betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The Mechanics of Curvature Inflation

Abstract

We examine slow roll directly in the Jordan-frame Hubble equation. For the quadratic Starobinsky action, this equation has an exact mechanical form. Comparing nearby solutions at the same Hubble value gives a local contraction law on the expanding branch with decreasing Hubble rate. A signed square root of the Hubble parameter also continues the vacuum background smoothly through its Hubble zeroes. For metric actions built from a smooth function of the Ricci scalar, coefficients depending only on the Hubble parameter require a derivative expansion. We derive the terms through cubic order and test both the equation residual and the error accumulated by an independently evolved approximation. A regularized inverse-logarithmic extension provides a nontrivial example. On the parameter slice studied, we prove a positive lower bound on the second curvature derivative of the action and compare separate Jordan- and Einstein-frame integrations. The third-order approximation reproduces the exact inflationary trajectory more accurately than the second-order approximation over the interval tested. We also compute the linear scalar and tensor spectra with numerical convergence checks. The benchmark gives a scalar spectral index of 0.97384 and a tensor-to-scalar ratio of 0.00527, evaluated 60 exact Einstein-frame e-folds before the first acceleration exit. These values depend on the chosen action and reference event. The mechanical form supplies approximation tests for the background; the scalaron and its perturbations follow from the original gravitational action.

Introduction

Slow roll is usually described through the motion of a scalar field on a nearly flat potential. In the Starobinsky model, the same approximation can also be examined directly in the equation for the Jordan-frame Hubble parameter. That equation contains terms proportional to the Hubble acceleration, velocity, and velocity squared. Comparing their sizes shows which balance supports slow evolution and how the approximation changes near the end of inflation. Here we derive these comparisons and test the resulting approximate trajectories against the exact background.

The Starobinsky action adds a positive curvature-squared term to the Einstein–Hilbert action [1, 2]. In metric gravity this introduces a scalaron, whose potential is nearly flat during inflation and quadratic near its minimum [3, 4]. The scalaron rolls during inflation and then undergoes coherent vacuum oscillations [5, 6]. The Einstein-frame potential makes this evolution and the calculation of fluctuations transparent. It provides a standard framework for studying inflationary dynamics and primordial perturbations in metric f(R)f(R) gravity [3, 4, 7, 8]. We restrict attention to metric f(R)f(R) theories; more general quadratic-curvature actions can contain additional degrees of freedom [9, 10].

We use the term mechanical for a particular organization of the homogeneous Hubble equation. Its acceleration, velocity-dependent, and algebraic terms resemble inertia, resistance, and a driving force. This interpretation is related to effective-fluid descriptions of higher-curvature terms [11]. The individual coefficients depend on the Hubble coordinate and on the normalization of the equation. They are useful for testing an approximation, but they do not define a physical particle mass or an independent channel of energy transfer. The field content remains that of the original action.

In the quadratic model, the mechanical equation is exact. We compare two decreasing-Hubble solutions at the same Hubble value, so an arbitrary shift of cosmic time does not enter the comparison. Their velocity difference obeys a contraction identity on their common expanding branch. This provides a precise local characterization of the approach toward the slowly evolving branch, complementing earlier analyses of inflationary attractor behavior in R2R^2 cosmology [6]. We also derive corrections to the nearly constant slow-roll velocity. During the later vacuum oscillations the Jordan-frame Hubble parameter repeatedly reaches zero. The vanishing of the highest-derivative coefficient at these points reflects a degeneracy of the Hubble-variable representation, rather than a physical singularity. A signed square-root variable gives a regular continuation. Matter production and thermal reheating require further equations [12, 13].

For a general smooth f(R)f(R), the exact Hubble equation has curvature-dependent coefficients. Since the curvature itself contains the Hubble velocity, replacing those coefficients by functions of the Hubble parameter alone requires an expansion. We give that expansion through cubic derivative order, including the mixed acceleration–velocity term. We then evaluate the truncated equations on an exact background and integrate them separately from the same initial state. These are two different tests: a small instantaneous residual need not imply a comparably small trajectory error. This extends the exact quadratic formulation to general smooth f(R)f(R) theories through a controlled derivative expansion and makes it possible to assess not only whether a particular term is small, but also whether the resulting approximation reproduces the background over the interval of interest.

Our numerical example adds a regularized inverse-logarithmic correction to the quadratic action. Logarithmic curvature corrections and running quadratic-gravity actions have already been studied extensively [14, 15, 16]. The high-curvature action, exact Hubble phase-space equation, and leading inverse-field spectral scaling overlap with that earlier work. Here an Einstein–Hilbert term and a smooth low-curvature continuation allow us to follow the vacuum solution through zero curvature. The regularization is a phenomenological choice. On the parameter domain considered, we establish an analytic lower bound on fRRf_{RR} and follow the background in both frames. § 4.2 gives the explicit relation to the running-gravity model. The purpose of the example is to test the derivative expansion on a regular branch.

We calculate scalar and tensor spectra from the standard quadratic perturbation actions [17, 18, 19]. The numerical modes also provide a check on potential slow-roll estimates [20, 21, 22]. The observational interpretation of a predicted tilt depends on the data combination and the cosmological parameter space [23, 24, 25, 26]. Our quoted values refer to specified e-fold events. Matching such an event to a dimensional CMB pivot requires a post-inflationary expansion history; testing statistical agreement requires a likelihood analysis. Neither is supplied by the mechanical rewriting.

The paper is organized as follows. § 2 treats the exact quadratic model, its contraction identity, and its regular Hubble zeroes. § 3 gives the canonical scalaron description and the general derivative expansion. § 4 introduces the regularized example and its branch properties. § 5 and § 6 present the background tests and linear spectra. Numerical mode details and convergence checks are collected in Appendix § 10. § 7 summarizes the results. We use signature (−,+,+,+)(-,+,+,+).

Exact Hubble dynamics in the quadratic model

Constraint, trace and mechanical equation

The metric action is given by

S=MPl22∫d4x−gJ f(R),MPl−2=8πG,(1)S = \frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}{2} \int\mathrm{d}^4x \sqrt{-g_J}\, f(R), \qquad M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^{-2} = 8\pi G, \tag*{(1)}

on a spatially flat FLRW background. Here R=RJR = R_J and F=fRF = f_R. Unless an Einstein-frame derivative is written explicitly, a dot means d/dtJ\mathrm{d}/\mathrm{d}t_J. The vacuum equations include

3FHJ2=U−3HJF˙,U=RF−f2,(2)3F H_J^2 = U - 3H_J\dot{F}, \qquad U = \frac{RF-f}{2}, \tag*{(2)}
R=6(H˙J+2HJ2),F¨+3HJF˙+2f−RF3=0.(3)R = 6(\dot{H}_J + 2H_J^2), \qquad\ddot{F} + 3H_J\dot{F} + \frac{2f-RF}{3} = 0. \tag*{(3)}

The trace and Ricci equations propagate the constraint. In fact, for C=3FHJ2−U+3HJF˙C = 3F H_J^2 - U + 3H_J\dot{F}, they imply C˙=−4HJC\dot{C} = -4H_J C. Conversely, differentiating the constraint at HJ≠0H_J \ne0 recovers the spatial background equation. At a zero of HJH_J, the trace–Ricci system should be retained instead of dividing the constraint by HJH_J.

For f=R+αR2f = R + \alpha R^2 with α>0\alpha> 0, we have F=1+2αRF = 1 + 2\alpha R, U=αR2/2U = \alpha R^2/2 and F˙=2αR˙\dot{F} = 2\alpha\dot{R}. The Friedmann constraint can therefore be written as

0=3HJ2+6αHJ2R−αR22+6αHJR˙=3HJ2+36αHJH¨J+108αHJ2H˙J−18αH˙J2,\begin{aligned} 0 &= 3H_J^2 + 6\alpha H_J^2R - \frac{\alpha R^2}{2} + 6\alpha H_J\dot{R} \\ &= 3H_J^2 + 36\alpha H_J\ddot{H}_J + 108\alpha H_J^2\dot{H}_J - 18\alpha\dot{H}_J^2, \end{aligned}

where R=6(H˙J+2HJ2)R = 6(\dot{H}_J + 2H_J^2) and R˙=6(H¨J+4HJH˙J)\dot{R} = 6(\ddot{H}_J + 4H_J\dot{H}_J) have been used without approximation. The resulting exact equation is

36αHJH¨J+108αHJ2H˙J−18αH˙J2+3HJ2=0.(4)36\alpha H_J\ddot{H}_J + 108\alpha H_J^2\dot{H}_J - 18\alpha\dot{H}_J^2 + 3H_J^2 = 0. \tag*{(4)}

In the normalization used here, this is

mH¨J+γH˙J−βH˙J2+F=0,m=36αHJ,γ=108αHJ2,β=18α,F=3HJ2.(5)\begin{aligned} m\ddot{H}_J + \gamma\dot{H}_J - \beta\dot{H}_J^2 + \mathcal{F} &= 0, \\ m &= 36\alpha H_J,\qquad\gamma= 108\alpha H_J^2, \\ \beta&= 18\alpha,\qquad\mathcal{F} = 3H_J^2. \tag*{(5)} \end{aligned}

The force-form terms are −γH˙J-\gamma\dot{H}_J, +βH˙J2+\beta\dot{H}_J^2 and −F-\mathcal{F}. The signs here refer to the acceleration side of the equation, rather than to a dissipative stress tensor: the terms are produced entirely by rearranging the field equation. On a decreasing-HJH_J branch, the first two oppose the motion. The quadratic force points toward increasing HJH_J for either velocity sign, so it is not a conventional resistive force on both branches. The coefficient mm is an effective inertia, not a particle mass. Multiplication of the differential equation by a nonzero function changes these coefficients, while leaving its solutions unchanged. In particular, the terms called damping in this analogy do not describe particle production or energy transfer to a matter sector.

Define the Jordan-frame Hubble-flow parameters

ϵJ=−H˙JHJ2,ηJ=ϵ˙JHJϵJ=H¨JHJH˙J+2ϵJ.(6)\epsilon_J=-\frac{\dot{H}_J}{H_J^2},\qquad\eta_J=\frac{\dot{\epsilon}_J}{H_J\epsilon_J}=\frac{\ddot{H}_J}{H_J\dot{H}_J}+2\epsilon_J. \tag*{(6)}

On an interval with HJ>0H_J>0, H˙J<0\dot{H}_J<0, the exact term ratios are

I≡∣mH¨J∣∣γH˙J∣=∣ηJ−2ϵJ∣3,βH˙J2∣γH˙J∣=ϵJ6.(7)\mathcal{I}\equiv\frac{\lvert m\ddot{H}_J\rvert}{\lvert\gamma\dot{H}_J\rvert}=\frac{\lvert\eta_J-2\epsilon_J\rvert}{3},\qquad\frac{\beta\dot{H}_J^2}{\lvert\gamma\dot{H}_J\rvert}=\frac{\epsilon_J}{6}. \tag*{(7)}

Both are small on the relaxed slow-roll branch, rather than on every solution with an initially small ϵJ\epsilon_J. Dropping them relative to the linear term gives the familiar drift

H˙J≃−136α,ϵJ≃136αHJ2.(8)\dot{H}_J\simeq-\frac{1}{36\alpha},\qquad\epsilon_J\simeq\frac{1}{36\alpha H_J^2}. \tag*{(8)}

Equation (7) is a consistency check of that approximation. A statement about attraction requires a comparison of neighboring solutions.

Local contraction and the slow-roll branch

On a monotone interval, let v(HJ)=H˙Jv(H_J)=\dot{H}_J. Equation (4) becomes

dvdHJ=−3HJ+v2HJ−HJ12αv.(9)\frac{\mathrm{d}v}{\mathrm{d}H_J}=-3H_J+\frac{v}{2H_J}-\frac{H_J}{12\alpha v}. \tag*{(9)}

If two solutions v1,v2<0v_1,v_2<0 are compared at the same HJ>0H_J>0, their difference obeys the exact identity

d(v1−v2)dHJ=(12HJ+HJ12αv1v2)(v1−v2).(10)\frac{\mathrm{d}(v_1-v_2)}{\mathrm{d}H_J}=\left(\frac{1}{2H_J}+\frac{H_J}{12\alpha v_1v_2}\right)(v_1-v_2). \tag*{(10)}

The coefficient is positive, so ∣v1−v2∣\lvert v_1-v_2\rvert decreases as HJH_J decreases along their common interval. This comparison eliminates the arbitrary choice of where the two solutions sit in cosmic time: it asks whether two histories approach the same velocity when they pass through the same Hubble value. For an infinitesimal displacement about a reference solution, with NJ=ln⁡aJ\mathcal{N}_J=\ln a_J increasing in time,

dln⁡∣δv∣dNJ=v2HJ2+112αv<0.(11)\frac{\mathrm{d}\ln\lvert\delta v\rvert}{\mathrm{d}\mathcal{N}_J}=\frac{v}{2H_J^2}+\frac{1}{12\alpha v}<0. \tag*{(11)}

This is a conditional attraction statement in the phase plane: both trajectories must remain on the expanding, decreasing-HJH_J branch. It is not a proof of a global basin of attraction, nor a comparison at equal cosmic times. In the leading drift regime the rate tends to −3-3, consistent with the known transient-attractor behavior [6].

To resolve the subleading drift, put h=αHJh=\sqrt{\alpha}H_J and write v=−(36α)−1w(h)v=-(36\alpha)^{-1}w(h). Equation (9) gives

2hwdwdh−w2+216h2(1−w)=0.(12)2hw\frac{\mathrm{d}w}{\mathrm{d}h}-w^2+216h^2(1-w)=0. \tag*{(12)}

The asymptotic branch with w→1w\to1 at large hh is

H˙J=−136α[1−1216αHJ2+17776α2HJ4+O((αHJ2)−3)].(13)\dot{H}_J=-\frac{1}{36\alpha}\left[1-\frac{1}{216\alpha H_J^2}+\frac{1}{7776\alpha^2H_J^4}+O\left((\alpha H_J^2)^{-3}\right)\right]. \tag*{(13)}

Consequently,

I=ϵJ29+O(ϵJ3).(14)\mathcal{I}=\frac{\epsilon_J^2}{9}+O(\epsilon_J^3). \tag*{(14)}

The inertial ratio on this branch is therefore smaller than a generic first-order slow-roll estimate.

Starting a numerical solution with only the leading velocity in Eq. (8) introduces a short transient and need not reproduce Eq. (14) immediately.

For the diagnostic plot we first allow the numerical trajectory to relax toward the decreasing-Hubble slow-roll branch, rather than treating a leading-order drift initial condition as exact. The figures use a solution started at hi=2.5h_i=2.5, dh/d(tJ/α)=−1/36\mathrm{d}h/\mathrm{d}(t_J/\sqrt{\alpha})=-1/36, evolved for more than 52 Jordan-frame e-folds before the displayed interval. The reference event is then selected 60 Jordan-frame e-folds before the first ϵJ=1\epsilon_J=1 crossing. At that event,

h∗≃1.827033,αH˙J,∗≃−0.02773957,I∗≃7.57×10−6.(15)h_\ast\simeq1.827033,\quad\alpha\dot{H}_{J,\ast}\simeq-0.02773957,\quad\mathcal{I}_\ast\simeq7.57\times10^{-6}. \tag*{(15)}

The drift series reproduces this velocity to a relative difference of 1.7×10−71.7\times10^{-7}. At ϵJ=1\epsilon_J=1, hJ≃0.157715h_J\simeq0.157715 and I≃0.04993\mathcal{I}\simeq0.04993; the quadratic term is still one sixth of the linear term (Figure 1). Thus the first loss of accelerated expansion does not coincide with quadratic dominance.

Figure 1. Term ratios along the relaxed Starobinsky trajectory. Left: D=∣γH˙J∣/(βH˙J2)=6/ϵJD = \lvert\gamma\dot{H}_J \rvert/(\beta\dot{H}_J^2) = 6/\epsilon_J. Right: the exact inertial-to-linear ratio I\mathcal{I} and its slow-roll asymptotic estimate ϵJ2/9\epsilon_J^2/9. The asymptotic estimate ϵJ2/9\epsilon_J^2/9 agrees closely with the exact inertial ratio on the relaxed slow-roll branch, but should not be extrapolated quantitatively to the end of inflation, where ϵJ\epsilon_J reaches unity. At the exit D=6D = 6, so this plot does not show quadratic dominance. NJN_J denotes the number of Jordan-frame e-folds remaining until the first ϵJ=1\epsilon_J = 1 crossing.

Signed square root and regular Hubble zeroes

On HJ>0H_J>0, the substitution HJ=Y2H_J=Y^2 removes the quadratic velocity term. Direct substitution into Eq. (4) gives

24αY¨+72αY2Y˙+Y=0.(16)24\alpha\ddot{Y}+72\alpha Y^2\dot{Y}+Y=0. \tag*{(16)}

The positive root Y=HJY=\sqrt{H_J} is only a local coordinate. Equation (16), however, is smooth at Y=0Y=0 and can be used with a signed YY. Its two signs describe the same HJH_J away from a zero. This is a regularizing parametrization, rather than a globally invertible field redefinition.

The change of variable is not merely algebraic convenience. It makes the late-time behavior easier to interpret because its equation has a smooth restoring term and an explicitly damped energy balance. In particular, a zero of YY is not by itself a singular event in spacetime.

The exact balance

EY=12αY˙2+12Y2,E˙Y=−72αY2Y˙2≤0(17)E_Y=12\alpha\dot{Y}^2+\frac{1}{2}Y^2,\qquad\dot{E}_Y=-72\alpha Y^2\dot{Y}^2\leq0 \tag*{(17)}

bounds YY and Y˙\dot{Y} in forward time for finite initial data. To check what its zero means physically, use the regular trace–Ricci system

H˙J=R6−2HJ2,R˙=P,P˙=−3HJP−R6α.(18)\dot{H}_J = \frac{R}{6} - 2H_J^2,\qquad\dot{R} = P,\qquad\dot{P} = -3H_JP - \frac{R}{6\alpha}. \tag*{(18)}

At HJ=0H_J = 0, the constraint requires R=H˙J=0R = \dot{H}_J = 0, but allows P0≠0P_0 \ne0. For an expanding tangency,

HJ(t0+ΔtJ)=P012ΔtJ2+O(ΔtJ4),P0>0.(19)H_J(t_0 + \Delta t_J) = \frac{P_0}{12}\Delta t_J^2 + O(\Delta t_J^4),\qquad P_0 > 0. \tag*{(19)}

The cubic Taylor coefficient vanishes because Eq. (18) gives P˙(t0)=0\dot{P}(t_0) = 0, and hence H¨J(t0)=0\ddot{H}_J(t_0) = 0. The signed solution of Eq. (16) gives P0=12Y˙02P_0 = 12\dot{Y}_0^2, in agreement with Eq. (18). It therefore continues through the tangency smoothly. The positive root alone behaves as ∣ΔtJ∣\lvert\Delta t_J\rvert and is not differentiable there. If HJ=R=P=0H_J = R = P = 0, uniqueness of Eq. (18) gives the Minkowski solution.

At small amplitude, the signed variable has frequency ωY=1/24α\omega_Y = 1/\sqrt{24\alpha}. This is not the scalaron mass. Indeed,

R=12YY˙+12Y4,(20)R = 12Y\dot{Y} + 12Y^4, \tag*{(20)}

so a leading harmonic Y≃Acos⁡(ωYtJ+θ)Y \simeq A\cos(\omega_Y t_J + \theta) produces a curvature oscillation with frequency 2ωY=1/6α2\omega_Y = 1/\sqrt{6\alpha}. Averaging Eq. (17) over a period gives A˙≃−3A3/8\dot{A} \simeq-3A^3/8 and, at late times,

HJ≃43(tJ−tc)cos⁡2(tJ26α+θ),⟨HJ⟩≃23(tJ−tc).(21)H_J \simeq\frac{4}{3(t_J-t_c)}\cos^2\left(\frac{t_J}{2\sqrt{6\alpha}}+\theta\right),\qquad\langle H_J\rangle\simeq\frac{2}{3(t_J-t_c)}. \tag*{(21)}

The averaging applies after the coherent oscillations have entered their small-amplitude regime; the oscillatory term in HJH_J and its averaged envelope should not be mistaken for separate fluids. This reproduces the known oscillatory vacuum behavior of the quadratic model [5, 8]. It describes coherent scalaron oscillations, not their conversion into a thermal matter sector [12, 13].

In the original Hubble variable one may instead define EH=12mH˙J2+HJ3E_H = \frac{1}{2}m\dot{H}_J^2 + H_J^3. Retaining the derivative of m(HJ)m(H_J) gives

E˙H=−γH˙J2+(β+12dmdHJ)H˙J3=−γH˙J2+2βH˙J3.(22)\dot{E}_H = -\gamma\dot{H}_J^2 + \left(\beta+ \frac{1}{2}\frac{\mathrm{d}m}{\mathrm{d}H_J}\right)\dot{H}_J^3 = -\gamma\dot{H}_J^2 + 2\beta\dot{H}_J^3. \tag*{(22)}

The combined nonlinear term has magnitude ϵJ/3\epsilon_J/3 times the linear term on the decreasing branch. Equations (17) and (22) are different mechanical balances for the same background. Neither defines an invariant fluid energy or an independent energy transfer into particles.

Canonical dynamics and a derivative expansion for general f(R)f(R)

Frame transformation and physical mass

On a branch with F>0F > 0 and locally invertible F(R)F(R), the exact transformation is

gμνE=FgμνJ,ϕ=32MPlln⁡F,dtE=F dtJ,HE=HJ+F˙/(2F)F.(23)g^E_{\mu\nu} = Fg^J_{\mu\nu}, \qquad\phi= \sqrt{\frac{3}{2}}M_{\mathrm{Pl}}\ln F, \qquad\mathrm{d}t_E = \sqrt{F}\,\mathrm{d}t_J, \qquad H_E = \frac{H_J + \dot{F}/(2F)}{\sqrt{F}}. \tag*{(23)}

The potential and homogeneous equations are [3, 4, 8]

VE(R)=MPl22RF−fF2,VE,ϕ=MPl62f−RFF2,(24)V_E(R) = \frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}{2}\frac{RF-f}{F^2}, \qquad V_{E,\phi} = \frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}}{\sqrt{6}}\frac{2f-RF}{F^2}, \tag*{(24)}
d2ϕdtE2+3HEdϕdtE+VE,ϕ=0,3MPl2HE2=12(dϕdtE)2+VE.(25)\frac{\mathrm{d}^2\phi}{\mathrm{d}t_E^2} + 3H_E\frac{\mathrm{d}\phi}{\mathrm{d}t_E} + V_{E,\phi} = 0, \qquad3M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2H_E^2 = \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{\mathrm{d}\phi}{\mathrm{d}t_E}\right)^2 + V_E. \tag*{(25)}

For example, the transformed acceleration and friction combine to give

d2ϕdtE2+3HEdϕdtE=32MPlF¨+3HJF˙F2.(26)\frac{\mathrm{d}^2\phi}{\mathrm{d}t_E^2} + 3H_E\frac{\mathrm{d}\phi}{\mathrm{d}t_E} = \sqrt{\frac{3}{2}}M_{\mathrm{Pl}}\frac{\ddot{F}+3H_J\dot{F}}{F^2}. \tag*{(26)}

The trace equation then yields the scalaron equation in Eq. (25), while the Einstein-frame Friedmann equation follows from the transformed Jordan-frame constraint (2). The canonical friction is obtained from the full transformation, rather than from the Jordan-frame linear velocity term alone.

For the quadratic model,

VE=MPl28α(1−e−2/3ϕ/MPl)2=ϕ212α+O(ϕ3αMPl),Mϕ2=16α.(27)V_E = \frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}{8\alpha}\left(1-e^{-\sqrt{2/3}\phi/M_{\mathrm{Pl}}}\right)^2 = \frac{\phi^2}{12\alpha} + O\left(\frac{\phi^3}{\alpha M_{\mathrm{Pl}}}\right), \qquad M_\phi^2 = \frac{1}{6\alpha}. \tag*{(27)}

Since VE≥0V_E \ge0 on the expanding Einstein branch, HJ=F[HE−(dϕ/dtE)/(6MPl)]≥0H_J = \sqrt{F}[H_E - (\mathrm{d}\phi/\mathrm{d}t_E)/(\sqrt{6}M_{\mathrm{Pl}})] \ge0. Its zero occurs at a passage through ϕ=0\phi= 0 with positive scalaron velocity, where F=1F = 1. This provides an independent check of the tangency in § 2.3. Figure 2 shows the canonical background. The monotone HEH_E must not be identified with the oscillatory HJH_J in Eq. (21).

Figure 2. Vacuum Starobinsky evolution in Einstein time. The initial field is ϕi/MPl=5.5\phi_i/M_{\mathrm{Pl}} = 5.5; its initial velocity is set by the leading slow-roll drift with the full Friedmann constraint imposed. Upper panels: the scalaron and the normalized Hubble parameter αHE\sqrt{\alpha}H_E. Lower panels: the exit of inflation and the coherent late-time scalaron oscillations. In the small-amplitude limit, the frequency of ϕ\phi tends to Mϕ=1/6αM_\phi= 1/\sqrt{6\alpha}. No particle-production or thermalization equation is included. The oscillations are a vacuum property of the model and serve as a consistency check of the background evolution.

The disappearance of an effective mechanical coefficient at a special Hubble value has no bearing on the mass of the canonical scalaron. The latter is read from the potential, while ghost and tachyon criteria require perturbing the action around a specified background. Physical stability must be assessed from the action and the appropriate perturbation problem. The sign of a mechanical inertial coefficient is not a ghost criterion. We work with F>0F > 0 and fRR>0f_{RR} > 0; these give the positive tensor kinetic coefficient and the conventional locally invertible curvature branch [27]. At a constant-curvature vacuum R⋆R_\star satisfying 2f=R⋆F2f = R_\star F, the trace mass in Jordan time is

MR,J2=F(R⋆)−R⋆fRR(R⋆)3fRR(R⋆).(28)M_{R,J}^{2} = \frac{F(R_\star) - R_\star f_{RR}(R_\star)}{3f_{RR}(R_\star)}. \tag*{(28)}

The canonical Einstein-frame mass there is MR,J2/F(R⋆)M_{R,J}^{2}/F(R_\star). Positivity of fRRf_{RR} alone does not prove positivity of this mass, and evaluating Eq. (28) along a rolling background does not give its complete perturbation mass.

Expansion and the first omitted terms

For a general smooth function, the exact Hubble equation is

Eex=18HJfRR(R)H¨J+72HJ2fRR(R)H˙J+3HJ2fR(R)−U(R)=0,(29)\mathcal{E}_{\mathrm{ex}} = 18H_J f_{RR}(R)\ddot{H}_J + 72H_J^2 f_{RR}(R)\dot{H}_J + 3H_J^2 f_R(R) - U(R) = 0, \tag*{(29)}

with R=R0+6H˙JR = R_0 + 6\dot{H}_J and R0=12HJ2R_0 = 12H_J^2. This formula is exact in vacuum and has no assumption of slow roll. Its dependence on the full RR is precisely why the simplified, position-only coefficients below require an additional approximation. For HJfRR≠0H_J f_{RR} \ne0, solving this standard constraint for H¨J\ddot{H}_J gives the exact Hubble phase-space equation used in the Supplemental Material of Ref. [16]. Its coefficients depend on the velocity through RR. Coefficients that depend on HJH_J alone require an expansion.

On an interval with HJ≠0H_J \ne0, write v=H˙Jv = \dot{H}_J and a=H¨Ja = \ddot{H}_J, and adopt the derivative counting

vHJ2=O(λ),aHJ3=O(λ2),λ≪1.(30)\frac{v}{H_J^2} = O(\lambda), \qquad\frac{a}{H_J^3} = O(\lambda^2), \qquad\lambda\ll1. \tag*{(30)}

Smoothness alone does not control the expansion. The curvature-derivative ratios R0fRRR/fRRR_0 f_{RRR}/f_{RR} and R02fRRRR/fRRR_0^2 f_{RRRR}/f_{RR} can offset the nominal powers of λ\lambda. Their behavior must be checked as RR varies from R0R_0 to R0+6vR_0 + 6v. Near sharp curvature features, the Taylor remainder must be evaluated directly.

Using UR=RfRR/2U_R = Rf_{RR}/2 and URR=(fRR+RfRRR)/2U_{RR} = (f_{RR} + Rf_{RRR})/2, the second-order equation is

E2=ma+γv−βv2+F=0,(31)\mathcal{E}_2 = ma + \gamma v - \beta v^2 + \mathcal{F} = 0, \tag*{(31)}

where all curvature derivatives below are evaluated at R0R_0:

m=18HJfRR,γ=54HJ2fRR,m = 18H_Jf_{RR}, \qquad\gamma= 54H_J^2f_{RR},
β=9fRR−378HJ2fRRR,F=3HJ2fR−U.(32)\beta= 9f_{RR} - 378H_J^2f_{RRR}, \qquad\mathcal{F} = 3H_J^2f_R - U. \tag*{(32)}

The linear coefficient can be checked without relying on the dictionary:

γ(HJ)H˙J=[72HJ2fRR(R0)+18HJ2fRR(R0)−6UR(R0)]H˙J=(72+18−36)HJ2fRR(R0)H˙J=54HJ2fRR(R0)H˙J.(33)\begin{aligned} \gamma(H_J)\dot{H}_J = \left[72H_J^2f_{RR}(R_0) + 18H_J^2f_{RR}(R_0) - 6U_R(R_0)\right]\dot{H}_J \\ &= (72 + 18 - 36)H_J^2f_{RR}(R_0)\dot{H}_J = 54H_J^2f_{RR}(R_0)\dot{H}_J. \tag*{(33)} \end{aligned}

where UR=RfRR/2U_R = Rf_{RR}/2 and R0=12HJ2R_0 = 12H_J^2. The result differs from what one would obtain by expanding the potential-like term alone. The time derivative of fRf_R and the curvature dependence of the coefficient of H˙J\dot{H}_J contribute at the same order. The fRRRv2f_{RRR}v^2 coefficient is the sum 54+432−108=37854 + 432 - 108 = 378: its pieces come from 3HJ2fR3H_J^2f_R, the explicit velocity term, and −U-U, respectively. The potential expansion also supplies −9fRRv2-9f_{RR}v^2. Retaining only URRU_{RR} would therefore give the wrong quadratic coefficient.

At the next order,

E3=E2+Mva+Kv3,M=108HJfRRR,K=1188HJ2fRRRR−36fRRR.(34)\mathcal{E}_3 = \mathcal{E}_2 + \mathcal{M}va + \mathcal{K}v^3, \qquad\mathcal{M} = 108H_Jf_{RRR}, \qquad\mathcal{K} = 1188H_J^2f_{RRRR} - 36f_{RRR}. \tag*{(34)}

In Eq. (30), both added terms have third derivative order. For example, the next inertial term is 324HJfRRRRv2a324H_Jf_{RRRR}v^2a and has fourth order. The equations used for the two truncated trajectories are

a2=−γv+βv2−Fm,a3=−γv+βv2−F−Kv3m+Mv,(35)a_2 = \frac{-\gamma v + \beta v^2 - \mathcal{F}}{m}, \qquad a_3 = \frac{-\gamma v + \beta v^2 - \mathcal{F} - \mathcal{K}v^3}{m + \mathcal{M}v}, \tag*{(35)}

where the relevant denominator must remain nonzero. These truncated equations are to be integrated only while the expansion ordering and the denominators remain under control. The residual of E2\mathcal{E}_2 on an exact solution and the error of a solution evolved with a2a_2 are different quantities. We compute both in § 5.

Within Eq. (31), γ/m=3HJ\gamma/m = 3H_J and a local coordinate removing its explicit quadratic velocity term satisfies

y,HJHJy,HJ=−βm,y,HJ∝HJ−1/2[fRR(12HJ2)]7/8,(36)\frac{y_{,H_JH_J}}{y_{,H_J}} = -\frac{\beta}{m}, \qquad y_{,H_J} \propto H_J^{-1/2}\left[f_{RR}(12H_J^2)\right]^{7/8}, \tag*{(36)}

on HJ>0H_J > 0, fRR>0f_{RR} > 0. This transformation removes a term of the chosen truncation, not the remainder or the scalaron’s physical nonlinear dynamics. For fRR=2αf_{RR} = 2\alpha, Eq. (31) is exact and Eq. (36) reduces to the square-root parametrization.

A regularized inverse-logarithmic example

Action, derivatives and scalaron potential

Consider

f(R)=R+αR2[1+δL(R)],L(R)=ℓ0+ln⁡(1+R2Rc2)(37)f(R) = R + \alpha R^2 \left[1 + \frac{\delta}{\mathcal{L}(R)}\right], \qquad\mathcal{L}(R) = \ell_0 + \ln\left(1 + \frac{R^2}{R_c^2}\right) \tag*{(37)}

with α\alpha, RcR_c, ℓ0>0\ell_0 > 0. The coefficient δ\delta is dimensionless; α\alpha has dimensions of inverse curvature. We study δ≥0\delta\ge0. The choice δ=0\delta= 0 returns the quadratic Starobinsky action, so the numerical scan has a direct reference model. The shifted logarithm L\mathcal{L} is positive and smooth for every real RR. The logarithm is regularized here specifically to permit the solution to cross R=0R = 0 during the vacuum oscillatory stage without encountering the logarithmic singularity of an unshifted expression. At ∣R∣≫Rc|R| \gg R_c, its inverse gives a correction that tends to zero, leaving a nonzero quadratic coefficient α\alpha. At R=0R = 0, the quadratic coefficient is instead α(1+δ/ℓ0)\alpha(1 + \delta/\ell_0). These choices define the interpolation used here; they do not establish a quantum origin or a unique ultraviolet completion. The motivation for considering an inverse logarithm is the running of curvature-squared couplings in quantum-gravity calculations and related logarithmically corrected inflationary actions [14, 16]. Our inverse-logarithmic factor is chosen to reproduce a comparable large-curvature functional dependence while keeping a smooth Minkowski branch. The shift inside the logarithm and its continuation through negative curvature are phenomenological choices; we do not derive them from a trace anomaly, a specified matter spectrum or a string effective action.

Introduce

x=αR,s=αRc,q=x2x2+s2,L=ℓ0+ln⁡(1+x2/s2).(38)x = \alpha R,\qquad s = \alpha R_c,\qquad q = \frac{x^2}{x^2 + s^2},\qquad\mathcal{L} = \ell_0 + \ln(1 + x^2/s^2). \tag*{(38)}

The following functions keep the derivatives compact:

A=1+δL−2δqL2,B=1+δL−δqL2,A = 1 + \frac{\delta}{\mathcal{L}} - \frac{2\delta q}{\mathcal{L}^2},\qquad B = 1 + \frac{\delta}{\mathcal{L}} - \frac{\delta q}{\mathcal{L}^2},
C=1+δL−δ(5q−2q2)L2+4δq2L3.(39)C = 1 + \frac{\delta}{\mathcal{L}} - \frac{\delta(5q - 2q^2)}{\mathcal{L}^2} + \frac{4\delta q^2}{\mathcal{L}^3}. \tag*{(39)}

Direct differentiation gives

F=1+2xB,fRR=2αC,fRRR=2α2Cx,fRRRR=2α3Cxx.(40)F = 1 + 2xB,\qquad f_{RR} = 2\alpha C,\qquad f_{RRR} = 2\alpha^2 C_x,\qquad f_{RRRR} = 2\alpha^3 C_{xx}. \tag*{(40)}

It is also useful to define

S=α(RF−f)=x2A,T=α(2f−RF)=x+2δx2qL2,Sx=2xC.(41)S = \alpha(RF - f) = x^2 A,\qquad T = \alpha(2f - RF) = x + \frac{2\delta x^2 q}{\mathcal{L}^2},\qquad S_x = 2xC. \tag*{(41)}

The exact potential and its mass at the Minkowski minimum are

VE=MPl22αSF2,Mϕ,02=16α(1+δ/ℓ0).(42)V_E = \frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}{2\alpha}\frac{S}{F^2},\qquad M_{\phi,0}^2 = \frac{1}{6\alpha(1 + \delta/\ell_0)}. \tag*{(42)}

Relation to running quadratic gravity

The large-number-of-matter-fields approximation of Ref. [16] has curvature dependence

fRG(R)∝R2[λtH+4ln⁡(R2/μ04)],(43)f_{\mathrm{RG}}(R) \propto R^2\left[\lambda_{\mathrm{tH}}+\frac{4}{\ln\left(R^2/\mu_0^4\right)}\right], \tag*{(43)}

where λtH\lambda_{\mathrm{tH}} parametrizes the renormalization-group trajectory and μ0\mu_0 is a mass scale. Suppressing the overall action normalization, the quadratic part of Eq. (37) has the same large-curvature form under the formal identification

δ=4λtH,μ02=Rce−ℓ0/2,L=ln⁡R2μ04+O(Rc2R2).(44)\delta=\frac{4}{\lambda_{\mathrm{tH}}},\qquad\mu_0^2=R_{\mathrm{c}}e^{-\ell_0/2},\qquad\mathcal{L}=\ln\frac{R^2}{\mu_0^4}+O\left(\frac{R_{\mathrm{c}}^2}{R^2}\right). \tag*{(44)}

The relation concerns the curvature functions. Here the Einstein–Hilbert term is present at all curvatures, and the regularized action has a Minkowski minimum. The running couplings, matter-loop content and Weyl-squared sector of Ref. [16] are outside this model. Their strong-coupling restriction on rr therefore cannot be transferred to the present parameter scan.

The common asymptotic behavior also appears in the potential. At fixed δ>0\delta>0 and ϕ/MPl→∞\phi/M_{\mathrm{Pl}}\to\infty,

VE=MPl28α[1−bMPlϕ+O(MPl2ϕ2)],b=38δ.(45)V_{\mathrm{E}}=\frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}{8\alpha}\left[1-b\frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}}{\phi}+O\left(\frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}{\phi^2}\right)\right],\qquad b=\sqrt{\frac{3}{8}}\delta. \tag*{(45)}

Indeed, L=8/3 ϕ/MPl+O(1)\mathcal{L}=\sqrt{8/3}\,\phi/M_{\mathrm{Pl}}+O(1) and the leading potential correction is −δ/L-\delta/\mathcal{L}. Slow roll then gives

N∗≃(ϕ/MPl)33b,ns≃1−43N∗,r≃4δ2/33N∗4/3.(46)N_\ast\simeq\frac{(\phi/M_{\mathrm{Pl}})^3}{3b},\qquad n_s\simeq1-\frac{4}{3N_\ast},\qquad r\simeq\frac{4\delta^{2/3}}{3N_\ast^{4/3}}. \tag*{(46)}

With Eq. (44), these are the leading spectral scalings of Ref. [16]. They are established asymptotics of this inverse-field plateau. The δ=0\delta=0 limit instead gives the exponential Starobinsky plateau; the fixed-positive-δ\delta large-field limit is not uniform at δ=0\delta=0.

The asymptotic formulas alone need not describe an event 60 e-folds before the exit. We therefore retain the full finite-curvature action in the numerical calculation. At the δ=3\delta=3, ℓ0=1\ell_0=1, s=0.01s=0.01 reference event, defined as 60 exact Einstein-frame e-folds before the first ϵE=1\epsilon_{\mathrm{E}}=1 crossing (§ 5), the Einstein–Hilbert contribution is about 1.58% of the quadratic part of ff, while the logarithmic-to-Einstein–Hilbert ratio in 2f−RF2f-RF is 0.983. Thus a small action fraction can still matter for the inflationary slope. The tests below concern the regular branch and the accuracy of the mechanical approximation in this specified extension.

Positive curvature derivative on the studied slice

Proposition 1. For ℓ0=1\ell_0=1, s>0s>0 and δ≥0\delta\geq0, Eq. (37) satisfies fRR≥2αf_{RR}\geq2\alpha at every real RR. The function F(x)F(x) is strictly increasing and has a unique negative zero xbx_b. On x>xbx>x_b, the scalaron potential is nonnegative and has a Minkowski minimum at x=0x=0.

Proof. Write C=1+δP(L,q)/L3C = 1 + \delta P(\mathcal{L},q)/\mathcal{L}^{3}, where

P(L,q)=L2−(5q−2q2)L+4q2.(47)P(\mathcal{L},q) = \mathcal{L}^{2} - (5q - 2q^{2})\mathcal{L} + 4q^{2}. \tag*{(47)}

For 1/2<q<11/2 < q < 1, the discriminant of Eq. (47), regarded as a quadratic in L\mathcal{L}, is q2(1−2q)(9−2q)<0q^{2}(1-2q)(9-2q) < 0. Since its leading coefficient is positive, P>0P > 0. For 0≤q≤1/20 \le q \le1/2, L=1−ln⁡(1−q)≥1+q\mathcal{L} = 1 - \ln(1-q) \ge1+q. On this interval, PL≥2−3q+2q2>0P_{\mathcal{L}} \ge2 - 3q + 2q^{2} > 0, and P(1+q,q)=(1−q)(1−2q)+2q3>0P(1+q,q) = (1-q)(1-2q) + 2q^{3} > 0. Thus C≥1C \ge1.

Since Fx=2C≥2F_x = 2C \ge2, FF is strictly increasing. Moreover, F(0)=1F(0) = 1 and F→−∞F \to-\infty as x→−∞x \to-\infty, giving one zero xb<0x_b < 0. Finally, S(0)=0S(0) = 0 and Sx=2xCS_x = 2xC imply S>0S > 0 at every x≠0x \ne0. Equation (42) proves the potential statement on F>0F > 0.

The potential diverges as F→0+F \to0^{+}, because S(xb)>0S(x_b) > 0. An expanding Einstein-frame solution with finite initial scalaron energy cannot reach that boundary: its energy obeys dρϕ/dtE=−3HE(dϕ/dtE)2≤0\mathrm{d}\rho_{\phi}/\mathrm{d}t_E = -3H_E(\mathrm{d}\phi/\mathrm{d}t_E)^2 \le0. This is a branch-regularity statement, not a theorem of perturbative stability on every rolling solution. The bound just proved uses ℓ0=1\ell_0 = 1; it should not be extrapolated to arbitrary positive ℓ0\ell_0 without another analysis.

Mechanical coefficients and potential slow roll

At x0=12αHJ2x_0 = 12\alpha H_J^2, Eq. (32) becomes

m=36αHJC(x0),γ=108αHJ2C(x0),β=18α[C(x0)−72x0Cx(x0)],F=3HJ2+72αδHJ4q(x0)L(x0)2.(48)\begin{aligned} m &= 36\alpha H_J C(x_0), \qquad\gamma= 108\alpha H_J^2 C(x_0),\\ \beta&= 18\alpha\left[C(x_0)-\frac{7}{2}x_0 C_x(x_0)\right], \qquad\mathcal{F} = 3H_J^2+\frac{72\alpha\delta H_J^4q(x_0)}{\mathcal{L}(x_0)^2}. \tag*{(48)} \end{aligned}

Neglecting mH¨Jm\ddot{H}_J and βH˙J2\beta\dot{H}_J^2 relative to γH˙J\gamma\dot{H}_J in Eq. (31), the leading drift is therefore

H˙J≃−136αC(x0)−2δHJ2q(x0)3C(x0)L(x0)2.(49)\dot{H}_J \simeq-\frac{1}{36\alpha C(x_0)}-\frac{2\delta H_J^2q(x_0)}{3C(x_0)\mathcal{L}(x_0)^2}. \tag*{(49)}

The logarithmic deformation is thus visible already in the slow background drift, but its significance cannot be read off from the magnitude of the added term in the action alone. The correction changes both the drift and the potential. Their physical interpretation remains tied to the exact background and canonical scalaron.

We use ℓ0=1\ell_0 = 1 because this slice admits the analytic lower bound on fRRf_{RR} proved above. The choice s=0.01s = 0.01 supplies a smooth, resolved low-curvature scale for the post-inflationary continuation. Within the scan 0≤δ≤50 \le\delta\le5, the reference value δ=3\delta= 3 is representative rather than an observational bound or a maximally allowed coupling: it gives an order-unity competition between the logarithmic and Einstein–Hilbert contributions to the inflationary potential slope, as quantified below. These values were chosen to stress-test the mechanical expansion, not by optimizing a cosmological likelihood.

For comparison with the mode calculation below, potential slow roll gives

ϵV=13(TS)2,ηV=23[F2Cddx(TS)+(TS)2],(50)\epsilon_V = \frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{T}{S}\right)^2,\qquad\eta_V = \frac{2}{3}\left[\frac{F}{2C}\frac{\mathrm{d}}{\mathrm{d}x}\left(\frac{T}{S}\right)+\left(\frac{T}{S}\right)^2\right], \tag*{(50)}

and ns(V)=1−6ϵV+2ηVn_s^{(V)}=1-6\epsilon_V+2\eta_V, r(V)=16ϵVr^{(V)}=16\epsilon_V. Its approximate e-fold integral is

NE(V)=3∫xend,Vx∗(V)SCTF dx,ϵV(xend,V)=1.(51)N_E^{(V)}=3\int_{x_{\mathrm{end},V}}^{x_*^{(V)}}\frac{SC}{TF}\,\mathrm{d}x,\qquad\epsilon_V(x_{\mathrm{end},V})=1. \tag*{(51)}

The superscript distinguishes this endpoint prescription from the exact background criterion ϵE=1\epsilon_E=1. For δ=3\delta=3, ℓ0=1\ell_0=1, s=0.01s=0.01 and NE(V)=60N_E^{(V)}=60, it gives x∗(V)=55.9502x_*^{(V)}=55.9502 and xend,V=0.473361x_{\mathrm{end},V}=0.473361. At the potential pivot, the logarithmic contribution to TT is about 1.0069 times its Einstein–Hilbert contribution. It therefore cannot be dropped from the potential slope even when its fractional correction to the action is modest.

Background evolution and approximation errors

We integrate the exact vacuum equations and the truncated Hubble equations from the same reference state. Comparing the solutions at common Jordan times measures the accumulated error. Separate Jordan- and Einstein-frame integrations check the time and frame transformations.

Use dimensionless times τJ=tJ/α\tau_J=t_J/\sqrt{\alpha}, τE=tE/α\tau_E=t_E/\sqrt{\alpha}, Hubble parameters hJ,E=αHJ,Eh_{J,E}=\sqrt{\alpha}H_{J,E}, and p=dx/dτJp=\mathrm{d}x/\mathrm{d}\tau_J. The exact Jordan system is

dhJdτJ=x6−2hJ2,dxdτJ=p,dpdτJ=−3hJp−CxCp2−T6C,3hJ2F=S2−6hJCp.(52)\begin{aligned} \frac{\mathrm{d}h_J}{\mathrm{d}\tau_J}&=\frac{x}{6}-2h_J^2,&\frac{\mathrm{d}x}{\mathrm{d}\tau_J}&=p,\\ \frac{\mathrm{d}p}{\mathrm{d}\tau_J}&=-3h_Jp-\frac{C_x}{C}p^2-\frac{T}{6C},&3h_J^2F&=\frac{S}{2}-6h_JCp. \tag*{(52)} \end{aligned}

The last equality is imposed on the initial state and monitored as a constraint. In the Einstein frame, put u=d(ϕ/MPl)/dτEu=\mathrm{d}(\phi/M_{\mathrm{Pl}})/\mathrm{d}\tau_E; then

dxdτE=uF6C,dudτE=−3hEu−T6F2,hE2=13(u22+S2F2).(53)\frac{\mathrm{d}x}{\mathrm{d}\tau_E}=\frac{uF}{\sqrt{6C}},\qquad\frac{\mathrm{d}u}{\mathrm{d}\tau_E}=-3h_Eu-\frac{T}{\sqrt{6}F^2},\qquad h_E^2=\frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{u^2}{2}+\frac{S}{2F^2}\right). \tag*{(53)}

The matching data are

hJ=F(hE−u6),p=uF3/26C,dτE=F dτJ.(54)h_J=\sqrt{F}\left(h_E-\frac{u}{\sqrt{6}}\right),\qquad p=\frac{uF^{3/2}}{\sqrt{6C}},\qquad\mathrm{d}\tau_E=\sqrt{F}\,\mathrm{d}\tau_J. \tag*{(54)}

We use δ=3\delta=3, ℓ0=1\ell_0=1 and s=0.01s=0.01 for the background comparison. The initial curvature is xi=100x_i=100. With W=αVE/MPl2=S/(2F2)W=\alpha V_E/M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2=S/(2F^2) and ϕ=φ/MPl\phi=\varphi/M_{\mathrm{Pl}}, we choose the initial scalaron velocity from the leading slow-roll relation, ui=−W,φ/(3hE,i)u_i = -W_{,\varphi}/(3h_{E,i}), and determine hE,ih_{E,i} from the full Friedmann constraint. Explicitly,

W,φ=T6F2,hE,i2=Wi+Wi2+2W,φ,i2/36,ui=−0.0035141761.(55)W_{,\varphi} = \frac{T}{\sqrt{6}F^2}, \qquad h_{E,i}^2 = \frac{W_i + \sqrt{W_i^2 + 2W_{,\varphi,i}^2/3}}{6}, \qquad u_i = -0.0035141761. \tag*{(55)}

The reference event is selected 60 exact Einstein-frame e-folds before the first ϵE=1\epsilon_E = 1 crossing. The direct Jordan integration starts from the transformed state at that event. Both time origins are reset there.

We use the DOP853 integrator in SciPy [28] with relative and absolute tolerances 2×10−132 \times10^{-13} and 2×10−152 \times10^{-15} and maximum dimensionless time step 0.0125. A comparison run uses 2×10−112 \times10^{-11}, 2×10−132 \times10^{-13} and step 0.025. The two frames are compared at 40 001 common events on 0≤τJ≤1600 \le\tau_J \le160. Maximum sampled absolute differences in xx, hJh_J and pp are below 10−1010^{-10}; the maximum absolute Jordan constraint residual is below 10−1010^{-10}. Relative residuals are poorly conditioned near simultaneous zeroes of HJH_J and RR, so an absolute residual is reported. These checks measure a finite trajectory, rather than a solver-independent error bound.

The exact reference state, defined at the chosen 60-e-fold event, is

x∗=54.2476675,ϕ∗/MPl=5.9270815,ϵE,∗=3.35782×10−4.(56)x_* = 54.2476675, \qquad\phi_*/M_{\mathrm{Pl}} = 5.9270815, \qquad\epsilon_{E,*} = 3.35782 \times10^{-4}. \tag*{(56)}

The first Einstein-frame acceleration exit occurs at x=0.2629670x = 0.2629670 and τJ=60.2800\tau_J = 60.2800. The Jordan-frame ϵJ=1\epsilon_J = 1 event occurs 0.179064 Einstein-frame e-fold later. The e-fold relation between any two common events is

NE=NJ+12ln⁡FendF∗.(57)N_E = N_J + \frac{1}{2}\ln\frac{F_{\mathrm{end}}}{F_*}. \tag*{(57)}

Thus the 60-NJN_J reference in Figure 1 and the 60-NEN_E reference here are distinct conventions. For the two Starobinsky events used in that figure, the same expansion is NE=57.9347N_E = 57.9347.

The vacuum logarithmic-model solution subsequently oscillates about R=0R = 0 (Figure 3). The sampled minima are F=0.81650F = 0.81650 and C=1.13967C = 1.13967, consistent with § 4.3. The narrower features near the regularization scale are evolved with the exact equations. No slow-roll expansion is used for the post-inflationary trajectory.

Figure 3. Exact vacuum background for δ=3\delta= 3, ℓ0=1\ell_0 = 1, and s=0.01s = 0.01. Upper panels: curvature evolution and the Jordan- and Einstein-frame acceleration parameters. The e-fold coordinate increases from the exact Einstein-frame reference event. Lower panels: the subsequent curvature oscillations and the positive functions FF and CC. Jordan time is measured from the reference event. This is a vacuum solution; no matter-production equation is included. The two end-of-inflation markers use ϵE=1\epsilon_E = 1 and ϵJ=1\epsilon_J = 1 and therefore occur at different events.

Two types of comparisons are shown in the plots. The curvature and coefficient histories in Figure 3 come from the untruncated field equations, while the curves in Figure 4 test an approximation against that same exact trajectory. In particular, a small residual of an approximate equation does not ensure a proportionally small accumulated error in its solution. The points near the end of the plotted inflationary interval should not be used to extrapolate either truncated equation into the oscillatory era.

Figure 4. Approximation tests for the logarithmic benchmark. Upper left: the magnitudes of the retained inertial and quadratic terms relative to the linear term, evaluated on the exact background. Upper right: second- and third-order equation residuals divided by the force magnitude. Lower panels: the relative errors in the Hubble parameter and its velocity, respectively, obtained by independently integrating the truncated equations and comparing them with the exact solution at the same Jordan times. The e-fold coordinate is assigned using the exact background. The initial trajectory errors vanish and are clipped at 10−1610^{-16} for logarithmic plotting. Term ratios, equation residuals, and integrated trajectory errors are distinct diagnostics.

At the reference event, the second-order mechanical ratios and residual are

∣mH¨J∣∣γH˙J∣=2.8403×10−3,∣βH˙J2∣∣γH˙J∣=1.8477×10−3,∣E2∣∣F∣=1.318×10−7.(58)\frac{\lvert m\ddot{H}_J\rvert}{\lvert\gamma\dot{H}_J\rvert}=2.8403\times10^{-3},\qquad\frac{\lvert\beta\dot{H}_J^2\rvert}{\lvert\gamma\dot{H}_J\rvert}=1.8477\times10^{-3},\qquad\frac{\lvert E_2\rvert}{\lvert\mathcal{F}\rvert}=1.318\times10^{-7}. \tag*{(58)}

The omitted mixed term alone is 1.702×10−71.702 \times10^{-7} of ∣F∣\lvert\mathcal{F}\rvert there; the cubic term also contributes.

Near the first Einstein-frame exit, the second-order residual reaches about 3.54×10−33.54 \times10^{-3} of ∣F∣\lvert\mathcal{F}\rvert.

For a quantitative local check, define

χp(tJ)=∣Ep[HJ,exact](tJ)∣∣F(HJ,exact(tJ))∣,p=2,3,(59)\chi_p(t_J)=\frac{\lvert E_p[H_{J,\mathrm{exact}}](t_J)\rvert}{\lvert\mathcal{F}(H_{J,\mathrm{exact}}(t_J))\rvert},\qquad p=2,3, \tag*{(59)}

on intervals where F≠0\mathcal{F}\ne0. This compares each truncated equation with the exact trajectory, rather than with its own numerical solution. A tolerance such as χp<10−3\chi_p<10^{-3} is a chosen one-per-mille accuracy criterion, not a model-independent slow-roll boundary. In the sampled inflationary interval of our δ=3\delta=3 benchmark, χ2\chi_2 first exceeds 10−310^{-3} at approximately n=59.60n=59.60 and remains below 10−210^{-2} through the first Einstein-frame acceleration exit. Where F\mathcal{F} is small or zero, the same residual must instead be normalized by a nonsingular scale formed from the retained terms. These pointwise criteria say nothing on their own about the accumulated solution error, which is tested separately below.

To measure accumulated error, we evolve each equation in Eq. (35) from the same exact HJH_J, H˙J\dot{H}_J at the reference event. We compare HJH_J at common Jordan times, labeled by the exact trajectory’s elapsed Einstein e-folds nn. This avoids comparing different endpoints. The resulting errors are reported in Table 1. Table 1 uses the nearest points of the 40 001-event sample; their

nn∣HJ,2/HJ−1∣\lvert H_{J,2}/H_J-1\rvert∣HJ,3/HJ−1∣\lvert H_{J,3}/H_J-1\rvert
301.44×10−71.44\times10^{-7}8.08×10−108.08\times10^{-10}
501.85×10−61.85\times10^{-6}2.13×10−82.13\times10^{-8}
557.07×10−67.07\times10^{-6}1.34×10−71.34\times10^{-7}
598.46×10−58.46\times10^{-5}4.50×10−64.50\times10^{-6}
606.52×10−46.52\times10^{-4}8.50×10−58.50\times10^{-5}

Table 1. Accumulated errors of the second- and third-order HJH_J equations, compared with the exact logarithmic-model trajectory at common Jordan-frame times.

e-fold labels differ from the displayed integers by at most 0.001. The third-order trajectory improves on the second-order one over this interval. The contrast is most informative toward the end of inflation: a small instantaneous residual does not imply that the integrated trajectory error will remain equally small. This example does not establish a uniform error bound for arbitrary models or license continuing the expansion through the sharp post-inflationary features (Figure 4).

Linear perturbations and conditional inflationary predictions

Tensor propagation and scalar fluctuations

We calculate scalar and tensor spectra from the standard gauge-invariant perturbation equations of metric f(R)f(R) gravity. The action and its constraints determine their kinetic terms and normalization. Appendix A gives the quadratic actions and numerical implementation used for the logarithmic benchmark.

For transverse–traceless tensor perturbations, hiji=∂ihij=0h^{i}_{\phantom{i}j} = \partial^{i}h_{ij} = 0 and the linear scalar-curvature perturbation vanishes, δR(T)=0\delta R^{(T)} = 0. This does not make tensor propagation identical to general relativity: the evolving background F=fRF = f_R changes the effective Planck mass. With no anisotropic-stress source, the tensor equation is [29, 30, 31]

h¨ij+(3HJ+F˙F)h˙ij−∇2hijaJ2=0.(60)\ddot{h}_{ij}+\left(3H_J+\frac{\dot{F}}{F}\right)\dot{h}_{ij}-\frac{\nabla^2 h_{ij}}{a_J^2}=0. \tag*{(60)}

The propagation speed remains unity; the additional damping is F˙/F\dot{F}/F [32, 33]. In the quadratic model,

F˙F=12α(H¨J+4HJH˙J)1+12α(H˙J+2HJ2).(61)\frac{\dot{F}}{F}=\frac{12\alpha(\ddot{H}_J+4H_J\dot{H}_J)}{1+12\alpha(\dot{H}_J+2H_J^2)}. \tag*{(61)}

At high curvature during slow roll, F˙/(HJF)≃−2ϵJ\dot{F}/(H_JF)\simeq-2\epsilon_J. Along the exact Starobinsky trajectory used in § 2.2, the full damping coefficient divided by HJH_J decreases from 2.98352 to 2.11494. The approximation 3−2ϵJ3-2\epsilon_J cannot be extended to the final crossing (Figure 5).

Figure 5. Diagnostics along the relaxed Starobinsky background. Left: the magnitudes of the two mechanical power terms in the mechanical balance (22), normalized to the initial linear contribution. Right: exact tensor damping coefficient, its high-curvature slow-roll approximation and the constant-FF reference value. Mechanical power terms are diagnostics of the background equation, not physical reheating rates. The high-curvature approximation to tensor damping fails near the final ϵJ=1\epsilon_J = 1 crossing.

The scalar perturbation is described by the comoving curvature perturbation R\mathcal{R} (distinct from the background Ricci scalar RR). We restrict the mode calculation to the rolling inflationary branch, where comoving scalaron slicing is regular. In the Einstein frame the scalar and tensor canonical modes obey

vs,k′′+(k2−zs′′zs)vs,k=0,vT,k′′+(k2−aE′′aE)vT,k=0,(62)v_{s,k}^{\prime\prime}+\left(k^2-\frac{z_s^{\prime\prime}}{z_s}\right)v_{s,k}=0,\qquad v_{T,k}^{\prime\prime}+\left(k^2-\frac{a_E^{\prime\prime}}{a_E}\right)v_{T,k}=0, \tag*{(62)}

where zs=aE dϕ/dln⁡aEz_s=a_E\,d\phi/d\ln a_E, primes denote conformal-time derivatives and dη=dtJ/aJ=dtE/aEd\eta=dt_J/a_J=dt_E/a_E. These are the established scalaron fluctuation equations, not additional consequences of the mechanical analogy [18, 19, 30].

Mode evolution, normalization and comparison with slow roll

We integrate the canonical scalar and tensor modes on the exact Einstein-frame background, taking n=ln⁡(aE/aE,∗)n=\ln(a_E/a_{E,*}) as the evolution variable. The reference event n=0n=0 is selected N∗N_* e-folds before the first exact ϵE=1\epsilon_E=1 crossing. The Bunch–Davies prescription [22, 34] is implemented at a finite, deep-subhorizon ratio Q=k/(aEHE)Q = k/(a_E H_E); the value of QQ is varied to test the initialization. Appendix § 10 gives the background and mode equations, their initial conditions and the convergence tests. With κ=kEα\kappa= k_E\sqrt{\alpha}, the dimensionless spectra are

PR=κ2∣R^∣24π2αMPl2,PT=2κ2∣T^∣2π2αMPl2,ns−1=dln⁡PRdln⁡k,r=PTPR.(63)\mathcal{P}_{\mathcal{R}} = \frac{\kappa^2|\widehat{\mathcal{R}}|^2}{4\pi^2\alpha M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}, \qquad\mathcal{P}_{T} = \frac{2\kappa^2|\widehat{T}|^2}{\pi^2\alpha M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}, \qquad n_s - 1 = \frac{\mathrm{d}\ln\mathcal{P}_{\mathcal{R}}}{\mathrm{d}\ln k}, \qquad r = \frac{\mathcal{P}_{T}}{\mathcal{P}_{\mathcal{R}}}. \tag*{(63)}

Here R^\widehat{\mathcal{R}} and T^\widehat{T} are the canonically normalized amplitudes defined in the Appendix § 10. The tensor power includes both helicities and approaches 2HE2/(π2MPl2)2H_E^2/(\pi^2M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2) in the usual leading slow-roll limit.

The quoted spectra describe linear vacuum perturbations during inflation. Post-inflationary gravitational-wave production and scalaron decay require additional equations. The reference calculation uses Q=400Q = 400 and evaluates the frozen modes at n=10n = 10, before the end of inflation. We determine the tilt with a centered five-point derivative in ln⁡k\ln k, and test the starting scale, integration tolerances and freeze-out time independently (Appendix § 10). The results in Table 2 are quoted to fewer digits than those numerical tests support.

δ\deltans(V)n_s^{(V)}nsn_s (modes)r(V)r^{(V)}rr (modes)
00.967830.967750.0029640.003007
10.970360.970270.0036850.003730
20.972360.972260.0044420.004489
30.973940.973840.0052220.005271
40.975200.975110.0060150.006066
50.976220.976130.0068130.006865

Table 2. Potential slow-roll estimates and linear-mode spectra at the separately defined 60-e-fold reference events for the regularized inverse-logarithmic model.

The values of ℓ0\ell_0, ss and δ\delta are used as specified test parameters for the regular branch, not as a best-fit point or a bound from CMB data. In particular, the δ=3\delta= 3 benchmark is not claimed to be the largest observationally permissible departure from Starobinsky inflation. At N∗=60N_* = 60, ℓ0=1\ell_0 = 1 and s=0.01s = 0.01, the results are The potential columns use Eq. (51) at

NE(V)=60N_E^{(V)} = 60; the numerical columns use 60 e-folds to the exact acceleration exit. Both the slow-roll approximation and the endpoint prescription therefore enter their difference. This is a comparison of two stated prediction procedures, not an isolated measurement of a higher-order spectral correction. The scalar tilt differs by about 10−410^{-4} and rr by roughly one percent over the values in Table 2 (Figure 6). For δ=0\delta= 0, the finite-NEN_E calculation retains endpoint and logarithmic corrections that are absent from the large-NEN_E estimates ns≃1−2/NEn_s \simeq1 - 2/N_E and r≃12/NE2r \simeq12/N_E^2. Those leading asymptotic expressions are not reference values at the precision of this table.

Figure 6. Potential shapes and conditional inflationary predictions for ℓ0=1\ell_0 = 1, s=0.01s = 0.01. Upper left: the Einstein-frame potentials using the same overall α\alpha. Upper right and lower left: the scalar spectral index nsn_s and the tensor-to-scalar ratio rr, respectively, comparing potential slow-roll estimates with numerical linear-mode results at their separately defined 60-e-fold reference events. The numerical points are connected only as a visual guide. Lower right: the ratio of the logarithmic to Einstein–Hilbert contributions to the potential slope, evaluated at the potential slow-roll reference event. These are conditional theoretical predictions at specified reference events; they are not the results of a likelihood analysis. The slow-roll and numerical-mode calculations use different end-of-inflation prescriptions; their differences therefore cannot be attributed solely to higher-order slow-roll corrections.

The amplitude fixes the overall scale, conditional on this reference choice. If PR(1)\mathcal{P}_{\mathcal{R}}^{(1)} denotes Eq. (63) evaluated with αMPl2=1\alpha M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2 = 1, then

αMPl2=PR(1)(k∗)As.(64)\alpha M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2 = \frac{\mathcal{P}_{\mathcal{R}}^{(1)}(k_*)}{A_s}. \tag*{(64)}

Taking As=2.1×10−9A_s = 2.1 \times10^{-9} [23] gives αMPl2≃1.306×109\alpha M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2 \simeq1.306 \times10^9 at δ=0\delta= 0 and 6.444×1086.444 \times10^8 at δ=3\delta= 3. Since s=αRcs = \alpha R_{\mathrm{c}} is held fixed, the corresponding dimensional RcR_{\mathrm{c}} changes when this normalization changes. The leading potential-amplitude expression As≃S/(48π2αMPl2ϵV2)A_s \simeq S/(48\pi^2\alpha M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2\epsilon_V^2) is useful for comparison, but was not substituted for the numerical amplitude.

The parameters and e-fold choice are not fixed by the background analogy. For example, the same δ=3\delta= 3, ℓ0=1\ell_0 = 1 model gives the following numerical sensitivity checks: Table 3 makes clear that the dependence on N∗N_* is larger than the numerical uncertainty. A data comparison must specify the post-inflationary expansion, match a dimensional pivot, and explore the model parameters. Cheslog et al. [26] show that allowing the effective relativistic energy density and neutrino masses to vary broadens the inferred tilt constraints and changes the apparent tension of Starobinsky inflation. Their likelihood analysis supplies observational context, rather than a test of the present action. The 60-e-fold choice used here is a numerical reference; its identification with a CMB pivot remains conditional on the post-inflationary history.

N∗N_*ssnsn_srr
500.0100.967910.006985
550.0100.971150.006025
600.0050.973380.004962
600.0100.973840.005271
600.0200.974330.005651

Table 3. Sensitivity of the numerical spectra to the e-fold reference N∗N_* and regularization parameter ss, with δ=3\delta= 3 and ℓ0=1\ell_0 = 1.

What the mechanical ratio says about rr

The ratios introduced in the HJH_J chart are useful for comparing terms in a background equation. They do not by themselves determine the scalar or tensor amplitudes. Nevertheless, in the high-curvature Starobinsky limit one may express the familiar leading tensor-to-scalar ratio in terms of a background mechanical ratio, once the frame conversion is performed correctly. On the expanding inflationary branch, where F>0F > 0, HJ≠0H_J \ne0, and HE>0H_E > 0, the exact vacuum background relation is

ϵE=3ϵ32(1+ϵ3)2,ϵ3=F˙2HJF.(65)\epsilon_E = \frac{3\epsilon_3^2}{(1+\epsilon_3)^2}, \qquad\epsilon_3 = \frac{\dot{F}}{2H_JF}. \tag*{(65)}

For high-curvature quadratic slow roll, F≃24αHJ2F \simeq24\alpha H_J^2 and ϵ3≃−ϵJ\epsilon_3 \simeq-\epsilon_J. Combining the leading spectrum result r≃16ϵEr \simeq16\epsilon_E with D=6/ϵJD = 6/\epsilon_J gives

r≃48ϵJ2=1728D2.(66)r \simeq48\epsilon_J^2 = \frac{1728}{D^2}. \tag*{(66)}

For this comparison, DD must be evaluated on the Jordan-frame background at the same pivot horizon-crossing event at which the Einstein-frame slow-roll spectrum is evaluated, with the two Hubble histories related by the conformal transformation. It is not a time-independent constant. In particular, DD is not a frame-invariant observable and the relation cannot replace the mode calculation. This is a rewriting of a standard approximation in a chosen background variable. On the 60-NJN_J Starobinsky trajectory, it gives 0.0033148, while the same event has 16ϵE=0.003314616\epsilon_E = 0.0033146. These are not the numerical mode value at the different 60-NEN_E reference in the table. Equation (66) is not valid for a general f(R)f(R) model or at the oscillatory stage. The homogeneous mechanical equation also supplies no independent stochastic tensor source.

Conclusion

The Jordan-frame Hubble equation gives a direct test of the slow-roll approximation in metric f(R)f(R) gravity. For the quadratic Starobinsky model the mechanical equation is exact. Its inertial-to-linear ratio on the relaxed branch is I=ϵJ2/9+O(ϵJ3)\mathcal{I}=\epsilon_J^2/9+O(\epsilon_J^3), while the quadratic-to-linear ratio is ϵJ/6\epsilon_J/6. The latter is only one sixth at the first Jordan-frame acceleration exit. The exit therefore cannot be identified with quadratic dominance in this normalization.

The comparison of neighboring trajectories is also precise. At a common decreasing Hubble value, the velocity difference contracts on the expanding branch. This removes the arbitrary time offset between histories. The result applies while both solutions remain on their common decreasing-Hubble interval; it does not establish a global attractor basin. At a Hubble zero the original equation becomes a poor coordinate description, although the trace–Ricci system remains regular. The signed variable HJ=Y2H_J=Y^2 passes smoothly through the tangency. Its small-amplitude frequency is half the curvature and scalaron frequency, as required by the relation between RR and YY.

For a general action, the curvature dependence of the coefficients matters. The second-order mechanical equation contains fRRRf_{RRR}, and the cubic terms include both H˙JH¨J\dot{H}_J\ddot{H}_J and an fRRRRf_{RRRR} contribution. Small Hubble-flow parameters must therefore be accompanied by a controlled hierarchy of curvature derivatives. We tested the approximation in two ways: through its residual on the exact background, and through the error of a separately integrated trajectory at common Jordan times. In the regularized logarithmic benchmark the cubic truncation improves the inflationary trajectory over the interval studied. The sharp features during the later oscillations require the untruncated equations.

On the slice ℓ0=1\ell_0=1, δ≥0\delta\geq0, the example satisfies fRR≥2αf_{RR}\geq2\alpha and has a regular positive-FF branch with a Minkowski minimum. Independent frame integrations agree within the reported numerical accuracy. The large-curvature action and leading inverse-field spectral scaling are shared with earlier running quadratic-gravity work; the tests here concern the smooth finite-curvature extension and its approximation errors.

The linear modes give ns≃0.97384n_s\simeq0.97384 and r≃0.00527r\simeq0.00527 for δ=3\delta=3, ℓ0=1\ell_0=1, s=0.01s=0.01, at the event 60 exact Einstein-frame e-folds before the first acceleration exit. These are conditional theoretical predictions. Their dependence on the e-fold reference is larger than the measured numerical uncertainty. A model for scalaron decay and the subsequent expansion would be needed to match a dimensional pivot, followed by a parameter likelihood analysis for an observational test. The vacuum oscillations studied here do not describe thermal reheating, and the mechanical velocity coefficient is not a scalaron decay rate.

Acknowledgments

This work is supported in part by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) Grant Nos. W2533015, 12375052, and 11935009 and by the Tianjin University Self-Innovation Fund for Extreme Basic Research Grant No. 2025XJ21-0007.

Data and code availability

Source code for reproducing the numerical results is provided in the Supplemental Material [35].

Quadratic actions and numerical mode checks

Canonical actions and equations

For gij=aJ2(δij+hij)g_{ij}=a_J^2(\delta_{ij}+h_{ij}) with h ii=∂ihij=0h^i_{\ i}=\partial^i h_{ij}=0, tracelessness gives δR(T)=0\delta R^{(T)}=0 at first order. The standard quadratic tensor action is [29, 30]

ST(2)=MPl28∫dtJd3x aJ3F[h˙ijh˙ij−∂khij∂khijaJ2].(67)S_T^{(2)}=\frac{M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2}{8}\int\mathrm{d}t_J\mathrm{d}^3x\,a_J^3F\left[\dot{h}_{ij}\dot{h}_{ij}-\frac{\partial_kh_{ij}\partial_kh_{ij}}{a_J^2}\right]. \tag*{(67)}

Variation gives Eq. (60). On an interval where comoving scalaron slicing is regular, the scalar action is

SR(2)=12∫dtJd3x aJ3Qs[R˙2−(∇R)2aJ2],Qs=3MPl2F˙22F[HJ+F˙/(2F)]2.(68)S_{\mathcal{R}}^{(2)}=\frac{1}{2}\int\mathrm{d}t_J\mathrm{d}^3x\,a_J^3Q_s\left[\dot{\mathcal{R}}^2-\frac{(\nabla\mathcal{R})^2}{a_J^2}\right],\qquad Q_s=\frac{3M_{\mathrm{Pl}}^2\dot{F}^2}{2F[H_J+\dot{F}/(2F)]^2}. \tag*{(68)}

The conformal-time interval is common to the frames. The tensor pump field is proportional to aJF=aEa_J\sqrt{F}=a_E, while zs=aE dϕ/dln⁡aEz_s=a_E\,\mathrm{d}\phi/\mathrm{d}\ln a_E. They give the canonical equations (62) used in Sec. 6.

Mode initial conditions and integration

For the numerical integration let n=ln⁡(aE/aE,∗)n=\ln(a_E/a_{E,*}), with n=0n=0 selected N∗N_* e-folds before the first exact ϵE=1\epsilon_E=1 event. Define φ=ϕ/MPl\varphi=\phi/M_{\mathrm{Pl}}, Uφ=dφ/dnU_\varphi=\mathrm{d}\varphi/\mathrm{d}n, and κ=kα\kappa=k\sqrt{\alpha}. We set aE,∗=1a_{E,*}=1 and κ∗=hE,∗\kappa_*=h_{E,*}. The exact inflationary background equations in this variable are

dxdn=UφF6C,dUφdn=−(3−ϵE)(Uφ+23TS),ϵE=Uφ22,(69)\frac{\mathrm{d}x}{\mathrm{d}n}=\frac{U_\varphi F}{\sqrt{6}C},\qquad\frac{\mathrm{d}U_\varphi}{\mathrm{d}n}=-(3-\epsilon_E)\left(U_\varphi+\sqrt{\frac{2}{3}\frac{T}{S}}\right),\qquad\epsilon_E=\frac{U_\varphi^2}{2}, \tag*{(69)}

with hE2=S/[2F2(3−ϵE)]h_E^2=S/[2F^2(3-\epsilon_E)]. Initial data are the same constraint-consistent scalar drift at xi=100x_i=100 used in Sec. 5.

For stable evolution outside the horizon, we integrate the curvature and tensor amplitudes instead of differencing the pump fields numerically. Define R^=2kMPlRk\widehat{\mathcal{R}}=\sqrt{2k}M_{\mathrm{Pl}}\mathcal{R}_k and T^=2kaE−1vT,k\widehat{T}=\sqrt{2k}a_E^{-1}v_{T,k}. They obey

R^,nn+(3−ϵE+2Uφ,nUφ)R^,n+qk2R^=0,T^,nn+(3−ϵE)T^,n+qk2T^=0,qk=κaEhE.(70)\widehat{\mathcal{R}}_{,nn}+\left(3-\epsilon_E+2\frac{U_{\varphi,n}}{U_\varphi}\right)\widehat{\mathcal{R}}_{,n}+q_k^2\widehat{\mathcal{R}}=0, \qquad \widehat{T}_{,nn}+(3-\epsilon_E)\widehat{T}_{,n}+q_k^2\widehat{T}=0, \qquad q_k=\frac{\kappa}{a_E h_E}. \tag*{(70)}

The canonical vacuum at a finite subhorizon ratio qk=Qq_k=Q gives, up to an irrelevant common phase,

R^i=1aE,iUφ,i,R^,n,i=(−iQ−1−Uφ,n,iUφ,i)R^i,T^i=1aE,i,T^,n,i=(−iQ−1)T^i.(71)\widehat{\mathcal{R}}_i=\frac{1}{a_{E,i}U_{\varphi,i}}, \qquad \widehat{\mathcal{R}}_{,n,i}=\left(-iQ-1-\frac{U_{\varphi,n,i}}{U_{\varphi,i}}\right)\widehat{\mathcal{R}}_i, \qquad \widehat{T}_i=\frac{1}{a_{E,i}}, \qquad \widehat{T}_{,n,i}=(-iQ-1)\widehat{T}_i. \tag*{(71)}

This is a finite-QQ approximation to the asymptotic short-wavelength vacuum. Its dependence on QQ is tested, rather than assumed to vanish. The tensor normalization includes both polarizations. The default mode solver uses DOP853 with relative/absolute tolerances 2×10−11/2×10−122\times10^{-11}/2\times10^{-12} and maximum step 0.02 in nn. A centered five-point derivative at ln⁡(k/k∗)=0\ln(k/k_*)=0, ±0.02\pm0.02, ±0.04\pm0.04 estimates nsn_s. The initial finite-QQ state approximates the asymptotic short-wavelength vacuum; its dependence on QQ is tested below.

Convergence and independent checks

All background integrations for the mode calculation use xi=100x_i=100 and the constraint-consistent scalar drift of Eq. (55), with the model-specific value of δ\delta. The e-fold background (69) is integrated with relative/absolute tolerances 3×10−13/3×10−153\times10^{-13}/3\times10^{-15} and maximum step 0.03. It reproduces the reference state obtained by the cosmic-time evolution. The following checks concern the numerical linear calculation; they do not estimate uncertainties from reheating or the phenomenological action.

At δ=0\delta=0 and 3, we repeat the calculation for Q=100Q=100, 200, 400, 800, halve the wavenumber spacing to 0.01, and tighten mode tolerances by ten while halving the maximum step to 0.01. Representative results are given in Table 4. The Q=400Q=400, Δln⁡k=0.02\Delta\ln k=0.02 rows use the tighter integration settings; the other rows use the defaults. Over the tested initializations, the starting-scale variations change nsn_s by less than 1.1×10−71.1\times10^{-7} and rr by less than 4×10−64\times10^{-6} in relative terms in these tests. Halving the wavenumber spacing or tightening the integration settings changes nsn_s by less than 10−1010^{-10}. The scalar and tensor canonical Wronskians are conserved to better than 10−910^{-9} from initialization through n=1n=1, where cancellation has not yet made a numerical Wronskian check ill-conditioned.

δ\deltaQQΔln⁡k\Delta\ln knsn_srr
01000.020.967747350.003006557
02000.020.967747330.003006551
04000.010.967747290.003006547
04000.020.967747290.003006547
08000.020.967747320.003006547
31000.020.973844750.005271005
32000.020.973844720.005270998
34000.010.973844650.005270992
34000.020.973844650.005270992
38000.020.973844690.005270993

Table 4. Mode-spectrum checks against the initial subhorizon ratio QQ, the wavenumber spacing and the integration tolerances.

Evaluating the scalar amplitude at n=8n=8 rather than 10 changes it by less than 1.1×10−71.1\times10^{-7} over all six scan points; the tensor change is of the same order. For δ=0\delta=0 and 3, extending the evaluation from n=10n = 10 to 12 changes both powers by less than 2.1×10−92.1 \times10^{-9}. Figure 7 uses the later reference n=12n = 12 for values displayed through n=10n = 10. These effects are below the precision used in the main table.

Figure 7. Scalar mode freeze-out for δ=0\delta= 0 and 33 at the exact 6060-NEN_E reference. Left: the power spectrum normalized to its value at n=12n = 12. Right: the relative difference from that later reference value after horizon exit, displayed through n=10n = 10. The nearly coincident curves show a similar approach to freeze-out in the two models. Tensor freeze-out is assessed separately using the same numerical procedure. This is a diagnostic of temporal convergence, not a new inflationary prediction.

A separate program evolves the canonical variables in Eq. (62), using analytic pump fields, rather than the amplitudes in Eq. (70). With the same Q=400Q = 400 initial prescription and evaluation at n=10n = 10, the two formulations agree in scalar and tensor power to within 8×10−118 \times10^{-11} in relative terms at δ=0\delta= 0 and 3; their tilts differ by less than 2.1×10−122.1 \times10^{-12}. This check tests the change of evolution variable and its normalization independently of the amplitude equations.

An independent normalization test uses a canonical power-law background with constant ϵE=0.01\epsilon_E = 0.01, for which zs/aE=MPl2ϵEz_s/a_E = M_{\mathrm{Pl}}\sqrt{2\epsilon_E} is constant. The exact canonical solution, with an irrelevant constant phase suppressed, is

vk(η)=πt4kHν(1)(t),2k vk=πt2Hν(1)(t),v_k(\eta) = \sqrt{\frac{\pi t}{4k}}H_\nu^{(1)}(t), \qquad\sqrt{2k}\,v_k = \sqrt{\frac{\pi t}{2}}H_\nu^{(1)}(t),
t=−kη=k(1−ϵE)aEHE,ν=3−ϵE2(1−ϵE)(72)t = -k\eta= \frac{k}{(1-\epsilon_E)a_EH_E}, \qquad\nu= \frac{3-\epsilon_E}{2(1-\epsilon_E)} \tag*{(72)}

Here tt is a positive dimensionless mode argument, distinct from cosmic time. The numerical variables use the rescaled mode 2k vk\sqrt{2k}\,v_k, which explains the two prefactors. Since Hν(1)(t)∼2/(πt)ei(t−πν/2−π/4)H_\nu^{(1)}(t) \sim\sqrt{2/(\pi t)}e^{i(t-\pi\nu/2-\pi/4)} at large tt, the canonical mode approaches e−ikη/2ke^{-ik\eta}/\sqrt{2k} up to that constant phase. Starting with this solution and its derivative at k/(aEHE)=80k/(a_EH_E) = 80, the numerical scalar and tensor powers at n=8n = 8 agree with the analytic solution within 3.2×10−123.2 \times10^{-12} in relative terms. Their ratio recovers r=16ϵEr = 16\epsilon_E to rounding accuracy. This check tests the evolution and normalization independently of the f(R)f(R) functions and of a slow-roll amplitude formula [22].

The dimensionless action αf(x/α)\alpha f(x/\alpha) and its first four derivatives were also checked by direct Taylor arithmetic at 75-digit precision for 55 curvature–parameter pairs. The sampled scaled differences ∣dcode−dTaylor∣/max⁡(1,∣dTaylor∣)|d_{\mathrm{code}} - d_{\mathrm{Taylor}}|/\max(1, |d_{\mathrm{Taylor}}|) are below 7×10−147 \times10^{-14}.

References

  1. [1]A. A. Starobinsky, “A New Type of Isotropic Cosmological Models Without Singularity,” Phys. Lett. B 91, 99–102 (1980).
  2. [2]A. Vilenkin, “Classical and quantum cosmology of the Starobinsky inflationary model,” Phys. Rev. D 32, 2511–2521 (1985), doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.32.2511.DOI
  3. [3]B. Whitt, “Fourth Order Gravity as General Relativity Plus Matter,” Phys. Lett. B 145, 176–178 (1984).DOI
  4. [4]K. Maeda, “Towards the Einstein-Hilbert Action via Conformal Transformation,” Phys. Rev. D 39, 3159–3162 (1989), doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.39.3159.DOI
  5. [5]M. B. Mijić, M. S. Morris, and W.-M. Suen, “The R² cosmology: Inflation without a phase transition,” Phys. Rev. D 34, 2934–2946 (1986), doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.34.2934.DOI
  6. [6]K. Maeda, “Inflation as a transient attractor in R^2 cosmology,” Phys. Rev. D 37, 858 (1988), doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.37.858.DOI
  7. [7]T. P. Sotiriou and V. Faraoni, “f(R) Theories of Gravity,” Rev. Mod. Phys. 82, 451–497 (2010) [arXiv:0805.1726 [gr-qc]].DOI
  8. [8]A. De Felice and S. Tsujikawa, “f(R) theories,” Living Rev. Rel. 13, 3 (2010) [arXiv:1002.4928 [gr-qc]].DOI
  9. [9]K. S. Stelle, “Renormalization of higher derivative quantum gravity,” Phys. Rev. D 16, 953–969 (1977).DOI
  10. [10]K. S. Stelle, “Classical gravity with higher derivatives,” Gen. Rel. Grav. 9, 353–371 (1978).DOI
  11. [11]H. Khodabakhshi, M. Farhang, F. Shojai, and H. Lü, “Cosmology with Higher-Derivative Gravities,” Phys. Rev. D 110, L061504 (2024), doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.110.L061504 [arXiv:2405.02879 [gr-qc]].DOI
  12. [12]L. Kofman, A. Linde, and A. A. Starobinsky, “Reheating after inflation,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 3195–3198 (1994), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.73.3195.DOI
  13. [13]L. Kofman, A. Linde, and A. A. Starobinsky, “Towards the theory of reheating after inflation,” Phys. Rev. D 56, 3258–3295 (1997), doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.56.3258 [arXiv:hep-ph/9704452].DOI
  14. [14]I. Ben-Dayan, S. Jing, M. Torabian, A. Westphal, and L. Zarate, “R^2 log R quantum corrections and the inflationary observables,” JCAP 09, 005 (2014), doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2014/09/005 [arXiv:1404.7349 [hep-th]].
  15. [15]M. Rinaldi, G. Cognola, L. Vanzo, and S. Zerbini, “Inflation in scale-invariant theories of gravity,” Phys. Rev. D 91, 123527 (2015) [arXiv:1410.0631 [gr-qc]], doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.91.123527.DOI
  16. [16]R. Liu, J. Quintin, and N. Afshordi, “Ultraviolet Completion of the Big Bang in Quadratic Gravity,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 136, 111501 (2026), doi:10.1103/6gtx-j455 [arXiv:2510.18733 [hep-th]].DOI
  17. [17]V. F. Mukhanov and G. V. Chibisov, “Quantum fluctuations and a nonsingular universe,” JETP Lett. 33, 532–535 (1981).
  18. [18]M. Sasaki, “Large Scale Quantum Fluctuations in the Inflationary Universe,” Prog. Theor. Phys. 76, 1036–1046 (1986), doi:10.1143/PTP.76.1036.DOI
  19. [19]V. F. Mukhanov, “Quantum theory of gauge-invariant cosmological perturbations,” Sov. Phys. JETP 67, 1297–1302 (1988).
  20. [20]A. R. Liddle, P. Parsons, and J. D. Barrow, “Formalizing the slow roll approximation in inflation,” Phys. Rev. D 50, 7222–7232 (1994) [arXiv:astro-ph/9408015].DOI
  21. [21]E. D. Stewart and D. H. Lyth, “A more accurate analytic calculation of the spectrum of cosmological perturbations produced during inflation,” Phys. Lett. B 302, 171–175 (1993) [arXiv:gr-qc/9302019], doi:10.1016/0370-2693(93)90379-V.DOI
  22. [22]I. J. Grivell and A. R. Liddle, “Accurate determination of inflationary perturbations,” Phys. Rev. D 54, 7191 (1996) [arXiv:astro-ph/9607096], doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.54.7191.DOI
  23. [23]Planck Collaboration, Y. Akrami et al., “Planck 2018 results. X. Constraints on inflation,” Astron. Astrophys. 641, A10 (2020) [arXiv:1807.06211 [astro-ph.CO]].
  24. [24]BICEP/Keck Collaboration, P. A. R. Ade et al., “Improved Constraints on Primordial Gravitational Waves using Planck, WMAP, and BICEP/Keck Observations through the 2018 Observing Season,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 151301 (2021) [arXiv:2110.00483 [astro-ph.CO]].
  25. [25]ACT Collaboration, T. Louis et al., “The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: DR6 Power Spectra, Likelihoods and ΛCDM Parameters,” JCAP 11, 062 (2025), doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2025/11/062 [arXiv:2503.14452 [astro-ph.CO]].
  26. [26]Z. Cheslog, E. Finson, A. MacInnis, N. Sehgal, N. Afshordi, S. K. Nerval, and R. Hložek, “Current and Future Constraints on the Primordial Power Spectrum,” arXiv:2609.35964 [astro-ph.CO] (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2609.35964
  27. [27]A. D. Dolgov and M. Kawasaki, “Can modified gravity explain accelerated cosmic expansion?,” Phys. Lett. B 573, 1–4 (2003), doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2003.08.039 [arXiv:astro-ph/0307285].DOI
  28. [28]P. Virtanen et al., “SciPy 1.0: Fundamental Algorithms for Scientific Computing in Python,” Nat. Methods 17, 261–272 (2020), doi:10.1038/s41592-019-0686-2.DOI
  29. [29]J. Hwang, “Cosmological perturbations in generalized gravity theories: Solutions,” Phys. Rev. D 42, 2601 (1990), doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.42.2601.DOI
  30. [30]J. Hwang and H. Noh, “Cosmological perturbations in generalized gravity theories,” Phys. Rev. D 54, 1460–1473 (1996), doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.54.1460.DOI
  31. [31]V. F. Mukhanov, H. A. Feldman, and R. H. Brandenberger, “Theory of cosmological perturbations,” Phys. Rep. 215, 203–333 (1992), doi:10.1016/0370-1573(92)90044-Z.DOI
  32. [32]I. D. Saltas, I. Sawicki, L. Amendola, and M. Kunz, “Anisotropic stress as a signature of nonstandard propagation of gravitational waves,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 191101 (2014), doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.113.191101 [arXiv:1406.7139].DOI
  33. [33]L. Lombriser and A. Taylor, “Breaking a dark degeneracy with gravitational waves,” JCAP 03, 031 (2016), doi:10.1088/1475-7516/2016/03/031 [arXiv:1509.08458].DOI
  34. [34]T. S. Bunch and P. C. W. Davies, “Quantum field theory in de Sitter space: Renormalization by point-splitting,” Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 360, 117–134 (1978), doi:10.1098/rspa.1978.0060.DOI
  35. [35]See Supplemental Material at [URL will be inserted by publisher] for the numerical source code and instructions for reproducing the results.

Paper details

vlnc:W_shjthrgk
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY-SA 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents