betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Elementary Methods for Infinite Resistive Networks with Complex Topologies

Abstract

Finding the equivalent resistance of an infinite ladder circuit is a classical problem in physics. We expand this well-known challenge to new classes of network topologies, in which the unit cells are much more entangled together. The exact analytical results there can still be obtained with elementary methods. These topology classes will add layers of complexity and much more diversity to a very popular kind of physics puzzles for teachers and students.

Introduction

The equivalent resistance RABR_{AB} of the infinite ladder network composed of identical 1Ω1\Omega resistors, shown in Figure 1, can be calculated elegantly by adding one more unit cell (a ladder step) in the front[1]:

Infinite ladder topology network and the trick of adding one more unit cell

Figure 1. (A) The infinite ladder topology network of 1Ω1\Omega resistors. (B) The trick of adding one more unit cell to the network, where the equal sign is valid under the assumption of convergence.

RAB=Rαβ=1+Rαβ1+Rαβ(1)R_{AB}=R_{\alpha\beta}=1+\frac{R_{\alpha\beta}}{1+R_{\alpha\beta}} \tag*{(1)}

Here we make the assumption that as the number of ladder steps go to infinity, the equivalent resistance will converge. There are two possible solutions, RAB=(1±5)/2ΩR_{AB}=(1\pm\sqrt{5})/2\Omega, and by getting rid of the unphysical one with negative value we arrive at the answer to be uniquely RAB=(1+5)/2ΩR_{AB}=(1+\sqrt{5})/2\Omega which is equal to the golden ratio.

This problem is addressed in many introductory physics courses in college, and was also introduced to high school students in the very first International Physics Olympiad (Poland 1967). Despite of being widely known for a long time, there aren’t many variations: the unit cells are always linearly linked to the one before or after it via N=2\mathcal{N}=2 nodes.

In this paper we will explore new classes of resistive networks with topologies more entangled, where the linear linking between unit cells has N>2\mathcal{N}>2 nodes. To our knowledge this kind of electrical circuits is rarely mentioned, though they can still be solved by elementary methods using resistive relations come from superposition theorem and reciprocal theorem. Starting with estimating the results in Section II, we then develop modified methods for infinite networks and consider two twisted ladder topologies as representatives (see Figure 2). Alongside, we will show some examples of network topologies that can be solved similarly, with all results being found analytically and confirmed numerically. We hope to provide teachers and students with more physics puzzles of this kind to explore.

Twisted ladder networks

Figure 2. (A) The N=3\mathcal{N}=3 infinite asymmetric twisted ladder network of 1Ω1\Omega resistors. (B) The N=4\mathcal{N}=4 infinite symmetric twisted ladder network of 1Ω1\Omega resistors.

Rough estimations using Rayleigh's Monotonicity Law

Even without arriving at the solutions to these problems, students should be encouraged to make guesses about what the resistances might be. We can make some rough estimations for the equivalent resistance values RAB(asym)R_{AB}^{(asym)} and RAB(sym)R_{AB}^{(sym)} of those infinite twisted ladders, using Rayleigh’s monotonicity law which states that when the resistance in one part of a circuit increases, the effective resistance also increases[2]. By setting some resistors to the extremes of 0Ω0\Omega and ∞Ω\infty\Omega (see Figure 3 and Figure 4), we can achieve within the level of ±10%\pm10\% uncertainty:

Estimations for the asymmetric twisted ladder

Figure 3. Estimations for RAB(asym)R_{AB}^{(asym)} of the infinite resistive network with asymmetric twisted ladder topology. (A) For the lower bound, we set some resistors to 0Ω0\Omega and get RAB(asym)>13/6ΩR_{AB}^{(asym)} > 13/6\Omega. (B) For the upper bound, we set some resistors to ∞Ω\infty\Omega and get RAB(asym)<7/3ΩR_{AB}^{(asym)} < 7/3\Omega.

Estimations for the symmetric twisted ladder

Figure 4. Estimations for RAB(sym)R_{AB}^{(sym)} of the infinite resistive network with symmetric twisted ladder topology. (A) For the lower bound, we set some resistors to 0Ω0\Omega and get RAB(sym)>6/5ΩR_{AB}^{(sym)} > 6/5\Omega. (B) For the upper bound, we set some resistors to ∞Ω\infty\Omega and get RAB(sym)<17/12ΩR_{AB}^{(sym)} < 17/12\Omega.

7/3Ω≈2.33Ω>RAB(asym)>13/6Ω≈2.17Ω(2)7/3\Omega\approx2.33\Omega> R_{AB}^{(asym)} > 13/6\Omega\approx2.17\Omega \tag*{(2)}
17/12Ω≈1.42Ω>RAB(sym)>6/5Ω=1.20Ω(3)17/12\Omega\approx1.42\Omega> R_{AB}^{(sym)} > 6/5\Omega= 1.20\Omega \tag*{(3)}

A Toolkit for Resistive Networks

In this section we create a toolkit for resistive networks, using only superposition theorem and reciprocal theorem. Define the generalized resistance GγδαβG_{\gamma\delta}^{\alpha\beta} from the voltage different Uγδ=Vγ−VδU_{\gamma\delta}=V_\gamma-V_\delta between nodes γ\gamma and δ\delta when there’s only a current IαβI_{\alpha\beta} comes into node α\alpha and goes out from node β\beta (see Figure 5A):

Generalized resistance and current-voltage relation

Figure 5. (A) The generalized resistance GγδαβG_{\gamma\delta}^{\alpha\beta} is defined from the input current IαβI_{\alpha\beta} and the induced voltage difference UγδU_{\gamma\delta}. It should be noted that the Greek labels α\alpha, β\beta, ... are not used as dummy indices. (B) A generalized current-voltage relation.

Gγδαβ=Uγδ/Iαβ(4)G_{\gamma\delta}^{\alpha\beta}=U_{\gamma\delta}/I_{\alpha\beta} \tag*{(4)}

The resistance RαβR_{\alpha\beta} between nodes α\alpha and β\beta is related to this as Rαβ=GαβαβR_{\alpha\beta}=G_{\alpha\beta}^{\alpha\beta}.

Follow from the definition, switching the voltage’s nodes and the current’s nodes gives the permutation rule:

Gγδαβ=−Gδγαβ=−Gγδβα(5)G_{\gamma\delta}^{\alpha\beta}=-G_{\delta\gamma}^{\alpha\beta}=-G_{\gamma\delta}^{\beta\alpha} \tag*{(5)}

For an arbitrary node σ\sigma, using the additivity of voltage difference and superposition theorem for current, we have the summing rule:

Gγδαβ=Gγσαβ+Gσδαβ,Gγδαβ=Gγδασ+Gγδσβ(6)G_{\gamma\delta}^{\alpha\beta}=G_{\gamma\sigma}^{\alpha\beta}+G_{\sigma\delta}^{\alpha\beta},\qquad G_{\gamma\delta}^{\alpha\beta}=G_{\gamma\delta}^{\alpha\sigma}+G_{\gamma\delta}^{\sigma\beta} \tag*{(6)}

With reciprocal theorem[3] (which can be derived from superposition theorem and uniqueness theorem), we arrive at the flipping rule:

Gγδαβ=Gαβγδ(7)G_{\gamma\delta}^{\alpha\beta}=G_{\alpha\beta}^{\gamma\delta} \tag*{(7)}

Some students might be more familiar with source transformation[4], which can also be used to obtain the above result and indeed is a direct application of reciprocal theorem.

From equations (5) and (6), every generalized resistance GαβγδG_{\alpha\beta}^{\gamma\delta} can be written in terms of resistances as:

Gαβγδ=Rαδ+Rβγ−Rαγ−Rβδ2.(8)G_{\alpha\beta}^{\gamma\delta} = \frac{R_{\alpha\delta}+R_{\beta\gamma}-R_{\alpha\gamma}-R_{\beta\delta}}{2}. \tag*{(8)}

For a “black box” of resistors with nn terminals α1\alpha_1, α2\alpha_2, ... αn\alpha_n, this implies that knowing the values of n(n−1)/2n(n-1)/2 resistances {Rαjαk}\{R_{\alpha_j\alpha_k}\} is enough to determine all characteristics {Gαjαkαlαm}\{G_{\alpha_j\alpha_k}^{\alpha_l\alpha_m}\} of the “black box”, thus knowing the global property of the network. In other words, internal resistor networks with identical set of {Rαjαk}\{R_{\alpha_j\alpha_k}\} are equivalent even though their topologies are different.

For n=3n=3, Δ\Delta-Y are the simplest topologies possible, and it is known that local transformation from Δ\Delta topology to Y topology[5] (see Figure 6A) does not change any global property. An extended version of Δ\Delta-Y transformation exists (see Figure 6B): an arbitrary internal network can be simplified to either Δ\Delta or Y topology, since there always exists a star network that satisfies (7) for any GαβγδG_{\alpha\beta}^{\gamma\delta} with {α,β,γ,δ}⊂{α1,α2,α3}\{\alpha,\beta,\gamma,\delta\}\subset\{\alpha_1,\alpha_2,\alpha_3\}. This simplification, illustrated in Figure 6, will be applied directly in Section IV A.

Diagrams showing the Delta-Y transformation and its extended version

Figure 6. (A) The Δ\Delta-Y transformation. (B) An extended version of Δ\Delta-Y transformation, where Δ\Delta can be generalized to any internal topology.

As it will be shown below, this method is easy to be done for n=3n=3. When n>3n>3, as the simplest topologies of which an arbitrary internal network can be simplified down to are either a mesh or specific combinations of many stars, it becomes highly convoluted to analyze even the simplified topologies in relation to the new unit cell. In this case, a method independent of internal topology becomes preferable.

Calculating the Equivalent Resistances

In this section, using the two methods above, we will show that RAB(asym)=27R_{AB}^{(asym)}=\sqrt{2\sqrt{7}} and RAB(sym)=−1+22R_{AB}^{(sym)}=\sqrt{-1+2\sqrt{2}}, along with analytical results for other N>2\mathcal{N}>2 entangled topologies.

N=3 Infinite Asymmetric twisted Ladder

To calculate RABR_{AB} for the asymmetric twisted ladder, we apply the extended Δ\Delta-Y transformation mentioned in Section III (see Figure 7A). Assume that the equivalent resistance between nodes AA, BB and CC converge in the infinity limit, the trick of adding one more unit cell can be used as shown in Figure 7B, which gives us a set of three consistency equations:

Infinite asymmetric twisted ladder and its extended Delta-Y transformation

Figure 7. (A) Apply the extended version of Δ\Delta-Y transformation to the infinite resistive network between nodes A, B and C. (B) The trick of adding one more unit cell to the network, where the equal sign is valid under the assumption of convergence.

RAB=rα+rβ=1+rβ+(1+rα)(1+rγ)2+rα+rγ,RBC=rβ+rγ=1+rα+rγ2+rα+rγ,RCA=rγ+rα=1+rβ+rα(2+rγ)2+rα+rγ.(9)\begin{aligned} R_{AB} &= r_\alpha+r_\beta= 1+r_\beta+\frac{(1+r_\alpha)(1+r_\gamma)}{2+r_\alpha+r_\gamma},\\ R_{BC} &= r_\beta+r_\gamma= \frac{1+r_\alpha+r_\gamma}{2+r_\alpha+r_\gamma},\\ R_{CA} &= r_\gamma+r_\alpha= 1+r_\beta+\frac{r_\alpha(2+r_\gamma)}{2+r_\alpha+r_\gamma}. \tag*{(9)} \end{aligned}

Three equations for three real positive unknowns rαr_\alpha, rβr_\beta, rγr_\gamma can be solved analytically:

rα=−1+7+272,(10)r_\alpha=\frac{-1+\sqrt{7}+\sqrt{2\sqrt{7}}}{2}, \tag*{(10)}
rβ=1−7+272,(11)r_\beta=\frac{1-\sqrt{7}+\sqrt{2\sqrt{7}}}{2}, \tag*{(11)}
rγ=−1+−7+472.(12)r_\gamma=\frac{-1+\sqrt{-7+4\sqrt{7}}}{2}. \tag*{(12)}

Thus we arrive at

RAB(asym)=27≈2.30 Ω,(13)R_{AB}^{(asym)}=\sqrt{2\sqrt{7}}\approx2.30\,\Omega, \tag*{(13)}

which is in agreement with (2a). We also confirm this results with numerical evaluation (see Figure 8).

Convergence of the resistance for finite resistive networks

Figure 8. We verify the analytical result for RABR_{AB} with the numerical results for RAB(N)R_{AB}(N) where NN is the size of the finite resistive network. The convergence can be quantified by Δ=RAB(N)/RAB−1\Delta=R_{AB}(N)/R_{AB}-1, which approaches 00 exponentially fast.

The method can also be applied to many different topologies, such as those in Figure 9 which are linear linking with number of nodes N=3\mathcal{N}=3 between unit cells. See tbl:I for the list of equivalent resistances RABR_{AB}.

Four infinite resistive circuits

Figure 9. All resistors are identically 1Ω1\Omega. (A) Half-and-half network. (B) Brick wall tiling network. (C) 3-parallel ladder network. (D) Triangular spiral fractal network.

CircuitEquivalent Resistance RABR_{AB} (in Ω\Omega)
A−3−5+38+1454≈0.77\frac{-3-\sqrt{5}+\sqrt{38+14\sqrt{5}}}{4}\approx0.77
B1−7+25145≈0.721-\sqrt{\frac{7+2\sqrt{5}}{145}}\approx0.72
C−1+13+1058≈0.70-1+\sqrt{\frac{13+\sqrt{105}}{8}}\approx0.70
D1−5+2+252≈0.65\frac{1-\sqrt{5}+\sqrt{2+2\sqrt{5}}}{2}\approx0.65

Table 1. Results for RABR_{AB} of infinite resistive circuits given in Figure 9.

N=4 Infinite Symmetric Twisted Ladder

We represent the infinite resistive network between nodes A, B, C, and D by a “black box” with four terminals α\alpha, β\beta, γ\gamma and δ\delta (see Figure 10A). Assume that the equivalent resistances between nodes A, B, C, and D converge in the infinity limit, the trick of adding one more unit cell can be used as shown in Figure 10B.

Infinite resistive network represented by a black box and the addition of one more unit cell

Figure 10. (A) The infinite resistive network between nodes A, B, C and D is represented by a “black box” with four terminals α\alpha, β\beta, γ\gamma and δ\delta. (B) The trick of adding one more unit cell to the network, where the equal sign is valid under the assumption of convergence.

Voltage path summation and current conservation are applied on this topology to obtain a set of six independent equations, and the symmetry of the problem reduces the number of variables down to four: RαβR_{\alpha\beta}, Rαγ=RβδR_{\alpha\gamma}=R_{\beta\delta}, Rαδ=RβγR_{\alpha\delta}=R_{\beta\gamma}, and RγδR_{\gamma\delta}. Using the toolkit we develop in Section III, we can obtain the following set of equations:

RAB=Rαβ={1+Gαβαγ−(1+Gαβδβ)1+Gαβγβ1+Gαδαγ1+GαδδβGαδγβ−(1+Gγβαγ)−(1+Gγβδβ)2+Rγβ},RCD=Rγδ={GβαδβGγβαγRαβ2+GδαδβGδααγGδαγβ2+Gδγδβ1+GδγαγGδγγβ},R_{AB}=R_{\alpha\beta}= \left\{ \begin{array}{ccc} 1+G_{\alpha\beta}^{\alpha\gamma} & -(1+G_{\alpha\beta}^{\delta\beta}) & 1+G_{\alpha\beta}^{\gamma\beta}\\ 1+G_{\alpha\delta}^{\alpha\gamma} & 1+G_{\alpha\delta}^{\delta\beta} & G_{\alpha\delta}^{\gamma\beta}\\ -(1+G_{\gamma\beta}^{\alpha\gamma}) & -(1+G_{\gamma\beta}^{\delta\beta}) & 2+R_{\gamma\beta} \end{array} \right\}, \quad R_{CD}=R_{\gamma\delta}= \left\{ \begin{array}{ccc} G_{\beta\alpha}^{\delta\beta} & G_{\gamma\beta}^{\alpha\gamma} & R_{\alpha\beta}\\ 2+G_{\delta\alpha}^{\delta\beta} & G_{\delta\alpha}^{\alpha\gamma} & G_{\delta\alpha}^{\gamma\beta}\\ 2+G_{\delta\gamma}^{\delta\beta} & 1+G_{\delta\gamma}^{\alpha\gamma} & G_{\delta\gamma}^{\gamma\beta} \end{array} \right\},
RAD=Rαδ={−1Gβδαγ11+RαγGαγβδ01+Gβγαγ+Gαγαγ2+Gβδβγ+Gαδβδ0},RBC=Rβγ={−1011+RβδGβδαγ01+Gαδβδ+Gβδβδ2+Gαγαγ+Gαγβγ0},R_{AD}=R_{\alpha\delta}= \left\{ \begin{array}{ccc} -1 & G_{\beta\delta}^{\alpha\gamma} & 1\\ 1+R_{\alpha\gamma} & G_{\alpha\gamma}^{\beta\delta} & 0\\ 1+G_{\beta\gamma}^{\alpha\gamma}+G_{\alpha\gamma}^{\alpha\gamma} & 2+G_{\beta\delta}^{\beta\gamma}+G_{\alpha\delta}^{\beta\delta} & 0 \end{array} \right\}, \quad R_{BC}=R_{\beta\gamma}= \left\{ \begin{array}{ccc} -1 & 0 & 1\\ 1+R_{\beta\delta} & G_{\beta\delta}^{\alpha\gamma} & 0\\ 1+G_{\alpha\delta}^{\beta\delta}+G_{\beta\delta}^{\beta\delta} & 2+G_{\alpha\gamma}^{\alpha\gamma}+G_{\alpha\gamma}^{\beta\gamma} & 0 \end{array} \right\},
RAC=Rαγ={1+GαβαγGαββδGαβγβ−1−Gαβαγ−Gαββδ1+Rβγ1+Gαγαγ2+GαγβδGαγγβ},RBD=Rαβ={1+GβδβδGβγαγGδαβδ−1−Gβαβδ−Gαγγβ1+Rαδ1+Gβδβδ2+GδααγGδαγβ}.(14)R_{AC}=R_{\alpha\gamma}= \left\{ \begin{array}{ccc} 1+G_{\alpha\beta}^{\alpha\gamma} & G_{\alpha\beta}^{\beta\delta} & G_{\alpha\beta}^{\gamma\beta}\\ -1-G_{\alpha\beta}^{\alpha\gamma} & -G_{\alpha\beta}^{\beta\delta} & 1+R_{\beta\gamma}\\ 1+G_{\alpha\gamma}^{\alpha\gamma} & 2+G_{\alpha\gamma}^{\beta\delta} & G_{\alpha\gamma}^{\gamma\beta} \end{array} \right\}, \quad R_{BD}=R_{\alpha\beta}= \left\{ \begin{array}{ccc} 1+G_{\beta\delta}^{\beta\delta} & G_{\beta\gamma}^{\alpha\gamma} & G_{\delta\alpha}^{\beta\delta}\\ -1-G_{\beta\alpha}^{\beta\delta} & -G_{\alpha\gamma}^{\gamma\beta} & 1+R_{\alpha\delta}\\ 1+G_{\beta\delta}^{\beta\delta} & 2+G_{\delta\alpha}^{\alpha\gamma} & G_{\delta\alpha}^{\gamma\beta} \end{array} \right\}. \tag*{(14)}

with

{a1b1c1a2b2c2a3b3c3}=∑i,j,k=13ϵijkaibjck∑i,j,k=13ϵijkaibj(15)\left\{\begin{array}{lll} a_1 & b_1 & c_1\\ a_2 & b_2 & c_2\\ a_3 & b_3 & c_3 \end{array}\right\} = \frac{\sum_{i,j,k=1}^{3}\epsilon_{ijk}a_i b_j c_k}{\sum_{i,j,k=1}^{3}\epsilon_{ijk}a_i b_j} \tag*{(15)}

where ϵijk\epsilon_{ijk} is the Levi-Civita symbol. From the set of equations, the real positive RαβR_{\alpha\beta}, RαγR_{\alpha\gamma}, RαδR_{\alpha\delta}, RγδR_{\gamma\delta} values can be found analytically:

Rαβ=−1+22,R_{\alpha\beta}=\sqrt{-1+2\sqrt{2}},
Rαγ=−4+22+5+5+424,R_{\alpha\gamma}=\frac{-4+2\sqrt{2}+\sqrt{5}+\sqrt{5+4\sqrt{2}}}{4},
Rαδ=5−22+5+424,R_{\alpha\delta}=\frac{\sqrt{5}-2\sqrt{2}+\sqrt{5+4\sqrt{2}}}{4},
Rδγ=−1+42−2.(16)R_{\delta\gamma}=-1+\sqrt{4\sqrt{2}-2}. \tag*{(16)}

Thus we arrive at

RAB=−1+22≈1.35Ω,(17)R_{AB}=\sqrt{-1+2\sqrt{2}}\approx1.35\Omega, \tag*{(17)}

which is in agreement with (2b). We also confirm this result with numerical evaluation (see Figure 11). This same method of using voltage path summation and current conservation to obtain a set of consistency equations can also be applied to many different topologies, such as those in Figure 12 which are linear linking with number of nodes N≥4\mathcal{N}\geq4 between unit cells. See Table II for the list of equivalent resistances RABR_{AB}.

Numerical convergence of the equivalent resistance

Figure 11. We verify the analytical result for RABR_{AB} with the numerical results for RAB(N)R_{AB}(\mathcal{N}) where N\mathcal{N} is the size of the finite resistive network. The convergence can be quantified by Δ=RAB(N)/RAB−1\Delta=R_{AB}(\mathcal{N})/R_{AB}-1, which approaches 0 exponentially fast.

Four infinite resistive network topologies

Figure 12. All resistors are identically 1Ω1\Omega. (A) Square spider-web network. (B) Pentagonal inception network. (C) 4-parallel ladder network. (D) 4th-order spiral fractal network.

CircuitEquivalent Resistance RABR_{AB} (in Ω\Omega)
A3(−19+183+122+653)376≈0.48\frac{3(-19+18\sqrt{3}+\sqrt{122+65\sqrt{3}})}{376}\approx0.48
B−2+23+172≈1.60\frac{-2+\sqrt{23}+\sqrt{17}}{2}\approx1.60
C−2+7+172≈0.68\frac{-2+\sqrt{7}+\sqrt{17}}{2}\approx0.68
DRAB=(1−x)x(1−x)x≈0.67R_{AB}=\frac{(1-x)x}{(1-x)x}\approx0.67, where x≈1.65x\approx1.65 satisfies x8−4x7+4x6+9x5−27x4+18x3+16x2−32x+16=0x^8-4x^7+4x^6+9x^5-27x^4+18x^3+16x^2-32x+16=0

Table II. Results for RABR_{AB} of infinite resistive circuits given in Figure 12.

It should be noted that for a highly entangled topology linking linearly, while it is still possible to use the resistive relations to calculate the equivalent resistance, there will be N(N−1)/2\mathcal{N}(\mathcal{N}-1)/2 consistency equations with N(N−1)/2\mathcal{N}(\mathcal{N}-1)/2 in general thus the algebraic manipulation gets messy quickly as N\mathcal{N} increases. Even if all resistors are identically 1Ω1\Omega, the solution might not have any algebraic representation1 (for example, RABR_{AB} of the network given in Figure 12D), though it should still be an algebraic number2.

We should also mention that the equivalent resistances of linearly linking infinite resistive networks can be calculated with a linear algebra method via transmission matrix3, which will be discussed elsewhere4. This approach, however, is problematic and even inapplicable for looping topologies such as the 4th-order spiral fractal network (see Figure 12D).

Discussion

The potential of the method discussed above expands to infinite network consisting of inductors and capacitors, yielding a physical explanation for the convergence of ZZ in the existence of infinitesimal resistances as well as the analytical expression of the point of convergence. It can also be utilized to provide a rigorous explanation for Rayleigh’s theorem for system with only resistors, and to expand this well-known theorem to system with both inductors and capacitors. Those applications will be discussed elsewhere[8].

Acknowledgments

We thank Tuan K. Do, Hiep T. Vu, Duy V. Nguyen, and xPhO journal club for their valuable feedback and insight throughout every stage of this research.

References

References

  1. [1]R. P. Feynman, R. B. Leighton, and M. L. Sands, The Feynman Lectures on Physics: electromagnetism and matter, Vol. 2 (Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, 1964) Chap. 22.DOI
  2. [2]J. C. Maxwell, A treatise on electricity and magnetism, Vol. 1 (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1873) Chap. 8.
  3. [3]H. H. Skilling, Electrical engineering circuits (Wiley, 1965) Chap. 11.
  4. [4]J. W. Nilsson and S. A. Riedel, Introductory circuits for electrical and computer engineering (Pearson, 2002) Chap. 2.
  5. [5]A. E. Kennelly, Electrical world and engineer 34, 413 (1899).
  6. [8]Q. M. Nguyen, L. K. Nguyen, T. X. Tran, C. D. Tran, T. H. Cai, and T. Phan, arXiv preprint arXiv:2010.05645 (2020).arxiv.org/abs/2010.05645

Paper details

vlnc:W_s4f2zwnp
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents