WorksMathematics
The symmetric Mahler conjecture and its equality cases
Abstract
We resolve the symmetric Mahler conjecture positively, including its equality classification. Every origin-symmetric convex body in has volume product at least , with equality exactly for invertible linear images of Hanner polytopes.
Introduction
A convex body is a compact convex subset of with nonempty interior. If , its center is an interior point, and its polar body is
Write for -dimensional Lebesgue volume and for the volume product. The two determinant factors cancel under an invertible linear change of coordinates, so . Mahler’s symmetric volume-product problem asks how small this linear invariant can be. The conjectured value is , the product of a cube and its polar cross-polytope. We prove this bound in every dimension and classify the equality cases.
The extremal bodies are defined recursively. A centered nondegenerate interval is a one-dimensional Hanner polytope. Given Hanner polytopes and , their Cartesian product and the convex hull
are Hanner polytopes in . These are the and sums, respectively. This class contains cubes, cross-polytopes, and mixed recursive sums. We call an invertible linear image of a Hanner polytope a linear Hanner body.
Theorem 1.1. For every integer and every origin-symmetric convex body ,
Equality holds if and only if is a linear Hanner body.
The linear equivalence in the statement respects the fixed origin used for polarity.
History and context
Mahler introduced the volume-product problem in his work on convex bodies and transference in the geometry of numbers [22]; the planar inequality also goes back to him [21]. Reisner later characterized its equality cases as parallelograms, as a consequence of his zonoid theorem [28], p. 340. Iriyeh and Shibata proved the complete three-dimensional symmetric theorem, including equality [14], Theorem 1.1. Fradelizi, Hubard, Meyer, Roldán-Pensado, and Zvavitch gave a shorter proof based on equipartitions, together with another equality argument and stability [9]. Chen, Li, Xi, and Xu recently gave a shadow-flow proof of that theorem in a preprint that also treats the nonsymmetric three-dimensional problem [4], Theorem 7.1.
Hanner’s recursively constructed spaces [12] already play a central role in the known higher-dimensional cases. Saint-Raymond proved the sharp inequality for unconditional bodies (those invariant under coordinate sign changes) [30]; Meyer and Reisner identified the Hanner equality cases in that class [23, 29]. Reisner also proved the sharp inequality for zonoids, which are Hausdorff limits of Minkowski sums of centered segments, and showed that equality within that class means a parallelotope [27, 28]; Gordon, Meyer, and Reisner later gave a short geometric proof [10]. For local questions in Banach–Mazur distance, Nazarov, Petrov, Ryabogin, and Zvavitch established strict local minimality, up to linear equivalence, of the cube [25]. Kim extended this to all Hanner polytopes [16]. Kim and Zvavitch obtained stability in the unconditional class and the inequality in a neighborhood of that class [17].
A separate line of work seeks dimension-independent exponential bounds without the sharp constant. Bourgain and Milman established such a reverse Blaschke–Santaló inequality [3]; Kuperberg obtained an explicit stronger bound by a geometric argument using Gauss linking integrals [18]. Complex-analytic approaches provide another setting for these questions. Nazarov used Hörmander’s theorem and Bergman kernels for the reverse Blaschke–Santaló inequality [24]. Berndtsson recast Kuperberg’s proof using complex integrals [1]. In a symplectic approach, Karasev proved the sharp inequality for hyperplane sections and projections of balls () and Hanner polytopes [15], Theorems 4.2 and 4.4. These works give analytic and geometric precedents for volume-product estimates; their estimates are not hypotheses of our proof.
The analytic ingredient is a conformal map of the disk for which uniform angular measure on the boundary maps to a uniform imaginary coordinate. It is a rotation of Gross’s example for the uniform distribution in his conformal Skorokhod embedding [11], Section 3.2. A holomorphic mass estimate turns that boundary law into a lower bound for an integral of feasible-simplex volumes over the primal body. We prove the mass estimate directly by Stokes’ theorem, with its precise normalization; its general background is the theory of generalized Lelong numbers [6], Sections 3 and 5. The symmetric-convex extremal-function framework of Lundin and Baran was a further motivation for the analytic search; see [20] and the formula recorded in [2], Proposition 1.2, pp. 246–247. The proof here instead uses the direct isolated-zero mass calculation, not those extremal-function formulas as premises. The equality argument leads to a classical property of normed spaces: any three pairwise-intersecting closed balls have a common point. Hanner studied the associated recursively constructed convex bodies [12]. Lima’s norm-additive decomposition criterion [19], Theorem 1.2, also recorded in Hansen–Lima [13], Theorem 3.6(4), is exactly the metric-median condition used below. Reisner’s unconditional equality theorem already connects minimal volume product to this ball intersection structure [29], Theorem 1. Our endpoint argument obtains the structure without assuming unconditionality; Hansen–Lima’s finite-dimensional classification is the final input [13], Corollary 7.4.
For a body without a prescribed center, the general Mahler problem instead minimizes over . Its conjectured constant is smaller than the symmetric constant for ; a result for that general problem alone therefore does not establish Theorem 1.1. The argument here uses symmetry throughout and is independent of the general theorem proved in the companion paper [26], Theorem 1.1.
Proof overview
Section 2 records polarity and the two norm-sum formulas. They show that every Hanner body has the stated volume product. The remaining work is the lower bound and its converse equality statement.
First let
where the nonzero, pairwise nonproportional rows span . Section 3 constructs a planar lens with horizontal half-width at height . For , use this width to form
Each independent -tuple of signed constraints that are tight at one point of determines a simplex: take the convex hull of and those signed rows. Let be the union of these simplices. It lies in .
Write for the conformal map from the unit disk to the lens. For each set of independent rows, sample independent uniform angles and solve , , for the complex vector . Let be the probability that all remaining row coordinates also lie in the closed lens. Section 5 applies the mass estimate of Section 4 to high powers of the inverse map: after a change of radial variables, the Jacobian integrals concentrate on these boundary samples and force . The uniform imaginary coordinate then identifies this probability sum with the simplex integral in Section 6:
The first inequality is analytic; the last is the inclusion just described. The exact identity behind this bound also controls the missing volume . Approximation extends the inequality to all origin-symmetric convex bodies.
For equality, set and pass to the body
in dimension . The norm-sum formula preserves equality at the new dimension. Inner polytope approximations to therefore have integrated missing volume tending to zero. Section 7 uses product neighborhoods to obtain, for each interior point of and each nonzero direction, a representation whose rows attain their lens bounds at one vector satisfying all the constraints. This includes degenerate limiting representations. Finally, Section 8 examines points approaching an apex of . The lens asymptotic gives a support-function inequality, and convex separation gives a metric median for every triple in the norm with unit ball : a point whose distances to each pair sum to that pair’s distance. The Hansen–Lima theorem then identifies , and hence , as a linear Hanner body [13], Corollary 7.4.
We next derive functional and entropy–transport consequences of the all-dimensional theorem. The geometric proof begins in Section 2 and ends in Section 8.
Functional Mahler inequality
The volume-product problem has a functional form in which polarity is replaced by convex conjugation. For a proper lower-semicontinuous convex function , its Fenchel–Legendre transform is
We use the convention .
Corollary 1.2 (Even functional Mahler inequality). For every integer and every even proper lower-semicontinuous convex function such that ,
The second integral is allowed to be infinite, in which case the inequality is immediate.
Proof. Set , a nonzero integrable log-concave function. For , Fradelizi and Meyer use the polar function
and the translation-minimized functional volume product
Their Proposition 1(a) states that the symmetric geometric Mahler inequality in every dimension implies for every even log-concave function on with [7]. Theorem 1.1 supplies this all-dimensional hypothesis. Since , the product in Corollary 1.2 is at least .
The cited implication uses auxiliary convex bodies in dimensions and lets tend to infinity; it is not an application only of the geometric theorem in dimension . The constant is sharp: for , the transform is zero on and outside, and both integrals in the corollary equal . The equality classification in Theorem 1.1 concerns convex bodies. The limiting implication does not by itself classify the even potentials for which equality holds [7], p. 1437.
For potentials without evenness, the companion paper on general convex bodies gives the sharp lower bound [26], Corollary 1.2.
The functional inequality also has an entropy–transport formulation. For a log-concave probability measure with a density, let denote its entropy relative to Lebesgue measure, the negative of differential Shannon entropy. For probability measures with finite first moments, set
where is the class of proper lower-semicontinuous convex functions and is the Fenchel–Legendre transform. The cost is allowed to be .
Corollary 1.3 (Symmetric entropy–transport inequality). For every integer , let , , be full-dimensional log-concave probability measures, both symmetric about the origin, with proper lower-semicontinuous convex potentials . Suppose their densities are essentially continuous, meaning that at -almost every point of . Their moment measures have finite first moments, is finite, and
Proof. For , the identity holds almost everywhere on the interior of the support. Lemma 4 and the proof of Proposition 7 of [5] give and , respectively. The pushforward definition of therefore gives its finite first moment, and is finite. Gozlan’s equivalence between the symmetric functional inverse Santaló and entropy–transport inequalities, as stated in [8], Theorem 1.3, applies to Corollary 1.2 with . □
Polarity, norm sums, and Hanner polytopes
All bodies below are symmetric about the origin. In addition to the polar and volume product defined in Section 1, we use the gauge and support function
Dual spaces are identified with Euclidean coordinate spaces, and always denotes volume in the dimension of . The notation also applies to any nonempty compact convex set. The gauge is a norm with closed unit ball . Convex separation gives the bipolar identity , and hence
Indeed is equivalent to for every . For an invertible linear map ,
since the two volumes acquire reciprocal determinant factors.
For bodies and , define
These operations are taken in the product space. More generally, complementary subspaces are identified with product coordinates by an invertible linear map. Their gauges are
For the second identity, a convex combination from the two coordinate bodies has gauge sum at most one. Conversely, when the sum is at most one, use these two gauges as the coefficients of the normalized coordinate vectors and place any remaining weight at 0. A zero coordinate contributes no term.
Lemma 2.1 (Polars and volumes of the two sums). For origin-symmetric convex bodies of dimensions ,
Moreover,
Consequently, for ,
Proof. Testing a functional on the two coordinate bodies gives the first polar identity; taking polars again gives the second. The product volume follows from Fubini. By (4), the fiber of over is . Since for , integration gives
The last integral is evaluated by repeated integration by parts. Combining the polar and volume identities proves (7).
The Hanner recursion from Section 1 uses precisely these two operations, following Hanner [12]. Their volume and polarity formulas give the attaining family immediately.
Lemma 2.2 (The Hanner volume product). Every -dimensional linear Hanner body satisfies
The polar of a linear Hanner body is again a linear Hanner body.
Proof. A centered interval , , has polar and volume product 4. Equation (7) propagates and to under either operation. Induction and linear invariance prove the first assertion. The polar identities exchange the two operations and preserve the interval base case. Equation (3) then proves closure under polarity also for linear images.
In dimension one every origin-symmetric convex body is a centered nondegenerate interval. Thus both the sharp inequality and the full equality classification in that dimension follow directly from the base case above.
A conformal lens with a uniform boundary coordinate
We construct a conformal image of the disk whose boundary has a uniformly distributed imaginary coordinate. This law will turn complex feasibility probabilities into real volumes. The horizontal half-width has further roles: strict curvature will make additional boundary equalities have probability zero, while concavity will extend feasibility from polar vertices to their convex hull. Its endpoint scaling will enter the equality argument near the apex of the lifted body. The map is a rotation of the uniform-distribution example in Gross’s conformal Skorokhod embedding [11], Section 3.2; we prove all its required properties directly.
Write and define
The series converges uniformly on .
Lemma 3.1 (The planar lens). The function is a biholomorphism from onto a bounded convex domain , with inverse , and . There is a continuous even function , positive on and zero at , such that
The function is smooth on and satisfies
If is uniform on , then
where is uniform on and is an independent uniform sign.
Proof. The map is odd and commutes with conjugation. Put
The fraction inside the logarithm lies in the right half-plane, where we use the principal logarithm. Thus , , and only when . Differentiating the series gives
with their limiting values at zero. In particular has no zeros. For , the real part of the last expression is
since ; its value at zero is 1. Fix and put . This curve is regular, and its tangent angle satisfies
The second identity uses the zero-free derivative in the disk. At a fixed parameter , project the curve onto its right unit normal there. The derivative of this projection has the sign of . It is negative until the tangent has turned through , and positive thereafter, until the curve returns to . Hence the projection has its unique maximum at . This proves simplicity and shows that every point of the curve is the unique supporting point of its convex hull in the corresponding normal direction. All normal directions occur, so the curve is the boundary of that convex hull and is positively oriented. The harmonic maximum principle for these supporting projections places strictly inside the curve. The argument principle then gives exactly one preimage for every point inside and none outside. Thus maps biholomorphically onto its bounded convex interior .
As increases, these domains exhaust . Consequently is univalent on , is convex, and its inverse is holomorphic. For each , continuity also gives . Continuity on the closed disk gives boundedness and . No boundary value , , lies in : otherwise continuity of there and would give . It follows that .
We now compute this boundary. On the right semicircle, with , one has
The formulas for and extend analytically across each compact subarc, so we may differentiate the boundary values. Writing gives
Since , we have . Define and extend it to by continuity. Conjugation makes even. The values are purely imaginary by the series, so . Differentiation gives (10); strict concavity and the endpoint values then give positivity in the interior. Oddness and conjugation show that the other semicircle traces the graph . These two graphs give (9). On either semicircle the imaginary coordinate traverses at constant absolute speed . Each semicircle has probability , which proves (11).
Figure 1 illustrates the coordinate law.
Figure 1. The conformal lens and its boundary coordinate. Equally spaced angles on either semicircle give equally spaced imaginary coordinates on the corresponding boundary branch. On the right semicircle, ; reflection gives the left branch. Thus a uniform angle gives a uniform coordinate in and an independent fair branch sign. The horizontal arrow marks the half-width , with and .
The two boundary graphs are smooth away from and have strictly turning tangent directions by (10). In particular, a fixed tangent line direction occurs at only finitely many parameters away from these two endpoints. The boundary has planar Lebesgue measure zero, as is also immediate from its graph description.
Lemma 3.2 (Endpoint scaling). As ,
For every ,
Proof. Equation (10) and give
Here uniformly as . Integration proves (13). Writing , the same uniform remainder gives
uniformly for , which proves (14).
Mass at an isolated holomorphic zero
The next estimate turns the order of a holomorphic zero into an integral bound for its Jacobian minors. Its application will use high powers of the inverse planar map. In complex dimension , the mass bound grows as the th power of their exponent, matching the radial rescaling that will produce boundary feasibility probabilities in Section 5. The estimate is a special case of the sublevel-mass and comparison formulas for generalized Lelong numbers; see Demailly [6], Sections 3 and 5. We give a direct Stokes proof in the normalization used here.
On , write and use the complex orientation
For a smooth real function , our convention is
Thus for a real tangent vector , and
The second identity follows by expanding the exterior product, or by a unitary diagonalization of the Hermitian Hessian.
Lemma 4.1 (Holomorphic mass). Let , , and let be open and contain . Suppose that is holomorphic and has the following properties:
;
for an integer ,
where each component of is a homogeneous polynomial of degree and whenever ;
for every , the set is compact in .
Then, with ,
All norms are Euclidean. Rows in each determinant are in increasing index order.
Proof. We first bound the integral of . The conversion to Jacobian minors will then follow from Cauchy–Binet. Both and away from have positive semidefinite complex Hessians. Indeed, if is the complex derivative matrix of , the Hessian of is . For a complex direction , the Hessian of evaluates to
by Cauchy–Schwarz. Their top exterior powers are therefore nonnegative.
Comparison with a small sphere. Fix a regular value of and set . By compactness of the sublevel and the regular-value theorem, is a compact smooth manifold with boundary . Stokes’ theorem gives
Put on . The identities
and the vanishing of the pullback of to imply
For sufficiently small , the closed Euclidean ball is contained in . Orient outward from this ball. Applying Stokes on gives
Thus it remains to determine the flux through a shrinking sphere.
The homogeneous flux. Let and . The holomorphic Taylor expansion implies
on a fixed closed annulus containing .
For example, termwise differentiation of the convergent Taylor series gives this convergence for the rescaled map and then for its squared norm. Since is strictly positive on that annulus, the logarithms converge in as well. Pulling back to by dilation, the additive constant disappears under . Consequently
We compare this flux with that of the radial function . Homogeneity gives
Thus is unchanged by dilation and by common phase rotation. These invariances will make its contribution to the flux vanish. On , put
Thus . For the nowhere-zero tangent vector field on , the dilation identity and (15) give and . The phase-rotation identity makes every invariant under the flow of . Cartan’s identity therefore gives
where denotes contraction and the Lie derivative. It follows that the top-degree form on the -dimensional sphere vanishes: its contraction with the nonzero vector is zero. Differentiation and integration by parts on the closed sphere now yield
For this is simply the derivative of ; the same argument applies.
On the unit sphere, and are the restrictions of and , respectively. Hence a final use of Stokes and (16) gives
The minor bound. Equations (19) and (20) imply
for every regular . Sard’s theorem supplies an increasing sequence of such values tending to . Since the integrand is nonnegative, monotone convergence gives
Finally, the complex Hessian and Cauchy–Binet give the identity
Division by proves (17).
Feasible bases
We now apply the holomorphic mass estimate to finitely many real strip constraints. It gives a lower bound for the sum of their boundary feasibility probabilities. For the lens of Lemma 3.1, these probabilities will become volumes of real simplices.
Fix and nonzero real row vectors spanning . Write
We identify rows with vectors when taking a convex hull, and extend their action complex-linearly to . The spanning assumption makes bounded, and . The polar identity follows from the bipolar theorem: the polar of the displayed convex hull is exactly . Let be the collection of -element sets of independent rows. For , put in increasing index order and . Dependent row sets are omitted throughout.
For the next lemma, may be any biholomorphism of the unit disk onto a bounded planar domain , with and a continuous extension to the closed disk. For independent uniform angles , , define
The active coordinates already belong to ; thus the probability tests only the remaining rows.
Lemma 5.1 (Boundary feasibility). Let and let be nonzero real rows spanning . Let be a biholomorphism onto a bounded planar domain, continuous on , with . Then the sum in (22) satisfies . No condition on extra-row boundary equalities or on dependent row subsets is required.
Proof. Let and set
The set is open, bounded, and contains 0. For an integer , apply Lemma 4.1 to the holomorphic map
We shall let tend to infinity. The mass lower bound has scale . The radial substitution below removes the same factor from the Jacobian integrals and leaves a fixed domain on which the inferred points tend to boundary samples. The unique zero of is 0: vanishes only at 0, and the rows span. Writing , its degree- leading term is , also nonzero whenever . For , the set is compact in . Indeed each of its row coordinates belongs to the fixed compact set . A basis of rows bounds ; limits retain all these inclusions and the inequality . All hypotheses of the mass lemma therefore hold. The derivative row of is a scalar multiple of , so dependent row subsets have zero minors. Consequently
Fix . The change of variables , , is one-to-one onto its image, with inverse . Its squared complex Jacobian is its real volume Jacobian. The squared determinant in is this Jacobian factor times . The transformed integration domain is contained in
We use this larger domain for an upper bound, and then put . The coordinate hyperplanes, on which polar coordinates are undefined, have Lebesgue measure zero. Since
we obtain
The measure in this integral is finite: its total mass is the volume of the unit ball in . For every positive , continuity of on the closed disk makes the inferred points converge to . If a limiting row coordinate lies outside , that constraint fails for all sufficiently large . Thus the upper limit of the indicator is bounded by the indicator of the event defining , including all possible boundary equalities. The upper-bound form of Fatou’s lemma, applied to functions bounded by 1 on this finite measure space, gives
There are only finitely many bases, so (23) and these upper bounds give
Thus .
Boundary equalities for the lens
The lower bound for allows additional boundary equalities. The real volume identity in Section 6 will need the stronger fact that these equalities have probability zero. From now on, , , and are those of Lemma 3.1. We may also require that no two rows are proportional. For any finite strip presentation this is achieved without changing by keeping, on each row line, a row of largest magnitude; its strip implies all the discarded strips on that line. Zero rows, if present initially, impose no constraint and are discarded. In dimension one the reduced list has a single row, so there are no extra-row boundary equalities to consider.
Lemma 5.2 (Additional boundary equalities have probability zero). Let be the lens map of Lemma 3.1. Assume that the nonzero spanning rows are pairwise nonproportional. For every and ,
Proof. Write . At least two coefficients, say , are nonzero; otherwise would be proportional to a basis row. Let . Apart from its two endpoints, the lens boundary consists of the smooth regular branches , . Their tangent directions have at most one occurrence on each branch for any fixed unoriented line direction, because is strictly monotone. The boundary parameter has constant nonzero speed in on each branch, as established in the proof of Lemma 3.1.
Hold all phases other than fixed. The map
has real Jacobian determinant . For every nonendpoint , it vanishes at only finitely many nonendpoint values of . Its zero set, including the excluded endpoint lines, therefore has planar measure zero by Fubini’s theorem. Off that set the inverse function theorem gives local diffeomorphism charts. A countable subcover of such charts suffices, and in each chart the inverse is locally Lipschitz, so it sends a planar null set to a null set. The set is planar-null, being a countable union of compact smooth subarcs and two points. Its inverse image consequently has measure zero in the two remaining phases. A final application of Fubini over the fixed phases proves the assertion.
The real simplex identity
The lens boundary law now turns the feasibility sum into an exact integral over the strip body. The simplices in this integral lie in the polar body; their missing volume will also be the quantity used in the equality argument.
Keep the nonzero spanning, pairwise nonproportional rows of (21). For , define
All widths are strictly positive, so contains a neighborhood of ; a basis of rows shows that it is bounded. It is therefore a convex polytope with nonempty interior. For a basis and signs , let
We call feasible at when this vector belongs to . This definition specifies a unique vector for every choice, whether or not it is feasible. Set
Thus is a finite union of closed -simplices contained in . This definition applies at every interior , including points with additional tight constraints. For integration only, declare every pair infeasible and set when .
A feasible pair specifies a vertex of . A strictly positive combination of its signed tight rows defines a linear functional maximized uniquely at that vertex. This is why different feasible pairs give simplices with disjoint interiors whenever their vertices are distinct. The proof below removes, outside a null set of , the boundary ties that could make two pairs specify the same vertex.
Proposition 6.1 (Feasible-simplex identity). Let be nonzero, pairwise nonproportional real rows spanning , and let be as in Lemma 3.1. With , , and defined in (21), (22), and (26), respectively,
In particular, , and
Proof. We first convert each probability into a real integral. By (11), each active boundary coordinate has the law , with uniform on and an independent fair sign. Consequently each fixed sign choice has joint measure on . Writing the inferred complex vector as gives
The constraints that all row coordinates lie in are exactly and , apart from the immaterial boundary . This boundary has measure zero, since it is contained in the finitely many hyperplanes . The change of variables therefore gives
For almost every , every feasible pair has no tight constraint outside . Indeed, such an additional equality means that an extra row of lies on . Lemma 5.2 makes this event null in the basis phases; the boundary law and the invertible change make its set of null for each fixed sign choice. There are finitely many bases, sign choices, and extra rows, so a single null set removes all these equalities.
Fix outside this null set. Distinct feasible pairs have distinct vectors . If their bases differ, a shared vector would have a tight row outside one of the bases. If their bases agree but some signs differ, the shared vector would satisfy opposite equations with the same strictly positive width, which is impossible.
The interiors of their simplices are disjoint. To see this, let . It has a representation with all and . For every ,
and equality holds at . Equality forces every independent equation , so this is the unique maximizer of the linear functional on . If belonged to the interiors of two feasible simplices, their distinct vectors would both be its unique maximizer, a contradiction. Each simplex has volume , and their boundaries have measure zero. It follows that, for almost every ,
All integrals here are measurable. For each pair, feasibility is a finite collection of closed inequalities between continuous functions of . In particular the set
is a finite union of products of Borel feasibility sets and fixed closed simplices. Fubini’s theorem makes measurable, and it is bounded by . Sum (29), use (30), and apply Lemma 5.1. This proves the first equality and lower bound in (27). The containment proves the upper bound. In particular, the missing volume has the exact expression
It is nonnegative by containment, and bounds it above by . This proves (28) and identifies the quantity that will tend to zero in the equality argument. □
For a concrete union with positive missing volume, take , , , and , as in Figure 2. Then and . Write . The endpoint integral for and for give
Figure 2. A feasible-simplex union can leave part of the polar uncovered. Here , , , , and . The third strip is redundant in , as verified above. The four witnesses , defined by for , correspond to the four triangles with matching sign labels. Their union is . The two hatched caps have total area , one third of .
The second bound uses the alternating series for . In particular, , so the third strip in the example is strictly redundant.
Approximation of an arbitrary convex body
Corollary 6.2 (The symmetric volume-product inequality). For every origin-symmetric convex body , ,
Proof. Put and choose with , where is the Euclidean unit ball. For , take a finite -net in , adjoin its negatives, and let be its convex hull. Thus , and their support functions satisfy, for every Euclidean unit vector ,
For , this implies
The first inclusions follow from the support-function inequalities and convex separation; the second follow by polarity. In particular and are full-dimensional symmetric polytopes for large .
Choose one vertex from each antipodal vertex pair of as a row list. These rows are nonzero and span. They are pairwise nonproportional: two distinct boundary vertices on the same ray from an interior origin cannot both be extreme, and the antipodal duplication has already been removed. Their strip body is . Proposition 6.1 therefore gives . The homothetic bounds (31) show both and , because dilation by multiplies volume by . Passing to the limit proves the assertion. No smoothness, simplicity, or general-position assumption is imposed on . In dimension one the assertion can also be read directly: has polar and product 4. □
Equality and a common feasibility witness
The integral in (27) measures how much of the polar body is covered by feasible simplices. For a body attaining the sharp volume product, we shall make the uncovered volume tend to zero after adjoining one segment. Compactness then gives a feasible witness at every interior point and in every direction. The resulting representation will be the input to the equality classification.
Throughout this section is a convex body, , satisfying
Set , , and
The polar has the two horizontal faces and . The representations constructed below will use vectors from these faces. In this lifted space, and belong to , while elements of act on them by the Euclidean pairing. Recall that the lens width is continuous, even and concave, with and .
Proposition 7.1 (A representation minimizing the lens cost). Let , , be an origin-symmetric convex body with . Put , , and define the lifted bodies by (32). For every and every nonzero , put
There are vectors with and , nonnegative numbers , and a vector , such that
and
In particular, for every finite representation with and ,
The choices may depend on and ; the same choice satisfies (35) for all the competing representations.
The last coordinates split the chosen rows into two groups. In Section 8, we compare representation costs as approaches the apex of ; the endpoint behavior of makes the two signs contribute differently. We now prove Proposition 7.1 in three steps: approximate by polytopes, locate feasible simplices near each prescribed point and direction, and pass to a common witness to compare costs.
Inner polytopes and vanishing missing volume
The horizontal section of at height is . Hence
and therefore
Choose full-dimensional symmetric polytopes converging to in Hausdorff distance. For example, take the convex hulls of increasingly fine finite symmetric nets in , including a fixed spanning symmetric set. There are numbers with such that
Indeed, if contains a Euclidean ball of radius and the Hausdorff error is , then on Euclidean unit directions
The support-function criterion for containment gives the claim, after discarding finitely many indices and choosing slightly smaller if necessary. Put and . The inclusions above give
In particular, . Use one row from each antipodal vertex pair of to describe as an intersection of strips. These rows span , and no two are proportional: a ray from the interior point meets the boundary of a convex body in only one point. Every signed row is a vertex of , and thus belongs to .
Let be the union of the feasible signed basis simplices for this strip description, as in (27). In particular, for every it is a finite union of closed simplices contained in . Its definition is retained also at the exceptional interior points where several constraints are simultaneously tight. The integral estimate and (36) imply
From an integral deficit to each point and direction
Fix and . We first construct indices and points
This is a consequence of (38) on product neighborhoods; it does not require a pointwise limit of the functions .
For each , choose a Euclidean ball of positive volume contained in . There is also a ball of positive volume with closure contained in . To see this at the boundary point , first move a small distance from toward ; the resulting point is interior because . Take a sufficiently small ball about that point. By (37), for every , and for all sufficiently large . The second assertion follows also from and .
Choose so large that these inclusions hold and . If missed for every , its missing volume would be at least throughout , contradicting this inequality. Thus choose and . This proves (39).
Choose one feasible simplex containing . Its signed basis rows, written , give weights satisfying
The coefficient left over is the weight of the simplex vertex 0. Feasibility supplies one vector such that
Here a sign on a basis row has been absorbed using the evenness of .
The last inequality extends to all . Indeed, write as a convex combination of vertices. The triangle inequality followed by concavity gives
Consequently . The polar sandwich (37) makes these witnesses uniformly bounded, even if the selected bases approach singularity.
Pass to a subsequence on which , every , and every . This uses a fixed finite product of compact sets: all rows belong to and all weights belong to . No independence of the limiting rows is needed. We have
and continuity of gives for all . For arbitrary , use in the feasibility inequality and pass to the limit. It follows that
The subsequence has already been fixed; this argument proves (41) for all with the same .
Since , its gauge is one. Therefore
Thus : none of the limiting mass remains at the simplex vertex 0.
Comparison with every positive representation
To prove Proposition 7.1, fix its and nonzero , and apply the preceding construction to . Set and discard any zero weights if desired. This gives at most rows and proves (33) and (34). For any finite competing representation , , , the common witness gives
This proves (35) and completes the proof of Proposition 7.1. In particular, the conclusion holds for each prescribed and , including directions for which every limiting representation is degenerate.
From endpoint costs to metric medians
We now convert the optimal representations into a geometric property of the polar body. A metric median of three points in a normed space is a point that lies between every pair: if the points are , a median satisfies
The median need not be unique. Its existence will imply the ball intersection property that characterizes linear Hanner bodies.
Proposition 8.1 (Medians of an equality body). Let , , be an origin-symmetric convex body with , and put . Every triple of points in has a metric median.
Proof. Write . Translation reduces the triple to . If two points coincide, that repeated point is a median, so assume that are distinct. Set
All three distances are positive. The triangle and reverse triangle inequalities give . Define
These numbers are nonnegative, with , , and .
The compact set of aggregate directions. Let
Our goal is to prove . Such membership supplies for which has distances to bounded by , respectively; the triangle inequalities then force the three median equalities. We shall prove this membership by estimating support functions in each direction.
The set is compact and convex: it is the linear image of the intersection of with the affine subspace . It is nonempty, since satisfy the constraints. This also covers or .
Endpoint comparison. Fix and let , . The lifted body contains in its interior because
Apply Proposition 7.1 with this and . Its total weight is . We obtain rows and weights satisfying (33) and (35). Their aggregates
have . Since , they satisfy and hence . No choice of these representations across different or is required.
For and , evenness of gives
The factors belong to , a compact subinterval of . Lemma 3.2 therefore gives an error such that
In particular, the normalized cost of the optimal representation is at least
Compare this cost, using (35), with the two-term representation
Both rows belong to . By (44), their normalized cost tends to . Letting yields
The error was uniform only over for the fixed ; that is all this limit requires.
Separation and the median. Continuity extends (45) to . For any nonzero , the point lies on , by (2). Homogeneity of support functions gives
The same inequality holds at . The right side is the support function of the compact convex set , with the convention . Convex separation therefore implies
Choose the corresponding pair in (43), and put
Then , so (46) gives
The triangle inequality forces all three bounds to be equalities:
Thus lies between and between , and
This proves the median property. The argument permits or either , so saturated triangle inequalities require no limiting argument.
Three balls and the equality classification
A normed space has the three-ball intersection property, also called the intersection property, if any three closed balls that intersect pairwise have a common point. Their radii may differ. The equivalence between this intersection property and the metric-median condition is Lima’s classical norm-additive decomposition criterion [19], Theorem 1.2; see also Hansen–Lima [13], Theorem 3.6(4). We include the short direction needed here, with arbitrary radii.
Lemma 8.2 (From medians to three balls). Suppose every triple of points in a real normed space has a metric median. Then the space has the three-ball intersection property, including balls of radius zero.
Proof. Consider pairwise-intersecting balls with centers , , and radii , , . Let be a metric median of their centers, and set . Pairwise intersection and the median property imply
If every , the median is a common point. Otherwise, after relabeling, . For the displayed inequalities give , so no other ball excludes . Since , the point
is well defined and lies on the segment from to . It satisfies
Thus lies in all three balls. This includes , when .
The required structure theorem is due to Hansen and Lima. In their terminology the balls are closed and have arbitrary radii [13], Section 1.
Theorem 8.3 (Hansen–Lima). A nonzero finite-dimensional real Banach space with the intersection property is linearly isometric to a space obtained from the real line by finitely many and direct sums.
This is [13], Corollary 7.4. The two direct-sum norms are exactly those in (4), so their unit balls are Hanner polytopes.
Proposition 8.4 (Classification of equality). If an origin-symmetric convex body , , satisfies , then it is a linear Hanner body.
Proof. Put . Proposition 8.1 and Lemma 8.2 give the intersection property for . This is a real Banach space, since every finite-dimensional normed space is complete. Theorem 8.3 gives an invertible linear map and a Hanner polytope with . By (3) and Lemma 2.2,
is a linear Hanner body. The converse was proved in Lemma 2.2; together with Corollary 6.2, this completes Theorem 1.1.
References
- [1]Bo Berndtsson. Complex integrals and Kuperberg’s proof of the Bourgain–Milman theorem. Advances in Mathematics, 388:107927, 2021. doi: 10.1016/j.aim.2021.107927. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2008.00838.
- [2]Len Bos, Jean-Paul Calvi, and Norman Levenberg. On the Siciak extremal function for real compact convex sets. Arkiv för Matematik, 39:245–262, 2001. URL https://archive.ymsc.tsinghua.edu.cn/pacm_download/116/7771-11512_2006_Article_BF02384556.pdf.DOI
- [3]Jean Bourgain and Vitali D. Milman. New volume ratio properties for convex symmetric bodies in ℝⁿ. Inventiones Mathematicae, 88(2):319–340, 1987. doi: 10.1007/BF01388911. URL https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01388911.DOI
- [4]Shibing Chen, Yuanyuan Li, Dongmeng Xi, and Zhe-Feng Xu. The Mahler conjecture in three dimensions, 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2605.09334v3. Version 3, 15 June 2026.
- [5]Dario Cordero-Erausquin and Bo’az Klartag. Moment measures. Journal of Functional Analysis, 268(12):3834–3866, 2015. doi: 10.1016/j.jfa.2015.04.001. URL https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfa.2015.04.001.
- [6]Jean-Pierre Demailly. Monge–Ampère operators, Lelong numbers and intersection theory. In Vincenzo Ancona and Alessandro Silva, editors, Complex Analysis and Geometry, University Series in Mathematics, pages 115–193. Plenum Press, New York, 1993. doi: 10.1007/978-1-4757-9771-8_4. URL https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4757-9771-8_4.DOI
- [7]Matthieu Fradelizi and Mathieu Meyer. Some functional inverse Santaló inequalities. Advances in Mathematics, 218(5):1430–1452, 2008. doi: 10.1016/j.aim.2008.03.013. URL https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aim.2008.03.013.
- [8]Matthieu Fradelizi, Nathael Gozlan, and Simon Zugmeyer. Transport proofs of some functional inverse Santaló inequalities, 2021. arXiv:2109.00871v3. Manuscript PDF.arxiv.org/abs/2109.00871
- [9]Matthieu Fradelizi, Alfredo Hubard, Mathieu Meyer, Edgardo Roldán-Pensado, and Artem Zvavitch. Equipartitions and Mahler volumes of symmetric convex bodies. American Journal of Mathematics, 144(5):1201–1219, 2022. doi: 10.1353/ajm.2022.0027. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1904.10765.
- [10]Yehoram Gordon, Mathieu Meyer, and Shlomo Reisner. Zonoids with minimal volume-product—a new proof. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 104(1):273–276, 1988. doi: 10.1090/S0002-9939-1988-0958082-9.DOI
- [11]Renan Gross. A conformal Skorokhod embedding. Electronic Communications in Probability, 24, 2019. doi: 10.1214/19-ECP272. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1905.00852. Article no. 68, 11 pp.
- [12]Olof Hanner. Intersections of translates of convex bodies. Mathematica Scandinavica, 4:65–87, 1956. doi: 10.7146/math.scand.a-10456. URL https://journals.msp.org/mscand/article/view/2863.DOI
- [13]Allan B. Hansen and Åsvald Lima. The structure of finite dimensional Banach spaces with the 3.2. intersection property. Acta Mathematica, 146:1–23, 1981. doi: 10.1007/BF02392457. URL https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02392457.
- [14]Hiroshi Iriyeh and Masataka Shibata. Symmetric Mahler’s conjecture for the volume product in the 3-dimensional case. Duke Mathematical Journal, 169(6):1077–1134, 2020. doi: 10.1215/00127094-2019-0072. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1706.01749v3.
- [15]Roman Karasev. Mahler’s conjecture for some hyperplane sections. Israel Journal of Mathematics, 241:795–815, 2021. doi: 10.1007/s11856-021-2114-4. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1902.08971.
- [16]Jaegil Kim. Minimal volume product near Hanner polytopes. Journal of Functional Analysis, 266(4):2360–2402, 2014. doi: 10.1016/j.jfa.2013.08.008. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1212.2544v1.
- [17]Jaegil Kim and Artem Zvavitch. Stability of the reverse Blaschke–Santaló inequality for unconditional convex bodies. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 143(4):1705–1717, 2015. doi: 10.1090/S0002-9939-2014-12334-3. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/1302.5719v1.
- [18]Greg Kuperberg. From the Mahler conjecture to Gauss linking integrals. Geometric and Functional Analysis, 18(3):870–892, 2008. doi: 10.1007/s00039-008-0669-4. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0610904.
- [19]Åsvald Lima. Intersection properties of balls in spaces of compact operators. Annales de l’Institut Fourier, 28(3):35–65, 1978. doi: 10.5802/aif.700. URL https://aif.centre-mersenne.org/articles/10.5802/aif.700/.DOI
- [20]Magnus Lundin. The extremal PSH for the complement of convex, symmetric subsets of ℝᴺ. Michigan Mathematical Journal, 32(2):197–201, 1985. doi: 10.1307/mmj/1029003186.DOI
- [21]Kurt Mahler. Ein Minimalproblem für konvexe Polygone. Mathematica (Zutphen), B7:118–127, 1938.
- [22]Kurt Mahler. Ein Übertragungsprinzip für konvexe Körper. Časopis pro pěstování matematiky a fysiky, 68(3–4):93–102, 1939. doi: 10.21136/CPMF.1939.109441. URL https://dml.cz/handle/10338.dmlcz/109441.
- [23]Mathieu Meyer. Une caractérisation volumique de certains espaces normés de dimension finie. Israel Journal of Mathematics, 55(3):317–326, 1986. doi: 10.1007/BF02765029. URL https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF02765029.DOI
- [24]Fedor Nazarov. The Hörmander proof of the Bourgain–Milman theorem. In Bo’az Klartag, Shahar Mendelson, and Vitali D. Milman, editors, Geometric Aspects of Functional Analysis, volume 2050 of Lecture Notes in Mathematics, pages 335–343. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2012. doi: 10.1007/978-3-642-29849-3_20. URL https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-29849-3_20.
- [25]Fedor Nazarov, Fedor Petrov, Dmitry Ryabogin, and Artem Zvavitch. A remark on the Mahler conjecture: local minimality of the unit cube. Duke Mathematical Journal, 154(3):419–430, 2010. doi: 10.1215/00127094-2010-042. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/0905.0867.
- [26]OpenAI. The Mahler Conjecture for General Convex Bodies. OpenAI Math Release preprint OAI:The-Mahler-Conjecture-for-General-Convex-Bodies-September-22-2026, 2026.
- [27]Shlomo Reisner. Random polytopes and the volume-product of symmetric convex bodies. Mathematica Scandinavica, 57:386–392, 1985. doi: 10.7146/math.scand.a-12124. URL https://journals.msp.org/mscand/article/view/1544.DOI
- [28]Shlomo Reisner. Zonoids with minimal volume-product. Mathematische Zeitschrift, 192(3): 339–346, 1986. doi: 10.1007/BF01164009.DOI
- [29]Shlomo Reisner. Minimal volume-product in Banach spaces with a 1-unconditional basis. Journal of the London Mathematical Society, 36(1):126–136, 1987. doi: 10.1112/jlms/s2-36.1.126. URL https://doi.org/10.1112/jlms/s2-36.1.126.
- [30]Jean Saint-Raymond. Sur le volume des corps convexes symétriques. In Séminaire d’initiation à l’analyse, 20e année, 1980–1981. Université Paris VI, Paris, 1981. Exposé no. 11.

