betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Lean-Verified No-Go Theorems for RR-Symmetries and Modular Symmetries in 4D GUTs

Abstract

RR-symmetries are instrumental in supersymmetric model building. However, a no-go theorem restricts us from using them in a large class of four-dimensional (4D) grand unified theories (GUTs). Specifically, it has been shown that a supersymmetric 4D GUT based on SU(5), with finitely many chiral multiplets, cannot be broken spontaneously to the exact minimal supersymmetric standard model (MSSM) while preserving a discrete ZMR\mathbb{Z}_M^R, with M≥3M \geq 3, or continuous U(1) RR-symmetry. We use Lean 4 to formalize this proof. In the process, we identify and close a gap in the general case of the published argument. Further, we discuss the implications for GUT models with modular symmetries. We point out that modular symmetries are inevitably RR-symmetries in a supersymmetric framework that also describes gravity. At certain critical points in moduli space, discrete RR-symmetries are linearly realized. In the context of 4D GUTs, the no-go theorem then implies that exotic states become massless at these points, provided the GUT-breaking vacuum preserves these symmetries. In the vicinity of these critical points, these exotics are parametrically light, which may spoil gauge coupling unification.

Introduction

Lean has revolutionized mathematics [1, 2, 3, 4]. This is because Lean allows us to formalize proofs, and check them automatically. Modern artificial intelligence (AI) agents are fluent in the Lean 4 syntax, and can even develop proofs. When applied to physics, arguably this development has not yet fully taken off. On the other hand, checking proofs is a very relevant task since theorems in the physics literature have been found to be not entirely correct when their proofs were formalized [5]. These results were obtained using PhysLib [6, 7]. The main purpose of this work is to use Lean 4 to check, and extend, the proof of a no-go theorem [8] in the physics literature.

This theorem concerns RR-symmetries and grand unified theories (GUTs). RR-symmetries are instrumental in supersymmetric model building. For instance, they can be argued to be essential to address the μ\mu problem [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14] in the minimal supersymmetric standard model (MSSM). four-dimensional (4D) supersymmetry (SUSY) GUTs (see e.g. [15] for a review) are popular not only because they are motivated by the fact that gauge couplings unify in the MSSM [16] but also because matter furnishes complete SU(5) representations. However, there is an obstruction that limits the use of RR-symmetries in 4D GUTs. In [8] it was shown that a 4D GUT with a simple gauge group cannot yield the exact MSSM together with an unbroken or U(1)RU(1)_R symmetry. This means that,if the GUT model has an RR-symmetry, there are certain exotic states the mass of which is tied to the scale of RR-symmetry breakdown.

This paper has two purposes. The first is to make the theorem fully rigorous by formalizing it in the Lean 4 proof assistant on top of Mathlib [17]. Even though PhysLib, which was used in [5], has extended group-theory capabilities [18], we work directly with Lean 4 [19]. As we shall see in § 2 and appendix B, this leads to a somewhat shorter proof than the one provided in [8]. It also closes a gap in the general case of the published argument, see § 3.1.

The second purpose is to discuss the implications for modular symmetries, which are RR-symmetries in the supergravity (SUGRA) framework [20, 21]. At certain critical points in moduli space, discrete RR-symmetries are linearly realized. The no-go theorem then implies that, in the context of 4D GUTs, at these points exotic states beyond the MSSM become massless.

The outline of the rest of the paper is as follows. In § 2, we state the abstract no-go theorem, and we prove it. In Section 3, we apply the no-go theorem to ZMRZ_M^R symmetries in SU(5) GUTs, and we compare the formalized proof with the original one. Section 4 is devoted to the extension of the results to larger gauge groups. In § 5, we explain how higher-dimensional models of grand unification evade the no-go theorem. § 6 discusses modular symmetries, which are RR-symmetries in SUGRA. There we identify the modular RR-symmetries that are linearly realized, and we discuss modular zeros, which can forbid mass terms even if no such symmetry is present. Finally, § 7 contains our concluding remarks. Details of how we use Lean are deferred to two appendices. In Appendix § 8, we summarize what has been formalized in Lean, and what has been assumed. Appendix § 9 contains the central parts of the Lean code.

No-Go Theorem

In this section, we develop a more general version of the no-go theorem as given in [8], using some key observations from [22]. This general proof, verified in Lean 4, is then used to show that a 4D N=1N = 1 GUT with gauge group SU(5) cannot have both an unbroken discrete RR-symmetry, ZMRZ_M^R, with M≠1,2M \ne1, 2 and a massless spectrum consisting only of the MSSM field content plus gauge singlets. We then comment on the extension of the no-go proof to larger GUT gauge groups, and on how higher-dimensional GUTs avoid the no-go theorem.

Setting, Notation, and Hypotheses

Consider a 4D GUT with gauge group GG, where GG is a compact connected Lie group. Let G0⊆GG_0 \subseteq G be the closed connected subgroup left unbroken by the vacuum. We will denote the maximal torus of G0G_0 as T0T_0, and we denote the set of roots of G0G_0, i.e. the non-zero T0T_0-weights of g0⊗C\mathfrak{g}_0 \otimes\mathbb{C}, as Δ0=Δ(G0,T0)\Delta_0 = \Delta(G_0,T_0). Note in particular that we do not assume rank G0=rank⁡GG_0 = \operatorname{rank} G, which will be crucial in extending our results beyond SU(5) GUT gauge groups later.

Let S\mathcal{S} be the group of linear symmetries of the microscopic theory that commute with GG, which includes RR-symmetries that act on the superspace coordinates θ\theta. The vacuum in general is not preserved by all of G×SG \times\mathcal{S}. We define Σ0⊆G×S\Sigma_0 \subseteq G \times\mathcal{S} as the subgroup of G×SG \times\mathcal{S} that leaves the vacuum invariant. The theorem we develop will apply to any unbroken symmetry element r∈Σ0r \in\Sigma_0, whose action on θ\theta generically multiplies θ\theta by a phase ζ\zeta. We assume that ζ2≠1\zeta^2 \ne1 since the transformation that sends all spinors and θ\theta to their negatives is a symmetry of any relativistic quantum field theory (QFT), and not a nontrivial RR-symmetry, see also Footnote 4. We further define BB as a closed connected subgroup of GG, with G0⊆B⊆GG_0 \subseteq B \subseteq G, that commutes with rr. Since BB and rr commute, they will share a simultaneous eigenspace, which will prove useful later.

The centralizer and normalizer of T0T_0 in BB are given as

CB(T0)={b∈B∣btb−1=t ∀t∈T0},(1)C_B(T_0) = \{b \in B \mid b t b^{-1} = t \ \forall t \in T_0\}, \tag*{(1)}
NB(T0)={b∈B∣bT0b−1=T0},(2)N_B(T_0) = \{b \in B \mid b T_0 b^{-1} = T_0\}, \tag*{(2)}

respectively. In words, the centralizer CB(T0)C_B(T_0) of T0T_0 in BB consists of the elements b∈Bb \in B that commute with all of T0T_0. The normalizer NB(T0)N_B(T_0) of T0T_0 in BB consists of the elements b∈Bb \in B that map T0T_0 back to itself. That is, the normalizer permutes the T0T_0-weights, while elements of CB(T0)C_B(T_0) commute with all of T0T_0 and leave every weight fixed. Two normalizer elements that differ by a centralizer element then permute the weights in the same way. Therefore, the part of the Weyl group that preserves the torus of G0G_0 is given by

Weyl⁡(B,T0)=NB(T0)/CB(T0),(3)\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0) = N_B(T_0)/C_B(T_0), \tag*{(3)}
(w⋅χ)(t)=χ(n−1tn),w∈Weyl⁡(B,T0).(4)(w \cdot\chi)(t) = \chi(n^{-1}tn), \qquad w \in\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0). \tag*{(4)}

Here, n∈NB(T0)n \in N_B(T_0) represents ww as a coset representative1, χ\chi is a T0T_0-weight, and t∈T0t \in T_0. This reduces to the ordinary Weyl group of GG when T0T_0 is the maximal torus2 of GG and B=GB = G. Since CB(T0)C_B(T_0) is connected,3 we can give a more concrete expression for Weyl⁡(B,T0)\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0) in terms of a maximal torus TBT_B of BB containing T0T_0 as

Weyl⁡(B,T0)={w∈Weyl⁡(B,TB)∣w t0=t0}∣t0.(5)\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0) = \{w \in\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_B) \mid w\,\mathfrak{t}_0 = \mathfrak{t}_0\}\big|_{\mathfrak{t}_0}. \tag*{(5)}

This just says that in practice we can take the ordinary Weyl group of BB, keep only the elements that map the Lie algebra t0\mathfrak{t}_0 of T0T_0 to itself, and then restrict them to t0\mathfrak{t}_0.

We now split the massless fermions in the spectrum based on the action of rr. We take rr to act linearly and unitarily on all fields. If rr acts on the scalar of a chiral multiplet by ξ\xi, it acts on the fermion in the same multiplet by ξζ−1\xi\zeta^{-1}. On the gauginos of BB sitting in vector multiplets, rr acts by ζ\zeta. Define F±\mathcal{F}_{\pm} as the ζ±1\zeta^{\pm1}-eigenspaces of rr on fermions. Then, F−\mathcal{F}_{-} consists of fermions whose scalar partner is rr-invariant, and F+\mathcal{F}_{+} consists of those whose scalar partner has eigenvalue ζ2\zeta^2, together with the BB gauginos. For the case that rr is a pure ZMR\mathbb{Z}_M^R element with ξ=ζq\xi= \zeta^q, the fermion has RR-charge f=q−1f = q - 1. F−\mathcal{F}_{-} then consists of the fermions of RR-charge 0 multiplets, and F+\mathcal{F}_{+} consists of the fermions of RR-charge 2 multiplets plus all gauginos.

We now state the following hypotheses we will make use of throughout our argument:

(A1) GG is compact and connected, with G0G_0, T0T_0, and Δ0\Delta_0 as defined above.

(A2) rr is a microscopic symmetry, i.e. it acts on the full field content, not just light fields, and is linear, unitary, unbroken, and satisfies ζ2≠1\zeta^2 \ne1.

(A3) rr commutes with a closed connected subgroup BB with G0⊆B⊆GG_0 \subseteq B \subseteq G. The direct product case where rr commutes with GG is B=GB = G. Commuting with BB excludes outer-automorphism actions.

(A4) By definition, the vacuum is invariant under Σ0\Sigma_0, with G0⊆Σ0G_0 \subseteq\Sigma_0 and r∈Σ0r \in\Sigma_0. Therefore, the fermion mass bilinear mm, a symmetric bilinear form on the fermion space F\mathcal{F}, is G0G_0- and rr-invariant.

(A5) There are finitely many fields, so F\mathcal{F} is a finite-dimensional unitary GG-representation, i.e. chiral fermions in GG-multiplets plus gauginos in ad⁡G\operatorname{ad}G.

Intermediate Results

To proceed to a statement of the no-go theorem and its proof, we first note a few intermediate results.

Here, we make use of our earlier observation that since BB and rr commute, they share a simultaneous eigenspace. The fermion space F\mathcal{F} splits into rr-eigenspaces, which we label as Fλ\mathcal{F}_\lambda. Since rr is unitary and commutes with BB, each Fλ\mathcal{F}_\lambda is also a BB-representation. It is useful to also construct the spaces Fλ(χ)\mathcal{F}_\lambda(\chi) in the following manner. Recall that since G0⊆BG_0 \subseteq B, BB contains the maximal torus of G0G_0, i.e. T0T_0. We can then take the spaces Fλ\mathcal{F}_\lambda, which are necessarily BB-representations, and split them further into T0T_0-weight spaces. We denote the Fλ\mathcal{F}_\lambda space with T0T_0-weight χ\chi as Fλ(χ)\mathcal{F}_\lambda(\chi). That is, rr acts on states in Fλ(χ)\mathcal{F}_\lambda(\chi) by multiplying by λ\lambda, while t∈T0t \in T_0 acts on states by the phase χ(t)\chi(t).

Invariance of the vacuum under Σ0\Sigma_0, Assumption (A4), requires m(rψa,rψb)=m(ψa,ψb)m(r\psi_a,r\psi_b)=m(\psi_a,\psi_b), i.e. m(ψa,ψb)=λaλbm(ψa,ψb)m(\psi_a,\psi_b)=\lambda_a\lambda_bm(\psi_a,\psi_b) for states ψa∈Fλa\psi_a \in\mathcal{F}_{\lambda_a} and ψb∈Fλb\psi_b \in\mathcal{F}_{\lambda_b}. Equality of both sides implies that mm pairs Fλ\mathcal{F}_\lambda only with Fλ−1\mathcal{F}_{\lambda^{-1}}. By Assumption (A2), ζ−1≠ζ\zeta^{-1} \ne\zeta, so mm vanishes on F+×F+\mathcal{F}_+ \times\mathcal{F}_+, and pairs F−\mathcal{F}_- only with F+\mathcal{F}_+. In particular, gaugino Majorana masses, which would live in F+×F+\mathcal{F}_+ \times\mathcal{F}_+, are forbidden. On F−⊕F+\mathcal{F}_- \oplus\mathcal{F}_+ the mass matrix is given by

\begin{pmatrix} 0 & \mathfrak{M} \\ \mathfrak{M}^{\mathsf{T}} & 0 \end{pmatrix}, \qquad\mathfrak{M}:\mathcal{F}_- \to\mathcal{F}_+^\vee, \qquad\mathfrak{M}(\psi)=m(\psi,\cdot), \tag*{(6)}\end{pmatrix}

where F+∨\mathcal{F}_+^\vee denotes the dual space to F+\mathcal{F}_+. This sector decouples from the other sectors, and its zero modes are ker⁡M⊕ker⁡MT\ker\mathfrak{M} \oplus\ker\mathfrak{M}^{\mathsf{T}} with dim⁡ker⁡MT=dim⁡coker⁡M\dim\ker\mathfrak{M}^{\mathsf{T}} = \dim\operatorname{coker}\mathfrak{M}.

Restricted to T0⊆G0T_0 \subseteq G_0, F±\mathcal{F}_\pm and F+∨\mathcal{F}_+^\vee split into T0T_0-weight spaces as discussed earlier. T0T_0-invariance of mm says that m(F−(χ),F+(χ′))=0m(\mathcal{F}_-(\chi),\mathcal{F}_+(\chi'))=0 unless χ+χ′=0\chi+\chi'=0. Therefore, M\mathfrak{M} decomposes in blocks as M=⨁χMχ\mathfrak{M}=\bigoplus_\chi\mathfrak{M}_\chi with

Mχ:F−(χ)→F+(−χ)∨.(7)\mathfrak{M}_\chi:\mathcal{F}_-(\chi)\to\mathcal{F}_+(-\chi)^\vee. \tag*{(7)}

We define L−(χ)=dim⁡ker⁡MχL_-(\chi)=\dim\ker\mathfrak{M}_\chi, i.e. the number of massless ζ−1\zeta^{-1}-eigenspace fermions at weight χ\chi, L+(−χ)=dim⁡coker⁡MχL_+(-\chi)=\dim\operatorname{coker}\mathfrak{M}_\chi, i.e. the number of massless ζ+1\zeta^{+1}-eigenspace fermions at weight −χ-\chi, and

ind⁡Mχ=L−(χ)−L+(−χ).(8)\operatorname{ind}\mathfrak{M}_\chi=L_-(\chi)-L_+(-\chi). \tag*{(8)}

For an RR-symmetry such as ZMR\mathbb{Z}_M^R or U(1)R\mathrm{U}(1)_R with superpotential RR-charge 2, L−(χ)L_-(\chi) counts the massless fermions of weight χ\chi from RR-charge 0 multiplets, whereas L+(−χ)L_+(-\chi) counts the massless fermions of weight −χ-\chi from RR-charge 2 multiplets together with the massless gauginos of weight −χ-\chi. By rank-nullity, with s=rank⁡Mχs=\operatorname{rank}\mathfrak{M}_\chi we have

ind⁡Mχ=(dim⁡F−(χ)−s)−(dim⁡F+(−χ)−s)=dim⁡F−(χ)−dim⁡F+(−χ).(9)\operatorname{ind}\mathfrak{M}_\chi=(\dim\mathcal{F}_-(\chi)-s)-(\dim\mathcal{F}_+(-\chi)-s)=\dim\mathcal{F}_-(\chi)-\dim\mathcal{F}_+(-\chi). \tag*{(9)}

Note that this corresponds to the cancellation of massive pairs in the arguments of [22].

Now let VV be a finite-dimensional BB-representation, n∈NB(T0)n\in N_B(T_0), and V(χ):={v∈V∣tv=χ(t)v ∀t∈T0}V(\chi):=\{v\in V\mid t v=\chi(t)v\ \forall t\in T_0\}. Then, for v∈V(χ)v\in V(\chi),

t(nv)=n(n−1tn)v=χ(n−1tn)nv=(w⋅χ)(t)nv,(10)t(nv)=n(n^{-1}tn)v=\chi(n^{-1}tn)nv=(w\cdot\chi)(t)nv, \tag*{(10)}

where the second equality uses that n−1tn∈T0n^{-1}tn\in T_0 for n∈NB(T0)n\in N_B(T_0), by definition. The third equality rewrites the conjugation of tt by nn as the action of an element w∈Weyl⁡(B,T0)w\in\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0) on the weight χ\chi. We can then conclude that nV(χ)⊆V(w⋅χ)nV(\chi)\subseteq V(w\cdot\chi). Repeating the argument for n−1n^{-1} shows n−1V(w⋅χ)⊆V(χ)n^{-1}V(w\cdot\chi)\subseteq V(\chi), so that nV(χ)=V(w⋅χ)nV(\chi)=V(w\cdot\chi) and dim⁡V(χ)=dim⁡V(w⋅χ)\dim V(\chi)=\dim V(w\cdot\chi). Applying this to V=F±V=\mathcal{F}_\pm and using (7), we find

ind⁡Mw⋅χ=ind⁡Mχ∀w∈Weyl⁡(B,T0).(11)\operatorname{ind}\mathfrak{M}_{w\cdot\chi}=\operatorname{ind}\mathfrak{M}_\chi\qquad\forall w\in\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0). \tag*{(11)}

Note that M\mathfrak{M} itself is only G0G_0-equivariant, and the invariance above comes from (7), which involves only the dimensions of BB-representations.

The No-Go Theorem and Its Proof

Theorem 1 (Abstract no-go theorem). Assume (A1)–(A5) within a 4D N=1\mathcal{N}=1 GUT. Let β∈Δ0\beta\in\Delta_0 and w∈Weyl⁡(B,T0)w \in\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0) with wβ∉Δ0w\beta\notin\Delta_0 (so β\beta, wβ≠0w\beta\ne0). Suppose that for χ∈{β,wβ}\chi\in\{\beta,w\beta\}

(a) L−(χ)=0L_-(\chi)=0, i.e. no massless ζ−1\zeta^{-1}-eigenspace fermion has weight β\beta or wβw\beta,

(b) L+(−χ)=dim⁡(g0⊗C)−χL_+(-\chi)=\dim(\mathfrak{g}_0\otimes\mathbb{C})_{-\chi}, i.e. the massless ζ+1\zeta^{+1}-eigenspace fermions at −β-\beta and −wβ-w\beta are exactly the G0G_0 gauginos there, so no massless chiral ζ+1\zeta^{+1}-eigenspace fermion, and no massless broken-generator gaugino,

then the index identity (11) is violated, i.e. such a massless spectrum cannot occur. Equivalently, there must be additional massless fermions at weight ±β\pm\beta or ±wβ\pm w\beta.

Proof. Since Δ0=−Δ0\Delta_0=-\Delta_0 and root spaces are one-dimensional, dim⁡(g0⊗C)−β=1\dim(\mathfrak{g}_0\otimes\mathbb{C})_{-\beta}=1, and dim⁡(g0⊗C)−wβ=0\dim(\mathfrak{g}_0\otimes\mathbb{C})_{-w\beta}=0 because −wβ∉Δ0-w\beta\notin\Delta_0, as wβ∉Δ0w\beta\notin\Delta_0 and Δ0=−Δ0\Delta_0=-\Delta_0. We also have that −wβ≠0-w\beta\ne0. Then,

ind⁡Mβ=0−1=−1,ind⁡Mwβ=0−0=0,(12)\operatorname{ind}\mathcal{M}_{\beta}=0-1=-1,\qquad\operatorname{ind}\mathcal{M}_{w\beta}=0-0=0, \tag*{(12)}

contradicting (11). □

The Lean formalization of this proof is summarized in Appendix § 8, with the relevant code presented in Appendix § 9.

Implications of the Theorem

In the following sections, we will apply this theorem to 4D N=1\mathcal{N}=1 GUT models. In this process, we will first identify the data GG, G0G_0, T0T_0, Δ0\Delta_0, rr, BB, and Weyl⁡(B,T0)\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0). Then, we verify that the hypotheses (A1)–(A5) are satisfied. Next, we identify the relevant F±\mathcal{F}_{\pm} sectors, and determine whether there are β\beta and ww that we can use to derive the contradiction. Such a pair exists if and only if Δ0\Delta_0 is not stable under Weyl⁡(B,T0)\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0). In words, this means there exists some element of the Weyl group that preserves the torus of G0G_0 and maps an unbroken root to a weight that is a broken root. In practice, we can construct Weyl⁡(B,T0)\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0) using Equation (5) and then test the stability of Δ0\Delta_0 under Weyl⁡(B,T0)\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0). We will see that the theorem of [8] follows. We will also discuss, using key insights from [22], how higher-dimensional models of grand unification evade this theorem.

Application of the No-Go Theorem to ZMR\mathbb{Z}^{R}_{M} Symmetries in SU(5) GUTs

Let us consider a 4D N=1\mathcal{N}=1 supersymmetric SU(5) GUT. We assume that there are finitely many multiplets, cf. Assumption (A5). Suppose that the vacuum leaves GSMG_{\mathrm{SM}} unbroken, and also an element rRr_R of an unbroken ZMR\mathbb{Z}^{R}_{M} symmetry, where the action of rRr_R on the superspace coordinates is the phase ζ=e2πi/M\zeta=e^{2\pi i/M}. In particular, ζ2≠1\zeta^2\ne1, so M∉{1,2}M\notin\{1,2\}.4 The inputs to the abstract no-go theorem are G=B=SU(5)G=B=\mathrm{SU}(5) and G0=GSMG_0=G_{\mathrm{SM}}. T0T_0 is the diagonal torus and is maximal in both G0G_0 and G=BG=B, so Weyl⁡(B,T0)=S5\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0)=S_5, the Weyl group of SU(5). Let us further denote the fundamental weights by eie_i. Roots are then given as differences of weights, ei−eje_i-e_j. Δ0\Delta_0 are the roots of G0=GSMG_0=G_{\mathrm{SM}}, which with color indices {0,1,2}\{0,1,2\} and weak indices {3,4}\{3,4\}. corresponds to the roots ei−eje_i-e_j of SU(5) where both i,ji,j are in {0,1,2}\{0,1,2\} or {3,4}\{3,4\}. There are 8 unbroken roots, and the other 12 correspond to the roots for the heavy leptoquark gauge bosons VV of SU(5). By assumption, the ZMR\mathbb{Z}^{R}_{M} is unbroken by the vacuum, so the vacuum is invariant under the action of both G0=GSMG_0=G_{\mathrm{SM}} and rRr_R. One can then verify that all of this input data satisfies the assumptions (A1)–(A5). Now we identify a pair of roots, {β,wβ}\{\beta, w\beta\}, that will lead to a contradiction. The element w=(1 3)w=(1\ 3) of S5S_5 sends the gluon root β=e0−e1\beta=e_0-e_1 to the VV root wβ=e0−e3w\beta=e_0-e_3, with β∈Δ0\beta\in\Delta_0 and wβ∉Δ0w\beta\notin\Delta_0. Next, we input a light chiral spectrum and check if such a spectrum is inconsistent with the existence of the unbroken ZMRZ_M^R in the GUT. Let us assume the light spectrum is the MSSM, possibly with additional gauge singlets. Recall that L−(χ)L_-(\chi) with χ∈{β,wβ}\chi\in\{\beta,w\beta\} denotes the number of massless fermions of weight χ\chi and RR-charge −1-1. The gauginos transform under rRr_R in the same way as the θ\theta superspace coordinates, so they transform with ζ+1\zeta^{+1} and are not in the ζ−1\zeta^{-1}-eigenspace. There are no other massless chiral fermions in the spectrum that can sit at a root, so L−(χ)=0L_-(\chi)=0 regardless of the RR-charge assignments to the MSSM fields and singlets. Similarly, for L+(−χ)L_+(-\chi) the only massless fermions that appear at a root in the ζ+1\zeta^{+1}-eigenspace are the gauginos of GSMG_{\mathrm{SM}}. At β=e0−e1\beta=e_0-e_1, there is a gluino and L+(−β)=L+(β)=1L_+(-\beta)=L_+(\beta)=1. At wβ=e0−e3w\beta=e_0-e_3, there is no massless fermion since the VV gauge bosons are heavy, so L+(−wβ)=L+(wβ)=0L_+(-w\beta)=L_+(w\beta)=0. This then provides the contradiction,

\begin{aligned} \operatorname{ind}\mathfrak{M}_{e_0-e_1}&=-1\\ \operatorname{ind}\mathfrak{M}_{e_0-e_3}&=0 \end{aligned} \qquad\Longrightarrow\qquad \operatorname{ind}\mathfrak{M}_{e_0-e_1}\ne\operatorname{ind}\mathfrak{M}_{e_0-e_3}. \tag*{(13)}\end{aligned}

This means that the spectrum cannot be the exact MSSM with additional gauge singlets.

The extension to non-standard embeddings is straightforward. The choice of embedding changes the position of t0\mathfrak{t}_0 in the Cartan of GG, which fixes Weyl⁡(G,T0)\operatorname{Weyl}(G,T_0). The no-go theorem can then be applied if Δ0\Delta_0 is not stable under Weyl⁡(G,T0)\operatorname{Weyl}(G,T_0). This fails, for example, for flipped SU(5)×U(1)X\mathrm{SU}(5)\times\mathrm{U}(1)_X, where Weyl⁡(G,T0)\operatorname{Weyl}(G,T_0) shrinks to Weyl⁡(GSM)\operatorname{Weyl}(G_{\mathrm{SM}}), under which Δ0\Delta_0 is stable.

Comparison with the Original Proof

The general case in [8 Section 2.1.2] proceeds in two steps. First, all pairs of representations that admit an SU(5)×ZMR\mathrm{SU}(5)\times Z_M^R-invariant mass term are removed from the fields of RR-charge 0 and RR-charge 2. Such a pair consists of a representation r\mathbf{r} of RR-charge 0 and its conjugate r‾\overline{\mathbf{r}} of RR-charge 2, for which r r‾\mathbf{r}\,\overline{\mathbf{r}} is an allowed mass term. The removal is decided by group theory alone. It asks whether a mass term is allowed, not whether the fields are actually massive in the vacuum. Second, the highest weights of the remaining representations are compared. After the removal, the two sectors no longer share an irreducible representation, so their highest weights differ. At the larger of the two, say the highest weight Λ0\Lambda_0 of the fields of RR-charge 0, there are states with no partner of RR-charge 2 at the opposite weight. These states, and their Weyl images, therefore remain massless. The case analysis of [8] then shows that they cannot all be harmless, and give rise to light exotics. The case Λ2>Λ0\Lambda_2>\Lambda_0 is analogous. This comparison uses that the remaining fields of RR-charge 0 still contain the vacuum, since otherwise the heavy gauge bosons could not acquire masses.5{}^{5} However, the first step may remove the multiplet that carries the vacuum. Consider, for instance, fields of RR-charge 0 and fields of RR-charge 2 that both transform as 24⊕75\mathbf{24}\oplus\mathbf{75}. All of these representations are real, so all of them can be removed in pairs. In this case, no highest weights remain, and the argument does not apply. The conclusion of [8] is nevertheless correct. Removing invariant pairs does not change the formal difference of the two sectors. By this we mean, for every weight χ\chi, the number of states of RR-charge 0 at χ\chi minus the number of states of RR-charge 2 at −χ-\chi. A removed pair (r,r‾)(\mathbf{r},\overline{\mathbf{r}}) contributes equally to both numbers. It is therefore legitimate for the comparison of highest weights. It is not legitimate for the vacuum and its Goldstone directions, which depend on the full field content. Where the VEV sits, which directions are eaten, and which states are actually massless depend on the superpotential of the full theory. Once the VEV is switched on, the removed fields mix with the field that carries it, with the Goldstone modes, and with the gauginos.

On the other hand, the proof of Theorem 1 does not remove any pairs. The index (7) is computed for the full field content, and the vacuum enters only through the gaugino count (b). Hence the example above is covered by the SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5) result (11). In particular, in this example the two sectors have the same content. Therefore, the chiral multiplets cancel in (7) and only the gaugino remains. The index is therefore −1-1 at all twenty roots. An exact MSSM would instead require −1-1 at the unbroken roots and 0 at the broken ones. The special case in which only 24\mathbf{24}-plets are present is treated separately in [8 Section 2.1.1], and its proof is correct.

ZMRZ_M^R Symmetries with Larger Gauge Groups

Now we turn to the application of the theorem to GUTs with larger gauge groups GG broken to G0=GSMG_0 = G_{\mathrm{SM}}.

Theorem 2. Let GG be compact and connected, and let SU(5)⊆G\mathrm{SU}(5) \subseteq G be a subgroup with GSM⊂SU(5)G_{\mathrm{SM}} \subset\mathrm{SU}(5) embedded in the standard way, i.e. SU(3)×SU(2)\mathrm{SU}(3) \times\mathrm{SU}(2) is the block subgroup and hypercharge Y∈su(5)Y \in\mathfrak{su}(5). We assume (A1)–(A5), with G0=GSMG_0 = G_{\mathrm{SM}}. Then, if an unbroken symmetry element r∈Σ0r \in\Sigma_0 with ζ2≠1\zeta^2 \ne1 commutes with SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5), the massless spectrum cannot be the MSSM plus gauge singlets.

Proof. Choose B=SU(5)B = \mathrm{SU}(5). Since SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5) is closed, connected, contains GSMG_{\mathrm{SM}}, and commutes with r∈Σ0r \in\Sigma_0 by assumption, this satisfies Assumption (A3). T0T_0 is the maximal torus of G0=GSMG_0 = G_{\mathrm{SM}}, and with the standard embedding T0T_0 is also the maximal torus of B=SU(5)B = \mathrm{SU}(5). As a result, Weyl⁡(B,T0)=S5\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0) = S_5. By Assumption (A5), the fermion space F\mathcal{F} is a GG-representation, which when restricted to SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5) must be an SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5)-representation as every GG-representation branches to an SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5)-representation. Furthermore, rr commutes with SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5), so each F±\mathcal{F}_{\pm} is also an SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5)-representation. The index relation Equation (11) then holds for SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5), and as before we can take β=e0−e1∈Δ0\beta= e_0 - e_1 \in\Delta_0 and w=(1 3)w = (1\ 3) so that wβ=e0−e3∉Δ0w\beta= e_0 - e_3 \notin\Delta_0. Now we verify the requirements (a) and (b) of Theorem 1.

We first verify (a), namely L−(χ)=0L_{-}(\chi) = 0 for χ∈{β,wβ}\chi\in\{\beta, w\beta\}. As in the discussion for the G=SU(5)G = \mathrm{SU}(5) case, the MSSM contains no massless ζ−1\zeta^{-1} fields sitting at a root. The singlets sit at weight 00, which is not a root, and the gauginos are in F+\mathcal{F}_{+}, not F−\mathcal{F}_{-}. Hence, no massless fermion sits at β\beta or wβw\beta, and we conclude L−(χ)=0L_{-}(\chi) = 0.

Now we verify (b), that L+(−χ)=dim⁡(g0⊗C)−χL_{+}(-\chi) = \dim(\mathfrak{g}_0 \otimes\mathbb{C})_{-\chi}. The above argument for (a) establishes that there are no massless chiral ζ+1\zeta^{+1}-eigenspace fermions at −β-\beta and −wβ-w\beta. At −β-\beta, the gluino is massless since G0=GSMG_0 = G_{\mathrm{SM}} is unbroken, and it lies in F+\mathcal{F}_{+} as a gaugino. At −wβ-w\beta, there is a massive gaugino since every gauge generator of GG at this weight lies outside of g0=gSM\mathfrak{g}_0 = \mathfrak{g}_{\mathrm{SM}}, and is broken. Then the proof proceeds as in the SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5) case, where there is a massless gluino at weight β=e0−e1\beta= e_0 - e_1, and a massive gaugino outside of GSMG_{\mathrm{SM}} at weight wβ=e0−e3w\beta= e_0 - e_3. As a result, ind⁡Me0−e1=−1\operatorname{ind}\mathcal{M}_{e_0-e_1} = -1, and ind⁡Me0−e3=0\operatorname{ind}\mathcal{M}_{e_0-e_3} = 0. This provides the contradiction that ind⁡Me0−e1≠ind⁡Me0−e3\operatorname{ind}\mathcal{M}_{e_0-e_1} \ne\operatorname{ind}\mathcal{M}_{e_0-e_3}, so the spectrum cannot be the exact MSSM with additional gauge singlets. □

How Higher-Dimensional Models of Grand Unification Evade the No-Go Theorem

In order to understand how higher-dimensional models evade the no-go theorem, let us first recall, at a qualitative level, why the no-go theorem applies. The basic argument can be illustrated in an SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5) model with an arbitrary RR-symmetry. Assume that a GUT Higgs HH transforming in the adjoint representation breaks SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5) to GSMG_{\mathrm{SM}}. Under GSMG_{\mathrm{SM}}, the adjoint decomposes as

24→(8,1)0⊕(1,3)0⊕(1,1)0⊕(3,2)−5/6⊕(3‾,2)5/6.(14)24 \to(8,1)_0 \oplus(1,3)_0 \oplus(1,1)_0 \oplus(3,2)_{-5/6} \oplus(\overline{3},2)_{5/6}. \tag*{(14)}

In order to preserve the RR-symmetry, HH has to carry RR-charge 00. This implies that any superpotential term built from HH alone has RR-charge 0≠20 \ne2 and is, therefore, forbidden. The components (3,2)−5/6⊕(3‾,2)5/6(3,2)_{-5/6} \oplus(\overline{3},2)_{5/6} are eaten by the heavy gauge bosons of SU(5)/GSM\mathrm{SU}(5)/G_{\mathrm{SM}}. On the other hand, the remaining components (8,1)0(8,1)_0, (1,3)0(1,3)_0 and (1,1)0(1,1)_0 remain massless. These are light, exotic states that go beyond the MSSM.

One may now try to introduce mass partners for the exotics. In [8], it has been shown that these mass partners have to be in the same congruency class as the adjoint. For instance, introducing an additional 2424-plet H′H' with RR-charge 22 does not help. The mass term HH′HH' is allowed, and allows us to pair up the (8,1)0(8,1)_0, (1,3)0(1,3)_0 and (1,1)0(1,1)_0 components of HH and H′H'. However, the (3,2)−5/6⊕(3‾,2)5/6(3,2)_{-5/6} \oplus(\overline{3},2)_{5/6} components of H′H' have no partners since the corresponding components of HH are eaten. We are thus, again, left with massless exotics.

More generally, let us consider n0n_0 adjoints with RR-charge 00 and n2n_2 adjoints with RR-charge 22. The absence of massless (8,1)0(8,1)_0 states requires n0=n2n_0 = n_2, while the absence of massless (3,2)−5/6(3,2)_{-5/6} states requires n0−1=n2n_0 - 1 = n_2. These conditions are incompatible with each other for any finite numbers n0n_0 and n2n_2. This counting is the special case of (11) in which only adjoints are present.

The basic argument can be generalized to arbitrary SU(5) representations, to larger GUT groups G⊃SU(5)G \supset\mathrm{SU}(5) and to singlet extensions of the MSSM [8]. The general version rests on three assumptions. First, the GUT is four-dimensional and based on a gauge group G⊃SU(5)G \supset\mathrm{SU}(5). Second, the GUT symmetry is broken spontaneously. Third, there are only finitely many fields. Under these assumptions it is impossible to obtain a low-energy effective theory that has both the exact MSSM field content and a residual RR-symmetry. See § 3.1 for additional details. In § 2, we have turned these arguments into a precise, formalized theorem.

The argument, and the theorem, no longer hold if there are infinitely many 24-plets, or other appropriate representations. As a consequence, higher-dimensional models of grand unification evade the no-go theorem. This is because, from a 4D perspective, they contain an infinite number of multiplets [22], thus violating Assumption (A5). In particular, scenarios in which the GUT symmetry gets broken by compactification evade the no-go theorem. These scenarios include the so-called orbifold GUTs and orbifold compactifications of the heterotic string [25, 26] (see e.g. [27, 28] for more references).

Modular Symmetries

Modular Symmetries Are RR-Symmetries

We start by pointing out that in a supersymmetric theory that also describes gravity, modular symmetries are RR-symmetries. Under a modular transformation γ:=(abcd)∈SL(2,Z)\gamma:= \begin{pmatrix} a & b \\ c & d \end{pmatrix} \in\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}), the modulus τ\tau, chiral superfields Φ(i)\Phi^{(i)} and superpotential W\mathcal{W} transform as

τ→γaτ+bcτ+d,(15)\tau\xrightarrow{\gamma} \frac{a\tau+b}{c\tau+d}, \tag*{(15)}
Φ(i)→γρr(i)(γ)(cτ+d)k(i)Φ(i):=ρr(i)(γ)jk(i)Φ(i),(16)\Phi^{(i)} \xrightarrow{\gamma} \rho_{r^{(i)}}(\gamma)(c\tau+d)^{k^{(i)}}\Phi^{(i)} := \rho_{r^{(i)}}(\gamma)j^{k^{(i)}}\Phi^{(i)}, \tag*{(16)}
W→γ(cτ+d)kWW:=jkWW.(17)\mathcal{W} \xrightarrow{\gamma} (c\tau+d)^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}\mathcal{W} := j^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}\mathcal{W}. \tag*{(17)}

Here, we introduced the shorthand j:=(cτ+d)j := (c\tau+d), and τ\tau denotes the modulus and Φ(i)\Phi^{(i)} the chiral superfields of the theory. k(i)k^{(i)} and kWk_{\mathcal{W}} stand for the modular weights of the chiral superfields and the superpotential, respectively. With this sign convention, a coupling Y(τ)∏iΦ(i)Y(\tau)\prod_i\Phi^{(i)} requires Y∈MkW−∑ik(i)Y \in M_{k_{\mathcal{W}}-\sum_i k^{(i)}}. Here, MkM_k denotes the space of holomorphic modular forms of weight kk (regular at the cusp) for the full modular group, unless specified otherwise [29]. The modular group is generated by

S:=(01−10),(18)S := \begin{pmatrix} 0 & 1 \\ -1 & 0 \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(18)}
T:=(1101).(19)T := \begin{pmatrix} 1 & 1 \\ 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix}. \tag*{(19)}

To understand why modular symmetries are necessarily RR-symmetries, recall that the unique supersymmetric framework that incorporates gravity is SUGRA. As is well known, in SUGRA the so-called G\mathcal{G}-function is given by

G=K+ln⁡∣W∣2.(20)\mathcal{G}=K+\ln|\mathcal{W}|^2. \tag*{(20)}

A typical Kähler potential is given by

Kmodulus=−ntoriln⁡(−iτ+iτˉ),(21)K_{\mathrm{modulus}}=-n_{\mathrm{tori}}\ln(-i\tau+i\bar{\tau}), \tag*{(21)}

where ntorin_{\mathrm{tori}} denotes the number of tori τ\tau parametrizes. Since KmodulusK_{\mathrm{modulus}} transforms nontrivially under (15), the superpotential has to undergo the transformation (17) to ensure modular invariance of the G\mathcal{G}-function (20). Indeed, Im⁡(γτ)=Im⁡τ/∣cτ+d∣2\operatorname{Im}(\gamma\tau)=\operatorname{Im}\tau/|c\tau+d|^2, hence Kmodulus(γτ)=Kmodulus(τ)+ntoriln⁡∣cτ+d∣2K_{\mathrm{modulus}}(\gamma\tau)=K_{\mathrm{modulus}}(\tau)+n_{\mathrm{tori}}\ln|c\tau+d|^2. Invariance of G\mathcal{G} then requires W↦(cτ+d)−ntoriW\mathcal{W}\mapsto(c\tau+d)^{-n_{\mathrm{tori}}}\mathcal{W}, up to a possible multiplier. Specifically, the Kähler potential (21) one has

kW=−ntori(22)k_{\mathcal{W}}=-n_{\mathrm{tori}} \tag*{(22)}

for the modular transformations (13). In particular, in the presence of gravity, modular invariance and SUSY imply that modular symmetries are RR-symmetries.

In heterotic orbifolds, discrete RR-symmetries have traditionally been linked to the H-momentum selection rule [30, 31, 32, 33, 34]. However, as is well known, in string compactifications RR-symmetries really originate from modular symmetries [20, 21]. This is, of course, in agreement with our earlier statement that in a supersymmetric framework that describes gravity, modular symmetries are RR-symmetries. It is, therefore, natural to ask what the implications of the no-go theorems for RR-symmetries are for modular symmetries.

R-Symmetries as Stabilizers

There are certain critical values of τ\tau, τ0\tau_0, which are invariant under a subgroup of SL⁡(2,Z)\operatorname{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}). The modular transformations γ\gamma with γτ0=τ0\gamma\tau_0=\tau_0 form the so-called stabilizer subgroup Γ⟨τ⟩\Gamma_{\langle\tau\rangle} of SL⁡(2,Z)\operatorname{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}). For γ0∈Γ⟨τ⟩\gamma_0\in\Gamma_{\langle\tau\rangle} one then has

τ→γ0τ,(23)\tau\xrightarrow{\gamma_0} \tau, \tag*{(23)}
Φ(i)→γ0ρr(i)(γ0)j0k(i)Φ(i),(24)\Phi^{(i)} \xrightarrow{\gamma_0} \rho_{r(i)}(\gamma_0)j_0^{k^{(i)}}\Phi^{(i)} , \tag*{(24)}
W→γ0j0kWW,(25)\mathcal{W} \xrightarrow{\gamma_0} j_0^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}\mathcal{W} , \tag*{(25)}

where now j0≔cτ0+dj_0\coloneqq c\tau_0+d. Provided that j0kW≠1j_0^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}\ne1, (18) is an RR-symmetry. In Table 1 we list the nontrivial stabilizers of SL⁡(2,Z)\operatorname{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}). Note that different modular symmetries such as congruence subgroups of SL⁡(2,Z)\operatorname{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}) can have different stabilizers [35].

τ0\tau_0generatorjjsuperpotential phasentori=1n_{\mathrm{tori}}=1ntorin_{\mathrm{tori}} oddntorin_{\mathrm{tori}} even
genericS2=−1\mathrm{S}^2=-1−1-1(−1)kW(-1)^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}Z4RZ_4^RZ4RZ_4^R—
iS−i-i(−i)kW(-i)^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}Z8RZ_8^RZ8RZ_8^RZ4RZ_4^R for ntori=2 mod 4n_{\mathrm{tori}}=2\bmod4; — for 4∣ntori4\mid n_{\mathrm{tori}}
ω=e2πi/3\omega=e^{2\pi i/3}−ST-\mathrm{S}\mathrm{T}eiπ/3e^{i\pi/3}eiπkW/3e^{i\pi k_{\mathcal{W}}/3}Z12RZ_{12}^RZ12RZ_{12}^R for 3∤ntori3\nmid n_{\mathrm{tori}}; Z4RZ_4^R for 3∣ntori3\mid n_{\mathrm{tori}}Z6RZ_6^R for 3∤ntori3\nmid n_{\mathrm{tori}}; — for 3∣ntori3\mid n_{\mathrm{tori}}
i∞i\inftyT11Z4RZ_4^RZ4RZ_4^R—

Table 1. Stabilizers of the vacuum value τ0\tau_0 in SL⁡(2,Z)\operatorname{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z}) and the corresponding superpotential phases. “—” indicates that there is no linearly realized symmetry. The last three columns refer to the full stabilizer, which always contains the center −1-1.

The stabilizer symmetries at ii, ω\omega and i∞i\infty in Table 1 act as ZMRZ_M^R symmetries unless ntorin_{\mathrm{tori}} takes special values. In particular, in the arguably most interesting case of a single torus, i.e. ntori=1n_{\mathrm{tori}}=1, there are linearly realized Z4RZ_4^R, Z8RZ_8^R and Z12RZ_{12}^R symmetries at generic τ\tau, at τ=i\tau=i and at τ=ω\tau=\omega, respectively. The superpotential has RR-charge 2kW2k_{\mathcal{W}}. We introduced the factor 2 here to make sure that the superspace coordinates θ\theta have integer RR-charge.6

The Center of SL(2,Z) and a Modular Z4R Symmetry

At a generic point in τ\tau moduli space, the stabilizer group Γ⟨τ⟩\Gamma_{\langle\tau\rangle} consists of the center {±1}\{\pm1\} only. The center acts on chiral multiplets Φ\Phi and the superpotential as

Φ→γ0=−1(−1)kΦρ(−1)Φ≡ϵΦΦ,(26)\Phi\xrightarrow{\gamma_0=-1} (-1)^{k_\Phi}\rho(-1)\Phi\equiv\epsilon_\Phi\Phi, \tag*{(26)}
W→γ0=−1(−1)kWW.(27)\mathcal{W} \xrightarrow{\gamma_0=-1} (-1)^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}\mathcal{W} . \tag*{(27)}

This center symmetry holds independently of τ\tau. We call Φ\Phi center-even if ϵΦ=+1\epsilon_{\Phi}=+1 and center-odd if ϵΦ=−1\epsilon_{\Phi}=-1. Note that the fact that ϵΦ\epsilon_{\Phi} can only take the values ±1\pm1 follows from Schur’s lemma and the fact that the symmetry is central.

For odd kWk_{\mathcal{W}} and an appropriate multiplier7, the center symmetry has order 4 since it acts on the superspace coordinates as

θ→Z4R±iθ.(28)\theta\xrightarrow{Z_{4}^{R}} \pm i\theta. \tag*{(28)}

The sign ambiguity is the same as the one commented on in Footnote 4. In particular, every modular symmetry with ntori=1n_{\mathrm{tori}}=1 and an appropriate multiplier leads to a Z4RZ_{4}^{R} symmetry that is linearly realized, independently of τ\tau. Note that the center symmetry, S2=−1S^{2}=-1, has been dubbed modular spin in [37].

Modular Stabilizer Symmetries in 4D GUTs

Modular symmetries provide us with a compelling way to address the flavor puzzle within the framework of modular flavor symmetries [38], see also the reviews [39, 40, 41, 42]. It is, therefore, natural to ask to which extent modular symmetries can be combined with 4D GUTs.

Given that the stabilizer symmetries of § 6.2 are linearly realized RR-symmetries, our no-go theorem of § 2 applies. This implies, in particular, that at the critical points in τ\tau moduli space, some exotic states become massless. Away from the fixed point, portions of the stabilizer symmetries are spontaneously broken, and the exotics can pick up masses. However, as stressed in Section 6.3, the center symmetry remains unbroken.

A No-Go Corollary for Modular Symmetries

The abstract no-go theorem, Theorem 1, applies with r=γ0∈Γ⟨τ⟩r=\gamma_{0}\in\Gamma_{\langle\tau\rangle} and ζ2=j0kW\zeta^{2}=j_{0}^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}, where γ0\gamma_{0} leaves the GUT-breaking vacuum invariant. Here, Γ⟨τ⟩\Gamma_{\langle\tau\rangle} denotes the stabilizer group defined above Equation (18). Then, F−\mathcal{F}_{-} consists of the fermions whose scalar partners are invariant under γ0\gamma_{0}. Likewise, F+\mathcal{F}_{+} consists of fermions whose scalar partners pick up the phase j0kWj_{0}^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}, together with the gauginos. Mass terms within F−\mathcal{F}_{-} and within F+\mathcal{F}_{+} are forbidden if and only if N∤kWN\nmid k_{\mathcal{W}}, where NN denotes the order of j0j_{0} (Modular.stabilizer_phases). In this case, the mass matrix has the block off-diagonal form (6). If γ0\gamma_{0} generates the full stabilizer, N=2N=2, 4 and 6 at generic τ\tau, at τ0=i\tau_{0}=i and at τ0=ω\tau_{0}=\omega, respectively.

Corollary 1. The light spectrum of a 4D SU(5) GUT with unbroken GSMG_{\mathrm{SM}} cannot be the exact MSSM with additional gauge singlets if an element of Γ⟨τ⟩\Gamma_{\langle\tau\rangle} fixes the GUT-breaking vacuum and multiplies the superpotential by a nontrivial phase. More generally, this holds for any linearly and unitarily realized symmetry gg, commuting with SU(5), with W∘g=ηW\mathcal{W}\circ g=\eta\mathcal{W}, η≠1\eta\ne1 and g v=vg\,v=v.

Note that Corollary 1 covers ZMRZ_{M}^{R}, U(1)R\mathrm{U}(1)_{R}, non-Abelian RR-symmetries [43], and the discrete RR-symmetries of heterotic orbifolds [44, 34, 37].

Modular Z4R Symmetry in 4D GUTs

As we have seen in Section 6.3, for odd superpotential weights there is a linearly realized Z4RZ_{4}^{R} symmetry at a generic point in τ\tau moduli space. This leads to another corollary.

Corollary 2 (Modular.center_bipartite). Let kWk_{\mathcal{W}} be odd, so that the superpotential is odd under the center with trivial multiplier. Further, let the GUT-breaking vacuum be center-even. Then the conclusion of Corollary 1 holds for every value of ⟨τ⟩\langle\tau\rangle.

Hence, to avoid massless exotics, the GUT-breaking vacuum has to break the modular Z4R\mathbb{Z}_4^R, for instance through a center-odd GUT Higgs. Indeed, for kW=−1k_{\mathcal{W}}=-1 and a single center-odd 24-plet of weight −3-3, the (8,1)(8,1) and (1,3)(1,3) components acquire masses at generic τ\tau. This breaking occurs at MGUTM_{\mathrm{GUT}} and may affect the predictions of modular flavor models.

Note that one cannot restore the modular Z4R\mathbb{Z}_4^R by combining it with an element of the center of SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5). This is because vacua of vanishing 5-ality are invariant under the center of SU(5)\mathrm{SU}(5). Hence, if the light spectrum is the exact MSSM, no remnant of the modular Z4R\mathbb{Z}_4^R survives as an RR-symmetry at low energies. In particular, the modular Z4R\mathbb{Z}_4^R cannot be used to forbid the μ\mu term.

Parametrically Light Exotics near Critical Points

At the critical points τ0=i\tau_0=i and τ0=ω\tau_0=\omega with kW=−2k_{\mathcal{W}}=-2, the respective superpotential phases are −1-1 and ω2\omega^2. Our no-go theorem applies at τ0\tau_0, provided that the full GUT-breaking vacuum preserves the stabilizer. Near τ0\tau_0 it provides us with additional valuable insights. To see this, define [45, 46]

u:={τ−iτ+ifor τ0=i,τ−ωτ−ω2for τ0=ω,(29)u := \begin{cases} \frac{\tau-i}{\tau+i} & \text{for }\tau_0=i,\\ \frac{\tau-\omega}{\tau-\omega^2} & \text{for }\tau_0=\omega, \end{cases} \tag*{(29)}

which measures the departure of τ\tau from its critical value. Under the stabilizer transformations (18), u↦j0−2uu \mapsto j_0^{-2}u, i.e. uu transforms like a field of modular weight −2-2. Hence uu carries RR-charge, which we list in Table 2.

τ0\tau_0ntori=1n_{\mathrm{tori}}=1ntorin_{\mathrm{tori}} oddntorin_{\mathrm{tori}} even
ii44 under Z8R\mathbb{Z}_8^R44 under Z8R\mathbb{Z}_8^R22 under Z4R\mathbb{Z}_4^R for ntori=2 mod 4n_{\mathrm{tori}}=2\ \mathrm{mod}\ 4; — for 4∣ntori4\mid n_{\mathrm{tori}}
ω\omega44 under Z12R\mathbb{Z}_{12}^R44 under Z12R\mathbb{Z}_{12}^R for ntori=1 mod 6n_{\mathrm{tori}}=1\ \mathrm{mod}\ 6; 88 under Z12R\mathbb{Z}_{12}^R for ntori=5 mod 6n_{\mathrm{tori}}=5\ \mathrm{mod}\ 6; 00 under Z4R\mathbb{Z}_4^R for 3∣ntori3\mid n_{\mathrm{tori}}22 under Z6R\mathbb{Z}_6^R for ntori=2 mod 6n_{\mathrm{tori}}=2\ \mathrm{mod}\ 6; 44 under Z6R\mathbb{Z}_6^R for ntori=4 mod 6n_{\mathrm{tori}}=4\ \mathrm{mod}\ 6; — for 6∣ntori6\mid n_{\mathrm{tori}}

Table 2. RR-charge of the expansion parameter uu under the linearly realized ZMR\mathbb{Z}_M^R symmetries of Table 1. The RR-charges are normalized such that θ\theta has RR-charge 1 and W\mathcal{W} has RR-charge 2. “—” indicates that there is no linearly realized RR-symmetry.

By holomorphy, only nonnegative powers of uu appear in the superpotential. Consider now a mass term whose residual charge differs from that of the superpotential by Δr\Delta r. In order to be allowed, it must be multiplied by unu^n, where nn is the least nonnegative integer with qun=Δr mod Mq_u n=\Delta r\ \mathrm{mod}\ M in ZM\mathbb{Z}_M. Here, quq_u denotes the RR-charge of uu under the linearly realized ZMR\mathbb{Z}_M^R as given in Table 2. Since the GUT-breaking vacuum preserves the residual symmetry at τ0\tau_0, the GUT Higgs HH has residual charge 0. For the mass term tr⁡H2\operatorname{tr}H^2, the charge mismatch is therefore Δr=2\Delta r=2.

As in the Froggatt–Nielsen [47] (FN) picture, uu acts as a charged FN spurion, so for a GUT Higgs HH neutral under the residual symmetry, the leading allowed term untr⁡H2u^n\operatorname{tr}H^2 is then determined by ZMR\mathbb{Z}_M^R charge conservation. That is, j0−2n=j0kWj_0^{-2n}=j_0^{k_{\mathcal{W}}}, with nn the smallest nonnegative integer satisfying this condition. More specifically, we have

mexotic∼MGUT∣u∣nwithn={1if τ0=i and kW=2 mod 4,1if τ0=ω and kW=4 mod 6,2if τ0=ω and kW=2 mod 6.(30)m_{\mathrm{exotic}}\sim M_{\mathrm{GUT}}|u|^n\quad\text{with}\quad n=\begin{cases} 1 & \text{if }\tau_0=i\text{ and }k_{\mathcal{W}}=2\ \mathrm{mod}\ 4,\\ 1 & \text{if }\tau_0=\omega\text{ and }k_{\mathcal{W}}=4\ \mathrm{mod}\ 6,\\ 2 & \text{if }\tau_0=\omega\text{ and }k_{\mathcal{W}}=2\ \mathrm{mod}\ 6. \end{cases} \tag*{(30)}

For odd kWk_{\mathcal{W}} and τ0=i\tau_0=i, no nn exists. A center-even vacuum leaves the exotics massless for every τ\tau by Corollary 2. A center-odd vacuum, on the other hand, breaks the center. Every nontrivial subgroup of the stabilizer $\langle S\rangle\cong\mathbb{Z}_4 of ii contains the center. Hence a center-odd vacuum breaks the stabilizer completely. At τ0=ω\tau_0 = \omega, however, ST\mathrm{S T} generates a Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 subgroup that does not contain the center. At level one, a center-odd vacuum preserves this Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 if 3∣kH3 \mid k_H. For 3∤kW3 \nmid k_W, the Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 multiplies the superpotential by ω2kW≠1\omega^{2k_W} \ne1. Then, the leading allowed term untr⁡H2u^n \operatorname{tr} H^2 has n=1n = 1 for kW=1 mod 3k_W = 1 \bmod3, and n=2n = 2 for kW=2 mod 3k_W = 2 \bmod3, so the exotics again have masses m∼MGUT∣u∣nm \sim M_{\mathrm{GUT}} |u|^n. For even kWk_W, this rule reproduces the values for τ0=ω\tau_0 = \omega given above.

It is instructive to consider a simple toy model (Modular.toy_model). Take kW=−2k_W = -2 and a single 24\mathbf{24} of weight kH=−4k_H = -4. The superpotential is then given by

Wtoy=ME6(τ)tr⁡H2+λE4(τ)E6(τ)tr⁡H3.(31)\mathcal{W}_{\mathrm{toy}} = \mathcal{M} E_6(\tau) \operatorname{tr} H^2 + \lambda E_4(\tau) E_6(\tau) \operatorname{tr} H^3 . \tag*{(31)}

We impose that the FF-term of the GUT Higgs vanishes, FH=0F_H = 0. For τ≠i\tau\ne i, the common factor E6(τ)E_6(\tau) cancels in the vacuum value ⟨H⟩∝M/(λE4)\langle H\rangle\propto\mathcal{M}/(\lambda E_4), which stays finite as τ→i\tau\to i. The masses of (8,1)(8,1) and (1,3)(1,3), however, are proportional to E6(τ)E_6(\tau), which has a simple zero at ii. Numerically, for M=λ=1\mathcal{M} = \lambda= 1, ∣m(8,1)∣/∣τ−i∣→66.6|m_{(8,1)}|/|\tau-i| \to66.6. In particular, the masses of the exotics vanish exactly at τ=i\tau= i.

What are the phenomenological consequences of these results? In modular flavor models, the proximity of the modulus to a fixed point is often used to generate fermion mass hierarchies [45, 46, 48]. In fact, the expansion parameter uu of Equation (29) was originally used to parametrize such hierarchies. Our above discussion, therefore, implies that when such scenarios get combined with 4D GUTs, there will be parametrically light adjoint-type exotics. The suppression of their masses goes like ∣u∣n|u|^n, just like the fermion masses. Generically, the presence of such states well below the GUT scale is expected to impact gauge coupling unification, one of the very motivations of GUTs.

Let us also note that in string models winding modes become massless when τ\tau attains a critical value [49, 50, 51, 52]. However, in contrast to the above-mentioned exotics, these states do not carry standard model (SM) quantum numbers, and therefore do not affect gauge coupling unification.

Modular Zeros beyond Symmetries

There is a corner case in which no linearly realized RR-symmetry exists, but the no-go theorem still applies. It arises away from the fixed points, for even kWk_W and a multiplier with χ(−1)=1\chi(-1) = 1, e.g. the trivial one. In this case, the center acts trivially on the superpotential, so it is not an RR-symmetry. Hence Corollary 1 does not apply. However, the proof of Theorem 1 uses the RR-symmetry only to obtain the block off-diagonal form (6). As we shall see, so-called modular zeros [37] can enforce this form even without a symmetry.

Modular zeros fall into three classes, see Figure 1. Trivial zeros arise if the required weight has the wrong sign, e.g. k<0k < 0. They are similar to the holomorphic zeros of FN-type models [53, 54], which arise if the required charge has the wrong sign. Structural zeros are due to modular spin, i.e. the center. These zeros can explain string selection rules that cannot be understood in terms of ordinary, linearly realized symmetries [37, 55]. Sporadic zeros follow no obvious pattern, and in general they, too, cannot be explained by linear symmetries.

Classification of modular zeros

Figure 1. Classification of modular zeros.

In particular, modular zeros can forbid all mass terms among the fermions of the fields that attain VEVs, as well as all mass terms among their potential partners. This is sufficient for (6) to hold.

Theorem 3 (Modular.gap_bipartite). Consider level one with trivial multipliers and kW=−2k_{\mathcal{W}}=-2. Suppose all chiral multiplets have modular weight 00 or −2-2, and only fields of weight 00 attain VEVs. Then, for every τ\tau, the mass matrix has the block off-diagonal form (6). Here F−F_{-} consists of the fermions of weight 00, and F+F_{+} of the fermions of weight −2-2 and the gauginos. Hence the conclusion of Theorem 1 holds, although the center acts trivially on the superpotential.

Modular zeros can thus enforce (6). In the example of Theorem 3, an ordinary Z4RZ_{4}^{R}, under which the weight-−2-2 fields carry the same charge as W\mathcal{W}, does the same. However, the two scenarios differ in their implications for other couplings. For a multiplet PP of weight −2-2, the Z4RZ_{4}^{R} forbids P4P^{4}, whereas modular invariance allows E6(τ)P4E_{6}(\tau)P^{4}. More generally, no Abelian symmetry under which the vacuum is invariant allows HPHP, P3P^{3} and P4P^{4} but forbids P2P^{2}. This means that the modular zero scenario has quite unusual properties when compared to settings with ordinary symmetries.

Summary of the Modular Case

Let us summarize our discussion of modular symmetries in 4D GUTs. The different cases are illustrated in Figure 2.

Consequences of the abstract no-go theorem for modular-invariant 4D GUTs

Figure 2. Consequences of the abstract no-go theorem, Theorem 1, for modular-invariant 4D GUTs. Shaded boxes mark the cases in which the exact MSSM is excluded, and white boxes the cases in which no unbroken symmetry forbids it. HH denotes the GUT-breaking Higgs and uu the local coordinate around the fixed point τ0\tau_{0}, see § 6.4.3.

  1. The no-go theorem applies to every linearly realized RR-symmetry that leaves the vacuum invariant and multiplies the superpotential by a nontrivial phase (Corollary 1). For modular symmetries, the stabilizer of ⟨τ⟩\langle\tau\rangle falls into this class. At generic τ\tau, only the center remains. Therefore, the symmetry-based no-go theorem holds for all τ\tau if and only if W\mathcal{W} is center-odd and the vacuum center-even (Corollary 2).

  1. Near a fixed point the no-go theorem turns into a prediction of light exotics. Their masses are suppressed by the powers ∣u∣n|u|^{n}, which are determined by the residual charges (§ 6.4.3).

  1. In the absence of linearly realized symmetries, there can still be modular zeros which prevent us from giving exotics masses (Theorem 3).

Concluding Remarks

The combination of Lean and AI has revolutionized mathematics. In this work, we used Lean to formalize no-go theorems in high-energy physics. This has allowed us to double-check the validity of these theorems and extend their scope. In the process, we identified and closed a gap in an earlier proof.

We also extended the analysis to modular symmetries, which we have argued to be inevitably RR-symmetries in any supersymmetric framework that also describes gravity. The no-go theorems then led to interesting corollaries for modular symmetries. In the context of 4D GUTs, modular symmetries imply the existence of exotic states that become massless at the critical points. This is because modular RR-symmetries are linearly realized at these points. In the framework of modular flavor symmetries, the modulus is often required to settle close to some critical point in order to accommodate fermion mass hierarchies. The no-go theorems then imply the existence of exotic states that become parametrically light. These states appear in incomplete GUT multiplets, and thus have the potential of ruining gauge coupling unification, one of the main motivations for GUTs.

We have also seen that higher-dimensional models of grand unification evade the no-go theorems. This means that an MSSM model with RR- and modular symmetries is compatible with unification provided that the GUT symmetry gets broken by compactification. In particular, string theory can give rise to such scenarios.

Acknowledgments

X.-G. L. was supported by the Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México Postdoctoral Program (POSDOC). A.S. was supported by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship Program. This material is based upon work supported by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship Program under Grant No. DGE-2235784. We acknowledge help by Anthropic’s Claude to generate Lean code, and to fix typographical and grammatical errors.

What Has Been Formalized

We have formalized the abstract no-go theorem, Theorem 1, and its application to SU(5) in the proof assistant Lean 4, using the mathematics library Mathlib. Lean accepts a proof only if every step can be checked mechanically against the definitions. The formalization therefore tests whether the argument of § 2 really follows from the stated hypotheses. It also makes these hypotheses explicit. The no-go theorem is formalized in the file RNoGoAbstract.lean, which is provided as supplementary material and described in Appendix § 9. The modular selection rules of § 6 are formalized in a separate file, Modular.lean. The command #print axioms lists every axiom a theorem ultimately relies on. For all main results, it reports only the three standard axioms of Lean’s logic, propext, Classical.choice and Quot.sound. Table 3 lists the main statements along with the corresponding Lean theorems.

StatementLean theoremStatus
Selection rule behind (6)selection_ruleproved
Counting identity (9)RFermionSystem.index_eqproved
Weyl invariance (11)finrank_weightSpace_act, RFermionSystem.index_actproved
Theorem 1no_go, no_go_of_Lplus_neproved
SU(5) contradiction (13)SU5.no_exact_MSSMproved
Selection rule of Corollary 1Modular.stabilizer_phasesproved
Selection rule of Corollary 2Modular.center_bipartiteproved
Selection rule of Theorem 3Modular.gap_bipartiteproved
Selection rules of the toy modelModular.toy_modelproved
Equation (3), Section 4, light exotics (Section 6.4.3)—not formalized

Table 3. Main statements of the paper and the corresponding Lean theorems in RNoGoAbstract.lean and, for the theorems with the prefix Modular, in Modular.lean.

What Is Proved

Let us go through the argument of § 2. The selection rule is proved. If ζ2≠1\zeta^2 \ne1, then also ζ−1ζ−1≠1\zeta^{-1}\zeta^{-1} \ne1 and ζ ζ≠1\zeta\,\zeta\ne1. Hence an rr-invariant mass term can only pair F−\mathcal{F}_{-} with F+\mathcal{F}_{+}. The counting identity (9) is proved from rank-nullity, separately for every weight block Wχ\mathcal{W}_{\chi}. The Weyl invariance (11) is proved as in the text. A representative nn of w∈Weyl⁡(B,T0)w \in\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_0) maps the weight space V(χ)V(\chi) onto V(w⋅χ)V(w\cdot\chi). Hence the two weight spaces have the same dimension. Theorem 1 then follows, because a Weyl-invariant function cannot take the value −1-1 at β\beta and 0 at wβw\beta. Finally, the SU(5) contradiction (13) is proved as a special case. Here the weights are elements of Z5\mathbb{Z}^5, S5S_5 permutes them, and Δ0\Delta_0 is the set of the eight roots of GSMG_{\mathrm{SM}}. 5-ality shows that no MSSM field sits at a root. A singlet weight is a multiple of (1,1,1,1,1)(1,1,1,1,1) and hence never a root. What remains are three statements about the massless spectrum. First, the massless fermions in F−\mathcal{F}_{-} are MSSM fields or singlets. Second, there is exactly one massless fermion in F+\mathcal{F}_{+} at the weight −(e0−e1)-(e_{0}-e_{1}), namely a gluino. Third, there is no massless fermion in F+\mathcal{F}_{+} at the weight −(e0−e3)-(e_{0}-e_{3}). The Lean theorem shows that these three statements are contradictory.

Modular Selection Rules

The file Modular.lean formalizes the selection rules of § 6 at level one with trivial multiplier. A coupling is defined to be allowed if the space of modular forms of the required weight is nonzero. Which of these spaces vanish is taken from Mathlib. On this basis, the file proves the selection rules behind Corollaries 1 and 2 and Theorem 3, as well as those of the toy model of § 6.4.3. These results establish the block off-diagonal form (6). They have not yet been combined with the Lean version of Theorem 1 into a single theorem.

What Is Assumed

Mathlib does not yet contain the structure theory of compact Lie groups, such as maximal tori and the Weyl groups NB(T0)/CB(T0)N_{B}(T_{0})/C_{B}(T_{0}). The corresponding input therefore enters the Lean theorems as explicit hypotheses, never as axioms. These hypotheses are the fields of the structure RFermionSystem and the hypotheses of the theorem no_go. There are three kinds of input.

First, F−\mathcal{F}_{-} and F+\mathcal{F}_{+} are finite-dimensional representations of T0T_{0}. Further, for every w∈Weyl⁡(B,T0)w \in\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_{0}) there are invertible maps on F−\mathcal{F}_{-} and on F+\mathcal{F}_{+} that intertwine the action of t∈T0t \in T_{0} with that of ntn−1n t n^{-1}, where nn represents ww. It is then proved that these maps send the weight space of χ\chi onto that of w⋅χw \cdot\chi. This replaces Assumptions (A3) and (A5). Indeed, by Assumption (A5) F\mathcal{F} is a finite-dimensional GG-representation. Since rr commutes with BB, F−\mathcal{F}_{-} and F+\mathcal{F}_{+} are separately BB-representations, and representatives of ww in BB provide the required maps.

Second, the mass operator is given directly as the family of maps Mχ:F−(χ)→F+(−χ)\mathfrak{M}_{\chi} : \mathcal{F}_{-}(\chi) \to\mathcal{F}_{+}(-\chi). That is, the block form (6) and the T0T_{0}-invariance of Assumption (A4) are built into the setup. They are not derived from a supersymmetric Lagrangean.

Third, the Weyl group acts on the weights by additive maps, as (w⋅χ)(t)=χ(n−1tn)(w \cdot\chi)(t) = \chi(n^{-1} t n). In Lean this is the hypothesis CharCompat of no_go. It is the only fact from Lie theory that the proof of Theorem 1 uses. No further property of the roots is needed. Indeed, Δ0\Delta_{0} enters only through β∈Δ0\beta\in\Delta_{0} and w⋅β∉Δ0w \cdot\beta\notin\Delta_{0}. For SU(5) the weights, the action of S5S_{5} and the torus are defined explicitly, and CharCompat is proved. Hence the SU(5) result rests only on the first two kinds of input and on the three statements about the massless spectrum.

The conditions (a) and (b) of Theorem 1 are hypotheses of the Lean theorem. In (b), the gaugino count is written as 1 on Δ0\Delta_{0} and 0 elsewhere, which is equivalent because the root spaces of G0G_{0} are one-dimensional.

What Is Not Formalized

The expression (5) for Weyl⁡(B,T0)\operatorname{Weyl}(B,T_{0}) and the connectedness of CB(T0)C_{B}(T_{0}) are not formalized, and neither is the derivation of the fermion mass matrix at a supersymmetric vacuum. For a general group BB the existence of a pair (β,w)(\beta,w) is not formalized. For SU(5) the pair β=e0−e1\beta=e_{0}-e_{1}, w=(1 3)w=(1\,3) is checked explicitly. The application to larger gauge groups in Section 4 is proved on paper only, as is the discussion of non-standard embeddings. In the modular case, the zero E6(i)=0E_{6}(i)=0 and the scaling of the masses of the light exotics in § 6.4.3 are not formalized.

Lessons

Two lessons from the formalization deserve mention. First, the order of the RR-symmetry is used in a single place, through ζ2≠1\zeta^{2} \ne1 in the selection rule. The argument is therefore the same for every ZMR\mathbb{Z}_{M}^{R} with M∉{1,2}M \notin\{1,2\}. It also applies to U(1)RU(1)_{R}. Second, the vacuum enters in only three ways. It enters through its symmetries, through the requirement that the light chiral spectrum be the MSSM plus singlets, and through the gaugino count (b). The gaugino count means one massless gluino at the weight −(e0−e1)-(e_{0}-e_{1}) of an unbroken root, and no massless fermion at the weight −(e0−e3)-(e_{0}-e_{3}) of its broken Weyl image. Neither FF- and DD-flatness nor the counting of Goldstone modes is needed.

Lean Formalization of the Abstract No-Go Theorem

In this appendix we show the central parts of the Lean file, so that the reader can see how the argument of § 2 reads in Lean. The complete file is provided as supplementary material, RNoGoAbstract.lean. It was checked with Lean 4.33.0 and Mathlib commit db584cd6d46c92f209a44c0f1c829460d327499d. Each box below reproduces a range of lines of this file without any change, and the title of the box gives the range.

Reading the Lean Code. A few words on the syntax are in order. A theorem lists its hypotheses as named arguments in parentheses, then a colon and the conclusion, and then the proof after :=. Most of our theorems have the conclusion False. That is, they state that their hypotheses cannot all hold, which is how a no-go theorem looks in Lean. A structure collects data together with the conditions they satisfy, and an argument such as (S : RFermionSystem act chr wt) reads “let SS be a fermion system.” Text between /- and -/ is documentation and is not checked by Lean.

We follow the notation of § 2 as far as possible. XX is the set of T0T_0-weights, WW is the group Weyl(B,T0)(B,T_0), and act w χ stands for w⋅χw \cdot\chi. The fermion spaces F−\mathcal{F}_{-} and F+\mathcal{F}_{+} are called Fm and Fp. In the comments of the file they are labeled by the fermion RR-charges f=−1f=-1 and f=+1f=+1 that they have for a ZMR\mathbb{Z}^{R}_{M} symmetry. The letter K denotes the field of numbers, for instance C\mathbb{C}, and not a group. One convention needs care. Lminus χ is L−(χ)L_{-}(\chi), the number of massless fermions in F−\mathcal{F}_{-} at weight χ\chi. Lplus χ, on the other hand, is the dimension of the cokernel of Mχ\mathfrak{M}_{\chi}, i.e. L+(−χ)L_{+}(-\chi), the number of massless fermions in F+\mathcal{F}_{+} at weight −χ-\chi.

The Fermion System. Recall that the argument of § 2 uses three ingredients, the two fermion sectors F±\mathcal{F}_{\pm} with the action of T0T_0, the action of the Weyl group, and the mass blocks Mχ\mathfrak{M}_{\chi}. The structure RFermionSystem collects exactly these. Its fields are the finite-dimensional spaces Fm and Fp, cf. Assumption (A5), the torus actions ρm\rho_m and ρp\rho_p, the invertible maps nm w and np w by which a representative of ww acts, together with the condition that they intertwine the torus action, and the mass blocks m. The maps nm and np encode that the fermions come in BB-multiplets and that rr commutes with BB, Assumption (A3). Note that MχM_{\chi} is a map from F−(χ)\mathcal{F}_{-}(\chi) to the dual of F+(−χ)\mathcal{F}_{+}(-\chi) by construction. That is, the block form (6) and the T0T_0-invariance of Assumption (A4) are built into the definition. The algebraic step behind (6), that ζ2≠1\zeta^2 \ne1 implies ζ−2≠1\zeta^{-2} \ne1, is proved separately as selection_rule.

Equation not extracted
/-- Fermion system (𝓕₋, 𝓕₊) with ‘T₀‘-action and Weyl intertwiners. The type of ‘M‘ is modelling
input: bipartite from ‘ζ ^2 ≠ 1‘ (‘selection_rule‘), weight-by-weight from ‘T₀‘-invariance. -/
structure RFermionSystem {K : Type u} [Field K] {X : Type uw} [AddCommGroup X]
  {W : Type x} [Group W] (act : W →* AddMonoid.End X) {T : Type y} [Group T]
  (chr : X → T → K) (wt : W →* MulAut T) where
  /-- 𝓕₋: fermions with r-phase ζ⁻¹ (f = -1 for Z_M^R). -/
  Fm : Type v
  /-- 𝓕₊: fermions with r-phase ζ, incl. all gauginos (f = +1 for Z_M^R). -/
  Fp : Type v
  [addCommGroupFm : AddCommGroup Fm]
  [moduleFm : Module K Fm]
  [finiteFm : FiniteDimensional K Fm]
  [addCommGroupFp : AddCommGroup Fp]
  [moduleFp : Module K Fp]
  [finiteFp : FiniteDimensional K Fp]
  /-- Torus action on ‘Fm‘. -/
  ρm : T →* (Fm →ₗ[K] Fm)
  /-- Torus action on ‘Fp‘. -/
  ρp : T →* (Fp →ₗ[K] Fp)
  /-- Weyl intertwiner on ‘Fm‘: representative of ‘w‘ in ‘N_B(T₀)‘. -/
  nm : W → (Fm ≃ₗ[K] Fm)
  /-- ‘nm w‘ intertwines the torus action on ‘Fm‘. -/
  hnm : ∀ w, IsIntertwiner wt ρm w (nm w)
  /-- Weyl intertwiner on ‘Fp‘: representative of ‘w‘ in ‘N_B(T₀)‘. -/
  np : W → (Fp ≃ₗ[K] Fp)
  /-- ‘np w‘ intertwines the torus action on ‘Fp‘. -/
  hnp : ∀ w, IsIntertwiner wt ρp w (np w)
  /-- Mass block at ‘T₀‘-weight ‘χ‘: ‘Fm(χ) → (Fp(-χ))^∨‘. -/
  M : ∀ χ : X, weightSpace chr ρm χ →ₗ[K] Module.Dual K (weightSpace chr ρp (-χ))

The Index and Its Weyl Invariance. Next, the file defines Lminus, Lplus and the index ind 𝔐χ = L−(χ)−L+(−χ)L_-(\chi)-L_+(-\chi). The theorem index_eq is the counting identity (9). Its proof applies rank-nullity to 𝔐χ, uses that a space and its dual have the same dimension, and finishes with omega, a tactic that solves linear equations between integers. The theorem index_act is the Weyl invariance (11). It rewrites both sides with index_eq and then uses that weight multiplicities are Weyl invariant, finrank_weightSpace_act (lines 115–121). The latter is proved exactly as in Section 2. A representative nn of ww maps V(χ)V(\chi) onto V(w⋅χ)V(w \cdot\chi). The hypothesis hc : CharCompat act chr wt is the formula (w⋅χ)(t)=χ(n−1tn)(w \cdot\chi)(t)=\chi(n^{-1}tn) that relates the action of ww on weights to its action on the torus.

/-- ‘Lminus χ = dim ker (M χ)‘: number of massless ‘Fm‘ fermions at weight ‘χ‘. -/
noncomputable def Lminus (χ : X) : N := Module.finrank K (LinearMap.ker (S.M χ))

/-- ‘Lplus χ = dim coker (M χ)‘ = L₊(-χ): number of massless ‘Fp‘ fermions at weight ‘-χ‘. -/
noncomputable def Lplus (χ : X) : N :=
  Module.finrank K (weightSpace chr S.ρp (-χ) / LinearMap.range (S.M χ))

/-- Index at ‘χ‘: massless ‘Fm‘ fermions at ‘χ‘ minus massless ‘Fp‘ fermions at ‘-χ‘. -/
noncomputable def index (χ : X) : Z := (S.Lminus χ : Z) - (S.Lplus χ : Z)

/-- Rank-nullity: ‘index χ = dim Fm(χ) - dim Fp(-χ)‘, independent of the mass matrix. -/
theorem index_eq (χ : X) :
  S.index χ = (Module.finrank K (weightSpace chr S.ρm χ) : Z)
    - Module.finrank K (weightSpace chr S.ρp (-χ)) := by
  have h1 := LinearMap.finrank_range_add_finrank_ker (S.M χ)  -- range + ker = dim Fm(χ)
  have h2 := Submodule.finrank_quotient_add_finrank (LinearMap.range (S.M χ))
    -- coker + range = dim of the dual
  have h3 := Subspace.dual_finrank_eq (K := K) (V := weightSpace chr S.ρp (-χ))
  unfold index Lminus Lplus
  omega

/-- Weyl invariance of the index: ‘index (w·χ) = index χ‘. -/
theorem index_act (hc : CharCompat act chr wt) {w : W} {χ : X} :
  S.index (act w χ) = S.index χ := by
  rw [S.index_eq, S.index_eq, finrank_weightSpace_act hc (S.hnm w) χ, ← act_neg,
finrank_weightSpace_act hc (S.hnp w) (-𝜒)]

The No-Go Theorem. The proof of Theorem 1 has two steps. The first is the elementary statement orbit_contradiction (lines 23–27). It states that a function that is invariant under a group action cannot take different values at xx and w⋅xw \cdot x. The theorem no_go_of_Lplus_ne applies it to the index. If L−L_- vanishes at β\beta and at w⋅βw \cdot\beta, the index equals −-Lplus at both weights, so Lplus must take the same value there.

/-- No massless ‘Fm‘ at ‘β‘, ‘w·β‘ forces ‘Lplus β = Lplus (w·β)‘ (index invariance). -/
theorem no_go_of_Lplus_ne (S : RFermionSystem.{u, uw, x, y, v} act chr wt)
    (hc : CharCompat act chr wt) (β : X) (w : W)
    (ha : S.Lminus β = 0 ∧ S.Lminus (act w β) = 0)
    (hne : S.Lplus β ≠ S.Lplus (act w β)) : False := by
  refine orbit_contradiction (fun g x => act g x) S.index
    (fun g x => S.index_act hc (w := g) (χ := x)) w β ?_
  intro h
  apply hne
  simp only [RFermionSystem.index, ha.1, ha.2] at h
  omega

The second step is the theorem no_go, which is Theorem 1 itself. Read from top to bottom, it says the following. Let SS be a fermion system whose Weyl action satisfies CharCompat, let Δ0\Delta_0 be a set of weights, let β∈Δ0\beta\in\Delta_0, and let ww be an element of the Weyl group with w⋅β∉Δ0w \cdot\beta\notin\Delta_0. Assume condition (a), i.e. Lminus vanishes at β\beta and at w⋅βw \cdot\beta, and condition (b) in the form Lplus χ=1\chi= 1 for χ∈Δ0\chi\in\Delta_0 and 0 otherwise, for χ∈{β,w⋅β}\chi\in\{\beta, w \cdot\beta\}. Then we arrive at a contradiction. Since Δ0=−Δ0\Delta_0 = -\Delta_0 and root spaces are one-dimensional, this form of (b) is condition (b) of Theorem 1. The input from Lie theory enters only through CharCompat and the intertwiners of the fermion system, and no property of Δ0\Delta_0 is needed beyond β∈Δ0\beta\in\Delta_0 and w⋅β∉Δ0w \cdot\beta\notin\Delta_0. The proof evaluates (b) at the two weights, which gives Lplus β=1\beta= 1 and Lplus (w⋅β)=0(w \cdot\beta) = 0, and applies no_go_of_Lplus_ne. The line open Classical in just above the box (line 227) allows the case distinction in (b) for an arbitrary set Δ0\Delta_0.

/-- **The no-go theorem.** An unbroken root ‘β ∈ Δ0‘ with Weyl image ‘w·β ∉ Δ0‘, no massless ‘Fm‘
at ‘β‘, ‘w·β‘, and ‘Lplus β = 1‘, ‘Lplus (w·β) = 0‘ (‘G0‘ gauginos) contradict invariance. -/
theorem no_go (S : RFermionSystem.{u, uw, x, y, v} act chr wt) (hc : CharCompat act chr wt)
    (Δ0 : Set X) (β : X) (hβ : β ∈ Δ0) (w : W) (hw : act w β ∉ Δ0)
    (ha : S.Lminus β = 0 ∧ S.Lminus (act w β) = 0)
    (hb : ∀ χ ∈ ({β, act w β} : Set X), S.Lplus χ = if χ ∈ Δ0 then 1 else 0) : False := by
  -- evaluate (b) at ‘β‘ (uses ‘hβ‘) and at ‘w·β‘ (uses ‘hw‘)
  have h1 : S.Lplus β = 1 := by
    rw [hb β (Set.mem_insert _ _)] ; simp [hβ]
  have h2 : S.Lplus (act w β) = 0 := by
    rw [hb (act w β) (Set.mem_insert_of_mem _ _)] ; simp [hw]
  exact no_go_of_Lplus_ne S hc β w ha (by rw [h1, h2]; decide)

The SU(5) Case. Finally, let us see how the SU(5) result follows. The weights are the elements of Z5\mathbb{Z}^5, i.e. the characters of the diagonal torus of U(5). Weights that differ by a multiple of (1,1,1,1,1)(1, 1, 1, 1, 1) agree on the torus of SU(5), and these multiples are the singlet weights. W is S5S_5 acting by permutations, and Δ0\Delta_0 is the set of the eight roots of GSM_{\mathrm{SM}}. The theorem SU5.no_exact_MSSM has three hypotheses. minus_content says that every massless fermion in F−\mathcal{F}_- has the weight of an MSSM field or of a singlet. plus_unbroken says that there is exactly one massless fermion in F+\mathcal{F}_+, the gluino, at a weight −(e0−e1)-(e_0 - e_1). plus_broken says that there is none at weight −(e0−e3)-(e_0 - e_3). The proof first shows that L−L_- vanishes at both roots. No MSSM weight is a root because of 5-ality, and no singlet weight is a root because a multiple of (1,1,1,1,1)(1, 1, 1, 1, 1) never is. It then applies no_go with β=e0−e1\beta= e_0 - e_1 and w=(1 3)w = (1\ 3). This is the contradiction (13). Here the action of S5S_5 on the weights and on the torus is defined explicitly and CharCompat is proved as SU5.su5_CharCompat, so no hypothesis about Lie theory remains.

/-- **No exact MSSM** in SU(5): MSSM-or-singlet massless ‘Fm‘ fermions, only the ‘SU(3)‘ gaugino
at ‘-(e0-e1)‘ and no massless ‘Fp‘ fermion at ‘-(e0-e3)‘ are contradictory. -/
theorem no_exact_MSSM {K : Type*} [Field K] (S : RFermionSystem (su5Act) (charOf (K := K)) su5Wt)
    (minus_content : ∀ χ, 0 < S.Lminus χ → IsMSSMWeight χ ∨ IsSingletWeight χ)
    (plus_unbroken : S.Lplus (root 0 1) = 1)
    (plus_broken : S.Lplus (root 0 3) = 0) : False := by
  -- (a) at a root ‘root i j‘: no light field there (5-ality), no singlet there
  have ha : ∀ i j : Fin 5, i ≠ j → S.Lminus (root i j) = 0 := fun i j hij =>
    Lminus_eq_zero_of_z’ (Light := {χ | IsMSSMWeight χ}) (Sing := {χ | IsSingletWeight χ})
      (z := fivealityHom) S minus_content fivealityHom_mssm
      (fivealityHom_rootSet _ ⟨i, j, hij, rfl⟩) (root_not_singlet hij)
  -- the abstract no-go with ‘Δ0 = unbrokenSet‘, ‘β = e0-e1‘, ‘w = (1 3)‘
  refine _root_.RNoGoAbstract.no_go S su5_charCompat unbrokenSet (root 0 1) root01_mem
    (Equiv.swap 1 3)
    (by rw [su5Act_apply, weylAct_swap_root]; exact root03_not_mem)
    ⟨ha 0 1 (by decide), by rw [su5Act_apply, weylAct_swap_root]; exact ha 0 3 (by decide)⟩ ?_
  intro χ hχ
  simp only [Set.mem_insert_iff, Set.mem_singleton_iff, su5Act_apply, weylAct_swap_root] at hχ
  rcases hχ with rfl | rfl
  · simp [plus_unbroken, root01_mem]
  · simp [plus_broken, root03_not_mem]

References

References

  1. [1]D. Castelvecchi, “Mathematicians welcome computer-assisted proof in ‘grand unification’ theory,” Nature 595 no. 7865, (2021) 18–19.DOI
  2. [2]J. Commelin and A. Topaz, “Abstraction boundaries and spec driven development in pure mathematics,” Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. (N.S.) 61 no. 2, (2024) 241–255.arxiv.org/abs/2309.14870
  3. [3]K. Buzzard, “Mathematical reasoning and the computer,” Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. (N.S.) 61 no. 2, (2024) 211–224.arxiv.org/abs/2502.07850
  4. [4]J. Avigad, “Mathematics and the formal turn,” Bull. Amer. Math. Soc. (N.S.) 61 no. 2, (2024) 225–240.arxiv.org/abs/2311.00007
  5. [5]J. Tooby-Smith, “Formalizing the stability of the two Higgs doublet model potential into Lean: identifying an error in the literature,” arXiv:2603.08139 [hep-ph].
  6. [6]J. Tooby-Smith, “HepLean: Digitalising high energy physics,” Comput. Phys. Commun. 308 (2025) 109457, arXiv:2405.08863 [hep-ph].
  7. [7]T. P. community, “Physlib: The Lean Physics Library.” https://github.com/leanprover-community/physlib, 2024.
  8. [8]M. Fallbacher, M. Ratz, and P. K. S. Vaudrevange, “No-go theorems for R symmetries in four-dimensional GUTs,” Phys. Lett. B 705 (2011) 503–506, arXiv:1109.4797 [hep-ph].DOI
  9. [9]L. J. Hall, Y. Nomura, and A. Pierce, “R symmetry and the mu problem,” Phys. Lett. B 538 (2002) 359–365, arXiv:hep-ph/0204062.DOI
  10. [10]K. S. Babu, I. Gogoladze, and K. Wang, “Natural R parity, μ-term, and fermion mass hierarchy from discrete gauge symmetries,” Nucl. Phys. B 660 (2003) 322–342, arXiv:hep-ph/0212245.DOI
  11. [11]H. M. Lee, S. Raby, M. Ratz, G. G. Ross, R. Schieren, K. Schmidt-Hoberg, and P. K. Vaudrevange, “A unique Z₄ᴿ symmetry for the MSSM,” Phys. Lett. B694 (2011) 491–495, arXiv:1009.0905 [hep-ph].
  12. [12]H. M. Lee, S. Raby, M. Ratz, G. G. Ross, R. Schieren, K. Schmidt-Hoberg, and P. K. Vaudrevange, “Discrete R symmetries for the MSSM and its singlet extensions,” Nucl. Phys. B850 (2011) 1–30, arXiv:1102.3595 [hep-ph].DOI
  13. [13]H. Baer, V. Barger, and D. Sengupta, “Gravity safe, electroweak natural axionic solution to strong CP and SUSY μ problems,” Phys. Lett. B 790 (2019) 58–63, arXiv:1810.03713 [hep-ph].DOI
  14. [14]P. N. Bhattiprolu and S. P. Martin, “High-quality axions in solutions to the μ problem,” Phys. Rev. D 104 no. 5, (2021) 055014, arXiv:2106.14964 [hep-ph].DOI
  15. [15]S. Raby, Supersymmetric Grand Unified Theories: From Quarks to Strings via SUSY GUTs, vol. 939. Springer, 2017.DOI
  16. [16]S. Dimopoulos, S. Raby, and F. Wilczek, “Supersymmetry and the Scale of Unification,” Phys. Rev. D 24 (1981) 1681–1683.DOI
  17. [17]The mathlib Community, “The Lean mathematical library,” in Proceedings of the 9th ACM SIGPLAN International Conference on Certified Programs and Proofs (CPP 2020), pp. 367–381. ACM, New York, 2020. arXiv:1910.09336 [cs.LO].DOI
  18. [18]S. Krippendorf and J. Tooby-Smith, “Physics as Code: From Scans to Theorems with ITP APIs in SU(5) Model Building,” arXiv:2603.28406 [hep-th].
  19. [19]L. de Moura and S. Ullrich, “The Lean 4 Theorem Prover and Programming Language,” in Automated Deduction – CADE 28, A. Platzer and G. Sutcliffe, eds., vol. 12699 of Lecture Notes in Computer Science, pp. 625–635. Springer, Cham, 2021.DOI
  20. [20]L. J. Dixon, V. Kaplunovsky, and J. Louis, “On Effective Field Theories Describing (2,2) Vacua of the Heterotic String,” Nucl. Phys. B 329 (1990) 27–82.DOI
  21. [21]L. E. Ibáñez and D. Lüst, “A Comment on duality transformations and (discrete) gauge symmetries in four-dimensional strings,” Phys. Lett. B 302 (1993) 38–46, arXiv:hep-th/9212089.DOI
  22. [22]M. W. Goodman and E. Witten, “Global symmetries in four and higher dimensions,” Nucl. Phys. B 271 (1986) 21–52.DOI
  23. [23]P. Fayet and J. Iliopoulos, “Spontaneously Broken Supergauge Symmetries and Goldstone Spinors,” Phys. Lett. B 51 (1974) 461–464.DOI
  24. [24]S. Dimopoulos and H. Georgi, “Softly Broken Supersymmetry and SU(5),” Nucl. Phys. B 193 (1981) 150–162.DOI
  25. [25]L. J. Dixon, J. A. Harvey, C. Vafa, and E. Witten, “Strings on Orbifolds,” Nucl. Phys. B 261 (1985) 678–686.
  26. [26]L. J. Dixon, J. A. Harvey, C. Vafa, and E. Witten, “Strings on Orbifolds. 2.,” Nucl. Phys. B 274 (1986) 285–314.
  27. [27]M. Quiros, “New ideas in symmetry breaking,” in Theoretical Advanced Study Institute in Elementary Particle Physics (TASI 2002): Particle Physics and Cosmology: The Quest for Physics Beyond the Standard Model(s), pp. 549–601. 2, 2003. arXiv:hep-ph/0302189.
  28. [28]S. Ramos-Sanchez and M. Ratz, Heterotic Orbifold Models. Springer, 2024. arXiv:2401.03125 [hep-th].
  29. [29]X.-G. Liu and G.-J. Ding, “Modular flavor symmetry and vector-valued modular forms,” JHEP 03 (2022) 123, arXiv:2112.14761 [hep-ph].DOI
  30. [30]S. Hamidi and C. Vafa, “Interactions on Orbifolds,” Nucl. Phys. B 279 (1987) 465–513.DOI
  31. [31]L. J. Dixon, D. Friedan, E. J. Martinec, and S. H. Shenker, “The Conformal Field Theory of Orbifolds,” Nucl. Phys. B 282 (1987) 13–73.
  32. [32]T. Kobayashi, S. Raby, and R.-J. Zhang, “Searching for realistic 4d string models with a Pati-Salam symmetry: Orbifold grand unified theories from heterotic string compactification on a Z(6) orbifold,” Nucl. Phys. B 704 (2005) 3–55, arXiv:hep-ph/0409098.DOI
  33. [33]N. G. Cabo Bizet, T. Kobayashi, D. K. Mayorga Pena, S. L. Parameswaran, M. Schmitz, and I. Zavala, “Discrete R-symmetries and Anomaly Universality in Heterotic Orbifolds,” JHEP 02 (2014) 098, arXiv:1308.5669 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/1308.5669
  34. [34]H. P. Nilles, S. Ramos-Sánchez, M. Ratz, and P. K. S. Vaudrevange, “A note on discrete R symmetries in Z₆-II orbifolds with Wilson lines,” Phys. Lett. B 726 (2013) 876–881, arXiv:1308.3435 [hep-th].DOI
  35. [35]F. Diamond, J. M. Shurman, and J. Shurman, A first course in modular forms, vol. 228. Springer, 2005.
  36. [36]L. E. Ibáñez and D. Lü̈st, “Duality anomaly cancellation, minimal string unification and the effective low-energy Lagrangian of 4-D strings,” Nucl. Phys. B 382 (1992) 305–361, arXiv:hep-th/9202046.DOI
  37. [37]X.-G. Liu and M. Ratz, “Modular Zeros,” Phys. Lett. B 875 (2026) 140372, arXiv:2512.21386 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2512.21386
  38. [38]F. Feruglio, Are neutrino masses modular forms?, pp. 227–266. 2019. arXiv:1706.08749 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/1706.08749
  39. [39]F. Feruglio and A. Romanino, “Lepton flavor symmetries,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 93 no. 1, (2021) 015007, arXiv:1912.06028 [hep-ph].
  40. [40]Y. Almumin, M.-C. Chen, M. Cheng, V. Knapp-Perez, Y. Li, A. Mondol, S. Ramos-Sanchez, M. Ratz, and S. Shukla, “Neutrino Flavor Model Building and the Origins of Flavor and CP Violation,” Universe 9 no. 12, (2023) 512, arXiv:2204.08668 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2204.08668
  41. [41]G.-J. Ding and S. F. King, “Neutrino mass and mixing with modular symmetry,” Rept. Prog. Phys. 87 no. 8, (2024) 084201, arXiv:2311.09282 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2311.09282
  42. [42]T. Kobayashi and M. Tanimoto, “Modular flavor symmetric models,” Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 39 no. 09n10, (2024) 2441012, arXiv:2307.03384 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2307.03384
  43. [43]M.-C. Chen, M. Ratz, and A. Trautner, “Non-Abelian discrete R symmetries,” JHEP 09 (2013) 096, arXiv:1306.5112 [hep-ph].DOI
  44. [44]R. Kappl, B. Petersen, S. Raby, M. Ratz, R. Schieren, and P. K. S. Vaudrevange, “String-Derived MSSM Vacua with Residual R Symmetries,” Nucl. Phys. B 847 (2011) 325–349, arXiv:1012.4574 [hep-th].DOI
  45. [45]F. Feruglio, V. Gherardi, A. Romanino, and A. Titov, “Modular invariant dynamics and fermion mass hierarchies around τ = i,” JHEP 05 (2021) 242, arXiv:2101.08718 [hep-ph].DOI
  46. [46]P. P. Novichkov, J. T. Penedo, and S. T. Petcov, “Fermion mass hierarchies, large lepton mixing and residual modular symmetries,” JHEP 04 (2021) 206, arXiv:2102.07488 [hep-ph].DOI
  47. [47]C. D. Froggatt and H. B. Nielsen, “Hierarchy of Quark Masses, Cabibbo Angles and CP Violation,” Nucl. Phys. B 147 (1979) 277–298.DOI
  48. [48]M.-C. Chen, X. Li, X.-G. Liu, and M. Ratz, “Modular flavor symmetries and fermion mass hierarchies,” JHEP 10 (2025) 033, arXiv:2506.23343 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2506.23343
  49. [49]L. E. Ibáñez, W. Lerche, D. Lü̈st, and S. Theisen, “Some Considerations About the Stringy Higgs Effect,” Nucl. Phys. B 352 (1991) 435–450.
  50. [50]R. Dijkgraaf, C. Vafa, E. P. Verlinde, and H. L. Verlinde, “The Operator Algebra of Orbifold Models,” Commun. Math. Phys. 123 (1989) 485.DOI
  51. [51]F. Beye, T. Kobayashi, and S. Kuwakino, “Gauge Origin of Discrete Flavor Symmetries in Heterotic Orbifolds,” Phys. Lett. B 736 (2014) 433–437, arXiv:1406.4660 [hep-th].DOI
  52. [52]X. Li, X.-G. Liu, H. P. Nilles, M. Ratz, and A. Stewart, “Flavor symmetries and winding modes,” JHEP 09 (2025) 026, arXiv:2506.12887 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2506.12887
  53. [53]M. Leurer, Y. Nir, and N. Seiberg, “Mass matrix models,” Nucl. Phys. B 398 (1993) 319–342, arXiv:hep-ph/9212278.DOI
  54. [54]M. Leurer, Y. Nir, and N. Seiberg, “Mass matrix models: The Sequel,” Nucl. Phys. B 420 (1994) 468–504, arXiv:hep-ph/9310320.DOI
  55. [55]V. Knapp-Perez, X.-G. Liu, H. P. Nilles, and S. Ramos-Sanchez, “Demystifying stringy miracles with eclectic flavor symmetries,” Phys. Rev. D 113 no. 10, (2026) 106015, arXiv:2512.21382 [hep-th].

Paper details

vlnc:W_sbr4zf89
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Anthropic’s Claude

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents