WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Complete set of bounded-from-below conditions for the -symmetric three-Higgs-doublet model
Abstract
We derive bounded-from-below necessary conditions for the scalar potential of an -invariant three-Higgs-doublet model. The field Ansätze that we have used were devised with the help of Claude. Testing our set of conditions on random potentials, that in parallel we minimize by brute force using the Mathematica package StableWein, we find that the set seems to be necessary and sufficient for boundedness-from-below.
Introduction
We consider the gauge model with scalar sector consisting of three doublets with equal hypercharge; this is called the three-Higgs-doublet model (3HDM). Let () denote the doublets. We study the version of the 3HDM where, besides the gauge symmetry, there is also invariance under the discrete non-Abelian group generated by the transformations
Such a model has been used to address the flavour puzzle [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8], to generate neutrino masses [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16], as an explanation for dark matter [17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24], amongst other applications [25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31].
Using
we write the most general renormalizable -symmetric scalar potential (SP) as , where and [32]
Both and are real. In the special case where , the potential is -symmetric [32, 33].
In this work, we are interested in the conditions that guarantee that an SP with given by Eq. (3) is bounded from below (BFB).1 That is, we look for conditions that ensure that for all possible field configurations.2 To that end, it is convenient to rewrite as
where
The set of values that may take is called the orbit space.
Notice that appears only as an additive constant in Eq. (7), i.e. the term is independent from the orbit-space point. Therefore, requiring at every point of orbit space implies BFB conditions of the form [34]
In sections 2 and 3 we derive various that provide a set of necessary BFB conditions. In section 4 we suggest that our set of necessary conditions actually is necessary and sufficient (n&s) for BnessFB. Section 5 is devoted to the -symmetric case.
Vertices
We say that a configuration of the scalar doublets is ‘neutral’ if one may use an transformation to nullify all the upper components of the doublets. If a configuration of the doublets is not neutral then we call it ‘charge-breaking’. In neutral configurations the doublets behave like singlets, meaning that . Thus, in the notation of (4), the formal definition of a neutral configuration is .
Neutral vertices
The possible neutral vacua of the -symmetric 3HDM have been found in Refs. [32, 34]. They are
point : ;
point : ;
point : ;
point : ;
points in circumference : , with .
Figure 1 depicts the orbit space sliced along the hyperplane . The points , , , and are marked, and the circumference is drawn in blue.

Figure 1. The points of orbit space with .
The points and circumference may be obtained, for example, by using the configurations of doublets4
where and .
As stated, for BFBness, cannot be negative at any of these points. The resulting necessary BFB conditions happen to be n&s if one restricts oneself to neutral configurations of doublets [33, 35]. Written in the form of inequality (6), they have equal to
respectively. Since , one may minimize with respect to and obtain [33]
where
Charge-breaking vertices
In Figure 2 we show the orbit space projected onto the plane. The neutral configurations lie on the black line where . One sees that there are additional vertices on the green line . Their coordinates are

Figure 2. Orbit space projected on the plane. The black line contains neutral configurations. The green line contains the charge-breaking vertices. Red line: the three -paths (they all coincide in this projection). Blue line: the -paths (they all coincide in this projection).
point : ;
point : ;
point :
point :
circumference : .
As first noticed for the -symmetric model in [33], these vertices can only be reached through charge-breaking field configurations. Examples of such configurations are
As the naming suggests, each charge-breaking configuration has an associated neutral configuration: at the charge-breaking configuration, is one quarter of its value at the corresponding neutral configuration. Thus,
Connecting the neutral and charge-breaking vertices
Mathematical preliminary
Consider the function defined as
where the coefficients , , and are real. Suppose one wants to guarantee that in the whole domain . This, of course, implies that both and . Thus, one must enforce
Additionally, if has a minimum at the point , and if happens to be inside the interval , then one must require . This means that
The -paths
-path 1
One may connect vertices , , and at Eqs. (7b), (27), and (16), respectively, through the Ansatz
where . Indeed, when , Eq. (34) reproduces Eq. (7b); when , it reproduces Eq. (11c); and when , it reproduces Eq. (7d). Now, configuration (34) produces and , hence
We call the orbit-space line given (in parametric form) by Eqs. (17b)–(17e) the -path 1.
Plugging the values (17) into Eq. (7) one obtains , with
So, according to the previous subsection, one must demand
and, besides,
where
Since point lies in -path 1, the BFB condition is made redundant.
t-path 2
In a similar fashion to what has been done in the previous subsection, one may connect vertices , , and at Eqs. (7b), (11d), and (7c), respectively, through the Ansatz
which is just Ansatz (16) with . Indeed, when , Eq. (46) reproduces Eq. (7b); when , it reproduces Eq. (11d); and when , it reproduces Eq. (7c).
As is obvious from Eqs. (5), making is equivalent to making . In Eq. (7) this is equivalent to making . So, one must demand
and, besides,
where
We call -path 2 the orbit-space line given by Eqs. (17b)–(17e) with . Since point lies in -path 2, the BFB condition is redundant.
-path 3
One may connect vertices , , and through the Ansatz
When , Eq. (50) reproduces Eq. (7d) with the upper and lower components of all three doublets interchanged; when , it reproduces Eq. (11b); and when , it reproduces Eq. (7c). Configuration (26) produces and , hence
We call the orbit-space line parametrically given by Eqs. (27b)–(27e) the -path 3. Plugging the values (27) into Eq. (7) one obtains , with
Accordingly, one must demand
and, besides,
where
Since point lies in -path 3, the BFB condition becomes redundant.
Depiction of the -paths
The -paths 1, 2, and 3 all have
for , and therefore they are all represented by the red vertical line in Figure 2.
Figure 3 shows the orbit space projected onto the hyperplane, cf. Eq. (62). The three -paths are marked in that figure.
The -paths
Both at point and at circumferences and one has . We connect those three configurations through the Ansatz
with . In orbit space, we call these the -paths (there is one path for each value of ).
Configuration (33) has, besides , , , and . Hence,

Figure 3. Orbit space projected on the hyperplane. Top (in yellow): the neutral configurations and the vertices , , and . Bottom (in yellow): the vertices , , and . In grey: all the points of orbit space. The three -paths, each of them joining two neutral vertices through a charge-breaking vertex, are depicted in red (-path 1), brown (-path 2), and pink (-path 3$).
So, defining
it has
Therefore, one must demand
and, besides,
Getting rid of the -dependence of conditions (38) takes some work. Firstly, we note that, from definition (35),
Secondly, we note that the second inequality (72) together with the negation of the third inequality (72) are equivalent to
(Remember that the first condition (71) is precisely , which we therefore take for granted.) So, when we need to impede that any in interval (73) also is in interval (74). One possibility of doing this is by setting
which means that interval (74) simply does not exist. We concentrate on the case where inequality (75) does not hold. Then, one must impede that the two intervals intersect. Hence,
Since circumference is in all -paths—it corresponds to in Ansatz (63)—the BFB condition is now superfluous.
Conclusions and hypothesis
We now summarize our findings: in order to guarantee that the SP of the -invariant 3HDM is BFB, one must
Enforce inequalities5
Impede the situation where
Forbid the situation where
Forbid the situation where
Discard cases where
In our numerical work, we have constructed one million sets of quartic couplings , , , , and that satisfy conditions (43).6 We checked how many of our million sets pass the brute-force minimization procedure for implemented in mode 4 of the Mathematica package StableWein [36];7 we found that, out of the one million initial sets, 957 888 sets correspond to BFB potentials, according to the numerical minimization procedure of StableWein. Now, exactly the same 957 888
where
set is obtained when one discards, from the original one million sets, those where any of conditions (44)–(47) holds true.8
We therefore conjecture that our necessary conditions for BnessFB are, in fact, necessary and sufficient.
The case of symmetry
When this model has an exact symmetry. In that limit, our method for assessing BnessFB reads:
Enforce inequalities
Impede the situation where
Forbid the situation where
Discard cases where
On the other hand, Ivanov & Vazão [33] have stated that the n&s conditions for BnessFB are
besides, the situation where
must be avoided, and the situation where
must also be avoided.
We have numerically checked that the two methods for guaranteeing BnessFB are in practice equivalent.
Acknowledgements: We thank Darius Jurčiukonis for independently performing the numerical check mentioned in section 4. Our work was supported by the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology (FCT) through projects UIDB/00777/2020 and UIDP/00777/2020, and by the Recovery and Resilience Plan within the scope of investment RE-C06-i06, measure RE-C06-i06.m02, project 2024.01362.CERN. The work of A.M. was supported by FCT - Fundação para a Ciência e Tecnologia, I.P. by project reference 2024.01340.BD and DOI identifier 10.54499/2024.01340.BD.
References
- [1]L. Lavoura and H. Kuhbock, A(4) model for the quark mass matrices, Eur. Phys. J. C 55 (2008) 303–308, [arXiv:0711.0670].DOI
- [2]A. C. B. Machado, J. C. Montero, and V. Pleitez, Three-Higgs-doublet model with A₄ symmetry, Phys. Lett. B 697 (2011) 318–322, [arXiv:1011.5855].DOI
- [3]R. de Adelhart Toorop, F. Bazzocchi, L. Merlo, and A. Paris, Constraining Flavour Symmetries At The EW Scale I: The A₄ Higgs Potential, JHEP 03 (2011) 035, [arXiv:1012.1791]. [Erratum: JHEP 01, 098 (2013)].DOI
- [4]R. de Adelhart Toorop, F. Bazzocchi, L. Merlo, and A. Paris, Constraining Flavour Symmetries At The EW Scale II: The Fermion Processes, JHEP 03 (2011) 040, [arXiv:1012.2091].DOI
- [5]E. Ma, Quark and Lepton Flavor Triality, Phys. Rev. D 82 (2010) 037301, [arXiv:1006.3524].DOI
- [6]R. González Felipe, H. Serôdio, and J. P. Silva, Models with three Higgs doublets in the triplet representations of A₄ or S₄, Phys. Rev. D 87 (2013), no. 5 055010, [arXiv:1302.0861].DOI
- [7]R. González Felipe, I. P. Ivanov, C. C. Nishi, H. Serôdio, and J. P. Silva, Constraining multi-Higgs flavour models, Eur. Phys. J. C 74 (2014), no. 7 2953, [arXiv:1401.5807].DOI
- [8]I. Bree, S. Carrolo, J. C. Romao, and J. P. Silva, A viable A₄ 3HDM theory of quark mass matrices, Eur. Phys. J. C 83 (2023), no. 4 292, [arXiv:2301.04676].DOI
- [9]E. Ma and G. Rajasekaran, Softly broken A(4) symmetry for nearly degenerate neutrino masses, Phys. Rev. D 64 (2001) 113012, [hep-ph/0106291].DOI
- [10]E. Ma, A(4) symmetry and neutrinos with very different masses, Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004) 031901, [hep-ph/0404199].
- [11]S. Morisi and E. Peinado, An A(4) model for lepton masses and mixings, Phys. Rev. D 80 (2009) 113011, [arXiv:0910.4389].DOI
- [12]R. Gonzalez Felipe, H. Serodio, and J. P. Silva, Neutrino masses and mixing in A₄ models with three Higgs doublets, Phys. Rev. D 88 (2013), no. 1 015015, [arXiv:1304.3468].DOI
- [13]E. Ma, Neutrino mixing: A₄ variations, Phys. Lett. B 752 (2016) 198–200, [arXiv:1510.02501].
- [14]Y. Izawa, Y. Shimizu, and H. Takei, Non-SUSY lepton flavor model with the three Higgs doublet model, PTEP 2023 (2023), no. 6 063B04, [arXiv:2209.10201].
- [15]B. Dziewit, M. Zralek, and J. Vergeest, Partial A₄ Flavor Symmetry of the Leptonic 3HDM, Acta Phys. Polon. Supp. 19 (2026), no. 2 2–A16, [arXiv:2512.10736].arxiv.org/abs/2512.10736
- [16]S. C. Chuliá and R. Kumar, Minimal A₄ type-II seesaw realization of testable neutrino mass sum rules, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026), no. 5 055023, [arXiv:2512.22343].
- [17]M. Hirsch, S. Morisi, E. Peinado, and J. W. F. Valle, Discrete dark matter, Phys. Rev. D 82 (2010) 116003, [arXiv:1007.0871].DOI
- [18]J. N. Esteves, F. R. Joaquim, A. S. Joshipura, J. C. Romao, M. A. Tortola, and J. W. F. Valle, A₄-based neutrino masses with Majoron decaying dark matter, Phys. Rev. D 82 (2010) 073008, [arXiv:1007.0898].DOI
- [19]D. Meloni, S. Morisi, and E. Peinado, Neutrino phenomenology and stable dark matter with A₄, Phys. Lett. B 697 (2011) 339–342, [arXiv:1011.1371].DOI
- [20]M. S. Boucenna, M. Hirsch, S. Morisi, E. Peinado, M. Taoso, and J. W. F. Valle, Phenomenology of Dark Matter from A₄ Flavor Symmetry, JHEP 05 (2011) 037, [arXiv:1101.2874].DOI
- [21]R. de Adelhart Toorop, F. Bazzocchi, and S. Morisi, Quark mixing in the discrete dark matter model, Nucl. Phys. B 856 (2012) 670–681, [arXiv:1104.5676].
- [22]I. de Medeiros Varzielas and D. Ivo, Softly-broken A₄ or S₄ 3HDMs with stable states, Eur. Phys. J. C 82 (2022), no. 5 415, [arXiv:2202.00681].
- [23]C. Bonilla, J. Herms, O. Medina, and E. Peinado, Discrete dark matter mechanism as the source of neutrino mass scales, JHEP 06 (2023) 078, [arXiv:2301.10811].DOI
- [24]R. Kumar, N. Nath, and R. Srivastava, Cutting the scotogenic loop: adding flavor to dark matter, JHEP 12 (2024) 036, [arXiv:2406.00188].DOI
- [25]J. Heeck, M. Holthausen, W. Rodejohann, and Y. Shimizu, Higgs → μτ in Abelian and non-Abelian flavor symmetry models, Nucl. Phys. B 896 (2015) 281–310, [arXiv:1412.3671].DOI
- [26]G. Bhattacharyya and D. Das, Nondecoupling of charged scalars in Higgs decay to two photons and symmetries of the scalar potential, Phys. Rev. D 91 (2015) 015005, [arXiv:1408.6133].DOI
- [27]I. de Medeiros Varzielas, O. Fischer, and V. Maurer, A₄ symmetry at colliders and in the universe, JHEP 08 (2015) 080, [arXiv:1504.03955].
- [28]G. C. Branco and I. P. Ivanov, Group-theoretic restrictions on generation of CP-violation in multi-Higgs-doublet models, JHEP 01 (2016) 116, [arXiv:1511.02764].DOI
- [29]I. de Medeiros Varzielas, S. F. King, C. Luhn, and T. Neder, CP-odd invariants for multi-Higgs models: applications with discrete symmetry, Phys. Rev. D 94 (2016), no. 5 056007, [arXiv:1603.06942].
- [30]S. Pramanick and A. Raychaudhuri, Three-Higgs-doublet model under A₄ symmetry implies alignment, JHEP 01 (2018) 011, [arXiv:1710.04433].DOI
- [31]N. Chakrabarty and I. Chakraborty, On the Higgs mass fine-tuning problem with multi-Higgs doublet models, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 34 (2019), no. 05 1950025, [arXiv:1801.05272].DOI
- [32]A. Degee, I. P. Ivanov, and V. Keus, Geometric minimization of highly symmetric potentials, JHEP 02 (2013) 125, [arXiv:1211.4989].DOI
- [33]I. P. Ivanov and F. Vazão, Yet another lesson on the stability conditions in multi-Higgs potentials, JHEP 11 (2020) 104, [arXiv:2006.00036].DOI
- [34]S. Carrol[o], J. C. Romao, and J. P. Silva, Conditions for global minimum in the A₄ symmetric 3HDM, Eur. Phys. J. C 82 (2022), no. 8 749, [arXiv:2207.02928].
- [35]N. Buskin and I. P. Ivanov, Bounded-from-below conditions for A₄-symmetric 3HDM, J. Phys. A 54 (2021) 325401, [arXiv:2104.11428].DOI
- [36]D. Jurčiukonis, L. Lavoura, and A. Milagre, Assessing boundedness from below in the Z₂ × Z₂-symmetric three-Higgs-doublet model: algorithm and machine learning, SciPost Phys. Core 9 (2026) 041, [arXiv:2603.23590].DOI