betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

A residue obstruction for the family F_2 with (m,n)=(3,5): the degree pair (75,125) in the plane Jacobian problem

Abstract

Guccione, Guccione and Valqui list the possible shapes of a counterexample to the plane Jacobian conjecture of small degree; the first shape of maximal degree 125 is the family F_2 with (m,n)=(3,5), of degrees (75,125). We show that no standard (3,5)-pair of this shape exists. The proof combines three results of Guccione-Guccione-Valqui with the residue theorem on a generic fibre of P: on such a fibre the form y^2 Q dQ has no residue along the left side of the Newton polygon, while its residues along the right side add up to a quantity that cannot vanish. All statements are proved relative to the cited results; the exact computations are reproduced by an ancillary script. The argument has not yet been examined by specialists.

Statement

Throughout, KK is an algebraically closed field of characteristic zero, L=K[x,y]L=K[x,y], and [P,Q]=PxQy−PyQx[P,Q]=P_{x}Q_{y}-P_{y}Q_{x}. We use the notation of [1] (Guccione–Guccione–Valqui): for a weight (ρ,σ)(\rho,\sigma), vρ,σv_{\rho,\sigma} is the weighted degree, ℓρ,σ\ell_{\rho,\sigma} the leading form, and st⁡ρ,σ,en⁡ρ,σ\operatorname{st}_{\rho,\sigma},\operatorname{en}_{\rho,\sigma} its end points. Standard (m,n)(m,n)-pairs, their regular corners and their starting triple are defined in [1 Definitions 4.3, 5.5, 6.2].

Standing data 1.1. (P,Q)(P,Q) is a standard (3,5)(3,5)-pair in LL with [P,Q]=J∈K×[P,Q]=J\in K^{\times}, deg⁡P=75\deg P=75, deg⁡Q=125\deg Q=125, starting triple ((5,20),(1,0),(5,−1))((5,20),(1,0),(5,-1)), and (−1,1)<Succ⁡P(1,0)<(−1,0)(-1,1)<\operatorname{Succ}_{P}(1,0)<(-1,0) as in [1 Corollary 5.21(4)].

By [2 Theorem 2.20 and Sections 5–6], this is the shape (family F2F_{2}, j=1j=1) that a counterexample of degrees (75,125)(75,125) produced by [1 Corollary 5.21] must have; see also [3] for the shapes of smaller degree.

Theorem 1.2. There is no pair (P,Q)(P,Q) as in Standing data 1.1.

Consequences of the standing data used below

Put t:=xy5t:=xy^{5}. Adding constants and rescaling xx, PP, QQ we may assume the following.

(D1) The support of PP lies in {(i,j):5i−j≤15, i+j≤75}\{(i,j):5i-j\le15,\ i+j\le75\}, that of QQ in {5i−j≤25, i+j≤125}\{5i-j\le25,\ i+j\le125\}, and

ℓ5,−1(P)=(xh(t))3,ℓ5,−1(Q)=μ(xh(t))5,μ∈K×,\ell_{5,-1}(P)=\left(xh(t)\right)^{3},\qquad\ell_{5,-1}(Q)=\mu\left(xh(t)\right)^{5},\qquad\mu\in K^{\times},

with h∈K[t]h\in K[t] monic of degree 44, h(0)≠0h(0)\ne0; thus st⁡5,−1(P)=(3,0)\operatorname{st}_{5,-1}(P)=(3,0) and en⁡5,−1(P)=(15,60)\operatorname{en}_{5,-1}(P)=(15,60) [1 Proposition 6.1, Theorem 7.6(2)]. We write u(t):=th(t)u(t):=th(t).

(D2) Every root of hh has multiplicity 1 or 2, and hh has at least one double root. Indeed, write ℓ5,−1(P)=x3p(z)\ell_{5,-1}(P)=x^{3}p(z) with z=x1/5yz=x^{1/5}y; a root of hh of multiplicity kk gives roots of pp of multiplicity 3k3k. By [1 Proposition 5.16] some root has multiplicity ≥154\ge\frac{15}{4}, so k≥2k\ge2 occurs. For any root with k≥2k\ge2, [1 Proposition 5.18] produces a (3,5)(3,5)-pair in L(5)L^{(5)} with a regular corner at A(1)=(1+k/5,k)A^{(1)}=(1+k/5,k). At such a corner, Case III several factors is excluded for k∈{3,4}k\in\{3,4\} by [1 Proposition 5.14(4)], because gcd⁡(5+k,k)=1\gcd(5+k,k)=1; Case III only translates [1 Proposition 5.17]; and Case I is excluded for k∈{3,4}k\in\{3,4\} by the end point conditions of [1 Proposition 5.13], which have no solution (ancillary script). The same shapes are recorded in the tables of [2 Section 5], where F2F_{2}, with final corner (7/5,2)(7/5,2), is the only family starting at (5,20)(5,20) that contains (m,n)=(3,5)(m,n)=(3,5).

Homogeneous brackets

Let N≥1N \ge1 be an integer and Rω:=K[τ][ω,ω−1]R_\omega:= K[\tau][\omega,\omega^{-1}], with the bracket {f,g}N:=ωN(fτgω−fωgτ)\{f,g\}_N := \omega^N(f_\tau g_\omega- f_\omega g_\tau). For s∈Q>0s \in\mathbb{Q}_{>0} put νs(τaω−d):=d−sa\nu_s(\tau^a\omega^{-d}) := d-sa, let νs(f)\nu_s(f) be the maximum over the monomials of ff and ℓs(f)\ell_s(f) the sum of the terms realising it. An element with a single νs\nu_s-value aa has the form ω−aF(σ)\omega^{-a}F(\sigma) with σ:=τω−s\sigma:= \tau\omega^{-s} and F∈K[σ]F \in K[\sigma].

Lemma 2.1. (a) {ω−aF(σ),ω−bG(σ)}N=ωN−a−b−s−1(aFG′−bF′G)(σ)\{\omega^{-a}F(\sigma),\omega^{-b}G(\sigma)\}_N = \omega^{N-a-b-s-1}(aFG' - bF'G)(\sigma).

(b) νs({f,g}N)≤νs(f)+νs(g)+s+1−N\nu_s(\{f,g\}_N) \le\nu_s(f) + \nu_s(g) + s + 1 - N, with equality if and only if {ℓsf,ℓsg}N≠0\{\ell_s f,\ell_s g\}_N \ne0.

(c) If {f,g}N=c∈K×\{f,g\}_N = c \in K^\times, then Σs:=νs(f)+νs(g)+s+1−N≥0\Sigma_s := \nu_s(f) + \nu_s(g) + s + 1 - N \ge0 for every ss; if Σs>0\Sigma_s > 0 then aFG′=bF′GaFG' = bF'G for the leading forms, and if Σs=0\Sigma_s = 0 then aFG′−bF′G=caFG' - bF'G = c.

Proof. (a) is a direct computation; (b) and (c) follow from (a) by comparing νs\nu_s-values. □

The plane enters through (τ,W):=(t−θ,y)(\tau,W) := (t-\theta,y) for θ∈K\theta\in K: since dx∧dy=y−5dt∧dydx \wedge dy = y^{-5}dt \wedge dy, one has [f,g]={f,g}5[f,g] = \{f,g\}_5 with ω=W\omega= W, and P=∑d≤15fd(t)W−dP = \sum_{d\le15} f_d(t)W^{-d} with f15=u3f_{15} = u^3, Q=∑d≤25gd(t)W−dQ = \sum_{d\le25} g_d(t)W^{-d} with g25=μu5g_{25} = \mu u^5.

The left side

Lemma 3.1. There is g∈vK[v]g \in vK[v] with deg⁡g≤3\deg g \le3 and v2∣gv^2 \mid g such that P^(z,v):=P(zv4+g(v),v−1)\widehat{P}(z,v) := P(zv^4 + g(v),v^{-1}), Q^(z,v):=Q(zv4+g(v),v−1)\widehat{Q}(z,v) := Q(zv^4 + g(v),v^{-1}) are polynomials in z,vz,v. Moreover P^\widehat{P} has total degree 15, top form H3H^3 with H(z,v):=v5u(z/v)H(z,v) := v^5u(z/v), P^(z,0)\widehat{P}(z,0) has degree 15 in zz, and

P^zQ^v−P^vQ^z=−Jv2.\widehat{P}_z\widehat{Q}_v-\widehat{P}_v\widehat{Q}_z=-Jv^2.

Proof. Apply the flip ψ1\psi_1 of [1 Section 8], so that the weight (5,−1)(5,-1) becomes (ρ0,σ0)=(−1,5)(\rho_0,\sigma_0)=(-1,5), with st⁡ρ0,σ0=(60,15)\operatorname{st}_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}=(60,15) and en⁡ρ0,σ0=(0,3)\operatorname{en}_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}=(0,3) for the flipped PP. Let FF be the element of [1 Theorem 2.6] for (ρ0,σ0)(\rho_0,\sigma_0). As in the proof of [1 Proposition 8.1]: if st⁡(F)=(1,1)\operatorname{st}(F)=(1,1) then en⁡(F)≠(1,1)\operatorname{en}(F)\ne(1,1), since FF is not a monomial [1 Remark 2.5], so en⁡(F)∼en⁡(P)=(0,3)\operatorname{en}(F)\sim\operatorname{en}(P)=(0,3) and ν−1,5(F)=4\nu_{-1,5}(F)=4 would give en⁡(F)=(0,4/5)\operatorname{en}(F)=(0,4/5), which is impossible; hence st⁡(F)∼(60,15)\operatorname{st}(F)\sim(60,15), so st⁡(F)=(16,4)=43st⁡(P)\operatorname{st}(F)=(16,4)=\frac{4}{3}\operatorname{st}(P) and q=5q=5 in [1 Corollary 7.4]. That corollary applies to the flipped pair and to every pair obtained from it by a translation of the second variable by a Laurent monomial in the first (the form ℓρ0,σ0\ell_{\rho_0,\sigma_0}, the degrees ν1,1\nu_{1,1}, ν0,1\nu_{0,1} and FF are unchanged). It yields: for every weight between (1,−4)(1,-4) and (ρ0,σ0)(\rho_0,\sigma_0) at which the pair has an edge, the edge form of PP is a 15th power R15R^{15}. In the original variables: for a weight (−s,1)(-s,1) with s<4s<4 carrying an edge with end point (15,60)(15,60), the form is (xy4−γy4−s)15(xy^4-\gamma y^{4-s})^{15}, so s∈Zs\in\mathbb{Z}, and s≥2s\ge2 by the condition on Succ⁡P(1,0)\operatorname{Succ}_P(1,0). The translation x↦x+γy−sx\mapsto x+\gamma y^{-s} removes this edge and leaves the forms of smaller ss unchanged [1 Proposition 3.9]. After at most two such translations (s=2,3s=2,3) no edge of weight (−s,1)(-s,1), s<4s<4, has end point (15,60)(15,60). Since the weight (−4,1)(-4,1) lies within a half-turn of (5,−1)(5,-1), the point (15,60)(15,60) is then still leading for (−4,1)(-4,1) [1 Remark 2.10, Proposition 3.7]; hence every monomial xiyjx^iy^j of the translated PP satisfies j≤4ij\le4i, that is, xiyj=ziv4i−jx^iy^j=z^iv^{4i-j} is a monomial in z=xy4z=xy^4, v=y−1v=y^{-1}. The same holds for QQ: at a weight where PP has an edge, [1 Proposition 7.3] with T0=QT_0=Q gives [ℓ(Q),ℓ(P)]=0[\ell(Q),\ell(P)]=0 and proportional values, so ℓ(Q)∼R25\ell(Q)\sim R^{25} and the same translation applies; at the remaining weights (−s,1)(-s,1), s<4s<4, the values of PP and QQ are positive, so the leading forms commute [1 Proposition 1.13] and ℓ(Q)\ell(Q) is the monomial at (25,100)(25,100); hence j≤4ij\le4i on the support of QQ by continuity. The degree statements follow from 5i−j≤155i-j\le15 in (D1), and the Jacobian from dx∧dy=−v2 dz∧dvdx\wedge dy=-v^2\,dz\wedge dv. □

Places at infinity of a fibre

Fix a generic p∈Kp\in K and let Γp:={P^=p}⊂Az,v2\Gamma_p:=\{\widehat{P}=p\}\subset\mathbb{A}^2_{z,v}, with Γ‾p\overline{\Gamma}_p the normalisation of its projective closure. Since H(1,0)=1H(1,0)=1, every place π\pi of Γ‾p\overline{\Gamma}_p at infinity satisfies v→∞v\to\infty and z/v→θz/v\to\theta with u(θ)=0u(\theta)=0; then y=v−1→0y=v^{-1}\to0 and t=xy5→θt=xy^5\to\theta. So π\pi is a branch, at (τ,W)=(0,0)(\tau,W)=(0,0), of P−pP-p regarded in K[τ][W,W−1]K[\tau][W,W^{-1}], τ=t−θ\tau=t-\theta.

Lemma 4.1. Let P,Q∈RωP,Q\in R_{\omega} with {P,Q}N=c∈K×\{P,Q\}_{N}=c\in K^{\times}, let (N,D)(N,D) be one of (5,15)(5,15), (5,12)(5,12), (5,9)(5,9), (9,27)(9,27), (9,21)(9,21) and let 0≤s∗<D/30\le s_{*}<D/3. Assume that for all ss in some interval (s∗,s∗+ε)(s_{*},s_{*}+\varepsilon) one has ℓs(P)=A′τ3ω−D\ell_s(P)=A'\tau^{3}\omega^{-D} and ℓs(Q)=B′τ5ω−5D/3\ell_s(Q)=B'\tau^{5}\omega^{-5D/3} with A′B′≠0A'B'\ne0. Then D=3ND=3N (so the hypotheses cannot hold for the other three pairs), and there is κ∈K[ω]\kappa\in K[\omega] with ord⁡ωκ>s∗\operatorname{ord}_{\omega}\kappa>s_{*} such that, for τ=κ(ω)+σωD/3\tau=\kappa(\omega)+\sigma\omega^{D/3}, both PP and QQ are polynomials in σ,ω\sigma,\omega. Every branch τ(ω)\tau(\omega) of P=pP=p with ord⁡ωτ>s∗\operatorname{ord}_{\omega}\tau>s_{*} has σ\sigma bounded; in particular QQ is regular along it.

Proof. Let s0s_0 be the supremum of the s>s∗s>s_{*} with ℓs(P)=A′τ3ω−D\ell_s(P)=A'\tau^3\omega^{-D}. It is finite, since otherwise τ3∣P\tau^3\mid P and {P,Q}N\{P,Q\}_N would vanish at τ=0\tau=0. Suppose s0<D/3s_0<D/3 and write ℓs0(P)=ω−aFP\ell_{s_0}(P)=\omega^{-a}F_P, ℓs0(Q)=ω−bFQ\ell_{s_0}(Q)=\omega^{-b}F_Q; then a=D−3s0>0a=D-3s_0>0, deg⁡FP=3\deg F_P=3, FPF_P has at least two terms, b≥5D/3−5s0=53ab\ge5D/3-5s_0=\frac{5}{3}a and deg⁡FQ≤5\deg F_Q\le5 (a monomial of PP of τ\tau-degree >3>3, or of QQ of τ\tau-degree >5>5, is not leading for any s>s∗s>s_{*}). By Lemma 2.1(c), either FPbF_P^b is proportional to FQaF_Q^a, or Σs0=0\Sigma_{s_0}=0 and aFPFQ′−bFP′FQ=caF_PF'_Q-bF'_PF_Q=c. In the first case degrees give b=53ab=\frac{5}{3}a, FP5∼FQ3F_P^5\sim F_Q^3, so FP=A′(σ−κ0)3F_P=A'(\sigma-\kappa_0)^3 with κ0≠0\kappa_0\ne0 and s0∈Zs_0\in\mathbb Z; the translation τ↦τ+κ0ωs0\tau\mapsto\tau+\kappa_0\omega^{s_0} preserves the bracket and the hypotheses, with s∗s_{*} replaced by s0s_0. The second case requires a monomial pair (τ1,τ0)(\tau^1,\tau^0) or (τ0,τ1)(\tau^0,\tau^1) with integer exponents in (ℓs0P,ℓs0Q)(\ell_{s_0}P,\ell_{s_0}Q) together with Σs0=0\Sigma_{s_0}=0 and b≥53a>0b\ge\frac{5}{3}a>0; for the five pairs (N,D)(N,D) this has no solution s0<D/3s_0<D/3 (ancillary script). Hence after finitely many translations s0≥D/3s_0\ge D/3, so νD/3(P)=0\nu_{D/3}(P)=0 and P∈K[σ,ω]P\in K[\sigma,\omega] with P(σ,0)P(\sigma,0) of degree 3. Let b:=νD/3(Q)≥0b:=\nu_{D/3}(Q)\ge0. If b>0b>0, Lemma 2.1(c) gives FP′FQ=0F'_PF_Q=0 or −bFP′FQ=c-bF'_PF_Q=c, both impossible; so b=0b=0 and Q∈K[σ,ω]Q\in K[\sigma,\omega]. Now dP∧dQ=cω−Ndτ∧dω=cωD/3−Ndσ∧dωdP\wedge dQ=c\omega^{-N}d\tau\wedge d\omega=c\omega^{D/3-N}d\sigma\wedge d\omega is regular, so D≥3ND\ge3N; among the five pairs this leaves only D=3ND=3N, the other three being contradictory. Finally, for every ss with s∗<s<D/3s_{*}<s<D/3 other than the finitely many slopes removed by the translations, ℓs(P−p)\ell_s(P-p) is a monomial, so no root τ(ω)\tau(\omega) of P−pP-p has order ss; at a removed slope s0s_0 the roots of order s0s_0 are those with σ→κ0\sigma\to\kappa_0, and the translation moves them to higher order. Hence every root with ord⁡τ>s∗\operatorname{ord}\tau>s_{*} has order ≥D/3\ge D/3 in the final coordinate, that is, σ\sigma is bounded. □

Corollary 4.2. At every place of Γ‾p\overline{\Gamma}_p at infinity lying over a simple root θ\theta of uu (including θ=0\theta=0), the function Q^\widehat{Q} is regular.

Proof. For small ss, ℓs(P)=u′(θ)3τ3W−15\ell_s(P)=u'(\theta)^3\tau^3W^{-15} and ℓs(Q)=μu′(θ)5τ5W−25\ell_s(Q)=\mu u'(\theta)^5\tau^5W^{-25}; apply Lemma 4.1 with (N,D)=(5,15)(N,D)=(5,15), s∗=0s_{*}=0. □

Lemma 4.3. Let θ=c\theta=c be a double root of hh and u(c+τ)=Uτ2+O(τ3)u(c+\tau)=U\tau^2+O(\tau^3), U≠0U\ne0. Then exactly one of the following holds.

  1. Q^\widehat{Q} is regular at every place of Γ‾p\overline{\Gamma}_p over cc.

  1. After a translation τ↦τ+κ1W+κ2W2\tau\mapsto\tau+\kappa_1W+\kappa_2W^2, with σ=τW−12/5\sigma=\tau W^{-12/5},

ℓ12/5(P)=W−3/5(Bσ+U3σ6),ℓ12/5(Q)=W−1G(1+3σ+95σ2),ζ:=U3Bσ5,\ell_{12/5}(P)=W^{-3/5}(B\sigma+U^3\sigma^6),\qquad\ell_{12/5}(Q)=W^{-1}G\left(1+3\sigma+\frac{9}{5}\sigma^2\right),\qquad\zeta:=\frac{U^3}{B}\sigma^5,

with BG=−JBG=-J and G=5μB2/(9U)G=5\mu B^2/(9U). There are exactly two places of Γ‾p\overline{\Gamma}_p over cc: a place β1\beta_1 with ord⁡β1(y)=5\operatorname{ord}_{\beta_1}(y)=5, at which Q^\widehat{Q} has a pole of order 55 and yQ^→−G/5y\widehat{Q}\to-G/5; and a place β2\beta_2 with ord⁡β2(y)=1\operatorname{ord}_{\beta_2}(y)=1, at which Q^\widehat{Q} has a simple pole and yQ^→Gy\widehat{Q}\to G. In case (ii), G6=25J4μ4/(81U2)G^6=25J^4\mu^4/(81U^2), and κ1,κ2,B,G\kappa_1,\kappa_2,B,G do not depend on pp.

Proof. Work with f:=P−pf:=P-p and QQ in K[τ][W,W−1]K[\tau][W,W^{-1}], N=5N=5. For small ss, ℓs(f)=U3τ6W−15\ell_s(f)=U^3\tau^6W^{-15}, ℓs(Q)=μU5τ10W−25\ell_s(Q)=\mu U^5\tau^{10}W^{-25}. Let s0s_0 be the first ss at which ℓs(f)\ell_s(f) is not a monomial; as ff has a nonzero constant term, s0≤5/2s_0\le5/2. Put a=νs0(f)=15−6s0a=\nu_{s_0}(f)=15-6s_0 and b=νs0(Q)≥53ab=\nu_{s_0}(Q)\ge\frac{5}{3}a, so that Σs0≥36−15s0\Sigma_{s_0}\ge36-15s_0. Put a=νs0(f)=15−6s0a=\nu_{s_0}(f)=15-6s_0 and b=νs0(Q)≥53ab=\nu_{s_0}(Q)\ge\frac{5}{3}a, so that Σs0≥36−15s0\Sigma_{s_0}\ge36-15s_0. Thus s0<12/5s_0<12/5. Then Σs0>0\Sigma_{s_0}>0, so FPb∼FQaF_P^b\sim F_Q^a, whence b=53ab=\frac{5}{3}a and FP=U3G3F_P=U^3\mathcal G^3, FQ=μU5G5F_Q=\mu U^5\mathcal G^5 with G\mathcal G monic quadratic, G≠σ2\mathcal G\ne\sigma^2. If G=(σ−κ)2\mathcal G=(\sigma-\kappa)^2, then s0∈{1,2}s_0\in\{1,2\} and we translate by κWs0\kappa W^{s_0} and start again. If G\mathcal G has two distinct roots and s0∈{1,2}s_0\in\{1,2\}, translating to either root gives the situation of Lemma 4.1 with N=5N=5, D=15−3s0∈{12,9}D=15-3s_0\in\{12,9\}, s∗=s0s_{*}=s_0, which is contradictory. Otherwise G=σ2−κ\mathcal G=\sigma^2-\kappa with 2s0∈{1,3}2s_0\in\{1,3\}; with W=ω2W=\omega^2 one has { ⋅,⋅ }5=12{ ⋅,⋅ }9\{\,\cdot,\cdot\,\}_5=\frac{1}{2}\{\,\cdot,\cdot\,\}_9, and translating to τ=κω2s0\tau=\sqrt{\kappa}\omega^{2s_0} gives the situation of Lemma 4.1 with N=9N=9, D=30−6s0∈{27,21}D=30-6s_0\in\{27,21\}, s∗=2s0s_{*}=2s_0.

::: For D=21D=21 this is contradictory; for D=27D=27 it gives (i), the six roots of ff with τ→0\tau\to0 being those near ±κ ω\pm\sqrt{\kappa}\,\omega, exchanged by ω↦−ω\omega\mapsto-\omega.

s0=12/5s_0=12/5. The only lattice point on the edge is τW−3\tau W^{-3}, so FP=Bσ+U3σ6F_P=B\sigma+U^3\sigma^6, a=3/5a=3/5. If b>1b>1, proportionality FPb∼FQaF_P^b\sim F_Q^a is impossible by degrees; so b=1b=1, Σs0=0\Sigma_{s_0}=0 and 35FP′FQ−35FPFQ′=J\frac{3}{5}F'_P F_Q-\frac{3}{5}F_PF'_Q=J with FQ=G+Eσ5+Dσ10F_Q=G+E\sigma^5+D\sigma^{10}, whose unique solution is E=3U3G/BE=3U^3G/B, D=9U6G/(5B2)D=9U^6G/(5B^2), BG=−JBG=-J. Comparing DD with the coefficient μU5\mu U^5 of τ10W−25\tau^{10}W^{-25} gives G=5μB2/(9U)G=5\mu B^2/(9U), hence B3=−9JU/(5μ)B^3=-9JU/(5\mu) and the value of G6G^6. For s>12/5s>12/5 the leading terms are BτW−3B\tau W^{-3} and GW−1GW^{-1}, with Σs=0\Sigma_s=0; the next edge of ff can only end at the constant term, at s=3s=3, where Lemma 2.1(c) forces ℓ3(Q)=GW−1\ell_3(Q)=GW^{-1}. Thus the roots τ(W)\tau(W) of ff with τ→0\tau\to0 are five conjugate roots of order 12/512/5, forming one place β1\beta_1 on which σ5→−B/U3\sigma^5\to-B/U^3 and WQ→G(1−3+95)=−G/5WQ\to G(1-3+\frac{9}{5})=-G/5, and one root of order 33, the place β2\beta_2, on which WQ→GWQ\to G.

12/5≤s0≤5/212/5\le s_0\le5/2. For s0<5/2s_0<5/2 there is no lattice point on such an edge. For s0=5/2s_0=5/2 one has a=0a=0 and Σs0=b−32≥0\Sigma_{s_0}=b-\frac{3}{2}\ge0, and Lemma 2.1(c) gives FP′FQ=0F'_PF_Q=0 or b=3/2b=3/2 and −32FP′FQ=J-\frac{3}{2}F'_PF_Q=J, both impossible since deg⁡FP=6\deg F_P=6.

Two double roots

Lemma 5.1. If h=(t−c1)2(t−c2)2h=(t-c_1)^2(t-c_2)^2 with c1≠c2c_1\ne c_2, then c12−3c1c2+c22=0c_1^2-3c_1c_2+c_2^2=0. In particular c12+c22≠0c_1^2+c_2^2\ne0.

Proof. In K(t)((y))K(t)((y)) let C:=uy−5(1+⋯ )C:=uy^{-5}(1+\cdots) be the cube root of PP, and recall [a(t)yα,b(t)yβ]=(βa′b−αab′)yα+β+4[a(t)y^\alpha,b(t)y^\beta]=(\beta a'b-\alpha ab')y^{\alpha+\beta+4}. From 3C2[C,Q]=J3C^2[C,Q]=J we get [C,Q]=J3u2y10(1+⋯ )[C,Q]=\frac{J}{3u^2}y^{10}(1+\cdots). If R=Q−∑λiCiR=Q-\sum\lambda_iC^i has leading term b(t)yβb(t)y^\beta with β<11\beta<11, then βu′b+5ub′=0\beta u'b+5ub'=0, so b=λu−β/5b=\lambda u^{-\beta/5}; as uu has a simple zero at 00 and b∈K(t)b\in K(t), 5∣β5\mid\beta and the term is removed by subtracting λC−β/5\lambda C^{-\beta/5}. Hence there are λ5,…,λ−2∈K\lambda_5,\ldots,\lambda_{-2}\in K with Q−∑i=−25λiCi=φ(t)y11+⋯Q-\sum_{i=-2}^{5}\lambda_iC^i=\varphi(t)y^{11}+\cdots, φ∈K(t)\varphi\in K(t), and

5uφ′+11u′φ=J3u2.5u\varphi'+11u'\varphi=\frac{J}{3u^2}.

A rational solution has poles only at the roots of uu, of order 3k−13k-1 at a root of multiplicity k≤2k\le2, and is O(t−11)O(t^{-11}) at infinity. So φ=(a0+a1t)t−2(t−c1)−5(t−c2)−5\varphi=(a_0+a_1t)t^{-2}(t-c_1)^{-5}(t-c_2)^{-5}, and eliminating a0,a1a_0,a_1 from the resulting polynomial identity gives c12−3c1c2+c22=0c_1^2-3c_1c_2+c_2^2=0 (ancillary script). If moreover c12=−c22c_1^2=-c_2^2, then c1c2=0c_1c_2=0, a contradiction.

Proof of Theorem 1.2

On Γ‾p\overline{\Gamma}_p consider the meromorphic forms

ω1:=v−1dQ^,ω2:=v−2Q^ dQ^.\omega_1:=v^{-1}d\widehat{Q},\qquad\omega_2:=v^{-2}\widehat{Q}\,d\widehat{Q}.

Finite points. They are regular where v≠0v\ne0. The points of Γp\Gamma_p with v=0v=0 are the (z0,0)(z_0,0) with P^(z0,0)=p\widehat{P}(z_0,0)=p; for generic pp, P^z(z0,0)≠0\widehat{P}_z(z_0,0)\ne0, so vv is a local parameter and, by Lemma 3.1, dQ^=−Jv2P^z−1 dvd\widehat{Q}=-Jv^2\widehat{P}_z^{-1}\,dv on Γp\Gamma_p. Hence ω1,ω2\omega_1,\omega_2 are regular at these points.

Places at infinity. There y=v−1y=v^{-1} vanishes, so ωj=yjQ^j−1dQ^\omega_j=y^j\widehat{Q}^{j-1}d\widehat{Q} is regular wherever Q^\widehat{Q} is regular. By Corollary 4.2 and Lemma 4.3, Q^\widehat{Q} has poles only at the places β1,β2\beta_1,\beta_2 over the double roots cc of hh that are in case (ii); there, writing ω2=(yQ^)2 dQ^/Q^\omega_2=(y\widehat{Q})^2\,d\widehat{Q}/\widehat{Q},

Res⁡β1ω2+Res⁡β2ω2=−5(G5)2−G2=−65G2,Res⁡β1ω1+Res⁡β2ω1=−5(−G5)−G=0.\operatorname{Res}_{\beta_1}\omega_2+\operatorname{Res}_{\beta_2}\omega_2=-5\left(\frac{G}{5}\right)^2-G^2=-\frac{6}{5}G^2,\qquad\operatorname{Res}_{\beta_1}\omega_1+\operatorname{Res}_{\beta_2}\omega_1=-5\left(-\frac{G}{5}\right)-G=0.

Conclusion. By the residue theorem, ∑cGc2=0\sum_cG_c^2=0, the sum being over the double roots in case (ii). If there is no such root, Q^\widehat{Q} has no pole on Γ‾p\overline{\Gamma}_p and is constant on each component, whereas dQdQ has no zero on the affine curve {P=p}\{P=p\} because [P,Q]=J≠0[P,Q]=J\ne0. If there is exactly one, Gc=−J/B≠0G_c=-J/B\ne0, a contradiction. By (D2) the only remaining possibility is h=(t−c1)2(t−c2)2h=(t-c_1)^2(t-c_2)^2 with both roots in case (ii) and Gc12=−Gc22G_{c_1}^2=-G_{c_2}^2. Then Gc16=−Gc26G_{c_1}^6=-G_{c_2}^6, and Lemma 4.3 gives U12=−U22U_1^2=-U_2^2, where Uk=ck(c1−c2)2U_k=c_k(c_1-c_2)^2; thus c12+c22=0c_1^2+c_2^2=0, contradicting Lemma 5.1.

Scope

  • Proved here, relative to the cited results: Theorem 1.2. The inputs are (D1), (D2) and [1 Theorem 2.6, Corollary 7.4, Propositions 5.13–5.18], as indicated.

  • Verified by exact computation: the bracket formula, the solution of the terminal bracket equation and the two residue sums, the formula for G6G^{6}, the arithmetic exclusions in (D2) and in Lemmas 4.1 and 4.3, and the elimination in Lemma 5.1 (ancillary file verify-residue.py, in the folder anc; it uses SymPy).

  • Not claimed: a statement on the plane Jacobian conjecture itself, or on other shapes of degree ≥125\ge125. Whether a counterexample of degrees (75, 125) is excluded unconditionally depends on the reduction to standard pairs in [1, 2].

  • [1 Proposition 7.3 and Corollary 7.4], on which Lemma 3.1 rests, are stated in [1] with the indication that their proofs mimic those of Proposition 7.1 and Corollary 7.2; they are applied here to Laurent translates, as in [1 Section 8].

  • The argument has been checked only by the author with AI assistance (Claude, Anthropic); it has not been validated by professionals.

Independent researcher, France

References

  1. [1]C. Valqui, J. A. Guccione, J. J. Guccione, On the shape of possible counterexamples to the Jacobian Conjecture, J. Algebra 471 (2017), 13–74, doi:10.1016/j.jalgebra.2016.08.039; arXiv:1401.1784v3. Statement numbers refer to the arXiv version 3.DOI
  2. [2]J. A. Guccione, J. J. Guccione, R. Horruitiner, C. Valqui, Some algorithms related to the Jacobian Conjecture, arXiv:1708.07936v1.arxiv.org/abs/1708.07936
  3. [3]J. A. Guccione, J. J. Guccione, R. Horruitiner, C. Valqui, Increasing the degree of a possible counterexample to the Jacobian Conjecture from 100 to 108, arXiv:2204.14178.arxiv.org/abs/2204.14178

Paper details

vlnc:W_rab5qd4g
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — published within the last 30 days
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 5

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Anthropic Claude Fable

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents