Device-independent conference key agreement (DI-CKA) enables N>2 distant parties to establish a common secret key without detailed characterization of the source or measurement devices. Many existing protocols rely on full-body Bell correlators, whose measurement can be demanding for a large number of parties. Here, we show that two-body correlators alone suffice for DI-CKA using balanced Dicke states for every even N≥4. We construct two-body Bell inequalities and derive a tight analytical lower bound on the conditional von Neumann entropy by comparing their Bell operators with those of asymmetric Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt inequalities. In the ideal setting, certified key rates can approach 1−h[(N−2)/(4(N−1))], where h is the binary entropy function. This rate remains bounded away from zero as N→∞, tending to 1−h(1/4)≈0.189 bits per key-generation round. We show that the honest implementation of our protocol is invariant under collective phase noise. Moreover, a complementary full-body Bell construction certifies positive conference-key rates from correlations arbitrarily close to the local set.
Introduction
**Introduction.—**Quantum key distribution (QKD) enables two distant parties to establish a secret key with information-theoretic security [1, 2]. Quantum conference key agreement (CKA) extends this task to N>2 parties sharing a common secret key [3]. The security of standard CKA protocols relies on models of the source and the measurement devices. Deviations from these models can compromise security, as demonstrated by attacks on practical QKD systems [4, 5].
Device-independent CKA (DI-CKA) certifies security from a loophole-free Bell-inequality violation without requiring a detailed model of the source and the measurement devices [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12]. Many existing DI-CKA protocols use Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger (GHZ) states [13] and Bell inequalities such as parity-Clauser-Horne-Shimony-Holt (CHSH) inequalities [6] or the Holz inequality [7, 8]. However, those Bell inequalities involve correlators of all remote parties, whose measurement can be experimentally demanding, particularly for a large number of parties.
Dicke states [14] offer a promising alternative because their nonlocality can be detected using only few-body correlators [15, 16]. Bell nonlocality alone, however, does not guarantee a device-independent conference key. The asymptotic DI-CKA key rate is the difference between the conditional von Neumann entropy of one remote party’s (say Alice’s) key bit given the side information which an eavesdropper (say Eve) may possess and the largest error-correction cost between Alice and the other remote parties. For the X-basis key measurements considered here, Dicke states have a nonzero error-correction cost even in the ideal setting, whereas GHZ-based protocols can have zero cost. The certified entropy must therefore be sufficiently large to compensate for these imperfect key correlations for Dicke states. Then, the following natural question arises: can we realize a DI-CKA protocol using the Dicke state and a Bell inequality involving only few-body correlators for arbitrarily many parties?
In this work, we show that two-body correlators suffice to certify a positive DI-CKA key rate using balanced Dicke states, where exactly half of the N modes are excited, for every even N≥4. We construct a family of Bell inequalities and establish a tight analytical lower bound on the conditional von Neumann entropy as a function of the Bell value through an operator comparison with the asymmetric CHSH inequality developed in Ref. [17]. The resulting ideal key rates remain bounded away from zero as the number of parties increases. In particular, we show that an ideal DI-CKA key rate of at least 1−h(1/4)≈0.189 bits per key-generation round can be certified for every even N≥4, where h is the binary entropy. As a complementary result, a full-body Bell inequality certifies a positive DI-CKA key rate for correlations arbitrarily close to the local set. We also show that the honest implementation with the balanced Dicke state is invariant under collective phase noise and compare its noise tolerance with that of a GHZ-based protocol.
Protocol
**Protocol.—**We describe an N-partite DI-CKA protocol which we consider in this work. We consider N parties, Alice, Bob1,…, BobN−1, who aim to establish a common secret key. Alice has two measurement inputs, x∈{0,1}, and each Bobi has three, yi∈{0,1,2}. Let a (bi) ∈{±1} denote Alice’s (Bobi’s) measurement outcomes. We denote the corresponding observables by Ax and Byii. In the honest implementation, an N-qubit balanced Dicke state is distributed in each round. Note that the security analysis allows arbitrary shared states and uncharacterized devices. For even N, the state is
DNN/2⟩=(N/2N)−1/2∣z∣=N/2∑∣z⟩,(1)
where z∈{0,1}N, ∣z∣ is its Hamming weight, and ∣z⟩ is the corresponding computational-basis state. Rounds with x=0 and yi=2 for all i are used for key generation. Rounds with x∈{0,1} and yi∈{0,1} are used to test the Bell inequality. Alice may apply noisy preprocessing by independently flipping each raw key bit with probability q to enhance the robustness of the protocol [18]. The parties use the test rounds and a sample of the key-generation rounds to estimate an achievable key rate. Under the independent and identically distributed assumption, the asymptotic DI-CKA key rate per key-generation round r is expressed as [19]
r≥H(A∣E,x=0)−imaxH(A∣Bi,x=0,yi=2).(2)
Here A denotes Alice’s key bit after noisy preprocessing, Bi denotes Bobi’s raw key bit, and E denotes Eve’s side information. The first term is the conditional von Neumann entropy of Alice’s measurement results for the key-generation rounds given Eve’s information and the second term is the maximal error-correction cost between Alice and the Bobs. If the estimated rate is positive, the parties perform error correction and privacy amplification to obtain a common secret key.
We assume that all parties use Pauli X measurements for key generation in the honest implementation with the balanced Dicke state: A0=B21=⋯=B2N−1=X. The pairwise key correlator is then ⟨XAXBi⟩=N/[2(N−1)]. Without noisy preprocessing, the error-correction cost is
H(A∣Bi,x=0,yi=2)=h(4(N−1)N−2).(3)
This cost is nonzero for every even N≥4 and approaches h(1/4)≈0.811 bits as N→∞.
Two-body Bell inequalities.—For α>0, define the following two-body Bell value
To relate this expression to the asymmetric CHSH inequality, let Uy≡∑i=1N−1Byi for y=0,1. For each fixed y, the observables Byi of different Bobs commute and have eigenvalues ±1. Since N−1 is odd, every eigenvalue of Uy is an odd integer. Thus, we can define Ry=sgn(Uy), satisfying Ry2=I. Treating all the Bobs as a single composite party, we obtain the following asymmetric CHSH expression
TN,αtwo=−α⟨A0(R0+R1)⟩−⟨A1(R0−R1)⟩,(5)
with local bound max{2,2α} and quantum maximum 21+α2. Let S^ and T^ denote the Bell operators associated with SN,αtwo and TN,αtwo, respectively. Then, the difference between these two Bell operators can be expressed as
T^−S^=y=0,1∑[41+α(Uy2−I)+Wy(Uy−Ry)].(6)
where W0=αA0+A1, W1=αA0−A1, and I is the identity. Let u and w denote the eigenvalues of Uy and Wy, respectively. Since [Uy,Wy]=0 and ∥Wy∥≤α+1, we have
where the first inequality uses ∣w∣≤α+1 and ∣u−sgn(u)∣=∣u∣−1, and the last inequality follows because ∣u∣ is a positive odd integer. Hence T^−S^≥0, which implies
SN,αtwo≤TN,αtwo.(8)
We show that the local bound and the quantum maximum of SN,αtwo are max{2,2α} and 21+α2, respectively, in Sec. A of the Supplemental Material [20].
We now transfer the tight analytical entropy bound for the asymmetric CHSH inequality of Ref. [17] to the two-body Bell value. Define Fα(s)=s2/4−α2 and
This bound is tight as a function of the two-body Bell value; an explicit saturating strategy is given in Sec. A of the Supplemental Material [20]. For the ideal implementation with the balanced Dicke state specified in Sec. C of the Supplemental Material [20], we derive the following lower bound on the conditional von Neumann entropy for 0<α<1, N≥4, and q=0
H(A∣E,x=0)≥2(1−α)(1+α2+1)−log2(1+2−κα),(14)
where
κα=1+α2(1+α2−1)1+1−α2.(15)
As α→0, the right-hand side of Eq. (14) approaches one. Combining this result with the error-correction cost in Eq. (3), the certified ideal DI-CKA key rate approaches
α→0limrN,αtwo≥1−h(4(N−1)N−2).(16)
This approaches 1−h(1/4)≈0.189 bits per key-generation round as N→∞. That is, a positive DI-CKA key rate can be obtained for every even N≥4 with the two-body Bell inequality and the balanced Dicke state in the ideal setting.
Figure 1 compares the certified ideal DI-CKA key rates with those of the GHZ-based protocol in Ref. [12] and the biseparable-state protocol in Ref. [10]. The GHZ-based protocol achieves one secret bit per round in the ideal setting, but its Bell test requires full-body correlators. The protocol of Ref. [10] uses only two-body correlators and biseparable states; its straightforward N-party extension yields a key rate of 1/(N−1). In our construction, the ideal DI-CKA rate remains bounded away from zero as N increases, including at fixed positive values of α as shown in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Certified ideal key rates versus the number of parties N. The red circles, the green diamonds, and the orange triangles represent DI-CKA key rates of the protocol based on the balanced Dicke states with the two-body Bell inequality for α→0, α=0.01, and α=0.1, respectively, where we use the explicit lower bound on the conditional von Neumann entropy in Eq. (14). The blue squares represent key rates of the GHZ-based protocol of Ref. [12] and the purple crosses represent key rates of the N-partite extension of the biseparable-state DI-CKA protocol of Ref. [10]. Rates are given in bits per key-generation round.
*DI-CKA from arbitrarily small nonlocality—*Positive key rates from arbitrarily small nonlocality are known in bipartite device-independent QKD [21, 22]. We now show that this phenomenon also occurs in DI-CKA using balanced Dicke states. The relevant notion of small nonlocality is proximity of a probability distribution for
measurement outcomes to the local set. Define the following set of N-partite local correlations LN
and the distance of a probability distribution from the local set as
d(P,LN)=PL∈LNinfd(P,PL).(19)
Then, we prove the following proposition:
Proposition 1. For every fixed even N≥4 and every 0<ϵ≤1, there exists a correlation Pϵ, obtainable from a balanced Dicke state, for which the following statements hold simultaneously
r(Pϵ)≥1−h(4(N−1)N−2),d(Pϵ,LN)≤2N−1ϵ,(20)
where r(Pϵ) represents a DI-CKA key rate for Pϵ.
We sketch the proof here; details are given in Sec. E of the Supplemental Material [20]. Consider the full-body Bell expression
TN,ϵfull=⟨A0(C0+C1)⟩+ϵ⟨A1(C0−C1)⟩(21)
where Cy=⨂i=1N−1Biy for y=0,1 and 0<ϵ≤1. Its local bound is 2 and its quantum maximum is 21+ϵ2. Choose A0=B2i=X, A1=Y, B0i=M(θ), and B1i=M(−θ), with M(θ)=cosθX+sinθY and θ=arctanϵ. These measurements on the balanced Dicke state define Pϵ and attain the quantum maximum, i.e., TN,ϵfull=21+ϵ2>2. Define Gϵ(t)=t2/4−1/ϵ. For q=0, the entropy bound is
H(A∣E,x=0)≥1−h(21+Gϵ(TN,ϵfull))(22)
We establish the tightness of this bound in Supplemental Material D [20]. At the quantum maximum, this bound gives one bit of conditional entropy. Together with the error-correction cost in Eq. (3), it certifies a key rate of 1−h[(N−2)/(4(N−1))] for every 0<ϵ≤1. On the other hand, at ϵ=0, every Bob measures X for all inputs. The resulting correlation P0 admits an explicit local-hidden-variable model, hence P0∈LN. Moreover, for the distance between Pϵ and P0, we derive the following inequality (see Sec. E of the Supplemental Material for the derivation [20])
d(Pϵ,P0)≤(N−1)sin2θ.(23)
Using sin(θ/2)≤θ/2 and θ=arctanϵ≤ϵ, we obtain the distance bound in Proposition 1. Thus, for each fixed even N, a positive DI-CKA key rate remains certified while the correlation approaches the local set.
Imperfection robustness.—We analyze the robustness of the DI-CKA protocol based on the balanced Dicke state against experimental imperfections. We examine collective phase noise, modeled as the same random phase rotation on all N qubits. For Uϕ=e−iϕZ/2, an N-partite GHZ state, ∣GHZN⟩=(∣0⟩⊗N+∣1⟩⊗N)/2, acquires a relative phase Nϕ:
Uϕ⊗N∣GHZN⟩=21(∣0⟩⊗N+eiNϕ∣1⟩⊗N).(24)
where the global phase has been omitted. Averaging over the random phase reduces the coherence of the GHZ state. In contrast, the balanced Dicke state satisfies Uϕ⊗N∣DNN/2⟩=∣DNN/2⟩. Therefore, the certified DI-CKA key rate with the honest implementation using the balanced Dicke state is invariant under this noise. Figure 2 compares the balanced-Dicke-based protocol and the GHZ-based protocol for a zero-mean Gaussian phase distribution. The key rate for the GHZ-based protocol
Figure 2. Certified key rates under collective phase noise. The same random phase ϕ acts on all N qubits, with ϕ drawn from a zero-mean Gaussian distribution of variance σϕ2. The solid curves show the key rates for the GHZ-based protocol of Ref. [12]; the dashed curves show the key rates for the two-body balanced-Dicke-based protocol in the limit α→0, for N=10, 20 and 30. Rates are given in bits per key-generation round.
decreases rapidly with increasing phase variance, particularly for larger N, whereas the key rate for the Dicke-based protocol is unchanged. We also analyze local depolarizing noise and detection inefficiency in Sec. F of the Supplemental Material [20]. For these imperfections, the Dicke-based protocols tolerate less noise than the GHZ-based protocol. This reflects the nonzero error-correction cost for the balanced Dicke state even in the ideal setting.
Conclusion.—In this work, we have shown that two-body Bell correlations can certify a nonvanishing DI-CKA key rate using balanced Dicke states for every even number of parties N≥4. We derive a tight analytical entropy bound by comparing the Bell operators of our two-body inequalities with those of asymmetric CHSH inequalities. The ideal key rates remain bounded away from zero as N increases. A complementary full-body Bell inequality certifies a positive DI-CKA key rate for correlations arbitrarily close to the local set. In addition, the key rate with the honest implementation using the balanced Dicke state is invariant under collective phase noise, although its tolerance to local depolarizing noise and detection inefficiency is lower than that of the GHZ-based protocol considered here. An interesting future direction is to construct few-body Bell inequalities which improve tolerance to those experimental imperfections.
Acknowledgments.—This work was supported by JST SPRING, Grant No. JPMJSP2123, JST Moonshot R&D, Grant No. JPMJMSP2656E, JST CRONOS, Grant No. JPMJCS24N6, JST COI-NEXT, Grant No. JPMJPF2221 and JST ASPIRE, Grant No. JPMJAP2427. The authors used OpenAI’s ChatGPT-6.1 Sol to assist with exploratory literature searches, checks of mathematical derivations, and language editing. All AI-assisted content and calculations were independently checked by the authors.
References
Tightness of the entropy bound for the two-body Bell inequality
We establish tightness of the entropy bound for the two-body Bell inequality by embedding a strategy that saturates the entropy bound for the asymmetric CHSH inequality. Define ∣ψ−⟩=21(∣01⟩−∣10⟩). Let Alice, the Bobs and Eve share the following quantum state
where ρAB1E corresponds to the optimal eavesdropping strategy which saturates the entropy bound for the asymmetric CHSH inequality. Here, all Bobs except Bob1 measure Z for both Bell-test inputs. Then, the following holds
(By2r+By2r+1)∣ψ−⟩=0.(26)
On the support of this state, Uy=By1 and Ry=By1. Hence
41+α(Uy2−I)+Wy(Uy−Ry)=0,(27)
and the two Bell values coincide, i.e.,
SN,αtwo=TN,αtwo.(28)
Consequently, the local bound and quantum maximum of SN,αtwo become max{2,2α} and 21+α2, respectively. In addition, on the support of ρABE, TN,αtwo becomes the standard asymmetric CHSH inequality, i.e.,
TN,αtwo=−α⟨A0(B01+B11)⟩−⟨A1(B01−B11)⟩.(29)
ρAB1E saturates the entropy bound for this inequality. Thus, we can conclude that the entropy bound for the two-body Bell inequality is tight.
An explicit entropy lower bound for 0<α<1
We derive an explicit approximation to the tight entropy bound gˉq,α for 0<α<1. For a Bell value s, define
Finally, we show that this lower bound is valid for gˉq,α. For s=2, we have
lq(2)−ϵq,α=h(q)−ϵq,α≤h(q).(54)
Therefore, lq(s)−ϵq,α lies below every convex combination of gq,α(s) and h(q). Consequently,
gˉq,α(s)≥lq(s)−ϵq,α.(55)
Furthermore, when Alice performs noisy preprocessing, we have H(A∣E,x=0)≥h(q) in general. Then, we obtain
max{h(q),h(q)+(1−h(q))λ−ϵq,α}≤gˉq,α(s).(56)
On the other hand, using the convexity of gˉq,α, gˉq,α(2)=h(q), and gˉq,α(21+α2)=1, we obtain
gˉq,α(s)≤(1−λ)h(q)+λ=lq(s).(57)
Nonvanishing key rates for an arbitrary even number of parties
We show that the two-body Bell inequality certifies an ideal DI-CKA key rate bounded away from zero for every even N≥4. We use the following measurements and set q=0:
and the last inequality holds for 0<α<1 and N≥4. Therefore, by using the explicit lower bound which we obtain in Sec. B of the Supplemental Material, we have the following lower bound on the conditional von Neumann entropy
Since ϵ0,α→0 for α→0, the key rate in this limit becomes
rN,αtwo→1−h(4(N−1)N−2).(67)
Tightness of the entropy bound for the full-body Bell inequality
In this section, we introduce a full-body Bell inequality which the balanced Dicke state maximally violates and derive a corresponding tight analytical lower bound on the conditional von Neumann entropy.
The balanced Dicke state admits a maximally entangled decomposition between Alice’s qubit and a two-dimensional logical subspace of the Bobs’ joint system:
DNN/2⟩=21(∣0⟩DN−1N/2⟩+∣1⟩DN−1N/2−1⟩).(68)
Defining ∣0L⟩=DN−1N/2−1⟩ and ∣1L⟩=DN−1N/2⟩, this becomes (∣0⟩∣1L⟩+∣1⟩∣0L⟩)/2. In addition, we consider the following measurement
M(θ)=cosθX+sinθY,(69)
satisfying M(θ)∣0⟩=eiθ∣1⟩ and M(θ)∣1⟩=e−iθ∣0⟩. For a Dicke state of N−1 modes with k excitations, the following holds
M(θ)⊗N−1DN−1k⟩=eiθ(N−1−2k)DN−1N−1−k⟩.(70)
Thus, for the logical qubits, we have M(θ)⊗N−1∣0L⟩=eiθ∣1L⟩ and M(θ)⊗N−1∣1L⟩=e−iθ∣0L⟩, that is, the product of the Bobs’ local outcomes realizes the corresponding logical observable. Using this gives the following for full-body correlators for the balanced Dicke state
⟨MA(γ)i=1⨂N−1MBi(β)⟩D=cos(γ−β),(71)
where γ is Alice’s measurement angle and β is the common measurement angle of all Bobs.
Using this logical representation, we define the following full-body Bell value
where 0<α and Cy=⨂i=1N−1Byi for y=0,1. This can be understood as a variant of the asymmetric CHSH inequality developed in [17]. Therefore, the local bound and the quantum maximum of this Bell value are max{2,2α} and 21+α2, respectively. The quantum maximum can be obtained with the balanced Dicke state and the following measurements: A0=X, A1=Y, B0i=M(θ), and B1i=M(−θ), where θ=arctanα1. Thanks to the equivalence of the above inequality and the asymmetric CHSH, we can utilize the analytical lower bound on the conditional von Neumann entropy, i.e., the following holds
H(A∣E,x=0)≥gˉq,α(SN,αfull).(73)
For the maximal quantum violation, SN,αfull=21+α2, the lower bound becomes 1. Therefore, with the error-correction cost in Eq. (3), the DI-CKA key rate in the ideal setting is
rN,αfull≥1−h(4(N−1)N−2),(74)
for arbitrary even N and q=0.
In the following, we show the tightness of the above entropy bound for the full-body Bell inequality. We assume that Alice, the Bobs, and Eve share the following entangled state
This coincides with the analytical lower bound for α≥1. For 0<α<1, by considering a probabilistic mixture of the above eavesdropping attack and a classical eavesdropping attack which gives H(A∣E,x=0)=h(q) at SN,αfull=2, we can show the tightness of the entropy bound.
Proof of Proposition 1
We describe the proof of Proposition 1. We aim to show that, for a fixed even N≥4 and a probability distribution Pϵ∈LN, the following statements hold simultaneously
r(Pϵ)>0,d(Pϵ,LN)≤2N−1ϵ,(94)
where r(Pϵ) represents a DI-CKA key rate for Pϵ.
We first derive the first inequality in Eq. (94). To this end, we use the full-body Bell value which we introduce in Sec. D of the Supplemental Material:
Since the local bound and the quantum maximum of SN,αfull are max{2,2α} and 21+α2, respectively, the local bound and the quantum maximum of TN,ϵfull become 2 and 21+ϵ2, respectively. We use the following measurements
A0=X,A1=Y,B0i=M(θ),B1i=M(−θ),B2i=X,(97)
where M(θ)=cosθX+sinθY and θ=arctanϵ. Let Pϵ denote a probability distribution obtained by performing these measurements on the balanced Dicke state. Using
⟨MA(γ)i=1⨂N−1MBi(β)⟩D=cos(γ−β),(98)
the Bell value can be expressed as
TN,ϵfull=2(cosθ+ϵsinθ)=21+ϵ2>2.(99)
That is, for all 0<ϵ≤1, we can achieve the quantum maximum. Define
Gϵ(t)=ϵt2/4−1.(100)
Using the analytical entropy bound for the original full-body Bell inequality, we have the following entropy bound:
H(A∣E,x=0)≥1−h(21+Gϵ(TN,ϵfull)),(101)
where we set q=0 for simplicity. When the quantum maximum TN,ϵfull=21+ϵ2 is achieved, Gϵ(TN,ϵfull)=1. Therefore, the DI-CKA key rate in the ideal setting becomes
r(Pϵ)=1−h(4(N−1)N−2)>0,(102)
for every 0<ϵ≤1.
Next, we derive the second inequality in Eq. (94). Define the following observable where we rotate the measurement axis by δ away from X,
M(δ)=cosδX+sinδY.(103)
Corresponding projectors can be expressed as
Π±1(δ)=2I±M(δ).(104)
Define D=Π+1(δ)−Π+1(0). Then, since X2=Y2=I and XY+YX=0, we have
D2=sin22δI.(105)
Since D is Hermitian, its eigenvalues are λ±=±sin2δ. The operator norm of D is therefore
∥D∥∞=sin2∣δ∣,(106)
where we assume −π≤δ≤π. We next consider the distance between two probability distributions after one party rotates their measurement axes by δ. Without loss of generality, we assume that Alice rotates her measurement axis. Let ρA∣b denote Alice’s quantum state conditioned on the Bobs’ measurement outcomes b. Define
Pafter(+1,b)=P(b)Tr[ρA∣bΠ+1(δ)],(107)
Pbefore(+1,b)=P(b)Tr[ρA∣bΠ+1(0)],(108)
where P(b) is the probability of obtaining b. Then, the following holds
Thus, when one party rotates their measurement axis by δ, the distance between two probability distributions is bounded by
d(Pafter,Pbefore)≤sin2∣δ∣.(112)
We can straightforwardly generalize this result to the cases where multiple parties rotate their measurement axes. When Nrotate parties rotate their measurement axes by δ, the distance between probability distributions before and after the rotation is bounded by
d(Pafter,Pbefore)≤Nrotatesin2∣δ∣.(113)
Finally, we construct a local-hidden-variable (LHV) model which reproduces the same probability distribution as the above configuration with ϵ→0. Note that Bi0=Bi1=Bi2=X when ϵ=0. Let P0 denote a probability distribution corresponding to this limit. We show P0∈LN in the following. First, for the balanced Dicke state, we have
X⊗NDNN/2⟩=DNN/2⟩,(114)
i.e., the balanced Dicke state is an eigenstate of X⊗N with eigenvalue of +1. Therefore, for the measurement outcomes of the legitimate parties, the following holds when all parties perform the X measurements
ai=1∏N−1bi=+1,(115)
and consequently
a=i=1∏N−1bi.(116)
In addition, when all the Bobs perform the X measurements on the balanced Dicke state, the remaining quantum state on Alice’s system becomes ∣+⟩⟨+∣ or ∣−⟩⟨−∣. Therefore, when Alice performs the Y measurement, she will obtain measurement outcomes ±1 with equal probabilities. Now, we construct an explicit LHV model which gives P0. Let PXB(b) denote a marginal probability distribution where all the Bobs perform the X measurements and obtain outcomes b=(b1,…,bN−1). In addition, we use a variable ξ, satisfying P(ξ=+1)=P(ξ=−1)=1/2. Then, we first sample the hidden variable λ=(b1,…,bN−1,ξ) with probability P(λ)=21PXB(b). Bobi outputs bi for every input for all i. On the other hand, Alice outputs ∏i=1N−1bi when her input is x=0 and outputs ξ when x=1. Since this LHV model produces the probability distribution P0, this distribution is in the set of local correlations, i.e., P0∈LN. In conclusion, the distance between Pϵ and P0 can be expressed as
where we use sin(θ/2)≤θ/2 and θ=arctanϵ≤ϵ for the last inequality. This concludes the proof of Proposition 1. Consequently, for a fixed even N and ϵ→0, we have
r(Pϵ)=1−h(4(N−1)N−2)>0,d(Pϵ,LN)→0.(118)
Noise analyses
We analyze the effect of experimental imperfections, i.e., local depolarizing noise, detection inefficiency, and collective phase noise. We consider three different DI-CKA protocols: balanced-Dicke-based protocol with the full-body inequality, balanced-Dicke-based protocol with the two-body inequality, and GHZ-based protocol with the asymmetric parity-CHSH inequality [12]. The same local depolarizing noise and detection efficiency are used for all parties.
Each qubit undergoes an independent depolarizing channel, defined for a single-qubit state ρ by
Dpdep(ρ)=(1−pdep)ρ+pdep2I,0≤pdep≤1.(119)
Consider an arbitrary traceless observable M=n1X+n2Y+n3Z, where n1, n2 and n3 are coefficients. The local depolarizing noise turns this observable into
Dpdep(M)=(1−pdep)M=vdepM,Dpdep(I)=I,(120)
where vdep=1−pdep. This means that a k-body correlator is attenuated with the factor vdepk.
We model each nondetection event by assigning an independent uniformly random binary outcome. For an ideal observable M, the effective POVM elements are
Ea∣M=η2I+aM+(1−η)2I=2I+ηaM.(121)
Then, the corresponding observable with detection efficiency η becomes
E+1∣M−E−1∣M=ηM.(122)
Therefore, full-body and two-body correlators are attenuated with the factors (ηvdep)N and (ηvdep)2, respectively, after these imperfections.
Consider a phase rotation Uϕ. We define the collective phase noise as
P(ρ)=∫dϕP(ϕ)Uϕ⊗Nρ(Uϕ†)⊗N,(123)
where P(ϕ) is a Gaussian distribution with zero mean and variance σϕ2. The balanced Dicke state is invariant under this noise, i.e., Uϕ⊗N∣DNN/2⟩=∣DNN/2⟩. On the other hand, the GHZ state becomes Uϕ⊗N∣GHZN⟩=(∣0⟩⊗N+eiNϕ∣1⟩⊗N)/2 up to a global phase.
Balanced-Dicke-based protocol with the two-body Bell inequality
The ideal two-body correlators follow from the reduced state in Eq. (59):
⟨XX⟩=⟨YY⟩=2(N−1)N,⟨ZZ⟩=−N−11,⟨XZ⟩=⟨ZX⟩=0.(124)
Considering the local depolarizing noise and detection efficiency, these correlators are attenuated with the factor (ηvdep)2.
Note that the quantum bit error rate becomes zero in the ideal setting, i.e., η=vdep=1 for q=0. By using the result in Ref. [12], the key rate of the GHZ-based protocol can be expressed as
rN,αGHZ≥gˉq,α(SN,αparity/noise)−h(QZq).(147)
We numerically optimize the coefficient α and the probability for noisy preprocessing q to maximize the key rate.
Numerical results
We numerically evaluate the optimized key rates and determine the noise thresholds. The local depolarizing threshold is the largest value of pdep compatible with a positive key rate, whereas the detection efficiency threshold is the minimum required efficiency η for a positive key rate. Figure 3 compares these thresholds for the three DI-CKA protocols. The GHZ-based protocol has the highest tolerance to local depolarizing noise and detection inefficiency, followed by the full-body Dicke-based protocol and then the two-body Dicke-based protocol. For the Dicke-based protocols, the nonzero error-correction cost in the ideal setting reduces the tolerable noise margin. The two-body protocol has an additional limitation: high conditional von Neumann entropy is certified at small α, whereas the separation between the local and quantum bounds of the inequality becomes smaller as α decreases. Consequently, the protocol becomes more sensitive to local depolarizing noise and detection loss.
Figure 3. Noise thresholds versus the number of parties N: (a) the full-body balanced-Dicke-based protocol, (b) the two-body balanced-Dicke-based protocol, and (c) the GHZ-based protocol with the asymmetric parity-CHSH inequality. The blue squares, read against the left axis, show the maximum tolerable local depolarizing noise pdep; the red circles, read against the right axis, show the minimum required detection efficiency η.
References
[1]C. H. Bennett and G. Brassard, Quantum cryptography: Public key distribution and coin tossing, Theor. Comput. Sci. 560, 7 (2014).DOI
[3]G. Murta, F. Grasselli, H. Kampermann, and D. Bruß, Quantum conference key agreement: A review, Adv. Quantum Technol. 3, 2000025 (2020).DOI
[4]L. Lydersen, C. Wiechers, C. Wittmann, D. Elser, J. Skaar, and V. Makarov, Hacking commercial quantum cryptography systems by tailored bright illumination, Nat. Photon. 4, 686 (2010).DOI
[5]I. Gerhardt, Q. Liu, A. Lamas-Linares, J. Skaar, C. Kurtsiefer, and V. Makarov, Full-field implementation of a perfect eavesdropper on a quantum cryptography system, Nat. Commun. 2, 349 (2011).DOI
[6]J. Ribeiro, G. Murta, and S. Wehner, Reply to “Comment on ‘Fully device-independent conference key agreement’ ”, Phys. Rev. A 100, 026302 (2019).DOI
[7]T. Holz, H. Kampermann, and D. Bruß, Genuine multipartite Bell inequality for device-independent conference key agreement, Phys. Rev. Research 2, 023251 (2020).
[8]F. Grasselli, G. Murta, H. Kampermann, and D. Bruß, Boosting device-independent cryptography with tripartite nonlocality, Quantum 7, 980 (2023).DOI
[9]M. Ishihara, A. J. E. Bjerrum, W. Roga, J. B. Brask, U. L. Andersen, and M. Takeoka, Long-distance device-independent conference key agreement, Phys. Rev. A 112, 032429 (2025).DOI
[10]L. Wooltorton, P. Brown, and R. Colbeck, Genuine multipartite entanglement is not necessary for standard device-independent conference key agreement, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 220803 (2025).DOI
[11]M. Ishihara, W. Roga, and M. Takeoka, Multipartite device-independent quantum key distribution using W states, arXiv:2603.00937 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2603.00937
[12]M. Ishihara, W. Roga, J. B. Brask, and M. Takeoka, Enhancing noise robustness in device-independent conference key agreement with asymmetric parity-CHSH inequalities, arXiv:2609.03551 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2609.03551
[13]D. M. Greenberger, M. A. Horne, A. Shimony, and A. Zeilinger, Bell’s theorem without inequalities, Am. J. Phys. 58, 1131 (1990).DOI
[14]R. H. Dicke, Coherence in spontaneous radiation processes, Phys. Rev. 93, 99 (1954).DOI
[15]J. Tura, R. Augusiak, A. B. Sainz, T. Vértesi, M. Lewenstein, and A. Acín, Detecting nonlocality in many-body quantum states, Science 344, 1256 (2014).DOI
[16]J. Tura, R. Augusiak, A. B. Sainz, B. Lücke, C. Klempt, M. Lewenstein, and A. Acín, Nonlocality in many-body quantum systems detected with two-body correlators, Ann. Phys. 362, 370 (2015).DOI
[17]E. Woodhead, A. Acín, and S. Pironio, Device-independent quantum key distribution with asymmetric CHSH inequalities, Quantum 5, 443 (2021).DOI
[18]M. Ho, P. Sekatski, E. Y.-Z. Tan, R. Renner, J.-D. Bancal, and N. Sangouard, Noisy preprocessing facilitates a photonic realization of device-independent quantum key distribution, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124, 230502 (2020).DOI
[19]J. Ribeiro, G. Murta, and S. Wehner, Fully device-independent conference key agreement, Phys. Rev. A 97, 022307 (2018).DOI
[20]See Supplemental Material at [URL] for saturating strategies, explicit entropy bounds, the proof of Proposition 1, and noise analyses.
[21]L. Wooltorton, P. Brown, and R. Colbeck, Device-independent quantum key distribution with arbitrarily small nonlocality, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 210802 (2024).DOI
[22]M. Farkas, Unbounded device-independent quantum key rates from arbitrarily small nonlocality, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 210803 (2024).DOI