Most quantum algorithms designed to generate or probe properties of the ground state of a quantum many-body system require as input an initial state with a large overlap with the desired ground state. One approach for preparing such a ground state is Imaginary Time Evolution (ITE). Recent work by [Motta, M., Sun, C., Tan, A.T.K. et al. (2020)] introduced an algorithm – which we will refer to as Quantum Imaginary Time Evolution (QITE) – that shows how ITE can be approximated by a sequence of unitary operators, making QITE potentially implementable on early fault-tolerant quantum computers. In this work, we provide a heuristic study of the capabilities of the QITE algorithm in approximating the ITE of lattice and molecular electronic structure Hamiltonians. We numerically study the performance of the QITE algorithm when provided with a good classical initial state for a large class of systems, some of which are of interest to industrial applications, and check if QITE is able to qualitatively replicate the ITE behavior and improve over a classical mean-field solution. The systems we consider in this work range from one- and two-dimensional lattice systems of various lattice geometries displaying short- and long-range interactions, to active spaces of molecular electronic structure Hamiltonians. In addition to the comparison of QITE and ITE, we explicitly show how imaginary time evolved fermionic Gaussian states can serve as initial states which can be efficiently computed on classical computers and efficiently implemented on quantum computers for generic spin Hamiltonians in arbitrary lattice geometries and dimensions, which can be of independent interest.
Introduction
Finding the ground state of a strongly correlated quantum many body system is one of the most fundamental problems in physics and related fields, such as quantum chemistry. Many approaches exist to tackle the ground state problem for strongly correlated quantum many-body systems on classical computers. However, in many instances of strong correlation, the computational cost becomes too demanding. This can be traced back to the fact that state-of-the art classical methods for tackling quantum chemistry or ground states of lattice systems such as coupled cluster [1] or Density Matrix Renormalization Group (DMRG) theory [2, 3] display a computational cost that scales as a large polynomial of the system size or require a bond dimension that growths exponentially with system size. A natural question to ask is whether a quantum computer could solve the ground state of a quantum many-body problem Hamiltonian in less computation time and/or higher accuracy. Unfortunately, finding the ground state of a quantum many-body Hamiltonian is considered to be hard even for an envisioned error-free quantum computer. More precisely, the problem has been shown to lie in the complexity class QMA-complete, which means that every algorithm that aims to solve the problem must be either heuristic in nature—and therefore not possess a performance guarantee—, or its cost must scale exponentially in at least one parameter that describes the problem [4]. However, most quantum algorithms designed to probe properties of the ground state only require access to a state ∣Ψ⟩ that approximates the ground state ∣Ψgs⟩ within some error 1−∣⟨Ψ∣Ψgs⟩∣<ϵ, where 0<ϵ≪1 [5]. In literature, the approximate state ∣Ψ⟩, which can be generated by a quantum computer, is usually called initial state or trial state. To avoid ambiguity we will use ∣Ψinit⟩ to denote an approximation to the ground state which is obtained from a classical algorithm (for instance, the Hartree-Fock ground state). We will consider two algorithms aimed at iteratively improving the overlap of a given initial state on a quantum computer. The first algorithm is a trotterized version of Imaginary Time Evolution (ITE), while the second algorithm was introduced in Ref. [42] and is called Quantum Imaginary Time Evolution (QITE). QITE is designed to approximate the non-unitary operators of trotterized ITE by unitary operators. Both, ITE and QITE require an initial state with a non-zero support of the ground state in order to be able to approximate the latter.
The computational cost of the currently most advanced quantum algorithms to probe ground state properties depend inversely on powers of the ground state overlap of the initial state being used [6]. While this overlap falls off exponentially with increasing system size [7], computations of real systems are carried out on finite system sizes, where sufficiently large overlaps might still be reached for states that can be implemented efficiently on a quantum computer [8]. However, for some systems that are e.g. of interest to the chemical industry, it is still an open question whether a sufficiently large overlap can be reached with existing methods [9, 10].
In this work, we put a lot of emphasis on providing a classical initial state ∣Ψinit⟩ (i.e. a solution from a classical algorithm that can be translated into a wave function) for the QITE and ITE simulations. We show how to obtain an initial state ∣Ψinit⟩ from the family of Fermionic Gaussian States (FGS) [11, 12, 13], which can be efficiently generated on a quantum computer [14, 15, 16] and efficiently computed on a classical computer for lattice Hamiltonians in arbitrary dimensions. This is achieved by performing an ITE of the respective covariance matrix [17] which fully describes a FGS. Since this classical algorithm can be applied to any spin and fermionic Hamiltonian, this part of our work may be of independent interest to the reader.
In order to be able to study systems where classical methods become unreliable, too expensive and slow, or inaccurate, much effort has been put in finding superior algorithms that can be executed on quantum computers. Various approaches for approximating the ground state have been suggested, such as quantum adiabatic state preparation [18], variational algorithms [19], or algorithms that generate the ground state by a projector method on early fault tolerant quantum computers [20], to name but a few. While the former two approaches are heuristic, the latter is a deterministic approach, provided access to a good initial state. Due to the hardness of the ground state problem, all quantum approaches have their drawbacks. For instance, adiabatic state preparation is heuristic in nature since it requires a protected energy gap, which is not guaranteed for arbitrary initial Hamiltonians and adiabatic paths, and can in some instances display a dependence between the ground state of the initial and final Hamiltonian [21]. On the other hand, the energy landscape of the Variational Quantum Eigensolver (VQE) [22] can be plagued by extremely small gradients for sufficiently deep circuits, a phenomenon known as the appearance of barren plateaus [23]. While fault tolerant algorithms such as Ref. [20] are not suffering from the above mentioned problems, they have an intrinsic dependence on the energy gap of the system Hamiltonian and on the overlap γ=∣⟨Ψ∣Ψgs⟩∣ of a provided initial state ∣Ψ⟩. The larger this overlap is, the faster the quantum computation will be at generating an approximate ground state of a given desired accuracy, or extract properties from it [6, 24, 25, 26].
In this work, we numerically investigate the capability of QITE to replicate the trotterized ITE algorithm. To this end, we apply QITE and ITE to initial states for various lattice and molecular systems and compare the resulting evolved states. We call this procedure algorithmic benchmark.
We add to the body of QITE literature by formulating a fermionic version of QITE and study if it could serve as a way of generating improved initial states ∣Ψ⟩ when applied to a fermionic lattice model, as well as the Active Space (AS) of molecular electronic structure Hamiltonians.
Our focus on obtaining proper initial states for the system Hamiltonians we study helps to be able get a more objective algorithmic performance evaluation of (Q)ITE. More precisely, the choice of a poor initial state will generally lead to a large improvement in the quality of the produced state, but often times the majority of this improvement can be traced back to a non-optimized initial state choice. Therefore, we initialize our systems in an optimized fermionic Gaussian state (which, among others, includes the Hartree-Fock state), that treats the interactions of the system in a mean-field approximation and use this state as a benchmark to see how much QITE can improve over a mean-field solution.
The paper is structured as follows. In Section II we cover the main aspects of the ITE and QITE algorithms. § 1.2 introduces the details of the studied lattice and quantum chemistry systems. Section IV describes how we obtain the initial states for the various systems, which is followed by the discussion of our numerical results in § 2.2, and a summary and outlook in Section VI.
Methods
This section introduces the QITE algorithm. After establishing the required structure of the Hamiltonian in Section II A, we discuss the ITE algorithm in Section II B, followed by a detailed introduction to the QITE algorithm in Section II C. The section concludes with an introduction of the mutual information in Section II D, which is used within a subroutine of QITE applied to molecular electronic structure systems.
Hamiltonian terms
In this work, we consider Hamiltonians which can describe either interacting spins or fermions and can be written as
H^=j=1∑m~h^[j]+α1,(1)
where 1 denotes the identity operator, h^[j] is a Hermitian operator which acts non-trivially (i.e. not as the identity) on at most k≤L spins or fermionic sites, and α∈R is a constant, while L describes the total number of spins or fermionic sites/orbitals. Examples of physical systems that are modelled by the Hamiltonian in Eq. (1) include fermionic and spin lattice systems describing e.g. condensed matter systems, as well as molecular electronic structure Hamiltonians. We note, that in principle one can map a fermionic system to a spin system (and vice versa) using various mappings [27, 28], but only a selected few mappings lead to a locality in the Hamiltonian terms h^[j] that does not scale with the system size [29]. In this work, we assume that Eq. (1) describes the Hamiltonian that results after a potential fermion-to-qubit or qubit-to-fermion mapping was made, and therefore, for instance when studying a fermionic system, h^[j] could equally well describe a qubit or a fermionic operator, depending whether a fermion-to-qubit mapping was applied or not. If h^[j] describes a spin operator, we will apply the spin-QITE algorithm that we introduce in Section II C 3, whereas if h^[j] describes a fermionic operator, we will use the fermionic-QITE algorithm that is introduced in Section II C 4.
Trotterized ITE
The solution of the imaginary time Schrödinger equation dτd∣Ψ(τ)⟩=−(H^−⟨Ψ(τ)∣H^∣Ψ(τ)⟩)∣Ψ(τ)⟩ with the initial condition ∣Ψ(0)⟩=∣Ψinit⟩ for time-independent Hamiltonians is given by by [30]
∣Ψ(τ)⟩=⟨Ψinit∣e−τH^∣Ψinit⟩e−τH^∣Ψinit⟩.(2)
Provided an initial state ∣Ψinit⟩ with overlap γinit=∣⟨Ψinit∣Ψgs⟩∣=0, ITE will lead to the ground state in the infinite time limit, ∣Ψgs⟩=limτ→∞∣Ψ(τ)⟩. Since in practice an approximation to the ground state suffices, we only have to evolve up to a finite value
τη=O(Δ1log(γinitη1))(3)
in order to assure that the overlap γ of the evolved state is bounded by 1−γ<n2η2 for a desired precision η[24]. Here, Δ≤∣E1−E0∣ is a lower bound on the energy gap of the system Hamiltonian, with E0 (E1) denoting the exact ground (first excited) state energy. From a physical point of view, ITE can be viewed as a cooling process where τ→∞ corresponds to the zero temperature limit, where the system will be found in its ground state. Thus, τ−1 can be interpreted as a temperature, and correspondingly ITE is a process which lowers the overall entropy of the system. In the context of quantum chemistry systems, it turns out that in practice one empirically finds that the properties of the ground state do not differ much from its low temperature (i.e. large, but finite τ) canonical density operator e−τH^ and that using a large but finite τ which is independent of the system size L is often times sufficient. This observation is consistent with the concept of locality in quantum chemistry Hamiltonians, and locality is also what allows us to get an accurate description of the ground state of the electronic structure Hamiltonian in the full basis by only solving the ground state problem within a small sub-region (the so-called active space) accurately [31].
We can divide the total ITE propagator into n-many small time steps Δτ=τ/n, such that the imaginary time propagator can be expressed as
e−τH^=(e−ΔτH^)n.(4)
We can split the ITE propagator e−ΔτH^ of the Hamiltonian in Eq. (1) into a product of ITE propagators e−2Δτh^[j] of the individual Hermitian operators h^[j] using a second-order Trotterization,
where m denotes the number of Hamiltonian terms which arise from the Trotterization of the m~ terms from the untrotterized Hamiltonian of Eq. (1). A second-order Trotterization gives m=2m~ [32][33]. Above, we have introduced an index function f(l) with l∈[mn] that ensures the correct prefactor for the step size, as well as the correct Hamiltonian term in Eq. (1) and it keeps track of the effect of the Trotterization of Eq. (5). For instance, in the second-order Trotterization of Eq. (5) we use, h^[f(m~+1)]=21h^[m~]. From this point on, we will mostly use h^[l] instead of h^[f(l)] for readability.
Since in general the individual terms h^[j] do not commute with each other, the Trotterization of Eq. (5) introduces an error in the imaginary time propagator which in our case scales as O(Δτ2). This leads to the trotterized ITE state in Eq. (6) for τ≥τη converging to a state whose energy expectation value will lie above the ground state energy,
EITE=l→∞lim⟨Ψl∣H^∣Ψl⟩≥E0,(7)
where either smaller step sizes, or a larger Trotter order at fixed step size will lead to EITE getting closer to E0.
The QITE algorithm
QITE workflow
We present an overview of the QITE workflow in Figure 1. One first considers the formalized problem introduced in Section II A, a Hamiltonian H^ that is composed of m~ terms h^[j] with j∈[m~]. The goal of QITE is to imitate the ITE, which requires the preparation of an initial state ∣Ψinit⟩ which is discussed in Section IV. The term h^[j] can either describe a linear combinations of Pauli strings (see Section II C 3) or a linear combination of fermionic operators (see Section II C 4). Depending on whether the underlying Hamiltonian describes a lattice system or a molecular electronic structure problem, we perform an operator expansion on a set Dj of spins, fermionic sites or orbitals. The choice of Dj is crucial for the success of QITE and is guided by the Manhattan distance when we deal with a lattice system (see Section II C 2 a), and by the mutual information between orbitals when we investigate molecular electronic structure systems (see Section II D), respectively. Finally, Section II C 2 gives a short introduction to the main idea of the QITE algorithm, with a more detailed discussion on how this is put to practice in spin and fermionic systems in Sections II C 3 and II C 4, respectively.
Figure 1. The scheme for the QITE workflow that is to be read from top to bottom shows the main elements of the QITE algorithm. The color-coding of the elements within the blue boxes highlight their entailment on the steps later on. The arrows in the second box indicate the kind of system that may arise from the composition of the Hamiltonian H^. Combining these pieces of information guides through the series of choices to be made when implementing the QITE algorithm.
Code details We implemented this workflow (see Figure 1) using Python. Our calculations rely on state vector simulations of the QITE algorithm on classical hardware. For our initial state preparation, we calculated the Pfaffian of skew-symmetric matrices using the pfapack library[34, 35]. Molecular electronic structure Hamiltonians for different basis sets as well as the studied Fermi-Hubbard system and their corresponding approximate ground states were determined using PySCF 2.2.1. [36] The OpenFermion 1.5.1 [39] library was used for generating the spin and fermionic operators, as well as to translate the obtained covariance matrix of a pure fermionic Gaussian state into a state vector in its Hilbert space representation through the relations we derive in Appendix A 4. The system of linear equations to derive the operator expansion has been solved by a Conjugate Gradient iteration of the SciPy 1.10.1. [40] library. Our calculations of the mutual information were supported by the TeNPy 0.10.0 [41] library, which was used to compute the required reduced density matrices of the ground state more efficiently, by using the Matrix Product State (MPS) representation of the latter for a large bond dimension.
QITE Introduction
The main idea of the QITE algorithm is to approximate the trotterized imaginary time propagator e−Δτh^[f(l)] by a unitary operator U^l at each iteration step, without the need of auxiliary qubits. More specifically,
for a fixed discretization step size Δτ and step l∈[m], the QITE algorithm tries to find the unitary U^l which approximates
∣Ψl+1⟩=cl1e−Δτh^[f(l)]∣Ψl⟩≃U^l∣Ψl⟩,(8)
by minimizing the distance
Ulmincl1e−Δτh^[f(l)]∣Ψl⟩−U^l∣Ψl⟩,(9)
where ∥φ∥=⟨φ∣φ⟩ is the Euclidean norm of a vector ∣φ⟩ and
References
[6]A. M. Dalzell, S. McArdle, M. Berta, P. Bienias, C.-F. Chen, A. Gilyén, C. T. Hann, M. J. Kastoryano, E. T. Khabiboulline, A. Kubica, G. Salton, S. Wang, and F. G. S. L. Brandão, Quantum algorithms: A survey of applications and end-to-end complexities (2023), arXiv:2310.03011 [quant-ph].DOI
[7]W. Kohn, Nobel lecture: Electronic structure of matter—wave functions and density functionals, Rev. Mod. Phys. 71, 1253 (1999).DOI
[8]N. M. Tubman, C. Mejuto-Zaera, J. M. Epstein, D. Hait, D. S. Levine, W. Huggins, Z. Jiang, J. R. McClean, R. Babbush, M. Head-Gordon, and K. B. Whaley, Postponing the orthogonality catastrophe: efficient state preparation for electronic structure simulations on quantum devices (2018), arXiv:1809.05523 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/1809.05523
[9]S. Lee, J. Lee, H. Zhai, Y. Tong, A. M. Dalzell, A. Kumar, P. Helms, J. Gray, Z.-H. Cui, W. Liu, M. Kastoryano, R. Babbush, J. Preskill, D. R. Reichman, E. T. Campbell, E. F. Valeev, L. Lin, and G. K.-L. Chan, Evaluating the evidence for exponential quantum advantage in ground-state quantum chemistry, Nature Communications 14, 1952 (2023).DOI
[10]P. J. Ollitrault, C. L. Cortes, J. F. Gonthier, R. M. Parrish, D. Rocca, G.-L. Anselmetti, N. Degroote, M. Moll, R. Santagati, and M. Streif, Enhancing initial state overlap through orbital optimization for faster molecular electronic ground-state energy estimation (2024), arXiv:2404.08565 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2404.08565
[11]Bravyi, S. (2005). Lagrangian representation for fermionic linear optics. Quantum Info. Comput., 5, 216–238.
[12]L. Hackl and E. Bianchi, Bosonic and fermionic Gaussian states from Kähler structures, SciPost Phys. Core 4, 025 (2021).DOI
[13]J. Surace and L. Tagliacozzo, Fermionic Gaussian states: an introduction to numerical approaches, SciPost Phys. Lect. Notes , 54 (2022).DOI
[14]M. P. Kaicher, S. B. Jäger, and F. K. Wilhelm, Algorithm for initializing a generalized fermionic gaussian state on a quantum computer, Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical 54, 395303 (2021).DOI
[15]Z. Jiang, K. J. Sung, K. Kecedzhi, V. N. Smelyanskiy, and S. Boixo, Quantum algorithms to simulate many-body physics of correlated fermions, Phys. Rev. Appl. 9, 044036 (2018).DOI
[16]D. Wecker, M. B. Hastings, N. Wiebe, B. K. Clark, C. Nayak, and M. Troyer, Solving strongly correlated electron models on a quantum computer, Phys. Rev. A 92, 062318 (2015).DOI
[17]C. V. Kraus and J. I. Cirac, Generalized hartree–fock theory for interacting fermions in lattices: numerical methods, New Journal of Physics 12, 113004 (2010).DOI
[18]E. Farhi, J. Goldstone, S. Gutmann, and M. Sipser, Quantum computation by adiabatic evolution (2000), arXiv:quant-ph/0001106 [quant-ph].DOI
[19]Cerezo, M., Arrasmith, A., Babbush, R., Benjamin, S. C., Endo, S., Fujii, K., McClean, J. R., Mitarai, K., Yuan, X., Cincio, L., & Coles, P. J. (2021). Variational quantum algorithms. Nature Reviews Physics, 3, 625.
[20]Ge, Y., Tura, J., & Cirac, J. I. (2019). Faster ground state preparation and high-precision ground energy estimation with fewer qubits. Journal of Mathematical Physics, 60, 022202.
[21]Roland, J., & Cerf, N. J. (2003). Adiabatic quantum search algorithm for structured problems. Phys. Rev. A, 68, 062312.
[22]A. Peruzzo, J. McClean, P. Shadbolt, M.-H. Yung, X.-Q. Zhou, P. J. Love, A. Aspuru-Guzik, and J. L. O’Brien, A variational eigenvalue solver on a photonic quantum processor, Nature Communications 5, 4213 (2014).DOI
[23]J. R. McClean, S. Boixo, V. N. Smelyanskiy, R. Babbush, and H. Neven, Barren plateaus in quantum neural network training landscapes, Nature Communications 9, 4812 (2018).DOI
[24]T. Keen, E. Dumitrescu, and Y. Wang, Quantum algorithms for ground-state preparation and green’s function calculation (2021), arXiv:2112.05731 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2112.05731
[25]K. Wan, M. Berta, and E. T. Campbell, Randomized quantum algorithm for statistical phase estimation, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 030503 (2022).DOI
[26]S. Wang, S. McArdle, and M. Berta, Qubit-efficient randomized quantum algorithms for linear algebra, PRX Quantum 5, 020324 (2024).DOI
[27]A. Miller, Z. Zimborás, S. Knecht, S. Maniscalco, and G. García-Pérez, Bonsai algorithm: Grow your own fermion-to-qubit mappings, PRX Quantum 4, 030314 (2023).DOI
[28]Tranter, A., Sofia, S., Seeley, J., Kaicher, M., McClean, J., Babbush, R., Coveney, P. V., Mintert, F., Wilhelm, F., & Love, P. J. (2015). The bravyi–kitaev transformation: Properties and applications. International Journal of Quantum Chemistry, 115, 1431.
[29]Verstraete, F., & Cirac, J. I. (2005). Mapping local hamiltonians of fermions to local hamiltonians of spins. Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment, 2005, P09012.
[30]Shi, T., Demler, E., & Cirac, J. I. (2018). Variational study of fermionic and bosonic systems with non-gaussian states: Theory and applications. Annals of Physics, 390, 245.
[33]A. Carrera Vazquez, D. J. Egger, D. Ochsner, and S. Woerner, Well-conditioned multi-product formulas for hardware-friendly Hamiltonian simulation, Quantum 7, 1067 (2023).DOI
[36][36–38]
[43]Brandão, F. G. S. L., & Horodecki, M. (2015). Exponential decay of correlations implies area law. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 333, 761.
[44]M. A. Nielsen and I. L. Chuang, Quantum Computation and Quantum Information: 10th Anniversary Edition (Cambridge University Press, 2010).
[45]Coester, F., & Kümmel, H. (1960). Short-range correlations in nuclear wave functions. Nuclear Physics, 17, 477.
[46]Bishop, R. F., & Kümmel, H. G. (1987). The Coupled Cluster Method. Physics Today, 40, 52.
[47]A. G. Taube and R. J. Bartlett, New perspectives on unitary coupled-cluster theory, International Journal of Quantum Chemistry 106, 3393 (2006).DOI
[48]D. González-Cuadra, D. Bluvstein, M. Kalinowski, R. Kaubruegger, N. Maskara, P. Nedelsky, T. V. Zache, A. M. Kaufman, M. D. Lukin, H. Pichler, B. Vermersch, J. Ye, and P. Zoller, Fermionic quantum processing with programmable neutral atom arrays, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 120, e2304294120 (2023).DOI
[49]Ding, L., Mardazad, S., Das, S., Szalay, U., Schollwöck, U., Zimborás, Z., & Schilling, C. (2021). Concept of orbital entanglement and correlation in quantum chemistry. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation, 17, 79.
[50]B. Groisman, S. Popescu, and A. Winter, Quantum, classical, and total amount of correlations in a quantum state, Phys. Rev. A 72, 032317 (2005).DOI
[51]Wolf, M. M., Verstraete, F., Hastings, M. B., & Cirac, J. I. (2008). Area laws in quantum systems: Mutual information and correlations. Phys. Rev. Lett., 100, 070502.
[52]J. Rissler, R. M. Noack, and S. R. White, Measuring orbital interaction using quantum information theory, Chemical Physics 323, 519 (2006).DOI
[53]Ghosh, D., Hachmann, J., Yanai, T., & Chan, G. K.-L. (n.d.). Orbital optimization in the density matrix renormalization group, with applications to polyenes and $\beta$-.
[54]Boguslawski, K., & Tecmer, P. (2015). Orbital entanglement in quantum chemistry. International Journal of Quantum Chemistry, 115, 1289.
[60]Ke, L., & Katsnelson, M. I. (2021). Electron correlation effects on exchange interactions and spin excitations in 2D van der Waals materials. Npj Comput Mater, 7, 1.
[61]Fouet, J. B., Sindzingre, P., & Lhuillier, C. (2001). An investigation of the quantum J1-J2-J3 model on the honeycomb lattice. The European Physical Journal B - Condensed Matter and Complex Systems, 20, 241.
[62]C. J. Stein and M. Reiher, Measuring multi-configurational character by orbital entanglement, Molecular Physics 115, 2110 (2017), https://doi.org/10.1080/00268976.2017.1288934.
[63]Auerbach, A. (2012). Interacting electrons and quantum magnetism.
[64]J. W. Britton, B. C. Sawyer, A. C. Keith, C.-C. J. Wang, J. K. Freericks, H. Uys, M. J. Biercuk, and J. J. Bollinger, Engineered two-dimensional ising interactions in a trapped-ion quantum simulator with hundreds of spins, Nature 484, 489 (2012).DOI
[65]Tsubokawa, I. (1960). On the Magnetic Properties of a CrBr3 Single Crystal. J. Phys. Soc. Jpn., 15, 1664.
[66]J. F. Dillon, Jr. and C. E. Olson, Magnetization, Resonance, and Optical Properties of the Ferromagnet CrI3, Journal of Applied Physics 36, 1259 (1965).DOI
[67]C. Gong, L. Li, Z. Li, H. Ji, A. Stern, Y. Xia, T. Cao, W. Bao, C. Wang, Y. Wang, Z. Q. Qiu, R. J. Cava, S. G. Louie, J. Xia, and X. Zhang, Discovery of intrinsic ferromagnetism in two-dimensional van der Waals crystals, Nature 546, 265 (2017), publisher: Nature Publishing Group.DOI
[68]Lee, J.-U., Lee, S., Ryoo, J. H., Kang, T. Y., Kim, Y. K., Park, P., Park, C.-H., & Park, J.-G. (2016). Ising-Type Magnetic Ordering in Atomically Thin FePS3. Nano Lett, 16, 7433.
[69]M. Bonilla, S. Kolekar, Y. Ma, H. C. Diaz, V. Kalappattil, R. Das, T. Eggers, H. R. Gutierrez, M.-H. Phan, and M. Batzill, Strong room-temperature ferromagnetism in VSe2 monolayers on van der Waals substrates, Nature Nanotech 13, 289 (2018), publisher: Nature Publishing Group.DOI
[70]D. J. O’Hara, T. Zhu, A. H. Trout, A. S. Ahmed, Y. K. Luo, C. H. Lee, M. R. Brenner, S. Rajan, J. A. Gupta, D. W. McComb, and R. K. Kawakami, Room Temperature Intrinsic Ferromagnetism in Epitaxial Manganese Selenide Films in the Monolayer Limit, Nano Lett. 18, 3125 (2018).DOI
[71]B. Huang, G. Clark, E. Navarro-Moratalla, D. R. Klein, R. Cheng, K. L. Seyler, D. Zhong, E. A. Schmidgall, M. A. McGuire, D. H. Cobden, W. Yao, D. Xiao, P. Jarillo-Herrero, and X. Xu, Layer-dependent ferromagnetism in a van der Waals crystal down to the monolayer limit, Nature 546, 270 (2017), publisher: Nature Publishing Group.DOI
[72]McGuire, M. A., Dixit, H., Cooper, V. R., & Sales, B. C. (2015). Coupling of Crystal Structure and Magnetism in the Layered, Ferromagnetic Insulator CrI3. Chem. Mater., 27, 612.
[73]McGuire, M. A. (2017). Crystal and Magnetic Structures in Layered, Transition Metal Dihalides and Trihalides. Crystals, 7, 121.
[74]Gibertini, M., Kaperski, M., Morpurgo, A. F., & Novoselov, K. S. (2019). Magnetic 2D materials and heterostructures. Nat. Nanotechnol., 14, 408.
[75]D. Zhong, K. L. Seyler, X. Linpeng, R. Cheng, N. Sivadas, B. Huang, E. Schmidgall, T. Taniguchi, K. Watanabe, M. A. McGuire, W. Yao, D. Xiao, K.-M. C. Fu, and X. Xu, Van der Waals engineering of ferromagnetic semiconductor heterostructure for spin and valleytronics, Science Advances 3, e1603113 (2017), publisher: American Association for the Advancement of Science.DOI
[76]O. Besbes, S. Nikolaev, N. Meskini, and I. Solovyev, Microscopic origin of ferromagnetism in the trihalides CrCl3 and CrI3, Phys. Rev. B 99, 104432 (2019), publisher: American Physical Society.DOI
[77]D. Soriano, M. I. Katsnelson, and J. Fernández-Rossier, Magnetic Two-Dimensional Chromium Trihalides: A Theoretical Perspective, Nano Lett. 20, 6225 (2020).DOI
[78]Solovyev, I. V. (2021). Exchange interactions and magnetic force theorem. Phys. Rev. B, 103, 104428.
[79]Schollwöck, U. (2011). The density-matrix renormalization group in the age of matrix product states. Annals of Physics, 326, 96.
[80]M. B. Hastings, An area law for one-dimensional quantum systems, Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment 2007, P08024 (2007).DOI
[81]Rigorous proofs for the area law conjecture are an open field of research, even though first steps have been made for two-dimensional frustration-free spin systems.. (n.d.). Rigorous proofs for the area law conjecture are an open field of research, even though first steps have been made for two-dimensional frustration-free spin systems..
[82]Anshu, A., Arad, I., & Gosset, D. (2022). An area law for 2d frustration-free spin systems. Proceedings of the 54th Annual ACM SIGACT Symposium on Theory of Computing, 12–18.
[83]F. Verstraete and J. I. Cirac, Renormalization algorithms for quantum-many body systems in two and higher dimensions (2004), arXiv:cond-mat/0407066 [cond-mat.str-el].DOI
[84]J. I. Cirac, D. Pérez-García, N. Schuch, and F. Verstraete, Matrix product states and projected entangled pair states: Concepts, symmetries, theorems, Rev. Mod. Phys. 93, 045003 (2021).DOI
[85]Vidal, G. (2007). Entanglement renormalization. Phys. Rev. Lett., 99, 220405.
[86]Schuch, N., Wolf, M. M., Verstraete, F., & Cirac, J. I. (2007). Computational complexity of projected entangled pair states. Phys. Rev. Lett., 98, 140506.
[87]S. Gonzalez-Garcia, S. Sang, T. H. Hsieh, S. Boixo, G. Vidal, A. C. Potter, and R. Vasseur, Random insights into the complexity of two-dimensional tensor network calculations (2023), arXiv:2307.11053 [quant-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2307.11053
[88]Elliott, R. J., Pfeuty, P., & Wood, C. (1970). Ising model with a transverse field. Phys. Rev. Lett., 25, 443.
[89]Koffel, T., Lewenstein, M., & Tagliacozzo, L. (2012). Entanglement entropy for the long-range ising chain in a transverse field. Phys. Rev. Lett., 109, 267203.
[90]Fey, S., Kapfer, S. C., & Schmidt, K. P. (2019). Quantum criticality of two-dimensional quantum magnets with long-range interactions. Phys. Rev. Lett., 122, 017203.
[91]P. Scholl, M. Schuler, H. J. Williams, A. A. Eberharter, D. Barredo, K.-N. Schymik, V. Lienhard, L.-P. Henry, T. C. Lang, T. Lahaye, A. M. Läuchli, and A. Browaeys, Quantum simulation of 2d antiferromagnets with hundreds of rydberg atoms, Nature 595, 233 (2021).DOI
[92]M. P. Kaicher, D. Vodola, and S. B. Jäger, Mean-field treatment of the long-range transverse field ising model with fermionic gaussian states, Phys. Rev. B 107, 165144 (2023).DOI
[94]T. H. Dunning, Gaussian basis sets for use in correlated molecular calculations. I. the atoms boron through neon and hydrogen, The Journal of Chemical Physics 90, 1007 (1989).DOI
[95]T. Egli, M. Bally, and T. Uetz, Microbial degradation of chelating agents used in detergents with special reference to nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA), Biodegradation 1, 121 (1990).DOI
[96]H. A. Mottola, Nltrilotriacetic acid as a chelating agent: Applications, toxicology, and bio-environmental impact, Toxicological & Environmental Chemistry 2, 99 (1974).DOI
[97]R. S. Dybczyński, Z. Samczyński, and E. Chajduk, Comparison of usefulness of four chelating agents (EDTA, NTA, ODA and IDA) for the chromatographic separation of micro and macro amounts of rare earth elements, Critical Reviews in Analytical Chemistry , 1 (2021).DOI
[98]A. Checa-Fernandez, A. Santos, A. Romero, and C. M. Dominguez, Application of chelating agents to enhance fenton process in soil remediation: A review, Catalysts 11, 722 (2021).DOI
[99]Gulcin, İ., & Alwasel, S. H. (2022). Metal ions, metal chelators and metal chelating assay as antioxidant method. Processes, 10, 132.
[100]Prete, P., Fiorentino, A., Rizzo, L., Proto, A., & Cuccin iello, R. (2021). Review of aminopolycarboxylic acids–based metal complexes application to water and wastewater treatment by (photo-)Fenton process at neutral pH. Current Opinion in Green and Sustainable Chemistry, 28, 100451.
[101]Sales, T. A., Prandi, I. G., de Castro, A. A., Leal, D. H., da Cunha, E. F., Kuca, K., & Ramalho, T. C. (2019). Recent developments in metal-based drugs and chelating agents for neurodegenerative diseases treatments. International Journal of Molecular Sciences, 20, 1829.
[102]A. Eviazihollagh, H. Svanedal, H. Edlund, and M. Norgren, On chelating surfactants: Molecular perspectives and application prospects, Journal of Molecular Liquids 278, 688 (2019).DOI
[103]I. S. S. Pinto, I. F. F. Neto, and H. M. Soares, Biodegradable chelating agents for industrial, domestic, and agricultural applications—a review, Environmental Science and Pollution Research 21, 11893 (2014).DOI
[104]Lehn, L., Deglmann, P., & Kühn, M. (2024). Chelate complexes of 3d transition metal ions – a challenge for electronic-structure methods?. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation, 20, 4545. 38805381
[105]F. Weigend, F. Furche, and R. Ahlrichs, Gaussian basis sets of quadruple zeta valence quality for atoms H-Kr, J. Chem. Phys. 119, 12753 (2003).DOI
[106]Weigend, F., & Ahlrichs, R. (2005). Balanced basis sets of split valence, triple zeta valence and quadruple zeta valence quality for H to Rn: Design and assessment of accuracy. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 7, 3297.
[107]Lewis, P. (1986). Effect of ozone on rubber: Countermeasures and unsolved problems. Polymer Degradation and Stability, 15, 33.
[108]Onishi, T. (2017). Molecular orbital calculation of diatomic molecule. In Quantum Computational Chemistry (pp. 113–157). https://doi.org/Springer Singapore
[109]Zaichenko, A., Schröder, D., Janek, J., & Mollenhauer, D. (2020). Pathways to triplet or singlet oxygen during the dissociation of alkali metal superoxides: Insights by multireference calculations of molecular model systems. Chemistry – A European Journal, 26, 2395.
[110]Gräfenstein, J., Kraka, E., & Cremer, D. (1998). Density functional theory for open-shell singlet biradicals. Chem. Phys. Lett., 288, 593.
[111]Siebert, R., Schinke, R., & Bittererová, M. (2001). Spectroscopy of ozone at the dissociation threshold: Quantum calculations of bound and resonance states on a new global potential energy surface. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys., 3, 1795.
[112]Holka, F., Szalay, P. G., Müller, T., & Tyuterev, V. G. (2010). Toward an improved ground state potential energy surface of ozone. J. Phys. Chem. A, 114, 9927.
[113]Dawes, R., Lolur, P., Ma, J., & Guo, H. (2011). Communication: Highly accurate ozone formation potential and implications for kinetics. J. Chem. Phys., 135, 081102.
[114]Dawes, R., Lolur, P., Li, A., Jiang, B., & Guo, H. (2013). Communication: An accurate global potential energy surface for the ground electronic state of ozone. J. Chem. Phys., 139, 201103.
[115]Amsler, M., Deglmann, P., Degroote, M., Kaicher, M. P., Kiser, M., Kühn, M., Kumar, C., Maier, A., Samsonidze, A., Schroeder, M., Streif, D., Vodola, D., Wever, C., & Group, Q. M. S. W. (2023). Classical and quantum trial wave functions in auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo applied to oxygen allotropes and a CuBr2 model system. The Journal of Chemical Physics, 159, 044119.
[116]Krupenie, P. H. (1972). The spectrum of molecular oxygen. Journal of Physical and Chemical Reference Data, 1, 423.
[117]Tanaka, T., & Morino, Y. (1970). Coriolis interaction and anharmonic potential function of ozone from the microwave spectra in the excited vibrational states. Journal of Molecular Spectroscopy, 33, 538.
[118]Helgaker, T., Jørgensen, P., & Olsen, J. (2000). Spin in second quantization. In Molecular Electronic-Structure Theory (pp. 34–79).
[119]Szabo, A., & Ostlund, N. S. (2012). Modern quantum chemistry: introduction to advanced electronic structure theory.
[120]Roothaan, C. C. J. (1960). Self-consistent field theory for open shells of electronic systems. Reviews of Modern Physics, 32, 179.
[121]Lee, T. J., & Taylor, P. R. (1989). A diagnostic for determining the quality of single-reference electron correlation methods. International Journal of Quantum Chemistry, 36, 199.
[122]Janssen, C. L., & Nielsen, I. M. (1998). New diagnostics for coupled-cluster and møller–plesset perturbation theory. Chemical Physics Letters, 290, 423.
[123]Murta, B., & Fernández-Rossier, J. (2024). From heisenberg to hubbard: An initial state for the shallow quantum simulation of correlated electrons. Physical Review B, 109, 035128.
[124]Gutzwiller, M. C. (1963). Effect of correlation on the ferromagnetism of transition metals. Physical Review Letters, 10, 159.
[125]Murta, B., & Fernández-Rossier, J. (2021). Gutzwiller wave function on a digital quantum computer. Physical Review B, 103, L241113.
[126]Seki, K., Otsuka, Y., & Yunoki, S. (2022). Gutzwiller wave function on a quantum computer using a discrete hubbard-stratonovich transformation. Physical Review B, 105, 155119.
[127]Bach, V., Lieb, E. H., & Solovej, J. P. (1994). Generalized hartree-fock theory and the hubbard model. Journal of Statistical Physics, 76, 3.
[128]Wick, G. C. (1950). The evaluation of the collision matrix. Physical Review, 80, 268.
[129]Jordan, P., & Wigner, E. (1928). Über das paulische äquivalenzverbot. Zeitschrift für Physik, 47, 631.
[130]Note, that simulations with ν = 2 would already require max(|Dₗ|) = 11 in the quasi one-dimensional triangular ladder we consider. For a true two-dimensional triangular ladder with extension in both x- and y-direction, a Manhattan distance ν = 1 (ν = 2) would lead to max(|Dₗ|) = 10 (max(|Dₗ|) = 24).
[131]Huang, Y., Shao, Y., Ren, W., Sun, J., & Lv, D. (2023). Efficient quantum imaginary time evolution by drifting real-time evolution: An approach with low gate and measurement complexity. Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation, 19, 3868.
[132]McArdle, S., Endo, S., Aspuru-Guzik, A., Benjamin, S. C., & Yuan, X. (2020). Quantum computational chemistry. Reviews of Modern Physics, 92, 015003.
[133]G. Aleksandrowicz, T. Alexander, P. Barkoutsos, L. Bello, Y. Ben-Haim, D. Bucher, F. J. Cabrera-Hernández, J. Carballo-Franquis, A. Chen, C.-F. Chen, J. M. Chow, A. D. Córcoles-Gonzales, A. J. Cross, A. Cross, J. Cruz-Benito, C. Culver, S. D. L. P. González, E. D. L. Torre, D. Ding, E. Dumitrescu, I. Duran, P. Eendebak, M. Everitt, I. F. Sertage, A. Frisch, A. Fuhrer, J. Gambetta, B. G. Gago, J. Gomez-Mosquera, D. Greenberg, I. Hamamura, V. Havlicek, J. Hellmers, Łukasz Herok, H. Horii, S. Hu, T. Imamichi, T. Itoko, A. Javadi-Abhari, N. Kanazawa, A. Karazeev, K. Krsulich, P. Liu, Y. Luh, Y. Maeng, M. Marques, F. J. Martín-Fernández, D. T. McClure, D. McKay, S. Meesala, A. Mezzacapo, N. Moll, D. M. Rodríguez, G. Nannicini, P. Nation, P. Ollitrault, L. J. O’Riordan, H. Paik, J. Pérez, A. Phan, M. Pistoia, V. Prutyanov, M. Reuter, J. Rice, A. R. Davila, R. H. Ruddy, M. Ryu, N. Sathyaye, C. Schnabel, E. Schoute, K. Setia, Y. Shi, A. Silva, Y. Siraichi, S. Sivarajah, J. A. Smolin, M. Soeken, H. Takahashi, I. Tavernelli, C. Taylor, P. Taylour, K. Trabing, M. Treinish, W. Turner, D. Vogt-Lee, C. Vuillot, J. A. Wildstrom, J. Wilson, E. Winston, C. Wood, S. Wood, S. Wörner, I. Y. Akhalwaya, and C. Zoufal, Qiskit: An Open-source Framework for Quantum Computing (2019).
[135]Wecker, D., Hastings, M. B., & Troyer, M. (2015). Progress towards practical quantum variational algorithms. Physical Review A, 92. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.92.024303
[136]D. Amaro, M. Rosenkranz, N. Fitzpatrick, K. Hirano, and M. Fiorentini, A case study of variational quantum algorithms for a job shop scheduling problem, EPJ Quantum Technology 9, 10.1140/epjqt/s40507-022-00123-4 (2022).DOI
[137]Gacon, J., Zoufal, C., Carleo, G., & Woerner, S. (2023). Stochastic approximation of variational quantum imaginary time evolution. 2023 IEEE International Conference on Quantum Computing and Engineering (QCE).
[138]R. Wiersema, C. Zhou, Y. de Sereville, J. F. Carrasquilla, Y. B. Kim, and H. Yuen, Exploring entanglement and optimization within the hamiltonian variational ansatz, PRX Quantum 1, 10.1103/prxquantum.1.020319 (2020).DOI
[139]N. Gomes, A. Mukherjee, F. Zhang, T. Iadecola, C. Wang, K. H. Ho, P. P. Orth, and Y. Yao, Adaptive variational quantum imaginary time evolution approach for ground state preparation, Advanced Quantum Technologies 4, 10.1002/qute.202100114 (2021).DOI
[140]Yang, C. N., & Yang, C. P. (1966). One-Dimensional Chain of Anisotropic Spin-Spin Interactions. I. Proof of Bethe’s Hypothesis for Ground State in a Finite System. Physical Review, 150, 321.
[141]Albertini, G., Korepin, V. E., & Schadschneider, A. (1995). XXZ model as an effective Hamiltonian for generalized hubbard models with broken eta-symmetry. Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and General, 28, L303–L309.
[142]E. van den Berg, Z. K. Minev, and K. Temme, Model-free readout-error mitigation for quantum computation, Physical Review A 105, 10.1103/physreva.105.032620 (2022).DOI
[143]K. Temme, S. Bravyi, and J. M. Gambetta, Error mitigation for short-depth quantum circuits, Physical Review Letters 119, 10.1103/physrevlett.119.180509 (2017).DOI
[144]Y. Li and S. C. Benjamin, Efficient variational quantum simulator incorporating active error minimization, Physical Review X 7, 10.1103/physrevx.7.021050 (2017).DOI
[145]Rivero, P., Metz, F., Hasan, A., Brańczyk, A. M., & Johnson, C. (2023). Zero noise extrapolation prototype.