betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Gravitational form factors in the perturbative limit

Abstract

Generalized distribution amplitudes (GDAs) have attracted significant attention in recent years due to their connection with the energy-momentum tensor (EMT) form factors (FFs). The GDAs can be experimentally accessed through the study of amplitudes in γ∗γ→M1M2γ^{\ast} γ\to M_1 M_2 and γ∗→M1M2γγ^{\ast} \to M_1 M_2 γ, where M1M2M_1M_2 is a pseudoscalar meson pair such as πηπη and ηη′ηη^{\prime}. In this work, we calculate these amplitudes in the perturbative limit and express the extracted M1M2M_1M_2 GDAs in terms of meson distribution amplitudes that have been constrained by the previous experiments. Our explicit calculation verifies the existence of a new EMT FF that violates the conservation law of EMT when the hadronic matrix element of the EMT operator is considered separately for each quark flavor. In addition, our result shows that the M1M2M_1M_2 GDAs are identical in γ∗γ→M1M2γ^{\ast} γ\to M_1 M_2 and γ∗→M1M2γγ^{\ast} \to M_1 M_2 γ, which confirms the universality of GDAs in the perturbative limit. In the future, the GDAs and the EMT FFs studied in this paper can be probed at Belle II. Our study enhances the accessibility to the PP-wave GDAs in γ∗γ→M1M2γ^{\ast} γ\to M_1 M_2 and γ∗→M1M2γγ^{\ast} \to M_1 M_2 γ, and provides a promising approach for searching for exotic hybrid mesons in future experiments.

Introduction

Hadronic matrix elements of the energy-momentum tensor (EMT) are commonly parameterized in terms of EMT form factors (FFs), which are also known as gravitational FFs. The EMT FFs have attracted considerable interest because they provide insight into the proton spin puzzle [1] and mechanical properties of hadrons [2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15]. They also describe the interaction of hadrons with classical gravity and the manifestation of the equivalence principle which can be considered for quarks and gluons separately [16, 17].

Generalized parton distributions (GPDs) and generalized distribution amplitudes (GDAs) serve as indirect probes of the EMT FFs in the spacelike and timelike regions, respectively [18, 19, 20, 21, 22]. The GDAs have been extensively studied in hadron pair production processes such as γ∗γ→hhˉ\gamma^*\gamma\to h\bar{h} [23, 24, 25] and γ∗→hhˉγ\gamma^* \to h\bar{h}\gamma [26, 27, 28, 29], where a perturbative treatment is valid at large photon virtuality Q2Q^2 and small invariant mass squared ss of the meson pair. These analyses can be extended to the M1M2M_1M_2 GDAs accessed in the production of two different pseudoscalar mesons such as πη\pi\eta and ηη′\eta\eta'. In contrast to the ππ\pi\pi case, there could be the PP-wave component in the M1M2M_1M_2 GDAs, which interestingly leads to the existence of a new EMT FF which may be called the shear viscosity term Θ3\Theta_3 [30]. The Θ3\Theta_3 term has not been commonly considered because it breaks the conservation law of hadronic matrix elements of EMT. However, in principle, it could exist for a single quark flavor or gluon as long as it vanishes when we take the sum for all the flavors and gluon. At current stage, there is no clear evidence for the existence of the Θ3\Theta_3 term. The smallness of its value may indicate a connection [30] between the approximate validity of the equivalence principle for quarks and gluon individually and the low viscosity observed in the holographic framework [31], with the latter further supported by a recent calculation involving black hole gravity [32].

The PP-wave GDAs are related to the study of exotic hybrid mesons. If a resonance is observed from the PP-wave M1M2M_1M_2 in γ∗γ→M1M2\gamma^*\gamma\to M_1M_2 [33] and γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^* \to M_1M_2\gamma [28], its quantum number JPC=1−+J^{PC}=1^{-+} cannot be described by the quark model. Recently, several candidates with JPC=1−+J^{PC}=1^{-+} have been reported by experiment such as η1(1855)\eta_1(1855) [34, 35], π1(1400)\pi_1(1400) [36, 37], π1(1600)\pi_1(1600) [38, 39, 40, 41] and π1(2015)\pi_1(2015) [42]. However, further investigation is still needed for the confirmation of the π1\pi_1 states [43, 44]. In future, one can investigate these exotic states in the production of M1M2M_1M_2, which is possible at Belle II and BESIII. Furthermore, the measurements of these reactions can be used to study the hadronic light-by-light contribution to the muon’s anomalous magnetic moment [45, 46, 47, 48].

Although the ππ\pi\pi GDA [49] has been extracted from γ∗γ→π0π0\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\pi^{0}\pi^{0} [50], there are no experimental measurements for the M1M2M_{1}M_{2} GDAs. In light of the current situation, we would like to focus on an interesting way to indirectly evaluate GDAs using meson distribution amplitudes (DAs). It is known that the ππ\pi\pi GDA can be expressed in terms of pion DAs in the amplitude for γ∗γ→π+π−\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\pi^{+}\pi^{-} in the kinematic region Q2≫s≫ΛQCD2Q^{2} \gg s \gg\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^{2}, which is referred to as the perturbative limit [51]. In this work, we apply the same technique to the helicity amplitudes for γ∗γ→M1M2\gamma^{*}\gamma\to M_{1}M_{2} and γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*} \to M_{1}M_{2}\gamma in order to establish a relation between M1M2M_{1}M_{2} GDAs and meson DAs in the perturbative limit. The obtained relation will be used to confirm the presence of a nonzero Θ3\Theta_{3} term and, in addition, to verify the universality of the GDAs in γ∗γ→M1M2\gamma^{*}\gamma\to M_{1}M_{2} and γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*} \to M_{1}M_{2}\gamma.

The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: In § 2, we provide a brief introduction to the πη\pi\eta GDAs and define the kinematical variables in γ∗γ→πη\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\pi\eta. In Section III, we present a detailed calculation of the helicity amplitude for γ∗γ→πη\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\pi\eta. The relation between GDAs and DAs is obtained in the perturbative limit. In Section IV, we extend this analysis to γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*} \to M_{1}M_{2}\gamma. The universality of the GDAs is discussed. In § 5, we evaluate the EMT FFs in terms of the meson DAs. § 6 concludes the paper with a summary.

πη\pi\eta GDAs OF γ∗γ→πη\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\pi\eta

We define the following kinematic variables for the process of γ∗(q)γ(q1)→π0(p)η(p1)\gamma^{*}(q)\gamma(q_{1}) \to\pi^{0}(p)\eta(p_{1}),

P=p+p1,Δ=p1−p,ξ=p⋅q1P⋅q1,q2=−Q2,(q1)2=0,s=P2,t=(q−p)2,u=(q−p1)2.(1)P = p + p_{1},\quad\Delta= p_{1} - p,\quad\xi= \frac{p \cdot q_{1}}{P \cdot q_{1}},\quad q^{2} = -Q^{2},\quad(q_{1})^{2} = 0,\quad s = P^{2},\quad t = (q-p)^{2},\quad u = (q-p_{1})^{2}. \tag*{(1)}

We work in a frame where the virtual photon has only nonzero zz-component, q=(0,0,0,Q)q = (0,0,0,Q). For convenience, we introduce two lightcone vectors nμ=(1,0,0,−1)/2n^{\mu} = (1,0,0,-1)/\sqrt{2} and nˉ=(1,0,0,1)/2\bar{n} = (1,0,0,1)/\sqrt{2}, and they are expressed in terms of qq and q1q_{1},

n=2QQ2+sq1,nˉ=2Qq+2QQ2+sq1.(2)n = \frac{\sqrt{2}Q}{Q^{2}+s}q_{1},\qquad\bar{n} = \frac{\sqrt{2}}{Q}q + \frac{\sqrt{2}Q}{Q^{2}+s}q_{1}. \tag*{(2)}

The light-cone components of a Lorentz vector aμa^{\mu} are defined as a+=a⋅na^{+} = a \cdot n and a−=a⋅nˉa^{-} = a \cdot\bar{n}.

If the QCD factorization (Q2≫s,ΛQCD2Q^{2} \gg s,\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^{2}) holds, the amplitude for γ∗γ→πη\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\pi\eta can be factorized into two parts, the subprocess γ∗γ→qqˉ\gamma^{*}\gamma\to q\bar{q} as the hard scattering part and the πη\pi\eta GDA Φπηq(z,ζ,s)\Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\zeta,s) as the nonperturbative soft part. The factorized formula is illustrated in Figure 1. The πη\pi\eta GDA is defined by [33, 52, 53, 54],

The leading-twist $\pi\eta$ GDA is accessed in $\gamma^{*}\gamma \to \pi\eta$

Figure 1. The leading-twist πη\pi\eta GDA is accessed in γ∗γ→πη\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\pi\eta.

Φπηq(z,ζ,s)=∫dx−2πe−izP+x−⟨η(p1)π(p)∣qˉ(x−)γ+q(0)∣0⟩,(3)\Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\zeta,s) = \int\frac{dx^{-}}{2\pi}e^{-izP^{+}x^{-}}\langle\eta(p_{1})\pi(p)|\bar{q}(x^{-})\gamma^{+}q(0)|0\rangle, \tag*{(3)}

where the Wilson line reduces to unity in the lightcone gauge A+=0A^{+}=0 and zz indicates the momentum fraction carried by the quark hadronizing into πη\pi\eta pair. The dependence on the factorization scale μF2\mu_{F}^{2}, which is conventionally set as μF2=Q2\mu_{F}^{2}=Q^{2}, is omitted in Eq. (3) for simplicity. The charge conjugation leads to

Φπηq(z,ζ,s)=−Φπηq(zˉ,ζ,s),(4)\Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\zeta,s) = -\Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(\bar{z},\zeta,s), \tag*{(4)}

with zˉ≡1−z\bar{z} \equiv1-z. Unlike the π0π0\pi^0\pi^0 GDA, the πη\pi\eta GDA does not satisfy Φπηq(z,ξ,s)=Φπηq(z,ξˉ,s)\Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s) = \Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\bar{\xi},s) followed by the interchange of identical particles. In the asymptotic limit Q2→∞Q^2 \to\infty, the πη\pi\eta GDA takes the form

Φπηq(z,ξ,s)=10zzˉC1(3/2)(2z−1)∑l=02B1l(s)Pl(cos⁡θ),(5)\Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s) = 10z\bar{z}C_{1}^{(3/2)}(2z-1)\sum_{l=0}^{2}B_{1l}(s)P_l(\cos\theta), \tag*{(5)}

where ll represents the orbital angular momentum of the meson pair, and θ\theta is the polar angle of the meson pair in the γ∗γ\gamma^*\gamma center of mass frame which can be expressed in terms of the parameter ξ\xi,

βcos⁡θ=2ξ−1−mπ2−mη2s,β=λ1/2(s,mπ2,mη2)s,(6)\beta\cos\theta= 2\xi- 1 - \frac{m_{\pi}^{2}-m_{\eta}^{2}}{s}, \qquad\beta= \frac{\lambda^{1/2}(s,m_{\pi}^{2},m_{\eta}^{2})}{s}, \tag*{(6)}

where λ(s,mπ2,mη2)\lambda(s,m_{\pi}^{2},m_{\eta}^{2}) is the Kallen function.

At the lowest order with respect to αs\alpha_s, the leading-twist amplitude for γ∗γ→πη\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi\eta survives only in the case that the incoming photons have the same helicity, and it is expressed as [33],

Mλλ1=e22δλλ1∑qeq2∫01dz2z−1zzˉΦπηq(z,ξ,s),(7)M_{\lambda\lambda_1} = \frac{e^2}{2}\delta_{\lambda\lambda_1}\sum_q e_q^2\int_0^1 dz \frac{2z-1}{z\bar{z}}\Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s), \tag*{(7)}

where the helicities of the virtual and real photons are denoted as λ\lambda and λ1\lambda_1, respectively.

πη\pi\eta GDAs in perturbative limit

In the perturbative limit Q2≫s≫ΛQCD2Q^2 \gg s \gg\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^2, the amplitude for γ∗γ→π+π−\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi^+\pi^- can be expressed in terms of the hard scattering amplitude and soft pion DAs [51, 55]. This approach can be extended to the process γ∗γ→πη\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi\eta, and the helicity amplitude is given by

Mλλ1=∑q∫01dxdy[Tλλ11q(x,y,s,t,Q2)ϕηq(y)+Tλλ12q(x,y,s,t,Q2)ϕπq(x)]ϕπq(x),(8)M_{\lambda\lambda_1} = \sum_q \int_0^1 dxdy \left[T_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{1q}(x,y,s,t,Q^2)\phi_{\eta}^{q}(y) + T_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{2q}(x,y,s,t,Q^2)\phi_{\pi}^{q}(x)\right]\phi_{\pi}^{q}(x), \tag*{(8)}

where Tλλ11qT_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{1q} is the parton level amplitude for γ∗γ→qqˉ+qqˉ\gamma^*\gamma\to q\bar{q}+q\bar{q}, and the sum runs over the quark flavors uu and dd due to isospin conservation. The function ϕMq(z)\phi_M^q(z) denotes the DA for a neutral pseudoscalar meson MM, such as π0\pi^0 and η(′)\eta^{(\prime)}, and is defined as

ϕMq(z)=i∫dx−2πe−izp+x−⟨M(p)∣qˉ(x−)γ+γ5q(0)∣0⟩,(9)\phi_M^q(z) = i\int\frac{dx^-}{2\pi}e^{-izp^+x^-}\langle M(p)|\bar{q}(x^-)\gamma^+\gamma_5q(0)|0\rangle, \tag*{(9)}

where zz is the momentum fraction carried by the quark hadronizing into MM. ϕMq(z)\phi^{q}_{M}(z) can be written in terms of its eigenfunctions, Gegenbauer polynomials,

ϕMu,d(z)=6fMu,dzzˉ∑i=0∞a2iu,dC2i3/2(2z−1),\phi^{u,d}_{M}(z)=6f^{u,d}_{M}z\bar z\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}a^{u,d}_{2i}C^{3/2}_{2i}(2z-1),
ϕη(′)s(z)=6fη(′)szzˉ∑i=0∞a~2iη(′)C2i3/2(2z−1).(10)\phi^{s}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)=6f^{s}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}z\bar z\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}\tilde a^{\eta^{(\prime)}}_{2i}C^{3/2}_{2i}(2z-1). \tag*{(10)}

where a0M=a~0η(′)=1a^{M}_{0}=\tilde a^{\eta^{(\prime)}}_{0}=1, and fMqf^{q}_{M} is the MM-meson decay constant for the quark flavor qq. The isospin symmetry implies fπ=2fπu=−2fπdf_{\pi}=\sqrt{2}f^{u}_{\pi}=-\sqrt{2}f^{d}_{\pi} for π0\pi^{0}. The ss-quark DA exists for η(′)\eta^{(\prime)} meson. The Gegenbauer coefficients are different between u/du/d and ss, and are denoted by a2iu,da^{u,d}_{2i} and a~2iη(′)\tilde a^{\eta^{(\prime)}}_{2i}, respectively.

In addition, we introduce an alternative definition of the η(′)\eta^{(\prime)} DAs,

ϕη(′)1,8(z)=i∫dx−2πe−izp+x−⟨η(′)(p)∣J5+1,8(x−;0)∣0⟩,(11)\phi^{1,8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)=i\int\frac{dx^{-}}{2\pi}e^{-izp^{+}x^{-}}\langle\eta^{(\prime)}(p)|J^{1,8}_{5+}(x^{-};0)|0\rangle, \tag*{(11)}

where the SU(3)SU(3) flavor-singlet current J51μJ^{1\mu}_{5} and the flavor-octet current J58μJ^{8\mu}_{5} are given by

J51μ(x−;0)=13[uˉ(x−)γμγ5u(0)+dˉ(x−)γμγ5d(0)+sˉ(x−)γμγ5s(0)],J^{1\mu}_{5}(x^{-};0)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\left[\bar u(x^{-})\gamma^{\mu}\gamma_{5}u(0)+\bar d(x^{-})\gamma^{\mu}\gamma_{5}d(0)+\bar s(x^{-})\gamma^{\mu}\gamma_{5}s(0)\right],
J58μ(x−;0)=16[uˉ(x−)γμγ5u(0)+dˉ(x−)γμγ5d(0)−2sˉ(x−)γμγ5s(0)].(12)J^{8\mu}_{5}(x^{-};0)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{6}}\left[\bar u(x^{-})\gamma^{\mu}\gamma_{5}u(0)+\bar d(x^{-})\gamma^{\mu}\gamma_{5}d(0)-2\bar s(x^{-})\gamma^{\mu}\gamma_{5}s(0)\right]. \tag*{(12)}

Similarly to Eq. (10), these DAs can be expanded in terms of Gegenbauer polynomials,

ϕη(′)1(z)=6fη(′)1zzˉ∑i=0∞aˉ2iC2i3/2(2z−1),\phi^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)=6f^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}z\bar z\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}\bar a_{2i}C^{3/2}_{2i}(2z-1),
ϕη(′)8(z)=6fη(′)8zzˉ∑i=0∞a^2iC2i3/2(2z−1).(13)\phi^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)=6f^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}z\bar z\sum_{i=0}^{\infty}\hat a_{2i}C^{3/2}_{2i}(2z-1). \tag*{(13)}

Following the convention in [56, 57], we assume that the Gegenbauer coefficients aˉ2i\bar a_{2i} and a^2i\hat a_{2i} are the same for the η\eta and η′\eta^{\prime} mesons, respectively. The decay constants fη(′)1f^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}} and fη(′)8f^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}} and the Gegenbauer coefficients aˉ2i\bar a_{2i} and a^2i\hat a_{2i} are different from those defined for each quark flavor in (10). fη1f^{1}_{\eta} and fη′8f^{8}_{\eta^{\prime}} describe the deviation of the η\eta and η′\eta^{\prime} mesons from their naive quark content, respectively, and they are responsible for the mixing of η\eta and η′\eta^{\prime} mesons (see e.g. [58]).

From Eqs. (9), (11) and (12), one can show the following relations,

ϕη(′)u(z)=ϕη(′)d(z)=16[2ϕη(′)1(z)+ϕη(′)8(z)],\phi^{u}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)=\phi^{d}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{6}}\left[\sqrt{2}\phi^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)+\phi^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)\right],
ϕη(′)s(z)=13[ϕη(′)1(z)−2ϕη(′)8(z)].(14)\phi^{s}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)=\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\left[\phi^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)-\sqrt{2}\phi^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}(z)\right]. \tag*{(14)}

Taking the first moments of these equations with respect to zz, we obtain the relations among the decay constants [59, 60, 61, 62, 63],

fη(′)u=fη(′)d=16[2fη(′)1+fη(′)8],f^{u}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}=f^{d}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{6}}\left[\sqrt{2}f^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}+f^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}\right],
fη(′)s=13[fη(′)1−2fη(′)8].(15)f^{s}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\left[f^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}-\sqrt{2}f^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}\right]. \tag*{(15)}

As a result, the relations among the Gegenbauer coefficients are given by

a2iη(′)=2fη(′)1aˉ2i+fη(′)8a^2i2fη(′)1+fη(′)8,a^{\eta^{(\prime)}}_{2i}=\frac{\sqrt{2}f^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}\bar a_{2i}+f^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}\hat a_{2i}}{\sqrt{2}f^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}+f^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}},
a~2iη(′)=fη(′)1aˉ2i−2fη(′)8a^2ifη(′)1−2fη(′)8.(16)\tilde a^{\eta^{(\prime)}}_{2i}=\frac{f^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}\bar a_{2i}-\sqrt{2}f^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}\hat a_{2i}}{f^{1}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}-\sqrt{2}f^{8}_{\eta^{(\prime)}}}. \tag*{(16)}

We will evaluate the shear viscosity term Θ3\Theta_3 in terms of anη(′)a_n^{\eta^{(\prime)}} and a~nη(′)\tilde{a}_n^{\eta^{(\prime)}} because we are interested in the existence of a nonzero Θ3\Theta_3 for each quark flavor and its cancellation among all the relevant quark flavors. However, the expression in terms of aˉn\bar{a}_n and a^n\hat{a}_n is also important when we take into account the scale evolution with respect to μF\mu_F as we will discuss below, and Eq. (16) enables us to switch these two expressions.

In Eq. (8), Tλλ∗T_{\lambda\lambda}^{*} denotes the amplitude of γ∗γ→qqˉ+gg\gamma^{*}\gamma\to q\bar{q}+gg. The hadronization of the gluon pair into η(′)\eta^{(\prime)} is described by the gluon DA, which is defined as [56, 61, 62, 63, 64]

p1+∫dx−2πe−izp1+x−⟨η(′)(p1)∣Aaα(x−)Abβ(0)∣0⟩=−133ϵTαβδab8Ψη(′)g(z)zzˉ,(17)p_1^+\int\frac{dx^-}{2\pi}e^{-izp_1^+x^-}\langle\eta^{(\prime)}(p_1)|A_a^\alpha(x^-)A_b^\beta(0)|0\rangle=-\frac{1}{3\sqrt{3}}\epsilon_T^{\alpha\beta}\frac{\delta_{ab}}{8}\frac{\Psi_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^g(z)}{z\bar{z}}, \tag*{(17)}

where the symbol [μν][\mu\nu] denotes antisymmetrization of a tensor, t[μν]=12(tμν−tνμ)t^{[\mu\nu]}=\frac{1}{2}(t^{\mu\nu}-t^{\nu\mu}), and ϵTαβ\epsilon_T^{\alpha\beta} is given by

ϵTαβ=ϵαβμνp1μq1νp1⋅q1.(18)\epsilon_T^{\alpha\beta}=\frac{\epsilon^{\alpha\beta\mu\nu}p_{1\mu}q_{1\nu}}{p_1\cdot q_1}. \tag*{(18)}

The gluon DA is also expressed in terms of Gegenbauer polynomials,

Ψη(′)g(z)=fη(′)1z2(1−z)2∑i=1∞b2iC2i−15/2(2z−1),(19)\Psi_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^g(z)=f_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^1 z^2(1-z)^2\sum_{i=1}^{\infty}b_{2i}C_{2i-1}^{5/2}(2z-1), \tag*{(19)}

where we assume that the Gegenbauer coefficients are the same for η\eta and η′\eta' [56, 57]. The gluon DA of η(′)\eta^{(\prime)} vanishes in the asymptotic limit Q2→∞Q^2\to\infty. For convenience, we adopt the convention ϕη(′)g(z)≡Ψη(′)g(z)/(zzˉ)\phi_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^g(z)\equiv\Psi_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^g(z)/(z\bar{z}). Charge conjugation leads to Ψη(′)g(z)=−Ψη(′)g(zˉ)\Psi_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^g(z)=-\Psi_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^g(\bar{z}) and

∫01dz Ψη(′)g(z)=∫01dz ϕη(′)g(z)=0.(20)\int_0^1 dz\,\Psi_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^g(z)=\int_0^1 dz\,\phi_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^g(z)=0. \tag*{(20)}

The meson DAs depend on the factorization scale μF\mu_F, whose evolution is governed by the ERBL equation [65, 66]. The evolution equations for the Gegenbauer coefficients a2iπa_{2i}^{\pi} and a^2i\hat{a}_{2i} are given by the same form,

Fn(μF)=Fn(μ0)Lγnqq/β0,Fn={anπ,a^n},(21)F_n(\mu_F)=F_n(\mu_0)L^{\gamma_n^{qq}/\beta_0},\qquad F_n=\{a_n^\pi,\hat{a}_n\}, \tag*{(21)}

where L=αs(μ0)/αs(μF)L=\alpha_s(\mu_0)/\alpha_s(\mu_F), β0=11−2Nf/3\beta_0=11-2N_f/3, and γnqq\gamma_n^{qq} is the anomalous dimension,

γnqq=CF[3+2(n+1)(n+2)−4∑i=1n+11k].(22)\gamma_n^{qq}=C_F\left[3+\frac{2}{(n+1)(n+2)}-4\sum_{i=1}^{n+1}\frac{1}{k}\right]. \tag*{(22)}

The Gegenbauer coefficients aˉn\bar{a}_n and bnb_n mix under the evolution [56, 67],

aˉn(μF)=an+(μ0)Lγn+/β0+ρn−an−(μ0)Lγn−/β0,\bar{a}_n(\mu_F)=a_n^+(\mu_0)L^{\gamma_n^+/\beta_0}+\rho_n^-a_n^-(\mu_0)L^{\gamma_n^-/\beta_0},
bn(μF)=ρn+an+(μ0)Lγn+/β0+an−(μ0)Lγn−/β0,(23)b_n(\mu_F)=\rho_n^+a_n^+(\mu_0)L^{\gamma_n^+/\beta_0}+a_n^-(\mu_0)L^{\gamma_n^-/\beta_0}, \tag*{(23)}

where

γn±=12[γnqq+γngg±(γnqq−γngg)2+4γnqgγngq],\gamma_n^\pm=\frac{1}{2}\left[\gamma_n^{qq}+\gamma_n^{gg}\pm\sqrt{(\gamma_n^{qq}-\gamma_n^{gg})^2+4\gamma_n^{qg}\gamma_n^{gq}}\right],
ρn+=6γnqgγn+−γngg,ρn−=16γngqγn−−γnqq.(24)\rho_n^+=6\frac{\gamma_n^{qg}}{\gamma_n^+-\gamma_n^{gg}},\qquad\rho_n^-=\frac{1}{6}\frac{\gamma_n^{gq}}{\gamma_n^--\gamma_n^{qq}}. \tag*{(24)}

The anomalous dimensions are given by

γnqq=CFn(n+3)3(n+1)(n+2),\gamma_n^{qq}=C_F\frac{n(n+3)}{3(n+1)(n+2)},
γnqg=Nf12(n+1)(n+2),\gamma_n^{qg}=N_f\frac{12}{(n+1)(n+2)},
γngg=β0+Nc[8(n+1)(n+2)−4∑k=1n+11k].(25)\gamma_n^{gg}=\beta_0+N_c\left[\frac{8}{(n+1)(n+2)}-4\sum_{k=1}^{n+1}\frac{1}{k}\right]. \tag*{(25)}

The initial conditions of an±(μ0)a_n^\pm(\mu_0) are simply written in terms of aˉn(μ0)\bar a_n(\mu_0) and bn(μ0)b_n(\mu_0) by setting μF=μ0\mu_F=\mu_0 in Eq. (23). Note that we do not take into account the scale dependence of the singlet decay constant fη(′)1f_{\eta^{(\prime)}}^1, because it is the order of αs2\alpha_s^2 and ignored in this study.

To express the twist-2 πη\pi\eta GDAs in terms of meson DAs, we need to calculate the helicity amplitudes of Eq. (8), where the helicities of the incoming photons are identical due to Eq. (7). There are four types of Feynman diagrams contributing to Tλλ11qT_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{1q} as shown in Figure 2, and the additional diagrams can be found by particle interchange from these four diagrams [51]. We choose the light-cone gauge A+=0A^+=0 for the calculation in which the gluon propagator takes the form

Feynman diagrams for $T_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{\pi\eta}$ in $\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi^0\eta$

Figure 2. Feynman diagrams for Tλλ1π0ηT_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{\pi^0\eta} in γ∗γ→π0η\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi^0\eta.

iδabl2+iϵ(−gμν+lμq1ν+q1μlνl⋅q1),(26)\frac{i\delta_{ab}}{l^2+i\epsilon}\left(-g^{\mu\nu}+\frac{l^\mu q_1^\nu+q_1^\mu l^\nu}{l\cdot q_1}\right), \tag*{(26)}

where ll is the momentum of the gluon. If we expand the hard amplitudes in powers of s/Q2s/Q^2, the diagrams AA and CC, the diagram BB, and the diagram DD are order of 1/Q21/Q^2, 1/s1/s, and s/Q4s/Q^4, respectively. Thus we only keep the contribution from BB in the perturbative limit of Q2≫s≫ΛQCD2Q^2\gg s\gg\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^2 [51]. The first term in Eq. (8) is then evaluated as

e2δλλ1∑qeq2(−8παs9)∫01dx dyxˉys{u+(2y−1)tyˉ(u+yt)(2−x)u+ytxˉu+yt+t−(2x−1)ux(t+xˉu)(1+y)t+xˉuyt+xˉu}ϕπq(x)ϕηq(y),(27)e^2\delta_{\lambda\lambda_1}\sum_q e_q^2\left(-\frac{8\pi\alpha_s}{9}\right)\int_0^1\frac{dx\,dy}{\bar{x}ys}\left\{\frac{u+(2y-1)t}{\bar{y}(u+yt)}\frac{(2-x)u+yt}{\bar{x}u+yt}+\frac{t-(2x-1)u}{x(t+\bar{x}u)}\frac{(1+y)t+\bar{x}u}{yt+\bar{x}u}\right\}\phi_\pi^q(x)\phi_\eta^q(y), \tag*{(27)}

In Eq. (27), the first (second) part originates from the diagrams where the gluon propagator connects the quark-antiquark pair hadronizing into π\pi (η\eta) meson. Neglecting the terms of order O(s/Q2)\mathcal{O}(s/Q^2), we have t=−(1−ξ)Q2t=-(1-\xi)Q^2 and u=−ξQ2u=-\xi Q^2. Thus, Eq. (27) can be re-expressed as

e2δλλ1∑qeq2(−8παs9)∫01dz2z−1zzˉ∫01dxs[θ(z−ξ)ξˉz−ξz+xˉξz−xξϕπq(x)xˉϕηq(ξz)+θ(ξ−z)ξz−ξzˉ+xˉξˉzˉ−xˉξˉϕπq(x)xˉϕηq(ξˉzˉ)],(28)e^2\delta_{\lambda\lambda_1}\sum_q e_q^2\left(-\frac{8\pi\alpha_s}{9}\right)\int_0^1 dz\frac{2z-1}{z\bar{z}}\int_0^1\frac{dx}{s}\left[\theta(z-\xi)\frac{\bar{\xi}}{z-\xi}\frac{z+\bar{x}\xi}{z-x\xi}\frac{\phi_\pi^q(x)}{\bar{x}}\phi_\eta^q\left(\frac{\xi}{z}\right)+\theta(\xi-z)\frac{\xi}{z-\xi}\frac{\bar{z}+\bar{x}\bar{\xi}}{\bar{z}-\bar{x}\bar{\xi}}\frac{\phi_\pi^q(x)}{\bar{x}}\phi_\eta^q\left(\frac{\bar{\xi}}{\bar{z}}\right)\right], \tag*{(28)}

where θ(x)\theta(x) is the step function, and the symmetry ϕMq(x)=ϕMq(xˉ)\phi_M^q(x)=\phi_M^q(\bar{x}) is taken into account. Comparing Eq. (28) with Eq. (7), the contribution from the first term in Eq. (8) to the quark GDAs is extracted,

Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)∣quark DAs=−16παs9{θ(z−ξ)ξz−ξ∫01dxsz+xˉξˉz−xξˉϕπq(x)xˉϕηq(ξz)+θ(ξ−z)ξz−ξ∫01dxszˉ+xˉξˉzˉ−xξˉϕπq(x)xˉϕηq(ξzˉ)}.(29)\left.\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^q(z,\xi,s)\right|_{\mathrm{quark\ DAs}}=-\frac{16\pi\alpha_s}{9}\left\{\theta(z-\xi)\frac{\xi}{z-\xi}\int_0^1\frac{dx}{s}\frac{z+\bar{x}\bar{\xi}}{z-x\bar{\xi}}\frac{\phi_\pi^q(x)}{\bar{x}}\phi_\eta^q\left(\frac{\xi}{z}\right)+\theta(\xi-z)\frac{\xi}{z-\xi}\int_0^1\frac{dx}{s}\frac{\bar{z}+\bar{x}\bar{\xi}}{\bar{z}-x\bar{\xi}}\frac{\phi_\pi^q(x)}{\bar{x}}\phi_\eta^q\left(\frac{\xi}{\bar{z}}\right)\right\}. \tag*{(29)}

We next consider Tλλ12qT_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{2q} in Eq. (8) associated with the η\eta gluon DA. There are also four types of Feynman diagrams contributing to Tλλ12qT_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{2q} as shown in Figure 3. Only Feynman diagrams of EE and GG contribute to the amplitude at the order of 1/s1/s, however, the FF and HH diagrams are suppressed by s/Q2s/Q^2, and are therefore neglected in the perturbative limit. The second term of Eq. (8) is then evaluated as

Feynman diagrams for $T_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{2q}$ in $\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi\eta$

Figure 3. Feynman diagrams for Tλλ12qT_{\lambda\lambda_1}^{2q} in γ∗γ→πη\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi\eta

e2δλλ1∑qeq2(−2παs93)∫01dx dyxxˉyyˉs{(2y−1)t+(2x−1)uytˉ+xˉuyyˉt+[x−(2x−1)y]uyt+xu+yˉ2[t−(2x−1)u]t+xˉu+yˉ2[t+(2x−1)u]t+xu}ϕπq(x)ϕηq(y).(30)e^2\delta_{\lambda\lambda_1}\sum_q e_q^2\left(-\frac{2\pi\alpha_s}{9\sqrt{3}}\right)\int_0^1\frac{dx\,dy}{x\bar{x}y\bar{y}s}\left\{\frac{(2y-1)t+(2x-1)u}{y\bar{t}+\bar{x}u}\frac{y\bar{y}t+[x-(2x-1)y]u}{yt+xu}+\frac{\bar{y}^2[t-(2x-1)u]}{t+\bar{x}u}+\frac{\bar{y}^2[t+(2x-1)u]}{t+xu}\right\}\phi_\pi^q(x)\phi_\eta^q(y). \tag*{(30)}

The first part in Eq. (30) originates from the diagram EE. The second (third) part originates from the diagram GG in which the gluon pair couples to the antiquark (quark) hadronizing into π\pi, and they give identical contributions due to the symmetry ϕπq(x)=ϕπq(xˉ)\phi_\pi^q(x)=\phi_\pi^q(\bar{x}). We then extract the corresponding GDAs from the amplitude of Eq. (30),

Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)∣quark−gluon DAs=4παsξ93 s{∫S1dy yˉ2−(2y−1)z+ξyˉyˉ(z−y−ξˉy)(z−ξˉy)ϕηq(y)ϕπq(x)−∫01dyyˉy[θ(ξ−z)z−ξϕπq(ξz)−θ(ξ−zˉ)zˉ−ξϕπq(ξzˉ)]ϕηg(y)}.(31)\left.\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^q(z,\xi,s)\right|_{\mathrm{quark-gluon\ DAs}}=\frac{4\pi\alpha_s\xi}{9\sqrt{3}\,s}\left\{\int_{S_1}\frac{dy\,\bar{y}^2-(2y-1)z+\xi\bar{y}}{\bar{y}(z-y-\bar{\xi}y)(z-\bar{\xi}y)}\phi_\eta^q(y)\phi_\pi^q(x)-\int_0^1dy\frac{\bar{y}}{y}\left[\frac{\theta(\xi-z)}{z-\xi}\phi_\pi^q\left(\frac{\xi}{z}\right)-\frac{\theta(\xi-\bar{z})}{\bar{z}-\xi}\phi_\pi^q\left(\frac{\xi}{\bar{z}}\right)\right]\phi_\eta^g(y)\right\}. \tag*{(31)}

where the condition Eq. (20) is used to simplify the expression. The three parts in Eq. (31) correspond directly to those in Eq. (30). In Eq. (31), we need to regard xx as a function of yy and zz, x=(z−yξˉ)/ξx=(z-y\bar{\xi})/\xi, and S1S_1 represents the integration boundary of yy, defined by the condition ∣x+y−1∣+∣x−y∣≤1\lvert x+y-1\rvert+\lvert x-y\rvert\leq1.

The πη\pi\eta GDA is just the sum of Eqs. (29) and (31),

Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)=Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)∣quark DAs+Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)∣quark-gluon DAs.(32)\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s)=\left.\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s)\right|_{\text{quark DAs}}+\left.\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s)\right|_{\text{quark-gluon DAs}}. \tag*{(32)}

Note that Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s) is not exactly same as Φπηq(z,ξ,s)\Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s) because it contains the components that violate the charge conjugation symmetry given in Eq. (4). We can re-express Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s) as

Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)=12[Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)−Φ^πηq(zˉ,ξ,s)]+12[Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)+Φ^πηq(zˉ,ξ,s)].(33)\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s)=\frac{1}{2}\left[\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s)-\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(\bar{z},\xi,s)\right]+\frac{1}{2}\left[\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s)+\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(\bar{z},\xi,s)\right]. \tag*{(33)}

where only the first part satisfies the symmetry of Eq. (4), and the second part does not contribute to the amplitude of Eq. (7) due to the existence of the prefactor (z−zˉ)/(zzˉ)(z-\bar{z})/(z\bar{z}). Therefore, in the perturbative limit the πη\pi\eta GDA is given by

Φπηq(z,ξ,s)=12[Φ^πηq(z,ξ,s)−Φ^πηq(zˉ,ξ,s)].(34)\Phi_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s)=\frac{1}{2}\left[\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(z,\xi,s)-\widehat{\Phi}_{\pi\eta}^{q}(\bar{z},\xi,s)\right]. \tag*{(34)}

The formula (34) could give logarithmic singularities around z=ξz=\xi and z=1−ξz=1-\xi for a specific form of the DAs like the asymptotic form ϕηq(x)∼x(1−x)\phi_{\eta}^{q}(x)\sim x(1-x)[51], which means that the relation between GDAs and DAs is not well-defined in the whole region of zz. Fortunately, the singularities are integrable and canceled in the moment of the GDAs as we will see in section V. We regard this as a fact that the moment of the GDAs is insensitive to the soft contribution which spoils the factorized formula (34) in the perturbative limit. More careful treatment was discussed in [51] by introducing a cutoff to regularize the singularities. It was shown that the cutoff dependence turns to a power correction O(ΛQCD2/s)O(\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^2/s) after taking the moment and, therefore, the moment of the GDAs which is expressed in terms of DAs is trustworthy as long as the power correction is negligible.

Universality of GDAs

The πη\pi\eta GDAs can be probed by a spacelike photon in γ∗γ→πη\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi\eta. Currently, there are no experimental facilities capable of testing the πη\pi\eta GDAs of Eq. (34) in the perturbative limit. However, the πη\pi\eta GDAs can also be accessed in γ∗→πηγ\gamma^*\to\pi\eta\gamma, which can be investigated at Belle II in the perturbative limit. The virtual photon is timelike in this process and the helicity amplitudes are also given by Eq. (7) [26, 28]. Therefore, the universality of GDAs can be tested by comparing the results from γ∗→πηγ\gamma^* \to\pi\eta\gamma and γ∗γ→πη\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi\eta, analogous to the universality of hadron GPDs in timelike and spacelike hard exclusive processes [68].

We define the following variables to describe the amplitude for γ∗(q)→π0(p)η(p1)γ(q1)\gamma^*(q) \to\pi^0(p)\eta(p_1)\gamma(q_1),

q2=Q2,(q1)2=0,ξ=p⋅q1(p+p1)⋅q1,(p+p1)2=s,(q1+p1)=t^,(q1+p)=u^,(35)q^2 = Q^2,\qquad(q_1)^2 = 0,\qquad\xi= \frac{p \cdot q_1}{(p+p_1)\cdot q_1},\qquad(p+p_1)^2=s,\qquad(q_1+p_1)=\hat{t},\qquad(q_1+p)=\hat{u}, \tag*{(35)}

where t^\hat{t} and u^\hat{u} are the squared invariant masses for the final meson-photon pairs, and they are positive unlike the variables tt and uu in Eq. (1). The process γ∗→πηγ\gamma^* \to\pi\eta\gamma is related to γ∗γ→πη\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi\eta through the crossing symmetry. Our explicit calculation shows that the amplitudes for γ∗→πηγ\gamma^* \to\pi\eta\gamma can also be described by Eqs. (27) and (30) after the following replacements,

t→t^,u→u^.(36)t \to\hat{t},\qquad u \to\hat{u}. \tag*{(36)}

t^\hat{t} and u^\hat{u} are respectively given by t^=(1−ξ)Q2\hat{t}=(1-\xi)Q^2 and u^=ξQ2\hat{u}=\xi Q^2. The πη\pi\eta GDAs extracted from the helicity amplitudes of the timelike process γ∗→πηγ\gamma^* \to\pi\eta\gamma are consistent with Eqs. (29), (31) and (34) which are derived from the spacelike process γ∗γ→πη\gamma^*\gamma\to\pi\eta in the perturbative limit. Thus, our calculation verifies the universality of GDAs in this limit.

At Belle II, the kinematic variables can reach Q2∼100 GeV2Q^2 \sim100\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 and s∼10 GeV2s \sim10\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 in γ∗→πηγ\gamma^* \to\pi\eta\gamma, and the perturbative limit Q2≫s≫ΛQCD2Q^2 \gg s \gg\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^2 is sufficiently satisfied. Therefore, our formulas for πη\pi\eta GDAs can be tested experimentally in the near future.

Gravitational Form Factors

The EMT for a single quark flavor TqμνT_q^{\mu\nu} is defined as

Tqμν(0)=i2q‾(0)γ{μD↔ν}q(0),(37)T_q^{\mu\nu}(0)=\frac{i}{2}\overline{q}(0)\gamma^{\{\mu}\overleftrightarrow{D}^{\nu\}}q(0), \tag*{(37)}

where t{μν}=12(tμν+tνμ)t^{\{\mu\nu\}}=\frac{1}{2}(t^{\mu\nu}+t^{\nu\mu}). The first moment of the πη\pi\eta GDA corresponds to the timelike matrix element of EMT operator [22, 23, 24],

∫01dz zΦπηq(z,ξ,s)=2(P+)2⟨η(p1)π(p)∣Tq++(0)∣0⟩,(38)\int_0^1 dz\,z\Phi_{\pi\eta}^q(z,\xi,s)=\frac{2}{(P^+)^2}\langle\eta(p_1)\pi(p)|T_q^{++}(0)|0\rangle, \tag*{(38)}

which is expressed in terms of the transition EMT FFs [30, 69],

⟨η(p1)π(p)∣Tqμν(0)∣0⟩=12[Θ1q(s)(sgμν−PμPν)+Θ2q(s)ΔμΔν+Θ3q(s)P{μΔν}].(39)\langle\eta(p_1)\pi(p)|T_q^{\mu\nu}(0)|0\rangle=\frac{1}{2}\left[\Theta_1^q(s)(sg^{\mu\nu}-P^\mu P^\nu)+\Theta_2^q(s)\Delta^\mu\Delta^\nu+\Theta_3^q(s)P^{\{\mu}\Delta^{\nu\}}\right]. \tag*{(39)}

The Θ3q\Theta_3^q term does not appear in the ππ\pi\pi case and the positive Θ1q(s=0)\Theta_1^q(s=0) corresponds to the stability condition of pion [70, 71]. It is also notable that Θ1q(s=0)=Θ2q(s=0)\Theta_1^q(s=0)=\Theta_2^q(s=0) has been obtained for ππ\pi\pi by the model calculations [22, 72, 73]. The new term Θ3q(s)\Theta_3^q(s) is associated with the P-wave component of GDA, which violates the conservation law ⟨η(p1)π(p)∣Tqμν(0)∣0⟩Pμ=0\langle\eta(p_1)\pi(p)|T_q^{\mu\nu}(0)|0\rangle P_\mu=0 [30]. However, this violation vanishes when summing Θ3\Theta_3 over all quark flavors and the gluon. Now these EMT FFs can be expressed in terms of the meson DAs using the extracted πη\pi\eta GDAs in Eq. (34),

Θ1q=−cs∫dxdy[1+xˉ+yxˉyϕηq(y)+c~y~x~ϕηg(y)]ϕπq(x),Θ2q=−cs∫dxdy[1+x+yˉxˉyϕηq(y)−c~y~x~ϕηg(y)]ϕπq(x),Θ3q=2cs∫dxdy[x−yˉxˉyϕηq(y)+c~y~x~ϕηg(y)]ϕπq(x),(40)\begin{aligned} \Theta_1^q&=-\frac{c}{s}\int dxdy\left[\frac{1+\bar{x}+y}{\bar{x}y}\phi_\eta^q(y)+\frac{\tilde{c}\tilde{y}}{\tilde{x}}\phi_\eta^g(y)\right]\phi_\pi^q(x),\\ \Theta_2^q&=-\frac{c}{s}\int dxdy\left[\frac{1+x+\bar{y}}{\bar{x}y}\phi_\eta^q(y)-\frac{\tilde{c}\tilde{y}}{\tilde{x}}\phi_\eta^g(y)\right]\phi_\pi^q(x),\\ \Theta_3^q&=\frac{2c}{s}\int dxdy\left[\frac{x-\bar{y}}{\bar{x}y}\phi_\eta^q(y)+\frac{\tilde{c}\tilde{y}}{\tilde{x}}\phi_\eta^g(y)\right]\phi_\pi^q(x), \tag*{(40)} \end{aligned}

where c=−8παs/9c=-8\pi\alpha_s/9 and c~=1/(43)\tilde{c}=1/(4\sqrt{3}). Substituting Eqs. (10) and (19) into Eq. (40), the timelike EMT FFs can be written as

Θ1q=−cfπq2s{6[5+4(a2π+a2η)+3a2πa2η]fηq+c~(1+a2η)b2fη1},Θ2q=−cfπq2s{6[7+8(a2π+a2η)+9a2πa2η]fηq−c~(1+a2π)b2fη1},Θ3q=cfπqs∑i=13[6(a2iπ−a2iη)fηq+c~(1+∑j=11a2jπ)b2ifη1].(41)\begin{aligned} \Theta_1^q&=-\frac{cf_\pi^q}{2s}\left\{6[5+4(a_2^\pi+a_2^\eta)+3a_2^\pi a_2^\eta]f_\eta^q+\tilde{c}(1+a_2^\eta)b_2f_\eta^1\right\},\\ \Theta_2^q&=-\frac{cf_\pi^q}{2s}\left\{6[7+8(a_2^\pi+a_2^\eta)+9a_2^\pi a_2^\eta]f_\eta^q-\tilde{c}(1+a_2^\pi)b_2f_\eta^1\right\},\\ \Theta_3^q&=\frac{cf_\pi^q}{s}\sum_{i=1}^{3}\left[6(a_{2i}^\pi-a_{2i}^\eta)f_\eta^q+\tilde{c}\left(1+\sum_{j=1}^{1}a_{2j}^\pi\right)b_{2i}f_\eta^1\right]. \tag*{(41)} \end{aligned}

where q=uq=u or dd denotes the quark flavor, and the Gegenbauer polynomials with n≥3n \ge3 are neglected for Θ1q\Theta^{q}_{1} and Θ2q\Theta^{q}_{2} due to lengthy expressions. These formulas can simply be extend to πη′\pi\eta' by replacing the indices η\eta with η′\eta'. If the asymptotic limit Q2→∞Q^{2} \to\infty is taken, we obtain 7Θ1q=5Θ2q7\Theta^{q}_{1}=5\Theta^{q}_{2} and find that the Θ3q\Theta^{q}_{3} term vanishes. However, if the general expressions of meson DAs are adopted, the first term of Θ3q\Theta^{q}_{3} arises when the quark DA of the π\pi meson differs from that of the η\eta meson, and the second term will be nonzero provided that the gluon DA does not vanish (b2iη≠0b^{\eta}_{2i} \ne0), as illustrated by Eq. (41).

If we set μF=30\mu_{F}=\sqrt{30} GeV, recent studies predicts a2π(μF)∼0.16a^{\pi}_{2}(\mu_{F}) \sim0.16 on average [74, 75, 76, 77, 78, 79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89], where the Eq. (21) is used with the input a2π∼0.25a^{\pi}_{2} \sim0.25 at μ0=1\mu_{0}=1 GeV. The authors of Ref. [57] obtain a^2(μ0)=−0.05\hat{a}_{2}(\mu_{0})=-0.05, aˉ2(μ0)=−0.12\bar{a}_{2}(\mu_{0})=-0.12, and b2(μ0)=19b_{2}(\mu_{0})=19 from a combined analysis of the experimental measurements by the CLEO Collaboration [90] and BABAR Collaboration [91]. After incorporating the evolution effects described in Eqs. (21) and (23), we have a^2(μF)=−0.032\hat{a}_{2}(\mu_{F})=-0.032, aˉ2(μF)=−0.027\bar{a}_{2}(\mu_{F})=-0.027, and b2(μF)=7.6b_{2}(\mu_{F})=7.6 for the quark octet, singlet and gluon DAs, respectively. We take the η\eta and η′\eta' decay constants from Ref. [60], and finally obtain the coefficients a2η(μF)∼−0.03a^{\eta}_{2}(\mu_{F}) \sim-0.03 and a2η′(μF)∼−0.03a^{\eta'}_{2}(\mu_{F}) \sim-0.03 using Eq. (16). One can also infer from Eq. (41) that for the Θ3q\Theta^{q}_{3} term, the contribution of the η′\eta' gluon DA is much larger than that of the η\eta gluon DA due to fη′1≫fη1f^{1}_{\eta'} \gg f^{1}_{\eta}. Thus, the existence of the Θ3q\Theta^{q}_{3} term seems quite plausible for the πη\pi\eta and πη′\pi\eta' pairs.

Moreover, with some model assumptions [30] one can express the famous ratio of viscosity to entropy density in terms of Θ3q/Θ2q\Theta^{q}_{3}/\Theta^{q}_{2} which appears to be about 0.055. It is slightly smaller than the bound [31] equal to 1/4π≈0.081/4\pi\approx0.08, but mentioned model assumptions cannot pretend for high accuracy and require further studies, especially in the timelike channel. Using the isospin symmetry relations for meson DAs, we find Θ3u(s)=−Θ3d(s)\Theta^{u}_{3}(s)=-\Theta^{d}_{3}(s) for the πη\pi\eta and πη′\pi\eta' pairs. Consequently, Θ3\Theta_{3} term vanishes when summing over quark flavors, and the conserved hadronic matrix elements of EMT is recovered.

For the η′η\eta'\eta pair, Eq. (40) will be slightly modified,

Θ1η′ηq=−cs∫dxdy1+xˉ+yxˉyϕη′q(y)ϕηq(x)−cc~~s∫dxdy[yxˉxϕη′q(x)ϕηq(y)+xyˉyϕη′q(x)ϕηq(y)],\Theta^{q}_{1\eta'\eta}=-\frac{c}{s}\int dxdy\frac{1+\bar{x}+y}{\bar{x}y}\phi^{q}_{\eta'}(y)\phi^{q}_{\eta}(x)-\frac{\widetilde{c\tilde{c}}}{s}\int dxdy\left[\frac{y}{\bar{x}x}\phi^{q}_{\eta'}(x)\phi^{q}_{\eta}(y)+\frac{x}{\bar{y}y}\phi^{q}_{\eta'}(x)\phi^{q}_{\eta}(y)\right],
Θ2η′ηq=−cs∫dxdy1+x+yˉxˉyϕη′q(y)ϕηq(x)+cc~~s∫dxdy[yxˉxϕη′q(x)ϕηq(y)+xyˉyϕη′q(x)ϕηq(y)],\Theta^{q}_{2\eta'\eta}=-\frac{c}{s}\int dxdy\frac{1+x+\bar{y}}{\bar{x}y}\phi^{q}_{\eta'}(y)\phi^{q}_{\eta}(x)+\frac{\widetilde{c\tilde{c}}}{s}\int dxdy\left[\frac{y}{\bar{x}x}\phi^{q}_{\eta'}(x)\phi^{q}_{\eta}(y)+\frac{x}{\bar{y}y}\phi^{q}_{\eta'}(x)\phi^{q}_{\eta}(y)\right],
Θ3η′ηq=2cs∫dxdyx−yˉxˉyϕη′q(y)ϕηq(x)+2cc~~s∫dxdy[yxˉxϕη′q(x)ϕηq(y)−xyˉyϕη′q(x)ϕηq(y)],(42)\Theta^{q}_{3\eta'\eta}=\frac{2c}{s}\int dxdy\frac{x-\bar{y}}{\bar{x}y}\phi^{q}_{\eta'}(y)\phi^{q}_{\eta}(x)+\frac{2\widetilde{c\tilde{c}}}{s}\int dxdy\left[\frac{y}{\bar{x}x}\phi^{q}_{\eta'}(x)\phi^{q}_{\eta}(y)-\frac{x}{\bar{y}y}\phi^{q}_{\eta'}(x)\phi^{q}_{\eta}(y)\right], \tag*{(42)}

where the quark flavor can be uu, dd, or ss. We obtain Θ3u(s)=Θ3d(s)\Theta^{u}_{3}(s)=\Theta^{d}_{3}(s) using the isospin symmetry relation. The Θ3\Theta_{3} term should vanish when we sum over the quark flavors and the gluon,

∑i=q,gΘ3i(s)=0.(43)\sum_{i=q,g}\Theta^{i}_{3}(s)=0. \tag*{(43)}

The gluon GDA will appear in the amplitudes of γ∗γ→η′η\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\eta'\eta [92] and γ∗γ→η′ηγ\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\eta'\eta\gamma when the higher-order corrections are included, and one of the typical Feynman diagrams is depicted in Figure 4(a). In this work, the gluonic contribution Θ3g\Theta^{g}_{3} is identically zero, and the existence of a nonzero Θ3g\Theta^{g}_{3} and its cancellation can be also investigated through the higher-order corrections to γ∗γ→η′η\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\eta'\eta and γ∗γ→η′ηγ\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\eta'\eta\gamma in the perturbative limit, and we also show one of its typical Feynman diagrams in Figure 4(b), which could be addressed in a future study.

Feynman diagrams for gluon GDA contributions

Figure 4. (a) Gluon GDA is accessed in the higher order corrections to the amplitudes of γ∗γ→η′η\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\eta'\eta [92], and the factorization condition Q2≫sQ^{2} \gg s, ΛQCD2\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^{2} is satisfied; (b) Gluon GDA is extracted from the higher order corrections to the amplitudes of γ∗γ→η′ηγ\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\eta'\eta\gamma in the perturbative limit.

In the future, the process γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*}\to M_{1}M_{2}\gamma can be measured at Belle II in the perturbative limit, which allows us to test the GDAs of Eq. (34) and the EMT FFs of Eqs. (40) and (42) experimentally. At Belle II, the GDAs can be also accessed in γ∗γ→M1M2\gamma^{*}\gamma\to M_1M_2, although the kinematics in this case do not satisfy the perturbative limit. Given that the maximum values of Q2Q^2 and ss in recent measurements [50] are approximately 25 GeV225\ \mathrm{GeV}^2 and 4 GeV24\ \mathrm{GeV}^2, respectively, the kinematic boundary is close to satisfying the perturbative limit. Therefore, Eqs. (34), (40) and (42) can still serve as a boundary constraint in the extraction of GDAs.

The existence of Θ3q(s)\Theta_3^q(s) also indicates that there are PP-wave GDAs for πη\pi\eta and η′η\eta'\eta, enabling the search for exotic resonances through the PP-wave production of these meson pairs in γ∗γ→M1M2\gamma^{*}\gamma\to M_1M_2 [33, 52] and γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*} \to M_1M_2\gamma [28], which is possible at Belle II and BESIII. Recently, the exotic resonance η1(1855)\eta_1(1855) was observed by BESIII through the PP-wave analysis of η′η\eta'\eta in J/Ψ→η′ηγJ/\Psi\to\eta'\eta\gamma [34, 35]. Given the similarity between J/ΨJ/\Psi and γ∗\gamma^{*}, it is promising to search for η1(1855)\eta_1(1855) in γ∗γ→η′η\gamma^{*}\gamma\to\eta'\eta and γ∗→η′ηγ\gamma^{*} \to\eta'\eta\gamma.

Summary

In the perturbative limit Q2≫s≫ΛQCD2Q^2 \gg s \gg\Lambda_{\mathrm{QCD}}^2, the helicity amplitudes of γ∗γ→M1M2\gamma^{*}\gamma\to M_1M_2 and γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*} \to M_1M_2\gamma can be factorized into the hard scattering amplitudes and soft meson DAs even when M1M2M_1M_2 is a pair of different mesons like πη\pi\eta and η′η\eta'\eta. This fact suggests a possible connection between the M1M2M_1M_2 GDAs and the meson DAs, particularly the gluon DA associated with η(′)\eta^{(\prime)} production. We have derived the formulas for GDAs in terms of the quark and the gluon DAs, and confirmed the universality of GDAs between γ∗γ→M1M2\gamma^{*}\gamma\to M_1M_2 and γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*} \to M_1M_2\gamma in the perturbative limit. The derived formulas allow us to express the timelike transition EMT FFs in terms of the meson DAs whose parameters have been constrained by the previous experiments. We have verified the existence of a new EMT FF Θ3q\Theta_3^q which does not exist for the ππ\pi\pi case, which confirms the anticipated appearance of exotic quantum numbers, being the counterpart of naive T-violation in spacelike channel making, in turn, the contact with a dissipative nature of viscosity. Although this new EMT FF violates the conservation law of EMT when its hadronic matrix element is considered for a single quark flavor, our result ensures that the conservation law is restored for πη(′)\pi\eta^{(\prime)} after summing over all the relevant quark flavors. At Belle II, the measurement of γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*} \to M_1M_2\gamma satisfies the condition of the perturbative limit, making it possible to test the M1M2M_1M_2 GDAs and EMT FFs obtained in this work experimentally. Furthermore, the obtained GDAs and EMT FFs can serve as boundary constraints for extracting M1M2M_1M_2 GDAs from γ∗γ→M1M2\gamma^{*}\gamma\to M_1M_2 at Belle II and γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*} \to M_1M_2\gamma at BESIII. Since the Θ3q\Theta_3^q term originates from the PP-wave components of the GDAs, our study suggests that it is feasible to search for exotic resonances through the PP-wave production of M1M2M_1M_2 in γ∗γ→M1M2\gamma^{*}\gamma\to M_1M_2 and γ∗→M1M2γ\gamma^{*} \to M_1M_2\gamma.

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge useful discussions with Markus Diehl, Yang Li, Cédric Lorcé, Sergey Mikhailov, Bernard Pire, Georgy Prokhorov and Valentin Zakharov. Qin-Tao Song was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant Number 12005191. O.V. Teryaev is thankful to PiFi program of CAS for support and Prof. Xurong Chen for hospitality at IMP (Huizhou).

References

  1. [1]X. D. Ji, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78 (1997), 610-613.
  2. [2]M. V. Polyakov and P. Schweitzer, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 33 (2018) no.26, 1830025.
  3. [3]V. D. Burkert, L. Elouadrhiri and F. X. Girod, Nature 557 (2018) no.7705, 396-399.
  4. [4]V. D. Burkert, L. Elouadrhiri, F. X. Girod, C. Lorcé, P. Schweitzer and P. E. Shanahan, Rev. Mod. Phys. 95 (2023) no.4, 041002.
  5. [5]C. Lorcé, H. Moutarde and A. P. Trawiński, Eur. Phys. J. C 79 (2019) no.1, 89.
  6. [6]H. Dutrieux, C. Lorcé, H. Moutarde, P. Sznajder, A. Trawiński and J. Wagner, Eur. Phys. J. C 81 (2021) no.4, 300.
  7. [7]K. Kumerički, Nature 570 (2019) no.7759, E1-E2.
  8. [8]P. E. Shanahan and W. Detmold, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122 (2019) no.7, 072003.
  9. [9]A. Freese and G. A. Miller, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021), 094023.
  10. [10]Y. Li and J. P. Vary, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) no.5, L051501.
  11. [11]A. García Martín-Caro, M. Huidobro and Y. Hatta, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) no.3, 034002.
  12. [12]S. Nair et al. [BLFQ], Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) no.5, 056027.
  13. [13]C. Lorcé and Q. T. Song, Phys. Lett. B 864 (2025), 139433.
  14. [14]W. Broniowski and E. Ruiz Arriola, arXiv:2503.09297 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2503.09297
  15. [15]M. Goharipour et al. [MMGPDs], [arXiv:2501.16257 [hep-ph]].arxiv.org/abs/2501.16257
  16. [16]O. V. Teryaev, arXiv:hep-ph/9904376 [hep-ph].DOI
  17. [17]O. V. Teryaev, Front. Phys. (Beijing) 11 (2016) no.5, 111207.
  18. [18]M. Diehl, Phys. Rept. 388 (2003), 41-277.
  19. [19]A. V. Belitsky and A. V. Radyushkin, Phys. Rept. 418 (2005), 1-387.
  20. [20]S. Boffi and B. Pasquini, Riv. Nuovo Cim. 30 (2007) no.9, 387-448.
  21. [21]K. Goeke, M. V. Polyakov and M. Vanderhaeghen, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 47 (2001), 401-515.
  22. [22]M. V. Polyakov, Nucl. Phys. B 555 (1999), 231.
  23. [23]M. Diehl, T. Gousset, B. Pire and O. Teryaev, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 (1998), 1782-1785.
  24. [24]M. Diehl, T. Gousset and B. Pire, Phys. Rev. D 62 (2000), 073014.
  25. [25]C. Lorcé, B. Pire and Qin-Tao Song, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022), 094030.
  26. [26]Z. Lu and I. Schmidt, Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006), 094021 [erratum: Phys. Rev. D 75 (2007), 099902].
  27. [27]J. P. Lees et al. [BaBar], Phys. Rev. D 92 (2015) no.7, 072015.
  28. [28]B. Pire and Q. T. Song, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) no.11, 114014.
  29. [29]B. Pire and Q. T. Song, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) no.7, 074016.
  30. [30]O. Teryaev, JPS Conf. Proc. 37, 020406 (2022).
  31. [31]P. Kovtun, D. T. Son and A. O. Starinets, Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005), 111601.
  32. [32]D. D. Lapygin, G. Y. Prokhorov, O. V. Teryaev and V. I. Zakharov, arXiv:2502.18199 [hep-th].
  33. [33]I. V. Anikin, B. Pire, L. Szymanowski, O. V. Teryaev and S. Wallon, Eur. Phys. J. C 47 (2006), 71-79.
  34. [34]M. Ablikim et al. [BESIII], Phys. Rev. Lett. 129 (2022) no.19, 192002 [erratum: Phys. Rev. Lett. 130 (2023) no.15, 159901].
  35. [35]M. Ablikim et al. [BESIII], Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) no.7, 072012 [erratum: Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) no.7, 079901].
  36. [36]D. Alde et al. [IHEP-Brussels-Los Alamos-Annecy (LAPP)], Phys. Lett. B 205 (1988), 397.
  37. [37]G. S. Adams et al. [E862], Phys. Lett. B 657 (2007), 27-31.
  38. [38]G. S. Adams et al. [E852], Phys. Rev. Lett. 81 (1998), 5760-5763.
  39. [39]M. Aghasyan et al. [COMPASS], Phys. Rev. D 98 (2018) no.9, 092003
  40. [40]A. Rodas et al. [JPAC], Phys. Rev. Lett. 122 (2019), 042002.
  41. [41]M. G. Alexeev et al. [COMPASS], Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022), 012005.
  42. [42]J. Kuhn et al. [E852], Phys. Lett. B 595 (2004), 109-117.
  43. [43]R. L. Workman et al. [Particle Data Group], PTEP 2022 (2022), 083C01.
  44. [44]H. X. Chen, W. Chen, X. Liu, Y. R. Liu and S. L. Zhu, Rept. Prog. Phys. 86 (2023) no.2, 026201.
  45. [45]C. Aubin, M. Benayoun, J. Bijnens, T. Blum, I. Caprini, G. Colangelo, H. Czyz, A. Denig, C. A. Dominguez and S. Eidelman, et al. arXiv:1407.4021 [hep-ph].
  46. [46]I. Danilkin and M. Vanderhaeghen, Phys. Lett. B 789 (2019), 366-372.
  47. [47]I. Danilkin, C. F. Redmer and M. Vanderhaeghen, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 107 (2019), 20-68.
  48. [48]B. Moussallam, Eur. Phys. J. C 81 (2021) no.11, 993.
  49. [49]S. Kumano, Qin-Tao Song and O. V. Teryaev, Phys. Rev. D 97 (2018), 014020.
  50. [50]M. Masuda et al. [Belle], Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) no.3, 032003.
  51. [51]M. Diehl, T. Feldmann, P. Kroll and C. Vogt, Phys. Rev. D 61 (2000), 074029.
  52. [52]I. V. Anikin, B. Pire, L. Szymanowski, O. V. Teryaev and S. Wallon, Phys. Rev. D 71 (2005), 034021.
  53. [53]I. V. Anikin, B. Pire, L. Szymanowski, O. V. Teryaev and S. Wallon, Phys. Rev. D 70 (2004), 011501.
  54. [54]I. V. Anikin, B. Pire, L. Szymanowski, O. V. Teryaev and S. Wallon, Nucl. Phys. A 755 (2005), 561-564.
  55. [55]S. J. Brodsky and G. P. Lepage, Phys. Rev. D 24 (1981), 1808.
  56. [56]P. Kroll and K. Passek-Kumericki, Phys. Rev. D 67 (2003), 054017.
  57. [57]P. Kroll and K. Passek-Kumericki, J. Phys. G 40 (2013), 075005.
  58. [58]Y. Klopot, A. Oganesian and O. Teryaev, Phys. Rev. D 87 (2013) no.3, 036013 [erratum: Phys. Rev. D 88 (2013) no.5, 059902].
  59. [59]T. Feldmann, P. Kroll and B. Stech, Phys. Lett. B 449 (1999), 339-346.
  60. [60]G. S. Bali et al. [RQCD], JHEP 08 (2021), 137.
  61. [61]Y. Y. Charng, T. Kurimoto and H. n. Li, Phys. Rev. D 74 (2006), 074024 [erratum: Phys. Rev. D 78 (2008), 059901].
  62. [62]P. Ball and G. W. Jones, JHEP 08 (2007), 025.
  63. [63]S. S. Agaev, V. M. Braun, N. Offen, F. A. Porkert and A. Schäfer, Phys. Rev. D 90 (2014) no.7, 074019.
  64. [64]A. Ali and A. Y. Parkhomenko, Eur. Phys. J. C 30 (2003), 367-380.
  65. [65]G. P. Lepage and S. J. Brodsky, Phys. Lett. B 87 (1979), 359-365.
  66. [66]A. V. Efremov and A. V. Radyushkin, Phys. Lett. B 94 (1980), 245-250.
  67. [67]V. N. Baier and A. G. Grozin, Nucl. Phys. B 192 (1981), 476-488.
  68. [68]D. Mueller, B. Pire, L. Szymanowski and J. Wagner, Phys. Rev. D 86 (2012), 031502.
  69. [69]H. Pagels, Phys. Rev. 144 (1966), 1250-1260.
  70. [70]K. Goeke, J. Grabis, J. Ossmann, M. V. Polyakov, P. Schweitzer, A. Silva and D. Urbano, Phys. Rev. D 75 (2007), 094021.
  71. [71]J. Hudson and P. Schweitzer, Phys. Rev. D 96 (2017) no.11, 114013.
  72. [72]M. V. Polyakov and C. Weiss, Phys. Rev. D 60 (1999), 114017.
  73. [73]J. F. Donoghue and H. Leutwyler, Z. Phys. C 52 (1991), 343-351.
  74. [74]V. L. Chernyak and A. R. Zhitnitsky, Nucl. Phys. B 201 (1982), 492 [erratum: Nucl. Phys. B 214 (1983), 547].
  75. [75]P. Ball, V. M. Braun and A. Lenz, JHEP 05 (2006), 004.
  76. [76]A. V. Radyushkin, Phys. Rev. D 80 (2009), 094009.
  77. [77]R. Arthur, P. A. Boyle, D. Brommel, M. A. Donnellan, J. M. Flynn, A. Juttner, T. D. Rae and C. T. C. Sachrajda, Phys. Rev. D 83 (2011), 074505
  78. [78]S. S. Agaev, V. M. Braun, N. Offen and F. A. Porkert, Phys. Rev. D 83 (2011), 054020.
  79. [79]A. P. Bakulev, S. V. Mikhailov, A. V. Pimikov and N. G. Stefanis, Phys. Rev. D 86 (2012), 031501
  80. [80]S. V. Mikhailov, A. V. Pimikov and N. G. Stefanis, Phys. Rev. D 103 (2021) no.9, 096003
  81. [81]I. C. Cloët, L. Chang, C. D. Roberts, S. M. Schmidt and P. C. Tandy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111 (2013), 092001.
  82. [82]P. Kroll, H. Moutarde and F. Sabatie, Eur. Phys. J. C 73 (2013) no.1, 2278.
  83. [83]K. Raya, L. Chang, A. Bashir, J. J. Cobos-Martinez, L. X. Gutiérrez-Guerrero, C. D. Roberts and P. C. Tandy, Phys. Rev. D 93 (2016) no.7, 074017.
  84. [84]G. S. Bali, V. M. Braun, G. Blägle, M. Göckeler, M. Gruber, F. Hutzler, P. Korcyl, A. Schäfer, P. Wein and J. H. Zhang, Phys. Rev. D 98 (2018) no.9, 094507.
  85. [85]G. S. Bali et al. [R QCD], JHEP 08 (2019), 065; JHEP 11 (2020) 037.
  86. [86]J. Hua et al. [Lattice Parton], Phys. Rev. Lett. 129 (2022) no.13, 132001.
  87. [87]T. Zhong, Z. H. Zhu, H. B. Fu, X. G. Wu and T. Huang, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) no.1, 016021.
  88. [88]C. Shi, M. Li, X. Chen and W. Jia, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) no.9, 094016.
  89. [89]X. Gao, A. D. Hanlon, N. Karthik, S. Mukherjee, P. Petreczky, P. Scior, S. Syritsyn and Y. Zhao, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) no.7, 074505.
  90. [90]J. Gronberg et al. [CLEO], Phys. Rev. D 57 (1998), 33-54.
  91. [91]P. del Moro Sanchez et al. [BaBar], Phys. Rev. D 84 (2011), 052001.
  92. [92]N. Kivel, L. Mankiewicz and M. V. Polyakov, Phys. Lett. B 467 (1999), 263-270.

Paper details

vlnc:W_s65zveqq
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents