WorksPhysics and Astronomy
High-pressure elastic properties of GeO2 polymorphs up to 120 GPa
Abstract
We systematically investigated the phase stability, pressure dependence of the elastic properties, and elastic anisotropy of four GeO2 polymorphs: rutile-, CaCl2-, alpha-PbO2-, and pyrite-type phases using theoretical calculations based on density functional theory. The elastic constants were calculated at regular pressure intervals within the stability fields of each phase, as determined by static enthalpy calculations. We further employed a strain-coupled Landau free-energy expansion to describe the pressure evolution of the elastic response associated with the rutile- to CaCl2-type transition and elucidate the origin of the elastic softening near the transition. The rutile- to CaCl2-type phase transition is consistent with a Landau-type second-order transition. As the transition is approached, elastic softening develops in the rutile-type phase, resulting in anomalous pressure dependence of the bulk and shear moduli. The calculated elastic-wave anisotropy increases markedly near the transition, primarily due to the rapid reduction in shear-wave velocity, reaching a maximum of approximately 190% at 20 GPa. Following the transition, the anisotropy decreases sharply in the CaCl2-type phase and exhibits discontinuity at the CaCl2-type/alpha-PbO2-type phase boundary. The higher-pressure alpha-PbO2- and pyrite-type phases exhibit comparatively weak pressure dependence of anisotropy, with small discontinuities at their respective phase boundaries. The pyrite-type phase has the lowest anisotropy with AP = 4% and AS = 12% at 120 GPa, consistent with its high-symmetry cubic structure and nearly isotropic elastic-wave propagation.
*Corresponding author: Gulshan Kumar ([email protected])
Introduction
Germanium dioxide () has been widely studied because it is a structural and chemical analog of silicon dioxide () and displays several pressure-induced phase transitions [1]. It is also of significant interest because of its important optical, electronic, and piezoelectric applications [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7] [8, 9, 10, 11, 12]. Therefore, a clear understanding of its mechanical stability and high-pressure behavior is of considerable importance in both geosciences and condensed matter physics. First-principles calculations based on density functional theory (DFT) provide a powerful approach for understanding the structural, electronic, elastic, and optical properties of materials [13–17].
At ambient conditions, crystalline crystallizes in a rutile-like tetragonal phase with space group [18]. With increasing pressure, the rutile-type phase first transforms into the -type phase (26 GPa, ), followed by transitions to the --type (36 GPa, ) phase and finally to a pyrite-type phase (65 GPa, ) [19–21]. This transition sequence is consistent with the phase transitions in other group-14 dioxides, such as [22], [23,24], and [25,26].
Raman spectroscopic studies, supported by both experimental observations [27] and theoretical calculations [28], suggest that the rutile- to -type phase transition in is a second-order ferroelastic transition. This transition is associated with the softening of the Raman-active mode and its coupling with acoustic modes, resulting in a strong nonlinear response of the elastic constants [29–31]. Ferroelastic phase transitions of this type are commonly interpreted within the framework of Landau theory, in which the transition is described by a symmetry-breaking order parameter that couples to spontaneous strain [32]. The other two transitions differ from the rutile-to -type transformation because they are reconstructive and first-order in character [20]. The -type --type pyrite-type transitions involve a rearrangement of the octahedral framework, which is associated with a finite volume change [20,21,33,34].
To understand the mechanism of these pressure-induced phase transitions, it is therefore important to study the elastic properties of these phases as pressure increases. Experimental [35] and theoretical [20,36] investigations of the elastic constants have primarily focused on the low-pressure rutile- and -type phases. However, studies of the elastic properties of at high pressures ( GPa) remain limited.
In this study, we establish the pressure evolution of the full elastic tensor of rutile-, -, --, and pyrite-type from 0 to 120 GPa, quantitatively analyze the coupling between the order parameter and strain within a Landau formalism to explain elastic softening across the rutile-to- transition, and characterize changes in elastic-wave anisotropy across all three phase boundaries.
Computational method
All computations were performed using plane-wave density functional theory (DFT) [37,38], as implemented in the Quantum ESPRESSO package [39,40]. The local density approximation (LDA) was used for the exchange-correlation functional. Electron-ion interactions were treated using Vanderbilt’s ultrasoft pseudopotentials [41]. A kinetic energy cutoff of 110 Ry was used for the basis set in all phases. The reciprocal space was sampled using a Monkhorst–Pack k-point grid [42]. Both lattice parameters and atomic positions were optimized at each pressure step using the Broyden-Fletcher-Goldfarb-Shanno (BFGS) algorithm [43]. Geometry optimizations were considered complete when the atomic forces were less than Ry/Bohr. Density functional perturbation theory (DFPT) was used to calculate the frequencies of the (soft) mode and (hard) mode for the rutile-type and CaCl-type phases at the gamma () point [q = (0,0,0)].
To calculate the elastic constants () and elastic moduli, the equilibrium structures at each pressure were subjected to a series of small deformations. The maximum absolute value of the Lagrangian strain set to , producing 19 distorted structures using the deformation types implemented in the ElaStic code [44]. Internal degrees of freedom were optimized, and the total energy of all the deformed structures was obtained using Quantum ESPRESSO [39,40]. To determine the second derivative of the energy with respect to Lagrangian strain at equilibrium, the calculated energy–strain data were fitted using a polynomial function. The coefficient of the quadratic term in the best-fitting polynomial can be expressed as a linear combination of the second-order elastic constants. This results in a set of linear equations for each deformed structure, which are subsequently solved using a least-squares fitting method to determine the second-order elastic constants (). A pressure correction was applied to the calculated elastic constants to account for the finite external pressure P, under which the calculations were performed [45].
Results and Discussion
Structural stability and phase transitions
The structural properties of the rutile-, CaCl-, -PbO-, and pyrite-type GeO polymorphs (Figure 1) were investigated over the pressure range of 0-120 GPa at regular pressure intervals of 5 GPa (10 GPa above 100 GPa), with additional calculations at 28 and 32 GPa to better resolve the narrow stability field of the CaCl-type phase. The optimized lattice parameters and unit-cell volumes are summarized in Table I and compared with existing theoretical and experimental values. The rutile-type () structure of GeO consists of edge-sharing GeO octahedra arranged in straight chains parallel to the tetragonal -axis, with adjacent chains linked by cornersharing oxygen atoms in the -plane [46]. In the CaCl-type () phase, the GeO octahedra retain the same connectivity as in the rutile structure but differ by an orthorhombic distortion arising from tilting and rotation of the octahedral chains along the -axis [46,47]. In contrast to the straight octahedral chains of the rutile and CaCl-type structures, the -PbO-type phase features zigzag chains of edge-sharing octahedra, together with a significant displacement of the Ge cations and a loss of the original chain alignment along the -axis [34,47]. The pyrite-type () phase represents the densest GeO polymorph. In this structure, GeO octahedra form a three-dimensional framework connected exclusively through corner sharing, with no edge sharing between adjacent octahedra [47]. Figure 2 shows the enthalpy () difference of each structure with respect to the rutile-type phase as a function of pressure at 0 K. The phase transition pressures, were determined by identifying the intersections of the enthalpy–pressure curves of the competing phases and interpolating between the calculated points. At each pressure, the phase with the lowest enthalpy among the polymorphs is thermodynamically stable at 0 K.
Figure 1. Crystal structures of the four polymorphs of GeO: (a) rutile-type at 0 GPa, (b) CaCl-type at 25 GPa, (c) -PbO-type at 35 GPa, and (d) pyrite-type at 65 GPa. The red and grey spheres represent the oxygen and germanium atoms, respectively.
Figure 2. Enthalpy differences of the four polymorphs (rutile-type: red circles, -type: green squares, --type: black triangles, and pyrite-type: blue vertical squares) relative to the rutile-type phase as a function of pressure. The inset shows an enlarged view of the enthalpy difference in the pressure range of 22.5 to 33 GPa for better visualization.
| Phase (GeO) | Method | Pressure (GPa) | (Å) | (Å) | (Å) | (Å) | (GPa) |
| Rutile-type (Z = 2) | This work | 0 | 4.384 | 2.868 | 55.12 | ||
| Exp [71] | 0.0001 | 4.396(4) | 2.863(2) | 55.33 | |||
| Exp [67] | - | 4.396 | 2.861 | 55.30 | |||
| Exp [35] | - | 4.406 | 2.861 | 55.57 | |||
| Exp [72] | - | 4.406(1) | 2.861(2) | 55.57 | |||
| Hartree-Fock [73] | 0 | 4.352 | 2.863 | 54.20 | |||
| Empirical pot.[74] | 0 | 4.562 | 2.747 | 57.20 | |||
| CaCl-type (Z = 2) | This work | 25 | 4.298 | 4.184 | 2.816 | 50.65 | 24 |
| Exp [46] | 28(1) | 4.284(9) | 4.209(9) | 2.808(3) | 50.63(9) | 28(1) | |
| Exp [28] | 35.9(2) | 4.258(2) | 4.176(1) | 2.796(1) | 49.72(2) | 35.9(2) | |
| Exp [47] | 30.1 | 4.429(7) | 4.403(7) | 2.804(4) | 54.68(7) | 30.1 | |
| Exp [75] | 29.6 | 4.265(1) | 4.225(1) | 2.799(1) | 50.42(1) | 29.6 | |
| DFT-GGA [3] | 30 | 4.375 | 4.134 | 2.844 | 51.44 | 30 | |
| -PbO-type (Z = 4) | This work | 35 | 4.121 | 5.119 | 4.608 | 97.22 | 33 |
| Exp [33] | 51.0 | 4.069(1) | 5.074(2) | 4.562(1) | 94.18 | 51.0 | |
| Exp [34] | 60 | 4.042(8) | 5.039(8) | 4.528(0) | 92.25 | 60 | |
| Exp [47] | 70.7 | 4.051(6) | 5.027(6) | 4.522(6) | 92.08 | 70.7 | |
| DFT-LDA [20] | 40 | 4.095 | 5.088 | 4.579 | 95.40 | 40 | |
| Pyrite-type (Z = 4) | This work | 65 | 4.429 | 86.86 | 63 | ||
| Exp [33] | 82.8 | 4.392(1) | 84.69 (3) | 82.8 | |||
| Exp [47] | 108 | 4.336(15) | 81.52 (4) | 108.0 | |||
| DFT-LDA [20] | 70 | 4.4046 | 85.45 | 70 |
Table I. Comparison of the calculated lattice parameters (Å) and unit-cell volumes (Å) of GeO polymorphs at different pressures with previously reported values ( = transition pressure, = number of formula units):
Our computations show that the tetragonal rutile- to orthorhombic CaCl-type phase transition occurs at 24 GPa. Although this value is higher than the transition pressure predicted by DFT calculations (19 GPa) [20], it is in excellent agreement with existing experimental observations (25–28 GPa) [27,46]. It is also in good agreement with recent theoretical studies (22.6–25.2 GPa) [28]. The CaCl-type phase of GeO is expected to transform into the orthorhombic -PbO-type structure at 33 GPa. This value is lower than that reported in laser-heated diamond anvil cell (LHDAC) experiments [34], where the -PbO-type phase was identified as the stable post-CaCl polymorph above 44 GPa. Coexistence of CaCl- and -PbO-type GeO was reported to persist up to 60 GPa. Our predicted transition pressure is in good agreement with existing first-principles calculations, which reported the - --type transition over a pressure range of 30.5–36 GPa [20,21].
The --type phase is predicted to transform into the pyrite-type structure at 63 GPa. This transition pressure is lower than that reported in the LHDAC experiments [48], where the pyrite-type phase was observed above 90 GPa. Although our calculated transition pressure is significantly lower than the experimentally determined value, it is in good agreement with previous theoretical predictions, which reported transition pressures in the range of 59–69.5 GPa [20,21]. The differences in the reported transition pressures may arise from variations in experimental conditions, including the pressure-transmitting medium, pressure calibrant, degree of hydrostaticity, thermal gradients within the DAC [49], as well as computational choices, such as the exchange-correlation functional and pseudopotentials. Our 0 K calculations use the LDA exchange–correlation functional, which tends to overbind and favor denser phases. Thermal and zero-point contributions are not included in our calculations. Moreover, the experiments observed the --type phase at 60 GPa and the pyrite-type phase at 100 GPa, with no measurements between these pressures; thus, a lower experimental transition pressure cannot be ruled out. The present work provides a complete and internally consistent dataset of the structural and elastic properties of all four polymorphs obtained within a single computational framework. Figure 3 shows the volume per formula unit as a function of pressure. Volume change across the rutile-to -type phase boundary is negligible, consistent with a second-order phase transition. The phase transition is characterized by the splitting of the equivalent -axis of the tetragonal rutile-type structure into inequivalent - and -axes in the -type phase, reflecting an orthorhombic distortion [28]. The - -- pyrite-type phase transitions are characterized by significant atomic rearrangements and finite volume discontinuities (1.17% and 4.70%, respectively), consistent with their first-order nature.
Figure 3. Pressure dependence of the unit cell volume (per formula unit) of the four investigated phases. Colors have the same meaning as in Figure 2.
Elastic constants
Elastic constants derived from DFT energy–strain calculations directly capture the microscopic elastic response and allow the analysis to be extended to the higher-pressure polymorphs. We have therefore calculated the pressure-dependent single-crystal elastic constants for all four phases within their stability range. Rutile-type has tetragonal symmetry and is characterized by six independent elastic constants (, , , , , and ). The - and --type phases exhibit orthorhombic symmetry and are described by nine independent elastic constants (, , , , , , , , and ). The pyrite-type phase crystallizes in a cubic structure and is characterized by three independent elastic constants (, , and ). The pressure dependence of the elastic constants is shown in Figure 4.
Figure 4. Variation of the elastic constants with pressure for the four polymorphs calculated using density functional theory: rutile-type (red), -type (green), --type (black), and pyrite-type (blue).
In the rutile-type phase, is the largest elastic constant and increases strongly with pressure, indicating increasing stiffness along the -axis. also increases with pressure but remains lower than , consistent with high-pressure X-ray diffraction results showing lower compressibility along the -axis than along the -axis [28,46]. The relatively lower values of indicate comparatively weaker resistance to shear deformation, whereas the smaller and values reflect weaker coupling between normal strains along different crystallographic directions. While and show only weak pressure dependence, and increase more significantly with pressure. The increase in suggests enhanced resistance to shear deformation within the basal plane as the rutile- to -type transition is approached. Table II compares the elastic constants obtained in the present study with available experimental and theoretical results at selected. pressures. For rutile-type GeO at ambient pressure, our calculated values are in good agreement with experimental measurements [35] and previous theoretical results [20].
| Phase | Pressure (GPa) | |||||||||||
| Rutile- Type | ||||||||||||
| This work | 0 | 318.7 | 565.7 | 151.4 | 260.9 | 197.8 | 179.9 | 251 | 139 | |||
| Exp [35] | 0.5 | 337.2 | 599.4 | 161.5 | 258.4 | 188.2 | 187.4 | 259 | ||||
| DFT-LDA [20] | 0 | 316.1 | 573.9 | 149.9 | 254.6 | 199.4 | 175.6 | |||||
| DFT-LDA [36] | 0 | 403.5 | 637.6 | 189.3 | 285.5 | 184.2 | 188.9 | 280 | 183 | |||
| CaCl-type | ||||||||||||
| This work | 30 | 605 | 446.6 | 704.5 | 200.3 | 229.2 | 377.2 | 275.5 | 247.9 | 179.9 | 344 | 217 |
| DFT-LDA [36] | 30 | 587.0 | 414.2 | 728.9 | 208.5 | 230.1 | 388.3 | 369.4 | 232.3 | 156.8 | 356 | 185 |
| -PbO-type | ||||||||||||
| This work | 40 | 610 | 691 | 731 | 217 | 235 | 267 | 312 | 295 | 247 | 415 | 219 |
| DFT-LDA [36] | 40 | 642.3 | 593.8 | 779.7 | 213 | 230 | 287.4 | 359.5 | 334.7 | 305.2 | 444 | 207 |
| Pyrite-type | ||||||||||||
| This work | 70 | 946 | 337 | 347 | 546 | 322 | ||||||
| DFT-LDA [36] | 70 | 956.6 | 304.8 | 425.5 | 603 | 289 |
Table II. Comparison of the elastic constants (GPa) and elastic moduli (GPa) of GeO polymorphs at 0 K with previously reported theoretical and experimental data:
In the orthorhombic CaCl-type phase, remains the largest elastic constant, indicating high stiffness along the -axis. increases rapidly with pressure and becomes significantly larger than , highlighting the strong elastic anisotropy of the orthorhombic structure. The splitting of , , and reflects the reduction in symmetry from tetragonal rutile to orthorhombic CaCl-type GeO. In contrast, and decrease slightly with pressure, indicating a weakening of the coupling between the corresponding normal strains. The shear elastic constants , , and show relatively weak pressure dependence over the investigated pressure range.
In the -PbO-type phase, all the elastic constants increase nearly linearly with pressure between 35 and 60 GPa, indicating progressive mechanical stiffening under pressure. The principal normal elastic constants follow the order , indicating that the structure is stiffest along the -axis, followed by the - and -axes. Compared with the CaCl-type phase, the pressure dependence is more systematic. The increases in , , and indicate stronger coupling between the corresponding normal strain directions, while , , and remain lower than the normal elastic constants, reflecting the comparatively lower resistance to the corresponding shear deformations. For the CaCl- and -PbO-type phases, our elastic constants at 30 and 40 GPa are broadly consistent with the previous first-principles calculations [36].
The pyrite-type phase shows the highest elastic constants among the four GeO polymorphs. is exceptionally large and increases from GPa at 65 GPa to GPa at 120 GPa, indicating a very high longitudinal stiffness and strong resistance to deformation along the corresponding crystallographic direction. and also increase steadily with pressure but remain substantially smaller than . This difference indicates weaker coupling between the corresponding normal strains and a lower resistance to shear deformation relative to the longitudinal response represented by . Apart from DFT calculations of elastic constants at specific pressures [36], pressure-dependent single-crystal elastic constants of the -PbO- and pyrite-type phases of GeO have not been reported, and no experimental data are available to the best of our knowledge. The present results therefore provide a useful reference dataset for understanding the elastic properties and pressure evolution of these high-pressure GeO polymorphs.
The mechanical stability of the GeO polymorphs was assessed using the appropriate pressure-dependent Born stability criteria at each pressure [50]. In the rutile-type phase, initially increases with pressure, but its rate of increase slows down upon further compression, whereas increases rapidly with pressure. Consequently, the tetragonal stability condition [50] is violated above 20 GPa, indicating a shear instability associated with the rutile- to CaCl-type transition. This is consistent with the theoretical study [20], which reported the instability at 19 GPa. For the CaCl-type phase, most elastic constants, including , , , , , , and , increase with pressure, although is only weakly pressure sensitive. In contrast, and decrease with compression, indicating weakening of selected interaxial strain couplings. Nevertheless, the calculated constants satisfy the orthorhombic Born stability criteria throughout the CaCl stability field, confirming its mechanical stability [50]. The -PbO-type phase also satisfies the orthorhombic stability criteria up to its transition pressure of 63 GPa. For the cubic pyrite-type phase, the conditions ; ; and remain fulfilled over the studied pressure range, indicating that this dense high-pressure phase is mechanically stable under compression [50].
Figure 5 shows the pressure dependence of the Hill average bulk modulus () and shear modulus (), together with Reuss and Voigt moduli for the rutile-, CaCl-, -PbO- and pyrite-type phases of GeO. Across the rutile- CaCl-type transition, the Hill-average bulk modulus decreases by 9%, whereas it increases by 10% and 5.5% across the CaCl- -PbO-type and -PbO pyrite-type transitions, respectively. On the other hand, the Hill-average shear modulus increases by 51% at the rutile- CaCl-type transition, decreases by 9% at the CaCl- -PbO-type transition and increases again by 22% upon transformation to the pyrite-type phase. In all four phases, is significantly larger than , indicating that GeO resists volume compression more strongly than shear deformation. In the rutile phase, remains nearly pressure independent and shows a slight decrease close to the transition pressure, indicating shear softening as the structure approaches the rutile CaCl transformation. In the other three high-pressure phases, both the bulk and shear moduli increase approximately linearly with pressure, indicating progressive elastic stiffening upon compression.
Figure 5. Pressure dependence of the bulk modulus () and shear modulus () for the four GeO polymorphs calculated using density functional theory. Colors have the same meaning as in Figure 4. The solid lines represent the Hill averages, while the dotted and dashed lines represent the Voigt and Reuss bounds, respectively.
Landau model
The rutile- to CaCl-type transition in GeO is a second-order ferroelastic transition characterized by the absence of volume discontinuity and a continuous evolution of the structural order parameter [27,28]. The transition is driven by the softening of the symmetry-breaking elastic constant combination (-) as the transition pressure is approached [51,52]. While DFT calculations quantitatively capture the phase transition and the pressure dependence of the elastic constants, they do not explicitly describe the mechanism of elastic softening in terms of the coupling between the symmetry-breaking order parameter and strain. In contrast, Landau free-energy expansion theory (see supplementary material for details) provides a classical framework for describing the coupling between the order parameter () and spontaneous strain [32,51]. Landau framework establishes a connection between microscopic lattice instability and macroscopic elastic anomaly. In the Landau formulation, the order parameter, is linearly coupled to the symmetry-breaking strain (). remains zero in the high-symmetry structure (rutile-type) and attains a finite positive value in the low-symmetry phase (CaCl-type) above a strain-derived critical pressure, (Figure S1). is the pressure at which, within the Landau model, the rutile-type structure becomes unstable against the symmetry-breaking strain. GPa is lower than the enthalpy-driven phase-transition pressure, i.e., GPa, because represents the bare critical pressure associated with spontaneous strain. Coupling between strain and the order parameter renormalizes the Landau coefficients, including the effective fourth-order coefficient of the order parameter [32,53]. The enthalpy transition pressure corresponds to the thermodynamic equilibrium phase boundary, where the CaCl-type phase becomes energetically favored over the rutile-type phase, as shown in Figure 2. The distinction between and the enthalpy crossover pressure, therefore, reflects the difference between the mechanical instability of the rutile-type structure and the thermodynamic stability of the two competing phases.

Figure S1. Pressure dependence of the strain difference in the rutile- and CaCl₂-type phases. The rutile-type phase (red circles) shows zero strain difference, whereas the CaCl₂-type phase (green squares) shows a linear increase in strain difference with increasing pressure.
To quantify the energetic contribution associated with the Landau transition, we evaluated the excess Gibbs free energy, using a strain-coupled Landau free energy expansion (Eq. (2) of the supplementary material). The total Gibbs free energy can be expressed as:
where represents the smooth background contribution of the rutile-type phase [32]. represents the excess Gibbs free energy contribution associated with the symmetry-breaking order parameter and its coupling to spontaneous strain. is zero in the rutile-type structure because both the order parameter and the spontaneous strains () is zero. Once the symmetry-breaking distortion develops above the critical pressure, becomes non-zero and turns negative, indicating that the symmetry-broken state is energetically favored relative to the smooth rutile-type background. Its magnitude increases continuously with pressure, reflecting the progressive stabilization of the CaCl-type phase and the increasing energetic contribution of the order-parameter and strain coupling to the phase transition, as shown in Figure 6.
Figure 6. Variation in Landau free energy across the rutile- to CaCl-type phase transition, illustrating the onset of symmetry-breaking strain and the associated stabilization of the CaCl-type phase.
The bare elastic constants used in the Landau formalism represent the elastic stiffness of the high-symmetry tetragonal parent phase in the absence of any symmetry-breaking distortion. These quantities are pressure-dependent because compression affects the intrinsic modulus of the parent structure [32,51–59]. The symmetry-breaking combination () softens as the transition pressure is reached, while its bare counterpart () is treated as pressure-independent within the Landau formulation (see supplementary material) and represents the intrinsic elastic response of the high-symmetry phase in the absence of -strain coupling.
Using the Landau coefficients listed in Table III and the corresponding derivatives of the free energy given in Equation (12) of the Supplementary Material, we calculated the pressure dependence of the elastic constants. The pressure dependence of the elastic constants predicted by the Landau model is shown in Figure 7a. increases linearly with pressure in both the rutile- and CaCl-type phases, whereas and show a slight decrease near the transition before increasing again with further compression. The tetragonal-to-orthorhombic symmetry lowering lifts the equivalence of several elastic constants, resulting in the splitting of the corresponding elastic constants as shown in Figure 7a. The tetragonal splits into and , both of which increase with pressure. Similarly, the tetragonal splits into and , where increases while decreases at the critical pressure. Following the transition, both elastic constants remain nearly pressure independent. The tetragonal splits into the orthorhombic and , both of which increase linearly with pressure. The most significant feature is the pronounced softening of the symmetry-breaking elastic combination in the tetragonal rutile phase, which decreases with pressure and approaches zero at the critical pressure (), indicating the loss of stability against the symmetry-breaking distortion. In contrast, the corresponding orthorhombic combination increases beyond the transition pressure, indicating the progressive recovery of stability against the symmetry-breaking distortion. This behavior represents the mechanical signature of the ferroelastic instability and reflects coupling between the order parameter and the spontaneous strain. Within the Landau formalism, , where is the strain-order parameter coupling coefficient and is the susceptibility of the order parameter (see supplementary material for more details). As the transition is approached, increasing susceptibility enhances the strain-order parameter coupling, progressively reducing the restoring force against the tetragonal shear deformation. The continuous softening of towards the critical pressure is consistent with a second-order phase transition..
Figure 7. Pressure dependence of the (a) elastic constants and (b) bulk and shear moduli in the rutile- and -type phases of obtained from the Landau model. In (b), the solid lines represent the Hill averages, while the dotted and dashed lines represent the Voigt and Reuss bounds. Red and green curves correspond to the rutile- and -type phases, respectively. The dashed black line shows the critical pressure, .
| Bare Elastic Constants | Landau Coefficients |
Table III. The coefficients of the classical Landau free-energy expansion. is the strain-derived critical pressure, is the pressure at which the and Raman modes cross, and is the pressure at which the extrapolated frequency of the rutile-type phase reaches zero (see supplementary material).
To understand the macroscopic elastic response, the aggregate bulk modulus () and shear modulus () were calculated from the full elastic tensor using the Voigt-Reuss-Hill averaging methods [60]. Figure 7b shows the change in the elastic moduli with pressure. The bulk modulus increases with pressure in both the rutile- and CaCl-type phases, reflecting the progressive stiffening of the lattice under compression. Near the transition pressure, the Reuss and Hill bulk moduli exhibit a pronounced discontinuity, while the Voigt bulk modulus shows a relatively weak decrease. In the rutile-type phase, the Reuss and Hill shear moduli decrease with pressure. The Reuss shear modulus exhibits the most pronounced softening, approaching zero at the critical pressure, while the Hill average also decreases significantly but remains finite. In contrast, the Voigt shear modulus shows relatively weak pressure dependence and does not exhibit a sharp decrease at the transition pressure. Following the transition to the -type phase, all three shear moduli increase with pressure, reflecting the progressive increase in resistance to shear deformation under compression.
Elastic anisotropy
The elastic constants and elastic softening associated with the rutile-type to -type ferroelastic transition are expected to strongly affect the directional elastic wave propagation. To understand this velocity anisotropy at high pressure and quantify its evolution across the transition, directional compressional-wave (P-wave) and shear-wave (S-wave) velocities were calculated using the Christoffel matrix formulation [61]: , where is the Christoffel matrix, is the unit vector describing propagation direction, and are the elastic constants. The wave velocities are obtained by solving the Christoffel eigenvalue equation, given by:
where is the polarisation wave vector, is the wave velocity, and is the density at the given pressure. The three eigenvalues yield one longitudinal () and two transverse modes ( and ) for a given propagation direction. After obtaining the full set of directional velocities, we identify the maximum and minimum values ( and ) for each wave mode and use them to evaluate directional variations using the following relation [62,63]:
where and are the aggregate P-wave and S-wave velocities, respectively; and are compressional and shear wave anisotropy, respectively.
Figure 8 shows the compressional and shear wave anisotropy for all four stable phases. Among these phases, the rutile-type structure exhibits the strongest elastic anisotropy. In this phase, rises sharply from ~71% at ambient pressure to ~190% at 20 GPa near the rutile- to -type transition pressure, while increases from ~28% to ~33% with pressure during the same stable pressure range. The sharp increase near the phase boundary is associated with the softening of () as the transition is approached. This softening reduces the elastic restoring forces in specific deformation modes, thereby enhancing the directional variation of the P- and S-wave velocities [31]. Elastic-wave anisotropy is governed by the full elastic stiffness tensor through the Christoffel matrix, , , and other elastic constants and their coupling terms, which contribute differently depending on the crystallographic propagation directions. In the rutile-type phase, the fastest and slowest P-wave directions are and , and the fastest and slowest S-wave directions are and . In the -type phase, the fastest P-wave direction is , and the slowest is , while the S-wave directions are unchanged: fastest along and slowest close to . Following transformation to the -type phase, both anisotropies decrease with pressure, with dropping from ~89% at ~25 GPa to ~63% at 32 GPa close to the second phase transition boundary (~33 GPa), while decreases from ~32% to ~28% in the same range.

Figure 8. Pressure dependence of the elastic wave anisotropy of the four GeO polymorphs calculated using density functional theory; colors have the same meaning as in Figure 4. The anisotropy parameters A and A represent shear and compressional wave anisotropy, respectively.
The -PbO-type phase shows a significant drop in elastic wave anisotropy and remains nearly pressure-independent, with and across its stable range (33–63 GPa). Finally, the pyrite-type phase, stable above ~63 GPa, shows the lowest anisotropy among all phases, with slowly increasing only from ~8% to ~12% and from ~3% to ~4% up to 120 GPa. The relatively weak directional dependence is consistent with its high-symmetry cubic structure. Although the pyrite-type phase has cubic symmetry, its elastic-wave anisotropy is not necessarily zero. Complete elastic isotropy is achieved only when the Zener anisotropy ratio, , equals unity. Thus, deviations of from 1 result in finite directional variations of the P- and S-wave velocities, consistent with the small but nonzero values of and calculated for the pyrite-type phase [64].
Understanding the high-pressure behavior of provides insights into pressure-induced phase transitions, elastic behavior, and elastic anisotropy in (, etc.) compounds. shows a similar sequence of phase transitions as , but at significantly lower pressures [33]. Therefore, serves as a low-pressure analog of , allowing the investigation of pressure-induced phase transitions and mechanical properties under compression under controlled, experimentally accessible conditions. Silica is the most abundant component of the mantle and the crust in the Earth. These insights can therefore help improve our understanding of the elastic behavior of and related oxides at conditions relevant to the deep Earth or exoplanetary interiors. Our high-pressure data on the equation of state, elastic properties, and elastic-wave anisotropy can also serve as reference data for geodynamic modeling of the interiors of giant terrestrial planets, particularly when combined with appropriate finite-temperature thermodynamic properties. Beyond the geophysical implications, they provide benchmarks for assessing and validating computational methods [65]. The Landau framework used here can be extended to other ferroelastic rutile-type oxides to investigate their phase-transition mechanisms and associated elastic softening [32,66]. Rutile-type is a proposed ultra-wide-bandgap semiconductor for power electronics [67,68]. Its strong elastic anisotropy is relevant to strain engineering in thin films and stress management in electronic devices [69,70].
Conclusions
In this study, we have presented a comprehensive first-principles investigation of the structural phase transitions and elastic properties of under high pressure, covering the rutile- (), CaCl- (), -PbO- (), and pyrite-type () phases. The rutile-type to
Acknowledgements
We acknowledge the National Supercomputing Mission (NSM) for providing computing resources of ‘PARAM Ananta’ at IIT Gandhinagar, which is implemented by C-DAC and supported by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) and the Department of Science and Technology (DST), Government of India. S.G. thanks CSIR-India for providing the research fellowship. R.D. would like to thank Princeton University for financial support.

Figure 9 (PDF p. 24).
Tables
References
Supplementary Material
Landau theory
The Landau Gibbs free energy expansion for a ferroelastic transition with a single order parameter coupled with strain is as follows [1].
Here, represents the Landau free energy, with as an order parameter, while and are Landau-normalized coefficients, () are the spontaneous strains, () are the order coupling parameter coefficients and are the bare elastic constants, which are unaffected by the phase transition.
The displacive phase transition from strain arrived at 18.33 GPa (), while is the pressure at which Raman modes go to zero for the rutile phase (see § 10). The normalized equations are written as:
The order parameter is related to pressure as:
The free energy can be rewritten in reduced form as:
The effective quadratic coefficient is given by:
At equilibrium, the strain components vary with as:
Strains , , and remain zero in the orthorhombic phase.
The inverse susceptibility of the order parameter is:
Elastic anomalies across the transition can be derived from second derivatives of with respect to strain components [2].
The relevant elastic constant combination is expressed in terms of the pressure deviation from the transition pressure [2, 3, 4] as:
The relationship between the susceptibility and the squared frequency can be illustrated using the potential energy of a harmonic oscillator in a double-well potential [5, 6, 7]. Assuming the Landau expansion near the equilibrium position:
And the curvature here for the free energy acts like an effective spring constant (k):
For a soft mode, the effective mass of the atom M can be written as:
This is the general equation for a harmonic oscillator, which gives:
This is the inverse of the susceptibility given by S9 and S10.
Strain Analysis
The spontaneous strains , , for a tetragonal to orthorhombic transition are defined as:
where , , and are lattice parameters of the orthorhombic CaCl-type phase; and are the lattice parameters of the tetragonal rutile-type phase extrapolated into the stability field of the CaCl-type phase.
The symmetry-breaking strain is:
If the non-symmetry-breaking strain is small, we can approximate the reference lattice constant as:
where the volume strain is expressed as:
where and are the unit-cell volumes of the orthorhombic CaCl-type phase and the extrapolated tetragonal rutile-type phase, respectively:
Critical pressure calculated from phonon calculations
The pressure dependence of the critical Raman modes of the rutile- and CaCl₂-type phases, as reported in Ref. [8], can be expressed as:
The second-order phase-transition pressure from both Raman modes ( and ) crossing () and the corresponding soft-mode critical pressure from extrapolating the Raman mode () for rutile phases, where it goes to 0 (),[6, 7] are 19.24 GPa and 35.1 GPa, respectively, as shown in Figure S2.

Figure S2. Pressure dependence of the critical Raman modes (modified after Ref. 8); for the rutile-type (red circles) and (green squares) for the -type phase.
The slope ratio of the above equation is greater than the ideal value of 2 [1]. This deviation suggests that ( and ()) make a finite contribution to the free energy and constrain the strain coupling coefficients and .
Shear and Bulk modulus calculations
We calculated the bulk () and shear () moduli using the following general expressions [9]:
The subscripts R and V represent the Reuss and Voigt bounds of the elastic moduli. represents the elastic compliance tensor (). The isotropic bulk () and shear () moduli are calculated using Hill's average, defined as the arithmetic mean of the Reuss and Voigt bounds:
Using , , and the density () of the crystal, we calculate the compressional () and shear () elastic wave velocities as:
References
- [1]Carpenter M A, Hemley R J and Mao H 2000 High-pressure elasticity of stishovite and the P₄₂/mnm⇌ Pnnm phase transition. J. Geophys. Res. Solid Earth 105 10807–16 https://doi.org/10.1029/1999JB900419
- [2]Knorr K, Loidl A and Kjems J K 1986 Ferroelastic transition in KBr: KCN studied by neutrons, X-rays and ultrasonic Physica B+C 136 311–14. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0378-4363(86)80080-8
- [3]Carpenter M A and Salje E K H 1998 Elastic anomalies in minerals due to structural phase transitions Eur. J. Mineral. 10 693–812. https://doi.org/10.1127/ejm/10/4/0693
- [4]Feile R, Loidl A and Knorr K 1982 Elastic properties of (KBr)₁₋ₓ(KCN)ₓ Phys. Rev. B 26 6875. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.26.6875
- [5]Chaikin P M and Lubensky T C 1995 Principles of Condensed Matter Physics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511813467
- [6]Bruce A D and Cowley R A 1981 Structural Phase Transitions (London: Taylor & Francis).DOI
- [7]Dove M T 1993 Introduction to Lattice Dynamics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press). https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511619885