betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Asymptotic normalization coefficients for α+12Cα+ {}^{12}{\rm C} synthesis and the SS-factor for 12C(α, γ)16O{}^{12}{\rm C}(α, \,γ){}^{16}{\rm O} radiative capture

Abstract

The 12C(α,γ)16^{12}{\rm C}(α,γ)^{16}O reaction, determining the survival of carbon in red giants, is of interest for nuclear reaction theory and nuclear astrophysics. A specific feature of the 16^{16}O nuclear structure is the presence of two subthreshold bound states, (6.92 MeV, 2+^+) and (7.12 MeV, 1−^-), that dominate the behavior of the low-energy SS-factor. The strength of these subthreshold states is determined by their asymptotic normalization coefficients (ANCs), which need to be known with high accuracy. Recently, using a model-independent extrapolation method, Blokhintsev et al. [Eur. Phys. J. A 59 (2023) 162] determined the ANCs for the αα-particle removal taking into account three subthreshold states in 16^{16}O. The goal of this paper is to address four main problems elucidating the impact of the subthreshold ANCs on the low-energy SS-factor. Firstly, we analyse the connection between variations of the subthreshold ANCs and the low-energy SS-factor, in particular, at the most effective energy of 300300 keV. Secondly, we calculate contributions to the S(300 keV)S(300\,{\rm keV})-factor from the subthreshold 1−1^{-} and 2+2^{+} resonances, that are controlled by the subthreshold ANCs. We also evaluate the contribution of the uncertainties of the subthreshold ANCs to the budget of the low-energy SS-factor uncertainty, especially, the S(300 keV)S(300\,{\rm keV})-factor. Thirdly, we analyse interference of the subthreshold resonances (SRs) with higher resonances and with the E1E1 and E2E2 direct captures to the ground state. Finally, we investigate a correlated effect of the subthreshold and ground-state ANCs on the low-energy SS-factor and, in particular, on the S(300 keV)S(300\,{\rm keV})-factor.

Introduction

The 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C}/16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} ratio in red giant stars has been attracting substantial scientific attention for a long time [1, 2]. While 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} is formed via the triple-α\alpha fusion, 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} is the result of the 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} radiative capture reaction, which determines the survival of carbon. Numerous attempts to obtain the astrophysical factor of the 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} reaction, both experimental and theoretical, have been made for almost 50 years (see [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18] and references therein). The latest comprehensive and thorough review of the state of the art has been presented in [2].

The main goal of the research is to obtain the astrophysical SS-factor for the 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} radiative capture in the Gamow window with the most effective astrophysical α−12C\alpha-{}^{12}\mathrm{C} relative kinetic energy energy E=300E=300 keV with the accuracy <10%<10\%. However, this goal is far from being achieved because at this energy direct measurements are hardly feasible due to the extremely small cross section1. Extrapolating down the experimental data available at energies E>1E>1 MeV to the low-energy region allows one to obtain the S(300 keV)S(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factor. The most popular method of the extrapolation is the RR-matrix approach [2]. It provides a way to control contributions of different interfering mechanisms of the radiative capture and impact of different input parameters.

It is very well known (see, for example, [2, 9] and references therein) that one of the important parameters for extrapolation of the experimental data to the low-energy region and determination of the S(300 keV)S(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factor are the asymptotic normalization coefficients (ANCs) for the α+12C→16O(7.12 MeV,1−)\alpha+{}^{12}\mathrm{C}\to{}^{16}\mathrm{O}(7.12\,\mathrm{MeV},1^-) and α+12C→16O(6.92 MeV,2+)\alpha+{}^{12}\mathrm{C}\to{}^{16}\mathrm{O}(6.92\,\mathrm{MeV},2^+) syntheses leading to the formation of two subthreshold (that is, near the α+12C\alpha+{}^{12}\mathrm{C} threshold) bound states, 1−1^- and 2+2^+. The binding energies of these bound states are εs1=0.045\varepsilon_{s1}=0.045 MeV and εs2=0.2449\varepsilon_{s2}=0.2449 MeV, respectively. Since these subthreshold states are the closest levels to the low-energy region E<0.5E<0.5 MeV (the nearest 1−1^- and 2+2^+ resonances are located at 2.43 and 2.68 MeV, respectively), they govern the behavior of the low-energy SS-factor of the 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} reaction (see [2] and references therein) through the dominating E1E1 and E2E2 resonance radiative captures to the ground state of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}. Hence the uncertainties of the subthreshold ANCs should play an important role in the determination of the uncertainty of the total S(300 keV)S(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factor. There are the following important problems regarding the impact of the subthreshold ANCs on the low-energy SS-factors. First, the ANCs available in the literature vary quite significantly (see Table I below) and the question is how much the variation of the subthreshold ANCs affects the low-energy SS-factors. The second problem is the necessity to determine the contribution of the 1−1^{-} and 2+2^{+} subthreshold resonances (SRs), which are controlled by the subthreshold ANCs, to the total low-energy SS-factor, and, in particular, S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factors. Answering this question will allow us to understand the contribution of the uncertainties of the subthreshold ANCs to the budget of the uncertainty of the low-energy SS-factor, especially, the S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor. The third problem is to understand the effect of the interference of the SRs with higher resonances and direct capture for the E1E1 and E2E2 transitions. Finally, we need to understand the correlated effect of the subthreshold and ground-state ANCs on the low-energy SS-factor and, in particular, on the S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor.

A novel method was developed and employed in a sequence of papers [19, 20, 21, 22] to ascertain the ANCs through extrapolation of elastic scattering phase shifts to subthreshold bound-state poles. Specifically, in Refs. [21, 22], this technique was applied to determine the ANCs for α\alpha-particle removal from the four subthreshold states of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}: 02+0^{+}_{2}, 3−3^{-}, 2+2^{+} and 1−1^{-}. In this paper, we address all the aforementioned problems by performing comprehensive RR-matrix calculations. We use the subthreshold ANCs found by the extrapolation procedure and the ones taken from Ref. [2], together with two ground-state ANCs of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}, a low value of 58 fm−1/258\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2}[2] and a high value of 337 fm−1/2337\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2}[18]. Unless stated otherwise, we adopt the unit system where ℏ=c=1\hbar=c=1.

Methodology

Subthreshold resonances

Nuclear excited states below the particle emission threshold (subthreshold states) typically undergo γ\gamma decay to lower lying states. Besides, the presence of the subthreshold states generate a new mechanism of the radiative capture to the low lying states in which the subthreshold states exhibit themselves as SRs. Below we can give a simple explanation of the capture through the SR.

Let us consider two spinless, structureless particles in the continuum forming a bound state by emitting a photon. A very simplified, schematical equation for the amplitude corresponding to the low-energy radiative transition to the ground state is

MNR∼⟨φf∣HelL∣ψ⟩.(1)M_{NR}\sim\langle\varphi_f|\mathcal{H}_{el}^{L}|\psi\rangle. \tag*{(1)}

Here ψ\psi is the scattering wave function, φf\varphi_f is the ground bound-state wave function of the interacting particles. The electromagnetic interaction Hamiltonian HelL\mathcal{H}_{el}^{L} is associated with the transition characterized by multipolarity LL.

There are two possible approaches to calculate ψ(r)\psi(r). One of them is the two-body potential model, which allows us to simultaneously treat nonresonant, SR and resonance transitions in the given partial wave (see [23] and the references therein). However, the adopted two-body potential should reproduce simultaneously available experimental scattering phase shifts, binding energies and the corresponding ANCs, and the resonances in the given partial wave. Besides, the two-body potential model may not be good enough to treat the nuclear interior where the many-body approach is required. Also accurate accounting for interference effects continues to be a problem.

The second approach is the RR-matrix formalism, which we utilize in this paper. We underscore the advantages of the RR-matrix method:

  1. By separating different mechanisms we can explicitly single out the ANCs of the subthreshold bound state and the ground-state ANC as the normalization coefficients of the corresponding amplitudes.

  2. Another advantage is that the internal part of the SR radiative amplitude is parametrized in terms of the internal radiative width amplitude which can be calculated using the experimental radiative widths and the channel (external) counterparts or can be a fitting parameter.

  3. Finally, the RR-matrix method allows one to take into account the interference effects in a straightforward manner.

We rewrite Eq. (1) in a form convenient for the RR-matrix formalism:

MNR∼⟨φ∣HelL∣I−SO⟩,(2)M_{NR}\sim\langle\varphi|\mathcal{H}_{el}^{L}|I-SO\rangle, \tag*{(2)}

where II and OO are the incident and outgoing scattered waves in the initial channel, SS is the elastic scattering SS-matrix element. The diagram shown in Figure 1 describes the nonresonant radiative capture.

Figure 1. The diagram describing the nonresonant radiative capture 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O}. The short-dashed line represents the emitted photon.

From Eq. (2) one can obtain the radiative capture amplitude proceeding through the SR. The presence of the subthreshold bound state generates a pole in the SS-matrix element at E=−εsE=-\varepsilon_s, where εs\varepsilon_s is the binding energy of the subthreshold bound state, affecting the second term of the initial scattering wave function in Eq. (2). The impact of the subthreshold bound state on the elastic scattering SS-matrix behavior, controlled by a subthreshold pole, becomes more pronounced as the energy approaches zero:

S∼E→+0AsE+εs+iΓ(E)2(3)S \mathrel{\mathop{\sim}_{E\to+0}} \frac{A_s}{E+\varepsilon_s+i\frac{\Gamma(E)}{2}} \tag*{(3)}

The residue in the bound-state pole As∼Cs2A_s \sim C_s^2 [24], where CsC_s is the ANC of the subthreshold bound state. However, if we consider the subthreshold bound state as the SR, As∼ΓSRA_s \sim\Gamma^{SR}, where ΓSR∼Cs2\Gamma^{SR} \sim C_s^2 is the width of the SR and Γ(E)=ΓSR(E)+Γγ(E)\Gamma(E)=\Gamma^{SR}(E)+\Gamma_\gamma(E) is the total resonance width of the SR. A tiny radiative width of the SR decaying to the ground state, denoted by Γγ(E)\Gamma_\gamma(E), will be disregarded in the following discussion. Note that for energy values less than zero, ΓSR\Gamma^{SR} becomes zero due to the presence in it of the penetrability factor, causing the elastic scattering SS-matrix element to exhibit a standard pole behavior,

S∼E→−εsAsE+εs(4)S \mathrel{\mathop{\sim}_{E\to-\varepsilon_s}} \frac{A_s}{E+\varepsilon_s} \tag*{(4)}

One can see that for small binding energy εs\varepsilon_s the pole term may significantly modify the behavior of the low-energy scattering wave function generating a new mechanism of the radiative capture, namely, the radiative capture “continuum →\to the ground state” occurring at positive energies of interacting nuclei but contributed by the pole term of the SS-matrix located at the negative energy. This mechanism can be called the radiative capture to the ground state through the SR. Its amplitude can be schematically written as

MSR∼⟨ϕf∣HelL∣ΓSR(E) O⟩ΓSR(E)E+εs+iΓSR(E)2(5)M_{SR}\sim\frac{\langle\phi_f|\mathcal{H}_{el}^{L}|\sqrt{\Gamma_{SR}(E)}\,O\rangle\sqrt{\Gamma_{SR}(E)}}{E+\varepsilon_s+i\frac{\Gamma_{SR}(E)}{2}} \tag*{(5)}

and is described by the pole diagram shown in Figure 2. The diagram contains the form factor corresponding to the formation of the SR, resonance propagator and the form factor describing the radiative decay of the SR to the ground state. It has a propagator similar to the real resonance propagator with the resonance energy ER>0E_R>0 replaced by −εs-\varepsilon_s.

Figure 2. The pole diagram describing the radiative capture 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} through the SR B∗B^*. The thick black line is the resonance propagator, two black spheres are the form factors and the short-dashed line is the emitted photon.

It is now clear that in the presence of the subthreshold bound state the amplitude MNRM_{NR} can be written as the sum of two amplitudes:

MNR=MNR′+MSR,(6)M_{NR}=M'_{NR}+M_{SR}, \tag*{(6)}

where the nonresonant radiative capture amplitude MNR′M'_{NR} is given by

MNR′∼⟨ϕf∣HelL∣I−S′O⟩.(7)M'_{NR}\sim\langle\phi_f|\mathcal{H}_{el}^{L}|I-S'O\rangle. \tag*{(7)}

Here S′S' is the elastic SS-matrix element, which does not contain the bound-state pole. While the initial scattering wave function in the nonresonant radiative transition amplitude MNR′M'_{NR} contains both incident and outgoing waves, the SR amplitude MSRM_{SR} contains only the outgoing scattered wave. A distinctive trait of the RR-matrix approach is the partitioning of the radiative capture amplitude into nonresonant and SR segments. The above presented schematic introduction can help the reader to better understand the phenomena of the SRs playing a dominant role in the low-energy radiative capture 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O}.

Subthreshold resonances in the RR-matrix formalism

The main focus of this paper is to analyze the impact of the subthreshold and ground state ANCs on the low-energy SS-factor for the radiative capture 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O}. The ANC determines the normalization of the peripheral amplitudes. This is the reason we focus on the radiative captures happening in the external (channel) region (r>Rchr>R_{ch}, where RchR_{ch} is the channel radius). This is why utilizing the RR-matrix approach, which separates the configuration space into the internal and channel regions, is advantageous. In the RR-matrix formalism, the calculation of nonresonant (direct) capture to the ground state of the final nucleus only considers the external region, as the nonresonant capture in the internal region is included in the resonance capture amplitude.

There was no mention of the internal and external regions in Eqs. (2)–(7). Nonetheless, a rigorous approach dictates that the internal and channel regions be considered separately. In the RR-matrix approach the total amplitude of the radiative transition to the ground state through the SR is written as the sum of two parts, internal and channel:

MSR(E)=MSR(int)(E)+MSR(ch)(E),(8)M_{SR}(E)=M_{SR}^{(int)}(E)+M_{SR}^{(ch)}(E), \tag*{(8)}

where

MSR(int)(E)=iei(σlsc−δlsc)2(kγRch)L+1/2ΓJsSR(E)γγJ0Js(int)(E)E+εs+iΓJsSR(E)/2(9)M_{SR}^{(int)}(E)=ie^{i(\sigma_{l_s}^{c}-\delta_{l_s}^{c})}\sqrt{2}(k_\gamma R_{ch})^{L+1/2}\frac{\sqrt{\Gamma_{J_s}^{SR}(E)}\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(int)}(E)}{E+\varepsilon_s+i\Gamma_{J_s}^{SR}(E)/2} \tag*{(9)}

is the internal SR radiative transition amplitude and

MSR(ch)(E)=iei(σlsc−δlsc)2(kγRch)L+1/2ΓJsSR(E)γγJ0Js(ch)(E)E+εs+iΓJsSR(E)/2(10)M_{SR}^{(ch)}(E)=ie^{i(\sigma_{l_s}^{c}-\delta_{l_s}^{c})}\sqrt{2}(k_\gamma R_{ch})^{L+1/2}\frac{\sqrt{\Gamma_{J_s}^{SR}(E)}\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(ch)}(E)}{E+\varepsilon_s+i\Gamma_{J_s}^{SR}(E)/2} \tag*{(10)}

is the channel one. Then the total amplitude MSR(E)M_{SR}(E) is given by

MSR(E)=iei(σlsC−δlshs)2(kγRch)L+1/2ΓJsSR(E)γγJ0Js(E)E+εs+iΓJsSR(E)/2.(11)M_{SR}(E)=i e^{i(\sigma_{l_s}^{C}-\delta_{l_s}^{hs})}\sqrt{2}(k_\gamma R_{ch})^{L+1/2}\frac{\sqrt{\Gamma_{J_s}^{SR}(E)}\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E)}{E+\varepsilon_s+i\Gamma_{J_s}^{SR}(E)/2}. \tag*{(11)}

We explicitly indicated the total angular momentum of the SR JsJ_s and the total angular momentum of the ground state J0=0J_0=0. Since in the case under consideration the channel spin is zero, Js=lsJ_s=l_s, where lsl_s is the orbital angular momentum of the SR, it is enough to indicate only JsJ_s or lsl_s. Phase shift δlshs\delta_{l_s}^{hs}, determined by

e−2iδlshs=Gls(k,Rch)−iFls(k,Rch)Gls(k,Rch)+iFls(k,Rch),(12)e^{-2i\delta_{l_s}^{hs}}=\frac{G_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})-iF_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})}{G_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})+iF_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})}, \tag*{(12)}

and σlsC\sigma_{l_s}^{C} are the hard-sphere and Coulomb scattering phase shifts in the partial wave lsl_s, respectively. Functions Fls(k,r)F_{l_s}(k,r) and Gls(k,r)G_{l_s}(k,r) are the regular and irregular Coulomb solutions, ΓJsSR(E)\Gamma_{J_s}^{SR}(E) and γγJ0Js(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E) are the observable width and the reduced radiative width amplitude of the SR, respectively.

Even though the SR is situated at negative energy as a subthreshold bound state, its resonance width is specified at E>0E>0 and vanishes at E≤0E\leq0:

ΓJsSR(E)=Pls(k,Rch)[γlsSR(Rch)]2,(13)\Gamma_{J_s}^{SR}(E)=P_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})[\gamma_{l_s}^{SR}(R_{ch})]^2, \tag*{(13)}

where at E>0E>0 the penetrability factor is

Pls(k,Rch)=kRchFls2(k,Rch)+Gls2(k,Rch)(14)P_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})=\frac{kR_{ch}}{F_{l_s}^{2}(k,R_{ch})+G_{l_s}^{2}(k,R_{ch})} \tag*{(14)}
=kRch∣Ols(k,Rch)∣2,(15)=\frac{kR_{ch}}{|O_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})|^2}, \tag*{(15)}

OlsO_{l_s} is the outgoing Coulomb scattered wave2:

Ols(k,r)=e−iσlsC[Gls(k,Rch)+iFls(k,Rch)]=e−iπls/2eπηsign⁡(Re⁡k)/2W−iη,ls+1/2(−i2kr).(16)\begin{aligned} O_{l_s}(k,r)=e^{-i\sigma_{l_s}^{C}}[G_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})+iF_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})] \\ &=e^{-i\pi l_s/2}e^{\pi\eta\operatorname{sign}(\operatorname{Re}k)/2}W_{-i\eta,l_s+1/2}(-i2kr). \tag*{(16)} \end{aligned}
sign⁡(x)={1for x>0,0for x=0,−1for x<0,(17)\operatorname{sign}(x)=\begin{cases}1 & \text{for }x>0,\\0 & \text{for }x=0,\\-1 & \text{for }x<0,\end{cases} \tag*{(17)}

W−iη,ls+1/2(−i2kr)W_{-i\eta,l_s+1/2}(-i2kr) and η\eta are the Whittaker function and the Coulomb parameter for k>0k>0. In addition,

[γlsSR(Rch)]2=(ℏc)2μW−ηs,ls+1/22(2κsRch)RchCls2(18)[\gamma_{l_s}^{SR}(R_{ch})]^2=\frac{(\hbar c)^2}{\mu}\frac{W_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}^{2}(2\kappa_sR_{ch})}{R_{ch}}C_{l_s}^{2} \tag*{(18)}

is the observable reduced width of the SR, see Appendix Appendix A and Refs.[24, 26]. W−ηs,ls+1/2(2κsRch)W_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}(2\kappa_sR_{ch}) is the Whittaker function describing the radial behavior of the bound-state wave function in the external region, κs=2μεs\kappa_s=\sqrt{2\mu\varepsilon_s} is the wave number of the subthreshold bound state, μ\mu is the reduced mass of the interacting nuclei expressed in MeV, ηs\eta_s is the α−12C\alpha-{}^{12}\mathrm{C} Coulomb parameter of the subthreshold bound state, ClsC_{l_s} is the ANC of the subthreshold bound state expressed in fm−1/2\mathrm{fm}^{-1/2}. We explicitly inserted (ℏc)2(\hbar c)^2 in Eq. (18) to validate that [γlsSR(Rch)]2[\gamma_{l_s}^{SR}(R_{ch})]^2 is measured in MeV. Equation (18) clearly shows that the reduced width of the SR depends only on the ANC ClsC_{l_s} and the channel radius radius RchR_{ch}. Hence the overall normalization of ΓJsSR(E)\sqrt{\Gamma_{J_s}^{SR}(E)} is expressed in terms of the ANC of the subthreshold bound state ClsC_{l_s}.

Equation (11) illustrates that the SR is a resonance located at the negative energy of −εs-\varepsilon_s. γγJ0Js(int)(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(int)}(E) and γγJ0Js(ch)(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(ch)}(E) in Eqs. (9) and (10) are the internal and channel radiative width amplitudes of the SR with the total one

γγJ0Js(E)=γγJ0Js(int)+γγJ0Js(ch)(E).(19)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E)=\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(int)}+\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(ch)}(E). \tag*{(19)}

In the RR-matrix approach γγJ0Js(int)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(int)} is a real constant, while γγJ0Js(ch)(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(ch)}(E) is complex and energy-dependent.

An explicit expression for γγJ0Js(ch)(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(ch)}(E) is

γγJ0Js(ch)(E)=Cl0DL(E)Pls(k,Rch)γlsSR(Rch)×⟨ls0∣L0∣l00⟩U(Ll0sJs;lsJ0)Jch(E),(20)\begin{aligned} \gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(ch)}(E)=C_{l_0}\mathcal{D}_{L}(E)\sqrt{P_{l_s}(k,R_{ch})}\gamma_{l_s}^{SR}(R_{ch}) \\ &\times\langle l_s0|L0|l_00\rangle U(Ll_0sJ_s;l_sJ_0)\mathcal{J}_{ch}(E), \tag*{(20)} \end{aligned}

where

DL(E)=12E1(2L+1)!!(L+1)(2L+1)L×Zeff(L)kRch(21)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{D}_{L}(E)=\sqrt{\frac{1}{2E}\frac{1}{(2L+1)!!}}\sqrt{\frac{(L+1)(2L+1)}{L}} \\ &\times Z_{eff}(L)\sqrt{kR_{ch}} \tag*{(21)} \end{aligned}

and (in a concise form)

Jch(E)=1RchL+1∫Rch∞dr rLW−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0r)×e−iδlshsOls(k,r).(22)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{J}_{ch}(E)=\frac{1}{R_{ch}^{L+1}}\int_{R_{ch}}^{\infty}dr\,r^{L}W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0r) \\ &\times e^{-i\delta_{l_s}^{hs}}O_{l_s}(k,r). \tag*{(22)} \end{aligned}

W−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0Rch)W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0R_{ch}) is the Whittaker function describing the external radial behavior of the α−12C\alpha-{}^{12}\mathrm{C} bound-state wave function in the ground state. Subscript ss denotes the continuum state corresponding to the SR, while subscript 00 refers to the ground state of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}. l0=0l_0=0, κ0=2με0\kappa_0=\sqrt{2\mu\varepsilon_0} and ε0=7.162\varepsilon_0=7.162 MeV are the α−12C\alpha-{}^{12}\mathrm{C} orbital angular momentum, bound-state wave number and the binding energy of the 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} ground state, respectively. η0\eta_0 is the α−12C\alpha-{}^{12}\mathrm{C} Coulomb parameter of the ground bound state. The quantity

Zeff(L)=eμL(ZαmαL+(−1)LZ12Cm12CL)(23)Z_{eff}(L)=e^{\mu L}\left(\frac{Z_\alpha}{m_\alpha^{L}}+(-1)^L\frac{Z_{{}^{12}\mathrm{C}}}{m_{{}^{12}\mathrm{C}}^{L}}\right) \tag*{(23)}

is the effective charge of the system for the transition with multipolarity LL, and ee is the proton charge.

Rewriting this matrix element in terms of the regular Fls(k,r)F_{l_s}(k,r) and irregular Gls(k,r)G_{l_s}(k,r) Coulomb solutions we get [6]

Jch(E)=W−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0Rch)Fls2(k,Rch)+Gls2(k,Rch)×JLlsl0(E),(24)\mathcal{J}_{\mathrm{ch}}(E)=W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0R_{\mathrm{ch}})\sqrt{F_{l_s}^{2}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})+G_{l_s}^{2}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})}\times\mathcal{J}_{L l_s l_0}(E), \tag*{(24)}

where

JLlsl0(E)=J2Llsl0(E)+iFls(k,Rch)Gls(k,Rch)Fls2(k,Rch)+Gls2(k,Rch)J1Llsl0(E),(25)\mathcal{J}_{L l_s l_0}(E)=\mathcal{J}_{2 L l_s l_0}(E)+i\frac{F_{l_s}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})G_{l_s}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})}{F_{l_s}^{2}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})+G_{l_s}^{2}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})}\mathcal{J}_{1 L l_s l_0}(E), \tag*{(25)}
J1Llsl0(E)=1RchL+1∫Rch∞dr rLW−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0r)W−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0Rch)[Fls(k,r)Fls(k,Rch)−Gls(k,r)Gls(k,Rch)],(26)\mathcal{J}_{1 L l_s l_0}(E)=\frac{1}{R_{\mathrm{ch}}^{L+1}}\int_{R_{\mathrm{ch}}}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}r\,r^{L}\frac{W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0r)}{W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0R_{\mathrm{ch}})} \left[\frac{F_{l_s}(k,r)}{F_{l_s}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})}-\frac{G_{l_s}(k,r)}{G_{l_s}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})}\right], \tag*{(26)}

and

J2Llsl0(E)=1RchL+1∫Rch∞dr rLW−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0r)W−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0Rch)[Fls(k,r)Fls(k,Rch)+Gls(k,r)Gls(k,Rch)Fls2(k,Rch)+Gls2(k,Rch)].(27)\mathcal{J}_{2 L l_s l_0}(E)=\frac{1}{R_{\mathrm{ch}}^{L+1}}\int_{R_{\mathrm{ch}}}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}r\,r^{L}\frac{W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0r)}{W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0R_{\mathrm{ch}})} \left[\frac{F_{l_s}(k,r)F_{l_s}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})+G_{l_s}(k,r)G_{l_s}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})}{F_{l_s}^{2}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})+G_{l_s}^{2}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})}\right]. \tag*{(27)}

Then

γγJ0Js(ch)(E)=Cl0kRchDL(E)γlsSR(Rch)×⟨ls 0 L 0∣l0 0⟩U(L l0 ss Js;ls J0)×W−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0Rch)JLlsl0(E).(28)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{ch})}(E)=C_{l_0}\sqrt{kR_{\mathrm{ch}}}\mathcal{D}_{L}(E)\gamma_{l_s}^{SR}(R_{\mathrm{ch}}) \times\langle l_s\,0\,L\,0|l_0\,0\rangle U(L\,l_0\,s_s\,J_s;l_s\,J_0) \times W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0R_{\mathrm{ch}})\mathcal{J}_{L l_s l_0}(E). \tag*{(28)}

Cl0C_{l_0} is the ANC of the 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} ground state, ZiZ_i is the number of the protons in nucleus ii, kγ=E+ε0k_\gamma=E+\varepsilon_0 is the momentum of the emitted photon, k=2μEk=\sqrt{2\mu E}, ⟨ls 0 L 0∣l0 0⟩\langle l_s\,0\,L\,0|l_0\,0\rangle is the Clebsch-Gordan coefficient, U(L l0 ss Js;ls J0)U(L\,l_0\,s_s\,J_s;l_s\,J_0) is the Racah coefficient, ss=0s_s=0 is the α−12C\alpha-{}^{12}\mathrm{C} channel spin in the subthreshold state.

For the bound states JLlsl0\mathcal{J}_{L l_s l_0} is given by [6]

JLlsl0=1RchL+1∫Rch∞dr rLW−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0r)W−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0Rch)W−ηs,ls+1/2(2κsr)W−ηs,ls+1/2(2κsRch).(29)\mathcal{J}_{L l_s l_0}=\frac{1}{R_{\mathrm{ch}}^{L+1}}\int_{R_{\mathrm{ch}}}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}r\,r^{L}\frac{W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0r)}{W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0R_{\mathrm{ch}})} \frac{W_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}(2\kappa_sr)}{W_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}(2\kappa_sR_{\mathrm{ch}})}. \tag*{(29)}

The channel radiative width pertaining to the bound state is given by

γγJ0Js(ch)(−εs)=μZeff(L)Rch1(2L+1)!!(L+1)(2L+1)LCl0W−η0,l0+1/2(2κ0Rch)×⟨ls 0 L 0∣l0 0⟩U(L l0 ss Js;ls J0)γJs(Rch)JLlsl0,(30)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{ch})}(-\varepsilon_s)=\sqrt{\mu}Z_{\mathrm{eff}}(L)R_{\mathrm{ch}}\frac{1}{(2L+1)!!} \sqrt{\frac{(L+1)(2L+1)}{L}}C_{l_0}W_{-\eta_0,l_0+1/2}(2\kappa_0R_{\mathrm{ch}}) \times\langle l_s\,0\,L\,0|l_0\,0\rangle U(L\,l_0\,s_s\,J_s;l_s\,J_0)\gamma_{J_s}(R_{\mathrm{ch}})\mathcal{J}_{L l_s l_0}, \tag*{(30)}

where γJs(Rch)\gamma_{J_s}(R_{\mathrm{ch}}) is the reduced width of the subthreshold bound state, which is expressed in terms of the subthreshold ANC CJsC_{J_s}.

We see that the normalization of the channel radiative width is expressed in terms of the subthreshold ANC ClsC_{l_s} and the ANC Cl0C_{l_0} of the ground state of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}. It explains why these ANCs govern the behavior of the low-energy amplitude MSR(ch)(E)M_{SR}^{(\mathrm{ch})}(E) describing the channel resonance radiative transition to the ground state through the SR.

The radiative width of the SR is expressed in terms of γγJ0Js(ch)(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{ch})}(E) as

ΓγJ0Js(E)=2(kγRch)2L+1∣γγJ0Js(E)∣2(31)\Gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E)=2(k_\gamma R_{\mathrm{ch}})^{2L+1}\left|\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E)\right|^{2} \tag*{(31)}
=2(kγRch)2L+1∣γγJ0Js(int)+γγJ0Js(ch)(E)∣2.(32)=2(k_\gamma R_{\mathrm{ch}})^{2L+1}\left|\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{int})}+\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{ch})}(E)\right|^{2}. \tag*{(32)}

If ∣γγJ0Js(int)∣≫∣γγJ0Js(ch)(E)∣\left|\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{int})}\right|\gg\left|\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{ch})}(E)\right|, then the energy dependence of ΓγJ0Js(E)\Gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E) is determined by the dimensionless factor (kγRch)2L+1(k_\gamma R_{\mathrm{ch}})^{2L+1} and we can write

ΓγJ0Js(E)=(E+ε0ε0−εs)2L+1ΓγJ0Js(−εs).(33)\Gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E)=\left(\frac{E+\varepsilon_0}{\varepsilon_0-\varepsilon_s}\right)^{2L+1}\Gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(-\varepsilon_s). \tag*{(33)}

This equation allows one to find the radiative width ΓγJ0Js(E)\Gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E) at positive energies if (it is often the case) ΓγJ0Js(−εs)\Gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(-\varepsilon_s) is known experimentally.

We remind that γγJ0Js(ch)(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{ch})}(E) can be explicitly calculated. If its energy dependence is weak, then Eq. (33) can be a good approximation even for the nonnegligible channel part. Then, in view of Eq. (32), one can find γγJ0Js(int)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{int})}:

γγJ0Js(int)=−Re⁡γγJ0Js(ch)(E)±ΓγJ0Js(E)2(kγRch)2L+1−[Im⁡γγJ0Js(ch)(E)]2.(34)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{int})}=-\operatorname{Re}\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{ch})}(E) \pm\sqrt{\frac{\Gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E)}{2(k_\gamma R_{\mathrm{ch}})^{2L+1}}-\left[\operatorname{Im}\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{ch})}(E)\right]^2}. \tag*{(34)}

Direct radiative capture

There is another radiative process where the subthreshold bound states contribute: the cascade radiative capture to the ground state through the subthreshold bound states. It is a two-step process, which begins with the first direct radiative capture to the subthreshold bound state, which is then followed by its decay to the ground state through photon emission. The direct capture amplitude to the subthreshold state, which is the first part of the cascade transition to the ground state, is given by

MDC(s)(E)=ei(σlic−δlihs)DL(E)(kγRch)L+1/2Cls×⟨li0L0∣ls0⟩U(LlsliJi;liJs)Jls(E),(35)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{DC}(s)}(E)=e^{i(\sigma_{l_i}^{c}-\delta_{l_i}^{hs})}\mathcal{D}_{L}(E)(k_{\gamma}R_{\mathrm{ch}})^{L+1/2}C_{l_s} \times\langle l_i0L0\mid l_s0\rangle U(Ll_sl_iJ_i;l_iJ_s)\mathcal{J}_{ls}(E), \tag*{(35)}

with

Jls(E)=1RchL+1∫Rch∞dr rLW−ηs,ls+1/2(2κsr)×[e−iδlihsIli(k,r)−eiδlihsOli(k,r)].(36)\mathcal{J}_{ls}(E)=\frac{1}{R_{\mathrm{ch}}^{L+1}}\int_{R_{\mathrm{ch}}}^{\infty}dr\,r^{L}W_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}(2\kappa_sr) \times\left[e^{-i\delta_{l_i}^{hs}}I_{l_i}(k,r)-e^{i\delta_{l_i}^{hs}}O_{l_i}(k,r)\right]. \tag*{(36)}

Here lil_i is the α−12C\alpha-{}^{12}\mathrm{C} orbital angular momentum in the continuum, si=0s_i=0 is their channel spin.

Rewriting Jls(E)\mathcal{J}_{ls}(E) in terms of the regular and irregular Coulomb solutions we get [6]

Jls(E)=2iW−ηs,ls+1/2(2κsRch)Fli(k,Rch)Gli(k,Rch)Fli2(k,Rch)+Gli2(k,Rch)J1Llils(E).(37)\mathcal{J}_{ls}(E)=2iW_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}(2\kappa_sR_{\mathrm{ch}}) \frac{F_{l_i}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})G_{l_i}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})} {\sqrt{F_{l_i}^{2}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})+G_{l_i}^{2}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})}}\mathcal{J}_{1L l_i l_s}(E). \tag*{(37)}

Equation (35) clarifies why in the RR-matrix approach the overall normalization of the direct capture amplitude is determined by the ANC of the final bound state formed as the result of the direct radiative capture [25].

We explicitly showed only the amplitude of the first step of the cascade radiative capture. For the subthreshold case under consideration, the cascade transitions through (7.12 MeV, 1−1^{-}) and (6.92 MeV, 2+2^{+}) subthreshold bound states are significantly weaker than the resonant captures to the ground state when these bound states reveal themselves as the SRs (see Figure 4 below). In addition to direct capture to the subthreshold bound state, it is necessary to consider the direct “continuum to ground state” capture. The amplitude of this transition is similar to the amplitude MDC(s)(E)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{DC}(s)}(E) (see Eq. (35)) and is given by

Figure 4. All the calculated SS-factors for radiative captures to the ground state. The total SS-factor given by the sum of all the SS-factors shown in this figure.

MDC(0)(E)=ei(σlic−δlihs)DL(E)(kγRch)L+1/2C0×⟨li0L0∣l00⟩U(Ll0siJi;liJ0)Jl0(E).(38)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{DC}(0)}(E)=e^{i(\sigma_{l_i}^{c}-\delta_{l_i}^{hs})}\mathcal{D}_{L}(E)(k_{\gamma}R_{\mathrm{ch}})^{L+1/2}C_{0} \times\langle l_i0L0\mid l_00\rangle U(Ll_0s_iJ_i;l_iJ_0)\mathcal{J}_{l_0}(E). \tag*{(38)}

The formula for Jl0(E)\mathcal{J}_{l_0}(E) can be derived from Jls(E)\mathcal{J}_{ls}(E) (refer to Eq. (36)) by substituting subscript ss with 0. Note that the only unknown quantity in Eq. (38) is the ANC C0C_0 of the ground state of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}. This ANC can be positive or negative3 determining the sign of MDC(0)(E)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{DC}(0)}(E).

Resonant transition

Since the main purpose of this paper is to investigate the role of the subthreshold ANCs, we only briefly discuss the resonance capture to the ground state of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}. Equations for the resonance capture can be obtained from the corresponding equations for resonance capture through the SR by replacing s→is\to i, ϵs→ER\epsilon_s\to E_R, where ERE_R is the resonance energy4, ΓlsSR(E)→Γli(E)\Gamma_{l_s}^{\mathrm{SR}}(E)\to\Gamma_{l_i}(E) and γJ0Js(E)→γJ0Ji(E)\gamma_{J_0}^{J_s}(E)\to\gamma_{J_0}^{J_i}(E). Here ΓJi(E)\Gamma_{J_i}(E) is the resonance width, γJ0Ji(E)\gamma_{J_0}^{J_i}(E) is the resonance radiative width amplitude, which can be split into the internal and channel parts; lil_i is α−12C\alpha-{}^{12}\mathrm{C} resonance orbital angular momentum. For li=lsl_i=l_s, the resonance amplitude interferes with the SR and direct capture amplitudes. Adding higher resonances interfering with the SR requires employing the multilevel RR-matrix equations [2, 8].

For li=lsl_i=l_s the direct capture amplitude MDC(0)(E)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{DC}(0)}(E) interferes with the amplitude MSR(E)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{SR}}(E) for the resonance capture to the ground state through the SR. The sign of Eq. (28) and, hence, of MSR(E)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{SR}}(E) is controlled by the product Cl0ClsC_{l_0}C_{l_s}. If we fix the sign of the subthreshold ANC ClsC_{l_s}, then the nonresonant amplitude MDC(0)(E)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{DC}(0)}(E) and the channel resonance radiative amplitude MSR(ch)(E)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{SR}}^{(\mathrm{ch})}(E) are normalized in terms of the same ANC, C0C_0. Such a normalization is physically transparent: both amplitudes describe peripheral processes and, hence, contain the tail of the nuclear overlap function of the ground state, whose normalization is given by the corresponding ANC.

For the interfering direct capture to the ground state and the resonance capture to the ground state through the SR, it is convenient to write the sum of the interfering amplitudes as

MSR(E)+MDC(0)(E)=[MSR(ch)(E)+MDC(0)(E)]+MSR(int)(E).(39)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{SR}}(E)+\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{DC}(0)}(E) =\left[\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{SR}}^{(\mathrm{ch})}(E)+\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{DC}(0)}(E)\right] +\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{SR}}^{(\mathrm{int})}(E). \tag*{(39)}

The relative sign of the sum in the brackets is well determined, while the sign of MSR(int)(E)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{SR}}^{(\mathrm{int})}(E), which contains γJ0Js(int)\gamma_{J_0}^{J_s}{}^{(\mathrm{int})}, is the fitting parameter.

The equations in this section shed light on the reason behind the extensive effort dedicated to determining the ANCs of the α\alpha-particle removal from the subthreshold bound states of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} (see [2]). The different experimental and theoretical methods of determining the ANCs are discussed in [25].

ANC of the ground state of 16^{16}O

Here we discuss the impact of the ground state ANC Cl0C_{l_0}. This ANC enters the channel radiative widths of the SR and the resonance, cascade transition and direct capture amplitudes to the ground state. Owing to the large binding energy of the ground state of the system α+12C\alpha+ {}^{12}\mathrm{C} (ε0=7.16\varepsilon_0 = 7.16 MeV), the internal part of the radiative width of the SR γγJ0Js(int)(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{int})}(E) and the resonance internal radiative width γγJ0Ji(int)(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_i(\mathrm{int})}(E) are dominant compared to the corresponding channel ones containing Cl0C_{l0}. Besides, for the E1E1 transition the channel part is suppressed because the effective charge Zeff(1)Z_{\mathrm{eff}}(1) is very small (Zeff(1)/e=−0.00097Z_{\mathrm{eff}}(1)/e = -0.00097). It significantly diminishes the role of the channel radiative widths. For the same reason, the E1E1 direct capture to the ground state is suppressed. The numerical evidence provided below indicates that the ground-state ANC has no influence on the E1E1 S(300 keV)S(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factor at low energies.

Also the cascade transitions to the ground state are small compared to the SR and resonance transitions. It makes the impact of the ground-state ANC less important than that of the ANCs of the subthreshold states 1−1^- and 2+2^+, but not negligible due to the interference of the 2+2^+ SR, resonance and the direct transition to the ground state. The role of Cl0C_{l0} on the low-energy SS-factor, especially, S(300 keV)S(300\,\mathrm{keV}), is analyzed through numerical calculations below. Two sets of subthreshold ANCs from the low end [2] and high end [22] are used in this paper for systematic comparison. The latter set was determined using the extrapolation procedure of the elastic scattering phase shifts. However, the ground-state ANC was not determined using the extrapolation method because it is located quite far from the threshold (the binding energy of the α\alpha-particle in the 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} ground state is 7.16 MeV). The values of the ground-state ANC published in the literature vary significantly [18]. In this paper, we explore two values of this ANC: 58 fm−1/2^{-1/2} [2] and 337 fm−1/2^{-1/2} [18]. The ground-state ANC of 337±45337 \pm45 fm−1/2^{-1/2} found in [18] from the heavy-ion induced transfer reaction requires a higher value of (1.55±0.09)×105(1.55 \pm0.09) \times10^5 fm−1/2^{-1/2} for the ANC of the (2+,6.92 MeV)(2^+, 6.92\,\mathrm{MeV}) excited state to reconcile with the SS-factor from [2] calculated for the ground-state ANC of 58 fm−1/2^{-1/2}. This value of the 2+2^+ subthreshold ANC is close but slightly higher than the ANC for the 6.92 MeV state from [22] (see Table I).

Subthreshold ANCs

One of the main goals of this paper is to check the impact of the ANCs of the α\alpha-particle removal from the subthreshold states 1−1^- and 2+2^+ of 16O∗{}^{16}\mathrm{O}^*. The ANCs of these subthreshold bound states available in the literature have been recently tabulated in Ref. [2]. This revealed large discrepancies between the ANCs determined by different techniques, suggesting further efforts are needed to pinpoint the ANCs of the two near-threshold bound states in 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}. The ANC values for the channels 16O∗→α+12C{}^{16}\mathrm{O}^* \to\alpha+ {}^{12}\mathrm{C} obtained by various methods are also compared in Table I.

It is not the goal of this paper to verify the reliability and uncertainty of each subthreshold ANC published in the literature. In order to assess the effects of the subthreshold ANCs, as previously mentioned, we will be analyzing two sets: one represents the lower end of the published subthreshold ANCs and is taken from [2], while the second set representing the high-end of the subthreshold ANCs was reported recently (the last two rows in Table I, which are taken from [21] and [22]).

The ANCs obtained in [21] and [22] were obtained by the extrapolation of the experimental phase shifts in the corresponding partial waves to the subthreshold bound-state poles located at negative energies. Unfortunately, uncertainties of the experimental phase shifts are unknown. Therefore, in this paper, in order to estimate uncertainties of the ANCs obtained by the extrapolation method we assumed 5% uncertainty in the experimental phase shifts.

To be consistent we included in our calculations all four subthreshold states in 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O}, although we understand that only 1−1^- and 2+2^+ give the dominant contribution. Note that the uncertainty of the ANC for the 02+0_2^+ state determined by applying the extrapolation method is significantly higher than for the three weaker bound subthreshold states presented in Table I. The reason is that the farther the threshold state from the pole that corresponds to the bound state in the energy plane, the lower is the accuracy of the ANC obtained by the extrapolation of the elastic-scattering phase shifts to the corresponding bound-state pole.

Radiative width amplitudes of the subthreshold resonances 1−1^- and 2+2^+

The amplitudes MSR(E)M_{\mathrm{SR}}(E) of the radiative capture 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} through the 1−1^- and 2+2^+ SRs give the dominant contribution to the low-energy SS-factors. These amplitudes depend on the resonance widths of SRs ΓJsSR(E)\Gamma_{J_s}^{\mathrm{SR}}(E), which can be calculated explicitly, and the radiative width amplitudes γγJ0Js(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s}(E) of the SRs. Before presenting the results of the low-energy SS-factor calculations, we will review the SR radiative widths amplitudes.

Subthreshold resonance 1−1^-

First, we consider the radiative width amplitude for the SR 1−1^-. Owing to the fact the ratio Zi/miZ_i/m_i for the α\alpha-particle and 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} is practically the same, the effective charge for the L=1L=1 transition is very small and the channel radiative width amplitude γγJ0Js(ch)(E)\gamma_{\gamma J_0}^{J_s(\mathrm{ch})}(E) should be negligible compared to the internal counterpart.3 Table II are shown the low-energy dependences of the channel and internal radiative width amplitudes for the SR 1−1^-. Just as anticipated, the inner component is unchanging. We can see that the internal part is significantly larger than the channel part, leading to the validity of Eq. (33). The experimental value of the radiative width of the subthreshold bound state 1−1^- decaying to the ground state is Γγ01(−0.045 MeV)=(5.5±0.3)×10−8\Gamma_{\gamma0}^{1}(-0.045\ \mathrm{MeV})=(5.5\pm0.3)\times10^{-8} MeV [34]. Hence the internal radiative width amplitude can be calculated using Eqs. (33) and (34). A 6% experimental uncertainty of Γγ01(−0.045 MeV)\Gamma_{\gamma0}^{1}(-0.045\ \mathrm{MeV}) propagates into the 3% uncertainty of γγ01(int)\gamma_{\gamma0}^{1}(int). γγ01(p)(int)\gamma_{\gamma0}^{1(p)}(int) (γγ01(m)(int)\gamma_{\gamma0}^{1(m)}(int)) in Table II corresponds to the higher (lower) solution of Eq. (34). For practical calculations we use γγ01(p)(int)=(1.46±0.05)×10−3 MeV1/2\gamma_{\gamma0}^{1(p)}(int)=(1.46\pm0.05)\times10^{-3}\ \mathrm{MeV}^{1/2}. It should be noted that even for the high subthreshold ANC (the last row of Table I) and the high ground-state ANC of 337 fm−1/2^{-1/2} [18] the channel radiative width amplitude γγ01(ch)(300 keV)=2.06×10−7+i 3.15×10−17 MeV1/2\gamma_{\gamma0}^{1(ch)}(300\ \mathrm{keV})=2.06\times10^{-7}+i\ 3.15\times10^{-17}\ \mathrm{MeV}^{1/2} remains negligible compared to the internal counterpart, which does not depend on the ANCs.

C0C_0; Jπ=0+J^\pi=0^+<br>ε=1.113\varepsilon=1.113 MeVC3C_3; Jπ=3−J^\pi=3^-<br>ε=1.032\varepsilon=1.032 MeVC2C_2; Jπ=2+J^\pi=2^+<br>ε=0.245\varepsilon=0.245 MeVC1C_1; Jπ=1−J^\pi=1^-<br>ε=0.045\varepsilon=0.045 MeVReferences
--(1.11±0.10)×105(1.11\pm0.10)\times10^5(2.08±0.19)×1014(2.08\pm0.19)\times10^{14}[9]
--(1.40±0.42)×105(1.40\pm0.42)\times10^5(1.87±0.32)×1014(1.87\pm0.32)\times10^{14}[12]
--(1.44±0.26)×105(1.44\pm0.26)\times10^5(2.00±0.69)×1014(2.00\pm0.69)\times10^{14}[27]
(1.56±0.09)×103(1.56\pm0.09)\times10^3(1.39±0.08)×102(1.39\pm0.08)\times10^2(1.22±0.06)×105(1.22\pm0.06)\times10^5(2.10±0.14)×1014(2.10\pm0.14)\times10^{14}[17]
--0.213×1050.213\times10^51.03×10141.03\times10^{14}[28]
0.4057×1030.4057\times10^3-0.505×1050.505\times10^52.073×10142.073\times10^{14}[29]
--(1.10–1.31)×105(1.10\text{--}1.31)\times10^52.21(0.07)×10142.21(0.07)\times10^{14}[30]
(0.64–0.74)×103(0.64\text{--}0.74)\times10^3(1.2–1.5)×102(1.2\text{--}1.5)\times10^2(0.21–0.24)×105(0.21\text{--}0.24)\times10^5(1.6–1.9)×1014(1.6\text{--}1.9)\times10^{14}[31]
0.293×1030.293\times10^3---[32]
1.34×1031.34\times10^31.22×1021.22\times10^2(0.98–1.07)×105(0.98\text{--}1.07)\times10^5(1.83–1.84)×1014(1.83\text{--}1.84)\times10^{14}[33]
1.56×1031.56\times10^31.39×1021.39\times10^21.14×1051.14\times10^52.08×10142.08\times10^{14}[2]
(0.886–1.139)×103(0.886\text{--}1.139)\times10^3---[21]
-(2.17±0.05)×102(2.17\pm0.05)\times10^2(1.42±0.05)×105(1.42\pm0.05)\times10^5(2.27±0.02)×1014(2.27\pm0.02)\times10^{14}[22]

Table 1. ANC ClC_l values in fm−1/2^{-1/2} for 16O∗(Jπ)→α+12C^{16}\mathrm{O}^*(J^\pi)\to\alpha+^{12}\mathrm{C}(g.s.).

nuclei the isospin projection T3=0T_3=0 and the isospin selection rule requires change of the isospin of the system by one. Since it is not fulfilled in our case, the considered E1 transition 1−→0+1^-\to0^+ is called isospin forbidden [35, 36]. However, the suppression is not very strict because of the mass difference between the protons and neutrons and the residual Coulomb effects.

EE (MeV)γγ01(ch)(E)\gamma_{\gamma0}^{1(ch)}(E) (MeV1/2^{1/2})γγ01(m)(int)\gamma_{\gamma0}^{1(m)}(int) (MeV1/2^{1/2})γγ01(p)(int)\gamma_{\gamma0}^{1(p)}(int) (MeV1/2^{1/2})
0.13.20×10−8+i 7.16×10−303.20\times10^{-8}+i\ 7.16\times10^{-30}−0.00146-0.001460.001460.00146
0.23.22×10−8+i 1.2×10−213.22\times10^{-8}+i\ 1.2\times10^{-21}−0.00146-0.001460.001460.00146
0.33.25×10−8+i 4.97×10−183.25\times10^{-8}+i\ 4.97\times10^{-18}−0.00146-0.001460.001460.00146
0.43.28×10−8+i 6.75×10−163.28\times10^{-8}+i\ 6.75\times10^{-16}−0.00146-0.001460.001460.00146
0.53.32×10−8+i 1.85×10−143.32\times10^{-8}+i\ 1.85\times10^{-14}−0.00146-0.001460.001460.00146

Table 2. Channel and internal radiaitive width amplitudes for the SR 1−1^-.

Subthreshold resonance 2+2^+

Although for L=2L=2 the effective charge is not small, due to the high binding energy of the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, γγ02(ch)\gamma_{\gamma0}^{2(ch)} is significantly smaller than γγ02(int)\gamma_{\gamma0}^{2(int)}, see Table III. Hence Eq. (33) is also applicable for L=2L=2. The experimental value of the radiative width of the subthreshold bound state 2+2^+ decaying to the ground state is Γγ02(−0.245 MeV)=(9.7±0.3)×10−8\Gamma_{\gamma0}^{2}(-0.245\ \mathrm{MeV})=(9.7\pm0.3)\times10^{-8} MeV [34]. Again, as it was for the 1−1^- subthreshold state, Eqs. (33) and (34) are used to calculate the internal radiative width amplitudes (notations are the same as in Table II). A 3% uncertainty of Γγ02(−0.245 MeV)\Gamma_{\gamma0}^{2}(-0.245\ \mathrm{MeV}) propagates to 1.5% uncertainty of γγ02(int)\gamma_{\gamma0}^{2}(int). For calculations we use γγ02(p)(int)=0.0089±0.0001 MeV1/2\gamma_{\gamma0}^{2(p)}(int)=0.0089\pm0.0001\ \mathrm{MeV}^{1/2}. It should be underscored that for the high subthreshold ANC for the 2+2^+ state (the last row of Table I) and the high ground-state ANC of 337 fm−1/2^{-1/2} [18] the channel radiative width amplitude γγ02(ch)(300 keV)=1.63×10−3+i 6.67×10−14 MeV1/2\gamma_{\gamma0}^{2(ch)}(300\ \mathrm{keV})=1.63\times10^{-3}+i\ 6.67\times10^{-14}\ \mathrm{MeV}^{1/2} remains small but not negligible compared to the internal counterpart.

EE (MeV)γ02(ch)(E)\gamma_0^{2(\mathrm{ch})}(E) (MeV1/2^{1/2})γ02(int)(E)\gamma_0^{2(\mathrm{int})}(E) (MeV1/2^{1/2})γ01(int)\gamma_0^{1(\mathrm{int})} (MeV1/2^{1/2})
0.11.5×10−5+i 8.13×10−281.5 \times10^{-5} + i\,8.13 \times10^{-28}−0.0089-0.00890.00890.0089
0.21.5×10−5+i 1.43×10−191.5 \times10^{-5} + i\,1.43 \times10^{-19}−0.0089-0.00890.00890.0089
0.31.5×10−5+i 6.19×10−161.5 \times10^{-5} + i\,6.19 \times10^{-16}−0.0089-0.00890.00890.0089
0.41.5×10−5+i 8.81×10−141.5 \times10^{-5} + i\,8.81 \times10^{-14}−0.0089-0.00890.00890.0089
0.51.5×10−5+i 2.53×10−121.5 \times10^{-5} + i\,2.53 \times10^{-12}−0.0089-0.00890.00890.0089

Table 3. Channel and internal radiative width amplitudes for the SR 2+2^+.

S-factors for 12C(α,γ)16O^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma)^{16}\mathrm{O} radiative capture to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}

S-factors for resonance E1E1 and E2E2 captures to the ground state

First we present the results of the calculations for two dominant low-energy SS-factors corresponding to the resonance E1E1 and E2E2 transitions to the ground state. The resonance E1E1 transition is made of contributions from the SR (7.12 MeV, 1−1^-), the first above the threshold resonance (9.59 MeV, 1−1^-), and higher 1−1^- resonances. Similarly, the resonance E2E2 transition is dominated by the SR (6.92 MeV, 2+2^+), the lowest above-threshold resonance (9.85 MeV, 2+2^+) and higher 2+2^+ resonances.

Although below for convenience we show the SS-factors for the radiative capture 12C(α,γ)16O^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma)^{16}\mathrm{O} for energies E<3E < 3 MeV, our main focus is the low-energy region E<1E < 1 MeV, and especially the most effective astrophysical energy E=300E = 300 keV, at which we can check the impact of the subthreshold ANCs on the S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factors. We compare the SS-factors calculated using the central values of the ANCs in the last row of Table I with the results from the review [2]. In this energy region it is enough to take into account the two lowest levels (the SR and the lowest resonance at E>0E > 0) in addition to background resonances for the E1E1 and E2E2 resonance transitions. Details and parameters used in the calculations are given in [2].

Thus the resonance E1E1 and E2E2 SS-factors depicted in Figure 3 are calculated for the subthreshold ANCs 2.08×1014 fm−1/22.08 \times10^{14}\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} (for the (7.12 MeV, 1−1^-)) and 1.14×105 fm−1/21.14 \times10^{5}\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} (for the (6.92 MeV, 2+2^+)) from [2], which are compared with the higher sets of the ANCs, 2.27×1014 fm−1/22.27 \times10^{14}\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} and 1.42×105 fm−1/21.42 \times10^{5}\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} [22] (the last row of Table I). It can be seen that as the values of the subthreshold ANCs increase, both E1E1 and E2E2 SS-factors exhibit an increase. The exact values of the calculated resonance E1E1 and E2E2 SS-factors at 300 keV are given in Table IV.

Figure 3. The SS-factors for the 12C(α,γ)16O^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma)^{16}\mathrm{O} radiative capture reaction to the ground state through the 1−1^- and 2+2^+ resonances.

We need to add some additional comments about the calculation of the E1E1 and E2E2 resonance captures to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}. Precisely speaking, we accounted for the interference of the E1E1 and E2E2 resonance captures to the ground state with the E1E1 and E2E2 direct captures to the ground state. Shown in Figure 3 E1E1 and E2E2 SS-factors include all the transitions to the ground state except for the cascade transitions, which are discussed in subsection III B. In the calculations shown in Figure 3 we adopted a low value of the ground-state ANC C0=58 fm−1/2C_0 = 58\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} taken from [2], because our goal was to compare with the results from [2] by varying only the subthreshold ANCs.

Radiative capture to subthreshold states and the total SS-factor for 12C(α,γ)16O^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma)^{16}\mathrm{O} radiative capture

Besides the E1E1 and E2E2 resonance captures to the ground state, we also calculated the cascade transitions to the ground state through the four excited bound states (6.05 MeV, 0+0^+), (6.13 MeV, 3−3^-), (6.92 MeV, 2+2^+) and (7.12 MeV, 1−1^-) using the ANCs from the last two rows of Table I. The cascade transitions to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} represent two-step processes: the direct capture to one of the excited states is followed by the radiative decay of the excited bound state to the ground state. The ANCs of the four subthreshold bound states under consideration govern the normalization of the direct capture amplitudes.

Figure 4 depicts all the SS-factors calculated using the ANCs obtained by the extrapolation procedure. In this figure we show not only the SS-factors for the cascade transition through the four excited states of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} but also the SS factors for the E1E1 and E2E2 resonance captures to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} (see Figure 3) and the total SS-factor, which is the sum of all six SS-factors shown in Figure 4.

Correlation between the subthreshold ANCs and the total E1 and E2 S-factors

The results of the comparison of the SS-factors from the current paper and the ones from [2] are presented in Table IV. The difference between them is caused by variation of only one parameter, the ANC of the corresponding subthreshold state. It is evident that the rise in subthreshold state ANCs leads to an increase in the E1E1 and E2E2 S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factors.

Transition to the ground state via resonance + direct captureS(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV}) PresentS(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV}) Ref. [2]
E1E19885
E2E27045
E1+E2E1 + E2168130
cascadePresentRef. [2]
02++3−+2++1−0^{+}_{2} + 3^{-} + 2^{+} + 1^{-}67
totalPresentRef. [2]
E1+E2+E1 + E2 + cascade174137

Table 4. Comparison of the current SS-factors and the SS-factors from [2] for transition to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} at the most effective astrophysical energy of 300 keV. The resonance E1E1 and E2E2 transitions include interference with the direct E1E1 and E2E2 captures to the ground state. The cascade transition is the radiative capture to the ground state proceeding through four subthreshold bound states of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}: 02+0^{+}_{2}, 3−3^{-}, 2+2^{+} and 1−1^{-}. We remind that all the calculations were done for the low ground-state ANC of 58 fm−1/2\mathrm{fm}^{-1/2}. The SS-factors are given in units of keVb.

Table V shows the correlation between the variations of the ANCs of the subthreshold bound states causing the corresponding variations S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factors. In this table ΔCl2=Cl(pr)2/Cl(RMP)2−1\Delta C_{l}^{2} = C_{l(pr)}^{2}/C_{l(RMP)}^{2} - 1 and ΔS(300 keV)=Spr(300 keV)/SRMP(300 keV)−1\Delta S(300\ \mathrm{keV}) = S_{pr}(300\ \mathrm{keV})/S_{RMP}(300\ \mathrm{keV}) - 1. Quantities with the subscript ”pr” are calculated using the present ANCs and those with the subscript ”RMP” use ANCs from [2]. We observe around 79% correlation between the uncertainties of the ANC for the 1−1^{-} subthreshold state and of the total SE1(300 keV)S_{E1}(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor for the E1E1 transition to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}. An additional contribution to the E1E1 transition may come from interference between the 1−1^{-} SR with the higher broad (EX=9.59 MeVE_{X} = 9.59\ \mathrm{MeV}; 1−1^{-}) MeV resonance and the direct capture to the ground state.5 Thus, a 5% uncertainty of the subthreshold ANC C1C_{1} generates about 4% uncertainty of the total E1 S(300 keV)E1\ S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor. As previously discussed, the E1 SE1(300 keV)E1\ S_{E1}(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor is independent of the ground-state ANC, as illustrated in Table VI below. Hence the interference of the E1E1 SR occurs only with the broad 9.59 MeV resonance.

Fig.SE1+E2S_{E1+E2}SE1S_{E1}SE2S_{E2}SE1(SR)S_{E1}^{(\mathrm{SR})}SE2(SR)S_{E2}^{(\mathrm{SR})}SE1(SR)/SE1S_{E1}^{(\mathrm{SR})}/S_{E1}SE2(SR)/SE2S_{E2}^{(\mathrm{SR})}/S_{E2}
5130854560460.711.02
6168987072720.741.03
7155995672720.731.29

Table VI. TABLE VI. The S(300 keV)S(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factors (expressed in keVb) for the radiative capture 12C(α,γ)16O^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma)^{16}\mathrm{O} presented in Figure 5, Figure 6 and Figure 7. The first column pertains to the figure displaying the relevant results. SE1S_{E1} and SE2S_{E2} are the total SS-factors for the E1E1 and E2E2 transitions, SE1+E2=SE1+SE2S_{E1+E2}=S_{E1}+S_{E2}. SE1(SR)S_{E1}^{(\mathrm{SR})} and SE2(SR)S_{E2}^{(\mathrm{SR})} are the S(300 keV)S(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factors for the resonance E1E1 and E2E2 transitions through the SRs 1−1^- and 2+2^+ only. SE1(SR)/SE1S_{E1}^{(\mathrm{SR})}/S_{E1} and SE2(SR)/SE2S_{E2}^{(\mathrm{SR})}/S_{E2} are the ratios of the corresponding SS-factors.

TransitionsΔCl2\Delta C_{l}^{2}, %ΔS(300 keV)\Delta S(300\ \mathrm{keV}), %
E1E11915
E2E25556
E1+E2E1 + E229

Table 5. Correlation between the uncertainties of squares of ANCs and the S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factors.

For the E2E2 transition we get almost 100% correlation between the subthreshold ANC for the subthreshold 2+2^{+} state and the SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor for the E2E2 transition to the ground state. We can conclude that at low ground-state ANC of 58 fm−1/2\mathrm{fm}^{-1/2}, the interference effect of the subthreshold 2+2^{+} resonance with higher resonance and the direct capture amplitudes is negligible. Hence, when other parameters are fixed, the uncertainty of the subthreshold ANC for the 2+2^{+} state almost completely propagates into the uncertainty of the SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\ \mathrm{keV}) for the E2E2 radiative captures to the ground state. Accordingly, for the low ground-state ANC, a 5% uncertainty of the subthreshold ANC C2C_{2} generates about 5% uncertainty in the total SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor.

Low-energy SS-factors for resonance capture to the ground state through subthreshold resonances

Contribution of the subthreshold 1− and 2+ resonances

While the importance of subthreshold ANCs in the analysis of the 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} reaction was acknowledged and large amount of the literature on this subject has been published (see [2] and references therein), the precise contribution of the SRs had not been determined previously. From Table V we can already draw some preliminary conclusions about contribution of the pure SRs into the total S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor. Below we present the calculations of the low-energy SS-factors for the E1E1 and E2E2 transitions through the subthreshold 1−1^- and 2+2^+ resonances for capture to the ground state. No other mechanisms are included. It allows us to evaluate numerically the contribution of the SRs to the total low-energy SS-factor, and, in particular, S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factors. We then can determine the role of the subthreshold ANCs and show the necessity to decrease their uncertainties to improve the uncertainty of the total S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor.

Figure 5-Figure 7 depict the results of the calculations. In Figure 5 we use the low ANCs from [2] (see Table I) including the ground-state ANC C0=58 fm−1/2C_0 = 58\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2}. In Figure 6 the ground-state ANC remains low (the same as in Figure 5), while the subthreshold ANCs are higher than in Figure 5 (the last row of Table I). In Figure 7 we use higher subthreshold ANCs (as in Figure 6) and higher the ground-state ANC, which is taken from [18]: C0=337 fm−1/2C_0 = 337\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2}.

Figure 5. The low-energy SS-factors for the 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} reaction calculated using all the subthreshold and ground-state ANCs from [2] (see Table I).

Figure 6. The low-energy SS-factors for the 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} reaction calculated using the ground-state ANC C0(0.0 MeV)=58 fm−1/2C_0(0.0\ \mathrm{MeV}) = 58\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} [2], while all other ANCs are taken from the last two rows of Table I.

Figure 7. The low-energy SS-factors for the 12C(α,γ)16O{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma){}^{16}\mathrm{O} reaction calculated for the ground-state ANC C0(0.0 MeV)=337 fm−1/2C_0(0.0\ \mathrm{MeV}) = 337\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} [18]. All other the ANCs are taken from the last two rows of Table I.

One can see that the E1E1 and E2E2 subthreshold 1−1^- and 2+2^+ resonance transitions to the ground state of 16O{}^{16}\mathrm{O} give

the dominant contribution to the total low-energy SS-factor confirming a pivotal role of the subthreshold ANCs in the calculation of the low-energy SS-factor.

The SS-factors depicted in Figure 5 and Figure 6 show very similar behavior near the energy of 300 keV: the SS-factors SE1(SR)(E)S_{E1}^{(SR)}(E) for the E1E1 transition to the ground state proceeding through the 1−1^- SR are slightly lower than the total E1E1 SS-factor SE1(E)S_{E1}(E). It agrees with our findings about correlation between the ANC of the subthreshold state 1−1^- and the total SE1(E)S_{E1}(E)-factor presented in Table V. However, according to Figure 5 and Figure 6, as well as Table VI, it is evident that the value of SE1(SR)(300 keV)S_{E1}^{(SR)}(300\ \mathrm{keV}) rises as the subthreshold ANC for the 1−1^- state increases.

The SE2(SR)(300 keV)S_{E2}^{(\mathrm{SR})}(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factor for the radiative capture through the SR 2+2^+ exceeds the total SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factor only by 3%. It means that we observe a small destructive interference of the amplitude for the E2E2 transition to the ground state through the SR 2+2^+ with the higher broad 2+2^+ resonances and the direct capture amplitudes.

Figure 7 displays the results obtained using the higher subthreshold ANCs (the last two rows in Table I) and the higher ground-state ANC of 337 fm−1/2\mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} [18]. One can see that the behavior of the SE1(SR)(E)S_{E1}^{(\mathrm{SR})}(E)-factor is very similar to the one from previous figures proving that this SS-factor practically does not depend on the ground-state ANC. The independence of the SE1(E)S_{E1}(E)-factor on the ground-state ANC follows from a simple fact that this dependence can come only from the channel radiative transition amplitude MSR(ch)(E)M_{\mathrm{SR}}^{(\mathrm{ch})}(E) of the SR 1−1^- and direct capture amplitude. However, both contain almost vanishing effective charge, which suppresses the contribution of both amplitudes.

The same is true for the SR SE2(SR)(300 keV)S_{E2}^{(\mathrm{SR})}(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factor for the E2E2 transition, which is not sensitive to the ground-state ANC. Still, the total SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factor shows a noticeable decrease as the ground-state ANC increases. It means that for the E2E2 transition we observe the destructive interference of the capture through the SR with the direct transition, which depends on the ground-state ANC. For the small ground-state ANC of 58 fm−1/2\mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} this interference is very small but it becomes significant for the higher ground-state ANC.

The numerical results of the calculations presented in Figure 5–Figure 7 are summarized in Table VI. We see that increase of the subthreshold ANCs increases SE1(SR)(300 keV)S_{E1}^{(\mathrm{SR})}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) and SE2(SR)(300 keV)S_{E2}^{(\mathrm{SR})}(300\,\mathrm{keV}). However, the contribution of the SE1(SR)(300 keV)S_{E1}^{(\mathrm{SR})}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) (7th column) to the budget of the total SE1(300 keV)S_{E1}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) changes very little, 71–74% and does not depend on the ground-state ANC.

The SE2(SR)(300 keV)S_{E2}^{(\mathrm{SR})}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) also does not depend on the ground-state ANC because the channel radiative width amplitude for the E2E2 transition is very small. But the total SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) depends on the ground-state ANC due to the destructive interference of the E2E2 SR amplitude with the direct capture amplitude to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}. It results in decrease of the SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) compared to the SE2(SR)(300 keV)S_{E2}^{(\mathrm{SR})}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) (8-th column in Table VI).

threshold 1−1^- and 2+2^+ ANCs from [22] (see also Table I), which include the interference of the resonances and direct captures, resulted in SE1(300 keV)=99S_{E1}(300\,\mathrm{keV})=99 keVb and SE2(300 keV)=56S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV})=56 keVb.

Our findings indicate that a notable rise in the ground-state ANC of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} has a minimal impact on the astrophysical SE1(300 keV)S_{E1}(300\,\mathrm{keV})-factor (compare the last two rows in column SE1S_{E1} of Table VI). However, it does lead to a 20% reduction of the SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) value compared with the SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) obtained for the lower ground-state ANC (compare the last two rows in column SE2S_{E2} of Table VI).

Meanwhile, the uptick in the subthreshold ANCs boosts both SE1(300 keV)S_{E1}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) and SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) values. Therefore, we can infer that the concurrent increase of the subthreshold and ground-state ANCs leads to a boost of the SE1(300 keV)S_{E1}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) and SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV}) values mitigated by a reduction of the latter at higher ground-state ANC. From Table VI we can see that the total SS-factor S(300 keV)=130S(300\,\mathrm{keV})=130 keVb calculated for low subthreshold and the ground-state ANCs elevates to 168 keVb for higher subthreshold ANCs and low ground-state ANC, but it decreases to 155 keVb for the higher subthreshold and ground-state ANCs.

Hence our calculations confirm a correlation between the ground-state ANC of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} and the ANC of the subthreshold 2+2^+ state, in agreement with [18]. From this perspective, taking into account the results from [2] and adopting the ANC for the 2+2^+ state from [22], we can assume that the ground-state ANC of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, which fits the SS-factor from [2], should be less than 337 fm−1/2\mathrm{fm}^{-1/2}.

Finally, we would like to point out that one of the main uncertainties of the ground-state ANC from [18], which we use in this paper, stems from the uncertainty of the ANC for 11B→α+7Li^{11}\mathrm{B}\rightarrow\alpha+{}^{7}\mathrm{Li}, which was not properly discussed in [18]. That is why at this stage, due to the lack of reliable ANC for the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, we cannot provide the total uncertainty of the ground-state ANC of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} extracted in [18].

Figure 8.

Figure 8 shows the total SS-factors contributed by the sum of the E1+E2E1+E2 resonance transitions to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} (including the interference with the direct

Impact of the ground-state ANC

Here, we revisit the role of the ground-state ANC once again. In this paper we employed two ground-state ANCs, 58 fm−1/2\mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} [2] and 337 fm−1/2\mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} [18].

As we mentioned above, for the low ground-state ANC the interference of the resonance E1E1 and E2E2 transitions with the direct captures to the ground state is small. The present calculations of the E1E1 and E2E2 transitions with the ground-state ANC of 337 fm−1/2\mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} and the subthreshold 1−1^- and 2+2^+ ANCs from [22] (see also Table I), which include the interference of the resonances and direct captures, resulted in SE1(300 keV)=99S_{E1}(300\,\mathrm{keV})=99 keVb and SE2(300 keV)=56S_{E2}(300\,\mathrm{keV})=56 keVb. captures) plus the cascade transition to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}. There are many experimental datasets available in the literature [2]. We show one of them as a representative example. The explanation of the three different lines is given in the caption to the figure. It is evident that increasing the ground-state ANC and the subthreshold ANCs is bringing the present results closer to those in [2], which were obtained using lower ANCs.

Figure 8 (PDF p. 13). The total SS-factors for the 12C(α,γ)16O^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma)^{16}\mathrm{O} reaction given by E1+E2+E1+E2+ cascade transitions to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} for three different calculations. The experimental data are from [3] and [37].

Summary

The SS-factors for the 12C(α,γ)16O^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma)^{16}\mathrm{O} reaction are calculated within the RR-matrix AZURE2 code using the recently determined ANCs for four subthreshold states 02+0^{+}_{2}, 3−3^{-}, 2+2^{+}, 1−1^{-} [21, 22], which represent the high end of the ANCs, and a low ground-state ANC of 58 fm−1/258\ \mathrm{fm}^{-1/2} of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} [2]. The results are compared with the those obtained in [2] using the subthreshold ANCs available in the literature, which represents the lower end of the ANCs. Our comprehensive calculations of the low-energy SS-factors encompass the E1E1 and E2E2 SR transitions to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, which interfere with the higher resonances and direct captures, and cascade radiative captures to the ground state of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O} through four subthreshold states: 02+0^{+}_{2}, 3−3^{-}, 2+2^{+} and 1−1^{-}. Since our ANCs are higher than those used by deBoer et al. [2], the present total SS-factor at the most effective astrophysical energy of 300 keV300\ \mathrm{keV} is 174 keVb174\ \mathrm{keVb} versus 137 keVb137\ \mathrm{keVb} of that work. Higher subthreshold bound-state ANCs used in the present calculations lead to a higher S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor and higher low-temperature reaction rates (see Appendix B).

Since in the present calculations, all the parameters, except for the subthreshold ANCs, were taken from [2], we are able to check the dependence of the SS-factors for the 12C(α,γ)16O^{12}\mathrm{C}(\alpha,\gamma)^{16}\mathrm{O} radiative capture at very low energies, where the resonance captures through the subthreshold state dominate. The contributions of the E1E1 and E2E2 SR transitions to the total SS-factors SE1(300 keV)S_{E1}(300\ \mathrm{keV}) (SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\ \mathrm{keV})) are 71%71\% and 74%74\% (102%102\% and 103%103\%) for the subthreshold ANCs from [2] and present ones, respectively. Moreover, we also observe that for the uncertainty of the 1−1^{-} (2+2^{+}) subthreshold ANC of 19%19\% (55%55\%) generates 15%15\% (56%56\%) uncertainty in the SE1(300 keV)S_{E1}(300\ \mathrm{keV}) (SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\ \mathrm{keV})). It is essential to emphasize that the ratio SE1(SR)(300 keV)/SE1(300 keV)=74%S_{E1}^{(\mathrm{SR})}(300\ \mathrm{keV})/S_{E1}(300\ \mathrm{keV})=74\% is less than the correlation of the uncertainties ΔC12\Delta C_{1}^{2} and ΔSE1(300 keV)\Delta S_{E1}(300\ \mathrm{keV}), which is 79%79\%. This arises from the additional contribution of the interference of the E1E1 SR and the broad (9.59 MeV,1−)(9.59\ \mathrm{MeV},1^{-}) resonance, which also depends on C1C_{1}.

The E1E1 transition of the SR 1−1^{-} is not influenced by the ground-state ANC as the E1E1 nonresonant capture is the isospin forbidden transition (with a negligibly small effective charge), yet it still interferes constructively with a broad (9.585 MeV;1−)(9.585\ \mathrm{MeV};1^{-}) resonance giving (for the present subthreshold ANCs) an additional 26%26\% contribution to the total SE1(300 keV)S_{E1}(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor.

The interference between the E2E2 transition of the SR 2+2^{+} and direct capture is minimal when the ground-state ANC is small, but becomes destructive at higher ground-state ANC, resulting in a contribution of −29%-29\%. The low-energy SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor experiences a smaller increase when both subthreshold and the ground-state ANCs rise together due to their anticorrelation, compared to when only the subthreshold ANCs increase.

In summary, our key findings indicate that: (1) For given parameters of the broad 1−1^{-} resonance 9.59 MeV9.59\ \mathrm{MeV} [2] we can control the uncertainty of the SE1(300 keV)S_{E1}(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor, which stems from the uncertainty of the square of the subthreshold ANC C12C_{1}^{2}, as the total uncertainty of the former is 79%79\% of the latter. (2) The uncertainty in the ground-state ANC limits the conclusiveness of our analysis for the E2E2 transition compared to the E1E1 case. The most pressing issue that needs attention is determining the ground-state ANC.

Nevertheless, we can draw some preliminary conclusions. For the low ground-state ANC, the uncertainty of the SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor is completely generated by the uncertainty of C22C_{2}^{2}. Hence the total uncertainty of the S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor is given by [0.79ΔC12]2+[ΔC22]2\sqrt{[0.79\Delta C_{1}^{2}]^{2}+[\Delta C_{2}^{2}]^{2}}. An increase in the ground-state ANC results in a decrease in the contribution of the SE2(300 keV)S_{E2}(300\ \mathrm{keV}) to the total S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV})-factor, making the uncertainty in C22C_{2}^{2} less important. Therefore, we can assert that the upper bound of the total uncertainty for the S(300 keV)S(300\ \mathrm{keV}) is [0.79ΔC12]2+[ΔC22]2\sqrt{[0.79\Delta C_{1}^{2}]^{2}+[\Delta C_{2}^{2}]^{2}}.

Acknowledgments

R.J.D. utilized resources from the Notre Dame Center for Research Computing and was supported by the National Science Foundation through grant Nos. PHY-1713857 and PHY-2011890, and the Joint Institute for Nuclear Astrophysics through grant No. PHY-1430152 (JINA Center for the Evolution of the Elements). A.S.K. acknowledges the support from the Australian Research Council.

Reduced width of the subthreshold resonance

Discussing the appearance of the Whittaker function in Eq. (18) is appropriate and ties in with deriving the expression for the reduced width of the SR. In order to establish a relationship between ΓsSR(E)\Gamma_{s}^{\mathrm{SR}}(E), γlsSR(Rch)\gamma_{ls}^{\mathrm{SR}}(R_{\mathrm{ch}}) and the ANC ClsC_{ls} of the subthreshold bound state, one can extrapolate the elastic scattering SS-matrix (see Eq. (3)) to the SR pole.

The fundamental concept of the SS-matrix’s analyticity requires the existence of a bound-state pole positioned on the upper part of the imaginary axis in the kk-plane. In the vicinity of the subthreshold pole in the kk-plane, the SS-matrix for elastic scattering is represented by [25]

Sls=k→iκs+0−i(−1)lseiπηsCls2k−iκs.(40)S_{ls} \underset{k\to i\kappa_s+0}{=} -i(-1)^{l_s}e^{i\pi\eta_s}\frac{C_{ls}^{2}}{k-i\kappa_s}. \tag*{(40)}

In this equation, the pole’s residue is articulated in terms of the subthreshold ANC ClsC_{ls}.

At the same time, the elastic scattering SS-matrix in the RR-matrix approach can be written in terms of the resonance width or, alternatively, in terms of the reduced width. In order to make the derivation of the SS-matrix in the presence of the SR clearer, we start from the beginning. In the RR-matrix formalism, the single-level, single-channel SS-matrix is provided by

Sls=e−2i(δclshs−σlsC)1/Rls−[Δls(E)−Bls−iPls(k,Rch)]1/Rls−[Δls(E)−Bls+iPls(k,Rch)].(41)S_{ls}=e^{-2i(\delta_{cls}^{\mathrm{hs}}-\sigma_{ls}^{C})}\frac{1/R_{ls}-[\Delta_{ls}(E)-B_{ls}-iP_{ls}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})]}{1/R_{ls}-[\Delta_{ls}(E)-B_{ls}+iP_{ls}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})]}. \tag*{(41)}

where Rls=γ~ls2/(Es−E)R_{ls}=\tilde{\gamma}_{ls}^{2}/(E_s-E) is the RR-matrix, γ~ls2\tilde{\gamma}_{ls}^{2} is the formal reduced width of the subthreshold level. Additionally, Δls(E)\Delta_{ls}(E) is the Thomas shift and BlsB_{ls} is the boundary condition. We remind that Js=lsJ_s=l_s. EsE_s is the RR-matrix level energy corresponding to the subthreshold resonance. We adopt Es=−εsE_s=-\varepsilon_s and Bls=Δls(−εs)B_{ls}=\Delta_{ls}(-\varepsilon_s). Then for EE in the vicinity of −εs-\varepsilon_s

Sls≈e−2i(δclshs−σlsC)−εs−E+iPls(k,Rch)γ~ls2−εs−E−iPls(k,Rch)γ~ls2.(42)S_{ls}\approx e^{-2i(\delta_{cls}^{\mathrm{hs}}-\sigma_{ls}^{C})}\frac{-\varepsilon_s-E+iP_{ls}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})\tilde{\gamma}_{ls}^{2}}{-\varepsilon_s-E-iP_{ls}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})\tilde{\gamma}_{ls}^{2}}. \tag*{(42)}

We employed Δls(E)−Δls(−εs)≈dΔls(E)dE∣E=−εs(E+εs)\Delta_{ls}(E)-\Delta_{ls}(-\varepsilon_s)\approx\left.\frac{d\Delta_{ls}(E)}{dE}\right|_{E=-\varepsilon_s}(E+\varepsilon_s). It allows one to introduce the observable reduced width

γls2=γ~ls21+dΔls(E)dE∣E=−εs.(43)\gamma_{ls}^{2}=\frac{\tilde{\gamma}_{ls}^{2}}{1+\left.\frac{d\Delta_{ls}(E)}{dE}\right|_{E=-\varepsilon_s}}. \tag*{(43)}

When extrapolating E→−εsE\to-\varepsilon_s Eq. (42) is reduced to

Sls≈E→−εs−2ie−2i(δclshs−σlsC)Pls(k,Rch)[γlsSR(Rch)]2E+εs.(44)S_{ls}\underset{E\to-\varepsilon_s}{\approx}-2ie^{-2i(\delta_{cls}^{\mathrm{hs}}-\sigma_{ls}^{C})}\frac{P_{ls}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})[\gamma_{ls}^{\mathrm{SR}}(R_{\mathrm{ch}})]^{2}}{E+\varepsilon_s}. \tag*{(44)}

To obtain it we took into account that in the denominator at E≤0E\leq0 ΓlsSR(E)=0\Gamma_{ls}^{\mathrm{SR}}(E)=0 due to the presence in it the barrier penetrability Pl(k,Rch)P_l(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}}) (see Eq. (13)), which represents the imaginary component of the logarithmic derivative of the wave function that remains real for negative energies. However, taking into account Eq. (12), the numerator is made up of

e2i(σlsC−δlshs)Pls(k,Rch)=kRch[Ols(k,Rch)]2=(−1)lse−πηs sgn⁡Re⁡k kRch[W−ηs,ls+1/2(−2ikRch)]2.(45)e^{2i(\sigma_{ls}^{C}-\delta_{ls}^{\mathrm{hs}})}P_{ls}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})=\frac{kR_{\mathrm{ch}}}{[O_{ls}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})]^{2}} =\frac{(-1)^{l_s}e^{-\pi\eta_s\,\operatorname{sgn}\operatorname{Re}k}\,kR_{\mathrm{ch}}}{[W_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}(-2ikR_{\mathrm{ch}})]^{2}}. \tag*{(45)}

eπη sgn⁡Re⁡k[W−η,l+1/2(k,Rch)]2e^{\pi\eta\,\operatorname{sgn}\operatorname{Re}k}[W_{-\eta,l+1/2}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})]^{2} is analytic function in the upper half kk plane (Im⁡k>0\operatorname{Im}k>0) except the point k=0k=0 [25]. Its extrapolation to the subthreshold bound state pole is simple, leading to the emergence of the Whittaker function W−ηs,ls+1/2(2κsRch)W_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}(2\kappa_sR_{\mathrm{ch}}) for the subthreshold bound state:

e2i(σlsC−δlshs)Pls(k,Rch)=k→iκs(−1)lseiπηsiκsRch[W−ηs,ls+1/2(2κsRch)]2.(46)e^{2i(\sigma_{ls}^{C}-\delta_{ls}^{\mathrm{hs}})}P_{ls}(k,R_{\mathrm{ch}})\underset{k\to i\kappa_s}{=}\frac{(-1)^{l_s}e^{i\pi\eta_s}i\kappa_sR_{\mathrm{ch}}}{[W_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}(2\kappa_sR_{\mathrm{ch}})]^{2}}. \tag*{(46)}

With Eq. (46) considered, in the vicinity of the subthreshold bound state pole in the kk plane Eq. (44) transforms to

Sls≈k→iκs−2iμRch(−1)lseiπηs[W−ηs,ls+1/2]2[γlsSR(Rch)]2k−iκs.(47)S_{ls}\underset{k\to i\kappa_s}{\approx}-2i\mu R_{\mathrm{ch}}\frac{(-1)^{l_s}e^{i\pi\eta_s}}{[W_{-\eta_s,l_s+1/2}]^{2}}\frac{[\gamma_{ls}^{\mathrm{SR}}(R_{\mathrm{ch}})]^{2}}{k-i\kappa_s}. \tag*{(47)}

Equation (18) is derived from the comparison of Eqs. (40) and (47).

Reaction Rates

In Table VII we compare the reaction rates calculated using the present total SS-factor with the ones from [2]. For easier comparison, the tabulated low-temperature reaction rates are calculated at the same temperatures as in [2]. Since the present SS-factor is larger than that from [2], at low temperatures T9<2.0T_9<2.0 our reaction rates exceed the reaction rates from [2]. However, since we constrain our calculations to low-energy SS-factor, at temperatures T9≥2T_9\geq2 the reaction rates from [2] exceed ours.

T9T_9Reaction Rates (cm3 s−1 mol−1\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}\,mol^{-1}}) PresentReaction Rates (cm3 s−1 mol−1\mathrm{cm^3\,s^{-1}\,mol^{-1}}) Ref. [2]
0.066.81×10−266.81 \times10^{-26}6.78×10−266.78 \times10^{-26}
0.073.65×10−243.65 \times10^{-24}3.28×10−243.28 \times10^{-24}
0.089.33×10−239.33 \times10^{-23}8.00×10−238.00 \times10^{-23}
0.091.42×10−211.42 \times10^{-21}1.18×10−211.18 \times10^{-21}
0.11.46×10−201.46 \times10^{-20}1.20×10−211.20 \times10^{-21}
0.111.11×10−191.11 \times10^{-19}9.03×10−209.03 \times10^{-20}
0.126.66×10−196.66 \times10^{-19}5.38×10−195.38 \times10^{-19}
0.133.29×10−183.29 \times10^{-18}2.65×10−182.65 \times10^{-18}
0.141.39×10−171.39 \times10^{-17}1.11×10−171.11 \times10^{-17}
0.155.11×10−175.11 \times10^{-17}4.08×10−174.08 \times10^{-17}
0.161.68×10−161.68 \times10^{-16}1.34×10−161.34 \times10^{-16}
0.181.37×10−151.37 \times10^{-15}1.09×10−161.09 \times10^{-16}
0.208.34×10−158.34 \times10^{-15}6.64×10−156.64 \times10^{-15}
0.304.68×10−124.68 \times10^{-12}3.73×10−123.73 \times10^{-12}
0.354.10×10−114.10 \times10^{-11}3.28×10−113.28 \times10^{-11}
0.42.44×10−102.44 \times10^{-10}1.96×10−101.96 \times10^{-10}
0.451.10×10−91.10 \times10^{-9}8.82×10−108.82 \times10^{-10}
0.53.99×10−93.99 \times10^{-9}3.22×10−93.22 \times10^{-9}
0.63.33×10−83.33 \times10^{-8}2.70×10−82.70 \times10^{-8}
0.71.80×10−71.80 \times10^{-7}1.47×10−71.47 \times10^{-7}
0.87.2×10−77.2 \times10^{-7}5.92×10−75.92 \times10^{-7}
0.92.32×10−62.32 \times10^{-6}1.92×10−61.92 \times10^{-6}
1.06.37×10−66.37 \times10^{-6}5.30×10−65.30 \times10^{-6}
1.254.85×10−54.85 \times10^{-5}4.10×10−64.10 \times10^{-6}
2.02.60×10−32.60 \times10^{-3}2.40×10−32.40 \times10^{-3}

Table VII. Low temperature reaction rates (T9≤2T_9 \le2)

References

References

  1. [1]C. E. Rolfs and W. S. Sidney, Cauldrons in the Cosmos, The University of Chicago Press, 1988.
  2. [2]R. J. deBoer, J. Görres, and M. Wiescher, R. E. Azuma, A. Best, C. R. Brune, C. E. Fields, S. Jones, M. Pignatari, D. Sayre, K. Smith, F. X. Timmes, Rev. Mod. Phys. 89, 035007 (2017).
  3. [3]D. Schürmann, A. Di Leva, et al., Eur. Phys. J. A 26, 301 (2005).
  4. [4]A. Redder, H. W. Becker, C. Rolfs, H. P. Trautvetter, T. R. Donghue, T. C. Rinckel, J. W. Hammer and K. Langanke, Nucl. Phys. A462, 385 (1987).
  5. [5]R. M. Kremer, C. A. Barnes, K. H. Chang, H. C. Evans, B. W. Filippone, K. H. Hahn, and L. W. Mitchell, Phys. Rev. Lett. 60, 1475 (1988).
  6. [6]F. C. Barker and T. Kājino, Austr. J. Phys. 44, 369 (1991).
  7. [7]J. M. L. Ouellet, H. C. Evans, H. W. Lee, J. R. Leslie, J. D. MacArthur, W. McLatchie, H.-B. Mak, P. Skensved, J. L. Whitton, X. Zhao, and T. K. Alexander, Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 1896 (1992).
  8. [8]R. E. Azuma, L. Buchmann, F. C. Barker, C. A. Barnes, J. M. D’Auria, M. Dombsky, U. Giesen, K. P. Jackson, J. D. King, R. G. Korteling, P. McNeely, J. Powell, G. Roy, J. Vincent, T. R. Wang, S. S. M. Wong, and P. R. Wrean Phys. Rev. C 50, 1194 (1994).
  9. [9]C. R. Brune, W. H. Geist, R. W. Kavanagh, and K. D. Veal, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 4025 (1999).
  10. [10]R. Kunz, M. Jaeger, A. Mayer, J. W. Hammer, G. Staudt, S. Harissopulos, and T. Paradellis, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 3244 (2001).
  11. [11]M. Assunção, M. Fey, A. Lefebvre-Schuhl, J. Kiener, V. Tatischeff, J. W. Hammer, C. Beck, C. Boukari-Pelisssie, A. Coc, J. J. Correia, S. Courtin, F. Flerout, E. Galanopoulos, C. Grama, F. Haas, F. Hammache, F. Hannach, S. Harissopulos, A. Korichi, R. Kunz, D. LeDu, A. Lopez-Martens, D. Malcherek, R. Meunier, Th. Paradellis, M. Rousseau, N. Rowley, G. Staudt, S. Szilner, J. P. Thibaud, and J. L. Weil, Phys. Rev. C 73 055801 (2006).
  12. [12]A. Belhout, S. Ouichaoui, H. Beaumevieille, A. Boughrara, S. Fortier, J. Kiener, J. M. Maison, S. K. Mehdi, L.Rosier, J. P. Thibaud, A.Trabelsi, J. Vernotte, Nucl. Phys. A 793, 178 (2007).
  13. [13]R. Plag, R. Reifarth, M. Heil, F. Käppeler, G. Rupp, F. Voss, and K. Wisshak, Phys. Rev. C 86, 015805 (2012).
  14. [14]D. B. Sayre, C. R. Brune, D. E. Carter, D. K. Jacobs, T. N. Massey, and J. E. O’Donnell, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 142501 (2012).
  15. [15]D. Schürmann, L. Gialanella, R. Kunz, F. Strieder, Phys. Lett. B711, 35 (2012).
  16. [16]M. Gai, Phys. Rev. C 88, 06280(R) (2013).
  17. [17]M. L. Avila, G. V. Rogachev, E. Koshchiy, L. T. Baby, J. Belarge, K. W. Kemper, A. N. Kuchera, A. M. Mukhamedzhanov, D. Santiago-Gonzalez, and E. Uberseder, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 071101 (2015).
  18. [18]Y. Shen, B. Guo, R. J. deBoer, E. Li, Zh. Li, Y. Li, X. Tang, D. Pang, S. Adhikari, Ch. Basu, J. Su, Sh. Yan, Q. Fan, J. Liu, Ch. Chen, Zh. Han, X. Li, G. Lian, T. Ma, W. Nan, Weike Nan, Y. Wang, Sh. Zeng, H. Zhang, and W. Liu, ApJ 945, 41 (2023).
  19. [19]L. D. Blokhintsev, A. S. Kadyrov, A. M. Mukhamedzhanov, and D. A. Savin, Phys. Rev. C 95, 044618 (2017).
  20. [20]L. D. Blokhintsev, A. S. Kadyrov, A. M. Mukhamedzhanov, and D. A. Savin, Phys. Rev. C 97, 024602 (2018).
  21. [21]L. D. Blokhintsev, A. S. Kadyrov, A. M. Mukhamedzhanov, and D. A. Savin, Eur. Phys. J. A 58, 257 (2022).
  22. [22]L. D. Blokhintsev, A. S. Kadyrov, A. M. Mukhamedzhanov, and D. A. Savin, Eur. Phys. J. A 59, 162 (2023).
  23. [23]S. B. Dubovichenko, A. S. Tkachenko, R. Ya. Kezerashvili, N. A. Burkova, and A. V. Dzhazairov-Kakhramanov, Phys. Rev. C 105, 065806 (2022).
  24. [24]A. M. Mukhamedzhanov, Eur. Phys. J. A 59, 43 (2023).
  25. [25]A. M. Mukhamedzhanov and L. D. Blokhintsev, Eur. Phys. J. A 58, 29 (2022).
  26. [26]A. M. Mukhamedzhanov and R. E. Tribble, Phys. Rev. C 59, 3418 (1999).
  27. [27]N. Oulevsir, F. Hammache, P. Roussel, M. G. Pellegriti, L. Audouin, D. Beaumel, A. Bouda, P. Descouvemont, S. Fortier, L. Gaudefrou, J. Kiener, A. Lefebvre-Schuhl, and V. Tatischeff, Phys. Rev. C 85, 035804 (2012).
  28. [28]Yu. V. Orlov, B. F. Irgaziev, and L. I. Nikitina, Phys. Rev. C 93, 014612 (2016).
  29. [29]Yu. V. Orlov, B. F. Irgaziev, and Jameel-Un Nabi, Phys. Rev. C 96, 025809 (2017).
  30. [30]O. L. Ramírez Suárez and J.-M. Sparenberg, Phys. Rev. C 96, 034601 (2017).
  31. [31]Shung-Ichi Ando, Phys. Rev. C 97, 014604 (2018).
  32. [32]Yu. V. Orlov, Nucl. Phys. A 1014, 122257 (2021); Erratum, Nucl. Phys. A 1018, 122385 (2022).
  33. [33]C. Hebborn, M. L. Avila, K. Kravvaris, G. Potel, and S. Quaglioni, arXiv:2307.05636v2 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2307.05636
  34. [34]D. R. Tilley, H. R. Weller, and C. M. Cheves, Nucl. Phys. A 564, 1 (1993).
  35. [35]J. M. Eisenberg and W. Greiner, Excitation Mechanisms Of The Nucleus. Electromagnetic and Weak Interactions, North-Holland Publishing Company, Amsterdam-London, 1970.
  36. [36]D. Baye and E. Tursunov, J. Phys. G 45, 085102 (2018).
  37. [37]H. Yamaguchi, K. Sagara, K. Fujita, D. Kodama, Y. Narikiyo, K. Hamamoto, T. Ban, N. Tao and T. Teranishi, AIP Conference Proceedings 1594, 229 (2014).

Paper details

vlnc:W_rsmnkuz4
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents