WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Collision-induced radiative quenching and other disintegration modes of the state of muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms
Abstract
The formation and various disintegration modes of states for muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms at kinetic energies both above and below the threshold are studied. The cross sections of the collision-induced radiative quenching, elastic scattering, and Coulomb deexcitation of and atoms in collisions with ordinary hydrogen and deuterium atoms at collision energies below the threshold are calculated in the framework of the close-coupling approach. The basis set includes all open and closed channels corresponding to exotic-atom states with principal quantum number from 1 up to 30. Results of these numerical quantum-mechanical calculations of cross sections are used as input data for detailed cascade calculations. The kinetics of atomic cascade for and atoms is studied in the wide range of the relative target densities, applying the improved version of the cascade model. It is shown that the collision-induced radiative quenching gives a significant contribution to the total disintegration of the state of muonic atoms at energies below the threshold. The initial population of the state for both muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms, absolute intensities and probabilities of the different disintegration modes as well as their lifetimes are calculated for the fractions with kinetic energies above and below the threshold. The obtained results are compared with the known experimental data.
Introduction
The negatively charged muons stopped in or gaseous target form or atoms in highly excited states [1, 2, 3]. The formation of muonic atoms of hydrogen isotopes is followed by a number of the subsequent radiative and collisional processes. In the process of deexcitation, an or atom passes through many intermediate states until it reaches the ground state or weak decay of the meson occurs () in the excited state of the atom. During this deexcitation cascade, a fraction of or atoms reaches the state. The number of atoms reached state is determined by several factors: the initial -distributions (e.g., see [4, 5]), the competition of collisional processes and radiative transitions during the deexcitation cascade, as well as the target temperature and density.
Muonic hydrogen and muonic deuterium atoms are of special interest among exotic atoms due to their simplest structure and possibility to investigate a number of problems both the exotic atom physics and the bound-state QED. The state plays a particular role in these atoms due to () Lamb shift, meV, and has no analog in hadronic atoms. A high-energy component of with kinetic energy keV was discovered [6, 7] from the analysis of the time-of-flight spectra (at low gas pressures and 64 hPa) and attributed to non-radiative quenching of the state due to the formation of the muonic molecule in a resonant collision and subsequent Coulomb deexcitation of the complex (see [8] and references therein). Theoretical estimation of the quenching rate in the framework of this model gives at liquid-hydrogen density (LHD= atoms/cm) that is about an order of magnitude smaller than the value extracted from experiments [7]. In our paper [4] the observed collisional quenching and high-energy component was explained by the direct Coulomb deexcitation (CD) process,
The problem of the collisional quenching in the hydrogen target has been studied previously both experimentally [6, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13] and theoretically [4, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18]. Experimental investigations with muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms at Paul Scherrer Institute [19, 20, 21, 22] performed at a low gas pressure have revived interest in the subject of the formation and disintegration modes of and atoms at kinetic energies both above and below the threshold. The theoretical description of the collisional processes and kinetics of the atomic cascade was improved significantly in our works (e.g., see [4, 5, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28] and refs. therein).
In the collision of muonic hydrogen or deuterium atoms in the state with the target atom or molecule, a strong coupling between this state and the unstable with respect to the radiative transition state leads to the collision-induced radiative quenching of the state at kinetic energies below the threshold. The consequences of this mechanism can be observed in both the absolute x-ray yield of the line and the lifetime of the muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms in the state. According to our knowledge, the process of the collision-induced radiative quenching of the state has been treated in the framework of the semiclassical approaches [15, 17] and was never taken into account in cascade calculations, since the delayed x-rays induced during the collisions have not been experimentally observed [11].
In this paper, we investigated the further history of and atoms formed in the state with kinetic energies both above and below the threshold. Their fate is determined by the interplay of a few processes: the elastic scattering, the Stark transition followed by the fast radiative deexcitation, the collision-induced radiative quenching, the Coulomb deexcitation , and -decay.
The paper is organized as follows. Section II presents the results of calculations of the cross sections for elastic scattering, Stark transitions, collision-induced radiation quenching, and Coulomb deexcitation for muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms performed in the framework of the close-coupling approach. Results of cascade calculations are presented in Sec. III. Initial populations and kinetic energy distributions of and atoms are presented in Sec. III A. Collisional rates for and atoms and intensities of the different modes of their disintegration are given in Secs. III B and III C, correspondingly. The contributions of different processes, forming the absolute x-ray yield of line are discussed in Sec. III D. Calculated probabilities of different disintegration modes and a lifetime of and atoms with energies both above and below the threshold are presented in Sec. III E. The results are summarized in Sec. IV.
Atomic units are used throughout unless otherwise stated.
Cross Sections of Collisional Processes for Muonic Hydrogen and Deuterium Atoms
In our paper [5], the cross sections of all processes at collisions of the excited and atoms with hydrogen isotope atoms in the ground state have been presented. In these calculations, performed in the framework of the close-coupling approach, the radiative widths or instability of the excited states of muonic atoms and the possibility of the collision-induced radiative transitions were not taken into account. This approximation is completely justified for all excited states except the state. Indeed, the radiative widths of highly excited states are very small and the rates of the collision-induced radiative transitions are negligible compared to the rate of the direct radiative dipole transitions .
The situation is quite different in the case of the state. At collision energies below the threshold, the Stark transition is energetically forbidden and the collision-induced radiative quenching
or , and may prove to be an important mechanism of the disintegration of the state. Therefore, in this paper devoted to the fate of the state in muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms, the cross sections of the elastic scattering
and Coulomb deexcitation (CD)
in and collisions calculated earlier [4, 5] at energies above the threshold were recalculated taking into account the radiation width or the instability of the state.
Calculations were performed in the framework of the closed coupling approach by using the propagation matrix method described in details in our paper [4]. The main advantage of this method is that it allows to describe both open and closed unstable-state channels as well as to avoid numerical errors caused by the exponentially increasing linearly-independent solutions of the system of the close-coupling equations. This method has been developed and applied earlier by the authors, in particular, for the description of the collision-induced absorption or annihilation in the case of hadronic atoms [27, 28].
The present calculations were performed with the extended basis set including all states of the muonic hydrogen (deuterium) atom with the principal quantum number values from up to . The value of the radiative width of the state was used for both muonic hydrogen and muonic deuterium atoms. All other states were considered as stable ones. In the case of the state at kinetic energies below the threshold, the matrix in the subspace of the open channels is not unitary due to the instability of the state. The unitary defect allows to determine the cross section of the collision-induced radiative transition from the state as follows:
Here, , is the relative motion energy in the entrance channel, and is the reduced mass of the scattering problem.
Cross sections for collisions calculated with and are shown in Figure 1. As can be seen from Figure 1, the cross sections of the elas-
Figure 1. The energy dependence of cross sections for collisions: elastic scattering , Coulomb deexcitation , collision-induced radiative quenching, and Stark transition. Cross sections of the elastic scattering and Coulomb deexcitation calculated with [4] are shown by dashed lines for comparison.
tic scattering and CD practically do not change when the radiative width of the state is taken into account except for the resonance region. This means that the width can be considered as a small perturbation, and the cross section of the collision-induced process is proportional to the width. The dependence of the cross section of the collision-induced process on the value has been studied in detail in our paper [28]. At the same time, in the resonance region, the cross sections of the elastic scattering and the CD are strongly suppressed (by several times in comparison with results presented in [4]) due to the process (2) of the collision-induced radiative quenching. In the resonance region, the cross section of the process (2) even exceeds the cross section of the elastic scattering.
The comparison of the collision-induced radiative cross sections calculated in the present fully quantum-mechanical approach with the cross sections calculated in [17] within a simple model of the potential scattering with the complex potential is shown in Figure 2. Here the cross section of the collision-induced radiative quenching calculated with the simplest basis set in which only wave functions of the , , and states of the muonic atom were included is also presented. In the paper [17], the Born-Oppenheimer approximation was applied using the four-term basis set with the lowest and orbitals in variational calculations. In such approximation, the scattering problem is reduced to a simple model of the potential scattering with the complex potential.
Figure 2. Cross sections of the collision-induced radiative quenching for collisions vs the laboratory kinetic energy below the threshold: the solid line and dashed-dotted line are the results of the present calculations with the basis sets and , respectively, and the dashed line is obtained from Fig. 4 of [17].
Figure 2 shows that the cross section of the collision-induced radiative quenching calculated in [17] is too small even in comparison with our close-coupling result obtained with the minimal basis set in which only the , , and muonic-atom wave functions were taken into account. Besides, the cross section of collision quenching calculated in [15] is somewhat less in comparison with the result of [17]. Therefore, the adiabatic description and correspondingly the Born-Oppenheimer approximation is
not justified for the realistic treatment of the collision-induced radiative quenching of the state in collisions at kinetic energies below the threshold.
Figure 3 shows the energy dependence of the cross sections for collisions. In contrast to the case of the , there are no pronounced sub-threshold resonances, and, therefore, taking into account the -state width does not at all affect the elastic scattering and CD cross sections.
Figure 3. The same as in Fig. 1 for collisions. Cross sections of the elastic scattering and Coulomb deexcitation calculated with from [5] are shown by dashed lines.
Results of cascade calculations
The cascade calculations for muonic hydrogen and muonic deuterium atoms were performed in the framework of the improved version of the cascade model developed in our recent papers [4, 5]. In particular, the probability densities of and initial (at the instant of the exotic atom formation) distributions as well as of the initial kinetic energy distribution (see Eqs. (22)-24 in [5]) were used in the present cascade calculations. Besides, the exact kinematic of the binary collision taking into account the target motion was applied in the present cascade calculations (for detail see [5]). Finally, the present cascade model includes new results given in § 2 for cross sections of the elastic scattering, collision-induced radiative quenching, and the CD for and at kinetic energies below the threshold.
To obtain good statistics, the fate of the muonic atoms has been analyzed in the present cascade calculations for each value of the target density in the relative density range, covering nine orders of magnitude , where is the target density in units of the liquid hydrogen density, atoms/cm.
The various characteristics of muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms in the state were calculated: the arrival population and kinetic energy distribution, the intensities and probabilities of the different disintegration modes, and lifetimes. Some of present results are compared with the available experimental data [6, 11, 19, 22].
Initial population and kinetic energy distribution of and
We define the total initial or arrival population of the state, , as the probability that the formed muonic hydrogen or deuterium atom will reach this state during the deexcitation cascade regardless of whether its kinetic energy is above or below of the threshold.
The density dependence of the total arrival population for and atoms calculated using the present version of the atomic cascade is shown in Figure 4. Calculations were performed at relative hydrogen density and at target temperature .

Figure 4. The total arrival population of (solid line) and (dashed line) atoms vs the density of the target calculated at a target temperature . The experimental data for are from [11].
The total arrival populations for the and have similar dependences on the target density. They are about 2% in the density range and grow up to 88% and 57% at a liquid hydrogen density for and atoms, respectively. In the case of muonic hydrogen the density dependence of the has been explained in detail in the paper [4]. The same explanation is also valid for the muonic deuterium.
At densities below , the role of collisional processes in the deexcitation cascade is extremely weak and the arrival population of the state is mainly determined by distributions at the instant of the exotic atom formation and the rates of radiative transitions from the higher states (). So, in this density range, the arrival population is equal to about 2% and is very weakly dependent on the density for both muonic hydrogen and muonic deuterium atoms.
In the density range , the arrival population increases from about 2% up to 6.77% and 6.34% for and atoms, respectively. In this density range, the total population of the state grows due to an increase of the intensity of all collisional processes, which in turn lead to a larger population of states () and accordingly to an increase of the intensity of the radiative transitions.
This explanation is in accordance with the density dependence of the relative x-ray yields, , for lines (, etc) (see also Figs. 17 and 18 in [5]) and a strong correlation between the relative yields of lines and the total population . At densities below , the calculated arrival population is in perfect agreement with the estimation based on formula (see Eq. (21) in [4])
At these densities, the calculated values of are in very good agreement with the experimental data obtained from the measured relative X-ray yields [11] at gas pressures between 0.25 and 150 Torr () that corresponds to the range of the relative densities from up to .
At densities above , the populations and have quite different dependences on the density. The population reaches its maximum value 7.7% and 7.5% at and then rapidly decreases to about 2.4% and 1.2% at , respectively for and atoms. Contrary to this, the arrival population in the density range rapidly grows from 10.4% (for ) and 8.6% (for ) up to 88% and 57% at a liquid hydrogen density for and atoms, respectively. It is important to note, that these values of the total arrival population significantly exceed the statistical weight of the state (25%) especially in the case of the muonic hydrogen.
In the density range , Stark transitions increase the population of states () from which the radiative transitions populate the state. This explanation is supported by the density dependence of the absolute x-ray yields of the and lines (see Fig. 15 in [5]).
At a density above , the CD , , and together with Auger radiative transitions result in very fast increasing of the population . Besides, at the density the rate of the Stark transition is comparable with the rate of the radiative transition and becomes even about two orders of the magnitude more at a liquid hydrogen density (). Therefore, at the density above the initial population of the state is mainly formed by the Auger transition (the CD (), and the always open Stark transition.
The kinetic energy of the muonic atom changes during the atomic cascade as a result of the complex interplay of various cascade processes preceding its arrival in the state. In cascade calculations, the kinetic energy distribution of exotic atoms at the time of their transition to the state is described by the probability density, , which is determined by the preceding cascade processes as well as by the target density and temperature.
In Figure 5 we present the distribution function of the probability,
Figure 5. Kinetic energy distributions of muonic hydrogen (solid lines) and deuterium (dashed lines) atoms on arrival in the 2s state vs. the laboratory kinetic energy calculated at a target temperature K for three values of the relative target density: , and . The dotted line corresponds to the initial energy distribution of muonic atoms at the instant of their formation (see Eq. (8)).
which determines the probability that the muonic atom has kinetic energy in the laboratory frame less than at the instant of the state formation. Further, this probability will be called the kinetic energy distribution of muonic hydrogen or muonic deuterium atoms on arrival in the state. Calculations were performed at a room target temperature K for three values of the relative target density: , , and . The dotted line in the figure shows the kinetic energy distribution of muonic atoms at the instant of their formation, given by the formula
where parameters , eV, and eV were determined in [4] from the fit of experimental data [6] at the density corresponding to the target pressure hPa and temperature K.
As it is seen from Figure 5, the kinetic energy distributions of the state for both muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms are practically indistinguishable at the density and have a small differences from the initial energy distribution given by Eq. (8). At very low target densities the deexcitation cascade is practically purely radiative and the initial kinetic energy distributions of muonic atoms at the instant of their formation are conserved up to the end of the cascade. In this density range the kinetic energy distributions of both muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms in the state show a very small acceleration due to the Coulomb deexcitation of highly-excited states.
At densities , the effect of the CD in the highly-excited states (preceding the population of the state) becomes more pronounced providing a high-energy component in the kinetic energy distribution of the state. In particular, at a density (see Figure 5), the contributions of the CD , , , and are explicitly seen in kinetic energy distributions of both and atoms. The
observed here small differences between kinetic energy distributions of and atoms are explained by the weak isotopic effect in cross sections of the CD for highly-excited states (for details see [5]). With the further density increasing the role of the CD becomes much more prominent. In particular, Figure 5 illustrates the significant isotopic effect of the CD in the kinetic energy distributions of the -state of muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms at a density . Here the strong isotopic effect in the cross sections and accordingly in rates of the CD , , and especially (e.g., see Figure 8, Figure 9,Figure 11, and Figure 12 in [5]) leads to significant differences in the kinetic energy distributions of atoms and at the instant of their formation.
Figure 8. The same as in Fig. 7 for collisions.
Figure 9. The density dependence of the different contributions to the absolute -line yield calculated for muonic hydrogen at the target temperature K.: (solid line with triangles), (dashed line), (solid line with filled circles), and their sum (solid line).

Figure 11. The density dependence of decay probabilities of for various disintegration modes: collision-induced radiative quenching (solid line), Stark transition (line with open circles), Coulomb de-excitation (line with asterisks), and -decay (dashed and dashed-dotted, and dotted lines for fractions below and above the threshold and their sum, respectively).

Figure 12. The same as in Figure 11 for atom.
In accordance with the kinetic energy distribution of the state (see Figure 5) the total arrival population can be divided into two fractions
where and denote arrival populations of fractions with the kinetic energy above and below the threshold, respectively. Absolute values of and calculated for and atoms at target densities from up to 1 and a target temperature K are shown in Table 1.
| (lhd) | ||||
| 1.06 | 0.87 | 1.05 | 0.88 | |
| 1.11 | 0.90 | 1.12 | 1.02 | |
| 1.48 | 0.98 | 1.48 | 1.03 | |
| 2.82 | 1.10 | 2.57 | 1.14 | |
| 4.64 | 1.28 | 4.10 | 1.41 | |
| 6.13 | 2.21 | 4.76 | 2.69 | |
| 15.74 | 3.35 | 7.89 | 4.95 | |
| 54.67 | 5.37 | 29.05 | 7.07 | |
| 76.02 | 11.93 | 46.55 | 11.04 |
Table 1. The density dependence of arrival populations and (per formed muonic atom) of and fractions above and below of the threshold, respectively.
It is important to notice some peculiarities in the formation of these fractions in muonic hydrogen and muonic deuterium atoms. First, the arrival population for the muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms with kinetic energies above the threshold is larger than the arrival population with kinetic energies below the threshold at all values of the target density. Second, the arrival population grows with the density much faster than the arrival population for both and atoms. Finally, the arrival population of the muonic deuterium is greater than the arrival population of the same fraction of the muonic hydrogen at all densities of the target except for the region very close to the liquid hydrogen density. On the contrary, at , the arrival population for the muonic hydrogen is more (and even significantly more at ) than the arrival population of the same fraction in the case of the muonic deuterium.
Collisional rates of and atoms
After the formation of the hydrogen exotic atoms in the state, their further fate is determined by the rate of the muon decay () and by the rates of the collisional processes: the elastic scattering , the collision-induced radiative quenching, the Stark transition followed by the fast radiative transition , and the CD . The rate of the collisional process in the laboratory frame is defined as follows
where and are the kinetic energy in the laboratory frame and the mass of the muonic atom, respectively.
Figure 6 shows the energy dependence of collisional rates for the elastic scattering , CD , and collision-induced radiative quenching of the state for muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms at the liquid hydrogen density (). The rate of the radiative transition is shown for comparison. A small difference of about 5% between radiative rates of the transition in muonic hydrogen and deuterium due to the difference of their reduced masses is not visible at the scale of the figure.
Figure 6. Collisional rates of the elastic scattering, CD , and collision-induced radiative quenching of the state as a function of the laboratory kinetic energy for (solid lines) and (dashed lines) atoms calculated at the liquid hydrogen density.
The isotope effect observed in cross sections for scattering of muonic atoms in states with values of the principal quantum number (see [5]) is practically absent for highly excited states with . The only source of the isotopic effect in the kinetics of the atomic cascade for states with is the trivial kinematic factor in Eq. (10). In the case of the state, the isotopic effect revealed in cross sections (see Figure 1 and Figure 3) is additionally enhanced by this factor associated with the difference of the exotic atom velocities at the same energy in the laboratory system. It is seen in Figure 6, that the isotopic effect in rates of all collisional processes is very strong.
Intensities of the different disintegration modes of and
The intensities of the decay modes, i.e. the number of atoms (per one formed muonic atom) disintegrated through a given mode were calculated within the present cascade model for muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms in state. The intensities of the destruction of the state for and atoms are shown as functions of the target density in Figure 7 and Figure 8, respectively, and are also presented in Tables II and III for several density values.
Figure 7. Intensities (per one formed atom) for all disintegration modes of vs the relative target density: collision-induced radiative quenching (solid line), Stark transition (line with open circles), Coulomb de-excitation (line with asterisks), and -decay (dashed and dashed-dotted lines for fractions below and above the threshold, respectively).
The figures and tables show the intensities of the following destruction modes: – collision-induced radiative quenching, – Stark transition followed by the fast radiative transition, – Coulomb deexcitation , – -decay at kinetic energies above the threshold, – -decay at kinetic energies below the threshold.
At the lowest densities, the muon decay is the main process resulting in the disintegration of the state of both muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms at kinetic energies above and below the threshold (see also Table II).
At kinetic energy above the threshold, the intensity of the -decay decreases rather rapidly with the density increasing. On the contrary, the intensity of -decay at kinetic energies below the threshold at first even increases with increasing density (especially in the case of ) and then decreases rapidly with further increase in density at .
The intensities of Stark transitions in muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms are in accordance with the primary populations of these atoms at kinetic energies above the threshold but turn out to be less than the values of the corresponding primary populations. The intensity of the Coulomb deexcitation for are about 1.5 - 2 times higher than in the case of , while the values of the radiation quenching intensity for these two isotopes are very close at the target density less than and with increasing density targets up to this ratio changes in favor of the muonic deuterium atom by about 1.5 times.
| (lhd) | ||||
| 0.86 | 0.95 | 0.91 | 0.95 | |
| 0.41 | 1.12 | 0.57 | 1.02 | |
| 0.08 | 1.05 | 0.16 | 1.43 | |
| 0.02 | 0.33 | 0.03 | 0.79 | |
| 0.00 | 0.04 | 0.00 | 0.14 | |
| 0.00 | 0.01 | 0.00 | 0.02 |
Table 2. The density dependence of intensities (per one formed muonic atom, in percent) of the -decay calculated for and with kinetic energies both above and below the threshold ( and , respectively).
| (lhd) | ||||||
| 0.00 | 0.00 | 0.11 | 0.00 | 0.004 | 0.07 | |
| 0.004 | 0.04 | 0.43 | 0.00 | 0.04 | 0.27 | |
| 0.04 | 0.40 | 0.90 | 0.01 | 0.31 | 0.58 | |
| 0.13 | 1.32 | 2.13 | 0.06 | 1.36 | 1.48 | |
| 0.17 | 1.74 | 3.97 | 0.11 | 2.25 | 3.01 | |
| 0.26 | 2.66 | 5.41 | 0.18 | 3.70 | 3.55 | |
| 0.39 | 3.91 | 14.76 | 0.28 | 5.69 | 6.85 | |
| 0.94 | 9.33 | 49.52 | 0.45 | 9.09 | 26.45 | |
| 4.93 | 48.98 | 32.38 | 1.51 | 30.59 | 24.33 |
Table 3. The density dependence of intensities , , and (in percent) calculated for and .
The fastest collisional process – the elastic scattering – leads to a deceleration of muonic atoms in the state. As a result, some part of the muonic -state atoms initially formed with kinetic energies above the threshold turns out to be below the threshold. Thus, the population of the fraction with kinetic energy above the threshold decreases, and the population of the fraction with kinetic energy below the threshold increases accordingly compared to their values at the instant of formation. Thus, the total population of the fraction with kinetic energy below the threshold is always greater than its initial population . This influence of elastic scattering on redistribution of fractions with kinetic energies above and below the threshold (in favor of increasing the sub-threshold fraction) increases with increasing target density.
In Table 4 we present the initial population and the total number of the disintegrated atoms with the energy below the threshold (per one formed atom):
Table 4. The initial population and the total number of the disintegrated atoms with the energy below the threshold (per one formed atom).
in comparison with the experimental data [6, 19].
On the whole, there is a satisfactory agreement between the theoretical results and experimental data. An exception is the experimental value obtained at a target density of [19], which is much less the corresponding theoretical value. It should be noted that this experimental value falls out of the general trend of population growth with increasing target density and, moreover, there are no arguments to explain it.
Absolute x-ray yield of line
The absolute x-ray yield of the line is determined as the intensity of this line per muonic atom formed. The total intensity, , of the line can be represented as a sum of three different contributions corresponding to the preceding history of the atoms involved in its formation:
Here denotes the intensity of the direct radiative transition occurring after the transition of a muonic atom to the state from states with the principal quantum number . Remind, that and are the intensities of the Stark transition (at kinetic energies above the threshold) followed by the radiative transition and the collision-induced radiative quenching of the state (at kinetic energies below the threshold), respectively.
Figure 9 and Figure 10 show the density dependence of the different modes forming the total absolute yield of the line as well as their sum calculated at a target temperature K for and atoms, respectively.
Figure 10. The same as in Figure 9 for atom.
As can be seen from Figure 9 and Figure 10, the contribution of the direct radiation transition to the absolute yield of the -line decreases with increasing target density . In the case of a muonic hydrogen atom, this decrease becomes rather rapid at and the contribution reaches a value of 0.1 at the density of liquid hydrogen. In the case of a muonic deuterium atom, we observe a similar dependence on the density at , however a further increase in the target density does not lead to a sharp decrease of the contribution (at the density of liquid hydrogen, this contribution is about 0.4). This difference in the dependence of on the density in muonic hydrogen and muonic deuterium is explained by isotope effect in the rates of collisional processes of these atoms (see [5]) in the upper part of the cascade of deexcitation (). In particular, this is reflected in the primary populations of the state at kinetic energies above the threshold (see Table I).
Probabilities of different disintegration modes and lifetime of and
The probability that the muonic atom formed in the state disintegrates due to one of decay modes, , is given by
Here, the is the rate of the process where index denotes the following disintegration channels: (-decay), (Coulomb deexcitation ), (collision-induced radiative quenching), and (Stark transition resulting in the radiative transition ). is a summary rate of all processes, which lead to the disintegration of the state:
The factor provides the correct behavior of the probability in the limit . The kinetic energy distribution is defined at the instant of the disintegration of the state through the -th decay mode and normalized by the condition:
The probability of the different disintegration modes for and atoms as functions on target density is shown in Figures 11 and 12, correspondingly. As can be seen from these figures, probabilities of -decay have a similar density dependence for muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms. This is explained by the fact that the -decay rate does not depend on either the energy or the target density, and the kinetic energy distributions of muonic hydrogen and deuterium are very close in the density region where the probability of muon decay is not negligible (see Figure 5).
On the contrary, for the probabilities of the destruction of the state in collisional processes, we observe significant differences between muonic hydrogen and deuterium in both the values of these probabilities and their dependence on the target density. These differences are especially pronounced in the ratio of the probabilities of Stark transitions and collision-induced radiation quenching. The observed differences are explained by two factors: significant differences in the ratio of velocities, as well as in the distributions over the kinetic energies of muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms.
The mean time interval between the formation of the muonic atom in the state and its decay we define as the lifetime of the state. In this work, to determine the lifetime of the state, we use the - decay probability
where a lifetime of the state is defined by
From Eqs. (16) and (17) we obtain
Formulas similar to Eqs. (16)–(18) allow to define and to calculate the lifetime for the fraction of atoms in the state with the kinetic energy above the threshold and also the lifetime for the fraction of atoms in the state with the kinetic energy below the threshold.
where
is the lifetime of the fraction of the state with the kinetic energy above () or below () the threshold, respectively. The corresponding total rates of these fractions are given by:
and
Infinite limits of integration in Eq. (20) are of a formal nature, since the probability densities and are different from zero only in the intervals and , respectively. From Eqs. (19) and (20) we obtain
In the present study three variants of the and lifetime were calculated: the lifetime, , of the fraction with the kinetic energy above the threshold, the lifetime, , of the fraction with the kinetic energy below the threshold, and the lifetime, , of the state independently whether the kinetic energy of muonic atom is above or below the threshold. Results of calculations are presented in Figure 13 and Figure 14 for the and atoms, respectively. As it is seen from the figures, the lifetime of the state for both muonic hydrogen and muonic deuterium has a similar dependence on density for both fractions. At the lowest densities, the lifetimes are determined by the muon decay rate. With increasing density, the role of collisional processes increases, which leads to a decrease in the lifetime of both fractions. The lifetime for the fraction with kinetic energy below the threshold, , decreases much more slowly with increasing target density than for the fraction with kinetic energy above the threshold. At a densities , the lifetime of a state behaves as , and the ratio is equal to about 15.
Figure 13. The density dependence of the lifetime calculated for various fractions: below the threshold - dashed line, above the threshold - dashed-dotted line. The lifetime, , of the state independently whether the kinetic energy of muonic atom is above or below the threshold is shown by the solid line. The experimental values from [19]
Figure 14. The same as in Figure 13 for . The experimental values from [22]
In the case of muonic hydrogen, the theoretical values of the lifetime of the fractions with kinetic energy both above and below the threshold are in excellent agreement with the available experimental data. In the case of muonic deuterium, the agreement between the theoretical and available at one density experimental values of the lifetimes of the state can be considered as good for and satisfactory for .
Conclusion
The fully quantum-mechanical study of the collisional processes — elastic scattering, collision-induced radiative quenching, and Coulomb deexcitation — has been performed in the framework of the close-coupling approach for and collisions at kinetic energies below the threshold. The cross sections have been calculated with the basis set including all open and closed channels associated with the exotic atom states with the principal quantum number up to and then have been used as input data in the kinetics of the atomic cascade.
An important result of this work is the elucidation of the role of the collision-induced radiative quenching in the destruction of a muonic atom in -state. As far as the authors know, this problem has not been previously investigated. Our calculations showed that this process makes a significant contribution to the total disintegration of the -state of muonic atoms at energies below the threshold.
The kinetics of the atomic cascade has been investigated for both muonic hydrogen and muonic deuterium atoms within the updated version of the cascade model, which has a number of essential improvements over the previous cascade calculations. The cascade calculations have been performed for target densities covering eight orders of magnitude from up to 1 (in the units of the liquid hydrogen density).
As a result of ab initio cascade calculations, a number of characteristics of the state of muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms were obtained: primary populations and kinetic energy distributions, absolute values of intensities different modes of disintegration, the probability of decay of the state through different channels and lifetimes of the state at kinetic energy both above and below the threshold. The obtained theoretical results are compared with the available experimental data. The results of the work can be used for the planning experiments and analysis of experimental data.
References
- [1]G. Ya. Korenman and V. P. Popov, Muon Catalyzed Fusion 4, 145 (1989).
- [2]G. Ya. Korenman, V. P. Popov, and G. A. Fesenko, Muon Catalyzed Fusion 7, 179 (1992).
- [3]J. S. Cohen, Rep. Prog. Phys. 67, 1769 (2004).
- [4]V. P. Popov and V. N. Pomerantsev, Phys. Rev. A 83, 032516 (2011).
- [5]V. P. Popov and V. N. Pomerantsev, Phys. Rev. A 95, 022506 (2017).
- [6]R. Pohl, Ph.D. thesis 14096, ETH Zurich, 2001.
- [7]R. Pohl, H. Daniel, F.J. Hartmann et al., PRL 97, 193402 (2006).
- [8]J. Wallenius, S. Jonsell, Y. Kino and P. Froelich, Hyperfine Interact. 138, 285 (2001).
- [9]R. Pohl et al., Hyperfine Interact. 138, 35 (2001).
- [10]P. O. Egan et al., Phys. Rev. A 23, 1152 (1981).
- [11]H. Anderhub et al., Phys. Lett. B 143, 65 (1984).
- [12]N. Bregant et al., Phys. Lett. A 241, 344 (1998).
- [13]F. Kottman et al., Hyperfine Interact. 119, 138, 55 (2001).
- [14]G. Kodosky and M. Leon, Nuovo Cimento B1, 41 (1971).
- [15]R. O. Mueller, V. W. Hughes, H. Rosenthal, and C. S. Wu, Phys. Rev. A 11, 1175 (1975).
- [16]G. Carboni and G. Fiorentini, Nuovo Cimento B39, 281 (1977).
- [17]James S. Cohen and J. N. Bardsley, Phys. Rev. A 23, 46 (1981).
- [18]T. S. Jensen and V. E. Markushin, Eur. Phys. J. D 21, 271 (2002).
- [19]Randolf Pohl et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 97, 193402 (2006).
- [20]L. Ludhova et al., Phys. Rev. A 75, 040501(R) (2007).
- [21]R. Pohl et al., Nature (London) 466, 213 (2010).
- [22]Marc Diepold et al., Phys. Rev. A 88, 042520 (2013).
- [23]Pomerantsev Vladimir N., Popov Vladimir P., Hyperfine Interact. 209, 75 (2012).
- [24]G. Ya. Korenman, V. N. Pomerantsev, and V. P. Popov, JETP Lett. 81, 543 (2005).
- [25]V. N. Pomerantsev and V. P. Popov, JETP Lett. 83, 331 (2006).
- [26]V. N. Pomerantsev and V. P. Popov, Phys. Rev. A 73, 040501(R) (2006).
- [27]Pomerantsev Vladimir N., Popov Vladimir P., Hyperfine Interact 209, 69 (2012).
- [28]V. P. Popov and V. N. Pomerantsev , Phys. Rev. A 86, 052520 (2012).










