betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Giant non-volatile electric field control of proximity induced magnetism in the spin-orbit semimetal SrIrO3

Abstract

With its potential for drastically reduced operation power of information processing devices, electric field control of magnetism has generated huge research interest. Recently, novel perspectives offered by the inherently large spin-orbit coupling of 5d transition metals have emerged. Here, we demonstrate non-volatile electrical control of the proximity induced magnetism in SrIrO3 based back-gated heterostructures. We report up to a 700 % variation of the anomalous Hall conductivity σ_AHE and Hall angle θ_AHE as function of the applied gate voltage Vg. In contrast, the Curie temperature TC = 100K and magnetic anisotropy of the system remain essentially unaffected by Vg indicating a robust ferromagnetic state in SrIrO3 which strongly hints to gating-induced changes of the anomalous Berry curvature. The electric-field induced ferroelectric-like state of SrTiO3 enables non-volatile switching behavior of σ_AHE and θ_AHE below 60 K. The large tunability of this system, opens new avenues towards efficient electric-field manipulation of magnetism.

^1Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Institute for Quantum Materials and Technologies, 76021 Karlsruhe, Germany;

^2Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Institute of Nanotechnology and Karlsruhe Nano Micro Facility, 76021 Karlsruhe, Germany;

Introduction

Electric field (EF) control of magnetism in materials is of central importance for the development of sustainable and low power consumption information technology[1–3]. It is particularly challenging to achieve in ferromagnetic (FM) metals in which EF large enough to induce sizeable modifications of the magnetic state can generally not be applied. This has triggered intense research activity in particular on multiferroic oxides, where magnetic and ferroelectric order are inherently coupled, albeit generally weakly, or on heterostructures combining FM metals with a dielectric or ferroelectric gating material. There, the mechanism for the EF control of magnetism can be based on e.g. elastic strain mediation in combination with the inverse magnetostrictive effect, on voltage control of exchange coupling[1], or a modulation of the charge carrier density.

Latter approach is particularly relevant when magnetic phase, -moment, and -anisotropy depend noticeably on the density of states near the Fermi energy EFE_{\mathrm{F}} but is generally not very efficient in good FM metals. There, the EF-induced modulation of the carrier density nn is limited by the Thomas-Fermi screening length λTF∝(1/n)1/6\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} \propto(1/n)^{1/6} which only amounts to about 1 Å[4]. This has proven more effective in semiconductors[5] or in transition metal oxides (TMOs)[1] known for exhibiting significantly smaller nn.

In heavier TMOs, such as the 4d4d TMO SrRuO3_3, electrostatic modulation of nn may not only result in changes of the magnetization and its anisotropy[6] but can also affect the integral of the Berry curvature (BC), thereby leading to changes of the anomalous Hall effect (AHE) - a fingerprint for the FM state in conductive materials[7]. AHE originates from the spin-orbit coupling (SOC) which is naturally present in heavy metals and enables, through an asymmetry in the scattering of spin-polarized electrons[8], an interplay between spin and charge on the electronic transport at the heart of the emerging field of spin-orbitronics.

SOC is particularly strong in the iridium-based 5d5d TMOs of the Ruddlesden-Popper series Srn+1_{n+1}Irn_nO3n+1_{3n+1} in which, however, in contrast to archetypical correlated 3d3d TMOs, the electron-electron correlation strength is generally too small to host ferromagnetism. The iridates display SOC which is on a similar energy scale than that of the electron correlation or electronic bandwidth[9]. Therefore, they are at the verge of a magnetic ground state and may display AFM or FM properties as well, depending on the details of the Hubbard interaction UU and SOC[9]. The rather large Ir5d5d and O2p2p orbital hybridization in SrIrO3_3 (SIO) (n=∞n = \infty) results in a semimetallic paramagnetic state[9–11]. We have recently shown that a FM state with large and positive AHE can be induced in SIO by proximity effect when putting it in direct contact with a FM insulator, LaCoO3_3 (LCO)[12]. Recent first principle calculations on SIO/LCO heterostructures indicate that it originates from unconventional topology of the electronic band-structure of FM SIO[13].

In this work we demonstrate the EF control of magnetism in SIO heterostructures, evidenced through manifold increases of the anomalous Hall conductivity σAHE\sigma_{\mathrm{AHE}}, the Hall angle ΘAHE\Theta_{\mathrm{AHE}} and the magnetoresistance. We further show that a non-volatile EF switching behavior is enabled by the EF-induced ferroelectric state of STO. The effects are discussed in terms of Rashba effect at the SIO/LCO interface and topological BC features of the SIO band structure, and we argue that the latter are more likely to account for the experimental observation.

Results and Discussion

Non-volatile electrostatic gating of SrIrO3_3

Three terminal back-gating devices consisting of epitaxial SIO/LCO heterostructures were prepared by pulsed laser deposition and photolithography, see Methods and Supporting Information (SI). SIO and LCO film thicknesses of 10 monolayers demonstrate stable and reproducible proximity induced ferromagnetism in SIO. A scheme of the device layout is shown in Figure 1a. The high degree of crystallinity at the SIO/LCO interface is documented by the high-resolution scanning transmission electron microscopy (HR-STEM) micrograph in Figure 1b. A gate-voltage Vg>0V_{\mathrm{g}} > 0 (<0< 0) usually results in an electron accumulation (electron depletion) in the SIO channel. The expected charge carrier modulation Δn\Delta n induced by electrostatic gating can be estimated by assuming a parallel-plate capacitor model to be of the order of 0.35 % (SI). The modulation thickness of the SIO channel is in principle limited by the Thomas-Fermi screening length[4], λTF\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}}, which can be significantly larger in semimetals than in good metals due to increased dielectric permittivity (SI). In addition, charge carrier localization may increase λTF\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} considerably as well. In LCO/SIO heterostructures, the first 6 SIO layers show insulating behavior [12]. Therefore, even for the rather short λTF≈0.92\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} \approx0.92 ML as deduced from experiment, a distinct electric field can be expected at the SIO/LCO interface (SI).

Figure 1. Electrostatic gating of a SIO/LCO heterostructure. a Scheme of the three terminal gating device structure. Source (S) and drain (D) contacts to the SIO/LCO interface were done by Al-wire bonding. The gate contact (G) was done by Pt-sputtering, silver paint and Al-wiring. As indicated, a positive gate voltage (VgV_{\mathrm{g}}) usually results in a negative charging of the SIO channel. b (top) Cross-sectional HR-STEM micrograph of a typical SIO/LCO interface. Cations are indicated. The interface displays stoichiometric composition without distinct

structural defects. Element line-scans are indicated and shown below. (bottom) Element line-profiles generated from the cross-sectional HR-STEM. Scan direction (position) is from SIO to LCO. The red (blue) line verifies the atoms on the B- (A-) site of the ABO3ABO_{3}-perovskite structure, i. e., Ir (Sr) and Co (La). Elements are indicated. c Variation of the channel resistance during sweeps of VgV_{\mathrm{g}} at different temperatures. Non-linear and non-volatile hysteretic behavior appears below about 60 K. Arrows indicated VgV_{\mathrm{g}}-sweeping direction. d Dynamic switching behavior (top) for a specific VgV_{\mathrm{g}}-sequence (bottom) at 20 K.

In Figure 1c the relative change of the SIO resistance, ΔR/R\Delta R/R, is shown for VgV_{\mathrm{g}}-sweeps at different temperatures TT. ΔR/R\Delta R/R increases with increasing VgV_{\mathrm{g}}. The positive field coefficient (dR/dVg>0)(\mathrm{d}R/\mathrm{d}V_{\mathrm{g}} > 0) suggests a hole-dominated conductivity in contrast to the generally observed negative Hall coefficient which hints to an electron-type transport[14–16]. This can be accounted for by the different mobilities of the electron and hole charge carriers demonstrated by magnetotransport[16] and electronic Raman scattering[17]. Note that electron- and hole-like pockets of semimetallic SIO sensitively depends on the structural properties (epitaxial strain)[11,14].

The increase of ΔR/R\Delta R/R at any VgV_{\mathrm{g}} with decreasing TT is consistent with the increase of the dielectric constant of STO, εg\varepsilon_{\mathrm{g}}. We obtain ΔR/R≈15%\Delta R/R \approx15\% at T=2T = 2 K for Vg=50V_{\mathrm{g}} = 50 V, which is larger than what is expected from simple electrostatics consideration and indicates decrease of electron mobility for electron accumulation in SIO/LCO (SI). Weak charge carrier localization also likely contributes to the monotonous increase of RR with decreasing TT[12], and explains the distinct increase of λTF\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}}.

At low temperatures, ΔR/R\Delta R/R displays a non-linear and hysteretic behavior upon sweeping VgV_{\mathrm{g}}, akin to gating effects reported in other STO heterostructures[18]. As such, the resistive state for Vg=0V_{\mathrm{g}} = 0 depends on the history (sweeping direction). The effect is only seen for T≤60T \le60 K, the temperature below which STO undergoes a phase transition to a ferroelectric-like state under electric fields E≥2E \ge2 kV/cm[19,20]. The applied field strength (Eg=+/−5E_{\mathrm{g}} = +/- 5 kV/cm) here is large enough to induce such transition and is therefore likely responsible for the observed and well-reproducible non-volatile switching behavior (Figure 1d).

Electric field control of magnetism

We now turn to magnetotransport of the thin SIO layer. The insulating character of LCO confines electric transport solely to SIO and allows unambiguous selective characterization of the proximity induced FM state in SIO[12]. The AHE and the anisotropic magnetoresistance (AMR), two hallmarks of a FM metal, are related to the structure and ordering temperature of the FM state and are therefore useful quantities to characterize the magnetic properties of the material. The Hall resistivity ρxy(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{xy}}(\mu_{0}H) and the magnetoresistance MR=[ρxx(μ0H)−ρxx0]/ρxx0MR = [\rho_{\mathrm{xx}}(\mu_{0}H) - \rho_{\mathrm{xx}}^{0}]/\rho_{\mathrm{xx}}^{0} (ρxx0=ρxx(μ0H=0)\rho_{\mathrm{xx}}^{0} = \rho_{\mathrm{xx}}(\mu_{0}H = 0)) with magnetic field μ0H\mu_{0}H applied perpendicular to the film surface are displayed in Figure 2 for different VgV_{\mathrm{g}} at T=20T = 20 K, i. e., in the FM state of SIO (TC≈100T_{\mathrm{C}} \approx100 K). For other temperatures, see SI.

The total Hall resistivity of SIO, ρxy(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{xy}}(\mu_{0}H) can be decomposed in two components, respectively ordinary (ρOHE\rho_{\mathrm{OHE}}) and anomalous (ρAHE\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}}). ρOHE\rho_{\mathrm{OHE}} is caused by Lorentz force and varies linearly with μ0H\mu_{0}H within the investigated field range. The large hysteresis seen in ρxy\rho_{\mathrm{xy}} (Fig. 2a) results from the anomalous contribution, typical for a FM metal[21]. In conventional magnetic systems, ρAHE\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}} is proportional to the perpendicular magnetization MM, ρAHE=RA×M\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}} = R^{\mathrm{A}} \times M, where RAR^{\mathrm{A}} depends on the longitudinal conductivity σxx\sigma_{\mathrm{xx}} [22]. On this basis, we can well describe our data using the empirical formula ρxy=RO×H+RA×M\rho_{\mathrm{xy}} = R^{\mathrm{O}} \times H + R^{\mathrm{A}} \times M, where M=(Ms×tanh⁡(h×(H±Hc)))M=(M_{\mathrm{s}}\times\tanh(h\times(H\pm H_{\mathrm{c}}))) is modelled using a modified Heaviside-step function. Here MsM_{\mathrm{s}}, hh and HcH_{\mathrm{c}} are the saturation value, the slope at HcH_{\mathrm{c}} and the coercive field, respectively. ρAHE\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}} is obtained after subtraction of the field-linear part contribution to ρxy(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{xy}}(\mu_{0}H) and is shown in Fig. 2b (for ρOHE\rho_{\mathrm{OHE}} see SI).

Remarkably, we observe a strong dependence of ρAHE\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}} with VgV_{\mathrm{g}}, from which we extract a relative increase of MsM_{\mathrm{s}}: (Ms(Vg)−Ms(0))/Ms(0)(M_{\mathrm{s}}(V_{\mathrm{g}})-M_{\mathrm{s}}(0))/M_{\mathrm{s}}(0) by a factor of 7 when going from Vg=−50V_{\mathrm{g}}=-50 V to +50+50 V. A significant increase is also observed for HcH_{\mathrm{c}} and the saturation field HsH_{\mathrm{s}}.

The MR obtained from longitudinal resistivity ρxx(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{xx}}(\mu_{0}H) at 20 K (see Fig. 2c) exhibits strong dependence with VgV_{\mathrm{g}} alike. It is also well described by the sum of two contributions, the classical Lorentz scattering (MR∝H2MR \propto H^{2}) [23] resulting in a positive contribution and spin-flip scattering (MR∝−M2MR \propto-M^{2}), which contributes negatively to MRMR in the FM state [24]. For Vg=+50V_{\mathrm{g}}=+50 V MR is dominated by the negative hysteretic contribution confirming strong FM character, in strong contrast to Vg=−50V_{\mathrm{g}}=-50 V where MRMR is bestridden by the classical positive contribution. For μ0H=14\mu_{0}H=14 T and Vg=+(−)50V_{\mathrm{g}}=+(-)50 V MR amounts to -0.2% (0.4%).

As for the Hall effect, we can extract MM from the MRMR data using a Heaviside step-function to model MM and fit the data, albeit only reliably for Vg>0V_{\mathrm{g}}>0. The effective magnetization MM perpendicular to the plane obtained this way is very similar to that obtained from AHE, as shown on a normalized scale in Fig. 2d. It is worth noting that this is not a trivial result as many different mechanisms – intrinsic (integral of the Berry curvature over occupied states [25]) as well as extrinsic (side-jump- and skew- impurity scattering [26]) can contribute to the AHE. For our SIO/LCO heterostructures the AHE was found to be intrinsic [12].

Figure 2.

Image not extracted

Figure 2 (PDF p. 6). Electric-field dependence of the magnetotransport. a Hall resistivity ρxy\rho_{xy} versus magnetic field μ0H\mu_{0}H for different VgV_g at T=20T = 20 K and b the extracted anomalous part of the Hall resistivity ρAHE\rho_{AHE} (symbols). Fits to the data (see text) are shown by solid lines. ρAHEs\rho_{AHE}^{s} and ρAHEr\rho_{AHE}^{r} define the saturated and remnant value of ρAHE\rho_{AHE}. c The magnetoresistance MRMR versus μ0H\mu_{0}H for different VgV_g at T=20T = 20 K and d the normalized perpendicular magnetization M∗=M(μ0H)/MsM^{*} = M(\mu_{0}H)/M_{s} as derived from the AHE and MRMR versus μ0H\mu_{0}H for Vg>0V_g > 0. Arrows indicate the field-sweep direction and color VgV_g.

Next, we take a closer look at the control of the FM state in SIO by electrostatic gating. In Figure 3a,Figure 3b we show the saturated and the remnant anomalous Hall resistivity ρAHEs=ρAHE\rho_{AHE}^{s} = \rho_{AHE} (μ0H=14\mu_{0}H = 14 T) and ρAHEr=ρAHE\rho_{AHE}^{r} = \rho_{AHE} (μ0H=0\mu_{0}H = 0), (see also Fig. 2b) versus VgV_g. The increase of ρAHEs\rho_{AHE}^{s} with VgV_g is non-linear and indicates the onset of a saturation for ∣Vg∣>50\lvert V_g\rvert> 50 V.

Figure 3. Control of the ferromagnetic state by electrostatic gating. a The saturated and b remnant anomalous Hall resistivity ρAHEs\rho_{AHE}^{s} and ρAHEr\rho_{AHE}^{r} versus VgV_g at T=20T = 20 K, c The Hall-angle QAHE=σAHE/σxx0Q_{AHE} = \sigma_{AHE}/\sigma_{xx}^{0} versus VgV_g at T=20T = 20 K. Arrows indicate the field-sweep direction. d ρAHEs\rho_{AHE}^{s} versus TT for different VgV_g.

The field sweep shows hysteretic behavior due to the hysteretic gating effect of the ferroelectric-like STO, see Figure 1c. As already mentioned, sweeping VgV_g from −50-50 V to +50+50 V increases ρAHEs\rho_{AHE}^{s} by a factor of 7, while ρAHEr\rho_{AHE}^{r} increases by more than one order of magnitude. To the best of our knowledge, and in contrast to reports in e.g. 4d TMO SrRuO3_3 and SrRuO3_3/SIO heterostructures, the dependence of the effective magnetization with VgV_g reported here is remarkably large[7,27,28]. Note that the unipolar electrostatic gating asymmetry of the effect for ρAHEr\rho_{AHE}^{r} which is less affected for Vg<0V_g < 0 (in contrast to ρAHEs\rho_{AHE}^{s}) than for Vg>0V_g > 0 might be of practical interest for the realization of spintronic devices.

Another quantity which is also highly relevant for spintronic purposes is the ratio between the saturated anomalous Hall conductivity σAHEs=ρAHEs/[(ρAHEs)2+(ρxx0)2]\sigma^{s}_{AHE}=\rho^{s}_{AHE}/[(\rho^{s}_{AHE})^2+(\rho^{0}_{xx})^2] and the longitudinal conductivity σxx0=ρxx0/[(ρAHEs)2+(ρxx0)2]\sigma^{0}_{xx}=\rho^{0}_{xx}/[(\rho^{s}_{AHE})^2+(\rho^{0}_{xx})^2] which defines the anomalous Hall angle θAHE=σAHEs/σxx0=ρAHEs/ρxx0\theta_{AHE}=\sigma^{s}_{AHE}/\sigma^{0}_{xx}=\rho^{s}_{AHE}/\rho^{0}_{xx}. Generally, due to the large SOC, θAHE\theta_{AHE} is much larger in the 5d iridates compared to 3d TMOs [22,29]. In Figure 3c, θAHE\theta_{AHE} is shown versus VgV_{\mathrm{g}} for T=20T=20 K. The gate voltage dependence is very similar to that of ρAHEs\rho^{s}_{AHE}, indicating a much stronger influence of VgV_{\mathrm{g}} on ρAHEs\rho^{s}_{AHE} than on ρxx0\rho^{0}_{xx}. This is in full agreement with the intrinsic nature of the AHE in SIO[12], where σAHE\sigma_{AHE} does not depend on σxx\sigma_{xx}. Sweeping VgV_{\mathrm{g}} from -50V to +50 V, increases θAHE\theta_{AHE} by more than 500%. The temperature dependence of MM expressed by ρAHEs(T)\rho^{s}_{AHE}(T) is shown in Figure 3d for different VgV_{\mathrm{g}}. Although ρAHEs(T)\rho^{s}_{AHE}(T) is significantly enhanced for positive VgV_{\mathrm{g}}, the onset of the effect TC≈100T_{\mathrm{C}}\approx100 K is not much affected by VgV_{\mathrm{g}}.

Anomalous magnetoresistance and magnetic anisotropy

Manipulation of the magnetic anisotropy or even switching of the magnetic easy-axis from in- to out-of-plane is of special practical interest. In the following, we discuss the EF-dependence of the magnetic anisotropy.

The proximity induced magnetism of SIO results in an angle-dependent anisotropic magnetoresistance AMR(α)=[ρxx(α)−ρxx(90∘)]/ρxx(90∘)AMR(\alpha)=[\rho_{xx}(\alpha)-\rho_{xx}(90^\circ)]/\rho_{xx}(90^\circ) below TCT_{\mathrm{C}}, where α\alpha is the angle between the in-plane magnetic field- and current-direction (Figure 4b).

Anomalous magnetoresistance of the SIO/LCO heterostructure

Figure 4. Anomalous magnetoresistance of the SIO/LCO heterostructure. a The angle-dependent anisotropic magnetoresistance AMR(α)AMR(\alpha) for different VgV_g at T=20T=20 K and 14 T. b Schematic of the pseudo-cubic crystallographic and in-plane magnetic field direction with respect to the current flow direction. c The two-fold and d the four-fold component of AMR(α)AMR(\alpha), shown in a. Fitting parameters are listed in SI.

Figure 4a displays AMR(α)AMR(\alpha) for different VgV_{\mathrm{g}} at 20 K and 14 T. Local maxima are seen close to 0, 90, 180 and 270 degrees, with amplitude that strongly depend on VgV_{\mathrm{g}}. This can be described combining a two- and a four-fold angle-dependent component: AMR(α)=C0+C2(α)+C4(α)AMR(\alpha)=C_{0}+C_{2}(\alpha)+C_{4}(\alpha), where C2(α)=⟨C2⟩×cos⁡(2α−ω2)C_{2}(\alpha)=\langle C_{2}\rangle\times\cos(2\alpha-\omega_{2}) and C4(α)=⟨C4⟩×cos⁡(4α−ω4)C_{4}(\alpha)=\langle C_{4}\rangle\times\cos(4\alpha-\omega_{4}). C0C_{0}, ⟨C2⟩\langle C_{2}\rangle, and ⟨C4⟩\langle C_{4}\rangle correspond to the amplitude of each component (offset angles ω2\omega_{2} and ω4\omega_{4} are allowed for each of them to account for backlash of the sample rotator).

The two-fold component shows maxima at α=0∘\alpha=0^\circ and 180∘180^\circ, whereas the four-fold component displays minima at α=45∘+(n×90∘)\alpha=45^\circ+(n\times90^\circ), n=0,1,2n=0,1,2, and 3. Fits to the data are shown by solid lines (for fitting parameters, see SI). The extracted two- and four-fold components of AMR(α)AMR(\alpha) are shown in Figure 4c and Figure 4d, respectively.

The angle-dependence of the two-fold component is similar to that of the classical AMR(α)AMR(\alpha) [30], the spin-Hall magnetoresistance, SMR(α)SMR(\alpha) [31], or the spin-orbit magnetoresistance, SOMR(α)SOMR(\alpha) [32]. However, the amplitude of ∼0.04%\sim0.04\% is about two orders of magnitude larger compared to values generally reported for SMR(α)SMR(\alpha) and SOMR(α)SOMR(\alpha) [31,32] and more typical for the normal AMR(α)AMR(\alpha), where the amplitude depends on the effective magnetization of the sample. This is confirmed by the strong increase of ⟨C2⟩\langle C_2\rangle by a factor of 5 with increasing VgV_g, strongly reminiscent of the behavior of ρAHEs\rho_{AHE}^{s} (so of MM).

The four-fold component, on the other hand, does not depend on current direction and is thus related to the magnetocrystalline anisotropy. The minima positions correspond to reduced spin-flip scattering and indicate an in-plane ⟨110⟩\langle110\rangle magnetic easy-axis direction[12]. In comparison, ⟨C4⟩\langle C_4\rangle changes only by a factor of 1.6 when VgV_g is increased which indicates slightly enhanced ⟨110⟩\langle110\rangle-easy-axis behavior. The minima positions of the four-fold magnetocrystalline component are obviously not affected by VgV_g. The measurements suggest negligible influence of VgV_g on the symmetry or strength of the magnetocrystalline anisotropy.

Discussion

We have presented a series of experimental results demonstrating efficient EF-control of the magnetic behavior of SIO-based heterostructures. Very large changes of ρAHE\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}} (×7) and ΘAHE\Theta_{\mathrm{AHE}} (×5) when sweeping the gate voltage from Vg=−50V_g=-50V to +50+50 V are observed, with a strong asymmetry of the effect, which is essentially occurring for Vg>0V_g>0. In contrast, the magnetic anisotropy and TCT_{\mathrm{C}} are rather unaffected. Note that in a Stoner description of SIO ferromagnetism, one could expect TCT_{\mathrm{C}} to be sensitive to changes of the charge carrier density Δn\Delta n upon gating. Given the weakness of the electrostatic modulation (Δn/n≈0.35%\Delta n/n \approx0.35\%, see SI) in this system, the variation of TCT_{\mathrm{C}} might simply be too small to be detected.

How to understand in this context the huge EF-induced changes of the AHE? Two natural options are the EF-dependence of the Rashba effect at the SIO/LCO interface[33–35] [33–36]on the one hand and topological features of SIO band structure on the other hand.

The strength of the Rashba effect can be controlled by an applied strong EF through the linear dependence of the Rashba coefficient αR\alpha_{\mathrm{R}} on EE for free charge carriers[37]. In order to obtain significant effects, large electric field strengths of the order of V/nm have to be applied[33]. Such a large EF may also result in a strong coupling to electronic structure via orbital deformation and anomalous band splitting[38]. The resulting momentum dependent ‘Rashba equivalent’ magnetic field is expected to affect σAHE\sigma_{\mathrm{AHE}} quadratically (so symmetrically) on EF or VgV_g[33], in strong contrast with our experimental observation, ruling out Rashba origin as the main source for the EF tunability of the AHE reported here. Note, electric field strength applied here is only of the order 10−410^{-4} V/nm.

Topological band properties of SIO may also contribute to the AHE. The scattering-independent intrinsic contribution to the AHE comes from the Berry phase supported anomalous velocity. An interesting aspect of the intrinsic contribution to the AHE is that the Hall conductivity σAHE\sigma_{\mathrm{AHE}} is given as an integral of the BC, Ωz\Omega^z, over all occupied states below the Fermi energy[39]:

σAHE=−e2ℏ∫dk(2π)3f(ϵk)Ωz(1)\sigma_{\mathrm{AHE}}=-\frac{e^2}{\hbar}\int\frac{\mathrm{d}k}{(2\pi)^3}f(\epsilon_k)\Omega^z \tag*{(1)}

Here, f(ϵk)f(\epsilon_k) is the Fermi-Dirac distribution function.

A direct connection between BC and magnetotransport has been recently reported for topological insulator Bi2Se3\mathrm{Bi_2Se_3}[40] in which gating-induced upshift of EFE_F was found to increase the contribution of conduction electrons to BC and to increase the spin Hall conductivity. In magnetic oxides with complex band structures, the intrinsic mechanism for the AHE and the spin Hall effect (SHE) is the same[22] and depends on the detailed properties of the momentum-space BC. The presence of band crossing points close to EFE_F can affect the BC and even result in a sign-change of the AHE[41].

For SIO, the large intrinsic SHE previously reported[42,43] supports the existence of BC anomalies. Furthermore, recent first principle calculations on SIO/LCO heterostructures unraveled a ferromagnetic band structure for the tetragonal structured SIO exhibiting non-trivial topological features (double Weyl points above and below EFE_F) responsible for a large AHE[13]. Their location in the Brillouin zone of the tetragonal distorted FM SIO is shown in Figure 5b.

Structure and topology of FM SIO and influence on the AHE

Figure 5. a Structure of the SIO/LCO heterostructure. Only the pseudo-cubic perovskite cells are indicated. In-plane lattice parameters are the same as for STO substrate. Out-of-plane lattice parameter of SIO (LCO) is larger (smaller) compared to that of STO. The (a0a0c−a^{0}a^{0}c^{-}) octahedral rotation pattern of LCO and SIO is indicated by arrows. b The Brillouin zone of the tetragonal distorted FM SIO. High symmetric points are indicated. Weyl points with positive (green) and negative (grey) chirality are highlighted. Data were taken from Ref.[13]. c Integral of the BC as a function of EFE_{\mathrm{F}}. Weyl crossing points occurring 20 meV below EFE_{\mathrm{F}} (indicated by black dashed line) result in a strong increase of −∫Ωz-\int\Omega^{z}. Similar behavior is expected when EFE_{\mathrm{F}} (indicated by red dashed line) is further increased above the second double of Weyl points located 10 meV above. An increase of VgV_{\mathrm{g}} and nn also increases EFE_{\mathrm{F}} resulting in a similar rise of σAHE\sigma_{\mathrm{AHE}} compared to that of −∫Ωz-\int\Omega^{z} which is shown on the right.

They indeed contribute positively to the AHE and the integral BC results in σAHE=7.5 Ω−1cm−1\sigma_{\mathrm{AHE}} = 7.5\ \Omega^{-1}\mathrm{cm}^{-1}, well comparable to the experimental value of 3 Ω−1cm−13\ \Omega^{-1}\mathrm{cm}^{-1} for SIO/LCO below 30 K[12].

This allows us to sketch a scenario for the EFE_{\mathrm{F}} control of magnetism in SIO reported here: since double Weyl points are located only 10 meV above EFE_{\mathrm{F}}, an EFE_{\mathrm{F}}-induced charge carrier accumulation (Vg>0V_{\mathrm{g}} > 0) may shift EFE_{\mathrm{F}} across those band-crossing points (indicated by the dashed black lines in Figure 5c). The shift of EFE_{\mathrm{F}} can be estimated by the electron doping Δn=3.5×1018 cm−3\Delta n = 3.5 \times10^{18}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} for Vg=+50V_{\mathrm{g}} = +50 V (see SI) and the density of states (DOS) at EFE_{\mathrm{F}} (see SI of Ref.[13]). Considering the integrated density of states, a shift of 0.01 eV by Δn\Delta n and therefore access of the second Weyl point by electric gating is very likely. When this occurs, the integral BC increases abruptly and so do σAHE\sigma_{\mathrm{AHE}} or ΘAHE\Theta_{\mathrm{AHE}}[44,45]. The minor influence of VgV_{\mathrm{g}} on the magnetic ordering temperature TCT_{\mathrm{C}} and anisotropy tend to favor such topology-based scenario [45].

Many properties such as the orbital magnetization and anomalous Hall conductivity can be expressed in terms of Berry phases, connections, and curvatures and are therefore directly related to each other. Hence, ρxx(μ0H)\rho_{xx}(\mu_{0}H) and MRMR will naturally be affected by the AHE alike[46]. As such, the direct relation between ρAHE(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}}(\mu_{0}H) and MRMR emphasized earlier (Fig. 2d) also favors the topological scenario.

Conclusion

In summary, we have shown that electrostatic gating allows for a very large tunability of the proximity induced σAHE\sigma_{\mathrm{AHE}}, ΘAHE\Theta_{\mathrm{AHE}} and MRMR in SIO/LCO heterostructures likely rooted by the singular band structure of SIO. The results demonstrate that the magnetic properties of FM topological materials can be very effectively controlled by electric fields, offering a promising avenue for realizing energy efficient spintronic devices.

Experimental Section/Methods

Sample preparation

The SIO/LCO heterostructures were grown on (001) oriented SrTiO3_3 (STO) substrates by pulsed laser deposition. First, 10 MLs of SIO were deposited on TiO2_2-terminated (001)-oriented STO substrate, followed by the deposition of 10 MLs of LCO. Film-thickness and layer-by-layer growth were controlled in-situ by reflection high energy electron diffraction (RHEED). More details on film preparation are described elsewhere [12,47]. After film preparation, microbridges (40 μ\mum width and 200 μ\mum length) were patterned by standard ultraviolet photolithography and Ar-ion etching. Next, the STO substrate was thinned down from the backside to about 0.1 mm to increase possible electric field strength. The back-gate electrode was provided by Pt-sputtering, silver-paste and Al-wiring, whereas source and drain contacts to the SIO/LCO interface were done by ultrasonic Al-wire bonding.

The structural properties of the SIO/LCO heterostructures were analyzed by x-ray diffraction using a Bruker D8 DaVinci diffractometer and high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) as shown elsewhere [12].

Electronic Transport and data analysis

Measurements of the electronic transport were carried out using a physical properties measurement system (PPMS) from Quantum Design. The modulated (2Hz) source-drain sample current was typically 1-10 μ\muA. A sample rotator HR- 133 was used for angle-dependent magnetoresistance measurements. The gate-voltage was provided externally by a Keithley 6517B Electrometer, constrained to 50V by the PPMS. Before the measurements, the sample were kept for 12 hours in the cryostat at 2K to stabilize sample and the gate-voltage was ramped up and down several times. AMR(α)AMR(\alpha) measurements were done starting from VgV_{\mathrm{g}} = -50 V to VgV_{\mathrm{g}} = +50 V.

The longitudinal and transversal resistivity were symmetrized and anti-symmetrized with respect to magnetic field to obtain ρxx(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{xx}}(\mu_0H) and ρxy(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{xy}}(\mu_0H), respectively. ρAHE(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}}(\mu_0H) was deduced from ρxy(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{xy}}(\mu_0H) by subtraction of the linear part, i. e., ρOHE(μ0H)\rho_{\mathrm{OHE}}(\mu_0H). Angle-dependent ρxx(α)\rho_{\mathrm{xx}}(\alpha) was corrected with respect to sample wobbling and offset resistance. All the fitting routines described in the text were carried out with MATLAB and fitting parameters are listed in the SI.

Supporting Information

Supporting Information is available from the Wiley Online Library or from the author.

Acknowledgements

A. K. J. acknowledges financial support from the European Union’s Framework Programme for Research and Innovation, Horizon 2020, under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No. 847471 (QUSTEC). D. F. thanks S. Rom and T. Saha-Dasgupta from the S. N. Bose National Centre for Basic Sciences (Kolkata, India) for fruitful discussions. We are grateful to R. Thelen and the Karlsruhe Nano-Micro Facility (KNMF) for technical support.

Giant non-volatile electric field control of proximity induced magnetism in the spin-orbit semimetal SrIrO3\mathrm{SrIrO}_{3}

A. K.; R.; D.; V.; M.; D.

Device preparation. Three terminal back-gating devices comprising epitaxial SIO/LCO heterostructures on (001) oriented SrTiO3_3 (STO) substrates were prepared by pulsed laser deposition and standard photolithography. After film preparation, microbridges (40 μm40\ \mathrm{\mu m} width and 200 μm200\ \mathrm{\mu m} length) were patterned by standard ultraviolet photolithography and Ar-ion etching. Next, the STO substrate was thinned down from the backside to about 0.1 mm0.1\ \mathrm{mm} to increase possible electric field strength. The back-gate electrode was provided by Pt-sputtering, silver-paste and Al-wiring whereas source and drain contacts to the SIO/LCO interface were done by ultrasonic Al-wire bonding. The final device is shown in Figure S1.

Three terminal back-gating device

Figure S1. Three terminal back-gating device. Top view of the device. Contact pads for current II, voltage VV and Hall-voltage VHV_{\mathrm{H}} are indicated. Microbridges (40 μm×200 μm40\ \mathrm{\mu m} \times200\ \mathrm{\mu m}) along the [100]pc_{\mathrm{pc}} and [010]pc_{\mathrm{pc}} pseudo-cubic direction of SIO are available. Al-bonds are located at the end of the contact pads. Back side of the thinned STO substrate is covered with silver paste for contacting the gate. Scale is visualized by millimeter paper.

Electric field-effect in SIO heterostructures. In the following, we show electric field-effect experiments on two different types of SIO heterostructures, a STO/SIO/STO/LCO (sample A) and a STO/SIO/LCO heterostructure (sample B). Both samples display a layer thickness of 10 monolayer (ML) of SIO and LCO. In contrast to sample B, where SIO shows proximity induced magnetism at the SIO/LCO interface, SIO is not magnetic in sample A, where proximity effect is suppressed by a 4 ML thick STO insertion layer. The field effect devices are prepared as documented in the main text. From a back-gate capacitor model, the change in the charge carrier concentration nn at Vg=+50V_g = +50 V amounts to Δn=3.5×1018\Delta n = 3.5 \times10^{18} cm−3^{-3}, see below. For sample A (n=1.9×1021n = 1.9 \times10^{21} cm−3^{-3}) and B (n=1×1021n = 1 \times10^{21} cm−3^{-3}) this corresponds to a relative change Δn/n\Delta n/n of 0.18% and 0.35%, respectively.

The expected charge carrier modulation Δn\Delta n induced by electrostatic gating was estimated by assuming a parallel-plate capacitor model:

Δn=ε0εgEgedch\Delta n = \frac{\varepsilon_0 \varepsilon_g E_g}{e d_{ch}}

where ε0\varepsilon_0 and εg\varepsilon_g are the permittivity of vacuum and STO, EgE_g the gate electric field strength, ee the elementary charge and dchd_{ch} the channel thickness. Due to the TT-dependence of εg\varepsilon_g the gating effect becomes increasingly efficient with decreasing TT. Assuming εg≈5000\varepsilon_g \approx5000 for T<40T < 40 K and Eg=5E_g = 5 kV/cm (Vg≈50V_g \approx50 V), Δn\Delta n amounts to 3.5×10183.5 \times10^{18} cm−3^{-3}. With respect to the charge carrier density n≈1021n \approx10^{21} cm−3^{-3} of the SIO channel this corresponds to a charge carrier modulation of about 0.35%.

To probe charge carrier concentration, Hall measurements were carried out. The transversal Hall resistance RxyR_{xy} of SIO films typically show linear behavior for magnetic fields B≤14B \le14 T, despite the semimetallic behavior of SIO. Considering two types of charge carriers, i. e., electrons and holes, a two-band model is used to describe RxyR_{xy}:

Rxy=(nhμh2−neμe2)+μh2μe2(nh−ne)B2(nhμh+neμe)2+μh2μe2(nh−ne)2B2(2)R_{xy} = \frac{(n_h \mu_h^2 - n_e \mu_e^2) + \mu_h^2 \mu_e^2 (n_h-n_e)B^2}{(n_h\mu_h+n_e\mu_e)^2+\mu_h^2\mu_e^2(n_h-n_e)^2B^2} \tag*{(2)}

which in the low field limit results in:

Rxy/B∝(nhμh2−neμe2)(3)R_{xy}/B \propto(n_h\mu_h^2-n_e\mu_e^2) \tag*{(3)}

where nhn_h, nen_e, and μh\mu_h, μe\mu_e are the density and mobility of holes and electrons, respectively. In Figure S2, the relative change of the SIO channel resistance of sample A is shown versus the gate voltage VgV_g for different TT. The hysteretic behavior for T<60T < 60 K is caused by electric-field induced ferroelectric-like state in STO, see also main text. Interestingly, RR increases for Vg>0V_g > 0. Generally, Vg>0V_g > 0 results in an electron accumulation, i. e., in an increase of nen_e (Δne>0\Delta n_e > 0). Therefore, a decrease of the electron mobility is expected where:

Electric field-effect plots for SIO heterostructures

Figure S2. Electric field-effect in SIO heterostructures. The electric field-effect on a STO/SIO/STO/LCO (sample A, see (a) and (b)) and a STO/SIO/LCO heterostructure (sample B, see (c) and (d)). Both samples display a layer thickness of 10 monolayer (ML) of SIO and LCO. In contrast to sample B, where SIO shows proximity induced magnetism at the SIO/LCO interface, SIO is not magnetic in sample A, where proximity effect is prevented by a 4 ML thick STO insertion layer. The relative change of the SIO channel resistance is shown versus the gate voltage

Δne<−Δ(μe2)(4)\Delta n_e < -\Delta(\mu_e^2) \tag*{(4)}

A change of nhn_h and μh\mu_h is neglected for Vg>0V_g > 0. With respect to Eq. (4), a decrease of μ\mu with increasing nn is usually observed for SIO and oxide heterostructures at low TT for n>1019n > 10^{19} cm−3^{-3}.

For sample A, ΔR/R\Delta R/R amounts to about +0.5% (-0.5%) for Vg=50V_g = 50 V (Vg=−50V_g = -50 V) and T≤30T \le30 K. Assuming R∝(nμ)−1R \propto(n\mu)^{-1} the relative change of RR is given by:

ΔR/R=−(Δn/n+Δμ/μ)(5)\Delta R/R = -(\Delta n/n+\Delta\mu/\mu) \tag*{(5)}

Therefore, for Δn/n=0.18%\Delta n/n = 0.18\%, the relative decrease of μ\mu should be around Δμ/μ=−0.68%\Delta\mu/\mu= -0.68\%, which is well in the range of what has been observed for SIO (see Manca et al., Phys. Rev. B. 97 (2018)).

The TT-dependence of the gating effect is shown in Figure S2, where ΔR/R\Delta R/R versus TT is plotted for Vg=+50V_g = +50 V. As expected, the TT-dependence is very similar to that of the permittivity ε(T)\varepsilon(T) of the STO gate material, i. e., a distinct increase below 100 K and saturation below about 30 K for E>1.5E > 1.5 kV/cm.2

From these observations, the gating effect on the STO/SIO/STO/LCO heterostructure (sample A) is well described by simple electrostatics and the semimetallic behavior of SIO. However, for the STO/SIO/LCO heterostructure (sample B), where LCO is in direct contact with SIO, the gating effect is different. The relative change ΔR/R\Delta R/R for Vg=+50V_g = +50 V amounts to 15% at 2 K and is about 30 times larger compared to sample A even though the field-induced electron accumulation should be the same in both samples. With respect to Eq. (5) a decrease of Δμ/μ≈−15.35%\Delta\mu/\mu\approx-15.35\% is expected, which may hint towards weak charge carrier localization in SIO. This is well consistent with the RR versus TT behavior of both samples (see SI of Ref. [12]). The TT-dependence of ΔR/R\Delta R/R, see Figure S2, also differs significantly to that of sample A. ΔR/R\Delta R/R steadily increases with decreasing TT down to 2 K.

for different TT in (a) and (c). The TT-dependence of the relative change of the SIO channel resistance ΔR/R=[R(Vg)−R(0)]/R(0)\Delta R/R = [R(V_{\mathrm{g}})-R(0)]/R(0) is displayed in (b) and (d).

Electric screening. The effective modulation thickness of the SIO channel is in principle limited by the Thomas-Fermi screening length λTF\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}}, which describes the penetration of the electric field EE into the channel material as a function of distance zz from the gate-channel interface: E(x)=E(0)exp⁡(−z/λTF)E(x) = E(0)\exp(-z/\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}}), where λTF=(ε0εk/e2N(EF))1/2\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} = (\varepsilon_0\varepsilon_{\mathrm{k}}/e^2N(E_{\mathrm{F}}))^{1/2}. Here, εk\varepsilon_{\mathrm{k}} and N(EF)N(E_{\mathrm{F}}) are the dielectric permittivity and density of states near the Fermi energy EFE_{\mathrm{F}} of the channel material. In the limit of a 3-dimensional electron gas this results in λTF≈(ε0εkℏ2π/me2)1/2×(π/(3n))1/6\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} \approx(\varepsilon_0\varepsilon_{\mathrm{k}}\hbar^2\pi/me^2)^{1/2}\times(\pi/(3n))^{1/6}, with the particle mass mm and density nn. Assuming εk=10\varepsilon_{\mathrm{k}} = 10 (typical for semimetals – large values of εk=30\varepsilon_{\mathrm{k}} = 30 have been reported for Sr2IrO4\mathrm{Sr}_2\mathrm{IrO}_4[48,49] and even higher values εk≈600\varepsilon_{\mathrm{k}} \approx600 for other iridates [1]) λTF\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} amounts to about 6 Å, which is significantly larger compared to good metals (λTF∼1\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} \sim1 Å), however still smaller compared to the SIO film thickness of 10 ML (≈40\approx40 Å). To increase λTF\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} by one order of magnitude (λTF≥60\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} \ge60 Å), εk\varepsilon_{\mathrm{k}} has to be increased by two orders of magnitude (εk≥1000\varepsilon_{\mathrm{k}} \ge1000).

On the other side, in case of electron localization classical Lindhard theory and derived formula for Thomas Fermi screening length λTF\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}}, which assumes uniform electron gas, does not hold any more. Localized electrons cannot move freely, and hence electric fields are not fully screened. In this case, even weak charge carrier localization such as likely present in sample B will result in a significant drop of the dynamic screening and a much larger screening length compared to the expected value of λTF\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}}. We want to point out here, that the first few layers of SIO on STO do show insulating behavior. As documented in Fig. 2b of Ref. [12], the first 6 layers of SIO in the SIO/LCO heterostructures are obviously not conductive. Therefore, distinct damping of the electric field in SIO may start not before the 7th layer!

To probe the thickness dependence of the electric field effect in more detail, we have prepared a set of LCO(10 ML)/SIO(xxML) heterostructures with different SIO film thickness (x=6x = 6 – 15 ML). In Figure S3 we have shown the normalized resistance versus TT for different xx. Obviously, for x<10x < 10 ML the resistance strongly increases with decreasing TT. For x=6x = 6, the films are insulating below 100K. The gating effect, i. e., the relative change of the resistance with gate voltage ΔR/R=[R(+50V)−R(0)]/R(0)\Delta R/R = [R(+50\mathrm{V})-R(0)]/R(0) versus xx is displayed in Figure S3 for T=10T = 10K. For x>10x > 10 ML the gating effect drops down exponentially, as expected from classical electric field damping. Assuming charge carrier modulation Δn/n\Delta n/n proportional to ΔR/R\Delta R/R and proportional to electric field strength EE we can deduce electric field damping. From the exponential drop, λTF≈0.92\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} \approx0.92 ML is deduced, which compares well with the estimated value of 6 Å. This result is also consistent with the assumption that the first 6 SIO layers are insulating. Figure S4 demonstrates E(x)E(x) assuming insulating behavior for the first 6 ML of SIO and λTF=0.92\lambda_{\mathrm{TF}} = 0.92 ML. A distinct electric field can be expected in the magnetic active SIO layers. As already shown in Ref.[12], the magnetic proximity effect is triggered by interfacial charge transfer from Ir4+\mathrm{Ir}^{4+} to Co2+\mathrm{Co}^{2+} and limited to the first or second SIO layer close to the SIO/LCO interface.

Normalized resistivity of LCO(10)/SIO(x) heterostructures and relative resistance change versus SIO thickness

Figure S3. (a) Normalized resistivity of LCO/SIO heterostructures for different SIO layer thickness xx as a function of TT. For x≤6x \le6 ML resistance is above measurement limit below 100K. (b) Relative change of the resistance with gating voltage VgV_{\mathrm{g}} as a function of SIO layer thickness xx at T=10T = 10K. ΔR/R=[R(+50V)−R(0)]/R(0)\Delta R/R = [R(+50\mathrm{V})-R(0)]/R(0). Red symbols correspond to samples with a STO-gate thickness of 0.17 mm. The black symbol corresponds to the heterostructure sample (B) – see also main text-, where the STO thickness was only 0.1 mm.

Screening of the electric field in the LCO/SIO/STO heterostructures

Figure S4. Screening of the electric field in the LCO/SIO/STO heterostructures. The insulating layers and magnetic active layers in SIO are indicated by grey and blue shaded region. The screening length was chosen to be 0.92 ML as deduced from experiment (see above). Distinct residual field is expected at the SIO/LCO interface.

Figure S5. Field-induced ferroelectric-like sate in SrTiO3_3. Figure S5. Remnant resistivity change versus TT. The remnant resistivity change ΔR/R\Delta R/R at Vg=0V_g = 0 as a function of temperature. The resistivity change was averaged for decreasing and increasing VgV_g to 0. The onset of ΔR/R\Delta R/R indicates field-induced ferroelectric-like state below 60 K.

Magnetotransport of SIO/LCO heterostructures. The normal magnetoresistance MR=(ρxx(μ0H)−ρxx(0))/ρxx(0)MR = (\rho_{xx}(\mu_0H)-\rho_{xx}(0))/\rho_{xx}(0) and the Hall resistivity ρxy(μ0H)\rho_{xy}(\mu_0H) with magnetic field μ0H\mu_0H perpendicular to the film surface are displayed in Figure S6 for different VgV_g (+50, 0, and -50 V) at various temperatures for T<TCT < T_\mathrm{C} (T=20T = 20, 30, 40, and 80 K). Magnetotransport reflects the FM state of SIO (TC≈100T_\mathrm{C} \approx100 K). MRMR (see Figure S6) is well described by the sum of two contributions, the classical Lorentz scattering (MR∝H2MR \propto H^2) resulting in a positive contribution to MRMR and spin-flip scattering (MR∝−M2MR \propto-M^2), which is effectively suppressed in the FM state and leading to a negative contribution to MRMR below TCT_\mathrm{C}. The Hall resistivity ρxy(μ0H)\rho_{xy}(\mu_0H) (see Figure S6) is also best described by the sum of two components, i. e., the ordinary Hall resistivity ρOHE\rho_\mathrm{OHE} caused by Lorentz force which for SIO films is usually found to be linear to μ0H\mu_0H in that field-range, and a hysteretic anomalous part ρAHE\rho_\mathrm{AHE}, typical for a FM metal. ρAHE\rho_\mathrm{AHE} (see Figure S6) has been obtained by subtracting the linear contribution ρOHE\rho_\mathrm{OHE} (see Figure S6) from ρxy(μ0H)\rho_{xy}(\mu_0H). Magnetization obviously increases with decreasing TT and positive gate voltage (Vg>0V_g > 0) resulting in a continuous increase of ρAHE\rho_\mathrm{AHE} and the negative contribution to MRMR.

Figure S6. Electric-field dependence of the magnetotransport for T<TcT<T_{\mathrm{c}}. The magnetoresistance MRMR (a), Hall-resistivity ρxy\rho_{xy} (b), the anomalous part ρxyAHE\rho_{xy}^{\mathrm{AHE}} of the Hall-resistivity ρxy\rho_{xy} (c), and the ordinary part ρxyOHE\rho_{xy}^{\mathrm{OHE}} of ρxy\rho_{xy} versus μ0H\mu_{0}H for different VgV_{\mathrm{g}} (blue: -50V, red: 0V, and black: +50V) for T=20T=20, 30, 40, and 80K.

The slope of ρOHE\rho_\mathrm{OHE} versus TT is always negative indicating electron-like transport. However, slope of ρOHE\rho_\mathrm{OHE} increases with increase VgV_g. Within a two-type carrier model, this is explained by a reduction of the electron mobility μ\mu in that way, that it overcompensates the increase of nn, see Eq. (4).

Anomalous magnetoresistance

Anomalous magnetoresistance. The proximity induced magnetism of SIO results in an angle-dependent anisotropic magnetoresistance AMR(α)=[ρxx(α)−ρxx(90∘)]/ρxx(90∘)AMR(\alpha)=[\rho_{xx}(\alpha)-\rho_{xx}(90^\circ)]/\rho_{xx}(90^\circ) below TCT_{\mathrm{C}}, where α\alpha is the angle between the in-plane magnetic field- and current-direction. AMR(α)AMR(\alpha) is well described by a two- and a four-fold component, i. e.,AMR(α)=C0+C2(α)+C4(α)i.\ e., AMR(\alpha)=C_{0}+C_{2}(\alpha)+C_{4}(\alpha), where C2(α)=⟨C2⟩×cos⁡(2α−ω2)C_{2}(\alpha)=\langle C_{2}\rangle\times\cos(2\alpha-\omega_{2}) and C4(α)=⟨C4⟩×cos⁡(4α−ω4)C_{4}(\alpha)=\langle C_{4}\rangle\times\cos(4\alpha-\omega_{4}), with the amplitudes C0C_{0}, ⟨C2⟩\langle C_{2}\rangle, and ⟨C4⟩\langle C_{4}\rangle and the offset angles ω2\omega_{2} and ω4\omega_{4}. Figures S7a and S8a display AMR(α)AMR(\alpha) for different VgV_{\mathrm{g}} at 5 and 10K for H=14H=14 T. The corresponding two-fold and four-fold components are shown in the figures (b) and (c), respectively.

C2(α)C_{2}(\alpha) shows maxima at α=0∘\alpha=0^\circ (current parallel to HH and the <100>pc<100>_{\mathrm{pc}} pseudo-cubic crystallographic direction) and 180∘180^\circ, whereas C4(α)C_{4}(\alpha) displays minima at α=45∘+n×90∘\alpha=45^\circ+n\times90^\circ (n=0n=0, 1, 2, and 3). The amplitude ⟨C2⟩\langle C_{2}\rangle increases strongly when VgV_{\mathrm{g}} changes from -50 V to 50 V. The increase is well comparable to the increase of ρAHES\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}}^{S} and hence obviously related to the increase of the magnetization. In comparison, ⟨C4⟩\langle C_{4}\rangle changes less with VgV_{\mathrm{g}} however still indicate enhanced <110><110>-easy-axis behavior. The positions of the extrema are obviously not affected by VgV_g. For T>40T > 40 K AMR(α)AMR(\alpha) diminishes very much which makes distinct data analysis difficult.

Figure S7. Anomalous magnetoresistance of SIO/LCO heterostructures at T=5T = 5K. (a) The angle-dependent anisotropic magnetoresistance AMR(α)AMR(\alpha) at T=5T = 5K for Vg=50V_g = 50V, 0, and -50 V. (b) The two-fold component C2C_2 and (c) the four-fold component C4C_4 of AMR(α)AMR(\alpha).

Figure S8. Anomalous magnetoresistance of SIO/LCO heterostructures at T=10KT = 10\mathrm{K}. (a) The angle-dependent anisotropic magnetoresistance AMR(α)\mathrm{AMR}(\alpha) at T=5KT = 5\mathrm{K} for Vg=50VV_{\mathrm{g}} = 50\mathrm{V}, 0, and −50V-50\mathrm{V}. (b) The two-fold component C2C_{2} and (c) the four-fold component C4C_{4} of AMR(α)\mathrm{AMR}(\alpha).

Fitting parameters. In the Table S1-Table S3 we have summarized all fitting parameters as deduced from fittings shown in the main manuscript, Fig. 2b and c, and Figure 4a.

VV (V)a1a_{1} (μΩcm\mu\Omega\mathrm{cm})ω1\omega_{1} (T−1\mathrm{T}^{-1})Bc,1B_{\mathrm{c},1} (T)a2a_{2} (μΩcm\mu\Omega\mathrm{cm})ω2\omega_{2} (T−1\mathrm{T}^{-1})Bc,2B_{\mathrm{c},2} (T)
+5016.410.1960.8166.310.5035.573
+3015.780.2630.5264.040.6312.547
09.310.6470.1163.990.1991.532
-300.651.4592.22045E-144.310.2101.107
-501.600.2272.22045E-141.830.2222.446

Table S1. Fitting parameters for fitting ρAHE\rho_{\mathrm{AHE}} at T=20KT = 20\mathrm{K} as shown in Fig. 2b. For the fitting, two Heaviside-step functions corresponding to ρxyAHE=a1tanh⁡(ω1(B−Bc,1))+a2tanh⁡(ω2(B−Bc,2))\rho_{xy}^{\mathrm{AHE}} = a_{1}\tanh\left(\omega_{1}(B-B_{\mathrm{c},1})\right) + a_{2}\tanh\left(\omega_{2}(B-B_{\mathrm{c},2})\right) were used:

TT (K)VgV_{\mathrm{g}} (V)C0C_0 (%)C2C_2 (%)ω2\omega_2 (°)C4C_4 (%)ω4\omega_4 (°)
20+50 V0.013370.03719186.310.021762.27
200 V-0.018440.0111185.480.019612.33
20-50 V-0.012830.00875190.140.01644-10.14

Table S3. Fitting parameters for fitting AMR(α)=[ρxx(α)−ρxx(90∘)]/ρxx(90∘)AMR(\alpha) = [\rho_{xx}(\alpha)-\rho_{xx}(90^\circ)]/\rho_{xx}(90^\circ). A two- and four-fold component was used to fit the data corresponding to AMR(α)=C0+⟨C2⟩×cos⁡(2α−ω2)+⟨C4⟩×cos⁡(4α−ω4)AMR(\alpha) = C_0 + \langle C_2\rangle\times\cos(2\alpha-\omega_2) + \langle C_4\rangle\times\cos(4\alpha-\omega_4).

VV (V)aa (T−2^{-2})bb (T−1^{-1})Ms,1M_{\mathrm{s},1} (T−1^{-1})ω1′\omega'_1 (T−1^{-1})B1c′B'_{1\mathrm{c}} (T)Ms,2M_{\mathrm{s},2} (T−1^{-1})ω2′\omega'_2 (T−1^{-1})B2c′B'_{2\mathrm{c}} (T)
+501.1123E-51.43608E-642.650.1330.03214.870.2394.533
+301.22407E-52.22099E-625.680.1670.25712.980.4981.693
01.86491E-53.56194E-725.000.5010.2052.22045E-142.22045E-142.22045E-14

Table S2. Fitting parameters for fitting MRMR at T=20T = 20 K as shown in Fig. 2c. For the fitting, two Heaviside-step functions for the description of MM were used, i. e., MR(%)=aB2−bM2=aB2−b(Ms,1tanh⁡(ω1′(B−B1c′))+Ms,2tanh⁡(ω2′(B−B2c′)))2MR(\%) = aB^2 - bM^2 = aB^2 - b(M_{\mathrm{s},1}\tanh(\omega'_1(B - B'_{1\mathrm{c}})) + M_{\mathrm{s},2}\tanh(\omega'_2(B - B'_{2\mathrm{c}})))^2.

References:

[1] J. Terzic et al., Phys. Rev. B 91, 235147 (2015).

References

  1. [1][S1] J. Terzic et al., Phys. Rev. B 91, 235147 (2015).

Paper details

vlnc:W_sd8mtscy
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents