betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Pressure-induced structural phase transitions of zirconium: An ab initio study based on statistical ensemble theory

Abstract

The structural phase behaviors of pure zirconium metal under compressions up to 160160 GPa at room temperature are investigated from the perspective of ensemble theory where the partition function is solved by our recently proposed method with ab initio precision. The derived Gibbs free energy is employed as the very criterion to determine phase transitions and the calculated transition pressures of the α→ω→βα\rightarrowω\rightarrowβ are 6.936.93 and 24.8324.83 GPa respectively, the former one of which is so far the only theoretical result agreeing with multiple experimental measurements to our best knowledge. The differences between the obtained parameter-free equation of state and those from latest experiments are less than 1.5%1.5\% in the whole studied pressure range, and particularly, within 0.7%0.7\% when the applied pressure exceeds over 4040 GPa, the coincidence of which makes us support the argument that the previously observed anharmonicity-driven isostructural phase transition does not exist in the ββ-phase even though the thermal effects at room temperature are confirmed to be nontrivial to the phase stability by our quantitative comparisons with the results at 00K.

Introduction

Investigations on structural phase transitions of condensed matters under high pressure-temperature conditions are not only directly related to understanding the mechanism of how the planets work[1, 2, 3], but also significant for their potential applications as novel functional and structural materials[4, 5, 6]. As important fuel cladding materials widely used in industrial nuclear reactors[7], zirconium (Zr) and Zr-based alloys have been extensively studied for their high-temperature properties[8, 9, 10], and recently, the structural transformations of pure Zr metal under high pressures attracted broad interests and controversies. Among various structural phase transitions, the isostructural one may be the most unique because, in terms of the pure-element crystals, such a phenomenon so far has been solely confirmed in the cerium metal that a 14% volume collapse would take place at the transition pressure of ∼0.8\sim0.8 GPa at room temperature[11, 12] and the underlying mechanism remains to be in disputes over the role played by 4f4f electrons[13, 14], 4f4f-5f5f electrons[15, 16] or the lattice vibrations[17]. After the denials of osmium[18] and boron[19], experimental observations and theoretical computations revealed a possibility of Zr metal as the second pure-element candidate possessing the feature of isostructural transformation.

Zr metal is in a hexagonal-closed-packed (HCP) structure (α\alpha-phase) at ambient conditions, and transforms into another HCP structure with space group P6/mm m (ω\omega-phase) as the pressure is increased up to 5-15 GPa, and finally ends up into a body-centered-cubic (BCC) structure (β\beta-phase) as the pressure reaches 30-37 GPa[20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26]. When the applied pressure is larger than 56 GPa, Akahama et al.[20] for the first time observed that the β\beta-phase would undergo an isostructural transition to β′\beta'-phase associated with a discontinued 1.2% volume change, which was later theoretically supported by Trubitsin et al.[27] analyzing the stability of the longitudinal and transverse phonon modes in the β\beta-phase. Despite of the following experiment[21] and ab initio computations based on either 0K enthalpy[28] or quasi-harmonic approximated (QHA) lattice dynamics[29, 30, 31, 32] failing to find the phenomenon, the experiment by Stavrou et al.[22] successfully reproduced the transition of β→β′\beta\to\beta' at the transition pressure of 58 GPa accompanied with a prominent 4% volume collapse and attributed the driving force to the anharmonicity of lattice dynamics, which was manifested by their quantum molecular dynamics (QMD) simulations of a quenching process from 1000K to 300K at a cooling rate of 100K per picosecond. Gal[33] further indicated a second isostructural transition of β′→β′′\beta' \to\beta'' above 110 GPa by more cautiously fitting the data from Ref.[22] to two commonly-used empirical Birch-Murnaghan[34] and Vinet[35] equations of states (EOSs). Nevertheless, after hydrostatic and non-hydrostatic runs focusing on the β\beta-phase with the obtained EOSs differing about 3% from each other, Pigott et al.[23] failed to observe the claimed volume collapse and speculated the reason to be the impurities effects on the Zr samples. At the same time, Anzellini et al.[24] conducted the compressions in a wider pressure range up to 150 GPa and the results showed no discontinuities where they excluded the impacts from the sample impurity but regarded the non-hydrostaticity[36] to be accounting for the observed isostructural transitions in Refs.[20] and [22]. The latest experiment of the β\beta-phase by Bannon et al.[25] also exhibited no evidence of the isostructural phenomenon and the inaccurately calibrated EOS of the pressure markers was considered to be the very cause of the observed abnormal volume collapse in Ref.[22].

In addition to the discrepancies of the isostructural transformation in the β\beta-phase, as pointed out by Bannon[25], another unsolved problem of Zr is that the two transition pressures of the α→ω→β\alpha\rightarrow\omega\rightarrow\beta determined by ab initio computations[27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 37, 38], with or without phonon vibration included, are much lower than all the experimental observations, especially the one for the α→ω\alpha\rightarrow\omega transition as summarized in Table I. From the perspective of thermodynamics, free energy (FE) is the very driving force that governs the phase stability, and actually, the statistical ensemble theory has already paved a rigorous way to derive all the thermodynamic state functions as long as the partition function (PF) is solved[39, 40]. Unfortunately, the complex high-dimension integral in the PF severely hinders the theory to be applied in the field of condensed matters so that the capability of ensemble theory has been seriously questioned when dealing with the first-order phase transitions of condensed matters[41, 42]. Despite of great progresses made to solve the PF[43, 44], the computational efficiency is still a bottleneck[45] that limits current algorithms to afford ab initio computations[46, 47, 48, 49] to characterize interatomic interactions but resort to empirical potentials for realistic condensed-matter materials, which leads to large deviations from experimentally determined phase behaviors under high pressure-temperature conditions[50].

Theoretical Worksα→ω\alpha\rightarrow\omegaω→β\omega\rightarrow\betaβ→β′\beta\rightarrow\beta'
present work (DIA)6.9324.83not found
present work (0K)0.5127.86/
Trubitsin et al.[27]a^{a}3.9922.6546.08
Zhang et al.[28]b^{b}0.1427.01not found
Wang et al.[32]b^{b}-3.732.4/
Schnell et al.[37]b^{b}<0< 028.2/
Hao et al.[38]b^{b}<0< 026.8/
Greeff[29]c^{c}2.232.6not found
Hao et al.[30]c^{c}1.7//
Hu et al.[31]c^{c}2.128.4not found
Experimental Works
Akahama et al.[20]d^{d}6.73356
Zhao et al.[21]5.5//
Stavrou et al.[22]d^{d}12.73058
Pigott et al.[23]d^{d}/37not found
Anzellini et al.[24]d^{d}14f^{f}35not found
20f^{f}35
Bannon et al.[25]d^{d}10.7g^{g}34.9g^{g}not found
10.8g^{g}35.0g^{g}
12.7g^{g}34.6g^{g}
Liu et al.[57, 58]e^{e}6.8//

Table I. Transition pressures (units in GPa) for crystalline Zr at 300K determined by theoretical and experimental works.

