WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Electrostatic Steering of Thermal Emission with Active Metasurface Control of Delocalized Modes
Abstract
We theoretically describe and experimentally demonstrate a graphene-integrated metasurface structure that enables electrically-tunable directional control of thermal emission. This device consists of a dielectric slab that acts as a Fabry-Perot (F-P) resonator supporting long-range delocalized modes bounded on one side by an electrostatically tunable metal-graphene metasurface. By varying the Fermi level of the graphene, the accumulated phase of the F-P mode is shifted, which changes the direction of absorption and emission at a fixed frequency. We directly measure the frequency- and angle-dependent emissivity of the thermal emission from a fabricated device heated to 250. Our results show that electrostatic control allows the thermal emission at 6.61 m to be continuously steered over 16, with a peak emissivity maintained above 0.9. We analyze the dynamic behavior of the thermal emission steerer theoretically using a Fano interference model, and use the model to design optimized thermal steerer structures.
Introduction
The mid infrared (MIR) is an important band for applications ranging from free-space laser communications[1] to chemical sensing[2, 3]. An optimal MIR source for these applications would be narrowband, and also offer high speed directional control, such that the beam can be rastered over a range of angles, or have a controllable focal point. Typically, such beam-steering is achieved by reflecting a beam using mechanical devices such as gimbal-mounted mirrors[4], optical phased arrays of antenna[5, 6], or liquid crystal-based devices[7]. While each of these techniques have their own set of advantages and disadvantages, one limitation common to them all is that they require an external source of light, such as a quantum cascade laser.
An alternative source of MIR light is one that can be found everywhere, thermal radiation. Any material at a non-zero temperature will emit thermal radiation over a broad range of frequencies which, at moderate temperatures (–), is peaked in the MIR. Though thermal emission is typically viewed as incoherent, isotropic, and broadband, recent advances in nanoengineering have demonstrated that it is possible to engineer the emissivity of a structured material to create narrowband[8] directional[9] emissions that exhibits coherence. These include metasurfaces composed of non-interacting, localized resonator elements tuned to specific wavelengths, such as metallic nanoantennas10 or semiconducting nanostructures that exhibit sharp quasi bound-state-int the continuum resonances11,12.
To achieve coherent directional emission, meanwhile, structures that support long-range delocalized modes can be utilized. These include surface waves that are out-coupled via gratings[9] [13, 14], Fabry-Perot (F-P) cavities15, photonic crystals16–18, epsilon near zero modes19 and delocalized modes formed by coupled resonators20–22. In all of these demonstrated devices, heating is all that is required to produce the desired light as the relevant optical modes are excited thermally, thus providing an elegant source of MIR radiation.
Imparting tunability into such devices - which could allow for dynamic beam control and frequency shifting - requires the integration of materials with variable optical properties. Materials with temperature-dependent phases and/or indices, such as GST23–25, VO26–29, or Si30 have been utilized to create metasurfaces that control the magnitude and phase of scattered light in reflection or transmission geometries, but such materials are unsuitable for thermal emission devices that operate at high, constant temperatures. Alternatively, materials with indices that depend on carrier density, including graphene, III-V quantum wells and indium tin oxide (ITO), can be utilized to bestow electrostatic tunability on metasurfaces, and devices that control phase, frequency, and intensity of reflected light have been demonstrated31–36. These materials are also chemically and phase stable at high temperatures, which has enabled them to be integrated within thermal-control metasurfaces to electrostatically tune the intensity and frequency of incandescent light in the mid-IR37–39. Unfortunately, such materials also introduce ohmic loss which can, in some geometries, suppresses formation of the long-range delocalized modes that are necessary for coherent, directional thermal emission. As such, dynamic angular tuning of thermal emission is an outstanding problem in the field of thermal metasurfaces.
In this work, we theoretically describe and experimentally demonstrate a thermal emission device that can be tuned electrostatically to control the directionality of thermal emission within a narrow bandwidth. We show experimentally that by using a tunable graphene-integrated metasurface as a boundary for a delocalized F-P cavity mode, the thermal emission from a surface at 6.61 µm (1508 cm) can be continuously steered by ± 16° by changing the carrier density of the graphene sheet. Theoretical calculations, meanwhile, show that an optimized geometry using real materials could achieve ± 60° of continuous tuning.
Results
For dynamic thermal emission steering, we utilize an electrically tunable F-P resonance of a SiN dielectric layer sandwiched by a gold back reflector and a graphene-based active metasurface as illustrated in Figure 1(a). The graphene metasurface consists of 30 nm thick, 1 µm wide gold strips spaced 40 nm apart on top of HfO (5 nm)/graphene/AlO (30 nm) trilayer, sitting on the 2 µm think SiN membrane with the 100 nm gold back reflector that also serves as a back gate electrode. The gaps between the gold strips are filled with a bilayer of 30 nm gold and 100 nm SiO. The sub-wavelength period of the structure suppresses far-field diffraction except for the zeroth order. We note that this structure does support metal-insulator-metal (MIM) surface plasmon modes40, but for the device dimensions used in this work the MIM resonances occur at frequencies (∼4500 cm) much higher than the active frequency (∼1500 cm), and thus have little effect on the thermal steering properties of the device.

Figure 1. Schematic and working principles of dynamic thermal steering device. a Diagram of the thermal steering device. The magnified view shows the geometry of a graphene-Au slit metasurface unit cell. b Illustration of the working mechanism of electrically tunable directional thermal emission via graphene metasurface control of the delocalized Fabry–Perot modes in the dielectric. The emission angle of the structure is controlled by the incident angle-dependent resonant absorption condition, which changes with the graphene Fermi level. The inset shows decomposed total reflection into two reflection channels: direct reflection and F-P reflection . c scanning electron microscopy image of graphene metasurface on top of SiN membrane. The width () and gap () of Au slit array are 1 m and 40 nm, respectively.
The working principle of our device is illustrated in Figure 1(b). The graphene-based metasurface covering the top surface of the SiN membrane acts as a partially reflecting mirror to form a vertical F-P cavity. By applying an electrostatic potential () across the dielectric spacer, the Fermi level of graphene () is modulated and so are the complex reflection and transmission coefficients of the top graphene metasurface. Consequently, the condition for the resonance shifts, causing a shift in the peak emission angle () for a given frequency. These changes can be qualitatively understood by treating the top metasurface as a two-dimensional sheet with an effective surface admittance, which is justified since the metasurface thickness is about two orders of magnitude shorter than the wavelength of the free space light[6] [31, 41]. In this model, the subwavelength metallic stips with narrow gaps make the overall optical response of the graphene metasurface to be highly capacitive (i.e. large imaginary impedance) at a low carrier concentration. As the conductivity of graphene raises with increasing , the metasurface exhibits a reduced, but still high, capacitance and also acquires a larger conductance, changing the reflection/transmission characteristics. The quantitative surface admittance model for the graphene metasurface is discussed in detail in Supplementary Notes 1, 2, and 3.
Recognizing the emissivity of a reciprocal object is equal to its absorptivity 42, one can understand the mechanism of the directional shift in thermal emission more intuitively by analyzing the absorption process. Since the transmission channel is blocked by the back reflector,
where is the total reflection, which can be decomposed into the direct reflection from the top surface () and the resonant reflection due to the F-P interference formed by multiple reflections inside the dielectric spacer (). The interplay between and , both of which are dependent on , determines the overall absorption (and thus the emission) of the device. The absorption peak occurs when and destructively interfere with each other by having similar amplitudes and a phase difference.
We first theoretically investigate the behavior of the proposed device using full-field electromagnetic simulations based on the finite element method as summarized in Figure 2. The dependence of on and for TM polarized light is shown in Figure 2(b). can be obtained by simulating the reflection by the graphene metasurface sitting on a semi-infinite SiN layer without a back reflector. Since the top graphene metasurface does not support any distinctive resonance around the target frequency of cm, the direct reflectance, , exhibit a generic weak dependence on within the range of 0° to 50°. As the carrier density of graphene increases, the metasurface becomes less capacitive, leading to better impedance matching as elaborated in (Supplementary Notes 1 and 3). Consequently, monotonically decreases with increasing . The phase of the direct reflection, , remains nearly constant round within and eV.

Figure 2. Angular and Fermi-level dependence of reflection coefficients and emissivity. Fermi-level and angular dependence of a the reflectance due to the F-B resonance (), b the direct reflectance from the top surface of the device (), c The phase difference between the two reflection (), and d the emissivity of the device (). The blue dashed line in (a) indicates the F-P resonance condition. The black dashed line in (c) and (d) indicates the condition for destructive interference between and , . All angular spectra are calculated for frequency .
Unlike , shows a strong dependence on both and due to its resonant nature. The F-P resonance occurs when the out-of-plane wavevector inside the dielectric, , satisfies the constructive interference condition:
where is the phase accumulation associated with vertical wave propagation across the dielectric spacer, and are the reflection phase from the top and bottom surfaces, respectively, and is an integer. does not dependent on since the bottom surface is a mere gold back reflector, which behaves like a perfect electric conductor at mid-infrared frequencies. , in principle, could depend on for metasurfaces with an admittance comparable to the surrounding medium, but in our device the admittance is large and, thus, the dependence of is weak for eV. (see Supplementary Note 1 for a detailed analysis). As a result, at a fixed frequency, the resonance angle slightly decreases from to when increases from 0.2 eV to 0.65 eV as indicated as a blue dashed curve in Figure 2(a); And, at a fixed , the resonance frequency slightly blueshifts with increasing . The F-P resonance becomes weaker with increasing as the top graphene metasurface becomes less reflective and more absorptive, raising both the radiative and dissipative decay rate of the resonant mode. However, while shows only a small dependence on , the overall phase shift due to the F-P resonance () includes phase accumulated while passing into and out of the F-P cavity, through the complex transmission coefficients and , which show considerably more dependence on . (see Supplementary Note 3)
Since the amplitude of is similar to that of near the broad F-P resonance, what mainly determines the overall absorption is their phase difference, . We note that the Fano interference between a non-resonant and a resonant scattering channel has been widely adopted to create a sharp resonant response43,44. The dependence of on and , which is dominated by due to the near constant , are plotted in Figure 2(c). monotonically decreases with because the propagation phase across the dielectric spacer, , decreases as shortens. also decreases with as the capacitive phase shift of the top graphene metasurface reduces. As a result, the condition for the Fano resonance, , shifts from to as alters from 0.2 eV to 0.62 eV. This change in the phase matching condition drives an overall change in the angular-dependent absorptivity/emissivity, shown in Figure 2(d), and thus allows the device to thermally emit at an angle that can be tuned by varying .
In order to experimentally verify the possibility of active thermal emission steering, we fabricated the proposed device using e-beam lithography over a mm area (see Methods), heated it to C, and measured its angle-dependent thermal emission spectra while varying the by applying different gate voltages . A polarizer was used to accept only TM polarized emission, and the acceptance angle of the emitted light was . The emissivity of the structure is calculated by normalizing the emitted radiation of the device to the emitted radiation of a reference carbon nanotube blackbody45.
The measured surface normal emissivity spectra for at , 0 and V, shown in Figure 3(a), exhibit a well-defined resonance peak at around cm, that blueshifts as the Fermi level of graphene increases, indicating that the thermal emission peaks are electrostatically tunable with minor variation in the intensity. The measured emissivity spectra also shows a strong angular dependence as shown in Figure 3(b). At a constant doping level ( V), the emission peak shifts from cm to cm as changes from to . There are also higher order features present around cm (see Supplementary Note 4) that show similar but more limited shifting. Finally, Figure 3(c) demonstrates the dynamic thermal emission steering by showing how the emission angle is modulated by altering the doping level of graphene at a fixed target frequency cm. At V, we observe that the emission peak is most intense at normal incidence and decreases in intensity as the angle is increased. As the applied gate voltage increases to 560 V, the lobe shifts from normal incidence to increasing angles, up to , allowing for continuous tuning in that range.

Figure 3. Measured and calculated emissivity dependence on gate voltage and measurement angle. a,b,c Experimental emission spectra for (a) different applied gate voltages at normal incidence, (b) at different angles at a constant applied voltage of V, and (c) the angular-dependent emission at 1508 cm. Experimental measurements were obtained for and are mirrored for visual clarity. d,e,f Show analogous simulated spectra, with f plotting angular-dependent emission at 1503 cm.
These experimental results can be compared to simulated emissivity spectra shown in Figure 3(d-Figure 3f). In these simulations, the value of at V was chosen as a fitting parameter and calculated spectra were compared to the experimental spectra obtained at V to determine that eV with no gate voltage applied. This indicates that the sample is heavily hole-doped, which is consistent with previous studies of graphene grown and transferred using similar procedures46. Using this initial value of , the Fermi energies at other gate voltages were derived with a simple capacitance model.
The overall qualitative behavior of the simulations (Figure 3(d-Figure 3f)) is consistent with our experimental results (Figure 3(a-Figure 3c)), however, the emission lobes are broader and the change of emission angle of the emitter is smaller in our experiment than was theoretically predicted. The likely sources of these inconsistencies are the metastructure geometric and material parameter variations across the full mm device (see Subsections A and B in Supplementary Note 5), and carrier density variation during the heating process due to the temperature dependence of the SiN, AlO, and HfO dielectric properties47–52. The detected carrier density tuning range is also affected by substrate and interface charge traps, which can act to decrease the overall doping range by screening the applied gating field (see Methods); Moreover, the tuning range is directly affected by the DC dielectric constant of the SiN layer, which has reported variations of 15% for the commercial membranes used in this work.53 We also note that the modulation depth at is predicted to be larger than what is observed experimentally, and we also attribute this mostly to decreases in the doping range, as well as small potential misalignment of the heating stage. (see Methods) The intensity of emission at large angles can also be reduced due to ellipsoidal elongation of the measurement area which, for small device areas, can extend the active zone to include some low emissivity, unpatterned gold areas. Finally, we note that the initial graphene doping level can affect the calculated spectra, but simulations show that such affects do not account for the discrepancies we observe (see Supplementary Note 5). Those simulation results do indicate, however, that the dynamic steering range could be improved in the future by using graphene with slightly less initial doping.
To further explore the potential performance of the proposed thermal steerer device, we investigate the maximum realizable emission angle under the limitation of realistic geometric and material parameters. The Fermi level of graphene is assumed to be electrostatically tunable between 0 eV and 0.6 eV, considering typical dielectric strength of SiN and numerical optimizations of the geometric parameters of the device were performed to maximize the angle tunability. To prevent performance degradation due to non-local effects (see Supplementary Note 5 for more discussion), we set the minimum gap width to 30 nm and carried out simulations in the frame of classical electrodynamics. Figure 4(a) shows the structure of the optimized device. The gap and width of Au slit array are 30 nm and 740 nm, respectively. The HfO is thinned to 1 nm which is achievable smallest value that could avoid quantum tunneling effect. The bilayer Au/SiO area eliminated to enhance interaction between graphene and Au slit array. The optimization results show that it is possible to achieve ∼60° thermal emission angle steering with unity peak emissivity (Figure 4(b)). The achievable performance is greater than most metasurface-based electrically tunable beam steering devices54 and is comparable to state-of-the-art MEMS-based beam steering device where field of view55. The improvements in the optimized structure in comparison to the experimentally measured sample are due to three main effects. First, the optimized structure utilized a smaller, 30 nm spacing between the gold strips. This acts to increase the electric field concentration within the graphene and minimize stray fields connecting the gold strips, allowing more interaction with the graphene and a stronger effect of the graphene on the metasurface properties. Second, a thinner HfO layer is used in the optimized structure, which brings the graphene closer to the gold and also increases the electric field intensity within the graphene sheet (see Supplementary Notes 2 and 5). And, third, in the optimized structure we assume a greater range of tunability, which is consistent with the potential properties of the dielectrics, but could not be achieved in our experiments due to our methods of contacting the sample (i.e. wirebonding) which weakened the dielectric strength and restricted the range of . We note that the required gate voltage for device operation can be significantly reduced by modifying the gating scheme. For example, as demonstrated in the work of N. H. Tu56 and B. Zeng57 by inserting a transparent conducting layer near the top graphene membrane, the gate voltage required to achieve the same level of Fermi energy can be reduced by orders of magnitudes with a marginal perturbation of the optical characteristics of the device.

Figure 4. Optimized steering of thermal emission. a Schematic of the device geometry that maximizes thermal emission steering performance. b The angular emission spectra of the optimized device for Fermi levels of 0 and 0.6 eV at .
Discussion
In conclusion, we have demonstrated a thermal emitter that can continuously change the angle of emission in the mid-IR for a designated frequency. We show that by including a graphene-metal metasurface as a boundary, a delocalized F-P optical mode can be tuned to exhibit resonances with angular and frequency dependencies that depend on the carrier density of graphene, which can be tuned electrostatically. The net result is a surface that has an emissivity that is strongly angular dependent and tunable. 16° of thermal emission steering at 6.61 μm was demonstrated experimentally, and we outline design strategies that could increase the tunability to almost 60°. This work lays the foundation for next generation beamsteering devices that do not require an external lightsource, and could be broadly applicable for remote sensing and thermal camouflage applications.
Methods
Fabrication of Device
SiN membranes (2 μm thick and 5 mm x 5 mm wide) on a 200 μm Si frame were purchased from Norcada. To the backside of the SiN membrane, we deposited a 2.5 nm chromium adhesion layer followed by a 100 nm of gold, which makes the lower layer opaque and reflective. Atomic Layer Deposition (a Fiji G2 ALD) was used to grow a 30 nm film of AlO on the top of the SiN membrane. Once the AlO was grown, a prepared graphene sheet was transferred on top of the AlO film. Graphene was purchased from Grolltex and was grown on a Cu foil. To remove the foil, first a protective layer of PMMA (950k, A4, MicroChem Corp.) was added on top of the graphene. The Cu foil was etched away with FeCl (CE-100, Transene) then the graphene/PMMA stack was rinsed in a series of deionized water baths until transfer to the prepared membranes. Once transferred, the PMMA was removed by soaking in 60 °C acetone for 1 h. After the graphene transfer, a 5 nm film of HfO was grown via atomic layer deposition. To prepare the SiN membranes for the next steps, the Si frame of the sample was glued to a carrier Si chip with PMMA (950k, A8, MicroChem Corp.). The prepared substrate was then coated with a negative tone hydrogen silsesquioxane resist (HSіQ, 6%, DisChem Inc.) at 100 nm. The sample was then exposed and patterned using the Elionix ELS G-100, an electron beam lithography tool. After exposure, the samples were developed in MF-321 for 90 s, with a 30 s rinse in DI water and then a 30 s rinse in IPA. The development process converts the exposed HSiQ to SiO. For metal deposition of the top, a metal mask was placed above the substrate to create electrically disconnected regions. The deposition consisted of a 2.5 nm chromium adhesion layer and 30 nm of gold. Following these processing steps, the graphene was found to be heavily hole-doped, similar to what has been observed in previous works37,46, Gate-dependent resistivity measurements showed an increase in resistance for positive gate bias, but no maximum resistance was observed that would indicate charge neutrality. These measurements also exhibited hysteresis, consistent with what has been observed elsewhere, and indicative of surface, interface, and substrate charge traps that can be populated with charge as is changed. At high biases, these traps can screen the applied gating field without doping the graphene, leading to deviations from the simple capacitance model that we use to estimate the graphene carrier density for a given 58–60.
Thermal Emission Measurements
The emission measurements were performed using a Bruker Vertex 70 FTIR, where thermal emission from a heated sample was used as the lightsource of the interferometer. The device was mounted on a rotation stage, and thermal emission from the device is collected by the FTIR45. A carbon-nanotube source was used as our blackbody reference measurement. The finite size of the aperture creates a acceptance angle, and there is also some uncertainty in the overall angle due to mechanical play in the stage holder and sample tilting within the sample holder. We estimate this uncertainly to be based on measurements with an alignment laser reflected off of an unpatterned area of the sample surface.
Optical Simulations
The frequency-dependent dielectric functions of AlO, Cr, Au and SiO were taken from the Palik data61. The dielectric functions of HfO and SiN were obtained from infrared ellipsometry31. Heat-induced dielectric function change of SiN is corrected through the higher-order F-P resonance peak which is insensitive to Fermi level modulation (see Supplementary Note 4). The graphene was modeled as a layer with zero thickness, and its optical conductivity was calculated by Kubo formula62. The carrier mobility of graphene is assumed to be which is comparable to a previously reported value31. The reflection/transmission coefficients and absorption spectrum of the proposed structure were calculated by full-wave simulation with the finite element method. We determined the Fermi level of graphene at by comparing the calculated and measured frequency and angular emissivity spectra. This process aimed to minimize the difference in various parameters, including resonance frequency, intensity and full-width half maximum. Throughout the estimation process, we constrained the expected Fermi level to the range of to 46, consistent with the hole-doped state observed at the .
Data Availability
The experimental and theoretical data used to generate the figures in this manuscript and in the Supporting Information are available on Zenado [10.5281/zenodo.10615359].
Acknowledgements
J.S. and V.W.B. were supported by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation through a Moore Inventors Fellowship. M.F. was supported by Office of Naval Research award N00014-20-1-2356. M.A.K. and C.W. acknowledge support from the US Office of Naval Research, award N00014-20-1-2297. This work was also supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) grants funded by the Ministry of Science and ICT (NRF-2022R1A2C2092095, S.K. and M.S.J.) and by the Ministry of Education (NRF-2022R1I1A1A01065727, S.K.).
Author Contributions
S.K., M.S.J., and V.W.B. conceived the idea. J.S. fabricated and characterized the devices, and performed the optical measurements. M.F. assisted in sample fabrication. M.A.K. and C.W. assisted in optical measurements. S.K. and M.S.J. conducted a theoretical analysis. S.K. conducted optical simulations and device optimization. L.S. and P.W. C.W. assisted in theoretical design and in fabrication planning. J.S., S.K., M.S.J., and V.W.B. wrote the manuscript. M.S.J. and V.W.B. supervised the project.
Competing Interests
The Authors declare no competing interests.
Correspondence to: [email protected], [email protected]
This PDF file includes:
Supplementary Notes 1 to 7
Surface admittance of a metasurface
Analysis of plasmonic structure in the metasurface
Fabry-Perot model analysis
Higher order Fabry-Perot resonance peak
Analysis of potential factors affecting device performance
Potential angle steering capability
Modulation of angle-frequency spectra
Derivation of surface admittance of a metasurface
The metasurface can be modeled as a thin conductive layer with effective surface admittance because the thickness of the metasurface is much thinner than the wavelength of the incident light [1, 2]. For normally incident light, can be solved for from the boundary condition . For the metasurface on top of the semi-infinite dielectric layer (Figure S1), the normalized surface admittance is expressed in terms of transmission and reflection coefficients ( and ) of a metasurface as:

Figure S1. Detailed configuration of metasurface and reflection/transmission coefficients.
Here, , and are the admittance of free space, input, and output media. For the top (bottom) excitation, and are air (SiN) and SiN (air), respectively. Figure S2(b) shows that the values of calculated admittance and are different. The surface admittance for both directions would be identical if the metasurface had zero thickness due to the same tangential electric fields at the top and bottom surfaces. However, the finite thickness of metasurface invalidates that condition and leads to two different surface admittance. In Note 1, we use normalized surface admittance derived from transmission coefficients.
We note that the dynamic behavior of the metasurface due to the Fermi level of graphene could be understood from the analysis of the surface admittance components. The real part (normalized surface conductance ) and imaginary part (normalized surface susceptance ) of the normalized surface admittance () provide information on absorption and scattering of the metasurface [3]. The normalized surface conductance indicates the strength of the scattering process with the absorption of the metasurface. Because metal has much higher conductivity than graphene, the conductance of the metasurface is approximated to the conductance of graphene. Figure S2(c) shows higher conductance of the metasurface is obtained with an increase (decrease) of the Fermi level (frequency). In contrast, normalized surface susceptance indicates the strength of the scattering process without absorption of the metasurface. The susceptance of the metasurface is determined by a capacitance () and an inductance () derived from geometry and material parameters, where the surface susceptance of metasurface is proportional to with the convention of . Since the period of the metal slit array is much shorter than a free space wavelength, the surface susceptance of the metasurface shows a capacitive response. We note that the kinetic inductance of graphene is inversely proportional to the optical conductivity of graphene[4]. Thus higher Fermi level of graphene results in lowering surface susceptance of metasurface.

Figure S2. Analysis of metasurface admittance. Conductance (left axis) and susceptance (right axis) of metasurface for different (a) excitation directions and (b) derivation variables ( and ) for eV. The (c) conductance and (d) susceptance for different Fermi levels of graphene.
Next, we calculate angle-dependent normalized surface admittance of the surface current which could be expressed in terms of angle-dependent transmission and reflection coefficients as:
where the angles and represent the angles of incidence and transmission, respectively. Figure S3 shows that the surface admittance remains constant regardless of the incident angle which is consistent with the ideal surface current model. This implies that the surface admittance derived from normal incident light could be exploited to derive angle-dependent reflection and transmission coefficients of the metasurface.

Figure S3. Dependence of metasurface admittance on illumination directions. Conductance (left axis) and susceptance (right axis) of metasurface for different excitation directions derived from (a) transmission and (b) reflection coefficient.
Analysis of plasmonic structure in metasurface
To investigate the impact of a plasmonic structure in the proposed graphene-metal hybrid metasurface, which serves as an electrically tunable mirror layer, we calculate the reflection coefficient for different geometric parameters of the plasmonic structure. The influence of the plasmonic structure is studied by comparing two different metasurface configurations MS₁ and MS₂ as shown in Figure S4. Figure S5 and (Figure S5) illustrate the calculated amplitude () and phase difference () of reflection coefficients as a function of gap width with Fermi levels 0 eV and 0.3 eV. By comparing Figure S5 and (Figure S5), we observe that the amplitude of the reflection coefficient is mainly influenced by the slit width , which represents the surface coverage of the highly reflective metal film. On the other hand, the phase modulation for the Fermi level is determined by the electric field intensity at the surface of graphene, which is determined by the compressed transmitted electromagnetic wave as the form of plasmonic wave. As a result, the phase difference is significantly affected by both geometric parameters. We emphasize that the shape of the resonance peak in the Fabry-Perot (F-P) resonator and the resonance frequency shift for the Fermi level modulation are determined by the reflection coefficient of the metasurface. Therefore, proper metasurface design is crucial for achieving a sufficiently high and sharp emissivity peak with a considerable resonance frequency shift for Fermi level modulation.

Figure S4. Schematic of two different types of metasurfaces, MS₁ and MS₂, which differ based on the presence of a plasmonic metal slit array.

Figure S5. Influence of plasmonic metasurfaces on reflection coefficient modulation. The amplitude and phase difference for slit (a, b) and gap (c, d) widths and , respectively. The black dashed line shows the reflection coefficient of bare graphene structure MS. The amplitude (e) and phase difference (f) of metasurface MS for constant ratio .
Fabry-Perot model analysis {#sec:Supplementary Note 3}
In order to deeply understand the operation mechanism of the proposed structure, we develop the semi-analytical solution of the reflection coefficient for the proposed structure based on F-P interference (Figure S6). To simplify the reflection coefficient equation of the structure, the dielectric film stack is merged into a single film, where reflection at the bottom interfaces of AlO and HfO films are ignored. The graphene layer thickness is excluded from the thickness of the dielectric stack because it was modeled as a zero-thickness conductivity sheet layer. Note that the subwavelength period and the non-resonant response of the metasurface suppress higher-order diffraction and deflection for incident light. We directly calculate the reflection () and transmission coefficients () from the definition in electromagnetic wave theory. The F-P reflection coefficient of the proposed structure is

Figure S6. Schematic of F-P model for a structure consisting of graphene-plasmonic metasurface/thick dielectric spacer/metal reflector.
where and are the out-of-plane wavevector and the thickness of the dielectric layer. The wavevector is a function of refractive index and incident angle, and thus total phase accumulation is sum of at each film.
We note that a rich free electron density of noble metal makes it difficult to obtain a noticeable electro-optic effect in the bottom and top metal layers. Therefore, the modulation of the resonant frequency of the proposed structure is determined by the Fermi-level dependent surface admittance of the metasurface. Figure S7 shows the reflection and transmission coefficients for normally incident TM polarized plane wave as a function of Fermi levels. In the extreme case ( eV), the amplitude and phase of has high value of 0.82 and which is close to planar metal film because metal slit array covers of surface area. In contrast, the increase (decrease) of conductance (susceptance) of the metasurface reduces the amplitude and phase of reflection coefficients for higher or lower . Similarly, the transmission coefficients also transit from a metal mirror-like response to a lossy dielectric response for and .

Figure S7. Fermi level dependence of transmission/reflection coefficients. The amplitude (left axis) and phase (right axis) of transmission (a,b) and reflection (c,d) coefficients for different Fermi levels.
In the F-P model, the total absorption can be calculated as . Note that the amplitude and phase variation () of the direct reflection is significantly smaller than the amplitude and phase () of the Fabry-Perot reflection as shown in Figure S8 and (b). Thus, the dynamic behavior of total absorption is primarily determined by . The dynamic behavior of these coefficients can be understood by analyzing the dependence of F-P reflection spectra on the Fermi level and the incident angle. The resonance frequency of is determined by the phase condition

Figure S8. Analysis of Fermi level dependence using the semi-analytical model. The (a) amplitude and (b) phase of reflection coefficient and for Fermi level eV (c) The amplitude of (left axis) and total absorption derived from F-P model (right axis). (d) The resonance frequencies and as a function of graphene Fermi levels. (e) The F-P model total absorption (left axis) and phase difference (right axis) for different Fermi levels of graphene. (f) The total absorption from FEM-based full wave simulation and F-P model.
where and are the phase of reflection coefficient and respectively, and is an integer. Given the nearly constant reflection phase of the bottom electrode, the reflection phase change of metasurface is compensated by the change of out-of-plane wavevector , which contributes to propagation phase . As is inversely proportional to the Fermi level, the at resonance frequency should be increased for higher Fermi level, leading to a blue shift in F-P resonance. Figure S8 shows that the resonance frequency
derived from the phase condition for maximum absorption () is larger than the F-P resonance frequency , and that the change of is faster than for Fermi level modulation. At the F-P resonance condition, the phase of is equal to the sum of phases of transmission coefficients and where the phase difference condition is not satisfied. Since and , the resonance frequency of maximum absorption becomes greater than F-P resonance frequency . In addition, phase modulation of , , and for Fermi level provides additional phase difference between and , thus the resonance frequency shift of is larger than .
On the other hand, the parameters and variables in the F-P reflection formula also depend on the incident angle of the excitation light. Figure S9 shows the incident angle-dependent reflection and transmission coefficients. In the discussion of angle-dependent calculation, the incident angle is defined as the angle in the air. The amplitude and phase of coefficients show slower variation for incident angles than the Fermi level of graphene. Larger amplitude change of than originates from the input admittance difference (Eq. (3) and 2). We emphasize that the shift of F-P resonance frequency comes from phase accumulation change of propagating wave () because the change of reflection and transmission coefficients for incident angles are smaller than the change of out-of-plane wavevector. The out-of-plane wavevector is given as where and are the wavevector and the propagation angle in the dielectric spacer. Since the propagation angle has the relation with incident angle as , a larger incident angle reduces propagation phase accumulation. To compensate for the phase decrease by , should be increased, which is equivalent to a blue shift of resonance frequency. Unlike the resonance frequency change for Fermi level modulation, the resonance frequency change of and for incident angle are similar due to the difference in the phase modulation method as shown in Figure S10.

Figure S9. Incident angle dependence of transmission/reflection coefficients. The amplitude (left axis) and phase (right axis) of transmission (a,b) and reflection (c,d) coefficients for different incident angles.

Figure S10. Analysis of incident angle dependence using the semi-analytical model. (a) The amplitude of (left axis) and total absorption derived from F-P model (right axis) for different incident angles. (b) The resonance frequencies and as a function of incident angles. (c) The F-P model total absorption (left axis) and phase difference (right axis) for different Fermi levels of graphene. (d) The total absorption from FEM-based full wave simulation and F-P model.
We note that the maximum absorption phase condition, , is worked when the amplitude of resonant mode is comparable with non-resonant direct reflection at the resonance frequency. The strength of F-P resonance is inversely proportional to the Fermi level due to increased free carrier absorption in the graphene (Figure S11). Therefore, this assumption cannot be satisfied at a high Fermi level, and the difference between resonance frequencies, , derived from the phase condition and the model-based calculation becomes larger as the increase of Fermi level (Figure S11). On the other hand, the maximum absorption phase condition is worked regardless of the incident angle due to the conservation of F-P resonance strength (Figure S11).

Figure S11. Range of applicability for the semi-analytical model: Fermi level and incident angle. The amplitude of and for different (a) Fermi levels of graphene and (c) incident angles. The resonance frequencies and as a function of (b) Fermi levels and (d) incident angles.
Calculation of emission angle at measured frequency is required to obtain desired functionality of the proposed device. However, this process requires the calculation of angular spectra for broad frequency spectrum and various Fermi levels. Instead of finite element method(FEM)-based full-wave angular spectrum calculation, we try to obtain angular spectrum from reflection and transmission coefficients derived from the surface admittance model. The Fresnel coefficients of the graphene metasurface are described by the following equations:
The calculated total absorption derived from these coefficients agrees well with the absorption calculated using FEM, as depicted in Figure S12.

Figure S12. Validation of the surface admittance-based F-P model. (a) The total absorption from FEM-based full wave simulation and surface admittance-based F-P model. (b) The resonance frequency as a function of incident angles for various Fermi levels of graphene. The black line indicates the resonance frequency for .
As a further step, we developed a graphical method that enables the rapid identification of required Fermi levels to achieve the desired emission angle at a given operating frequency. Figure S12 illustrates the calculated resonance frequencies of the device as a function of the incident angle of light. In this plot, we include a straight line with the measurement frequency as the y-intercept. The intersection point of the resonance frequency curve and the straight line indicates the emission angle at the measurement frequency. This approach allows for the rapid estimation of the emission angle, which is essential for thermal emission steerer design.
Higher order Fabry-Perot resonance peak

Figure S13. Emission spectra in the high frequency regime The measured emission spectrum in high frequency regime as a function of (a) applied voltages and (b) incident angles.
Analysis of potential factors affecting device performance
Elemental absorption analysis
To deeply understand the resonance behavior in the F-P resonator with a non-resonant metasurface, we performed FEM simulation to calculate elemental absorptions. The absorption of elements was calculated from for graphene sheet and for finite thickness films where , , , and are incident wave power, current density, electric field, and complex permittivity of materials. Figure S14 shows the elemental absorption of Graphene, SiN, and other components.

Figure S14. Elemental absorption analysis of the device. (a) The absorbed power by different material elements with . (b) The total, graphene and SiN absorption for and .
It is important to emphasize that the dominant absorption occurs in the graphene sheet and SiN membrane. Consequently, the total absorption peak is formed by the summation of these two absorption components. As a result, the resonance peak of the total absorption exhibits a broader frequency range and a larger shift than a single F-P resonance peak, as illustrated in Figure S14.
Geometry and material parameters
We analyze the impact of material and geometry on the device caused by imperfect fabrication. Figure S15 shows the total absorption of the device for various geometric parameters. The deviation in structural parameters was determined by considering the fabrication tolerance specific to each fabrication process. Among the geometrical parameters, the gap width, slit width, and thickness exhibit noticeable resonance peak frequency shifts and broadening. This is because electromagnetic energy density at the surface of graphene is influenced by two geometric factors: exposed graphene area (gap width/slit width) and metal-graphene distance ( thickness). Even a 2 nm thickness variation in thickness considerably alters the modulation performance of resonance frequency. The broadening of the resonance peak is directly proportional to the Fermi level due to enhanced free carrier absorption. In contrast, variation in the thickness of other elements (, , and Slit) have negligible effects on the optical properties of the device.

Figure S15. Deviation analysis of structural parameters in the device. The total absorption for different geometric parameters (a) gap width, (b) slit width, (c) slit thickness, (d) SiO thickness, (e) HfO thickness, and (f) AlO thickness with eV and eV, respectively.
To investigate the impact of deviations in material optical properties, we performed calculations of the total absorption for different carrier mobilities (graphene) and permittivities (, , and ). Figure S16 shows that at moderate carrier mobilities (), the resonance peak of the total absorption exhibited tolerance to deviations. However, excessively low carrier mobilities broaden the resonance peak and decrease the resonance frequency shift for Fermi level modulation. Considering the potential damage induced by fabrication processes such as dielectric deposition and e-beam exposure, the lower modulation performance observed in the fabricated devices of this project could be attributed to this effect. On the other hand, for calculating the total absorption spectra of the device for different frequency-dependent permittivity , where is the scaling factor, it was observed that there is a small resonance frequency shift with a slight change in broadness for high permittivity deviations. Therefore, in the proposed scheme, the deviation in material properties of dielectric layers has minimal effect on the calculation of the total absorption.

Figure S16. Deviation analysis of optical properties of materials in the device. The total absorption for different material parameters (a) carrier mobility of graphene, the real part of permittivity of (b) AlO, (c) SiO, and (d) HfO with and for different scaling factor , respectively.
Nonclassical effects in metal-graphene interaction
For the proposed structure, the length scale of metallic structures (graphene and slit array) is close to the electron wavelength in materials. Therefore, nonclassical effects that are not considered in classical electromagnetic simulations, such as the nonlocal effect, quantum tunneling effect, and quantum confinement effect, need to be taken into account. Additionally, the 30 nm thickness of metal slit is thick enough to avoid optical property change by the quantum confinement effect[5]. In the case of the quantum tunneling effect between graphene-metal structures, it becomes observable for gap distance less than 1 nm [6]. Thus, 5 nm passivation layer between the metal slit array and graphene does not enter the quantum tunneling regime. Therefore, the nonclassical effect of concern is the nonloal effect, which has been observed in metallic structures on the scale of a few tens of nanometers. This effect arises from the nonideal spatial concentration of electrons due to quantum pressure in electron wave functions.
To investigate the nonlocal effect, we employ a hydrodynamic model for Au slit array and graphene sheet. The currents density inside metal and graphene sheet induced by electric field with frequency can be described by the following equation in the nonlocal frame[7, 8]:
where , and are the vacuum permittivity, damping coefficient and plasma frequency, respectively. The nonlocal parameter, , depends on the Fermi level and dimensionality. We solve the equation using PDE and wave optics modules in COMSOL commericial FEM software. Figure S17 compares the total absorption of the device for different simulation configurations: full local, graphene nonlocal, metal nonlocal and full nonlocal. The results indicate that the fabricated device is rarely affected by the nonlocal effect. This can be attributed to two factors: (1) non-resonant scattering of the metal slit array (2) the increased effective gap width due to electric field spreading. However, when the thickness of HfO₂ is decreased to 1 nm, the nonlocal effect starts to affect the resonance peak due to increased electric field confinement in the gap region.

Figure S17. Analysis of nonlocal effect in the device. (a) The total absorption for different models with (blue) and (red). (b) The normalized magnitude of electric field distribution at resonance frequency with . The white dot line is zero thickness graphene layer. The total absorption of local and nonlocal models for different gap sizes with (c) 5 nm and (d) 1 nm of thickness.
Leakage current in dielectric spacer
In the classical capacitor model, the assumption in calculating induced charge density is that the applied voltage is the same value as the voltage drop along the dielectric films sandwiched by the two electrode pairs. If the voltage drops across other parts of the device are significant, the estimated induced charge density by the capacitor model may be higher than the actual charge density during the operation of the device. Thus, the inefficient gating of graphene by this factor diminishes the angle steering range and the associated spectral peak shift. To investigate the degradation of the device operation caused by inefficient gating, we measured the leakage current in the layer at , shown in Figure S18. The measured resistance across the dielectric spacer () is many orders of magnitude higher than any electrical contact in our circuit and the resistance of the graphene sheet (). Consequently, the gate voltage drop occurs almost entirely across the , despite the small leakage current.

Figure S18. Measurement of leakage current across the layers between the graphene sheet and the bottom Au backgate. The device temperature is maintained at during measurement.
Dependence of gate capacitance on temperature and gate voltage
The capacitance between the graphene and the backgate is determined by the static dielectric constants of the dielectric materials. The electrostatic dielectric constant of the membrane layer could vary with temperature and gating voltage. Therefore, it is important to investigate the effects of the aforementioned factors to understand the discrepancy of emissivity spectra in measurement and calculation. For the SiN substrates used in this work, measurements in our previous study have shown that the dielectric constant increases only slightly with temperature up to 250 C, and remains unchanged by the applied gate voltage[9]. These measurements justify the basic capacitance model used in estimating how carrier density changes with applied gate voltage, which assumes the dielectric constants of the SiN/AlO to be independent of temperature and gate voltage.
Uncertainty of dielectric constant
Commercially available products have a variance of dielectric constant owing to the fluctuation of growth conditions. In calculating induced carrier density at the surface of graphene by gating, the dielectric constant of the SiN membrane layer was assumed to be 7.5, as derived in our previous work[1]. However, the dielectric constant of the purchased product has a variance of 1, corresponding to ∼15% of dielectric constant. Considering this variance, the magnitude of the induced carrier density could be reduced to 20% of our expectation.
Impurity and charge trap effect
One of the important issues in the graphene-based active metasurface is charge traps and atmospheric impurities on or in the SiN/AlO which are known to change their charge state depending on the applied gate voltage. The effects of such impurities lead to deviations from the simple capacitor model. Our evidence for such impurity states is the hysteresis observed in resistance vs. gate voltage measurements, consistent with previous studies that systematically investigated such charge traps and impurities.
Effect of initial doping of angle steering

Figure S19. Calculated angle steering range as a function of the initial doping level of graphene
The Fermi level-angular (Figure 2(d)) and frequency-angular (Figure S21) emissivity spectra indicate variations in both the steering angle range and modulation depth depending on the initial doping level of graphene. The correlation between the Fermi level and carrier density follows the relationship

Figure S21. Comparing calculated and measured emissivity map of the device. The calculated angle-frequency total emissivity spectra of the fabricated device for (a) and (b) , respectively. Panels (c) and (d) show the measured angle-frequency emissivity spectra of the device for and , corresponding to each Fermi level.
suggesting that higher Fermi levels undergo less change with the same increase in carrier density (proportional to ). Consequently, a higher initial doping level results in less alteration of the Fermi level for a given applied gate voltage. Figure S19 shows that the steering angle range for at is higher than in the case of an initial doping of .
Potential angle steering capability
In this study, We primarily focus on demonstrating dynamic control of directional emission angles, and the change of emission angles of the fabricated device was limited to 16°. However, the proposed design scheme has the potential for a much larger emission angle change through the optimization of structural parameters and slight modifications to the configuration, as shown in Figure S20. The results of the structural parameter effect analysis indicate that the strength of interaction between graphene and the metal slit array strongly influences the emission angle . To maximize electromagnetic field intensity at the surface of graphene, we propose ideal structure where layer, located on top of graphene, is reduced to 1 nm. This configuration ensures the smallest distance between graphene and the metal slit array without the quantum tunneling effect. The gap and slit widths are optimized for the largest emission angle change.

Figure S20. Theoretical performance limit of the proposed configuration. (a) The schematic of geometry modification for optimization. (b) The total absorption of optimized structure ideal structure for different gap sizes and models with eV. (c) The total absorption of optimized for various Fermi levels of graphene. The angular absorption spectrum for (d) 0 eV/0.6 eV at 1614 cm and (e) 0 eV/0.3 eV at 1536 cm.
Considering the significant degradation of performance due to the nonlocal effect for gaps less than 30 nm, the minimum gap width is limited to 30 nm. For Fermi level modulation at the 0 eV and 0.6 eV, we obtain an emission angle change of approximately for gap and slit widths of 30 nm and 740 nm, respectively. Here, we focus on maximizing angle change. However, if the goal is to achieve emission steering with narrow beam, we can obtain a narrower beam by setting a high Fermi level at 0.3 eV, as shown in Figure S20. In this case, the maximum emission angle change is due to reduced Fermi level modulation. Additionally, by employing other materials with smaller material loss than graphene, we anticipate the possibility of even narrower beam steering.
Modulation of angle-frequency spectra
To gain a deeper understanding of the device’s operation, it is essential to analyze the emissivity behavior for the angle-frequency spectrum with fixed Fermi levels. Figures 21(a) and 21(b) depict the angle- and frequency-dependent emissivity spectra for and corresponding to and , respectively. The resonance frequency gradually shifts to a higher frequency with an increase in the incident angle, consistent with the previous result. The incident angle-dependent propagation phase accumulation is compensated by frequency-dependent phase change. It is noteworthy that the change in the Fermi level of graphene induces a simple translation of the resonance frequency curve. This constant frequency translation of the curve is inferred through nonresonant phase modulation of the graphene metasurface. The width of the resonance peak is broader for a higher Fermi level due to increased optical loss (see Supplementary Note 5). The experimentally measured angle- and frequency-dependent emissivity is well matched with the calculation results, as shown in Figure S21 and (Figure S21).
References
- [1]Min Seok Jang, Victor W. Brar, Michelle C. Sherrott, Josue J. Lopez, Laura Kim, Seyoon Kim, Mansoo Choi, and Harry A. Atwater. Tunable large resonant absorption in a midinfrared graphene salisbury screen. Phys. Rev. B, 90(5):165409, 2014.
- [2]Seyoon Kim, Min Seok Jang, Victor W. Brar, Kelly W. Mauser, Laura Kim, and Harry A. Atwater. Electronically tunable perfect absorption in graphene. Nano Lett., 18(2):971–979, 2018.DOI
- [3]Younes Ra’di, Constantin R. Simovski, and Sergei A. Tretyakov. Thin perfect absorbers for electromagnetic waves: Theory, design, and realizations. Phys. Rev. Appl., 3:037001, Mar 2015.
- [4]Farhan Rana. Graphene terahertz plasmon oscillators. IEEE Transactions on Nanotechnology, 7: 91, 2008.DOI
- [5]Haoliang Qian, Yuzhe Xiao, Dominic Lepage, Li Chen, and Zhaowei Liu. Quantum electrostatic model for optical properties of nanoscale gold films. Nanophotonics, 4:413, 2015.
- [6]Kevin J. Savage, Matthew M. Hawkeye, Rubé’n Esteban, Andrei G. Borisov, Javier Aizpurua, and Jeremy J. Baumberg. Revealing the quantum regime in tunnelling plasmonics. Nature, 491:574, 2012.
- [7]Wen Chen, Shunping Zhang, Meng Kang, Weikang Liu, Zhenwei Ou, Yang Li, Yexin Zhang, Zhiqiang Guan, and Hongxing Xu. Probing the ultimate limits of plasmonic enhancement. Science, 337:1072, 2012.
- [8]A. D. Boardman. Electromagnetic Surface Modes. Wiley Chichester, 1982.
- [9]Victor W. Brar, Michelle C. Sherrott, Min Seok Jang, Seyoon Kim, Laura Kim, Mansoo Choi, Luke A. Sweatlock, and Harry A. Atwater. Electronic modulation of infrared radiation in graphene plasmonic resonators. Nat. Commun., 6(1):7032, 2015. ISSN 2041-1723.