WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Structure of the B and Li nuclei and the astrophysical -factor of the Be()B direct capture process within a three-body model
Abstract
The structure of the ground and excited bound states of the B and Li nuclei is studied within the framework of the He(H)+ three-body potential cluster model based on the hyperspherical Lagrange-mesh method. The two-body realistic potentials have been applied from the literature. Convergent theoretical estimates for the three-body binding energy and matter radius have been obtained with the maximal hypermomentum and 28 for the ground and excited states, respectively. The ANC value of the virtual transition of the B nucleus is estimated self-consistently by matching the overlap integral of the B three-body and the Be two-body wave functions with it's asymptotics. The obtained values are ~fm and ~fm in the spin 1 and spin 2 channels, respectively. For the ANC values of the Li nucleus the estimates ~fm and ~fm are extracted. The ratio implies a breaking of the mirror symmetry of the strong nuclear forces of order 27% due to the Coulomb interaction and the dynamical three-body effects. For the -factor an estimate eV b was obtained based on the asymptotic theory developed by D. Baye [Phys. Rev. C 62,065803 (2000)]. The spin 2 channel contributes with eV b, while the spin 1 channel yields eV b. These results for are in a good agreement with the estimate eV b of the SF II, but larger than the recommended value eV b of the SF III. At the same time, our estimate is very close to the value 22.4 eV b used in the most successful Solar Model BAR2M [W.~Yang and Z.~Tian, AJ 970 (2024), 38].
Introduction
The radiative capture reaction plays a significant role in nuclear astrophysics, particularly in understanding solar neutrino production processes within the proton-proton ()-chain [1, 2]. The low-energy cross section of this reaction cannot be measured directly with high precision due to the Coulomb barrier and the extremely small reaction probabilities at stellar energies [2]. Therefore, different types of reliable theoretical techniques have been developed for the extrapolation of the -factor to zero energy [3, 4]. The estimation of the asymptotic normalization coefficient (ANC) for the virtual decay is a basis of the study of the direct capture processes in nuclear astrophysics [5, 6]. The ANC plays the main role in reliably estimating of the cross-section (astrophysical factor) of important reactions in the ultralow energy region, including zero energy [1]. Traditionally, the empirical ANC values are determined from different types of nuclear transfer reactions [7, 8, 9] within the distorted-wave Born approximation (DWBA). The empirical value of the squared ANC for the virtual decay has been extracted from the analysis of the experimental differential cross-sections of the and proton transfer reactions [8]. On the other hand, the analysis of the reaction predicted a value [9] for this quantity. The ANC value can also be calculated within purely realistic theoretical models such as the microscopic three-body cluster model [10], the no-core shell model/resonating group method (NCSM/RGM) [11], and Skyrme Hartree-Fock theory [12], as well as halo effective field theory (EFT) [13, 14] at next-to-leading order. The three-body calculations of the ANC value for the virtual transition have been done in the hyperspherical harmonics method [15, 16]. The latter method was limited by the value of the maximal hypermomentum, which requires careful verification of the convergence of the results obtained there.
Particular attention should be paid to calculations performed within the framework of different approaches. Nollett and Wiringa obtained a squared ANC value using a combination of the realistic Argonne V18 two-nucleon and Urbana IX three-nucleon potentials within the variational Monte-Carlo method (VMC) [17], slightly different from the value of of P. Navratil et al. within the no-core shell model/resonating group method (NCSM/RGM) [11]. The same NCSM was previously applied with a realistic CD-Bonn 2000 NN-potential yielding the result for the squared ANC and for the zero-energy factor [18]. The new result of the same group within the NCSM with continuum based on the chiral effective field theory NN-potentials at the NLO plus three-nucleon potentials turned out to be smaller with [19]. On the other hand, the experimental values of the -wave scattering lengths were not reproduced in last work. Since the initial -wave channel yields the main contribution to the synthesis process, its reliable description is preferable.
In addition to above results, the estimates from the halo effective field theory (EFT) [13, 14] and obtained within the Bayesian approximation [20] demonstrate clearly that the problem of determination of the ANC and the astrophysical factor with a high precision from the theory is still far from being resolved, since the range of ANC estimates from to is quite large. In addition, the zero-energy astrophysical factor was extracted by an indirect method [4] by employing the measured solar B and Be neutrino fluxes of the Borexino Collaboration [21], which yields .
One should note that the new SFIII recommended value [1] mostly based on the results of Ref. [19], is quite smaller than the SFII estimate [2]. On the other hand, the most successful new Solar Model BAR2M [22] is based on the value for this quantity, as well as previous Solar Models [23].
Another important point is that the potential models which account for cluster effects in nuclei explicitly, can complement the methods in describing the astrophysical reactions with light nuclei. Recent studies of the direct capture process within the three-body model [24, 25, 26, 27, 28] on the basis of the hyperspherical Lagrange-mesh method have demonstrated that it can explain in details the data of direct measurements of the LUNA collaboration [29, 30]. The three-body model was able to reproduce not only the absolute values, but also the energy and temperature dependence, of the astrophysical factor and the reaction rates, respectively. The obtained result for the primordial abundance of the Li element in the Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) model is close to the Standard Model estimate [26]. The most important results of that research was a consistent realistic description of the isospin-forbidden astrophysical -factor due-to very small isotiplet component of the Li nucleus of order which yields the main contribution to the capture process at low energies below 100 keV.
A two-body effective potential model within a single-channel approximation [31] provides a good description of the direct astrophysical capture process mostly due-to the correct reproduction of the -wave scattering length [32]. The model reproduces the existing experimental data for the astrophysical factor in the energy region up to 6 MeV, while yielding the squared ANC value of and the zero-energy factor , consistent with the Solar Fusion II (SFII) estimate [2]. However, this model does not take into account the effects of the Be core excitation, and the obtained results should be considered as a first approximation within the framework of the approach based on the cluster model.
A determination of the ANC value for the virtual decay is important for the study of the capture reaction in neutron-rich stars [33, 34]. This reaction is also useful for the study of the mirror symmetry properties of strong nuclear forces. The most important value for the squared ANC value for the virtual decay [35] was obtained from the analysis of the experimental differential cross-sections of the transfer reaction in the frame of the DWIA. In particular, the authors of Refs. [15, 36] have studied the three-body structure of the Li nucleus with further application to the radiative capture process within the hyperspherical harmonics method. Burkova et al. [37] have calculated the total cross sections of the neutron radiative capture reaction on Li at the low energy region in the frame of the two-body potential cluster model.
The aim of the present work is to calculate the ANC values of the virtual decays and in the spin 1 and spin 2 channels within a self-consistent three-body potential cluster model using realistic , , and two-body interaction potentials. Furthermore, the obtained ANC values will be applied for the estimation of the astrophysical factor of the radiative capture reaction at the zero-energy. For this purpose we calculate the characteristics of the B and Li nuclei in the framework of the three-body potential cluster model in the hyperspherical Lagrange-mesh method. The formalism of the hyperspherical method is well known as presented in Refs. [38, 39, 40], and is widely used to study the three-body structure, energy spectra, and spectroscopic information of light nuclei.
The article is organized as follows. The theoretical model will be briefly described in Section II, the two-body interaction potentials are given in § 3, the numerical results are presented in § 4, and the conclusions are drawn in the last section.
THEORETICAL MODEL
In this section, a theoretical model for the three-particle quantum system in hyperspherical coordinates is briefly described. The mass numbers are given by (in units of the nucleon mass ), and the space coordinates are . The three-body Hamiltonian is written as [40, 41, 42]
where is the kinetic energy of the –th nucleus, and is a nucleus-nucleus interaction potential. Starting from coordinates in Figure 1, we define the Jacobi coordinates and () as [40]

Figure 1. The Jacobi coordinates for the three-body system + + p(n).
where is an even permutation of and the reduced mass numbers are defined as
The hyperradius and hyperangle are then defined
as , , respectively. The hyperangle and the orientations and provide a set of angles . In this notation the kinetic energy reads [40, 41]
where is the c.m. kinetic energy, and is a five-dimensional angular momentum operator whose eigenfunctions (with eigenvalues ) are given by [40, 43]
where is a normalization factor [39], is the hypermomentum, and are the orbital momenta associated with the coordinates and , respectively, is a positive integer defined by , is the Jacobi polynomial. Introducing the spin component as a tensor product of the proton (neutron) and spin functions
for the hyperspherical function with total momentum and its projection , one obtaines:
where the index stands for . The wave function , which is a solution of the Schrödinger equation associated with the Hamiltonian Eq. (1), is expanded over basis functions as [41]
where are hyperradial wave functions to be determined. Rigorously, the summation over involves an infinite number of terms. In practice, this expansion is limited by a maximal value, denoted as . For weakly bound states, it is well known that the convergence is rather slow, and therefore the large values of are required. The radial functions are derived from a set of coupled differential equations [41]
with . The potential terms are given by the contribution of the three nucleus-nucleus interactions
where the nuclear (N) and Coulomb (C) terms have been explicitly written. The system of coupled equations Eq. (8) is solved by expanding the trial function over the Lagrange-mesh basis function. The Pauli forbidden states in the three-body system are eliminated with the help of the orthogonalizing pseudopotentials (OPP) method [41].
Cluster-cluster interaction potentials
interaction potential
For the interaction, a nuclear potential with odd-even splitting proposed by Voronchev et al. [44] was used. The potential includes a deep Pauli-forbidden state in the -wave and provides an accurate description of the phase shifts for both and elastic scattering in the -, -, - partial waves within the energy range of 0-20 MeV:
The radial dependencies of the central and spin-orbital terms have been accurately parameterized using the Gaussian functions
with the parameters given in Table I. The Coulomb part of the interaction [45].
| Parity | , MeV | , MeV | , fm | , fm |
| Even | -66.580 | -12.169 | 0.6203 | 0.8032 |
| Odd | -46.303 | -15.931 | 0.4321 | 0.6282 |
Table 1. The potential parameters of the interaction [44].
-He(H) interaction potential
The central -He and -H two-body potentials are also taken in a simple Gaussian form [46]:
where the Coulomb part is given as
with the Coulomb radius fm, and charge numbers , of the first and second clusters, respectively. The parameters of the central part of the potential are specified for each partial wave (see Table II), while a value of fm is the same for all partial waves [46]. The potential had been constructed according to the classification of orbital states of the Young schemes. It contains two Pauli forbidden states in the -waves, and a single forbidden state in each of the partial - and -waves. The energy values of these states are presented in the second row of the table.
The interaction potential describes the experimental data [47, 48, 49] quite accurately for the He+ and H+ phase shifts in the -, -, - and - partial waves.
| , MeV | -67.47 | -81.92 | -83.83 | -66.0 | -69.0 | -75.9 | -84.8 |
| , MeV | -36.0; -7.4 | -27.5 | -28.4 | -2.9 | -4.1 | - | - |
Table 2. Values of the depth parameter of the -He (H) potential for different partial waves [46].
He(H) interaction potential
The He and H two-body potentials are taken as a sum of the Gaussian attractive and the exponential repulsive nuclear parts [50] with an additional Coulomb term:
The Coulomb part of the potential is given with the point-like charge distribution. It also contains a Pauli forbidden state in the -wave. The potential parameters are given in Table III. The last column contains energies of the corresponding forbidden states in the singlet and triplet -waves.
| , MeV | , fm | , MeV | , fm | , MeV | |
| even | -110.0 | 0.37 | 45.0 | 0.67 | -9.0(-11.4) |
| odd | -14.0 | 0.10 | |||
| even | -43.0 | 0.26 | -3.6(-5.3) | ||
| -10.0 | 0.10 | - | |||
| -15.0 | 0.10 | - | |||
| -20.0 | 0.10 | - |
Table 3. Parameters of the He(H) interaction potential in different partial waves [50].
Numerical results
Energies of the ground and first excited bound states
The three-body bound state wave functions of the B and Li nuclei are calculated using the hyperspherical Lagrange-mesh method [40] with the above described , -He(H), and He(H) two-body interaction potentials. The parameter values MeV fm, , , , and MeV fm are used throughout numerical calculations. The charge numbers are , , and , , for the B and Li nuclei, respectively. Actually, the three-body calculations must reproduce the three-body bound state energies. In our case, the three-body calculations reproduce approximately the experimental energy values in respect to the three-body threshold, -1.724 MeV and -4.499 MeV [51] for the ground states of the and nuclei, respectively, without including any three-body forces. The projecting constant MeV which enables a convergence of the OPP method for eliminating all Pauli forbidden states from the functional space of the three-body wave functions. In panel (a) of Figure 2 we present a convergence of the energy values of the ground and first excited bound states of the and nuclei in respect to the maximal hypermomentum . The ground state energies are saturated at for both nuclei. For the excited bound states, all the two-body potentials are slightly renormalized by a scaling factor of 1.02 in order to reproduce the experimental energy values of -0.954 MeV and -3.518 MeV [51], respectively. This procedure is equivalent to adding a three-body potential and is even used to describe the ground states of nuclei [40]. In panel (b) of Figure 2 we show a convergence of the energy values in respect to the for the first excited bound states. One can note here that a convergence of the energy values for the excited states is slower than for the ground states. The calculated bound state energies are presented in Table IV in comparison with the experimental data [51].

Figure 2. Convergence of the ground (a) and first excited (b) bound state energies of the , nuclei with respect to .
Table IV. Calculated bound state energies (MeV) and matter radii (fm).
Nucleon separation energies of the and nuclei
The proton separation energy of the ground state is a key characteristic for the study of the ANC of the virtual transition. In the two-body cluster model the proton separation is easily reproduced with the help of the high-accuracy Lagrange-mesh and Numerov algorithms. However, reproducing the proton separation energy within the three-body model is a rather complex task due to its very small value MeV [51] and the limited in the numerical calculations.
The two-body energies for the ground states of the and nuclei have been calculated using a highly accurate Lagrange-Laguerre mesh method [54] with the same – and – potentials of Ref. [46], which were used for the calculation of the three-body energy and wave functions of the and nuclei. The calculations have been done with the number of mesh points and a scaling parameter . The calculated binding energy values of the ground and the first excited bound states of the nucleus are 1.5924 MeV and 1.1368 MeV, respectively. Thus, theoretical results slightly differ from the experimental data of 1.5866 MeV and 1.1575 MeV, respectively [55]. The corresponding binding energies of the ground and the first excited bound states of the mirror nucleus are 2.4656 MeV and 1.9943 MeV, close to the experimental data [55].
Similar to the three-body binding energy, the theoretical proton separation energy of the nucleus strongly depends on the value of the maximal hypermomentum . The momentum is subtracted from the binding energy using the theoretical estimate MeV and the equation . The neutron separation energy of the nucleus is estimated in an analogous way: with MeV in the channel. In Table V the calculated values of the three-body binding energies of the and nuclei and the corresponding proton and neutron separation energies are presented in dependence on the maximal value of the hypermomentum . As can be seen from the table, a good convergence of the results for the proton separation energy is achieved at and 22. However, a limitation [15, 16] does not enable convergent results. In the case of the nucleus, the neutron separation energy is well reproduced beginning from due to absence of the Coulomb interaction between the core and the neutron.
| 8 | 12 | 16 | 20 | 22 | Exp. | |
| (MeV) | 1.3901 | 1.6221 | 1.6895 | 1.7121 | 1.7175 | 1.7236 |
| (MeV) | -0.0203 | 0.0297 | 0.0971 | 0.1197 | 0.1251 | 0.1375 |
| (MeV) | 4.1005 | 4.2846 | 4.3274 | 4.3380 | 4.3399 | 4.4992 |
| (MeV) | 1.6349 | 1.8190 | 1.8618 | 1.8724 | 1.8743 | 2.0323 |
Table V. Dependence of the proton separation energy of the g.s. and of the neutron separation energy of the g.s. on the value of .
Matter radii
The root-mean-square (rms) nuclear matter radii of the and nuclei can be calculated with the help of the three-body wave functions. The matter radius of the nucleus is defined as:
where [56], [57], and [58] are experimental charge radii of the corresponding nuclei. The mean square hyperradius is calculated numerically.
In the case of the nucleus, the matter radius is calculated using the value [57] instead of as for the second particle. In Figure 3 we examine a convergence of the calculated matter radii for the ground states of the and nuclei as a function of , which varies from 4 up to 22. Within the developed three-body model the matter rms radius of the one-proton halo nucleus is overestimated by about 5%. At the same time, the rms radius of the nucleus is reproduced within the experimental error bar [53]. In Table IV we present the rms matter radii in comparison with experimental data from Refs. [52, 53]. These theoretical results differ slightly from the values 2.56 fm and 2.38 fm obtained using the similar method in Ref. [15] for the and nuclei, respectively. However, one should note that the results of Ref. [15] have been obtained with the value .

Figure 3. Convergence of the matter radii of the and nuclei with respect to .
ANC and the astrophysical factor
For the estimation of the ANC values within the three-body model we rewrite the three-body bound state wave function of the and nuclei as described in equation (7), renormalized in relative coordinates , in the following form
where is a hyperradius, is a hyperangle, are the hyperspherical harmonics. The Jacobi coordinates (between the -particle and (or and (between the (or and the proton (or the neutron)) and the relative coordinates , are related as and , respectively.
In order to extract the ANC value for the virtual decay in the or spin fixed channel, the overlap integral is matched with its asymptotics at large values of the relative distance between the core and the proton:
where is known Whittaker function, is the wave number, is the Sommerfeld parameter, and
is an effective wave function. The wave number is calculated at the separation energy 0.1375 MeV of the bound state into the proton and . In the case of the nucleus, the neutron separation energy is 2.0323 MeV. Integration in Eq. (17) is done over the spatial variable , angular variable , and the spin coordinates and . Since a value of is fixed, we denote the ANC as for simplicity.
In the present three-body model, over the interval 3 - 10 fm follows the expected asymptotic behavior . In Figure 4 the overlap integrals with the initial three-body and the corrected asymptotics are presented. For the ground state the spin 1 channel asymptotics is corrected at the matching point fm, while for the main spin 2 channel fm. In the case of the ground state the asymptotics is corrected at the matching points fm and fm in the spin 1 and spin 2 channels, respectively.

(a)

(b)
Figure 4. Overlap integrals in the spin 1 and spin 2 channels with the initial three-body and the corrected asymptotics for the ground () states of the B (a) and Li (b) nuclei.
From above Eq. (17) one can estimate a value of ANC self-consistently in a theoretical way. At asymptotic distance between the () core and the valence proton (neutron) the ANC value is calculated with the help of the ratio . A physical
| Method | , fm | eV b | Refs. |
| Hyperspherical Lagrange-mesh | 0.591 0.013 | 22.492 0.503 | Present work |
| Two-body potential model | [31] | ||
| Microscopic three-body (He p) model | 0.668 | 25.38 | [10] |
| 0.812 | 30.86 | [10] | |
| NCSM/CD Bonn 2000 NN | 0.587 | 22.1 1.0 (at keV) | [18] |
| NCSM/RGM | 0.509 | 19.4 0.7 | [11] |
| NCSM/ChEFT NN+3N | 19.8 0.3 | [19] | |
| Halo EFT at NLO | 0.564 0.023 | 21.3 0.7 | [13, 14] |
| Variational Monte-Carlo ab initio | 0.537 0.027 | [17] | |
| MDWBA BeB | 0.613 0.060 | 22.8 2.2 | [9] |
| MDWBA B(Be,B)Be; N(Be,B)C | 0.465 0.041 | 18.2 1.8 | [8] |
| Breakup Pb(B,pBe)Pb | 0.548 | (th) 0.50(exp) | [60] |
| CDCCM BeB | (th) 0.070(exp) | (th) 2.7(exp) | [61] |
| Coulomb breakup A(B,pBe)A | 0.450 0.072 | 17.4 1.5 | [62] |
| Ni(B,pBe)Ni | 0.543 0.027 | 20.8 1.1 | [63] |
| R-matrix Be(p,)B | 0.518 | 19.41 | [64] |
| ANC method | 17.60 | [65] | |
| Phenomenological way | 20.9 0.6(th) 0.7(exp) | [66] | |
| 21.2 0.7 | [67] | ||
| 20.0 0.8 | [68] | ||
| Three-body hyperspherical harmonics method | 19.2 0.1 | [15] | |
| Microscopic shell model | 21.4 28.3 | [69] | |
| GCM | 24.5 31.5 | [69] | |
| Source term approach | 0.389 0.431 | [70] | |
| Updated source term approach | 0.451 | [71] | |
| From solar neutrino fluxes | 19.5 1.9 | [4] | |
| Solar fusion II | 20.8 0.7(th) 1.4(exp) | [2] | |
| Solar fusion III | 20.5 0.7 | [1] |
Table VI. Values of the squared ANC () for the BBe+p and astrophysical factor for the Be(p,)B capture reaction from different sources.
ANC value is determined from the stable plateau region as a function of the matching point [59]. In Figure 5 we show a dependence of the calculated values of in the spin 1 () and spin 2 () channels on the matching point for the ground states of the B and Li nuclei. The stable plateau region in the spin 1 channel of the B nucleus is a range from 3.5 to 7 fm, and the average ANC value fm. In the spin 2 channel of this nucleus a stable plateau begins from 5.0 fm up to 9.0 fm which yields . The corresponding estimates within the ab initio NCSM/RGM approach are and , respectively [11]. An estimate for the sum of the squared ANC values in the present model is consistent with the NCSM/CD Bonn 2000 NN [18], but larger than the ab initio NCSM/RGM result of [11]. Additionally, the three-body result is consistent with the result of the halo EFT at NLO within the error bars [13, 14].
(a)
(b)
Figure 5. Calculated ANC values for the ground () states of the B (a) and Li (b) nuclei in dependence on the matching point of the overlap integral with its asymptotics.
The ANC value is calculated also for the mirror nucleus virtual transition . In the spin 1 channel, a value was obtained in the stable plateau region of (3.5 - 7) fm. And in the spin 2 channel the stable plateau region (5.0-9.0) fm yields the result . For the sum of the squared ANC the present model yields a value , while the microscopic model of Ref. [10] gives . These numbers can be compared with the experimental value extracted from the data for the neutron transfer reaction [35], which seems too small.
Now we aim to examine the mirror symmetry of the strong nuclear forces between the two mirror processes and . The charge symmetry of the strong interaction implies a relation between the asymptotic normalization coefficients of the mirror nuclei and [72, 73, 74, 75]. According to Ref. [75] the modified approximate relation
is predicted at the nuclear interior radius fm, where and are regular Coulomb and spherical Bessel functions, respectively. The parameters and represent the spectroscopic factors for the and mirror nuclei. The wave numbers and are calculated from corresponding proton and neutron separation energies MeV and MeV for the and mirror nuclei, respectively. The numerical calculations yield and . Then the value can be compared with the value of . A difference between the two numbers is understood as a result of breaking of the mirror symmetry of nuclear forces by the three-body dynamical effects as was explained in Ref. [75] and by the Coulomb interaction.
The astrophysical factor is calculated on the basis of the theoretical formalism developed in Ref. [3] which connects this quantity with the -wave scattering length. This theory is based on the replacement of the initial -wave scattering and final -wave bound state functions of the system by the asymptotic wave functions, the Whittaker and Coulomb functions, respectively. This approach is consistent with the one proton halo structure of the nucleus with a very small binding energy of MeV. Using the most precise experimental values of the -wave scattering lengths from Ref. [32] fm and fm in the spin 1 and spin 2 channels, respectively, one can estimate the astrophysical factor. According to this theory, each term of the sum of the astrophysical factors at zero energy in the spin 1 and spin 2 channels is expressed as (see Eq. (27) of Ref. [3])
in eV b with in fm. In the spin 1 channel with the zero-energy -factor eV b. In the spin 2 channel with we obtain eV b. Thus, for the total astrophysical -factor the three-body model yields a value eV b, where the error bars are summed quadratically.
An interesting point is that our theoretical estimate for the astrophysical factor has been obtained on the basis of the asymptotic theory of D. Baye [3] using the best ANC values and , extracted from the three-body wave function, and the values of the -wave scattering lengths in the spin 1 and spin 2 channels, extracted in Ref. [32] within the R-matrix theory. At the same time, in the last work, the R-matrix fit was performed with the ANC values of 0.315(19) and 0.662(19) in the spin 1 and spin 2 channels, respectively. Moreover, a value of the ANC square in present study is quite different from the estimate of 0.537(27) [17]. The seemed discrepancy can be understood with the help of the statement that the fit to the scattering data was not highly sensitive to the choice of ANC values in that R-matrix analysis, and although the elastic scattering data was fitted reasonably well, but the inelastic scattering data could not be explained [32].
The calculated results of the total squared ANC value for the virtual decay and the astrophysical factor eV b for the direct capture reaction obtained in the present three-body model are compared in Table VI with the results of different theoretical methods and experimental measurements from Refs. [1, 2, 4, 8, 9, 10, 11, 13, 14, 15, 17, 18, 19, 31, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71].
As can be seen from the table, the present results are in a good agreement with the results and eV b [9] extracted from the experimental differential cross-section of the proton transfer reaction using the MDWBA approach. The results of the Halo Effective Field Theory [13, 14] studies are much more close to the present three-body model, than the microscopic models of Ref. [10]. Another observation is that the theoretical studies based on the three-body hyperspherical method [15], R-matrix calculations [64], the ANC method [65], NCSH/RGM [11], NCSM/ChEFT NN+3N [19] yield for the astrophysical factor estimates, lower than 20 eV b, mostly consistent with the Solar Fusion III analysis, while the results of the study of the transfer reaction within the CDCCM approach [61] are consistent with the present three-body results and with the result of the indirect method eV b [4] extracted from the measured solar and neutrino fluxes from Borexino Collaboration [21]. Microscopic shell-model and Generator-coordinate method calculations turn out to be very sensitive to the description of the NN-interaction [69], while the Source term approach [70] and its updated version [71] based on the shell-model wave functions yield quite stable results.
On the other hand, the result of the present three-body model for the astrophysical factor is consistent with the Solar Fusion II recommended value eV b, while higher than the recommended value eV b of the Solar Fusion III analysis [1]. Surprisingly, the central value of the estimate of the three-body model is very close to the value 22.4 eV b, used for the most successful new Solar Model BAR2M among other Solar Models, which predicts both a nearly flat rotation profile in the external part of the radiative region and an increase in the rotation rate in the solar core [22]. Additionally, the Solar Model BAR2M is consistent with the estimate of the neutrino flux by the Borexino Collaboration [21].
The goal of the three-body model developed in the present work is due-to the use of the most realistic − scattering data of S.N. Paneru et al. [32] for the estimation of the astrophysical factor within the asymptotic theory of D. Baye and the self-consistent treatment of the realistic cluster-cluster potentials in the three-body and two-body systems. The asymptotic normalization coefficient was extracted directly from the asymptotics of the overlap integral between these three-body and two-body wave functions. A consistence of the theoretical result eV b for the direct capture reaction with the previous Solar Fusion II recommended value and with the new most successful Solar Model BAR2M [22] from one hand, and its contradiction to the Solar Fusion III results indicates, that new experimental efforts are required with an expectation to precisely measure the solar neutrino flux to clarify the situation. Hopefully, the ongoing experimental efforts of the JUNO collaboration will eventually allow it to perform a model-independent measurement of the solar neutrino flux [76].
The three-body potential cluster model using the hyperspherical Lagrange-mesh method. The two-body –, -nucleon, -nucleon realistic potentials have been used from the literature. A good convergence of the three-body binding energy and matter radius was demonstrated with the maximal hypermomentum and for the ground () and excited () states, correspondingly. The ground states energies have been reproduced without any renormalization of the two-body potentials or additional three-body potential. For the extraction of the ANC in a self-consistent way, the asymptotics of the overlap integral of the three-body wave function was matched with the Whittaker function. The ANC values fm and fm are extracted for the virtual decay in the spin 1 and spin 2 channels, respectively. The obtained squared ANC value of 0.591(13) fm is consistent with the results of some analysis of transfer reactions, the NCSM/CD Bonn 2000 NN method and halo EFT at NLO, but larger than the result of the NCSM/RGM study. For the ANC values of the virtual transition of the mirror nucleus the estimates fm and fm were obtained.
The ratio of the squared ANC values of the mirror nuclei and estimated within the three-body model implies a breaking of the mirror symmetry of the strong nuclear forces due to the dynamical three-body effects and the Coulomb interaction potential.
A detailed three-body analysis of the direct nuclear capture reaction, a critical process for understanding solar neutrino fluxes and the Solar Metallicity Problem has been carried out. The zero-energy astrophysical factor eV b was obtained based on the asymptotic theory of Ref. [3]. It was found that the most important contribution comes from the spin 2 channel with , while the spin 1 channel yields . The obtained value of the astrophysical factor at zero energy is in a good agreement with the Solar Fusion II result eV b, but overestimates the recommended value eV b of the Solar Fusion III [1]. Fortunately, the result of the developed three-body model is very consistent with the value 22.4 eV b, used in the most successful new Solar Model BAR2M among different Solar Models [22].
Conclusion
The structure of the and nuclei was studied in the framework of the three-
Acknowledgements
E.M.T. thanks Daniel Baye and Natalia Timofeyuk for useful discussion of presented results.
References
- [1]Solar Fusion III (B. Acharya, et al.), Rev. Mod. Phys. 97, 035002 (2025).
- [2]Solar Fusion II (E.G. Adelberger, et al.), Rev. Mod. Phys. 83, 195 (2011).
- [3]D. Baye, Phys. Rev. C 62, 065803 (2000).
- [4]M.P. Takács, D. Bemm erer, A.R. Junghans, and K. Zuber, Nucl. Phys. A 970, 78 (2018).
- [5]A.M. Mukhamedzhanov, H.L. Clark, C. A. Gagliardi, et al., Phys. Rev. C 56, 1302 (1997).
- [6]F. Carstoiu, L. Trache, C.A. Gagliardi, R.E. Tribble, and A.M. Mukhamedzhanov, Phys. Rev. C 63, 054310 (2001).
- [7]A. Azhari, V. Burjan, F. Carstoiu, H. Dejbakhsh, C.A. Gagliardi, V. Kroha, A.M. Mukhamedzhanov, L. Trache, and R.E. Tribble, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 3960 (1999).
- [8]G. Tabacaru, A. Azhari, J. Brinkley, et al., Phys. Rev. C 73, 025808 (2006).
- [9]O.R. Tojiboev, R. Yarmukhamedov, S.V. Artemov and S.B. Sakuta, Phys. Rev. C 94, 054616 (2016).
- [10]P. Descouvemont, Phys. Rev. C 70, 065804 (2004).
- [11]P. Navratil, R. Roth, and S. Quaglioni, Phys. Lett. B 704, 379 (2011).
- [12]S.S. Descouvemont, S.K. Dhiman, and R. Shyam. Phys. Rev. C 68, 054320 (2003).
- [13]X. Zhang, K.M. Nollett, and D.R. Phillips, Phys. Lett. B 751, 535 (2015).
- [14]X. Zhang, K.M. Nollett, and D.R. Phillips, Phys. Rev. C 98, 034616 (2018).
- [15]L.V. Grigorenko, B.V. Danilin, V.D. Efros, N.B. Shul'gina, M.V. Zhukov, Phys. Rev. C 57, R2099 (1998).
- [16]L.V. Grigorenko, B.V. Danilin, V.D. Efros, N.B. Shul'gina, M.V. Zhukov, Phys. Rev. C 60, 044312 (1999).
- [17]K.M. Nollett and R.B. Wiringa, Phys. Rev. C 83, 041001(R) (2011).
- [18]P. Navratil, C.A. Bertulani, E. Caurier, Phys. Rev. C 73, 065801 (2006).
- [19]K. Kravvaris, P. Navratil, S. Quaglioni, C. Hebborn, G. Hupin, Phys. Lett. B 845, 138156 (2023).
- [20]Ö. Sürer, F.M. Nunes, M. Plumlee, and S.M. Wild, Phys. Rev. C 106, 024607 (2022).
- [21]Borexino Collaboration (M. Agostini, et al.), Phys. Rev. D 100, 082004 (2019).
- [22]W. Yang and Z. Tian, AJ 970, 38 (2024).
- [23]J.N. Bahcall and M.H. Pinsonneault, Rev. Mod. Phys 64, 885 (1992).
- [24]E.M. Tursunov, A.S. Kadyrov, S.A. Turakulov, and I. Bray, Phys. Rev. C 94, 015801 (2016).
- [25]D. Baye and E.M. Tursunov, J. Phys. G: Nucl. Part. Phys. 45,085102 (2018).
- [26]E.M. Tursunov, S.A. Turakulov, A.S. Kadyrov, and I. Bray, Phys. Rev. C 98, 055803 (2018).
- [27]E.M. Tursunov, S.A. Turakulov, and A.S. Kadyrov, Nucl. Phys. A 1000, 121884 (2020).
- [28]E.M. Tursunov and D. Baye, Phys. Rev. C 114, 014636 (2026).
- [29]M. Anders et al. (LUNA Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 042501 (2014).
- [30]D. Trezzi et al. (LUNA Collaboration), Astropart. Phys. 89, 57 (2017).
- [31]E.M. Tursunov, S.A. Turakulov, A.S. Kadyrov, and L.D. Blokhintsev, Phys. Rev. C 104, 045806 (2021).
- [32]S.N. Paneru, C.R. Brune, R. Giri, et al., Phys. Rev. C 99, 045807 (2019).
- [33]M. Heil, F. Käppeler, M. Wiescher, and A. Mengoni, Astrophys. Jour. 507, 997 (1998).
- [34]M. Igashira and T. Ohsaki, Sci. Technol. Adv. Mater. 5, 567 (2004).
- [35]L. Trache, A. Azhari, F. Carstoiu, et al., Phys. Rev. C 67, 062801(R) (2003).
- [36]N.B. Shul’gina, B.V. Danilin, V.D. Efros, J.M. Bang, J.S. Vaagen, M.V. Zhukov, Nucl. Phys. A 597, 197 (1996).
- [37]N.A. Burkova, S.B. Dubovichenko, A.V. Dzhazhairov-Kakhramanov, S.Zh. Nurmukhametova, J. Phys. G, Nucl. Part. Phys. 48, 045201 (2018).
- [38]M.V. Zhukov, B.V. Danilin, D.V. Fedorov, J.M. Bang, I.J. Thompson, J.S. Vaagen, Phys. Rep. 231, 51 (1993).
- [39]C.D. Lin, Phys. Rep. 257, 1 (1995).
- [40]P. Descouvemont, C. Daniel, D. Baye, Phys. Rev. C 67, 044309 (2003).
- [41]P. Descouvemont, E.M. Tursunov, D. Baye, Nucl. Phys. A 765, 370 (2006).
- [42]B.V. Danilin, M.V. Zhukov, S.N. Ershov, F.A. Gareev, R.S. Kurnanov, J.S. Vaagen, J.M. Bang, Phys. Rev. C 43, 2835 (1991).
- [43]J. Raynal, J. Revai, Nuovo Cimento A68, 612 (1970).
- [44]V.T. Voronchev, V.I. Kukulin, V.N. Pomerantsev, G.G. Ryzhikh, Few-Body Systems 18, 191 (1995).
- [45]I. Reichstein, Y.C. Tang, Nucl. Phys. A 158, 529 (1970).
- [46]S.B. Dubovichenko, Physics of Atomic Nuclei, 73, 1526 (2010).
- [47]W.R. Boykin, S.D. Baker, D.M. Hardy, Nucl. Phys. A 195, 241 (1972).
- [48]D.M. Hardy, R.J. Spiger, S.D. Baker, Y.S. Chen, T.A. Tombrello, Nucl. Phys. A 195, 250 (1972).
- [49]R.J. Spiger and T.A. Tombrello, Phys. Rev. 163, 964 (1967).
- [50]S.B. Dubovichenko, A.V. Dzhazhairov-Kakhramanov, Elem. Chast. Atomn. Yadra 28, 1529-1594 (1997).
- [51]D.R. Tilley, J.H. Kelley, J.L. Godwin et al. Nucl. Phys. A 745, 155 (2004).
- [52]G.A. Korolev, A.V. Dobrovolsky, A.G. Inglessi, et al., Phys. Lett. B 780, 200 (2018).
- [53]G.D. Alkhazov, I.S. Novikov, and Yu.M. Shabelski, Int. Jour. Mod. Phys. E 20, 583 (2011).
- [54]D. Baye, Phys. Rep. 565, 1 (2015).
- [55]D.R. Tilley, C.M. Cheves, J.L. Godwin et al. Nucl. Phys. A 708, 3 (2002).
- [56]J.J. Krauth, K. Schuhmann, M.A. Ahmed, et al., Nature 589, 527 (2021).
- [57]I. Angeli, K.P. Marinova, At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 99, 69 (2013).
- [58]L. Maisenbacher, V. Wirthl, A. Matveev, et al., Nature 650, 845 (2026).
- [59]V.I. Kukulin, V.N. Pomerantsev, Kh.D. Razikov, V.T. Voronchev, G.G. Ryzhikh, Nucl. Phys. A 586, 151 (1995).
- [60]K. Ogata, S. Hashimoto, Y. Iseri, M. Kamimura, and M. Yahiro, Phys. Rev. C 73, 024605 (2006).
- [61]K. Ogata, M. Yahiro, Y. Iseri, and M. Kamimura, Phys. Rev. C 67, 011602(R) (2003).
- [62]L. Trache, F. Carstoiu, C.A. Gagliardi, and R.E. Tribble, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 271102 (2001).
- [63]T.L. Belyaeva, E.F. Aguilera, E. Martinez-Quiróz, A.M. Moro, and J.J. Kolata, Phys. Rev. C 80, 064617 (2009).
- [64]J.T. Huang, C.A. Bertulani, and V. Guimarães, At. Data Nucl. Data Tables 96, 824 (2010).
- [65]H.M. Xu, C.A. Gagliardi, R.E. Tribble, A.M. Mukhamedzhanov, N.K. Timofeyuk, Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 2027 (1994).
- [66]A.R. Junghans, K.A. Snover, M.C. Mohrmann, E.G. Adelberger, and L. Buchmann, Phys. Rev. C 81, 012801(R) (2010).
- [67]L.T. Baby, C. Bordeanu, G. Goldring, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 022501 (2003); Phys. Rev. C 67, 065805 (2003).
- [68]R. Buompane, A. DiLeva, L.Gialanella, et al., Phys. Lett. B 824, 136819 (2022).
- [69]N.K. Timofeyuk, D. Baye, P. Descouvemont, Nucl. Phys. A 620, 29 (1997).
- [70]N.K. Timofeyuk, Phys. Rev. C 81, 064306 (2010).
- [71]N.K. Timofeyuk, I.J. Thompson, Phys. Rev. C 88, 044315 (2013).
- [72]N.K. Timofeyuk, R.C. Johnson, A.M. Mukhamedzhanov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 232501 (2003).
- [73]N.K. Timofeyuk, P. Descouvemont, Phys. Rev. C 71, 064305 (2005).
- [74]N.K. Timofeyuk, P. Descouvemont, R.C. Johnson,Eur. Phys. J. A 27 (Suppl 1), 269 (2006).
- [75]N.K. Timofeyuk, I.J. Thompson, Phys. Rev. C 78, 054322 (2008).
- [76]I. Esteban, M.C. Gonzalez-Garcia, M. Maltoni et al. (JUNO collaboration) J. High Energ. Phys. 2026, 89 (2026). https://doi.org/10.1007/JHEP04(2026)089