We recently put forward a parameter-free direct integral approach (DIA) to the PF of condensed matters[51], the ultrahigh efficiency and precision of which were examined by previous comparisons with state-of-the-art sampling algorithm[52] and the QHA phonon model[53]. The method has been successfully applied to study the EOS of copper[51], the optimum growth condition for two-dimension materials[54] and structural phase transitions of vanadium[55] and aluminum[56] with the density functional theory (DFT) computations incorporated for the interatomic interactions. In this work, we aim at applying DIA to compute the Gibbs FE and EOS of pure Zr metal in order to settle down the discrepancies from a different theoretical path. The paper is organized as follows: The theoretical model of DIA, the regarding implementations to the α\alpha, ω\omega and β\beta-Zr, and the detailed parameters of the DFT computations are presented in § 2. The obtained phase transitions and the EOSs by DIA are discussed and compared with both the results at 0K and experiments in Sec.III. Finally, a conclusion is made in § 4.

Method

Theoretical Model: DIA

According to ensemble theory, the PF for a system consists of NN particles with their Cartesian coordinate qN={q1,q2,…qN}\mathbf{q}^{N} = \{\mathbf{q}_{1}, \mathbf{q}_{2}, \ldots\mathbf{q}_{N}\} confined within a volume VV at temperature TT is formulated as

Z=1N!(2πmβh2)32N∫dqNexp⁡[−βU(qN)]=1N!(2πmβh2)32NQ,(1)\begin{aligned} Z = \frac{1}{N!}\left(\frac{2\pi m}{\beta h^{2}}\right)^{\frac{3}{2}N}\int d\mathbf{q}^{N}\exp[-\beta U(\mathbf{q}^{N})] \\ &= \frac{1}{N!}\left(\frac{2\pi m}{\beta h^{2}}\right)^{\frac{3}{2}N}Q, \tag*{(1)} \end{aligned}

where hh denotes the Planck constant, mm the particle mass, β=1/kBT\beta= 1/k_{B}T with kBk_{B} the Boltzmann constant, U(qN)U(\mathbf{q}^{N}) the total potential energy, and Q=∫dqNexp⁡[−βU(qN)]Q = \int d\mathbf{q}^{N}\exp[-\beta U(\mathbf{q}^{N})] the so-called configurational integral (CI) that is related to the structures of the system at given conditions. If the CI is solved, then the pressure-volume (PP-VV) EOS and the Gibbs FE (G\mathcal{G}) can be computed as

P=1β∂ln⁡Q∂V,(2)P = \frac{1}{\beta}\frac{\partial\ln Q}{\partial V}, \tag*{(2)}
G=−1βln⁡[1N!(2πmβh2)32N]−1βln⁡Q+PV.(3)\mathcal{G} = -\frac{1}{\beta}\ln\left[\frac{1}{N!}\left(\frac{2\pi m}{\beta h^{2}}\right)^{\frac{3}{2}N}\right]-\frac{1}{\beta}\ln Q+PV. \tag*{(3)}

For a crystalline system with atoms locating on the lattice sites, QN\mathbf{Q}^{N}, and with the total potential energy, U0(QN)U_{0}(\mathbf{Q}^{N}), the model of DIA[51] firstly introduces transformations as

q′N=qN−QN,U′(q′N)=U(q′N)−U0(QN),(4)\mathbf{q}^{\prime N}=\mathbf{q}^{N}-\mathbf{Q}^{N},\quad U^{\prime}(\mathbf{q}^{\prime N})=U(\mathbf{q}^{\prime N})-U_{0}(\mathbf{Q}^{N}), \tag*{(4)}

where q′N\mathbf{q}^{\prime N} represents the displacements of atoms away from their lattice sites and U′(q′N)U^{\prime}(\mathbf{q}^{\prime N}) stands for the corresponding differences of total potential energy with respect to the U0(QN)U_{0}(\mathbf{Q}^{N}). Therefore, the CI can be expressed as

Q=e−βU0(QN)∫e−βU′(q′N)dq′N.(5)Q=e^{-\beta U_{0}(\mathbf{Q}^{N})}\int e^{-\beta U^{\prime}(\mathbf{q}^{\prime N})}\mathrm{d}\mathbf{q}^{\prime N}. \tag*{(5)}

Based on our reinterpretations of integrals, the 3N3N-fold integral in Eq. (5) is mapped to an effective 3N3N-dimension volume, and may be further simplified as

Q=e−βU0(QN)×∏i=1N∫e−βU′(qix′)dqix′∫e−βU′(qiy′)dqiy′∫e−βU′(qiz′)dqiz′=e−βU0(QN)∏i=1NLixLiyLiz,(6)\begin{aligned} Q={}&e^{-\beta U_{0}(\mathbf{Q}^{N})}\times\\ &\prod_{i=1}^{N}\int e^{-\beta U^{\prime}(q'_{ix})}\mathrm{d}q'_{ix}\int e^{-\beta U^{\prime}(q'_{iy})}\mathrm{d}q'_{iy}\int e^{-\beta U^{\prime}(q'_{iz})}\mathrm{d}q'_{iz}\\ ={}&e^{-\beta U_{0}(\mathbf{Q}^{N})}\prod_{i=1}^{N}\mathcal{L}_{ix}\mathcal{L}_{iy}\mathcal{L}_{iz}, \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

where qi(x,y,z)′q'_{i(x,y,z)} denotes the distance of the iith atom moving along the xx (or yy, zz) axis relative to its lattice site while the other two degrees of freedom of the atom and all the other atoms are kept fixed, U′(qi(x,y,z)′)U'(q'_{i(x,y,z)}) represents the potential-energy curve (function) felt by the moved atom, and Li(x,y,z)\mathcal{L}_{i(x,y,z)} is called the effective length of the atom along the xx (or yy, zz) axis. It should be emphasized here that Eq. (6) is the only approximation in the model of DIA and the original physics picture as well as detailed mathematical proof is referred to Ref.[51].

For pure-element crystals with BCC structure where all the atoms in the lattice are geometrically equivalent and the potential-energy curve Ux′U'_x felt by an arbitrary atom moving along xx axis is the same as the one along yy or zz axis, the CI can thus be simplified as

Q=e−βU0(QN)L3N,(7)Q=e^{-\beta U_{0}(\mathbf{Q}^{N})}\mathcal{L}^{3N}, \tag*{(7)}

where L\mathcal{L} represents the effective length of an arbitrary atom along either xx, yy or zz axis. For the pure-element crystals with HCP structure where the atoms are geometrically equivalent but the three effective lengths Lx(y,z)\mathcal{L}_{x(y,z)} of each atom are not equivalent to each other, the CI consequently turns into

Q=e−βU0(QN)(LxLyLz)N,(8)Q=e^{-\beta U_{0}(\mathbf{Q}^{N})}\left(\mathcal{L}_{x}\mathcal{L}_{y}\mathcal{L}_{z}\right)^{N}, \tag*{(8)}

For crystals with more complex structures or with multiple elements, the atoms may be divided into MM groups with each containing a number of NIN_{I} equivalent atoms on the basis of the geometric feature of the lattice, and the CI would be

Q=e−βU0(QN)∏I=1M(LIxLIyLIz)NI,(9)Q=e^{-\beta U_{0}(\mathbf{Q}^{N})}\prod_{I=1}^{M}\left(\mathcal{L}_{Ix}\mathcal{L}_{Iy}\mathcal{L}_{Iz}\right)^{N_{I}}, \tag*{(9)}

the detailed applications of which can be found in our previous works of large molecules[51] and two-dimension materials[54].

Implementation of DIA to Zr

As shown in Figure 1(a), the β\beta-phase is placed in a 3×3×33 \times3 \times3 cubic supercell with two atoms in the unit cell where the lattice vectors are set as a1=aβ(1,0,0)\mathbf{a}_1 = a_\beta(1,0,0), a2=aβ(0,1,0)\mathbf{a}_2 = a_\beta(0,1,0) and a3=aβ(0,0,1)\mathbf{a}_3 = a_\beta(0,0,1) with aβa_\beta being the lattice parameter, and the basis vectors are b1=(0,0,0)\mathbf{b}_1 = (0,0,0) and b2=(12,12,12)\mathbf{b}_2 = \left(\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2},\frac{1}{2}\right). The DIA is applied by using Eq. (7) and an arbitrary atom is selected to move 0.50.5 Å from the lattice site at a step of 0.050.05 Å long its xx axis to obtain the corresponding potential-energy curve.

Schematic diagrams of implementations of DIA

Figure 1. (Color Online) Schematic diagrams of implementations of DIA. (a) The β\beta-phase are placed in a cubic lattice with lattice parameter of aβa_{\beta}, and an arbitrarily selected atom is moved from its lattice site (colored in red) along the xx axis by 0.5 Å (denoted by red arrow) for the computation of effective length L\mathcal{L} defined in Eq. (7). (b) The α\alpha-phase is placed in a hexagonal lattice with lattice parameter of aαa_{\alpha} and axial ratio cα/aαc_{\alpha}/a_{\alpha}, and an atom is moved from its lattice site (colored in red) along the xx, yy and zz axis separately by 0.5 Å (denoted by red, cyan and blue arrows respectively) for the computations of effective lengths Lx\mathcal{L}_{x}, Ly\mathcal{L}_{y} and Lz\mathcal{L}_{z} defined in Eq. (8). (c) The ω\omega-phase is placed in a hexagonal lattice with lattice parameter of aωa_{\omega} and axial ratio cω/aωc_{\omega}/a_{\omega}, and atoms are divided into two groups to apply Eq. (9). In the first group, one atom (colored in red) is moved from its lattice site along the xx, yy and zz axis separately by 0.5 Å, and one atom in the second group (colored in yellow) is conducted in the same way except that, along the yy axis, the atom is moved in both positive and negative directions by 0.5 Å. The view angles of the above shown lattices are slightly tilted for a more clear illustration.

For the α\alpha-phase, as shown in Figure 1(b), the atoms are placed in a 3×3×23 \times3 \times2 hexagonal supercell with two atoms in the unit cell where the lattice vectors are a1=aα(1,0,0)\mathbf{a}_1 = a_\alpha(1,0,0), a2=aα(12,32,0)\mathbf{a}_2 = a_\alpha\left(\frac{1}{2},\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2},0\right) and a3=aα(0,0,cαaα)\mathbf{a}_3 = a_\alpha\left(0,0,\frac{c_\alpha}{a_\alpha}\right) with aαa_\alpha being the lattice parameter and cαaα\frac{c_\alpha}{a_\alpha} the axial ratio, and the basis vectors are b1=(0,0,0)\mathbf{b}_1 = (0,0,0) and b2=(13,13,12)\mathbf{b}_2 = \left(\frac{1}{3},\frac{1}{3},\frac{1}{2}\right). The DIA is applied by using Eq. (8) and an arbitrarily selected atom is moved from the lattice site along the xx, yy and zz axes separately by 0.50.5 Å at a step of 0.050.05 Å to obtain the three potential-energy curves.

The ω\omega-phase has the most complex structure among the three phases and a detailed elaboration of the structure can be found in supplementary materials. As shown in Figure 1(c), the atoms are placed in a 3×3×23 \times3 \times2 hexagonal supercell with three atoms in the unit cell where the lattice vectors are set as a1=aω(1,0,0)\mathbf{a}_1 = a_\omega(1,0,0), a2=aω(−12,32,0)\mathbf{a}_2 = a_\omega\left(-\frac{1}{2},\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2},0\right) and a3=aω(0,0,cωaω)\mathbf{a}_3 = a_\omega\left(0,0,\frac{c_\omega}{a_\omega}\right) with aωa_\omega being the lattice parameter and cωaω\frac{c_\omega}{a_\omega} the axial ratio, and the basis vectors are b1=(0,0,0)\mathbf{b}_1 = (0,0,0), b2=(13,23,12)\mathbf{b}_2 = \left(\frac{1}{3},\frac{2}{3},\frac{1}{2}\right), b3=(23,13,12)\mathbf{b}_3 = \left(\frac{2}{3},\frac{1}{3},\frac{1}{2}\right).

Since neither the geometric symmetry of all the atoms nor the three potential-energy curves of each atom are equivalent, to apply DIA to the ω\omega-structure, Eq. (9) has to be used and the atoms are divided into two groups that the first one includes the atoms in the bottom layer (and equivalent repeated layers) and the second group includes the atoms in layers with z=12cωz = \frac{1}{2}c_\omega (and equivalent repeated layers). In the first group, the actions on an arbitrarily selected atom are the same as those on the α\alpha-structure, and in the second group, the arbitrarily selected atom is moved along its xx and zz axes separately by 0.50.5 Å for the potential-energy curves, while, for obtaining the curve along the yy axis, the atom is moved 0.50.5 Å in both positive and negative directions due to the asymmetric geometry of the ω\omega-structure (see details in supplementary materials). For all the three structures, the potential energies at each moving step are calculated by the DFT computations and afterwards smoothened by the spline interpolation algorithm[59, 60] (see potential-energy curves displayed in the supplementary materials).

Details of DFT Computations

The DFT computations are all conducted in the Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package[61, 62] where the projector-augmented wave formalism[63, 64] is used for the pseudopotential and the general gradient approximation of the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof parametrizations[65] is adopted for the exchange-correlation functional with 12 valence electrons (4s24p65s24d24s^24p^65s^24d^2) considered. The Gaussian smearing method with a smearing energy of 0.0260.026 eV is applied in order to smooth the transition of the electron number of orbital occupation[66], together with Γ\Gamma-centered 7×7×77 \times7 \times7, 5×5×115 \times5 \times11 and 9×9×99 \times9 \times9 uniform kk-mesh grids being set to sample the Brillouin zone of the α\alpha, ω\omega and β\beta-phases by the Monkhorst-Pack scheme[67] respectively, 400400 eV as the cut-off energy of the plane-wave basis, and 1×10−61 \times10^{-6} eV as the stop condition for the electron self-consistent calculations of the total energy.

Results and Discussions

Phase Transition of α→ω\alpha\rightarrow\omega at 0K and 300K

We first consider the α→ω\alpha\rightarrow\omega phase transition at 0K, where the Gibbs FE becomes equivalent to enthalpy as H=U0+P0V\mathcal{H} = U_0 + P_0V with U0U_0 the total potential energy and P0=−∂U0/∂VP_0 = -\partial U_0/\partial V the pressure at 0K. Although the ideal axial ratios of α\alpha and ω\omega-structures are cα/aα=8/3c_\alpha/a_\alpha= \sqrt{8/3} and cω/aω=3/8c_\omega/a_\omega= \sqrt{3/8} respectively, the realistic values of the most stable structures may vary from the ideal ones, and as a result, six α\alpha-structures with axial ratio from 1.59-1.64 and three ω\omega-structures with axial ratio from 0.61-0.63 are considered, the calculated enthalpies of which with respect to the α\alpha-structure with axial ratio of 1.59 are shown in Figure 2(a). By the identifications of the one with minimum enthalpy, the axial ratio of the stable α\alpha-structure remains to be 1.60 from 0 GPa up to ∼\sim 5 GPa and then turns to be 1.61 afterwards. As to the ω\omega-phase, the entropy differences between the structure with axial ratio of 0.62 and that of 0.63 are quite negligible from 0-6 GPa, while the entropy of the one with 0.61 is over 3 meV/atom larger than the other two. The axial ratio of stable ω\omega-structure is determined to be 0.62 from 0 GPa to ∼\sim 2.5 GPa and then to be 0.63 till 6 GPa.

Plots of the alpha-to-omega phase transition at 0 K and 300 K

Figure 2. (Color Online) The α→ω\alpha\to\omega phase transition. (a) The enthalpies at 0K of five α\alpha-structures with axial ratio from 1.59-1.64 (denoted by blue, magenta, cyan, green and violet dashed-dotted lines respectively) and of three ω\omega-structures with axial ratio from 0.61-0.63 (denoted by black, skyblue and grey dashed lines respectively) relative to that of the α\alpha-structure with axial ratio of 1.59 (red dashed-dotted line). (b) Similar to (a) except that the comparisons are on the basis of Gibbs FEs at 300K calculated by DIA.

With the determined stable α\alpha and ω\omega-structures versus the changes of pressures, the phase transition of α→ω\alpha\rightarrow\omega at 0K is identified at the cross point between the relative enthalpy curves belonged to the two stable structures shown in Figure 2(a) and the transition pressure locates at 0.51 GPa, which, as can be seen in Table.Table I, agrees with the 0.14 GPa from Ref.[28] where the same frozen-core pseudopotential DFT method was used. In spite of the disagreement of the negative values from Refs.[32, 37, 38], it is notable that the calculated transition pressures at 0K, though slightly differ from each other, are all close to 0 GPa and quite different from the experimentally measured pressure range 5-15 GPa, which indicates the potential influences from the neglected thermal contributions on the phase transition.

The Gibbs FEs at 300K of the above considered α\alpha and ω\omega-structures are computed by DIA using Eqs. (8) and (9) respectively, and the corresponding differences relative to the α\alpha-structure with axial ratio of 1.59 are shown in Figure 2(b). Different from the case at 0K, it is found that the axial ratio of stable α\alpha-structure at 300K turns to be 1.61 from 0-8 GPa and becomes 1.62 till 10 GPa. As to the ω\omega-phase, the differences of the Gibbs FE are getting prominently larger to be ∼\sim 1 meV/atom between the structures with axial ratio of 0.62 and 0.63, and unambiguously identify the former one to be the stable ω\omega-structure as the pressure is increased up to 10 GPa.

After the confirmations of the stable structures of the two phases, the transition pressure of α→ω\alpha\to\omega at 300K is determined to be 6.93 GPa as the cross point highlighted in Figure 2(b), which greatly lifts the pressure value by about 6.5 GPa compared with the one at 0K and is by far the only theoretical value coinciding with the experimental pressure range of 5-15 GPa[20, 21, 22, 24, 25, 57, 58]. As noticed by Velisavljevic et al.[68] and Bannon et al.[25], experimentally speaking, the transition pressure is closely

related to the purity of Zr sample in a way that the value would be increased as the purity decreases, which may account for the deviations of our obtained pressure from the reported 12.7 GPa in Ref[22] with 99.5% pure sample or 14-20 GPa in Ref[24] with 98.8 ∼\sim 99.2% pure samples. As a comparison, the observed values of the sample with 99.8% purity in Ref.[20] and with 99.9995% in Refs.[57, 58] are 6.7 and 6.8 GPa respectively, which are in excellent agreement with our result. The impurity effect on the structural transformations of Zr metal is worthy being carefully investigated in the future but beyond the scope of this work.

According to the determined transition pressure, the PP-VV EOSs of α\alpha and ω\omega-phases in a pressure range of 0-25 GPa at 300K by Eq. (2) are plotted in Figure 3 (the higher end of the pressure range of the ω\omega-phase is discussed in the next subsection). The atomic volume at ambient conditions, V0V_0, by the EOS is determined to be 23.58 Å3^3/atom, and the relative deviations, ∣V0(DIA)−V0(EXP)∣/V0(EXP)|V_0(DIA)-V_0(EXP)|/V_0(EXP), are about 1.11% comparison with 23.32 Å3^3/atom from Ref.[57] using third-order Birch-Murnaghan EOS, 1.25% compared with 23.20 Å3^3/atom from Ref.[24] using Rydberg-Vinet EOS[69] and 1.64% compared with 23.2 Å3^3/atom from Ref.[33] using Vinet EOS to fit the data measured in Ref.[22]. The relative deviations of PP-VV EOS, ∣PDIA−PEXP∣/PEXP|P_{DIA}-P_{EXP}|/P_{EXP}, of the α\alpha-phase are 0.34%, 0.69% and 1.01% compared with the experimental data from Refs.[20, 22] and [24] respectively, and are 0.68%, 1.14% and 1.46% respectively in terms of the ω\omega-phase. At the transition point of α→ω\alpha\to\omega where V/V0=0.93V/V_0=0.93, a discontinuity of the EOS accompanies with a −1.05%-1.05\% volume change, which is qualitatively consistent with the −1.26%-1.26\% reported in Ref.[21], $-1.36% in Ref.{citep}[57] and $-1.5\% in Ref.[24].

Pressure-volume equations of state for the alpha and omega phases

Figure 3. (Color Online) PP-VV EOSs of the α\alpha-phase (magenta dashed line) and the ω\omega-phase (skyblue dashed line) at 300K by DIA along with those from experiments in a pressure range of 0-25 GPa. The region encircled by the skyblue rectangle is inferred to a possible two-phase coexistence for experimental observations.

By the above comparisons, the computations of Gibbs FE by DIA manifest the importance of thermal contributions to the phase stability of the α\alpha and ω\omega-phases at a room-temperature condition, the phenomenon of which can be also seen in our previous work of aluminum metal under ultrahigh pressures[56]. Moreover, the excellent agreements between our obtained EOSs and those from experiments not only further validate the accuracy of the PF calculated by DIA for the two phases, but also ensures the accuracy of the following investigations on phase transitions related to ω\omega-phase in higher pressure zone.

Phase Transition of ω→β\omega\to\beta at 0K and 300K

For the phase stability in the pressure zone from 5 to 40 GPa, we do not take the α\alpha-phase into account because of either the enthalpies or the Gibbs FE of the α\alpha-structures being apparently larger than that of the ω\omega-structure with the increased pressure according to the trends demonstrated in Figure 2(a) and (Figure 2b). We still consider the phase transitions at 0K at first and the enthalpy differences of the three ω\omega-structures relative to that of β\beta-structure are shown in the dotted lines in Figure 4(a), where the ω\omega-structure with axial ratio of 0.63 possesses the minimum enthalpy up to ∼16\sim16 GPa and then is replaced by the one of 0.62 till 35 GPa. The transition pressure identified by the cross point of enthalpy curves between the ω\omega and β\beta-structures locates at 27.86 GPa, which agrees with previous 0K-based theoretical predictions about 27-28 GPa from [28, 37, 38] but is lower than the 32.4 GPa from Ref.[32] that used same pseudopotential method and electronic exchange-correlation functional but considered less valence electrons (4d35s14d^{3}5s^{1}) than this work.

Phase transition and equations of state plots

Figure 4. (Color Online) (a) The ω→β\omega\to\beta phase transition. The Gibbs FEs at 300K of three ω\omega-structures with axial ratio of 0.61, 0.62 and 0.63 (denoted in black, skyblue and grey dashed lines respectively) relative to that of β\beta-structure (denoted in yellow dotted line) and the enthalpy at 0K of the three structures (denoted in blue, green and cyan dashed lines) relative to that of β\beta-structure (denoted in yellow dotted line). (b) PP-VV EOSs of ω\omega-phase (skyblue dashed line) and β\beta-phase (yellow dashed line) at 300K by DIA along with those from experiments in a pressure range of 15-40 GPa. The region encircled by the yellow rectangle is inferred to a possible two-phase coexistence for experimental observations.

The Gibbs FEs at 300K of the ω\omega and β\beta-structures are computed by DIA according to Eqs. (9) and (7) respectively, and the differences of the three ω\omega-structures relative to the β\beta-structure are plotted in the dashed lines in Figure 4(a), which clearly exhibits that the one with axial ratio of 0.62 continues to be the most stable up to 35 GPa. With the determined cross point as highlighted in Figure 4(a), it is interesting to find that the transition pressure at 300K turns to be 24.83 GPa, which shows that, on the contrary to the situation of the α→ω\alpha\to\omega, the thermal contributions reduce the transition pressure of ω→β\omega\to\beta by about 3 GPa and lead to more deviations from existing experimental values of 30-35 GPa (listed in Table I) when compared with the transition pressure at 0K.

On the experimental side, one possible cause may be from the effects of sample impurity as discussed in the last subsection and our obtained pressure is indeed closer to the 33 and 30 GPa measured in Refs. [20, 22] whose purity is higher than 99.95% while such effects cannot explain why the pressure at 0K deviates less from experiments. On the theoretical side, since there is no adjustable parameters in the model of DIA, another possible cause may be resulted from the intrinsic precision limits of DFT computations of potential energies, which has been analyzed in our previous work of aluminum[56]. If there exists a ∼1\sim1 meV/atom error of potential-energy computations, we estimate a corresponding 4 meV/atom variation of Helmholtz FE (F\mathcal{F}), which can produce the pressure as P=−∂F/∂VP=-\partial\mathcal{F}/\partial V. According to our computations of F\mathcal{F} and obtained EOSs as shown below, a 4 meV/atom variation would lead to a pressure variation of ΔP∼0.1\Delta P \sim0.1-0.2 GPa and the total variation of Gibbs FE, ΔG=ΔF+ΔP⋅V\Delta\mathcal{G}=\Delta\mathcal{F}+\Delta P\cdot V, corresponds to ∼20\sim20 meV/atom at the transition region, which is much smaller than the total thermal contributions, G−H\mathcal{G}-\mathcal{H}, up to 180 meV/atom at the transition point (see Figure 6 in the next subsection). As a result, the computational error may limitedly affect the obtained transition pressure but still cannot account for the 5-10 GPa deviations.

Difference between Gibbs free energy and enthalpy

Figure 6. (Color Online) The difference between Gibbs FE at 300K by DIA and enthalpy at 0K.

We further compare the PP-VV EOS in a pressure range of 15-40 GPa by DIA with recent experiments as shown in Figure 4(b), and the agreement is excellent, where the relative differences of the ω\omega-phase are 0.86%, 1.34% and 1.40% from those in Refs.[20, 22], [24] respectively, and of the β\beta-phase are less than 0.78% compared with Refs.[20, 23, 24, 25]. At the transition of point where V/V0=0.82V/V_0 = 0.82, the volume change is determined to be −2.9%-2.9\% and coincides with the measured −2.0%-2.0\% in Ref.[24]. In the pressure range of 25-32 GPa, it is noticeable that the calculated EOS of β\beta-phase (encircled by a yellow rectangle in Figure 4(b)) perfectly agrees with the observed data identified as ω\omega-phase in Ref.[22] with a relative difference of 0.23%, as well as of 1.54% compared with the data in Ref.[24], and for the α→ω\alpha\to\omega transition, a similar phenomenon also exists in the pressure range of 8-12 GPa where the calculated EOS of ω\omega-phase (encircled by a skyblue rectangle in Figure 3) coincides perfectly with the data of α\alpha-phase in Ref.[24]. Since there are affirmative observations of α\alpha and ω\omega-phase coexistence in the high purity Zr sample[58], and our former analysis excludes large influences from either purity effects or computational variations, here we suggest that the onset of the ω→β\omega\to\beta transition is in advance than those reported in experiments, which may be more difficult to be experimentally discerned due to a two-phase coexistence and needs to be scrutinized in future experiments.

The Stability of β\beta-Phase at 300K

By the computations of DIA, the β\beta-structure becomes the dominant phase with the minimum Gibbs FE at 300K as the pressure being larger than 24.83 GPa and the calculated PP-VV EOS of Zr up to 160 GPa by (2) is shown in Figure 5. The EOS of the β\beta-phase does not show any discontinuity and is in excellent agreement with the three latest experimental observations with the relative difference being 0.07% in terms of the second run of Ref.[23], 0.42% of Ref.[25] and 0.62% of Ref.[24], while deviates about 1.2% from the first run of Ref.[23]. Compared with the two experiments claiming the isostructural transition, the relative differences are 0.96% in terms of Ref.[20], and 4.15% of Ref.[22], which is by far the largest deviation of PP-VV EOS between our computations and all the experiments.

P–V equation of state of pure Zr metal

Figure 5. (Color Online) The PP-VV EOS of pure Zr metal determined by DIA (black dashed line) up to 160 GPa along with those from experiments, where the α\alpha-, ω\omega- and β\beta-phases are colored in magenta, skyblue and yellow respectively and the inset exhibits details of the β\beta-EOSs in a pressure range of 35-70 GPa.

By conducting the QMD simulations in Ref.[22], Stavrou et al. attributed the observed anomaly to the anharmonicity of the β\beta-phase, which was confirmed by previous theoretical works at high-temperature zone (over 1000K)[70] and experimentally proved to be in close relationship to the strong glass forming ability of Zr with pressure over 6 GPa and temperature at 900K[71], though not reported at room-temperature conditions in any literatures. As brought out by Anzellini et al.[24], one questionable point towards the simulation lies in the usage of only one single kk-point (18,18,18)\left(\frac{1}{8},\frac{1}{8},\frac{1}{8}\right) that may lead to less precision of ab initioab\ initio interatomic interactions and result in misleading instability when compared with the outcomes from reproduced QMD simulation in Ref.[24] employing a 2×2×22 \times2 \times2 kk-mesh. Another point should be mentioned is the simulated cooling rate of 101410^{14} K/s in Ref.[22], which is much faster than the critical cooling rate of 10−10310^{-10^{3}} K/s of Zr-based alloys[72, 73] or the estimated 101110^{11}-101310^{13} K/s of pure Zr metal[74, 75]. With such a high rate, the cooled down structure in the simulation would be more inclined to stay in a meta stable amorphous structure instead of a crystalline β\beta-lattice. In the model of DIA, the thermal contributions from both harmonic and anharmonic lattice motions are naturally included and entangled together [53], which are on the whole reflected by the value of effect length defined in Eq. (6) that is decided by the shape of potential-energy curve U′U^{\prime} and the Boltzmann factor e−βU′e^{-\beta U^{\prime}} at given temperatures. Although we cannot separate these two parts, the total thermal contributions, consisting of kinetic energy of thermal atoms, entropy and additional work from thermal pressure, can be quantitatively computed by subtracting the enthalpy at 0K from the Gibbs FE at 300K, G−HG-H, and the result is shown in Figure 6. As we can see, the thermal contributions are at least over 120 meV and getting larger from lower pressure zone (α\alpha-phase) to higher pressure zone (β\beta-phase) with a difference of about 60-80 meV/atom. Moreover, the thermal contributions abruptly become large at the two phase boundaries, especially for the ω→β\omega\to\beta, indicating nontrivial impacts on the phase stabilities of Zr metal under high pressures. With the above the comparisons and analysis, we support the conclusion from latest experiments that there is no isostructural phase transitions in the β\beta-phase.

Conclusions

In conclusion, by the criterion of the Gibbs FEs derived directly from PF, the transition pressure of α→ω\alpha\to\omega is determined to be 6.93 GPa, which is so far the only theoretical result coinciding well with experimental observations, and the one of ω→β\omega\to\beta is 24.83 GPa, which needs to be further validated in future experiments that, as we suggest, may particularly pay attentions to the possible phase coexistence. Additionally, in considerations to the excellent agreement within 0.7% difference between our obtained EOS in the high pressure zone up to 160 GPa and those from latest experiments, we are in favor of the argument that there does not exit isostructural phase transitions in the β\beta-phase. With quantitative comparisons with the results on the basis of enthalpy at 0K, we show that the thermal contributions are not negligible but are indeed important for the phase stability of Zr. With the method of DIA and more advanced ab initio computations, the ensemble theory can be practically applied to investigate the phase behaviors and thermodynamic properties of more complex systems under extreme conditions.

Acknowledgement

BYN is grateful to A.De Waele for kindly providing the raw experimental data in Ref.[24]. Part of the computational tasks was conducted in HPC platform supported by The Major Science and Technology Infrastructure Project of Material Genome Big-science Facilities Platform supported by Municipal Development and Reform Commission of Shenzhen.

References

  1. [1]T. Sakamaki, E. Ohtani, H. Fukui, S. Kamada, S. Takahashi, T. Sakairi, A. Takahata, T. Sakai, S. Tsutsui, D. Ishikawa, R. Shiraishi, Y. Seto, T. Tsuchiya, and A. Q. R. Baron, Science Advances 2, e1500802 (2016).
  2. [2]D. Kim, R. F. Smith, I. K. Ocampo, F. Coppari, M. C. Marshall, M. K. Ginnarne, J. K. Wicks, S. J. Tracy, M. Millot, A. Lazicki, J. R. Rygg, and J. H. Eggert, Nat. Communications 13, 2260 (2022).
  3. [3]F. D. Stacey, Rep. Prog. Phys. 68, 341 (2005).
  4. [4]L. Dubrovinsky, S. Khandarkhaeva, T. Fedotenko, D. Laniel, M. Bykov, C. Giacobbe, E. Lawrence Bright, P. Sedmak, S. Chariton, V. Prakapenka, A. V. Ponomareva, E. A. Smirnova, M. P. Belov, F. Tasnádi, N. Shulumba, F. Trybel, I. A. Abrikosov, and N. Dubrovinskaia, Nature 605, 274 (2022).
  5. [5]J. S. Tse, Natl. Sci. Rev. 7, 149 (2019).
  6. [6]A. Lazicki, D. McGonegle, J. R. Rygg, D. G. Braun, D. C. Swift, M. G. Gorman, R. F. Smith, P. G. Heighway, A. Higginbotham, M. J. Suggit, D. E. Fratanduono, F. Coppari, C. E. Wehrenberg, G. Kraus, D. Erskine, J. V. Bernier, J. M. McNaney, R. E. Rudd, G. W. Collins, and J. H. Eggert, Nature 589, 1476 (2021).
  7. [7]B. Cox, J. Nucl. Mater. 336, 331 (2005).
  8. [8]M. Mermoux and C. Duriez, J. Raman Spectrosc. 52, 2131 (2021).
  9. [9]B. Ensor, A. Motta, A. Lucente, J. Seidensticker, J. Parte z ana, and Z. Cai, J. Nucl. Mater. 558, 153358 (2022).
  10. [10]W. S. Morais, D. A. Lopes, and C. G. Schön, J. Nucl. Mater. 488, 173 (2017).
  11. [11]F. Decremps, L. Belhadi, D. L. Farber, K. T. Moore, F. Occelli, M. Gauthier, A. Polian, D. Antonangeli, C. M. Aracne-Ruddle, and B. Amadon, Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 065701 (2011).
  12. [12]M. J. Lipp, A. P. Sorini, J. Bradley, B. Maddox, K. T. Moore, H. Cynn, T. P. Devereaux, Y. Xiao, P. Chow, and W. J. Evans, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 195705 (2012).
  13. [13]L. Huang and H. Lu, Phys. Rev. B 99, 045122 (2019).
  14. [14]M. Casadei, X. Ren, P. Rinke, A. Rubio, and M. Scheffler, Phys. Rev. B 93, 075153 (2016).
  15. [15]N. Lanatà, Y.-X. Yao, C.-Z. Wang, K.-M. Ho, J. Schmalian, K. Haule, and G. Kotliar, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 196801 (2013).
  16. [16]B. Amadon and A. Gerossier, Phys. Rev. B 91, 161103 (2015).
  17. [17]I.-K. Jeong, T. W. Darling, M. J. Graf, T. Proffen, R. H. Heffner, Y. Lee, T. Vogt, and J. D. Jorgensen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92, 105702 (2004).
  18. [18]B. K. Godwal, J. Yan, S. M. Clark, and R. Jeanloz, J. Appl. Phys. 111, 112608 (2012).
  19. [19]L. Godec, J. Superhard Mater. 33, 388 (2011).
  20. [20]Y. Akahama, M. Kobayashi, and H. Kawamura, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn 60, 3211 (1991).
  21. [21]Y. Zhao, J. Zhang, C. Pantea, J. Qian, L. L. Daemen, P. A. Rigg, R. S. Hixson, G. T. Gray, Y. Yang, L. Wang, Y. Wang, and T. Uchida, Phys. Rev. B 71, 184119 (2005).
  22. [22]E. Stavrou, L. H. Yang, P. Söderlind, D. Aberg, H. B. Rado?usky, M. R. Armstrong, J. L. Belof, M. Kunz, E. Greenberg, V. B. Prakapenka, and D. A. Young, Phys. Rev. B 98, 220101 (2018).
  23. [23]J. S. Pigott, N. Velisavljevic, E. K. Moss, D. Popov, C. Park, J. A. V. Orman, N. Draganic, Y. K. Vohra, and B. T. Sturtevant, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 32, 12LT02 (2019).
  24. [24]S. Anzellini, F. m. c. Bottin, J. Bouchet, and A. Dewaele, Phys. Rev. B 102, 184105 (2020).
  25. [25]E. F. O’Bannon, P. Söderlind, D. Sneed, M. J. Lipp, H. Cynn, J. S. Smith, C. Park, and Z. Jenei, High Press. Res. 41, 247 (2021).
  26. [26]H. Zong, T. Lookman, X. Ding, C. Nisoli, D. Brown, S. R. Niezgoda, and S. Jun, Acta Materialia 77, 191 (2014).
  27. [27]V. Y. Trubitsin and E. B. Dolgusheva, Phys. Rev. B 77, 172302 (2008).
  28. [28]S. Zhang, Y. Zhu, X. Zhang, S. Zhang, L. Qi, and R. Liu, Computational Materials Science 50, 179 (2010).
  29. [29]C. W. Greeff, Modelling Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 13, 1015 (2005).
  30. [30]Y.-J. Hao, L. Zhang, X.-R. Chen, L.-C. Cai, Q. Wu, and D. Alfè, Phys. Rev. B 78, 134101 (2008).
  31. [31]C.-E. Hu, Z.-Y. Zeng, L. Zhang, X.-R. Chen, and L.-C. Cai, Computational Materials Science 50, 835 (2011).
  32. [32]B.-T. Wang, P. Zhang, H.-Y. Liu, W.-D. Li, and P. Zhang, J. Appl. Phys. 109, 065314 (2011).
  33. [33]J. Gal, Phys. B: Condens. Matter 613, 412979 (2021).
  34. [34]F. Birch, Phys. Rev. 71, 809 (1947).
  35. [35]P. Vinet, J. R. Ferrante, J. R. Smith, and J. H. Rose, J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 19, L467 (1986).
  36. [36]D. Errandonea, Y. Meng, M. Somayazulu, and D. Häusermann, Phys. B: Condens. Matter 355, 116 (2005).
  37. [37]I. Schnell and R. C. Albers, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 18, 1483 (2006).
  38. [38]Y.-J. Hao, L. Zhang, X.-R. Chen, Y.-H. Li, and H.-L. He, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 20, 235230 (2008).
  39. [39]N. Hansen and W. F. van Gunsteren, J. Chem. Theory Comput. 10, 2632 (2014).
  40. [40]A. J. Ballard, S. Martiniani, J. D. Stevenson, S. Somani, and D. J. Wales, WIREs. Comput. Mol. Sci. 5, 273 (2015).
  41. [41]M. V. Uschats, L. A. Bulavin, V. M. Sysoev, V. Y. Bardik, and A. N. Alekseev, J. Mol. Liq. 224, 694 (2016).
  42. [42]G. A. Martynov, Phys. Usp. 42, 517 (1999).
  43. [43]C. Sutton and S. V. Levchenko, Front. Chem. 8 (2020).
  44. [44]C. Chipot and A. Pohorille, eds., Free Energy Calculations: Theory and Applications in Chemistry and Biology (Springer Berlin, 2007).
  45. [45]S. Singh, M. Chopra, and J. J. de Pablo, Annu. Rev. Chem. Biomol. Eng. 3, 369 (2012).
  46. [46]N. Marzari and A. Ferretti, Nature Materials 20, 736 (2021).
  47. [47]J. A. Moriarty, J. F. Belak, R. E. Rudd, R. E. Söderlind, F. H. Streitz, and L. H. Yang, J. Phys.: Conden. Matter. 14, 2825 (2002).
  48. [48]R. O. Jones, Rev. Mod. Phys. 87, 897 (2015).
  49. [49]P. Kratzer and J. Neugebauer, Front. Chem. 13, 106 (2019).
  50. [50]R. J. N. Baldock, L. B. Pártay, A. P. Bartók, M. C. Payne, and G. Csányi, Phys. Rev. B 93, 174108 (2016).
  51. [51]B.-Y. Ning, L.-C. Gong, T.-C. Weng, and X.-J. Ning, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 33, 115901 (2021).
  52. [52]L.-C. Gong, B.-Y. Ning, T.-C. Weng, and X.-J. Ning, Entropy 21, 1050 (2019).
  53. [53]L.-C. Gong, B.-Y. Ning, C. Ming, T.-C. Weng, and X.-J. Ning, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 33, 085901 (2020).
  54. [54]Y.-P. Liu, B.-Y. Ning, L.-C. Gong, T.-C. Weng, and X.-J. Ning, Nanomaterials 9, 978 (2019).
  55. [55]B.-Y. Ning and X.-J. Ning, J. Phys: Condens. Matter 34, 425404 (2022).
  56. [56]B.-Y. Ning and L.-Y. Zhang, arXiv:2204.07318(2022).DOI
  57. [57]W. Liu, B. Li, L. Wang, J. Zhang, and Y. Zhao, Journal of Applied Physics 104, 076102 (2008).
  58. [58]W. Liu, B. Li, L. Wang, J. Zhang, and Y. Zhao, Phys. Rev. B 76, 144107 (2007).
  59. [59]P. Dierckx, Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics 1, 101 (1985).
  60. [60]P. Dierckx, SIAM J.Numer.Anal 19, 1286 (1985).
  61. [61]G. Kresse and J. Furthmüller, Comput. Mat. Sci. 6, 15 (1996).
  62. [62]G. Kresse and J. Furthmüller, Phys. Rev. B 54, 11169 (1996).
  63. [63]P. E. Blöchl, Phys. Rev. B 50, 17953 (1994).
  64. [64]G. Kresse and D. Joubert, Phys. Rev. B 59, 1758 (1999).
  65. [65]J. P. Perdew, K. Burke, and M. Ernzerhof, Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3865 (1996).
  66. [66]P. Liu, C. Verdi, F. Karsai, and G. Kresse, Phys. Rev. Materials 5, 053804 (2021).
  67. [67]H. J. Monkhorst and J. D. Pack, Phys. Rev. B 13, 5188 (1976).
  68. [68]N. Velisavljevic, G. N. Chesnut, L. L. Stevens, and D. M. Dattelbaum, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 23, 125402 (2011).
  69. [69]P. Vinet, J. H. Rose, J. Ferrante, and J. R. Smith, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 1, 1941 (1989).
  70. [70]Y. Wang, R. Ahuja, M. C. Qian, and B. Johansson, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 14, L695 (2002).
  71. [71]J. Zhang, Y. Zhao, C. Pantea, J. Qian, L. L. Daemen, P. A. Rigg, R. S. Hixson, C. W. Greeff, G. T. Gray, Y. Yang, L. Wang, Y. Wang, and T. Uchida, J. Phys. Chem. Solids 66, 1213 (2005).
  72. [72]Y. Huang, J. Shen, J. J. Chen, and J. Sun, J. Alloys and Compounds 477, 920 (2009).
  73. [73]H. Hng, Y. Li, S. Ng, and C. Ong, J. Non-Crystalline Solids 208, 127 (1996).
  74. [74]H. Zhang, Y. Mo, Z. Tian, R. Liu, L. Zhou, and Z. Hou, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 19, 12310 (2017).
  75. [75]S. A. Rogachev, A. S. Rogachev, and M. I. Alymov, Doklady Phys. 4, 214 (2019).

Paper details

vlnc:W_sftdwnp3
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents