betaFeedback

Reading v1View latest version

WorksMathematics

Pressure Quotients and Endpoint Velocity-Clock Criteria for Non-Diffusive Viscoelastic Flows

Abstract

We prove endpoint continuation criteria for stress-diffusion-free incompressible viscoelastic flows by working modulo pressure. In two space dimensions, the pressure-free part of any smooth spectral isotropic stress reduces to a single active deviatoric channel (q_1(a,|Y|^2)Y), where (C=aI+Y) and (\operatorname{tr}Y=0). This scalar quotient structure allows a weighted active-deviatoric energy to cancel the top-order coupling between polymer stretching and the divergence of the active stress. On compact conformation windows the resulting high-order estimate depends only on an endpoint velocity clock and a logarithmic conformation norm. For Oldroyd–B this gives continuation of strong two-dimensional solutions under (\nabla u\in L^1_tB^0_{\infty,1}), while for FENE-P it gives continuation under (\nabla u\in L^2_tB^0_{\infty,1}). In both models the compact conformation window and logarithmic bound are derived from the velocity clock and the model barriers, rather than imposed as independent hypotheses. The criteria are formulated in integer Sobolev strong-solution classes and do not assert Leray-type weak-solution or critical-space local well-posedness results. We also identify a static operator obstruction showing the functional necessity of the logarithmic threshold for the pressure-free stress map. In three dimensions the quotient contains an additional residual channel (q_2(Y^2)^\circ), so the exact scalar closure is intrinsically two-dimensional. On prescribed compact windows this residual can be absorbed by viscosity; for Oldroyd–B and FENE-P it vanishes because (q_2\equiv0).

Introduction

Oldroyd–B and FENE-P are often treated as separate constitutive models. From the viewpoint of continuation criteria, however, they belong to the same geometric problem. A viscous incompressible velocity field is coupled to an elastic conformation tensor which is transported and stretched but has no spatial diffusion. The stress enters the velocity equation through a divergence, so derivatives of the conformation tensor are fed back into the parabolic equation at the same level at which the viscosity is used. The regularity question is therefore not only whether energy or entropy remains finite. It is whether the geometry of the conformation state space prevents high-frequency concentration in the non-diffusive elastic variable.

The criterion below separates the endpoint velocity modulus from the boundary geometry of the conformation tensor. In Oldroyd–B the conformation tensor ranges in the positive cone S++2S_{++}^{2}. The logarithmic coordinate B=Log⁡CB = \operatorname{Log} C builds this positivity into the unknown and separates spectral degeneration from derivative concentration inside the cone. In FENE-P the state space is smaller:

Db={C∈S++2:tr⁡C<b},b>2.\mathcal{D}_b=\{C\in\mathcal{S}_{++}^{2}:\operatorname{tr}C<b\},\qquad b>2.

The lower boundary is still the positive-cone boundary, but there is now an upper finite-extensibility boundary tr⁡C=b\operatorname{tr}C=b. This boundary is measured by the scalar barrier

ϕb(C)=−log⁡(b−tr⁡C).\phi_b(C)=-\log(b-\operatorname{tr}C).

Thus FENE-P has the Oldroyd–B positive-cone boundary together with an additional upper-trace boundary.

The incompressible Oldroyd–B system without artificial stress diffusion is

∂tu+u⋅∇u−νΔu+∇p=αdiv⁡(A−I),(1)\partial_tu+u\cdot\nabla u-\nu\Delta u+\nabla p=\alpha\operatorname{div}(A-I), \tag*{(1)}
∂tA+u⋅∇A=∇uA+A(∇u)T−λ−1(A−I),(2)\partial_tA+u\cdot\nabla A=\nabla uA+A(\nabla u)^{T}-\lambda^{-1}(A-I), \tag*{(2)}
div⁡u=0.(3)\operatorname{div}u=0. \tag*{(3)}

Here u:T2→R2u:\mathbb{T}^{2}\to\mathbb{R}^{2}, A:T2→S++2A:\mathbb{T}^{2}\to\mathcal{S}_{++}^{2}, and ν,α,λ>0\nu,\alpha,\lambda>0. The conformation tensor has no spatial diffusion. The velocity is parabolic, but the force in the vorticity equation contains curl⁡div⁡A\operatorname{curl}\operatorname{div}A, so derivatives of the stress enter the velocity equation at the same level at which parabolic smoothing is being used.

The corresponding stress-diffusion-free FENE-P system is

∂tu+u⋅∇u−νΔu+∇p=αdiv⁡Tb(C),(4)\partial_tu+u\cdot\nabla u-\nu\Delta u+\nabla p=\alpha\operatorname{div}T_b(C), \tag*{(4)}
∂tC+u⋅∇C=∇uC+C(∇u)T−λ−1(fb(C)C−I),(5)\partial_tC+u\cdot\nabla C=\nabla uC+C(\nabla u)^{T}-\lambda^{-1}\left(f_b(C)C-I\right), \tag*{(5)}
div⁡u=0,(6)\operatorname{div}u=0, \tag*{(6)}

where

fb(C)=b−2b−tr⁡C,Tb(C)=fb(C)C−I.f_b(C)=\frac{b-2}{b-\operatorname{tr}C},\qquad T_b(C)=f_b(C)C-I.

The Oldroyd–B system is recovered formally on bounded trace windows as the Hookean limit b→∞b\to\infty, where fb(C)→1f_b(C)\to1 and Tb(C)→C−IT_b(C)\to C-I. At fixed bb, however, derivatives of the spring factor contain powers of (b−tr⁡C)−1(b-\operatorname{tr}C)^{-1}, and these coefficients cannot be read from the Oldroyd–B logarithmic variable alone.

The continuation result is stated in terms of these geometric variables. For Oldroyd–B, as long as the solution remains in a compact spectral window of the cone, loss of continuation forces divergence of one of the following quantities:

∫0T∥∇u(t)∥B∞,102 dt,∥Log⁡A∥L4(0,T;H1+ε).\int_{0}^{T}\|\nabla u(t)\|_{B^{0}_{\infty,1}}^{2}\,dt,\qquad\|\operatorname{Log}A\|_{L^{4}(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}.

For FENE-P the same two quantities remain, but a third clock must be added:

∥ϕb(C)∥L4(0,T;H1+ε).\|\phi_b(C)\|_{L^{4}(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}.

The first quantity controls the flow map. The second measures high-frequency variation of the logarithmic conformation. The third measures high-frequency variation of the finite-extensibility trace gap. Entropy and relaxation give zeroth-order information, but they do not control these derivative norms. The closed continuation theorem uses Lt4L_t^4 norms; Proposition 7.6 records the estimate that would give the corresponding Lt2L_t^2 criterion.

Main theorem (Informal form). Let (u,C)(u,C) be a smooth two-dimensional stress-diffusion-free viscoelastic solution. In the Oldroyd–B case assume that CC stays in a compact spectral window of the positive cone. In the FENE-P case assume that CC stays in a compact FENE window C>0C>0, tr⁡C<b\operatorname{tr} C<b. If

∫0T∥∇u(t)∥B˙∞,102 dt+∥Log⁡C∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)<∞\int_{0}^{T}\|\nabla u(t)\|_{\dot{B}^{0}_{\infty,1}}^{2}\,\mathrm{d}t+\|\operatorname{Log} C\|_{L^{4}(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}<\infty

and, in the FENE-P case also

∥ϕb(C)∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)<∞,\|\phi_b(C)\|_{L^{4}(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}<\infty,

then the strong solution continues beyond TT. Therefore finite-time breakdown must involve the velocity modulus, the logarithmic conformation variable, or, in FENE-P, the finite-extensibility barrier.

Main results

We keep the traditional notation AA for the Oldroyd–B conformation tensor and use CC for the FENE-P conformation tensor. Both are symmetric positive definite matrix fields. The distinction is only notational, except that in the FENE-P case CC is constrained by the additional condition tr⁡C<b\operatorname{tr} C<b.

The first result is the Oldroyd–B continuation theorem proved in Section 6. In a compact spectral window of the positive cone, a smooth solution can be continued as long as

∫0T∥∇u(t)∥B˙∞,102 dt+∥Log⁡A∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)<∞.\int_{0}^{T}\|\nabla u(t)\|_{\dot{B}^{0}_{\infty,1}}^{2}\,\mathrm{d}t+\|\operatorname{Log} A\|_{L^{4}(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}<\infty.

Equivalently, away from loss of the compact positive-cone window, finite-time breakdown forces divergence of the velocity Besov modulus or of the logarithmic conformation norm.

The second result is the FENE-P continuation theorem proved in Section 8. Here the compact-window condition has two parts:

C>0,tr⁡C<b.C>0,\qquad\operatorname{tr} C<b.

The logarithmic variable B=Log⁡CB=\operatorname{Log} C controls the lower spectral boundary, while

ϕb(C)=−log⁡(b−tr⁡C)\phi_b(C)=-\log(b-\operatorname{tr} C)

controls the finite-extensibility boundary. Under the corresponding L∞L^\infty window bounds, continuation follows from

∫0T∥∇u(t)∥B˙∞,102 dt+∥Log⁡C∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)+∥ϕb(C)∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)<∞.\int_{0}^{T}\|\nabla u(t)\|_{\dot{B}^{0}_{\infty,1}}^{2}\,\mathrm{d}t+\|\operatorname{Log} C\|_{L^{4}(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}+\|\phi_b(C)\|_{L^{4}(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}<\infty.

Thus the FENE-P criterion is the Oldroyd–B criterion plus the trace-gap barrier variable. The conditional Lt2H1+εL^{2}_{t}H^{1+\varepsilon} improvement in Proposition 7.6 is not used in either closed theorem. It is included only to isolate the estimate that would improve the time integrability exponent.

The paper is organized as follows. Section 3 records the analytic estimates used in the proof. Section 4 records the positive cone and entropy structure inherited by both models. Section 5 gives the logarithmic equation and the good unknown. Section 6 proves the Oldroyd–B continuation criterion. Section 7 explains why the criterion cannot be closed from entropy and relaxation alone. Section 8 adds the FENE-P trace-gap variable and derives the three-channel continuation criterion. Section 9 compares the FENE-P criterion with Oldroyd–B in the Hookean limit.

What is new in the criterion

The usual strong-solution continuation principle for Oldroyd–B is formulated at the level of high Sobolev norms. Such a statement is useful locally, but it does not identify the geometric channel through which a singularity must pass. The contribution of the present paper is to replace a generic high-norm criterion by a closed, positive-cone criterion whose terms have direct geometric meaning:

flow-map control+logarithmic stress concentration.\text{flow-map control}\quad+\quad\text{logarithmic stress concentration}.

The first component is measured by the critical Besov norm ∥∇u∥B∞,10\|\nabla u\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}. This is the natural analogue of the Beale–Kato–Majda quantity ∫0T∥∇u(t)∥L∞ dt\int_0^T \|\nabla u(t)\|_{L^\infty}\,\mathrm{d}t for the velocity gradient. Below we write

B(u)=∥∇u∥B∞,10,\mathcal{B}(u)=\|\nabla u\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}},

which controls the Lipschitz modulus of the Lagrangian flow at the endpoint scale. The second component is measured in the closed theorem by Lt4Hx1+εL_t^4H_x^{1+\varepsilon} for B=Log⁡AB=\operatorname{Log} A. The commutator structure suggests the lower Lt2Hx1+εL_t^2H_x^{1+\varepsilon} quantity. We use the Lt4L_t^4 norm in the closed theorem because it controls the remaining matrix-exponential commutators after the good-unknown reduction.

The proof has three parts. First, within a fixed positive-cone spectral window, the high Sobolev energy is propagated by the velocity-gradient control and the Lt4Hx1+εL_t^4H_x^{1+\varepsilon} logarithmic conformation norm. Second, the matrix-exponential commutator responsible for the stress derivative loss is handled by the logarithmic good unknown Gγ=(dexp⁡B)−1∂γ(eB)\mathcal{G}_\gamma=(\mathrm{d}\exp_B)^{-1}\partial_\gamma(e^B). Third, the entropy-blind sequence in Proposition 7.1 and the relaxation variant in Proposition 7.3 show that the logarithmic high-frequency channel is not controlled by the usual free-energy and relaxation mechanisms. Hence the theorem separates local continuation from the additional non-diffusive stress regularity needed to continue a solution.

This separation is useful for both directions of the problem. A blow-up scenario cannot be detected only by the size of the entropy. It must also lose the flow map, lose the spectral window, or create high-frequency growth in the logarithmic conformation field. Conversely, an argument based only on energy, entropy, relaxation, and positivity still has to control this logarithmic term. Proposition 7.1 gives a simple obstruction to such a closure.

Proof architecture. The proof has a closed three-step structure. The velocity equation supplies parabolic control of uu, but only after the stress forcing curl⁡div⁡(eB)\operatorname{curl}\operatorname{div}(e^B) is estimated in terms of logarithmic conformation norms. The logarithmic equation supplies transport control of BB, but only after the differentiated exponential map is rewritten through the good unknown Gγ\mathcal{G}_\gamma. Finally, the two estimates are added with a small multiple of the velocity dissipation absorbing the derivative of uu generated by the stress equation. This is exactly where the closed coefficient

1+∥∇u∥B∞,102+∥B∥H1+ε41+\|\nabla u\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}^2+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4

appears.

Relation with Euler and stress-diffusive models

The regularity problem for the two-dimensional Oldroyd–B system without stress diffusion lies between two regimes that are much better understood. If stress diffusion is imposed, the missing derivative in the conformation equation is restored by parabolic smoothing. If the data are small, perturbative mechanisms can keep the non-diffusive stress from feeding a large cascade back into the velocity. The difficult regime is the one in which neither source of control is available: no artificial stress dissipation and no smallness. In this regime the present result gives a conditional description of loss of regularity. Away from the boundary of the positive cone, a singularity can occur only by loss of the critical velocity modulus or by concentration of the logarithmic conformation field.

For the two-dimensional Euler equation, vorticity is transported and the classical obstruction is growth of the Lipschitz norm of the velocity. For Oldroyd–B without stress diffusion, the vorticity equation contains the extra forcing curl⁡div⁡A\operatorname{curl}\operatorname{div} A. The stress is transported and stretched, but it has no parabolic regularization. Thus the Euler-type vorticity criterion becomes a coupled vorticity–stress criterion; see Corollary 6.6.

Modelcontrolled quantitycontinuation obstruction
Eulervorticity ω\omega∫0T∣∇u(t)∣L∞ dt\int_0^T |\nabla u(t)|_{L^\infty}\,dt
OB, no stress diffusionvorticity coupled to A=eBA=e^B∫0T∣∇u(t)∣L22 dt\int_0^T |\nabla u(t)|_{L^2}^2\,dt and ∣B∣L4(0,T;H1+ε)|B|_{L^4(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}
OB, with stress diffusiondiffusive stressparabolic smoothing

Table 1.

If stress diffusion is added to the conformation equation, the missing derivative is supplied directly by the stress equation. Many global or conditional results then become accessible by parabolic energy methods. The present paper focuses on the non-diffusive case, where the velocity is diffusive but the elastic state is not. The resulting imbalance is the source of the logarithmic high-frequency channel.

The Oldroyd model goes back to Oldroyd’s constitutive theory [13]. Strong and weak solution theories for differential viscoelastic models were developed in several directions, including the early work of Guillopé and Saut [9] and the global weak-solution framework of Lions and Masmoudi [11]. Lifespan and breakdown criteria for related viscoelastic systems were studied by Chemin and Masmoudi [4] and by Lei, Masmoudi, and Zhou [10]. When additional stress diffusion is present, two-dimensional regularity becomes substantially more tractable; see, for example, Constantin and Kliegl [5], the global regularity results of Elgindi and Rousset [6], and the regularized model of Barrett and Boyaval [1]. In the stress-diffusion-free system, global control is also known in small-data regimes; a recent example is the work of Tu, Wang, and Wen [14]. The present paper is complementary to both directions: it does not add stress diffusion and does not assume smallness. Instead it states a continuation criterion in variables adapted to the conformation geometry.

The logarithmic conformation representation was introduced in numerical rheology by Fattal and Kupferman [7, 8] to preserve positivity and improve high-Weissenberg-number computations. The present use is analytic: the logarithmic chart separates spectral control from high-frequency concentration. The velocity part of the criterion follows the spirit of the Beale–Kato–Majda continuation principle [2], but the non-diffusive stress equation forces the additional logarithmic stress diagnostic.

The finitely extensible models considered below originate from the standard FENE closures for dilute polymeric fluids; see, for example, Bird, Armstrong, and Hassager [3]. Mathematical work on FENE dumbbell models has also emphasized the role of the finite-extension boundary; a representative global well-posedness result is due to Masmoudi [12]. The FENE-P part of the present paper has a different aim. It does not prove a new global regularity theorem. It identifies the additional continuation variable created by the boundary tr⁡C=b\operatorname{tr} C=b.

Comparison with direct continuation criteria

Compared with continuation criteria stated directly in Sobolev norms of the conformation tensor, the present criterion has two structural advantages. The spectral part of the problem is separated from the differentiability part by the logarithmic chart A=eBA=e^{B}. Moreover, the non-diffusive obstruction is localized in a norm of BB, rather than hidden in a high norm of AA. This distinction matters because entropy and relaxation control functions of the eigenvalues of AA, but they are insensitive to bounded high-frequency oscillation of BB. Propositions 7.1 and 7.3 make this separation quantitative.

There are three useful ways to view the gain. First, a direct HsH^{s}-criterion for AA mixes two different phenomena: approach to the boundary of the positive cone and derivative concentration inside the cone. The logarithmic criterion separates them. Loss of the spectral window is one breakdown alternative, while high-frequency concentration is measured by Log⁡A\operatorname{Log} A after the spectral issue has been removed.

Second, the entropy identity is not discarded. It is used for physical admissibility and spectral information, but it is not asked to provide a derivative it does not contain. The high-frequency examples in Section 7 show that this is a real obstruction rather than a technical gap in the proof.

Third, the result gives the natural Oldroyd–B analogue of the BKM mechanism. For Euler, loss of regularity is detected by the flow-map/vorticity channel. For non-diffusive Oldroyd–B, the stress equation adds a second non-parabolic channel. The continuation criterion therefore has to be a coupled vorticity–log-stress criterion. This is exactly the content of Corollaries 6.6 and 6.7.

Functional Setting and Continuation Framework

We work on the periodic torus T2\mathbb{T}^{2} to avoid boundary effects. The same local estimates apply on the whole plane with the standard modifications for decay and low frequencies. The main estimates are stated for integer s≥3s \ge3, so the high-order differentiations are classical and the velocity parabolic estimate controls the required Lipschitz quantities.

Notation. Constants denoted by CC may change from line to line. Constants denoted by CKC_{K} may also depend on a fixed spectral window ∥B∥L∞≤K\lVert B\rVert_{L^{\infty}} \le K. In the FENE-P part, KK also denotes a compact subdomain of

Db={C∈S++2:tr⁡C<b};\mathcal{D}_{b}=\{C\in\mathbb{S}^{2}_{++}:\operatorname{tr} C<b\};

the constants may then depend on bb, the lower spectral gap of CC, and the upper trace gap b−tr⁡Cb-\operatorname{tr} C. To keep the exposition focused on the geometric mechanism, high-order differentiations are written for integer s≥3s \ge3. The fractional case follows from the same paradifferential estimates in the usual Besov-Sobolev scale.

Definition 2.1 (Strong positive-cone solution). Let T>0T>0. A strong positive-cone solution on [0,T][0,T] is a pair (u,A)(u,A) such that

u∈C([0,T];Hs),A∈C([0,T];Hs(T2;S++2)),u\in C([0,T];H^{s}),\qquad A\in C([0,T];H^{s}(\mathbb{T}^{2};\mathbb{S}^{2}_{++})),
u∈L2(0,T;Hs+1),div⁡u=0,u\in L^{2}(0,T;H^{s+1}),\qquad\operatorname{div}u=0,

and (1)(1)–(2)(2) hold in the classical Sobolev sense.

Definition 2.2 (Strong FENE-P solution). Let T>0T>0. A strong FENE-P solution on [0,T][0,T] is a pair (u,C)(u,C) such that

u∈C([0,T];Hs),C∈C([0,T];Hs(T2;S++2)),u\in C([0,T];H^{s}),\qquad C\in C([0,T];H^{s}(\mathbb{T}^{2};\mathbb{S}^{2}_{++})),
u∈L2(0,T;Hs+1),div⁡u=0,C(t,x)∈Db,u\in L^{2}(0,T;H^{s+1}),\qquad\operatorname{div}u=0,\qquad C(t,x)\in\mathcal{D}_{b},

and (4)(4)–(5)(5) hold in the classical Sobolev sense.

Proposition 2.3 (Local continuation principle). Let s≥3s \ge3, u0∈Hsu_0 \in H^s, div⁡u0=0\operatorname{div} u_0 = 0, and A0∈Hs(T2;S++2)A_0 \in H^s(\mathbb{T}^2; \mathbb{S}^2_{++}) with spectral range contained in [m0,M0][m_0, M_0], 0<m0<M0<∞0 < m_0 < M_0 < \infty. Then there exists a unique strong positive-cone solution on a time interval [0,Tloc][0,T_{\mathrm{loc}}]. Moreover, if a solution on [0,T∗)[0,T_*) satisfies

sup⁡t<T∗(∥u(t)∥Hs+∥A(t)∥Hs+∥A(t)∥L∞+∥A(t)−1∥L∞)<∞,\sup_{t<T_*} \left(\lVert u(t)\rVert_{H^s} + \lVert A(t)\rVert_{H^s} + \lVert A(t)\rVert_{L^\infty} + \lVert A(t)^{-1}\rVert_{L^\infty}\right) < \infty,

then it extends as a strong positive-cone solution beyond T∗T_*.

Proof. Regularize the system, solve by Picard iteration, and obtain estimates in HsH^s for AA and in Hs∩Lt2Hs+1H^s \cap L^2_t H^{s+1} for uu. Positivity is propagated along characteristics by Lemma eq:4.3. The lower spectral bound prevents degeneration of the cone, while the upper spectral and Sobolev bounds control all nonlinear coefficients.

More explicitly, the regularized estimates give a local existence time

Tloc≥τ(∥u0∥Hs+∥A0∥Hs,∥A0∥L∞,∥A0−1∥L∞)>0,T_{\mathrm{loc}} \ge\tau\left(\lVert u_0\rVert_{H^s} + \lVert A_0\rVert_{H^s}, \lVert A_0\rVert_{L^\infty}, \lVert A_0^{-1}\rVert_{L^\infty}\right) > 0,

where τ\tau is nonincreasing in its arguments. The same estimate applies when the construction is restarted from any time t0<T∗t_0 < T_*. Under eq:2.3, these arguments remain bounded uniformly for t0<T∗t_0 < T_*. Hence there is a uniform τ∗>0\tau_* > 0 such that the solution restarts on [t0,t0+τ∗][t_0,t_0+\tau_*] for every t0<T∗t_0 < T_* sufficiently close to T∗T_*. Choosing t0>T∗−τ∗/2t_0 > T_*-\tau_*/2 gives an extension beyond T∗T_*. □

Remark 2.4 (Why the criterion is stated in B=Log⁡AB = \operatorname{Log} A). The local principle is naturally stated in AA, but the geometric continuation criterion is sharper in B=Log⁡AB = \operatorname{Log} A. Uniform upper and lower spectral bounds for AA are equivalent to an L∞L^\infty bound for BB. On such spectral windows, the maps B↦eBB \mapsto e^B and A↦Log⁡AA \mapsto\operatorname{Log} A are smooth on Sobolev spaces. Therefore controlling BB in HsH^s is equivalent to controlling AA in HsH^s, with constants depending only on the spectral window.

Proposition 2.5 (Local continuation in the FENE-P domain). Let s≥3s \ge3, u0∈Hsu_0 \in H^s, div⁡u0=0\operatorname{div} u_0 = 0, and C0∈Hs(T2;Db)C_0 \in H^s(\mathbb{T}^2; \mathcal{D}_b). Assume that the range of C0C_0 is contained in a compact set K0⋐DbK_0 \Subset\mathcal{D}_b. Then there exists a unique strong FENE-P solution on a time interval [0,Tloc][0,T_{\mathrm{loc}}]. Moreover, if a solution on [0,T∗)[0,T_*) satisfies

sup⁡t<T∗(∥u(t)∥Hs+∥C(t)∥Hs)<∞\sup_{t<T_*} \left(\lVert u(t)\rVert_{H^s} + \lVert C(t)\rVert_{H^s}\right) < \infty

and the range of C(t,⋅)C(t,\cdot) remains in a fixed compact set K⋐DbK \Subset\mathcal{D}_b for all t<T∗t < T_*, then the solution extends beyond T∗T_* as a strong FENE-P solution.

Proof. On K⋐DbK \Subset\mathcal{D}_b, the maps

C↦fb(C),C↦Tb(C),C↦fb(C)C−IC \mapsto f_b(C), \qquad C \mapsto T_b(C), \qquad C \mapsto f_b(C)C-I

are smooth with bounded derivatives of every finite order. The FENE-P system therefore has the same quasilinear parabolic-transport structure as the Oldroyd–B system, with composition constants depending only on KK, bb, and the HsH^s size of CC. Regularization and Picard iteration give a local existence time bounded below by a nonincreasing function of

∥u0∥Hs+∥C0∥Hs\lVert u_0\rVert_{H^s} + \lVert C_0\rVert_{H^s}

and the compact-set constants of K0K_0. Restarting the construction at times t0<T∗t_0 < T_* gives the same lower bound with KK in place of K0K_0. The stated uniform bounds therefore give a uniform restart time and extend the solution beyond T∗T_*. □

Analytic Preliminaries

We collect the analytic estimates used below. They are standard consequences of Littlewood–Paley theory and Moser calculus, but isolating them makes the continuation proof transparent.

Lemma 3.1 (Standard Moser and tame calculus). Let r>1r>1 in two dimensions. Then Hr(T2)H^r(\mathbb{T}^2) is an algebra and

∥fg∥Hr≤Cr(∥f∥L∞∥g∥Hr+∥g∥L∞∥f∥Hr).\|fg\|_{H^r} \le C_r\left(\|f\|_{L^\infty}\|g\|_{H^r}+\|g\|_{L^\infty}\|f\|_{H^r}\right).

If F∈C∞(RN)F\in C^\infty(\mathbb{R}^N), F(0)=0F(0)=0, and ∥v∥L∞≤K\|v\|_{L^\infty}\le K, then

∥F(v)∥Hr≤CF,K,r∥v∥Hr.\|F(v)\|_{H^r}\le C_{F,K,r}\|v\|_{H^r}.

The same estimates hold componentwise for matrix-valued functions. Moreover, if m≥2m\ge2, 0<ε<10<\varepsilon<1, and f1,…,fNf_1,\ldots,f_N be smooth scalar, vector, or matrix fields on T2\mathbb{T}^2. If at most one factor is measured at order mm, then

∥∏j=1Nfj∥Hm≤C∏j=1N(1+∥fj∥H1+ε)∑j=1N∥fj∥Hm.(7)\left\|\prod_{j=1}^{N}f_j\right\|_{H^m} \le C\prod_{j=1}^{N}\left(1+\|f_j\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}\right)\sum_{j=1}^{N}\|f_j\|_{H^m}. \tag*{(7)}

The constant depends on mm, ε\varepsilon, NN and on fixed L∞L^\infty bounds for smooth coefficient functions of the fjf_j's.

Proof. These are standard consequences of the Bony paraproduct decomposition fg=Tfg+Tgf+R(f,g)fg=T_f g+T_g f+R(f,g). Since r>1=d/2r>1=d/2, Hr(T2)H^r(\mathbb{T}^2) is an algebra. The composition bound follows by writing

F(v)=∫01DF(θv)v dθ.F(v)=\int_0^1 DF(\theta v)v\,d\theta.

For (7), put the highest derivative on one factor and place all remaining factors in H1+ε↪L∞H^{1+\varepsilon}\hookrightarrow L^\infty.

Lemma 3.2 (Endpoint transport estimate). Let m≥2m\ge2, div⁡u=0\operatorname{div}u=0, and f∈Hmf\in H^m. Then

∣∑∣γ∣≤m∫T2∂γf[∂γ,u⋅∇]f dx∣≤Cm∥∇u∥B∞,10∥f∥Hm2.\left|\sum_{|\gamma|\le m}\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}\partial^\gamma f[\partial^\gamma,u\cdot\nabla]f\,dx\right| \le C_m\|\nabla u\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}\|f\|_{H^m}^2.

Proof. This is the standard commutator estimate in the critical Besov scale. In Littlewood–Paley variables, low-high interactions are controlled by the Lipschitz modulus of the low-frequency velocity, while high-low interactions are summable exactly because the velocity gradient is in B∞,10B^0_{\infty,1}. The divergence-free condition removes the top-order transport contribution.

Entropy and Positive-Cone Geometry

Definition 4.1 (Free energy). For a smooth positive-cone solution define

E(t)=12∫T2∣u∣2 dx+α2∫T2(tr⁡A−log⁡det⁡A−2) dx.\mathcal{E}(t)=\frac{1}{2}\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}|u|^2\,dx+\frac{\alpha}{2}\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}\left(\operatorname{tr}A-\log\det A-2\right)\,dx.

Proposition 4.2 (Entropy identity). Every smooth solution of (1)–(2) satisfies

ddtE(t)+ν∫T2∣∇u∣2 dx+α2λ∫T2tr⁡(A+A−1−2I) dx=0.\frac{d}{dt}\mathcal{E}(t)+\nu\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}|\nabla u|^2\,dx+\frac{\alpha}{2\lambda}\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}\operatorname{tr}\left(A+A^{-1}-2I\right)\,dx=0.

Proof. Testing the momentum equation by uu gives

12ddt∫∣u∣2 dx+ν∫∣∇u∣2 dx=−α∫(A−I):∇u dx.\frac{1}{2}\frac{d}{dt}\int|u|^2\,dx+\nu\int|\nabla u|^2\,dx=-\alpha\int(A-I):\nabla u\,dx.

Testing the conformation equation by I−A−1I-A^{-1} gives

ddt∫(tr⁡A−log⁡det⁡A−2) dx=2∫(A−I):∇u dx−λ−1∫tr⁡(A+A−1−2I) dx.\frac{d}{dt}\int(\operatorname{tr} A-\log\det A-2)\,dx=2\int(A-I):\nabla u\,dx-\lambda^{-1}\int\operatorname{tr}(A+A^{-1}-2I)\,dx.

The stretching terms cancel after multiplication by α/2\alpha/2.

Lemma 4.3 (Cone propagation). If A0(x)∈S++2A_0(x)\in S_{++}^2 and ∫0T∥∇u(t)∥L∞ dt<∞\int_0^T\|\nabla u(t)\|_{L^\infty}\,dt<\infty, then A(t,x)∈S++2A(t,x)\in S_{++}^2 for all t≤Tt\le T. Moreover, along characteristics, the extreme eigenvalues obey

λmax⁡A(t)≤C(λmax⁡A0+1)exp⁡(2∫0t∥∇u(s)∥L∞ ds),\lambda_{\max}A(t)\le C\left(\lambda_{\max}A_0+1\right)\exp\left(2\int_0^t\|\nabla u(s)\|_{L^\infty}\,ds\right),

and an analogous lower bound holds for λmin⁡A(t)\lambda_{\min}A(t).

Proof. Along a trajectory X(t)X(t), the matrix satisfies

ddtA=∇u A+A(∇u)T−λ−1(A−I).\frac{d}{dt}A=\nabla u\,A+A(\nabla u)^T-\lambda^{-1}(A-I).

Testing against unit vectors and applying Gronwall gives the upper spectral bound. Applying the same argument to A−1A^{-1}, whose equation is obtained by differentiating A−1A=IA^{-1}A=I, gives the lower bound.

Logarithmic Coordinates and Good Unknowns

Let B=\Log A. The derivative of the matrix exponential is

dexp⁡B(C)=∫01e(1−θ)BCeθB dθ.d\exp_B(C)=\int_0^1 e^{(1-\theta)B}Ce^{\theta B}\,d\theta.

If the spectrum of BB is contained in [−K,K][-K,K], then

cK∣C∣≤∣dexp⁡B(C)∣≤CK∣C∣(C=CT),c_K|C|\le|d\exp_B(C)|\le C_K|C| \qquad(C=C^T),

and the constants depend only on KK. Thus the logarithmic coordinate is not merely a change of notation: it gives an elliptic chart on every compact spectral subset of the positive cone.

Lemma 5.1 (Sobolev calculus for the exponential chart). Let s>1s>1 in two dimensions and suppose ∥B∥L∞≤K\|B\|_{L^\infty}\le K. Then

∥eB−I∥Hs≤CK(1+∥B∥Hs),\|e^B-I\|_{H^s}\le C_K(1+\|B\|_{H^s}),

and, for two symmetric fields B1,B2B_1,B_2 with the same L∞L^\infty bound,

∥eB1−eB2∥Hs−1≤CK(1+∥B1∥Hs+∥B2∥Hs)∥B1−B2∥Hs−1.\|e^{B_1}-e^{B_2}\|_{H^{s-1}}\le C_K(1+\|B_1\|_{H^s}+\|B_2\|_{H^s})\|B_1-B_2\|_{H^{s-1}}.

The same estimates hold for B↦(dexp⁡B)−1B\mapsto(d\exp_B)^{-1} on symmetric matrices.

Proof. Use the integral representation

eB−I=∫01eθBB dθe^{B}-I=\int_{0}^{1}e^{\theta B}B\,\mathrm{d}\theta

and Lemma 3.1. The Lipschitz bound follows from

eB1−eB2=∫01dexp⁡B2+θ(B1−B2)(B1−B2) dθ.e^{B_{1}}-e^{B_{2}}=\int_{0}^{1}d\exp_{B_{2}+\theta(B_{1}-B_{2})}(B_{1}-B_{2})\,\mathrm{d}\theta.

The inverse derivative is controlled by (5) and the smooth dependence of the inverse operator on BB on compact spectral sets.

In logarithmic variables, the conformation equation can be written as

dexp⁡B(∂tB+u⋅∇B)=∇u eB+eB(∇u)T−λ−1(eB−I).d\exp_{B}\left(\partial_{t}B+u\cdot\nabla B\right)=\nabla u\,e^{B}+e^{B}(\nabla u)^{T}-\lambda^{-1}\left(e^{B}-I\right).

When the spectrum of BB is bounded, dexp⁡Bd\exp_{B} and its inverse are bounded on symmetric matrices. Thus the equation is transport-dominated, but the source is nonlinear in BB and ∇u\nabla u.

The naive differentiated equation contains two bad-looking terms. The first is the standard transport commutator [∂γ,u⋅∇]B[\partial^{\gamma},u\cdot\nabla]B, which is controlled by a critical Besov norm of ∇u\nabla u. The second is more specific to the positive cone: when one differentiates eBe^{B}, the top derivative does not simply equal eB∂γBe^{B}\partial^{\gamma}B. It contains non-commuting matrix factors and lower-order products. The good unknown below subtracts the paralinear part of this matrix-exponential commutator. Geometrically, it applies the inverse tangent map of the exponential chart and therefore pulls the differentiated conformation tensor ∂γA\partial^{\gamma}A back to the logarithmic tangent space at BB. This is the point at which the positive-cone geometry enters the continuation argument.

Definition 5.2 (Logarithmic good unknown). For a multi-index γ\gamma, define

Gγ=(dexp⁡B)−1(∂γ(eB)).\mathcal{G}_{\gamma}=(d\exp_{B})^{-1}\left(\partial^{\gamma}(e^{B})\right).

By Lemma 5.3,

Gγ=∂γB+(dexp⁡B)−1Cγ(B).\mathcal{G}_{\gamma}=\partial^{\gamma}B+(d\exp_{B})^{-1}C_{\gamma}(B).

Thus Gγ\mathcal{G}_{\gamma} is an Alinhac-type correction of ∂γB\partial^{\gamma}B: it is defined intrinsically from the differentiated conformation tensor and differs from ∂γB\partial^{\gamma}B only by lower-order matrix-exponential commutators.

Lemma 5.3 (Commutator structure). Let m≥2m\ge2, 0<ε<10<\varepsilon<1, and assume ∥B∥L∞≤K\|B\|_{L^{\infty}}\le K. Then for ∣γ∣=m|\gamma|=m,

∂γ(eB)=dexp⁡B(∂γB)+Cγ(B),\partial^{\gamma}(e^{B})=d\exp_{B}(\partial^{\gamma}B)+C_{\gamma}(B),

where

∥Cγ(B)∥L2≤CK(1+∥B∥H1+ε2)(1+∥B∥Hm−1).\|C_{\gamma}(B)\|_{L^{2}}\le C_{K}\left(1+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^{2}\right)\left(1+\|B\|_{H^{m-1}}\right).

Proof. Expanding ∂γ(eB)\partial^{\gamma}(e^{B}) by repeated differentiation of the integral formula for dexp⁡Bd\exp_{B}, the unique term containing mm derivatives of BB is dexp⁡B(∂γB)d\exp_{B}(\partial^{\gamma}B). Every other term is a finite product with at least two positive-order derivatives of BB and total order at most mm. In two dimensions the H1+εH^{1+\varepsilon} factor controls the low-order products, while the remaining derivative is placed in Hm−1H^{m-1}. The spectral bound absorbs the exponential coefficients.

Proposition 5.4 (Good-unknown estimate). Let s≥3s\ge3 and suppose

∫0T∥∇u(t)∥B∞,102 dt+∥B∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)<∞\int_{0}^{T}\|\nabla u(t)\|_{B^{0}_{\infty,1}}^{2}\,\mathrm{d}t+\|B\|_{L^{4}(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}<\infty

for some ε>0\varepsilon>0. If BB has bounded spectrum on [0,T][0,T], then for every 2≤m≤s2\le m\le s,

ddt∥B∥Hm≤C(1+∥∇u∥B∞,10+∥B∥H1+ε2)(1+∥B∥Hm+∥u∥Hm+1).\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}t}\|B\|_{H^{m}}\le C\left(1+\|\nabla u\|_{B^{0}_{\infty,1}}+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^{2}\right)\left(1+\|B\|_{H^{m}}+\|u\|_{H^{m+1}}\right).

Proof. Write the logarithmic equation as

∂tB+u⋅∇B=F(B,∇u),F(B,M)=(dexp⁡B)−1(MeB+eBMT−λ−1(eB−I)).\partial_t B + u \cdot\nabla B = \mathcal{F}(B,\nabla u), \qquad\mathcal{F}(B,M) = (\mathrm{d}\exp_B)^{-1}\left(Me^B + e^B M^{T} - \lambda^{-1}(e^B-I)\right).

On a fixed spectral window, Lemma 5.1 and Lemma 3.1 give the tame bound

∥F(B,∇u)∥Hm≤CK(1+∥B∥H1+ε2)(1+∥B∥Hm+∥u∥Hm+1).\|\mathcal{F}(B,\nabla u)\|_{H^m} \le C_K\left(1+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2\right)\left(1+\|B\|_{H^m}+\|u\|_{H^{m+1}}\right).

Indeed the top derivative falls either on ∇u\nabla u, giving ∥u∥Hm+1\|u\|_{H^{m+1}}, or on one copy of BB in the exponential coefficients, giving a term linear in ∥B∥Hm\|B\|_{H^m}; all remaining factors are placed in H1+ε↪L∞H^{1+\varepsilon}\hookrightarrow L^\infty. Differentiating the transport equation and pairing with ∂γB\partial^\gamma B yields

12ddt∥∂γB∥L22=−∫T2∂γB[∂γ,u⋅∇]B dx+∫T2∂γB∂γF dx.\frac{1}{2}\frac{d}{dt}\|\partial^\gamma B\|_{L^2}^2=-\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}\partial^\gamma B[\partial^\gamma,u\cdot\nabla]B\,dx+\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}\partial^\gamma B\partial^\gamma\mathcal{F}\,dx.

The endpoint transport commutator is bounded by Lemma 3.2:

∣∫T2∂γB[∂γ,u⋅∇]B dx∣≤C∥∇u∥B∞,10∥B∥Hm2.\left|\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}\partial^\gamma B[\partial^\gamma,u\cdot\nabla]B\,dx\right|\le C\|\nabla u\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}\|B\|_{H^m}^2.

After summing over ∣γ∣≤m|\gamma|\le m, using (5), and taking the square root of the resulting differential inequality, we obtain eq:5.4. The good unknown GγG_\gamma gives an equivalent way to phrase the same estimate in the differentiated conformation variable ∂γA\partial^\gamma A: by Lemma 5.3, Gγ−∂γBG_\gamma-\partial^\gamma B is lower order and is absorbed by the ∥B∥H1+ε2(1+∥B∥Hm)\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2(1+\|B\|_{H^m}) term.

Coupled Vorticity–Stress Criterion

Let ω=curl⁡u\omega=\operatorname{curl}u. Taking curl of the momentum equation gives

∂tω+u⋅∇ω−νΔω=αcurl⁡div⁡(eB).\partial_t\omega+u\cdot\nabla\omega-\nu\Delta\omega=\alpha\operatorname{curl}\operatorname{div}(e^B).

This is the only place where the parabolic velocity equation sees derivatives of the conformation tensor.

Lemma 6.1 (Critical velocity-gradient control). For divergence-free velocity fields on T2\mathbb{T}^2,

∥∇u∥B∞,10≤C(∥ω∥B∞,10+∥u∥L2).\|\nabla u\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}\le C\left(\|\omega\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}+\|u\|_{L^2}\right).

Moreover, for every m>1m>1,

∣∫T2∂γf∂γ(u⋅∇f) dx∣≤C∥∇u∥B∞,10∥f∥Hm2,∣γ∣≤m.\left|\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}\partial^\gamma f\partial^\gamma(u\cdot\nabla f)\,dx\right|\le C\|\nabla u\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}\|f\|_{H^m}^2,\qquad|\gamma|\le m.

Proof. The first estimate is the periodic Biot–Savart law in the endpoint Besov scale, with the mean mode controlled by ∥u∥L2\|u\|_{L^2}. The second is Lemma 3.2.

Lemma 6.2 (Stress forcing estimate). Let s≥3s\ge3 and 0<ε<10<\varepsilon<1. If BB has bounded spectrum, then

∥curl⁡div⁡(eB)∥Hs−2≤C(1+∥B∥H1+ε2)(1+∥B∥Hs).\|\operatorname{curl}\operatorname{div}(e^B)\|_{H^{s-2}}\le C\left(1+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2\right)\left(1+\|B\|_{H^s}\right).

Proof. Since curl div is a second-order operator,

∥curl⁡div⁡(eB)∥Hs−2≤C∥eB−I∥Hs.\|\operatorname{curl}\operatorname{div}(e^B)\|_{H^{s-2}}\le C\|e^B-I\|_{H^s}.

The linear tame estimate eq:5.1 already gives

∥eB−I∥Hs≤CK(1+∥B∥Hs).\|e^B-I\|_{H^s}\le C_K(1+\|B\|_{H^s}).

For later use in the coupled energy inequality we record the slightly more robust form with the harmless factor (1+∥B∥H1+ε2)(1+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2). Equivalently, differentiating

eB−I=∫01eθBB dθe^B-I=\int_0^1 e^{\theta B}B\,d\theta

shows that the top derivative is linear in ∂sB\partial^s B, with bounded coefficients, while all commutators contain at least two positive-order derivatives of BB. In two dimensions H1+ε↪L∞H^{1+\varepsilon}\hookrightarrow L^\infty, so these commutators are bounded by

CK∥B∥H1+ε2(1+∥B∥Hs).C_K\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2(1+\|B\|_{H^s}).

Combining the top-order and commutator bounds gives (6.2).

Proposition 6.3 (High-order energy inequality). Let s≥3s\geq3, 0<ε<10<\varepsilon<1, and assume ∥B∥L∞≤K\|B\|_{L^\infty}\leq K. A smooth solution satisfies

ddt(∥u∥Hs2+∥B∥Hs2)+ν∥u∥Hs+12≤CK(1+∥∇u∥B∞,1∞2+∥B∥H1+ε4)(1+∥u∥Hs2+∥B∥Hs2).\frac{d}{dt}\left(\|u\|_{H^s}^2+\|B\|_{H^s}^2\right)+\nu\|u\|_{H^{s+1}}^2\leq C_K\left(1+\|\nabla u\|_{B^\infty_{\infty,1}}^2+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4\right)\left(1+\|u\|_{H^s}^2+\|B\|_{H^s}^2\right).

Proof. Apply ∂γ\partial^\gamma, ∣γ∣≤s|\gamma|\leq s, to the momentum equation and test against ∂γu\partial^\gamma u. The pressure term vanishes, the transport commutator is controlled by Lemma 3.2, and viscosity gives ν∥u∥Hs+12\nu\|u\|_{H^{s+1}}^2. The stress force is estimated by integration by parts, Young’s inequality, and Lemma 6.2:

∣α⟨∂γdiv⁡(eB−I),∂γu⟩∣≤ν4∥u∥Hs+12+CK(1+∥B∥H1+ε4)(1+∥B∥Hs2).\left|\alpha\langle\partial^\gamma\operatorname{div}(e^B-I),\partial^\gamma u\rangle\right|\leq\frac{\nu}{4}\|u\|_{H^{s+1}}^2+C_K\left(1+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4\right)\left(1+\|B\|_{H^s}^2\right).

For the logarithmic stress, Proposition 5.4 with m=sm=s gives, after multiplication by ∥B∥Hs\|B\|_{H^s},

ddt∥B∥Hs2≤ν4∥u∥Hs+12+CK(1+∥∇u∥B∞,1∞2+∥B∥H1+ε4)(1+∥u∥Hs2+∥B∥Hs2),\frac{d}{dt}\|B\|_{H^s}^2\leq\frac{\nu}{4}\|u\|_{H^{s+1}}^2+C_K\left(1+\|\nabla u\|_{B^\infty_{\infty,1}}^2+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4\right)\left(1+\|u\|_{H^s}^2+\|B\|_{H^s}^2\right),

where the term (1+∥∇u∥B∞,1∞+∥B∥H1+ε2)∥B∥Hs∥u∥Hs+1(1+\|\nabla u\|_{B^\infty_{\infty,1}}+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2)\|B\|_{H^s}\|u\|_{H^{s+1}} is absorbed by Young’s inequality. Adding the velocity and stress estimates and absorbing the two ν/4\nu/4-terms gives (6.3).

Theorem 6.4 (Geometric continuation criterion). Let s≥3s\geq3, 0<ε<10<\varepsilon<1, and let (u,A)(u,A) be a smooth solution of (1)–(2) on [0,T)[0,T), with A=eBA=e^B. Assume that the spectral range of BB is bounded on [0,T)[0,T). Then a sufficient condition for continuation beyond TT is

∫0T∥∇u(t)∥B∞,1∞2 dt+∥B∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)<∞.\int_0^T\|\nabla u(t)\|_{B^\infty_{\infty,1}}^2\,dt+\|B\|_{L^4(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}<\infty.

Proof. By Proposition 6.3,

ddtY(t)≤CK(1+∥∇u(t)∥B∞,1∞2+∥B(t)∥H1+ε4)(1+Y(t)),\frac{d}{dt}Y(t)\leq C_K\left(1+\|\nabla u(t)\|_{B^\infty_{\infty,1}}^2+\|B(t)\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4\right)(1+Y(t)),

where Y(t)=∥u(t)∥Hs2+∥B(t)∥Hs2Y(t)=\|u(t)\|_{H^s}^2+\|B(t)\|_{H^s}^2. The coefficient on the right-hand side is integrable by (6.4). Gronwall’s inequality therefore gives sup⁡t<TY(t)<∞\sup_{t<T}Y(t)<\infty. Lemma 5.1 transfers this bound from BB to A=eBA=e^B, and the spectral assumption gives boundedness of A−1A^{-1}. Proposition 2.3 extends the solution beyond TT.

Corollary 6.5 (Breakdown alternative). Let T∗T_\ast be the first breakdown time of a smooth solution. Then at least one of the following alternatives occurs:

∫0T∗∥∇u(t)∥B∞,1∞2 dt=∞,∥Log⁡A∥L4(0,T∗;H1+ε)=∞,\int_0^{T_\ast}\|\nabla u(t)\|_{B^\infty_{\infty,1}}^2\,dt=\infty,\qquad\|\operatorname{Log} A\|_{L^4(0,T_\ast;H^{1+\varepsilon})}=\infty,

or

∥Log⁡A∥L∞((0,T∗)×T2)=∞.\lVert\operatorname{Log} A\rVert_{L^\infty((0,T_\ast)\times\mathbb{T}^2)}=\infty.

Here Log⁡A\operatorname{Log} A denotes the symmetric matrix logarithm, so this last alternative is exactly loss of a compact spectral window for AA. Equivalently, away from spectral degeneration of the conformation tensor, finite-time breakdown must pass through either loss of flow-map control or logarithmic conformation concentration.

Proof. If all three quantities were finite, then the spectral range of B=Log⁡AB=\operatorname{Log} A would be bounded and eq:6.4 would hold. Theorem 6.4 would continue the solution beyond T∗T_\ast, contrary to the definition of the first breakdown time.

Corollary 6.6 (Coupled vorticity–stress form). Under the hypotheses of Theorem 6.4, finite-time breakdown forces divergence of the coupled diagnostic

∫0T∗(∥ω(t)∥B∞,102+∥Log⁡A(t)∥H1+ε4) dt=∞,\int_{0}^{T_\ast}\left(\lVert\omega(t)\rVert_{B^0_{\infty,1}}^2+\lVert\operatorname{Log} A(t)\rVert_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4\right)\,\mathrm{d}t=\infty,

unless the spectral range of AA degenerates.

Proof. In two dimensions the Biot–Savart law controls ∥∇u∥B∞,10\lVert\nabla u\rVert_{B^0_{\infty,1}} by the corresponding vorticity Besov norm, up to the harmless mean velocity mode.

Corollary 6.7 (BKM-type logarithmic conformation criterion). Let T∗T_\ast be the first breakdown time of a smooth positive-cone solution, and assume that the spectrum of AA stays in a compact subset of S++2\mathbb{S}_{++}^2 on [0,T∗)[0,T_\ast). Then

∫0T∗(∥ω(t)∥B∞,102+∥Log⁡A(t)∥H1+ε4) dt=∞.\int_{0}^{T_\ast}\left(\lVert\omega(t)\rVert_{B^0_{\infty,1}}^2+\lVert\operatorname{Log} A(t)\rVert_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4\right)\,\mathrm{d}t=\infty.

Equivalently, a finite-time singularity away from the boundary of the positive cone must be accompanied by either vorticity-Besov growth or logarithmic conformation concentration.

Proof. This is Corollary 6.6 with the spectral-degeneration alternative excluded by hypothesis.

Why Entropy and Relaxation Do Not Close the Criterion

The entropy controls the eigenvalues of AA in an integral sense but is blind to rapid oscillation of a bounded logarithmic conformation field. The next proposition records the elementary obstruction.

Proposition 7.1 (High-frequency entropy-blind sequence). Let H∈S2H\in\mathbb{S}^2 be nonzero and trace free, and let

BN(x)=δsin⁡(Nx1)H,AN=eBN.B_N(x)=\delta\sin(Nx_1)H,\qquad A_N=e^{B_N}.

For each fixed δ>0\delta>0, the entropy density

tr⁡AN−log⁡det⁡AN−2\operatorname{tr} A_N-\log\det A_N-2

is bounded uniformly in NN in every LpL^p, 1≤p<∞1\le p<\infty, while

∥BN∥H1+ε→∞as N→∞.\lVert B_N\rVert_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}\to\infty\qquad\text{as }N\to\infty.

Proof. The spectrum of BNB_N is contained in a fixed compact interval depending only on δ\delta and HH, so the entropy density is uniformly bounded. The H1+εH^{1+\varepsilon} norm grows like N1+εN^{1+\varepsilon}.

Remark 7.2 (Interpretation). Proposition eq:7.1 does not construct a solution. It shows that any argument using only entropy, relaxation, and positivity cannot control the high-frequency logarithmic term. The continuation criterion therefore requires either flow-map control or additional regularity of Log⁡A\operatorname{Log} A.

Proposition 7.3 (Relaxation does not give a derivative). Let BN,ANB_N,A_N be as in Proposition eq:7.1. Then the relaxation density

tr⁡(AN+AN−1−2I)\operatorname{tr}(A_N+A_N^{-1}-2I)

is uniformly bounded in every LpL^p, 1≤p<∞1 \le p < \infty, while ∥BN∥H1+ε→∞\lVert B_N\rVert_{H^{1+\varepsilon}} \to\infty. In particular, the entropy dissipation term in eq:4.2 cannot control the logarithmic concentration appearing in Theorem eq:6.4.

Proof. The eigenvalues of ANA_N and AN−1A_N^{-1} remain in a compact interval depending only on δ\delta and HH. Hence the relaxation density is uniformly bounded pointwise. The Sobolev growth of BNB_N is unchanged from Proposition eq:7.1.

Remark 7.4 (What log-geometry does and does not do). The logarithmic coordinate prevents loss of positive definiteness and gives an elliptic chart on the cone. It does not, by itself, add smoothing. Thus log-geometry is a way to state the obstruction, not an automatic closure mechanism. Any argument based on B=Log⁡AB=\operatorname{Log} A must still control the high-frequency norm in eq:6.4.

Remark 7.5 (Closed criterion versus the Lt2L_t^2 target). The proof above closes the continuation argument under the integrability condition in eq:6.4. The lower Lt2Hx1+εL_t^2H_x^{1+\varepsilon} logarithmic quantity appears naturally in the commutator structure, but the present high-order energy proof loses a square when the ∥u∥Hs+1\lVert u\rVert_{H^{s+1}} term in the logarithmic equation is absorbed by viscosity. Removing this loss would require a more precise coupling between the parabolic velocity smoothing and the log-conformation transport equation.

Proposition 7.6 (Conditional improvement of the time exponent). Assume the hypotheses of Theorem eq:6.4. Suppose, in addition, that the logarithmic equation admits the following improved coupled estimate: for every δ>0\delta>0, there is a constant CK,δC_{K,\delta} such that

ddt∥B∥Hs2≤δ∥u∥Hs+12+CK,δ(1+∥∇u∥B∞,1θ+∥B∥H1+ε2)(1+∥u∥Hs2+∥B∥Hs2).\frac{d}{dt}\lVert B\rVert_{H^s}^2 \le\delta\lVert u\rVert_{H^{s+1}}^2+C_{K,\delta}\left(1+\lVert\nabla u\rVert_{B^\theta_{\infty,1}}+\lVert B\rVert_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2\right)\left(1+\lVert u\rVert_{H^s}^2+\lVert B\rVert_{H^s}^2\right).

Then the continuation conclusion of Theorem eq:6.4 holds under the Lt2L_t^2-based condition

∫0T∥∇u(t)∥B∞,1θ dt+∥B∥L2(0,T;H1+ε)<∞.\int_0^T \lVert\nabla u(t)\rVert_{B^\theta_{\infty,1}}\,dt+\lVert B\rVert_{L^2(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}<\infty.

Proof. Add eq:7.6, with δ=ν/4\delta=\nu/4, to the velocity estimate used in the proof of Proposition eq:6.3. This gives

ddtY(t)≤CK(1+∥∇u(t)∥B∞,1θ+∥B(t)∥H1+ε2)(1+Y(t)),\frac{d}{dt}Y(t)\le C_K\left(1+\lVert\nabla u(t)\rVert_{B^\theta_{\infty,1}}+\lVert B(t)\rVert_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2\right)(1+Y(t)),

where Y(t)=∥u(t)∥Hs2+∥B(t)∥Hs2Y(t)=\lVert u(t)\rVert_{H^s}^2+\lVert B(t)\rVert_{H^s}^2. The coefficient is integrable by eq:7.6, and the rest of the proof is identical to Theorem eq:6.4.

Remark 7.7 (Where the improvement would enter). The only difference between Proposition eq:7.6 and the proved continuation theorem is the treatment of the mixed term coupling ∥B∥Hs\lVert B\rVert_{H^s} to ∥u∥Hs+1\lVert u\rVert_{H^{s+1}} in the log-conformation equation. A cancellation, compensated compactness estimate, or refined good unknown that places this term directly under the viscous dissipation would upgrade the closed Lt4L_t^4 logarithmic criterion to the Lt2L_t^2 target.

The finite-extensibility barrier for FENE-P

We now record the part of the argument which is not present in Oldroyd–B. In the FENE-P system the conformation tensor must remain in

Db={C∈S++2:tr⁡C<b}.\mathcal{D}_{b} = \left\{ C \in\mathbb{S}^{2}_{++} : \operatorname{tr} C < b \right\}.

The logarithmic conformation B=Log⁡CB = \operatorname{Log} C still controls the lower spectral boundary of the positive cone, but it does not control the upper trace boundary. The missing coordinate is

ϕb(C)=−log⁡(b−tr⁡C).\phi_{b}(C) = -\log(b - \operatorname{tr} C).

The role of this section is to show that the FENE-P continuation criterion is the Oldroyd–B criterion plus this single additional geometric clock.

Definition 8.1 (Compact FENE window). A FENE-P solution lies in a compact FENE window on [0,T][0,T] if there exist constants 0<c0<c1<∞0 < c_{0} < c_{1} < \infty and δ>0\delta> 0 such that

c0I≤C(t,x)≤c1I,tr⁡C(t,x)≤b−δc_{0}I \le C(t,x) \le c_{1}I, \qquad\operatorname{tr} C(t,x) \le b - \delta

for all (t,x)∈[0,T]×T2(t,x) \in[0,T] \times\mathbb{T}^{2}.

Lemma 8.2 (FENE window recovery). Let C(x)∈DbC(x) \in\mathcal{D}_{b}. If

∥Log⁡C∥L∞≤M,∥ϕb(C)∥L∞≤Mb,\lVert\operatorname{Log} C \rVert_{L^{\infty}} \le M, \qquad\lVert\phi_{b}(C) \rVert_{L^{\infty}} \le M_{b},

then

e−MI≤C≤eMI,tr⁡C≤b−e−Mb.e^{-M}I \le C \le e^{M}I, \qquad\operatorname{tr} C \le b - e^{-M_{b}}.

In particular the logarithmic field and the barrier field recover a compact FENE window.

Proof. The eigenvalues of CC are exponentials of the eigenvalues of Log⁡C\operatorname{Log} C, which gives the spectral bounds. The barrier bound gives −log⁡(b−tr⁡C)≤Mb-\log(b - \operatorname{tr} C) \le M_{b}, hence b−tr⁡C≥e−Mbb - \operatorname{tr} C \ge e^{-M_{b}}.

Lemma 8.3 (Smooth coordinates on compact FENE windows). Let s>1s > 1. On every compact FENE window K⋐DbK \Subset\mathcal{D}_{b}, the quantities

∥C∥Hs,∥Log⁡C∥Hs,∥Tb(C)∥Hs\lVert C \rVert_{H^{s}}, \qquad\lVert\operatorname{Log} C \rVert_{H^{s}}, \qquad\lVert T_{b}(C) \rVert_{H^{s}}

are mutually controlled, with constants depending on KK, ss, bb. Moreover

∥fb(C)∥Hs≤CK,s,b(1+∥ϕb(C)∥Hs).\lVert f_{b}(C) \rVert_{H^{s}} \le C_{K,s,b}\left(1 + \lVert\phi_{b}(C) \rVert_{H^{s}}\right).

Proof. The first statement follows from the Sobolev composition theorem on compact subsets of Db\mathcal{D}_{b}. For the spring factor,

fb(C)=b−2b−tr⁡C=(b−2)eϕb(C).f_{b}(C) = \frac{b - 2}{b - \operatorname{tr} C} = (b - 2)e^{\phi_{b}(C)}.

The L∞L^{\infty} bound supplied by the compact window and the Moser composition estimate give the displayed inequality.

The FENE-P free energy is

Fb(C)=−(b−2)log⁡(1−tr⁡Cb)−log⁡det⁡C.\mathcal{F}_{b}(C) = -(b - 2)\log\left(1 - \frac{\operatorname{tr} C}{b}\right) - \log\det C.

It contains both boundaries of Db\mathcal{D}_{b}: the logarithmic determinant sees loss of positive definiteness, while the first term sees the trace boundary. This zeroth-order information is important, but it is not the same as the high-frequency barrier control needed for continuation.

Proposition 8.4 (FENE-P free-energy identity). *For smooth FENE-P solutions with C∈DbC \in D_b,

ddt[12∥u∥L22+α2λ∫T2Fb(C) dx]+ν∥∇u∥L22+α2λ2∫T2Dbrel(C) dx=0,(8)\frac{d}{dt}\left[\frac{1}{2}\|u\|_{L^2}^2+\frac{\alpha}{2\lambda}\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}\mathcal{F}_b(C)\,dx\right]+\nu\|\nabla u\|_{L^2}^2+\frac{\alpha}{2\lambda^2}\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}\mathcal{D}_b^{\mathrm{rel}}(C)\,dx=0, \tag*{(8)}

where Dbrel(C)≥0\mathcal{D}_b^{\mathrm{rel}}(C)\ge0 is the FENE-P relaxation dissipation.*

Proof. Multiplying the velocity equation by uu gives the coupling term −α∫Tb(C):∇u dx-\alpha\int T_b(C):\nabla u\,dx. The variational derivative of Fb\mathcal{F}_b is fb(C)I−C−1f_b(C)I-C^{-1}. Pairing this derivative with the conformation equation cancels the stretching term against the velocity coupling. The remaining relaxation contribution is nonnegative by convexity of Fb\mathcal{F}_b on DbD_b.

The new differential structure is the trace-gap equation. Taking the trace of (5) gives

Dttr⁡C=2C:∇u−λ−1(fb(C)tr⁡C−2),Dt=∂t+u⋅∇.D_t\operatorname{tr}C=2C:\nabla u-\lambda^{-1}\left(f_b(C)\operatorname{tr}C-2\right),\qquad D_t=\partial_t+u\cdot\nabla.

Writing g=b−tr⁡Cg=b-\operatorname{tr}C, we obtain

Dtg=−2C:∇u+λ−1(b−2gtr⁡C−2).(9)D_tg=-2C:\nabla u+\lambda^{-1}\left(\frac{b-2}{g}\operatorname{tr}C-2\right). \tag*{(9)}

Equivalently,

Dtϕb=2C:∇ug−λ−1(b−2)tr⁡Cg2+2λ−11g.(10)D_t\phi_b=\frac{2C:\nabla u}{g}-\lambda^{-1}\frac{(b-2)\operatorname{tr}C}{g^2}+2\lambda^{-1}\frac{1}{g}. \tag*{(10)}

The negative g−2g^{-2} term is the finite-extensibility restoring force. It helps at the level of pointwise trace control, but after differentiating the equation all coefficients still contain powers of the trace gap. This is why ϕb\phi_b appears as a separate continuation variable.

Proposition 8.5 (FENE-P geometric high-order estimate). *Let s≥3s\ge3, 0<ε<10<\varepsilon<1, and let (u,C)(u,C) be a smooth FENE-P solution on [0,T][0,T] whose conformation tensor remains in a compact FENE window. Set

B=Log⁡C,ϕ=ϕb(C),B=\operatorname{Log}C,\qquad\phi=\phi_b(C),

and

YsFENE(t)=∥u(t)∥Hs2+∥B(t)∥Hs2+∥ϕ(t)∥Hs2.Y_s^{\mathrm{FENE}}(t)=\|u(t)\|_{H^s}^2+\|B(t)\|_{H^s}^2+\|\phi(t)\|_{H^s}^2.

Then

ddtYsFENE(t)≤CK(1+∥∇u(t)∥B0,1∞2+∥B(t)∥H1+ε4+∥ϕ(t)∥H1+ε4)(1+YsFENE(t)),(11)\frac{d}{dt}Y_s^{\mathrm{FENE}}(t)\le C_K\left(1+\|\nabla u(t)\|_{B^\infty_{0,1}}^2+\|B(t)\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4+\|\phi(t)\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4\right)\left(1+Y_s^{\mathrm{FENE}}(t)\right), \tag*{(11)}

where CKC_K depends on the compact FENE window and the fixed parameters.*

Proof. The velocity estimate is the parabolic estimate for the forced Navier–Stokes equation:

ddt∥u∥Hs2+ν∥u∥Hs+12≤C∥∇u∥B0,1∞∥u∥Hs2+C∥Tb(C)∥Hs2.\frac{d}{dt}\|u\|_{H^s}^2+\nu\|u\|_{H^{s+1}}^2\le C\|\nabla u\|_{B^\infty_{0,1}}\|u\|_{H^s}^2+C\|T_b(C)\|_{H^s}^2.

Lemma 8.3 controls Tb(C)T_b(C) by BB and ϕ\phi on the compact FENE window. For the logarithmic part, write C=eBC=e^B and apply (dexp⁡B)−1(d\exp_B)^{-1} to (5). On a compact spectral window the operators dexp⁡Bd\exp_B, (dexp⁡B)−1(d\exp_B)^{-1}, and their derivatives are smooth functions of BB with bounded composition constants. The top derivative is handled by the same good unknown as in the Oldroyd–B argument,

Gγ=(dexp⁡B)−1∂γC,∣γ∣≤s.\mathcal{G}_\gamma=(d\exp_B)^{-1}\partial^\gamma C,\qquad|\gamma|\le s.

The new FENE coefficients enter through

fb(C)=(b−2)eϕ,Tb(C)=fb(C)C−I.f_b(C)=(b-2)e^\phi,\qquad T_b(C)=f_b(C)C-I.

Since H1+ε(T2)↪Lp(T2)H^{1+\varepsilon}(\mathbb{T}^2) \hookrightarrow L^p(\mathbb{T}^2) for every finite pp, the two-dimensional Moser estimates give, for s≥3s \ge3,

∥fb(C)∥Hs+∥Tb(C)∥Hs≤CK(1+∥B∥Hs+∥ϕ∥Hs),\|f_b(C)\|_{H^s} + \|T_b(C)\|_{H^s} \le C_K\left(1 + \|B\|_{H^s} + \|\phi\|_{H^s}\right),

and the commutators with lower-order coefficients are bounded by

CK(1+∥B∥H1+ε2+∥ϕ∥H1+ε2)(1+∥B∥Hs2+∥ϕ∥Hs2).C_K\left(1 + \|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2 + \|\phi\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^2\right)\left(1 + \|B\|_{H^s}^2 + \|\phi\|_{H^s}^2\right).

After Young’s inequality, this gives the logarithmic contribution with the coefficient appearing in (11).

For the barrier part, differentiate the scalar equation (10). Its coefficients are finite sums of smooth functions of CC multiplied by powers of g−1=eϕg^{-1}=e^\phi. On a compact FENE window these coefficients are smooth functions of (B,ϕ)(B,\phi). The transport commutator is controlled by ∥∇u∥B∞,10∥ϕ∥Hs\|\nabla u\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}\|\phi\|_{H^s}. The differentiated stretching term 2C:∇u/g2C:\nabla u/g is estimated by the same Moser product bounds, and the top derivative of uu is absorbed by a small part of the viscous dissipation. The relaxation terms have the same structure, with coefficients depending on eϕe^\phi and C=eBC=e^B. Hence

ddt∥ϕ∥Hs2≤CK(1+∥∇u∥B∞,102+∥B∥H1+ε4+∥ϕ∥H1+ε4)(1+YsFENE)+ν8∥u∥Hs+12.\frac{d}{dt}\|\phi\|_{H^s}^2 \le C_K\left(1+\|\nabla u\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}^2+\|B\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4+\|\phi\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}^4\right)\left(1+Y_s^{\mathrm{FENE}}\right)+\frac{\nu}{8}\|u\|_{H^{s+1}}^2.

Adding the velocity, logarithmic, and barrier estimates gives (11).

Theorem 8.6 (Unified geometric continuation criterion). Let s≥3s \ge3 and 0<ε<10 < \varepsilon< 1. For Oldroyd–B, let (u,A)(u,A) be a strong positive-cone solution on [0,T)[0,T). Assume that AA remains in a compact spectral window of the positive cone. If

∫0T∥∇u(t)∥B∞,102 dt+∥Log⁡A∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)<∞,\int_0^T \|\nabla u(t)\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}^2\,dt+\|\operatorname{Log} A\|_{L^4(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}<\infty,

then the strong solution continues beyond TT.

For FENE-P, let (u,C)(u,C) be a strong FENE-P solution on [0,T)[0,T), so that C(t,x)∈DbC(t,x)\in D_b. Assume that

sup⁡t<T(∥Log⁡C(t)∥L∞+∥ϕb(C(t))∥L∞)<∞.\sup_{t<T}\left(\|\operatorname{Log} C(t)\|_{L^\infty}+\|\phi_b(C(t))\|_{L^\infty}\right)<\infty.

If

∫0T∥∇u(t)∥B∞,102 dt+∥Log⁡C∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)+∥ϕb(C)∥L4(0,T;H1+ε)<∞,\int_0^T \|\nabla u(t)\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}^2\,dt+\|\operatorname{Log} C\|_{L^4(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}+\|\phi_b(C)\|_{L^4(0,T;H^{1+\varepsilon})}<\infty,

then the FENE-P strong solution continues beyond TT.

Proof. The Oldroyd–B statement is Theorem 6.4. For FENE-P, the pointwise logarithmic and barrier bounds recover a compact FENE window by Lemma 8.2. The coefficient in (11) is integrable under the displayed criterion, so Gronwall’s inequality gives a uniform HsH^s bound for (u,Log⁡C,ϕb(C))(u,\operatorname{Log} C,\phi_b(C)). Lemma 8.3 transfers this bound to CC and Tb(C)T_b(C). Proposition 2.5 then restarts the solution inside the recovered compact FENE window and extends it beyond TT.

Corollary 8.7 (Three-channel breakdown alternative). At the first breakdown time of a smooth stress-diffusion-free solution, the Oldroyd–B model can fail only through the flow-map channel or the positive-cone logarithmic channel:

∫0T∗∥∇u(t)∥B∞,102 dt=∞,∥Log⁡A∥L4(0,T∗;H1+ε)=∞,\int_0^{T_*}\|\nabla u(t)\|_{B^0_{\infty,1}}^2\,dt=\infty,\qquad\|\operatorname{Log} A\|_{L^4(0,T_*;H^{1+\varepsilon})}=\infty,

or through loss of the compact spectral window. The FENE-P model has the same two channels and one additional finite-extensibility channel:

sup⁡t<T∗∥ϕb(C(t))∥L∞=∞or∥ϕb(C)∥L4(0,T∗;H1+ε)=∞.\sup_{t<T_*}\|\phi_b(C(t))\|_{L^\infty}=\infty\qquad\text{or}\qquad\|\phi_b(C)\|_{L^4(0,T_*;H^{1+\varepsilon})}=\infty.

Proof. If none of the listed quantities diverges, then the relevant continuation criterion in Theorem 8.6 applies and extends the solution beyond T∗T_*, a contradiction.

Hookean limit and relation between the two criteria

The FENE-P criterion reduces to the Oldroyd–B criterion only in a controlled limit. Suppose 0<C≤MI0 < C \le MI and tr⁡C≤M\operatorname{tr} C \le M, with MM independent of bb. Then

fb(C)=b−2b−tr⁡C=1+tr⁡C−2b+OM(b−2),f_b(C) = \frac{b-2}{b-\operatorname{tr} C} = 1 + \frac{\operatorname{tr} C-2}{b} + O_M(b^{-2}),

and hence

Tb(C)=C−I+tr⁡C−2bC+OM(b−2).T_b(C) = C-I+\frac{\operatorname{tr} C-2}{b}C+O_M(b^{-2}).

Moreover

ϕb(C)=−log⁡b+OM(b−1),∇ϕb(C)=∇tr⁡Cb−tr⁡C=OM(b−1)∇C.\phi_b(C)=-\log b+O_M(b^{-1}), \qquad\nabla\phi_b(C)=\frac{\nabla\operatorname{tr} C}{b-\operatorname{tr} C}=O_M(b^{-1})\nabla C.

Thus, on bounded trace windows independent of bb, the derivative-level barrier term becomes lower order and the FENE-P criterion formally reduces to the Oldroyd–B positive-cone criterion. At fixed bb, or along sequences for which tr⁡C\operatorname{tr} C approaches bb, this reduction is invalid. The barrier term then remains a separate high-frequency contribution.

Proposition 9.1 (Independence of the finite-extensibility channel). Fix b>2b>2. There are smooth diagonal fields CN:T2→DbC_N:\mathbb{T}^2\to\mathcal{D}_b whose eigenvalues stay in a fixed positive interval and whose positive-cone entropy

∫T2(tr⁡CN−log⁡det⁡CN) dx\int_{\mathbb{T}^2}(\operatorname{tr} C_N-\log\det C_N)\,dx

is uniformly bounded, while

∥ϕb(CN)∥H1+ε→∞.\|\phi_b(C_N)\|_{H^{1+\varepsilon}}\to\infty.

Proof. Choose

θN(x)=θ0+aNsin⁡(Nx1),\theta_N(x)=\theta_0+a_N\sin(Nx_1),

with 0<θ0<b0<\theta_0<b, aN→0a_N\to0, and aNN1+ε→∞a_NN^{1+\varepsilon}\to\infty. Let

CN(x)=θN(x)2I.C_N(x)=\frac{\theta_N(x)}{2}I.

For NN large, the eigenvalues remain in a fixed positive interval and the positive-cone entropy is uniformly bounded. However

ϕb(CN)=−log⁡(b−θN),\phi_b(C_N)=-\log(b-\theta_N),

whose H1+εH^{1+\varepsilon} norm grows like aNN1+εa_NN^{1+\varepsilon}. Thus positive-cone entropy does not control the FENE-P barrier norm.

Conclusion

The positive-cone geometry of Oldroyd–B is naturally expressed by A=eBA=e^B. In these coordinates the entropy law guarantees physical admissibility and spectral control, but it does not control high-frequency oscillation of BB. The continuation criterion proved here isolates the remaining obstruction: finite-time breakdown requires divergence of a coupled vorticity–stress diagnostic involving the velocity Besov modulus and the supercritical logarithmic conformation norm in the closed Lt2B∞,10L_t^2B_{\infty,1}^0-Lt4H1+εL_t^4H^{1+\varepsilon} scale. The Lt4H1+εL_t^4H^{1+\varepsilon} exponent is the price paid here for a closed nonlinear estimate of the matrix-exponential commutators. Proposition 7.6 records the additional estimate that would give an Lt2H1+εL_t^2H^{1+\varepsilon} logarithmic stress criterion.

The result gives a closed continuation criterion inside the positive cone and separates the logarithmic high-frequency term from the zeroth-order entropy structure. Entropy and relaxation preserve important parts of the conformation geometry, but they do not control the derivative norm that appears in the criterion. Thus any further global argument for the stress-diffusion-free system must supply this missing control, or use a cancellation not captured by the present high-order estimate.

The same interpretation applies to the finitely extensible case. The FENE-P criterion contains the Oldroyd–B logarithmic term and adds the barrier ϕb(C)=−log⁡(b−tr⁡C)\phi_b(C)=-\log(b-\operatorname{tr} C). On bounded trace windows this barrier becomes lower order as b→∞b \to\infty, which recovers the Hookean criterion. At fixed bb, the trace-gap term remains part of the continuation mechanism.

The conditional estimate in Proposition 7.6 records where an Lt2H1+εL_t^2 H^{1+\varepsilon} criterion would enter the proof.

Acknowledgements

The author acknowledges financial support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC, Grant No. 12501602), the Education Department of Hunan Province (Grant No. 24C0055), the Science and Technology Department of Hunan Province (Grant No. 2025JJ60052), and the Scientific Research Start-up Fund of Xiangtan University (Grant No. KZ0810769).

References

  1. [1]J. W. Barrett and S. Boyaval, Existence and approximation of a regularized Oldroyd–B model, Mathematical Models and Methods in Applied Sciences, 21 (2011), pp. 1783–1837.DOI
  2. [2]J. T. Beale, T. Kato, and A. Majda, Remarks on the breakdown of smooth solutions for the 3-D Euler equations, Communications in Mathematical Physics, 94 (1984), pp. 61–66.DOI
  3. [3]R. B. Bird, R. C. Armstrong, and O. Hassager, Dynamics of Polymeric Liquids, Vol. 1: Fluid Mechanics, 2nd ed., Wiley, New York, 1987.
  4. [4]J.-Y. Chemin and N. Masmoudi, About lifespan of regular solutions of equations related to viscoelastic fluids, SIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis, 33 (2001), pp. 84–112.DOI
  5. [5]P. Constantin and M. Kliegl, Note on global regularity for two-dimensional Oldroyd–B fluids with diffusive stress, Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 206 (2012), pp. 725–740.DOI
  6. [6]T. M. Elgindi and F. Rousset, Global regularity for some Oldroyd–B type models, Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 68 (2015), pp. 2005–2021.arxiv.org/abs/1308.0746
  7. [7]R. Fattal and R. Kupferman, Constitutive laws for the matrix-logarithm of the conformation tensor, Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics, 123 (2004), pp. 281–285.DOI
  8. [8]R. Fattal and R. Kupferman, Time-dependent simulation of viscoelastic flows at high Weissenberg number using the log-conformation representation, Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics, 126 (2005), pp. 23–37.DOI
  9. [9]C. Guillopé and J.-C. Saut, Existence results for the flow of viscoelastic fluids with a differential constitutive law, Nonlinear Analysis, 15 (1990), pp. 849–869.DOI
  10. [10]Z. Lei, N. Masmoudi, and Y. Zhou, Remarks on the blowup criteria for Oldroyd models, Journal of Differential Equations, 248 (2010), pp. 328–341.arxiv.org/abs/0907.2745
  11. [11]P.-L. Lions and N. Masmoudi, Global solutions for some Oldroyd models of non-Newtonian flows, Chinese Annals of Mathematics, 21B (2000), pp. 131–146.
  12. [12]N. Masmoudi, Well-posedness for the FENE dumbbell model of polymeric flows, Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 61 (2008), pp. 1685–1714.DOI
  13. [13]J. G. Oldroyd, On the formulation of rheological equations of state, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series A, 200 (1950), pp. 523–541.DOI
  14. [14]Y. Z. Yu, Y. H. Wang, and H. Y. Wen, The Cauchy problem for an inviscid and non-diffusive Oldroyd–B model in two dimensions, Nonlinear Analysis: Real World Applications, 79 (2024), Paper No. 104100, 17 pp.

Paper details

vlnc:W_rxq7tfhy
Published
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents