betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Unmasking Hidden Wigner's Symmetry from First Principles

Abstract

We present quantitative evidence that high-quality internucleon forces derived from χχEFT exhibit a striking dominance of Wigner's supermultiplet symmetry, without invoking the large-NcN_c limit of QCD or assumptions about specific nuclei. We trace the manifestation of this symmetry in nuclear structure using the ab initio Symmetry Adapted Model (SAM) and identify suppressed spin-isospin polarizability. Our calculations show that a majority of 4He\rm ^4He, 6Li\rm ^6Li, and 6He\rm ^6He wave functions is concentrated in a few U(4)\rm U(4) irreducible representations, without imposing any a priori constraints on the model space. This emergent feature points to a strategy for reducing explosive many-body bases of the NCSM while retaining physically important configurations needed to compute observables.

Symmetry is a fundamental organizing principle that appears throughout the natural and human-made world. Atomic nuclei are no exception; despite the intricacy of the nuclear force, nuclei exhibit an orderly pattern of large deformation underpinned by the recurring dominance of Elliott’s SU(3) and symplectic Sp(3, R) symmetries [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]. In addition, nuclei display a so-called supermultiplet symmetry, an idea suggested by Wigner almost a century ago [6] as an umbrella symmetry encompassing the spin and isospin degrees of freedom of nucleons via a special unitary group chain SU(4) ⊃\supset SUS_S(2) ⊗\otimes SUT_T(2). Figure 1 illustrates the limit of the SU(4) symmetry, where the six ss-wave spin-isospin states of the two-nucleon system transform under an SU(4) sextet [7]. The symmetry emerges in the large-NcN_c (number of colors) limit of quantum chromodynamics (QCD) at momentum resolution around 500 MeV and in the limit of large scattering lengths [21]. Wigner’s symmetry also arises at the SU(3)-flavor-symmetric point of QCD [22], and is linked to entanglement suppression of the strong interaction in the infrared [23]. Early investigations tested the symmetry in sd-shell [24, 25] and fp-shell nuclei [26], while algebraic solutions have been proposed to mitigate SU(4)-symmetry breaking in heavy systems [27, 28]. Recently, the first ab initio probe of the symmetry and its impact on the two-body weak current have been established via the No-Core Shell Model (NCSM) [29].

Illustration of Wigner’s symmetry for the two-nucleon system

Figure 1. Illustration of Wigner’s symmetry for the two-nucleon system (green balls). Neutron (red balls) and proton (blue balls) can assume spin up or down. There are two spin-singlet states for nn and pp cases. For np case, there are three spin-triplet states and one spin-singlet state. At the exact SU(4) limit, all six states are identical as seen by the nuclear force.

Much progress has been made to establish the origin of Wigner’s symmetry and its relevance to nuclear systems. Evidence for the symmetry appears in the weak binding of the deuteron [8] and nucleon-nucleon scattering phase shifts [9], while its consequences extend to heavier nuclei through nuclear mass [10, 11], β\beta-decay [12, 13, 14], ββ\beta\beta-decay [15, 16], electron scattering [17], and Gamow–Teller resonances [18]. Effective field theories (EFTs) and lattice simulations [8, 9, 19, 20] show that

Nuclear physicists have strived to exploit Wigner’s symmetry in first-principles modeling of atomic nuclei. Notable application is the use of SU(4)-symmetric interactions in lattice simulations of nuclei and nuclear matter [30, 31, 32, 33, 34]. The advantage of such symmetry-preserving potentials lies in their capability to mitigate the sign problem of fermionic quantum Monte Carlo [35] and map out nuclear structure with resolution on par with high-fidelity realistic interactions [36, 37]. Nonetheless, understanding how the symmetry emerges in structure of nuclei from the strong nuclear force and, more importantly, leveraging the symmetry in modeling nuclear states remain elusive.

This Letter presents the first ab initio calculation that fully employs Wigner’s symmetry as a guiding principle, enabled by the ab initio Symmetry Adapted Model (SAM), the successor to the Symmetry-Adapted No-Core Shell Model (SA-NCSM) [38]. The SAM offers unequivocal evidence for the prevalence of Wigner’s symmetry in realistic nuclear forces without considering the large-NcN_c limit or any nuclei. Moreover, analysis of SAM nuclear wave functions reveals a preference toward suppressed spin-isospin polarizability that complements dominant quadrupole collectivity. These wave functions are high-resolution maps of all U(4) irreducible representations (irreps) realized by a nucleus, made possible by the first fully generic calculator of U(4)U(4) coupling coefficients [39] together with its modern U(3)U(3) counterpart [40]. (Though SU(4)SU(4) irreps suffice for spin and isospin decomposition, we build the SAM with U(4)U(4) irreps to implicitly include the particle number.) We further show that this pattern can be leveraged to compress NCSM bases to sets of physically relevant configurations that are adequate to compute nuclear observables, including binding energies, radii, electromagnetic moments and weak decay. Our long-term goal is to design a selection strategy optimized for SU(4)SU(4)-driven electroweak processes, especially β\beta-decay for tests of the Standard Model [41, 42, 43].

Wigner’s Symmetry of the Nuclear Force—In the SAM, nucleons are strongly interacting via realistic nuclear potentials derived from the state-of-the-art χ\chiEFT and constrained by few-body data. In conventional shell models

like the NCSM, one must construct these interactions with the standard quantum numbers of the three dimensional harmonic oscillator, ∣ηljmjmt⟩\lvert\eta l j m_j m_t\rangle. However, as the SAM builds on a symmetry-adapted basis of the harmonic oscillator, adoption of these interactions necessitates a transformation to tensors that carry the same quantum numbers as the basis. In other words, these interactions are expanded in terms of U(3)⊗U(4)U(3) \otimes U(4) tensors, each equipped with their own strength [44] that is determined by matrix elements of the interaction together with U(4)U(4) [39] and U(3)U(3) [40] coupling coefficients, see Eqs. (1)–(2) in the Supplemental Material (SM) [45]. While facilitating the admittance of high-fidelity interactions, this task can reveal special symmetries hidden in nuclear potentials, which might not be trivial to realize in other bases.

We explore the two-body part of four χ\chiEFT interactions, namely N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}} [46], N2LOsat_{\mathrm{sat}} [47], N3LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}} and N4LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}} by Entem-Machleidt-Nosyk with a 500 MeV regulator cutoff [48], whose matrix elements are streamlined from NuHamil library [49]. Without limiting to any specific nuclei or renormalization, we study these potentials across various shell separation energies, ℏΩ\hbar\Omega, and Nmax⁡N_{\max} model spaces in which the tensor expansion is capped (definition of Nmax⁡N_{\max} herein is analogous to that of the NCSM). There are four U(4)U(4) ranks in the expansion, [0,0,0,0][0,0,0,0], [2,2,0,0][2,2,0,0], [4,2,2,0][4,2,2,0] and [2,1,1,0][2,1,1,0], as shown in Figure 2. The first is U(4)U(4)-scalar and representative of the central nuclear force, whereas the rest appear due to the symmetry-breaking interactions (e.g., spin-orbit, tensor, Coulomb). To gain quantitative insights into the signature of Wigner’s symmetry, we perform statistical analysis of the strength distributions in the tensor expansion.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Expansion of four interactions, namely N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}} (blue circle), N2LOsat_{\mathrm{sat}} (gold square), N3LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}} (green diamond) and N4LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}} (red right triangle) in terms of U(3)⊗U(4)U(3) \otimes U(4) tensors. Plot (a) shows the distributions of strengths for four U(4)U(4) ranks, [0,0,0,0][0,0,0,0], [2,2,0,0][2,2,0,0], [4,2,2,0][4,2,2,0] and [2,1,1,0][2,1,1,0], at ℏΩ=20\hbar\Omega= 20 MeV and Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4. Plot (b) juxtaposes their statistical means and standard deviations (std). Plot (c) demonstrates the Nmax⁡N_{\max} dependence of the mean strengths for N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}}; the middle line represents ℏΩ=20\hbar\Omega= 20 MeV, whereas the colored bands are bounded by ℏΩ=15\hbar\Omega= 15 MeV and ℏΩ=25\hbar\Omega= 25 MeV.

Our probe reveals that the largest strengths are concentrated in U(4)U(4)-scalar tensors, Figure 2(a), which in turn protect the spin-isospin content of wave functions. This is further supported by evidence that the standard deviations of the strength distributions of the scalar tensors are roughly 2-5 times larger than those of the other U(4)U(4) tensors across the four interactions, Figure 2(b). Moreover, the mean strengths of the scalar tensors dominate by a significant departure from zero; indeed, at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4, they are about 6-9, 12-14, 28-53 times larger than those of [2,2,0,0][2,2,0,0], [2,1,1,0][2,1,1,0] and [4,2,2,0][4,2,2,0] tensors, respectively. Such a dominance continues to be valid for different ℏΩ\hbar\Omega energies and even gets enhanced in larger Nmax⁡N_{\max} spaces, Figure 2(c), notwithstanding the convergence of all mean strengths toward zero, see Fig. 1 in SM [45]. These results confirm that the primary drivers of nuclear binding possess dominant U(4)U(4) symmetry [30].

Note that comparing the means and standard deviations of the strength distributions between these potentials reveals that the most U(4)U(4)-symmetric one is N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}}, which points to the softness of this interaction and suggests emergent symmetries and other large-NcN_c constraints [9] be considered in optimizing realistic interactions.

Wigner’s Symmetry in Nuclear Structure

Having seen the approximate U(4) symmetry of nuclear interactions, one wonders how such a feature is manifested in nuclear structure. First-principles SAM calculations confirm results in [29] that a large fraction of nuclear wave functions is concentrated within a few irreps regardless of the interaction and uncover that their dominance is persistent across each ℏΩ\hbar\Omega subspace. Distinct from [29], which extracts irrep probabilities by diagonalizing the SU(4) quadratic Casimir operator, C2C_2, our basis is constructed explicitly on U(4) irreps, enabling direct reading of the irrep contribution. We compute the ground state (01+0_1^+) of 4^{4}He (even-even), the ground state (11+1_1^+) and three low-lying excited states (31+3_1^+, 21+2_1^+, 12+1_2^+) of 6^{6}Li (odd-odd), and the ground-state rotational band (01+0_1^+) of 6^{6}He (halo), followed by an analysis of all U(4) irrep probabilities in their Nmax⁡=10N_{\max}=10 model spaces. The two-body Hamiltonian consists of three terms, the intrinsic kinetic energy, a realistic potential (N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}}, N3LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}} or N4LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}}) and the Gloeckner-Lawson term for removal of the center-of-mass excitations [50]. Inclusion of three-body forces increases the symmetry breaking slightly but leaves the dominance pattern intact [29].

First, we observe that for all interactions a major probability of the ground-state wave functions is occupied by a single irrep residing in the 0ℏΩ0\hbar\Omega subspace, Figure 3, which has the lowest value of C2C_2. Since C2=S2+T2+GT2C_2=S^2+T^2+GT^2 [51], where the SU(4) generators SS, TT and GTGT are the spin, isospin and Gamow-Teller operators, respectively, such a strong preference toward low values of C2C_2 may be understood as a suppression of spin-isospin polarizability of the nuclear force, which is also found to exist in infinite nuclear matter at low densities [52].

Probability distributions of all U(4) irreps in the ground states of $^{4}$He, $^{6}$Li and $^{6}$He

Figure 3. Probability distributions of all U(4) irreps in the ground states of 4^{4}He, 6^{6}Li and 6^{6}He computed in Nmax⁡=10N_{\max}=10 model spaces with three bare interactions, namely N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}}, N3LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}} and N4LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}} at ℏΩ=20\hbar\Omega=20 MeV. The gray-shaded areas indicate that the irreps are not allowed within a given subspace. The irreps are organized in the increasing order of the SU(4) quadratic Casimir invariant from left to right on the horizontal axes. Here the irreps are normalized according to [39].

Second, as more quanta are added to excite nucleons to higher shells, more arrangements of particles are allowed, thus more irreps can enter to the model space. However, since the total number of nucleons, AA, is constrained, at sufficiently high Nmax⁡N_{\max} where the most symmetric irrep [A,0,0,0][A,0,0,0] begins to appear, no new irreps can show up. We find that in excited subspaces, mixing between different irreps takes place, Figure 3; nevertheless, the admixture is distributed among the same set of irreps across these ℏΩ\hbar\Omega spaces. Specifically, we witness that the ground state of the α\alpha-particle is predominantly U(4)-scalar ([0,0,0,0][0,0,0,0]) [4] slightly mixed with [2,2,0,0][2,2,0,0] irrep, whereas the other irreps contribute no more than 0.05%. Similarly, the two A=6A=6 isobars assume virtually the same set of three dominant irreps ([1,1,0,0][1,1,0,0], [3,2,1,0][3,2,1,0] and [3,3,0,0][3,3,0,0]) in each excited ℏΩ\hbar\Omega subspace, whereas the others represent less than 0.8%. Such akin U(4) structure paves the way for β\beta-decay to occur between them [8, 29]. These results suggest that i) solving nuclei with small Nmax⁡N_{\max} may be sufficient to predict the most significant irreps in larger model spaces, and ii) isobaric species share analogous U(4) patterns allowing for electroweak processes [29].

Third, the considered excited states demonstrate similar patterns of U(4) irrep probability distribution compared to the ground state (Figure 2 in SM [45]). The irrep of smallest C2C_2 in the 0ℏΩ0\hbar\Omega subspace remains the largest contributor; and despite a slight enhancement of admixture in excited subspaces, it is astonishingly distributed to the same set of irreps that dominate the ground state.

**Pattern-Recognition Nuclear Modeling—**The efficacy of the SA-NCSM stems from its exceptional capability to expose recurring orderly patterns of physically relevant degrees of freedom, thus empowering a strategic selection of configurations that suffice to reproduce and predict nuclear observables accurately. Following the footstep of its predecessor, the SAM with many-body basis built explicitly on U(3) and U(4) irreps also allows for a selection scheme to refine the NCSM space based upon the dominance of these two symmetries. Specifically, SAM model spaces are defined by a pair of numbers ⟨Nmax⁡⊥⟩Nmax⁡⊤\langle N_{\max}^{\perp}\rangle N_{\max}^{\top} [2], which implies the inclusion of all configurations up through Nmax⁡⊥N_{\max}^{\perp} and only a subset of U(3) and U(4) irreps between Nmax⁡⊥N_{\max}^{\perp} and Nmax⁡⊤N_{\max}^{\top}. Such a truncation still guarantees the spurious center-of-mass separation [53] since the Gloeckner-Lawson operator is a U(3)- and U(4)-scalar and cannot connect different ℏΩ\hbar\Omega subspaces.

This Letter focuses on how U(4)-guided selection of basis states affects ab initio calculations of nuclear observables without any U(3) irrep selection as it has been investigated extensively via the SA-NCSM. Specifically, we construct model spaces for 6^{6}Li and 6^{6}He with Nmax⁡⊤=10N_{\max}^{\top}=10 and vary Nmax⁡⊥N_{\max}^{\perp} from 2 to 8. In each ℏΩ\hbar\Omega subspace where selection of U(4) irreps is performed, we keep the most dominant irreps [1,1,0,0][1,1,0,0], [3,2,1,0][3,2,1,0] and [3,3,0,0][3,3,0,0] for both nuclei. The resulting dimensions of ⟨2⟩10\langle2\rangle10, ⟨4⟩10\langle4\rangle10, ⟨6⟩10\langle6\rangle10 and ⟨8⟩10\langle8\rangle10 spaces are roughly 67–74% for 6^{6}Li and 47–57% for 6^{6}He compared with their complete Nmax⁡=10N_{\max}=10 spaces. Our calculations include binding energies EE, electric quadrupole moments QQ, magnetic dipole moments μ\mu, point-nucleon root-mean-squared matter radii rmr_m, and Gamow-Teller β\beta-decay reduced matrix elements GT, using the N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}} interaction with ℏΩ=20\hbar\Omega=20 MeV. Among these observables, the magnetic dipole moments prove to be the least dependent on Nmax⁡N_{\max} in full and truncated spaces (deviations ∼10−3\sim10^{-3}–10−210^{-2} for 6^{6}Li, Figure 5).

Selected observables of $^{6}$Li using N2LO$_{\mathrm{opt}}$

Figure 5. Selected observables of 6^{6}Li using N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}} at ℏΩ=20\hbar\Omega= 20 MeV, including electric quadrupole moments QQ, magnetic dipole moments μ\mu, point-nucleon root-mean-squared matter radii rmr_m, and reduced Gamow-Teller matrix elements GTthGT_{\mathrm{th}} relative to the experimental value GTexpGT_{\mathrm{exp}} from [58]. Herein, the markers have similar meaning to those in Figure 4.

Figure 4 demonstrates the efficacy of the selection for computing binding energies. For the stable nucleus 6^{6}Li, the ⟨2⟩10\langle2\rangle10 space already delivers 99%, 99%, 98% and 97% of binding energies for the states 11+1^{+}_{1}, 31+3^{+}_{1}, 21+2^{+}_{1} and 12+1^{+}_{2}, respectively, relative to the full-space calculations, Figure 4(a). Meanwhile, the same level of predictions for the ground state and first excited state of 6^{6}He is achieved in the ⟨6⟩10\langle6\rangle10 space, Figure 4(c). Moreover, varying Nmax⁡⊥N_{\max}^{\perp}

Binding energies for ground and excited states of 6Li and 6He

Figure 4. Binding energies for ground and excited states of 6^{6}Li and 6^{6}He at ℏΩ=20\hbar\Omega=20 MeV. We employ N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}} [(a) and (c)] and the two-body part of N3LOEM500_{\mathrm{EM}}500 used in the resolution scale λ=2.0\lambda=2.0 fm−1^{-1} [(b) and (d)]. Herein, black circles represent full model space calculations, whereas red diamonds correspond to restricted spaces with Nmax⁡⊤=10N_{\max}^{\top}=10. Blue horizontal bars demonstrate experimental values [54].

produces almost identical results with differences in the order of 10−110^{-1} MeV.

We also explore combining the same selection with a low-momentum interaction obtained from the similarity renormalization group (SRG) [55]. We use the two-body part of N3LOEM500_{\mathrm{EM}}500 potential by Entem-Machleidt with 500 MeV regulator cutoff [56], which is softened using the momentum scale λ=2.0\lambda=2.0 fm−1^{-1} [57], and compute binding energies for the same states for 6^{6}Li and 6^{6}He. Incorporating both methodologies is very effective: this soft interaction produces faster convergence to experiment than the N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}}, and the selection preserves that trend. Specifically, the binding and excitation energies for both nuclei converge toward experimental values within 0.3–1.1 MeV, and the ⟨2⟩10\langle2\rangle10 space reproduces binding of 6^{6}Li’s ground and excited states within 330 keV of the full-space results, Figure 4(b), while 98% and 97% of 01+0^{+}_{1} and 21+2^{+}_{1} bindings are attained in the same space of 6^{6}He, Figure 4(d).

To investigate how spin-isospin-guided selection affects long-range correlations in the wave functions, we examine the electric quadrupole moments and point-nucleon root-mean-squared matter radii of 6^{6}Li, Figure 5. First, all restricted spaces reproduce the correct sign of the challenging 11+1^{+}_{1} quadrupole moment and yield nearly identical values for 31+3^{+}_{1} and 21+2^{+}_{1} relative to full-space results, while differences for 12+1^{+}_{2} remain at only a few percent. Second, the selected spaces produce nearly indistinguishable radii to those of the complete spaces, with deviations appearing only at the second decimal place for all states.

Of special interest in the SAM development is the weak process, β\beta-decay, because the transition is dominated by the Gamow-Teller (GTGT) operator [59], an SU(4) generator [29], implying that a basis encoding Wigner’s symmetry can guide selection of configurations that capture vital spin-isospin correlations for this process. Figure 5 displays the results obtained from the full and restricted model spaces. First, our complete Nmax⁡=10N_{\max} = 10 reduced matrix element agrees with NCSM calculation using the same interaction [60] and differs from experiment within 5%. Moreover, we find that [1,1,0,0][1,1,0,0] strongly dominates the process, contributing roughly 90% of the total GTGT. Second, we witness that values from the selected spaces slightly exceed complete spaces of lower Nmax⁡N_{\max}, which we attribute to an enhanced [1,1,0,0][1,1,0,0] contribution and will investigate other truncation choices in future work. Nevertheless, that the restricted spaces yield deviation within 2% of the complete space demonstrates that essential configurations are retained.

In summary, we report an exceptional predominance of Wigner’s symmetry in low-energy realistic nuclear forces without examining the large-NcN_c limit or making assumptions about any nuclei. That we find the N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}} interaction to be slightly more symmetric than the others suggests emergent symmetries and other large-NcN_c properties be appreciated in future structure calculations. We trace the presence of the symmetry in wave functions of some light nuclei and identify a suppression of spin-isospin polarizability of the nuclear force. Recognizing the recurring pattern of the U(4) symmetry, we test the potency of a strategic selection that filters out less important configurations in NCSM model spaces. Calculations of nuclear observables in truncated spaces prove to retain the accuracy of our predictions. It is also seen that deployment of a low-momentum interaction in symmetry-guided bases can be powerful by preserving the fast convergence in smaller spaces. Nonetheless, much more work remains to be done, our ultimate goal is to establish a comprehensive strategy that can go upward in the nuclear chart and tackle heavy species, one that combines high-quality nuclear forces, state-of-the-art SRG methods and many-body bases guided by emergent orderly patterns.

We thank Anna McCoy, Feng Pan, Dean Lee, Bingcheng He, Thomas Papenbrock, William Shelton, Kristina D. Launey and József Cseh for useful discussions and insights. This work was supported by LSU Sponsored Research Rebate Program as well as LSU Foundation’s Distinguished Research Professorship Program. PD acknowledges support from the Quad Fellowship of the Institute of International Education and from LSU Summer Funding Opportunity for Graduate Students in STEM and Business Programs. This work was performed using high performance computing resources provided by LSU (www.hpc.lsu.edu).

All data produced in this work are included in the Letter. Specific numbers of quantities that are reported figuratively can be obtained from PD upon request.

References

Supplemental Material

Transformation of nuclear interactions to U(3) ⊗ U(4) tensors

The SA-NCSM admits realistic nuclear interactions by expanding them in terms of two-body SU(3) ⊗ SU(2) tensors which are coupled products of creation and annihilation operators [44]; each tensor is equipped with a strength that is computed from normal ordered two-body JJ-coupled matrix elements [49] along with SU(3) coupling and SU(2) recoupling coefficients. Since the SAM works in U(3) ⊗ U(4)-adapted basis, we extend this formalism to transform nuclear interactions into U(3) ⊗ U(4) tensors, which is only possible with the first generic calculator of U(4) coupling coefficients [39].

The tensor expansion of a two-body nuclear potential is computationally demanding and is obtained via the following expression

V=14∑ηaηbηcηdΓa3Γa4Γb3Γb4ρ03Γ03κ0L0η0Γ04S0T0g{[a[1,0,0,0]†×a[1,0,0,0]†]Γf4Γf3×[a~[1,1,1,0]×a~[1,1,1,0]]Γi4Γi3}κ0L0S0T0J0=MJ0=MT0ρ0Γ03η03η04,(1)\mathcal{V} = \frac{1}{4} \sum_{\substack{\eta_a\eta_b\eta_c\eta_d\\ \Gamma^3_a\Gamma^4_a\Gamma^3_b\Gamma^4_b\\ \rho^3_0\Gamma^3_0\kappa_0L_0\\ \eta_0\Gamma^4_0S_0T_0}} g \left\{ \left[ a^\dagger_{[1,0,0,0]} \times a^\dagger_{[1,0,0,0]} \right]^{\Gamma^3_f}_{\Gamma^4_f} \times\left[ \widetilde{a}_{[1,1,1,0]} \times\widetilde{a}_{[1,1,1,0]} \right]^{\Gamma^3_i}_{\Gamma^4_i} \right\}^{\rho_0\Gamma^3_0\eta^3_0\eta^4_0}_{\kappa_0L_0S_0T_0J_0=M_J{}_0=M_T{}_0}, \tag*{(1)}

where the shell numbers (ηa,ηb,ηc,ηd)(\eta_a,\eta_b,\eta_c,\eta_d) run from 0 to the maximum shell, and Γ3\Gamma^3 and Γ4\Gamma^4 are shorthand notations for general U(3) and U(4) irreps, respectively. Note that T0T_0 is not vanishing as a generic two-body nuclear potential consists of isoscalar, isovector and isotensor parts. The strengths gg in the expansion are computed as follows

g=∑κiLiκfLf⟨⟨Γf3κfLf;Γi3κiLi∥∥Γ03κ0L0⟩⟩ρ0g = \sum_{\kappa_iL_i\kappa_fL_f} \left\langle\left\langle\Gamma^3_f\kappa_fL_f;\Gamma^3_i\kappa_iL_i \right\Vert\left\Vert\Gamma^3_0\kappa_0L_0 \right\rangle\right\rangle_{\rho_0}
∑lalb⟨[ηa,0,0]la;[ηb,0,0]lb∥Γf3κfLf⟩∑lcld⟨[ηd,ηd,0]ld;[ηc,ηc,0]lc∥Γi3κiLi⟩∑jajbjcjd1NabNcd\sum_{l_al_b} \left\langle[\eta_a,0,0]l_a;[\eta_b,0,0]l_b \middle\Vert\Gamma^3_f\kappa_fL_f \right\rangle\sum_{l_cl_d} \left\langle[\eta_d,\eta_d,0]l_d;[\eta_c,\eta_c,0]l_c \middle\Vert\Gamma^3_i\kappa_iL_i \right\rangle\sum_{j_aj_bj_cj_d} \frac{1}{\mathcal{N}_{ab}\mathcal{N}_{cd}}
∑JTiTf⟨ηalaja,ηblbjb;JTf∥V∥ηclcjc,ηdldjd;JTi⟩(2J+1)(2Tf+1)2T0+1(−)ηc+ηd+1−jc−jd+J+Ti×∑SiSfU(la1/2jalb1/2jbLfSfJ)⟨[1,0,0,0]1/2,1/2;[1,0,0,0]1/2,1/2∥ΓfSfTf4⟩×U(ld1/2jdlc1/2jcLiSiJ)⟨[1,1,1,0]1/2,1/2;[1,1,1,0]1/2,1/2∥ΓiSiTi4⟩×U(LfSfJLiSiJL0S00)⟨ΓfSfTf4;ΓiSiTi4∥Γ0ζ0S0T04⟩η0,(2)\begin{aligned} &\sum_{JT_iT_f}\langle\eta_a l_a j_a,\eta_b l_b j_b;JT_f\Vert V\Vert\eta_c l_c j_c,\eta_d l_d j_d;JT_i\rangle \sqrt{\frac{(2J+1)(2T_f+1)}{2T_0+1}}(-)^{\eta_c+\eta_d+1-j_c-j_d+J+T_i}\\ &\quad\times\sum_{S_iS_f}U\begin{pmatrix}l_a&1/2&j_a\\l_b&1/2&j_b\\L_f&S_f&J\end{pmatrix} \langle[1,0,0,0]1/2,1/2;[1,0,0,0]1/2,1/2\Vert\Gamma^4_{fS_fT_f}\rangle\\ &\quad\times U\begin{pmatrix}l_d&1/2&j_d\\l_c&1/2&j_c\\L_i&S_i&J\end{pmatrix} \langle[1,1,1,0]1/2,1/2;[1,1,1,0]1/2,1/2\Vert\Gamma^4_{iS_iT_i}\rangle\\ &\quad\times U\begin{pmatrix}L_f&S_f&J\\L_i&S_i&J\\L_0&S_0&0\end{pmatrix} \langle\Gamma^4_{fS_fT_f};\Gamma^4_{iS_iT_i}\Vert\Gamma^4_{0\zeta_0S_0T_0}\rangle_{\eta_0}, \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

where

  • ⟨ΓfκfLf3;ΓiκiLi3∥Γκ0L03⟩ρ0\langle\Gamma^3_{f\kappa_fL_f};\Gamma^3_{i\kappa_iL_i}\Vert\Gamma^3_{\kappa_0L_0}\rangle_{\rho_0}, ⟨[ηa,0,0]la;[ηb,0,0]lb∥ΓfκfLf3⟩\langle[\eta_a,0,0]_{l_a};[\eta_b,0,0]_{l_b}\Vert\Gamma^3_{f\kappa_fL_f}\rangle and ⟨[ηd,ηd,0]ld;[ηc,ηc,0]lc∥ΓiκiLi3⟩\langle[\eta_d,\eta_d,0]_{l_d};[\eta_c,\eta_c,0]_{l_c}\Vert\Gamma^3_{i\kappa_iL_i}\rangle are U(3) ⊃\supset SO(3) reduced coupling coefficients [40],

  • ⟨ΓfSfTf4;ΓiSiTi4∥Γ0ζ0S0T04⟩η0\langle\Gamma^4_{fS_fT_f};\Gamma^4_{iS_iT_i}\Vert\Gamma^4_{0\zeta_0S_0T_0}\rangle_{\eta_0}, ⟨[1,0,0,0]1/2,1/2;[1,0,0,0]1/2,1/2∥ΓfSfTf4⟩\langle[1,0,0,0]1/2,1/2;[1,0,0,0]1/2,1/2\Vert\Gamma^4_{fS_fT_f}\rangle and ⟨[1,1,1,0]1/2,1/2;[1,1,1,0]1/2,1/2∥ΓiSiTi4⟩\langle[1,1,1,0]1/2,1/2;[1,1,1,0]1/2,1/2\Vert\Gamma^4_{iS_iT_i}\rangle are U(4) ⊃\supset SUS_S(2) ⊗\otimes SUT_T(2) reduced coupling coefficients [39],

  • U(…)U(\ldots) coefficients are SU(2) recoupling coefficients,

  • Nab=1/1+δηaηbδlalbδjajb\mathcal{N}_{ab}=1/\sqrt{1+\delta_{\eta_a\eta_b}\delta_{l_al_b}\delta_{j_aj_b}} and Ncd=1/1+δηcηdδlcldδjcjd\mathcal{N}_{cd}=1/\sqrt{1+\delta_{\eta_c\eta_d}\delta_{l_cl_d}\delta_{j_cj_d}} are normalization factors,

  • ⟨ηalaja,ηblbjb;JTf∥V∥ηclcjc,ηdldjd;JTi⟩\langle\eta_a l_a j_a,\eta_b l_b j_b;JT_f\Vert V\Vert\eta_c l_c j_c,\eta_d l_d j_d;JT_i\rangle are normalized and antisymmetrized JTJT-coupled reduced matrix elements of the potential [49].

Tensor expansion statistics of N2LOsat, N3LOEMN500 and N4LOEMN500

In analyzing the behavior of the mean strengths of U(4) tensors as one increases Nmax⁡N_{\max} for N2LOopt (Figure 2) and N2LOsat, N3LOEMN500, N4LOEMN500 (Figure 6), we further identify three common features across all these nuclear potentials:

Mean strengths versus $N_{\max}$ for four U(4) ranks across three interactions

Figure 6. Dependence on Nmax⁡N_{\max} of the mean strengths for four U(4) ranks, [0,0,0,0][0,0,0,0] (purple down triangle), [2,2,0,0][2,2,0,0] (green stars), [4,2,2,0][4,2,2,0] (orange up triangle) and [2,1,1,0][2,1,1,0] (blue pentagons) in the tensor expansion of N2LOsat_{\mathrm{sat}}, N3LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}} and N4LOEMN500_{\mathrm{EMN500}} at shell separation energy ℏΩ=20\hbar\Omega= 20 MeV.

  1. As one expands the model space of tensor expansion with higher Nmax⁡N_{\max}, starting to appear are “long-range” tensors that can connect configurations differing in a large number of harmonic oscillator quanta. These tensors, though large in their numbers, possess very small strengths, which in turn bring down the overall mean strengths in the tensor expansion, demonstrated by the fact that all mean strengths converge toward zero. This behavior is consistent with the short-range nature of the nuclear force.

  1. In spite of the convergence trend, at each value of Nmax⁡N_{\max}, the scalar tensors always eclipse the other tensors. Specifically, at Nmax⁡=8N_{\max}=8, the mean strengths of the U(4)-symmetric tensors dominate those of [2, 2, 0, 0], [2, 1, 1, 0] and [4, 2, 2, 0] by a factor of 6-12, 41-59, 52-143, respectively.

  1. The mean strengths of the [4, 2, 2, 0] tensors approach zero the most quickly. It is seen that at Nmax⁡=2N_{\max}=2, these tensors seem to be the second dominant contributor to the nuclear force, however, at Nmax⁡=4N_{\max}=4, they begin to intrude below the [2, 2, 0, 0] tensors with the mean under 0.05, being the smallest among the four U(4) ranks.

Wigner’s symmetry in excited states

Figure 7 maps out the probability distributions of three excited states of 6Li^{6}\mathrm{Li} (31+3^+_1, 21+2^+_1, 12+1^+_2), and the first excited state of 6He^{6}\mathrm{He} (21+2^+_1) across six ℏΩ\hbar\Omega subspaces of their Nmax⁡=10N_{\max}=10 model spaces. It can be seen that the most prominent U(4) irreps in these states are [1, 1, 0, 0], [3, 2, 1, 0] and [3, 3, 0, 0], which also dominate the structure of their ground states. As pointed out in the main text, there is a slight enhancement of mixing. Specifically, the 12+1^+_2 state of 6Li^{6}\mathrm{Li} and the 21+2^+_1 state of 6He^{6}\mathrm{He} see an increased presence of the [2, 0, 0, 0] irrep.

Probability distributions of U(4) irreps in low-lying excited states of $^{6}$Li and $^{6}$He

Figure 7. Probability distributions of all U(4) irreps in low-lying excited states of 6^{6}Li (31+3^{+}_{1}, 21+2^{+}_{1}, 12+1^{+}_{2}), and 6^{6}He (21+2^{+}_{1}) computed in Nmax⁡=10N_{\max}=10 model spaces. The gray-shaded areas indicate that the irreps are not allowed within a given subspace. The irreps are organized in the increasing order of the quadratic Casimir invariant of the SU(4) group from left to right on the horizontal axes. Calculations are performed with N2LOopt_{\mathrm{opt}} at intershell distance ℏΩ=20\hbar\Omega= 20 MeV. Here the irreps are normalized according to [39].

References

  1. [1]T. Dytrych, K. Sviratcheva, C. Bahri, J. Draayer, and J. Vary, Evidence for Symplectic Symmetry in Ab Initio No-Core Shell Model Results for Light Nuclei, Physical Review Letters 98, 162503 (2007).DOI
  2. [2]T. Dytrych, K. D. Launey, J. P. Draayer, P. Maris, J. P. Vary, E. Saule, U. Catalyurek, M. Sosonkin, D. Langr, and M. A. Caprio, Collective Modes in Light Nuclei from First Principles, Physical Review Letters 111, 252501 (2013).DOI
  3. [3]T. Dytrych, K. D. Launey, J. P. Draayer, D. J. Rowe, J. L. Wood, G. Rosensteel, C. Bahri, D. Langr, and R. B. Baker, Physics of Nuclei: Key Role of an Emergent Symmetry, Physical Review Letters 124, 042501 (2020).DOI
  4. [4]K. D. Launey, T. Dytrych, and J. P. Draayer, Symmetry-guided large-scale shell-model theory, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 89, 101 (2016).DOI
  5. [5]A. E. McCoy, M. A. Caprio, T. Dytrych, and P. J. Fasano, Emergent Sp(3,R) Dynamical Symmetry in the Nuclear Many-Body System from an Ab Initio Description, Physical Review Letters 125, 102505 (2020).DOI
  6. [6]E. P. Wigner, On the Consequences of the Symmetry of the Nuclear Hamiltonian on the Spectroscopy of Nuclei, Physical Review 51, 106 (1937).
  7. [7]J.-W. Chen, D. Lee, and T. Schaefer, Inequalities for Light Nuclei in the Wigner Symmetry Limit, Physical Review Letters 93, 242302 (2004).DOI
  8. [8]D. B. Kaplan and M. J. Savage, The spin-flavor dependence of nuclear forces from large-N QCD, Physics Letters B 365, 244 (1996).DOI
  9. [9]D. Lee, S. Bogner, B. A. Brown, S. Elhatisari, E. Epelbaum, H. Hergert, M. Hjorth-Jensen, H. Krebs, N. Li, B.-N. Lu, and U.-G. Meißner, Hidden Spin-Isospin Exchange Symmetry, Physical Review Letters 127, 062501 (2021).DOI
  10. [10]P. Franzini and L. Radicati, On the validity of the supermultiplet model, Physics Letters 6, 322 (1963).DOI
  11. [11]M. Cauvin, V. Gillet, F. Soulagnon, and M. Danos, Mass formula based on SU(4), Nuclear Physics A 361, 192 (1981).DOI
  12. [12]E. P. Wigner, On Coupling Conditions in Light Nuclei and the Lifetimes of β-Radioactivities, Physical Review 56, 519 (1939).DOI
  13. [13]J.-I. Fujita and K. Ikeda, Existence of Isobaric States and Beta Decay of Heavier Nuclei, Nuclear Physics 67, 145 (1965).DOI
  14. [14]J. P. Elliott, Isospin in Nuclear Physics (North-Holland Publishing, 1969).
  15. [15]P. Vogel and M. R. Zirnbauer, Suppression of the Two-Neutrino Double-Beta Decay by Nuclear-Structure Effects, Physical Review Letters 57, 3148 (1986).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10033969
  16. [16]P. Vogel, M. Ericson, and J. Vergados, Sum rules for two-particle operators and double beta decay, Physics Letters B 212, 259 (1988).DOI
  17. [17]T. Donnelly and G. Walker, Inelastic electron scattering and supermultiplets in the particle-hole model for C12, O16, Si28, S32, and Ca40, Annals of Physics 60, 209 (1970).
  18. [18]Y. V. Gaponov and Y. S. Lutostansky, Giant Gamow-Teller Resonance in Neutron-Rich Nuclei, Physics of Atomic Nuclei 73, 1360 (2010).DOI
  19. [19]D. B. Kaplan and A. V. Manohar, Nucleon-nucleon potential in the 1/Nc expansion, Physical Review C 56, 56 (1997).DOI
  20. [20]A. C. Cordón and E. R. Arriola, Wigner symmetry, large Nc, and renormalized one-boson exchange potentials, Physical Review C 78, 054002 (2008).DOI
  21. [21]T. Mehen, I. W. Stewart, and M. B. Wise, Wigner Symmetry in the Limit of Large Scattering Lengths, Physical Review Letters 83, 931 (1999).DOI
  22. [22]S. R. Beane, E. Chang, S. D. Cohen, W. Detmold, P. Junnarkar, H. W. Lin, T. C. Luu, K. Orginos, A. Parreño, M. J. Savage, and A. Walker-Loud, Nucleon-nucleon scattering parameters in the limit of SU(3) flavor symmetry, Physical Review C 88, 024003 (2013).DOI
  23. [23]S. R. Beane, D. B. Kaplan, N. Klco, and M. J. Savage, Entanglement Suppression and Emergent Symmetries of Strong Interactions, Physical Review Letters 122, 102001 (2019).DOI
  24. [24]K. T. Hecht and J. P. Draayer, Spectral distributions and the breaking of isospin and supermultiplet symmetries in nuclei, Nuclear Physics A 223, 285 (1974).DOI
  25. [25]R. U. Haq and J. C. Parikh, Space symmetry in light nuclei: (II). SU(4) isospin-spin averages, Nuclear Physics A 220, 349 (1974).
  26. [26]P. Vogel and W. E. Ormand, Spin-isospin SU(4) symmetry in sd- and fp-shell nuclei, Physical Review C 47, 623 (1993).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9968479
  27. [27]P. V. Isacker, A. Algora, A. Vitéz-Sveiczer, G. G. Kiss, S. E. A. Orrigo, B. Rubio, and P. Aguilera, Gamow–Teller Beta Decay and Pseudo-SU(4) Symmetry, Symmetry 15, 2001 (2023).DOI
  28. [28]V. K. B. Kota and R. Sahu, Proxy-SU(4) symmetry in A = 60–90 region, Physica Scripta 99, 065306 (2024).DOI
  29. [29]S. S. Li Muli, T. R. Djärv, C. Forssén, and D. R. Phillips, Role of Spin-Isospin Symmetries in Nuclear β-Decays, Physical Review Letters 136, 242501 (2026).
  30. [30]B.-N. Lu, N. Li, S. Elhatisari, D. Lee, E. Epelbaum, and U.-G. Meißner, Essential elements for nuclear binding, Physics Letters B 797, 134863 (2019).DOI
  31. [31]B.-N. Lu, N. Li, S. Elhatisari, D. Lee, J. E. Drut, T. A. Lähde, E. Epelbaum, and U.-G. Meißner, Ab Initio Nuclear Thermodynamics, Physical Review Letters 125, 192502 (2020).DOI
  32. [32]S. Shen, T. A. Lähde, D. Lee, and U.-G. Meißner, Wigner SU(4) symmetry, clustering, and the spectrum of 12C, The European Physical Journal A 57, 276 (2021).DOI
  33. [33]Z. Ren, S. Elhatisari, T. A. Lähde, D. Lee, and U.-G. Meißner, Ab initio study of nuclear clustering in hot dilute nuclear matter, Physics Letters B 850, 138463 (2024).
  34. [34]Z. Ren, S. Elhatisari, and U.-G. Meißner, Ab Initio Study of the Radii of Oxygen Isotopes, Physical Review Letters 135, 152502 (2025).DOI
  35. [35]Z.-W. Niu and B.-N. Lu, Sign-Problem-Free Nuclear Quantum Monte Carlo Simulation, Physical Review Letters 135, 22504 (2025).DOI
  36. [36]S. Shen, S. Elhatisari, T. A. Lähde, D. Lee, B.-N. Lu, and U.-G. Meißner, Emergent geometry and duality in the carbon nucleus, Nature Communications 14, 2777 (2023).
  37. [37]S. Shen, S. Elhatisari, D. Lee, U.-G. Meißner, and Z. Ren, Ab Initio Study of the Beryllium Isotopes 7Be to 12Be, Physical Review Letters 134, 162503 (2025).
  38. [38]J. Draayer, F. Pan, and P. Dang, Reconsideration of Wigner’s Supermultiplet Symmetry, Physica Scripta 99, 102002 (2024).DOI
  39. [39]P. Dang, J. P. Draayer, F. Pan, T. Dytrych, D. Langr, D. Kekejian, K. S. Becker, and N. Thompson, Coupling and Recoupling Coefficients for Wigner’s U(4) Supermultiplet Symmetry, The European Physical Journal Plus 139, 933 (2024).
  40. [40]P. Dang, J. P. Draayer, F. Pan, and K. S. Becker, New Procedure for Evaluation of U(3) Coupling and Recoupling Coefficients, The European Physical Journal Plus 139, 704 (2024).
  41. [41]G. H. Sargsyan, K. D. Launey, M. T. Burkey, A. T. Gallant, N. D. Scielzo, G. Savard, A. Mercenne, T. Dytrych, D. Langr, L. Varriano, B. Longfellow, T. Y. Hirsh, and J. P. Draayer, Impact of clustering on the 8Li β decay and recoil form factors, Physical Review Letters 128, 202502 (2022).
  42. [42]M. T. Burkey, G. Savard, A. T. Gallant, N. D. Scielzo, J. A. Clark, T. Y. Hirsh, L. Varriano, G. H. Sargsyan, K. D. Launey, M. Brodeur, D. P. Burdette, E. Heckmaier, K. Joeres, J. W. K. Klimes, K. Kolos, A. Lamanick, K. G. Leach, A. F. Levand, B. Longfellow, B. Maaß, S. T. Marley, G. E. Morgan, P. Mueller, R. Orford, S. W. Padgett, A. P. Galván, J. R. Pierce, D. Ray, R. Segel, K. Siegl, K. S. Sharma, and B. S. Wang, Improved Limit on Tensor Currents in the Weak Interaction from 8Li β Decay, Physical Review Letters 128, 202502 (2022).DOI
  43. [43]G. B. King, Gamow-teller β-decay in light nuclei, in Electroweak Structure and Reactions in Light Nuclei with Quantum Monte Carlo Methods (Springer Nature Switzerland, Cham, 2025) pp. 31–64.DOI
  44. [44]T. Oberhuber, T. Dytrych, K. Launey, D. Langr, and J. P. Draayer, Transformation of a nucleon-nucleon potential operator into its SU(3) tensor form using GPUS, Discrete and Continuous Dynamical Systems – Series S 14, 1111 (2021).DOI
  45. [45]See Supplemental Material at [URL will be inserted by publisher] for tensor transformation of two-body nuclear potentials, tensor expansion statistics of N2LO_sat, N3LO_EMN500, N4LO_EMN500 and probability distributions of U(4) irreps in excited states of ⁶Li and ⁶He.
  46. [46]A. Ekström, G. Baardsen, C. Forssén, G. Hagen, M. Hjorth-Jensen, G. R. Jansen, R. Machleidt, W. Nazarewicz, T. Papenbrock, J. Sarich, and S. M. Wild, Optimized Chiral Nucleon-Nucleon Interaction at Next-to-Next-to-Leading Order, Physical Review Letters 110, 192502 (2013).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23705702
  47. [47]A. Ekström, G. R. Jansen, K. A. Wendt, G. Hagen, T. Papenbrock, B. D. Carlsson, C. Forssén, M. Hjorth-Jensen, P. Navrátil, and W. Nazarewicz, Accurate nuclear radii and binding energies from a chiral interaction, Physical Review C 91, 051301 (2015).DOI
  48. [48]D. R. Entem, R. Machleidt, and Y. Nosyk, High-quality two-nucleon potentials up to fifth order of the chiral expansion, Physical Review C 96, 024004 (2017).DOI
  49. [49]T. Miyagi, Nuhami: A numerical code to generate nuclear two- and three-body matrix elements from chiral effective field theory, The European Physical Journal A 59, 150 (2023).
  50. [50]D. Gloeckner and R. Lawson, Spurious center-of-mass motion, Physics Letters B 53, 313 (1974).DOI
  51. [51]F. Pan, Y. Wu, A. Li, Y. Zhang, L. Dai, and J. P. Draayer, An algebraic projection procedure for construction of the basis vectors of irreducible representations of U(4) in the SU(2) ⊗ SU_T(2) basis, The European Physical Journal Plus 138, 662 (2023).
  52. [52]A. A. Isayev, Spin-ordered phase transitions in isospin asymmetric nuclear matter, Physical Review C 74, 057301 (2006).
  53. [53]B. Verhaar, A method for the elimination of spurious states in the nuclear harmonic oscillator shell model, Nuclear Physics 21, 508 (1960).DOI
  54. [54]D. Tilley, C. Cheves, G. Godwin, G. Hale, H. Hofmann, J. Kelley, C. Sheu, and H. Weller, Energy levels of light nuclei A=5, 6, 7, Nuclear Physics A 708, 3 (2002).
  55. [55]S. Bogner, R. Furnstahl, and A. Schwenk, From low-momentum interactions to nuclear structure, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 65, 94 (2010).
  56. [56]D. R. Entem and R. Machleidt, Accurate charge-dependent nucleon-nucleon potential at fourth order of chiral perturbation theory, Physical Review C 68, 041001 (2003).DOI
  57. [57]E. D. Jurgenson, P. Navrátil, and R. J. Furnstahl, Evolution of Nuclear Many-Body Forces with the Similarity Renormalization Group, Physical Review Letters 103, 082501 (2009).DOI
  58. [58]A. Knecht, R. Hong, D. W. Zumwalt, B. G. Delbridge, A. García, P. Müller, H. E. Swanson, I. S. Towner, S. Utsuno, W. Williams, and C. Wrede, Precision measurement of the ⁶He half-life and the weak axial current in nuclei, Physical Review C 86, 035506 (2012).DOI
  59. [59]P. Gysbers, G. Hagen, J. D. Holt, G. R. Jansen, T. D. Morris, P. Navrátil, T. Papenbrock, S. Quaglioni, A. Schwenk, S. R. Stroberg, and K. A. Wendt, Discrepancy between experimental and theoretical β-decay rates resolved from first principles, Nature Physics 15, 428 (2019).DOI
  60. [60]I. J. Shin, Y. Kim, P. Maris, J. P. Vary, C. Forssén, J. Rotureau, and N. Michel, Ab initio no-core solutions for ⁶Li, Journal of Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics 44, 075103 (2017).

Paper details

vlnc:W_rgnnwhue
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 13

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents