betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

ΔΔ resonance contributions to QED radiative corrections in neutron and inverse beta decay

Abstract

We incorporate the Δ(1232)Δ(1232) resonance into pion-induced QED radiative corrections to neutron decay and inverse beta decay (IBD). Within the framework of heavy-baryon chiral perturbation theory with explicit ΔΔ degrees of freedom, we compute additional contributions and study their impact on IBD cross sections and on the renormalization of the nucleon isovector vector and axial-vector charges. ΔΔ resonance does not renormalize the vector charge. For the axial-vector charge, including the ΔΔ resonance improves convergence and reduces the QED radiative correction to the experiment-over-lattice-QCD ratio gA/(gAQCDgV)g_A/\left(g^\mathrm{QCD}_A g_V\right). ΔΔ resonance increases the pion-induced QED radiative corrections to IBD by a factor 1.21.2-1.31.3.

Prepared for submission to JHEP

Introduction

The inverse beta decay (IBD) process νˉe+p→e++n\bar{\nu}_e + p \to e^+ + n is the primary detection mechanism for reactor and supernova antineutrinos in water-based and hydrocarbon-based detectors. With next-generation experiments such as JUNO [1, 2, 3], Hyper-K [4, 5], and DUNE [6, 7] targeting percent- and sub-percent-level precision in neutrino oscillation parameters, an accurate theoretical description of the IBD cross section is a necessary input. Achieving precision demands a systematic treatment of electroweak, strong-interaction, and quantum electrodynamics (QED) radiative corrections within a controlled theoretical framework.

In the preceding papers [8, 9], we performed a detailed evaluation of QED radiative corrections to IBD within the framework of heavy-baryon chiral perturbation theory (HBChPT). Subsequently, we included explicit pion degrees of freedom in [10]. The analysis demonstrated that pion-induced electromagnetic corrections contribute at the sub-percent level to the IBD cross section, with the dominant kinematic dependence arising from leading-order pion loops in the HBChPT expansion. At next-to-leading order, recoil effects and the HBChPT Wilson coefficient c4c_4 produce only moderate modifications, well below the uncertainties from the nucleon form factors for (anti)neutrino energies up to several hundred MeV.

Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance plays a crucial role in (anti)neutrino-nucleon interactions at low and intermediate energies. In processes such as neutron decay and IBD, Δ\Delta can make significant contributions through pion-exchange and radiative-correction diagrams that are not captured by the effective theory with pions only. The chiral perturbation theory with explicit Δ\Delta degrees of freedom has been extensively developed over the past decades [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19]. This framework provides a systematic power counting for observables involving the Δ\Delta resonance, treating the Δ\Delta-nucleon mass splitting Δ0=mΔ−mN∼293\Delta_0 = m_\Delta- m_N \sim293 MeV as a small parameter compared to the chiral symmetry breaking scale. The inclusion of Δ\Delta has proven essential for achieving convergence in calculations of the nucleon isovector axial-vector charge gAg_A [20, 21, 21, 22, 23], the pion-nucleon scattering amplitudes [24? –26], and various electromagnetic observables [12, 13, 17, 27, 28, 29, 30].

In precise predictions of neutron decay and inverse beta decay, the isovector axial-vector coupling constant of the nucleon gAg_A is one of the dominant sources of uncertainty. Chiral perturbation theory predicts significant corrections to gAg_A from both pion and Δ\Delta loops [31, 32], which are essential for understanding the quark-mass dependence of gAg_A and connecting lattice quantum chromodynamics (QCD) calculations to experimental measurements. A key question concerns the electromagnetic corrections to the relation between the physical gAg_A and the QCD-defined isovector axial-vector charge, gAQCDg_A^{\mathrm{QCD}}, obtained from lattice-QCD calculations. As demonstrated in Refs. [33? –35], the QED radiative corrections to the ratio gA/(gAQCDgV)g_A/(g_A^{\mathrm{QCD}} g_V) from the matching to the pionless HBChPT can be large. Δ\Delta-resonance contributions to this matching coefficient have not been previously evaluated and may significantly affect the interpretation of the lattice-QCD results.

In this work, we extend our previous analysis of pion-induced QED radiative corrections in neutron decay and IBD by including the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance in HBChPT within the small-scale expansion power-counting scheme. We provide additional interactions involving the Δ\Delta resonance and calculate the diagrams that appear when the Δ\Delta is included as an explicit degree of freedom. We then compare the nucleon isovector axial-vector charge and IBD cross sections with and without Δ\Delta contributions.

Our analysis reveals several important findings. First, we demonstrate that the Δ\Delta-resonance contributions to the renormalization of the vector charge vanish identically, according to the Behrends-Sirlin-Ademollo-Gatto theorem [36, 37]. The corrections to the isovector axial-vector charge are of the same order as the pion contributions. Second, we show that including the Δ\Delta degrees of freedom improves the convergence of the perturbation theory in the QED radiative correction to the experiment-over-lattice-QCD ratio gA/(gAQCDgV)g_A/(g_A^{\mathrm{QCD}} g_V), reducing the size of the correction. Third, we find that the Δ\Delta resonance increases the pion-induced QED radiative corrections to the IBD cross section by a factor of 1.2 to 1.3, with the relative contribution decreasing with antineutrino energy.

The paper is organized as follows. We specify kinematics, leading-order Lagrangian, and corresponding cross sections of the IBD reaction in § 2. In § 3, we present the leading and next-to-leading-order HBChPT Lagrangian for the Δ\Delta field, relevant for QED radiative corrections in neutron decay and IBD. Section 4 provides QED radiative corrections from virtual diagrams with Δ\Delta and discusses associated bremsstrahlung. In subsection 4.1, we present the leading-order QED radiative corrections. Corrections from the next-to-leading order HBChPT Lagrangian are provided in subsection 4.2. We present numerical results for the renormalization of the nucleon isovector vector and axial-vector charges and IBD cross sections in subsection 5.1 and subsection 5.2, respectively, of § 5 and emphasize the differences between theories with and without explicit Δ\Delta degrees of freedom. Our conclusions and outlook are presented in § 6. The Wolfram Mathematica notebook and the Python library for fast and accurate evaluation of IBD cross sections are available at github.com/tomalak7/IBDxsec.

Charged-current semileptonic processes with nucleons at leading order

In this section, we specify the leading-order Lagrangian and the kinematics for charged-current semileptonic processes involving nucleons at low energies, considering the IBD reaction.

At energy scales below the pion mass, charged-current semileptonic processes with nucleons, neutron and inverse beta decay, are described by the effective Lagrangian L\mathcal{L} [8, 9, 33, 34, 38, 39, 40, 41]

L=−2GFVud∗νˉeLγρe⋅Nˉv(gVvρ−2gASρ)τ−Nv+h.c.,(1)\mathcal{L}=-\sqrt{2}G_{\mathrm{F}}V_{ud}^{*}\bar{\nu}_{eL}\gamma_{\rho}e\cdot\bar{N}_{v}\left(g_{V}v^{\rho}-2g_{A}S^{\rho}\right)\tau^{-}N_{v}+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(1)}

with the isovector vector, gVg_{V}, and the axial-vector, gAg_{A}, low-energy coupling constants (LECs), the scale-independent Fermi coupling constant GFG_{\mathrm{F}} [42, 43, 44, 45], and the Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) quark mixing matrix element VudV_{ud} [46, 47, 48, 49]. In the above expression, MM, vμ=(1,0)v^{\mu}=(1,0), and SμS^{\mu} (v⋅S=0v\cdot S=0) denote the mass, velocity, and spin of the heavy nucleon. The fields of proton pp and neutron nn are combined in the isodoublet Nv=(p,n)TN_{v}=(p,n)^{T}, while τ−=τ1−iτ22\tau^{-}=\frac{\tau^{1}-i\tau^{2}}{2} stands for the lowering operator in the isospin space with the Pauli matrices τi\tau^{i}. The electron and neutrino fields are denoted as ee and νeL\nu_{eL}, respectively.

In this paper, we evaluate Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections to IBD cross sections and renormalization of the isovector vector and axial-vector LECs, gVg_{V} and gAg_{A}. To achieve these goals, it is sufficient to consider the IBD reaction νˉep→e+n\bar{\nu}_{e}p\rightarrow e^{+}n. We denote IBD kinematics in Figure 1.

Figure 1. Kinematics in inverse beta decay.

The incoming antineutrino in the rest frame of the proton has momentum kμ=(Eνˉe,k)k^{\mu}=(E_{\bar{\nu}_{e}},\mathbf{k}), the final positron has momentum k′μ=(Ee,k′)k'^{\mu}=(E_{e},\mathbf{k}'), the initial proton has momentum pμ=(mp,0)p^{\mu}=(m_{p},0), with the proton mass mpm_{p}, and the final neutron momentum is determined by energy and momentum conservation as p′μ=pμ+kμ−k′μp'^{\mu}=p^{\mu}+k^{\mu}-k'^{\mu}. The momenta of external particles are constrained as k2=0k^{2}=0, k′2=me2k'^{2}=m_{e}^{2}, p′2=mn2p'^{2}=m_{n}^{2}, with electron mem_{e} and neutron mnm_{n} masses, respectively. The momentum transfer, qμq^{\mu}, is defined as qμ=kμ−k′μq^{\mu}=k^{\mu}-k'^{\mu}.

For convenience, we also define two independent Lorentz-invariant Mandelstam variables. The squared momentum transfer Q2Q^2,

Q2=−q2=−(p′−p)2=mp2−mn2+2mp(Eνˉe−Ee),(2)Q^2=-q^2=-(p'-p)^2=m_p^2-m_n^2+2m_p(E_{\bar{\nu}_e}-E_e), \tag*{(2)}

and the squared energy in the center-of-mass reference frame ss,

s=(p+k)2=mp2+2mpEνˉe.(3)s=(p+k)^2=m_p^2+2m_pE_{\bar{\nu}_e}. \tag*{(3)}

Inverse beta decay is kinematically allowed only for antineutrino energies above the threshold Eνˉe≥Eνˉethr=(mn+me)22mp−mp2E_{\bar{\nu}_e}\geq E_{\bar{\nu}_e}^{\mathrm{thr}}=\frac{(m_n+m_e)^2}{2m_p}-\frac{m_p}{2}, with Eνˉethr≈1.806066E_{\bar{\nu}_e}^{\mathrm{thr}}\approx1.806066 MeV. For a fixed antineutrino energy EνˉeE_{\bar{\nu}_e}, the final positron energy is bounded in the narrow range Eemin⁡≤Ee≤Eemax⁡E_e^{\min}\leq E_e\leq E_e^{\max}:

Eemin⁡=(s−mn2+me2)(mp+Eνˉe)−EνˉeΣ(s,mn2,me2)2s,(4)E_e^{\min}=\frac{(s-m_n^2+m_e^2)(m_p+E_{\bar{\nu}_e})-E_{\bar{\nu}_e}\sqrt{\Sigma(s,m_n^2,m_e^2)}}{2s}, \tag*{(4)}
Eemax⁡=(s−mn2+me2)(mp+Eνˉe)+EνˉeΣ(s,mn2,me2)2s,(5)E_e^{\max}=\frac{(s-m_n^2+m_e^2)(m_p+E_{\bar{\nu}_e})+E_{\bar{\nu}_e}\sqrt{\Sigma(s,m_n^2,m_e^2)}}{2s}, \tag*{(5)}

with the kinematic triangle function Σ(s,mn2,me2)=(s−(mn+me)2)(s−(mn−me)2)\Sigma(s,m_n^2,m_e^2)=\left(s-(m_n+m_e)^2\right)\left(s-(m_n-m_e)^2\right). Up to nucleon recoil corrections, the positron energy is related to the antineutrino energy as Ee≈Eνˉe+mp−mn+O(1mn)E_e\approx E_{\bar{\nu}_e}+m_p-m_n+\mathcal{O}\left(\frac{1}{m_n}\right).

The differential IBD cross section at leading order can be evaluated from the interaction Lagrangian in Eq. (1) as

dσLOdQ2=GF2∣Vud∣22π[(1−E0Eνˉe)(gV2+gA2)−Q2+me24Eνˉe2(gV2−gA2)],(6)\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma_{\mathrm{LO}}}{\mathrm{d}Q^2}=\frac{G_F^2|V_{ud}|^2}{2\pi}\left[\left(1-\frac{E_0}{E_{\bar{\nu}_e}}\right)(g_V^2+g_A^2)-\frac{Q^2+m_e^2}{4E_{\bar{\nu}_e}^2}(g_V^2-g_A^2)\right], \tag*{(6)}

with E0=mn2+me2−mp22mn≈1.292581E_0=\frac{m_n^2+m_e^2-m_p^2}{2m_n}\approx1.292581 MeV, approximately determined by the neutron-proton mass difference: E0≈mn−mpE_0\approx m_n-m_p. All relevant corrections to Eq. (6) are described in detail in Refs. [8, 9, 10].

Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance in HBChPT

In this section, we provide details of the HBChPT Lagrangian with explicit Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) degrees of freedom, relevant to the study of Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections. We follow the notation and conventions of Refs. [14, 26] with the most recent fit results for the relevant low-energy coupling constants to the pion-nucleon scattering data, while we take the πN\pi N interaction Lagrangian from Refs. [10, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58].

Four physical states of the Δ\Delta resonance (Δ++,Δ+,Δ0,Δ−\Delta^{++},\Delta^+,\Delta^0,\Delta^-) form a triplet. They are conveniently combined in 3 isospin doublets Ψμi\Psi_\mu^i [14]:

Ψμ1=12(Δ++−13Δ013Δ0−Δ−)μ,Ψμ2=i2(Δ+++13Δ013Δ++Δ−)μ,Ψμ3=−23(Δ+Δ0)μ,(7)\Psi_\mu^1=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}\begin{pmatrix}\Delta^{++}-\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\Delta^0\\ \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\Delta^0-\Delta^-\end{pmatrix}_{\mu},\qquad \Psi_\mu^2=\frac{i}{\sqrt{2}}\begin{pmatrix}\Delta^{++}+\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\Delta^0\\ \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\Delta^+ +\Delta^-\end{pmatrix}_{\mu},\qquad \Psi_\mu^3=-\sqrt{\frac{2}{3}}\begin{pmatrix}\Delta^+\\ \Delta^0\end{pmatrix}_{\mu}, \tag*{(7)}

with an off-shell isospin constraint τiΨμi=0\tau^i\Psi^i_\mu= 0.

In this work, we consider a small-scale expansion of the heavy-baryon formulation of chiral perturbation theory [14] and exploit spin-3/2 and isospin-3/2 projections onto light degrees of freedom TiμT^\mu_i.1

Tiμ(x)=Pv+ξ3/2ij(P^333/2)μνΨνj(x)eimnv⋅x,(8)T^\mu_i(x)=P_v^+\xi^{ij}_{3/2}\left(\widehat{P}^{3/2}_{33}\right)^{\mu\nu}\Psi^j_\nu(x)e^{im_n v\cdot x}, \tag*{(8)}

that can be obtained from the field Ψμi\Psi^i_\mu by acting with the spin projector (P^333/2)μν\left(\widehat{P}^{3/2}_{33}\right)^{\mu\nu}:

(P^333/2)μν=gμν−vμvν−41−dSμSν,(9)\left(\widehat{P}^{3/2}_{33}\right)^{\mu\nu}=g^{\mu\nu}-v^\mu v^\nu-\frac{4}{1-d}S^\mu S^\nu, \tag*{(9)}

in d=4−2ϵd=4-2\epsilon space-time dimensions, the isospin projector ξ3/2ij\xi^{ij}_{3/2}:

ξ3/2ij=23δij−i3ϵijkτk,(10)\xi^{ij}_{3/2}=\frac{2}{3}\delta^{ij}-\frac{i}{3}\epsilon^{ijk}\tau^k, \tag*{(10)}

and the projector on light degrees of freedom Pv+P_v^+:

P_v^+=\frac{1+\slashed{v}}{2}. \tag*{(11)}

The leading-order heavy-baryon πΔ\pi\Delta interaction Lagrangian LπΔ(1)\mathcal{L}^{(1)}_{\pi\Delta} is expressed in terms of the spin-3/2 isospin-3/2 projection onto light Δ\Delta degrees of freedom TiμT^\mu_i as [14]

LπΔ(1)=−T‾iμ[iv⋅Dij−Δ0δij+g1S⋅uij]gμνTjν,(12)\mathcal{L}^{(1)}_{\pi\Delta}=-\overline{T}^{\mu}_i\left[iv\cdot D^{ij}-\Delta_0\delta^{ij}+g_1S\cdot u^{ij}\right]g_{\mu\nu}T^\nu_j, \tag*{(12)}

with the Δ\Delta-nucleon mass shift Δ0=mΔ−mn≈293 MeV\Delta_0=m_\Delta-m_n\approx293\ \mathrm{MeV}, the coupling constant g1g_1, the covariant derivative DμijD^{ij}_\mu:

Dμij=δij∂μ+Γμij,(13)D^{ij}_\mu=\delta^{ij}\partial_\mu+\Gamma^{ij}_\mu, \tag*{(13)}

with the chiral connection Γμij\Gamma^{ij}_\mu

Γμij=Γμδij−iϵijk⟨τkΓμ⟩,(14)\Gamma^{ij}_\mu=\Gamma_\mu\delta^{ij}-i\epsilon^{ijk}\langle\tau^k\Gamma_\mu\rangle, \tag*{(14)}

where the trace of any object O\mathcal{O} in the isospin space is ⟨O⟩\langle\mathcal{O}\rangle, expressed in terms of the pion degrees of freedom π⃗\vec{\pi} entering uu, u2=U=eiπ⃗⋅τ⃗/Fπu^2=U=e^{i\vec{\pi}\cdot\vec{\tau}/F_\pi}, with the decay constant of the pion FπF_\pi, and external left and right sources lμl_\mu and rμr_\mu, respectively, as

Γμ=12[u(∂μ−ilμ)u†+u†(∂μ−irμ)u].(15)\Gamma_\mu=\frac{1}{2}\left[u(\partial_\mu-il_\mu)u^\dagger+u^\dagger(\partial_\mu-ir_\mu)u\right]. \tag*{(15)}

uμij=ξ3/2iluμξ3/2lju^{ij}_\mu=\xi^{il}_{3/2}u_\mu\xi^{lj}_{3/2} denotes the isospin rotated pion field uμu_\mu:

uμ=i[u†(∂μ−irμ)u−u(∂μ−ilμ)u†].(16)u_\mu=i\left[u^\dagger(\partial_\mu-ir_\mu)u-u(\partial_\mu-il_\mu)u^\dagger\right]. \tag*{(16)}

To evaluate low-energy charged-current processes with leptons and nucleons, we account for the electromagnetic and electroweak interactions through the external sources as

lμ=−eQAμ+QWγ‾μνeeL+QW†ν‾eeLγμe,(17)l_\mu=-eQA_\mu+Q_W\overline{\gamma}_\mu\nu_e e_L+Q_W^\dagger\overline{\nu}_e e_L\gamma_\mu e, \tag*{(17)}
rμ=−eQAμ,(18)r_\mu=-eQA_\mu, \tag*{(18)}

with the photon field AμA_\mu, the proton charge ee, the charge matrix Q=diag⁡(1,0)Q=\operatorname{diag}(1,0), and the electroweak matrix QW†=−22GFVud∗τ−.Q_W^\dagger=-2\sqrt{2}G_FV_{ud}^*\tau^-.

At leading order, the πNΔ\pi N\Delta interaction Lagrangian LπNΔ(1)\mathcal{L}_{\pi N\Delta}^{(1)} can be written as [14]

LπNΔ(1)=T‾iμhu‾μiN+h.c.,(19)\mathcal{L}_{\pi N\Delta}^{(1)}=\overline{T}^{\mu}_i h\overline{u}^{i}_{\mu}N+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(19)}

with the πNΔ\pi N\Delta coupling constant hh and wμi=12⟨τiuμ⟩w^i_\mu=\frac{1}{2}\langle\tau^i u_\mu\rangle.

At next-to-leading order, the relevant terms of the πNΔ\pi N\Delta interaction Lagrangian LπNΔ(2)\mathcal{L}_{\pi N\Delta}^{(2)} can be written as

LπNΔ(2)=T‾iμ[ib1fμν+Sν2mn+(b3+b6)iwμivν+b4wμiS⋅u+b5uμS⋅wi]N+h.c.−12mnT‾iμ[2d−1hg1z0uijμξjkS⋅wk+2hiDijμξjkv⋅wk]N+h.c.,(20)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{L}_{\pi N\Delta}^{(2)}={}&\overline{T}^{\mu}_i\left[\frac{i b_1 f_{\mu\nu}^{+}S^\nu}{2m_n}+(b_3+b_6)iw^i_\mu v^\nu+b_4w^i_\mu S\cdot u+b_5u_\mu S\cdot w^i\right]N+\mathrm{h.c.}\\ &-\frac{1}{2m_n}\overline{T}^{\mu}_i\left[\frac{2}{d-1}hg_1z_0u^\mu_{ij}\xi^{jk}S\cdot w^k+2hiD^\mu_{ij}\xi^{jk}v\cdot w^k\right]N+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(20)} \end{aligned}

with the NLO LECs b1b_1–b6b_6, the tensor wμνi=12⟨τi[Dμ,uν]⟩w^i_{\mu\nu}=\frac{1}{2}\langle\tau^i[D_\mu,u_\nu]\rangle, with Dμ=∂μ+ΓμD_\mu=\partial_\mu+\Gamma_\mu, fμν+=u†(∂μrν−∂νrμ−i[rμ,rν])u+u(∂μlν−∂νlμ−i[lμ,lν])u†f_{\mu\nu}^{+}=u^\dagger(\partial_\mu r_\nu-\partial_\nu r_\mu-i[r_\mu,r_\nu])u+u(\partial_\mu l_\nu-\partial_\nu l_\mu-i[l_\mu,l_\nu])u^\dagger, and the off-shell parameter z0z_0.2 To restore the explicit dd-dependence in the Lagrangian, an additional contribution to the pion-nucleon interaction Lagrangian LπN(2)\mathcal{L}_{\pi N}^{(2)} is added [14],

LπN(2)=−h22mn4d−1(2z0+(d−1)z02)N‾S⋅wiξijS⋅wjN−h22mn1d−1(4(d−2)+2(d−3)z0−z02)N‾v⋅wiξijv⋅wjN.(21)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{L}_{\pi N}^{(2)}={}&-\frac{h^2}{2m_n}\frac{4}{d-1}(2z_0+(d-1)z_0^2)\overline{N}S\cdot w^i\xi^{ij}S\cdot w^jN\\ &-\frac{h^2}{2m_n}\frac{1}{d-1}\left(4(d-2)+2(d-3)z_0-z_0^2\right)\overline{N}v\cdot w^i\xi^{ij}v\cdot w^jN. \tag*{(21)} \end{aligned}

With appropriate redefinitions of LECs, the redundant dependence on LECs b3b_3 and b4b_4 and the off-shell parameter z0z_0 disappears [19, 26].

Parts of recoil corrections and Δ\Delta contributions are generated by the following terms of the next-to-leading order πΔ\pi\Delta interaction Lagrangian LπΔ(2)\mathcal{L}_{\pi\Delta}^{(2)}:

LπΔ(2)=12mnT‾iμ[DαikDβkjgαβ−v⋅Dikv⋅Dkj−[Sα,Sβ](DαikDβkj−DβikDαkj)]gμνTjν+ig12mnT‾iμ(S⋅Dikv⋅ukj+v⋅uikS⋅Dkj)gμνTjν−T‾iμc1Δmπ2⟨U†+U⟩δijgμνTjν,(22)\begin{aligned} \mathcal{L}_{\pi\Delta}^{(2)}={}&\frac{1}{2m_n}\overline{T}^{\mu}_i\left[D^{ik}_\alpha D^{kj}_\beta g^{\alpha\beta}-v\cdot D^{ik}v\cdot D^{kj}-[S^\alpha,S^\beta]\left(D^{ik}_\alpha D^{kj}_\beta-D^{ik}_\beta D^{kj}_\alpha\right)\right]g_{\mu\nu}T^\nu_j\\ &+\frac{ig_1}{2m_n}\overline{T}^{\mu}_i\left(S\cdot D^{ik}v\cdot u^{kj}+v\cdot u^{ik}S\cdot D^{kj}\right)g_{\mu\nu}T^\nu_j-\overline{T}^{\mu}_i c_1^\Delta m_\pi^2\langle U^\dagger+U\rangle\delta^{ij}g_{\mu\nu}T^\nu_j, \tag*{(22)} \end{aligned}

where we present only the terms relevant to this work.

Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections

In this section, we evaluate QED radiative corrections to IBD cross sections and renormalization of the isovector vector gVg_V and axial-vector gAg_A LECs induced by Δ\Delta degrees of freedom at leading order in the electromagnetic coupling constant α\alpha. We evaluate contributions from leading and next-to-leading HBChPT interactions in subsections 4.1 and 4.2, respectively. We do not provide known results in the Δ\Delta-less theory [10, 33, 35] but emphasize the difference in LECs between theories with vs without explicit Δ\Delta degrees of freedom.

Leading-order HBChPT contributions

Repeating the analysis of pionless diagrams in Refs. [10, 61], we find that the sum of diagrams with virtual photon, electron, nucleon, Δ\Delta, and pion fields at LO, but without the isospin-breaking interaction, is suppressed by the electron mass and, consequently, we neglect all such diagrams, both in forward and non-forward kinematics. The same argument also applies to the Δ\Delta-induced bremsstrahlung at the amplitude level.

The remaining QED radiative corrections at LO are induced by the isospin-breaking LEC Zπ≈0.81Z_\pi\approx0.81, which generates the diagrams in Figure 2 and also gives rise to Δ\Delta-induced contributions to the proton and neutron field renormalization factors.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections without virtual photons at leading and next-to-leading order. The pion isospin-breaking vertex is shown as a square, with all possible placements of this vertex implied. The nucleon field-renormalization diagram (e) is also illustrated.

In the following, we provide the results for each diagram in Figure 2.3

a) The contribution of this diagram can be represented as the kinematic-dependent change of the vector coupling constant

δgV=2α3πh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−2)+2α9πh2Zπ(cβLOβln⁡β−1β+1−cβΔLOβΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ)+2α9πh2Zπ(4+Σγ)(23)\delta g_V = \frac{2\alpha}{3\pi}h^2 Z_\pi\left(\ln\frac{\mu^2}{m_\pi^2}+\frac{1}{\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}-2\right)+\frac{2\alpha}{9\pi}h^2 Z_\pi\left(\frac{c_\beta^{\mathrm{LO}}}{\beta}\ln\frac{\beta-1}{\beta+1}-\frac{c_{\beta_\Delta}^{\mathrm{LO}}}{\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}\right)+\frac{2\alpha}{9\pi}h^2 Z_\pi\left(4+\frac{\Sigma}{\gamma}\right) \tag*{(23)}
1ϵ−γE+ln⁡(4π)+1.(24)\frac{1}{\epsilon}-\gamma_E+\ln(4\pi)+1. \tag*{(24)}

In the evaluation, we have reproduced the master integrals from Refs. [62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72].

with βΔ=1−mπ2Δ02\beta_{\Delta}=\sqrt{1-\frac{m_{\pi}^{2}}{\Delta_{0}^{2}}}, β=1+4me2Q2\beta=\sqrt{1+\frac{4m_{e}^{2}}{Q^{2}}}, γ=Q2Δ0\gamma=\frac{Q}{2\Delta_{0}}, the sum Σ\Sigma,

Σ=∑σ1,σ2=±1σ1(Li⁡21−σ1γ1−σ2βγ+Li⁡21+σ11+σ2βΔ/γ)(25)\Sigma=\sum_{\sigma_{1},\sigma_{2}=\pm1}\sigma_{1}\left(\operatorname{Li}_{2}\frac{1-\sigma_{1}\gamma}{1-\sigma_{2}\beta\gamma}+\operatorname{Li}_{2}\frac{1+\sigma_{1}}{1+\sigma_{2}\beta_{\Delta}/\gamma}\right) \tag*{(25)}

and the coefficients cβLOc_{\beta}^{\mathrm{LO}} and cβΔLOc_{\beta_{\Delta}}^{\mathrm{LO}} defined as

cβLO=1+2β2−1βΔ2−γ2,(26)c_{\beta}^{\mathrm{LO}}=1+2\beta^{2}-\frac{1}{\beta_{\Delta}^{2}-\gamma^{2}}, \tag*{(26)}
cβΔLO=2−γ2βΔ2−γ2,(27)c_{\beta_{\Delta}}^{\mathrm{LO}}=2-\frac{\gamma^{2}}{\beta_{\Delta}^{2}-\gamma^{2}}, \tag*{(27)}

and a non-factorizable correction to the IBD cross section

dσdQ2=29απh2ZπΣGF2∣Vud∣22πQEνegA.(28)\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma}{\mathrm{d}Q^{2}}=\frac{2}{9}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}h^{2}Z_{\pi}\Sigma\frac{G_{F}^{2}|V_{ud}|^{2}}{2\pi}\frac{Q}{E_{\nu_{e}}}g_{A}. \tag*{(28)}

b) Neglecting terms suppressed by the electron mass and recoil απEνemn\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{E_{\nu_{e}}}{m_{n}}, this diagram does not contribute to charged-current semileptonic processes with a nucleon.

c) This diagram is absent at LO HBChPT.

d) This diagram contributes only to the renormalization of the isovector vector and axial-vector LECs as

δgV=−2απh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−2),(29)\delta g_{V}=-2\frac{\alpha}{\pi}h^{2}Z_{\pi}\left(\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{m_{\pi}^{2}}+\frac{1}{\beta_{\Delta}}\ln\frac{1-\beta_{\Delta}}{1+\beta_{\Delta}}-2\right), \tag*{(29)}
δgAgA(0)=−1027απg1gA(0)h2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−4615),(30)\frac{\delta g_{A}}{g_{A}^{(0)}}=-\frac{10}{27}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{g_{1}}{g_{A}^{(0)}}h^{2}Z_{\pi}\left(\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{m_{\pi}^{2}}+\frac{1}{\beta_{\Delta}}\ln\frac{1-\beta_{\Delta}}{1+\beta_{\Delta}}-\frac{46}{15}\right), \tag*{(30)}

with the nucleon isovector axial-vector coupling constant in the chiral limit gA(0)g_{A}^{(0)}.

d*) In addition to the contributions with a Δ\Delta inside the virtual loop, the πNΔ\pi N\Delta interactions in Eq. (19) generate a diagram in topology (d) containing one nucleon and one Δ\Delta propagator. This diagram contributes to the isovector axial-vector LEC as

δgAgA(0)=−43απh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ+23−πmπΔ0).(31)\frac{\delta g_{A}}{g_{A}^{(0)}}=-\frac{4}{3}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}h^{2}Z_{\pi}\left(\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{m_{\pi}^{2}}+\beta_{\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_{\Delta}}{1+\beta_{\Delta}}+\frac{2}{3}-\frac{\pi m_{\pi}}{\Delta_{0}}\right). \tag*{(31)}

e) The nucleon field renormalization factors renormalize the isovector vector and axial-vector LECs as follows:

δgV=δgAgA(0)=4α3πh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−2).(32)\delta g_{V}=\frac{\delta g_{A}}{g_{A}^{(0)}}=\frac{4\alpha}{3\pi}h^{2}Z_{\pi}\left(\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{m_{\pi}^{2}}+\frac{1}{\beta_{\Delta}}\ln\frac{1-\beta_{\Delta}}{1+\beta_{\Delta}}-2\right). \tag*{(32)}

Combining all pieces, we obtain the Δ\Delta-induced renormalization of the isovector vector and axial-vector LECs at leading order

δgVLO=0,(33)\delta g_{V}^{\mathrm{LO}} = 0, \tag*{(33)}
δgALOgA(0)=4α3πh2Zπ[(1−518g1gA(0))(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−2)+827g1gA(0)]−4α3πh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ+23−πmπΔ0).(34)\begin{aligned} \frac{\delta g_{A}^{\mathrm{LO}}}{g_{A}^{(0)}} ={}& \frac{4\alpha}{3\pi}h^{2}Z_{\pi}\left[\left(1-\frac{5}{18}\frac{g_{1}}{g_{A}^{(0)}}\right)\left(\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{m_{\pi}^{2}}+\frac{1}{\beta_{\Delta}}\ln\frac{1-\beta_{\Delta}}{1+\beta_{\Delta}}-2\right)+\frac{8}{27}\frac{g_{1}}{g_{A}^{(0)}}\right] \\ &-\frac{4\alpha}{3\pi}h^{2}Z_{\pi}\left(\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{m_{\pi}^{2}}+\beta_{\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_{\Delta}}{1+\beta_{\Delta}}+\frac{2}{3}-\frac{\pi m_{\pi}}{\Delta_{0}}\right). \tag*{(34)} \end{aligned}

In agreement with the Behrends-Sirlin-Ademollo-Gatto theorem [36, 37], the vector coupling constant gVg_{V} does not get renormalized. Contributions in Eqs. (33) and (34) are included in the LECs gVg_{V} and gAg_{A} in the calculation of the effective field theory without pions. The remaining kinematic dependence of the LO Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections can be expressed as the kinematic-dependent part of the vector coupling constant shift in Eq. (23) and the non-factorizable IBD cross section in Eq. (28).

Next-to-leading-order HBChPT contributions

As for leading-order corrections, the next-to-leading-order contribution from the sum of diagrams with virtual photon, electron, nucleon, Δ\Delta fields, and pions, but without isospin-breaking interaction and b1b_{1} coupling, in virtual and real radiative corrections is suppressed by the electron mass and can be neglected. In contrast to the pion-induced QED contribution at NLO [10], the Δ\Delta resonance does not generate a diagram with a five-point, pionless, four-fermion-photon vertex at NLO. Therefore, neither corrections of order απEνmn\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{E_{\nu}}{m_{n}} to IBD nor corrections of order απΔ0mn\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{\Delta_{0}}{m_{n}} to the renormalization of LECs are generated by NLO interactions at 5.

All Δ\Delta-induced NLO QED radiative corrections are described by diagrams in Figure 2, with recoil or NLO vertices on the baryon side, and the pionless triangle diagrams with the photon from the magnetic dipole N→ΔN \to\Delta transition entering with the LEC b1b_{1}. All contributions from the pion isospin-breaking interaction are manifestly gauge-invariant and do not generate any bremsstrahlung at the order of the calculation in this paper, both at LO and NLO HBChPT. Consequently, all radiation from the LO HBChPT interactions and Δ\Delta-induced radiation at NLO, excluding contributions from b1b_{1}, is suppressed by the electron mass and therefore does not require precise calculations. Neglecting the renormalization of the nucleon magnetic moments and higher-order operators, as well as the electron-mass-suppressed terms, we provide the NLO contributions from each topology in Figure 2 as follows.

a) The contribution of this diagram, after removing the renormalization of the nucleon magnetic moments and higher-order operators, can be represented as the kinematicdependent change of the vector coupling constant

δgV=2απΔ0mnh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1+5βΔ26βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−1)+29απΔ0mnh2Zπ(βΔ2−γ2)Σγ+29απΔ0mnh2Zπ(cβNLOβln⁡β−1β+1−cβΔNLOβΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ+5−βΔ2βΔ2−γ2).(35)\begin{aligned} \delta g_V = 2\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{\Delta_0}{m_n}h^2 Z_\pi\left(\ln\frac{\mu^2}{m_\pi^2}+\frac{1+5\beta_\Delta^2}{6\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}-1\right)+\frac{2}{9}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{\Delta_0}{m_n}h^2 Z_\pi(\beta_\Delta^2-\gamma^2)\frac{\Sigma}{\gamma} \\ &+\frac{2}{9}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{\Delta_0}{m_n}h^2 Z_\pi\left(\frac{c_\beta^{\mathrm{NLO}}}{\beta}\ln\frac{\beta-1}{\beta+1}-\frac{c_{\beta_\Delta}^{\mathrm{NLO}}}{\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}+5-\frac{\beta_\Delta^2}{\beta_\Delta^2-\gamma^2}\right). \tag*{(35)} \end{aligned}

with the coefficients cβNLOc_\beta^{\mathrm{NLO}} and cβΔNLOc_{\beta_\Delta}^{\mathrm{NLO}} defined as

cβNLO=2β2βΔ2−γ2βΔ2−γ2+γ2(βΔ2−γ2)2,(36)c_\beta^{\mathrm{NLO}}=\frac{2\beta^2\beta_\Delta^2-\gamma^2}{\beta_\Delta^2-\gamma^2}+\frac{\gamma^2}{\left(\beta_\Delta^2-\gamma^2\right)^2}, \tag*{(36)}
cβΔNLO=2βΔ2−12βΔ2γ2βΔ2−γ2+βΔ2γ2(βΔ2−γ2)2+32γ2βΔ2−γ2,(37)c_{\beta_\Delta}^{\mathrm{NLO}}=2\beta_\Delta^2-\frac{1}{2}\frac{\beta_\Delta^2\gamma^2}{\beta_\Delta^2-\gamma^2}+\frac{\beta_\Delta^2\gamma^2}{\left(\beta_\Delta^2-\gamma^2\right)^2}+\frac{3}{2}\frac{\gamma^2}{\beta_\Delta^2-\gamma^2}, \tag*{(37)}

and a non-factorizable correction to the IBD cross section

dσdQ2=19απQmnh2Zπγ2βΔ2−γ2(βln⁡β−1β+1−1βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ)GF2∣Vud∣22πQEνegA.(38)\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma}{\mathrm{d}Q^2}=\frac{1}{9}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{Q}{m_n}h^2Z_\pi\frac{\gamma^2}{\beta_\Delta^2-\gamma^2}\left(\beta\ln\frac{\beta-1}{\beta+1}-\frac{1}{\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}\right)\frac{G_F^2|V_{ud}|^2}{2\pi}\frac{Q}{E_{\nu_e}}g_A. \tag*{(38)}

b) Recoil corrections renormalize the vector coupling constant as

δgV=−43απΔ0mnh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ).(39)\delta g_V=-\frac{4}{3}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{\Delta_0}{m_n}h^2Z_\pi\left(\ln\frac{\mu^2}{m_\pi^2}+\beta_\Delta\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}\right). \tag*{(39)}

NLO HBChPT interactions contribute to the renormalization of the nucleon isovector axial-vector coupling constant at next-to-leading order as

δgAgA(0)=2απhΔ0(179b5+2b4)Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ+29)+28α81πhΔ0b5Zπ.(40)\frac{\delta g_A}{g_A^{(0)}}=2\frac{\alpha}{\pi}h\Delta_0\left(\frac{17}{9}b_5+2b_4\right)Z_\pi\left(\ln\frac{\mu^2}{m_\pi^2}+\beta_\Delta\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}+\frac{2}{9}\right)+\frac{28\alpha}{81\pi}h\Delta_0b_5Z_\pi. \tag*{(40)}

Neglecting the renormalization of the nucleon magnetic moments and higher-order operators, this diagram does not produce a kinematic-dependent non-factorizable contribution to the IBD cross section.

b*) In addition to contributions with Δ\Delta inside the virtual loop, contact nucleon-nucleon interactions in Eq. (21) generate the diagram in topology (b) with a nucleon propagator. However, the part of this diagram that is independent of the off-shell parameter z0z_0 vanishes in both forward and non-forward kinematics, while the dependence on z0z_0 is removed by the shift in NLO LECs [26],

b4→b4−23g1mnh1d−1z0,(41)b_4\rightarrow b_4-\frac{2}{3}\frac{g_1}{m_n}h\frac{1}{d-1}z_0, \tag*{(41)}
b5→b5+g1mnh1d−1z0.(42)b_5\rightarrow b_5+\frac{g_1}{m_n}h\frac{1}{d-1}z_0. \tag*{(42)}

c) This diagram contributes only the terms that depend on the off-shell parameter z0z_0.

These terms are removed by the shift in the NLO LEC c4c_4 [26]

c4→c4−13h2mn1d−1(2z0+(d−1)z02).(43)c_4 \to c_4 - \frac{1}{3}\frac{h^2}{m_n}\frac{1}{d-1}\left(2z_0+(d-1)z_0^2\right). \tag*{(43)}

d) The contribution of this diagram can be represented as the kinematic-dependent change of the isovector vector and axial-vector coupling constants

δgV=−2απΔ0mnh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1+βΔ22βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−3)+απQ2mnΔ0h2Zπ1βΔ2(1+1−βΔ22βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ),(44)\delta g_V=-2\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{\Delta_0}{m_n}h^2Z_\pi\left(\ln\frac{\mu^2}{m_\pi^2}+\frac{1+\beta_\Delta^2}{2\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}-3\right) +\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{Q^2}{m_n\Delta_0}h^2Z_\pi\frac{1}{\beta_\Delta^2}\left(1+\frac{1-\beta_\Delta^2}{2\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}\right), \tag*{(44)}
δgAgA(0)=−1027απg1gA(0)Δ0mnh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1+βΔ22βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−373)+527απg1gA(0)Q2mnΔ0h2Zπ1βΔ2(1+1−βΔ22βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ).(45)\frac{\delta g_A}{g_A^{(0)}}=-\frac{10}{27}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{g_1}{g_A^{(0)}}\frac{\Delta_0}{m_n}h^2Z_\pi\left(\ln\frac{\mu^2}{m_\pi^2}+\frac{1+\beta_\Delta^2}{2\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}-\frac{37}{3}\right) +\frac{5}{27}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{g_1}{g_A^{(0)}}\frac{Q^2}{m_n\Delta_0}h^2Z_\pi\frac{1}{\beta_\Delta^2}\left(1+\frac{1-\beta_\Delta^2}{2\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}\right). \tag*{(45)}

d*) In addition to contributions with Δ\Delta inside the virtual loop, the diagram in topology (d) with one nucleon and one Δ\Delta propagator is also present. This diagram contributes to the kinematic-dependent change of the isovector axial-vector LEC

δgAgA(0)=−8027απΔ0mnh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ+1360)−13απQ2mnΔ0h2Zπ1βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ.(46)\frac{\delta g_A}{g_A^{(0)}}=-\frac{80}{27}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{\Delta_0}{m_n}h^2Z_\pi\left(\ln\frac{\mu^2}{m_\pi^2}+\beta_\Delta\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}+\frac{13}{60}\right)-\frac{1}{3}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{Q^2}{m_n\Delta_0}h^2Z_\pi\frac{1}{\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}. \tag*{(46)}

e) NLO HBChPT interactions contribute to the proton and neutron field renormalization factors as recoil corrections

δgV=δgAgA(0)=43απΔ0mnh2Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1+βΔ22βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−3).(47)\delta g_V=\frac{\delta g_A}{g_A^{(0)}}=\frac{4}{3}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{\Delta_0}{m_n}h^2Z_\pi\left(\ln\frac{\mu^2}{m_\pi^2}+\frac{1+\beta_\Delta^2}{2\beta_\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_\Delta}{1+\beta_\Delta}-3\right). \tag*{(47)}

The results for the nucleon field renormalization factors can be readily applied to all low-energy processes involving the nucleon.

Additionally, the pionless triangle diagrams with the magnetic dipole N→ΔN\to\Delta transition contribute to the isovector axial-vector coupling constant as

δgAgA(0)=19απhb1Δ0mn(ln⁡μ24Δ02−43),(48)\frac{\delta g_A}{g_A^{(0)}}=\frac{1}{9}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}h b_1\frac{\Delta_0}{m_n}\left(\ln\frac{\mu^2}{4\Delta_0^2}-\frac{4}{3}\right), \tag*{(48)}

up to corrections suppressed by the positron mass and/or energy. After subtracting the decoupling-breaking terms [25, 26] that diverge in the limit Δ0→∞\Delta_0\to\infty, the contribution of the triangle diagrams vanishes.

Combining all pieces, we obtain the renormalization of the isovector vector and axialvector coupling constants at next-to-leading order

δgVNLO=0,(49)\delta g_{V}^{\mathrm{NLO}}=0, \tag*{(49)}
δgANLOgA(0)=43απΔ0mnh2Zπ[(1−518g1gA(0))(ln⁡μ2mπ2+1+βΔ22βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ−3)+7027g1gA(0)−1327]+2απhΔ0(2b4+179b5−4027hmn)Zπ(ln⁡μ2mπ2+βΔln⁡1−βΔ1+βΔ+29)+19απhb1Δ0mn(ln⁡μ24Δ02−43)+2881απΔ0b5Zπ.(50)\begin{aligned} \frac{\delta g_{A}^{\mathrm{NLO}}}{g_{A}^{(0)}}={}&\frac{4}{3}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\frac{\Delta_{0}}{m_{n}}h^{2}Z_{\pi}\left[\left(1-\frac{5}{18}\frac{g_{1}}{g_{A}^{(0)}}\right)\left(\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{m_{\pi}^{2}}+\frac{1+\beta_{\Delta}^{2}}{2\beta_{\Delta}}\ln\frac{1-\beta_{\Delta}}{1+\beta_{\Delta}}-3\right)+\frac{70}{27}\frac{g_{1}}{g_{A}^{(0)}}-\frac{13}{27}\right]\\ &+2\frac{\alpha}{\pi}h\Delta_{0}\left(2b_{4}+\frac{17}{9}b_{5}-\frac{40}{27}\frac{h}{m_{n}}\right)Z_{\pi}\left(\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{m_{\pi}^{2}}+\beta_{\Delta}\ln\frac{1-\beta_{\Delta}}{1+\beta_{\Delta}}+\frac{2}{9}\right)\\ &+\frac{1}{9}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}hb_{1}\frac{\Delta_{0}}{m_{n}}\left(\ln\frac{\mu^{2}}{4\Delta_{0}^{2}}-\frac{4}{3}\right)+\frac{28}{81}\frac{\alpha}{\pi}\Delta_{0}b_{5}Z_{\pi}. \tag*{(50)} \end{aligned}

In agreement with the Behrends-Sirlin-Ademollo-Gatto theorem [36, 37], the vector coupling constant gVg_{V} does not renormalize, with the vanishing result separately for recoil corrections to the Δ\Delta propagator from Eq. (22), recoil corrections to the interactions in the second line in Eq. (20), as well as NLO contributions from the Wilson coefficients c1Δc_{1}^{\Delta}, b1b_{1}-b6b_{6}. By directly evaluating contributions from the Lagrangian in Eq. (20), we find that the redundant πN\pi N scattering NLO Wilson coefficients b3b_{3} and b6b_{6} [26] do not contribute at NLO. The dependence on the off-shell parameter z0z_{0} is removed by the shift in NLO LECs [26],

c3→c3−131mnh21d−1(2z0+(d−1)z02),(51)c_{3}\to c_{3}-\frac{1}{3}\frac{1}{m_{n}}h^{2}\frac{1}{d-1}\left(2z_{0}+(d-1)z_{0}^{2}\right), \tag*{(51)}
c4→c4−131mnh21d−1(2z0+(d−1)z02),(52)c_{4}\to c_{4}-\frac{1}{3}\frac{1}{m_{n}}h^{2}\frac{1}{d-1}\left(2z_{0}+(d-1)z_{0}^{2}\right), \tag*{(52)}
b4→b4−23g1mnh1d−1z0,(53)b_{4}\to b_{4}-\frac{2}{3}\frac{g_{1}}{m_{n}}h\frac{1}{d-1}z_{0}, \tag*{(53)}
b5→b5+g1mnh1d−1z0,(54)b_{5}\to b_{5}+\frac{g_{1}}{m_{n}}h\frac{1}{d-1}z_{0}, \tag*{(54)}

in agreement with the independence of matrix elements from the off-shell parameter z0z_{0} [19, 26]. Contributions in Eqs. (49) and (50) are included in the LECs gVg_{V} and gAg_{A} in the calculation of the effective field theory without pions. The remaining kinematic dependence of the NLO Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections can be expressed as the kinematic-dependent part of the isovector vector and axial-vector coupling constant shifts in Eqs. (35), (44), (45), and (46) and the non-factorizable IBD cross section in Eq. (38). The Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections to the kinematic dependence of IBD cross sections are independent of the NLO HBChPT LECs.

Results and Discussion

In this section, we present results for the pion- and Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections at LO and NLO HBChPT. In § 5.1, we study the renormalization of the isovector vector and the axial-vector coupling constants. In § 5.2, we provide kinematic-dependent QED radiative corrections to IBD cross sections. For all results in § 5.1, we subtract the decoupling-breaking terms [25, 26, 73] from expressions in section 4.

%Δ-less, p2p^2Δ-less, p3p^3Δ-less, p4p^4p2p^2p3p^3p4p^4
π LO0.99(0.18)0.99(0.18)0.99(0.18)0.99(0.18)0.99(0.18)0.99(0.18)
Δ LO----0.30.4
π NLO2.01.91.40.61.00.3
Δ NLO-----0.10.7
other [10]0.16 (0.30)0.16 (0.30)0.16 (0.30)0.16 (0.30)0.16 (0.30)0.16 (0.30)
total3.1 (0.4)3.0 (0.4)2.6 (0.4)1.7(0.4)2.3(0.4)2.5 (0.4)

Table 1. Pion- and Δ-induced QED radiative corrections to gAgAQCDgV−1\frac{g_A}{g_A^{\mathrm{QCD}}g_V}-1 are presented. Results are evaluated for HBChPT Wilson coefficients obtained from fits in Refs. [25, 26] at O(p2)\mathcal{O}(p^2), O(p3)\mathcal{O}(p^3), and O(p4)\mathcal{O}(p^4), employing the complex mass approach, and in the Δ-less theory. For O(p3)\mathcal{O}(p^3), only recoil NLO contributions from the Δ resonance are included.

Renormalization of gVg_V and gAg_A

The vector coupling constant gVg_V does not renormalize at leading and next-to-leading orders, according to the Behrends-Sirlin-Ademollo-Gatto theorem [36, 37]. The contribution of the Δ resonance to the renormalization of the isovector axial-vector coupling constant depends on the LECs hh and g1g_1 at LO and, in addition, on the Wilson coefficients b4b_4 and b5b_5 at NLO. In the following table 1, we compare the pion-induced QED radiative corrections to the nucleon isovector axial-vector charge to the contribution from loops with Δ and provide the resulting correction to gAgAQCDgV\frac{g_A}{g_A^{\mathrm{QCD}}g_V} [35], for comparison with lattice-QCD determinations of the nucleon isovector axial-vector charge gAQCDg_A^{\mathrm{QCD}}. We exploit an exact cancellation pattern observed between the HBChPT radiative corrections and the matching coefficient to the Standard Model [34], evaluate the results of this paper for the Δ-induced infrared parts of the nucleon matrix elements, and take estimates of the nucleon contribution to these matrix elements from Ref. [35]. To obtain numerical results, we exploit fits to πN\pi N scattering data in Δ-less theory from Ref. [25], with subthreshold parameters constrained by Roy-Steiner analysis, and fits in the theory with Δ from Ref. [26], for the complex mass approach. We investigate the convergence of the HBChPT by presenting the results for fits at O(p2)\mathcal{O}(p^2), O(p3)\mathcal{O}(p^3), and O(p4)\mathcal{O}(p^4). For O(p3)\mathcal{O}(p^3), we take b4=b5=0b_4=b_5=0 and provide only the recoil NLO contribution.

We find that including the Δ resonance in HBChPT improves the convergence of the perturbation theory. Δ resonance reduce the total QED radiative correction in the ratio gAgAQCDgV\frac{g_A}{g_A^{\mathrm{QCD}}g_V}. Within the uncertainty estimate procedure of Ref. [35], i.e., adding in quadrature the uncertainties from the scale variation between mnm_n and 2mn\sqrt{2}m_n of the LO pion-induced QED contributions to nucleon matrix elements and the difference between two evaluation methods for the nucleon contribution to nonperturbative matrix elements, we find that the total pion-induced QED radiative correction is 2.5(0.4)%2.5(0.4)\%.4

QED radiative corrections in IBD

In Figure 3, we present the ratio of the Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections to the leading-order IBD cross section as a function of the recoil positron energy for antineutrino energies Eνˉe=10E_{\bar{\nu}_e}=10 MeV, 30 MeV, 55 MeV, and 150 MeV. The kinematic-dependent part of the radiative corrections and the separate contributions start from zero at forward scattering, corresponding to the largest recoil positron energy. As with kinematic-dependent pion-induced contributions, QED radiative corrections from diagrams with virtual Δ\Delta fields are determined by LO HBChPT interactions with negligible effects from the NLO HBChPT Lagrangian up to energies around 150 MeV. Δ\Delta-induced effects are smaller than the contributions from diagrams only with pions. However, these two corrections have the same sign and order of magnitude over all (anti)neutrino energies. Including the Δ\Delta resonance increases the magnitude of the kinematic-dependent QED radiative corrections from diagrams with virtual pions by a factor 1.2 to 1.3. The relative contribution of Δ\Delta loops decreases with the (anti)neutrino energy. Δ\Delta-resonance contributions are below the uncertainty from the isovector axial-vector form factor [74, 75] across all energies considered. Precise IBD cross sections at supernova energies and above can be obtained only with improved results for the isovector axial-vector form factor and the HBChPT Wilson coefficients in theories with explicit Δ\Delta degrees of freedom.

Image not extracted

Figure 3. The ratio of the Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative contributions to the leading-order cross section σLO\sigma_{\mathrm{LO}} is shown as a function of the recoil positron energy EeE_e for (anti)neutrino beam energies Eνˉe=10E_{\bar{\nu}_e}=10 MeV, 30 MeV, 55 MeV, and 150 MeV. The dashed lines show the sum of pion-induced QED contributions at LO and NLO (without Δ\Delta), the dotted lines show the Δ\Delta contributions at LO, and the sum of LO and NLO Δ\Delta contributions is shown by dash-dotted lines. The total QED radiative corrections in the HBChPT with explicit Δ\Delta degrees of freedom are shown by solid lines. The HBChPT fit parameters are taken from fits to πN\pi N scattering data [25, 26], with constraints from the Roy-Steiner analysis, while the additional constants are the same as in Refs. [10, 35]. The fits are represented by the following colours: p4p^4 in black (the lowest curves), p3p^3 in green (2nd from the bottom). Other fits are illustrated in lighter colours.

Conclusions and Outlook

In this paper, we include contributions from the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance to pion-induced QED radiative corrections in low-energy charged-current processes with nucleons within the framework of heavy-baryon chiral perturbation theory.

Contributions to the vector coupling constant vanish, in agreement with the Behrends-Sirlin-Ademollo-Gatto theorem. Corrections to the isovector axial-vector charge have the same magnitude as corrections from the diagrams with pions only and depend on the leading-order and next-to-leading-order Wilson coefficients b4b_4 and b5b_5. Including the Δ\Delta degrees of freedom improves the HBChPT convergence in the QED radiative correction and reduces QED radiative corrections to the experiment-over-lattice-QCD ratio gAgAQCDgV\frac{g_A}{g_A^{\mathrm{QCD}}g_V}.

Within the precision of our analysis, the Δ\Delta-induced QED radiative corrections to the kinematic dependence of IBD cross sections are independent of the NLO HBChPT LECs. Δ\Delta contributions are smaller than corrections with pions only, but have a similar magnitude. Δ\Delta resonance increases the magnitude of the kinematic-dependent QED radiative correction by a factor 1.2 to 1.3 compared to the contribution from pions only. The relative correction from Δ\Delta loops decreases with the (anti)neutrino energy and represents the subdominant source of uncertainty in precise predictions of IBD, after errors from the CKM matrix element VudV_{ud}, the isovector axial-vector charge gAg_A, and the isovector axial-vector form factor. Future experimental, phenomenological, and lattice-QCD efforts are essential to reduce these error sources.

Acknowledgments

We thank Zhewen Mo for discussions and his help in preparing the figures while working on the preceding project, and Luis Alvarez Ruso for useful communication. Near completion of this work, a paper [73] with partially overlapping research appeared on arXiv, which helped us verify the completeness of relevant interactions and Feynman diagrams. We also acknowledge Emanuele Mereghetti for a subsequent verification of results with [73]. This work is supported by the National Science Foundation of China under Grants No. 12347105, 12525504, and 12447101. In this work, FeynCalc [76, 77, 78], Mathematica [79], and DataGraph [80] were used.

References

  1. [1]JUNO collaboration, Neutrino Physics with JUNO, J. Phys. G 43 (2016) 030401 [1507.05613].
  2. [2]JUNO collaboration, JUNO Conceptual Design Report, 1508.07166.
  3. [3]JUNO collaboration, JUNO physics and detector, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 123 (2022) 103927 [2104.02565].
  4. [4]Hyper-Kamiokande collaboration, Physics potential of a long-baseline neutrino oscillation experiment using a J-PARC neutrino beam and Hyper-Kamiokande, PTEP 2015 (2015) 053C02 [1502.05199].
  5. [5]Hyper-Kamiokande collaboration, Hyper-Kamiokande Design Report, 1805.04163.
  6. [6]DUNE collaboration, Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE), Far Detector Technical Design Report, Volume II: DUNE Physics, 2002.03005.
  7. [7]DUNE collaboration, Deep Underground Neutrino Experiment (DUNE) Near Detector Conceptual Design Report, Instruments 5 (2021) 31 [2103.13910].
  8. [8]O. Tomalak, Theory of inverse beta decay for reactor antineutrinos, 2512.07956.DOI
  9. [9]O. Tomalak, On radiative corrections to inverse beta decay at low energies, 2512.07957.
  10. [10]O. Tomalak, QED radiative corrections in inverse beta decay from virtual pions, JHEP 07 (2026) 201 [2604.07113].DOI
  11. [11]E.E. Jenkins and A.V. Manohar, Baryon chiral perturbation theory using a heavy fermion Lagrangian, Phys. Lett. B 255 (1991) 558.DOI
  12. [12]T.R. Hemmert, B.R. Holstein and J. Kambor, Systematic 1/M expansion for spin 3/2 particles in baryon chiral perturbation theory, Phys. Lett. B 395 (1997) 89 [hep-ph/9606456].
  13. [13]T.R. Hemmert, B.R. Holstein and J. Kambor, Delta (1232) and the polarizabilities of the nucleon, Phys. Rev. D 55 (1997) 5598 [hep-ph/9612374].DOI
  14. [14]T.R. Hemmert, B.R. Holstein and J. Kambor, Chiral Lagrangians and delta(1232) interactions: Formalism, J. Phys. G 24 (1998) 1831 [hep-ph/9712496].
  15. [15]J. Kambor, The Delta (1232) as an effective degree of freedom in chiral perturbation theory, Lect. Notes Phys. 513 (1998) 138 [hep-ph/9711484].DOI
  16. [16]N. Fettes and U.G. Meissner, Pion - nucleon scattering in an effective chiral field theory with explicit spin 3/2 fields, Nucl. Phys. A 679 (2001) 629 [hep-ph/0006299].DOI
  17. [17]V. Pascalutsa and D.R. Phillips, Effective theory of the delta(1232) in Compton scattering off the nucleon, Phys. Rev. C 67 (2003) 055202 [nucl-th/0212024].
  18. [18]L.S. Geng, J. Martin Camalich, L. Alvarez-Ruso and M.J. Vicente Vacas, Leading SU(3)-breaking corrections to the baryon magnetic moments in Chiral Perturbation Theory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101 (2008) 222002 [0805.1419].
  19. [19]H. Krebs, E. Epelbaum and U.G. Meissner, Redundancy of the off-shell parameters in chiral effective field theory with explicit spin-3/2 degrees of freedom, Phys. Lett. B 683 (2010) 222 [0905.2744].DOI
  20. [20]M. Procura, B.U. Musch, T.R. Hemmert and W. Weise, Chiral extrapolation of g(A) with explicit Delta(1232) degrees of freedom, Phys. Rev. D 75 (2007) 014503 [hep-lat/0610105].DOI
  21. [21]Z.B. Hall et al., Signs of nonmonotonic finite-volume corrections to gA, Phys. Rev. C 113 (2026) 055206 [2503.09891].DOI
  22. [22]F. Alvarado and L. Alvarez-Ruso, Light-quark mass dependence of the nucleon axial charge and pion-nucleon scattering phenomenology, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 074001 [2112.14076].DOI
  23. [23]F. Alvarado and L. Alvarez-Ruso, Extraction of the nucleon axial form factor from Lattice QCD using NLO chiral perturbation theory, 2606.30834.
  24. [25]D. Siemens, V. Bernard, E. Epelbaum, A.M. Gasparyan, H. Krebs and U.-G. Meißner, Elastic and inelastic pion-nucleon scattering to fourth order in chiral perturbation theory, Phys. Rev. C 96 (2017) 055205 [1704.08988].DOI
  25. [26]D. Siemens, Elastic pion-nucleon scattering in chiral perturbation theory: Explicit Λ(1232) degrees of freedom, 2001.03906.
  26. [27]O. Scholten, S. Kondratyuk, L. Van Daele, D. van Neck, M. Waroquier and A.Y. Korchin, Compton scattering on the proton and light nuclei in the Delta-resonance region, Acta Phys. Polon. B 33 (2002) 847.
  27. [28]V. Pascalutsa and M. Vanderhaeghen, Chiral effective-field theory in the Delta(1232) region: I. Pion electroproduction on the nucleon, Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006) 034003 [hep-ph/0512244].
  28. [29]V. Pascalutsa, M. Vanderhaeghen and S.N. Yang, Electromagnetic excitation of the Delta(1232)-resonance, Phys. Rept. 437 (2007) 125 [hep-ph/0609004].
  29. [30]V. Lensky and V. Pascalutsa, Predictive powers of chiral perturbation theory in Compton scattering off protons, Eur. Phys. J. C 65 (2010) 195 [0907.0451].DOI
  30. [31]V. Bernard and U.-G. Meißner, The Nucleon axial-vector coupling beyond one loop, Phys. Lett. B 639 (2006) 278 [hep-lat/0605010].DOI
  31. [32]V. Bernard, J. Gegelia, S. Ghosh and U.-G. Meißner, Calculation of the axial-vector coupling constant g_A to two loops in covariant chiral perturbation theory, Phys. Lett. B 868 (2025) 139637 [2505.05941].DOI
  32. [33]V. Cirigliano, J. de Vries, L. Hayen, E. Mereghetti and A. Walker-Loud, Pion-Induced Radiative Corrections to Neutron β Decay, Phys. Rev. Lett. 129 (2022) 121801 [2202.10439].DOI
  33. [34]V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, E. Mereghetti and O. Tomalak, Effective field theory for radiative corrections to charged-current processes. II. Axial-vector coupling, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) 053005 [2410.21404].arxiv.org/abs/2410.21404
  34. [35]O. Tomalak and Y.-B. Yang, Radiative corrections to the nucleon isovector g_V and g_A, Universe 12 (2026) 109 [2603.08596].
  35. [36]R.E. Behrends and A. Sirlin, Effect of mass splittings on the conserved vector current, Phys. Rev. Lett. 4 (1960) 186.
  36. [37]M. Ademollo and R. Gatto, Nonrenormalization Theorem for the Strangeness Violating Vector Currents, Phys. Rev. Lett. 13 (1964) 264.DOI
  37. [38]S. Ando, H.W. Fearing, V.P. Gudkov, K. Kubodera, F. Myhrer, S. Nakamura et al., Neutron beta decay in effective field theory, Phys. Lett. B 595 (2004) 250 [nucl-th/04020100].DOI
  38. [39]A. Falkowski, M. González-Alonso, A. Palavrić and A. Rodríguez-Sánchez, Constraints on subleading interactions in beta decay Lagrangian, JHEP 02 (2024) 091 [2112.07688].DOI
  39. [40]O. Tomalak, Radiative Corrections to Neutron Beta Decay and (Anti)Neutrino-Nucleon Scattering from Low-Energy Effective Field Theory, Few Body Syst. 64 (2023) 23 [2302.00642].DOI
  40. [41]V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, E. Mereghetti and O. Tomalak, Effective field theory for radiative corrections to charged-current processes: Vector coupling, Phys. Rev. D 108 (2023) 053003 [2306.03138].DOI
  41. [42]E. Fermi, An attempt of a theory of beta radiation. 1., Z. Phys. 88 (1934) 161.
  42. [43]R.P. Feynman and M. Gell-Mann, Theory of Fermi interaction, Phys. Rev. 109 (1958) 193.
  43. [44]T. van Ritbergen and R.G. Stuart, On the precise determination of the Fermi coupling constant from the muon lifetime, Nucl. Phys. B 564 (2000) 343 [hep-ph/9904240].DOI
  44. [45]MuLan collaboration, Detailed Report of the MuLan Measurement of the Positive Muon Lifetime and Determination of the Fermi Constant, Phys. Rev. D 87 (2013) 052003 [1211.0960].
  45. [46]N. Cabibbo, Unitary Symmetry and Leptonic Decays, Phys. Rev. Lett. 10 (1963) 531.
  46. [47]M. Kobayashi and T. Maskawa, CP Violation in the Renormalizable Theory of Weak Interaction, Prog. Theor. Phys. 49 (1973) 652.
  47. [48]Particle Data Group collaboration, Review of Particle Physics, PTEP 2020 (2020) 083C01.
  48. [49]J.C. Hardy and I.S. Towner, Superallowed 0+ → 0+ nuclear β decays: 2020 critical survey, with implications for Vud and CKM unitarity, Phys. Rev. C 102 (2020) 045501.DOI
  49. [50]J. Gasser and H. Leutwyler, Chiral Perturbation Theory to One Loop, Annals Phys. 158 (1984) 142.DOI
  50. [51]U.G. Meissner and S. Steininger, Isospin violation in pion nucleon scattering, Phys. Lett. B 419 (1998) 403 [hep-ph/9709453].DOI
  51. [52]G. Muller and U.-G. Meissner, Virtual photons in baryon chiral perturbation theory, Nucl. Phys. B 556 (1999) 265 [hep-ph/9903375].DOI
  52. [53]M. Knecht, H. Neufeld, H. Rupertsberger and P. Talavera, Chiral perturbation theory with virtual photons and leptons, Eur. Phys. J. C 12 (2000) 469 [hep-ph/9909284].
  53. [54]J. Gasser, M.A. Ivanov, E. Lipartia, M. Mojzis and A. Rusetsky, Ground state energy of pionic hydrogen to one loop, Eur. Phys. J. C 26 (2002) 13 [hep-ph/0206068].DOI
  54. [55]J. Gasser, M.E. Sainio and A. Svarc, Nucleons with chiral loops, Nucl. Phys. B 307 (1988) 779.DOI
  55. [56]A. Krause, Baryon Matrix Elements of the Vector Current in Chiral Perturbation Theory, Helv. Phys. Acta 63 (1990) 3.DOI
  56. [57]G. Ecker and M. Mojzis, Low-energy expansion of the pion - nucleon Lagrangian, Phys. Lett. B 365 (1996) 312 [hep-ph/9508204].
  57. [58]V. Bernard, N. Kaiser and U.-G. Meissner, Chiral dynamics in nucleons and nuclei, Int. J. Mod. Phys. E 4 (1995) 193 [hep-ph/9501384].DOI
  58. [59]H.W. Griesshammer, J.A. McGovern, D.R. Phillips and G. Feldman, Using effective field theory to analyse low-energy Compton scattering data from protons and light nuclei, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 67 (2012) 841 [1203.6834].DOI
  59. [60]J.A. McGovern, D.R. Phillips and H.W. Griesshammer, Compton scattering from the proton in an effective field theory with explicit Delta degrees of freedom, Eur. Phys. J. A 49 (2013) 12 [1210.4104].DOI
  60. [61]O. Tomalak, Radiative (anti)neutrino energy spectra from muon, pion, and kaon decays, Phys. Lett. B 829 (2022) 137108 [2112.12395].DOI
  61. [62]P.L. Cho, Heavy hadron chiral perturbation theory, Nucl. Phys. B 396 (1993) 183 [hep-ph/9208244].
  62. [63]A.F. Falk and B. Grinstein, Anti-B —> Anti-K e+ e- in Chiral Perturbation Theory, Nucl. Phys. B 416 (1994) 771 [hep-ph/9306310].
  63. [64]C.G. Boyd and B. Grinstein, Chiral and heavy quark symmetry violation in B decays, Nucl. Phys. B 442 (1995) 205 [hep-ph/9402340].
  64. [65]I.W. Stewart, Extraction of the D* D pi coupling from D* decays, Nucl. Phys. B 529 (1998) 62 [hep-ph/9803227].DOI
  65. [66]A.O. Bouzas, Three and two point one loop integrals in heavy particle effective theories, Eur. Phys. J. C 12 (2000) 643 [hep-ph/9910536].DOI
  66. [67]S. Fajfer, P. Singer and J. Zupan, The Rare decay D0 —> gamma gamma, Phys. Rev. D 64 (2001) 074008 [hep-ph/0104236].
  67. [68]A.O. Bouzas, Vertex integrals in heavy particle theories, AIP Conf. Proc. 623 (2002) 277 [hep-ph/0112055].DOI
  68. [69]A.I. Davydychev and A.G. Grozin, HQET quark - gluon vertex at one loop, Eur. Phys. J. C 20 (2001) 333 [hep-ph/0103078].DOI
  69. [70]J. Zupan, One loop scalar functions in the heavy quark effective theory, Eur. Phys. J. C 25 (2002) 233 [hep-ph/0202135].
  70. [71]A.O. Bouzas and R. Flores-Mendieta, One loop vertex integrals in heavy particle effective theories, J. Phys. G 28 (2002) 1179 [hep-ph/0202268].DOI
  71. [72]D. Becirevic, S. Prelovsek and J. Zupan, B —> pi and B —> K transitions in standard and quenched chiral perturbation theory, Phys. Rev. D 67 (2003) 054010 [hep-lat/0210048].DOI
  72. [73]L. Gialdidi, E. Mereghetti and J. de Vries, Radiative corrections to neutron beta decay with explicit delta degrees of freedom, 2608.14794.
  73. [74]MINERvA collaboration, Measurement of the axial vector form factor from antineutrino–proton scattering, Nature 614 (2023) 48.
  74. [75]O. Tomalak, A.S. Meyer, C. Wret, T. Cai, R.J. Hill and K.S. McFarland, Nucleon axial-vector form factor and radius from radiatively corrected antineutrino scattering data, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026) 073004 [2601.21155].
  75. [76]R. Mertig, M. Bohm and A. Denner, FEYN CALC: Computer algebraic calculation of Feynman amplitudes, Comput. Phys. Commun. 64 (1991) 345.DOI
  76. [77]T. Hahn and M. Perez-Victoria, Automatized one loop calculations in four-dimensions and D-dimensions, Comput. Phys. Commun. 118 (1999) 153 [hep-ph/9807565].
  77. [78]V. Shtabovenko, R. Mertig and F. Orellana, New Developments in FeynCalc 9.0, Comput. Phys. Commun. 207 (2016) 432 [1601.01167].
  78. [79]Wolfram Research, Inc., Mathematica, Version 15.0.0.0, 2026.
  79. [80]M.R. MacAskill, Datagraph 3.0, Journal of Statistical Software 47 (2012) 1–9.

Paper details

vlnc:W_rxhfk58g
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents