betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Δ(1232)Δ(1232) production in the γp→ϕπpγp \to ϕπp reaction

Abstract

In this work, the production of baryon resonances in the γp→ϕπpγp \to ϕπp reaction near threshold is investigated within an effective Lagrangian approach. incorporates intermediate resonances, including Δ(1232)Δ(1232), N(1440)N(1440), N(1520)N(1520), and N(1535)N(1535), alongside non-resonant background contributions. The results indicate that the reaction is dominated by the Δ(1232)Δ(1232) excitation near threshold. A key focus of this study is the exploration of the a0(980)a_0(980) meson exchange in the Δ(1232)Δ(1232) production, as this reaction offers a unique opportunity to probe the poorly known Δ(1232)Na0Δ(1232)N a_0 coupling. We demonstrate that the parity asymmetry (PσP_σ), accessible through the ϕϕ-meson's spin density matrix elements, serves as a suitable experimental observable to identify the contribution from the a0(980)a_0(980) exchange.

Introduction

Investigating baryon resonances plays a crucial role in hadronic physics, shedding light on the non-perturbative dynamics of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). Due to their extremely short lifetimes, resonances such as the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) cannot be observed directly. Instead, their existence and properties are inferred from analyses of intermediate states in scattering or decay processes. The Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance, characterized by its prominent peak in both πN\pi N and γN\gamma N scattering reactions, serves as a particularly important archetype for these studies. This is primarily due to its relatively low mass and strong coupling to the πN\pi N channel [1]. However, the low mass of the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) also presents significant challenges when investigating its coupling to channels involving heavier particles. A key limitation arises because the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) mass lies below the kinematic thresholds required to produce the heavier states. Consequently, decay channels that would probe such couplings: such as Δ→Nρ\Delta\to N\rho, Δ→Na0(980)\Delta\to Na_0(980), and Δ→KΣ\Delta\to K\Sigma, are kinematically forbidden. This physical constraint precludes direct experimental investigation of these specific interactions through the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) decays. As a result, the couplings of the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance to heavier particle systems, such as NρN\rho [2], Na0(980)Na_0(980), and KΣK\Sigma, remain poorly constrained or entirely unknown. These significant gaps in our knowledge considerably hamper efforts to achieve a comprehensive understanding of the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232)’s dynamical properties and its possible role within the broader landscape of hadronic interactions.

In recent years, photoproduction reactions have emerged as a powerful tool for investigating the properties of baryon resonances [3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10]. While most studies have focused on single-meson production processes, extending investigations to multi-meson final states—for example, the NππN\pi\pi, NKKˉNK\bar{K}, NηπN\eta\pi channels etc. [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17]—

offers unique opportunities to probe resonance characteristics. Furthermore, it was demonstrated in Ref. [18] that the reaction γp→ϕK+Λ\gamma p \to\phi K^+\Lambda, owing to its specific production dynamics, is particularly well-suited for studying the N(1535)KΛN(1535)K\Lambda coupling [19, 20]. Probing this specific coupling through single-meson production processes presents significant challenges. This example, along with other works [21, 22, 23, 24, 25], demonstrate that the dynamics of multi-meson final states provide a unique avenue to study resonance couplings.

In this paper, we present the results of a study of the γp→ϕϕp\gamma p \to\phi\phi p reaction near threshold using an effective Lagrangian approach. We consider the contributions from the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232), N(1440)N(1440), N(1520)N(1520) and N(1535)N(1535) resonances as intermediate states, which subsequently decay into the πN\pi N in the final state. Contributions from resonances in the ϕπ\phi\pi and ϕp\phi p channels are ignored in this work, because no significant resonance signals have been found in these two channels in the energy region under study [1]. This observation suggests that the present reaction is well suited for studying the excitation mechanisms of the aforementioned baryon resonances in the γp→ϕΔ\gamma p \to\phi\Delta or ϕN∗\phi N^* processes since their decays into the πN\pi N are well known. Such studies are not only important for understanding the reaction mechanism itself but also valuable for probing the coupling of baryon resonances with exchanged particles. For the tt-channel of the γp→ϕΔ\gamma p \to\phi\Delta or ϕN∗\phi N^* subprocesses, vector meson exchange is forbidden due to the conservation of C-parity. Since the nucleon and Δ\Delta resonances considered in this work have relatively large decay branch ratios to the NπN\pi channel, it is natural to expect that the π\pi-meson exchange plays an important role in the excitation of the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) and N∗N^*s in this reaction. Furthermore, for the N(1535)N(1535) production, η\eta-meson exchange could also be important. Other possible contributions, such as the exchange of scalar mesons (σ\sigma, f0(980)f_0(980) and a0(980)a_0(980)) and axial vector mesons (a1(1260)a_1(1260), b1(1235)b_1(1235)), may also exist. These contributions were usually ignored in previous studies due to their relatively large mass or their poorly known couplings with the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) or N∗N^*s. These assumptions require experimental verification.

In this work, we try to investigate the role of a0(980)a_0(980), hereafter denoted as a0a_0, in the excitation of the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) in this reaction. To this end, we note that since the isospin of Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) is 3/23/2, isoscalar meson exchanges are forbidden in this process. Meanwhile, the PDG book [1] shows that axial vector mesons such as a1(1260)a_1(1260) and b1(1235)b_1(1235) do not have a significant decay branch ratio to the ϕγ\phi\gamma channel, which means their contributions are suppressed to some extent. Considering this and their relatively large masses, we neglect their contributions. Furthermore, we will focus on the near-threshold region, where the production of Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) is expected to be dominant. To estimate the a0a_0 exchange contribution, knowledge of the ϕa0γ\phi a_0\gamma and ΔNa0\Delta N a_0 couplings is essential. The ϕa0γ\phi a_0\gamma coupling can be extracted from the radiative decay width of ϕ\phi to γa0\gamma a_0[26]. However, the coupling of Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) with Na0N a_0 has been rarely studied in previous studies. Therefore, if the a0a_0 exchange contribution can be identified experimentally, it offers an opportunity to study the Δ(1232)Na0\Delta(1232)N a_0 coupling. To do this, a crucial step is to separate the a0a_0 exchange contribution from that of the π\pi exchange. This problem can be solved by following the method suggested in previous works[27, 28], where it was shown that spin observables are very useful for this purpose. The spin density matrix elements (SDMEs) of the ϕ\phi meson can be extracted from its decay angular distribution. By analyzing the SDMEs of the ϕ\phi meson, it is possible to obtain the information about the exchanged particles. This method was already used in Refs.[29, 30] to identify the role of the scalar κ\kappa meson exchange. In this work, we will show that the SDMEs can also provide useful information about the exchanged meson in the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) production process.

The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In § 2, we present the model and the theoretical formalism used in the calculations. Numerical results and discussions are presented in § 3, followed by a summary in the last section.

The Model

The Feynman diagrams for the γp→ϕπp\gamma p \to\phi\pi p reaction in our model are depicted in Figure 1. Since we focus on the near-threshold region, resonance states such as Δ(1232)\Delta(1232), N(1440)N(1440), N(1520)N(1520), and N(1535)N(1535) in the intermediate states are included. As mentioned in the Introduction, we consider the π\pi and η\eta exchanges for nucleon resonance excitations, and the π\pi and a0a_0 exchanges for the excitation of the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance, as other meson exchanges are either forbidden or considered unimportant. To calculate the Feynman diagrams shown in Figure 1, the following Lagrangian densities are needed[18, 31, 32]:

Feynman diagrams for the $\gamma p \to \phi\pi p$ reaction

Figure 1. Feynman diagrams for the γp→ϕπp\gamma p \to\phi\pi p reaction.

LπNN=−gπNN2mNNˉγ5γμ∂μπN,(1)\mathcal{L}_{\pi NN}=-\frac{g_{\pi NN}}{2m_N}\bar{N}\gamma_5\gamma^\mu\partial_\mu\pi N, \tag*{(1)}
Lργπ=emϕgργπϵμναβ∂μϕν∂αAβπ,(2)\mathcal{L}_{\rho\gamma\pi}=\frac{e}{m_\phi}g_{\rho\gamma\pi}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\partial_\mu\phi_\nu\partial_\alpha A_\beta\pi, \tag*{(2)}
Lγηπ=emϕgγηπϵμναβ∂μϕν∂αAβη,(3)\mathcal{L}_{\gamma\eta\pi}=\frac{e}{m_\phi}g_{\gamma\eta\pi}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\partial_\mu\phi_\nu\partial_\alpha A_\beta\eta, \tag*{(3)}
Lρπγ=emρgρπγϵμναβ∂μρν∂αAβπ,(4)\mathcal{L}_{\rho\pi\gamma}=\frac{e}{m_\rho}g_{\rho\pi\gamma}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\partial_\mu\rho_\nu\partial_\alpha A_\beta\pi, \tag*{(4)}
Lϕρπ=gϕρπmϕϵμναβ∂μϕν∂αρβπ,(5)\mathcal{L}_{\phi\rho\pi}=\frac{g_{\phi\rho\pi}}{m_\phi}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}\partial_\mu\phi_\nu\partial_\alpha\rho_\beta\pi, \tag*{(5)}
Lϕa0γ=emϕgϕa0γ∂αϕβ(∂αAβ−∂βAα)a0,(6)\mathcal{L}_{\phi a_0\gamma}=\frac{e}{m_\phi}g_{\phi a_0\gamma}\partial^\alpha\phi^\beta(\partial_\alpha A_\beta-\partial_\beta A_\alpha)a_0, \tag*{(6)}
LϕNN1535∗=gϕNN1535∗Nˉ∗MN+h.c.,(7)\mathcal{L}_{\phi NN^*_{1535}}=g_{\phi NN^*_{1535}}\bar{N}^{*}MN+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(7)}
LπNN1440∗=−gπNN1440∗mN+mN∗Nˉ∗γ5γμ∂μπN+h.c.,(8)\mathcal{L}_{\pi NN^*_{1440}}=-\frac{g_{\pi NN^*_{1440}}}{m_N+m_{N^*}}\bar{N}^{*}\gamma_5\gamma^\mu\partial_\mu\pi N+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(8)}
LπNN1520∗=−gMNN1520∗mπNˉ∗μ∂μMγ5N+h.c.,(9)\mathcal{L}_{\pi NN^*_{1520}}=-\frac{g_{MNN^*_{1520}}}{m_\pi}\bar{N}^{*\mu}\partial_\mu M\gamma_5N+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(9)}
LΔNa0=gΔNa0ma0Δˉμ(τ⃗⋅∂μa0)γ5N+h.c.,(10)\mathcal{L}_{\Delta N a_0}=\frac{g_{\Delta N a_0}}{m_{a_0}}\bar{\Delta}^{\mu}(\vec{\tau}\cdot\partial_\mu a_0)\gamma_5N+\mathrm{h.c.}, \tag*{(10)}
LΔNπ=gΔNπmπΔˉμ(τ⃗⋅∂μπ⃗)N+h.c.(11)\mathcal{L}_{\Delta N\pi}=\frac{g_{\Delta N\pi}}{m_\pi}\bar{\Delta}^{\mu}(\vec{\tau}\cdot\partial_\mu\vec{\pi})N+\mathrm{h.c.} \tag*{(11)}

where ϕμ\phi_\mu is the ϕ\phi meson field, Φ\Phi stands for the π\pi or η\eta fields, and AμA_\mu is the photon field. The coupling constant gπNNg_{\pi NN} is taken from Refs.[33, 34] with a value of gπNN=13.45g_{\pi NN}=13.45. The elementary charge ee is taken as 4π/137\sqrt{4\pi/137}. Other coupling constants can be calculated through the partial decay width using the following formulae:

Γ[V→Φγ]=e2gVΦγ212π∣p⃗∣3mV2,(12)\Gamma[V\to\Phi\gamma]=\frac{e^2g_{V\Phi\gamma}^2}{12\pi}\frac{|\vec{p}|^3}{m_V^2}, \tag*{(12)}
Γ[ϕ→ρπ]=e2gϕρπ212π∣p⃗∣3mϕ2,(13)\Gamma[\phi\to\rho\pi]=\frac{e^2g_{\phi\rho\pi}^2}{12\pi}\frac{|\vec{p}|^3}{m_\phi^2}, \tag*{(13)}
Γ[ϕ→a0γ]=e2gϕa0γ212π∣p⃗∣3mϕ2,(14)\Gamma[\phi\to a_0\gamma]=\frac{e^2g_{\phi a_0\gamma}^2}{12\pi}\frac{|\vec{p}|^3}{m_\phi^2}, \tag*{(14)}
Γ[N(1535)→ΦN]=κgϕNN∗24πEN+mNmN∗∣p⃗∣,(15)\Gamma[N(1535)\to\Phi N]=\frac{\kappa g_{\phi NN^*}^2}{4\pi}\frac{E_N+m_N}{m_{N^*}}|\vec{p}|, \tag*{(15)}
Γ[N(1440)→πN]=3gπNN∗24πEN−mNmN∗∣p⃗∣,(16)\Gamma[N(1440)\to\pi N]=\frac{3g_{\pi NN^*}^2}{4\pi}\frac{E_N-m_N}{m_{N^*}}|\vec{p}|, \tag*{(16)}
Γ[N(1520)→πN]=3gπNN∗24πEN−mNmN∗mπ2∣p⃗∣3,(17)\Gamma[N(1520)\to\pi N]=\frac{3g_{\pi NN^*}^2}{4\pi}\frac{E_N-m_N}{m_{N^*}m_\pi^2}|\vec{p}|^3, \tag*{(17)}
Γ[Δ(1232)→πN]=3gπNΔ24πEN+mNmΔmπ2∣p⃗∣3.(18)\Gamma[\Delta(1232)\to\pi N]=\frac{3g_{\pi N\Delta}^2}{4\pi}\frac{E_N+m_N}{m_\Delta m_\pi^2}|\vec{p}|^3. \tag*{(18)}

where ∣p⃗∣|\vec{p}| denotes the magnitude of the three-momentum of the final particles in the center-of-mass (CM) frame. P stands for the π\pi or η\eta meson, and V represents the ρ\rho or ϕ\phi meson. κ\kappa is an isospin factor which equals 11 for the η\eta meson and 33 for the π\pi meson. Using the central values from the PDG[1] for the partial decay widths, the coupling constants are calculated and listed in Tab. I.

Since hadrons are not point-like particles, it is necessary to introduce form factors at the interaction vertices.

StateWidth (Mev)Decay channelAdopt branching ratiog2/4πg^2/4\pi
ρ0\rho^0147.8πγ\pi\gamma4.7×10−44.7 \times10^{-4}2.6×10−22.6 \times10^{-2}
ϕ\phi4.25πγ\pi\gamma1.32×10−31.32 \times10^{-3}1.60×10−31.60 \times10^{-3}
ηγ\eta\gamma1.3×10−21.3 \times10^{-2}3.97×10−23.97 \times10^{-2}
ρπ\rho\pi0.150.326
a0γa_0\gamma7.6×10−57.6 \times10^{-5}0.20
Δ(1232)\Delta(1232)117NπN\pi0.9940.12
N(1440)N(1440)350NπN\pi0.653.37
N(1520)N(1520)110NπN\pi0.600.19
N(1535)N(1535)150NπN\pi0.423.43×10−23.43 \times10^{-2}
NηN\eta0.420.28

Table 1. Coupling constants used in this work. The experimental branch ratios are taken from PDG[1].

For the baryon resonance exchange diagrams, we use the following form factor, as in Refs. [35, 36]:

FB(qex,mex)=ΛB4ΛB4+(qex2−mex2)2.(19)F_B(q_{\mathrm{ex}},m_{\mathrm{ex}})=\frac{\Lambda_B^4}{\Lambda_B^4+(q_{\mathrm{ex}}^2-m_{\mathrm{ex}}^2)^2}. \tag*{(19)}

For the π\pi, η\eta and a0a_0 meson exchanges, we adopt the form factor from Ref. [37]:

FM(qex,mex)=(ΛM2−mM2ΛM2−qex2)2.(20)F_M(q_{\mathrm{ex}},m_{\mathrm{ex}})=\left(\frac{\Lambda_M^2-m_M^2}{\Lambda_M^2-q_{\mathrm{ex}}^2}\right)^2. \tag*{(20)}

For the ρ\rho meson, we use the following form factor from Ref. [38]:

FV(qex)=(ΛV2−mV2ΛV2−qex2)2.(21)F_V(q_{\mathrm{ex}})=\left(\frac{\Lambda_V^2-m_V^2}{\Lambda_V^2-q_{\mathrm{ex}}^2}\right)^2. \tag*{(21)}

Here, qexq_{\mathrm{ex}} and mexm_{\mathrm{ex}} are the four-momentum and mass of the exchanged particle, respectively. For the cutoff parameters, we take Λπ=Λη=1.3\Lambda_\pi=\Lambda_\eta=1.3 GeV and Λρ=1.2\Lambda_\rho=1.2 GeV for meson exchanges [21, 33], and ΛB=2.0\Lambda_B=2.0 GeV [18] for baryon exchanges.

The propagators for the exchanged particles are given as follows. For spin-0 mesons (π\pi and η\eta):

G0(q)=iq2−m2.(22)G_0(q)=\frac{i}{q^2-m^2}. \tag*{(22)}

For spin-1 ρ\rho meson:

G1μν(q)=−i(gμν−qμqν/q2)q2−m2.(23)G_1^{\mu\nu}(q)=-\frac{i(g^{\mu\nu}-q^\mu q^\nu/q^2)}{q^2-m^2}. \tag*{(23)}

For spin-1/2 baryon resonances:

G_{\frac{1}{2}}(q)=\frac{i(\slashed{q}+m)}{q^2-m^2+im\Gamma}. \tag*{(24)}

For the spin-3/2 baryon resonances:

G_{\frac{3}{2}}^{\mu\nu}(q)=\frac{i(\slashed{q}+m)P^{\mu\nu}(q)}{q^2-m^2+im\Gamma}. \tag*{(25)}

with the PμνP^{\mu\nu} given by

Pμν(q)=−gμν+13γμγν+13m(γμqν−γνqμ)+23m2qμqν.(26)P^{\mu\nu}(q)=-g^{\mu\nu}+\frac{1}{3}\gamma^\mu\gamma^\nu+\frac{1}{3m}(\gamma^\mu q^\nu-\gamma^\nu q^\mu)+\frac{2}{3m^2}q^\mu q^\nu. \tag*{(26)}

Here qq, mm, and Γ\Gamma are the four-momentum, mass and width of the exchanged particle, respectively.

Using the above effective Lagrangian densities and propagators, we obtain the scattering amplitudes of the Feynman diagrams shown in Figure 1. Here the momenta of individual particles in the reaction γ(p1)+p(p2)→ϕ(p3)+π(p4)+p(p5)\gamma(p_1)+p(p_2)\to\phi(p_3)+\pi(p_4)+p(p_5) are indicated in parentheses. The corresponding amplitudes involving nucleon resonances (Figure 1a) are

MN∗(1535)=egϕγPgN∗NPgN∗Nπmϕuˉ(p5,s5)G12(qN∗)εμναβp3μεν∗(p3,s3)p1αεβ(p1,s1)FB(qN∗,mN∗)FM(qP,mP)(p3−p1)2−mP2.(27)\mathcal{M}_{N^*(1535)}=\frac{e g_{\phi\gamma P}g_{N^*NP}g_{N^*N\pi}}{m_\phi}\bar{u}(p_5,s_5)G_{\frac{1}{2}}(q_{N^*}) \varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{3\mu}\varepsilon^*_\nu(p_3,s_3)p_{1\alpha}\varepsilon_\beta(p_1,s_1) \frac{F_B(q_{N^*},m_{N^*})F_M(q_P,m_P)}{(p_3-p_1)^2-m_P^2}. \tag*{(27)}
\mathcal{M}_{N^*(1440)}=\frac{e g_{\phi\gamma\pi}g_{N^*N\pi}^2}{m_\phi(m_p+m_{N^*})}\bar{u}(p_5,s_5)\gamma_5\slashed{p}_4G_{\frac{1}{2}}(q_{N^*})\gamma_5(\slashed{p}_3-\slashed{p}_1)u(p_2,s_2)\frac{F_B(q_{N^*},m_{N^*})F_M(q_\pi,m_\pi)}{(p_3-p_1)^2-m_\pi^2}\varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{3\mu}\varepsilon^*_\nu(p_3,s_3)p_{1\alpha}\varepsilon_\beta(p_1,s_1). \tag*{(28)}
MN∗(1520)=egϕγπgN∗Nπ2mϕmπ2uˉ(p5,s5)p4μγ5G32μν(qN∗)γ5(p1−p3)νu(p2,s2)FB(qN∗,mN∗)FM(qP,mP)(p3−p1)2−mP2εμναβp3μεν∗(p3,s3)p1αεβ(p1,s1).(29)\mathcal{M}_{N^*(1520)}=\frac{e g_{\phi\gamma\pi}g_{N^*N\pi}^2}{m_\phi m_\pi^2}\bar{u}(p_5,s_5)p_{4\mu}\gamma_5G_{\frac{3}{2}}^{\mu\nu}(q_{N^*})\gamma_5(p_1-p_3)_\nu u(p_2,s_2)\frac{F_B(q_{N^*},m_{N^*})F_M(q_P,m_P)}{(p_3-p_1)^2-m_P^2}\varepsilon^{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}p_{3\mu}\varepsilon^*_\nu(p_3,s_3)p_{1\alpha}\varepsilon_\beta(p_1,s_1). \tag*{(29)}

where P denotes the exchanged π\pi or η\eta. The amplitudes for the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) production process (Figure 1b) are

MΔπ=2egϕπγgΔNπ2mϕmπ2uˉ(p5,s5)p4μG32μν(qΔ)(p1−p3)νu(p2,s2)FB(qΔ,mΔ)FM(qπ,mπ)(p3−p1)2−mπ2×εμαβγp3μεν∗(p3,s3)p1αεβ(p1,s1),(30)\mathcal{M}_{\Delta}^{\pi}=\frac{2eg_{\phi\pi\gamma}g_{\Delta N\pi}^{2}}{m_{\phi}m_{\pi}^{2}}\bar{u}(p_{5},s_{5})p_{4\mu}G_{\frac{3}{2}}^{\mu\nu}(q_{\Delta})(p_{1}-p_{3})_{\nu}u(p_{2},s_{2})\frac{F_{B}(q_{\Delta},m_{\Delta})F_{M}(q_{\pi},m_{\pi})}{(p_{3}-p_{1})^{2}-m_{\pi}^{2}}\times\varepsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta\gamma}p_{3\mu}\varepsilon_{\nu}^{*}(p_{3},s_{3})p_{1\alpha}\varepsilon_{\beta}(p_{1},s_{1}), \tag*{(30)}
MΔa0=−egϕγa0gΔNa0gΔNπmϕma0mπuˉ(p5,s5)p4μG32μν(qΔ)γ5u(p2,s2)(p1−p3)ν[(p3⋅p1)(ε3∗⋅ε1)−(p3⋅ε1)(p1⋅ε3∗)]×FB(qΔ,mΔ)FM(qa0,ma0)(p3−p1)2−ma02.(31)\mathcal{M}_{\Delta}^{a_{0}}=-\frac{eg_{\phi\gamma a_{0}}g_{\Delta Na_{0}}g_{\Delta N\pi}}{m_{\phi}m_{a_{0}}m_{\pi}}\bar{u}(p_{5},s_{5})p_{4\mu}G_{\frac{3}{2}}^{\mu\nu}(q_{\Delta})\gamma_{5}u(p_{2},s_{2})(p_{1}-p_{3})_{\nu}\left[(p_{3}\cdot p_{1})(\varepsilon_{3}^{*}\cdot\varepsilon_{1})-(p_{3}\cdot\varepsilon_{1})(p_{1}\cdot\varepsilon_{3}^{*})\right]\times\frac{F_{B}(q_{\Delta},m_{\Delta})F_{M}(q_{a_{0}},m_{a_{0}})}{(p_{3}-p_{1})^{2}-m_{a_{0}}^{2}}. \tag*{(31)}

The corresponding amplitude for Figure 1c can be written as

\mathcal{M}_{t}=-\frac{ieg_{\phi\pi\gamma}g_{\pi\rho\gamma}g_{\pi NN}}{2m_{p}m_{\phi}m_{\rho}}\bar{u}(p_{5},s_{5})\gamma_{5}(\slashed{p}_{2}-\slashed{p}_{5})u(p_{2},s_{2})\frac{F_{V}(q_{\rho})F_{M}(q_{\pi},m_{\pi})}{(p_{5}-p_{2})^{2}-m_{\pi}^{2}}\varepsilon^{\mu\alpha\beta\gamma}p_{3\mu}\varepsilon_{\nu}^{*}(p_{3},s_{3})(p_{1}-p_{4})_{\alpha}G_{1,\beta\delta}(p_{4}-p_{1})\varepsilon^{\rho\sigma\gamma\delta}p_{1\rho}\varepsilon_{\sigma}(p_{1},s_{1})(p_{1}-p_{4})_{\gamma}. \tag*{(32)}

With these individual amplitudes, the differential cross section for this reaction is calculated by integrating over the three-body final state phase space:

dσ=141(p1⋅p2)∑spins∣M∣2dΦ3,(33)d\sigma=\frac{1}{4}\frac{1}{(p_{1}\cdot p_{2})}\sum_{\text{spins}}|\mathcal{M}|^{2}d\Phi_{3}, \tag*{(33)}

where the summation is over the final state spins and an average is taken over the initial state spins of the photon and proton. The full scattering amplitude M\mathcal{M} is a coherent sum of the individual amplitudes. The Lorentz-invariant phase space element is given by

dΦ3=(2π)4δ(4)(p1+p2−p3−p4−p5)×d3p3(2π)32E3d3p4(2π)32E4d3p5(2π)32E5.(34)d\Phi_{3}=(2\pi)^{4}\delta^{(4)}(p_{1}+p_{2}-p_{3}-p_{4}-p_{5})\times\frac{d^{3}p_{3}}{(2\pi)^{3}2E_{3}}\frac{d^{3}p_{4}}{(2\pi)^{3}2E_{4}}\frac{d^{3}p_{5}}{(2\pi)^{3}2E_{5}}. \tag*{(34)}

Results and Discussion

Using the formalism from the preceding section, we have calculated the total and differential cross sections. We first consider the case without the a0a_{0} exchange contribution. The results are presented in Figure 2. The figure details the contributions from various resonances and the tt-channel background, showing that the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance production clearly dominates the reaction near the threshold. This dominance is primarily attributed to its large coupling to the NπN\pi channel and its relatively low mass. In contrast, other nucleon resonances

Figure 2. Total cross section as a function of the beam energy EγE_{\gamma} for the γp→ϕπp\gamma p \to\phi\pi p reaction, without considering the a0a_{0} exchange. The contributions from Δ(1232)\Delta(1232), N(1535)N(1535) and N(1520)N(1520), and N(1440)N(1440) are presented by the red-short-dashed, purple-dash-dot-dotted, blue-dash-dotted and brown-dotted lines, respectively. The green-long-dashed line shows the tt-channel background contribution. Their sum is shown by the solid-black line.

and the background term provide only minor contributions at these energies. However, with increasing energy, the roles of the N(1535)N(1535) and N(1520)N(1520) resonances become more significant. Interference effects among the individual amplitudes can be crucial for describing experimental data. In our model, most coupling constants are extracted from experimental decay widths, a method that determines their magnitudes but not their relative signs. Nevertheless, due to the dominance of the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) in the energy region under study, we expect the interference effects to be insignificant. To verify this, we have altered the relative signs of the amplitudes by a factor of −1-1 and observed no significant changes in the results. It is also worth noting that our evaluation of the ϕρπ\phi\rho\pi coupling constant uses the upper limit of the ϕ→ρπ\phi\to\rho\pi branching ratio suggested by the PDG [1]. This implies that the calculated background contribution is likely an upper estimate and could be even smaller in reality.

In Figure 3, we present our model’s predictions for the invariant mass spectra of the pπ0p\pi^{0}, ϕπ0\phi\pi^{0}, and pϕp\phi systems, along with a Dalitz plot of our predictions, versus Mpπ02M_{p\pi^{0}}^{2}, Mϕπ02M_{\phi\pi^{0}}^{2} for the γp→ϕπ0p\gamma p\to\phi\pi^{0}p reaction. In the spectra plots, the solid lines represent the model calculation, while the dotted lines show the phase space distributions for reference. As expected, the most prominent feature of the result is observed in the π0\pi^{0} invariant mass spectrum (Mpπ0M_{p\pi^{0}}, top-right panel). A clear and dominant peak is located at Mpπ0≈1.23M_{p\pi^{0}}\approx1.23 GeV, corresponding to the well-established Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance. This indicates that the reaction proceeds overwhelmingly through the sequential decay channel γp→ϕΔ+→ϕ(pπ0)\gamma p\to\phi\Delta^{+}\to\phi(p\pi^{0}). This conclusion is further supported by the Dalitz plot analysis (bottom-right panel). The plot is dominated by a prominent horizontal band of high event density centered at Mpπ02≈1.5 GeV2M^{2}_{p\pi^{0}} \approx1.5\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2}, which is caused by the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance. The less pronounced structures observed in the invariant mass spectra of the other particle pairs (ϕπ\phi\pi and pϕp\phi) are mainly due to kinematic reflections of the dominant Δ\Delta production process.

Invariant mass spectra and Dalitz plot for the $\gamma p \to \phi\pi p$ reaction

Figure 3. Invariant mass spectra and Dalitz plot for the γp→ϕπp\gamma p \to\phi\pi p reaction. The gray-dotted line in the invariant mass spectra show the corresponding phase space distributions for comparison.

In addition to the invariant mass spectra and the Dalitz plot, we further investigate the reaction dynamics of γp→ϕπ0p\gamma p \to\phi\pi^{0}p by examining the angular distributions of the final-state particles, as shown in Figure 4. In the calculations, the beam direction is taken as the zz-axis.

Angular distributions of the final-state particles

Figure 4. Angular distributions of the final-state particles for the γp→ϕπp\gamma p \to\phi\pi p reaction at Eγ=2.5E_\gamma= 2.5 GeV. The black solid lines are obtained in the center-of-mass frame, taking the direction of the beam momentum as the zz-axis. The red dashed line represents the angular distribution in the πp\pi p rest frame using the Jackson frame. The gray dotted lines show the phase space distributions.

The left panel of Figure 4 displays the differential cross section dσ/dΩd\sigma/d\Omega for the final ϕ\phi as a function of cos⁡θϕ\cos\theta_{\phi}. A prominent forward peak in the CM frame(solid line) is observed, indicating that the ϕ\phi meson is preferentially produced in the direction of the incident photon beam. This forward-scattering behavior is a clear signal of a tt-channel exchange process, which is consistent with the Feynman diagrams considered in our model. This feature can be verified by future experiments.

The middle and right panels of Figure 4 shows the angular distributions of the final π0\pi^{0} and proton, respectively. The solid line, representing the results in the CM frame, shows a prominent backward enhancement. This feature can be attributed to a dominant tt-channel meson exchange mechanism for the production of the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) resonance, which subsequently decays and enhances the π0\pi^{0} and pp yields at the backward angles. The dashed line represents the angular distributions in the pπ0p\pi^{0} rest frame, calculated in the Jackson frame[39], where the zz-axis is aligned with the initial proton’s momentum. It exhibits a characteristic U-shaped, roughly symmetric distribution with a minimum near cos⁡θπ≈0\cos\theta_{\pi} \approx0 or cos⁡θp≈0\cos\theta_{p} \approx0 and maxima in the forward and backward directions. This angular dependence is consistent with the decay of a spin-3/2 particle, i.e., the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232), into a spin-1/2 nucleon and a spin-0 π\pi meson.

Next, we turn to the possible role of the a0a_{0} exchange in this reaction. Evaluating this contribution requires two poorly constrained parameters: the Δ(1232)Na0\Delta(1232)Na_{0} coupling constant, gΔ(1232)Na0g_{\Delta(1232)Na_{0}}, and the cutoff parameter in the form factor. To date, both parameters are not well-established in the literature. It is possible to extract gΔ(1232)Na0g_{\Delta(1232)Na_{0}} from experimental data on the π+p→Δ(1232)++η\pi^{+}p \to\Delta(1232)^{++}\eta reaction, where tt-channel a0a_{0} exchange is expected to contribute. However, this approach is unfeasible due to the significant uncertainties in the available data measured in the late 1970s[40] and the limited knowledge of competing ss-channel processes, which involve the poorly known Δ∗Δη\Delta^{*}\Delta\eta couplings. A reliable determination of gΔ(1232)Na0g_{\Delta(1232)Na_{0}} is therefore not possible through this channel at present.

Given these challenges, we choose to estimate the impact of the a0a_{0} exchange by relating its strength to the well-known π0\pi^{0} exchange contribution in this reaction.

Using a cutoff of Λa0=1.3\Lambda_{a_0}=1.3 GeV, we examine three scenarios by varying the coupling constant gΔ(1232)Na0g_{\Delta(1232)Na_0}. Specifically, the values gΔ(1232)Na0=20.8g_{\Delta(1232)Na_0}=20.8, 9.3, and 2.9 are chosen such that the a0a_0 exchange contribution is roughly 1/2, 1/10, and 1/100 of the π0\pi^0 exchange contribution, respectively. We have verified that even with the largest adopted value, gΔ(1232)Na0=20.8g_{\Delta(1232)Na_0}=20.8, the resulting a0a_0 exchange contribution to the π+p→ηΔ++\pi^+p\to\eta\Delta^{++} reaction is compatible with current experimental data, given the aforementioned uncertainties.

With these assumptions about the magnitude of the a0a_0 exchange contribution, we can estimate its effects on various observables. To identify the role of the a0a_0 exchange in this reaction experimentally, it is essential to find an observable that can distinguish between different meson exchange contributions. According to the pioneering works in Refs. [27, 28], the parity asymmetry was found to be suitable for distinguishing between natural and unnatural parity meson exchange contributions. In Ref. [29], it was shown that this observable can be used to identify the scalar meson exchange contribution. The parity asymmetry is defined by the SDMEs as

Pσ=2ρ1−11−ρ001.(35)P_\sigma= 2\rho^{1}_{1-1} - \rho^{1}_{00}. \tag*{(35)}

In Refs. [27, 28], it was shown that for the γN→VN\gamma N\to VN reaction, the parity asymmetry PσP_\sigma equals 1 and −1-1 for natural and unnatural parity exchanges, respectively. Since the scalar meson a0a_0 has natural parity and the pseudoscalar meson π(η)\pi(\eta) has unnatural parity, it is possible to distinguish their contributions by measuring this observable. It is worth noting that one difference between our work and the works in Ref. [27, 28, 29] is that our model includes baryon resonances in the intermediate state. However, the aforementioned features of PσP_\sigma determined solely by the ϕ\phi-γ\gamma-Meson vertex when only scalar or pseudoscalar meson exchanges are involved. Therefore, one may expect these features to persist in our case. This argument can be verified by the numerical calculations.

In the left panel of Figure 5, we present the predictions for the PσP_\sigma with gΔ(1232)Na0=20.8g_{\Delta(1232)Na_0}=20.8 (black solid line), 9.3 (blue dashed line), and 2.9 (purple dotted line), respectively. For gΔ(1232)Na0=20.8g_{\Delta(1232)Na_0}=20.8, the PσP_\sigma is positive at backward angles, starting at about 0.1 at cos⁡θϕ=−1\cos\theta_{\phi}=-1. As cos⁡θϕ\cos\theta_{\phi} increasing, the PσP_{\sigma} decreases gradually and reaches about −0.8-0.8 at cos⁡θϕ=1\cos\theta_{\phi}=1. This feature can be understood by studying the angular distribution of ϕ\phi in the center of mass frame caused by the π\pi and a0a_{0} exchanges, which are shown in the right panel of Figure 5. As can be seen from the figure, the π\pi exchange (black solid line) causes a prominent forward enhancement, while the a0a_{0} exchange (red dashed line) causes a slight backward enhancement. The backward enhancement for the a0a_{0} exchange can be attributed to the relatively large mass of a0a_{0} and the D-wave nature of the Δ(1232)Na0\Delta(1232)Na_{0} coupling. This difference makes the a0a_{0} exchange contribution more important at backward angles. Therefore, the a0a_{0} exchange effect is best probed at backward angles in experiments.

Figure 5. Left: Predictions for the PσP_\sigma asymmetry versus cos⁡θϕ\cos\theta_\phi in the center-of-mass frame, with the direction of the beam momentum as the zz-axis. The lines correspond to different values of the coupling constant gΔ(1232)Na0g_{\Delta(1232)Na_0}: 20.8 (black solid line), −20.8-20.8 (green dash-dot-dotted line), 9.3 (blue dashed line), 2.9 (purple dotted line), and 0 (red dash-dotted line). Right: Individual contributions to the ϕ\phi angular distribution in the center-of-mass frame. The black solid line represents the a0a_0 exchange contribution (with gΔ(1232)Na0=20.8g_{\Delta(1232)Na_0}=20.8), and the red dashed line represents the π\pi exchange contribution.

If we take gΔ(1232)Na0=9.3g_{\Delta(1232)Na_{0}}=9.3 (blue dashed line), the a0a_{0} exchange contribution is significantly smaller than that of the π\pi exchange. In this case, PσP_{\sigma} ranges from about −0.5-0.5 at the most backward angles to −0.9-0.9 at the most forward angles. When the coupling is further reduced to gΔ(1232)Na0=2.9g_{\Delta(1232)Na_{0}}=2.9 (purple dotted line), PσP_{\sigma} varies from approximately −0.98-0.98 to −1-1, closely matching the value of −1-1 (red dash-dotted line) expected for an almost pure unnatural-parity exchange (e.g., the dominant π\pi exchange). These findings highlight PσP_{\sigma} as a valuable tool for identifying the a0a_{0} exchange contribution in this reaction. It is important to note that the foregoing analysis does not incorporate uncertainties stemming from potential interference effects. To offer a preliminary assessment of these effects, we also computed the result with gΔ(1232)Na0=−20.8g_{\Delta(1232)Na_{0}}=-20.8 (green dash-dot-dotted line).

This calculation indicates that interference effects on the overall result are relatively weak. Nevertheless, if the Δ(1232)Na0\Delta(1232)Na_{0} coupling is very weak, for instance, on the order of gΔ(1232)Na0=2.9g_{\Delta(1232)Na_{0}}=2.9 or smaller, the uncertainties in the analysis may make it challenging to discern the a0a_{0} exchange contribution and extract the coupling constant. In such cases, only an upper limit for this coupling might be estimable.

Summary

In this work, we investigate the γp→ϕπp\gamma p \to\phi\pi p reaction using an effective Lagrangian approach. This analysis includes contributions from the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232), N(1440)N(1440), N(1535)N(1535) and N(1520)N(1520) in the intermediate state and the background term. Our results show that the production of the Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) dominates this reaction in the near threshold region. Particularly, we examine the potential role of the a0(980)a_{0}(980) exchange in Δ(1232)\Delta(1232) excitation. We demonstrate that the parity asymmetry PσP_{\sigma} serves as an effective observable for identifying scalar exchange contributions and can be used to study the Δ(1232)Na0\Delta(1232)Na_{0} coupling in this reaction.

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge the supports from the Natural Science Foundation of Shaanxi Province under Grants No.2024JC-YBMS-010.

References

  1. [1]S. Navas et al. [Particle Data Group], Phys. Rev. D 110, no.3, 030001 (2024).
  2. [2]J. j. Xie, C. Wilkin and B. s. Zou, Phys. Rev. C 77, 058202 (2008).
  3. [3]A. Thiel, F. Afzal and Y. Wunderlich, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 125, 103949 (2022).
  4. [4]V. I. Mokeev et al. [CLAS], Few Body Syst. 63, no.3, 59 (2022).
  5. [5]D. G. Ireland, E. Pasyuk and I. Strakovsky, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 111, 103752 (2020).
  6. [6]V. D. Burkert, Few Body Syst. 59, 57 (2018).
  7. [7]A. V. Anisovich et al. , Eur. Phys. J. A53, 242 (2017).
  8. [8]P.T. Mattione et al. (CLAS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. C96, 035204 (2017).
  9. [9]Kamano. H. et al. , Phys. Rev. C88, 035209 (2013).
  10. [10]Ralf W. Gothe, Viktor Mokeev and Elena Santopinto, Few Body Syst. 57, 869 (2016).
  11. [11]V. Schmieden et al. [CBELSA/TAPS], Eur. Phys. J. A 51, no.8, 95 (2015) [erratum: Eur. Phys. J. A 51, no.12, 187 (2015)].
  12. [12]M. Dieterle et al. [A2], Eur. Phys. J. A 51, no.11, 142 (2015).
  13. [13]E. Gutz et al. [CBELSA/TAPS], Eur. Phys. J. A 50, 74 (2014).
  14. [14]A. Käser et al. [A2], Eur. Phys. J. A 52, no.9, 272 (2016).
  15. [15]V. Sokhoyan et al. [A2], Phys. Rev. C 97, no.5, 055212 (2018).
  16. [16]S. Lombardo et al. [CLAS], Phys. Rev. D 98, no.5, 052009 (2018).
  17. [17]E. Golovatch et al. [CLAS], Phys. Lett. B 788, 371-379 (2019).
  18. [18]Q. F. Lv, R. Wang, J. J. Xie and X. R. Chen, Phys. Rev. C 91, 035204 (2015).
  19. [19]T. Inoue, E. Oset and J. Vicente, Phys. Rev. C 65, 035204 (2002).
  20. [20]B. C. Liu and B. S. Zou, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 042002 (2006).
  21. [21]B. C. Liu and S. F. Chen, Phys. Rev. C96, 054001 (2017).
  22. [22]J. Q. Fan, S. F. Chen and B. C. Liu, Phys. Rev. C 99, no.2, 025203 (2019).
  23. [23]S. F. Chen and B. C. Liu, Phys. Rev. C 102, no.2, 025202 (2020).
  24. [24]C. G. Zhao, G. Y. Wang, G. N. Li, E. Wang and D. M. Li, Phys. Rev. D 99, no.11, 114014 (2019).
  25. [25]M. Y. Dai, S. W. Liu, C. Chen, D. M. Li, E. Wang and J. J. Xie, Chin. Phys. C 49, no.6, 063102 (2025).
  26. [26]Yu. S. Kalashnikova et al. , Eur. Phys. J. A24, 437 (2005).
  27. [27]G. Cohen-Tannoudji, Ph. Salin and A. Morel, Nuovo Cimento 55, 412 (1968).
  28. [28]K. Schilling, P. Seyboth and G. Wolf, Nucl. Phys. B15, 397(1970); B18, 332(E) (1970).
  29. [29]Y. Oh and H. Kim, Phys. Rev. C73, 065202 (2006).
  30. [30]S. H. Hwang et al.(LEPS Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 092001 (2012).
  31. [31]Je-Hee Lee et al., TPEP 2017 no.9, 093D05 (2017).
  32. [32]B. S. Zou and F. Hussain, phys. Rev. c67, 015204 (2003).
  33. [33]J. J. Xie, B. S. Zou and H. C. Chiang, Phys. Rev. C 77, 015206 (2008).
  34. [34]J. J. Xie, B. C. Liu and C. S. An, Phys. Rev. C88, 015203 (2013).
  35. [35]B. C. Liu and J. J. Xie, Phys. Rev. C85, 038201 (2012).
  36. [36]V. Shklyar, H. Lenske and U. Mosel, Phys. Rev. C72, 015210 (2005).
  37. [37]Y. Oh, C. M. Ko and K. Nakayama, Phys. Rev. C77, 045204 (2008).
  38. [38]K. Nakayama, Y. Oh and H. Haberzettl, J. Kor. Phys. Soc. 59, 224 (2011).
  39. [39]J. D. Jackson, Nuovo Cim. 34, 1644-1666 (1964).
  40. [40]D. Grether, G. Gidal and G. Borreani, Phys. Rev. D 7, 3200-3212 (1973).

Paper details

vlnc:W_sahyhmfa
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents