WorksMathematics
An asymptotic ball algebra with countably determined spectra and a nonseparable character space
Abstract
Let and let be the restrictions to of functions in the ball algebra . The unital uniform Banach algebra is inverse-closed in . Consequently one countable family of evaluation characters generates the spectrum of every element of . Nevertheless contains continuum many pairwise disjoint nonempty open subsets and is therefore nonseparable. This gives a negative answer to a problem posed by Ohrysko, Wojciechowski and Graham.
The statement and the base algebra
For a commutative unital complex Banach algebra , let denote its character space with the Gelfand topology. A subset generates all spectra if
Problem 18 of [1] asks whether the existence of such a countable forces to be separable. In Nikolski’s terminology [2 Definition 0.2.1], the spectrum of is 1-visible from if for every . The classical Wiener–Pitt phenomenon, observed by Wiener and Pitt [3] and proved rigorously by Šre˘ıder [4], illustrates the failure of this property for Fourier evaluations on the convolution algebra of complex Borel measures on the circle. There exist measures such that . Our construction shows that 1-visibility from a countable family is nevertheless compatible with a nonseparable character space.
Theorem 1. There is a commutative unital semisimple uniform Banach algebra such that all spectra are generated by one countable family of characters, but has continuum many pairwise disjoint nonempty open subsets.
Write
Let be the algebra of continuous functions on that are holomorphic in , and put
The maximum-modulus principle gives . Thus restriction is an isometric algebra isomorphism onto the closed unital subalgebra . For denote its unique ball-algebra extension by , and define
This is a character of norm one. If denotes the th coordinate function on , then
Lemma 2. The subalgebra is inverse-closed in .
Proof. Let and assume has no zeros on . By continuity and compactness there is such that has no zeros on the shell . The function is holomorphic on . The classical Hartogs extension theorem extends it to a holomorphic function on ; see, for example, [5 Theorem 2.3.2]. Since on the shell, the identity theorem gives throughout . The function agrees with near the boundary and hence extends continuously to . Therefore .
Notice that inverse-closedness here is a statement about single functions. The pair has no common zero on , although annihilates both.
The asymptotic algebra and its spectra
Give its usual pointwise product and norm
Define
Equivalently,
Indeed, approximants with can be chosen bounded whenever is bounded.
Lemma 3. The set is a norm-closed unital subalgebra of and is inverse-closed in .
Proof. The set is an ideal of , and is a unital subalgebra. Hence (3) is a unital subalgebra. To check closedness, suppose uniformly in . The inequality
gives . Letting proves .
For inverse-closedness, let be invertible in , so that for all and . Choose bounded such that . For all sufficiently large , on . Lemma 2 gives , and
The finitely many initial coordinates do not affect condition (2). Thus .
For and let . These are characters and separate the elements of , so is semisimple. Its norm is uniform, since it is a closed subalgebra of the commutative -algebra .
Proposition 4. Let be any countable dense subset. Then
is countable and generates all spectra in . More explicitly,
Proof. Each value belongs to the spectrum by evaluation at , so the closure of their union is contained in . If is outside that closure, then has a uniform positive lower bound. Lemma 3 shows that . This proves the first equality. The second follows from continuity of every and density of .
Restriction to the countable set embeds , and hence , isometrically into . The image of is closed and inverse-closed there, by the same uniform lower-bound argument. Since is countable, this proves the last realization assertion of Theorem 1.
Finite-coordinate and ultrafilter characters
For put
Every belongs to and is an idempotent. Write , and let be the constant sequence whose every term is , for .
Lemma 5. If and , then for some . In particular,
Proof. The algebra is exactly supported in coordinate , since every such sequence belongs to . Restricting gives a unital character of , hence evaluation at some . For every , multiplicativity gives . Now apply (1). □
Lemma 6. For every free ultrafilter on there is a character satisfying
Proof. For , choose bounded with and set
If is a second choice, then
A free ultrafilter contains every cofinite set, so (6) is independent of the choice. Linearity follows by using as approximants to a sum. For products, if approximates and approximates , then approximates , because the sequences are bounded. The multiplicativity of and of scalar ultrafilter limits gives multiplicativity of . Also and . Finally, choose the exact approximants and to obtain (5). □
Continuum many disjoint open subsets
Set
This is open and nonempty by Lemma 6. Lemma 5 shows that every annihilates every , and therefore every finite sum of the .
Choose a family of continuum many infinite subsets of with pairwise finite intersections. Such a family is obtained by enumerating the finite binary words and taking the sets of prefixes of distinct infinite binary sequences. For define
These sets are open. Since is idempotent, ; hence the second condition in (7) simply means .
Each is nonempty: choose a free ultrafilter containing and use . If and , multiplicativity gives
But is finite, and every character in annihilates finite-coordinate idempotents. This is a contradiction. The sets are therefore pairwise disjoint.
A countable dense subset would have to meet each of these continuum many pairwise disjoint nonempty open sets. Consequently is nonseparable, completing the proof of Theorem 1.
Remark 7 (Two-function form of the open sets). For put
At every coordinate evaluation one has
Nevertheless, if is free and , then . Moreover,
Thus the disjoint open sets require two simultaneous conditions. There is no conflict with (4), which concerns one element at a time.
Remark 8 (The Shilov boundary). The Shilov boundary of is exactly the closure of , and is separable. Indeed, this closure is a closed norming set. Conversely, finite-coordinate functions from provide functions supported in arbitrarily small neighborhoods of each , showing that all these evaluations are strong boundary points. The open set lies outside this closed boundary. In particular, nonseparability is not being inferred merely from a nonseparable closed subset of a possibly separable space: it follows from the explicit disjoint open sets above.
Remark 9 (A general construction principle). The same proof works for any compact Hausdorff separable and any closed unital inverse-closed subalgebra admitting a character outside the evaluation image of . By compactness, there are finitely many with and . Replace by these throughout, and use a countable dense subset of in Proposition 4. No metrizability is used. The ball algebra on supplies an explicit instance of all the hypotheses.
Remark 10 (The global implication for corona theorems). The preceding amplification principle supplies the additional argument needed to connect Problem 18 with corona theorems. Let be a separable complex domain and let . Put . The space is compact and separable: evaluations at a countable dense subset of are dense in it. Restriction of the Gelfand transform identifies isometrically with a closed unital subalgebra . This subalgebra is inverse-closed: a uniform lower bound on is a uniform lower bound on , so the reciprocal is again bounded and holomorphic. If the corona is nonempty, then has a character outside . The amplification principle therefore produces an algebra with countably generated spectra and nonseparable character space. Consequently, a positive answer to Problem 18 for all commutative unital Banach algebras would imply the corona theorem for , including balls and polydisks. This implication is stronger than merely applying a putative positive answer directly to , which would give only separability of its character space.
Use of artificial intelligence
The proof was obtained in collaboration with OpenAI’s GPT 6.1 Sol model. The author has read the entire manuscript and takes full responsibility for its contents.
References
- [1]P. Ohrysko, M. Wojciechowski, and C. C. Graham, Non-separability of the Gelfand space of measure algebras, Ark. Mat. 54 (2016), no. 2, 525–535. doi:10.1007/s11512-016-0240-8, Definition 16 and Problem 18.DOI
- [2]N. Nikolski, In search of the invisible spectrum, Ann. Inst. Fourier (Grenoble) 49 (1999), no. 6, 1925–1998. doi:10.5802/aif.1743.DOI
- [3]N. Wiener and H. R. Pitt, On absolutely convergent Fourier–Stieltjes transforms, Duke Math. J. 4 (1938), no. 2, 420–436. doi:10.1215/S0012-7094-38-00435-1.DOI
- [4]Yu. A. Šreĭder, The structure of maximal ideals in rings of measures with convolution, Mat. Sb. (N.S.) 27(69) (1950), no. 2, 297–318 (in Russian). English translation in Amer. Math. Soc. Transl. no. 81 (1953), 28 pp.
- [5]L. Hörmander, An Introduction to Complex Analysis in Several Variables, 3rd revised ed., North-Holland Mathematical Library, vol. 7, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1990.