betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Nonsolvable critical groups with the spectrum of S10S_{10}

Abstract

We classify the nonsolvable finite groups that are critical with respect to the spectrum of the symmetric group S10S_{10}. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly two such groups: S10S_{10} and (A9×C3)⋊C2(A_9\times C_3)\rtimes C_2, where the involution acts on A9A_9 by conjugation by a transposition and on C3C_3 by inversion. The quotient of any nonsolvable group with this spectrum by its solvable radical is almost simple. All possible simple socles are treated without assuming that the radical is nilpotent. The final cases, L3(4)L_3(4) and A6A_6, are excluded using the canonical subgroup K=[R(G)∩G∞,G∞]K=[R(G)\cap G^\infty,G^\infty], actions on chief factors, and the required element orders 9,20,309,20,30. In the A6A_6 case, the final contradiction is the existence of an element of order 1616. Reproducible certificates accompany the character-table and matrix calculations.

Introduction

The spectrum of a finite group GG is the set ω(G)\omega(G) of its element orders. We consider the spectrum of the symmetric group of degree 10:

Ω=ω(S10)={1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,12,14,15,20,21,30}.\Omega= \omega(S_{10}) = \{1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,12,14,15,20,21,30\}.

A group with spectrum Ω\Omega is called Ω\Omega-critical if none of its proper sections has this spectrum. Sections and the remaining notation are defined below.

Theorem 1. Up to isomorphism, there are exactly two nonsolvable finite ω(S10)\omega(S_{10})-critical groups:

S10andH=(A9×C3)⋊C2.S_{10} \qquad\text{and} \qquad H=(A_9 \times C_3)\rtimes C_2.

In the definition of HH, a generator of C2C_2 acts on A9A_9 by conjugation by a transposition in S9S_9, and on C3C_3 by inversion.

The proof proceeds as follows. First, we calculate the spectra of the two groups in the statement and prove that they are critical. Next, the exclusions 25,35∉Ω25,35\notin\Omega show that the quotient of any nonsolvable group with spectrum Ω\Omega by its solvable radical is almost simple. We then treat every possible simple socle. The socles A9,A10A_9,A_{10} lead to the groups in the statement; the other socles are excluded without assuming criticality.

To analyze the solvable radical, we introduce the perfect residual L=G∞L=G^\infty, its radical P=R(G)∩LP=R(G)\cap L, and the characteristic subgroup K=[P,L]=[K,L]K=[P,L]=[K,L]. The quotient L/KL/K is a perfect central cover of the simple socle. We study the joint actions of the radical and the perfect residual on chief factors inside KK. Choosing an uppermost chief factor on which KK acts nontrivially gives a nilpotent normal subgroup in the induced action group. Theorems on minimal polynomials and critical subgroups then control its structure. The final contradictions use both the required orders in Ω\Omega and the absence of the orders 16,18,24,28,35,42,45,6316,18,24,28,35,42,45,63.

All lemmas, reductions, and proofs needed for this argument are included here. Classical theorems used without proof are stated explicitly. The data on simple groups, their central covers, and modules are given to the extent needed, with references to published sources. The appendices contain verification calculations. The proof of the main theorem is completed in § 24.

Notation and preliminary facts

All groups considered in this text are finite. Groups are called isospectral if they have the same spectrum; a group is subspectral to another if its spectrum is contained in that of the other group. We denote by ω(G)\omega(G) the set of element orders of GG, by R(G)R(G) its largest solvable normal subgroup, and by Soc⁡(G)\operatorname{Soc}(G) the subgroup generated by all minimal normal subgroups of GG. We write conjugation as ax=x−1axa^x=x^{-1}ax and commutators as [a,b]=a−1b−1ab[a,b]=a^{-1}b^{-1}ab. For subgroups A,BA,B, the notation [A,B][A,B] denotes the subgroup generated by all commutators [a,b][a,b], a∈Aa\in A, b∈Bb\in B.

Definition 2. A section of a group GG is a quotient group K/LK/L, where L⊴K≤GL\trianglelefteq K\leq G. The section is proper if (K,L)≠(G,1)(K,L)\ne(G,1). For a set of positive integers Ω\Omega, a group GG is called Ω\Omega-critical if ω(G)=Ω\omega(G)=\Omega, but the spectrum of every proper section differs from Ω\Omega.

Lemma 3. For every section K/LK/L of a finite group GG,

ω(K/L)⊆ω(K)⊆ω(G).\omega(K/L)\subseteq\omega(K)\subseteq\omega(G).

Consequently, to prove that a group GG with spectrum Ω\Omega is Ω\Omega-critical, it suffices to exclude:

  1. all proper subgroups K<GK < G with ω(K)=Ω\omega(K) = \Omega;

  1. all proper quotients G/LG/L, 1≠L⊴G1 \ne L \trianglelefteq G, with ω(G/L)=Ω\omega(G/L) = \Omega.

Proof. The second inclusion is obvious. Suppose that xLxL has order dd and xx has order ee. Then d∣ed \mid e, and xe/dx^{e/d} has order dd. Hence d∈ω(K)d \in\omega(K). If the section is proper, then either K<GK < G, or K=GK = G and L≠1L \ne1, proving the final assertion.

A normal subgroup is called minimal normal if it is nontrivial and contains no proper nontrivial normal subgroup of the ambient group. A chief factor of GG is a quotient N/MN/M, where M,N⊴GM,N \trianglelefteq G, M<NM < N, and there is no normal subgroup of GG strictly between them. A solvable chief factor is elementary abelian and is regarded as a simple module for the group induced by conjugation on that factor. We write F(A)F(A) for the Fitting subgroup of a solvable group AA, that is, its largest nilpotent normal subgroup; Op(A)O_p(A) is its largest normal pp-subgroup. The subgroup Φ(A)\Phi(A) is the intersection of the maximal subgroups of AA. For a pp-group it equals A′ApA'A^p. If U≤AU \leq A and UΦ(A)=AU\Phi(A) = A, then U=AU = A: otherwise UU would be contained in a maximal subgroup, which also contains Φ(A)\Phi(A). For an abelian pp-group, Ω1(A)\Omega_1(A) denotes the subgroup of elements whose orders divide pp. The exponent exp⁡A\exp A is the least common multiple of the element orders of AA. A group EE is called an extraspecial pp-group if Z(E)=E′=Φ(E)Z(E) = E' = \Phi(E) has order pp.

The derived series is defined by G(0)=GG^{(0)} = G, G(i+1)=[G(i),G(i)]G^{(i+1)} = [G^{(i)},G^{(i)}]. Its stable term is denoted by G∞G^\infty and called the perfect residual. A group AA is perfect if A=A′A = A'. A perfect central cover of a simple group SS is a perfect group DD with D/Z(D)≅SD/Z(D) \cong S. The abbreviated notation m.Sm.S, S.AS.A for covers and outer extensions is specified whenever it is used. We write π(A)\pi(A) for the set of prime divisors of ∣A∣|A|, and μ(A)\mu(A) for the elements of ω(A)\omega(A) maximal under divisibility.

By a simple type we mean an isomorphism class of simple modules over the specified field, identified with a chosen representative when convenient.

In the analysis of the radical, we use the global notation

L=G∞,P=R(G)∩L,K=[P,L].L = G^\infty,\qquad P = R(G) \cap L,\qquad K = [P,L].

In individual local lemmas, the letters P,Q,H,TP,Q,H,T may denote Sylow subgroups, kernels, or groups acting on modules; their meanings are specified in the corresponding statements. The notation H=(A9×C3)⋊C2H = (A_9 \times C_3) \rtimes C_2 refers to the group in the main theorem. In local arguments, the same letter may denote a Hall subgroup; each such use is introduced explicitly.

Classical results

The following classical results are used without reproducing their general proofs. The versions needed are stated here or immediately before their first specific application.

Classical result used below (Hall’s and Schur–Zassenhaus theorems). For every set of primes π\pi, a finite solvable group has Hall π\pi-subgroups, and all such subgroups are conjugate. A subgroup A≤GA \leq G is called a Hall subgroup if (∣A∣,[G:A])=1(|A|, [G:A]) = 1. If A⊴GA \trianglelefteq G is a Hall subgroup, then it has a complement BB in GG: G=ABG = AB, A∩B=1A \cap B = 1. If at least one of A,G/AA,G/A is solvable, all complements are conjugate by elements of AA.

Classical result used below (Maschke’s and Clifford’s theorems and Schur’s lemma). If the characteristic of a field kk does not divide the order of a finite group AA, every kAkA-module is completely reducible. If N⊴GN \trianglelefteq G, the restriction of a simple kGkG-module to NN is completely reducible, and GG permutes its isotypic components transitively. The endomorphism ring of a simple module is a division ring; over an algebraically closed field, every endomorphism of a finite-dimensional simple module is scalar.

Classical result used below (Gaschütz’s complement criterion). Let A⊴GA \trianglelefteq G be an abelian pp-subgroup, and let UU be a Sylow pp-subgroup of GG. If AA has a complement in UU, then it has a complement in GG. The converse also holds. We use the formulation of Theorem 1.1 in [1].

Classical result used below (Universal central extension). A finite perfect group SS has a universal central extension S^→S\widehat{S} \to S with kernel M(S)M(S), called the Schur multiplier. Every perfect central extension D→SD \to S is a quotient of it; in particular, the kernel of D→SD \to S is a quotient of M(S)M(S).

Classical result used below (Jordan’s theorem). If P≤SnP \leq S_n is a primitive permutation group containing a cycle of prime length pp, where p≤n−3p \leq n-3, then An≤PA_n \leq P.

Here a cycle means a single cyclic permutation of length pp, fixing the other n−pn-p points. A transitive group is called primitive if it preserves no partition of the point set into equal blocks of size strictly between 11 and nn. This formulation appears, for example, as Theorem 1.1 in Jones’s paper [2].

Classical result used below (Simplicity and automorphisms of alternating groups). For n≥5n \geq5, the group AnA_n is nonabelian simple. For n≥7n \geq7, we have Aut⁡(An)≅Sn\operatorname{Aut}(A_n) \cong S_n. For the two groups used in the main argument,

Aut⁡(A5)≅S5,∣Aut⁡(A5)∣=120,∣Aut⁡(A6)∣=1440.\operatorname{Aut}(A_5) \cong S_5,\qquad|\operatorname{Aut}(A_5)|=120,\qquad|\operatorname{Aut}(A_6)|=1440.

In particular, both of the latter orders are coprime to 77.

For automorphism data one may use the ATLAS [3]; for A6A_6, we have Aut⁡(A6)≅PΓL⁡2(9)\operatorname{Aut}(A_6) \cong\operatorname{P\Gamma L}_2(9), and ∣Out⁡(A6)∣=4|\operatorname{Out}(A_6)|=4. We also use Cauchy’s and Sylow’s theorems in their usual formulations: if a prime pp divides the order of a finite group, the group has an element of order pp; Sylow pp-subgroups have order equal to the full pp-part of the group order, and their images under an epimorphism are Sylow pp-subgroups of the image. Every pp-subgroup is contained in a Sylow pp-subgroup, and all Sylow pp-subgroups are conjugate.

References

No references were extracted for this paper.

Paper details

vlnc:W_s849757k
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents