WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Study of pion condensate in nuclear matter based on a Parity Doublet Model
Abstract
In this work, we investigate the possibility of pion condensate in isospin-asymmetric nuclear matter within a parity doublet model at zero temperature, treating the baryon and isospin chemical potentials as independent variables. We include the , , , and mesons and determine their mean fields from the gap equations. We introduce a novel subtraction scheme to calculate the thermodynamic potential in the no-sea approximation, in which the effective isospin chemical potential is retained in the subtraction term to remove the divergence. We find that the presence of baryons suppresses pion condensate, and that transition to the pion condensation phase is of second order. We further find that the phase boundary depends systematically on the chiral-invariant mass : a smaller requires a larger critical isospin chemical potential for pion condensate. The presence of pion condensate also shifts the nuclear Liquid-Gas phase boundary toward larger baryon chemical potentials. Finally we study the existence of pion condensation phase in neutron star matter and find that pion condensate is unlikely to occur.
Introduction
The origin of nucleon mass remains one of the most challenging frontiers in quantum chromodynamics (QCD)—the fundamental theory to describe strong interactions—and nuclear physics. A nucleon weighs around 1 GeV but three quarks that make this nucleon only weigh around 10 MeV. In the QCD vacuum, the chiral symmetry spontaneously breaks down to by the quark-antiquark condensate, which generates nucleon mass. However, Lattice QCD simulations [1, 2, 3] and QCD sum rule studies [4, 5, 6] suggest that spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking does not account for the entire nucleon mass. In particular, a nonzero component of the nucleon mass may persist even after chiral symmetry is restored. This idea is adopted by the parity doublet model (PDM) [7, 8], in which the nucleon mass is divided into a chiral variant contribution generated by spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking and a chiral invariant contribution that remains even in the chiral symmetric phase.
To explore chiral invariant mass, strongly interacting matter under extreme conditions, such as high temperature or high density, provides a particularly useful setting. For instance, in high density regime, chiral symmetry is partially restored and chiral condensate is reduced, while the chiral invariant mass remains. In the past few years, there are many studies aiming on how to constrain chiral invariant mass based on neutron star observational data [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16]. In particular, Refs. [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16] use a PDM-NJL crossover model, in which neutron star equation of state is constructed by combining low density hadronic matter made from the parity doublet model and high density quark matter from Nambu-Jona-Lassino type quark model. Comparing the resultant mass-radius relation with neutron star observational data, it is found that the chiral invariant mass is more than half of nucleon mass.
However, for simplicity, pion condensation has not been included in previous studies based on PDMs. Pion is a meson with a relatively small mass MeV, and carries isospin number. Its chemical potential is equal to the isospin chemical potential , . Since neutron star matter is highly neutron rich, can be large enough as , so that a Bose-Einstein condensate may form. In other words, pion condensate is possible to occur in neutron star matter. Moreover, previous and recent studies indicate the possible existence of pion condensate based on different models [17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26].
In this work, we investigate whether pion condensation occurs within the PDM constructed in Ref. [27] and characterize its properties by studying isospin-asymmetric nuclear matter at zero temperature, with the isospin chemical potential and baryon chemical potential treated as independent parameters. For this purpose, we introduce four mesons , , and to include the attractive and repulsive force. In particular, vector mesons and are introduced based on the hidden local symmetry (HLS) [28, 29] to keep the Lagrangian chiral invariant. Regarding the determination of the model parameters, we assume that, at the saturation density, there is no pion condensate and fit the model parameters to the nuclear saturation properties.
After the model parameters are fixed as in the previous analyses [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16], we calculate the thermodynamic potential in the no-sea approximation. Here, we propose a new subtraction scheme in which we keep the effective isospin chemical potential in the subtraction term to cancel the divergence. Then, we study the phase structure of asymmetric nuclear matter and show the existence of pion condensation phase.
This paper is structured as below. In Sec. II we briefly introduce the parity doublet model and write down the Lagrangian. In Sec. III we construct the nuclear matter with a non-zero pion field and employ a new subtraction scheme. In Sec. IV we investigate the phase structure of nuclear matter with pion condensate and present the phase boundary between the pion condensation phase and the normal phase as well as the phase boundary of the Liquid-Gas phase transition. In Sce. V we discuss how pion condensate affect the neutron star matter in parity doublet model. Finally, in Sec. VI we give a summary and discussions.
Formulation
In this section we briefly review the PDM constructed in Ref. [27], and determine the model parameters.
Lagrangian and mean field approach
First of all, we introduce two kinds of nucleons as parity partners to construct the Lagrangian, one is (normal nucleon with ) and the other is (excited state with ). Since different nucleons can belong to different representations, in this work we adopt the so-called mirror assignment [7, 8]. The transformation properties of two fields under the chiral symmetry are given by
where . This assignment allows the existence of the chiral invariant mass.
The kinetic and mass terms for these two fields are given by [7, 8]
where is the matrix field for scalar and pseudoscalar mesons, which transforms as
In Eq. (3) the covariant derivatives acting on the nucleon fields are defined as
where () is the external gauge field corresponding to () chiral symmetry, and is the external gauge field corresponding to the baryon number symmetry.
In Ref. [27], the vector mesons and are introduced based on the hidden local symmetry (HLS) [28, 29] by decomposing the matrix field as
where and transform as
with and being the elements of and , respectively. In the unitary gauge of the HLS, the variables and are written in terms of the pion fields () as
where the matrix with being the Pauli Matrix. In Eq. (6) is the non-matrix field expressing the iso-singlet scalar meson, which is invariant under both the chiral symmetry and HLS.
The relevant Maurer-Cartan one-forms are given by
where the covariant derivatives are
with and being HLS gauge fields for and , and and their gauge couplings, respectively. The Lagrangian for vector mesons is given by
where and are the masses of and mesons, and and are the gauge field strengths of the HLS gauge bosons. The Lagrangian for the interactions to the vector mesons is expressed as [27]
For obtaining the thermodynamic potential to construct nuclear matter, we take mean-field approximation. As in the previous analyses (see e.g. Ref. [16]), we introduce the chemical potentials for the baryon number and the isospin through the time component of the external gauge fields as
We assume that the rotational symmetry of the system is not broken, so that vector mesons and have nonzero mean field values only for the time components. Furthermore, due to the isospin symmetry, we assume that the meson has a nonzero mean field value only for the third component. In this study, we consider only the S-wave pion condensate as a first step. Since meson does not feel isospin chemical potential and baryon chemical potential , it does not condense in the matter. In neutron star matter, the isospin chemical potential is negative, so that one can expect that meson condenses. The existence of a finite isospin chemical potential explicitly breaks the isospin symmetry to , which allows us to rotate condensate to the direction in the mean field approach. Now, we introduce the mean fields , and as
and use for the mean field for meson. With mean-field values and external chemical potentials, the Maurer-Cartan one-forms are calculated as
Then the vector meson Lagrangian is reduced to
In addition, the kinetic term of scalar mesons and the symmetry breaking term are expressed as
In the Lagrangian (12), nucleon fields often appears together with . For simplicity of the calculation, we perform the chiral transformation as below to absorb :
The Lagrangian is finally written as
with the meson part
Determination of model parameters
The present model includes following 12 relevant parameters:
First of all, we use the physical values for , , and as shown in Table I. The scalar coupling constants
| [MeV] | [MeV] | [MeV] | [MeV] |
| 783 | 776 | 140 | 92.4 |
Table I. Masses and the pion decay constant used in the analysis.
and are determined by using MeV and MeV as inputs for given value of the chiral invariant mass . The results are shown in tbl:2. Because pion condensate does not occur at nuclear saturation density in symmetric nuclear matter, so that we
| [MeV] | 500 | 600 | 700 | 800 | 900 |
| 9.02 | 8.48 | 7.81 | 6.99 | 5.96 | |
| 15.47 | 14.93 | 14.26 | 13.44 | 12.41 |
caption: Values of scalar Yukawa coupling constants for different chiral invariant mass
simply use the method introduced in Ref. [27], and determine the remaining five parameters by fitting to the nuclear saturation properties shown in Table III, combined with the stationary condition for the meson potential at vacuum which is expressed as
| [] | [MeV] | [MeV] | [MeV] |
| 0.16 | 16 | 240 | 31 |
caption: Saturation properties of normal nuclear matter. , , and are the saturation density, the biding energy, the incompressibility and the symmetry energy.
The resultant parameters are shown in Table IV.
| [MeV] | 500 | 600 | 700 | 800 | 900 |
| [MeV] | 46.981 | 56.126 | 60.552 | 61.124 | 57.991 |
| [MeV] | 22.748 | 18.298 | 14.641 | 11.346 | 7.060 |
| 22.701 | 22.350 | 19.278 | 11.930 | 1.498 | |
| 41.940 | 40.392 | 35.460 | 23.118 | 4.429 | |
| 16.943 | 15.746 | 13.887 | 8.893 | 0.636 | |
| 11.345 | 9.125 | 7.302 | 5.658 | 3.521 | |
| 7.316 | 7.855 | 8.131 | 8.298 | 8.436 |
caption: Values of model parameters and the mean fields at saturation, and .
Construction of nuclear matter with pion condensate
Thermodynamic potential
To get the thermodynamic potential of the system, path integral approach is a powerful tool to use. Here we use the standard process to calculate the thermodynamic potential. The partition function in the imaginary-time formalism is given by
with the Lagrangian in matrix form
The matrix in momentum space is given by
Then the partition function is calculated as
In the above expression, is the Hamiltonian in the momentum space and is the Matsubara frequency ( is an integer). We note that is the matrix in the space of the parity doubling, the isospin and the spinor spaces. The trace in Eq. (26) is taken in these spaces. By diagonalizing the Hamiltonian, the partition function is calculated as
where
with being the th eigenvalue of the Hamiltonian . Performing the Matsubara frequency sum, we finally get the thermodynamic potential as
Subtraction scheme
In the last subsection, we formaly obtained the thermodynamic potential for nucleons. To make the thermodynamic potential finite, we adopt the following subtraction scheme:
where represents the mean field values of mesons. In the following, we explain why we subtract instead of . Actually, if we subtracted , a divergence would arise from the momentum integration. This implies that subtracting is not enough in our case. The reason why we include the chemical potential in the subtraction term as is that proton and neutron carry different chemical potentials:
where the effective baryon and isospin chemical potentials are defined as
To understand and seek a better subtraction scheme, we first look at the Lagrangian (19). It is obvious that all the pion mean fields are coupled to the nucleon with the isospin chemical potential . If we set , pion fields are unaffected by the nucleons. On the other hand, when calculating the first term , the coupling of the pion field to the nucleons introduces effects that include divergences. Consequently, it is evident that simply subtracting is insufficient to eliminate these divergences. In Appendix B, we show that keeping is enough to subtract the divergence by taking the one-loop correction to the two-point function of mean field as an example.
Gap equations
Now we are going to compute the pressure as a function of baryon number chemical potential , isospin chemical potential . For given values of and , four mean field values , , and are determined by solving gap equations from the stationary condition of the thermodynamic potential.
In the present analysis, we numerically diagonalize the Hamiltonian given in Eq. (42). Then, instead of performing the numerical differentiation, we utilize Feynman-Hellman Theorem to solve the gap equation numerically. From the nucleon part of the thermodynamic potential given in Eq. (31), the gap equation of nucleon part is written as
The derivatives of energy eigenvalues are expressed as
Now, for evaluating this derivative numerically, we use the Feynman-Helmann theorem:
where and are the matrices that diagonalize the Hamiltonian.
Phase structure
Existence of pion condensate and chiral symmetry restoration
Let us first check the existence of the pion condensation phase in pure mesonic matter. In Figure 1, we show the dependence of pressure on the isospin chemical potential for . In this figure, the pressure begins to increase from zero after the isospin chemical potential becomes larger than the critical value MeV. Since there is no contribution from baryons at , this contribution comes from pion condensate. This result is consistent with the result from chiral perturbation theory [30].

Figure 1. Contribution of pion condensate to pressure for and MeV.
In the upper panel of Figure 2 we show the and mean field values at vacuum for and MeV, where and are defined as

Figure 2. Mean field values for MeV and MeV. The upper panel shows and . The lower panel shows and
For MeV, implies that pion condensation does not occur. For MeV, pion condensation occurs and is suppressed. In the lower panel of Figure 2, we show and at . The combination is invariant under chiral rotations and characterizes the magnitude of the chiral condensate, whereas depends on both its magnitude and orientation in the plane. As increases beyond the onset of pion condensation, increases and then remains stable. On the other hand, first decreases to zero and then becomes negatively large. This behavior indicates a redistribution of the condensate from the sigma direction toward the pion direction, accompanied by an increase in its total magnitude. Chiral symmetry is once restored and then broken again, with the magnitude enhanced by the pion condensate.4
Next, we include the effect of nucleons. In the upper panel of Figure 3, we show the effective pion chemical potential and mass , which are defined as (see Appendix C for derivation)

Figure 3. Isospin chemical potential dependences of the effective pion chemical potential and mass (upper panel), and the pressure (lower panel), for MeV and MeV.
In the lower panel, pressure for both normal phase (blue curve) and pion condensation phase (orange curve) are given. When increases, both and increase.
When is smaller than the critical point ( MeV), is larger than () and pion condensation does not occur. At the critical point , agrees with . For , and we obtain two solutions by solving the gap equations (34): one gives and the other gives a non-zero . As shown in Figure 3, the pressure of the normal phase (blue curve) with is smaller than that of the pion condensation phase (orange curve) with . This implies that the pion condensation phase is realized for . From the upper panel of Figure 2, this phase transition is of second order.
Phase diagram and dependence on
In Figure 4, we show the dependence of phase boundary between normal phase and the pion condensation phase on the plane. For MeV, the phase boundary—traced by increasing at a fixed —coincides at the critical , MeV for all values of . In contrast, for MeV, found by increasing at a fixed exceeds 140 MeV and varies depending on . This shift of arises from baryonic effects. It should be emphasized here that, regardless of the value of , this change of from 140 MeV appears for MeV. The reason for this can be explained as follows: As increases from 0 on the phase boundary, the neutron effective chemical potential increases as well. Since phase transition to the pion condensation phase is of second order, the pion condensation vanishes at phase boundary. Furthermore, and mean fields also vanish because there is no nucleon in matter. As a result, at the phase boundary. In addition, neutron mass is equal to the vacuum one, MeV. As increases further and reaches , neutrons start to appear. This point is characterized by:

Figure 4. Phase boundary for different
where MeV. This determines MeV.
Now let us explain how baryon affects the phase boundary. We can see from Figure 4, after baryon enters into the matter, phase boundary starts to bend upward, which means that is needed to induce the pion condensation. The reason why the existence of baryon makes the critical larger than is as follows: Before baryon enters, all the energy from isospin chemical potential is used to induce pion. After baryon enters into the matter, part of the energy is used to induce baryons and so that we need more energy (a larger isospin chemical potential) to induce pion in this case. As a result, the phase boundary bends upward and the is increased.
We now turn our attention on dependence of the phase boundary. In Figure 4, for a fixed , is larger for a smaller . We explain this by studying the tree-level effective pion chemical potential and effective pion mass . In fig. 5, we show dependences of (left panel), (middle panel) and (right panel) on and , respectively. The left panel shows that depends on but is not sensetive to , since is much smaller than . While the middle panel shows that depends on both. For fixed , is larger for smaller excluding the region where -900 MeV. This can be understood as follows: The Yukawa coupling and are larger for smaller , which leads to larger correction to resulting smaller for smaller . In the right panel, the white curve shows the phase boundary where , which means is larger for smaller .
Liquid-Gas phase transition
In this subsection, we study how the phase boundary of the liquid-gas phase transition is affected by the pion condensation. In Figure 6, we show the Liquid-Gas coexistence curves. The orange curve from to shows the Liquid-Gas coexistence curve drawn by assuming no pion condensation. For MeV, the Liquid-Gas phase transition is of first order (dashed curve), while for MeV, it is of second order (solid curve). For MeV, pion condensate occurs, the green curve shows the coexist-ing curve with the effect of pion condensation included. With the onset of pion condensation, the green curve departs from orange curve and starts to bend upward. As a result, for a fixed , the critical baryon chemical potential for the Liquid-Gas phase transition becomes larger when pion condensation is considered. The reason is as below: in the present system, the neutron first enters to the matter. Part of the energy (isospin chemical potential) is used to populate pion, which implies that a larger is needed to populate neutron.

Figure 6. Liquid-Gas phase transition line with pion condensation for MeV
Comparison with NS matter
In this section, we investigate whether pion condensation occurs inside neutron stars. In Figure 7, the dashed curves show the relation between the baryon number chemical potential and the isospin chemical potential realized inside the neutron stars, which is determined by imposing -equilibrium and electric charge neutrality with assuming no pion condensation. Solid curves are the phase boundaries as shown in Figure 4. We see only the purple curves (phase boundary and the relation between and inside neutron star matter for MeV) in Figure 7 intersects with each other, which indicates that pion condensate appears in neutron star matter at this point and the equation of state should be modified for density higher than this. However, we notice that at this intersection point, the density is already near four times of nuclear saturation density , where the parity doublet model may not be applicable. On the other hand, if we use pure PDM matter to solve Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff (TOV) equation to obtain the Mass-Radius relation, it is difficult to satisfy the two-time solar mass constraint. Therefore we conclude that in the present parity doublet model, pion condensate is unlikely to occur in neutron star matter.

Figure 7. Relations between and in the neutron star matter (dashed curves) together with the phase boundaries for the pion condensation (solid curves).

Figure 5. Dependence of , and on and .
SUMMARY AND DISCUSSIONS
In this work, we constructed nuclear matter based on the parity doublet model proposed in Ref. [27], taking pion condensate into account. We proposed a new subtraction scheme to obtain the finite thermodynamic potential within the no-sea approximation. Differently from the standard no-sea approximation, we keep in the subtraction part while we set to be zero. After obtaining the thermodynamic potential, we solved the four gap equations for a given and to determine the four mean fields, , , and . We found that pion condensate actually occurs when is large enough. However, the existence of baryons makes the critical isospin chemical potential larger than MeV. The mechanism of this phenomenon is explained as follows: When is smaller than the neutron mass, all the energy from isospin chemical potential is used to induce pion, so that the pion condensate occurs when
. For , on the other hand, part of the energy is used to induce neutron and the pion condensate is suppressed.
We studied the dependence of phase boundary between the pion condensation phase and the normal phase. Our results showed that, for a fixed , is larger for a smaller , which is mainly caused by the dependence of the effective pion mass . We also studied the effect of the pion condensation to the Liquid-Gas coexistence curve of nuclear matter. The result shows that for a given , the critical baryon chemical potential for the Liquid-Gas phase transition becomes larger when pion condensation occurs. This is because part of the energy (chemical potential) used to induce neutron is now employed to induce pion condensate.
We compared the resultant phase boundary for the pion condensate on the phase diagram with the relation of and in the neutron star matter. Our result shows that there is a possibility of the appearance of the pion condensate in the neutron star matter for , but the density is four times of normal nuclear density. Thus we conclude that pion condensate is unlikely to occur in neutron star in the present parity doublet model.
For future work, including - mixing term is one thing valuable to do. The motivation can be explained from two perspectives. One is that adding - mixing helps to reduce the slope parameter . In current model, the slope parameter at nuclear saturation density is around . However, this values is a little large if we compared with the empirical value shown in Ref. [32]. Besides, according to Refs. [12, 13], - mixing term can soften the equation of states of neutron star. On the phase diagram, the possibility of intersection increases when EoSs shift to the left.
We can also extend our model to three-flavor nuclear matter to include hyperons and kaon condensate. In particular, a phase composed of kaon condensate and hyperon mixed baryonic matter is shown to exist in neutron star (see, e.g. Refs. [33, 34]). The phase was never studied in the parity doublet models, to our best knowledge. It is interesting to study it by extending the parity doublet model to three-flavor as done in Refs. [35, 36, 37, 38]. Additionally, it is interesting to study the effect of meson condensates to the neutron star cooling (see, e.g. Refs. [34, 39, 40]).
Acknowledgement
The work of X. Liu is financially supported by JST SPRING, Grant Number JPMJSP2125. X. Liu would also like to use the chance to thank the “Tokai Higher Education and Research System Make New Standards Program for the Next Generation Researchers”. The work of M.H. is supported in part by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Nos. 23H05439 and 24K07045. The work of B. Gao is supported by Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research No. 26K17147.
Hamiltonian
By performing the Legendre transformation from the Lagrangian in Eq. (19), the baryon contribution to the Hamiltonian is expressed as
where
From the rotational symmetry, we can take the first and second component of as zero. As a result, the explicit form of the matrix between and is expressed as
where , , , , , , , and denote
In the calculation, we devide this Hamiltonian into two 8-by-8 matrices because the energy eigenvalues of the spin up and down parts are the same. The matrix which we use is expressed as:
This is to be compared with the Hamiltonian in the vacuum given by
where , , , , , , and denote
Subtraction scheme
In this section, we explain why we adopt the current subtraction scheme by considering a one-loop contribution to the thermodynamic potential as shown in Figure 8.

Figure 8. Feynman diagram for the one-loop contribution to the thermodynamic potential. () is the positive parity neutron (proton).
In Figure 8, a proton and a neutron are coupled with each other by the vertex . We assign the zero component of momentum for the neutron as , and the one for the pion as , where and are the Matsubara frequency for Fermions and Bosons, respectively. and are effective neutron and pion chemical potentials. Accordingly, the zeroth component of the proton momentum is expressed as with satisfying .
As we can see, is explicitly included in the coefficient, which provides an intuitive reason for keeping in the subtraction part. Here, for explaining why subtraction term includes the chemical potential in a more general case, we omit the coefficient of Eq. (44). Since we are taking the mean field approximation, we set the vector component of pion momentum to be zero and the pion Matsubara frequency to be zero . Defining the energy and neglecting the coefficient, this one loop contribution is rewritten as
with . Following the standard procedure, we take the summation over the Matsubara frequency as
where
We note that, in the standard procedure where only one chemical potential exists, does not depend on the chemical potential. In the present case, on the other hand, two different chemical potentials exist, so that does include the chemical potential as shown in Eq. (47). The first and second term in Eq. (46) are the contributions from particles and antiparticles at non-zero temperature. They will disappear when we take zero-temperature limit. The third term is the contribution from finite density which is the main contribution to the thermodynamic potential. The last term is the vacuum contribution that we subtract. Here it is
In the normal phase where pion condensation does not exist and only , , and mean fields exist, no loop contribution contains both protons and neutrons; it contains only one or the other. Then, we can easily apply the no-sea approximation to subtract the vacuum contribution by simply setting the chemical potential to be zero. However, when the pion condensate exits, as we can see in Eq. (48), the difference of the two chemical potentials is explicitly included in the subtraction term. This is the reason why the subtraction term include the isospin chemical potential as in Eq. (31). We numerically checked that this subtraction actually removes the divergence.
Derivation of effective mass and chemical potential for
In this appendix, we derive the effective mass and chemical potential of pion. By using non-linear decomposition given in Eq. (6) and Eq. (8) with field replaced by , the mesonic Lagrangian is rewritten as
where . From the definition of mean field given in Eq. (14), the effective pion chemical potential is expressed as
The explicit breaking term given in Eq. (18) is rewritten as
where
References
References
- [1]G. Aarts, C. Allton, S. Hands, B. Jäger, C. Praki, and J.-I. Skullerud, Nucleons and parity doubling across the deconfinement transition, Phys. Rev. D 92, 014503 (2015), arXiv:1502.03603 [hep-lat].DOI
- [2]G. Aarts, C. Allton, D. De Boni, S. Hands, B. Jäger, C. Praki, and J.-I. Skullerud, Light baryons below and above the deconfinement transition: medium effects and parity doubling, JHEP 06, 034, arXiv:1703.09246 [hep-lat].DOI
- [3]G. Aarts, C. Allton, D. De Boni, and B. Jäger, Hyperons in thermal QCD: A lattice view, Phys. Rev. D 99, 074503 (2019), arXiv:1812.07393 [hep-lat].DOI
- [4]J. Kim and S. H. Lee, Vector meson mass in the chiral symmetry restored vacuum, Phys. Rev. D 103, L051501 (2021).DOI
- [5]J. Kim and S. H. Lee, Masses of hadrons in the chiral symmetry restored vacuum, Phys. Rev. D 105, 014014 (2022).DOI
- [6]S. H. Lee, Chiral symmetry breaking and the masses of hadrons: A review, Symmetry 15, 10.3390/sym15040799 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2303.14415
- [7]C. E. Detar and T. Kunihiro, Linear σ Model With Parity Doubling, Phys. Rev. D 39, 2805 (1989).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9959975
- [8]D. Jido, M. Oka, and A. Hosaka, Chiral symmetry of baryons, Prog. Theor. Phys. 106, 873 (2001), arXiv:hep-ph/0110005.DOI
- [9]T. Yamazaki and M. Harada, Constraint to chiral invariant masses of nucleon from GW170817 in an extended parity doublet model, Phys. Rev. C 100, 025205 (2019), arXiv:1901.02167 [nucl-th].
- [10]T. Minamikawa, T. Kojo, and M. Harada, Quark–hadron crossover equations of state for neutron stars: constraining the chiral invariant mass in a parity doublet model, Phys. Rev. C 103, 045205 (2021), arXiv:2011.13684 [nucl-th].DOI
- [11]T. Minamikawa, T. Kojo, and M. Harada, Chiral condensates for neutron stars in hadron–quark crossover: From a parity doublet nucleon model to a Nambu–Jona-Lasinio quark model, Phys. Rev. C 104, 065201 (2021), arXiv:2107.14545 [nucl-th].DOI
- [12]B. Gao, T. Minamikawa, T. Kojo, and M. Harada, Impacts of the U(1)A anomaly on nuclear and neutron star equation of state based on a parity doublet model, Phys. Rev. C 106, 065205 (2022), arXiv:2207.05970 [nucl-th].
- [13]Y. K. Kong, T. Minamikawa, and M. Harada, Neutron star matter based on a parity doublet model including the a0(980) meson, Phys. Rev. C 108, 055206 (2023), arXiv:2306.08140 [nucl-th].DOI
- [14]T. Minamikawa, B. Gao, T. Kojo, and M. Harada, Chiral Restoration of Nucleons in Neutron Star Matter: Studies Based on a Parity Doublet Model, Symmetry 15, 745 (2023), arXiv:2302.00825 [nucl-th].arxiv.org/abs/2302.00825
- [15]B. Gao, Y. Yan, and M. Harada, Reconciling constraints from the supernova remnant HESS J1731-347 with the parity doublet model, Phys. Rev. C 109, 065807 (2024), arXiv:2404.04786 [nucl-th].arxiv.org/abs/2404.04786
- [16]B. Gao, X. Liu, M. Harada, and Y.-L. Ma, Implication of neutron star observations to the origin of nucleon mass, Sci. China Phys. Mech. Astron. 69, 232011 (2026), arXiv:2508.00243 [nucl-th].arxiv.org/abs/2508.00243
- [17]R. F. Sawyer, Condensed pi- phase in neutron star matter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 29, 382 (1972).
- [18]D. J. Scalapino, Pi- condensate in dense nuclear matter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 29, 386 (1972).DOI
- [19]A. B. Migdal, Pi condensation in nuclear matter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 31, 257 (1973).
- [20]G. Baym and E. Flowers, Pion condensation in neutron star matter: Equilibrium conditions and model calculations, Nucl. Phys. A 222, 29 (1974).DOI
- [21]G. Brown and W. Weise, Pion condensates, Physics Reports 27, 1 (1976).
- [22]T. Kojo, D. Suenaga, and R. Chiba, Isospin QCD as a Laboratory for Dense QCD, Universe 10, 293 (2024), arXiv:2406.11059 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2406.11059
- [23]D. N. Voskresensky, S-wave pion condensation in symmetric nuclear matter, Phys. Rev. D 105, 116007 (2022), arXiv:2201.07536 [nucl-th].DOI
- [24]B. Fore, N. Kaiser, S. Reddy, and N. C. Warrington, Mass of charged pions in neutron-star matter, Phys. Rev. C 110, 025803 (2024), arXiv:2301.07226 [nucl-th].arxiv.org/abs/2301.07226
- [25]Y. Chen, M. Ding, D. Li, K. B. Fadafan, and M. Huang, Pion condensation and pion star from holographic qcd, Phys. Rev. D 111, 126010 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2408.17080
- [26]T. F. Motta, R. H. V. Pradineti, and G. Krein, Hyperon- induced inhomogeneous pion condensation and moat regimes in neutron star cores, Phys. Rev. D 113, 094028 (2026), arXiv:2602.23433 [nucl-th].
- [27]Y. Motohiro, Y. Kim, and M. Harada, Asymmetric nuclear matter in a parity doublet model with hidden local symmetry, Phys. Rev. C 92, 025201 (2015), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.C 95, 059903 (2017)], arXiv:1505.00988 [nucl-th].DOI
- [28]M. Bando, T. Kugo, and K. Yamawaki, Nonlinear realization and hidden local symmetries, Physics Reports 164, 217 (1988).DOI
- [29]M. Harada and K. Yamawaki, Hidden local symmetry at loop: A new perspective of composite gauge boson and chiral phase transition, Physics Reports 381, 1 (2003).DOI
- [30]D. T. Son and M. A. Stephanov, QCD at finite isospin density, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 592 (2001), arXiv:hep-ph/0005225.
- [31]H. Nishihara and M. Harada, Enhancement of Chiral Symmetry Breaking from the Pion condensation at finite isospin chemical potential in a holographic QCD model, Phys. Rev. D 89, 076001 (2014), arXiv:1401.2928 [hep-ph].DOI
- [32]B.-A. Li, B.-J. Cai, W.-J. Xie, and N.-B. Zhang, Progress in Constraining Nuclear Symmetry Energy Using Neutron Star Observables Since GW170817, Universe 7, 182 (2021), arXiv:2105.04629 [nucl-th].DOI
- [33]T. Muto, Properties of a kaon-condensed phase in hyperon-mixed matter with three-baryon forces, Phys. Rev. C 111, 045802 (2025), arXiv:2411.09967 [nucl-th].arxiv.org/abs/2411.09967
- [34]B. Bhat, A. Dohi, T. Muto, and T. Noda, Cooling of Isolated Neutron Stars with Hyperon-mixed Kaon-Condensation Matter, (2026), arXiv:2605.09723 [astro-ph.HE].arxiv.org/abs/2605.09723
- [35]B. Gao, T. Kojo, and M. Harada, Parity doublet model for baryon octets: Ground states saturated by good diquarks and the role of bad diquarks for excited states, Phys. Rev. D 110, 016016 (2024), arXiv:2403.18214 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2403.18214
- [36]T. Minamikawa, B. Gao, T. Kojo, and M. Harada, Parity doublet model for baryon octets: diquark classifications and mass hierarchy based on the quark-line diagram, (2023), arXiv:2306.15564 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2306.15564
- [37]B. Gao, Chiral symmetry restoration and hyperon suppression in neutron stars, Phys. Rev. D 113, 083012 (2026), arXiv:2602.12503 [nucl-th].arxiv.org/abs/2602.12503
- [38]B. Gao and M. Harada, A quark-diquark model for parity doublet structure of baryons, (2026), arXiv:2607.25178 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2607.25178
- [39]L. Brodie and R. D. Pisarski, Parity-Doubled Nucleons Can Rapidly Cool Neutron Stars, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 152702 (2025), arXiv:2501.02055 [nucl-th].DOI
- [40]R. Negreiros, L. Brodie, J. Steinheimer, V. Dexheimer, and R. D. Pisarski, Enhanced Neutrino Cooling from Parity-Doubled Nucleons in Neutron Star Cooling Simulations, (2026), arXiv:2603.06789 [astro-ph.HE].arxiv.org/abs/2603.06789