficit of Eq. (31) in the window of Section VI against , for twenty seed pairs at each value, with the paired excess of the frozen field and the Eulerian estimate over the same window. The band marks the at which the exponents of A match She–Lévêque. Details in Appendix B.
Item (ii) deserves a second look, because it is where the construction is most easily spoiled, and it is the content of this paper. In Euler the deformation is the cascade — it moves the element’s wavelet content to finer scales — and the transfer term of the energy equation is what replenishes each scale. A model that prescribes the energy of each generation has no such term, so if it deforms its elements it loses them from their band and nothing replaces them. The alternative can be stated exactly, and is Lemma 1 below. A spectrally localised pattern is not an arbitrary function but a convolution of a fixed profile with an atomic measure of centres, and there are two inequivalent ways to move it. Composing it with the flow map, , is Euler’s transport with the true : it multiplies the pattern’s gradient by the carrier’s strain and smears its spectrum across wavenumbers, and on the field of this paper it leaves only 1.4 to 7.3% of each generation’s energy in its band (Figure 1C). Pushing the measure forward and re-convolving, , is : it changes only the phases of , and the expected spectral envelope is exactly invariant, at every time and along every trajectory the centres take (Theorem 1). The two agree whenever is a constant orthogonal matrix preserving the profile and part company as soon as leaves . The distinction is invisible at the level of a translation, however large, which is presumably why it has not been isolated before; it is the gradient of the displacement — the strain of the carrier, the thing one is trying to model — that separates them. Transporting the eddy centres, each generation carried by the sum of all coarser generations, therefore keeps the cascade intact while realising the quasi-Lagrangian cancellation up to the residual of Eq. (11).
The frame, the field, and what this paper does
The renewal model is one closure of Eq. (9), and the alternatives are instructive, because each keeps something it gives up. The oldest removes the sweep from the observer rather than from the field. Belinicher and L’vov [45] observe the field from a frame riding with a marked fluid particle, with ; because the sweeping velocity is common to the observer and to the small scales, it cancels from velocity increments and the infrared divergences it generates disappear order by order. Applied to a kinematic model the recipe is to give each particle its own displacement registers , one per generation, to read octave at the shifted point , and to advance . Then
so the point at which octave is read moves under octaves only, and every coarser octave is removed from the relative motion identically. This is what Lacorata and Vulpiani [46] implement, and it yields the desired statistics: with quasi-Lagrangian coordinates a chaotic multiscale model recovers the expected finite-size Lyapunov scaling.
In the language of § 1 B the registers are a label map built one trajectory at a time: stands in for at the scales coarser than , but it is a functional of the whole trajectory of and not a function of , and that is what it costs. Two particles occupying the same point at the same time with different histories are assigned different velocities. What Eq. (12) defines is a map on an extended phase space; the object it induces on is the relation , which is not a graph. There is no with , and therefore no divergence, no Jacobian, and no advection–diffusion equation: the third requirement of § 1 A is met exactly and the fourth is lost. In the model studied below, the fraction of each octave’s kinetic energy that is not a function of position is , , , , , for ; only the largest octave, whose shift is empty, is single-valued. The renewal model makes the opposite exchange. Its centres, finitely many of them, solve ordinary differential equations in alone, so the field is a function of position, and the frame holds only up to the residual of Proposition 2, of order . Exactness of the frame for existence of the field is the substance of the paper.
Two constructions do transport localised structure in a field, and in each the element is deformed. Ghate and Lele [47, 48] enrich a large-eddy simulation with localised Gabor modes and advect their centres, , explicitly in order to put the small scales in the sweeping frame. But the carrier is a separately resolved LES field, coupled one way, and the enrichment spans a single band of a factor four to eight rather than a cascade; the wavevectors refract along the trajectory, , which is the deformation of Eq. (9) acting on the wavevector, so the profile does not stay fixed and the envelope is not preserved; and the assembled field is divergence-free only to leading order in the window width. Armstrong and Vicol [23] do carry every scale in the frame of the coarser ones, but by composition — the true , route (ii) of Lemma 1 — and their inverse flow maps must then be renewed on a time scale short compared with the inverse Lipschitz constant, with the shears paused across each renewal. Neither reports pair dispersion, and neither reports a scalar anomaly.
So the two goals have been mutually exclusive. Richardson’s law needs the frame; the anomaly needs a field; and the frame is not a field. We construct a field that is both. The construction occupies Sections II–IV: the generating data — scales, profile, epochs and weights — in § 1.1, the co-motion of the centres in Section III, and in Section IV the Eulerisation by push-forward, with Lemma 1 and Definition 1. § 1.4 collects the properties of the result: it is a function of position and exactly divergence-free; its flow preserves measure and orientation and does not fold (Proposition 1); the transport leaves the expected spectral envelope every generation unchanged (Theorem 1); the residual sweeping is bounded by a quantity of the order of the eddy’s own velocity (Proposition 2); and the field converges in as generations are added (Theorem 2). Section VI puts pairs in it, against a frozen control sharing every random number. The finite-size Lyapunov exponent of the co-moving field obeys threshold by threshold within the scaling range, with a deficit , consistent with zero, against for the frozen field; the paired gap, (), doubles at the intermittency of Navier–Stokes turbulence, persists at Kubo numbers from to and at twice the resolution, and exceeds by a factor of sixty-six the effect of replacing the birth lattice by a Poisson process. The same section tests spontaneous stochasticity directly: pairs released from one point with independent Brownian kicks have a median separation that varies as over twenty-two decades of particle diffusivity, against for a smooth control, with a residual that falls as as the cutoff is removed and is the same forward and backward in time. Section VII places a scalar in the field, which only a field permits: the exact scale-by-scale budget closes, four independently measured terms balancing the dissipation to 15% over 1.2 decades with no adjustable constant; the inertial–convective asymptote is reached to once the measured diffusive transfer is restored; and under a mean gradient , where a scalar without an anomaly gives . Section VIII discusses what has been constructed, the part played by intermittency, the absence of an energy cascade and the origin of the arrow of time of the anomaly, and the relation to the rigorous constructions.
What is new is therefore not the superposition but its motion, in four respects. The dichotomy of Lemma 1 — that a spectrally localised pattern admits two inequivalent transports, agreeing only where is orthogonal — is what makes the choice a choice, and we have not found it stated. Once it is made, Theorem 1 is an identity in , at every time and along every trajectory the centres take, with no hypothesis on their arrangement: nothing is renewed and nothing degrades. The carrier is internal, generation being advected by the sum of the coarser members of the same construction, so the recursion closes at any depth and no resolved outer field enters. And the multivaluedness of the quasi-Lagrangian alternative is measured rather than asserted, octave by octave. To these the derivation of Sections I B and I C adds a placement: the model is the Lagrangian wavelet decomposition of the Euler equations with one closure, the refresh of the elements in place of their deformation, whose price in the proof — a small Kubo number — is here examined at Kubo numbers of order one. What those buy is the pair of measurements that follow, which no synthetic velocity field has carried at once.
The generating data
We work on the torus ; lengths are in grid cells and .
a. Scales. Fix an integral scale , a Hölder exponent , a Kubo number , and a scale ratio . For put
Thus is the spatial scale of generation , its velocity amplitude, and its lifetime — the turnover time of an eddy of size moving at the bare amplitude , up to the constant . (The realised turnover time is longer by — unity at , at ; we tie to so that the time lattice is unchanged by the refinement.) The factor makes the total energy and the spectrum independent of : refining from octaves () to half-octaves () doubles the number of bands and halves the energy in each, leaving and the second-order structure function unchanged to leading order. At the normalisation is unity and one recovers the classical octave model , , . Why the refinement matters is a measurement, reported in Section VI.
b. Profile. Set . The only condition on the integral scale is , so that the largest eddy fits in the torus; the runs use . Fix then a specific “model macroscopic eddy”, namely a non-trivial, zero-average, divergence-free velocity field with the property that and that its maximum modulus is normalised to 1. We then define the model eddies at scale as
With this normalisation automatically. For instance in two space dimensions we could take , let , where , set , and set . In three dimensions we could use a vector potential in place of , set and proceed analogously. The following properties are used throughout the rest of the paper and nothing else: ; ; , , and its average is 0.
c. Epochs. Generation is renewed on the time lattice , . Epoch lives on with weight
Exactly two epochs are alive at any outside the discrete set , the exponent 2 is not cosmetic: writing ,
so the epochs form an exact partition of unity, which is what makes the identity of Theorem 1 uniform in ; a cross-fade with loses (16) and forces a compensating retuning of . Consecutive epochs carry independent amplitudes and independent birth lattices, so the second moment picks up instead: the energy of generation retains a modulation of period between 1 and . This is a property of any renewal cross-fade with independent epochs and is common to every field compared here. Write .
d. Random coefficients. Let . The birth positions of epoch are the points, , of the periodic lattice , with the offset drawn uniformly on independently for each ; the wrap keeps independent of the offset when ; we write them and we call them birth lattice points. The amplitudes are independent across and across ,
so that , and : unit variance at every generation and a flatness growing geometrically in , which is the inter-generation intermittency of a multiplicative cascade. Setting returns i.i.d. standard normal amplitudes; nothing below depends on the choice beyond , and independence.
That the arrangement of the centres is equally inessential is not an assumption but a measurement: replacing the randomly offset lattice of Eq. (19) by a Poisson process of the same density — against a Bragg peak at the spacing — moves the dispersion exponent by 0.0014, sixty-six times less than switching off the transport does (Figure 3C).
Figure 3. The scalar, and the eddy arrangement. (A) Scalar dissipation against diffusivity at fixed field, for six realisations of the co-moving field (thin lines) and their mean (symbols, with standard errors). The dotted line, , is the behaviour of a scalar without an anomaly. (B) The scale-by-scale budget, Eq. (36), in the octave-spaced field: three of its four terms, each measured independently and normalised by , and the sum of all four (the unsteady term is below 1% and is not drawn). The rise above is the large-scale damping, which is not plotted. (C) Pair correlation of the eddy centres for a randomly offset lattice and for a Poisson process of the same density. The dispersion exponents of the two differ by 0.0014.
Co-motion: the inductive step
Write with . The construction is inductive in : given every coarser generation, the centres of generation are carried by the sum of the previous generations. More precisely, they solve the system of ODEs
subject to the initial condition
In particular the centres start at the birth lattice points at the initial time . The centres need only be tracked in the time interval , the lifetime of epoch . The ones of generation 0 never move. Equivalently, and this is the form in which the construction is most compactly stated, one may integrate Eq. (18) as a flow. We can consider the global flow of which starts as the identity at time , and regard the solution of Eqs. (18)–(19) as tracking the trajectories of a finite number of particles starting at the birth lattice points. More precisely we have
This continuous form is what we use, and it is what makes Proposition 2 hold at every instant rather than only at epoch boundaries.
The point of Eq. (18) is Eq. (12) without the registers. A particle and an eddy of generation that are close enough to interact are advected by the same coarse field, so the coarse velocity cancels from their relative motion up to the variation of across the eddy. Proposition 2 bounds that variation by a quantity of the order of the eddy’s own velocity: the sweep of the coarse field is removed, and what remains is comparable to the eddy rather than to the sweep.
Eulerisation: push the centres, not the field
It remains to say how a transported set of centres generates a velocity. The naive answer — compose the pattern with the flow map — is the one that fails, and the reason it fails is the content of the construction.
Write the epoch’s eddies as a convolution. With the atomic measure , the random combination is , and with a potential such that it is . To move it along the flow of one may advect the potential, , and take the curl. That is the route we do not take.
The key point of this paper is the other one: push the measure forward, , and re-convolve. Since , the model eddy is moved without being deformed, and in Fourier — a product, not a convolution. The two routes behave very differently.
Lemma 1 (the dichotomy). Let be the atomic measure of an epoch, let be a measure-preserving diffeomorphism of , and write , so that . The two objects
coincide for every whenever is a translation, and differ as follows.
(i) Push the centres. For every and every ,
The profile factor is untouched by : the transform factorises, and enters the second factor only through unimodular phases. (It is the factorisation that matters and not a support statement: is compactly supported, so vanishes on no open set.)
(ii) Compose the field. Let be arbitrary. Since one has , while
componentwise if is vector-valued, and equality with holds for every if and only if for a.e. $y.
Unless a.e., composition therefore moves the mean wavenumber of some $\Theta. Push-forward moves it only through the structure factor, never through the profile — and by Theorem 1 not even through the structure factor once the weights are averaged over.
Proof. If then . Part (i) is with and . For (ii), the chain rule gives ; substituting , whose Jacobian is , gives Eq. (22). A matrix with satisfies for every precisely when . If on a set of positive measure, pick a Lebesgue point of there and a direction with ; the oscillating test functions , with a bump at , concentrate along as and make Eq. (22) differ from .
Remark 1. The same spreading can be written in Fourier variables: with ,
If is constant then and the modulus is unchanged; if the kernel is no longer diagonal. Turning that into a width needs hypotheses on — with , so that is a diffeomorphism — and a convention for what “width” means. Part (ii) needs neither, which is why the dichotomy is stated in a norm.
Remark 2. Equality for every does not force to be a translation: any with and — for the example of Section II, the eight symmetries of the square — gives equality too, being a measure-preserving automorphism of with constant Jacobian. The dichotomy the proof establishes is between a.e. and not: a constant but non-orthogonal , such as a hyperbolic automorphism of , already separates the two routes.
Remark 3. The obvious repair of the composition route — keep the translation and rotation in and delete the symmetric traceless part — does not exist. A matrix field with antisymmetric and non-constant violates the compatibility condition and is therefore the Jacobian of no map: a “locally rigid but spatially varying” deformation is not available.
Lemma 1 says what to do. Transport the centres and re-convolve with the same fixed profile.
Definition 1 (the field). With the centres of Eq. (18), set , and
The velocity at at time is a finite sum of translated copies of fixed, compactly supported, divergence-free vector profiles, one term per live eddy, with time-dependent centres and constant amplitudes. Because only eddies with contribute, so the sum is finite and local; in the octave configuration (, , ) some eddies are alive in total, and in the half-octave configuration used below.
Equations (18) and (24) look circular — the centres move under a field built from the centres — but the coupling is triangular. Eqs. (18), (19) and (24) have a unique solution on whenever for every , constructed generation by generation: at each step is already built and Lipschitz, so the centres of generation follow by Cauchy–Lipschitz and follows from them.
Remark 4 (renewal is free). Epoch is created at on a fresh lattice and discarded at . Both instants have , so is continuous across them: what is discarded was multiplying zero, and what is created multiplies zero.
Properties of the field
Two properties follow at once from the definition. For each , is a function on : every ingredient of Eq. (24) is fixed by and , the centres solve an ordinary differential equation in alone, and nothing depends on the history of a particle passing through , as it does in Eq. (12). And for every and every configuration of the centres, since each generation is a curl.
Proposition 1 (measure preservation; no folding). Let be the flow of . Then is a bi-Lipschitz homeomorphism of preserving Lebesgue measure, with a.e.; if then is a diffeomorphism and .
Proof. is Lipschitz, so the flow exists, is unique and is injective at every . Injectivity already says that no two fluid elements reach the same point, so the flow cannot fold, and Liouville's formula with gives measure preservation. The statement needs , which the example of Section II is not ( jumps at ); the bi-Lipschitz statement suffices here.
The per-particle construction behaves very differently. Of 384 triads of particles with side a quarter of the smallest eddy, 28% fold under Eq. (12), against 0.01% for the field of Definition 1 and 1.8% for the frozen field, which cannot fold either and so measures the interpolation floor.
Theorem 1 (exact preservation of the expected spectral envelope). For every and every configuration of the centres,
and, because the weights are i.i.d., zero-mean and independent of the centre positions (generation is carried by , which is built from generations alone), the cross terms in the second moment vanish and
For every , every and every trajectory of the centres. The -dependence is carried entirely by the fixed profile . The motion of the centres enters only through the unimodular phases , which change the structure factor of the measure but not the spectral envelope, so the carrier cannot redistribute generation across scales and no filter is needed. The expectation in Eq. (26) is over the generation- amplitudes at a fixed trajectory of the centres; it is conditional on the coarse field rather than an average over it, and neither equation says that the energy at a given is preserved in a single realisation.
Proof. Eq. (25) is . For Eq. (26), expand the square: by Eq. (17) the weights satisfy , and they are independent of , so every off-diagonal term vanishes and each of the diagonal terms contributes . No hypothesis on the centres is used. ◻
Because has compact support, its transform does not vanish on any open set, so no generation is strictly confined to a band; what Eq. (26) fixes is the envelope. In particular the fraction of each generation's energy near its own wavenumber is, on average, unchanged by the transport. Figure 1C checks this on the discretised field. With the centres transported as in Definition 1, the fraction of each generation's energy inside , , averaged over four realisations, agrees with that of the frozen field to within 0.022, with no filter applied. The composition route of Lemma 1, applied to the same random data, leaves only 1.4 to 7.3% of each generation's energy in its band and lowers the realised regularity from 0.369 to 0.145. Movie S1 shows the two transports side by side.
The centres also keep, on average, the density at which they were born. Since the flow of preserves area, the number of centres in a set equals the number of birth lattice points in its preimage, and for any whose boundary has finite -dimensional upper Minkowski content this count is up to a boundary error, uniformly in wherever is uniformly bounded, as it is for bounded weights at small Kubo number, where the flow over one renewal period and its inverse are Lipschitz with constant at most 2 [1, 2]. Individual centres can still approach one another, since an area-preserving map compresses in one direction while it stretches in another, but this is harmless: two coincident centres simply make one eddy, of amplitude . The spectral envelope does not need even this much, because it is blind to the arrangement: with every centre of an epoch at a single point, still. The density of the centres matters only for statistics beyond second order, including the Lagrangian ones of Section VI (Appendix C).
The per-particle construction satisfies the frame equation, Eq. (12), identically. The field of Definition 1 satisfies it only approximately, and the error can be written down.
Proposition 2 (residual sweeping). Let solve and let be any centre of generation . Then
and, since unless , the error is only ever evaluated where . It vanishes identically if is a uniform translation.
Proof. Subtract Eq. (18) from ; the bound is the Lipschitz estimate on the support of . □
The residual changes the velocity against which generation decorrelates. Because increases with , the nearest coarser generation dominates the Lipschitz constant, with . With and this gives, at ,
The inequality holds for typical values and not deterministically, because the supremum of grows with the depth of the cascade through the log-normal weights: at the r.m.s. of stays at about twice for , 7 and 10, while its supremum grows from 8 to 30 times that value. With log-normal weights that growth is the obstacle to letting in the flow, although the field itself converges (Theorem 2); with bounded weights and a small Kubo number it is absent, and the field is Hölder continuous uniformly in [1, 2].
The bound is of order , so the residual is not small; what matters is what it replaces. The sweeping removed by Eq. (18) is dominated by the largest generation, , because decreases with . Co-motion therefore lowers the velocity that sets the decorrelation time of generation from to , a factor , which is about three at the smallest scales of our runs. If this exchange were complete, replacing the sweeping time in Eq. (3) by at would give a pair diffusivity in place of , and hence in place of . For bounded weights and a small Kubo number the conclusion is a theorem: Ref. [1] proves at over a range of times, uniformly in , and its central estimate is the one above: the coarse flow carries the fine eddy together with the point at which it is read, so only the increment of across the eddy survives. For the log-normal weights and order-one Kubo numbers used here the question is quantitative — Eq. (28) bounds the size of the residual, whereas the third entry of Eq. (3) is a correlation time, and a residual of amplitude could still decorrelate on the much shorter time of the coarse field that produces it — and the pair measurements of the next section settle it.
The field itself, though not Lipschitz constant, has a limit as generations are added. The following result and its proof are due to L. Sarieddine (private communication).
Theorem 2 ( limit). Extend the construction below the grid scale by giving every generation the birth lattice of spacing , with an offset drawn uniformly from . Then for every the fields converge in almost surely as .
The idea is that each generation is small in on average. Generation is built from the coarser ones alone, so the are partial sums of a single series. The weights have zero mean and are independent of the centres, so the cross terms drop out and , with independent of because the centres sit apart and is bounded. Since is summable, is finite almost surely and the partial sums converge.
Richardson dispersion
We now put particles in the field. Each one obeys
with the field of Definition 1, and we follow pairs released a small distance apart. The question is the one of Figure 1A. In a real flow a pair of size is pulled apart by the eddies of its own size and stays with them for their turnover time. In a frozen synthetic field it is dragged through those eddies by the large ones and loses them after the much shorter sweeping time . We want to know which of the two clocks the co-moving field keeps;
Movie S2 shows one pair in both fields. The computations are two-dimensional, which is where the necessary range of scales is affordable (Appendix A).
The dispersion measurements are read against a frozen control, the same field with Eq. (18) switched off, so that each eddy stays where it was born. The control is built from the same random numbers as the experiment, down to the released pairs, and differs only in whether the eddies move. The difference between the two is therefore the effect of co-motion, and taking it realisation by realisation removes most of the scatter.
Richardson's law at fixed scale
The textbook form of the law, , is awkward to test over a finite range of scales. At any given time some pairs are still close together while others have already reached the largest eddies, and the average mixes the two. It is cleaner to turn the question around, fix the separation and measure how long the pairs take to reach it [49, 50]. We set thresholds , record the first time at which a pair exceeds each one, and form the finite-size Lyapunov exponent, the rate at which pairs of size grow, together with its local slope,
Richardson’s argument then becomes a statement about . In a field of Hölder exponent , a pair at separation that is pulled apart by the eddies of its own size grows at the rate , so . At this is , the law read at fixed scale [51]. The theorem of Ref. [1], recalled in § 1.4, is the same law read at fixed time: there grows linearly in .
We do not assume the value of . We measure it on the same field, from the velocity structure function , as at , and compare the two sides of through the deficit
Pairs that obey Richardson’s law, at whatever regularity the field actually has, give . Sweeping makes positive: a pair dragged through a pattern that stands still spends a time proportional to in each eddy instead of its turnover time, so its separation rate falls off with more slowly than Richardson’s law predicts. Intermittency also shifts , for an unrelated reason: the exponent is built from mean crossing times and from the mean square velocity increment, and the two weigh the rare strong eddies differently. We measure this shift in the Discussion, by changing the intermittency of the weights (Figure 4C).
Co-motion restores Richardson’s clock
The deficit means something only where is constant, and the classical octave-spaced field has no such range: its realised falls steadily with however many octaves are added. Half-octave bands, which sample the same scales twice as finely with the same spectrum ( in Eq. (13)), produce a plateau at , close to the input , that widens with resolution (Figure 2A). We use them for the dispersion runs and read the deficit in a fixed window inside the plateau, above the release transient (Appendix B). At and over twenty realisations,
The co-moving deficit is consistent with zero and the frozen one is not (Figure 2C). The two arms share every amplitude, so the difference
isolates what co-motion removes. With weaker intermittency, close to that of Navier–Stokes turbulence, it doubles (Figure 4C). Figure 2B shows the same thing in the exponents themselves: the co-moving field follows the Richardson line threshold by threshold, and the frozen field rises above it.
Doubling the resolution does not change the result. At , on four independent realisations, every number agrees with its value to within one standard deviation (Figure 2D; Table I), although four realisations confirm the effect rather than establish it on their own. Nor does the lifetime of the eddies. At Kubo numbers from 0.25 to 2 the co-moving deficit stays consistent with zero, while the frozen field, once the release transient has passed, separates pairs more slowly the longer its eddies live, at 0.96 of the co-moving rate at and 0.51 at $\mathrm{Ku} = 2 ({xref}Table II). That trend is the obstruction at work: the longer a frozen eddy lives, the more likely a pair is to be swept out of it before it dies. The regular arrangement of the centres plays no part either. By Theorem 1 it is invisible to second-order statistics, and in octave-spaced runs replacing the lattice by a Poisson process of the same density moves the dispersion exponent by 0.0014, sixty-six times less than switching off the co-motion there ({xref}Fig. 3C`). Richardson scaling in this field comes from the motion of the eddies and not from where they sit.
Spontaneous stochasticity
Richardson’s law has a sharper relative. If holds with no memory of , then two particles that start from the same point still separate, and their trajectories are not unique. This is spontaneous stochasticity, the property that Drivas and Eyink showed to be equivalent to anomalous dissipation [18]. The two are not the same thing. Spontaneous stochasticity fixes no exponent: it can hold in a field of any Hölder exponent , with . And a power law does not establish it, since over a finite range of scales a smooth field can imitate one. We therefore test it directly.
We release the two members of a pair from the same point and give each its own weak Brownian kicks ,
and record their separation at a fixed time . In a smooth flow the separation is the noise, stretched by the flow, and the whole distribution of shrinks like as the noise is turned down. If trajectories are not unique, the distribution of tends instead to a non-trivial limit as [52]. Our field is Lipschitz below its smallest eddy, of size , so at finite its flow is unique and must eventually shrink; what we measure is how weakly it depends on , and whether that dependence goes away as is lowered. The noise acts on the particles and not on a field, so there is no small scale to resolve and can be varied over many decades (Movie S3).
In the smooth control, a single generation of eddies, the median separation scales as to four digits over twenty-two decades, from to . With the eleven generations of the field it scales as over the same twenty-two decades it moves only from 40 to 279 cells, where in the smooth control it changes by a factor . The dependence that is left has a simple origin. Below a pair grows exponentially from the size set by the noise, so the time it needs to escape into the rough range grows only as the logarithm of , and that time shrinks as generations are added. So does the exponent, as (Table V), and it vanishes as the cutoff is removed. Over the upper five decades, to , where the pairs have reached the integral scale by time , the exponent is and, across the three deepest cascades, falls as , the escape-time prediction .
| – | full range | ||
| 1 | — | (22) | |
| 6 | 45 | (5) | |
| 8 | 23 | (11) | |
| 9 | 16 | (15) | |
| 10 | 11 | (19) | |
| 11 | 8 | (22) |
Table V. Slope of the median separation at time against the particle diffusivity, , as generations are added at fixed , over – and over each cascade’s full usable range (decades in brackets; below it the pairs no longer escape by the time ); in cells. A field smooth on the scales the pair explores gives ; spontaneous stochasticity gives 0.
The equivalence with anomalous dissipation is a statement about trajectories run backward in time: the scalar at time is an average of its initial values over the paths that arrive at each point at . The two directions need not behave alike, as Burgers turbulence shows [53], so we replayed the stored field backward over the five-decade window. The exponent is backward and forward, and the result holds in the direction the equivalence requires. Pairs run backward are also the route of the proof of anomalous dissipation in Ref. [1], which bounds the separation of diffusing pairs in the time-reversed field from below at Richardson’s rate.
Yaglom's relation and the dissipative anomaly
Because is a velocity field and not a rule for moving particles, a passive scalar can be placed in it. We solve
in the field of Definition 1, pseudospectrally (Appendix A). The source comes from an imposed mean gradient and feeds scalar variance in, mostly at the largest scales; is the rate at which diffusion destroys it at the smallest, and in between the flow has to carry it down through every scale. We ask two things of the scalar: that this transfer obey Yaglom’s law, and that the rate of destruction survive as .
Yaglom's relation
Yaglom’s law [54] says that the flux of scalar variance through scale equals the rate at which variance is destroyed. The flux is measured by the mixed third-order structure function , and the exact scale-by-scale budget in two dimensions reads
where and is a damping of the two lowest wavenumber shells, which keeps the run statistically steady and acts only at scales comparable to .
Each term on the left can be measured on its own, and we measured all four, from 300 snapshots of a stationary run of the octave-spaced field. Over 1.2 decades of separation their sum equals the independently measured to within 15%, with no adjustable constant (Figure 3B). The cascade term carries the variance through the middle of this range, the mean gradient takes over at large separations and diffusion at small ones. Neither numerical diffusion nor a lack of stationarity can produce this balance: is a signed third-order moment, the unsteady term is measured separately, and numerical diffusion would show up as a failure to close. The balance also needs velocity and scalar increments taken at the same point and the same instant, which only a velocity field can supply.
In the inertial–convective range the budget reduces to Yaglom’s law in its textbook form, [54, 55], which has been observed in direct numerical simulations of the Navier–Stokes equations [56, 57, 58]. A mean gradient injects variance at every scale, so to see this form we replace it by a random source acting only on the lowest wavenumber shell, and run at . Even so the measured flux falls short of , by 18% at the smaller diffusivity and 30% at the larger, because at this resolution diffusion still carries part of the variance through the range. That diffusive transfer is measured too, so it can be put back, with two small corrections that do not depend on (Appendix B). Pooling four realisations and two diffusivities, we then find
within of the value Yaglom’s law requires, and the dependence on that remains is more than forty times smaller than before the correction.
The scalar’s own scaling exponent is a harder test. Obukhov and Corrsin tie it to the velocity’s through , where . At our resolution the scalar’s scaling range is squeezed between the diffusive and the forcing scales, and has not yet reached the Obukhov–Corrsin value, but comparing two resolutions shows it moving towards that value as the range widens (Appendix B).
The dissipation does not follow the diffusivity
The anomaly concerns the limit . As the diffusivity is lowered, diffusion acts at ever finer scales, but the flow keeps delivering variance to them at a rate it sets itself, so need not follow down. We probe this with a scan in at fixed field under the mean gradient of Eq. (35) (Figure 3A and Movie S4). The dissipation rate barely responds,
where a scalar without an anomaly would give . Over a factor 5.8 in , changes by 14%, and the points are fitted much better by , which has a finite limit, than by a power law; is finite in every realisation. For a version of this field with bounded symmetric weights and a small Kubo number the anomaly is a theorem [1, 2]: a decaying scalar loses, on average, at least a fixed fraction of its variance in a fixed time as the diffusivity goes to zero, both when the diffusivity is lowered together with the cutoff and in the limiting field itself.
The scan has to use the mean gradient. With the random source of the previous subsection the injection rate is fixed in advance, so in a steady state equals it whatever is, and such runs say nothing about the limit. Under a mean gradient the injection rate is an output of the flow, and only then does a -independent say something about the transport (Appendix B).
Co-motion matters for the scalar too. In paired runs of the octave-spaced field the scalar variances of the frozen and co-moving fields differ by , but the co-moving field destroys variance faster: is larger in each of four realisations, by on average. The co-motion that restores Richardson’s clock for pairs also speeds up the scalar cascade, as one expects if both are set by how long a fluid element stays with its own eddies, and the construction is what allows the two to be measured in one object.
The scalar is finally destroyed at the Batchelor scale , with the r.m.s. strain rate. That scale lies below the smallest eddy, , where the velocity is smooth. This does not undermine the measurement. What has to survive is the flux through the scaling range, and Figure 3B places it above : the cascade term peaks near cells against , and only the diffusive term, which dominates below , depends on . A rough velocity above a cutoff with a Batchelor range below it is also the arrangement of Navier–Stokes turbulence at large Schmidt number, the regime covered by the rigorous results of Refs. [59, 60]. The Lagrangian test of spontaneous stochasticity has no Batchelor scale at all.
Discussion
What has been constructed
Equation (24) defines, for any , any number of generations and any scale ratio, a divergence-free velocity field on that is an honest function of position, whose flow is measure- and orientation-preserving, whose transport leaves the expected spectral envelope of each generation unchanged (Theorem 1), and in which the quasi-Lagrangian cancellation holds up to the error of Eq. (28). In it, pair separation obeys Richardson’s law in the sharp local form , threshold by threshold within the scaling range, at two resolutions and at Kubo numbers from 0.25 to 2, with a residual consistent with zero, also at the intermittency of Navier–Stokes turbulence, while the same field with its eddies held still carries an additional deficit, , which doubles to at that intermittency; for bounded weights and a small Kubo number, Richardson’s law is a theorem for a version of this field, and so, for symmetric weights, is anomalous dissipation [1, 2].
A passive scalar in the field of Definition 1 satisfies Yaglom’s scale-by-scale relation, all four terms measured independently and balancing to 15% over 1.2 decades, and reaches the inertial–convective asymptote to once the measured diffusive transfer is restored — the coefficient fixed to 0.2% with no adjustable constant, though is not reached in this range and we measure its approach rather than claim it. Its dissipation rate barely follows the diffusivity, a test that needs an advection–diffusion equation and is therefore unavailable to any per-particle construction.
Sharper still, the field approaches spontaneous stochasticity as its cutoff is removed. At any finite it is Lipschitz below and its trajectories are unique, but pairs released from a single point with independent Brownian kicks depend on the particle diffusivity only through the time needed to cross that smooth range: over twenty-two decades, against for a single-scale smooth control on the same random data, and this residual falls as as generations are added. Over the five decades in which the pairs reach the integral scale the exponent is , falling across the three deepest generation counts as , the escape-time prediction ; run backward in time, the direction in which Ref. [18] states the equivalence, it returns . This is the sharper of the two Lagrangian statements: a field that is smooth on the scales a pair explores can imitate a power law over a bounded window, but its separation keeps the memory of , and it is non-uniqueness rather than the exponent for which the equivalence is stated. We are not aware of another synthetic velocity field with a finite correlation time — as opposed to a per-particle prescription, or a white-in-time ensemble in which sweeping is absent by construction [52, 61] — in which the Thomson–Devenish obstruction has been shown absent by direct measurement against a control sharing its random data.
The mechanism is a single algebraic fact. A spectrally localised pattern can be moved in two inequivalent ways, and only one commutes with the band structure (Lemma 1). Composing the field with a flow map is what a Lagrangian intuition suggests, and it destroys the cascade; pushing the centres forward keeps it. The distinction is invisible at the level of a translation, which is presumably why it has not been isolated before: the two agree exactly for any translation, however large, and it is the gradient of the displacement — the strain of the carrier, the thing one is trying to model — that separates them.
Intermittency
The weights of Eq. (17) make the field intermittent, and its structure functions measure how much (Figure 4A). With , falls from at to at , a drop of , nearly three times that of the She–Lévêque exponents of Navier–Stokes turbulence, [62]. This is a choice and not a prediction of the model: the drop is 0.010, 0.025, 0.051 and 0.083 for , 0.1, 0.2 and 0.3, and reproduces Navier–Stokes. All of them pass through at , because the spectrum is prescribed. Navier–Stokes turbulence is pinned instead at by the four-fifths law; here nothing holds at one, since nothing carries energy between scales, and it falls from with Gaussian weights to at . In a snapshot the co-moving field and the frozen control agree to 0.002 at every order, as they must, since they share every amplitude and co-motion only moves the eddies. Where they differ is in time (Figure 4B). Along a tracer the velocity of one generation stays correlated 1.1 to 1.8 times longer in the co-moving field, the more so the smaller the eddies, while at a fixed point it decorrelates 2.5 to 7 times faster, because the eddies are now carried past it. The tracer gain falls short of the ratio of the sweeping to the turnover time, since a tracer moves relative to its eddy with the velocity of that generation and the finer ones and with the strain of the coarser ones (Proposition 2).
Intermittency also enters the Richardson test of Section VI, because is built from mean exit times and from . To see how much, we repeated the paired experiment with , close to Navier–Stokes, on the same twenty seeds (Figure 4C). The frozen field still lags, and by more: the excess is (), against () at . The co-moving deficit is at most two standard errors from zero at both values, and . How the deficits move with is less simple. The frozen one moves as the Eulerian estimate predicts, by against ; the co-moving one moves by , more than three times the of that estimate. We think this is because pairs that move with the eddies stay with the strong ones, so the rare strong eddies weigh more on their exit times than the statistics of a snapshot allow. The residual deficit of the co-moving field is therefore not the intermittency allowance of a monofractal argument. What is robust is that it is consistent with zero, with the intermittency of the model and with that of Navier–Stokes turbulence, while the same field with its eddies held still is not.
No cascade, and the origin of the arrow of time
The field has no energy cascade, in either direction. Its velocity is prescribed, the energy of each generation is fixed by construction, and no equation moves energy between scales. The usual diagnostics of a cascade agree. In both arms the skewness of the longitudinal velocity increment, , is below 0.03 in magnitude at every separation from 2 to 64 cells, where the four-fifths law gives about in the inertial range of three-dimensional turbulence. The filtered energy flux averages to less than 5% of its mean magnitude at , 32 and 64 cells, and it is negative, carrying energy to larger scales, on 49 to 53% of the area (Appendix B). Energy is moved up and down the scales in equal measure and nowhere on balance. In the frozen field this is exact, because reversing the sign of every weight leaves the ensemble unchanged and reverses ; co-motion breaks that symmetry without producing a measurable cascade. The scalar, by contrast, cascades forward, as Yaglom’s law requires. Richardson dispersion and the dissipative anomaly in this field do not come from a cascade of energy but from the roughness of the field and the co-motion of its eddies.
Nor is the velocity measurably irreversible. The frozen ensemble is invariant under , , since the cross-fade and the weights are symmetric. The co-moving ensemble is not exactly invariant: every epoch is born on a lattice and carried forward, so its arrangement melts in one direction of time. But the arrangement barely enters the dispersion (Section VI), and pairs separate alike in the two directions, with spontaneous-stochasticity exponents forward and backward. In three-dimensional Navier–Stokes turbulence the cascade gives the velocity an arrow of its own: pairs separate faster backward than forward [63], and fluid particles lose kinetic energy faster than they gain it [64]. This field has neither.
The arrow of time of the anomaly comes from the scalar. For any the scalar problem is irreversible, but in a velocity field whose trajectories are unique the variance lost in a fixed time vanishes with . By the Lagrangian fluctuation–dissipation relation [18], the scalar at is the average of its initial values over the starting points of noisy trajectories run backward from , and the variance it has lost is set by how widely those starting points are spread. Spontaneous stochasticity keeps them spread over a finite region as , so the scalar stays an average of its initial values over a finite patch and loses variance at a finite rate. Time-reversal symmetry is therefore broken spontaneously. At the equations are reversible and the anomaly nearly so, yet the limit of the solutions at picks a direction of time, as a symmetry is picked by a field that has been switched off. Reversing the velocity does not unmix the scalar, because the reversed problem, at any , mixes forward in its own time. The Kraichnan model, whose white-in-time Gaussian velocity is exactly symmetric under time reversal, has the same anomaly [52, 55]; here the same mechanism operates in a velocity with finite correlation times and the sweeping structure of a physical flow. The arrow of time of turbulent mixing does not need a velocity that cascades. It needs trajectories that are not unique.
Relation to the rigorous constructions
The mathematical literature has lately produced velocity fields for which anomalous scalar dissipation is a theorem. Colombo, Crippa and Sorella [24] obtain the full supercritical Obukhov–Corrsin range with a uniform-in- Hölder bound, and show that vanishing diffusivity fails to select a solution; on the other side of the threshold with forbids the anomaly outright [65]. Armstrong and Vicol [23] construct an explicit deterministic field in , , for which every datum dissipates, by a fractal-homogenisation cascade inserting periodic shears at infinitely many scales in Lagrangian coordinates; Eyink [27] identifies it as the first synthetic velocity field carrying the sweeping structure of a physical flow. Burczak, Székelyhidi and Wu [25] combine that machinery with convex integration to obtain the same for scalars advected by weak solutions of Euler.
The field of Definition 1 is complementary. It converges in as (Theorem 2), and [1, 2] prove Richardson’s law for its flow uniformly in , and anomalous dissipation for a passive scalar it advects, the latter both for the truncated fields and for their limit. They do so for a version with abrupt renewals in place of the cross-fade, bounded weights (symmetric, for the dissipation), a radial stream function for the eddy and a small Kubo number. The proof needs one property of the profile, its condition (ND): for a single eddy, the variance of the velocity increment across the separation, , is at least the one along it, . The bump used in our runs, , is neither radial nor , so we checked this direction by direction: holds in every direction to grid accuracy, with near (Appendix A). The measurements here extend the picture to the log-normal weights and the cross-fade of Definition 1, with pair dispersion measured at Kubo numbers from 0.25 to 2. The field is also explicit, cheap, tunable in , and its Lagrangian statistics can be read off directly. It realises the sweeping structure by a different device: where Armstrong and Vicol insert each scale in the Lagrangian coordinates of the preceding ones, Eq. (18) advects the generators and reconvolves, which is what makes Theorem 1 exact rather than asymptotic. The obstruction to is visible in Eq. (28), a residual of order per generation whose ratio to the local amplitude does not decay; Ref. [1] controls it uniformly in the number of generations through the estimate recalled in Section V, by which the coarse flow carries the fine eddy together with the point at which it is read. In the same spirit, Eq. (12) holds here only up to a residual of order : the exact frame is available only in the multivalued construction, and that exchange — exactness of the frame for existence of the field — is the substance of the paper.
Data availability
The code of the construction, the analysis scripts that produce every figure and number in the paper, the run configurations, the data behind the figures and the supplementary movies are available at https://github.com/R1967J/kinematic-field. A single self-contained generator of the velocity field, which depends on nothing else, is in kinematic_field.py at the top level of that repository.
Acknowledgments
We thank Leonid Sarieddine for Theorem 2 and its proof. This work was supported by a grant from the Simons Foundation (00017375; RJ, SM, CdL, DNS, ME).
This model was developed during a retreat in August 2026 at the CIEM (Centro Internacional de Encuentros Matemáticos/International Centre for Mathematical Meetings), a joint initiative of the University of Cantabria and the City Council of Castro Urdiales. We are grateful for their hospitality.
AI usage: Denario [66] was used in the initial stages of this project to explore ideas autonomously. Claude Code and Codex were used to assist with coding, computations, and graphic generation. The ideas, inferences, and results all originate in the (human) brains of the authors. Claude and ChatGPT were used to check citations, spelling, grammar, and inconsistencies. The text was written by the authors, who are responsible for the results, findings, and conclusions of this article.
Numerical methods
a. Field. Eq. (24) is evaluated on an grid. Each measure is deposited with the bilinear (cloud-in-cell) kernel and the generations are summed by fast Fourier transform, at cost . This replaces by , an equally fixed profile, so Theorem 1 holds with replaced by . Sampling a centre deposited at a non-integer position aliases the kernel slightly, but the co-moving arm, whose centres leave the lattice, returns the same as the frozen arm to 0.005 and the same in-band fractions to 0.022. On the grid . The centres are advanced by a second-order Runge–Kutta step with , with interpolated bilinearly. Each generation is rescaled every step, in each arm from its own field, to hold its r.m.s. velocity at its value times (factor 0.64–1.94). Condition (ND) of Ref. [1] is checked for the bump by computing its single-eddy structure function in 19 directions out to .
b. Parameters. Unless stated otherwise , , , and , with generations added while cells: at and at , in both. The octave-spaced runs (Figure 3B,C and the comparison of the two arms’ ) use , , .
c. Dispersion. 3000 pairs per run, , , 20 thresholds, ; shorter runs are censored and flatten spuriously. At least 99.7% of the pairs reach every threshold below at . Twenty seeds at and four at ; the arms share seeds and every contrast is paired. Exponents are local logarithmic slopes by centred differences, errors are standard errors over realisations, and in Eq. (32) is the mean over eight diagnostic realisations per arm.
d. Spontaneous stochasticity. , , pairs and four seeds, to ; errors are a leave-one--out jackknife on the seed-averaged medians. At short times the scheme returns to 0.1%. The backward runs replay the stored field as with the same seeds and Brownian streams.
e. Scalar. Eq. (35) is solved pseudospectrally with dealiasing, an exact integrating factor for and second-order Runge–Kutta advection sub-cycled at ; for the budget run of Figure 3B, with 300 snapshots for the third-order moments, and for the diffusivity scans; averages over the last 40%. The damping of the two lowest shells removes 31% of the production in the budget run and enters Eq. (36) as . The band-forced runs use (, , , ), , , four seeds and at ; runs sharing a seed share the field and the forcing history, so the contrasts are paired, and the window of Eq. (37) is fixed once from and the smallest .
The measurements in detail
Pair dispersion
a. Intermittency and the deficit. With the exponents of the velocity structure functions, gives [51] and gives , so intermittency shifts the deficit by about , which is non-negative by concavity of and vanishes only for a non-intermittent field. The subsection on intermittency below measures it and tests it by lowering the intermittency of the weights. It describes the frozen control, but not the co-moving field, whose deficit moves with the intermittency more than three times as much. We therefore use it only as an order of magnitude. The comparison between the two arms, which share every amplitude, does not rest on it.
b. Scaling range and window. The realised of the octave-spaced field falls from 0.73 at to 0.04 at , identically for , 7 and 8. The half-octave plateau widens from 0.73 decades at to 0.86 at . The window holds five thresholds over 0.31 decades and starts above the release transient at . In exponents the paired contrast over the window is , which involves no . Table 1 gives the window at both resolutions.
| , 20 seeds | , 4 seeds | |
| co-moving | ||
| frozen | ||
| , paired |
Table 1. The window at both resolutions. is the mean over eight diagnostic realisations; the frozen and co-moving arms differ in by and . The of against zero uses local slopes on shared trajectories, which are correlated, and measures pointwise consistency rather than goodness of fit.
c. The release transient and the range above the window. Averaged over , a band that straddles the end of the release transient, the paired contrast is
. Above the scaling range, where is no longer constant, the two arms separate much further, by and at the two resolutions (Figure 2D), but we do not use that range as evidence.
d. The Kubo number. The paired experiment at was repeated at , 0.5 and 2 with eight seeds per arm and everything else unchanged (Table II). One thing moves with Ku: the end of the release transient, located by the sign change of the paired contrast. For it sits at –; at , where the smallest eddies live twice as long, it sits at , and four of the five window thresholds lie inside it, so the frozen and paired window values at are not quoted. Past the transient, over , the paired contrast is negative at every Ku, in 43 of the 44 seeds.
e. The eddy arrangement. In octave-spaced runs (, , three seeds) the dispersion exponents of the lattice and of the Poisson set are and , while switching off the co-motion in the same comparison moves the exponent to , a change of 0.093.
Intermittency
The exponents of Figure 4 and Section VIII come from the frozen control and the field of Definition 1 at with half-octave bands: eight realisations of each at (seeds 0 to 7) and two at (seeds 0 and 1), with six snapshots per realisation, every 250 time units up to (diagnostics/intermittency.py, fitted by analysis/intermittency.py). The increments are taken at fixed time along both grid axes, so the measurement is Eulerian, and are of three kinds: longitudinal ( along and along ), transverse ( along and along ), and of the full vector, , whose second moment defines in Figure 2A. For each, is computed for to 8 in steps of 0.5 at 22 separations spaced geometrically from 2 to cells, and is the least-squares slope of against log for the snapshot-averaged of each realisation over the plateau of Figure 2A, cells at and at , above at both. Values are means over realisations with their standard errors; with two realisations the errors at are only indicative.
| Ku | seeds | co-moving | frozen | |||
| 0.25 | 8 | |||||
| 0.5 | 8 | |||||
| 1 | 20 | |||||
| 2 | 8 | — | — |
Table 2. The paired experiment at four Kubo numbers (, half-octave bands). and in the window , with from eight diagnostic realisations per arm; past the release transient, over , where is not constant, only and the ratio of the frozen to the co-moving separation rate are given. At four of the five window thresholds lie inside the release transient.
A moment is counted as converged when, in every snapshot and at every separation of the fit, the largest single increment carries less than 1% of the sum that makes up . For the vector increment this holds up to at and up to at ( in the frozen control). Beyond, is set by a few of the strongest eddies, those in the log-normal tail of Eq. (17), the fitted varies from realisation to realisation and stops increasing with , and we do not quote it.
Table III gives the exponents of the vector increment. The longitudinal and transverse increments give the same picture: , 0.368, 0.320 and 0.349, 0.314, 0.265 for , 2, 3 in the co-moving field at , and over the plateau lies between 0.034 and 0.039 for every kind of increment, both arms and both resolutions. For the vector increment the two arms agree to 0.002 in for at both resolutions.
Over the window 0.078 of Section VI (20 at , 40 at ), is in the co-moving field and in the frozen control at , and and at , the Eulerian estimate of the shift of the deficit by intermittency (paragraph *Intermittency and the deficit above); the next subsection tests it. The same fits give over the window at , against from the diagnostic realisations of Table I, and at , against . Over the whole plateau the eight realisations give at , with a seed-to-seed scatter of 0.03, so the single realisation of Figure 2A, with , is a typical one.
a. Weaker intermittency. The paired experiment of Section VI was repeated with in Eq. (17), on the twenty seeds of Table I and with the same protocol: , half-octave bands, , 3000 pairs per arm and realisation, , and from eight diagnostic realisations per arm (campaigns/cmu.sh, analysis/cmu.py). The weights at different are made from the same random numbers, so every change with is taken seed by seed. The structure functions were measured as in the previous subsection at and 0.2, eight realisations each. Table IV collects the results. As falls the moments converge to higher orders and the exponents approach the non-intermittent line; the drop matches the She–Lévêque at , by interpolation. At the two arms again agree to 0.002 in , and over the window is unchanged: 0.301 0.011 (co-moving) and 0.304 0.013 (frozen), against 0.299 0.013 and 0.301 0.015 at $c_\mu = 0.3.
From to the frozen deficit moves by , in line with the change of the estimate over the window, . The co-moving deficit moves by , against for the estimate, a difference of (3.2); almost all of it is in , which changes by , while changes by . The runs at were made on a different machine from those at . Re-running the co-moving seeds 0 to 4 at on the second machine changes over the window by , with a seed-to-seed spread of 0.005, so the comparison carries no offset between machines.
b. Clocks. The clocks of Figure 4B come from the frozen control and the field of Definition 1 at , and , four realisations each (diagnostics/clocks.py, analysis/clocks.py). The velocity of generation , , is recorded every time unit for 300 units, after a burn-in of 60, at 4096 tracers pushed as in the dispersion runs and at 4096 fixed points. Its autocorrelation is formed over every time origin, and is the lag at which it first falls to . Over , at the fixed points of the frozen field, where is set by the cross-fade of Eq. (15); along its tracers, which are swept through the eddies; at the fixed points of the co-moving field, past which the eddies are carried; and along its tracers, between 0.73 and 0.88 depending on the bands fitted. Paired seed by seed, the ratio of the co-moving to the frozen clock along tracers grows from at to at , and at fixed points falls from to . The largest generation, which is moved in neither field, gives along tracers. Structure functions in time, , have no scaling range at this resolution: the tracer velocity decorrelates in 28 to 29 time units in the two fields (diagnostics/lagrangian.py, eight realisations each), so we quote no exponents in time. At short lags the local slope of the second-order function along tracers is the steeper in the co-moving field, against at .
| seeds | plateau | window | , window | ||||
| , co-moving | 8 | ||||||
| , frozen | 8 | ||||||
| , co-moving | 2 | ||||||
| , frozen | 2 | ||||||
| She–Lévêque |
Table III. Exponents of the vector increment, , over the plateau ( at , at ), and the estimate of the shift of the deficit by intermittency, over the plateau and over the window of Section VI, with there. Errors are standard errors over realisations. The last row gives the She–Lévêque exponents of Navier–Stokes turbulence.
| co-moving | frozen | excess | |||||
| () | |||||||
| (paper) | () | ||||||
| She–Lévêque |
Table IV. Intermittency of the weights, in Eq. (17), against the exponents of the vector increment over the plateau (, co-moving field, eight realisations), the highest converged order, the estimate over the window of Section VI, and the deficits of the paired dispersion experiment in that window (twenty seed pairs).
The velocity has no cascade
The statement that the field carries no energy cascade rests on the frozen control and the field of Definition 1 at with half-octave bands and , two realisations each (seeds 0 and 1), with 35 snapshots per realisation, every 10 time units from to (diagnostics/cascade.py).
The skewness of the longitudinal increment, , pooled over the increments of along and of along , lies between and at , , , , and cells in all four runs. The four-fifths law, , with , gives in the inertial range of three-dimensional turbulence.
With a Gaussian filter of width , of transfer function , the filtered energy flux , with , averages over the domain and the snapshots to between and times its mean magnitude at , 32 and 64 cells, and is negative on 49.3 to 52.7% of the area.
In the frozen control these quantities vanish in expectation: the weights of Eq. (17) are symmetric, so and have the same law and every odd moment of the velocity is zero. Its measured values therefore give the sampling scatter, which is set by the few eddies of the largest generations. The co-moving field lacks the symmetry, since flipping the signs of the coarse generations changes the paths of the finer centres, but its values fall in the same range: to for the skewness, against to in the frozen control, and to for the normalised flux, against to . The same symmetry, together with the symmetric cross-fade of Eq. (15), makes the frozen ensemble invariant under , . In the co-moving field the departure from that invariance is that each epoch is born on its lattice at the start of its window and not at its end; the arrangement of the centres barely affects the dispersion (Section VI).
Spontaneous stochasticity
Below a pair grows exponentially at a rate of order , so it escapes into the rough range after , a time that grows only logarithmically with ; since , the residual dependence on is only weak. Table V gives the exponent for each number of generations. Over to the median separation at lies between 242 and 279 cells, against , and the 10th, 25th, 75th and 90th percentiles of , divided by the median, agree to within 0.025 at the two ends of that range.
The scalar
a. The inertial–convective asymptote. The random source on the lowest wavenumber shell contributes to the budget, with the normalised forcing correlation, in place of the mean-gradient term, and needs no large-scale damping. Integrating Eq. (36) from the origin then gives an identity in which every term is measured,
with . The first correction is the diffusive transfer, which is linear in ; the other two do not depend on and are small. Over the separations between the resolution limit and the forcing scale the raw flux is 0.825 at and 0.705 at , and with the corrections restored 1.00090.0026 and 0.99810.0026, which pool to Eq. (37).
b. The Obukhov–Corrsin exponent. The band-forced runs give , so . Under the mean gradient, moves towards the Obukhov–Corrsin value by 0.1150.018 when doubles from 32 to 64.
c. The diffusivity scan. The straight line leaves an r.m.s. residual of 0.3%, against 1.3% for a power law. The band-forced runs return because doubles, as the prescribed injection demands.
The centres do not concentrate
Lemma 2. Fix an epoch , let be the flow of , and let have finite -dimensional upper Minkowski content . Then
Proof. The centres in are the birth lattice points in , which has volume because and boundary . Counting points of spacing gives the volume term up to the points in an -neighbourhood of that boundary.
The hypothesis is on the Minkowski content and not the perimeter because the count sees a neighbourhood of the topological boundary, which for a set of finite perimeter can have positive measure. For the log-normal weights the bound on is measured rather than proved (for bounded weights at small Kubo number it is part of Lemma 2.2 of Ref. [1]): Grönwall with is vacuous, since at grows from 8 at to 106 at , but the r.m.s. strain gives , flat from to , and 5.20.2 at , as the self-similarity of Eq. (13) requires. Individual centres do approach one another: over one epoch the smallest nearest-neighbour distance falls from to , and the variance of the count in boxes of side , in units of the mean, is 0.76, 0.59, 0.38 and 0.21 at and 8, against 0.99, 0.98, 0.93 and 1.02 for a Poisson set. Short-range order is lost and long-range uniformity is kept.
Supplementary movies
Movies S1–S4 are single realisations (seed 0) of runs described in the main text, made with the code of the paper; the numbers quoted in the paper come from the campaigns of Appendix A. Each is 1920 1080 at 25 frames per second, one frame per time unit (Movie S3: one per two). Time is shown in units of , the lifetime of Eq. (13) of the smallest eddies. Each title below links to the file in the movies/ directory of the repository named under Data availability.
a. Movie S1. Push the centres, not the field. One generation of eddies, of size cells, in the octave-spaced field of Figure 1C (, , ), moved three ways from the same random numbers, over the central of the domain for 300 time units. Left: the frozen field. Centre: the pattern composed with the flow of the coarser generations, the composition route of Lemma 1. Right: the field of Definition 1, whose centres are carried by and re-convolved with the fixed profile. Colour: vorticity of that generation; grey arrows: . The bars and the strip give the fraction of the generation’s energy inside , the quantity of Figure 1C. Under composition it falls from 0.67 to below 0.05 in about two lifetimes of the smallest eddy and then stays between 0.008 and 0.048; in the frozen field and in Definition 1 it stays between 0.61 and 0.68.
MovieS1_push_the_centres.mp4
b. Movie S2. Who carries the pair. The frozen control (left) and the co-moving field (right) of Section VI at with half-octave bands and , from the same random numbers (seed 0 of the dispersion runs), seen by a fixed camera on the whole periodic domain for 300 time units. Colour: vorticity of the generations with cells, the sizes the pair passes through. Black: one pair released cells apart, chosen close to the median separation in both fields at , with the last 60 time units of its trajectory. In the frozen field the pattern stands still, apart from the renewal of its eddies, and the pair is swept through it; in the co-moving field the pattern moves with the flow. Right: the median separation of all 3000 pairs of the run, which at is 106 cells in the co-moving field and 68 in the frozen one.
MovieS2_who_carries_the_pair.mp4
c. Movie S3. Born at one point. 1500 particles released at one point with independent Brownian kicks, Eq. (34), of diffusivity , , and (columns), for 1000 time units. Top: the field of Definition 1 with eleven half-octave generations (, ), as in Section VI; bottom: its largest generation alone, the smooth control, from the same seed. Colour: vorticity. In the multiscale field each cloud explodes once its particles have escaped the smooth range below , after a time that grows like ; in the smooth control the cloud shrinks with . Right: the median separation at time of 2000 pairs released from coincident points at random positions, for twelve values of from to . At its slope against is 0.030 in the multiscale field and 0.499 in the smooth control, against 0.0333 ± 0.0038 and 0.5000 from the four seeds of Table V.
MovieS3_born_at_one_point.mp4
Colour: vorticity. In the multiscale field each cloud explodes once its particles have escaped the smooth range below , after a time that grows like ; in the smooth control the cloud shrinks with . Right: the median separation at time of 2000 pairs released from coincident points at random positions, for twelve values of from to . At its slope against is 0.030 in the multiscale field and 0.499 in the smooth control, against 0.0333 ± 0.0038 and 0.5000 from the four seeds of Table V.
MovieS3_born_at_one_point.mp4
d. Movie S4. The dissipation does not follow the diffusivity. The scalar of Eq. (35) at (left) and (right), the end points of the scan of Figure 3A, in the co-moving field at with half-octave bands, with the same field and the same source for both. Top: ; bottom: the local dissipation on a logarithmic scale common to both; central of the domain. Right: , after a spin-up of 600 time units (shaded), for the 300 time units shown. Over that interval averages 16.0 at and 19.7 at , a ratio of 1.23 for a factor 5.8 in ; without an anomaly the ratio would be 0.17. This single realisation corresponds to ; Eq. (38) averages six realisations and four diffusivities. The movie integrates the scheme of Appendix A with real transforms.
MovieS4_dissipation_vs_diffusivity.mp4
References
References
- [1]Fefferman, C., Mayboroda, S., Richardson dispersion and anomalous dissipation for the random velocity model with controlled sweeping. Preprint.
- [2]De Lellis, C., An Obukhov–Corrsin–Yaglom law for a kinematic model of turbulence. Preprint.
- [3]Richardson LF (1926) Atmospheric diffusion shown on a distance-neighbour graph. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 110(756):709–737.DOI
- [4]Obukhov AM (1941) Spectral energy distribution in a turbulent flow. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Geogr. Geofiz. 5:453.
- [5]Batchelor GK (1950) The application of the similarity theory of turbulence to atmospheric diffusion. Q. J. R. Meteorol. Soc. 76(328):133–146.
- [6]Onsager L (1949) Statistical hydrodynamics. Nuovo Cimento 6(Suppl. 2):279–287.DOI
- [7]Eyink GL, Sreenivasan KR (2006) Onsager and the theory of hydrodynamic turbulence. Rev. Mod. Phys. 78(1):87–135.DOI
- [8]Obukhov AM (1949) Structure of the temperature field in a turbulent flow. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Geogr. Geofiz. 13:58.
- [9]Corrsin S (1951) On the spectrum of isotropic temperature fluctuations in an isotropic turbulence. J. Appl. Phys. 22(4):469–473.DOI
- [10]Donzis DA, Sreenivasan KR, Yeung PK (2005) Scalar dissipation rate and dissipative anomaly in isotropic turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 532:199–216.DOI
- [11]Constantin P, E W, Titi ES (1994) Onsager’s conjecture on the energy conservation for solutions of Euler’s equation. Comm. Math. Phys. 165(1):207–209.DOI
- [12]Constantin P (2001) An Eulerian–Lagrangian approach for incompressible fluids: local theory. J. Amer. Math. Soc. 14(2):263–278. arXiv:math/0004059.DOI
- [13]Constantin P (2001) An Eulerian–Lagrangian approach to the Navier–Stokes equations. Comm. Math. Phys. 216(3):663–686. arXiv:math/0005116.DOI
- [14]Constantin P, Vicol V, Wu J (2015) Analyticity of Lagrangian trajectories for well posed inviscid incompressible fluid models. Adv. Math. 285:352–393. arXiv:1403.5749.arxiv.org/abs/1403.5749
- [15]Frisch U, Zheligovsky V (2014) A very smooth ride in a rough sea. Comm. Math. Phys. 326(2):499–505. arXiv:1212.4333.DOI
- [16]Isett P (2018) A proof of Onsager’s conjecture. Ann. of Math. 188(3):871–963.arxiv.org/abs/1608.08301
- [17]De Lellis C, Székelyhidi L Jr (2019) On turbulence and geometry: from Nash to Onsager. Notices Amer. Math. Soc. 66(5):677–685.arxiv.org/abs/1901.02318
- [18]Drivas TD, Eyink GL (2017) A Lagrangian fluctuation–dissipation relation for scalar turbulence. Part I. Flows with no bounding walls. J. Fluid Mech. 829:153–189.
- [19]Bourgoin M, Ouellette NT, Xu H, Berg J, Bodenschatz E (2006) The role of pair dispersion in turbulent flow. Science 311(5762):835–838.
- [20]Elsinga GE, Ishihara T, Hunt JCR (2022) Non-local dispersion and the reassessment of Richardson’s t³-scaling law. J. Fluid Mech. 932:A17.DOI
- [21]Sawford BL (2001) Turbulent relative dispersion. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 33:289–317.
- [22]Salazar JPLC, Collins LR (2009) Two-particle dispersion in isotropic turbulent flows. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 41:405–432DOI
- [23]Armstrong S, Vicol V (2025) Anomalous diffusion by fractal homogenization. Ann. PDE 11(1):art. 2. arXiv:2305.05048.arxiv.org/abs/2305.05048
- [24]Colombo M, Crippa G, Sorella M (2023) Anomalous dissipation and lack of selection in the Obukhov–Corrsin theory of scalar turbulence. Ann. PDE 9(2):art. 21. arXiv:2207.06833.arxiv.org/abs/2207.06833
- [25]Burczak J, Székelyhidi L Jr, Wu B (2023) Anomalous dissipation and Euler flows. arXiv:2310.02934.arxiv.org/abs/2310.02934
- [26]Hess-Childs E, Rowan K (2025) Turbulent and intermittent phenomena in a universal total anomalous dissipator. arXiv:2508.00115.
- [27]Eyink GL (2024) Onsager’s “ideal turbulence” theory. J. Fluid Mech. 988:P1.
- [28]Kraichnan RH (1970) Diffusion by a random velocity field. Phys. Fluids 13(1):22–31.DOI
- [29]Fung JCH, Hunt JCR, Malik NA, Perkins RJ (1992) Kinematic simulation of homogeneous turbulence by unsteady random Fourier modes. J. Fluid Mech. 236:281–318.DOI
- [30]Fung JCH, Vassilicos JC (1998) Two-particle dispersion in turbulentlike flows. Phys. Rev. E 57(2):1677–1690.DOI
- [31]Malik NA, Vassilicos JC (1999) A Lagrangian model for turbulent dispersion with turbulent-like flow structure: comparison with direct numerical simulation for two-particle statistics. Phys. Fluids 11(6):1572–1580.DOI
- [32]Çağlar M (2007) Velocity fields with power-law spectra for modeling turbulent flows. Appl. Math. Model. 31(9):1934–1946.DOI
- [33]Çağlar M, Çinlar E (2001) Lyapunov exponents of Poisson shot-noise velocity fields. Stoch. Process. Appl. 94(1):29–49.DOI
- [34]Townsend AA (1976) The Structure of Turbulent Shear Flow, 2nd Ed. (Cambridge Univ Press, Cambridge).
- [35]Lundgren TS (1982) Strained spiral vortex model for turbulent fine structure. Phys. Fluids 25(12):2193–2203.DOI
- [36]Pullin DI, Saffman PG (1993) On the Lundgren–Townsend model of turbulent fine scales. Phys. Fluids A 5(1):126–145.DOI
- [37]Thomson DJ, Devenish BJ (2005) Particle pair separation in kinematic simulations. J. Fluid Mech. 526:277–302.DOI
- [38]Eyink GL, Benveniste D (2013) Suppression of particle dispersion by sweeping effects in synthetic turbulence. Phys. Rev. E 87(2):023011.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23496614
- [39]Osborne DR, Vassilicos JC, Sung K-S, Haigh JD (2006) Fundamentals of pair diffusion in kinematic simulations of turbulence. Phys. Rev. E 74(3):036309.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17025745
- [40]Dávila J, Vassilicos JC (2003) Richardson’s pair diffusion and the stagnation point structure of turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 91(14):144501.DOI
- [41]Devenish BJ, Thomson DJ (2009) Comment on “Fundamentals of pair diffusion in kinematic simulations of turbulence”. Phys. Rev. E 80(4):048301.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19905492
- [42]Malik NA (2017) Residual sweeping errors in turbulent particle pair diffusion in a Lagrangian diffusion model. PLoS ONE 12(12):e0189917.DOI
- [43]Nicolleau F, Vassilicos JC (2003) Turbulent pair diffusion. Phys. Rev. Lett. 90(2):024503.
- [44]Jullien M-C, Paret J, Tabeling P (1999) Richardson pair dispersion in two-dimensional turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 82(14):2872–2875.DOI
- [45]Belinicher VI, L’vov VS (1987) A scale-invariant theory of fully developed hydrodynamic turbulence. Sov. Phys. JETP 66(2):303.
- [46]Lacorata G, Vulpiani A (2017) Chaotic Lagrangian models for turbulent relative dispersion. Phys. Rev. E 95(4):043106.DOI
- [47]Ghate AS, Lele SK (2017) Subfilter-scale enrichment of planetary boundary layer large eddy simulation using discrete Fourier–Gabor modes. J. Fluid Mech. 819:494–539.DOI
- [48]Ghate AS, Lele SK (2020) Gabor mode enrichment in large eddy simulations of turbulent flow. J. Fluid Mech. 903:A13.DOI
- [49]Artale V, Boffetta G, Celani A, Cencini M, Vulpiani A (1997) Dispersion of passive tracers in closed basins: beyond the diffusion coefficient. Phys. Fluids 9(11):3162–3171.DOI
- [50]Aurell E, Boffetta G, Crisanti A, Paladin G, Vulpiani A (1997) Predictability in the large: an extension of the concept of Lyapunov exponent. J. Phys. A 30(1):1–26.DOI
- [51]Boffetta G, Sokolov IM (2002) Relative dispersion in fully developed turbulence: the Richardson’s law and intermittency corrections. Phys. Rev. Lett. 88(9):094501.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11864014
- [52]Bernard D, Gawȩdzki K, Kupiainen A (1998) Slow modes in passive advection. J. Stat. Phys. 90(3–4):519–569.
- [53]Eyink GL, Drivas TD (2015) Spontaneous stochasticity and anomalous dissipation for Burgers equation. J. Stat. Phys. 158(2):386–432.DOI
- [54]Yaglom AM (1949) On the local structure of the temperature field in a turbulent flow. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 69(6):743–746.
- [55]Falkovich G, Gawȩdzki K, Vergassola M (2001) Particles and fields in fluid turbulence. Rev. Mod. Phys. 73(4):913–975.DOI
- [56]Gotoh T, Watanabe T (2015) Power and nonpower laws of passive scalar moments convected by isotropic turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 115(11):114502.DOI
- [57]Saito I, Watanabe T, Gotoh T (2024) Spectrum of passive scalar carried by particles in isotropic turbulence. Phys. Rev. Fluids 9(5):054601.DOI
- [58]Iyer KP, Yeung PK (2014) Structure functions and applicability of Yaglom’s relation in passive-scalar turbulent mixing at low Schmidt numbers with uniform mean gradient. Phys. Fluids 26(8):085107.DOI
- [59]Bedrossian J, Blumenthal A, Punshon-Smith S (2022) Lagrangian chaos and scalar advection in stochastic fluid mechanics. J. Eur. Math. Soc. 24(6):1893–1990.arxiv.org/abs/1809.06484
- [60]Bedrossian J, Blumenthal A, Punshon-Smith S (2022) The Batchelor spectrum of passive scalar turbulence in stochastic fluid mechanics at fixed Reynolds number. Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 75(6):1237–1291.arxiv.org/abs/1911.11014
- [61]Kraichnan RH (1968) Small-scale structure of a scalar field convected by turbulence. Phys. Fluids 11(5):945–953.DOI
- [62]She Z-S, Lévêque E (1994) Universal scaling laws in fully developed turbulence. Phys. Rev. Lett. 72(3):336–339.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10056405
- [63]Berg J, Lüthi B, Mann J, Ott S (2006) Backwards and forwards relative dispersion in turbulent flow: an experimental investigation. Phys. Rev. E 74(1):016304.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16907188
- [64]Xu H, et al. (2014) Flight-crash events in turbulence. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 111(21):7558–7563.DOI
- [65]Drivas TD, Elgindi TM, Iyer G, Jeong I-J (2022) Anomalous dissipation in passive scalar transport. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 243(3):1151–1180.arxiv.org/abs/1911.03271



